## outcomes-of-the-holistic-review-survey-of-bpm6-update-priorities

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [outcomes-of-the-holistic-review-survey-of-bpm6-update-priorities](https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/data/statistics/bpm6/outcomes-of-the-holistic-review-survey-of-bpm6-update-priorities.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/files/data/statistics/bpm6/outcomes-of-the-holistic-review-survey-of-bpm6-update-priorities.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/files/data/statistics/bpm6/outcomes-of-the-holistic-review-survey-of-bpm6-update-priorities.pdf.json)

---

### Purpose, context, and process
- The Committee on Balance of Payments Statistics endorsed the process for the holistic review of the Balance of Payments and International Investment Position Manual, sixth edition (BPM6) update priorities in its October 2021 meeting.
- Review inputs: previously endorsed reports, clarification notes, BPM and joint BPM/System of National Accounts (SNA) Task Teams’ Guidance Notes (GNs).
- Objective: achieve full consistency between BPM7 and the System of National Accounts 2025 (2025 SNA).
- IMF Statistics Department (STA) prepared a discussion note and two annexes: Annex I (summary of survey responses) and Annex II (summary list of all BPM6 update recommendations with preliminary assessments into three buckets: (i) will be included in BPM7; (ii) will remain on the Committee’s research agenda and be mentioned in BPM7; (iii) will not be included in BPM7 and will be dropped).

### Global survey design, participation, and aggregate patterns
- Survey design:
  - Focus: new data breakdowns (standard components and supplementary items).
  - Compilers provided cost assessments on a 0–5 scale (0 = no costs; 5 = very high costs).
  - Users provided benefit assessments on a 0–5 scale.
- Participation and coverage:
  - Gross total responses: 125.
  - Net total responses after cleaning: 95.
  - Cost assessments provided for 3,123 items.
  - Benefit assessments provided for 2,201 items.
  - Geographic representation: responses from 71 economies (Europe: 26; Asia & Pacific: 12; Western Hemisphere: 12; Africa: 11; Middle East & Central Asia: 10).
  - Institutional representation (consolidated responses): Central bank total 54 (Compiler 33; User 3; Both 18); National statistics office total 18 (Compiler 6; User 9; Both 3); Central bank/national statistics office joint total 10 (Compiler 1; Both 9); International organization total 10 (Compiler 1; User 7; Both 2); Other public sector institution total 3 (Both 3). Grand total: Compiler 41; User 19; Both 35; Grand total 95.
- Aggregate result patterns:
  - Users assessed benefits of most recommendations as relatively high; cost assessments varied more.
  - In 32 out of 57 cases, the average benefit assessment exceeded the average cost assessment.
  - Conclusion: cost/benefit assessments indicate a solid case for implementing many recommended new data breakdowns to meet core users’ needs at reasonable compilation costs.

### Preliminary assessments — new standard components
- Inclusion criterion: high bar because standard components fully contribute to totals and balancing items and are expected to be compiled by economies.
- Survey outcome and Committee decision:
  - Strong case to include five out of six recommended new standard components in BPM7:
    - Split telecommunications, computer, and information services (GN C.6).
    - Split other business services (GN C.6).
    - Add a sectoral breakdown of direct investment (GN D.7).
    - Split nonfinancial corporations, and households and nonprofit institutions serving households (GN F.1).
    - Produce an integrated international investment position statement (GN B.4).
  - The sixth recommendation — breakdown of financial derivatives by market risk category (GN F.4) — had average cost assessment higher and less support; Committee agreed it should be included as a supplementary item rather than a standard component.

- Selected numeric evidence supporting standard-component decisions:
  - C.6 Split telecommunications, computer, and information services — SC: Benefits 3.7 (42); Costs 1.2 (69); Difference 2.5.
  - C.6 Split other business services — SC: Benefits 3.7 (42); Costs 1.5 (68); Difference 2.3.
  - D.7 Sectoral breakdown of DI — SC: Benefits 3.7 (43); Costs 2.0 (67); Difference 1.7.
  - F.1 Split NFCs and Households/NPISH — SC: Benefits 3.6 (29); Costs 2.4 (52); Difference 1.2.
  - B.4 Produce an integrated IIP statement — SC: Benefits 4.2 (33); Costs 2.2 (50); Difference 2.0.
  - F.4 Financial derivatives by market risk category — SC: Benefits 3.1 (36); Costs 3.7 (48); Difference -0.5 (reclassified to supplementary).

### Preliminary assessments — new supplementary items and thresholds
- Inclusion approach:
  - Lower bar than for standard components; supplementary items are outside standard presentation and may be compiled depending on national circumstances.
  - Recommendation included when (average benefit assessment) minus (average cost assessment) is not below -0.5.
  - Threshold rationale: -0.5 chosen because Task Team ESS experts recommended supplementary items only when clear benefits were identified.
  - Phased implementation possibility: BPM7 can be phased so not all recommendations must be implemented immediately.

- Selected supplementary-item decisions (scores preserved):
  - Current account:
    - GN C.1 constructions — Difference -0.7; proposed inclusion in BPM7 to improve linkages with national accounts.
    - GN C.1 construction services — Difference -0.6; proposed inclusion.
    - GN C.3 breakdown of services by currency — Difference -0.6; proposed inclusion due to importance for core users (e.g., IMF work on dominant currencies and external adjustment).
    - GN C.4 merchanting item identifying material inputs procured by the principal in global manufacturing arrangement — Difference -0.9; proposed inclusion.
    - GN C.7 travel packages — Difference -0.6; proposed inclusion.
  - Direct investment:
    - GN D.1 excluding pass-through funds from greenfield DI — Difference -0.8; proposed to remain a small part of supplementary items.
    - GN D.4 corporate inversions — Difference -0.6; proposed to keep due to high relevance for some economies (BPM6 paragraph 8.20 already mentions supplementary data).
    - GN D.12 “of which: between affiliates” under financial derivatives — Difference -1.1; proposed to drop (Committee excluded).
  - Financial and payment systems:
    - GN F.2 reinvested earnings for portfolio investment — Difference -0.8; proposed to keep as supplementary item.
    - GN F.3 reverse transactions by type of (lent/borrowed) assets — Difference -1.0; proposed to drop.
    - GN F.4 change breakdown of financial derivatives by market category to supplementary item and proposed to drop breakdown by trading venue (trading venue Difference -1.2).
    - GN F.7 “of which” categories for fintech companies and instruments — Differences -1.0 and -1.1; proposed to drop but include fintech on research agenda.
  - Globalization:
    - GN G.4 breakdown by SPEs supported (Difference 0.6) but nationality-based SPE statistics had Difference -1.0; proposed to drop nationality-based SPE statistics from BPM7 and keep on research agenda.

### BPM6 update recommendations not included in the global survey
- All recommendations not part of the global survey proposed to be included in BPM7.
- Rationale:
  - These are conceptual recommendations already approved by the Committee and do not lead to new standard components or supplementary items.
  - Guidance Notes underwent global consultations where compilers could flag concerns.
  - Complex issues were subject to testing to ensure feasibility.
  - Draft annotated outlines of BPM7 chapters will be posted for global consultation.

### Committee October 2022 meeting outcomes and majority positions
- Committee support to include five recommended new standard components in BPM7:
  - Split telecommunications, computer, and information services (GN C.6).
  - Split other business services (GN C.6).
  - Add a sectoral breakdown of direct investment (GN D.7).
  - Split nonfinancial corporations, and households and nonprofit institutions serving households (GN F.1).
  - Produce an integrated international investment position statement (GN B.4).
- Agreement that GN F.4 (breakdown of financial derivatives by market risk category) should be a supplementary item rather than a standard component.
- Supplementary items:
  - Majority support to include 49 of the 51 recommended supplementary items in BPM7 and to exclude two:
    - Exclude “of which: between affiliates” under financial derivatives (GN D.12).
    - Exclude reverse transactions by type of (lent/borrowed) assets (GN F.3).
- Member concerns and proposals:
  - Feasibility concerns where costs exceed benefits; potential impacts on data quality and confidentiality.
  - Need for practical compilation guidance and assistance: BPM7 Compilation Guide and IMF regional outreach seminars (Phase II update process) recommended.
  - Support for close collaboration with the SNA community to ensure consistency; further user consultation may be relevant for challenging items (e.g., GN F.18 on crypto assets).
  - Agreement that prioritization of supplementary items should depend on each economy’s specific circumstances; no global prioritization to be mandated in the manuals.
  - Support to add BPM7 text to guide national compilers on circumstances under which compiling certain supplementary items is most relevant.

### Key survey statistics and selected GN response averages (preserved)
- Overall survey totals:
  - Gross responses: 125; Consolidated responses used in summary: 95; Cost assessments: 3,123; Benefit assessments: 2,201; Economies: 71.
- Selected GN item averages (Benefit; Cost; Difference):
  - C.2 Breakdown of goods trade by industry — SI: Benefits 3.7 (46); Costs 2.9 (65); Difference 0.8.
  - C.3 Breakdown of goods by currency — SI: Benefits 3.3 (42); Costs 3.2 (64); Difference 0.1.
  - C.4 Merchanting material inputs item — SI: Benefits 3.2 (41); Costs 4.2 (57); Difference -0.9.
  - D.1 Greenfield DI (total net inward DI) — SI: Benefits 3.6 (42); Costs 3.3 (66); Difference 0.3.
  - D.1 Greenfield DI excluding pass-through funds — SI: Benefits 3.3 (38); Costs 4.1 (58); Difference -0.8.
  - D.6 DI statistics by ultimate investing economy — SI: Benefits 3.8 (41); Costs 3.0 (60); Difference 0.8.
  - D.12 “of which: between affiliates” under derivatives — SI: Benefits 2.9 (34); Costs 4.0 (51); Difference -1.1.
  - F.2 Reinvested earnings for portfolio investment — SI: Benefits 3.1 (36); Costs 3.9 (49); Difference -0.8.
  - F.4 Financial derivatives by market risk category — SC: Benefits 3.1 (36); Costs 3.7 (48); Difference -0.5.
  - F.6 OFC breakdown: Pension funds — SI: Benefits 3.9 (35); Costs 2.5 (50); Difference 1.4.
  - F.7 Fintech “of which” category — SI: Benefits 3.0 (35); Costs 4.0 (47); Difference -1.0.
  - B.2 Standardized statistical definition of net international reserves — SI: Benefits 3.5 (30); Costs 2.2 (43); Difference 1.3.
  - B.4 Integrated IIP statement — SC: Benefits 4.2 (33); Costs 2.2 (50); Difference 2.0.
  - G.4 Breakdown by SPEs — SI: Benefits 3.4 (32); Costs 2.8 (43); Difference 0.6.
  - G.7 Supplementary cross-border statistics detailed by geography — SI: Benefits 4.0 (33); Costs 3.6 (37); Difference 0.4.

### Clarification notes, task force reports, and GN highlights selected
- Clarification notes (2–11) provide practical recording guidance on topics such as remaining maturity (CN 2), negative interest rates (CN 3), reserve position in the IMF (CN 4), central bank swap arrangements (CN 5), precious metals accounts (CN 6), sectoral classification of international organizations (CN 7), transfers and loan agreements of sport players (CN 8), crypto assets (CN 9; status: superseded by GN F.18), freight and insurance in merchanting (CN 10), and participations in capital of international organizations (CN 11; status: superseded by GN B.12).
- Previously Committee-endorsed task force reports were superseded by corresponding GNs (examples: SPEs → GN G.4; Informal economy → GN IE.7; GVCs → GN G.7).
- Selected GN highlights and Committee decisions:
  - GN B.4: center BPM7 on integrated presentation of flows and positions; include integrated IIP statement as a standard component and break down “Other Changes in Volume” into “Reclassifications” and “Debt Cancellation and Write-offs”.
  - GN D.7 / GN D.8: implement sectoral breakdown of DI as standard presentation for equity and debt instruments.
  - GN F.4 / F.5 / F.8: refine classification of financial derivatives, include guidance on CDS, and include supplementary reconciliation of nominal and market valuation of debt securities.
  - GN F.6: introduce supplementary OFC breakdowns (MMFs, non-MMF investment funds, insurance corporations, pension funds, other financial intermediaries, captive financial institutions and money lenders).
  - GN F.7: avoid separate fintech sector; consider “of which” fintech categories and include practical compilation guidance.
  - GN G.4 and GN G.7: adopt international SPE definition (supplementary breakdown) and include GVC description with voluntary supplementary cross-border statistics by geography/product.

### Proposed way forward and decision process
- Outstanding considerations:
  - Some pending issues mainly affect the 2025 SNA (e.g., Digitalization and Wellbeing and Sustainability Task Teams) and may need reflection in BPM7 for consistency.
  - Pending issues are not expected to change the fundamental BPM framework or significantly increase the number of data series to be collected.
- Decision proposal and timetable:
  - Committee to make tentative decisions in the October 2022 meeting on recommendations already agreed on an individual basis to guide BPM7 drafting.
  - Decisions on some recommendations could be revisited later only for compelling reasons (e.g., to ensure consistency with national accounts).
  - Remaining recommendations, as finalized, would be approved by the Committee on an ad-hoc basis to keep the BPM7 timetable on track.
- Collaboration: the note and decisions to be shared with the Advisory Expert Group on National Accounts (AEG) as part of ongoing collaboration on the Manual updates.

*Source: IMF Statistics Department discussion note for the Committee on Balance of Payments Statistics (October 2022).*

### INTRODUCTION

### outcomes-of-the-holistic-review-survey-of-bpm6-update-priorities - INTRODUCTION

### Purpose and context
- The Committee on Balance of Payments Statistics endorsed the process for the holistic review of the Balance of Payments and International Investment Position Manual, sixth edition (BPM6) update priorities in its October 2021 meeting.
- The review is based on recommendations in previously endorsed reports, clarification notes, and BPM and joint BPM/System of National Accounts (SNA) Task Teams’ Guidance Notes (GNs).
- The Advisory Expert Group on National Accounts (AEG) has been informed as achieving full consistency between BPM7 and the System of National Accounts 2025 (2025 SNA) is a key objective.
- IMF’s Statistics Department (STA) prepared a discussion note and two annexes: Annex I (summary of survey responses) and Annex II (summary list of all BPM6 update recommendations with preliminary assessments into three buckets: (i) will be included in BPM7; (ii) will remain on the Committee’s research agenda and be mentioned in BPM7; (iii) will not be included in BPM7 and will be dropped).

### Global survey of ESS compilers and users (July–August 2022)
- Survey design:
  - Focused on new data breakdowns (standard components and supplementary items).
  - ESS compilers provided cost assessments on a 0–5 scale (0 = no costs; 5 = very high costs).
  - Users provided benefit assessments on a 0–5 scale.
- Participation and coverage:
  - Gross total responses: 125.
  - Net total responses after cleaning: 95.
  - Cost assessments provided for 3,123 items.
  - Benefit assessments provided for 2,201 items.
  - Geographic representation: responses from 71 economies.
    - Europe: 26 economies.
    - Asia & Pacific: 12 economies.
    - Western Hemisphere: 12 economies.
    - Africa: 11 economies.
    - Middle East & Central Asia: 10 economies.
  - Institutional representation: mostly central banks, followed by national statistics offices and international organizations; several respondents were both compilers and users.
- Aggregate result patterns:
  - Users assessed benefits of most recommendations as relatively high; cost assessments varied more.
  - In 32 out of 57 cases, the average benefit assessment exceeded the average cost assessment.
  - Conclusion: cost/benefit assessments indicate a solid case for implementing many recommended new data breakdowns to meet core users’ needs at reasonable compilation costs.

### Preliminary assessments — new standard components
- Inclusion criterion: high bar for standard components because they fully contribute to totals and balancing items and are expected to be compiled by economies.
- Survey outcome:
  - Strong case to include five out of six recommended new standard components.
  - Recommendations with significantly higher average benefit than average cost:
    - Split telecommunications, computer, and information services (GN C.6).
    - Split other business services (GN C.6).
    - Add a sectoral breakdown of direct investment (GN D.7).
    - Split nonfinancial corporations, and households and nonprofit institutions serving households (GN F.1).
    - Produce an integrated international investment position statement (GN B.4).
  - The sixth recommendation — breakdown of financial derivatives by market risk category (GN F.4) — had relatively high average cost assessment and less support; proposed change to classify it as a supplementary item rather than a standard component.

### Preliminary assessments — new supplementary items
- Inclusion approach:
  - Lower bar than for standard components; supplementary items are outside standard presentation and may be compiled depending on national circumstances.
  - Recommendations included when (average benefit assessment) minus (average cost assessment) is not below -0.5.
  - Threshold rationale: -0.5 chosen because Task Team ESS experts recommended supplementary items only when clear benefits were identified.
  - Possibility of phased implementation of BPM7 so not all recommendations must be implemented immediately.
- Specific supplementary-item decisions and scores (selected):
  - Current account:
    - GN C.1: adding supplementary items on constructions had benefit-cost score -0.7; construction services -0.6. Proposed inclusion in BPM7 to improve linkages with national accounts.
    - GN C.3: breakdown of services by currency had benefit-cost score -0.6. Proposed inclusion in BPM7 due to importance for core users (e.g., IMF work on dominant currencies and external adjustment).
    - GN C.4: item under net exports of goods to identify material inputs procured by the principal in a global manufacturing arrangement had score -0.9. Proposed inclusion due to increasing importance of such arrangements.
    - GN C.7: travel packages had score -0.6. Proposed inclusion to assist national accounts compilers and price statistics; some economies already compile this at low costs.
  - Direct investment:
    - GN D.1: most recommendations positive; recommendation to exclude pass-through funds from greenfield direct investment had score -0.8 but proposed to keep it as a small part of new supplementary items.
    - GN D.4: corporate inversions score -0.6 but proposed to keep due to high relevance for some economies; BPM6 paragraph 8.20 already mentions supplementary data for corporate inversions.
    - GN D.12: “of which: between affiliates” under financial derivatives had score -1.1; proposed to drop.
  - Financial and payment systems:
    - GN F.2: reinvested earnings for portfolio investment had score -0.8 but proposed to keep as supplementary item because of conceptual desirability and tested estimation strategies in some economies.
    - GN F.3: reverse transactions by type of (lent/borrowed) assets had score -1.0; proposed to drop.
    - GN F.4: change breakdown of financial derivatives by market category to supplementary item and proposed to drop breakdown by trading venue (score -1.2).
    - GN F.7: “of which” categories for fintech companies and instruments had scores -1.0 and -1.1; proposed to drop but include fintech on research agenda.
  - Globalization:
    - GN G.4: breakdown by special purpose entities (SPEs) supported, but nationality-based SPE statistics had benefit-cost score -1.0; proposed to drop nationality-based SPE statistics from BPM7 and keep on research agenda.

### BPM6 update recommendations not included in the global survey
- Proposed inclusion: all recommendations not part of the global survey would be included in BPM7.
- Rationale:
  - These are conceptual recommendations already approved by the Committee and do not lead to new standard components or supplementary items.
  - GNs underwent global consultations where compilers could flag concerns.
  - Complex issues were subject to testing to ensure feasibility.
  - Draft annotated outlines of BPM7 chapters will be posted for global consultation.

### Proposed way forward and decision process
- Outstanding considerations:
  - Some pending issues mainly affect the 2025 SNA (e.g., Digitalization and Wellbeing and Sustainability Task Teams) and may need reflection in BPM7 for consistency.
  - Pending issues are not expected to change the fundamental BPM framework or significantly increase the number of data series to be collected.
- Decision proposal:
  - Committee to make tentative decisions in the October 2022 meeting on recommendations already agreed on an individual basis to guide BPM7 drafting.
  - Decisions on some recommendations could be revisited later only for compelling reasons (e.g., to ensure consistency with national accounts).
  - Remaining recommendations, as finalized, would be approved by the Committee on an ad-hoc basis to keep the BPM7 timetable on track.
- Collaboration: the note and decisions to be shared with the AEG as part of ongoing collaboration on the Manual updates.

### Outcomes of the Committee discussion at the October 2022 meeting
- Committee support (five recommended new standard components to be included in BPM7):
  - Split telecommunications, computer, and information services (GN C.6).
  - Split other business services (GN C.6).
  - Add a sectoral breakdown of direct investment (GN D.7).
  - Split nonfinancial corporations, and households and nonprofit institutions serving households (GN F.1).
  - Produce an integrated international investment position statement (GN B.4).
- Agreement that breakdown of financial derivatives by market risk category (GN F.4) should be included as a supplementary item rather than a standard component.
- Supplementary items:
  - Majority support to include 49 of the 51 recommended supplementary items in BPM7 and to exclude two:
    - Exclude “of which: between affiliates” under financial derivatives (GN D.12).
    - Exclude reverse transactions by type of (lent/borrowed) assets (GN F.3).
- Member concerns and proposals:
  - Concerns about feasibility to implement supplementary items where costs exceed benefits and potential impacts on data quality and confidentiality.
  - Emphasis on need for practical compilation guidance and assistance, including a BPM7 Compilation Guide and IMF regional outreach seminars (Phase II update process).
  - Support for close collaboration with the SNA community to ensure consistency; further user consultation may be relevant for challenging items (e.g., GN F.18 on crypto assets).
  - Agreement that prioritization of supplementary items should depend on each economy’s specific circumstances; no global prioritization to be mandated in the manuals.
  - Support to add BPM7 text to guide national compilers on circumstances under which compiling certain supplementary items is most relevant.

*Source: IMF Statistics Department discussion note for the Committee on Balance of Payments Statistics (October 2022).*

### Annex I. Summary of Responses to the Survey for t he Holistic Review of BP M6 Update Priorities

### Annex I. Summary of Responses to the Survey for the Holistic Review of BPM6 Update Priorities

### Who Responded to the Survey?
- Gross total number of responses: 125.
- After removing duplicates and consolidating multiple assessments per economy/institution (averaging rounded assessments on a scale from 0 to 5), number of consolidated responses included in the summary: 95.
- Consolidated responses represent a total of 3,123 cost assessments and 2,201 benefit assessments.
- Geographic representation: responses from 71 economies.
  - Europe: 26 economies
  - Asia & Pacific: 12 economies
  - Western Hemisphere: 12 economies
  - Africa: 11 economies
  - Middle East & Central Asia: 10 economies
- Institutional representation (number of consolidated responses by institution and role):
  - Central bank: Compiler 33, User 3, Both Compiler and User 18; Total 54
  - National statistics office: Compiler 6, User 9, Both Compiler and User 3; Total 18
  - Central bank/national statistics office (joint responses from compilers): Compiler 1, User 0, Both Compiler and User 9; Total 10
  - International organization: Compiler 1, User 7, Both Compiler and User 2; Total 10
  - Other public sector institution: Compiler 0, User 0, Both Compiler and User 3; Total 3
  - Total: Compiler 41, User 19, Both 35; Grand total 95
- Both compilers and users are well represented; several respondents identified as both.

### Summary of Responses: Current Account (selected items and averages)
- Notes: Type codes — SC = standard component; SI = supplementary item. Benefits/costs are average assessments on a scale from 0 (no benefits/costs) to 5 (very high benefits/costs). Difference = average benefit minus average cost (non-rounded averages).
- Selected GN items with average benefit (number of responses), average cost (number of responses), and difference:
  - C.1 Add personal, cultural, and recreation services (acquired by travelers) — SI: Benefits 2.7 (44); Costs 3.1 (61); Difference -0.4
  - C.1 Add constructions — SI: Benefits 2.8 (45); Costs 3.5 (60); Difference -0.7
  - C.1 Add construction services — SI: Benefits 2.8 (45); Costs 3.3 (62); Difference -0.6
  - C.2 Breakdown of goods trade by industry — SI: Benefits 3.7 (46); Costs 2.9 (65); Difference 0.8
  - C.2 Breakdown of services trade by industry — SI: Benefits 3.6 (46); Costs 3.1 (64); Difference 0.5
  - C.3 Breakdown of goods by currency — SI: Benefits 3.3 (42); Costs 3.2 (64); Difference 0.1
  - C.3 Breakdown of services by currency — SI: Benefits 3.3 (43); Costs 3.8 (64); Difference -0.6
  - C.4 Add item under general merchandise to identify trade in goods within a global manufacturing arrangement — SI: Benefits 3.4 (43); Costs 3.9 (57); Difference -0.5
  - C.4 Add item under net exports of goods under merchanting to identify material inputs procured by the principal in a global manufacturing arrangement from third parties and sold to the contractor — SI: Benefits 3.2 (41); Costs 4.2 (57); Difference -0.9
  - C.6 Split telecommunications, computer, and information services — SC: Benefits 3.7 (42); Costs 1.2 (69); Difference 2.5
  - C.6 Split other business services — SC: Benefits 3.7 (42); Costs 1.5 (68); Difference 2.3
  - C.7 Add travel packages — SI: Benefits 2.8 (45); Costs 3.5 (61); Difference -0.6

### Summary of Responses: Direct Investment (selected items)
- D.1 Greenfield direct investment (total net inward DI) — SI: Benefits 3.6 (42); Costs 3.3 (66); Difference 0.3
- D.1 Greenfield DI (excluding pass-through funds) — SI: Benefits 3.3 (38); Costs 4.1 (58); Difference -0.8
- D.1 Greenfield DI (additional information on reinvested earnings) — SI: Benefits 3.5 (41); Costs 3.5 (64); Difference 0.0
- D.1 Greenfield DI (economy of immediate investor) — SI: Benefits 3.5 (40); Costs 3.2 (62); Difference 0.3
- D.1 Greenfield DI (economy of ultimate investor) — SI: Benefits 3.6 (40); Costs 3.9 (64); Difference -0.3
- D.4 Provide statistics on corporate inversions — SI: Benefits 3.2 (41); Costs 3.8 (59); Difference -0.6
- D.6 DI statistics by ultimate investing economy — SI: Benefits 3.8 (41); Costs 3.0 (60); Difference 0.8
- DI statistics that look through SPEs to the first operating unit — SI: Benefits 3.6 (38); Costs 4.0 (55); Difference -0.4
- DI statistics identifying pass-through funds — SI: Benefits 3.6 (37); Costs 4.0 (54); Difference -0.4
- D.7 Sectoral breakdown of DI — SC: Benefits 3.7 (43); Costs 2.0 (67); Difference 1.7
- D.12 Include “of which: between affiliates” item under financial derivatives — SI: Benefits 2.9 (34); Costs 4.0 (51); Difference -1.1

### Summary of Responses: Financial and Payments Systems (selected items)
- F.1 Split nonfinancial corporations, and households and nonprofit institutions serving households — SC: Benefits 3.6 (29); Costs 2.4 (52); Difference 1.2
- F.2 Reinvested earnings for portfolio investment — SI: Benefits 3.1 (36); Costs 3.9 (49); Difference -0.8
- F.3 Reverse transactions by type of (lent/borrowed) assets — SI: Benefits 2.8 (32); Costs 3.8 (47); Difference -1.0
- F.4 Financial derivatives by market risk category — SC: Benefits 3.1 (36); Costs 3.7 (48); Difference -0.5
  - Financial derivatives by instrument — SI: Benefits 3.1 (36); Costs 3.3 (49); Difference -0.2
  - Financial derivatives by trading venue — SI: Benefits 2.8 (36); Costs 4.0 (46); Difference -1.2
- F.6 OFC breakdown: Money market funds (MMFs) — SI: Benefits 3.6 (36); Costs 2.7 (51); Difference 0.8
  - OFC breakdown: Non-MMF investment funds — SI: Benefits 3.7 (35); Costs 2.8 (49); Difference 0.9
  - OFC breakdown: Insurance corporations — SI: Benefits 3.7 (36); Costs 2.4 (51); Difference 1.3
  - OFC breakdown: Pension funds — SI: Benefits 3.9 (35); Costs 2.5 (50); Difference 1.4
  - OFC breakdown: Other financial intermediaries — SI: Benefits 3.7 (36); Costs 2.7 (50); Difference 1.0
  - OFC breakdown: Other financial intermediaries (of which: central clearing counterparties) — SI: Benefits 3.3 (34); Costs 3.2 (45); Difference 0.2
  - OFC breakdown: Captive financial institutions and money lenders, and financial auxiliaries — SI: Benefits 3.5 (34); Costs 2.9 (48); Difference 0.6
- F.7 Introduce “of which” category for fintech companies within the subsector classification — SI: Benefits 3.0 (35); Costs 4.0 (47); Difference -1.0
  - Introduce “of which” category for instruments or services classifications where necessary to separate out fintech-related instruments and services — SI: Benefits 3.0 (35); Costs 4.2 (47); Difference -1.1
- F.8 Debt securities at nominal value — SI: Benefits 3.4 (36); Costs 2.7 (52); Difference 0.7
  - Introduce table to reconcile nominal and market valuation of debt securities liabilities — SI: Benefits 3.3 (36); Costs 3.2 (49); Difference 0.0
  - Direct investment inter-company lending (as supplement to the reconciliation table) — SI: Benefits 3.3 (35); Costs 3.3 (48); Difference -0.1

### Summary of Responses: General Principles, Structural, and Cross-Cutting Issues (selected items)
- B.2 Introduce standardized statistical definition of net international reserve — SI: Benefits 3.5 (30); Costs 2.2 (43); Difference 1.3
- B.4 Produce an integrated international investment position statement — SC: Benefits 4.2 (33); Costs 2.2 (50); Difference 2.0
- Break down “other changes in volume” into two supplementary “of which” categories—“reclassifications” and “debt cancellation and write offs” — SI: Benefits 3.8 (33); Costs 3.6 (50); Difference 0.2
- B.6 Geographical and industrial sector breakdowns of DI — SI: Benefits 3.6 (35); Costs 2.9 (47); Difference 0.7
- Introduce “of which” category to identify green bonds — SI: Benefits 3.6 (33); Costs 3.5 (43); Difference 0.1

### Summary of Responses: Globalization (selected items)
- G.4 Breakdown by special purpose entities (SPEs) — SI: Benefits 3.4 (32); Costs 2.8 (43); Difference 0.6
- Nationality-based SPE statistics — SI: Benefits 3.3 (31); Costs 4.2 (41); Difference -1.0
- G.7 Supplementary cross-border statistics detailed by geography — SI: Benefits 4.0 (33); Costs 3.6 (37); Difference 0.4
  - Supplementary cross-border statistics detailed by product — SI: Benefits 3.9 (32); Costs 4.0 (37); Difference -0.1

### Detailed Findings and Select Questionnaire Results (excerpts)
- Guidance Note C.1 (transactor-based components: travel, construction, government goods and services not included elsewhere)
  - Cost assessment averages (supplementary data scale 0–5):
    - Personal, cultural, and recreation services (acquired by travelers): Average 3.1 (counts: 6 responses at 0; 1 at 1; 9 at 2; 19 at 3; 16 at 4; 10 at 5)
    - Constructions: Average 3.5 (counts: 2 at 0; 2 at 1; 7 at 2; 13 at 3; 25 at 4; 11 at 5)
    - Construction services: Average 3.3 (counts: 4 at 0; 3 at 1; 7 at 2; 13 at 3; 24 at 4; 11 at 5)
  - Benefit assessment averages:
    - Personal, cultural, and recreation services (acquired by travelers): Average 2.7 (counts: 4 at 0; 6 at 1; 4 at 2; 17 at 3; 10 at 4; 3 at 5)
    - Constructions: Average 2.8 (counts: 3 at 0; 5 at 1; 9 at 2; 14 at 3; 11 at 4; 3 at 5)
    - Construction services: Average 2.8 (counts: 3 at 0; 5 at 1; 8 at 2; 16 at 3; 10 at 4; 3 at 5)
- Guidance Note C.2 (goods, services, and investment income by enterprise characteristics)
  - Cost assessment averages for annual breakdowns by industry/ownership/firm size (goods, services, investment income) — selected averages:
    - Goods trade by Industry: Average 2.9
    - Goods trade by Ownership: Average 3.3
    - Goods trade by Firm size: Average 3.1
    - Services trade by Industry: Average 3.1
    - Services trade by Ownership: Average 3.4
    - Services trade by Firm size: Average 3.3
    - Investment income by Industry: Average 3.4
    - Investment income by Ownership: Average 3.7
    - Investment income by Firm size: Average 3.7
  - Benefit assessment averages for corresponding breakdowns — selected averages:
    - Goods trade by Industry: Average 3.7
    - Goods trade by Ownership: Average 3.5
    - Goods trade by Firm size: Average 3.3
    - Services trade by Industry: Average 3.6
    - Services trade by Ownership: Average 3.5
    - Services trade by Firm size: Average 3.4
    - Investment income by Industry: Average 3.5
    - Investment income by Ownership: Average 3.5
    - Investment income by Firm size: Average 3.3
- Guidance Note C.3 (international trade classified by currency)
  - Cost assessment averages:
    - Recommendation 1 (goods broken down by currency): Average 3.2 (counts: 7 at 0; 3 at 1; 9 at 2; 13 at 3; 18 at 4; 14 at 5)
    - Recommendation 2 (services broken down by currency): Average 3.8 (counts: 5 at 0; 0 at 1; 4 at 2; 10 at 3; 19 at 4; 26 at 5)
  - Benefit assessment averages:
    - Recommendation 1 (goods): Average 3.3 (counts: 1 at 0; 5 at 1; 2 at 2; 13 at 3; 16 at 4; 5 at 5)
    - Recommendation 2 (services): Average 3.3 (counts: 1 at 0; 4 at 1; 3 at 2; 14 at 3; 17 at 4; 4 at 5)
- Guidance Note C.4 (merchanting and factoryless producers)
  - Cost assessment averages:
    - Adding supplementary item under General Merchandise to identify trade in goods within a global manufacturing arrangement: Average 3.9 (counts: 1 at 0; 2 at 1; 2 at 2; 11 at 3; 19 at 4; 22 at 5)
    - Adding supplementary item under Net exports of goods under Merchanting to identify material inputs procured by the principal in a global manufacturing arrangement from third parties and sold to the contractor: Average 4.2 (counts: 0 at 0; 2 at 1; 0 at 2; 10 at 3; 19 at 4; 26 at 5)
  - Benefit assessment averages:
    - General Merchandise item: Average 3.4 (counts: 2 at 0; 3 at 1; 1 at 2; 10 at 3; 23 at 4; 4 at 5)
    - Merchanting material inputs item: Average 3.2 (counts: 4 at 0; 2 at 1; 2 at 2; 9 at 3; 20 at 4; 4 at 5)
- Guidance Note C.6 (trade in services classifications)
  - Cost assessment averages:
    - Recommendation 1 (Split Telecommunications, computer, and information services): Average 1.2 (counts: 34 at 0; 8 at 1; 11 at 2; 11 at 3; 5 at 4; 0 at 5)
    - Recommendation 2 (Split Other business services): Average 1.5 (counts: 29 at 0; 8 at 1; 9 at 2; 14 at 3; 8 at 4; 0 at 5)
  - Benefit assessment averages:
    - Recommendation 1 (Split Telecommunications, computer, and information services): Average 3.7 (counts: 0 at 0; 1 at 1; 2 at 2; 13 at 3; 18 at 4; 8 at 5)
    - Recommendation 2 (Split Other business services): Average 3.7 (counts: 0 at 0; 1 at 1; 2 at 2; 12 at 3; 19 at 4; 8 at 5)
- Guidance Note C.7 (treatment of travel packages)
  - Cost assessment (recording travel packages as a separate supplementary line): Average 3.5 (counts: 3 at 0; 4 at 1; 6 at 2; 8 at 3; 28 at 4; 12 at 5)
  - Benefit assessment (recording travel packages as a separate supplementary line): Average 2.8 (counts: 2 at 0; 4 at 1; 8 at 2; 19 at 3; 9 at 4; 3 at 5)

*Annex I. Summary of Responses to the Survey for the Holistic Review of BPM6 Update Priorities*

### 11. Please f eel free to elaborate on your responses related to the current account (optional):

### 11. Please f eel free to elaborate on your responses related to the current account (optional):

### General comments
- Costs will differ across countries, depending on current collection tools, but generally such changes are key to improve analysis of the external sector.
- The costs are very high if we would have to modify the current surveys, or carry out new ones, to comply with the proposed disaggregation (this comment applies mainly t o the case of services).
- Since we have full consistency with the national accounts, it will be important that cross-cutting issues, such as the treatment of travel packages, are fully coordinated with the national accounts, and thus the SNA (and f or our purpose the ESA as well).
- Even if data are available from the Statistical Office, new data reception, compilation, and reporting by new entities implicate high costs and IT developments.
- We welcome the effort to launch this consultation, which will provide valuable information for the preparation of the BPM7 drafting. At the same time, we see the relevance of undertaking a similar exercise in due time to cover other GNs that are not included here because a conclusion has not yet been reached on the specific dataset to require. Moreover, we think that this exercise should be applied to other GNs that even though might not entail substantial data requirements they refer to controversial issues where information on benefits, together with costs, would help take an appropriate decision. We also suggest that the holistic review that will be based on this survey -and possible extensions- is undertaken jointly with the national accounts community, so that the objective of achieving full consistency between the (digital) manuals, with identical texts where appropriate, is ensured.
- In the current account, it is convenient to have the openings indicated (such as new breakdowns) both in goods, services, and investment, for the preparation of the Supply and Use Tables with the purpose of better and more accurately considering the impacts of globalization.

### Comments related to specific Guidance Notes (GNs)
- GN C.1
  - Would require the alternative presentation in travel as standard presentation with further detail and especially further details in the services questionnaire. Therefore, the costs would be high, and we do not see respective data needs.
- GN C.2
  - Enterprise characteristics are not part of BPM methodology but are enterprise statistics. For goods, data by enterprise are not available to the BoP compiler in our country, they are part of Merchandise Statistics, and the Goods Account cannot be broken down to the enterprise level. Portfolio investment income relies on the sec-by-sec data model, which is designed for BoP purposes. To transfer results to the enterprise level will be highly resource intensive.
  - Our trade statistics have undergone major redevelopment in recent year, so most elements are currently available. There would be high costs involved in developing the breakdowns for investment income for both the central bank and statistical office. Investment income is presented by f unctional category and broken down by sector. The sector breakdown goes some way to providing an industry break down already. Overall, we do not see the benefits of such breakdowns.
- GN C.3
  - Data by currency are not available for the goods account but only for Merchandise Statistics. Data by currency for the services account are relevant for Central Banks but require in-depth data analysis and high co mpilation costs.
- GN C.4
  - Information on goods within global manufacturing arrangements are already included in our BoP. They are compiled from I/O analysis and require in-depth data analysis. We do not think that merchanting can or should be interfered with inputs in global manufacturing arrangements as merchanting does not involve any production arrangements, but the goods are rather traded without any changes in product.
  - This GN recommends not only the addition of supplementary items stated in this survey but also a change of item under which FGP-type transactions should be recorded—from "net exports of goods under merchanting" (i.e., net recording of sales minus acquisition) to "general merchandise" (i.e., gross recording of exports and imports). Transactions that may be classified as FGP-type transactions as defined in the GN are often conducted not only by so-called FGPs but also by traditional manufacturers. A change in the recording of merchanting transactions by traditional manufacturers from current "net" to proposed "gross" recording would involve a si gnificant cost and would substantially increase both exports and imports to cause a break in time-series data. Besides, even if transactions solely by so-called FGPs—not including the traditional manufactures—should be recognized as "FGP-type transactions," it would be rather costly to distinguish such transactions and to collect relevant data.
- GN C.7
  - The compilation of travel packages is one of the most challenging issues in the services account. It is dif ficult to disentangle the single components and to attribute them to the various services items. It is also difficult to get hold of the correct counterpart countries, which are sometime even unknown to the respondents. As there is no single co unterpart in travel packages and as they also may include resident-to-resident transactions, an “of which” position in BoP can only be stated globally.
  - For the time being, NA treats travel packages as a single product as foreseen by SNA. In case of revision of BPM7/SNA rules, it is possible to implement the new provisions with low costs.
  - Skimming this GN, the benefits of recording travel packages as a separate supplementary line were not very clear.

### DIRECT INVESTMENT — Guidance Note D.1: Greenfield Investment and Extension of Capacity
- Definition and collection recommendations:
  - Broader definition: greenfield DI is both investment in new direct investment enterprises (DIEs) (narrow definition) and new capital injections/extension of capacity (broader definition) into existing DIEs.
  - Compilers encouraged to collect inward greenfield investments and extension of capacity as part of DI transactions as a supplementary series under DI using “the transactions approach” (breaking down DI transactions by M&As; greenfield investment; extension of capacity; residual category including financial restructuring).
  - Countries should collect these data for both equity and debt instruments, exclude “pass-through” funds if possible, record on net inward DI, and ideally collect breakdowns by industry of the DIE and geographical breakdown of the (ultimate) investor. Compilers should also provide additional information on reinvested earnings (RIE) if possible.
- 12a. Assessment of costs associated with compiling supplementary statistics on greenfield DI transactions (rows preserve response counts and averages exactly):
  - Total net inward DI: 5 1 7 17 26 10 3.3
  - Excluding pass-through funds: 0 2 2 8 24 22 4.1
  - Additional information on reinvested earnings: 4 2 6 14 22 16 3.5
  - Economy of immediate investor: 7 2 7 15 17 14 3.2
  - Economy of ultimate investor: 1 1 4 14 24 20 3.9
- 12b. Assessment of benefits associated with supplementary statistics on greenfield DI transactions:
  - Total net inward DI: 3 1 2 8 18 10 3.6
  - Excluding pass-through funds: 3 2 4 8 15 6 3.3
  - Additional information on reinvested earnings: 3 1 3 9 15 10 3.5
  - Economy of immediate investor: 3 1 2 8 18 8 3.5
  - Economy of ultimate investor: 3 1 1 10 15 10 3.6

### DIRECT INVESTMENT — Guidance Note D.4: Corporate Inversions
- Recommended inclusions:
  - Taxonomy of usual cases of corporate actions involving inversions and restructurings with similar economic effects.
  - Official definition of corporate inversion: “A corporate inversion describes the corporate restructuring of a transnational enterprise group such that the original parent company in one economy that is the ultimate parent of the corporate group becomes a subsidiary of the new parent in another economy. In addition, ownership of a group of enterprises may be shifted to the new parent company.”
  - Strengthened guidance on compiling supplementary statistics covering transactions, positions, and income of corporate inversions for relevant economies.
- 13a. Assessment of costs associated with providing supplementary statistics for corporate inversions:
  - Responses: 1 0, 1 1, 3 2, 13 3, 26 4, 15 5
  - Average: 3.8
- 13b. Assessment of benefits associated with providing supplementary statistics for corporate inversions:
  - Responses: 1 0, 3 1, 2 2, 18 3, 15 4, 2 5
  - Average: 3.2

### DIRECT INVESTMENT — Guidance Note D.6: Ultimate Investing Economy/Ultimate Host Economy and Pass-through Funds
- Recommendations:
  - Recommendation 1 (UIE): Define UIE based on control of the group (align with “Winner Takes All”) and develop a supplementary presentation of DI statistics by UIE.
  - Recommendation 2 (UHE): Develop a supplementary presentation of DI statistics that looks through SPEs to the first operating unit as a first step in presenting DI statistics by UHE.
  - Recommendation 3 (pass-through funds): Streamline the definition of pass-through funds and develop a supplementary presentation of DI statistics identifying pass-through funds based on residency of the ultimate investor.
- 14a. Assessment of costs associated with implementing recommendations:
  - Recommendation 1 (supplementary presentation of DI statistics by UIE): 8 5 8 11 16 12 3.0
  - Recommendation 2 (supplementary presentation of DI statistics that looks through SPEs to the first operating unit): 1 4 2 7 16 25 4.0
  - Recommendation 3 (supplementary presentation of DI statistics identifying pass-through funds): 0 2 2 10 19 21 4.0
- 14b. Assessment of benefits associated with implementing recommendations:
  - Recommendation 1 (supplementary presentation of DI statistics by UIE): 1 1 1 6 25 7 3.8
  - Recommendation 2 (supplementary presentation of DI statistics that looks through SPEs to the first operating unit): 2 1 1 9 20 5 3.6
  - Recommendation 3 (supplementary presentation of DI statistics identifying pass-through funds): 2 0 1 10 19 5 3.6

### DIRECT INVESTMENT — Guidance Note D.7: Sectoral Breakdown of Direct Investment
- Proposal:
  - Implement a sectoral breakdown of DI (central bank; deposit-taking corporations, except the central bank; general government; other financial corporations; nonfinancial corporations; households, and nonprofit institutions serving households) as part of the standard presentation in the balance of payments and the IIP, for both equity and debt instruments and applied to reinvested earnings for total equity investment. Maintain BPM6 standard components used to derive directional values within DI as memorandum items.
- 15a. Assessment of costs associated with incorporating a sectoral breakdown of DI:
  - Responses: 13 0, 14 1, 14 2, 17 3, 3 4, 6 5
  - Average: 2.0
- 15b. Assessment of benefits associated with incorporating a sectoral breakdown of DI:
  - Responses: 0 0, 0 1, 6 2, 11 3, 17 4, 9 5
  - Average: 3.7

### DIRECT INVESTMENT — Guidance Note D.12: Including Intra-Concern [Between Affiliates] Derivatives in Direct Investment
- Recommendation:
  - Continue to report intra-concern derivatives in the financial derivatives functional category but add a supplementary “of which: between affiliates” item so intra-concern financial derivatives can be separately identified.
- 16a. Assessment of costs associated with providing a supplementary “of which: between affiliates” item under financial derivatives:
  - Responses: 1 0, 1 1, 4 2, 6 3, 17 4, 22 5
  - Average: 4.0
- 16b. Assessment of benefits associated with having a supplementary “of which: between affiliates” item under financial derivatives:
  - Responses: 2 0, 3 1, 5 2, 10 3, 13 4, 1 5
  - Average: 2.9

*Source: IMF survey Outcomes of the Holistic Review of BPM6 update priorities.*

### 17. Please f eel free to elaborate on your responses related to direct investment (optional):

### Outcomes of the Holistic Review Survey of BPM6 Update Priorities — 17. Please feel free to elaborate on your responses related to direct investment (optional)

### General comments
- New data requests regarding FDI are manifold; prioritization in implementing new methodologies and presentations is necessary to avoid rising asymmetries between respondents.
- International guidance is needed to harmonize approaches across respondents; otherwise asymmetries will rise.
- For some new data requests, data sources are not yet available or are in a testing phase (derivatives); cost assessments are preliminary—especially for financial derivatives. The foremost task should be to develop the compilation of the standard presentation in BoP further before raising new data requests.
- Important to include breakdowns to identify the new gross capital formation originated by direct investment, and the investments made through different subsidiaries of the parent company, identifying the countries from which these investments are made.
- FDI data come from the foreign private capital survey (annual and quarterly surveys); new data requirements will require adjustments to survey questionnaires and capacity building for enumerators.
- When micro data are needed and not readily available from alternative sources, implementation costs are usually very high. Changing a survey and implementing all changes in the synthesis process is a long and costly process.
- Further breakdown of DI statistics is important for understanding and policy analysis, but data availability and response burden should be seriously considered.

### Comments related to specific Guidance Notes

- GN D.1 (Greenfield, extensions, breakdowns)
  - Recording greenfield investment and extension of capacity on net inward DI is recommended, but gross basis data are considered more useful than net basis data because net basis records capital injection minus withdrawals and does not allow observing the amount of greenfield investment flow into the invested economy. Recommendation: greenfield investment should be recorded on gross basis.
  - Greenfield investment and extension of capacity are breakdowns of equity investment; an additional breakdown by economy of investor will induce confidentiality problems.
  - Producing greenfield FDI estimates using the transactions approach would require a whole new survey to collect details on transactions per affiliate rather than the consolidated information collected at present; increase in response burden would likely be prohibitive. Attempts to collect this directly on the current survey yielded less than 5% response to the new questions.
  - Shifting greenfield statistics from the capital approach to the transactions approach would be very costly and result in decreased utility for data users. Currently publish greenfield DI by both immediate and ultimate investor according to the capital approach.
  - Breaking down FDI flows into "M&As", "greenfield investment", "extension of capital" and "restructurings" is popular among analysts but these concepts as currently defined are not necessarily operational in official statistics; distinctions (e.g., greenfield vs. extensions of capital; intra-group restructurings vs. M&As) are often difficult in practice. Analytically useful would be segregating M&A-related FDI transactions (transactions between an acquirer/receiver and a seller/transferor of assets in DI enterprises) from genuine capital injections/withdrawals in/from the target DI enterprise (transactions where the DI enterprise is the actual counterpart).

- GN D.4 (Corporate inversions)
  - Benefit would be high if corporate inversions are important in the reporting economy.

- GN D.6 (Look-through SPEs; UBO/UIE methods; identification of UIE/UHE/pass-through funds)
  - Recommendation on look-through SPEs to the first operating unit is N/A for the respondent because it exceeds the national compiler; international coordination, data sharing and implementation of LEI as an identifier would be necessary.
  - Current practice: proportional method for determining the UBO (UIE) in the BOP DI statistics. The proportional method is described in D.6 as conceptually more accurate; the Winner-Takes-All approach was recommended for pragmatic ease of implementation. Switching methods would be very costly and result in less accurate statistics.
  - Emphasis on relevance of recommendations in D.6 to identify UIE, UHE, and pass-through funds; such information would help identify ultimate ownership and disentangle proper FDI flows from mere pass-through, aiding analysis of globalization effects and MNEs. Notes interlinkages with G.2 Treatment of MNE and Intra-MNE Flows and recommendations on identification of foreign-controlled corporations and corporations that are part of domestic MNE groups.

- GN D.7 (Sectoral breakdown)
  - Sectoral breakdown can be produced internally; costs would come from updating internal reporting systems, adapting output tables and systems to complete reporting templates.
  - Less benefit seen in providing sectoral breakdown for DI because the majority is in private non-financial corporations.
  - Refining sectoral categorization to distinguish public enterprises from private enterprises would be very helpful.

- GN D.12 (DI intra-concern derivatives)
  - Consolidated results by country and industry for non-MFIs are collected, so intra-concern derivatives are included in reported values without separate identification.
  - FDI information on MFIs is collected by central bank and consolidated in reported values for FDI statistics.
  - Unclear what benefit external users would gain from having intra-concern derivatives as a supplementary series.
  - GN states it is beneficial to separate affiliates’ derivatives in DI because they may behave atypically and differ from market terms; summing affiliates’ derivatives together and presenting them in one line under financial derivatives, while beneficial, does not completely address the GN concern.

### Financial and payments systems — selected guidance note survey responses and statistics

- Guidance Note F.1: More Disaggregated Institutional Sector and Financial Instrument Breakdowns
  - Question 18a: Costs associated with splitting nonfinancial corporations, and households & NPISH?
    - Responses: 11 0, 6 1, 6 2, 15 3, 7 4, 7 5
    - Average: 2.4
  - Question 18b: Benefits associated with splitting nonfinancial corporations, and households & NPISH?
    - Responses: 0 0, 0 1, 2 2, 10 3, 14 4, 3 5
    - Average: 3.6

- Guidance Note F.2: Asymmetric Treatment of Retained Earnings (supplementary information on portfolio investment RIE)
  - Question 19a: Costs associated with providing supplementary information on portfolio investment RIE?
    - Responses: 0 0, 2 1, 3 2, 11 3, 14 4, 19 5
    - Average: 3.9
  - Question 19b: Benefits associated with receiving supplementary information on portfolio investment RIE?
    - Responses: 2 0, 4 1, 4 2, 9 3, 13 4, 4 5
    - Average: 3.1

- Guidance Note F.3: Reverse Transactions (supplementary information by type of lent/borrowed assets)
  - Question 20a: Costs associated with providing supplementary information on reverse transactions by type of (lent/borrowed) assets?
    - Responses: 1 0, 1 1, 3 2, 9 3, 21 4, 12 5
    - Average: 3.8
  - Question 20b: Benefits associated with receiving supplementary information on reverse transactions by type of (lent/borrowed) assets?
    - Responses: 2 0, 3 1, 4 2, 15 3, 6 4, 2 5
    - Average: 2.8

- Guidance Note F.4: Financial Derivatives by Type (recommended classifications and assessment)
  - Recommended classifications:
    - (a) by market risk category (foreign exchange; single-currency interest rate; equity; commodity; credit; others) — standard component
    - (b) by instrument (options; forwards and related instruments; futures; swaps; credit derivatives; marketable employee stock options and other instruments) — supplementary
    - (c) by trading venue (exchange traded; over the counter (cleared); over the counter (not cleared)) — supplementary
  - Question 21a: Costs associated with implementing the recommendations (Breakdown by: Market risk category; Instrument; Trading venue)
    - Market risk category (standard component): responses 2 1 3 13 14 15 — Average: 3.7
    - Instrument (supplementary): responses 4 2 8 7 17 11 — Average: 3.3
    - Trading venue (supplementary): responses 1 1 2 9 14 19 — Average: 4.0
  - Question 21b: Benefits associated with implementing the recommendations
    - Market risk category (standard component): responses 3 1 4 12 12 4 — Average: 3.1
    - Instrument (supplementary): responses 3 1 4 12 13 3 — Average: 3.1
    - Trading venue (supplementary): responses 4 1 7 15 6 3 — Average: 2.8

- Guidance Note F.6: Capturing Non-Bank Financial Intermediation (OFC breakdowns)
  - Question 22a: Costs associated with providing further supplementary breakdowns of OFCs
    - Money market funds (MMFs): responses 12 3 5 10 10 11 — Average: 2.7
    - Non-MMF investment funds: responses 11 2 6 8 11 11 — Average: 2.8
    - Insurance corporations: responses 10 5 9 15 5 7 — Average: 2.4
    - Pension funds: responses 8 5 12 13 5 7 — Average: 2.5
    - Other financial intermediaries: responses 11 2 9 10 7 11 — Average: 2.7
    - Other financial intermediaries (of which: central clearing counterparties): responses 5 2 8 9 8 13 — Average: 3.2
    - Captive financial institutions and money lenders, and financial auxiliaries: responses 8 2 8 8 11 11 — Average: 2.9
  - Question 22b: Benefits associated with having further supplementary breakdowns of OFCs
    - Money market funds (MMFs): responses 1 2 3 9 12 9 — Average: 3.6
    - Non-MMF investment funds: responses 0 1 4 10 11 9 — Average: 3.7
    - Insurance corporations: responses 1 2 1 7 16 9 — Average: 3.7
    - Pension funds: responses 0 1 2 7 15 10 — Average: 3.9
    - Other financial intermediaries: responses 1 1 2 10 13 9 — Average: 3.7
    - Other financial intermediaries (of which: central clearing counterparties): responses 0 4 4 10 9 7 — Average: 3.3
    - Captive financial institutions and money lenders, and financial auxiliaries: responses 0 2 4 10 10 8 — Average: 3.5

- Guidance Note F.7: Impact of Fintech on Macroeconomic Statistics
  - Recommendation: existing international statistical standards allow proper treatment of fintech activities in most cases; introduce a supplementary “of which” category for fintech companies within the subsector classification if a country has strong need to identify them separately; consider “of which” for instruments or services classifications where necessary (e.g., CBDCs, crypto assets, fintech platform services).
  - Question 23a: Costs associated with implementing the recommendations
    - Introduction of a supplementary “of which” category for fintech companies within the subsector classification: responses 0 0 1 12 18 16 — Average: 4.0
    - Introduction of a supplementary “of which” category for instruments or services classifications where necessary: responses 0 0 1 9 18 19 — Average: 4.2
  - Question 23b: Benefits associated with implementing the recommendations
    - Introduction of a supplementary “of which” category for fintech companies within the subsector classification: responses 3 2 3 12 13 2 — Average: 3.0
    - Introduction of a supplementary “of which” category for instruments or services classifications where necessary: responses 3 2 3 13 11 3 — Average: 3.0

- Guidance Note F.8: Valuation of Debt Securities at Both Market and Nominal Value
  - Recommendation: include explicit guidance to compile stocks of debt securities at nominal value as a supplement to market valuation; strengthen recommendation to compile securities liabilities using both market and nominal values; adopt a supplementary presentation table reconciling nominal and market valuation of debt securities liabilities; report debt securities used in DI inter-company lending as a supplementary item.
  - Question 24a: Costs associated with implementing the recommendations
    - Nominal values: responses 6 8 5 15 13 5 — Average: 2.7
    - Reconciliation table: responses 1 5 6 14 16 7 — Average: 3.2
    - Direct investment inter-company lending (as supplement to the table): responses 3 2 5 13 16 9 — Average: 3.3
  - Question 24b: Benefits associated with implementing the recommendations
    - Nominal values: responses 1 2 4 7 18 4 — Average: 3.4
    - Reconciliation table: responses 1 2 4 10 18 1 — Average: 3.3
    - Direct investment inter-company lending (as supplement to the table): responses 1 2 7 6 15 4 — Average: 3.3

*Outcomes of the Holistic Review Survey of BPM6 Update Priorities, IMF.*

### 25. Please f eel free to elaborate on your responses related to financial and payments systems (optional):

### Outcomes of the Holistic Review Survey of BPM6 Update Priorities — Financial, Payments, General Principles, and Globalization (Q25–32)

### Financial and payments systems — general comments and GN-specific observations
- General observations:
  - Some required new details (e.g., additional sectoral breakdown) are in line with the G-20 Data Gaps Initiative.
  - Fintech-related new details lack international guidance for classifying and capturing respective entities and instruments (crypto assets).
  - A revised definition of debt is considered necessary due to a contradiction about SDR: "SDR allocations is considered debt, but that is not the case in an analysis of debt sustainability."
  - High costs to comply with proposed recommendations originate from limitations in sources of information; implementation requires processing information that captures requested transaction and position types, implying expenditure of monetary resources, time, and people.

- Comments related to specific Guidance Notes (GNs):
  - GN F.2 (Asymmetric Treatment of Retained Earnings):
    - Very high costs are related to the assets side only; for liabilities, costs would probably be moderate.
    - Costs would be low because an estimation strategy has been implemented.
    - Providing portfolio RIE for the ESS could be done at moderate cost using the estimation approach used for the international portfolio RIE exercise.
    - Specific cost drivers cited for F.2 rated "very high":
      - (i) To calculate reinvested earnings of portfolio investment equities, the securities database would need enhancement with information on operating earnings of issuers; collecting this information is costly, particularly for foreign issuers.
      - (ii) Ensuring a certain level of quality and harmonization on credits and debits is costly.
      - (iii) Information availability will be delayed (as with Direct investment), requiring development and maintenance of estimations that would be considerably revised after data collection.
  - GN F.5:
    - Proposed breakdowns on derivatives would be useful.
    - More detailed guidance is needed on how to treat different types of derivatives in ESS.
  - GN F.8:
    - For debt securities, nominal value is only available; for shares only the market value is available. Government-issued debt securities have both.

### Guidance Note B.2 — Standardized Statistical Definition of Net International Reserves (NIR)
- Summary of the Guidance Note:
  - NIR definitions and practices differ across sources along dimensions including specificity and treatment of liabilities (maturity and residential basis), liabilities to the IMF, and SDR allocations.
  - Recommendation: introduce a standardized statistical definition of NIR based on existing BPM6 and IRFCL frameworks; include the new definition in updated versions.
  - The recommended statistical definition aims to inform reserve adequacy assessments and macroeconomic policy advice; modifications for country-specific characteristics remain crucial.
  - The proposed NIR definition goes beyond the standard balance of payments framework and could be included in BPM7 in an annex/box and as part of the IRFCL framework.

- Survey assessments of costs and benefits:
  - 26a. Costs associated with producing information on NIR according to the standardized statistical definition:
    - 5 votes: 0 (no costs; already compile these data)
    - 8 votes: 1 (very low costs)
    - 11 votes: 2 (low costs)
    - 13 votes: 3 (moderate costs)
    - 4 votes: 4 (high costs)
    - 2 votes: 5 (very high costs)
    - Average: 2.2
  - 26b. Benefits associated with having information on NIR according to the standardized statistical definition:
    - 0 votes: 0 (no benefits)
    - 2 votes: 1 (very low benefits)
    - 4 votes: 2 (low benefits)
    - 7 votes: 3 (moderate benefits)
    - 12 votes: 4 (high benefits)
    - 5 votes: 5 (very high benefits)
    - Average: 3.5

- Additional comments:
  - BoP compilers depend on national central banks’ accounting departments for international reserves information; for the euro area, information needs assessment by the ECB.

### Guidance Note B.4 — Reconciliation Between Flows and Stocks
- Summary of the Guidance Note:
  - Recommends integrated presentation of flows and positions in BPM7 as three intertwined elements: (i) balance of payments, (ii) IIP, and (iii) accumulation accounts explaining IIP changes via transactions, revaluations, and other changes in volume.
  - Recommends the integrated IIP statement as a standard component in BPM7.
  - Recommends presenting "Other Changes in Volume" with a total and two supplementary "of which" categories: "Reclassifications" and "Debt Cancellation and Write-offs".

- Survey assessments of costs:
  - 27a. Producing an integrated IIP statement as a standard component:
    - 16 votes: 0 (no costs; already compile these data)
    - 5 votes: 1 (very low costs)
    - 6 votes: 2 (low costs)
    - 8 votes: 3 (moderate costs)
    - 7 votes: 4 (high costs)
    - 8 votes: 5 (very high costs)
    - Average: 2.2
  - 27a. Breaking down "Other Changes in Volume" into "Reclassifications" and "Debt Cancellation and Write offs":
    - 1 vote: 0 (no costs)
    - 2 votes: 1 (very low costs)
    - 6 votes: 2 (low costs)
    - 13 votes: 3 (moderate costs)
    - 13 votes: 4 (high costs)
    - 15 votes: 5 (very high costs)
    - Average: 3.6

- Survey assessments of benefits:
  - 27b. Producing an integrated IIP statement as a standard component:
    - 0 votes: 0 (no benefits)
    - 1 vote: 1 (very low benefits)
    - 1 vote: 2 (low benefits)
    - 2 votes: 3 (moderate benefits)
    - 17 votes: 4 (high benefits)
    - 12 votes: 5 (very high benefits)
    - Average: 4.2
  - 27b. Breaking down "Other Changes in Volume" into the two supplementary categories:
    - 0 votes: 0 (no benefits)
    - 2 votes: 1 (very low benefits)
    - 2 votes: 2 (low benefits)
    - 7 votes: 3 (moderate benefits)
    - 12 votes: 4 (high benefits)
    - 10 votes: 5 (very high benefits)
    - Average: 3.8

- Additional comments:
  - Introduction of a third "BoP" table on reconciliation is considered the main way forward in BPM7.
  - Data availability varies; distinction between "Reclassifications" and "Debt Cancellation and Write offs" is not available in sec-by-sec system for portfolio investment compilation.
  - Reconciliation between the current account and the IIP will shed more light on errors and omissions.

### Guidance Note B.6 — Sustainable Finance: Integrating Measures of Climate Change Risk into ESS
- Summary of the Guidance Note:
  - Recommends an updatable appendix in BPM7 on measures and BoP/IIP indicators related to climate change-related financial risks.
  - Initial indicators include:
    - Recommendation 1: include supplementary geographical and industrial sector breakdowns of direct investment.
    - Recommendation 2: add a supplementary "of which" category to identify green bonds in the BoP/IIP.

- Survey assessments of costs:
  - 28a. Recommendation 1 (supplementary geographical and industrial sector breakdowns of direct investment):
    - 10 votes: 0 (no costs; already compile these data)
    - 2 votes: 1 (very low costs)
    - 5 votes: 2 (low costs)
    - 8 votes: 3 (moderate costs)
    - 10 votes: 4 (high costs)
    - 12 votes: 5 (very high costs)
    - Average: 2.9
  - 28a. Recommendation 2 (supplementary "of which" category to identify green bonds):
    - 1 vote: 0 (no costs)
    - 2 votes: 1 (very low costs)
    - 4 votes: 2 (low costs)
    - 12 votes: 3 (moderate costs)
    - 14 votes: 4 (high costs)
    - 10 votes: 5 (very high costs)
    - Average: 3.5

- Survey assessments of benefits:
  - 28b. Recommendation 1 benefits:
    - 2 votes: 0 (no benefits)
    - 2 votes: 1 (very low benefits)
    - 2 votes: 2 (low benefits)
    - 4 votes: 3 (moderate benefits)
    - 17 votes: 4 (high benefits)
    - 8 votes: 5 (very high benefits)
    - Average: 3.6
  - 28b. Recommendation 2 benefits:
    - 1 vote: 0 (no benefits)
    - 1 vote: 1 (very low benefits)
    - 3 votes: 2 (low benefits)
    - 4 votes: 3 (moderate benefits)
    - 19 votes: 4 (high benefits)
    - 5 votes: 5 (very high benefits)
    - Average: 3.6

- Additional comments:
  - International guidance on a harmonized definition/classification of green bonds is missing.
  - The proposal to use only the ICMA definition may be inconsistent with other statistical initiatives using extended definitions; a common definition should be agreed beforehand.
  - Recommendation 2 would have low costs if a relevant identifier is included in the Centralized Securities Database (CSDB).
  - Identifying green bonds indicates financial institutions' contribution to financing green investment but is not a good proxy for quantifying public or private green investment because purchasing such bonds is only one of many investment channels.
  - A breakdown of FDI by country and sector is published annually in line with the OECD's BD4.
  - BoP framework is resident-to-non-resident based; detailed geographical (e.g., city-level) direct investment data are not feasible. Industry classification should align with other statistics; ISIC revision discussions should be considered.

### Globalization — GN G.4 (SPEs and Residency) and GN G.7 (GVCs and Trade in Value Added)
- GN G.4 — Treatment of Special Purpose Entities and Residency:
  - Recommendations:
    - Recommendation 1: adopt an international definition of SPEs in BPM7 and the 2025 SNA, aligned with IMF Committee on Balance of Payments Statistics work; leave core framework unchanged and integrate SPE breakdown within institutional sector accounts on a supplementary basis for countries where SPEs are significant.
    - Recommendation 2: present nationality-based SPE statistics as a supplement to residency-based statistics for economies where SPEs are important (reflects global consolidation of MNEs and ownership/control).
  - Survey assessments of costs:
    - 30a. Recommendation 1 (supplementary breakdown for SPEs):
      - 8 votes: 0 (no costs; already compile these data)
      - 4 votes: 1 (very low costs)
      - 4 votes: 2 (low costs)
      - 7 votes: 3 (moderate costs)
      - 11 votes: 4 (high costs)
      - 9 votes: 5 (very high costs)
      - Average: 2.8
    - 30a. Recommendation 2 (producing supplementary nationality-based SPE statistics):
      - 1 vote: 0 (no costs)
      - 1 vote: 1 (very low costs)
      - 0 votes: 2 (low costs)
      - 5 votes: 3 (moderate costs)
      - 12 votes: 4 (high costs)
      - 22 votes: 5 (very high costs)
      - Average: 4.2
  - Survey assessments of benefits:
    - 30b. Recommendation 1 benefits:
      - 1 vote: 0 (no benefits)
      - 2 votes: 1 (very low benefits)
      - 2 votes: 2 (low benefits)
      - 9 votes: 3 (moderate benefits)
      - 13 votes: 4 (high benefits)
      - 5 votes: 5 (very high benefits)
      - Average: 3.4
    - 30b. Recommendation 2 benefits:
      - 2 votes: 0 (no benefits)
      - 2 votes: 1 (very low benefits)
      - 3 votes: 2 (low benefits)
      - 7 votes: 3 (moderate benefits)
      - 12 votes: 4 (high benefits)
      - 5 votes: 5 (very high benefits)
      - Average: 3.3

  - Additional comments:
    - SPE statistics have been experimented with for direct investment using the IMF decision tree, but not investigated for other functional categories or trade.
    - SPE statistics are available for direct investment but not for other parts of external sector statistics.

- GN G.7 — Global Value Chains (GVCs) and Trade in Value Added:
  - Recommendation: no changes to core BPM and SNA concepts; include a description of GVCs and trade in value added in updated manuals. Within BPM, include supplementary cross-border statistics detailed by geography or product as part of a reporting template for GVC data collection.
  - Survey assessments of costs:
    - 31a. Supplementary cross-border statistics detailed by geography:
      - 3 votes: 0 (no costs)
      - 1 vote: 1 (very low costs)
      - 1 vote: 2 (low costs)
      - 11 votes: 3 (moderate costs)
      - 6 votes: 4 (high costs)
      - 15 votes: 5 (very high costs)
      - Average: 3.6
    - 31a. Supplementary cross-border statistics detailed by product:
      - 2 votes: 0 (no costs)
      - 0 votes: 1 (very low costs)
      - 1 vote: 2 (low costs)
      - 8 votes: 3 (moderate costs)
      - 7 votes: 4 (high costs)
      - 19 votes: 5 (very high costs)
      - Average: 4.0
  - Survey assessments of benefits:
    - 31b. Supplementary cross-border statistics detailed by geography benefits:
      - 1 vote: 0 (no benefits)
      - 0 votes: 1 (very low benefits)
      - 1 vote: 2 (low benefits)
      - 6 votes: 3 (moderate benefits)
      - 13 votes: 4 (high benefits)
      - 12 votes: 5 (very high benefits)
      - Average: 4.0
    - 31b. Supplementary cross-border statistics detailed by product benefits:
      - 1 vote: 0 (no benefits)
      - 0 votes: 1 (very low benefits)
      - 1 vote: 2 (low benefits)
      - 8 votes: 3 (moderate benefits)
      - 11 votes: 4 (high benefits)
      - 11 votes: 5 (very high benefits)
      - Average: 3.9

  - Additional comments:
    - Supplementary nationality-based SPE statistics and cross-border statistics detailed by product go beyond the scope of national BoP statistics.
    - Both globalization GNs raise data sourcing and processing challenges to ensure timeliness and robust quality.
    - Monthly published statistics on international trade in goods by trading partner and limited product breakdown exist; greater detail for GVCs can be complex.
    - Compilation of supplementary breakdowns for GVCs should remain voluntary.
    - The supplementary breakdown by product and geography required for GVCs is often too detailed; basic sources used for goods and services estimation in BoP lack the required information.
    - Customs statistics do not indicate whether ownership changed for imported/exported goods; data quality may be insufficient for comprehensive interpretation.
    - Current data sources do not identify global value chains; significant resources would be needed to implement these recommendations despite their potential analytic benefits.

*Source: IMF — Outcomes of the Holistic Review Survey of BPM6 Update Priorities (selected responses Q25–Q32).*

### Section IV.

### Section IV.

### Clarification notes (2–11): definitions and recording guidance
- Clarification Note 2 — Remaining Maturity Classification:
  - Conceptual guidance: remaining maturity should be calculated by discounting payments due, with payments falling within one year or less as short-term remaining maturity and those falling beyond one year as long-term remaining maturity (BPM6 paragraphs 5.104 and 5.105).
  - Practical guidance: the undiscounted value of principal payments to calculate remaining maturity provides an acceptable proxy.
  - Classification/impact metadata: CL B + D; No No No Yes 1

- Clarification Note 3 — Statistical Treatment of Negative Interest Rates:
  - Guidance: negative interest rates on deposits should be recorded as negative income receivable by the investors (and payable by the financial institutions) in the primary income account excluding FISIM, analogous to positive interest income on deposits.
  - Classification/impact metadata: CL B + D; No No No Yes 1

- Clarification Note 4 — Reserve Position in the IMF:
  - Guidance: reserve position in the IMF should be classified as other deposits without a maturity breakdown.
  - If original maturity classification is deemed necessary, attribute as long-term, consistent with the reserves tranche being the main component.
  - Classification/impact metadata: CL D; No No No Yes 1

- Clarification Note 5 — Recording of Central Bank Swap Arrangements:
  - Off-market central bank currency swap arrangements: record as an exchange of deposits with maintenance of value.
  - Standard (market priced) currency swaps: record as an exchange of deposits with the simultaneous creation of a financial derivative (a forward contract).
  - Classification/impact metadata: CL B + D; No No No Yes 1

- Clarification Note 6 — Statistical Treatment of Precious Metals Accounts:
  - Allocated precious metals accounts (other than monetary gold): represent ownership of nonfinancial assets.
  - Unallocated precious metals accounts: treated as deposits in foreign currency.
  - For allocated accounts: certificate fees and ongoing storage fees recorded as financial services.
  - Reaffirmation: monetary gold remains classified as a financial asset within reserve assets as an exception among commodities.
  - Classification/impact metadata: CL D; No No No Yes 1

- Clarification Note 7 — Sectoral Classification of International Organizations:
  - National accounts: international organizations (except currency union or economic union institutions) should be included in the rest of the world (not resident in any country’s economic territory) with a separate code according to their activity.
  - Balance of payments: include them in one of the additional sectors for counterpart data.
  - Specific classification: the IMF is to be classified as an “international financial organization.”
  - Classification/impact metadata: CL B + D; No No No Yes 1

- Clarification Note 8 — Transfers and Loan Agreements of Sport Players:
  - Fees for temporary transfer of rights to use sports players under loan agreements: record as rent.
  - Amounts related to other terms (risk factors, transfers of registration, agents’ commissions, players’ sponsorship, media rights): record in relevant balance of payments items.
  - If parent club pays part of salary of a player on loan: deduct this part from the loan fee and consider it paid by the borrower.
  - If loan lasts for more than one year: the player’s country of residence should be considered to have changed.
  - Classification/impact metadata: CL D; No No No Yes 1

- Clarification Note 9 — Treatment of Crypto Assets:
  - Bitcoin-like crypto assets and digital tokens without counterpart liabilities: classify as produced nonfinancial assets as a distinct sub-category under valuables.
  - Other crypto assets with characteristics similar to standard financial instruments: classify according to current guidelines.
  - Monitoring: recommendations may need revisiting if conditions substantially change.
  - Status: [This clarification note has been superseded by GN F.18]
  - Classification/impact metadata: CL A + B + D; No No F.18 - -

- Clarification Note 10 — Freight and Insurance Associated to Merchanting; Geographical Allocation:
  - Freight and insurance costs associated to merchanting: record at transaction prices as agreed between parties and dependent on delivery terms (i.e., not “free on board” (fob)).
  - Country allocation of “net exports of goods under merchanting”: allocate by adding up all credit and debit entries of goods under merchanting for each partner country.
  - Classification/impact metadata: CL D; No No No Yes 1

- Clarification Note 11 — Participations in Capital of International Organizations and Respective Income:
  - Recommendation: classify all capital subscriptions in international organizations, including unlisted shares, under other investment – other equity.
  - Consequence: income on such subscriptions recorded under primary income – investment income – other investment – withdrawals from income of quasi-corporations.
  - Implementation note: this introduces a change relative to BPM6 and will require a change in the next edition of the Manual.
  - Status: [This clarification note has been superseded by GN B.12]
  - Classification/impact metadata: CH D; No No B.12 - -

### Previously Committee-endorsed task force reports and their outcomes
- BOPCOM 18/03 — Final Report of the Task Force on Special Purpose Entities:
  - Key recommendations: adopt an international definition of SPEs with a decision tree and typology; launch an international data collection to separately identify cross-border transactions and positions for SPEs.
  - Status: [Superseded by GN G.4; data collection in place since start of 2022]
  - Metadata: AD A + B + C + D; CI SI; G.4 - -

- BOPCOM 19/03 — Final Report of the Task Force on Informal Economy:
  - Key recommendations: continue dissemination of encouraged collection/compilation practices via dedicated web platform; tailor collection and compilation to data availability and capacity; step up coordination between ESS and NA compilers; emphasize informal economy issues for the financial account and the IIP.
  - Status: [Superseded by GN IE.7]
  - Metadata: CL A + B + D; No No IE.1 - -

- BOPCOM 19/04 — Working Group on Balance of Payments Statistics Relevant for Global Value Chains:
  - Final recommendations: compile and disseminate proposed BOP items for GVC analysis; encourage supplementary data to highlight MNEs' role in the current account; develop statistics not included in GVC proposal; provide international technical assistance; increase coordination between international and national accounts compilers.
  - Status: [Superseded by GN G.7]
  - Metadata: AD A + B + C + D; CI SI; G.7 - -

- BOPCOM 19/23 — UN Report on Guidelines on Accounting for Global Value Chains:
  - The final Guidelines contain five parts including accounting for global value chains and satellite accounts.
  - Status: [Superseded by GN G.7]
  - Metadata: AD A + B + C + D; CI SI; G.7 - -

### Balance of Payments Task Team guidance notes (selected)
- GN B.2 — Standardized Statistical Definition of Net International Reserves (NIR):
  - Recommendation: introduce a standardized statistical definition of NIR based on BPM6 and the International Reserves and Foreign Currency Liquidity Guidelines; include new definition in updated versions.
  - Purpose: provide a comprehensive approach to inform reserve adequacy assessments and macroeconomic policy advice while allowing country-specific modifications.
  - Metadata: AD B + D; No SI No Yes 1

- GN B.3 — Treatment of Centralized Currency Unions:
  - Issues and recommendations:
    - Imputed reserve assets: maintain BPM6 guidance using net claims on the currency union central bank for deriving imputed reserve assets.
    - Resident institutional units: national agencies are residents where located; impute notional units where none are established.
    - Own account transactions: maintain concept; clarify that own account transactions exclude regular monetary authority operations.
  - Metadata: SQ / CL D; No No No / Yes 1

- GN B.4 — Reconciliation Between Flows and Stocks:
  - Recommendation: center BPM7 on integrated presentation of flows and positions, composed of (i) balance of payments, (ii) IIP, and (iii) accumulation accounts explaining changes in IIP via financial account transactions, revaluations, and other changes in volume.
  - Presentation: include integrated IIP statement with same line items as Appendix 9B of BPM6; present “Other Changes in Volume” with total and supplementary “of which” categories – “Reclassifications” and “Debt Cancellation and Write-offs”.
  - Metadata: CH A + B + C + D; QI SC + SI; No Yes 1

- GN B.6 — Sustainable Finance: Integrating Climate Change Risk Measures:
  - Recommendation: include an updatable appendix in revised BPM on measures and BOP/IIP indicators related to climate change-related financial risks.
  - Initial content: geographical and industrial sector breakdowns of direct investment and an “of which” category to identify green bonds in the BOP/IIP, with analytical uses and limitations noted.
  - Metadata: AD A + B + D; No SI WS.7 Yes 1

- GN B.7 — Arrears in IIP:
  - Recommendation: maintain status quo on methodology and presentation of arrears due to collection burden and costs of alternatives.
  - Metadata: SQ; No No No No - -

- GN B.9 — Treatment of External Assets Declared Under Tax Amnesty:
  - Recommendation: adjust external assets and related income declared under tax amnesties by applying the BPM6 accrual principle:
    - (i) adjust assets/income series in the current period and backwards when feasible; or
    - (ii) if historical adjustments are not possible, adjust only the current period estimates.
  - Scope: does not cover recording of corresponding taxes (transactions between residents).
  - Metadata: CL D BR; No No Yes 1

- GN B.12 — Treatment of Equity in International Organizations (Unlisted Shares):
  - Recommendation: classify all capital subscriptions in international organizations, including unlisted shares, under other investment; amend standard presentations of BOP and IIP to reflect other investment – equity in international organizations and corresponding income items.
  - Metadata: CH D BR; No No Yes 1

### Current account, direct investment, and financial system guidance highlights (selected)
- GN C.1 — Transactor-Based Components of Services:
  - Recommendation: retain transactor-based approach for travel, construction, and government goods and services n.i.e.; add supplementary reporting under travel to include personal, cultural and recreation services acquired by travelers; introduce supplementary reporting under construction for constructions and construction services; clarify compilation of government goods and services.
  - Metadata: AD B + D; QI SI; C.4 + C.7; Yes 1

- GN C.2 — Goods, Services, and Investment Income by Enterprise Characteristics:
  - Recommendation: include supplementary annual data on goods, services, and investment income by enterprise characteristics (industry, ownership, size) as part of current account reporting.
  - Metadata: AD A + B + D; CI SI; D.6 + C.4; Yes 1

- GN C.3 — International Trade Classified by Currency:
  - Recommendation: annual supplementary disaggregation of international trade in goods and services (gross imports and exports) by currency.
  - Metadata: AD A + D; CI SI; No Yes 1

- GN C.4 — Merchanting and Factoryless Producers; Merchanting of Services:
  - Recommendations include classifying FGPs in manufacturing, recording final goods transactions within global manufacturing arrangements gross under general merchandise (not net under merchanting), and adding supplementary items to identify such trade.
  - Metadata: CH A + B + C + D; BR + CI + QI SI; C.2 + C.7; Yes 1

- GN C.6 — Trade in Services Classifications:
  - Recommendations to split Telecommunications, computer, and information services into two first-level items; split Other business services into five first-level items (Research and development; Professional and management consulting; Trade-related; Operating leasing; Technical and other business services).
  - Metadata: CH B + D; No SC; C.1 + C.2 + C.4 + C.5; Yes 1

- GN C.7 — Travel Packages, Health-Related Travel, and Taxes and Fees on Passenger Tickets:
  - Travel packages: recommend unbundling components, treat tour operator service as a fee on contract, add guidance and a supplementary line in BPM7.
  - Health-related travel: align “medical reasons” scope with International Recommendations for Tourism Statistics 2008; classify companions’ expenses as other personal travel.
  - Taxes and fees on passengers’ tickets: recommend no change to BPM6.
  - Metadata: AD / CL / SQ as detailed; No SI; C.1 + C.4; Yes 1 / Yes 1 / - -

- GN C.8 — Recording of Fines and Penalties:
  - Clarifications and recommendations:
    - Define fines/penalties as “punitive in nature” and distinguish from compensation.
    - Major compensation payments intended to recover multi-year losses or replace assets: record as capital transfers.
    - Record fines/penalties only when issuer has an “unconditional claim to the funds”; clarify timing when judgments are appealed.
    - Clarify whether fines/penalties impact direct investment income when DIEs are responsible.
    - Treat contingent fines/penalties in M&A contracts as price adjustments (thus DI or portfolio investment transactions), not transfers.
    - Add guidance on possible fines/penalties related transactions.
  - Metadata: CL B + D; No No No Yes 1

- GN D.1 — Greenfield Investment and Extension of Capacity:
  - Definition: broaden greenfield DI to include new DI enterprises (narrow) and capital injections/extension of capacity into existing DIEs (broader).
  - Data collection: compile inward greenfield investments and extension of capacity as supplementary DI series using the transactions approach; collect for equity (other than reinvestment of earnings) and debt instruments; exclude pass-through funds if possible; provide breakdowns by industry and ultimate investor geography; provide additional RIE information if possible.
  - Metadata: AD A + B + C + D; CI + QI SI; D.6 + D.9; Yes 1

- GN D.2 — Valuation of Unlisted Equity:
  - Preferred methods: explain concept to be measured (own funds = assets minus liabilities measured at market prices); recommend own funds at book value (OFBV), transaction prices, and market capitalization as preferred methods and use a decision tree.
  - Treatment of negative equity: recommend producing a separate clarification note on negative equity, including zeroing out for limited liability cases.
  - Treatment of provisions: recommend review of accounting provisions treatment under OFBV; issue considered in GN WS.9.
  - Metadata: CL A + B + D; BR; No No Yes 1

- GN D.3 — Treatment of Collective Investment Institutions:
  - Recommendation: always treat investments in investment fund shares as portfolio investment; investments by funds may be recorded under DI or portfolio investment per current BPM6 rules.
  - Metadata: CH B + D; BR; No D.7 Yes 1

- GN D.6 — Ultimate Investing Economy/Ultimate Host Economy and Pass-through Funds:
  - UIE: recommend streamlining UIE definition to align with MNE statistics (‘Winner Takes All’) and develop supplementary DI presentation by UIE.
  - UHE: recommend developing supplementary DI presentation that looks through SPEs to the first operating unit for UHE presentation.
  - Pass-through funds: recommend streamlining definition and developing supplementary presentation identifying pass-through funds.
  - Metadata: AD A + B + D; CI SI; D.9 + G.2 + G.4; Yes 1

- GN D.8 — Sectoral Breakdown of Direct Investment:
  - Recommendation: implement a sectoral breakdown of DI (equity and debt instruments) as a standard presentation in BOP and IIP; apply to reinvestment of earnings for total equity.
  - Metadata: AD A + B + D; CI SC; F.1 Yes 1

- GN D.9 — Reconciling DI and Activities of MNEs (AMNE) Statistics:
  - Recommendation: develop a framework for reconciling DI and AMNE statistics, including additional breakdowns (e.g., influence vs. control), supplementary presentations (e.g., inward DI by UIE), and possibly additional variables (consolidated assets/liabilities) to enable joint use; align MNE definition with GN G.2.
  - Status: new supplementary items (e.g., inward DI by UIE) to be introduced in BPM7; further research recommended.
  - Metadata: AD A + B + D; CI SI; D.1 + D.6 + G.2; Yes 1 + 2

- GN D.10 — Defining the Boundaries of Direct Investment:
  - Recommendations: retain a numerical threshold to define DI; retain threshold at 10 percent; maintain status quo that DI relationships are achieved only by ownership of equity; remove from research agenda the question of DI via instruments other than equity.
  - Metadata: SQ; No No No; D.3 + G.2; - -

- GN D.11 — Debt Between Affiliated Insurance Corporations and Pension Funds:
  - Conclusion: maintain status quo; debt between ICPFs and affiliates remains linked to the DI relationship and does not justify a change in treatment.
  - Metadata: SQ; No No No; No - -

- GN D.12 — Intra-Concern Derivatives in Direct Investment:
  - Recommendation: continue reporting intra-concern derivatives in the financial derivatives functional category, and add a supplementary “of which: between affiliates” item to separately identify intra-concern derivatives.
  - Implementation note: Committee decided this recommendation should not be included in BPM7.
  - Metadata: AD D; QI SI; F.4 - 3

- GN D.18 — Cash Pooling in Direct Investment:
  - Recommendation: include a detailed description of main types of cash pooling arrangements and guidance to identify/classify associated debt instruments as DI or other investment in the updated manual.
  - Metadata: CL D; No No No Yes 1

- GN F.1 — More Disaggregated Institutional Sector and Instrument Breakdowns:
  - Consolidation of recommendations: confirm additional sector breakdowns (e.g., OFC breakdowns), do not recommend separate fintech sectors/instruments, recommend “of which” SPE items for supplementary reporting.
  - Additional sector breaks: split NFCs and Households/NPISH as two separate standard components (currently aggregated).
  - Instrument breakdowns: confirm recommended financial derivatives breakdowns and include repurchase agreements, securities lending with cash collateral, and margin lending as “of which” under loans.
  - Metadata: AD A + B + D; CI SI; F.6 + F.7 + G.4; - -

- GN F.2 — Asymmetric Treatment of Retained Earnings:
  - Issue: RIE treatment applies to FDI but not portfolio or domestic equity, creating asymmetries.
  - Recommendation: keep core BOP accounts unchanged; add supplementary information on portfolio investment RIE.
  - Metadata: AD A + B + C + D; QI SI; D.3 + D.16 + D.17; Yes 1

- GN F.3 — Reverse Transactions:
  - Recommendation: maintain current BPM6 recording of reverse transactions (no change in economic ownership; record securities/gold lending fees as interest; short positions from on-selling recorded as negative assets).
  - Metadata: SQ; No No No; No - -

- GN F.4 and related guidance:
  - Multiple references throughout the section recommend instrument and sector disaggregations (e.g., financial derivatives breakdowns, “Repurchase agreements, securities lending with cash collateral, and margin lending” as of-which items under loans).
  - Metadata: cross-referenced in GN F.1 and other GNs; see individual GNs for details.

*Outcomes of the Holistic Review Survey of BPM6 — Section IV, International Monetary Fund.*

### 7.28 and 7.61). BPM6 does not clearly explain that the use of

### Outcomes of the Holistic Review: Survey of BPM6 Update Priorities (selected guidance notes and recommendations)

### Reverse transactions, short positions, and manufactured income
- Issue: BPM6 does not clearly explain that the use of negative positions is to address double-counting of the security by both the economic (original) owner and the final owner, nor the implications for who-to-whom presentations by counterpart sector and geography.
  - Recommendation: Introduce further clarifications (possibly a Box) for recording of short positions (including their income streams and from-whom-to-whom implications) in the income and financial accounts for reverse transactions in the updated BPM.
  - Classification/Type: CL A + D
  - Inclusion in BPM7: Yes
  - Bucket: 1
- Issue 3 (classification of income for security lender, borrower, and short-seller): The economic owner continues recording dividends and the accrual of interest on the securities even when legal ownership changes under a reverse transaction.
  - Recommendation: Record positive credit in dividends/interest for the security lender and negative credit in dividends/interest for the security borrower.
  - Classification/Type: CL A + D
  - Inclusion in BPM7: Yes
  - Bucket: 1
- Issue 4 (identification of the partner economy and sector counterpart for “manufactured dividends or interest”):
  - Recommendation: Identify the partner for “Manufactured dividends/interest” by the economy and sector of the security issuer, consistent with positions held by the security lender and borrower.
  - Classification/Type: CL A + D
  - Inclusion in BPM7: Yes
  - Bucket: 1
- Issue 5 (clarification on commodities under reverse transactions):
  - Recommendation: Include commodities, in addition to securities and gold, in the discussion on reverse transactions in the updated BPM.
  - Classification/Type: CL A + D
  - Inclusion in BPM7: Yes
  - Bucket: 1
- Issue 6 (supplementary information on reverse transactions):
  - Recommendation: Discuss usefulness of separate identification of repo-related transactions and positions and encourage economies engaged in reverse transactions to prepare supplementary information by type of assets (cash, securities, or other) and role of assets (provided/lent vs. received/borrowed).
  - Note: Based on global survey results, the Committee decided this recommendation should not be included in BPM7.
  - Classification/Type: AD A + B + D
  - Data/Link: SI F.1 + F.6; GN F.4
  - Bucket: 3

### Financial derivatives classification, notional values, and revaluations
- GN F.4 Issue 1 (broad classification of financial derivatives):
  - Recommendation: Discontinue breakdown by broad type (options and forward-type contracts) in favor of classifications: (a) by market risk category (standard component), (b) by instrument (supplementary), and (c) by trading venue (supplementary). Committee decision: change the market risk category breakdown from a standard component to a supplementary item.
  - Classification/Type: CH A + B + C + D
  - Links: BR SI D.12 + F.1 + F.5
  - Inclusion in BPM7: Yes
  - Bucket: 1
- Issue 2 (compiling notional values of foreign currency derivatives):
  - Observation: Very limited country coverage for Tables A9-I-2a and A9-I-2b (currency composition of notional amounts of derivatives with foreign currency payment obligations crossed by sector).
  - Recommendation: Present current Tables A9-I-1b and A9-I-2b more prominently in updated BPM; consider a simplified table if compilation is too burdensome.
  - Classification/Type: CL A + B + C
  - Bucket: -1
- Issue 3 (convention for recording of revaluations on foreign currency derivatives):
  - Recommendation: Enhance analytical clarity on exchange rate revaluations. Change convention so that revaluation effects for certain derivatives are recorded as other price revaluations rather than exchange rate revaluations, to comply with BPM6, paragraphs 9.28 and 9.31.
  - Classification/Type: CH D BR
  - Inclusion in BPM7: Yes
  - Bucket: 1

### Post-trading activities, net vs gross recording, and derivative subtypes
- Issue 4 (recording of post trading activities):
  - Recommendation: Expand BPM6 Chapter 8 (Financial Account) to provide methodological guidance for recording novation and portfolio compression as financial transactions; this calls for additional guidance rather than methodological change.
  - Classification/Type: CL B + D
  - Inclusion in BPM7: Yes
  - Bucket: 1
- Issue 5 (gross and net recording of assets and liabilities):
  - Recommendation: Clarify paragraph 8.34 of BPM6 that net recording is acceptable where separate data on transactions in assets and liabilities are unavailable and positions may change between assets and liabilities; apply method consistently during instrument life.
  - Classification/Type: CL D
  - Inclusion in BPM7: Yes
  - Bucket: 1
- GN F.5 (Treatment of Credit Default Swaps):
  - Recommendation: Continue to classify CDS as option-type derivatives; suggest including a brief explanation or text box on CDS characteristics in the next standards. Supplementary breakdowns by risk categories recommended (credit derivatives separately identified) — covered in GN F.4.
  - Classification/Type: CL A + B + D
  - Links: F.4
  - Inclusion in BPM7: Yes
  - Bucket: 1

### Non-bank financial intermediation, OFC breakdowns, and instrument detail
- GN F.6 Issue 1 (further institutional sector breakdown):
  - Recommendation: Introduce further breakdowns of Other Financial Corporations (OFCs) as supplementary items: (i) money market funds (MMFs), (ii) non-MMF investment funds, (iii) insurance corporations, (iv) pension funds, (v) other financial intermediaries (including central clearing counterparties), and (vi) captive financial institutions and money lenders, and financial auxiliaries.
  - Classification/Type: AD A + B + D
  - Links: CI SI F.1 + F.7
  - Inclusion in BPM7: Yes
  - Bucket: 1
- Issue 2 (additional breakdowns for financial instruments):
  - Recommendation: Include “of which” supplementary items under loans in main presentation: Repurchase agreements, securities lending with cash collateral, and margin lending to provide liquidity risk and leverage information.
  - Note: This recommendation will not be included in BPM7 (see GN F.3 Issue 6).
  - Classification/Type: AD A + B + D
  - Links: CI SI F.1 + F.3
  - Bucket: 3

### Fintech, e-money, and practical compilation guidance
- GN F.7 Issue 1 (sector and instrument breakdowns for fintech):
  - Finding: Existing international statistical standards allow proper treatment and recording of fintech activities in most cases.
  - Recommendation: Do not introduce separate sectors or instruments for fintech; instead, introduce an “of which” category for fintech companies within subsector classification where needed. Consider similar “of which” categories for instruments/services (e.g., central bank digital currencies, crypto assets, financial services by fintech platforms).
  - Classification/Type: AD A + B + D
  - Data/Links: CI + QI SI F.1 + F.6 + F.18
  - Bucket: -1 + 2
- GN F.7 Issue 2 (practical guidance):
  - Recommendation: Include practical guidance in the next BPM edition to address compilation issues related to fintech and give clear guidance on recording “e-money” in line with the Monetary and Financial Statistics Manual and Compilation Guide.
  - Classification/Type: CL A + B + D
  - Inclusion in BPM7: Yes
  - Bucket: 1

### Valuation of debt securities and loans
- GN F.8 (Valuation of Debt Securities at Both Market and Nominal Value):
  - Observation: BPM6 and 2008 SNA recommend market value valuation.
  - Recommendation: Include explicit guidance to compile stocks of debt securities at nominal value as a supplement to market valuation; strengthen recommendation to compile securities liabilities using both market and nominal values; adopt presentation table reconciling nominal and market valuation of debt securities liabilities; report debt securities used in direct investment inter-company lending as a supplementary item.
  - Classification/Type: AD A + B + C + D
  - Inclusion in BPM7: Yes
  - Bucket: 1
- GN F.9 (Valuation of Loans (Fair Value)):
  - Recommendation: Maintain current nominal valuation principle for loans and strengthen framework allowing for value reset beyond bankruptcy/liquidation when there is public evidence of loan deterioration.
  - Classification/Type: CL B + D
  - Links: F.6 + F.8 + F.15
  - Inclusion in BPM7: Yes
  - Bucket: 1

### Insurance, pension products, and hybrid instruments
- GN F.12 (Covering Hybrid Insurance and Pension Products):
  - Issue 1 (insurance products):
    - Recommendation: Keep current categories for life insurance/nonlife insurance and clarify that hybrid insurance products are classified based on the predominant nature of the policy.
    - Classification/Type: CL D
    - Inclusion in BPM7: Yes
    - Bucket: 1
  - Issue 2 (pension products):
    - Recommendation: Clarify that autonomous, employer-independent schemes or funds can qualify as social insurance pensions; specify criterion: “Accumulated contributions are set aside for retirement income and are subject to regulation or supervision in line with or similar to employer-related pension schemes/funds.”
    - Classification/Type: CL D
    - Inclusion in BPM7: Yes
    - Bucket: 1

### Subscription rights, crypto assets, and other financial instruments
- GN F.16 (Subscription Rights):
  - Observation: BPM6 and 2008 SNA silent on classification of stock subscription rights; contradictory guidance exists between handbooks.
  - Recommendation: Updated manuals should explicitly require classification of subscription rights as equity.
  - Classification/Type: CL B + D
  - Inclusion in BPM7: Yes
  - Bucket: 1
- GN F.18 (Recording of Crypto Assets in Macroeconomic Statistics):
  - Status: Final version not yet ready.
  - Bucket: F.7

### Informal economy and Islamic finance
- GN IE.1 (Statistical Framework of the Informal Economy):
  - Content: Presents coherent conceptual recommendations for measurement of work and economic activity in the informal economy; redefines informal sector; outlines formal enterprises’ informal activities; delineates production of households for own use; considers digitalization and informal cross-border flows.
  - Recommendation: No changes to BPM methodology recommended; framework can strengthen compilation practices.
  - Classification/Type: CL A + B + D
  - Inclusion in BPM7: Yes
  - Bucket: 1
- GN IF.1 (Islamic Finance in the SNA and External Sector Statistics):
  - Issue 1 (terminology for investment income): Recommend changing term “interest” to “interest and similar returns” for Islamic deposits, loans, and debt securities.
    - Classification/Type: CH B
    - Inclusion in BPM7: Yes
    - Bucket: 1
  - Issue 2 (sectorization and output of Islamic financial entities): Recommendations for sectorization and output calculation across several Islamic product types (restricted investment accounts, Islamic windows, Waqf funds, Hajj funds).
    - Classification/Type: CL B + D
    - Inclusion in BPM7: Yes
    - Bucket: 1
  - Issue 3 (economic ownership of non-financial assets related to Islamic financing arrangements): Clarifications on possible separate institutional unit, facilitator roles, ultimate purchasers, and timing of recording acquisition; default cases where client remains economic owner despite payment default.
    - Classification/Type: CL B + D
    - Inclusion in BPM7: Yes
    - Bucket: 1
  - Issue 4 (classification decision tree): Recommend constructing a decision tree for classifying Islamic financial instruments using factors: institutional unit form, instrument design, on/off-balance-sheet, type of claim, negotiability, and ownership size.
    - Classification/Type: CL B + D
    - Inclusion in BPM7: Yes
    - Bucket: 1
  - Issue 6 (Islamic insurance (takaful and retakaful)):
    - Recommendations: (i) classify takaful operators and takaful funds as separate institutional units; (ii) sectorize them into S126 (financial auxiliaries) and S128 (insurance corporations) as appropriate; (iii) calculate output of takaful operators as wakalah fees and/or share of profits from investing takaful funds, and output of takaful funds as sum of costs plus share of profit payable to takaful operators and other intermediate consumption.
    - Classification/Type: CL B + D
    - Inclusion in BPM7: Yes
    - Bucket: 1
  - Issue 7 (appendix on Islamic finance): Recommend including special section or appendix on Islamic finance in updated BPM and SNA to highlight differences and interconnections.
    - Classification/Type: AD B + D
    - Bucket: -1
  - Issue 8 (compilation guide on Islamic finance): Recommend developing Islamic finance compilation guide covering differences, satellite accounts, and practical guidance with numerical examples.
    - Classification/Type: AD B + D
    - Bucket: -

### Globalization, SPEs, MNEs, and intellectual property
- GN G.1 (Valuation of Imports and Exports: CIF to FOB Adjustment):
  - Observation: BPM6 and 2008 SNA recommend recording imports and exports at FOB; alternatives (transaction/invoice values) considered conceptually sound but not adopted now.
  - Recommendation: Maintain status quo for current updates; set use of transaction prices (Option 3) as conceptual goal for next round of BPM and SNA updates; phased approach between BPM7 and 2025 SNA recommended.
  - Type: SQ
  - Bucket: 2
- GN G.2 (Treatment of MNE and Intra-MNE Flows):
  - Recommendation: Define MNE as legal entity with (i) at least one nonresident affiliate or branch and (ii) control exercised directly (over 50 percent voting) or by indirect transmission of control; MNE is the ultimate controlling parent (UCP). Support including a new chapter on globalization in BPM7.
  - Classification/Type: CL A + B + D
  - Links: D.4 + D.6 + G.4 + G.7
  - Inclusion in BPM7: Yes
  - Bucket: 1
- GN G.4 (Treatment of SPEs and Residency):
  - Issue 1: Recommend adopting international definition of Special Purpose Entities (SPEs) in BPM7 and 2025 SNA and integrating breakdown of SPEs within institutional sector accounts as supplementary for relevant countries.
    - Classification/Type: AD A + B + C + D
    - Links: CI SI D.5 + D.14 + F.1
    - Inclusion in BPM7: Yes
    - Bucket: 1
  - Issue 2: Recommend presenting nationality-based SPE statistics as supplement to residency-based statistics where SPEs are important.
    - Classification/Type: AD A + B + C + D
    - Links: CI SI D.6
    - Bucket: 1
- GN G.5 (Economic Ownership of Intellectual Property Products):
  - Finding: Economic ownership of previously produced IPP within MNEs depends on underlying arrangements; no default solution.
  - Recommendation: Use the Guide to Measuring Global Production decision tree to determine economic owner; clarify SPEs can be economic owners of IPP aligned with GN G.4 and IMF “Operational Guidelines on SPEs.”
  - Classification/Type: CL A + B + D
  - Links: G.4
  - Inclusion in BPM7: Yes
  - Bucket: 1
- GN G.7 (Global Value Chains and Trade in Value Added):
  - Recommendation: No changes to core BPM and SNA concepts; include description of GVCs and trade in value added in updated manuals; within BPM, include supplementary cross-border statistics detailed by geography or product as part of reporting template for GVC data collection.
  - Classification/Type: AD A + B + C + D
  - Links: CI SI C.2 + C.4 + D.6 + G.2
  - Inclusion in BPM7: Yes
  - Bucket: 1

### Digitalization and selected task team notes
- GN DZ.3 (Treatment of "Free" Digital Products):
  - Recommendation: No changes in framework for balance of payments statistics; updated BPM should note that free services of non-resident platforms may be funded indirectly through international transactions in advertising and other items; references to OECD-WTO-IMF Handbook on Measuring Digital Trade can be made.
  - Classification/Type: CL A + B
  - Inclusion in BPM7: Yes
  - Bucket: 1
- GN DZ.7 (Improving visibility of Artificial Intelligence in national accounts):
  - Recommendation: Update SNA definition of intellectual property rights and include definition of artificial intelligence; these SNA definitions could be included in the updated BPM.
  - Classification/Type: CL A + B
  - Inclusion in BPM7: No
  - Bucket: 1

Italic: IMF Committee on Balance of Payments Statistics — Outcomes of the Holistic Review: Survey of BPM6 Update Priorities

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/data/statistics/bpm6/outcomes-of-the-holistic-review-survey-of-bpm6-update-priorities.pdf_
