## Managing Fiscal Risks Under Fiscal Stress

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [Managing Fiscal Risks Under Fiscal Stress](https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/covid19-special-notes/special-series-on-covid-19-managing-fiscal-risks-under-fiscal-stress.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/files/publications/covid19-special-notes/special-series-on-covid-19-managing-fiscal-risks-under-fiscal-stress.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/files/publications/covid19-special-notes/special-series-on-covid-19-managing-fiscal-risks-under-fiscal-stress.pdf.json)

---

### I. Overview: nature and sources of fiscal stress
- COVID-19 impacts public finances through increased spending, reduced revenue collection, and conversion of contingent liabilities into actual liabilities.
- Governments face both existing exposures realizing and new fiscal risks created by crisis-response measures.
- Key potential sources of fiscal risk include:
  - Sharply deteriorating macroeconomic conditions, sharp declines in commodity prices, large currency depreciations, and widening in sovereign spreads.
  - Requirements to service existing explicit guarantees (e.g., loan guarantees for enterprises; support payments to transport-sector PPPs).
  - Bailouts of troubled state-owned enterprises (SOEs), particularly in industries directly affected by COVID-19 (e.g., national airline companies), or support to subnational governments.
  - A need to support liquidity in the financial sector.
  - Top-ups for defined benefit pension funds affected by reductions in asset values and/or crystallization of pension guarantees.
- Historical precedent: during the global financial crisis, fiscal risks that materialized increased the public debt of the most heavily affected economies by an average of 26 percentage points of GDP, with a third of this coming from non-budget operations.2
- Transparency priority: identify and quantify large items with a high probability of crystallization, including explicit and implicit contingent liabilities.

### II. Policy measures to respond to the COVID-19 outbreak — types and fiscal implications
- Budgetary measures (fiscal costs reflected in deficit and balance sheet):
  - Additional spending (e.g., health services and unemployment benefits).
  - Capital grants and targeted transfers (e.g., wage subsidies or direct transfers).
  - Tax measures (cuts, relief, or deferrals).
  - Full cost reflected in fiscal balance and government debt unless offset by reprioritization.
- Off-budget or extrabudgetary measures (fiscal costs reflected in increased debt and financing, often not in deficit unless uneconomic):
  - Equity injections to financial and non-financial public corporations (examples cited: Germany, South Korea, Chile).
  - Loans to firms or households (examples cited: US, Norway, Thailand).
  - Asset purchases (e.g., non-performing assets or low-grade corporate bonds; example cited: US Federal Reserve).
  - Assumption of third-party debts and liabilities (no initial fiscal cost but immediate increase in public debt).
  - Government guarantees to banks, firms, or households (examples cited: UK, Germany, France, Australia); these create contingent liabilities with no immediate upfront cost.
  - Extrabudgetary funds (EBFs) created to channel assistance (example cited: the French Solidarity Fund); risk undermining fiscal accountability unless integrated into budget and time-limited.
  - Quasi-fiscal operations through central banks or state-owned institutions (example cited: Saudi Arabia); subsidy component of QFAs should be recorded in the budget per international standards.
- Guidance: assess, track, manage, and transparently report fiscal implications of extrabudgetary and off-budget measures; include sunset clauses and strategies to integrate operations into the budget as the situation normalizes.

### III. Evaluating and managing risks associated with crisis-response policies
- Decision criteria before using off-budget measures:
  - Rationale: Is there a sound rationale (market failures, macroeconomic stability) and are there more cost-efficient or transparent alternatives?
  - Costs: Assess maximum exposure from contingent liabilities and off-budget transactions; estimate expected costs and likelihood of materialization, acknowledging heightened uncertainty makes precise probabilities difficult.
  - Risk mitigation options:
    - Limit or cap government exposures.
    - Include sunset clauses and develop exit strategies.
    - For guarantees: provide partial guarantees, secure collateral, include asset recovery provisions, and charge risk-based fees.
    - Global cooperation to respond to pandemic fallout.
  - Risk management mechanisms:
    - Require a gatekeeper/central approval (e.g., Minister of Finance or Cabinet), with possible parliamentary involvement for legitimacy.
    - Establish clear accountability for monitoring, managing, and reporting contingent liabilities.
    - Set up monitoring mechanisms to regularly review risk realization potential, policy appropriateness, and adequacy of mitigation measures.
    - Ensure intra-governmental coordination (finance and economic ministries, central banks) to monitor and manage financial sector exposures.
    - Ensure full disclosure of all fiscal measures, both direct and contingent, on-budget and off-budget.

### IV. Strengthening public financial management (PFM) institutional capacities
- Adopt a “whole-of-government” approach (e.g., inter-ministerial PFM crisis management team) to assess fiscal/budgetary impact of policies and oversee consistent PFM application.
- Maintain an up-to-date view of public finances:
  - Heightened and more frequent monitoring of revenue, expenditure, and off-budget operations; require higher frequency updates from tax agencies, payment systems (IFMIS), and debt managers; periodic monitoring of contingent liabilities.
  - Institute a weekly fiscal developments note showing: i) variation of revenue and spending from normal, ii) impact of policy announcements including off-budget, iii) realizations of contingent liabilities, and iv) the debt and liquidity position of government.
- Maintain costings of emergency response options:
  - Cost all government decisions and announcements, with initial costings involving Ministry of Finance and executing line ministries; update costings as events unfold.
  - Communicate fiscal policy responses clearly to bolster business and consumer confidence.
- Remove barriers to necessary emergency spending:
  - Put in place legislative approvals and flexible use of existing spending authorities; example: a recent supplementary budget in France prepared and adopted within a week.
  - Seek external support from international financial institutions for capacity development where needed.
  - Identify low-priority and lagging spending to free resources.
- Ensure timely cash delivery:
  - Share cash flow needs across government units; monitor cash balances daily with banking providers; focus cash releases on high-priority items; explore bringing government cash pools under treasury control.
- Manage debt positions, market access and overall risk4:
  - Ensure continuity of funding and flexible approaches to mitigate refinancing risk; debt managers should monitor markets and adapt issuance techniques (e.g., shorter auction lags, uniform price auctions, syndications, shorter-term instruments).
  - Consider liability management exercises and coordinate public entities to avoid competition in markets.
  - Increase flexibility via cash buffers, credit lines, and alternative financing (including multilateral lending facilities and grants).
  - Track risks from forex, short-term debt, and contingent liabilities with attention to long-term fiscal space and debt sustainability.
- Keep PFM functions operational:
  - Maintain core systems (payments and approvals) and activate business continuity plans; enable remote/online tools and manage cyber security risks.
  - Temporarily relax controls to speed high-priority payments where appropriate (e.g., delegate authority for reallocations and reduce pre-audit controls).
  - Ensure close coordination with subnational governments and other governments through more frequent coordination meetings.

### Annex 1: examples of policy measures and recommended fiscal/risk management actions
- Budget measures (costs reflected in deficit and balance sheet):
  - Measures: spending (health, unemployment), capital grants and transfers (wage subsidies, direct transfers), tax measures (cuts, relief, deferrals).
  - Fiscal management: approve and execute through usual budget and PFM mechanisms; reflect full costs up-front in fiscal deficit, debt and financing.
- Below-the-line or off-budget measures (costs reflected in increased debt and financing):
  - Measures: equity injections to SOEs; loans to firms or households; asset purchases (non-performing); debt assumption.
  - Fiscal management: ensure clear rationale; assess fiscal costs; ensure central approval mechanisms; disclose all measures.
- Government guarantees (no up-front cash flows but exposure to risks and potential future costs):
  - Measures: umbrella guarantees to financial/other sectors; one-off guarantees to specific entities.
  - Fiscal management: quantify size of risk; consider partial guarantees and risk-based charges; retain asset recovery ability; make budget provisions for expected costs.
- Other contingent liabilities (e.g., quasi-fiscal operations):
  - Fiscal management: quantify size of risk; disclose all contingent liabilities.

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/covid19-special-notes/special-series-on-covid-19-managing-fiscal-risks-under-fiscal-stress.pdf_
