## New Foundations for International Macro Policy

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [New Foundations for International Macro Policy](https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/news/speech/2023/aea-slides-v7.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/files/news/speech/2023/aea-slides-v7.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/files/news/speech/2023/aea-slides-v7.pdf.json)

---

### Mundell-Fleming framework and its role
- Mundell-Fleming laid the groundwork for the analysis of floating regimes after the collapse of Bretton Woods in 1973.
- Core questions posed by Mundell-Fleming:
  - Do monetary policy and flexible exchange rates achieve domestic goals (i.e., employment, price, and financial stability) after shocks?
  - Are foreign exchange intervention & capital controls needed to achieve those goals?
- Slide answers (classic view):
  - Do monetary policy and flexible exchange rates achieve domestic goals after shocks? YES
  - Are foreign exchange intervention & capital controls needed to achieve those goals? NO
- Today: remains a workhorse in undergraduate textbooks, but policy analysis complements Mundell-Fleming with other models and evidence to capture shocks and frictions affecting emerging markets and developing economies.
- IMF’s Integrated Policy Framework (2020 onwards):
  - Incorporates shocks and frictions outside Mundell-Fleming, interactions between different frictions.
  - Role for FX intervention, macroprudential measures, and capital controls.

### Have the key insights changed?
- New research on pricing and financial frictions (illustrated by diagrams from the IMF’s IPF conceptual model) suggests revised insights that should inform the next generation of textbooks.
- Two core questions revisited:
  1. Do monetary policy and flexible exchange rates achieve domestic goals after shocks?  
     - Impact of exchange rate on trade balance and output may differ from textbook predictions.
  2. Are FXI & capital controls needed to achieve those goals?  
     - Answers depend on new research on pricing (invoice currency) and financial frictions.

### Dominant Currency Paradigm (DCP) and trade-pricing frictions
- Empirical observation: there are around 180 currencies; only very few are used in international trade, finance, and official reserves.
- Price stickiness literature (selected references from slides) separates pricing regimes:
  - Producer currency, local currency, and dominant currency invoicing literatures cited.
- Key mechanism: invoice-currency-weighted exchange rate (often the dollar) matters for exchange-rate pass-through (ERPT) and import-price inflation, not the bilateral or trade-weighted exchange rate.
  - Example evidence: Chen, Chung, and Novy (2018) for the UK: short-run pass-through into import unit values is 43.6% when using vehicle currency exchange rates vs. 17.9% when using only bilateral exchange rates.
- Expenditure switching in short-term:
  - Effect of 10% Depreciation takes place mainly through imports and not exports in the short-term (source: Adler et al. (2020)).

DCP: takeaways (from slides)
- 1. Do monetary policy and flexible exchange rates achieve domestic goals after shocks?
  - Yes→No
  - Impact of exchange rate on trade balance and output: smaller
  - Asymmetry: USD appreciation reduces global trade, including non-US-related trade, causing additional spillovers
- 2. Are FXI & capital controls needed to achieve those goals?
  - No
  - Policy rate continues to target producer price inflation
  - FX intervention, capital controls cannot mitigate DCP friction

### Financial frictions and borrowing constraints
- Important frictions:
  - External debt limits (positive and normative literatures cited).
  - Shallow markets and imperfect substitutability of assets (positive and normative literatures cited).
  - Financial terms-of-trade externality and pecuniary externalities appear when external borrowing constraints bind.
- Global Financial Cycle transmits US monetary policy and credit conditions (literature cited).
- Empirical response of emerging markets to inflows: tend to use policy rate, FX intervention, capital controls (source: Ghosh et al. (2017)).

Frictions in borrowing: takeaways (from slides)
- 1. Do monetary policy and flexible exchange rates achieve domestic goals after shocks?
  - Yes→Not always
  - Credit conditions co-move owing to global financial cycle
  - If financial constraints bind, goals are not achieved
- 2. Are FXI & capital controls needed to achieve those goals?
  - No→Yes, sometimes
  - Ex ante FX regulations and market development support ex post exchange rate flexibility after fundamental shocks
  - Ex post FX intervention and capital controls dominate policy rate and exchange rate flexibility after non-fundamental shocks

### Policy analysis: optimal responses vary by shock
- Framework distinguishes shocks and timing:
  - t=0: Price-setting decision
  - t=1: Shock realized
  - t=2: Borrowing constraints; ex ante policies and ex post policies matter
- Adverse commodity price shock (fundamental):
  - Decline in wealth ⇒ Reduce imports ⇒ Shift IS curve inward.
  - External FX debt limit may bind; if so, home output gap is not closed due to pecuniary externality.
  - Ex ante FX regulations + market development ⇒ Greater benefits of ex post exchange rate flexibility.
- Taper tantrum (non-fundamental) + shallow FX market:
  - Imports↓, premia↑
  - Depreciation alone does not insulate the economy.
  - Ex post FX intervention and capital controls can insulate; with those tools, depreciation is not needed.
  - Visual slides illustrate sequences where FX intervention and capital controls restore outcomes that depreciation alone cannot.

### Conclusions and implications for policy instruments
- Summary of answers across frictions:
  - 1. Do monetary policy and flexible exchange rates achieve domestic goals after shocks?
    - Yes→No under DCP and/or financial frictions
  - 2. Are FXI & capital controls needed to achieve those goals?
    - No→No under DCP
    - No→Yes, sometimes with financial frictions
- Drivers of international monetary system (IMS): endogenous currency choice
  - DCP may incentivize borrowing and lending in USD, and vice versa (Gopinath and Stein (2020)); additional literature noted.

Evolution of IMF thinking (slides)
- Role for capital controls in specific circumstances:
  - Institutional View on Capital Flows (2012): To manage surges
  - Review of Institutional View (2022): To manage FX mismatches pre-emptively
- Whether and how to use multiple instruments:
  - Integrated Policy Framework (2020 onwards)
  - FX intervention, capital controls, and macroprudential measures alongside policy rate and exchange rate flexibility

### Open questions (from slides)
- Inflation targeting with financial frictions
- Gains from monetary policy coordination
- New issues from shadow banking and crypto assets
- Implications of geo-economic fragmentation

*AEA/AFA Luncheon Address, January 6, 2023 — slides titled "New Foundations for International Macro Policy" by Gita Gopinath (International Monetary Fund).*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/news/speech/2023/aea-slides-v7.pdf_
