## Gender Equality and COVID-19: Policies and Institutions for Mitigating the Crisis

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [Gender Equality and COVID-19: Policies and Institutions for Mitigating the Crisis](https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/covid19-special-notes/en-special-series-on-covid-19-gender-equality-and-covid-19.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/files/publications/covid19-special-notes/en-special-series-on-covid-19-gender-equality-and-covid-19.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/files/publications/covid19-special-notes/en-special-series-on-covid-19-gender-equality-and-covid-19.pdf.json)

---

### Summary findings
- The COVID-19 crisis threatens decades of progress for women and girls, disproportionately impacting women’s incomes, employment, and education opportunities, while increasing unpaid care pressures and fueling a “shadow pandemic” of gender-based violence.
- Countries should deploy gender-responsive policies and gender-responsive budgeting to mitigate short-term impacts and address long-term structural drivers of gender inequality.
- Drawing on the UNDP–UN Women COVID-19 Global Gender Response Tracker, only a fraction of fiscal and social protection measures enacted in response to the pandemic were explicitly gender-sensitive:
  - Of a sample of 580 fiscal measures, only 12 percent are defined as “gender-sensitive.”
  - Of 1,700 social protection and labor market measures, 23 percent are gender-sensitive.

### I. Introduction: COVID and impact on gender gaps
- Women account for 70 percent of the health and social care workforce responding to the pandemic, raising risk of infection and concerns over their health and safety.
- Poverty projections and timing:
  - Poverty rates rising from 11.7 percent in 2019 to 12.5 percent in 2021 for women and girls.
  - Poverty rates rising from 11.3 percent in 2019 to 12.1 percent in 2021 for men and boys.
  - It may take until 2030 to revert to pre-pandemic levels.
- Gender-based violence is on the rise as lockdown and social isolation exacerbate risks of domestic violence.
- Employment and labor-market impacts:
  - The pandemic heavily affected sectors with large shares of women workers: retail, hospitality, food service, and the garment industry.
  - In low-income countries, more than 80 percent of women’s employment is in the informal sector.
  - Female labor force participation declined more than for men in some countries, raising the risk of long-term unemployment or lower participation rates.
- Education and digital access:
  - The Malala Fund estimates that 20 million girls in developing countries may never return to the classroom after pandemic-related school shutdowns.
  - Persistent gender gaps in digital access may reduce job and education opportunities for women and girls.

### II. Policies to address gender impacts of COVID-19
- Overall fiscal response scale and gender sensitivity:
  - As of March 17, 2021, direct budget support (expenditure and foregone revenue) amounted to $10 trillion or 9.2 percent of global 2020 GDP.
  - Revenue and spending measures were 16.4 percent of 2020 GDP for advanced economies, 4.2 percent for emerging market economies, and 1.7 percent for low-income developing countries (April 2021 Fiscal Monitor).
- Bolstering women’s incomes through social protection and leave:
  - Paid leave examples:
    - Italy: parents of children younger than 12 allowed up to 30 days leave while receiving 50 percent of the salary paid by the state.
    - United States: parents caring for children whose schools were closed allowed a maximum of 12 weeks of paid family leave, provided for by employers.
    - Spain: temporary 100 percent reduction of working hours made available to those providing care for dependents.
    - Canada: provided cash support to those who stopped working because, among other reasons, they were caring for children.
  - Cash transfers:
    - Brazil: Emergency Aid cash transfer program covering about one-third of the population and providing double the benefits to households headed by women.
    - Egypt: expanded Takaful and Karama cash transfer programs to reach about 3.8 million households, mainly targeting female heads of households.
    - Colombia: extraordinary subsidy to 2.7 million households where mothers are the main recipient.
  - Example of temporary progressivity enhancement:
    - India: three months of pension contributions were covered by the government for firms with fewer than 100 employees of which at least 90 percent must earn low wages.
  - Medium-term priority: invest in robust, gender-responsive social protection systems by increasing coverage and adequacy, especially in countries with high informality.
- Supporting women’s employment in crisis and recovery:
  - Childcare and unpaid care:
    - Increased unpaid care associated with school closures and illness has disproportionately fallen upon women, contributing to exits from the labor force and reductions in hours and earnings.
    - Example: in Latin America, women with children younger than 6 experienced the sharpest drop in labor force participation.
    - Short-term pandemic measures included emergency childcare services for essential workers and financial compensation to parents for school and daycare closures (“cash for care”).
  - Flexible work and leave:
    - Almost all OECD countries provide mothers with at least 14 weeks leave around childbirth; most provide benefits that replace more than 50 percent of previous earnings.
  - Tax systems and incentives to work:
    - Family-based tax systems can disincentivize work for secondary earners (who tend to be women) by imposing higher marginal tax rates on secondary earners or providing family-level benefits that are lost if a secondary earner becomes employed.
    - Many countries have very high tax wedges at the lower end of the labor market; reforms to reduce high tax wedges at the lower end would provide stronger incentives for women and the poor to join the labor market.
  - Gender gaps over the lifecycle:
    - Average gender pension gap of 25 percent among OECD countries.

### Policy recommendations and instruments emphasized
- Deploy gender-responsive policies and gender-responsive budgeting to:
  - Mitigate immediate impacts on women’s incomes, employment, education, and safety.
  - Address long-term structural drivers of gender inequality and avoid long-term scarring.
- Design fiscal policy (expenditure and tax) with an explicit gender lens to:
  - Protect incomes and support employment through paid leave, cash transfers, and social protection expansion.
  - Use tax policy to finance gender-responsive spending and to reduce disincentives for female labor force participation (e.g., reform family-based taxation and lower tax wedges at the bottom of the labor market).
- Prioritize investment in social infrastructure and care services to reduce unpaid care burdens and support women’s labor force participation and long-term human capital formation.
- Expand coverage and adequacy of social protection systems, targeting informality and ensuring decent living wages and rights protection for workers in formal and informal sectors.
- Use gender-responsive budgeting to monitor gender outcomes and assess impacts of gender-responsive fiscal policies during recovery.

### Support for women's employment and female-dominated sectors
- Tax and labor-market measures:
  - Introduce earned income tax credits where administrative capacity exists; reduce high marginal tax rates to support women’s employment.
  - Defer or reduce social security contributions to support the lower end of the labor market and women.
  - Out of 107 policy packages that deferred or reduced taxes, 22 were targeted at sectors with high female employment rates.
- Targeted support and examples:
  - Public works programs (example: MGNREGA program in India).
  - Financial and logistical support for women-owned enterprises (examples: Paraguay, South Africa, Turkey).
  - Morocco supported women’s cooperatives to produce 30,000 reusable masks per day.
- Sectoral tax measures:
  - Burkina Faso: suspension of recovery of tax debts and collection of the flat-rate minimum for transport, hotel and catering sectors, where accommodation and food service activities account for 7.8 percent of women's employment compared to 1.7 percent of men's.
  - Côte d’Ivoire: deferred for three months the payment of capital income tax for tourism and hotel businesses; tourism-related activities cover 10 percent of female employment but only 1 percent of male employment.
- Recommendation: Maintain or expand these measures depending on pandemic developments; consider amending tax systems that increase likelihood of bankruptcies (for example through earnings-independent taxes, such as minimum taxes or business property taxes) that can disproportionately harm women entrepreneurs.

### Invest in decent work for women and public care services
- Adopt active labor market measures to support reintegration of women into the labor force, including training programs, wage incentives, and skills development.
  - Chile: subsidize salaries for up to six months with higher benefits for women, young people, and persons with disabilities to incentivize rehiring and new hires.
- Public investment in the care economy:
  - Simulation for eight OECD countries shows investments in quality care services would create 40–90 percent more jobs than the same level of investments in construction.
  - South Africa: making childcare universally available to all children younger than 5 could create 2–3 million new jobs and raise female employment rates by 10 percentage points.

### Promoting well-being, opportunities, and addressing social norms
- Support frontline workers with continued healthcare spending for personal protective equipment and necessary medical supplies; prioritize medical personnel for vaccination.
- Compensate for loss of education to avoid permanent scarring from instructional losses due to school closures:
  - Ramp up public spending on education to support remote learning, encourage re-enrollment (prioritizing those at higher risk of dropping out, especially girls), and offset learning losses.
- Target the gender digital divide to support livelihoods, access to services, employment, health, finance, social capital, and protection from gender-based violence.
- Explicitly address gender social norms through fiscal policy:
  - UNDP Gender Social Norms Index finding: 50 percent of men worldwide think that, in times of scarcity and crisis, employment should be prioritized for men.
  - Behavioral tools: non-transferrable mandatory paternity leaves; tax incentives for companies meeting gender-equality targets; creation of public women-in-STEM clubs.

### Policy conclusions and fiscal strategy
- Public spending, tax policy measures, and off-budget interventions are critical to building more resilient and inclusive societies and economies; fiscal policy is an important driver of inclusive recovery and progress toward gender equality, contributing to poverty reduction.
- Short-term policy focus:
  - Attenuate negative pandemic impacts on specific groups, including women.
  - Extend income support to those most in need, preserve employment linkages, help manage work and caring responsibilities, and expand support for small businesses and the self-employed.
  - For countries with limited fiscal space, enhance spending efficiency and reallocate resources toward those most affected before scaling up spending.
- Medium-term policy focus:
  - Build fiscal space for gender-responsive policies by enhancing domestic revenue mobilization and improving spending efficiency while accounting for post-COVID strategic priorities.
- Coordinate tax and spending policies for greater effectiveness (example: combine tax cuts to boost labor supply with access to childcare that ensures functioning and safe provision).
- Use Integrated National Financing Frameworks (INFF) to coordinate financing of gender equality and the Sustainable Development Goals across tax and spending policies.
- Strengthen social protection systems to improve pandemic preparedness and response.

### Using gender-responsive budgeting (GRB) and gender impact assessments (GIA)
- GRB integrates gender considerations into public financial management (laws, rules, systems and processes to allocate public funds, undertake public spending, account transactions and monitor and audit results).
- Key GRB institutions and tools:
  - Legislative framework and guidelines, gender-impact assessments, fiscal reports using gender tagging, performance-related frameworks for gender policies, and government accountability systems including parliamentary oversight and audits.
- Data and practice gaps:
  - IMF survey on gender budgeting practices in 91 countries: less than 30 percent of respondents have sex-disaggregated data in all or most sectors; in countries where such data are produced, less than 40 percent use them regularly to inform budget preparation.
  - Data reported by 69 countries and territories on SDG Indicator 5.c.1 find that as of 2018, only 32 percent of countries produce gender budget statements.
- Ex ante Gender Impact Assessments (GIA):
  - Ex ante GIA estimates the different impacts (positive, negative, or neutral) of a policy proposal on gender equality and can be applied to gender-specific and non-gender-specific programs.
  - Country practices:
    - Canada: Gender Based Analysis (GBA+) requires all new budget proposals to be submitted to ex ante GIA according to a governmentwide methodology.
    - Spain: Institute of Women and Equal Opportunities compiled and published an ex ante GIA of the COVID-19 emergency measures.
    - Rwanda: expanded access to Public Works, cash-transfer programs, and the Community Based Health Insurance (CBHI) scheme; impact analysis showed a stronger benefit to women-led households.
  - IMF GRB survey: only 20 percent of respondent countries undertake GIAs for all or most new policy proposals.
- Performance audits and evaluation:
  - Supreme Audit Institutions (SAIs) can integrate a gender dimension into audit work to provide ex post accountability.
  - Examples: Peru’s SAI gathers performance-related information on vulnerable groups benefiting from emergency measures; SAIs of Serbia and Uganda announced audits on intimate partner violence increases during COVID-19.
  - UN Data from SDG Indicator 5.c.1: independent gender audits are used in 19 percent of reporting countries (13 out of 69 countries).
  - Barriers to gender audits include capacity constraints, gaps between strategic planning and budgeting, and limited sex-disaggregated data.
- Operational guidance:
  - Apply GRB tools throughout the public finance management cycle: planning, budgeting, executing, and evaluating budget performance from a gender perspective.
  - Use Gender Budget Statements, Pre-Budget Statements, budget call circulars, and gender-impact assessments to anchor gender-responsive goals, ensure resources are channeled, and create transparency and accountability.

*IMF Special Series note, July 28, 2021.*

### Section 1

### Gender Equality and COVID-19: Policies and Institutions for Mitigating the Crisis

### Summary findings
- The COVID-19 crisis threatens decades of progress for women and girls, disproportionately impacting women’s incomes, employment, and education opportunities, while increasing unpaid care pressures and fueling a “shadow pandemic” of gender-based violence.
- Countries should deploy gender-responsive policies and budgeting to mitigate short-term impacts and address long-term structural drivers of gender inequality.
- Drawing on the UNDP–UN Women COVID-19 Global Gender Response Tracker, only a fraction of fiscal and social protection measures enacted in response to the pandemic were explicitly gender-sensitive.

### I. Introduction: COVID and impact on gender gaps
- Women account for 70 percent of the health and social care workforce responding to the pandemic, raising risk of infection and concerns over their health and safety.
- Poverty projections and timing:
  - Poverty rates rising from 11.7 percent in 2019 to 12.5 percent in 2021 for women and girls.
  - Poverty rates rising from 11.3 percent in 2019 to 12.1 percent in 2021 for men and boys.
  - It may take until 2030 to revert to pre-pandemic levels.
- Gender-based violence is on the rise as lockdown and social isolation exacerbate risks of domestic violence.
- Employment and labor-market impacts:
  - The pandemic heavily affected sectors with large shares of women workers: retail, hospitality, food service, and the garment industry.
  - In low-income countries, more than 80 percent of women’s employment is in the informal sector, with less job security, lower social protection, and lower pay.
  - Female labor force participation declined more than for men in some countries, raising the risk of long-term unemployment or lower participation rates.
- Education and digital access:
  - The Malala Fund estimates that 20 million girls in developing countries may never return to the classroom after pandemic-related school shutdowns.
  - Persistent gender gaps in digital access may reduce job and education opportunities for women and girls.

### II. Policies to address gender impacts of COVID-19
- Overall fiscal response scale and gender sensitivity:
  - As of March 17, 2021, direct budget support (expenditure and foregone revenue) amounted to $10 trillion or 9.2 percent of global 2020 GDP.
  - Revenue and spending measures were 16.4 percent of 2020 GDP for advanced economies, 4.2 percent for emerging market economies, and 1.7 percent for low-income developing countries (April 2021 Fiscal Monitor).
  - UNDP–UN Women Tracker: of a sample of 580 fiscal measures, only 12 percent are defined as “gender-sensitive.”
  - Of 1,700 social protection and labor market measures, 23 percent are gender-sensitive.
- Bolstering women’s incomes through social protection and leave
  - Paid leave examples:
    - Italy: parents of children younger than 12 allowed up to 30 days leave while receiving 50 percent of the salary paid by the state.
    - United States: parents caring for children whose schools were closed allowed a maximum of 12 weeks of paid family leave, provided for by employers.
    - Spain: temporary 100 percent reduction of working hours made available to those providing care for dependents.
    - Canada: provided cash support to those who stopped working because, among other reasons, they were caring for children.
  - Cash transfers:
    - Brazil: Emergency Aid cash transfer program covering about one-third of the population and providing double the benefits to households headed by women.
    - Egypt: expanded Takaful and Karama cash transfer programs to reach about 3.8 million households, mainly targeting female heads of households.
    - Colombia: extraordinary subsidy to 2.7 million households where mothers are the main recipient.
  - Tax measures that target the poor will benefit women who are overrepresented in lower-income brackets.
  - Example of temporary progressivity enhancement:
    - India: three months of pension contributions were covered by the government for firms with fewer than 100 employees of which at least 90 percent must earn low wages.
  - Medium-term priority: invest in robust, gender-responsive social protection systems by increasing coverage and adequacy, especially in countries with high informality.
- Supporting women’s employment in crisis and recovery
  - Childcare and unpaid care:
    - Increased unpaid care associated with school closures and illness has disproportionately fallen upon women, contributing to exits from the labor force and reductions in hours and earnings.
    - Example: in Latin America, women with children younger than 6 experienced the sharpest drop in labor force participation.
    - Policy priorities: enhance availability and affordability of care services (children, older people, persons with disabilities), expand access to paid parental leave, and support social infrastructure (childcare services, water, sanitation, energy, digital services).
    - Short-term pandemic measures included emergency childcare services for essential workers and financial compensation to parents for school and daycare closures (“cash for care”).
    - Tax policies to mitigate childcare costs for users (child-care tax credits or tax-deductibility) or measures to support childcare facilities are recommended.
  - Flexible work and leave:
    - Flexible work arrangements and access to paid family leave help working parents balance unpaid care with paid employment.
    - Redistribution of household responsibilities—e.g., mandatory and non-transferable paternity leave—can alleviate burdens on women.
    - Almost all OECD countries provide mothers with at least 14 weeks leave around childbirth; most provide benefits that replace more than 50 percent of previous earnings. Availability and generosity of father-specific parental and paternity leave vary considerably.
  - Tax systems and incentives to work:
    - Notionally gender-neutral tax policy can exacerbate inequalities when it negatively affects groups where women are over-represented or ignores structural gender differences.
    - Family-based tax systems disincentivize work for secondary earners (who tend to be women) by imposing higher marginal tax rates on secondary earners or providing family-level benefits that are lost if a secondary earner becomes employed.
    - Many countries have very high tax wedges at the lower end of the labor market, often driven by social security contributions; reforms that reduce high tax wedges at the lower end would provide stronger incentives for women and the poor to join the labor market.
  - Gender gaps over the lifecycle:
    - The gender gap in current income reinforces inequality among the elderly, with an average gender pension gap of 25 percent among OECD countries.

### Policy recommendations and instruments emphasized
- Deploy gender-responsive policies and gender-responsive budgeting to:
  - Mitigate immediate impacts on women’s incomes, employment, education, and safety.
  - Address long-term structural drivers of gender inequality and avoid long-term scarring.
- Design fiscal policy (expenditure and tax) with an explicit gender lens to:
  - Protect incomes and support employment through paid leave, cash transfers, and social protection expansion.
  - Use tax policy to finance gender-responsive spending and to reduce disincentives for female labor force participation (e.g., reform family-based taxation and lower tax wedges at the bottom of the labor market).
- Prioritize investment in social infrastructure and care services to reduce unpaid care burdens and support women’s labor force participation and long-term human capital formation.
- Expand coverage and adequacy of social protection systems, targeting informality and ensuring decent living wages and rights protection for workers in formal and informal sectors.
- Use gender-responsive budgeting to monitor gender outcomes and assess impacts of gender-responsive fiscal policies during recovery.

*IMF Special Series note, July 28, 2021.*

### Section 2

### en-special-series-on-covid-19-gender-equality-and-covid-19 - Section 2

### Support for women's employment and female-dominated sectors
- Introduce earned income tax credits where administrative capacity exists; reduce high marginal tax rates to support women’s employment.
- Defer or reduce social security contributions to support the lower end of the labor market and women; example: Chile’s law requiring employers to pay social security and pension contributions if employment contracts are suspended, in exchange for government-extended unemployment insurance benefits.
- Targeted support for female-dominated sectors and women-owned enterprises:
  - Public works programs (example: MGNREGA program in India).
  - Financial and logistical support for women-owned enterprises (examples: Paraguay, South Africa, Turkey).
  - Morocco supported women’s cooperatives in logistics, product delivery, communication, e-commerce platform development, and certification to produce 30,000 reusable masks per day.
- Tax measures targeting sectors with high female employment:
  - Suspension of recovery of tax debts and collection of the flat-rate minimum for transport, hotel and catering sectors in Burkina Faso, where accommodation and food service activities account for 7.8 percent of women's employment compared to 1.7 percent of men's.
  - Côte d’Ivoire deferred for three months the payment of capital income tax for tourism and hotel businesses; tourism-related activities (accommodation and food services) cover 10 percent of female employment but only 1 percent of male employment.
- Coverage and targeting statistics:
  - Out of 107 policy packages that deferred or reduced taxes, 22 were targeted at sectors with high female employment rates.
- Recommendation: Maintain or expand these measures depending on pandemic developments; consider amending tax systems that increase likelihood of bankruptcies (for example through earnings-independent taxes, such as minimum taxes or business property taxes) that can disproportionately harm women entrepreneurs.

### Invest in decent work for women and public care services
- Adopt active labor market measures to support reintegration of women into the labor force, including training programs, wage incentives, and skills development.
- Chile example: subsidize salaries for up to six months with higher benefits for women, young people, and persons with disabilities to incentivize rehiring and new hires.
- Address vertical and horizontal labor market segregation and gender pay gaps through:
  - Incentive packages and disincentives for bad practices for companies.
  - Education programs and entrepreneurship schemes.
  - Public investments in quality care services to enable workers with care responsibilities to compete equally.
- Public investment in the care economy:
  - Simulation for eight OECD countries shows investments in quality care services would create 40–90 percent more jobs than the same level of investments in construction.
  - South Africa example: making childcare universally available to all children younger than 5 could create 2–3 million new jobs and raise female employment rates by 10 percentage points.

### Promoting well-being, opportunities, and addressing social norms
- Support frontline workers with continued healthcare spending for personal protective equipment and necessary medical supplies; prioritize medical personnel for vaccination.
- Compensate for loss of education to avoid permanent scarring from instructional losses due to school closures:
  - Ramp up public spending on education to support remote learning, encourage re-enrollment (prioritizing those at higher risk of dropping out, especially girls), and offset learning losses.
  - Note: education attainments are positively correlated with female labor force participation.
- Target the gender digital divide to support livelihoods, access to services, employment, health, finance, social capital, and protection from gender-based violence.
- Explicitly address gender social norms through fiscal policy:
  - UNDP Gender Social Norms Index finding: 50 percent of men worldwide think that, in times of scarcity and crisis, employment should be prioritized for men.
  - Behavioral economic tools to disrupt norms: non-transferrable mandatory paternity leaves; tax incentives for companies meeting gender-equality targets; creation of public women-in-STEM clubs.

### Policy conclusions and fiscal strategy
- Public spending, tax policy measures, and off-budget interventions are critical to building more resilient and inclusive societies and economies; fiscal policy is an important driver of inclusive recovery and progress toward gender equality, contributing to poverty reduction.
- Reform tax systems during and after the pandemic to address long-standing structural impediments and avoid measures that disproportionately harm women.
- Short-term policy focus:
  - Attenuate negative pandemic impacts on specific groups, including women.
  - Extend income support to those most in need, preserve employment linkages, help manage work and caring responsibilities, and expand support for small businesses and the self-employed.
  - For countries with limited fiscal space (elevated debt or large gross financing needs), enhance spending efficiency and reallocate resources toward those most affected before scaling up spending.
- Medium-term policy focus:
  - Build fiscal space for gender-responsive policies by enhancing domestic revenue mobilization and improving spending efficiency while accounting for post-COVID strategic priorities.
- Coordinate tax and spending policies for greater effectiveness (example: combine tax cuts to boost labor supply with access to childcare that ensures functioning and safe provision).
- Use Integrated National Financing Frameworks (INFF) to coordinate financing of gender equality and the Sustainable Development Goals across tax and spending policies.
- Strengthen social protection systems to improve pandemic preparedness and response.

### Using gender-responsive budgeting (GRB) to implement gender-responsive policies
- GRB integrates gender considerations into public financial management (laws, rules, systems and processes to allocate public funds, undertake public spending, account transactions and monitor and audit results).
- Key GRB institutions (IMF, 2017):
  - Legislative framework and guidelines (including gender budget statements and gender-specific instructions in budget call circulars).
  - Gender-impact assessments.
  - Fiscal reports of gender programs and activities, using gender tagging.
  - Performance-related frameworks for gender policies.
  - Government accountability systems, including parliamentary oversight and audits.
- Entry points for countries at any experience level to jumpstart GRB.
- Assess the impact of the pandemic on gender:
  - Gender Needs Assessments consolidate evidence on sectoral impacts and reliance on public services.
  - Examples: UK Women and Equality Parliamentary committee inquiry; Thailand monitoring gender-based violence since lockdown in March 2020.
- Use sex-disaggregated data and gender statistics:
  - Draw on official statistics, administrative data, ad hoc surveys, studies, and nongovernmental sources.
  - Examples: Canada’s dedicated web portal on sex-disaggregated COVID-19 data; Honduras uses sex- and age-disaggregated data to monitor violence against women; UK Quarterly Labour Survey showing women were one-third more likely to work in a shutdown sector than men.
  - Rapid Gender Assessment Surveys (RGAS) and Socio-Economic Impact Assessments (SEIA) can temporarily bridge data gaps; examples of RGAS use in Uganda, Nigeria, Albania, North Macedonia, Kazakhstan; SEIA and rapid assessments used by UNDP (example: Gender Needs Assessment in Ukraine based on phone and online surveys).
- Data and practice gaps:
  - IMF survey on gender budgeting practices in 91 countries: less than 30 percent of respondents have sex-disaggregated data in all or most sectors; in countries where such data are produced, less than 40 percent use them regularly to inform budget preparation.
  - Data reported by 69 countries and territories on SDG Indicator 5.c.1 find that as of 2018, only 32 percent of countries produce gender budget statements.
- Set out a coherent strategy and allocate sufficient resources:
  - Gender Budget Statements (GBS) show how resources pursue gender equality goals but are typically annual and may not suit rapid crisis response; alternative formats (COVID-19 response plans) have been used to communicate gendered spending (example: Canada linking COVID-19 economic response plan to longer-term gender goals).
  - Anchor gender-responsive goals through Pre-Budget Statements and GBS to ensure resources are channeled and to create transparency and accountability.
  - Countries producing regular GBS include Australia, Bangladesh, Canada, India, Japan, Morocco, Rwanda, South Korea, and Spain.
- Budget preparation tools:
  - Use budget call circulars to issue guidelines on gender objectives and anchor gender equality into sectoral budget submissions.
  - Example: Philippines’ Budget Memorandum highlights priority policies and strategies with a gender perspective in health, nutrition, and social protection; a Joint Memorandum Circular of the Commission on Human Rights and Department of Interior and Local Government addresses violence against women with directives for gender-responsive and intersectional interventions during crisis, transition, and recovery.

*IMF | Fiscal Affairs*

### Section 3

### C. Design effective policy responses; D. Audit gender-related policy measures and evaluate their impact on women

### Ex Ante Gender Impact Assessments (GIA)
- Ex ante Gender Impact Assessments (GIA) improve formulation and prioritization of policies by identifying intended and unintended effects on gender equality.
- Ex ante GIA is the estimation of the different impacts (positive, negative, or neutral) of a policy proposal on gender equality.
- GIAs can be applied to policies specifically aimed at tackling gender gaps and to non-gender-specific programs to highlight unintended bias (for instance, during fiscal consolidation).
- Examples of potential unintended effects cited:
  - A wage subsidy scheme might leave out informal workers—often predominantly women.
  - A tax policy could discourage women from seeking employment.
- Country examples of GIA use and policy adjustments:
  - Iceland: The Ministry of Finance asked line ministries to estimate the number of jobs created and their gender ratio in project proposals for the 2020 investment program.
  - Enterprise Georgia: Using gender analysis, the program eliminated preconditions for eligibility and was expanded to some sectors where women often run businesses or are intensive in female labor force.
  - Rwanda: Expanded and facilitated access to the Public Works and cash-transfer programs and the rural-focused Community Based Health Insurance (CBHI) scheme; impact analysis showed a stronger benefit to women-led households.
- Survey evidence on GIA uptake:
  - According to the IMF GRB survey, GIAs are not widely used yet and only 20 percent of respondent countries undertake them for all or most new policy proposals.

### Government-wide methodology and country practices
- Government-wide methodologies can support systematic use of ex ante GIA by setting out:
  - Key gender gaps to analyze.
  - Transmission channels of policies.
  - Metrics to quantify impact.
- Country practices:
  - Canada: Gender Based Analysis (GBA+) requires all new budget proposals to be submitted to ex ante GIA according to a governmentwide methodology.
  - Spain: The Institute of Women and Equal Opportunities (IWEO) compiled and published an ex ante GIA of the COVID-19 emergency measures on the basis of a governmentwide methodology.
  - Kosovo: UN Women supported the Ministry of Finance in conducting ex ante GIA on selected measures of the Economic Recovery Program.
  - Philippines: Policy initiatives targeted toward women for the COVID-19 response were published and included a GIA.

### Performance audits of gender policies and evaluation
- Performance audits can assess the effectiveness of government responses on women and marginalized groups.
- Supreme Audit Institutions (SAIs) can integrate a gender dimension into audit work to provide ex post accountability on whether national responses addressed needs of women, girls, and marginalized groups.
- Country audit examples and initiatives:
  - Peru’s SAI gathers performance-related information on the number and geographic location of vulnerable groups and families benefiting from emergency measures (e.g., food parcels, economic support) as light-touch evaluations.
  - SAIs of Serbia and Uganda announced audits on the increase of intimate partner violence against women (linked to SDG 5.2) during the COVID-19 crisis.
  - SAIs that have conducted gender audits include Mexico, Canada, and Austria.
- International guidance and use statistics:
  - INTOSAI’s Development Initiative and UN Women’s Independent Evaluation and Audit Services have published guidance material on gender-related audits for COVID-19 spending.
  - UN Data from SDG Indicator 5.c.1 found independent gender audits are used in 19 percent of reporting countries (13 out of 69 countries).
- Reasons for limited use of gender audits:
  - Capacity constraints.
  - Gaps between strategic planning and budgeting.
  - Limited available sex-disaggregated data on access to and use of services.
- Note on audit timing:
  - Fully-fledged performance audits are typically conducted ex post to assess benefits produced by a measure; audits often require an advanced implementation stage for effects to be perceptible. Some SAIs have implemented concurrent or real-time audits during emergencies (examples: Peru, Auditor Service of Sierra Leone during Ebola).

### Gender-Responsive Budgeting Conclusions and operational guidance
- Gender-responsive budgeting is a strategic approach to operationalizing and monitoring gender-responsive COVID-19 policies.
- It provides a framework with specific tools to be applied at each stage of the public finance management cycle:
  - Planning.
  - Budgeting.
  - Executing.
  - Evaluating budget performance from a gender perspective.
- Evidence from country efforts provides entry points for applying specific gender budgeting tools in the current context and for longer-term recovery.
- Rapid adoption and approval of COVID-19 policy measures increase the importance of public performance setting and oversight tools.

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/covid19-special-notes/en-special-series-on-covid-19-gender-equality-and-covid-19.pdf_
