## Issue Note: Use of Credit/Debit vs Revenue/Expenditure in Balance of Payments Statistics

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [Issue Note: Use of Credit/Debit vs Revenue/Expenditure in Balance of Payments Statistics](https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/data/statistics/bpm6/approved-guidance-notes/issue-note-use-of-credit-debit-vs-revenue-expenditure-in-balance-of-payments-statistics.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/files/data/statistics/bpm6/approved-guidance-notes/issue-note-use-of-credit-debit-vs-revenue-expenditure-in-balance-of-payments-statistics.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/files/data/statistics/bpm6/approved-guidance-notes/issue-note-use-of-credit-debit-vs-revenue-expenditure-in-balance-of-payments-statistics.pdf.json)

---

### Introduction and background
- Prepared by the Statistics Department, INTERNATIONAL MONETARY FUND; relates to BPM6/2008 SNA Update and the Inter-secretariat Working Group on National Accounts and IMF Committee on Balance of Payments Statistics.
- The Issue Note examines three options for replacing the BPM6 terminology credit/debit to harmonize terminology across statistical domains (BPM, 2008 SNA, GFSM 2014) and presents feasibility considerations for BPM7.
- Key meetings and dates:
  - Discussion at the July 2023 joint AEG/Committee meeting raised concerns about changing credit/debit to revenue/expenditure and translation challenges.
  - Consultations at the October 2023 BOPCOM meeting and a subsequent written consultation informed the final outcome.
- GN CM.2 (Guidance Note “CM.2 Terminology and Branding of the Economic Accounting Statistical Standards”) proposed harmonized terminology across BPM6, 2008 SNA, and GFSM 2014, including replacing credit/debit with revenue/expenditure and, for the capital account, using changes in assets/changes in liabilities to align with SNA accumulation accounts.

### Key findings on terminology, comparability, and system conventions
- BPM6 introduced net acquisition of financial assets/net incurrence of liabilities in the financial account to align with the SNA; credit/debit remain used in current and capital accounts in BPM6.
- The double-entry basis (credits and debits at transaction level) underlies balance of payments statistics despite alternative labels in presentation.
- Terminology differences across domains:
  - BPM6: Credit/Debit for current and capital accounts; financial account uses Net acquisition of financial assets/Net incurrence of liabilities.
  - 2008 SNA: Resources/Uses for current accounts; Change in assets/Change in liabilities and net worth for accumulation accounts.
  - GFSM 2014: Revenue/Expense.
  - GN CM.2 proposed mapping (Table 1) to Revenue/Expenditure (BPM7) for current accounts and changes in assets/changes in liabilities for capital accounts to improve alignment.

### Options considered for BPM7 (three main options)
- Option 1 (GN CM.2–oriented):
  - Use revenue/expenditure in the current account.
  - Use disposal of nonproduced nonfinancial assets and capital transfers receivable (CR) / acquisition of nonproduced nonfinancial assets and capital transfers payable (DR) in the capital account.
  - Pros:
    - Achieve further (not full) harmonization of BPM and national accounts terminology for current and capital accounts.
    - Proposed terms are more self-explanatory than credits and debits.
  - Cons:
    - Transition costs for users (different terminologies across current, capital, and financial accounts).
    - Transition costs for compilers (updates to terminology in tables and databases).
    - Scope of revenue/expenditure under GN CM.2 would slightly differ from GFSM revenue/expense (GFSM includes capital transfers under revenue/expense).
- Option 2:
  - Use revenue/expenditure in both current and capital accounts.
  - Pros:
    - Further (but less than Option 1 for the capital account) harmonization of BPM and national accounts terminology.
    - More self-explanatory than credits/debits.
  - Cons:
    - Transition costs for users (though lower than Option 1).
    - Different scope of revenue/expenditure in BPM relative to SNA (SNA resources/uses apply only to current accounts; SNA capital account uses change in assets/change in liabilities and net worth).
    - Transition costs for compilers (updates to terminology in tables and databases).
- Option 3 (status quo):
  - Maintain credit/debit in current and capital accounts.
  - Pros:
    - No transition costs for compilers and users; preserves well-known terminology.
  - Cons:
    - No further harmonization of BPM and national accounts terminology for the current and capital accounts.

### Committee deliberations, compromise and final agreement
- At the October 2023 Committee meeting the Committee could not reach a single agreed option and proposed three alternatives for written consultation:
  - Option A (compromise): For the current account use revenues/credits and expenditures/debits; for the capital account use receivables/credits and payables/debits.
  - Option B: Propose a better alternative meeting user-friendliness and enhanced consistency.
  - Option C: Maintain the status quo.
- Outcome of written consultation:
  - It was agreed to use credits/revenues and debits/expenditures (proposed by one member under Option B) for both current and capital accounts in BPM7.

### Terminology definitions and scope (selected definitions from Annex II)
- Revenue (GFSM): "An increase in net worth of a unit resulting from a transaction." Includes capital transfers receivable (under grants), but transactions in non-financial assets are not part of it.
- Resources (SNA): "Transactions in the current accounts which add to the amount of economic value of a unit or a sector..." Only relates to current accounts; transactions in non-financial assets and capital transfers are recorded in the SNA capital account.
- Credit (BPM): "In the BPM, credit entries relate to exports of goods and services, earned income receivable, transfer income receivable and disposals of non-produced non-financial assets..." Credit entries cover both current and capital accounts in BPM.
- Expense (GFS): "A decrease in net worth for a unit resulting from a transaction." Includes capital transfers receivable (under grants), but transactions in non-financial assets are not part of it.
- Uses (SNA): "Transactions in the current accounts that reduce the amount of economic value of a unit or institutional sector..." Only relates to current accounts; transactions in non-financial assets and capital transfers are recorded in the SNA capital account.
- Debit (BPM): "In the BPM, debit entries relate to imports of goods and services, earned income payable, transfer income payable and acquisitions of non-produced non-financial assets..." Debit entries cover both current and capital accounts in BPM.

### Annex III summary: Pros and cons condensed
- Option 1 (revenue/expenditure current; disposal/acquisition + capital transfers in capital):
  - Pros: Further harmonization (not full); more self-explanatory terms.
  - Cons: Higher transition costs for users and compilers; mixed terminology across BPM accounts.
- Option 2 (revenue/expenditure current and capital):
  - Pros: Easier to implement than Option 1; more self-explanatory.
  - Cons: Different term scopes across BPM and SNA; transition costs exist.
- Option 3 (credit/debit status quo):
  - Pros: No transition costs; familiar terminology.
  - Cons: No progress on harmonization for current and capital accounts.

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/data/statistics/bpm6/approved-guidance-notes/issue-note-use-of-credit-debit-vs-revenue-expenditure-in-balance-of-payments-statistics.pdf_
