## Reaching Households in Emerging and Developing Economies: Citizen ID, Socioeconomic Data, and Digital Delivery

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [Reaching Households in Emerging and Developing Economies: Citizen ID, Socioeconomic Data, and Digital Delivery](https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/covid19-special-notes/en-special-series-on-covid-19-reaching-households-in-emerging-and-developing-economies.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/files/publications/covid19-special-notes/en-special-series-on-covid-19-reaching-households-in-emerging-and-developing-economies.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/files/publications/covid19-special-notes/en-special-series-on-covid-19-reaching-households-in-emerging-and-developing-economies.pdf.json)

---

### Key challenge: reaching affected households
- Protecting households during an economic crisis requires sufficient information on household characteristics (such as income and household composition) and a reliable delivery system to ensure support reaches intended beneficiaries.
- Informal sector prevalence limits verifiable employment and income data: about two-thirds of workers earn their living in the informal economy.
- Low coverage of social insurance systems in many LIDCs reflects reliance on income- or formal-employment–based eligibility criteria.
- Safety nets in many LIDCs have low coverage of the poorest income groups, who are least able to cope with short-term income shocks.

### Importance of ID, integrated socioeconomic databases, and digital delivery
- Three integrated components are critical to deliver broad and adequate income support:
  - Reliable identification (ID) system: example—Aadhaar is biometric, rolled out starting in 2009, provides a 12-digit unique identification number with demographic and biometric information (fingerprint and iris scan), and currently covers 1.2 billion people (95 percent of Indian population);
  - Financial inclusion: Jan Dhan started in 2014; in 2017, 85 percent of the population had access to a bank account, up from a prior coverage of 56 percent;
  - Mobile network: covers more than 1.16 billion phones with a growing share of smartphones and internet-enabled devices, serving as an effective service delivery platform.
- Integration of these pillars (the “JAM trinity”) allows linking ID with beneficiary databases, tax databases, bank accounts, and mobile SIMs to improve targeting, reduce leakage, and enable direct cash transfers.

### Policy tradeoffs when components are missing
- Absence of a reliable citizens’ registry:
  - People without IDs are excluded; people with IDs may receive benefits multiple times.
  - Poor and vulnerable households are more likely to be missed.
- Absence of cashless delivery (e.g., mobile money):
  - Governments may need to rely on physical handouts (cash or in-kind), which is challenging during a health crisis requiring social distancing and confinement.
- Absence of integrated socioeconomic database:
  - Without integration, targeting relies on ID-contained information (household composition, place of residence), risking substantial under-coverage of vulnerable groups and leakage to non-vulnerable groups.

### Data coverage and financial inclusion constraints
- Birth registration rates in most low-income countries and many emerging economies range between 15 to 80 percent; registration at older age is often not available.
- In LIDCs, about half of the population—especially non-poor informal workers—are systematically excluded from any analysis of their socioeconomic status.
- Population coverage by social registries varies widely across countries and programs.
- Examples of rapid mobile-money adoption:
  - Two-thirds of adults in Kenya, Rwanda, Tanzania, and Uganda actively used mobile payment accounts in 2017.
  - In Kenya, the value of annual mobile transactions is four times the size of the formal sector wage bill.
- Regional indicators shown in source figures:
  - Share of adults receiving government-to-person payments into financial institution accounts varies across countries (examples listed include Latvia, Sweden, Iran, United States, Ukraine, Russia, Mongolia, South Africa, Thailand, Turkey, Egypt, Kenya, China, Mexico, India, Vietnam, Ethiopia, Cambodia).
  - Adult coverage of financial accounts and mobile phones by region (percent) presented for Sub-Saharan Africa, South Asia, Latin America and Caribbean, Middle East and North Africa, East Asia and Pacific, Europe and Central Asia.

### Country examples of integrated systems and rapid expansion
- India: Aadhaar + Jan Dhan + mobile network enabled program transformations such as converting LPG subsidies into direct cash transfers deposited into Aadhaar-linked bank accounts.
- Turkey: Integrated Social Assistance System uses 28 databases to determine individuals’ capacity to pay health insurance premiums and eligibility for social assistance.
- Senegal: National Unique Registry combining geographical targeting and selection of poorest households increased conditional cash transfer program coverage from 3 to 16 percent of the population between 2013 and 2016.

### Short-run approaches when systems are partial or missing
- Ways around partial/unreliable ID systems:
  - Temporarily relax ID requirements to speed take-up.
  - Example: Togo’s Novissi uses voter IDs to identify beneficiaries and pays transfers through mobile money, with a top-up for women recipients.
  - Example: Jamaica is ramping up roll out of the national identification system NIDS.
- Ways around low financial inclusion:
  - Scale up demand and supply measures: waive mobile transaction fees, run information campaigns (text messages, radio, TV).
  - Example: Colombia collaborates with mobile network operators to map phone numbers to active financial accounts and mobile technology type for outreach about Ingreso Solidario.
  - Example: Ecuador relaxed criteria for agents distributing cash transfers to expand cash-out points from 3,000 to 7,000.
- Ways around scarce socioeconomic data:
  - Use proxy registries and alternative data sources (company/individual registries held by informal business associations, utility bills, invoices, local government registries, mobile network operators’ data).
  - Example: Nigeria collaborates with mobile network operators to identify vulnerable informal workers via airtime purchase patterns.
  - Example: Chile transfers “Bono COVID-19” directly into bank accounts (Cuenta Rut) of more than 2 million vulnerable Chileans.

### Operational and design considerations
- Many LIDCs lack capacity to implement fully integrated schemes in the short run; some Sub-Saharan African countries have used biometric deduplication to issue unique identifiers to older children and adults.
- Even where digital access is large, digital exclusion risks must be assessed and mitigated through complementary programs.
- Rapid scalability during crises requires addressing administrative constraints, information gaps, and limited fiscal space.

*Prepared by Delphine Prady; Fiscal Affairs Department, IMF.*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/covid19-special-notes/en-special-series-on-covid-19-reaching-households-in-emerging-and-developing-economies.pdf_
