## CBDC: Further Navigating Challenges and Opportunities

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [CBDC: Further Navigating Challenges and Opportunities](https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/oap/oap-home/2025/tokyo-2025-session-1-cbdc-handbook-tommaso-v2.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/files/oap/oap-home/2025/tokyo-2025-session-1-cbdc-handbook-tommaso-v2.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/files/oap/oap-home/2025/tokyo-2025-session-1-cbdc-handbook-tommaso-v2.pdf.json)

---

### Current CBDC Landscape
- IMF notes growing global interest in CBDCs, with particular expansion in wholesale use cases.
- Exact survey and adoption findings:
  - "91% of 93 CBs are exploring rCBDCs, wCBDCs, or both (BIS 2024 survey)."
  - Interest in rCBDCs remains high in certain regions e.g. Sub-Saharan Africa.
  - Yet rCBDC adoption remains low (Nigeria, Jamaica, Bahamas).
  - Pilots have expanded via FPS-CBDC linkages (China-HK) and onboarding of non-banks (India).
  - Some are preparing for near-term issuance (Kazakhstan, Russia), while others continue to carefully assess use cases, market fit, and operational feasibility (UK, EU).
  - Some have paused rCBDC efforts (Canada, Australia, Thailand,and the US).
- wCBDC work is advancing, driven by tokenization and cross-border use cases.
- IMF capacity development guidance:
  - Encourages a careful and systematic approach, rather than rushing to deployment.
  - Emphasizes being more data-driven and tailored to country-specific conditions.
  - Expands into adjacent areas, such as cross-border payments.

### Background: CBDC Handbook Chapters
- The Handbook contains chapters covering objectives, framework, foundational requirements and readiness, design process, technology and project approaches, potential macro-financial implications, digital money positioning, legal considerations, adoption strategies for intermediaries and users, Project Management: 5P Framework, CBDC’s Role in Promoting Financial Inclusion, cyber resilience, financial integrity, monetary policy transmission, tokenized reserves strategy, evaluation, data use and privacy protection, implications for financial stability, capital flow management measures, retail CBDC for cross-border payments, payment resilience in fragile and conflict-affected states, impact on payments competition, and implications for monetary operations.
- Legend for publication timing used in the Handbook:
  - "Published in 2023"
  - "Published in 2024"
  - "To be published in 2025"

### 1. Evaluating the Implications of rCBDC for Financial Stability
- Six interrelated channels identified: asset, liability, fee income, run risk, information, payment system resilience.
- Impact depends on factors such as adoption, country characteristics, and design features.
- Quantitative studies found that rCBDC would not pose significant financial stability issues if mildly adopted.
- Assessment approach and mitigation:
  - Impact assessments can begin with bank balance sheet analyses, and evolve with macro-financial modeling and ongoing data collection.
  - Risk mitigation via careful rCBDC design (e.g. limits on CBDC holdings or fees applied to holdings above a certain limit) and traditional safeguards.

### 2. The Impact of rCBDC on Competition in Retail Payments
- Retail payment markets prone to concentration from strong network effects and platform dynamics.
- Impact of rCBDC depends on market structure, regulatory environment, and design choices.
- Alternative policy tools and comparative effects:
  - Other tools exist (e.g., fee caps, public FPS) but may fall short.
  - In markets dominated by unregulated private platforms, rCBDC may have the strongest effect by reducing fees, improving access, and enhancing service standards.
  - In regulated markets with fee caps or in markets with strong public FPS, rCBDC stands to have a more moderate effect.
- Trade-offs:
  - Competition benefits must be balanced against risks, such as crowding out private providers, reducing market resilience, or increasing operational costs for central banks.

### 3. Selected Legal Considerations for CBDC
- Jurisdictions need to assess legal frameworks to minimize legal, financial, operational, and reputational risks.
- rCBDC legal points:
  - Granting currency status may necessitate amendments to central bank and monetary laws.
  - Adequate legal frameworks are imperative to issue rCBDC and to own and operate rCBDC platforms.
  - Clear delineation of legal responsibilities is required among the central bank, intermediaries, and users.
  - Limits, fees, interest, programmability, and offline use, must be anchored in the law.
- wCBDC legal points:
  - Statutory authority should extend to issue wCBDC and operate wCBDC platforms, while maintaining central bank's ultimate control.
  - Legal clarity is needed on settlement finality and treatment of wCBDC tokens in cases of loss, unauthorized transfer, or good-faith acquisition.

### 4. Financial Integrity Considerations for rCBDC
- Financial integrity implications depend on rCBDC’s specific features.
- AML/CFT implications:
  - rCBDCs may pose challenges or could present opportunities for effective implementation of AML/CFT measures.
  - ML/TF risks should be understood and assessed throughout development, pilot, and launch.
  - Some aspects of AML/CFT implementation can mirror traditional approaches, but others may require new systems or further guidance.
- Open questions:
  - Little precedent on the application of the FATF Standards to rCBDCs, raising interpretive and practical challenges.
  - Key questions relate to evolving role of central banks, whether effective application of AML/CFT preventive measures can be achieved in models with "cash-like" features.

### 5. Payment Ecosystem Resilience in Fragile and Conflict-Affected States (FCS)
- Payment ecosystem resilience is essential for maintaining trust and economic continuity in FCS.
- Five interconnected layers: (i) users; (ii) payment solutions; (iii) intermediaries; (iv) payment infrastructure; (v) connectivity infrastructure.
- Lessons drawn from FCS experiences: CEMAC, Haiti, Tuvalu, Sudan, Ukraine, West Bank & Gaza, Yemen.
- How CBDC could strengthen resilience:
  - Reinforcing trust as a complementary form of central bank money.
  - Providing a backup payment channel and bridging infrastructure gaps.
  - Embedding resilience-by-design features (e.g. offline, cloud for redundancy), under flexible regulation.

### 6. Central Bank Exploration of Tokenized Reserves
- Central banks are exploring tokenizing reserves to enhance the wholesale payment system and preserve the role of central bank money if asset tokenization becomes widespread.
- Implementation model trade-offs:
  - Single ledger vs. compatible ledgers.
  - Models require different degrees of central bank’s involvement (sole operator vs. shared responsibility).
- Potential benefits and requirements:
  - Tokenization offers new capabilities to enhance monetary operations, via smart contracts which could help automate and support 24/7 market operations or improve collateral management.
  - Central banks need to adopt coherent policies and operational safeguards.
- Alternatives and strategic variation:
  - Countries could also consider alternative solutions e.g., RTGS links, tokenized deposits, omnibus accounts.
  - Strategic decisions and policy options will vary across jurisdictions.

### Key Takeaways
- CBDC design and implementation require a holistic, country-specific approach.
- There is no one-size-fits-all path, underscoring the need for careful, evidence-based assessment rather than rushing to deployment.
- The six new Handbook chapters offer guidance to policymakers on further navigating challenges and opportunities, including evaluating the macro-financial implications.
- The Handbook serves as a basis for the IMF’s bilateral capacity development work, which is complemented by analytical work thereby facilitating knowledge-sharing among countries.
- "We express sincere appreciation to the Government of Japan for supporting the Handbook and capacity development efforts."

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/oap/oap-home/2025/tokyo-2025-session-1-cbdc-handbook-tommaso-v2.pdf_
