## cr17223

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [cr17223](https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/cr/2017/cr17223.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/files/publications/cr/2017/cr17223.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/files/publications/cr/2017/cr17223.pdf.json)

---

### EXECUTIVE SUMMARY — Context, program, and recent shocks
- Program launched: ECF-supported program in July 2016 to assist recovery and break a cycle of low investment and low growth.
- Program emphasis:
  - scaling up investment and social spending;
  - creating fiscal space (boosting revenue and cutting low productivity spending);
  - enhancing governance and fighting corruption;
  - strengthening financial sector development and stability.
- 2016–early 2017 shocks:
  - cyclone (March 2017, worst in 13 years);
  - serious drought (central plateau; hit hydropower production);
  - costly restructuring of the national airline (Air Madagascar).
- Authorities’ requests related to shocks:
  - modify the fiscal balance target for end-June 2017;
  - modify the 2017 fiscal framework to accommodate additional one-off expenditures;
  - augmentation in access of 12.5 percent of quota or SDR 30.55 million.
- Staff supports:
  - completion of the first review under the ECF arrangement;
  - modification of a performance criterion and waiver for non-observance of a continuous performance criterion on external payment arrears;
  - an augmentation of access.

### RECENT ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENTS AND KEY STATISTICS
- Growth and inflation:
  - Growth: 3.1 percent in 2015; 4.2 percent in 2016.
  - Inflation: 7.0 percent at end-2016.
- Fiscal/revenue:
  - Gross revenue collections over-performed program targets by 0.2 percent of GDP in 2016.
  - Tax-to-GDP ratios reported: 12 percent of GDP in 2008; 9 percent in 2013.
  - Tax revenue increased from 9.9 percent of GDP in 2014 to 10.9 percent of GDP in 2016 (of which 0.3 percent of GDP in one-off measures).
  - Capital expenditure: 3.9 percent of GDP in 2014 → 5.2 percent of GDP in 2016.
  - VAT arrears repayment in 2016: 1.2 percent of GDP.
- Public sector / SOEs:
  - JIRAMA financial performance weakened toward end-2016.
  - Transfers to JIRAMA budgeted at 1.3 percent of GDP in 2017 (compared with 0.7 percent in the approved budget).
- External sector and reserves:
  - Current account: surplus of 0.8 percent of GDP in 2016 (from deficit of 2.3 percent in 2015).
  - Vanilla export prices: nearly 4 times higher than in 2015 (positive shock).
  - Central bank net foreign exchange purchases in 2016: $312 million.
  - Gross official reserves: $775 million (2.5 months import cover) at end-2014; $1,121 million (3.9 months import cover) at end-2016.
  - Without augmentation, import coverage would fall to 3.3 months in 2017 (below recommended range and initial program projections).
- Poverty and development:
  - Over 80 percent of the population living on less than $1.90 a day.
  - Donor pledges at December 2016 conference: $6.4 billion (over 60 percent of GDP).

### NATURAL DISASTERS, ECONOMIC COSTS, AND FINANCING NEEDS
- Shocks and estimated impacts:
  - Cyclone economic costs (damage plus lost production): about $400 million (4 percent of GDP); approx one-third on public sector, two-thirds on households and private sector.
  - Public spending needs for relief and reconstruction: estimated in the range of $100 million for 2017-18.
  - Estimated balance of payments impact in 2017 from the two shocks: $225 million.
  - Authorities plan to spend $52 million in 2017 for relief and reconstruction; one-third financed through re-allocation of planned spending.
  - Planned recapitalization of Air Madagascar costing 0.8 percent of GDP.
  - On-lending envisaged: up to $50 million (0.5 percent of GDP) of the IMF disbursement to meet spending needs.
- Supplementary budget adjustments:
  - Overall deficit revised upward by 1.4 percent of GDP to 5.9 percent (cash basis) because of:
    - cyclone-related emergency spending 0.3 percent of GDP;
    - increases in transfers to JIRAMA 0.6 percent of GDP;
    - recapitalization of Air Madagascar 0.8 percent of GDP.
  - Adjustment measures: raising revenue targets and reducing some lower-priority spending.
  - Donors agreed exceptional financing linked to Air Madagascar operation, but sufficient domestic and external financing not available to cover all additional cyclone/drought spending needs.

### MEDIUM-TERM OUTLOOK, DRIVERS, AND RISKS
- Growth and inflation projections:
  - Growth: expected 4.3 percent in 2017 (despite disasters); recovery in private sector credit (9.9 percent growth in real terms) to support 2017.
  - Growth forecast to peak at 5.9 percent in 2019 and stabilize around 5 percent a year over the long term.
  - Inflation forecast: peak around 8 percent in 2017, then fall gradually to around 5 percent over the medium-term.
- Main growth drivers: public investment, tourism, garments and light manufacturing, mining, productivity gains in agriculture (shift toward export-oriented agribusiness).
- Key downside and external risks:
  - Domestic: weak implementation capacity, fiscal slippages (including SOE losses), political instability (ahead of 2018 presidential elections).
  - External: shifting terms of trade, reductions in donor funding/concessionality, loss of trade preferences (AGOA), falling FDI.
  - Natural disasters: 1990–2014 Madagascar hit by 55 natural disasters, killing at least 3,561 people and leaving 10 million people with urgent aid needs (EM‑DAT).

### PROGRAM PERFORMANCE, STRUCTURAL BENCHMARKS, AND ARREARS
- Program implementation to end-December 2016:
  - End-September indicative targets and end-December quantitative performance criteria on NFA, NDA, and domestic primary balance: all observed; NFA over-performing by a large margin.
  - Indicative target on social spending: met at end-December after narrowly missing at end-September.
- Arrears:
  - Technical barriers to servicing debt to Libya caused missed payment in November and external arrears effective February 2017; arrears have been cleared and authorities seek a waiver for non-observance of the continuous PC.
  - Madagascar owes external arrears to Angola which continue to be deemed away under policy on arrears to official bilateral creditors.
- Structural benchmarks (SBs) and continuous benchmarks:
  - 3 of 7 SBs fully met; 2 SBs implemented with delay.
  - Council of Budget and Financial Discipline operational only in March 2017 (end-September 2016 benchmark).
  - Law on asset recovery submitted to Parliament in June 2017 (end-October 2016 benchmark).
  - One of three continuous benchmarks observed (publication of any PPP contracts).
  - Fuel pricing formula not applied automatically (continuous SB); no budgetary cost resulted.
  - JIRAMA signed one single source contract without prior notification (continuous benchmark breach); practice nearly eliminated thereafter.

### A. PROMOTING INCLUSIVE AND SUSTAINABLE GROWTH — findings and plans
- Rationale and priorities:
  - NDP (2015) emphasizes: increase growth via infrastructure, PPPs, legal framework; make growth inclusive via more resources for education, health, social protection; ensure sustained growth by managing natural resources sustainably.
- Poverty and inequality:
  - Gini coefficient: 42.7 in 2012.
  - Undernourishment: 33 percent of the population in 2015.
- Infrastructure shortfall (World Economic Forum Global Competitiveness Index 2016):
  - road quality: 138th of 138;
  - mobile phone penetration: 135th;
  - quality of electricity supply: 130th.
- Public investment scaling-up (2017–22 medium-term plan):
  - Plan assumes total public investment about 9½ per-cent of GDP a year, peaking at 10½ percent of GDP in 2019.
  - Nearly all external financing (about 7 percent of GDP a year) identified after December 2016 donor conference.
  - Authorities received external financing commitments enabling cumulative increase in planned investment spending by 6½ percentage points (2017-2020) while maintaining moderate risk of debt distress.
  - Prioritized sectors: transportation, energy, agriculture, social spending.
  - Investment coordination unit at the Presidency established February 2017.
  - Structural benchmark: medium-term strategy to enhance public investment management capacity (end-December 2017).
- Social and human capital spending:
  - Government spending 2015: health ~1.5 percent of GDP; education ~2 percent of GDP.
  - Sub-Saharan Africa averages: health ~2.7 percent of GDP; education ~4.5 percent of GDP.
  - Long-term goals: universal health coverage; recruit >1,000 new teachers; expand social protection cash transfers and cash-for-work programs (currently cover ~half a million people).
  - Structural benchmark: new law on non-contributive social protection to strengthen coordination by Ministry of Population (end-December 2017).
- Agriculture and rural development:
  - Agriculture supports 80 percent of the population.
  - Only ~8 percent of household heads hold formal title to their land.
  - Priorities: land tenure security, infrastructure, modern farming skills, export-oriented agribusiness, weather-resilient practices, increased fertilizer use.
- Private investment and business climate:
  - Doing Business ranking: 167th out of 190 countries in 2017 (Sub-Saharan Africa average 143rd).
  - Improvements in 2017 survey: starting a business (to 113), trading across borders (to 129).
  - Legal/regulatory reforms: decrees implementing new PPP law adopted March 2017; drafting mining/petroleum/SEZ/industrial development laws.
- Macroeconomic compatibility and risks:
  - Scaling up judged compatible with macro stability and debt sustainability under program policies.
  - Staff projects moderate growth acceleration peaking just below 6 percent in 2019; inflation in single digits.
  - Risk of debt distress remains moderate; NPV of debt kept below 30 percent of GDP due to generous external financing terms.
- Resilience to natural disasters:
  - Priorities: resilient physical infrastructure and land planning; small-scale rural resilience investments; institutional infrastructure for social protection.

### B. CREATING MORE FISCAL SPACE — targets, measures, and SOE actions
- Objective: create space for higher public investment and social spending while preserving macro stability.
- Financing stance:
  - Initially relies on external financing; domestic resources to increase via enhanced revenue collection and improved spending composition.
- Fiscal anchor:
  - Positive primary balance excluding foreign-financed investment over medium term.
  - Exceptional spending (cyclone, JIRAMA, Air Madagascar) will temporarily lower the fiscal balance to negative 0.6 percent of GDP in 2017.
- Overall deficits:
  - Commitment basis: 5.0 percent of GDP in 2017; average 4.3 percent for 2018-20.
  - Cash basis: 5.9 percent of GDP in 2017; average 4.6 percent for 2018-20.
- Revenue mobilization:
  - Goal: improve tax-to-GDP ratio by ½ percent a year.
  - Administrative reforms: unique TIN extended across Ministry of Finance by end-September and CNAPS by end-December 2017 (SB).
  - Tax policy unit to be established end-September 2017 (SB).
  - Publication of audit of tax credits for major companies end-June 2017 (SB).
- Concerns on fiscal incentives:
  - Draft laws on SEZs, industrial/agricultural development could create parallel fiscal incentive regimes.
  - Staff recommends cost-efficient incentives and eventual unification of SEZs and FTZs.
- Spending-side reforms and SOE measures:
  - JIRAMA:
    - New management and Board; business plan adopted June 12, 2017 (prior action) to eliminate subsidies within four years.
    - Tariff increase of 7.5 percent (weighted average) from July 1; transfers fall from 1.3 percent of GDP in 2017 to projected 0.6 percent in 2018 and gradually to zero by 2021 under the business plan.
  - Air Madagascar:
    - Strategic partnership: Air Austral to manage airline and inject $40 million for 49 percent equity.
    - Government to clean balance sheet of past net liabilities with estimated net fiscal cost in 2017 of about $88 million (0.8 percent of GDP, excluding tax arrears to be forgiven).
    - Estimated net liabilities assumed by government and financed through mixed measures estimated at $66 million (Text Table 1).
- Text Table 1 (Air Madagascar — Balance of Payments and Fiscal Impact in 2017):
  - Revenue:
    - Tax arrears cancellations: 30.2 / 0.3
  - Spending:
    - Transfers: 87.7 / 0.8
    - Tax arrears cancellations: 30.2 / 0.3
  - Financing:
    - Foreign financing: 53.6 / 0.5
    - Domestic financing: 34.0 / 0.3
  - Fiscal Impact:
    - Inflows 64.3
    - Outflows 1 43.3
    - Net inflow 21.0
- Other measures:
  - Fuel pricing: avoid budget costs; staff urged fully automatic application with smoothing; authorities committed to avoid budget costs and discuss smoothing mechanism.
  - Civil service pension reform: expected savings 0.2 percent of GDP in current year via employee contribution increase from 4 to 6 percent and allowing voluntary retirement after age 60; beneficiary records to be verified by July 1, 2017. Planned savings in 2018 and beyond total 0.3 percent of GDP but require additional measures.
  - Domestic arrears clearance: plans on track to clear domestic arrears equivalent to 0.7 percent of GDP in 2017; staff recommends ongoing comprehensive accounting.

### C. ENHANCING ECONOMIC GOVERNANCE — legal and institutional measures
- Anti-corruption and legal framework:
  - National anti-corruption strategy adopted 2015.
  - Law to combat traffic of precious woods adopted 2015.
  - Anti-corruption law enacted August 2016 (criminalizes UNCAC offences; expanded asset disclosure obligations) — submission to Parliament was a prior action.
  - Law strengthening confiscation powers submitted June 2017 (end-October 2016 SB and prior action).
  - First anti-corruption centers (pole anti-corruption) to become operational July 2017.
  - Draft laws in preparation: new AML law (revised FATF standards) and mutual legal assistance in criminal matters.
- Shift to implementation and transparency:
  - Authorities committed to progressively publish comprehensive asset declarations of high-level officials.
  - Plans to strengthen judicial independence: increase anti-corruption centers, publish statistics on prosecutions/convictions, publish all court decisions by anti-corruption centers.
- Public Financial Management (PFM):
  - New PFM reform strategy 2016-19 adopted; updated action plan to be developed by July 2017.
  - Further improvements needed: more analysis on budget execution, financial assets, impact of new measures; more information on multinationals and SOEs in extractive industries.
  - Strengthen public procurement, SOE supervision, and public investment management.

### D. STRENGTHENING FINANCIAL SECTOR DEVELOPMENT AND STABILITY
- Central bank stance and objectives:
  - Monetary policy appropriate amid shocks; aim to keep inflation in single digits and steer toward 5 percent over medium-term.
  - New central bank law effective November 2016: strengthens independence, tightens limits on central bank lending to government, mandates timely recapitalization in event of losses.
- Monetary framework evolution and reforms:
  - Improve central bank internal organization and liquidity forecasting.
  - Strengthen interbank money and foreign exchange markets (TA requested).
  - Agreement by end-2017 with banks/participants on securities market development strategy.
  - Submit draft legislation promoting repo transactions by end-December 2018 (SB).
  - Introduce overnight deposit facility to create an interest rate corridor.
  - Staff encouraged phasing out partial surrender requirement on export proceeds over time.
- Banking sector oversight and FSAP follow-up:
  - 2016 FSAP: sector generally sound and resilient but major gaps in oversight.
  - Planned actions:
    - Audits of CEM and postal service by end-2017.
    - Action plan for risk-based supervision adopted by December 2017.
    - Legislative amendments to strengthen recovery/resolution for microfinance by end-2017 and for banks by October 2018.
    - New prudential regulations and strengthened supervision by December 2018; effective risk-based supervision by 2019.
    - Enhanced insurance supervision consolidated under CSBF by 2019; increase CSBF independence.
    - Establish credit bureau and collateral registry by 2019.
- Financial inclusion and payments modernization:
  - Access: ~9 percent of population have a bank account; 10 percent have access to mobile money.
  - Law on electronic money promulgated February 2017; implementing decrees/regulations for mobile money to be issued by end-December 2017 (SB).
  - Law regulating national payment system planned by end-2017.
  - World Bank partnership on financial inclusion project (digitalization, access to credit).
- Central bank reserves and liquidity:
  - Reserves: $1.12 billion (3.9 months import cover) at end-2016.
  - Vanilla-related cash payments expanded currency in circulation by 18 percent between May and September 2016 and drained bank liquidity; central bank net purchases of foreign exchange from September 2016 totaled $312 million, improving liquidity.

### EXTERNAL BALANCE ASSESSMENT (Annex I) — 2016 assessment and implications
- Staff assessment: 2016 external balance stronger than fundamentals and desirable policy settings due to vanilla price spike.
- Current account adjustments and gaps (percent of GDP):
  - Actual current account (A): 0.8
  - Temporary factors (vanilla price spike) (B): 3.0
  - Adjusted current account (C = A − B): -2.3
  - Fitted current account (D): -3.5
  - Policy gap (E): 1.4
  - Current account norm (F = D − E): -5.0
  - Current account gap (G = C − F): -2.7
  - Interpretation: adjusted current account deficit (-2.3 percent of GDP) was 2.7 percent of GDP stronger than its norm in 2016.
- NIIP and exchange rate:
  - NIIP: increased from below 40 percent of GDP in 2008 to roughly 105 percent of GDP in 2016 (mainly higher private-sector liabilities linked to mining projects).
  - REER assessment: elasticity -0.27; REER gap 10 percent (staff-assessed undervaluation); alternative model suggests ~27 percent undervaluation in 2016 (interpret with caution).
- Reserves:
  - Reserves coverage: 3.9 months of imports at end-2016 vs 2.9 months at end-2015.
  - Reserve accumulation exceeded projections in 2016; expected to level off in 2017.
- Policy recommendations:
  - scale up investment gradually;
  - ensure investment projects are well targeted;
  - rely on resources with the most attractive financing conditions.

### DEBT SUSTAINABILITY ANALYSIS (DSA) — key findings and scenarios
- Risk of external debt distress: Moderate.
- Baseline projections and public debt metrics (selected):
  - Total public debt (percent of GDP): 2015: 41.3; 2016: 41.7; 2017: 38.7; 2018: 42.8; 2019: 41.3; 2020: 42.2; 2024: 44.3 (proj. series provided).
  - External public debt (percent of GDP): 2016: 30.4; 2017: 27.0; 2018: 32.6; 2019: 29.6; 2024: 35.8.
  - PV of external debt projected to increase from 15½ percent of GDP in 2016 to 21 percent by 2022 then decline.
  - PV of total PPG debt projected to remain <30 percent of GDP throughout forecast horizon.
- Stress test outcomes:
  - Simultaneous slowdown in GDP, decline in exports, depreciation, and reduction in non-debt creating flows (one-half standard deviation) pushes PV debt-to-revenue ratio to 243 percent in 2017 (above CPIA threshold) — supports moderate risk classification.
  - Historical scenario produces large breaches of external debt thresholds.
- Natural disasters and debt dynamics:
  - Example event (2004 cyclones): damage ~5.7 percent of GDP; primary expenditure rose from 17 to 22 percent of GDP; inflation rose to 14 percent in 2004 and 18 percent in 2005.
  - Customized severe-disaster scenario: 35 percent depreciation and 10 percent faster inflation in 2018; effects on PV Debt-to-GDP roughly offset.

### PROGRAM FINANCING, IMF ECF ARRANGEMENT, AND AUTHORITIES’ REQUESTS
- IMF ECF schedule (SDR and percent of quota):
  - July 27, 2016: 12.9 percent; 31,428,000 SDRs (Board approval)
  - June 28, 2017: 25.4 percent; 61,978,000 SDRs (first review)
  - Remaining scheduled reviews through November 2019 total nominal amounts leading to Total: 102.5 percent; 250,550,000 SDRs.
- Authorities’ requests (Appendix I Letter of Intent):
  - approval of augmentation of ECF arrangement to total SDR 250.55 million (Jul 27, 2016 – Nov 27, 2019);
  - waiver for non-observance of continuous PC on new external payment arrears;
  - modification of performance criterion (floor) on primary balance excluding foreign-financed investment at end-June 2017;
  - completion of the first review.
- IMF staff support for modification, waiver, and augmentation related to natural disaster financing needs.
- External shock financing needs estimated at 1.1 percent of GDP in 2017.
- Authorities envisage central bank on-lending up to $50 million of the IMF disbursement; staff supports this plan.

### PROGRAM MONITORING, TMU HIGHLIGHTS, AND DATA REPORTING
- TMU definitions and program exchange rates provided (e.g., Malagasy Ariary (MGA)/SDR 4,443.86; U.S. Dollar/SDR 1.389049).
- Performance criteria cover NFA and NDA of CBM, external payment arrears, non-concessional external debt ceilings, and primary balance excluding foreign-financed investment (commitment basis).
- Adjustment mechanisms:
  - NFA and NDA adjusters linked to deviations in official external program support (capped at SDR75 million).
  - Floor on primary balance excl. foreign-financed investment adjusted by deviations in official external program grants (capped at SDR30 million).
- Data provision requirements (selected):
  - Monthly NFA and NDA with lag no more than four weeks.
  - Monthly other data with lag no more than six weeks.
  - Extensive daily, monthly, quarterly reporting templates specified for CBM, MFB, INSTAT, OCH, SAMIFIN, BIANCO, and SOEs.

### SELECTED ECONOMIC INDICATORS (summary highlights — values preserved)
- Real GDP at market prices (growth):
  - 2015: 3.1
  - 2016: 4.1
  - 2017 (Actuals): 4.2
  - 2018 (EBS): 4.5
  - 2019 (Proj.): 4.3
  - 2020 (EBS): 5.3
  - 2021 (Proj.): 5.9
  - 2022 (EBS): 5.5
  - 2023 (Proj.): 5.2
  - 2024 (Proj.): 5.0
- Consumer prices (end of period):
  - 2015: 7.6
  - 2016: 7.1
  - 2017: 7.0
  - 2018 (EBS): 7.1
  - 2019 (Proj.): 7.7
  - 2020 (EBS): 6.8
  - 2021 (Proj.): 6.0
  - 2022 (EBS): 5.4
  - 2023 (Proj.): 5.4
  - 2024 (Proj.): 5.0
- Gross official reserves (millions of SDRs):
  - 2015: 600
  - 2016: 701
  - 2017: 834
  - 2018: 782
  - 2019: 896
  - 2020 (EBS): 942
  - 2021 (Proj.): 1,045
  - 2022 (EBS): 1,161
  - 2023 (Proj.): 1,296
  - 2024 (Proj.): 1,394
- Months of imports of goods and services (reserves coverage):
  - 2015: 2.9
  - 2016: 3.3
  - 2017: 3.9
  - 2018: 3.4
  - 2019: 3.4
  - 2020 (EBS): 3.4
  - 2021 (Proj.): 3.5
  - 2022 (EBS): 3.6
  - 2023 (Proj.): 3.7
  - 2024 (Proj.): 3.7
- Total revenue (excluding grants) as percent of GDP:
  - 2015: 10.4
  - 2016: 11.0
  - 2017: 11.2
  - 2018 (EBS): 11.2
  - 2019 (Proj.): 11.6
  - 2020 (EBS): 11.8
  - 2021 (Proj.): 12.2
  - 2022 (EBS): 12.7
  - 2023 (Proj.): 13.1
  - 2024 (Proj.): 13.5
- Capital expenditure (percent of GDP):
  - 2015: 3.5
  - 2016: 5.3
  - 2017: 5.2
  - 2018: 8.0
  - 2019: 8.3
  - 2020 (EBS): 10.2
  - 2021 (Proj.): 10.5
  - 2022 (EBS): 9.4
  - 2023 (Proj.): 9.3
  - 2024 (Proj.): 9.1
- Overall fiscal balance (commitment basis, percent of GDP):
  - 2015: -3.3
  - 2016: -3.2
  - 2017: -1.3
  - 2018: -4.4
  - 2019: -5.1
  - 2020 (EBS): -4.7
  - 2021 (Proj.): -4.5
  - 2022 (EBS): -3.8
  - 2023 (Proj.): -3.5
  - 2024 (Proj.): -3.3

### IMF STAFF RECOMMENDATIONS / PRIORITY POLICY RESPONSES (selected)
- Protect macro stability while scaling up investment:
  - Scale up investment gradually and ensure projects are well targeted.
  - Rely primarily on grants and concessional financing; limit non-concessional short-term external borrowing.
- Fiscal and revenue measures:
  - Improve revenue mobilization (target: increase tax-to-GDP by ½ percent a year).
  - Continue administrative reforms: unique TIN rollout, tax policy unit, customs anti-fraud performance contracts.
  - Reduce transfers and subsidies progressively through SOE reforms (JIRAMA business plan; Air Madagascar strategic partnership).
- Governance and anti-corruption:
  - Complete legal framework alignment with international standards and shift focus to enforcement and transparency.
  - Publish asset declarations progressively; strengthen judicial independence and anti-corruption centers.
- Financial sector and monetary policy:
  - Strengthen central bank operational framework (overnight deposit facility, repo framework, securities market development).
  - Improve banking supervision and implement FSAP recommendations (risk-based supervision, resolution framework, audits of NBFIs).
  - Continue TA-supported work on statistics, national accounts rebasing, and data publication.
- Disaster resilience:
  - Invest in resilient infrastructure and rural resilience measures; consider risk transfer mechanisms and maintain fiscal/reserve buffers as feasible.

*IMF staff report excerpts and Madagascar authorities’ Letter of Intent and TMU (cr17223).*

### EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

### EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

### Context and Program Objectives
- Madagascar launched an ECF-supported program in July 2016 to assist economic recovery from a prolonged political crisis and to break a cycle of low investment and low growth.
- The program emphasizes: scaling up investment and social spending, creating fiscal space (boosting revenue and cutting low productivity spending), enhancing governance and fighting corruption, and strengthening financial sector development and stability.
- Unexpected shocks in 2016 and early 2017 included a cyclone, a drought (that hit hydropower production), and a costly restructuring of the national airline.

### Article IV Consultations and Policy Consensus
- Broad agreement on policies for:
  - Inclusive growth through scaling up investment and social spending.
  - Creating fiscal space by boosting revenue and cutting low productivity spending.
  - Enhancing governance and fighting corruption.
  - Strengthening financial sector development and stability.

### Program Performance and Requested Modifications
- Despite capacity constraints, program implementation has generally been strong; key macroeconomic targets achieved and structural reforms advanced, though some reforms progressed more slowly than planned.
- Authorities requested modifications to respond to shocks:
  - Modify the fiscal balance target for end-June 2017.
  - Modify the fiscal framework for 2017 to accommodate additional one-off expenditures.
  - Receive an augmentation in access of 12.5 percent of quota or SDR 30.55 million to counter balance of payments difficulties from the natural disasters.
- Staff supports:
  - Completion of the first review under the ECF arrangement.
  - Modification of a performance criterion.
  - Waiver for non-observance of a performance criterion.
  - An augmentation of access.

### Recent Economic Developments, Outlook, and Key Statistics
- Growth and inflation:
  - Growth estimated at 3.1 percent in 2015 and 4.2 percent in 2016.
  - Inflation at 7.0 percent at end-2016.
- Fiscal and revenue developments:
  - Gross revenue collections over-performed program targets by 0.2 percent of GDP in 2016.
  - Tax-to-GDP ratios: 12 percent of GDP in 2008; 9 percent in 2013; tax revenue increased from 9.9 percent of GDP in 2014 to 10.9 percent of GDP in 2016 (of which 0.3 percent of GDP in one-off measures).
  - Capital expenditure grew from 3.9 percent of GDP in 2014 to 5.2 percent in 2016.
  - VAT arrears repayment in 2016 implemented successfully at 1.2 percent of GDP.
- Public sector and SOEs:
  - Financial performance of public utility JIRAMA weakened toward end-2016.
  - Transfers to JIRAMA budgeted at 1.3 percent of GDP in 2017 (compared with 0.7 percent in the approved budget).
- External sector and reserves:
  - Current account recorded a surplus of 0.8 percent of GDP in 2016 (from a deficit of 2.3 percent in 2015).
  - Positive shock: vanilla export prices nearly 4 times higher than in 2015.
  - Central bank net foreign exchange purchases in 2016: $312 million.
  - Gross official reserves: $775 million (2.5 months import cover) at end-2014; $1,121 million (3.9 months import cover) at end-2016.
  - Without augmentation, import coverage would fall back to 3.3 months in 2017, below the recommended range and initial program projections.
- Poverty and development indicators:
  - Over 80 percent of the population living on less than $1.90 a day.
  - During the 2009-13 crisis, donor support fell as low as 2 percent of GDP in 2012 (from 14 percent of GDP in 2006).
  - Donor pledges at the December 2016 conference estimated at $6.4 billion (over 60 percent of GDP).

### Natural Disasters, Fiscal Impact, and Financing Needs
- Shocks:
  - Serious drought affecting the central plateau and a major cyclone in March 2017 (worst in 13 years).
- Estimated economic costs and needs:
  - Cyclone economic costs (damage plus lost production) estimated at about $400 million (4 percent of GDP), of which approximately one-third fell on the public sector and two-thirds on households and the private sector.
  - Public spending needs for relief and reconstruction estimated in the range of $100 million for 2017-18.
  - Estimated balance of payments impact in 2017 of $225 million from the two shocks.
  - Authorities plan to spend $52 million in 2017 for relief and reconstruction; one-third financed through re-allocation of planned spending.
  - Planned recapitalization of Air Madagascar costing 0.8 percent of GDP.
  - On-lending envisaged of up to $50 million (0.5 percent of GDP) of the IMF disbursement to meet spending needs.
- Budgetary outcome and adjustments:
  - Supplementary budget projects overall deficit revised upward by 1.4 percent of GDP (to 5.9 per cent, cash basis) because of:
    - Cyclone-related emergency spending of 0.3 percent of GDP.
    - Increases in transfers to JIRAMA of 0.6 percent of GDP.
    - Recapitalization of Air Madagascar of 0.8 percent of GDP.
  - Adjustment measures include raising revenue targets and reducing some lower-priority spending.
  - Donors agreed to provide exceptional financing linked to the Air Madagascar operation, but sufficient domestic and external financing is not available to cover all additional spending needs related to cyclone and drought.

### Monetary and Exchange Rate Developments and Challenges
- Currency and liquidity effects:
  - Un-banked small vanilla producers received large cash payments, expanding currency in circulation by 18 percent between May and September 2016 and draining bank liquidity; banks tightened lending.
  - Central bank net purchases of foreign exchange beginning in September 2016 totaled $312 million, improving bank liquidity and accelerating money growth in late 2016.
  - Persistently high vanilla prices are generating a second shock and demand for currency should remain high until end-2017.
- Exchange rate and REER:
  - Real effective exchange rate (REER) appreciated by about 3½ percent in 2016, followed by an additional 2.2 percent through March 2017.
  - External position in 2016 assessed to be stronger than implied by fundamentals and optimal policy settings, largely due to the positive vanilla price shock.
  - Madagascar’s current account norm has a high deficit due to long-term development needs; current account expected to converge to its norm as temporary terms of trade shocks unwind and imports rise with public investment scaling up.

### Risks
- Key risk factors include:
  - Weak implementation capacity in a fragile, low-income country.
  - Fiscal slippages, including losses at JIRAMA or other SOEs.
  - Political instability, particularly ahead of 2018 presidential elections.
  - Shifting terms of trade.
  - Natural disasters.
  - Reliance on donor funding and trade preferences.

*IMF staff discussions took place in Antananarivo during March 8-24, 2017 and in Washington DC during April 19-21, 2017; IMF staff team included Messrs. Mills (head), Engstrom, and Oestreicher (AFR), Ms. Baum (FAD), Ms. Esquivel Soto (LEG), and Mr. Eugster (SPR), and others. June 14, 2017.*

### 11.      The medium-term macroeconomic outlook is favorable but challenges remain.

### 11.      The medium-term macroeconomic outlook is favorable but challenges remain.

### Medium-term outlook and projections
- Notwithstanding the negative effects of the natural disasters, growth is expected to remain steady at 4.3 percent in 2017, supported by growing public and private investment, textile exports, tourism, and agroindustry.
- An expected recovery in private sector credit (9.9 percent growth in real terms) will buoy the expansion in 2017.
- Growth is forecast to peak at 5.9 percent in 2019 and stabilize around 5 percent a year over the long term.
- Main drivers of medium-term growth: public investment, tourism, garments and other light manufacturing, mining, and productivity gains in agriculture (notably the shift from subsistence to export-oriented agribusiness such as vanilla and cloves).
- Madagascar’s growth is expected to exceed the average for Sub-Saharan African countries over the next few years.
- Inflation is forecast to peak around 8 percent in 2017 before falling gradually to around 5 percent over the medium-term, as the vanilla and natural disaster shocks unwind and monetary policy responds with restrained money growth.

### Downside and external risks
- Domestic risks:
  - Weak implementation capacity and uncertain growth impact of investment (which could delay increases in public investment and growth).
  - Fiscal slippages (including transfers to SOEs).
  - Political instability, particularly ahead of the 2018 presidential elections.
  - Ongoing need for technical assistance to identify and mitigate fiscal risks, including development of statements to be annexed to the budget.
- External risks:
  - Shifting terms of trade.
  - Possible reductions in donor funding and concessionality.
  - Loss of trade preferences (especially AGOA).
  - Falling FDI.
- Natural disaster risk:
  - Madagascar is prone to costly natural disasters; during 1990-2014 Madagascar was hit by 55 natural disasters that killed at least 3,561 people and left 10 million people with an urgent need for aid (EM‑DAT database).

### Authorities’ views
- Authorities broadly concurred with the outlook, risks assessment, and external position.
- Authorities believed scaling up public investment could have a stronger than projected impact on growth and that projections for private investment, including FDI, could prove conservative.
- Authorities agreed the current account will adjust over the medium-term and that exchange rate flexibility is important to absorb shocks.

### Program performance (quantitative and structural)
- Performance to end-December 2016:
  - End-September indicative targets and end-December quantitative performance criteria (PCs) on net foreign assets (NFA), net domestic assets (NDA), and the domestic primary balance were all observed, with NFA over-performing by a large margin.
  - The indicative target on social spending was met at end-December, after narrowly missing at end-September.
- Debt servicing and arrears:
  - Technical barriers to servicing debt to Libya persisted during most of 2016, leading to a missed payment in November and external arrears effective February 2017; these arrears have been cleared since then and the authorities are seeking a waiver of non-observance of the related continuous PC on the basis of the temporary nature of the arrears accumulation.
  - Madagascar owes external arrears to Angola which continue to be deemed away under the policy on arrears to official bilateral creditors.
- Structural benchmarks (SBs) and continuous benchmarks:
  - Three (out of seven) SBs were fully met; measures in two benchmarks were implemented with a delay.
  - The Council of Budget and Financial Discipline became operational only in March 2017 (end-September 2016 benchmark).
  - The law on asset recovery was submitted to the Parliament in June 2017 (end-October 2016 benchmark).
  - One of three continuous benchmarks was observed (publication of any PPP contracts).
  - The fuel pricing formula was not applied automatically (continuous SB) out of concern over social impact; no budgetary cost resulted.
  - JIRAMA signed one single source contract for energy supply without prior notification, failing to observe a continuous benchmark; the practice of single source contracts was nearly eliminated thereafter.

### Policy discussions and priorities
- Four key objectives guided policy discussions and priorities:
  - Promoting inclusive and sustainable growth, especially through scaling up public investment.
  - Creating more fiscal space, enhancing revenue and containing lower priority spending.
  - Enhancing economic governance, especially fighting corruption.
  - Strengthening financial sector development and stability.
- Key topics of policy discussions included:
  - Scaling up and debt management, Public-private partnerships, Spending on social priorities.
  - Revenue mobilization, Spending prioritization, Management of state-owned enterprises.
  - Legal and institutional framework, Control and enforcement, Transparency in public financial management.
  - Monetary policy operations, Financial sector supervision, Central bank governance, Financial inclusion.

### A. Promoting inclusive and sustainable growth — findings and plans
- Rationale:
  - Sustained and inclusive growth is necessary to reduce poverty and improve living standards.
  - The NDP (2015) emphasizes (i) increasing growth via infrastructure, public-private dialogue, and legal framework for good governance; (ii) making growth inclusive via more resources for education, health, and social protection; and (iii) ensuring sustained growth by managing natural resources sustainably.
- Poverty and inequality:
  - Poverty is very high.
  - Gini coefficient: 42.7 in 2012 (close to the Sub-Saharan African average; fell slightly over 2001–12).
- Infrastructure shortfall:
  - World Economic Forum Global Competitiveness Index 2016 rankings: road quality 138th of 138 countries surveyed; mobile phone penetration 135th; quality of electricity supply 130th.
- Public investment scaling up (medium-term 2017-22):
  - The plan assumes total public investment of about 9½ per-cent of GDP a year, peaking at 10½ percent of GDP in 2019.
  - Nearly all external financing (about 7 percent of GDP a year) was identified following the donor conference in December 2016.
  - Authorities received external financing commitments larger and on better terms than assumed in the original program, enabling an increase in planned investment spending by a cumulative 6½ percentage points (2017-2020) while maintaining a moderate risk of debt distress.
  - Prioritized investment plans focus on transportation, energy, agriculture, and social spending.
  - Implementation challenges: limited implementation capacity and macroeconomic stability risks; an investment coordination unit at the Presidency was established in February 2017 to monitor absorption capacity.
  - Authorities are developing a medium-term strategy to enhance public investment management capacity (end-December 2017 structural benchmark), addressing: (i) institutional framework; (ii) project selection and evaluation; (iii) supervision of investment; (iv) donor coordination.
- Social and human capital spending:
  - Increased spending on health, education, and social protection is part of the scaling up.
  - Government spending in 2015: health about 1.5 percent of GDP; education about 2 percent of GDP.
  - Sub-Saharan Africa averages: health about 2.7 percent of GDP; education about 4.5 percent of GDP.
  - Undernourishment: 33 percent of the population in 2015.
  - Long-term goals: universal health coverage; expanded teacher recruitment (more than 1,000 new teachers), training, grants for facilities, and meals for poor children.
  - Social protection programs (with co-financing) aim to expand coverage of cash transfers and cash-for-work programs that currently cover about half a million people in extreme poverty.
  - Legal/institutional reforms: submission to Parliament of the new law on non-contributive social protection to strengthen coordination by the Ministry of Population (end-December 2017 SB).
- Agriculture and rural development:
  - Agriculture supports 80 percent of the population.
  - Only about 8 percent of household heads hold formal title to their land.
  - Priorities: expand land tenure security, improve infrastructure, develop modern farming skills, shift toward export-oriented agribusiness, promote weather-resilient practices, improve coordination of rural development policies, and increase fertilizer use cost-effectively.
- Private investment and business climate:
  - Growth impact of investment scaling up depends in part on promoting private investment, including FDI.
  - Main impediments: weak governance, poor infrastructure (transport and electricity), and a shallow financial system with limited access to services.
  - Doing Business ranking: 167th out of 190 countries in 2017; Sub-Saharan Africa average 143rd.
  - Improvements noted in 2017 survey for opening a business and ease of international trade.
  - Legal and regulatory reforms: decrees implementing the new PPP law adopted in March 2017; authorities drafting laws related to mining, petroleum, special economic zones, and industrial development.
- Macroeconomic compatibility and risks of scaling up:
  - Assuming program policies, scaling up is judged compatible with macroeconomic stability and debt sustainability.
  - Staff projects a moderate growth acceleration peaking just below 6 percent in 2019, inflation remaining in the single digits, and continuing export competitiveness.
  - Risks that inflationary or exchange rate pressures might be stronger than expected merit careful monitoring; authorities committed to respond to first signs of overheating.
  - Risk of debt distress remains moderate.
  - Even though public debt to GDP will rise slightly, generous external financing conditions keep the net present value of debt below 30 percent of GDP.
- Enhancing resilience to natural disasters:
  - Madagascar’s vulnerability stems from geography, low income, weak institutional capacity, and heavy reliance on rain-fed agriculture.
  - Priorities: more resilient physical infrastructure and land planning (especially in the capital); small-scale rural resilience investments (better water management, drought-resistant agriculture); institutional infrastructure for social protection (registration for assistance and access to primary health care for relief efforts).

*Source: IMF staff report excerpt — “The medium-term macroeconomic outlook is favorable but challenges remain.”*

### 25.      Authorities’ views. The authorities recognize the challenges of the planned scaling up,

### cr17223 - 25.      Authorities’ views. The authorities recognize the challenges of the planned scaling up,

### B. Creating More Fiscal Space
- Objective: create space for higher public investment and social spending while preserving macroeconomic stability and sustainability.
- Financing strategy:
  - Initially relies on external financing, while maintaining a moderate risk of debt distress.
  - Domestic resources for priority spending projected to increase progressively through enhanced revenue collection and improved composition of spending.
- Fiscal anchor:
  - A positive primary balance excluding foreign financed investment over the medium term.
  - Exceptional spending related to the cyclone, JIRAMA, and Air Madagascar will temporarily lower this fiscal balance to negative 0.6 percent of GDP this year.
- Overall deficit (commitment basis):
  - Will reach 5.0 percent of GDP in 2017 and average 4.3 percent for 2018-20.
  - Corresponding deficits on a cash basis are 5.9 percent of GDP in 2017 and an average of 4.6 percent for 2018-20, with arrears clearance accounting for most of the discrepancy with commitment basis.
- Revenue mobilization:
  - Goal: improve the tax-to-GDP ratio by ½ percent a year.
  - Administrative reforms in customs and tax departments based on medium-term action plans.
  - Unique TIN to be extended to the entire Ministry of Finance by end-September and to CNAPS by end-December 2017 (SB).
  - Tax policy unit to be established (end-September 2017 SB) to reconcile tax and customs data, improve tax policy analysis, and review tax exemptions (~0.9 percent of GDP in 2016).
  - Customs to expand performance contracts to the anti-fraud unit (end-September 2017 SB).
  - Publication of an audit of tax credits for investment by major companies (end-June 2017 SB).
- Concerns about fiscal incentive regimes:
  - Proposals for mining, petroleum, special economic zones, agriculture, and industrial development.
  - Draft laws on SEZs, industrial development, and agricultural development would create fiscal incentive regimes parallel to zones franches.
  - Staff recommendation: keep fiscal incentives cost-efficient and avoid excessive complexity; eventually unify treatment of SEZs and FTZs.
  - Authorities have requested TA to evaluate effects across these laws.
- Spending-side reforms:
  - JIRAMA:
    - New management and Board; new CEO hired after competitive process.
    - On June 12, 2017, Board adopted a business plan (prior action) aiming to eliminate subsidies within four years.
    - Business plan elements: (i) 2017 budget limits transfers to the amount in the budget with monitorable monthly targets; (ii) renegotiation or cancellation of high-cost contracts where consistent with law; (iii) full utilization of competitive bidding.
    - Tariff increase of 7.5 percent (weighted average) from July 1; intention to continue nominal tariff increases differentiated to protect vulnerable consumers.
    - Under business plan, transfers fall from 1.3 percent of GDP this year to a projected 0.6 percent next year, and then gradually to zero by 2021.
  - Air Madagascar:
    - Strategic partnership: Air Austral to manage the airline and inject $40 million in capital for a 49 percent equity share.
    - Government to clean the balance sheet of past net liabilities with an estimated net fiscal cost in 2017 of about $88 million (0.8 percent of GDP, excluding tax arrears to be forgiven).
    - Net liabilities assumed by government and financed through a mix of debt write-downs, payment rescheduling (partly through special government securities), and new domestic and external borrowing linked to the operation, estimated at $66 million (Text Table 1).
    - Under business plan, restructured airline expected to be financially viable without further government support.
- Text Table 1: Air Madagascar's Debt and Capital Transactions — Balance of Payments and Fiscal Impact in 2017 (US$ million / Percent of GDP)
  - Revenue
    - Tax arrears cancellations: 30.2 / 0.3
  - Spending
    - Transfers: 87.7 / 0.8
    - Tax arrears cancellations: 30.2 / 0.3
  - Financing
    - Foreign financing: 53.6 / 0.5
    - Domestic financing: 34.0 / 0.3
  - Fiscal Impact
    - Inflows 64.3
    - Outflows 1 43.3
    - Net inflow 21.0
  - Balance of Payments Impact note: Loan amortization, imports, and increases in commercial banks' foreign assets. Part of Air Austral's capital injection is assumed to be deposited in a foreign-currency account at a commercial bank, which will then deposit the equivalent amount abroad with a correspondent bank.
- Other measures to reduce transfers and subsidies:
  - Fuel pricing: program avoids any budget costs from fuel pricing; staff urged fully automatic application of fuel pricing mechanism, possibly with a smoothing formula. Authorities committed to avoid budget costs and are discussing a smoothing mechanism with distributors.
  - Civil service pension reform:
    - Authorities expect to save 0.2 percent of GDP this year through an increase in employee contribution rates from 4 to 6 percent and allowing voluntary retirement after age 60.
    - All beneficiary records to be verified by July 1, 2017.
    - Planned savings in 2018 and beyond total 0.3 percent of GDP but will require additional measures; World Bank TA recommended changing the base for setting retirement payments to several years.
- Domestic arrears clearance:
  - Plans on track to clear domestic arrears equivalent to 0.7 percent of GDP in 2017.
  - Staff recommends continuing comprehensive accounting of arrears and accounts payable at the beginning of each year.
  - Authorities strengthening accounting, improving budget forecasting, reforming JIRAMA, and enhancing treasury cash flow plans to mitigate arrears risk.

### Authorities’ views (on fiscal space)
- Authorities stressed firm commitment to enhancing revenue and reducing transfers.
- On tax incentives, authorities note incentives in competing destinations and seek a balance between attracting investment and enhancing revenue.
- Actions at JIRAMA (new management and business plan) and Air Madagascar (strategic partnership) seen as critical turning points.
- Authorities caution that expectations for results should account for capacity constraints and the magnitude of accumulated problems.

### C. Enhancing Economic Governance
- Context:
  - Post-2014 democratic elections, government recommitted to addressing governance weaknesses and fighting corruption.
  - Weak governance and corruption impact economic performance by diverting public resources, undermining institutions and legitimacy, weakening business climate, lowering investment quantity and quality, and eroding tax collections.
- Estimated economic impact of weaker governance:
  - Perception indicators moved from the average of middle-income countries in Sub-Saharan Africa to the average of the region’s low-income fragile countries over the last ten years.
  - Empirical studies suggest this deterioration likely reduces Madagascar’s economic growth by ½ percent or more a year and tax revenues by at least 3 percent of GDP annually.
- Legal and institutional actions taken:
  - National anti-corruption strategy adopted in 2015.
  - Law adopted in 2015 to combat traffic of precious woods.
  - Anti-corruption law enacted in August 2016 criminalizing offences in UNCAC and expanding asset disclosure obligations (submission to Parliament was a prior action for program request).
  - First specialized anti-corruption centers (pole anti-corruption) envisioned under the law to become operational in July 2017.
  - Law strengthening powers to confiscate proceeds of crime submitted to Parliament in June 2017 (end-October 2016 SB and prior action).
  - Council of Budget and Financial Discipline launched first inquiries in March 2017 (end-September 2016 SB).
  - Draft laws under preparation: new anti-money laundering law (to adhere to revised FATF standards) and a law on mutual legal assistance in criminal matters.
- Focus shifting to implementation:
  - Enforcement and transparency prioritized.
  - Authorities committed to progressively publish comprehensive asset declarations of high-level officials.
  - Plans to strengthen judicial independence by:
    - Increasing number, independence and resources of anti-corruption centers.
    - Regularly publishing statistics on prosecutions and convictions of corruption cases.
    - Publishing all court decisions by the anti-corruption centers.
- Public Financial Management (PFM) transparency and integrity:
  - New PFM reform strategy for 2016-19 adopted; updated action plan to be developed by July 2017.
  - Fiscal reporting has improved, but budget documents could provide more analysis on budget execution, financial assets, and impact of new measures.
  - Need for more information on multinationals and SOEs in extractive industries.
  - Scope to strengthen control of public spending: stricter public procurement implementation, more efficient SOE supervision, and improved public investment management.

### Authorities’ views (on governance)
- Implementation of the national strategy to fight corruption is advancing.
- Bringing the legal framework up to international standards will be a significant achievement but is demanding.
- Steps underway to reinforce and establish institutions (e.g., anti-corruption centers) take time and resources to yield results.

### D. Strengthening Financial Sector Development and Stability
- Central bank stance and objectives:
  - Conduct of monetary and financial sector policy appropriate amid shocks (notably the vanilla price shock).
  - Committed to keeping inflation in single digits through money targeting, using domestic assets, and aims to steer inflation toward 5 percent over the medium-term.
  - Has kept inflation within the targeted range during the last ten years.
  - Current stance appropriate despite temporary higher money growth and inflation.
  - Inflation expected to fall in the medium-term partly due to unwinding of vanilla and food price shocks.
  - Monetary policy will need to be appropriately tight over the medium-term to remain consistent with money growth and inflation objectives.
  - New central bank law (effective in November 2016) strengthens independence, tightens limits on central bank lending to government, and mandates timely recapitalization in event of losses.
- Monetary policy framework evolution and key reforms:
  - Improve central bank internal organization.
  - Strengthen interbank money and foreign exchange markets (with TA requested).
  - Reach agreement by end-2017 with banks and market participants on a strategy to develop the government securities market.
  - Submit draft legislation promoting repo transactions (end-December 2018 SB).
  - Introduce an overnight deposit facility to help create an interest rate corridor.
  - Staff notes successful interest rate corridor introduction requires market trust that repo transactions and deposit facility will be available on demand.
  - Staff encouraged phasing out the partial surrender requirement on export proceeds (a CFM under IMF’s Institutional View); authorities see it as supporting liquidity in the shallow foreign exchange market and agree on the long-term goal but not the immediate removal.
  - Central bank to reinforce analytical capacity, especially in liquidity forecasting, with TA from IMF’s Monetary and Capital Markets Department and AFRITAC South.

*IMF staff report content (cr17223) excerpt.*

### 41. Improvements in banking sector oversight and the resolution framework will bolster

### 41. Improvements in banking sector oversight and the resolution framework will bolster

### Banking sector stability and planned actions
- The 2016 Financial Sector Assessment Program (FSAP) found a generally sound and resilient sector but identified major gaps in financial oversight and significant risks that need to be addressed.
- Key actions planned for the next few years:
  - Audits of the savings fund (Caisse d’Epargne de Madagascar, CEM) and the postal service, to be completed by end-2017.
  - Action plan for the effective implementation of risk-based supervision adopted by December 2017, including addressing the shortage of supervisory staff.
  - Submission to Parliament of legislative amendments to strengthen the recovery and resolution system for microfinance institutions by end-2017 and for banks by October 2018.
  - Strengthening supervision through improved compliance with the Basel core principles, issuance of new prudential regulations, and reinforcement of existing regulations by December 2018.
  - Enhanced supervision of insurance companies, to be moved to the financial sector supervisor (Commission de Supervision Bancaire et Financière, CSBF) by 2019.
  - Increasing the independence of the CSBF, including legal protections for its staff.
  - Establishment of a functioning credit bureau and collateral registry by 2019.

### FSAP recommendations and follow-up (summary)
- FSAP diagnostic highlights:
  - Financial system underdeveloped; banking supervision needed significant improvement.
  - Low levels of financial inclusion; system segmented and dominated by two to three foreign-owned banks.
  - Banking supervision underperformed against the Basel core principles.
  - Many non-bank financial institutions (assets of 6-7 percent of GDP) operated with minimal supervision.
  - Legislative and regulatory frameworks needed updating for internal controls, governance, and risk management (credit, liquidity, operational, market, concentration and interest rate risk).
  - Regulatory staff need further training; on-site supervision should be more frequent and risk-based.
- Key recommended actions and status targets:
  - More frequent and penetrating supervision of banks and nonbanks; better resourced and more independent regulators; fill regulatory gaps (e.g., related-party lending).
    - New regulations on internal controls, risk management and risk control, and corporate governance to enter into force in January 2018.
    - Approval of new law on supervision by end-2018.
    - New regulations on prudential supervision issued by end-2018.
    - Effective implementation of risk-based supervision by 2019.
  - Step up anti-money laundering and combating the financing of terrorism (AML/CFT).
    - Action plan to be developed by end-June 2017 following a national risk assessment.
  - Establish legal and operational framework for intervention and resolution of problem institutions.
    - Approval of new law on resolution of banks and micro-financial institutions expected by end-2018.
  - Independent audits and prudential oversight for government-owned NBFIs; possible privatization.
    - Independent financial audits of CEM and postal financial services on track for completion by end-2017.
    - Responsibility for insurance supervision to be fully transferred to CSBF by end-2019.
  - Promote modern payment methods (electronic money).
    - New law on electronic money promulgated in February 2017.
    - Law regulating the national payment system planned by end-2017.
  - Improve credit risk management: merge two credit reporting systems and modernize property registration for collateral.
    - Law regulating the credit reporting system expected to be approved by end-2017.

### Financial inclusion and payments modernization
- Current access statistics:
  - About 9 percent of the population have a bank account.
  - Only 10 percent have access to mobile money.
- Developments and reforms:
  - Law on electronic money passed in February 2017; implementing decrees and regulations for mobile money to be issued by end-December 2017 (SB).
  - Laws on banking and microfinance are being redrafted.
  - Better functioning credit and collateral registries are underway with World Bank support.
  - Authorities and the World Bank preparing a new financial inclusion project focusing on digitalization of transactions and access to credit.

### Authorities’ views and reform priorities
- Authorities committed to improving monetary policy framework and financial sector supervision across legal framework, supervisory function, and monetary policy operational framework.
- Emphasize long-term development of financial markets, policy instruments, and competition.
- Acknowledge complex reforms (e.g., legal framework for repo transactions, development of supervision capacity) take considerable time.
- Major long-term goals:
  - Gradual move to a more effective, interest-rate based monetary policy framework.
  - Development of a more inclusive and prudentially sound financial system responsive to Madagascar’s development needs.

### Macroeconomic context and implications for financial sector reforms
- Recent performance and outlook:
  - Central bank foreign exchange reserves boosted to $1.12 billion (3.9 months import cover) at end-2016.
  - Medium-term growth expected to be around 5 percent, surpassing the average for Sub-Saharan Africa.
  - Staff warns of downside risks given Madagascar’s fragility and advises readiness for timely corrective actions.
- 2017 shocks and fiscal implications:
  - Worst cyclone in 13 years and a serious drought impacted 2017.
  - Natural disasters had a total estimated impact on the current account of $225 million.
  - Authorities need to spend at least an additional $50 million on emergency relief and reconstruction work and an additional $60 million in transfers to JIRAMA in 2017.
  - Launch of Air Madagascar’s strategic partnership will require a costly one-off recapitalization.
  - Authorities requested modification of the end-June 2017 performance criterion (floor) on the primary domestic balance and an augmentation of access of 12.5 percent of quota (SDR 30.55 million) to help offset the impact of natural disasters; staff supports these requests.
  - External shock financing needs estimated at 1.1 percent of GDP in 2017.
  - Authorities envisage that the central bank on-lend up to $50 million of the IMF disbursement; staff supports this plan.

### Governance, statistics, and safeguards relevant to financial sector oversight
- Governance and anti-corruption:
  - Continued commitment to strengthen legal and institutional framework to combat corruption; emphasis on completing legal framework, focusing on implementation, and strengthening judicial independence.
- Statistics and data improvements (key actions):
  - Publication of a revised series of annual national accounts (base year updated to 2007 from 1984) by end-June 2017.
  - New statistics law to be submitted to the Parliament by end-2017 (SB).
  - Publication of a reweighted consumer price index in 2018.
  - Census scheduled to start in November 2017.
- Safeguards assessment (updated March 2017):
  - Progress in implementing recommendations from the 2015 assessment.
  - Legal framework strengthened and an Audit Committee established.
  - BCM improved timeliness of audit completion and publication of financial statements, though BCM’s outdated accounting framework remains a transparency weakness.
  - Foreign exchange investment practices, currency procurement practices, and controls over note processing and destruction require improvement; central bank committed to addressing these issues.

*Source: IMF country report excerpt (cr17223).*

### 56. It is proposed that the next Article IV Consultation be held on a 24-month cycle, in

### It is proposed that the next Article IV Consultation be held on a 24-month cycle

### Real sector developments (2006–17)
- Growth was held back by weakness in private and foreign direct investment and the slow post-crisis recovery in tourism, partially due to problems at Air Madagascar.
- For several years, mining was the main driver of growth—first through investment in 2007-08 and then through exports.
- Public investment has contributed to economic growth in recent years.
- Inflation is projected to increase in 2017 partly because of the effect of natural disasters.
- Madagascar is prone to costly natural disasters (charts reference "Annual average (1970-2013)" and "Global median (1970-2013)").

### Fiscal developments (2006–17)
- The mobilization of fiscal revenue remains challenging.
- Donor flows have started to increase but are less than levels reached in 2006.
- The automatic petroleum pricing formula, launched in February 2016, eliminated the need to subsidize petroleum consumption.
- Subsidies and transfers continue to absorb a large share of spending, mainly driven by transfers to SOEs and pensions.
- Tax exemptions and suspensions have been declining (charts show "Estimated Costs of Exemptions and Suspension of Petroleum Taxes (Percent of GDP)").
- Share of total budgetary transfers and subsidies includes JIRAMA, Air Madagascar, Pension Funds, and Other.

### External sector developments (2006–17)
- The current account will weaken because of growing imports.
- Madagascar's export earnings are based on the free-trade zone (manufacturing), mining, and agriculture.
- Investment scaling up and cyclone-related rehabilitation work are projected to increase imports significantly in 2017.
- While the NEER is depreciating, higher inflation than in its trading partners has kept the REER relatively stable.
- Charts highlight the composition of the current account (Trade balance, Income balance, Private transfers, Official transfers) and the financing composition (FDI, donor grants, government borrowing, other transactions).
- Profit repatriation (shown in other transactions) is creating significant balance of payment outflows over the medium term.

### Monetary developments (2015–17)
- Broad money growth is driven by growing net foreign assets, private sector credit growth (about 11 percent year-on-year in March 2017), and net lending to the central government.
- Interest rates follow a strong seasonal pattern with low levels early in the year when banks are the most liquid.
- Bank reserves fell until the central bank started to intervene in the foreign exchange and money markets in September 2016.
- Even when banks are liquid, two or three large banks hold most of the excess reserves.
- Charts include NDA (net domestic assets), NFA (net foreign assets), M3, net credit to central government, private sector credit, statutory advances (MGA billions), outstanding Treasury bills (MGA billions), and one-year Treasury bill rate (percent).

### Medium-term macroeconomic prospects (2008–22)
- Reforms and scaled-up public and private investment are projected to sustain growth.
- Inflation is projected to approach 5 percent a year over the medium term.
- Scaling-up of public investment is increasing medium-term fiscal spending (capital expenditure, current expenditure, revenue and grants).
- Following new donor pledges, nearly all financing needs have been covered.
- Financing of the current account deficit over the medium term includes FDI, donor grants, government borrowing (net), current account deficit, and other transactions.
- Following significant reserve accumulation in 2016, the import cover is projected to remain (charts show Gross Official Reserves in Millions of US$ and Months of import cover).

*Republic of Madagascar — International Monetary Fund (figures and captions from the source document).*

### 3.5 to 4 months over the medium term.

### cr17223 - 3.5 to 4 months over the medium term.

### Selected economic indicators (summary highlights)
- Real GDP at market prices (growth):
  - 2015: 3.1
  - 2016: 4.1
  - 2017 (Actuals): 4.2
  - 2018 (EBS): 4.5
  - 2019 (Proj.): 4.3
  - 2020 (EBS): 5.3
  - 2021 (Proj.): 5.9
  - 2022 (EBS): 5.5
  - 2023 (Proj.): 5.2
  - 2024 (Proj.): 5.0
- Consumer prices (end of period):
  - 2015: 7.6
  - 2016: 7.1
  - 2017: 7.0
  - 2018 (EBS): 7.1
  - 2019 (Proj.): 7.7
  - 2020 (EBS): 6.8
  - 2021 (Proj.): 6.0
  - 2022 (EBS): 5.4
  - 2023 (Proj.): 5.4
  - 2024 (Proj.): 5.0
- Gross official reserves (millions of SDRs):
  - 2015: 600
  - 2016: 701
  - 2017: 834
  - 2018: 782
  - 2019: 896
  - 2020 (EBS): 942
  - 2021 (Proj.): 1,045
  - 2022 (EBS): 1,161
  - 2023 (Proj.): 1,296
  - 2024 (Proj.): 1,394
- Months of imports of goods and services (reserves coverage):
  - 2015: 2.9
  - 2016: 3.3
  - 2017: 3.9
  - 2018: 3.4
  - 2019: 3.4
  - 2020 (EBS): 3.4
  - 2021 (Proj.): 3.5
  - 2022 (EBS): 3.6
  - 2023 (Proj.): 3.7
  - 2024 (Proj.): 3.7
- Public debt (percent of GDP):
  - Total public debt:
    - 2015: 41.3
    - 2016: 41.7
    - 2017: 38.7
    - 2018: 42.8
    - 2019: 41.3
    - 2020 (EBS): 42.2
    - 2021 (Proj.): 43.1
    - 2022 (EBS): 43.4
    - 2023 (Proj.): 43.9
    - 2024 (Proj.): 44.3
  - External public debt:
    - 2015: 28.4
    - 2016: 30.4
    - 2017: 27.0
    - 2018: 32.6
    - 2019: 29.6
    - 2020 (EBS): 31.9
    - 2021 (Proj.): 33.9
    - 2022 (EBS): 34.8
    - 2023 (Proj.): 35.4
    - 2024 (Proj.): 35.8
  - Domestic public debt:
    - 2015: 12.9
    - 2016: 11.3
    - 2017: 11.7
    - 2018: 10.2
    - 2019: 11.8
    - 2020 (EBS): 10.4
    - 2021 (Proj.): 9.2
    - 2022 (EBS): 8.6
    - 2023 (Proj.): 8.5
    - 2024 (Proj.): 8.5

### Public finances (key fiscal aggregates and projections)
- Total revenue (excluding grants) as percent of GDP:
  - 2015: 10.4
  - 2016: 11.0
  - 2017: 11.2
  - 2018 (EBS): 11.2
  - 2019 (Proj.): 11.6
  - 2020 (EBS): 11.8
  - 2021 (Proj.): 12.2
  - 2022 (EBS): 12.7
  - 2023 (Proj.): 13.1
  - 2024 (Proj.): 13.5
- Total expenditures (percent of GDP):
  - 2015: 15.1
  - 2016: 16.2
  - 2017: 16.0
  - 2018: 18.3
  - 2019: 20.2
  - 2020 (EBS): 20.0
  - 2021 (Proj.): 20.1
  - 2022 (EBS): 18.8
  - 2023 (Proj.): 18.9
  - 2024 (Proj.): 19.0
- Capital expenditure (percent of GDP) and financing split:
  - Capital expenditure:
    - 2015: 3.5
    - 2016: 5.3
    - 2017: 5.2
    - 2018: 8.0
    - 2019: 8.3
    - 2020 (EBS): 10.2
    - 2021 (Proj.): 10.5
    - 2022 (EBS): 9.4
    - 2023 (Proj.): 9.3
    - 2024 (Proj.): 9.1
  - Domestic-financed capital:
    - 2015: 1.0
    - 2016: 1.5
    - 2017: 1.2
    - 2018: 1.9
    - 2019: 2.3
    - 2020 (EBS): 2.5
    - 2021 (Proj.): 3.1
    - 2022 (EBS): 3.4
    - 2023 (Proj.): 3.5
    - 2024 (Proj.): 3.6
  - Foreign-financed capital:
    - 2015: 2.5
    - 2016: 3.7
    - 2017: 4.0
    - 2018: 6.1
    - 2019: 6.0
    - 2020 (EBS): 7.7
    - 2021 (Proj.): 7.4
    - 2022 (EBS): 6.0
    - 2023 (Proj.): 5.8
    - 2024 (Proj.): 5.5
- Overall fiscal balance (commitment basis, percent of GDP):
  - 2015: -3.3
  - 2016: -3.2
  - 2017: -1.3
  - 2018: -4.4
  - 2019: -5.1
  - 2020 (EBS): -4.7
  - 2021 (Proj.): -4.5
  - 2022 (EBS): -3.8
  - 2023 (Proj.): -3.5
  - 2024 (Proj.): -3.3
- Overall balance (cash basis, percent of GDP):
  - 2015: -3.7
  - 2016: -4.5
  - 2017: -2.1
  - 2018: -5.1
  - 2019: -6.0
  - 2020 (EBS): -5.2
  - 2021 (Proj.): -4.8
  - 2022 (EBS): -4.0
  - 2023 (Proj.): -3.5
  - 2024 (Proj.): -3.3
- Primary balance (excl. foreign-financed investment, percent of GDP):
  - 2015: -1.3
  - 2016: -0.6
  - 2017: 0.8
  - 2018: 0.1
  - 2019: -0.7
  - 2020 (EBS): 1.3
  - 2021 (Proj.): 1.1
  - 2022 (EBS): 0.9
  - 2023 (Proj.): 1.0
  - 2024 (Proj.): 0.9

### National accounts (sectoral composition and saving/investment)
- Real supply-side growth by sector (selected points):
  - Agriculture (growth):
    - 2015: -2.4
    - 2016: 2.8
    - 2017: 1.4
    - 2018: 3.5
    - 2019: -0.3
    - 2020 (EBS): 3.5
    - 2021 (Proj.): 3.7
    - 2022 (EBS): 3.7
    - 2023 (Proj.): 2.7
    - 2024 (Proj.): 2.7
  - Secondary sector (growth):
    - 2015: 7.3
    - 2016: 4.9
    - 2017: 5.5
    - 2018: 5.0
    - 2019: 5.7
    - 2020 (EBS): 6.1
    - 2021 (Proj.): 7.7
    - 2022 (EBS): 7.3
    - 2023 (Proj.): 7.0
    - 2024 (Proj.): 7.0
  - Tertiary sector (growth):
    - 2015: 3.3
    - 2016: 4.8
    - 2017: 4.8
    - 2018: 5.3
    - 2019: 5.8
    - 2020 (EBS): 6.5
    - 2021 (Proj.): 6.9
    - 2022 (EBS): 6.4
    - 2023 (Proj.): 6.0
    - 2024 (Proj.): 5.6
- Investment and savings (percent of GDP):
  - Investment:
    - 2015: 13.1
    - 2016: 15.3
    - 2017: 15.2
    - 2018: 18.2
    - 2019: 19.2
    - 2020 (EBS): 21.5
    - 2021 (Proj.): 21.4
    - 2022 (EBS): 20.4
    - 2023 (Proj.): 20.3
    - 2024 (Proj.): 20.0
  - Gross national savings:
    - 2015: 11.2
    - 2016: 13.0
    - 2017: 16.0
    - 2018: 14.5
    - 2019: 14.5
    - 2020 (EBS): 16.2
    - 2021 (Proj.): 16.4
    - 2022 (EBS): 16.2
    - 2023 (Proj.): 16.1
    - 2024 (Proj.): 16.1

### External sector (trade, current account, and financing)
- Exports of goods, f.o.b. (percent of GDP):
  - 2015: 21.0
  - 2016: 21.5
  - 2017: 21.6
  - 2018: 20.8
  - 2019: 22.3
  - 2020 (EBS): 21.5
  - 2021 (Proj.): 22.2
  - 2022 (EBS): 23.8
  - 2023 (Proj.): 24.5
  - 2024 (Proj.): 25.0
- Imports of goods, c.i.f. (percent of GDP):
  - 2015: 28.7
  - 2016: 30.2
  - 2017: 28.6
  - 2018: 31.2
  - 2019: 34.6
  - 2020 (EBS): 34.4
  - 2021 (Proj.): 34.8
  - 2022 (EBS): 35.5
  - 2023 (Proj.): 36.3
  - 2024 (Proj.): 36.9
- Current account balance (percent of GDP):
  - Excluding grants:
    - 2015: -3.4
    - 2016: -4.3
    - 2017: -2.7
    - 2018: -6.4
    - 2019: -8.1
    - 2020 (EBS): -8.9
    - 2021 (Proj.): -8.4
    - 2022 (EBS): -6.5
    - 2023 (Proj.): -6.4
    - 2024 (Proj.): -6.2
  - Including grants:
    - 2015: -1.9
    - 2016: -2.3
    - 2017: 0.8
    - 2018: -3.7
    - 2019: -4.7
    - 2020 (EBS): -5.3
    - 2021 (Proj.): -5.0
    - 2022 (EBS): -4.2
    - 2023 (Proj.): -4.1
    - 2024 (Proj.): -4.0
- Balance of payments (millions of SDRs; current account):
  - 2015: -131.6
  - 2016: -158.8
  - 2017: 54.0
  - 2018 (EBS): -273.3
  - 2019 (Proj.): -363.1
  - 2020 (EBS): -433.7
  - 2021 (Proj.): -442.4
  - 2022 (EBS): -399.5
  - 2023 (Proj.): -417.5
  - 2024 (Proj.): -428.8
- External financing requirements and sources (millions of U.S. dollars):
  - Total financing requirements:
    - 2015: 859
    - 2016: 908
    - 2017: 1,362
    - 2018: 1,488
    - 2019: 1,561
    - 2017-19 total: 4,411
  - Available financing (2017-19 totals):
    - Foreign direct and portfolio investment (2017-19 total): 1,488
    - Budgetary support (2017-19 total): 167
    - Project support (2017-19 total): 2,388
    - IMF: RCF and ECF arrangement (2017-19 total): 297
  - External financing gap:
    - 2015: 0
    - 2016: 0
    - 2017: 0
    - 2018: 33
    - 2019: 38
    - 2017-19 total: 71

### Monetary accounts and banking sector (key aggregates)
- Broad money (M2/M3) and growth:
  - Money and quasi-money (M3) end-period (billions of ariary):
    - 2015: 7,502
    - 2016: 8,293
    - 2017: 8,844
    - 2018 (Dec projection): 8,993
    - 2019 (EBS): 9,268
    - 2020 (Mar): 9,666
    - 2021 (Jun): 10,003
    - 2022 (Dec proj.): 11,102
    - 2023 (Dec proj.): 12,820
    - 2024 (Dec proj.): 14,893
  - Broad money (M2) end-period (billions of ariary):
    - 2015: 6,600
    - 2016: 7,367
    - 2017: 7,868
    - 2018 (Dec projection): 7,993
    - 2019 (EBS): 8,143
    - 2020 (Mar): 8,661
    - 2021 (Jun): 8,981
    - 2022 (Dec proj.): 10,011
    - 2023 (Dec proj.): 11,629
    - 2024 (Dec proj.): 13,668
- Credit to the private sector (levels and growth):
  - Credit to private sector (billions of ariary):
    - 2015: 3,785
    - 2016: 3,957
    - 2017: 4,128
    - 2018 (EBS/Actuals): 4,094
    - 2019 (Proj.): 4,187
    - 2020 (EBS): 4,481
    - 2021 (Proj.): 4,765
    - 2022 (EBS): 4,715
    - 2023 (Proj.): 4,815
    - 2024 (Proj.): 5,208
  - Credit to the private sector (percent change relative to beginning-of-period M3):
    - 2015: 16.5
    - 2016: 11.3
    - 2017: 9.1
    - 2018: 8.2
    - 2019: 11.4
    - 2020 (EBS): 16.9
    - 2021 (Proj.): 20.4
    - 2022 (EBS): 14.2
    - 2023 (Proj.): 17.6
    - 2024 (Proj.): 24.4
- Central bank net foreign assets (millions of ariary; end period):
  - 2015: 1,763
  - 2016: 2,014
  - 2017: 2,250
  - 2018 (Dec proj.): 2,709
  - 2019 (EBS): 2,569
  - 2020 (Mar): 2,607
  - 2021 (Jun): 2,537
  - 2022 (Dec proj.): 2,769
  - 2023 (Dec proj.): 2,711
  - 2024 (Dec proj.): 2,832

### Central bank balance sheet (high-level)
- Reserve money (end period, billions of ariary):
  - 2015: 3,067
  - 2016: 3,457
  - 2017: 3,599
  - 2018 (Dec proj.): 3,559
  - 2019 (EBS): 3,845
  - 2020 (Mar): 3,687
  - 2021 (Jun): 3,761
  - 2022 (Dec proj.): 4,019
  - 2023 (Dec proj.): 4,271
  - 2024 (Dec proj.): 4,012
- Net foreign assets (BCM, millions of SDRs—memorandum/coverage indicators are provided in the source tables)

### Financial soundness indicators (banking sector, selected ratios)
- Regulatory capital to risk-weighted assets:
  - 2009: 14.64
  - 2010: 14.37
  - 2011: 15.31
  - 2012: 15.17
  - 2013: 14.75
  - 2014: 13.25
  - 2015: 12.37
  - 2016: 12.71
  - 2017 (Mar): 12.23
- Non-performing loans to total gross loans:
  - 2009: 11.29
  - 2010: 13.11
  - 2011: 14.61
  - 2012: 14.21
  - 2013: 13.78
  - 2014: 12.02
  - 2015: 10.58
  - 2016: 9.66
  - 2017 (Mar): 9.82
- Return on assets:
  - 2009: 1.60
  - 2010: 1.50
  - 2011: 1.80
  - 2012: 1.95
  - 2013: 2.34
  - 2014: 3.10
  - 2015: 3.78
  - 2016: 3.13
  - 2017 (Mar): 2.93
- Liquid assets to total assets:
  - 2009: 46.89
  - 2010: 45.87
  - 2011: 49.66
  - 2012: 50.43
  - 2013: 43.24
  - 2014: 39.93
  - 2015: 37.74
  - 2016: 41.11
  - 2017 (Mar): 42.68

### Program implementation: performance criteria, indicative targets, and structural benchmarks (selected)
- Quantitative performance criteria (September 2016 to March 2017; selected outcomes):
  - Floor on primary balance excl. foreign-financed investment (commitment basis, billons of Ariary):
    - End-Sep. 2016 Adjusted Target: -126; Actual: 128; Status: Met
    - End-Dec. 2016 Adjusted Target: -184; Actual: 40; Status: Met
    - End-Mar. 2017 Indicative Target: 180; Actual: 35; Status: Not Met
  - Floor on net foreign assets of BCM (millions of SDRs):
    - End-Sep. 2016 Adjusted Target: 435; Actual: 396; Status: Met
    - End-Dec. 2016 Adjusted Target: 477; Actual: 413; Status: Met
    - End-Mar. 2017 Indicative Target: 477; Actual: 427; Status: Met
  - Ceiling on net domestic assets of BCM (billions of Ariary):
    - End-Sep. 2016 Adjusted Target: 1,524; Actual: 1,698; Status: Met
    - End-Dec. 2016 Adjusted Target: 1,441; Actual: 1,725; Status: Met
    - End-Mar. 2017 Indicative Target: 1,566; Actual: 1,789; Status: Met
- Indicative targets (selected):
  - Floor on social priority spending (billions of Ariary):
    - End-Sep. 2016 Adjusted Target: 162; Actual: 134; Status: Not Met
    - End-Dec. 2016 Adjusted Target: 235; Actual: 259; Status: Met
    - End-Mar. 2017 Indicative Target: 60; Actual: 62; Status: Met
  - Floor on gross tax revenue (billions of Ariary):
    - End-Sep. 2016 Adjusted Target: 2,491; Actual: 2,568; Status: Met
    - End-Dec. 2016 Adjusted Target: 3,587; Actual: 3,618; Status: Met
    - End-Mar. 2017 Indicative Target: 846; Actual: 951; Status: Met
- Structural benchmarks (through end-February 2017; status notes):
  - Continued implementation of automatic pricing formula for full cost-recovery fuel prices (continuous benchmark): Not met; mechanism avoided budget costs though not fully automatic.
  - Collect at least MGA 30 billion of outstanding tax arrears in 2016 and publish a report (End-February 2017): Met.
  - Publication of terms and conditions of PPP contracts on ARMP’s web site (continuous benchmark): Met (no PPP contracts signed).
  - Prior notification to IMF and World Bank for single-source procurement for JIRAMA (continuous benchmark): Not met (one single source contract signed without notification).
  - Make the Council of Budget and Financial Discipline (CDBF) operational by issuing decree, appointing staff, and publishing disciplinary decisions (End-September 2016): Not met; implemented with delay; CDBF launched first inquiries in March.
  - Submission to Parliament of law regulating management of seized assets (End-October 2016): Not met; implemented with delay; law submitted on June 13, 2017.
  - Publication and submission of 2015 financial statements of ten large SOEs to the Court of Auditors (End-December 2016): Met.

### IMF financing and ECF arrangement (schedule and capacity to repay)
- Proposed schedule of disbursements and timing of ECF arrangement reviews (SDR amounts and percent of quota):
  - July 27, 2016: 12.9 percent; 31,428,000 SDRs (Board approval)
  - June 28, 2017: 25.4 percent; 61,978,000 SDRs (first review)
  - November 20, 2017: 12.9 percent; 31,428,000 SDRs (second review)
  - May 20, 2018: 12.9 percent; 31,428,000 SDRs (third review)
  - November 20, 2018: 12.9 percent; 31,428,000 SDRs (fourth review)
  - May 20, 2019: 12.9 percent; 31,428,000 SDRs (fifth review)
  - November 20, 2019: 12.9 percent; 31,432,000 SDRs (sixth review)
  - Total: 102.5 percent; 250,550,000 SDRs
- Indicators of capacity to repay the Fund (selected projections and ratios):
  - Total obligations based on existing and prospective credit (Millions of SDRs; 2017–2031): 4.0 (2017), 6.3 (2018), 3.5 (2019), 6.5 (2020), 12.7 (2021), 25.1 (2022), 40.8 (2023), 50.3 (2024), 56.7 (2025), 50.6 (2026), 38.1 (2027), 22.4 (2028), 9.9 (2029), 0.4 (2030), 0.4 (2031)
  - Outstanding IMF credit based on existing and prospective drawings (Millions of SDRs):
    - 2017: 191.9
    - 2018: 248.8
    - 2019: 308.7
    - 2020: 302.6
    - 2021: 290.4
    - 2022: 265.7
    - 2023: 225.3
    - 2024: 175.4
    - 2025: 119.2
    - 2026: 69.1
    - 2027: 31.3
    - 2028: 9.3
    - 2029–2031: 0.0
  - Net use of IMF credit (millions of SDRs): 89.7 (2017), 57.0 (2018), 59.8 (2019), -6.1 (2020), -12.2 (2021), -24.7 (2022), -40.4 (2023), -49.9 (2024), -56.2 (2025), -50.1 (2026), -37.6 (2027), -22.0 (2028), -9.4 (2029), 0.0 (2030), 0.0 (2031)

### Memoranda and other items of note
- GDP per capita (U.S. dollars):
  - 2015: 402
  - 2016: 391
  - 2017: 401
  - 2018: 405
  - 2019: 412
  - 2020 (EBS): 424
  - 2021 (Proj.): 444
  - 2022 (EBS): 464
  - 2023 (Proj.): 485
  - 2024 (Proj.): 503
- Terms of trade (percent change, deterioration -):
  - 2015: 1.3
  - 2016: 6.6
  - 2017: 23.2
  - 2018: -4.6
  - 2019: -5.1
  - 2020 (EBS): -3.2
  - 2021 (Proj.): 2.2
  - 2022 (EBS): 0.3
  - 2023 (Proj.): -1.8
  - 2024 (Proj.): -2.3

*Sources: Malagasy authorities; and IMF staff estimates and projections.*

### Annex I. External Balance Assessment

### Annex I. External Balance Assessment

### Staff assessment of the 2016 external position
- Staff assesses the 2016 external balance to be stronger than values consistent with fundamentals and desirable policy settings.
- Improvements in the terms of trade, most importantly due to higher vanilla prices, contributed to a significant strengthening of the external position.
- International reserves are adequate but in the lower end of the target range.

### Current account: 2016 numbers and adjustments
- Actual current account (A): 0.8 (percent of GDP)
- Temporary factors (spike in vanilla prices) (B): 3.0 (percent of GDP)
  - If the price of vanilla in 2016 had been identical to the average price over 2004-16, Madagascar’s export earnings from vanilla would have been about $300 million (3.0 percent of GDP) lower.
- Adjusted current account (C = A − B): -2.3 (percent of GDP)
- Fitted current account (D): -3.5 (percent of GDP)
- Policy gap (E): 1.4 (percent of GDP) — reflecting a constrained fiscal stance (1.0 percent of GDP), limited private credit disbursements (0.3 percent of GDP), and relatively rapid reserve accumulation (0.2 percent of GDP)
- Current account norm (F = D − E): -5.0 (percent of GDP)
- Current account gap (G = C − F): -2.7 (percent of GDP)
- Interpretation: The adjusted current account (a deficit of -2.3 percent of GDP) was 2.7 percent of GDP stronger than its norm in 2016.

### External financing, NIIP, and exchange rate
- Net international investment position (NIIP): increased from below 40 percent of GDP in 2008 to roughly 105 percent of GDP in 2016, mainly because of higher private-sector liabilities linked to the mining projects.
  - Staff note: Given their predominantly intra-group character, the risk related to these liabilities is small.
- Exchange rate regime: Madagascar has a floating exchange rate regime. The central bank intervenes in the interbank market to smooth large exchange rate fluctuations and meet foreign reserve targets.
  - In 2015, the central bank intervened heavily with buyback operations; buyback operations were completely abolished in September 2015.
- REER assessment:
  - Elasticity (regression of observed REER on the current account): -0.27
  - REER gap (percent): 10 (percent) — staff-assessed based on the current account gap of 2.7 percent and elasticity of -0.27 indicates an REER undervaluation of 10 percent.
  - Alternative model result: the REER model suggests a larger REER undervaluation of about 27 percent in 2016.
  - Caution: these results should be interpreted with caution because the REER has been more stable than the current account deficit would suggest.

### International reserves and liquidity dynamics
- Reserves coverage:
  - Estimated reserves covered 3.9 months of current imports by end-2016 compared to 2.9 months at end-2015.
  - This import coverage is in the lower half of the target range given an assumed cost of holding reserves of 6 percent, the heavy reliance on mining exports, and the challenging international environment.
- 2016 reserve dynamics:
  - The accumulation of central bank reserves exceeded projections in 2016.
  - The spike in vanilla export prices paid un-banked small vanilla producers large cash payments, expanding currency in circulation and draining bank liquidity.
  - In response, the central bank started buying substantial amounts of foreign exchange, which increased bank liquidity and satiated the demand for local currency.
  - Reserve accumulation is expected to level off in 2017.
  - The above-normal amounts of currency in circulation are expected to return to the banking system when vanilla prices retreat to more typical levels; at that time, the central bank may sell some foreign exchange to avoid excess liquidity and keep inflationary pressure under control.
- Outlook: Following a projected rapid increase in imports, import coverage of reserves is likely to fall in 2017. Reserve accumulation is projected to continue at a gradual pace over the medium term.

### Outlook, drivers, and policy recommendations
- Outlook drivers:
  - The current account is expected to adjust to its norm as terms of trade return to historical levels and especially as public investment scales up.
  - The vanilla price boom will probably be short lived based on historical evidence.
  - Investment needs will remain significant; imports are likely to increase because of scaling up of investment and reconstruction work following cyclone Enawo.
  - Growing current account deficits will be offset by related surpluses in the capital and financial accounts from public sector grants and loans and foreign direct investment.
  - Constraints to external borrowing should decrease with increasing political stability and implementation of policies supported by an IMF arrangement that reinforce relations with development partners.
  - Improvements in the business climate would make Madagascar more attractive to foreign investors.
- Policy recommendations:
  - To maintain debt sustainability and macro-economic stability, the authorities need to:
    - scale up investment gradually (as planned),
    - ensure that investment projects are well targeted,
    - rely on resources with the most attractive financing conditions.

### Risk assessment: key risks, likelihoods, impacts, and policy responses (selected)
- Domestic risks (high likelihood / high impact examples):
  - Weak project implementation capacity
    - Potential impact: Slower economic growth and higher inflation.
    - Policy response: Monitor domestic capacity (particularly in construction), postpone project implementation, and give precedence to priority investment with highest returns.
  - Larger than anticipated transfers to SOEs (JIRAMA and Air Madagascar)
    - Potential impact: Transfers to SOEs reduce other priority expenditure. Potential economic disruption if SOE’s operations are affected.
    - Policy response: Identify options to protect key public services. Strengthen governance structures, including government oversight of key SOEs. Consider private management of specific units or operations.
  - Growing political uncertainty and tensions ahead of 2018 elections
    - Potential impact: Reduced inflows from FDI, donor support, and tourism. Less fiscal space impedes the ability to deliver public services.
    - Policy response: Maintain exchange rate flexibility and reallocate fiscal spending from investment to support of the most vulnerable. Encourage authorities and development partners to protect spending in social priority areas.
  - Failure to begin tackling corruption
    - Potential impact: Reduced inflow of FDI and donor support.
    - Policy response: Step-up anti-corruption and anti-money laundering/combating financing of terrorism (AML/CFT) efforts.
- External risks (examples):
  - Structurally weak growth in key advanced and emerging economies
    - Relative likelihood: High (Euro area and Japan) / Medium (emerging markets)
    - Potential impact: Less financing reduces the ability to deliver public services. Slower growth in tourism. Weaker commodity prices and balance of payments.
    - Policy response: Maintain exchange rate flexibility as a shock absorber. Energize donor support through a campaign emphasizing the merits and needs of the medium-term development plan; protect key public services within budget. Diversify sources of tourism. Promote “open skies” policy to improve travel connections.
  - Retreat from cross-border integration
    - Potential impact: Reduced inflows from FDI and donor support (including lower concessionality). Reduced access to foreign markets.
    - Policy response: Maintain exchange rate flexibility and reallocate fiscal spending from investment to support of the most vulnerable.

### Vulnerability to natural disasters and resilience policy
- Vulnerability overview:
  - Madagascar is highly vulnerable to natural disasters given its geographical location, weak institutional capacity, and high dependency on natural resources.
  - During 1990-2014, Madagascar was hit by 55 natural disasters that killed at least 3,561 people and left 10 million people with an urgent need for aid (EM-DAT database).
  - Madagascar was struck by a plague of locusts in 2012, infesting over half of the island's cultivated land and pastures, causing the loss of 25 percent of national food consumption.
  - Madagascar’s current food security rating of 35.4 is “alarming” (Global Hunger Index 2016).
  - One-quarter of Madagascar’s population—approximately five million people—lives in zones at high risk of natural disasters (World Bank 2016).
- Socioeconomic context:
  - High levels of poverty and dependence on rain-fed agriculture: a large and rising proportion of the Malagasy population living in absolute poverty ($1.90 a day) limits coping mechanisms for emergencies.
- Macroeconomic impacts (event analysis, 1990–2014):
  - Growth rebounds in the year after a disaster, but results suggest a slowdown of economic growth following droughts, storms, and epidemics, but not floods.
  - Food prices rise in the event of natural disaster, and persistently so in the year following floods.
  - Trade balance deteriorates in the year of a natural disaster, but recovers the next year, except in the event of floods and storms.
  - Near-term impact on the fiscal balance is muted, possibly reflecting policy adjustments.
- Policy approach:
  - Building resilience through risk reduction and transfer strategies is appropriate.
  - Authorities have integrated resilience through adaptation into national development policies.
  - Development partners, particularly the World Bank, have been assisting efforts (e.g., Urban Development and Resilience, Pilot Program for Climate Resilience).
  - Risk transfer mechanisms are less advanced; authorities are considering options such as the World Bank’s Catastrophe Deferred Drawdown Option and the Africa Risk Capacity insurance scheme.
  - Self-insurance through building international reserve and fiscal buffers could also make sense, although the desirable size of the buffers is limited by their high opportunity cost in a context of high interest rates and infrastructure gaps.

*Sources: Malagasy authorities; and IMF staff estimates.*

### Appendix I. Letter of Intent

### Appendix I. Letter of Intent

### Program progress and requests
- The Republic of Madagascar reports progress under an IMF arrangement under the Extended Credit Facility (ECF) since July 2016.
- All end-December 2016 performance criteria (PCs) were met; a zero ceiling on the accumulation of new external payment arrears was not observed in February 2017 because of a delayed debt service payment that has since been made.
- The government requests:
  - Approval of an augmentation of the three-year ECF arrangement up to a total amount of SDR 250.55 million for the period from July 27, 2016 through November 27, 2019.
  - A waiver for non-observance of the continuous performance criterion on new external payment arrears.
  - A modification of the performance criterion (floor) on the primary balance excluding foreign-financed investment at end-June 2017.
  - Completion of the first review.
- With the requested augmentation, at the first review the government is seeking total financial support from the Fund equivalent to 25.4 percent of quota, or SDR 61.98 million.
- The government agrees to publication of this Letter of Intent, the attached MEFP, and the TMU, as well as the IMF staff report and the Debt Sustainability Analysis, after Executive Board approval.

### Recent economic developments (highlights)
- Growth and investment:
  - Real GDP growth accelerated to 4.2 percent in 2016.
  - Total investment increased from about 13.1 percent of GDP in 2015 to an estimated 15.3 percent of GDP in 2016.
- Fiscal performance:
  - Overall fiscal deficit (commitment basis) at 1.3 percent of GDP in 2016.
  - Primary balance excluding foreign-financed investment stood at 0.8 percent of GDP, exceeding the program target (the program’s fiscal anchor).
  - Tax revenues exceeded original budget targets for the first time in many years; current grants were higher than projected.
  - Transfers to loss-making public enterprises (JIRAMA and Air Madagascar) created fiscal challenges.
- Monetary and external sector:
  - Inflation reported at 7.0 percent in December 2016.
  - BFM made net foreign exchange purchases of US$312 million in 2016.
  - Reserves reached US$1,121 million at end-2016, equivalent to 3.9 months of imports (compared to 2.2 months at end-2013).
  - The real effective exchange rate appreciated by an estimated 8 percent (year-on-year in December 2016).
  - The current account recorded a surplus of 0.8 percent of GDP in 2016.
- Banking sector:
  - Capital adequacy (measured as capital to assets ratio) is adequate; overall banking sector profitability is strong.
  - The ratio of nonperforming loans is declining.
  - Some microfinance institutions face difficulties.

### Performance under the ECF-supported program
- Quantitative performance:
  - All quantitative PCs and continuous PCs were observed through end-December 2016, except for the temporary February breach on the continuous PC on external arrears (see waiver request).
  - The PC on net foreign assets was met by a large margin.
  - All indicative targets were met; social spending missed narrowly at end-September but was recouped by end-December (MGA 259 billion).
- Structural reforms:
  - Achievements:
    - Continuous benchmark: terms and conditions of all PPP contracts published within one month on ARMP’s web site was observed.
    - Publication and submission to the Court of Auditors of the 2015 financial statements of ten large state-owned enterprises was met.
    - The Council of Budget and Financial Discipline launched its first inquiries in March (meeting end-September 2016 benchmark).
    - The law to enhance asset recovery was submitted to Parliament on June 13, 2017 (end-October 2016 benchmark).
  - Misses/slippages:
    - Continuous benchmark on implementation of an automatic fuel price mechanism was not met because a price smoothing mechanism was introduced following agreement with petroleum product distributors; no additional budget costs were incurred.
    - Continuous benchmark on notifying World Bank and IMF staff of any single source contracts awarded by JIRAMA was not met because one contract was signed urgently to meet an investor deadline.
  - Management response:
    - New JIRAMA management (appointed January 2017) renewed commitment to competitive and transparent procurement practices, including informing Fund and Bank staff in writing in advance of signing any single-source procurement contracts (continuous structural benchmark).

### Economic outlook and vulnerabilities
- Growth projections:
  - Growth projected to accelerate from 4.3 percent in 2017 to 5.9 percent in 2019, driven by scaled-up public investment and structural reforms.
- Financing and debt:
  - Targeted increase in investment spending will be financed largely through external grants and concessional loans.
  - Risk of external debt distress assessed as moderate using the IMF/World Bank debt sustainability framework; authorities commit to maintaining this level of risk.
  - Authorities will avoid all non-concessional short-term external borrowing (original maturity of less than one year).
  - Explicit cumulative ceilings for longer-term non-and semi-concessional borrowing set at US$383 million up to end-June 2018, of which only US$100 million can have a grant element of less than 20 percent (PC, Table 1).
  - If concessional external financing is unavailable, limited long-term non- and semi-concessional borrowing could be considered within ECF limits, with prior consultation with IMF and World Bank staff.
- Vulnerabilities:
  - Domestic: risk of implementation capacity constraints delaying scaling up; loss-making state-owned enterprises requiring additional transfers.
  - External: shifting terms of trade; dependence on external donor funding; possible loss of trade preferences; dependence on FDI.
  - Natural disasters: vulnerability illustrated by cyclone Enawo in March (the most severe in 13 years), droughts affecting hydropower generation, food prices, and regions including a three-year drought in the South.

### Macroeconomic and structural policies (priorities and actions)
- Scaling up public investment:
  - Priority sectors: energy, roads, port facilities, agricultural development, education, and health.
  - Investment planning and capacity building:
    - A prioritized investment program has been developed consultatively.
    - Short-term: implement a 6-month priority action plan developed with AFRITAC South technical assistance (March 2017).
    - Medium-term: adopt a medium-term strategy to enhance public investment management capacity in line with PIMA recommendations by end-December 2017 (structural benchmark).
    - An investment coordination unit in the Presidency and a central strategy and coordination unit established under the Presidency (established February 2017) to manage risks and coordinate work.
    - Authorities stand ready to stretch out implementation of investment projects if necessary to contain risks.
- Public investment financing stance:
  - Priority is to seek financing by grants and concessional external borrowing.
  - Commitment to follow the debt management strategy adopted in December 2015 to maximize concessional financing share and reinforce debt management capacity at the Ministry of Finance and Budget.
- Public-Private Partnerships (PPPs):
  - New PPP law enacted February 2016; application decrees adopted by the Cabinet in March 2017.
  - A dedicated unit at the Presidency coordinates PPPs; the ministry of finance and budget retains the right to disapprove/stop projects before signature if fiscal implications are disproportionate.
  - PPP contracts can be suspended by the Comité de Suivi in the event of a breach.
  - The PPP unit in the ministry of finance and budget will remain appropriately staffed and financed and fully involved throughout the process.
  - Capacity building: intensify staff training on PPP identification and analysis, implicit and explicit guarantees, and fiscal risks; IMF and World Bank to provide technical support.
  - Continuous benchmark: terms and conditions of all PPP contracts will be published within one month of the date of signature on the web site of the Ministry of Finance and Budget.

*Letter of Intent and attached MEFP and TMU submitted by Mr. François Marie Maurice Gervais Rakotoarimanana, Minister of Finance and Budget, and Mr. Alain Hervé Rasolofondraibe, Governor, Central Bank of Madagascar (Antananarivo, June 13, 2017).*

### 16.      The government will prioritize legislative and regulatory reforms with the potential of

### 16.      The government will prioritize legislative and regulatory reforms with the potential of

### Business climate and investment promotion
- The government will prioritize legislative and regulatory reforms with the potential of “quick wins” for improving the business climate and reducing barriers to FDI.
- Cooperation with the World Bank to improve the business climate and strengthen the public-private interface to increase investor confidence and private investment.
- 2017 Doing Business Survey estimates:
  - Madagascar’s overall performance is currently 45 percent of best performance (up from 44 percent in the 2016 survey).
  - Madagascar ranks 167 (out of 190 countries) on ease of doing business in 2017—an improvement of 2 places compared to the previous 2016 survey.
  - Starting a business improved by 13 steps to 113.
  - Trading across borders improved by 5 steps to 129.
- Planned legal reforms:
  - Modernize the company act and submit revisions to the Parliament.
  - Pursue steps toward joining the OHADA (Organisation pour l’Harmonisation en Afrique du Droit des Affaires).

### Mining, petroleum, and Special Economic Zones (SEZs)
- New legislation and regulations under preparation aim to provide cost-effective incentives for potential investors in mining, petroleum, and special economic zones.
- Several laws are being drafted, including:
  - Mining law and petroleum law to be brought in line with international best practice.
  - Principal measures include: an increase in royalty rates and more differentiation by type of mineral; a review of the royalty revenue-sharing formula; and a reduction in length of fiscal stability clauses.
  - A law on Special Economic Zones (SEZ) is under preparation; focus on structural benefits such as easier access to infrastructure and electricity; fiscal incentives will be kept to a level that does not undermine future revenue generation.
  - Examination of harmonization of the regimes for SEZs and Zones Franches over the medium term.
  - Draft Law on Industrial Development under consideration; any fiscal incentives will be kept to a level that does not undermine future revenue generation.

### Social protection and inclusive growth
- Government actions to support implementation of the social protection policy approved in 2015.
- With World Bank support, implementing three social protection programs:
  - Conditional cash transfers targeting 39,000 households with children under the age of 12.
  - Cash-for-work program providing a regular income for 32,500 households.
  - Non-conditional cash transfer targeting 45.000 households in 2017 and 65.000 households in 2018, with a shift to conditional cash transfers.
- Coverage and outcomes:
  - In total, these programs cover more than half a million people living in extreme poverty.
  - 97 percent of the children in the beneficiary families now attend school.
- Plans and institutional measures:
  - With co-financing from development partners, hope to expand coverage.
  - Submit to Parliament the new law on social protection to strengthen the coordination function of the Ministry of Population regarding social safety net programs by end-2017 (structural benchmark).
  - Enhance implementation and coordination of agricultural and rural development.
  - Efforts to enhance inclusive growth are intertwined with resilience to natural disasters and climate change.

### Creating more fiscal space: targets, institutions, and arrears
- Fiscal targets and institutional reforms:
  - Limit the budget deficit (commitment basis) to 5.0 percent of GDP in the current year.
  - Aim for a deficit of 0.6 percent of GDP in the primary balance excluding foreign financed investment.
  - Repaying domestic arrears remains a priority after repayments in 2016 reduced the stock by more than 1 percent of GDP.
  - Establish a tax policy unit at the Ministry of Finance and Budget by end-September 2017 (structural benchmark) to undertake impact studies, analyze tax expenditures, and improve coordination and data sharing between tax and customs departments.
  - Improve public wage bill planning and execution with IMF technical assistance.
- Revenue performance and actions:
  - Net/gross revenue collections exceeded projections in 2016 by 0.1/0.2 percent of GDP.
  - Collection of outstanding tax arrears (MGA 42 billion) boosted revenues in 2016; completion of a structural benchmark by publishing a report in February.
  - Aim at recovering a similar amount in 2017.
  - Administrative measures in 2016 included better risk-based auditing and establishment of a unique tax identification number (TIN) at both customs and tax departments, clearer rules in tax litigation, and performance based contracts at customs.
  - Madagascar’s tax and customs collections remain significantly below potential.
- Prioritized near-term revenue actions:
  - Publish a report summarizing the tax credits granted and irregular tax credits by major companies that will have been cancelled by end-June 2017 (structural benchmark).
  - Employ the use of the new TIN throughout all departments of the Ministry of Finance and Budget and CNAPS by end-December 2017 (structural benchmark).
  - Prepare to expand the use of TINs to all other ministries by end-December 2018.
  - Extend performance contracts to the anti-fraud unit at customs by end-September 2017 (structural benchmark).
  - Strengthen coordination between tax and customs with clearly outlined measures and repeated progress updates.
  - Electronic tax reforms to create the basis to implement the 5 percent withholding tax.
- Reducing low-priority spending:
  - Reduce transfers where appropriate; social spending protected and sheltered from budget cuts in 2016.
  - State-owned enterprises, in particular JIRAMA and Air Madagascar, continue to create fiscal challenges and will need additional financial support in 2017.

### Fiscal impact of natural disasters and exceptional spending needs
- Cyclone and drought effects:
  - Drought increased operational cost of JIRAMA, requiring additional transfers (MGA 200 billion).
  - The cyclone (the worst in 13 years) led to significant human costs and economic damage, creating unexpected additional spending needs for relief and reconstruction.
  - Committed US$52 million spending for pressing reconstruction and relief needs (of which MGA 8 billion in transfers and US$14 million re-programmed financing from the World Bank will be budget neutral), increasing capital expenditures by MGA 123 billion (US$36 million) total.
  - Focus sectors: agriculture, education, social protection, health, transportation, and road rehabilitation.
  - Government seeking additional external assistance for these needs and longer-term reconstruction.

### JIRAMA financial situation and reform plan
- Causes of deterioration in JIRAMA’s financial position:
  - Exceptional drought starting in November 2016 cut hydropower generation, increasing reliance on more expensive diesel-based thermal generation.
  - Delays in shifting from diesel-based thermal generation to heavy fuel oil.
  - Unexpectedly high increases in fuel costs linked to rising world prices and disadvantageous supply contracts, which expired in April 2017.
  - Slower improvement in enforcement of customer payments and control of theft.
  - Many disadvantageous contracts remain in place.
- Increased transfer needs:
  - JIRAMA’s needs for transfers to maintain operations rose from MGA 250 billion to MGA 420 billion.
  - An additional MGA 30 billion needed for a necessary reduction in accounts payable from previous years.
- JIRAMA business plan (approved June 12, 2017; prior action) key elements and targets:
  - Detailed financial projections and concrete measures, with monitorable, monthly targets for cost savings and revenue collection to keep projected financial needs within budgeted amounts.
  - Measures providing for periodic price increases in line with the evolution of JIRAMA’s costs and differentiated by type of customer; an increase of 7.5 percent (weighted average) will be applied from July 1, 2017.
  - Measures to pursue electricity theft based on the decree criminalizing the theft of electricity.
  - Steps to improve collection of payments due.
  - Program for installation of smart meters: at least 3,500 smart meters will be installed by end-June 2018 (structural benchmark).
  - Enhanced review and transparency in contracting practices; some contracts already revised.
  - Schedule for transition from diesel to heavy fuel oil at all major facilities when technical conditions allow it.
  - Where legally appropriate, renegotiation or cancellation of disadvantageous, high-cost contracts.
  - Adoption of a model contract to strengthen JIRAMA’s negotiating position, boost transparency, and build public trust.
  - Continued reliance on competitive and open bidding for all contracts in conformity with the existing procurement law, with prior written notification of World Bank and IMF staff of any exceptions allowing for single source procurement contracts for JIRAMA’s purchase of fuel and electricity, and purchase and rental of generators (continuous structural benchmark).
  - Projections for 2018-20 that bring transfer needs down gradually over time, with an objective of no transfers by 2020.
  - Develop a medium-term action plan to develop the electricity sector to provide reliable, low-cost electricity with increasing reliance on renewable energy.
  - Target: providing access to 30 percent of the population by 2030.

### Air Madagascar and supplementary budget financing
- Strategic partnership for Air Madagascar:
  - Entering into a strategic partnership that will put the airline on a sustainable commercial footing and allow it to remain the main domestic carrier.
  - The state is assuming its liabilities related to past losses; this will involve a one-time budget charge up to MGA 303 billion in 2017.
  - Combined with a capital injection from the strategic partner, Air Madagascar will emerge as a financially sound and commercially viable company with no further need for government support.
- Supplementary budget submitted to Parliament on June 9 2017 (prior action) provisions:
  - Revenue measures to increase domestic revenues by MGA 30 billion and customs revenue by MGA 25 billion compared to the budget (LFI).
  - Transfers to JIRAMA increased by MGA 200 billion, of which MGA 30 billion are financed by a corresponding amount of budget cuts (MGA 13 billion in goods and services, MGA 16 billion in domestically-financed capital expenditure (without reducing counterpart funding), and MGA 1 billion in transfers).
  - Following the ECF disbursement, the central bank will on-lend up to $50 million to meet the exceptional needs; terms of the loan will resemble the ECF disbursement and all foreign exchange risks will be carried by the government, as formalized in a memorandum of understanding.
  - Additional cyclone financing to be provided by development partners, most notably the World Bank and the African Development Bank.
  - Following discussions with creditors and potential lenders, financing assurances of about $60 million have been identified to ensure the strategic partnership between Air Madagascar and Air Austral is fully financed and non-concessional external financing will be limited to at most $45 million.

### Enhancing economic governance and anti-corruption measures
- Commitment to strengthen institutions and reduce corruption, including illegal trafficking of natural resources.
- Background:
  - Madagascar’s governance indicators improved up to 2009 but deteriorated during the 2009-13 period.
  - Government adopted a new “National Strategy to Fight Corruption, 2015-2025” to strengthen rule of law, state capacities, sanction corruption, and reduce risks and opportunities for corruption.
  - Government commitment that individuals engaged in corrupt practices will be prosecuted.
- Legal and institutional measures:
  - Two new laws on declaration of assets and formation of judicial anti-corruption centers were adopted in 2016.
  - A new law on asset recovery was submitted to the Parliament on June 13, 2017 to ensure judicial authorities can confiscate instrumentalities and proceeds of crime in line with the FATF standard (prior action).
  - By end-June, submit bills strengthening the anti-corruption legal framework to ensure: (i) domestic politically exposed persons are covered under the anti-money laundering legislation in line with the FATF standard; (ii) asset declarations from officials covered under article 41 of the Constitution and article 2 of the anti-corruption law are comprehensive (covering both assets legally owned and beneficially owned), verifiable, subject to dissuasive sanctions for non-compliance, and made publicly available online progressively; and (iii) SAMIFIN, BIANCO, and the anti-corruption police can effectively participate in international cooperation in line with the FATF and UNCAC standards.
- Judicial independence and anti-corruption centers:
  - Ensure anti-corruption centers (poles anti-corruption) are completely independent and free of influence and confirm their authority to evaluate conduct of all officers of the court (including judges), in line with the Constitution.
  - Launch a case assignment system to eliminate “ownership” of a case by a judge before trial readiness.
  - Publish statistics to monitor timely justice and reduce backlog of cases.
  - Launch process of publishing all court decisions online beginning with anti-corruption centers starting in January 2018.
- Capacity, resources, and transparency:
  - Improve coordination, strengthen capacity building, and allocate adequate budget resources to control organs and anti-corruption agencies.
  - Starting in July 2017, publish statistics on a quarterly basis on corruption cases based on investigations by BIANCO and SAMIFIN (see Tables 2-5 in the technical memorandum of understanding, TMU).
  - Improve recruitment quality and allocate more financial resources to control organs and anti-corruption agencies.
  - 2018 Budget to allocate sufficient financial resources for at least one additional anti-corruption center beyond Antananarivo.
- Public financial management transparency measures:
  - Measures implemented so far include: (i) publication and submission to the Court of Auditors of the 2015 financial statements of ten large state-owned enterprises (end-December 2016 structural benchmark); (ii) approval by Parliament of audit reports on budget execution (loi de reglement) for 2012-14 in 2016; and (iii) Madagascar’s participation in an assessment by Open Budget Survey.
  - Further transparency aims:
    - Submit to Parliament the audit report on budget execution for 2015 during the first session of 2017.
    - Expand the variety of budget documents published.
    - Make timely on-line publishing of all budget documents.
    - Make budget documents more comprehensive by including information about state-owned enterprises, autonomous public establishments, and PPPs.
    - Revise and submit to Parliament the law governing the National Public Establishments (Etablissements publics nationaux, EPN) by end-June 2018 (structural benchmark) to enhance transparency and accountability, with the goal of issuing the application decrees before the end of 2018.

*Republic of Madagascar — IMF staff report excerpt*

### 33.      After adopting a PFM strategy for 2017-2026 in December, we now plan to develop

### 33.      After adopting a PFM strategy for 2017-2026 in December, we now plan to develop

### Public Financial Management (PFM) action plan
- Develop and implement a three-year action plan for priority PFM reforms following consultations with civil society, development partners, and the IMF.
- Recent improvements: prioritization of public expenditure, enhanced transparency, advancement of multi-year budgeting, strengthened public procurement.
- Action plan to be adopted by end-June 2017 by the steering committee of the SNMGFP2 20 and will give priority to:
  - (i) preventing and managing existing domestic arrears;
  - (ii) settling cross-debts between the state and the private sector;
  - (iii) strengthening medium-term budgeting;
  - (iv) managing budgetary risks, in particular risks associated with PPPs and state-owned enterprises.
- The PFM action plan will integrate related action plans when possible, including actions to enhance public investment management in both the near-term priority action plan and the medium-term strategy once completed.

### Monetary policy framework and central bank reforms
- Near-term: develop a priority action plan by end-June 2017 to enhance the effectiveness of monetary policy, especially transmission mechanisms.
- Long-term: move gradually from monetary targeting to an interest rate-based framework once on-demand overnight deposit facilities and an interest-rate corridor are established.
- Long-term goal: a transparent, forward-looking policy strategy linking policy objectives to actions through a consistent, transparent, predictable, and market-based operating framework.
- Enactment of the new Central Bank Act (CBA) on November 7, 2016:
  - Major step for governance, accountability, and operational and policy-related central bank independence.
  - Legal limits on the BFM’s lending to Government significantly advance independence.
- Implementation priorities:
  - Fully implement the BFM law (including capital levels) to ensure independence and resources.
  - Upgrade audit function (external and internal); extend procedures for competitive tenders for purchases of currency with deference to sensitivity.
  - Anticipated shift to IFRS accounting by 2019; prepare an action plan for IFRS implementation by September 2017.
  - Publish pro-forma IFRS accounts as annex to annual financial statements in the run-up to adoption of IFRS.
  - Continue improving forecasting capacity and understanding of the monetary transmission mechanism.

### Financial markets and monetary policy transmission (specific market actions)
- Interbank market:
  - Market is shallow with low activity; aim to equate the interbank rate with the policy rate via liquidity operations.
  - Implement risk-based banking supervision in the medium-term (¶40).
  - Develop a functioning market for repurchase agreements (repos) in the shorter term.
  - Submit to Parliament draft legislation to promote repo transactions by end-December 2018 (structural benchmark).
- Government securities markets:
  - Encourage nonbank participation in the primary market.
  - Reach agreement on a securities market development strategy by end-2017 in consultation with the banking sector and other actors.
- Foreign exchange market:
  - Aim for more efficient, liquid, and transparent functioning.
  - First flash foreign exchange auction held in December (with IMF TA); aim to make such auctions primary modality of intervention and move towards a rules-based intervention strategy.
  - Increase transparency of market operations: better monitoring of foreign exchange positions and transactions, improve comprehensiveness of commercial banks reporting, facilitate availability of relevant regulations.
  - Work towards introduction of foreign exchange forward contracts and swap arrangements with IMF TA, beginning with development of an action plan by end-December 2017 for introduction of swap arrangements.

### Central bank operational framework reforms
- Develop an action plan to:
  - Initiate an overnight deposit facility available to banks on demand, with an interest rate indexed to, but lower than, the policy rate.
    - Combined with an overnight repo facility (indexed to but higher than the policy rate) to create an interest rate corridor around the policy rate.
    - Study the possibility of incorporating seasonality in reserve requirements due to high seasonal liquidity variations.
  - Introduce a shorter-term deposit auction facility and a repo facility (both of less than 7-day tenor) to absorb and inject liquidity over periods shorter than the current 7 days.

### Financial inclusion and banking sector competition
- Access to banking system in Madagascar:
  - Currently less than 10 percent overall access rate.
  - About half that rate in rural areas.
- Mobile money:
  - 10 percent of the adult population participating.
  - Madagascar is one of only two countries in Sub-Saharan Africa where all mobile money networks are fully interconnected.
  - Electronic Money law passed in February 2017 to provide legal framework for operations and prudential supervision.
  - Issue implementing decrees and regulations for this law by end-December 2017 with World Bank TA (structural benchmark).
- Banking sector measures:
  - Submit to parliament legal framework for establishment of a private credit bureau by December 2017, tender for proposals in 2018, establish a functioning bureau by 2019.
  - Establish a collateral registry to reduce banks’ credit risk and promote financial intermediation.
  - Aim to increase competition while improving loan portfolio quality.

### Foreign exchange operational modalities and communication
- Change to avoid potential multiple currency practice (MCP):
  - Amended service level agreement for urgent client transactions:
    - Transactions before opening of the FX market executed at previous day’s reference rate.
    - Transactions after opening executed at ongoing market exchange rate at that time.
    - Any penalty imposed on urgent client transactions will not exceed 2 percent.
- Strategic communication:
  - BFM committed to implementing a strategic communication plan since beginning of 2015 to ensure credibility.
  - Implemented procedures to reinforce communication unit staff and technical capacity.
  - Regular quarterly meetings with banks to discuss liquidity and BFM intervention held.
  - Action plans to strengthen communication with priority audiences (banks, media, staff) to be implemented by the end of 2017.
- Private sector surveys:
  - Quarterly business surveys started in April 2017 with IMF TA support to gauge growth and employment intentions, wage pressure experience, and inflationary expectations.

### Financial sector supervision and regulation
- Strengthen Banking Law with submission to parliament in October 2018.
  - Seek technical assistance.
  - Improve bank recovery and resolution framework, expand corrective measures, develop robust prompt corrective action framework.
- Extend supervisory discipline to non-bank financial institutions:
  - Complete audits of Caisse d’Epargne de Madagascar (CEM) and the postal service by end-July 2017 and implement near-term recommendations by end-December 2017.
- Build supervisory capacity and improve compliance with Basel Core Principles.
  - Full implementation of a system of risk-based supervision by end 2019 with IMF TA.
  - Issue new prudential regulations and strengthen existing ones by December 2018.
  - Establish an action plan for effective implementation of risk-based supervision by end 2017.

### Statistics and data improvements
- Government commitments:
  - Strengthen legal framework for statistics and submit a new statistics law to Parliament by end-December 2017 (structural benchmark).
  - Increase human, financial, and material resources for statistics production.
  - Improve coordination among producers of statistics and make a coordination committee operational by end-June 2018.
- Sectoral actions:
  - National accounts: Publish revised annual national accounts series based on the 1993 SNA covering 2007-14 (base year updated to 2007 from 1984) by end-June 2017 (structural benchmark). Quarterly GDP estimates by production to follow later in the year.
  - Price statistics: Reweighted CPI based on the 2012 national household survey with 2017 as the base year; after a test period the new CPI would become official starting January 2018.
  - Monetary and financial statistics: Start consolidating balance sheets of micro-financial institutions in preparation of the monetary survey by end-September 2018.
  - Government finance statistics: Extend coverage from central government only to the general public sector including local authorities and National Public Establishments (EPN) over the long term.

### Program monitoring and timetable highlights
- Program evaluated on quantitative performance criteria and structural benchmarks and semi-annual reviews; definitions and reporting set out in the TMU.
- Review schedule:
  - Second, third, and fourth reviews scheduled on or after November 20, 2017; May 20, 2018; and November 20, 2018 respectively.
  - Test dates for periodic performance criteria: end-June 2017, end-December 2017, end-June 2018.
- Selected structural benchmarks and deadlines (extracted):
  - Adopt a business plan for JIRAMA: Completed on June 12, 2017.
  - Submit draft law on asset recovery to parliament: Completed on June 13, 2017.
  - Submit draft supplementary budget law to parliament: Completed on June 9, 2017.
  - Adopt medium-term strategy to enhance public investment management capacity: End-Dec. 2017.
  - Submit new law on social protection to parliament: End-Dec. 2017.
  - Publish report summarizing tax credits cancelled by end-June 2017.
  - Employ the new Tax Identification Number (TIN) across Ministry departments and CNAPS: End-Dec. 2017.
  - Establish a Tax Policy Unit at the Ministry of Finance and Budget: End-Sept. 2017.
  - Extend performance contracts to anti-fraud service at customs: End-Sept. 2017.
  - Install 3,500 smart meters for JIRAMA: End-June 2018.
  - Publish terms and conditions of all PPP contracts within one month of signature: Continuous benchmark.
  - Notify World Bank and IMF in advance of any single source procurement for JIRAMA: Continuous benchmark.
  - Revise and submit law governing EPNs to Parliament: End-June 2018.
  - Issue implementing decrees and regulations for electronic money law: End-Dec. 2017.
  - Submit draft legislation to promote repo transactions: End-Dec. 2018.
  - Submit new statistics law to Parliament: End-Dec. 2017.

*Source: cr17223 - 33. After adopting a PFM strategy for 2017-2026 in December, we now plan to develop*

### 1.      This technical memorandum of understanding (TMU) contains definitions and adjuster

### Technical memorandum of understanding (TMU): definitions and adjuster mechanisms

### I. Definitions
- External and domestic are defined on a residency basis.
- Government comprises the scope of operations of the treasury shown in the opérations globales du Trésor (OGT). The government does not include operations of state-owned enterprises and sub-national authorities.
- Program exchange rates:
  - Malagasy Ariary (MGA)/SDR 4,443.86
  - U.S. Dollar/SDR 1.389049
  - Euro/SDR 1.270538
  - Australian dollar/SDR 1.903723
  - Canadian dollar/SDR 1.926401
  - Japanese Yen/SDR 167.377024
  - Swiss Franc 1.375855
  - U.K. Pound Sterling/SDR 0.937470
- Foreign currency accounts denominated in currencies other than the SDR will first be valued in SDRs and then converted to MGA. Amounts in other currencies than those reported above and monetary gold will first be valued in SDRs at the exchange rates and gold prices that prevailed on December 31, 2015, and then converted to MGA.
- Performance criteria refer to: net foreign assets and net domestic assets of the central bank, external payments arrears, non-concessional external debt owed or guaranteed by the central government and/or the central bank, and the primary balance excluding foreign financed investment (commitment basis).
- Timing: Performance criteria set for end-June and end-December 2017 and end-June 2018; indicative targets set for end-September 2017 and end-March 2018.
- Prior notification requirement: World Bank and IMF staff must receive written communication at least 3 working days before signing any single-source procurement contracts for JIRAMA’s purchases of fuel and electricity and purchases and rentals of generators; addendums and extensions are also subject to prior notification.

### II. Provision of data to the Fund
- Monthly data provision:
  - Data on net foreign assets (NFA) and net domestic assets (NDA) of the Central Bank of Madagascar (CBM): monthly with a lag of no more than four weeks.
  - Other data: monthly with a lag of no more than six weeks.
  - Authorities will promptly transmit any data revisions to the Fund.
- Publication requirements:
  - SAMIFIN to publish quarterly data (no later than the end of the month following the quarter) on reports sent to BIANCO relating to suspicions of laundering of the proceeds of corruption (Table 2).
  - BIANCO to publish quarterly data (no later than the end of the month following the quarter) on the number of persons indicted, the number of persons convicted by a first instance court decision, and the number of persons convicted pursuant to a final court decision (Tables 3-5).
- For variables not specifically defined in the memorandum, authorities will consult with Fund staff on measurement and reporting.

### III. Quantitative performance criteria

A. Fiscal aggregates
- Floor on primary balance excluding foreign financed investment (commitment basis):
  - Measurement: total domestic revenue less spending excluding interest payments and foreign financed investment.
  - Total domestic revenues include tax and non-tax revenues plus current (budgetary) grants.
  - Tax revenues measured on a net basis (net of refund of VAT credits).
  - Spending includes wages and salaries, goods and services, transfers and subsidies, treasury operations (net) excluding refund of VAT credits, and domestically financed capital expenditure.
  - In 2017, spending excludes government financial assistance to Air Madagascar of up to MGA 330 billion as a result of direct transfers or guarantees to service Air Madagascar’s existing liabilities, including arrears to suppliers but excluding tax arrears, provided such assistance is specified in a strategic partnership agreement between Air Madagascar and another airline.
  - The primary balance excluding foreign financed investment (commitment basis) will be calculated cumulatively from the beginning of the calendar year.
- Reference for year ending December 2015 (domestic primary current balance, commitment basis): MGA -377 billion, calculated as follows:
  - Primary balance excluding foreign financed investment (commitment basis): -377
  - Total revenue and current grants: 2,999
  - Total revenue: 2,959
  - Net tax revenue: 2,878
  - Non-tax revenue: 81
  - Current grants: 40
  - Less: Current expenditures: 3,101
    - Wages and salaries: 1,566
    - Goods and services: 157
    - Transfers and subsidies: 966
    - Treasury operations (net): 412
    - Domestic financed capital expenditures: 275
- Note: Projections for domestic taxes and other treasury operations (net) in 2016 include an amount of MGA 90 billion corresponding to tax arrears of Air Madagascar used for its recapitalization.

B. External debt
- Ceiling on accumulation of new external payment arrears:
  - Arrears consist of overdue debt-service obligations (payments of principal and interest) related to loans contracted or guaranteed by the government or CBM.
  - Debt service obligations considered overdue if not paid 30 days after the due date or after the end of a grace period agreed with, or unilaterally granted by, each creditor before the due date.
  - Excludes arrears where creditor has accepted in writing to negotiate alternative payment schedules, and excludes debt service payments delayed for reasons beyond the control of Malagasy authorities.
  - Monitoring target observed continuously from end-May 2016.
- Ceilings on new non-concessional external debt:
  - Concessional debt for program monitoring: grant element of at least 35 percent.
    - Grant element = (nominal value - NPV) / nominal value.
    - NPV calculated by discounting future debt-service payments using a discount rate of 5 percent.
  - Semi-concessional: grant element of at least 20 percent.
  - For agreements with multiple disbursements and interest linked to a reference rate since signature, the interest rate at signature applies for grant element calculation for all disbursements.
  - Definition of debt per point 9 of the Guidelines on Performance Criteria with Respect to External Debt (Executive Board Decision No. 6230-(79/140), as amended).
  - For variable-rate loans in the form of benchmark rate plus fixed spread:
    - PV calculated using program reference rate plus fixed spread (in basis points) specified in the contract.
    - Program reference rate for six-month USD LIBOR: 3.37 percent (fixed for duration of program).
    - Spreads over six-month USD LIBOR:
      - Six-month Euro LIBOR: -249 basis points
      - Six-month JPY LIBOR: -286 basis points
      - Six-month GBP LIBOR: -108 basis points
      - For currencies other than Euro, JPY, and GBP, spread over six-month USD LIBOR is -209 basis points
    - Where benchmark other than six-month USD LIBOR is used, a spread reflecting difference between benchmark rate and six-month USD LIBOR (rounded to nearest 50 bps) will be added.
  - Medium- and long-term external debt:
    - Two continuous ceilings on new non-concessional external debt with original maturities of more than one year contracted or guaranteed by government or CBM:
      - First ceiling: new non-concessional external debt with grant element of less than 35 percent.
      - Second ceiling: new non-concessional external debt with grant element of less than 20 percent.
    - Ceilings apply to debt and commitments contracted or guaranteed for which value has not yet been received and to private debt backed by official guarantees.
    - Monitoring targets observed continuously from January 1, 2016.
    - Exclusions from ceilings:
      - (i) Use of IMF resources;
      - (ii) Concessional debts;
      - (iii) Debts incurred to restructure, refinance, or prepay existing debts, to the extent incurred on more favorable terms than existing debt and up to the amount of the restructured/refinanced/prepaid debt (applies to liabilities of Air Madagascar assumed by government in context of strategic partnership agreement);
      - (iv) Debts classified as international reserve liabilities of CBM.
    - If government has special need for external non-concessional financing, discussions with IMF staff should take place in advance.
  - Short-term external debt:
    - Continuous ceiling on new non-concessional external debt with original maturities up to and including one year contracted or guaranteed by government or CBM.
    - Ceiling applies to debt and commitments contracted or guaranteed for which value has not yet been received and to private debt backed by official guarantees.
    - Monitoring target observed continuously from end-May 2016.
    - Exclusions:
      - (i) Concessional debts;
      - (ii) Debts incurred to restructure, refinance, or prepay existing debts on more favorable terms and up to the restructured/refinanced/prepaid amount (applies to Air Madagascar liabilities assumed by government);
      - (iii) Debts classified as international reserve liabilities of CBM;
      - (v) Normal import financing (self-liquidating credits).

C. Monetary aggregates
- Floor on Net Foreign Assets (NFA) of CBM:
  - Evaluated using end-period stock calculated using program exchange rates.
  - NFA = CBM’s gross foreign assets minus total foreign liabilities, including debt owed to the IMF.
  - All foreign assets and liabilities converted to SDRs at program exchange rates and then valued in MGA as described in paragraph 4.
  - Reference at end-December 2015 (MGA, presumably billions unless otherwise specified):
    - Foreign Assets: 2,665.623
      - Cash: 0.040
      - Demand deposits: 366.972
      - Term deposits and securities: 2,032.812
      - Other foreign assets (including SDR holdings): 265.798
    - Foreign Liabilities: 902.863
      - Non-residents deposits: 0.761
      - Deposits of international organizations: 0.278
      - Use of Fund credit and loans: 381.495
      - Medium-and long-term foreign liabilities (including SDR allocation): 520.329
    - Net Foreign Assets: 1,762.760
- Ceiling on Net Domestic Assets (NDA) of CBM:
  - Evaluated using end-period stock at program exchange rates.
  - NDA = reserve money minus NFA of CBM (valued in MGA using program exchange rates).
  - Includes net credit to government, credit to economy, claims on banks, liabilities to banks (including proceeds of CBM deposit auctions—appels d’offres négatifs, open market operations), and other items (net).
  - Reference at end-December 2015:
    - Net Foreign Assets: 1,762.760
    - Base Money: 3,066.683
      - Currency in circulation: 2,115.441
      - Currency in banks: 188.180
      - Bankers’ reserves: 762.484
      - Other deposits included in monetary base: 0.578
    - Net Domestic Assets: 1,303.923
      - Net credit to the central government: 1,049.296
      - Credit to the economy: 5.865
      - Net credit to banks: -110.000
      - Other items (net): 358.762

### IV. Indicative targets
- Floor on priority social spending:
  - Includes domestic spending primarily related to interventions in nutrition, education, health, and the provision of social safety nets.
  - Calculated cumulatively from the beginning of the calendar year.
  - Set as the sum of budget allocations in the Loi de Finance to the Ministries of Health, Education, Population and Water, excluding salaries and externally financed investment.
- Floor on gross tax revenue:
  - Government tax revenue measured on a gross basis (before refund of VAT credits).
  - Comprises all domestic taxes and taxes on foreign trade received by the central government treasury.
  - Excludes:
    - (1) receipts from local sale of in-kind grants;
    - (2) gross inflows on account of signature bonus receipts from auction of hydrocarbon and mining exploration rights;
    - (3) tax arrears recorded in regularization operations (e.g., recapitalization of Air Madagascar in 2016).
  - Revenue measured on a cash basis as reported in the table of government financial operations prepared by the Directorate of Budget and the Directorate of Treasury.
  - Calculated cumulatively from the beginning of the calendar year.
  - Reference for year ending December 2015:
    - Gross government tax revenue: MGA 3,012 billion
      - Net tax revenue: MGA 2,878 billion
      - VAT refunds: MGA 134 billion

### V. Memorandum items
- Official external program support:
  - Defined as grants and loans, including in-kind aid when products are sold by government and receipts earmarked for a budgeted spending item, and other exceptional financing provided by foreign official entities and the private sector and incorporated into the budget.
  - Does not include grants and loans earmarked to investment projects.
  - Calculated as a cumulative flow from January 1, 2016.
- Official external program grants:
  - Defined as grants, including in-kind aid when products are sold by government and receipts earmarked for a budgeted spending item, and other exceptional financing provided by foreign official entities and incorporated into the budget.
  - Does not include grants earmarked to investment projects.
  - Calculated as a cumulative flow from the beginning of the calendar year.
- New concessional external debt contracted or guaranteed with original maturity of more than one year by the central government or the CBM: debt with a grant element of at least 35 percent.

### VI. Use of adjusters
- Adjustments apply to performance criteria on NFA and NDA of CBM in line with cumulative deviations from projected official external program support (from January 1, 2016).
- Adjuster rules:
  - The floor on NFA will be adjusted downward (upward) by the cumulative deviation downward (upward) of actual from projected budget support (official external program support).
    - This adjustment capped at equivalent of SDR75 million, evaluated at program exchange rates as described in paragraph 4.
  - The ceiling on NDA will be adjusted upward (downward) by the cumulative deviation downward (upward) of actual from projected budget support (official external program support).
    - This adjustment capped at equivalent of SDR75 million, evaluated at program exchange rates as described in paragraph 4.

*REPUBLIC OF MADAGASCAR — INTERNATIONAL MONETARY FUND (Technical Memorandum of Understanding).*

### 26.      The performance criteria on the primary balance excluding foreign financed investment

### 26. The performance criteria on the primary balance excluding foreign financed investment

### Adjustment mechanism for the performance criterion
- The performance criteria on the primary balance excluding foreign financed investment (commitment basis) will be adjusted in line with deviations from amounts projected in the program for official external program grants.
- These deviations will be calculated cumulatively from the beginning of each calendar year.
- Explanation of the adjustment:
  - The floor on the primary balance excluding foreign financed investment (commitment basis) will be adjusted downward by the cumulative downward deviation of actual from projected official external program grants, calculated at quarterly period-average actual exchange rates.
  - This adjustment will be capped at the equivalent of SDR30 million, evaluated at program exchange rates as described in paragraph 4.

### Data reporting requirements (selected items and periodicities)
- Exchange rate data — Central Bank of Madagascar (CBM)
  - Total daily CBM gross purchases of foreign exchange – break down by currency purchased: Daily, next working day
  - The weighted average exchange rate of CBM gross purchases, the highest traded exchange rate, and the lowest traded exchange rate – break down by currency purchased: Daily, next working day
  - Total daily CBM gross sales of foreign exchange – break down by currency purchased: Daily, next working day
  - The weighted average exchange rate of CBM gross sales, the highest traded exchange rate, and the lowest traded exchange rate – break down by currency purchased: Daily, next working day
  - Total CBM net purchases/sales of foreign exchange - break down by currency purchased: Daily, next working day
  - Total interbank foreign exchange transactions (net of CBM transactions) - break down by currency purchased: Daily, next working day
  - Total interbank and retail foreign exchange transactions (net of CBM transactions) - break down by currency purchased: Daily, next working day
- Monetary, interest rate, and financial data — Central Bank of Madagascar (CBM)
  - Foreign exchange cash flow, including foreign debt operations: Monthly
  - Stock of gross international reserves (GIR) and net foreign assets (NFA), both at program and market exchange rates: Monthly
  - Detailed data on the composition of gross international reserves (GIR), including currency composition: Monthly
  - Market results of Treasury bill auctions, including the bid level, bids accepted or rejected, and interest rates: Monthly
  - Stock of outstanding Treasury bills: Monthly
  - Data on the secondary market for Treasury bills and other government securities: Monthly
  - Bank-by-bank data on excess/shortfall of required reserves: Monthly
  - Money market operations and rates: Monthly
  - Bank lending by economic sector and term: Monthly
  - Balance sheet of CBM: Monthly, within two weeks of the end of each month
  - Balance sheet (aggregate) of deposit money banks: Monthly, within six weeks of the end of each month
  - Monetary survey: Monthly, within six weeks of the end of each month
  - Financial soundness indicators of deposit money banks: Quarterly, within eight weeks of the end of the quarter
- Fiscal data — Ministry of Finance and Budget (MFB)
  - Preliminary revenue collections (customs and internal revenue): Monthly, within three weeks of the end of each month
  - Treasury operations (OGT): Monthly, within eight weeks of the end of each month
  - Stock of domestic arrears, including arrears on expenditure and VAT refunds: Monthly, within eight weeks of the end of each month
  - Priority social spending as defined by the indicative target: Monthly, within eight weeks of the end of each month
  - Subsidies to JIRAMA’s suppliers: Monthly, within eight weeks of the end of each month
- State-owned enterprise data
  - Data summarizing the financial position of JIRAMA and Air Madagascar: Quarterly, by the end of the subsequent quarter
- Debt data — Ministry of Finance and Budget (MFB)
  - Public and publicly-guaranteed debt stock at end of month, including: (i) by creditor (official, commercial domestic, commercial external); (ii) by instrument (Treasury bills, other domestic loans, external official loans, external commercial loans, guarantees); and (iii) in case of new guarantees, the name of the guaranteed individual/institution: Monthly, within four weeks of the end of each month
- External data — Central Bank of Madagascar (CBM)
  - Balance of payments: Quarterly, by the end of the subsequent quarter
- Real sector and price data — INSTAT
  - Consumer price index data (provided by INSTAT): Monthly, within four weeks of the end of each month
  - Details on tourism: Monthly, within twelve weeks of the end of each month
  - Electricity and water production and consumption: Monthly, within twelve weeks of the end of each month
- Other data — OCH
  - Petroleum shipments and consumption: Monthly, within four weeks of the end of each month

### Reporting templates and criminal justice tables (excerpted items)
- Tables included in the source document outline reporting templates and counts for:
  - Reports sent by SAMIFIN to BIANCO (fields include Members of the Supreme Powers, Magistrates, Heads of province and district, Directors of Ministry or equivalent, SOE Managers, Others; Number of reports disseminated; Aggregated value of suspected money laundering)
  - Number of Persons Indicted by Penal Code Article across categories (President, Members of parliament, High Constitutional Court Magistrates, Magistrates, Heads of province and district, Directors of Ministry or equivalent, SOE Managers, Others)
  - Number of Persons Convicted—First Instance and Number of Persons Convicted—Final Decision, with columns for Fine and Jail across the same categories
- For fines, total value is reported in ariary. For jail, total months (and suspended jail) are reported.

### Annex I: Guidelines on Performance Criteria with Respect to External Debt (excerpt)
- Definition of “debt” (paragraph 1(a)):
  - Debt is a current (not contingent) liability, created under a contractual arrangement through the provision of value in the form of assets (including currency) or services, requiring the obligor to make one or more payments in the form of assets (including currency) or services at some future point(s) in time.
  - Primary forms of debt identified:
    - i) loans, including deposits, bonds, debentures, commercial loans and buyers’ credits, temporary exchanges of assets equivalent to fully collateralized loans (repurchase agreements and official swap arrangements);
    - ii) suppliers’ credits, where the supplier permits the obligor to defer payments until after goods are delivered or services provided;
    - iii) leases, where debt is the present value (at the inception of the lease) of all lease payments expected to be made during the period of the agreement excluding payments that cover operation, repair, or maintenance of the property.
- Paragraph 1(b): Arrears, penalties, and judicially awarded damages arising from the failure to make payment under a contractual obligation that constitutes debt are debt. Failure to make payment on an obligation that is not considered debt under this definition (e.g., payment on delivery) will not give rise to debt.

### Fund relations and financials (selected figures as of May 31, 2017)
- Membership Status: Joined: September 25, 1963; Article VIII
- General Resources Account:
  - Quota: 244.40 SDR Million (100.00 percent of quota)
  - Fund Holdings of currency: 213.78 SDR Million (87.47 percent)
  - Reserve Tranche Position: 30.62 SDR Million (12.53 percent)
- SDR Department:
  - Net cumulative allocation: 117.09 SDR Million (100.00 percent)
  - Holdings: 13.21 SDR Million (11.28 percent)
- Outstanding Purchases and Loans:
  - RCF Loans: 61.10 SDR Million (25.00 percent of quota)
  - ECF Arrangements: 41.05 SDR Million (16.80 percent of quota)
- Latest Financial Arrangements:
  - ECF (Jul 27, 2016 – Nov 26, 2019): Amount Approved 220.00 SDR Million; Amount Drawn 31.43 SDR Million
  - ECF (Jul 21, 2006 – Jul 20, 2009): Amount Approved 73.32 SDR Million; Amount Drawn 53.03 SDR Million
  - ECF (Mar 01, 2001 – Mar 01, 2005): Amount Approved 91.65 SDR Million; Amount Drawn 91.65 SDR Million
- Projected Payments to Fund (SDR Million; based on existing use of resources and present holdings of SDRs):
  - Forthcoming Principal: 2017: 3.73; 2018: 5.89; 2019: 3.06; 2020: 6.11; 2021: 12.22
  - Charges/Interest: 2017: 0.28; 2018: 0.57; 2019: 0.57; 2020: 0.58; 2021: 0.57
  - Total: 2017: 4.02; 2018: 6.47; 2019: 3.63; 2020: 6.69; 2021: 12.79
- HIPC and MDRI implementation (selected figures):
  - Assistance committed by all creditors (US$ Million) under HIPC Enhanced Framework: 835.75
  - IMF assistance (US$ million) and SDR equivalent: 19.17 (SDR 14.73)
  - Completion point date: Oct 2004
  - Disbursement of IMF assistance (SDR Million): Assistance disbursed to the member: 14.73; Interim assistance: 5.62; Completion point balance: 9.11; Additional disbursement of interest income: 1.69; Total disbursements: 16.42
  - MDRI – eligible debt (SDR Million): 137.29; Financed by MDRI Trust: 128.50; Remaining HIPC resources: 8.79
  - Debt Relief by Facility (SDR Million): Eligible Debt Delivery Date January 2006; GRA: N/A; PRGF: 137.29; Total: 137.29

### Safeguards, exchange rate, and technical assistance (selected points)
- Safeguards Assessments:
  - An updated safeguards assessment of the Banque Centrale de Madagascar (BCM) was completed in March 2017.
  - The assessment found progress on recommendations from the 2015 assessment (strengthening legal framework; establishing an audit committee) but noted delays in publication of audited financial statements, an outdated accounting framework, elevated risks in currency operations and reserves management, and capacity constraints despite technical assistance on internal audit and financial reporting.
- Exchange Rate Arrangement:
  - Currency: Malagasy ariary.
  - De jure exchange rate arrangement: floating. De facto classification: floating.
  - The exchange rate followed a pre-determined path until September 2015, and has been free-floating since.
  - The official exchange rate depreciated by about 10 percent against the US Dollar in September 2015 when official and market rates converged after buyback operations were discontinued.
- Technical Assistance (selected FAD and MCM activities and years):
  - Fiscal Affairs Department (FAD) missions and outputs in 2014–2017 include: Diagnostic Mission: Improving Tax and Customs Revenue Collection 2014; PFM Reform Strategy 2014; Medium-Term Fiscal Framework (MTFF) 2014; Energy Subsidy Reform 2014; Tax Policy Review 2014; MTFF and Natural Resources Management 2014; Tax Administration: Review of the legal framework for taxation of mining and petroleum operations 2015; Revenue Mobilization: Transfer pricing 2015; Budget Formulation: Strengthening medium-term macro fiscal and budget frameworks 2015; Customs Administration: Risk management and post clearance audit 2015; and multiple missions in 2016–2017 on public investment management, medium-term budgeting, revenue and customs administration, and data matching.
  - Monetary and Capital Markets Department (MCM): Technical Assistance Needs Assessment Diagnostic 2014

*Source: cr17223 - 26. The performance criteria on the primary balance excluding foreign financed investment (commitment basis), Madagascar staff report excerpts (June 14, 2017).*

### Introduction of IFRS in Central Bank Accounting 2015

### Introduction of IFRS in Central Bank Accounting 2015

### Technical assistance and capacity building (central bank, 2015–2017)
- 2015 activities listed:
  - Introduction of IFRS in Central Bank Accounting 2015
  - Strengthening Internal Audit and Controls 2015
  - Transitioning to a Modern Monetary Policy Operational Framework 2015
  - Set Objectives for Monetary Policy (AFS) 2015
  - Coherent Approach to Monetary Policy Formulation (AFS) 2015
  - Liquidity Management and Forecasting (AFS) 2015
  - Functioning of the Interbank Foreign Exchange Market (AFS) 2015
  - Strengthening Internal Audit 2015
  - Inflation Analysis and Forecasting (AFS) 2015
- 2016 activities listed:
  - Central Bank Accounting and Auditing 2016
  - Foreign Exchange Operations (AFS) 2016
  - Monetary Policy Communication (AFS) 2016
  - Inflation Analysis and Forecasting 2016
  - Risk Based Supervision 2016
- 2017 activities listed:
  - Liquidity Management and Implementation of Repo Agreements 2017
  - Internal Audit and Risk Management 2017
  - Regulation and Functioning of the Interbank Foreign Exchange Market (AFS) 2017
- Institutional contributors noted:
  - Legal Department (LEG) and Monetary and Capital Markets Department (MCM)
  - Statistics Department (STA): National Accounts (AFS) 2015; Balance of Payments Statistics 2015; Multisector Statistics 2015; Monetary and Financial Statistics 2015; National Accounts (AFS) 2015; Price Statistics (AFS) 2016; National Accounts (AFS) 2016; Open Data Initiative 2016; Government Finance Statistics 2016; Monetary and Financial Statistics 2016; National Accounts (AFS) 2017; Balance of Payments Statistics 2017; Price Statistics (AFS) 2017

### Resident representation
- Resident Representative:
  - Mr. Patrick Imam has been the Resident Representative since September 2014.

### Relations with the World Bank Group — assessment and macro-critical reform priorities (as of May, 2017)
- Joint assessment conclusion:
  - Madagascar’s main economic challenge is to create the foundation for a sustained economic recovery and poverty reduction.
- Priority policy needs identified (verbatim text preserved):
  - (i) broaden the tax base and implement tax and customs administration reforms;
  - (ii) improve the allocation and use of public resources to raise the economy’s productivity, improve service delivery, and help meet acute social needs of vulnerable groups through reduced subsidies and transfers to public enterprises and civil service reforms, including pension reform;
  - (iii) strengthen public financial management, including: reporting, monitoring and control systems;
  - (iv) advance other policies that support economic growth and improve the business climate, including actions that strengthen governance and create a level playing field for the private sector;
  - (v) proceed with reforms that improve central bank operations and strengthen financial sector stability; and
  - (vi) promote financial access and financial inclusion.
- Macro-critical structural reform areas identified:
  - Tax and customs administration: Tax revenues are at historically low levels because of the large informal economy, corruption, and weak administration. Corruption is also widespread in customs with many discretionary and non-transparent customs duty exemptions.
  - Public financial management (PFM) including control of public enterprises: Actual budget allocations deviate significantly from the original budget. Budget execution and cash management are too weak to adjust for changes in available resources during the course of the year. Government transfers to cover losses in public enterprises are crowding out higher-priority public spending.
  - Public expenditure efficiency: The high share of non-discretionary spending induces significant rigidities in the budget. Going forward, it will be important to rebalance spending in favor of social priorities through revenue growth and reforms that reduce the need for transfers to public enterprises and the pension system.
  - Public investment and debt management: A priority against the background of planned scaling up of public investment and new financing from public-private partnerships (PPPs), especially the need to enhance public investment capacity and donor coordination. Implementation of the priority investment plan must be phased in such a way that debt is maintained at sustainable levels.
  - Economic governance and corruption: Governance weakened and corruption increased after the unconstitutional change of government in 2009. People perceive payment of bribes to be a frequent feature in interactions with the government and political parties have become a tool to maintain influential individuals in power through the distribution of favors. The justice system is perceived to be partial with an unfair enforcement of laws and Madagascar is seen as having one of the least independent judicial systems in Sub-Saharan Africa.
  - Business environment: In addition to improved governance, reforms creating a level playing field and reducing excessive bureaucratic procedures would be critical to improve the business climate. In this context it is also essential to modernize the mining and petroleum codes to bring them in line with good international practice.
  - Service delivery and social safety nets: Public spending on health and education is lagging other Sub-Saharan African countries and the gap is growing. Access and use of basic healthcare is not universal, decreasing, and increasingly rationed by money. It will be important to scale up and target fiscal spending in favor of the most vulnerable, through demand side interventions such as cash transfer to households conditional on children attending school, and supply side interventions such as rehabilitation of basic health centers, increased provision of basic vaccines, and repairing and building school buildings.
  - Central bank operations: The transmission of monetary policy impulses is limited in effectiveness due largely to an insufficiently developed financial system. The government securities market is segmented and exclusively short term with little activity in the interbank money market and the market for secondary Treasury Bill trading. While there is significant excess liquidity in the money market, the seasonal fluctuations are strong with effectively all excess liquidity held by two or three of the dominant banks.
  - Financial sector stability: Financial regulation and supervision is inadequate with significant regulatory gaps and scarce resources. Banking supervision performs poorly when assessed against the Basel Core Principles. The supervisory authorities lack a framework for early and effective intervention and many non-bank financial institutions are not supervised by any authority.
  - Financial access and inclusion: Micro-financial institutions (MFIs) are still small but growing rapidly. New measures, including stronger supervision, are needed to strengthen consumer protection and financial education.
  - The statistical system: Key statistics are provided by the National Institute of Statistics (NIS) and other government agencies. The central bank, ministries, and NIS regularly undertake standard economic and social surveys with donor financing. Quality and timely reporting remains an issue of concern. The last population census was held in 1993 and the national accounts are currently based on the 1968 system of national accounts. The quality of sector statistics must be improved, including through better coordination. While data production has increased in recent years, data access remains challenging.

### Division of labor between the Fund and the World Bank (agreed responsibilities)
- Tax and customs administration: Shared responsibility. TA to refocus resources, remove regulatory obstacles, streamline management, prioritize revenue-generating measures; customs to move toward post-clearance audits, upgrade risk management, review import/export control procedures, and implement targeted actions against fraud.
- PFM including control of public enterprises: Shared responsibility. Fund TA: develop medium-term fiscal objectives, improve budget execution and public investment management, develop new internal control procedures to avoid arrears. Bank assistance examples: public sector project (revenue management and local service delivery), energy sector project (support for JIRAMA operational performance and fuel supply system rehabilitation), support to Air Madagascar.
- Public expenditure efficiency: World Bank public sector projects supporting selected reforms in education based on a previous public expenditure review in health and education.
- Public investment and debt management: Shared responsibility. Joint Public Investment Management Assessment (PIMA) conducted in 2016.
- Economic governance and corruption: Shared responsibility. Joint review of legislation, regulations, and supervisory practices to hinder money laundering and the financing of terrorism. Fund TA focused on reducing administrative discretion in tax/customs and public expenditure management.
- Business environment: World Bank-led. PIC2 to improve commercial justice and economic opportunities; Bank and Fund assist drafting mining and petroleum codes.
- Service delivery and social safety nets: Bank-led. Emergency food security and social protection project supports labor-intensive public works and pilot conditional cash transfers; safety nets project preparing systematic social protection approach; Bank conducted actuarial assessment of public pension system.
- Central bank operations: IMF-led. Fund assisting authorities in strengthening central bank strategy and core operations, including internal audit and accounting, and making monetary policy formulation and instruments more effective by:
  - (i) strengthening the interbank market and the market for short-term Treasury bills;
  - (ii) improving liquidity management and forecasting;
  - (iii) strengthening monetary policy operations;
  - (iv) strengthening the foreign exchange market; and
  - (iv) producing short- and medium-term inflation forecasts.
- Financial sector stability: Bank and Fund coordinate support to banking supervision (CSBF). Both assist in risk-based supervision and establishing AML/CFT legal and regulatory framework. Bank supported electronic money legal framework and explores institutional framework for non-bank financial institution supervision.
- Financial access and inclusion: Bank will continue to strengthen engagement in SME finance.
- Statistical system: Shared responsibility. Fund TA in national accounts and price statistics. Bank supports NIS in preparing the general population census; revising national accounts for 2007-12 using the 1993 system of national accounts and rebasing to 2007; capacity building; and updating the national strategy for the development of statistics.

### Information sharing arrangements
- After World Bank missions: Fund team will be kept informed of progress in macro-critical structural reform areas; Fund staff (including the resident representative) invited to debriefs and will receive aide-memoires and reports timely.
- After IMF missions: Bank team will be kept informed of progress where the Fund leads and on shared areas; Fund will share outputs systematically; Bank staff invited to debriefs and will receive aide-memoires and reports timely.

### Planned Bank and Fund activities (selected items from Table 1: 2017–2018)
- Bank Work Program (selected entries):
  - TA in project prioritization tool for PIM: Q2, 2017 — Expected Delivery Date of Report: Q2, 2017
  - Resident Advisor on PIM: Q3, 2017 — Expected Delivery Date of Report: Ongoing
  - TA in Pension reforms: Q2, 2017 — Q2, 2017
  - Pump price structure analysis: Ongoing — Q2, 2017
  - TA in Debt management: Q3, 2017 — Q4, 2017
  - TA in Public expenditure analysis (BOOST): Q2, 2017 — Q2, 2017
  - TSA Assessment: Q2, 2017 — Q2, 2017
  - PPP - Pipeline project elaboration: Q2, 2017 — Q2, 2017
  - FIRST project on Microfinance Supervision: Q2, 2017 — Q2, 2018
  - FIRST project on Payment Systems: Q3, 2017 — Q4, 2018
  - IFC TA on Credit Information: Q3, 2017; Q1, 2018 — Q1, 2018
  - IFC TA on Collateral registry: Q4, 2017 — Q2, 2018
  - Assessment of the Malagasy AML/CFT regime: No mission – World Bank report presented at the ESAAMLG Plenary (Sept 2017 or April 2018) — To be determined
  - Governance of State Owned Enterprises: Ongoing — Q2, 2017
  - Tax administration modernization (public sector performance project): Q3, 2017 — Q3, 2017
- Fund Work Program (selected entries):
  - STA TA in national accounts: Q2, 2017 — Q3, 2017
  - AFS TA in price statistics: Q2, 2017 — Q3, 2017
  - LEG TA in foreign exchange legislation: Q2, 2017 — Q3, 2017
  - FAD TA on MTBF, public investment, and natural resource management: Q3, 2017 — Q4, 2017
  - LEG multi-topic TA on banking law and the legal framework for repo agreements: Q3, 2017 — Q4, 2017
  - FAD TA in fiscal risk management: Q4, 2017 — Q1, 2018
  - STA TA in public finances: Q4, 2017 — Q1, 2018
  - FAD TA in cash and arrear management: Q1, 2018 — Q2, 2018
  - LEG TA in banking law: Q1, 2018 — Q2, 2018
  - LEG TA in the legal framework for repo agreements: Q1, 2018 — Q2, 2018
  - AFS TA in PIMA follow up: To be determined — To be determined
  - AFS TA in fiscal forecast: To be determined — To be determined
  - FAD TA in tax policy: To be determined — To be determined
  - FAD TA in tax and customs administration (follow-up mission): To be determined — Within 45 days after the last day of the mission
  - AFS TA in customs administration: To be determined — Within 45 days after the last day of the mission
  - AFS TA in tax administration: To be determined — Within 45 days after the last day of the mission
  - AFS TA in payment system legislation: To be determined — To be determined
  - AFS TA in monetary policy implementation: To be determined — To be determined
  - AFS TA in foreign exchange market: To be determined — To be determined
  - AFS TA in central bank governance: To be determined — To be determined
  - AFS TA in central bank communication: To be determined — To be determined
  - AFS TA in business surveys: To be determined — To be determined
  - LEG TA in AML/CFT issues: To be determined — To be determined
  - MCM TA in central bank accounting: To be determined — To be determined
  - Long-term expert on macro-fiscal issues: To be determined — To be determined
- Joint Work Program (selected entries):
  - Debt sustainability analysis: Q1, 2017 — Q2, 2017
  - AML/CFT: Q1, 2017 — Q2, 2017

### Relations with the African Development Bank Group (AfDB) (as of April, 2017)
- Membership and portfolio totals:
  - Madagascar became a member of the African Development Bank Group (AfDB) in 1977.
  - To date, the AfDB has financed 91 operations in the country, for a total net commitment of UA1,329.2 billion. This comprises of 78 projects, including institutional support, and 13 studies.
- Portfolio status as of March 30, 2017:
  - Ongoing portfolio comprised of 8 active projects, 4 studies, and 1 humanitarian assistance for a total commitment of UA194.5 million.
  - Ongoing operations include: Project for Rehabilitation of Agriculture Infrastructure (PRIASO); Project to Extend the Perimeter of Bas Mangoky (PEPBM); Project for Rural Youth Enterprises in the Mid-West of Madagascar (PROJERMO); Road Maintenance Project (PAIR); Project to Support Institutional Governance (PAGI); Project to Promote Investment (PAPI); a grant to support the fight against the plague; and a grant to provide school meals and food aid to the drought afflicted southern regions.
  - The average age of the portfolio is slightly over 2 years.
  - The portfolio’s average disbursement rate stands at 13.85 percent.
  - Sector distribution: agriculture represents 57 percent of the total value of the portfolio; transport 35 percent; governance 7 percent; health 1 percent.
  - Two ongoing private sector projects: the Ambatovy Nickel Project and the Sahanivotry Hydroelectric Power Plant Project.
- AfDB country strategy (CSP) preparation:
  - The AfDB is preparing a new CSP covering 2017-2021. The new CSP’s main objective is to contribute to improving the quality of life of the population through strong and inclusive growth.
  - Proposed strategy pillars:
    - Pillar I – development of energy and transport infrastructure to support inclusive growth;
    - Pillar II – support for the transformation of agriculture and the development of industry.
  - Both pillars are stated as consistent with the authorities’ priorities in the National Development Plan (NDP) and with the AfDB’s 2013-2022 strategy.

*International Monetary Fund — cr17223 (Introduction of IFRS in Central Bank Accounting 2015; excerpts from the Madagascar country relations and partner activities section)*

### 4.      As part of its strategy and knowledge products, the AfDB also envisages to undertake the

### cr17223 - 4.      As part of its strategy and knowledge products, the AfDB also envisages to undertake the

### AfDB planned economic and sector works
- AfDB envisages the following economic and sector works:
  - (i) a study on the poverty profile, food insecurity, and inequality;
  - (ii) a study on Madagascar’s fragility and building resilience;
  - (iii) a general profile of Madagascar;
  - (iv) the development of a renewable energy investment plan;
  - (v) a study to value Madagascar’s natural resources;
  - (vi) a study on the establishment of social safety nets, particularly for the vulnerable women and children of the country.
- Within the context of its projects, AfDB will undertake:
  - (i) a study on investment in renewable energies;
  - (ii) a study on governance in the energy sector;
  - (iii) a study on growth in the Southern regions.

### AfDB assistance under HIPC and MDRI
- Madagascar reached the HIPC decision and completion points in 2000 and 2004, respectively, becoming eligible for the MDRI.
- AfDB’s total assistance under HIPC and the MDRI amounted to US$299.6 million of debt relief in end-2010 present value terms.
- At the end of December 2010 in present value terms, the AfDB provided:
  - US$69.1 in debt relief under HIPC
  - US$230.5 million under the MDRI

### AfDB ongoing projects and program commitments and disbursement rates (selected statistics)
- Total: UA194.5 million; Disbursement Rate: 30.95 percent
- Agriculture projects (approval dates, commitments in Millions of UA, disbursement rates in Percent):
  - Projet de Réhabilitation des infrastructures agricoles s.o. (PRIASO) — June 19, 2013 — 28.88 — 33
  - Projet d’Extension du Périmètre du Bas Mangoky (PEPBM) — November 11, 2014 — 40.14 — 01
  - Projet Jeunes Entreprises Rurales dans le Moyen Ouest (PROJERMO) — September 24, 2012 — 24.61 — 01
  - Programme Entrepreneuriat des Jeunes dans l'Agriculture et l'Agro-Industrie (étude) — May 23, 2016 — 0.67 — 10
  - Etude de faisabilité du Programme de Transformation de l'Agriculture Malagasy — November 25, 2016 — 1 — 0
- Transportation:
  - Projet d’Aménagement des infrastructures routières (PAIR) — October 18, 2013 — 58.20 — 37
- Governance:
  - Projet d’Appui à la Gouvernance Institutionnelle (PAGI) — September 17, 2013 — 4.50 — 44
  - Projet d’Appui à Promotion des Investissements (PAPI) — July 9, 2015 — 7.00 — 02
  - Programme d'Appui au Réformes de la Gestion Economique (PARGE) — March 30, 2016 — 12.5 — 100
  - Programme d’Appui à la Réforme du Secteur de l’Energie (PARSE) — November 25, 2017 — 13.77 — 100
- Social:
  - Projet d'élaboration de Schémas Directeurs d'Assainissement de huit centres Urbains secondaires (étude) — March 21, 2016 — 1.44 — 4
  - Don d'aide humanitaire d'urgence pour l'assistance à la lutte contre la Malnutrition suite à la sècheresse dans le grand sud — July 13, 2016 — 0.72 — 0
  - Appui à l’amélioration de l’efficacité et de l’efficience en matière de réduction des risques de catastrophes (naturelles, climatiques et anthropiques) (étude) — December 01, 2017 — 1 — 0

### Data adequacy and statistical issues (assessment summary as of June 7, 2017)
- General:
  - Data provision has some shortcomings, but is broadly adequate for surveillance.
  - Database weaknesses: real sector, government finances, balance of payments, and social statistics.
  - Fund technical assistance was interrupted in 2009 and re-engagement occurred in 2014.
- National Accounts:
  - Complete national accounts (based on benchmark data) are infrequent; last complete sets cover 2015.
  - Reliability weak due to gaps in source data and methodological shortcomings.
  - Agricultural estimates poor due to lack of suitable information on size and evolution of sector.
  - Service activities not properly covered; little information on informal sector magnitude.
  - INSTAT suspended production of two industrial production indices (IPI-ZF and IPI-RC) due to financing issues.
- Price Statistics:
  - CPI covers seven principal cities, base year 2000, expenditure weights from 1999 household survey.
  - CPI generally reported to Fund staff on a timely basis.
  - Producer price index (“l’Indice de la Production Industrielle (IPI)”) publication suspended since 2008 due to financing issues.
- Government Finance Statistics:
  - 2004 multi-sector mission found significant gaps and recommended broader coverage to include public agencies part of central government.
  - Recommendations made on classification, recording of transactions, and calculation of domestic arrears.
  - Central government financial operations disseminated only annually.
  - Since August 2014, public debt data disseminated with the “Statistical Bulletin of Debt”.
  - Madagascar does not report sub-annual data for publication in International Finance Statistics (IFS).
- Monetary Statistics:
  - BCM has reported monetary data to STA for publication in IFS since August 2001.
- Balance of Payments:
  - Compilation system flawed; external trade data derived from customs data with inadequate coverage and deficient recording procedures.
  - Significant smuggling, particularly in mining sector, reduces reliability of trade data.
  - Recurring issues: excessive processing lags due to partial automation of customs reports and inadequate coverage of several transactions.
  - Compilation of external debt statistics is generally satisfactory.
- Data Standards and Quality:
  - Madagascar participates in the General Data Dissemination System (GDDS) since May 2004.

### Table of Common Indicators Required for Surveillance (selected entries)
- Exchange rate — Date of latest observation: 070/6/17 — Date received: 07/06/17 — Frequency of Data: D — Frequency of Reporting: D — Frequency of Publication: D
- International Reserve Assets and Reserve Liabilities of the Monetary Authorities — 31/05/17 — 01/06/17 — M — M — M
- Reserve/Base Money — 31/05/17 — 01/06/17 — M — M — M
- Broad Money — 31/03/17 — 08/05/17 — M — M — M
- Central Bank Balance Sheet — 31/05/17 — 01/06/17 — M — M — M
- Consolidated Balance Sheet of the Banking System — 31/03/17 — 08/05/17 — M — M — M
- Interest Rates — 19/04/17 — 02/05/17 — M — M — M
- Consumer Price Index — 03/17 — 02/05/17 — M — M — M
- Revenue, Expenditure, Balance and Composition of Financing – Central Government — 30/04/17 — 01/06/17 — M — M — A
- Stocks of Central Government and Central Government-Guaranteed Debt — 2016 — 08/03/17 — A — A — A
- External Current Account Balance — 03/2017 — 12/04/17 — Q — Q — Q
- Exports and Imports of Goods and Services — 03/2017 — 12/04/17 — Q — Q — Q
- GDP/GNP — 2016 — 09/03/17 — A — A — A
- Frequency codes: Daily (D); weekly (W); monthly (M); quarterly (Q); annually (A); irregular (I); and not available (NA).

### Debt sustainability analysis (high-level findings and projections)
- Risk of external debt distress: Moderate (in line with the last DSA at the time of the ECF program request in July 2016).
- Debt dynamics have improved slightly, mainly because of more favorable financing assumptions following a successful donor conference in late 2016.
- Public DSA suggests total public and publicly-guaranteed (PPG) debt dynamics are sustainable, but vulnerabilities remain:
  - Weak fiscal revenue generation;
  - Possible exchange rate shocks;
  - Contingent liabilities related to state-owned enterprises.
- Recent debt levels and composition:
  - Total public debt: around $3.7 billion (41 percent of GDP) in 2015; remained stable at that amount with a decline to 39 percent of GDP in 2016.
  - These levels are substantially less than the pre-HIPC peak of 95 percent of GDP.
  - Domestic debt grew from 7.6 percent of GDP in 2008 to 12.9 percent in 2015; declined to 11.7 percent of GDP in 2016.
  - Debt service to revenue ratio has been trending upward.
- External debt composition (end-2016, Table 1):
  - Domestic debt: US$1,113 — 11.7 percent of GDP — 30.3 percent of total
    - Treasury bills: 473 — 5.0 percent of GDP — 12.9 percent of total
    - Debt to the Central Bank: 337 — 3.6 percent of GDP — 9.2 percent of total
    - Arrears: 214 — 2.3 percent of GDP — 5.8 percent of total
    - Other inc. loans: 89 — 0.9 percent of GDP — 2.4 percent of total
  - External debt: US$2,562 — 27.0 percent of GDP — 69.7 percent of total
    - Multilateral: 2,074 — 21.9 percent of GDP — 56.4 percent of total
    - Paris Club: 129 — 1.4 percent of GDP — 3.5 percent of total
    - Non-Paris Club: 337 — 3.6 percent of GDP — 9.2 percent of total
    - Commercial & Garanties: 23 — 0.2 percent of GDP — 0.6 percent of total
  - Total PPG debt: 3,675 — 38.7 percent of GDP — 100.0 percent of total
- Private external debt:
  - Mainly issued by local subsidiaries of multinational companies.
  - Largest debtor example: Ambatovy with external debt just under $2bn (20 percent of GDP); projected to be fully repaid by 2030.
- Contingent liabilities and state-owned enterprises:
  - Recapitalization of Air Madagascar is included in baseline assumptions.
  - JIRAMA long-term debt ~ ½ percent of GDP and short-term debt ~ 5 percent of GDP at end-2014.
  - Postal savings scheme and Madagascar Savings Fund (Caisse d’Epargne de Madagascar, CEM) may need future recapitalization (probably less than 1 percent of GDP combined).
  - Banks: government minority shareholder in several commercial banks; most banks have financially solid foreign majority shareholders; liabilities mainly deposits exceeding loans.

### Baseline macroeconomic assumptions and projections (Table 2; 2017DSA vs 2016DSA)
- Real GDP growth (percent):
  - 2017DSA: 2017: 4.3; 2018: 5.3; 2019: 5.9; 2020: 5.5; 2021: 5.2; 2022: 5.0
  - 2016DSA: 2017: 4.5; 2018: 4.8; 2019: 5.0; 2020: 5.0; 2021: 5.0
- Non-interest CA deficit (% of GDP):
  - 2017DSA: 2017: 4.4; 2018: 4.9; 2019: 4.6; 2020: 3.8; 2021: 3.7; 2022: 3.5
  - 2016DSA: 2017: 3.3; 2018: 3.7; 2019: 3.7; 2020: 3.6; 2021: 3.5
- Primary deficit (% of GDP):
  - 2017DSA: 2017: 4.2; 2018: 3.6; 2019: 3.4; 2020: 2.8; 2021: 2.5; 2022: 2.4
  - 2016DSA: 2017: 3.4; 2018: 3.3; 2019: 3.1; 2020: 2.9; 2021: 2.7
- Total revenues, excl grants (% of GDP):
  - 2017DSA: 2017: 11.6; 2018: 11.8; 2019: 12.2; 2020: 12.7; 2021: 13.1; 2022: 13.5
  - 2016DSA: 2017: 11.2; 2018: 11.7; 2019: 12.2; 2020: 12.7; 2021: 13.2
- Grants (% of GDP):
  - 2017DSA: 2017: 3.5; 2018: 3.6; 2019: 3.4; 2020: 2.4; 2021: 2.3; 2022: 2.3
  - 2016DSA: 2017: 2.8; 2018: 1.7; 2019: 2.0; 2020: 2.1; 2021: 1.8
- Non-Interest Expenditure (% of GDP):
  - 2017DSA: 2017: 19.2; 2018: 19.0; 2019: 19.1; 2020: 17.8; 2021: 17.9; 2022: 18.1
  - 2016DSA: 2017: 17.3; 2018: 16.6; 2019: 17.0; 2020: 17.2; 2021: 17.3

*Prepared by the Staffs of the International Monetary Fund and the International Development Association (excerpts from the source document).*

### 9.      Following a successful donor-conference in late 2016, expected financing

### 9.      Following a successful donor-conference in late 2016, expected financing

### Financing outlook and pledges
- At the donor conference in Paris in December 2016, the authorities received pledges of $6.4 billion (over 60 percent of 2016 GDP).
- Not all of this amount is available for investment in the near-term, but concrete pledges for project financing have exceeded assumptions in previous frameworks in 2017-2020.

### Borrowing composition and terms
- Semi-concessional and very limited non-concessional borrowing is envisaged throughout the forecast horizon.
- Non-concessional borrowing (with a negative average grant element of 12 percent) is foreseen at $100 million in 2017.
  - Of this $100 million, $55 million will be disbursed before end-June 2017 under a long-delayed loan with an AfDB guarantee.
  - An additional $45m is expected under similar conditions to finance the restructuring of Air Madagascar.
- Over the medium term, the importance of semi-concessional borrowing is expected to increase, reducing the average grant element of new borrowing from above 45 percent in 2019 to roughly 37 percent in 2037.
- Assumptions underlying grant element calculations include: 8.5 percent interest rate, 7-year maturity, and two-year grace period (only part of future commercial loans are assumed to benefit from a guarantee from an external agency).

### Key risks to assumptions
- Main risks: political instability, revenue generation, the exchange rate, and the persistence of donor grant support.
- Specific channels:
  - Political instability could weaken economic confidence, negatively affecting growth, the exchange rate and donor support.
  - Continued weak revenue performance would accelerate debt accumulation.
  - Faster-than-expected depreciation of the Ariary would increase the real value of the existing debt stock.
  - Lack of reform progress could undo gains in donor grant support.
- Risk assessment:
  - Risks are assessed to be symmetric because the exchange rate may continue to surprise on the upside and revenue generation has significant upside potential given the low base.
  - Upside scenarios (stronger exchange rate, stronger revenues, successful structural fiscal reforms) could boost ability to service higher debt levels and increase donor support.

### External DSA — Baseline projections
- Level of PPG external debt was roughly $2.5 billion in 2016 and is projected to grow gradually throughout the forecast period.
- PPG external debt is forecast to increase from 27 percent of GDP in 2016 to a peak of 36 percent of GDP in 2022.
- PPG external debt is projected to decline to 25 percent of GDP by 2037 as domestic debt markets deepen.
- Present value (PV) of external debt is projected to increase from 15½ percent of GDP in 2016 to 21 percent of GDP by 2022 and then decline to 16 percent by 2037.
- Private external debt is projected to decline slowly as loans related to a major mining project are repaid; the DSA does not forecast substantial new external borrowing from the private sector.

### External DSA — Alternative scenarios and stress tests
- Standard bound tests and a historical scenario (macroeconomic variables set to 2007-16 averages) are applied to the baseline.
- Standard bound tests:
  - A simultaneous slowdown in GDP, decline in exports, a depreciation, and reduction of non-debt creating flows (all a one-half standard deviation) would cause the PV of debt-to-revenue ratio to peak at 243 percent in 2017, above the threshold implied by Madagascar’s CPIA rating.
  - The same shock would just barely exceed the threshold for the PV of debt-to-GDP ratio.
  - A one standard deviation decline in exports would result in the PV of debt-to-exports increasing to 108 percent, above its threshold of 100.
  - The first stress test is sufficient to classify Madagascar as standing at moderate risk of external debt distress.
- Historical scenario:
  - Projects a rapid increase in all debt metrics and causes a breach for four of the five external debt thresholds, with substantial breaches in the PV of debt-to-GDP and PV of debt-to-revenue ratios.
  - The historical scenario places less weight because the large current account deficits in 2008 and 2009 (over 20 percent of GDP) were driven by imports for large mining projects financed principally through non-debt creating FDI.

### Public DSA — Baseline projections
- Domestic PPG debt is projected to decline as a proportion of GDP over the next decade as authorities replace domestic financing by concessional external borrowing.
- The importance of domestic PPG debt is then expected to grow again over the long term as domestic markets deepen and savings become more abundant.
- The PV of total PPG debt is projected to remain less than 30 percent of GDP throughout the forecast horizon—well-below the threshold of 38 percent.

### Public DSA — Alternative scenarios and stress tests
- Two of three alternative scenarios used to stress test total PPG debt breach the risk threshold:
  - The most extreme shock—a one standard deviation reduction in GDP growth in 2018-2019—would lead to a rapid and persistent breach of the threshold starting in 2022.
  - Assuming the primary deficit remains unchanged as a proportion to GDP throughout the forecast horizon also results in a breach in the PV of debt-to-GDP ratio in the outer years.
- Policy implication: Reducing the current gap between revenue and spending is a clear priority.

### Natural disasters and debt dynamics (Box 2 summary)
- Natural disasters are recurring in Madagascar; since 2000 the country has been affected by 30 natural disasters (droughts, storms, floods, epidemics and insect infestation).
- Historical event study (2004 tropical cyclones):
  - Estimated economic damage equivalent to 5.7 percent of GDP in 2004; 400 deaths and nearly 1,000 injured.
  - Primary expenditure increased from 17 percent of GDP to 22 percent of GDP in 2004.
  - General government revenues also rose, with 3 of the 5 percentage points of GDP increase coming from additional grant support.
  - Primary fiscal deficit increased by only 0.3 percent of GDP, from 1.7 to 2 percent of GDP in 2004. In 2005 primary fiscal accounts were roughly in balance.
  - GDP growth remained above 5 percent in 2004.
  - Inflation rose to 14 percent in 2004 and 18 percent in 2005 (compared to an average 8 percent over the previous 5 years).
  - The currency depreciated in nominal terms by 34 percent in 2004.
- Customized debt scenario for a severe disaster:
  - Includes a 35 percent depreciation of the exchange rate and 10 percent faster inflation in 2018, with fiscal variables and GDP growth for the shock year unchanged.
  - The effects of the depreciation and higher inflation roughly offset one another for the PV of Debt-to-GDP ratio; other fiscal indicators improve.

### Conclusion and policy recommendations
- Overall assessment: Breaches of debt thresholds occur only under stress scenarios, resulting in a moderate risk rating.
- While authorities are expected to be able to service current and future debt obligations, debt sustainability is vulnerable to shocks, poor revenue collection, and contingent liabilities related to state-owned enterprises.
- Measures initiated by the authorities to address vulnerabilities:
  - Enhanced revenue collections and budgetary execution.
  - Strengthened debt monitoring capacity.
  - Improved policy and institutional performance.
- If successful, these measures should help to maintain favorable financing conditions and increase Madagascar potential economic growth.
- It is important to strengthen monitoring and management of state-owned enterprises, including by publishing their audited financial statements.

*Republic of Madagascar — IMF Country Report content unit*

### 21.      The DSA was discussed with the authorities during the March 2017 Article IV

### 21. The DSA was discussed with the authorities during the March 2017 Article IV mission

### DSA discussion and authorities' response
- Staff presented the DSA results during the March 2017 Article IV mission to illustrate the need for prudence and continued reform of public financial management when increasing external borrowing to maintain debt sustainability.
- The authorities agreed with the overall assessment and policy implications and expressed their firm commitment to tackle any risks that could push them beyond a moderate risk rating.

### Policy recommendations from the DSA
- Reforms should focus on:
  - (i) increasing tax revenues to safeguard the capacity of the state to service debt;
  - (ii) ensuring that debt continues to be financed on the most concessional terms possible;
  - (iii) ensuring that investments are carefully prioritized to enhance growth and human capital accumulation;
  - (iv) improving debt monitoring capacity, especially the control of debt guarantees and potential contingent liabilities.

### Recent developments cited in the statement
- Madagascar suffered two large shocks since last year, notably:
  - a severe drought; and
  - the most violent cyclone in recent history which struck the island in March 2017.
- Effects of the cyclone:
  - loss of more than 80 lives;
  - destroyed the homes of about a quarter million people;
  - resulted in considerable physical damages estimated at about 4 percent of GDP.
- Macroeconomic outcome noted:
  - Real GDP growth accelerated to 4.2 percent in 2016.

### Baseline projections and key sustainability indicators (selected)
- External debt (nominal) (selected years, in percent of GDP): 2014: 45.0; 2015: 48.6; 2016: 45.4; 2017: 43.0; 2018: 7.8; 2019: 45.3; 2020: 45.6; 2021: 45.7; 2022: 44.9; 2027 (average 2027-2037): 34.7; 2037: 32.6.
- PPG (public and publicly guaranteed) external debt (in percent of GDP) (selected): 2014: 24.4; 2015: 28.4; 2016: 27.0; 2017: 25.0; 2018: 1.7; 2019: 29.6; 2020: 31.9; 2021: 33.9; 2022: 34.8; 2027 (average 2027-2037): 29.7; 2037: 29.8.
- PV of external debt (selected): 2018: 33.9; 2019: 33.2; 2020: 32.5; 2021: 31.7; 2022: 30.6; 2027-2037 average: 28.6; 2037: 20.6.
- PV of PPG external debt (selected): 2018: 15.5; 2019: 17.4; 2020: 18.8; 2021: 20.0; 2022: 20.5; 2027-2037 average: 19.3; 2037: 16.2.
- PV of PPG external debt (in percent of exports) (selected): 2018: 46.2; 2019: 52.4; 2020: 58.1; 2021: 60.4; 2022: 59.4; 2027-2037 average: 54.5; 2037: 43.0.
- PPG debt service-to-revenue ratio (in percent) (selected): 2014: 7.4; 2015: 6.5; 2016: 8.6; 2017: 9.7; 2018: 8.3; 2019: 7.4; 2020: 8.8; 2021: 8.8; 2022: 9.1; 2027-2037 average: 8.6; 2037: 8.9.
- Grant element of new public sector borrowing (in percent) (selected projection years): 2024: 36.2; 2025: 43.1; 2026: 47.8; 2027: 45.0; 2028: 45.3; 2029: 43.7; 2030: 43.5; 2031: 43.5; 2032: 40.4; 2033: 37.0; 2037: 39.1.
- Government revenues (excluding grants, in percent of GDP) (selected): 2014: 10.1; 2015: 10.4; 2016: 11.2; 2017: 10.6; 2018: 1.0; 2019: 11.6; 2020: 11.8; 2021: 12.2; 2022: 12.7; 2027-2037 average: 15.3; 2037: 15.5.
- Aid flows (in Millions of US dollars) (selected): 2014: 246; 2015: 144; 2016: 343; 2017: 658; 2018: 759; 2019: 858; 2020: 713; 2021: 751; 2022: 751; 2027-2037 memoranda: multiple yearly entries up to 1820 and 1575 in later rows as presented.
- Nominal GDP (Millions of US dollars) (selected): 2014: 1067; 2015: 497; 2016: 441; 2017: 1000; 2018: 1105; 2019: 711; 2020: 1161; 2021: 1200; 2022: 912; projection series continues as presented.

### Stress tests and sensitivity analysis (high-level)
- The DSA presents alternative scenarios and bound tests through 2017-2037 including:
  - A1. Key variables at their historical averages in 2017-2037;
  - A2. New public sector loans on less favorable terms in 2017-2037 (interest rate on new borrowing higher by 2 percentage points);
  - B1–B6 bound tests including lower real GDP growth, lower export value growth, lower US dollar GDP deflator, lower net non-debt creating flows, a combination of shocks, and a one-time 30 percent nominal depreciation in 2018.
- Tables and figures show that the most extreme stress tests raise PV-of-debt and debt-service indicators materially relative to the baseline, with specific year-by-year sensitivities provided in the tables for PV of debt-to-GDP, PV of debt-to-exports, PV of debt-to-revenue, debt service-to-exports, and debt service-to-revenue ratios.

*Source: cr17223 - 21.      The DSA was discussed with the authorities during the March 2017 Article IV mission.*

### 3.1 percent in 2015, supported mainly by higher investment, stronger exports from the export

### 3.1 percent in 2015, supported mainly by higher investment, stronger exports from the export

### Macroeconomic performance and outlook
- Growth: "3.1 percent in 2015, supported mainly by higher investment, stronger exports from the export processing zones and improved agricultural output supported by higher vanilla prices."
- Inflation: "about 7 percent at end-2016."
- External sector: "strengthened."
- International reserves: "growing to an equivalent of 3.9 months of imports compared to 3.3 months in the program."
- Current account: "a surplus of 0.8 percent of GDP."
- Authorities’ outlook: growth forecasts premised on "increased public and private investments, prudent macroeconomic policies, sustained structural reforms, and strong contribution from the mining, agricultural and tourism sectors."
- Investment pledges: "catalyzing strong financial pledges of over $6 billion."

### Performance under the ECF and program implementation
- Overall assessment: "Performance under the ECF was strong. All end-December 2016 performance criteria (PCs) and indicative targets were observed, some with considerable margins."
- Arrears and waiver request:
  - "Servicing debt to Libya was delayed due to technical problems beyond the authorities’ control, leading to a temporary breach of the continuous performance criterion on the accumulation of new external payment arrears."
  - "All arrears have since been cleared and the Malagasy authorities are seeking a waiver for non-observance of this continuous performance criterion."
- Structural benchmarks: "Progress was also made in the implementation of the ambitious structural reform program, although not all benchmarks were met through end-February 2017. Two benchmarks were met with delays."
  - Examples: "establishment of the Council of Budget and Financial Discipline" and "the law on asset recovery which was only submitted to Parliament recently, due to the need for further revision and consultations."
- Specific non-observation: "The continuous benchmark on the prior notification of Fund and World Bank regarding the signing of any single source contracts by JIRAMA was not met as one contract was signed as a matter of urgency to meet a deadline agreed upon with the investor."

### Fiscal performance and public finances
- Revenue and expenditure:
  - "Total revenues were 11.2 percent of GDP, higher than the 11 percent budgeted."
  - "Overall expenditure was kept within the program target."
- Budget balance:
  - "The overall balance (on a commitment basis) registered a deficit of 1.3 percent of GDP, significantly less than the 3.2 percent programmed."
  - "The primary balance, excluding foreign financed investment, registered a surplus of 0.8 percent of GDP compared to a projected deficit of 0.6 percent."
- Fiscal outlook and measures:
  - "Efforts will continue to improve efficiency at the tax and customs administrations."
  - "Broaden the use of tax identification number (TIN) throughout all departments of the Ministry of Finance and Budget by year-end, and to all other ministries by end-2018."
  - "Performance contracts will be extended to the anti-fraud units at Customs by end-September 2017."
  - Recognition of higher 2017 spending drivers: "climate-related emergency spending, higher transfers to the utility company, JIRAMA, and the national airline, Air Madagascar, will cause an increase in government expenditure in 2017."
- Requests to IMF: "the Malagasy authorities request the completion of this first review under the ECF as well as a waiver for the non-observance of the continuous performance criterion on external payment arrears, and the modification of the performance criterion on the primary balance, excluding foreign-financed investment, for end-June 2017. Moreover, in view of the additional balance of payments needs due to climate-related shocks, the authorities are requesting an augmentation of access under the ECF arrangement."

### Monetary policy and banking sector
- Monetary stance: "Monetary policy was prudent, and the inflation rate was kept under control."
- Liquidity operations: "the central bank undertook foreign exchange purchases and domestic liquidity operations" to restore liquidity after vanilla export payments "drew liquidity from banks."
- Policy direction: "Going forward, the authorities will pursue a tight monetary policy consistent with the objectives of money growth and inflation."
- Framework transition: "The aim is to move gradually from monetary targeting towards an interest-rate based framework over the medium- to long-term."
- Financial sector: "Madagascar’s financial sector is sound and resilient, as confirmed by the 2016 FSAP."
  - Gaps noted: "notably in the area of financial oversight."
  - Follow-up: "The authorities are following up on staff recommendations."

### Structural reforms, investment program, and governance
- Investment program:
  - "The Investment Program, which is consistent with the National Development Plan (NDP) and the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) was presented to international donors and investors in December 2016, catalyzing strong financial pledges of over $6 billion."
  - Financing stance: "Priority is being given to grants and concessional borrowing, with a view to maintaining debt sustainability."
  - Implementation safeguards: "The authorities recognize that the rapid increase in investment can pose risks" and are "taking steps to reinforce implementation capacity, strengthen supervision of projects, and improve donors’ coordination, among others."
  - Institutional measures: "A new PPP law has been enacted, and the application decrees were adopted by the Cabinet in March 2017."
  - Project oversight: "a dedicated unit will be responsible for project coordination."
  - Transparency: "The terms and conditions of all PPP contracts will be published within one month of the date of signature on the web site of the Ministry of Finance and Budget."
  - Capacity support: "the Fund and the World Bank are called upon to help build capacities within the Ministry of Finance and Budget which will retain the right to disapprove or stop projects that may entail fiscal risks."
- Governance measures:
  - Legislation and institutions: "adoption of legislation aimed at promoting assets disclosure for a wider range of public officials, setting up specialized anti-corruption centers, and combatting the traffic of precious wood."
  - Laws in preparation: "two new laws are in an advanced stage of preparation for submission to Parliament. They are in regards to anti-money laundering, and the cooperation with other countries on the exchange of mutual legal assistance in criminal matters."

### State-owned enterprises: JIRAMA and Air Madagascar
- JIRAMA:
  - Causes of deterioration: "exceptional drought ... affected significantly the production of hydro-electricity, causing an increased reliance on more expensive imported diesel" and delays in conversion to heavy fuel oil and enforcement of customer payments.
  - Management response: "A new management team for JIRAMA has been put in place and has developed a multi-year business plan along with a timetable and a list of concrete measures to reverse the deteriorating financial situation."
  - Medium-term objective: "The measures are expected to reduce the need for government transfers gradually over the medium term with an objective of zero transfer by 2020."
- Air Madagascar:
  - Strategic partnership: "An agreement has been reached with a strategic partner, Air Austral, that will help to put the airline on a financially sound and commercially viable position, while allowing it to continue to provide vital domestic services."
  - Financial terms: "As part of the agreement, there will be an injection of new capital from the new partner, with the government having to assume past net liabilities."
- Fiscal impact: "Overall, the fiscal deficit and borrowing requirements will increase this year, compared to the original program. However, these additional expenses are being accompanied by strong reforms that will lead to permanent improvements in these two strategic SOEs, and enable them to contribute solidly to economic growth and government revenue, over the medium- to long-term."

### Social protection, poverty reduction, and financial inclusion
- Social measures: "The authorities are also taking measures with World Bank assistance to improve social conditions and reduce poverty, especially for the poorest members of society. These consist, among others, projects that involve cash transfers and cash for work."
- Agriculture and human capital: "The authorities are also undertaking agricultural and rural development projects which are aimed at helping to raise income of the rural population. Projects in the education and health sectors are ongoing."
- Financial inclusion:
  - Legal and regulatory steps: "the law on electronic money was passed in February and the associated decrees and regulations are expected to be issued by year-end."
  - Projects: "the authorities are also working closely with the World Bank on a new financial inclusion project that will focus on the digitalization of transactions and access to credit."
  - Legislative work: "the laws on banking and microfinance are being redrafted."

### Conclusion and requests to Directors
- Program outcome: "In spite of significant shocks, Madagascar has continued to implement steadfastly its economic and financial program with encouraging results: growth has rebounded, macroeconomic stability has strengthened, and the medium-term outlook is improving."
- Authorities’ requests: support for (i) "the completion of this first review under the ECF", (ii) "a waiver for the non-observance of the continuous performance criterion on external payment arrears", (iii) "the modification of the performance criterion on the primary balance, excluding foreign-financed investment, for end-June 2017", and (iv) "an augmentation of access under the ECF arrangement" due to "additional balance of payments needs due to climate-related shocks."
- Closing ask: "In light of the above, we would appreciate Directors’ support for the authorities’ requests."

*Source: IMF country report text provided in the content unit.*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/cr/2017/cr17223.pdf_
