## cr17226 — 1. Improving the Prioritization of Foreign-Financed Capital Expenditure

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [cr17226 — 1. Improving the Prioritization of Foreign-Financed Capital Expenditure](https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/cr/2017/cr17226.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/files/publications/cr/2017/cr17226.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/files/publications/cr/2017/cr17226.pdf.json)

---

### Key findings on FF capital expenditure execution (2016–17)
- Realized FF capital expenditures in 2016 were around $260 million—roughly $100 million or 1 percent of GDP over budget but slightly below the level projected at the time of the fourth review.
- Main contributors to the 2016 over-execution included:
  - catch-up in implementation of the North-South Highway: $23 million;
  - under-budgeting for the rehabilitation of the M6 Highway: $11 million;
  - rural financing: $20 million;
  - partial disbursement of a long-term, low-interest defense loan: $23 million.
- For 2017, the authorities identified around $100 million of high-priority FF project spending that was not included in the 2017 budget.
- Authorities plan to accommodate high-priority projects by raising total capital spending in 2017 to $195 million. Most projects are concessional and involve multiple phases and donors (both bilateral and multilateral).
- Projects de-prioritized in the 2017 exercise included the Caucasus Electric Transmission Network, worth around $300 million.

### Rationale for changing 2017 capital-spending stance
- The 2017 budget originally envisaged a large fiscal adjustment, primarily by delaying capital expenditure, to meet Armenia’s fiscal rule; the corrective mechanism under the fiscal rule was triggered in 2016 for the first time.
- Given weaker-than-expected GDP growth (larger output gap), high penalties/operational costs from delaying some projects, and limited impact of monetary easing on growth, staff and the authorities agreed that the budgeted large cut in capital spending would be excessively pro-cyclical and sub-optimal.
- Delaying the projects would:
  - exert a sizable negative fiscal impulse when the output gap is relatively large; and
  - harm future productive capacity.

### Policy decision and fiscal implications
- Staff and the authorities agreed to additional capital spending of around 1 percent of GDP, projected to increase the fiscal deficit by up to ½ percent of GDP.
- Strong revenue overperformance in 2017Q1 (¼ percent of GDP) prompted staff to revise up revenue projections for 2017 by ½ percent of GDP.
- As a result of the additional capital spending and upward revenue revision, the budget deficit for 2017 is projected to increase to 3.3 percent of GDP (½ percent of GDP higher compared to the fourth review).
- The projected 2017 deficit implies a deviation from the existing fiscal rule in 2017; the rule is being revised before end-2017 as part of modernizing the medium-term fiscal framework.
- Despite the higher deficit in 2017, staff projects public debt to start declining in 2019 as before.

### Prioritization methodology for FF projects (criteria used)
- Projects prioritized if they:
  - are due to be closed by end-2017 or were already 75 percent or more complete as of January 2017;
  - relate to national security;
  - have significant growth and defense impact;
  - are not possible to delay/cancel without significant penalties.

### Projects targeted for increased execution in 2017
- The bulk of the additional expenditure will be used to increase the pace of execution of:
  - the North-South Highway;
  - the M6 Highway;
  - the Vedi Reservoir;
  - irrigation system modernization.

### Key fiscal figures (selected exact values)
- Overall fiscal balance: -5.6 (2016), -3.3 (2017), -2.7 (2018), -1.7 (2019), -1.3 (2020), -1.4 (2021), -1.3 (2022).
- Cyclically adjusted fiscal balance: -5.1 (2016), -2.6 (2017), -2.2 (2018), -1.3 (2019), -1.0 (2020), -1.2 (2021), -1.3 (2022).
- Cyclically adjusted primary fiscal balance: -3.0 (2016), -0.5 (2017), -0.2 (2018), 0.7 (2019), 0.9 (2020), 0.3 (2021), 0.0 (2022).
- Additional details cited:
  - 2016 realized FF capital expenditures: around $260 million;
  - 2016 over-execution relative to budget: roughly $100 million or 1 percent of GDP;
  - Identified high-priority 2017 FF spending not included in budget: around $100 million;
  - Planned total FF capital spending in 2017 after reprioritization: $195 million;
  - De-prioritized Caucasus Electric Transmission Network: around $300 million;
  - Projected increase in fiscal deficit due to additional spending: up to ½ percent of GDP;
  - Revenue overperformance in 2017Q1: ¼ percent of GDP;
  - Staff upward revision of 2017 revenue projections: ½ percent of GDP;
  - Resulting projected budget deficit for 2017: 3.3 percent of GDP.

### Macroeconomic and fiscal policy guidance (linked to FF prioritization)
- Given fragile growth and a negative output gap, the planned large cut in capital spending envisaged in the 2017 budget and triggered by the fiscal rule is inappropriate.
- Staff supports the authorities’ planned increase in concessional foreign-financed capital expenditure by about 1 percent of GDP.
- To ensure debt sustainability, enhance revenue mobilization and increase efficiency in spending.
- Rigorously implement the new Tax Code and strengthen SRC’s powers to monitor tax compliance.
- Amend the existing fiscal rule to improve flexibility and consideration for cyclical conditions; ensure robust communication to justify revisions.

### Medium-term planning and procedural changes
- Authorities are extending the prioritization exercise to inform the medium-term fiscal plans.
- The moratorium on signing new commitments remains in place, but there is already a large pipeline of approved FF projects for implementation over the medium term.
- A decree extends strict controls over domestically-financed expenditure to future foreign-financed capital projects.
- Any future commitments will be subject to new registration procedures to ensure consistency with the budget and the medium-term framework, effectively shifting fiduciary functions from Project Implementation Units to the Treasury.

### Donor and project management challenges
- The pipeline’s scale and the number of projects will make management challenging, particularly in the context of an ambitious fiscal consolidation plan.
- Authorities are conducting a similar prioritization exercise to underpin the 2018 budget and their medium-term fiscal plans, balancing potential positive impacts on growth and development with the need to ensure debt sustainability.
- Maximize the impact of concessional donor financing by effectively managing and prioritizing the large pipeline of capital projects.

### Links to debt sustainability and DSA highlights
- DSA baseline assumptions and projections:
  - Foreign-financed capital expenditure: expected to be 1 percent of GDP higher than budgeted, bringing the overall fiscal deficit to around 3.3 percent of GDP.
  - Tax collection: expected to be ½ percent of GDP higher than budgeted in 2017.
- Total public debt projections:
  - Projected to reach 56 percent of GDP in 2017 and increase further in 2018 before starting to decline.
- Fan chart uncertainty (public debt-to-GDP):
  - Symmetric distribution: between 41 and 73 percent (10th–90th percentile) in 2017 and between 25 and 94 percent in 2022.
  - Asymmetric fan chart (rules out real exchange rate appreciation): between 40 and 108 percent of GDP (10th–90th percentile) at the end of the projection horizon.
- Stress-test example:
  - Real GDP growth shock (adverse shock: real GDP contracts by 4 percent in 2018–19): public debt increases to 77 percent of GDP, and public gross financing needs exceed 7 percent of GDP by 2019.

### Monetary and financial policies (context and recommendations)
- Headline inflation has turned positive but monetary conditions remain relatively tight; inflation expectations remain depressed despite a recent pickup.
- Real interest rates have started to fall but are still high for the current cyclical position.
- Lending rates are not responding well to lower policy rates, reflecting risk premia and dollarization.
- Staff recommendations and CBA stance:
  - CBA should remain open to further easing, if justified by data, but highlighted risks of capital outflows and further deposit dollarization.
  - Staff emphasized that further monetary easing may be needed as part of a broader adjustment in the macro policy mix to support fiscal policy, while macroprudential policies should continue to be used to address risks relating to dollarization.
  - Monetary policy should be supported by maintaining two-way exchange rate flexibility and adequate external buffers.
- Financial sector policy recommendations:
  - Promote a well-functioning interbank market to strengthen interest-based monetary transmission.
  - Develop multi-maturity bond markets to facilitate maturity transformation and improve transmission.
  - Enhance communication and promote de-dollarization.
  - Monitor bank consolidation to balance competition and “too-big-to-fail” concerns.
  - Continue implementing FSAP recommendations and strengthen macroprudential framework; operationalize risk-based supervision in line with Basel III by end-2017.

### Financial sector and inclusion (selected metrics and concerns)
- Credit-to-GDP ratio: 45 percent.
- Account ownership: only 17 percent of the adult population owns financial accounts.
- Borrowing (2014): 20 percent of adults obtained loans from financial institutions; 27 percent received credit from family/friends.
- Outstanding deposits and loans with commercial banks in 2015: 28 and 40 percent of GDP respectively.
- Corporate access: 46 percent of companies have loan or credit lines with banks; less than 10 percent of corporate investment is financed by banks.
- Collateral required for 89 percent of loans; collateral averages 264 percent of the loan value.
- Policy recommendations to strengthen financial deepening:
  - Reduce participation cost and make financial services more affordable.
  - Remove unnecessary borrowing constraints and increase financial intermediation efficiency.
  - Improve credit reporting systems and tackle transparency problems.
  - Address low levels of financial literacy and inclusion jointly between the CBA and the government.

### External vulnerabilities and recommendations
- Current account deficit fell from 7.6 percent of GDP in 2014 to 2.7 percent of GDP in 2016.
- Medium-term current account projections broadly in line with EBA-lite estimates of a current account deficit norm between 4 to 5 percent of GDP.
- Reserves and buffers:
  - Gross international reserves increased to $2.2 billion at end-2016.
  - Under the Fund’s ARA metric for floating exchange rate regimes, reserves were around 116 percent at end-2016.
- NIIP and external public debt:
  - NIIP at end-2016: -80 percent of GDP.
  - External debt-to-GDP rose to 93 percent at end-2016 (from 70 percent at end-2014).
- Policy recommendations to mitigate external risks:
  - Maintain exchange rate flexibility as a key shock absorber; limit intervention to dealing with disorderly market conditions.
  - Maintain reserve buffers given vulnerability to external shocks and high dollarization.
  - Shift liability composition from public to private sector and from debt to non-debt creating flows.
  - Continue planned fiscal consolidation to reduce the financing burden on public sector debt.
  - Implement structural reforms to enhance non-price competitiveness, improve the business environment, upgrade physical infrastructure, and boost FDIs and growth in the tradable sector.

### Staff appraisal and program assessment (selected conclusions)
- Authorities’ efforts, backed by their Fund-supported program, helped mitigate shocks and restore macroeconomic stability.
  - Higher fiscal deficits reduced the negative impact on growth.
  - Monetary and financial policies safeguarded financial stability and helped rebuild external buffers.
- Risks ahead:
  - Downside risks include volatile and narrowly based growth, limited trade opportunities, and rising public debt.
- Staff supports the completion of the fifth and final review: all PCs, indicative targets, and structural benchmarks have been met.
- Capacity to repay the Fund is adequate; increased buffers and the results of the DSA suggest that risks to the program going forward are manageable.

_Source: IMF staff report (cr17226) — "Box 1. Improving the Prioritization of Foreign-Financed Capital Expenditure (Concluded)" and associated annexes and tables as provided in the source content unit._

### 1. Improving the Prioritization of Foreign-Financed Capital Expenditure _________________________ 10

### 1. Improving the Prioritization of Foreign-Financed Capital Expenditure

### Key findings on foreign-financed (FF) capital expenditure execution in 2016–17
- Realized FF capital expenditures in 2016 were around $260 million—roughly $100 million or 1 percent of GDP over budget but slightly below the level projected at the time of the fourth review.
- Main contributors to the 2016 over-execution included:
  - catch-up in implementation of the North-South Highway: $23 million;
  - under-budgeting for the rehabilitation of the M6 Highway: $11 million;
  - rural financing: $20 million;
  - partial disbursement of a long-term, low-interest defense loan: $23 million.
- For 2017, the authorities identified around $100 million of high-priority FF project spending that was not included in the 2017 budget.
- Authorities plan to accommodate high-priority projects by raising total capital spending in 2017 to $195 million. Most of these projects are concessional and involve multiple phases and donors (both bilateral and multilateral).
- Projects de-prioritized in the 2017 exercise included the Caucasus Electric Transmission Network, worth around $300 million.

### Analysis and rationale for changing the 2017 capital-spending stance
- The 2017 budget originally envisaged a large fiscal adjustment, primarily by delaying capital expenditure, to meet Armenia’s fiscal rule; the corrective mechanism under the fiscal rule was triggered in 2016 for the first time.
- Given weaker-than-expected GDP growth (larger output gap), high penalties/operational costs from delaying some projects, and limited impact of monetary easing on growth, staff and the authorities agreed that the budgeted large cut in capital spending would be excessively pro-cyclical and sub-optimal.
- Delaying the projects would: (i) exert a sizable negative fiscal impulse when the output gap is relatively large; and (ii) harm future productive capacity.

### Policy decision and fiscal implications
- Staff and the authorities agreed to additional capital spending of around 1 percent of GDP, projected to increase the fiscal deficit by up to ½ percent of GDP.
- Strong revenue overperformance in 2017Q1 (¼ percent of GDP) prompted staff to revise up revenue projections for 2017 by ½ percent of GDP.
- As a result of the additional capital spending and upward revenue revision, the budget deficit for 2017 is projected to increase to 3.3 percent of GDP (½ percent of GDP higher compared to the fourth review).
- The projected 2017 deficit implies a deviation from the existing fiscal rule in 2017; the rule is being revised before end-2017 as part of modernizing the medium-term fiscal framework.
- Despite the higher deficit in 2017, staff projects public debt to start declining in 2019 as before.

### Prioritization methodology for FF projects (criteria used)
- The authorities’ exercise prioritized projects that:
  - are due to be closed by end-2017 or were already 75 percent or more complete as of January 2017;
  - relate to national security;
  - have significant growth and defense impact;
  - are not possible to delay/cancel without significant penalties.

### Projects targeted for increased execution in 2017
- The bulk of the additional expenditure will be used to increase the pace of execution of:
  - the North-South Highway;
  - the M6 Highway;
  - the Vedi Reservoir;
  - irrigation system modernization.

### Key fiscal figures (from Text Table and discussion)
- Overall fiscal balance: -5.6 (2016), -3.3 (2017), -2.7 (2018), -1.7 (2019), -1.3 (2020), -1.4 (2021), -1.3 (2022) [In percent of GDP or percent of potential GDP]
- Cyclically adjusted fiscal balance: -5.1 (2016), -2.6 (2017), -2.2 (2018), -1.3 (2019), -1.0 (2020), -1.2 (2021), -1.3 (2022) [In percent of GDP or percent of potential GDP]
- Cyclically adjusted primary fiscal balance: -3.0 (2016), -0.5 (2017), -0.2 (2018), 0.7 (2019), 0.9 (2020), 0.3 (2021), 0.0 (2022) [In percent of GDP or percent of potential GDP]
- Additional details cited:
  - 2016 realized FF capital expenditures: around $260 million;
  - 2016 over-execution relative to budget: roughly $100 million or 1 percent of GDP;
  - Identified high-priority 2017 FF spending not included in budget: around $100 million;
  - Planned total FF capital spending in 2017 after reprioritization: $195 million;
  - De-prioritized Caucasus Electric Transmission Network: around $300 million;
  - Projected increase in fiscal deficit due to additional spending: up to ½ percent of GDP;
  - Revenue overperformance in 2017Q1: ¼ percent of GDP;
  - Staff upward revision of 2017 revenue projections: ½ percent of GDP;
  - Resulting projected budget deficit for 2017: 3.3 percent of GDP.

*cr17226 — 1. Improving the Prioritization of Foreign-Financed Capital Expenditure*

### Box 1.  Improving the Prioritization of Foreign-Financed Capital Expenditure (Concluded)

### Box 1.  Improving the Prioritization of Foreign-Financed Capital Expenditure (Concluded)

### Prioritization of Foreign-Financed (FF) Capital Expenditure and Medium-Term Plans
- The macroeconomic impact of capital spending is difficult to quantify but is expected to have a positive impact on growth, both in the short and long terms.
- Example projects: the North-South and M6 Highway projects are estimated by donors to have a high economic internal rate of return (15–20 percent), and by improving border access they should, over time, help facilitate trade and improve economic resilience.
- The authorities are extending the prioritization exercise to inform the medium-term fiscal plans.
- The moratorium on signing new commitments currently remains in place, but there is already a large pipeline of approved FF projects for implementation over the medium term.
- Management challenges:
  - The pipeline’s scale and the number of projects will make management challenging, particularly in the context of an ambitious fiscal consolidation plan.
  - Authorities are conducting a similar prioritization exercise to underpin the 2018 budget and their medium-term fiscal plans, balancing potential positive impacts on growth and development with the need to ensure debt sustainability.
- Additional procedural change:
  - A decree extends strict controls over domestically-financed expenditure to future foreign-financed capital projects.
  - Any future commitments will be subject to new registration procedures to ensure consistency with the budget and the medium-term framework, effectively shifting fiduciary functions from Project Implementation Units to the Treasury.

### Monetary and Exchange Rate Policies
- Headline inflation has turned positive but monetary conditions remain relatively tight.
- Inflation expectations remain depressed despite a recent pickup.
- Real interest rates have started to fall but are still high for the current cyclical position.
- Lending rates are not responding well to lower policy rates, in part reflecting risk premia associated with the uncertain economic outlook.
- Staff recommendations and CBA stance:
  - Staff noted that the CBA should remain open to further easing, if justified by data.
  - The CBA argued that, following a series of interest rate cuts over the past 18 months, a pause was justified given stronger activity in 2017Q1, subsiding deflationary pressures, and risks of capital outflows at lower dram interest rates.
  - The CBA expressed concern that lowering the policy rate further could lead to capital outflows and further deposit dollarization.
  - Staff agreed with a data-dependent wait-and-see approach but pointed to still high real interest rates and negative core inflation.
  - Staff emphasized that further monetary easing may be needed as part of a broader adjustment in the macro policy mix to support fiscal policy, while macroprudential policies should continue to be used to address risks relating to dollarization.
  - Monetary policy should be supported by maintaining two-way exchange rate flexibility and adequate external buffers.

### Financial Sector Policy
- Overall assessment: the financial system remains sound, but close monitoring is warranted given the difficult economic environment.
- Key conditions and risks:
  - Higher minimum capital has led to increased competition for lending, which could exert some downward pressure on lending rates and likely lead to further consolidation in the banking sector.
  - Conditions remain challenging with relatively high NPLs, extensive dollarization, low profitability, and high credit concentration.
  - Single largest borrower’s exposures of 4 banks out of 17 exceeded 20 percent of individual banks’ capital at end-2016.
- Regulatory and supervisory developments:
  - Improvements to the macro-prudential framework are being supported by bolstering capital adequacy and liquidity coverage ratios, risk-based supervision in line with Basel III, and are expected to become operational by end-2017.
  - The CBA remains committed to implementing the remaining recommendations of the 2014 Safeguards Assessment.
  - Further legislative changes to the Central Bank Law to strengthen the CBA’s autonomy are expected to be approved by the National Assembly in the second half of the year.
  - The CBA reiterated its commitment to divesting PanArmenian Bank to a private investor by end-2017.

### Structural Reforms
- Reforms focus on improving the business climate and attracting FDI; growing reform momentum under the government appointed in September 2016.
- Institutional initiatives:
  - Center for Strategic Initiatives established in January 2017 to foster PPP, attract FDI, and align developmental goals between investors and line ministries.
  - Establishment of an Armenian-Russian investment fund and the Armenia Investors Club, supported by the diaspora.
- Anti-corruption and governance:
  - Government stepping up efforts to tackle corruption, including improving tax and customs administration.
  - Law on centralized procurement strengthened to ensure a more competitive and transparent procurement process.
- Trade and integration:
  - Negotiations with the EU for adopting a Single Support Framework are advancing.
  - Amendments to economic competition law are expected to be approved by end-2017.
  - Authorities are leveraging EEU membership to promote export diversification, improve standards, enhance domestic competition, and invest in infrastructure, while pursuing greater trade integration beyond the EEU.

### Other Program Issues and Article IV Discussions
- Program continuation:
  - Authorities are considering a successor arrangement to consolidate and extend progress made during the current extended arrangement.
  - Staff view: a new arrangement can provide a strong policy framework to support authorities’ efforts to deal with ongoing external shocks, support medium-term fiscal consolidation, and enable implementation of reforms to promote inclusive growth.
- Macroeconomic context:
  - Armenia faces a period of moderate growth due to lower potential growth in trading partners, sluggish domestic investment, absence of strong growth drivers, and a still-weak business climate.
  - Economy remains vulnerable to external shocks, financial dollarization continues to be high, and public debt has risen sharply.
  - Discussions emphasized more decisive implementation of reforms to reduce vulnerabilities, ensure sustainability, and boost potential growth.

### Advancing Reforms to Preserve Fiscal Sustainability
- Fiscal strategy:
  - Medium-term challenge: preserve debt sustainability while safeguarding essential capital and social spending.
  - Authorities committed to medium-term fiscal consolidation through strengthened revenue mobilization, expenditure management, and structural fiscal reforms (as described in their 2018–20 medium-term fiscal plans).
  - Staff’s Debt Sustainability Analysis (DSA) suggests that, under the projected fiscal path, public debt should remain sustainable, but stay above 50 percent of GDP in the medium term (Annex II: Public DSA).
- Revenue mobilization:
  - Tax revenues increased from 15 percent of GDP in 2002 to 20 percent of GDP in 2016.
  - The new Tax Code enacted in 2016 is expected to raise revenues by about 2 percent of GDP in the medium term.
  - Staff urged rigorous implementation of the new Tax Code and resistance to political pressures to water down its provisions.
  - Staff welcomed recent improvement in tax administration and noted further efforts are needed to strengthen State Review Committee’s (SRC) power to monitor compliance and fight fraud, and to broaden the tax net for fairer sharing of the tax burden.
- Expenditure management:
  - Need to improve expenditure management, especially for capital spending.
  - New mechanism for monitoring and prioritizing projects and completion of the new project database.
  - Decree to extend strict controls and new registration procedures for future FF projects (see Prioritization section).

### Armenia’s Tax Revenue Mobilization: Progresses and Challenges (Box 2 highlights)
- Historical progress:
  - Tax revenues increased from 15 percent of GDP in 2002 to 20 percent of GDP in 2016, largely from comprehensive tax policy and administration reforms.
- Recent problems:
  - Accumulation of unpaid VAT refunds (4 percent of GDP), delayed indexation of certain tax bases, expansion of presumptive taxation, elimination of minimum profit tax, and reduction in turnover tax for traders have eroded collections.
- New Tax Code objectives:
  - Shift balance from direct to indirect taxation (e.g., increasing excise tax rates on alcohol, tobacco, and fuel).
  - Improve equity by broadening the base (e.g., taxation of dividends received by individuals, revising PIT rate schedule).
  - Reduce tax compliance costs by speeding VAT refunds and clarifying tax audit rules.
  - Strengthen SRC’s power to fight fraud and reduce scope of presumptive taxation.
- Further recommended reforms:
  - Broadening PIT base by including capital gains and interest income.
  - Including large agribusiness activities in PIT and corporate income tax bases.
  - Increasing property tax rates and aligning cadastral prices with market values.
  - Strengthening SRC’s monitoring powers by expanding use of taxpayer identification numbers, implementing self-assessment tools, and allowing SRC use of third-party information and audits on high net worth individuals.

### Revamping the Fiscal Rule (Box 3 highlights and staff engagement)
- Current rule:
  - Armenia’s fiscal rule adopted in 2008 lacks features of second-generation rules: no mechanism to mitigate procyclical bias, smooth adjustment after severe shocks, or cope with volatility of foreign-financed projects.
  - Shortcomings could lead to abrupt short-term adjustments, destabilizing aggregate demand and limiting space for capital spending.
- Fund support:
  - Fund is providing TA to overhaul the existing fiscal rule to address these shortcomings.
  - The revised rule will be submitted to the National Assembly in October 2017 together with the 2018 budget.
  - Authorities are committed to rule-based fiscal management and need to clearly communicate the reform’s purpose to improve fiscal management and enhance credibility.
- Implementation caveat:
  - While staff expects the rule to be amended within 2017, in the event it is not, authorities will continue with their fiscal consolidation plan as described in the medium-term fiscal strategy, which will put debt on a declining path by 2019 in line with staff’s projection.

### Modernizing Monetary and Financial Frameworks
- Monetary framework advances:
  - CBA has moved toward an IT regime with the inflation forecast as the intermediate target and the policy interest rate as the main operational target; the move started in 2006.
  - CBA independence strengthened and direct financing of the government prohibited.
  - Decisions and minutes of the CBA Board meetings are published regularly.
  - In 2016 the CBA adopted a review-based monetary policy conditionality under the Fund-supported program.
- Financial stability integration:
  - Macro-economic stress scenario builder being strengthened with more focus on micro-level data.
  - With Fund TA, a structural macro-financial analytical framework is being developed.
  - CBA is strengthening the role of the forecasting and policy analysis system coordinator to establish structured internal communications and to counter risks from assigning dual objectives to one agency.
- Financial sector expansion:
  - Armenia’s financial system has been rapidly growing, albeit from a low base.
  - Banking services expanded, notably branch penetration, which has doubled over the past decade.
  - Increased minimum capital requirement and further consolidation should help provision of financing and increase efficiency.
  - Efforts to develop capital markets include modernizing the settlement and depository system and increased foreign participation in domestic government bond markets.

*Source: IMF staff summary of "Box 1. Improving the Prioritization of Foreign-Financed Capital Expenditure (Concluded)"*

### 0.2 percent at end-2015 to 2 percent at end-March 2017.

### cr17226 - 0.2 percent at end-2015 to 2 percent at end-March 2017.

### Macro-financial risks and banking sector resilience
- Credit-to-GDP ratio is 45 percent.
- Credit gap is currently in negative territory despite a recent pickup in credit.
- Correlation between the credit gap (deviation of credit from trend) and the output gap is relatively strong.
- The CBA’s stress tests suggest improved resilience of the banking system, with a falling number of banks facing liquidity and capital strains under the tests.
- Monetary transmission mechanism remains weak, evidenced by:
  - Difficulties in managing excess liquidity in the system and market interest rates.
  - Fragmented interbank market that limits provision of liquidity in the banking system.
- Policy recommendations:
  - Promote a well-functioning interbank market to strengthen interest-based monetary transmission and macroeconomic policy effectiveness.
  - Develop multi-maturity bond markets to facilitate maturity transformation and improve transmission.
  - Enhance communication and promote de-dollarization to strengthen monetary policy effectiveness.
  - Monitor bank consolidation closely to balance benefits for competition and financial intermediation against “too-big-to-fail” stability concerns.
  - Reduce informality and increase financial education as complements to other measures.
- The CBA has requested an FSAP in 2018 to cover capital market development, modernization of the payment system, and pension reform.

### Financial inclusion and deepening (Box 4)
- Account ownership: only 17 percent of the adult population owns financial accounts.
- Borrowing patterns (2014):
  - 20 percent of adults obtained loans from financial institutions.
  - 27 percent of adults received credit from their family/friends.
- Outstanding deposits and loans with commercial banks in 2015: 28 and 40 percent of GDP respectively.
- Corporate access to finance:
  - Only 46 percent of companies have loan or credit lines with banks.
  - Less than 10 percent of corporate investment is financed by banks.
  - Collateral is required for 89 percent of loans and appears excessive (264 percent of the loan value on average).
- Structural constraints:
  - Banks’ funding relies largely on short-term deposits, constraining medium- and long-term financing.
  - Absence of reliable firms’ financial statements, lack of credit history, and deficiencies in the credit reporting system lead banks to apply high risk premia and require substantial collateral.
- Policy recommendations to strengthen financial deepening:
  - Reduce participation cost and make financial services more affordable to foster financial inclusion.
  - Remove unnecessary borrowing constraints and increase financial intermediation efficiency to support medium-term lending.
  - Improve credit reporting systems and tackle transparency problems in the lending market.
  - Address low levels of financial literacy and inclusion jointly between the CBA and the government.

### External vulnerabilities and resilience
- Current account developments:
  - Current account deficit fell from 7.6 percent of GDP in 2014 to 2.7 percent of GDP in 2016 (driven by a contraction in imports and diversified export performance).
  - Medium-term current account projections are broadly in line with the External Balance Approach (EBA)-lite estimates of a current account deficit norm between 4 to 5 percent of GDP.
- Reserves and buffers:
  - After a rapid drawdown in late-2014, buffers have slowly been rebuilt and are now judged adequate based on the Fund’s Assessing Reserve Adequacy (ARA) metric for floating exchange rate regimes (Armenia’s current de facto classification).
- External public debt and NIIP:
  - Armenia’s large negative net international investment position is a source of concern.
  - External public debt has risen substantially since the last Article IV, largely driven by nominal exchange rate depreciation in 2015, and is projected to fall only gradually over the medium term.
  - External debt is highly sensitive to exchange rate depreciation and to shocks to growth or the current account.
- Policy recommendations to mitigate external risks:
  - Maintain exchange rate flexibility as a key shock absorber; limit intervention to dealing with disorderly market conditions.
  - Maintain reserve buffers given vulnerability to external shocks and high dollarization.
  - Shift liability composition from public to private sector and from debt to non-debt creating flows.
  - Continue planned fiscal consolidation to reduce the financing burden on public sector debt.
  - Maximize the impact of concessional donor financing by effectively managing the large pipeline of capital projects.
  - Implement structural reforms to enhance non-price competitiveness, improve the business environment, upgrade physical infrastructure, and boost FDIs and growth in the tradable sector.

### Achieving sustainable inclusive growth and labor market challenges
- Poverty and inequality:
  - Poverty declined during the 2000s but was partially reversed after the global crisis and remains on the high side with significant regional disparities.
  - Inequality as measured by the Gini index and the decile dispersion ratio is relatively low but worsening since the crisis.
  - Recent growth has benefitted high-income groups more, partly due to the fall in construction activity.
- Unemployment:
  - Unemployment reached 18 percent at end-2016, concentrated in urban areas and among youth and women.
  - Massive emigration has shrunk the labor force, but the economy has not generated enough jobs to prevent high unemployment.
- Recommendations to raise potential growth and reduce unemployment and poverty:
  - Close infrastructure gaps, diversify the production base, reduce economic informality, and deepen financial intermediation.
  - Increase competition and reduce barriers to entry in the private sector to provide sustainable growth and employment.
  - Increase public spending on education, health, and infrastructure to foster inclusive growth.
  - Implement decisive policies to improve labor market conditions, the quality of education, and the business environment.
  - Strengthen centralized procurement, improve tax and customs administration, and reduce the informal economy via legislative amendments.

### Fiscal and monetary policy guidance
- Fiscal policy:
  - Given fragile growth and a negative output gap, the planned large cut in capital spending envisaged in the 2017 budget and triggered by the fiscal rule is inappropriate.
  - Staff supports the authorities’ planned increase in concessional foreign-financed capital expenditure by about 1 percent of GDP.
  - To ensure debt sustainability, enhance revenue mobilization and increase efficiency in spending.
  - Rigorously implement the new Tax Code and strengthen SRC’s powers to monitor tax compliance.
  - Amend the existing fiscal rule to improve flexibility and consideration for cyclical conditions; ensure robust communication to justify revisions.
- Monetary policy:
  - Remain focused on bringing inflation back to its medium-term target, with the exchange rate acting as a key shock absorber.
  - The CBA should monitor the impact of recent policy actions and assess the need for further easing.
  - Two-way exchange rate flexibility and limiting intervention to dealing with disorderly market conditions should ensure adjustment to changes in fundamentals.
- Financial sector policy:
  - Increase effectiveness of the IT framework by improving the monetary transmission mechanism, developing a well-functioning interbank market, and enhancing communication.
  - Continue implementing 2012 FSAP recommendations and strengthen financial sector resilience (including by increasing minimum capital requirement).
  - Further develop capital markets and strengthen financial literacy to foster better financial intermediation.

### Staff appraisal and program assessment
- Armenia faced significant external challenges since late 2014 that impeded policy implementation and program performance.
- Authorities’ efforts, backed by their Fund-supported program, helped mitigate shocks and restore macroeconomic stability.
  - Higher fiscal deficits reduced the negative impact on growth.
  - Monetary and financial policies safeguarded financial stability and helped rebuild external buffers.
- Risks and challenges ahead:
  - Outlook is clouded by downside risks: volatile and narrowly based growth, limited trade opportunities, and rising public debt.
- Support for program actions:
  - Staff supports the completion of the fifth and final review: all PCs, indicative targets, and structural benchmarks have been met.
  - Capacity to repay the Fund is adequate.
  - Increased buffers and the results of the DSA suggest that risks to the program going forward are manageable.

*Source: IMF staff report (cr17226) as provided.*

### 49.      Staff recommends that the next Article IV Consultations be concluded on the standard

### cr17226 - 49.      Staff recommends that the next Article IV Consultations be concluded on the standard 12-month cycle, in accordance with Decision No. 14747-(10/96), as amended.

### Recommendation
- Staff recommends that the next Article IV Consultations be concluded on the standard 12-month cycle, in accordance with Decision No. 14747-(10/96), as amended.

### Selected economic and financial indicators (highlights from Table 1)
- Real GDP (percent change): 3.3, 3.6, 3.2, 2.4, 0.2, 2.7, 2.9, 2.9, 3.0 (2013–2019 series as listed).
- CPI (period average; percent change): 5.8, 3.0, 3.7, -1.4, -1.4, 1.6, 1.7, 3.5, 4.0.
- Investment (in percent of GDP): 20.7, 20.8, 20.9, 21.7, 21.2, 21.8, 22.2, 22.3, 22.3.
- National savings (in percent of GDP): 13.4, 13.2, 18.3, 18.7, 18.5, 17.8, 18.4, 19.2, 19.3.
- Overall balance on a cash basis (central government, in percent of GDP): -1.0, -2.1, -4.8, -5.9, -5.6, -2.8, -3.3, -2.7, -1.7.
- Public and publicly-guaranteed debt (in percent of GDP): 40.8, 43.6, 48.7, 54.7, 55.1, 56.4, 55.7, 57.0, 56.4.
- Current account balance (in percent of GDP): -7.3, -7.6, -2.6, -2.9, -2.7, -4.0, -3.8, -3.2, -3.0.
- Gross international reserves (in millions of U.S. dollars): 2,253, 1,489, 1,771, 1,953, 2,204, 1,981, 2,259, 2,458, 2,755.
- Import cover (months): 4.9, 4.0, 4.7, 5.0, 5.2, 5.0, 5.2, 5.4, 5.8.
- GDP (in billions of drams): 4,556; 4,829; 5,044; 5,151; 5,076; 5,405; 5,362; 5,710; 6,117.

### Balance of payments (highlights from Table 2)
- Current account (in millions of U.S. dollars): -813, -883, -279, -312, -285, -418, -362, -363, -466, -584, -677 (2013–2022 series).
- Trade balance (in millions of U.S. dollars): -2,196, -2,055, -1,186, -880, -944, -1,050, -960, -926, -993, -1,115, -1,241.
- Exports, fob (in millions of U.S. dollars): 1,636, 1,698, 1,624, 1,856, 1,891, 2,212, 2,420, 2,610, 2,701, 2,770, 2,844.
- Imports, fob (in millions of U.S. dollars): -3,832, -3,754, -2,810, -2,736, -2,835, -3,262, -3,380, -3,537, -3,695, -3,885, -4,085.
- Capital and financial account (in millions of U.S. dollars): 1,758, 346, 720, 385, 945, 432, 612, 718, 641, 773, 677.
- Foreign direct investment (net, in millions of U.S. dollars): 475, 388, 162, 272, 281, 402, 344, 354, 365, 378, 393.
- Gross international reserves (end of period, in millions of U.S. dollars): 2,253, 1,489, 1,771, 1,953, 2,204, 2,259, 2,458, 2,755, 2,869, 3,002, 2,864.
- Nominal external debt (in millions of U.S. dollars): 8,682, 8,274, 8,902, 9,402, 9,803, 10,189, 10,396, 10,690, 10,898, 11,231, 11,478.

### Monetary accounts (highlights from Table 3)
- Reserve money (end of period, in billions of drams): 888.1, 886.8, 921.3, 849.8, 777.0, 897.9, 1,042.3, 970.5, 977.0, 1,001.7, 1,074.0, 1,195.3 (selected quarterly and annual points shown).
- Broad money (end of period, in billions of drams): 1,552.1, 1,689.8, 1,869.8, 1,890.0, 1,942.1, 2,022.0, 2,180.1, 2,219.7, 2,216.6, 2,242.4, 2,363.9, 2,608.5.
- 12-month change in reserve money (in percent): 29.9, -0.1, 3.9, 7.3, -5.0, 2.3, 13.1, 14.2, 25.7, 11.6, 3.0, 11.3.
- 12-month change in broad money (in percent): 15.2, 8.9, 10.7, 15.4, 12.7, 15.5, 16.6, 17.4, 14.1, 10.9, 8.4, 10.3.
- Net international reserves (NIR, program definition, USD millions): 1,068; 796; 1,013; 896; 945; 1,038; 1,315; 1,269; 1,323; 1,407; 1,486; 1,646 (memorandum).

### Financial soundness indicators for banking sector (highlights from Table 4)
- Total regulatory capital to risk-weighted assets (percent): 16.7, 14.5, 15.1, 15.4, 15.7, 16.2, 17.3, 17.4, 18.4, 20.0, 20.0.
- Nonperforming loans to gross loans (percent): 4.5, 6.8, 8.1, 9.0, 8.4, 7.8, 10.0, 9.2, 9.7, 6.7, 6.8.
- Provisions to nonperforming loans (percent): 49.5, 41.3, 39.1, 38.1, 40.7, 42.9, 40.6, 46.0, 47.5, 52.0, 52.5.
- ROA (profits to period average assets): 1.9, 1.0, -0.2, -0.3, -0.3, -0.5, 0.2, 0.5, 0.5, 1.1, 1.1.
- ROE (profits to period average equity): 12.0, 6.4, -1.7, -1.8, -2.4, -3.5, 1.0, 3.3, 3.2, 7.0, 6.4.
- Foreign exchange loans to total loans (percent): 63.8, 64.7, 67.7, 67.1, 66.7, 66.7, 67.9, 67.1, 67.3, 64.6, 64.1.

### Central government operations (selected items from Tables 5 and 6)
- Total revenue and grants (in billions of drams): 1011.5, 1064.6, 1084.1, 1090.3, 1085.2, 1180.5, 1199.6, 1,276.0, 1,404.3 (annual series shown).
- Total revenue (in billions of drams): 1000.7, 1050.1, 1056.3, 1054.7, 1056.9, 1,152.8, 1,171.9, 1,252.0, 1,390.8.
- Tax revenues (in billions of drams): 956.6, 1,018.4, 1,011.3, 1,003.5, 1,016.2, 1,091.1, 1,110.2, 1,185.2, 1,306.8.
- Total expenditure (in billions of drams): 1,084.1, 1,158.4, 1,328.0, 1,395.6, 1,370.6, 1,330.6, 1,374.7, 1,429.8, 1,508.0.
- Overall balance (below-the-line, in billions of drams): -43.9, -101.4, -244.0, -305.3, -295.6, -150.1, -175.1, -153.8, -103.7.
- Program balance (memorandum, in percent of GDP): -0.9, -3.3, -5.9, -6.9, -7.2, -3.3, -3.8, -3.5, -2.3.
- Debt-creating fiscal balance (memorandum, in percent of GDP): -1.1, -2.8, -6.1, -6.8, -6.6, -3.7, -4.2, -3.6, -2.5.

### Medium-term macroeconomic framework (highlights from Table 7)
- Real GDP (percent change, projections): 2.9 (2017), 3.0 (2018), 3.1 (2019), 3.4 (2020), 4.0 (2021).
- Gross domestic product (in millions of U.S. dollars): 11,121; 11,610; 10,553; 10,565; 10,969; 11,453; 12,028; 12,632; 13,319 (2013–2021 series).
- Investment (percent of GDP): 20.7, 20.8, 20.9, 21.2, 22.2, 22.3, 22.3, 22.2, 22.6, 22.6.
- Public and publicly-guaranteed debt (percent of GDP, memorandum): 40.8, 43.6, 48.7, 54.7, 55.1, 57.0, 56.4, 54.6, 53.6, 52.4.
- Current account (in percent of GDP, projection path): -3.8 (2017), -3.2 (2018), -3.0 (2019), -3.7 (2020), -4.4 (2021), -4.8 (2022).

### Indicators of capacity to repay the Fund (highlights from Table 8)
- Fund obligations based on existing credit (principal, in millions of SDRs): 180.2, 98.1, 17.9, 25.7, 33.1, 45.2, 52.8, 54.6, 50.7 (2013–2021 series).
- Total obligations based on existing and prospective credit (in millions of SDRs): 185.7, 100.5, 19.5, 27.6, 34.8, 48.2, 55.5, 56.9, 52.5.
- Total obligations (in millions of U.S. dollars): 282.2, 152.6, 27.3, 38.4, 46.8, 64.7, 64.7, 76.5, 70.6.
- Total obligations as percent of gross international reserves: 12.5, 10.2, 1.5, 1.7, 2.1, 2.6, 2.7, 2.7, 2.4.
- Outstanding Fund credit based on existing credit (in millions of SDRs): 379.7, 305.1, 299.0, 304.6, 269.6, 224.4, 171.6, 117.0, 67.6.
- Outstanding Fund credit (in millions of U.S. dollars): 577.0, 463.4, 418.3, 423.3, 362.3, 301.1, 230.5, 157.2, 90.9.
- Outstanding Fund credit as percent of gross international reserves: 25.6, 31.1, 23.6, 19.2, 16.0, 12.3, 8.4, 5.5, 3.0.

### External financing requirements and sources (highlights from Table 9)
- Gross Financing Requirements (in millions of U.S. dollars): 1,054 (2014), 1,414 (2015), 1,387 (2016), 1,245 (2017), 1,343 (2018).
- External current account deficit (excl. transfers, in millions of U.S. dollars): 1,628, 846, 847, 1,024, 987.
- Debt amortization and Fund repurchases (in millions of U.S. dollars): 190, 287, 107, 133, 167.
- Gross international reserve accumulation (in millions of U.S. dollars): -764, 282, 433, 88, 189.
- Available financing (in millions of U.S. dollars): 1,054, 1,414, 1,387, 1,123, 1,343.
- Financing gap / Exceptional financing (in millions of U.S. dollars): 0, 0, 0, 1, 2, 1, 0 (as presented in table layout).

### Purchases from the Fund and timing under the three-year EFF (highlights from Table 10)
- March 7, 2014 (Board approval of the arrangement): Amount 11.74 (millions of SDRs); Percent of Quota 12.76.
- September 30, 2014 (completion of first review): Amount 11.74 (millions of SDRs); Percent of Quota 12.76.
- March 30, 2015 (completion of second review): Amount 11.74 (millions of SDRs); Percent of Quota 12.76.
- March 30, 2016 (completion of third review): Amount 15.65 (millions of SDRs); Percent of Quota 12.15.
- September 30, 2016 (completion of fourth review): Amount 15.65 (millions of SDRs); Percent of Quota 12.15.
- March 30, 2017 (completion of fifth review): Amount 15.69 (millions of SDRs); Percent of Quota 12.18.
- Total under EFF: 82.21 (millions of SDRs); 63.83 percent of quota.

*Source: IMF staff report tables and text as provided in the source content unit.*

### Annex I. Risk Assessment Matrix

### Annex I. Risk Assessment Matrix

### Global risks — nature, likelihood, impact, and policy responses
- Policy and geopolitical uncertainties
  - Relative likelihood: High
  - Staff assessment: High/Medium
  - Possible impact: Lower global growth and trade, move toward protectionism could create a hostile environment for trade, which could adversely affect Armenia. Intensification of tension in neighboring countries in the Middle East and renewed sanctions on Iran could also reduce trade and investment.
  - Policy response:
    - Prepare and implement contingency plans for potential trade and financial spillovers.
    - Maintain exchange rate flexibility.
    - Strengthen social safety nets to cushion impact of shocks on most vulnerable sectors.
- Financial conditions (stronger US dollar and/or higher rates)
  - Relative likelihood: High
  - Staff assessment: Medium
  - Possible impact: A stronger US dollar could harm Armenia’s highly dollarized banking system with an expected increase in NPLs in dollar. An appreciation of the dollar against other currencies could also harm the trade balance in case the dram does not depreciate.
  - Policy response:
    - Continue the de-dollarization efforts.
    - Maintain exchange rate flexibility.
    - Strengthen banking supervision and provision in the event of higher NPLs in dollar.
- Weaker-than-expected global growth (including significant China slowdown)
  - Relative likelihood: Low/Medium (China slowdown: Likelihood low in short-term, medium thereafter); Medium for significant slowdown in other large EMs/frontier economies; High/Medium for structurally weak growth in key advanced and emerging economies
  - Staff assessment: Medium
  - Possible impact: Mining exports would be hit. Remittances could fall further if economic growth in major trading partners remains sluggish.
  - Policy response:
    - Diversify export destination and products.
    - Accelerate structural reforms to improve the business climate for FDI.
    - Strengthen social safety nets to cushion the impact of shocks.
- Lower energy prices
  - Relative likelihood: Low
  - Staff assessment: Medium/High
  - Possible impact: Negative indirect effects via major trading partners.
  - Policy response:
    - Diversify trade partners.
    - Improve the business climate for international investors.

### Country-specific risks — nature, likelihood, impact, and policy responses
- Large fiscal adjustment
  - Assessment: Low
  - Staff assessment: Low
  - Possible impact: Large fiscal adjustment can adversely impact growth when fiscal policy needs to support the nascent recovery; slippages could endanger debt sustainability.
  - Policy response:
    - Modify the current fiscal rule to preserve debt sustainability while allowing a smoother adjustment in the event of shocks to protect short-term growth.
  - Additional note: The planned backloading of the adjustment should mitigate the impact on growth and could reduce the possibility of slippages.
- Regional conflict (Nagorno-Karabakh-related tensions)
  - Assessment: High/Medium
  - Staff assessment: High/Medium
  - Possible impact: Severe impacts, including possible regional military action.
  - Policy response:
    - Prepare and implement contingency plans.

---

### Annex II. Public Debt Sustainability Analysis — key findings, projections, and stress tests

### Background and recent drivers
- Main driver of public debt increase: Widening of the fiscal deficit due to subdued economic activity, weaker-than-budgeted revenue, and stepped up capital spending.
- Gross debt-to-GDP ratio: rose to 55 percent in 2016.
- Fiscal rule requirement: fiscal deficit next year should be no more than 3 percent of the average GDP of the previous three years (equivalent to about 2.8 percent of 2017 GDP).
- Share of external debt: decreased slightly in 2016 to 84 percent of total debt.
- Domestic debt: rose by 36 percent in 2016 due to increased issuance of dram-denominated government securities.

### DSA assumptions and baseline projections
- Real GDP growth projection for 2017: revised up slightly relative to the fourth review.
- Potential growth: revised down in the medium term, now 1 percent lower than the pre-crisis period.
- Inflation: expected to return slowly to the authorities’ 4 percent target over the medium term.
- Tax collection: expected to be ½ percent of GDP higher than budgeted in 2017.
- Foreign-financed capital expenditure: expected to be 1 percent of GDP higher than budgeted, bringing the overall fiscal deficit to around 3.3 percent of GDP.
- Primary deficit (including net lending) projected to be cut to 1.8 percent of GDP in 2017.

### Public DSA results and medium-term outlook
- Total public debt projections:
  - Projected to reach 56 percent of GDP in 2017 and increase further in 2018 before starting to decline.
- Gross financing needs:
  - Expected to decline gradually from around 6 percent of GDP in 2017 as consolidation continues.
- Financing composition:
  - External financing primarily on concessional terms (project-related loans and budget support from multilateral donors).
  - Domestic financing increasing but expected to remain relatively small with increasing average maturity.
- Debt dynamics:
  - Debt stabilizes and starts to decline after 2019 under the baseline, reflecting favorable developments captured in the interest-growth differential.

### Uncertainty and vulnerability indicators
- Fan chart (symmetric distribution): public debt-to-GDP range between 41 and 73 percent (10th–90th percentile) in 2017 and between 25 and 94 percent in 2022.
- Asymmetric fan chart (rules out real exchange rate appreciation): debt could range between 40 and 108 percent of GDP (10th–90th percentile) at the end of the projection horizon.
- Key vulnerability: high share of FX-denominated debt and debt held by non-residents.
  - Mitigating factors: over 90 percent of debt is long-term, mostly provided by official creditors, and at fixed interest rates.

### Scenarios and stress-test findings
- Constant primary balance and historical-average scenarios:
  - Debt ratio rises to over 60 percent and financing needs to close to 10 percent of GDP in 2022 if the primary balance remains at the current level.
  - Implication: without active policy measures to reduce the fiscal deficit, debt sustainability would be jeopardized.
- Stress tests:
  - Real GDP growth shock (adverse shock: real GDP contracts by 4 percent in 2018–19): public debt increases to 77 percent of GDP, and public gross financing needs exceed 7 percent of GDP by 2019.
  - Stress tests based on standardized primary balance, real interest, and exchange rate shocks show moderate deterioration relative to baseline, with real exchange rate depreciation having a somewhat larger impact.
- Additional stress test scenarios presented:
  - Primary Balance Shock, Real GDP Growth Shock, Real Interest Rate Shock, Real Exchange Rate Shock, Combined Shock.
  - Stress test outcomes highlight that real GDP growth shocks have the largest impact on debt indicators.

### DSA quantitative highlights (selected exact figures from baseline projections)
- Structure of government debt (percent of total), Dec-15 vs Mar-17:
  - By initial maturity:
    - Short-term: 1.0 / 1.7
    - Medium-term: 6.9 / 8.6
    - Long-term: 92.2 / 89.7
  - By type of interest rate:
    - Floating: 10.5 / 12.5
    - Fixed: 89.5 / 87.5
- Baseline public-sector debt table (as of May 04, 2017) — selected rows:
  - Nominal gross public debt: 33.2 (2015), 48.7 (2016), 55.1 (2017), 55.7 (2018), 57.0 (2019), 56.4 (2020), 54.6 (2021), 53.6 (2022), 52.4 (projection years per table).
  - Public gross financing needs: 6.5 (2015), 9.7 (2016), 9.3 (2017), 5.3 (2018), 4.2 (2019), 2.4 (2020), 3.6 (2021), 1.5 (2022), 3.3 (projection years per table).
  - Net public debt: 41.2 (2015), 47.7 (2016), 48.8 (2017), 50.2 (2018), 49.7 (2019), 49.4 (2020), 48.8 (2021), 48.4 (2022).
  - Real GDP growth (in percent): 4.5 (2015), 3.3 (2016), 0.2 (2017), 2.9 (2018), 2.9 (2019), 3.0 (2020), 3.1 (2021), 3.4 (2022), 4.0 (projection endpoint).
  - Inflation (GDP deflator, in percent): 4.5 (2015), 1.2 (2016), 0.5 (2017), 2.6 (2018), 3.5 (2019), 4.0 (2020), 4.0 (2021), 4.0 (2022).
  - Nominal GDP growth (in percent): 9.3 (2015), 4.5 (2016), 0.6 (2017), 5.6 (2018), 6.5 (2019), 7.1 (2020), 7.2 (2021), 7.5 (2022), 8.2 (projection endpoint).
  - Effective interest rate (in percent): 2.4 (2015), 3.5 (2016), 4.0 (2017), 3.5 (2018), 3.7 (2019), 3.6 (2020), 3.5 (2021), 2.8 (2022), 2.6 (projection years per table).
  - Change in gross public sector debt (cumulative): 2.1 (2015), 5.0 (2016), 66.4 (2017) [note: table shows "66.4" which should be preserved as presented], 50.6 (2018), 1.3 (2019), -0.6 (2020), -1.8 (2021), -1.0 (2022), -1.2 (subsequent), -2.7 (final).
  - Primary deficit: 3.4 (2015), 4.5 (2016), 5.2 (2017), 1.8 (2018), 2.0 (2019), 0.8 (2020), -0.9 (2021), 0.6 (2022), 0.8 (cumulative 5.1).
  - Primary (noninterest) revenue and grants: 20.9 (2015), 21.5 (2016), 21.4 (2017), 22.4 (2018), 22.3 (2019), 23.0 (2020), 23.1 (2021), 23.2 (2022), cumulative 137.2.
  - Primary (noninterest) expenditure: 24.3 (2015), 26.0 (2016), 26.6 (2017), 24.2 (2018), 24.3 (2019), 23.8 (2020), 22.1 (2021), 23.8 (2022), cumulative 142.3.
- Stress test example (Real GDP Growth Shock scenario table rows):
  - Real GDP growth under shock: 2.9 (2017), -4.2 (2018), -4.1 (2019), 3.1 (2020), 3.4 (2021), 4.0 (2022).
  - Primary balance under shock: -1.8 (2017), -4.2 (2018), -5.4 (2019), 0.9 (2020), -0.6 (2021), -0.8 (2022).

*Source: IMF staff.*

### Annex III. External Stability Assessment

### Annex III. External Stability Assessment

### Current Account
- Since the global financial crisis, Armenia’s current account deficit peaked in 2009 at around 16 percent of GDP and fell steadily to around 7 percent of GDP in 2014.
- Drivers of consolidation:
  - fiscal consolidation in 2009–11;
  - rising remittances in 2012–13.
- Since the last Article IV, the current account deficit fell to below 3 percent of GDP, driven by a strengthening of the trade balance.
- Recent dynamics:
  - dramatic decline in imports reflecting reduced remittances and weak domestic demand;
  - relatively strong export growth despite falling international prices, supported by the opening of a new copper mine in 2015 and diversification into non-traditional markets and products;
  - Armenia’s entry into the EEU represents an important structural change with uncertain trade impacts during transition.
- Outlook and projection:
  - current account deficit projected to rise gradually, to around 5 percent of GDP by 2022;
  - reasons: near-term slowdown in export growth due to weak external environment, a boost to exports from the opening of a new gold mine from 2018 onwards, and recovery of imports driven by pick-up in remittances and domestic demand;
  - EEU membership increases uncertainty about trade outlook (temporary vs. permanent effects).

### Capital and Financial Account
- 2015–16 composition of flows:
  - dominated by a Eurobond issuance of $500m in March 2015;
  - increased government borrowing from multilateral and bilateral donors, mostly on concessional terms.
- FDI developments:
  - FDI dropped significantly in 2015 to around a third of the 2012–14 average;
  - partial recovery in 2016 largely due to inflows into financial institutions to meet mandatory capital requirements rather than to the real economy;
  - weakness in FDI reflects lower reinvested earnings, large sales in telecommunications and mining, and lower “fresh” flows.
- Policy implications and recommendations:
  - no immediate financing concerns, but efficient management of concessional government borrowing and boosting FDI would reduce potential future pressures;
  - donor financing for a $2 billion pipeline of capital projects is in place—challenge is to manage and prioritize the pipeline balancing growth and debt sustainability;
  - Eurobond repayment is due in 2020;
  - broader structural reforms to improve the business environment and upgrade transportation infrastructure would facilitate non-debt creating flows and tradable-sector growth.

### Net International Investment Position (NIIP)
- At end-2016, NIIP reached -80 percent of GDP, up from -30 percent of GDP in 2007.
- External liabilities have tilted towards debt, which now amount to over 60 percent of GDP.
- Mitigating factors:
  - most debt liabilities are long-term and the majority of government liabilities are concessional (reflecting recent transition from low-income to emerging market status);
  - NIIP has been relatively stable since the large 2009 deterioration (averaging around 75 percent of GDP);
  - current account balance and reserve buffers have strengthened significantly since the last Article IV in 2014.
- Risks and recommendations:
  - size and composition of NIIP and recent flow trajectories indicate potential for future external vulnerabilities;
  - attracting FDI and generating private sector-led growth would reduce dependence on external government borrowing and improve balance-sheet resilience.

### Reserve Adequacy
- Gross international reserves increased to $2.2 billion at end-2016.
- Drivers of reserve rebuilding: strong export receipts, large multilateral and bilateral donor disbursements, and limited FX sales by the CBA.
- IMF ARA metric assessment:
  - under the Fund’s ARA metric for floating exchange rate regimes (the current de facto classification), reserves were around 116 percent at end-2016 and projected to remain stable through 2018;
  - reserves would be around 80 percent of the ARA metric for “non-floating” regimes.
- Policy implications:
  - highlights importance of authorities’ commitment to continued two-way exchange rate flexibility;
  - exchange rate should continue to act as key shock absorber;
  - authorities should aim to retain reserve buffers given vulnerability to shocks and high dollarization, only drawing down to counteract excessive exchange rate volatility.

### External Balance Assessment
- EBA-lite results and staff interpretation:
  - External sustainability (ES) approach: estimates a current account norm of -4.7 percent of GDP to stabilize Net IIP over 20 years at the end-2016 level of -79.8 percent of GDP; compared with medium-term projection for the current account of -4.8 percent of GDP, implying a current account gap of -0.1 percent.
  - Stabilizing IIP at -75 percent of GDP (average since 2008) implies CA norm of -4.5 percent of GDP and a CA gap of -0.3 percent.
  - Current account (CA) approach: suggests CA norm of -6.7 percent of GDP for 2016 relative to actual balance of -2.7 percent of GDP, implying a CA gap of 4.0 percent of GDP (± 1 percent) and a policy gap of -0.3 percent of GDP.
    - staff view: stronger CA norm needed to mitigate external vulnerabilities; underlying actual CA reflects temporary factors not fully captured by model—particularly large contraction in imports.
  - REER approach implies an overvaluation of 13 percent (±4 percent); CPI-based REER ended 2016 roughly at same level as 2015.
- Staff-assessment summary:
  - places special emphasis on ES approach given large negative NIIP;
  - adopts CA norm of -4.7 percent of GDP (ES) as more appropriate than -6.7 percent (CA approach);
  - medium-term CA projection of -4.8 percent of GDP considered more useful than underlying CA of -2.7 percent;
  - staff-assessed current account gap of -0.1 percent of GDP, equating to a slight REER overvaluation of 0.4 percent (±4 percent);
  - conclusion: current account and REER remain broadly in line with fundamentals and desirable policies.

### External Debt Sustainability
- External debt metrics and trajectory:
  - external debt-to-GDP ratio rose to 93 percent of GDP at end-2016, up from 70 percent at end-2014 and a low of 30 percent in 2008;
  - projected to peak in 2017 and gradually fall to around 82 percent by end-2022.
- Drivers of historical increase:
  - larger external current account deficits combined with lower growth after global crisis;
  - sizable nominal depreciation and increase in external public borrowing since 2014, including the 2015 Eurobond and higher multilateral disbursements.
- Projected composition:
  - public sector debt projected to grow more quickly than private sector debt.
- Key assumptions and contributions to improvement:
  - stronger current account is key driver of improvement over medium term;
  - non-interest current account deficit projected to remain significantly below estimated debt-stabilizing level of 5.4 percent of GDP;
  - non-debt creating flows expected to continue offsetting the non-interest current account deficit;
  - debt dynamics aided by projected pickup in growth and fall in nominal external interest rates.
- Vulnerabilities to shocks:
  - shocks to growth, the non-interest current account, and the combined shock scenario raise external debt to between 93 and 97 percent of GDP by the end of the projection period;
  - a one-time 30 percent real ER depreciation would increase the debt ratio to over 120 percent of GDP by 2022, reflecting high share of foreign currency debt;
  - impact of interest rate shocks limited due to large share of concessional financing in external public debt.
- Selected baseline and scenario figures (from projections table):
  - Baseline external debt: 70.2 (2012), 78.1 (2013), 71.3 (2014), 84.4 (2015), 92.8 (2016), 93.7 (2017), 91.5 (2018), 89.6 (2019), 87.0 (2020), 85.0 (2021), 82.7 (2022);
  - Debt-stabilizing non-interest current account: -5.4 (percent of GDP).
- Gross external financing need:
  - in billions of US dollars: 2.7 (2012), 2.6 (2013), 2.5 (2014), 1.9 (2015), 1.4 (2016), 2.0 (2017), 1.8 (2018), 1.8 (2019), 2.4 (2020), 2.0 (2021), 2.1 (2022);
  - in percent of GDP: 25.1 (2012), 23.8 (2013), 21.9 (2014), 17.6 (2015), 13.7 (2016), 10-Year and 10-Year values shown in table context.
- Key macro assumptions (selected):
  - Real GDP growth (in percent): 7.1 (2012), 3.3 (2013), 3.6 (2014), 3.3 (2015), 0.2 (2016), 3.1 (2017), 7.1 (2018), 2.9 (2019), 2.9 (2020), 3.0 (2021), 3.1 (2022), 3.4 (historical), 4.0 (deviation).
  - Nominal external interest rate (in percent): 3.1 (2012), 3.3 (2013), 3.4 (2014), 4.0 (2015), 4.1 (2016), 2.4 (2017), 2.3 (2018), 4.0 (2019), 3.7 (2020), 3.6 (2021), 3.5 (2022), 3.1 (historical), 2.9 (deviation).
  - Growth of exports (US dollar terms, in percent): 6.4 (2012), 8.2 (2013), 5.2 (2014), -5.5 (2015), 11.6 (2016), 9.5 (2017), 8.9 (2018), 10.6 (2019), 6.7 (2020), 5.9 (2021), 3.3 (2022), 2.7 (historical), 4.2 (deviation).
  - Growth of imports (US dollar terms, in percent): 4.3 (2012), 6.7 (2013), 0.2 (2014), -19.5 (2015), 3.4 (2016), 8.8 (2017), 18.8 (2018), 11.2 (2019), 3.8 (2020), 4.4 (2021), 4.3 (2022), 4.7 (historical), 5.2 (deviation).

_Annex III. External Stability Assessment (IMF staff report content)._

### 2. Economic performance has remained subdued due to the continued adverse external

### 2. Economic performance has remained subdued due to the continued adverse external environment and the slow recovery of domestic demand

### Economic performance and outlook
- 2016 real GDP growth: 0.2 percent.
- End-2016 headline CPI inflation: -1.1 percent.
- Current account deficit in 2016: 2.7 percent of GDP (same level as 2015).
- Fiscal deficit in 2016: widened to 5.6 percent (compared with the revised program target of 5.9 percent of GDP).
- Central Bank policy rate: cut to 6 percent.
- Banking sector: all banks satisfy the higher minimum capital requirement; concerns about low profitability and high dollarization persist.
- Early-2017 indicators (first three months): exports continue to grow strongly; remittances appear to be picking up; imports and domestic demand are recovering; tax revenues are rising.
- Headline CPI inflation turned positive in April 2017, while non-food price inflation remained negative.
- Risks: Armenia remains vulnerable to external shocks, including setbacks in key trading partners’ growth and the uncertain outlook for commodity markets (remittances and copper prices channels).

### Key recent program performance
- All end-December and continuous performance criteria (PCs) were met, along with the program inflation target.
- End-December indicative ceiling for net domestic assets of the central bank and the social expenditure floor were met.
- December and March structural benchmarks (SBs) were met:
  - Mechanism to strengthen monitoring and prioritizing foreign-financed capital projects (December 2016 SB).
  - Centralized database of all ongoing, planned, and pledged projects built (March 2017 SB).
  - 2017 budget secured funding for the Pension System Awareness Center (December 2016 SB).
  - CBA prepared a plan for divestment of PanArmenian Bank (December 2016 SB).

### Request to IMF Executive Board
- Request that the IMF Executive Board complete the Fifth Review of the EFF-supported program and approve the associated disbursement in an amount equivalent to SDR 15.69 million.

---

### Fiscal policy: assessment, measures, and outlook
- 2016 revenue shortfalls driven by: weak domestic demand; change in composition of imports reducing the taxable base; declining receipts from the EEU customs pool; larger-than-anticipated effects of past policy changes.
- 2016 countercyclical over-execution of foreign-financed capital projects (catch-up of previously delayed projects) contributed to the fiscal outcome, pushing general government debt above 50 percent of GDP and triggering the debt brake mechanism.
- 2017 budget envisaged a large adjustment: overall deficit target of 2.8 percent of GDP, mostly via substantial reduction in foreign-financed capital expenditure; moratorium on signing new foreign-financed projects; discussions with donors to postpone or restructure some projects.

Fiscal developments in 2017 and adjustments:
- Q1 2017 tax collection over-performed by AMD 13 billion (around 0.25 percent of GDP) relative to budget projections.
- Revised up 2017 revenue projections by around AMD 50 billion (1 percent of GDP).
- Identified around $100 million (1 percent of GDP) of additional high-priority foreign-financed spending for 2017 that would be economically inappropriate to discontinue or delay; proceeding with these projects would allow a less dramatic cut in capital spending while still complying with the 2.8 percent of GDP deficit target.
- Under the revised plan, the domestically-financed deficit would not increase relative to the 2017 budget.
- Authorities stand ready to implement contingency measures in case downside risks materialize and will protect social spending on education, health, and social benefits.

Medium-term fiscal commitments:
- Objective to put debt on a downward path by 2019 and maintain central government debt below 60 percent of GDP in the medium term.
- Medium-Term Expenditure Framework to be updated in May 2017 and will require a fiscal deficit in 2018 of less than 3 percent of GDP.
- Commitment to implement the Tax Code and other revenue-enhancing tax policy measures, including improving property taxation and strengthening revenue administration to reduce informality.

Fiscal rule reform:
- Existing fiscal rule (enacted 2008) judged inflexible and pro-cyclical; lacks smooth correction mechanism and escape clauses.
- IMF technical assistance requested (scheduled for June 2017) to revise the fiscal rule and strengthen the fiscal framework; goal to complete technical work and stakeholder consultation to send a draft fiscal rule to the National Assembly alongside the draft budget for 2018 by October 2017.

---

### Monetary and financial sector policies
Monetary policy stance and objectives:
- Since H2 2015, the CBA cut the policy rate by 450 basis points to 6 percent; 150 basis points of the cuts occurred since H2 2016.
- Transmission: lending rates have come down somewhat; early signs of recovery in private sector credit; transmission remains weak due to high dollarization and an elevated risk premium in the real sector.
- Inflation objective: stabilize inflation within the CBA’s medium-term 4±1.5 percent target by end-2017.
- CBA remains open to further monetary policy adjustment and will review policy given stronger-than-expected activity in early 2017; stands ready to adjust to keep inflation on track.
- Plan to promote a well-functioning interbank market with IFI assistance to enhance liquidity provision and distribution.

Exchange rate and reserves:
- Reserves rebuilt to $2.2 billion at end-2016 due to strong export receipts, large donor flows, and limited FX sales.
- Commitment to a flexible dram exchange rate: allow adjustment in both directions, use limited intervention to smooth excessive fluctuations and mitigate transitory pressures.
- Assessment: the dram exchange rate likely remains close to its equilibrium level.

Financial sector resilience and supervision:
- All banks achieved the new CBA-mandated minimum capital of 30 billion drams without CBA support.
- Banking sector capital adequacy ratio: around 20 percent.
- Ongoing challenges: post-crisis increase in NPLs (despite modest fall recently), low profitability, and high dollarization.
- CBA actions: develop an enhanced macroprudential framework; operationalize risk-based supervision in late 2017 (aligned with international best practice and Basel III guidance); continue monitoring vulnerabilities and enhancing regulation and supervision.
- Financial intermediation: efforts to increase financial literacy and inclusion.
- FSAP requested for 2018 to better monitor and assess risks and take comprehensive action to ensure soundness of the financial system.
- Commitment to selling PanArmenian Bank to a private investor, or following an appropriate resolution mechanism, no later than end-2017.

---

### Structural policy reforms and initiatives
Main reform areas and status:
- Domestic competition: draft amendment to the economic competition law submitted to the National Assembly in December 2016; expected adoption by end-2017.
- Energy sector: priorities include strengthening the sector’s financial position, improving electricity distribution, increasing affordability; longer-term concessional donor financing in place; restructured short-term loans; adopted a business-friendly tariff scheme with no cost to the budget.
- Pension reform and capital market development: commitment to full implementation of the pension reform by July 2018; adoption of a donor-supported strategy to speed capital market development; establishment of Armenia Investors Club to help financial and capital market development.
- Anti-corruption and transparency: strengthened procurement law (reduced procedures, expanded e-procurement, publication of winning bids); improved tax and customs administration (e.g., speeding up tax refunds for exporters); criminalized illicit enrichment; developed legislative amendments to reduce cash transactions, tackle the shadow economy, and increase financial intermediation.
- Connectivity and international integration: Open Sky Agreement with the EU scheduled for later in the year; EU-Armenia New Framework Agreement negotiations concluded and initialed in March 2017; negotiations on the EU-Armenia Common Aviation Area Agreement and the Single Support Framework for Armenia—2017-20 ongoing.
- FDI promotion: Center for Strategic Initiatives established in January 2017 to encourage reforms to attract FDI, particularly in the tradable sector; initiatives to foster public-private partnerships; Armenian-Russian investment fund established.

---

### Program continuity and next steps
- Authorities will consider the possibility of a successor arrangement in due course to continue progress toward becoming a more dynamic emerging market economy; discussions envisaged later in the year.
- Authorities will maintain close policy dialogue with the Fund and stand ready to take additional measures as appropriate to achieve social and economic objectives and provide data requested for program monitoring.

*Republic of Armenia — International Monetary Fund (Letter of Intent and attachments, Fifth Review of EFF-supported program).*

### 1. This memorandum sets out understandings between the Armenian authorities and the

### 1. This memorandum sets out understandings between the Armenian authorities and the IMF staff regarding the definition of performance criteria (PCs) and indicative targets (ITs), adjusters, and data reporting requirements for the Extended Arrangement

### A. Quantitative Targets

- Program exchange rate assumptions for monitoring:
  - Program exchange rate of the Armenian dram to the U.S. dollar: 410 dram per one U.S. dollar.
  - Cross-rates for other foreign currencies are provided in Table 1 (LOI/MEFP).

- Performance criteria (PCs) set by the program:
  - Floor on the net official international reserves (NIR) of the Central Bank of Armenia (CBA).
  - Ceiling on external public debt arrears (continuous).
  - Floor on the program fiscal balance.
  - Ceiling on domestic budgetary lending.
  - Ceiling on absorption of losses or liabilities and making of payments on behalf of utilities and other companies (continuous).

- Indicative targets (ITs) set by the program:
  - Ceiling on the net domestic assets (NDA) of the CBA.
  - Floor on average concessionality of newly contracted external debt.
  - Ceiling on new government guaranteed external debt.
  - Floor on social spending of the government.

- Monetary Policy Consultation Clause (MPCC):
  - Headline inflation (defined below).

- Net official international reserves (NIR) definition and treatment:
  - NIR (stock) = total gross official international reserves (excluding commercial bank required and excess reserves at CBA in FX) minus gross official reserve liabilities.
  - Gross official international reserves include: CBA’s holdings of monetary gold (excluding amounts pledged as collateral), holdings of Special Drawing Rights (SDRs) (including the August 28, 2009 General Allocation and the September 9, 2009 Special Allocation), the country’s reserve position at the IMF, and holdings of convertible currencies in cash or in nonresident financial institutions (deposits, securities, or other financial instruments).
  - Gross reserves held in the form of securities and other financial instruments are marked to market.
  - Excluded from gross reserves: balance on the government’s Special Privatization Account (SPA), capital subscriptions in foreign financial institutions and illiquid foreign assets, any assets that are pledged, collateralized, or otherwise encumbered, claims on residents, claims in foreign exchange arising from derivatives in foreign currencies vis-à-vis domestic currency (such as futures, forwards, swaps, and options), precious metals other than gold, assets in nonconvertible currencies, and illiquid assets.
  - Official reserve liabilities: total outstanding liabilities of the government and the CBA to the IMF and convertible currency liabilities of the CBA to nonresidents with an original maturity of up to and including one year, as well as commitments to sell foreign exchange arising from derivatives (such as futures, forwards, swaps, and options).
  - NIR is monitored in U.S. dollars; assets and liabilities in convertible currencies other than the U.S. dollar are converted into dollar-equivalent values using the convertible exchange rates specified in Table 1.
  - Convertible currencies are limited to: U.S. dollar, U.K. pound, euro, Japanese yen, SDR, Australian dollar, Canadian dollar, and Swiss franc.

- MPCC headline inflation:
  - Defined as the year-on-year rate of change of the Consumer Price Index as measured by Armenia’s National Statistics Service.
  - MPCC considered met if headline inflation falls within a range of +/- 1½ percentage point around the mid-point target specified in Table 1 in the LOI/MEFP.

- Net domestic assets (NDA) definition and tolerance:
  - NDA = reserve money minus NIR, minus other assets not included in gross official international reserves, minus commercial bank required and excess reserves at CBA in FX, plus medium and long-term foreign liabilities (liabilities with a maturity of one year or more) of the CBA, plus other foreign liabilities not included in official reserve liabilities, minus the balance of outstanding Fund purchases credited to the government account at the CBA.
  - NDA composed of net CBA credit to the general government plus outstanding credit to domestic banks by the CBA (including overdrafts) minus liabilities not included in reserve money and other items net.
  - Ceiling considered met if outcome is within AMD 15 billion of the targets set in Table 1 attached to the LOI/MEFP.

- External public debt arrears:
  - Defined as all unpaid debt-service obligations (payments of principal and interest) arising in respect of public sector loans contracted or guaranteed to non-residents, including unpaid penalties or interest charges associated with these obligations that are overdue beyond 30 days after the due date.
  - Ceiling on external payment arrears is set at zero.
  - Public sector definition follows GFS 2001 and 1993 SNA; includes the general government and nonfinancial public enterprises (as defined in paragraph 14).

- Program fiscal balance (cumulative from the beginning of the fiscal year), measured from the financing side as the negative of:
  - Net domestic banking system credit to the central government.
  - Net domestic nonbank financing.
  - Net external financing to the central government.
  - If a general subsidy or other fiscal transaction is introduced off-budget, the overall balance will be measured including the subsidy and other fiscal transactions as part of government spending.
  - Components:
    - Net banking system credit to the central government = change during the period of net credit to the central government.
    - Net nonbank financing = sum of: (1) change during the period of outstanding treasury bills and bonds to nonbanks (including accrued interest for treasury bills and excluding accrued interest for treasury bonds); (2) any other disbursement or transaction that increases nonbanks’ claims on the central government plus withdrawals from the SPA or the treasury sub-account containing privatization proceeds in drams, less amortization paid by the central government to private resident nonbank agents.
      - Domestic nonbank holdings of treasury bills and treasury bonds defined as total outstanding treasury bills and bonds less holdings by the banking system and the State Fund for Social Insurance.
    - Net external financing = total debt-increasing disbursements from non-residents to the central government (including Fund net purchases credited directly to the government accounts at the CBA) less total amortization from the central government to non-residents; includes privatization proceeds from non-residents in foreign currency not held in the SPA.
  - Budgetary exchange rate for 2017 transactions included in the 2017 budget: 475.4 drams per one US dollar, except amounts received for project implementation units (PIU) where prevailing ER at time of transaction was used.
  - Additional unbudgeted transactions for 2017 take place at the market exchange rate.
  - New foreign currency-denominated transactions introduced at any time take place at prevailing ER at time of transaction.
  - Framework arrangement will not be modified in substance (clarifications may be made).

- Treatment of external and domestic net lending:
  - External and domestic net lending (recorded as financing items) are excluded from calculation of program fiscal balance (calculated from financing side), effectively treating net lending as an expenditure when loans are made and as revenue when loans are repaid.

- Metsamor nuclear power station transactions:
  - Transactions related to extension of operating life (via lending from the Russian Federation to MoF of Armenia and from MoF to Armenian Nuclear Power Plant JSC) will be excluded from measure of program fiscal deficit.

- Project implementation units (PIUs) and grants/loans:
  - PIUs may maintain accounts at the CBA.
  - Grants received by PIUs recorded in fiscal accounts as external grants on revenue side and as foreign-financed expenditure on expenditure side.
  - Loans to finance investments intermediated through banking system recorded in financial accounts as financing item below the line and excluded from net lending.

- Special Privatization Account (SPA) treatment and transparency:
  - Foreign currency proceeds from selling enterprises credited to the SPA and their use is reflected in the state budget.
  - Government will ensure full transparency of revenues and spending from sales of major assets (beyond regular day-to-day operations), including presentation of use of funds from sale of hydroelectric assets of Vorotan Cascade Company, including for electricity subsidies and payment of wage arrears of Nairit.
  - SPA held at the CBA; proceeds invested abroad together with CBA’s international reserves.
  - These proceeds included in monetary accounts of the CBA as part of net foreign assets with a counter entry in other items net.
  - Any withdrawal from SPA accounted as privatization proceeds used to finance the budget and recorded below the line.
  - Domestic currency proceeds from selling enterprises to residents deposited in sub-account of treasury single account and treated as financing item recorded below the line.
  - Privatization proceeds received from non-residents in foreign currency and not held in SPA treated as financing item (sale of financial assets) and recorded below the line.

- Domestic budgetary lending:
  - Defined as gross amount of new loans made to resident individuals, enterprises, or entities financed from the state budget or other general government resources.
  - Includes lending financed from Economic Stabilization Fund and lending under government programs (e.g., agricultural sector support, real estate development).
  - Lending operations related to targeted projects financed with external loans and grants excluded from ceiling on budget domestic lending.

- Absorption of losses or liabilities and payments on behalf of utilities and other companies:
  - Continuous ceiling on absorption by public sector of losses or liabilities from outside budgetary sector.
  - Public sector defined as state budget and state debt (central and local governments) plus CBA and enterprises or other entities with state ownership or control.
  - Absorption defined as direct payment by public sector of losses/liabilities of other parties or coverage via transactions (debt-for-equity swaps, write-off of tax obligations or other state claims).
  - Ceiling set at zero, and excludes AMD 9.7 billion, (approximately $20.3 million) of subsidies in the 2017 budget for specified entities (Yerevan Metro, Yerevan Electric Transport, Irrigations Systems, Armenian Water and Sanitation, Nor Akunk, Lori Water and Sanitation, Shirak Water and Sanitation, and irrigation water intake entities).

- Floor on average concessionality of newly contracted external debt:
  - Annual indicative floor: 30 percent on average concessionality of new debt on a contraction basis with nonresidents with original maturities of one year or more as contracted and guaranteed by public sector.
  - Concessionality floor calculated on a calendar-year basis.
  - Grant element = difference between present value (PV) of debt and its nominal value, expressed as percentage of nominal value.
  - PV of debt at time of contracting calculated by discounting future stream of payments of debt service due on this debt using unified discount rate set at 5 percent.
  - Public sector comprises general government (central plus local governments and covering state budget and state debt), central bank, and nonfinancial public enterprises (enterprises and agencies in which government holds a controlling stake—typically owns more than 50 percent of the shares, but which are not consolidated in the budget).
  - Guarantee of a debt arises from any explicit legal obligation of public sector to service a debt in event of nonpayment by debtor (payments in cash or in kind), or from any implicit legal or contractual obligation of public sector to finance partially or in full any shortfall incurred by the debtor.

- Ceiling on government guaranteed external debt:
  - Separate cumulative ceiling (IT) of $50 million for program period applies to new government guarantees of total of concessional and non-concessional external financing.
  - Issuance of debt guarantees measured at exchange rates listed in Table 1.
  - Limit covers debt guarantees issued by general government to entities outside general government (excluding the CBA).
  - Guarantee issuance monitored monthly; Ministry of Finance to provide data within 21 days from the end of the month.

- Floor on social spending of the government:
  - Defined for program purposes as 95 percent of the budgeted amount of the family benefit program and maternity benefits, one-time childbirth benefits, and childcare benefits for children less than two years of age.

- Adjusters applicable to PCs and ITs (calculated using program exchange rates where relevant):
  - Changes in reserve requirements:
    - Ceiling on NDA of CBA adjusted downward (upward) by amount of banks’ reserves freed (seized) by any reduction (increase) of reserve requirement ratio on both domestic currency and foreign currency liabilities relative to baseline assumption as per formula: ΔNDA = ΔrB, where B denotes level of liabilities subject to reserve requirements in initial definition and Δr is change in reserve requirement ratio.
  - KfW, Asian Development Bank, and World Bank loan disbursements:
    - Ceiling on NDA of CBA adjusted upward (downward) by full amount of any excess (shortfall) of disbursements from these loans directed at SME financing compared to programmed amounts (Table 2).
    - Floor on NIR adjusted upward (downward) by cumulative amount of any excess (shortfall) of these disbursements compared to program amounts.
  - Budget support definitions:
    - Budget support grants: grants received by general government for direct budget support from external donors not related to project financing.
    - Budget support loans: disbursements of commercial loans (e.g., Eurobonds), loans from bilateral and multilateral donors for budget support, and Fund purchases credited directly to government accounts at the CBA.
    - Project financing: disbursements of loans from bilateral and multilateral donors for public sector projects.
  - NIR adjusters:
    - Floor on NIR adjusted upward (downward) by cumulative amount of any excess (shortfall) of budget support loans or budget support grants (excluding Fund purchases by government) compared to program amounts (Table 3).
    - Floor on NIR adjusted downward for any external public debt amortization amounts in excess of program amounts.
    - Floor on NIR adjusted upward by amount of any funds received in respect of deposits held at the Inter State Bank as well as for privatization proceeds received from non-residents in foreign currency and not held in SPA.
  - NDA adjusters:
    - Ceiling on NDA adjusted downward (upward) by cumulative amount of any excess (shortfall) of budget support loans or budget support grants compared to program amounts (Table 3).
  - Program fiscal balance on cash basis adjusters:
    - Floor on program fiscal balance adjusted upward (downward) by cumulative total amount of budget support grants received in excess (to account for a shortfall) of program amounts (Table 3), subject to a cap of $50 million per year in either direction.
    - Floor on program fiscal balance adjusted downward (upward) by cumulative total amount of project financing received in excess (to account for a shortfall) of program amounts (Table 3), subject to a cap of $50 million in either direction.
  - Ceiling on domestic budgetary lending:
    - Adjusted upward by amount of undisbursed funds under domestic budgetary lending programs approved in the previous year.

### B. Data Reporting

- (Section heading present in source; no further data reporting details provided in the supplied content.)

*Memorandum of understandings between the Armenian authorities and IMF staff on PCs, ITs, adjusters, and data reporting for the Extended Arrangement (excerpts).*

### 19. The government and the CBA will provide the IMF the information specified in the

### 19. The government and the CBA will provide the IMF the information specified in the

### Reporting requirements — Central Bank of Armenia (CBA)
- CBA balance sheet
  - Type: Summary
  - Frequency: Daily
  - Timing: The following working day
- CBA balance sheet (at program exchange rates; and by chart of accounts at actual official exchange rates)
  - Type: Summary
  - Frequency: Monthly
  - Timing: Within seven days of the end of each month
- Monetary survey
  - Description: Summary banking system balance sheet for the central bank at both program exchange rates and by chart of accounts at actual official exchange rates; the consolidated balance sheet of commercial banks by chart of accounts at actual official exchange rates
  - Frequency: Monthly
  - Timing: Within 25 days of the end of each month
- International reserves
  - Description: By chart of accounts; at (i) program exchange rates; and (ii) at actual official exchange rates
  - Frequency: Daily
  - Timing: The following working day
- Foreign exchange market (official exchange rates)
  - Description: Official exchange rates (buying and selling); daily trade volume, and weighted average exchange rate of the interbank, intrabank and Nasdaq-OMX
  - Frequency: Daily
  - Timing: Within 1 day
- Foreign exchange market (CBA operations)
  - Description: CBA foreign exchange operations, (exchange rate, volume)
  - Frequency: Daily
  - Timing: Within 1 day
- Foreign exchange market (exchange rate)
  - Description: Exchange rate (buying and selling)
  - Frequency: Daily
  - Timing: Within 1 day
- Interest rates (Refinance rate)
  - Frequency: At least monthly
  - Timing: Within 1 days of the CBA Board decision
- Interbank money market
  - Description: Daily interbank repo volume and interest rate and number of trades
  - Frequency: Daily
  - Timing: Within 1 day
- CBA operations
  - Description: Repo (reverse repo) operations, open market operations, Lombard credits, deposit facility, and foreign exchange swaps (volumes, maturity, yields, exchange rates)
  - Frequency: Daily
  - Timing: Within 1 day
- Bank liquidity
  - Description: Reserves and excess reserves, by currency
  - Frequency: Monthly
  - Timing: Within 15 days of the end of each reference period
- Interest rates and flows of funds attracted and allocated by commercial banks
  - Description: By currency and maturity
  - Frequency: Weekly
  - Timing: Last working day of the week
- T-bill and coupon bond financing, CBA securities
  - Description: Auction data: date, original and remaining maturities, issuance volume, allocation, average yield and coupon yield (if available)
  - Frequency: Weekly
  - Timing: Last working day of the week
- Banking data
  - Description: Sectoral distribution of loans and deposits; dollarization of loans and deposits; loan maturities; interbank rate, by volume and maturity; T-bill rate, bond yield; deposit and lending rates, by maturity; monthly weighted average interest rate on government bonds
  - Frequency: Monthly
  - Timing: Within 25 days of the end of each month
- Banking indicators
  - Description: Capital adequacy; asset composition and quality; profitability; liquidity; open FX positions; and compliance with prudential norms
  - Frequency: Monthly
  - Timing: Within 30 days of the end of each month
- Banking sector stress tests
  - Description: Results of stress tests on exchange rate, liquidity, and credit risk
  - Frequency: Monthly
  - Timing: Within 30 days of the end of each month
- On-lending via commercial banks
  - Description: On lending via the CBA and government (from the Russian loan, KfW, WB, ADB, etc.) by type of on-lending projects (including loan disbursements and repayments)
  - Frequency: Monthly
  - Timing: Within 10 days of the end of each month
- CPI
  - Description: Index of core inflation
  - Frequency: Monthly
  - Timing: Within 21 days of the end of each month
- Transfers
  - Description: Non-commercial transfers of individuals
  - Frequency: Monthly
  - Timing: Within 31 of the end of each month
- Other monetary data
  - Description: IFS format
  - Frequency: Monthly
  - Timing: Within 45 days of the end of each month

### Reporting requirements — Balance of payments and external sector
- Balance of payments
  - Description: Detailed balance of payments data
  - Frequency: Quarterly
  - Timing: Within 92 days of the end of each quarter
- T-bill and coupon bond financing (by holders)
  - Description: By holders, i.e., CBA, resident banks, resident nonbanks, and nonresidents
  - Frequency: Monthly
  - Timing: Within 7 days of each month
- External debt (government, CBA, state-owned companies)
  - Description: Disbursements and stock of outstanding short-term and contracting or guaranteeing and outstanding stock of medium-and long-term external debt of the government, the CBA, and state-owned companies (by company); any stock of arrears on external debt service and outstanding stock of government guarantees and external arrears
  - Frequency: Monthly
  - Timing: Within 21 days of the end of each month. For project implementation units, within 21 days of the end of each month (preliminary data) and within 45 days of the end of each month (final data)

### Reporting requirements — Ministry of Finance (MoF)
- Revenue collection
  - Description: Total revenue collected separately by the tax administration and customs administration, including revenue by individual tax, and social contributions
  - Frequency: Monthly
  - Timing: Within 7 days of the end of each month
- Domestic expenditure arrears
  - Description: All unpaid claims outstanding at the end of the month which includes wages, social contributions (including for pensions), family allowances, and amortization and domestic interest payments
  - Frequency: Monthly
  - Timing: Within 45 days of the end of each month for government arrears
- Privatization receipts
  - Description: Balance on the SPA; gross inflows into and outflows from the SPA during the month, specifying the nature of each transaction
  - Frequency: Monthly
  - Timing: Within 7 days of the end of each month
- Treasury single account (TSA)
  - Description: Detailed breakdown of central treasury account, including deposits at the central treasury, community budgets, off budget account, monetization account, state budget account and the Republic correspondent account—flows during the month and end of month stocks.
  - Frequency: Monthly
  - Timing: Within 7 days of the end of each month
- Consolidated central government
  - Description: State budget
  - Frequency: Monthly
  - Timing: Within 30 days of the end of each month
- Consolidated general government
  - Description: Central and local governments, and Non-Commercial Enterprises that belong within the general government (NCEs)
  - Frequency: Quarterly
  - Timing: Within 60 days of the end of each quarter
  - Frequency (annual): Annual
  - Timing (annual): Within 180 days of the end of each year
- Budget execution
  - Description: All cash receipts, cash expenditures, including domestic and external debt-service payments, external and domestic borrowing and lending operations, and inflow of grants to the central government; expenditure data will be provided according to both economic and functional classifications, consistent with the GFSM2001 methodology
  - Frequency: Monthly
  - Timing: Within one month following the end of each quarter.
- Financial information on utilities and other major companies with a state interest
  - Description: Profit and loss indicators for regulated utilities, for companies with state shareholding of 50 percent or greater, and for companies with state shareholding of 0–50 percent and annual sales or outstanding liabilities of AMD 10 billion.
  - Frequency: Quarterly
  - Timing: Within 60 days of the end of each quarter

### Reporting requirements — National Statistical Service (NSS)
- Balance of payments
  - Description: Detailed export and import data (issues that have arisen in 2015 with EEU trade data need to be overcome as soon as possible)
  - Frequency: Monthly
  - Timing: Within 28 days of the end of each month
  - Frequency (quarterly): Quarterly
  - Timing (quarterly): Within 45 days of the end of each quarter
- CPI (by category)
  - Frequency: Monthly
  - Timing: Within 5 days of the end of each month

### Reporting requirements — State Revenue Committee (SRC) and tax administration
- Tax arrears
  - Description: By type of tax
  - Frequency: Monthly
  - Timing: Within 30 days of the end of each quarter (monthly data provided on a quarterly basis)
  - Additional: For the 30 largest debtors and for all major companies in the energy, water, and irrigation sectors — Quarterly; Timing: Within 30 days of the end of each quarter
- Tax credits
  - Description: Detailed data, by type of tax, of outstanding tax credits for all types of tax revenues, in both net and gross terms
  - Frequency: Monthly
  - Timing: Within 45 days of the end of each (monthly data provided on a quarterly basis)
- Tax Revenues
  - Description: Tax Revenue by type of tax
  - Frequency: Monthly
  - Timing: Within 45 days of the end of each quarter (monthly data provided on a quarterly basis)
- VAT and turnover tax: Number of registered taxpayers
  - Frequency: Monthly
  - Timing: Within 45 days of the end of each month (monthly data provided on a quarterly basis)
- VAT refund claims in arrears
  - Description: Detailed data on VAT refunds in arrears which include all outstanding VAT refunds that have not been accepted (and refunded), or offset (in full or in part), or rejected (in full or in part) after the 90 day statutory processing period. Number of refund applications processed per month.
  - Frequency: Monthly
  - Timing: Within 45 days of the end of each month (monthly data provided on a quarterly basis)
- Large taxpayers
  - Description: Data on the number of taxpayers and amount of taxes managed by the large tax inspectorate
  - Frequency: Monthly
  - Timing: Within 45days after the end of each month
- Import data (detailed list of 8 items)
  - Frequency: Quarterly
  - Timing: Within 30 days of the end of each quarter
  - Items requested (verbatim):
    1. Total value of recorded imports, breaking out raw diamond imports;
    2. Total value of non-duty free recorded imports;
    3. Number of total transactions involving recorded imports;
    4. Number of total transactions involving non-duty free recorded imports
    5. Value of recorded imports where customs value was assessed using transaction prices, breaking out raw diamond imports;
    6. Value of non-duty free recorded imports where customs value was assessed using transaction prices;
    7. Number of transactions involving recorded imports where customs value was assessed using transaction prices;
    8. Number of transactions involving non duty free recorded imports where customs value was assessed using transaction prices
- Automated VAT refunds
  - Description: Number of refunds that were processed automatically (share of total refunds); total value of automated and automatic refunds and offsets; average waiting time (days) to receive refund
  - Frequency: Monthly
  - Timing: Within 45 days of the end of each month (monthly data provided on a quarterly basis)
- Risk-based selection approach
  - Description: Percentage of selected companies chosen on the basis of risk-based approach, identified revenue from risk-based audits
  - Frequency: Monthly
  - Timing: Within 45 days of the end of each month (monthly data provided on a quarterly basis)
- Pension system
  - Description: Number of participants in the pension second pillar, social payments and funded contributions
  - Frequency: Monthly
  - Timing: Within two months of the end of each quarter (monthly data provided on a quarterly basis)

### Table 1: Armenia — (Program) Exchange Rates of the CBA (As of July 31, 2013 in U.S. dollars per currency rates)
- Australian dollar: Drams Per Currency 371.95 ; Dollars Per Currency 0.9072
- Canadian dollar: Drams Per Currency 398.33 ; Dollars Per Currency 0.9715
- Swiss franc: Drams Per Currency 440.91 ; Dollars Per Currency 1.0754
- Danish krone: Drams Per Currency 73.06 ; Dollars Per Currency 0.1782
- Euro: Drams Per Currency 544.28 ; Dollars Per Currency 1.3275
- Pound sterling: Drams Per Currency 627.83 ; Dollars Per Currency 1.5313
- Japanese yen: Drams Per Currency 4.18 ; Dollars Per Currency 0.0102
- Norwegian krone: Drams Per Currency 69.14 ; Dollars Per Currency 0.1686
- Russian ruble: Drams Per Currency 12.47 ; Dollars Per Currency 0.0304
- Swedish krone: Drams Per Currency 62.47 ; Dollars Per Currency 0.1524
- SDR: Drams Per Currency 621.04 ; Dollars Per Currency 1.5147

### Fund relations and financial arrangements (selected items)
- Membership Status: Joined 05/28/1992; Article VIII
- General Resources Account (SDR Million)
  - Quota 128.80 ; Percent of Quota 100.00
  - Fund holdings of currency 306.85 ; Percent of Quota 238.24
  - Reserve Tranche Position 0.00 ; Percent of Quota 0.00
- SDR Department (SDR Million)
  - Net cumulative allocation 87.99 ; Percent of Allocation 100.00
  - Holdings 7.10 and 8.07 (as reported)
- Outstanding Purchases and Loans (SDR Million; Percent of Quota)
  - ECF Arrangements 124.68 ; 96.80
  - Extended Arrangements 178.05 ; 138.23
- Latest Financial Arrangements (type, approval, expiration, amounts)
  - EFF 03/07/2014 08/31/2017 Amount Approved (SDR Million) 82.21 Amount Drawn (SDR Million) 66.52
  - ECF 06/28/2010 07/02/2013 Amount Approved 133.40 Amount Drawn 133.40
  - EFF 06/28/2010 06/24/2013 Amount Approved 133.40 Amount Drawn 133.40
- Projected Payments to Fund (SDR million; based on existing use of resources and present holdings of SDRs)
  - Forthcoming Principal 2017 33.14 ; 2018 45.17 ; 2019 52.83 ; 2020 54.63 ; 2021 49.35
  - Charges/interest 2017 2.14 ; 2018 2.66 ; 2019 2.31 ; 2020 1.92 ; 2021 1.51
  - Total 2017 35.28 ; 2018 47.83 ; 2019 55.14 ; 2020 56.55 ; 2021 50.86

### Safeguards assessment — key findings and implementation status
- An update safeguards assessment concluded in August 2014 with respect to the Extended Fund Facility approved in March 2014.
- Findings:
  - The assessment found that the CBA maintains safeguards in its financial reporting practices, external audit mechanism, and internal audit function.
  - Recommended amendments to the central bank law to strengthen the CBA’s governance arrangements, and to provide the CBA with marketable, interest-bearing government securities to cover its losses.
  - Noted CBA investments in enterprises engaged in financial sector development and infrastructure, including a credit card processing company, a mortgage finance company, and a cash collection agency.
- Implementation progress:
  - CBA has adopted a charter for its board members to clarify roles and responsibilities.
  - CBA presents a consolidated position inclusive of these enterprises in audited financial statements and has an annex describing the rationale for the investments and management of the enterprises.
  - Further work needed: the annex should cover risks, risk-mitigation efforts, or divestment strategies.
  - Pending legislation to provide the CBA with marketable, interest-bearing government securities to cover losses has not advanced in parliament.

### Technical assistance (summary of TA provided, 2010–17)
- Fiscal Affairs Department (FAD): multiple short-term missions on tax administration, tax policy, budget process, public financial management, fiscal risk, customs administration, and related topics (dates range March 2010 through April-May 2017).
- Legal Department: Banking Law (Short-term June 2011); AML/CFT (Short-term Various)
- Monetary and Capital Markets Department: Contingency planning, crisis preparedness; Workshops on inflation targeting; Bank resolution framework; Medium-term debt management strategy; FSAP update; Bank prudential framework; Monetary and foreign exchange policy; Safeguard assessment; Central Bank communication; TA needs assessment for the Central Bank. (missions spanning 2010–2016)
- Statistics Department: National accounts, BOP and external debt statistics, monetary statistics, Construction Price Index (missions between September 2010 and September 2013)
- Resident Representative: Ms. Teresa Daban Sanchez, since August 2013.

*Prepared by the Middle East and Central Asia Department (In Consultation with Other Departments); material drawn from the informational annex.*

### 1. Bank program in the

### 1. Bank program in the next 12 months

### Selected ongoing and new operations
- Public Sector Modernization Project II (US$9 million) — Project implementation started in September 2010 and was completed in January 2017; the draft Implementation Completion Report is being prepared.
- Tax Administration Modernization Project (US$12 million).
- DPO series to support competitiveness and ensure sustainability (US$197 million).
  - Board for DPO-2 (US$75 million): November 2014
  - DPO-3 (US$50 million): December 2015
  - DPO-4 (US$50 million): December 2016
- New Health Project for Disease Prevention and Control (US$30 million) — Board approval in March 2013.
- Public Sector Modernization (III) and PFM project (US$26.5 million) — Board approval in September 2015, effective since March 2016; expected completion in December, 2017.
- Power Sector Financial Recovery Project (US$32 million) — Board approval in April 2016.

### Analytic work (programmatic and sectoral)
- Programmatic Poverty work — Annual Series (2015 report). Completed in June 2015 and disseminated in November 2015.
- Programmatic Fiscal work (fiscal incidence assessment, public sector wage assessment, review of social assistance programs) — The 2015 report was completed June 2015, disseminated in November, 2015.
- PER on Quasi-fiscal activities, Macro-Fiscal sustainability and fiscal Subsidies — Completed in June 2016 and disseminated in November 2016.
- New Country Economic Memorandum on Drivers of Dynamism — Completed.
- Assessment of EEU membership on Armenia’s economy — On-going.
- Promoting Productive employment in Armenia – a note on labor market activation — On-going.
- Systematic Country Diagnoses (SCD) — On-going.

### Selected technical assistance
- IDF grant for guillotine exercise — Completed in June 2015.
- Macro-monitoring — Completed and disseminated in December 2014.
- One-stop shop for providing construction permits — Started in June 2016 with expected completion in June 2017.
- CGE model-based technical assistance to simulate trade and growth projections (US$120K) — Concept Note prepared in February 2017 with expected completion in July 2017.
- Technical Assistance on Tax Policy (US$150K) — Completed in June 2015.
- Technical Assistance on Tax Policy (US$75K) — Completed in June 2016.
- Additional technical assistance items — Completed in June 2015; Completed in June 2016; Commenced in June 2016 and expected completion in June 2017.

### Monitoring / mission timing and delivery cadence
- Semi Annual monitoring for multiple analytic products.
- Quarterly monitoring for selected projects.
- Continuous monitoring for some items.
- Expected IMF mission timing entries noted elsewhere in the program.

*REPUBLIC OF ARMENIA — INTERNATIONAL MONETARY FUND (excerpt)*

---

### 2. IMF work program in the next 12 months

### Main engagements
- Fifth EFF Review and 2017 Article IV Consultation.
- Technical Assistance/Training engagements:
  - FAD (fiscal rule) — March 2017.
  - ICD/RES (macro modeling to include financial stability consideration in inflation targeting framework) — June 2017.
  - Additional ongoing TA/training items — June 2017; 2nd half of 2017; Ongoing.

*REPUBLIC OF ARMENIA — INTERNATIONAL MONETARY FUND (excerpt)*

---

### Relations with the European Bank for Reconstruction and Development (EBRD) (As of April 30, 2017)

### EBRD scorecard and portfolio
- 158 Numbers of projects to date
- €1,112m Cumulative EBRD investment
- €771 million Cumulative disbursements
- 88 percent Private sector share of portfolio
- Current portfolio: 305 million euro* (*Includes undisbursed commitments)
- Portfolio Composition (2014–16): 26% Infrastructure; 8% Industry, commerce and agribusiness; 52% Financial institutions; 16% Energy.

### Financial institutions and local currency development
- Signing of 29 deals channelling €200.5 million to Armenian commercial banks and micro financing institutions for on-lending primarily to SMEs; approximately €100 million has been disbursed in local currency.
- Since 2013, five Armenian banks, one credit organisation and one financial leasing company joined CEEP, signing more than €35 million in loans for on-lending to industrial and residential EE sub-projects.
- 2015 equity participation: AMD 9.8 billion for up to 22.7 percent of shares in Inecobank to finance the acquisition of ProCredit Bank Armenia.
- 2015 investment: $40 million for 20% equity stake in Ameriabank.
- Local currency loans equivalent to €12.3 million to Ameriabank and ACBA bank for on-lending to women-led SMEs under Women in Business expansion.
- As of December 2016, the Bank had issued €44.1 million equivalent in drams of local currency bonds.

### Infrastructure projects (2014–16 highlights)
- Yerevan Street Lighting pilot project signed in 2015 (€3.7 million).
- Kotayk Solid Waste Management project loan in 2014 (€3.5 million) complemented by €3.5 million EU grant; loan extended by €2 million in 2016 to involve 12 small municipalities.
- 2015: €8 million loan for a solid waste landfill in Yerevan co-financed by €8 million EIB credit line and €8 million EU capital grant; benefits for 1.1 million residents.
- 2015 participation in €28.3 million syndication for Zvartnots International Airport; 2014 Armenian International Airport Phase II for €30.8 million.
- 2016 financing: €14.6 million sovereign loan for energy efficient street lighting and city street rehabilitation in Gyumri (three tranches).

### Sustainable energy and mining
- Three deals: loan of €3.3 million to Dundee Precious Metals and two equity investments totalling €9.8 million with Lydian International.
- Lydian’s Amulsar mine project permitted in late 2014 under new Mining Code; financing earmarked for biodiversity off-set programme and passive water treatment facility as recommended by ESIA.

### Industry, commerce, agribusiness and SME support
- Eight deals totalling €22.4 million supporting agribusiness, manufacturing and services companies (last 3 years).
- Advise for Small Business (ASB): 264 local advisory and 15 international advisory projects for SMEs since 2014.
- €15 million EU-NIF Grant secured to establish Armenian SME Finance & Advice Facility: €4 million for ASB advice to corporates, €11 million to assist establishment of an Armenia-only private equity fund.

### Policy dialogue and market infrastructure
- Support to Investment Council and reforms in tax, customs, business registration, simplified taxation regime for SMEs, phased tax regime for IT start-ups, simplification of customs clearance procedures.
- 2016 updated MOU among CBA, Ministry of Finance, and EBRD on local currency and capital market development; formation of a high-level steering committee co-chaired by the CBA and EBRD.
- 2016 parliamentary package of laws regulating local financial markets and amendments to the law on the securities market; amendments introduce enforceability of derivatives transactions, netting, close-out netting, financial collaterals, and settlement finality; over 17 laws amended and more than 15 new regulations introduced.
- EBRD-provided technical cooperation to the CBA on legal reform; project coordinated with ISDA.

### Sector outreach and knowledge sharing
- 2016 forum: ‘Innovation and Knowledge-Sharing in the Dairy Sector’ organized with the Armenian Ministry of Agriculture.

*REPUBLIC OF ARMENIA — INTERNATIONAL MONETARY FUND (excerpt)*

---

### Relations with the Asian Development Bank (AsDB) (As of April 30, 2017)

### Membership and strategy
- Armenia joined the AsDB in September 2005.
- AsDB’s Country Partnership Strategy for Armenia for 2014–18 (endorsed 27 January 2015) focuses on: (i) transport, (ii) water supply and other municipal services, and (iii) energy.
- As of January 1, 2017, Armenia reclassified as a Group C country eligible for market-based ordinary capital resources only.

### Lending and major projects (cumulative and recent approvals)
- As of April 30, 2017, AsDB cumulative sovereign lending amounted to $1,050.3 million for 18 loans.
- 2016 approvals:
  - Policy-Based Loan of $90 million for phase 2 of the Infrastructure Sustainability Support Program.
  - $50 million for the Armenia-Georgia Border Regional Road (M6 Vanadzor-Bagratashen) Improvement Project — 51.5 kilometers rehabilitation; collaborative cofinancing of $56.4 million from the European Investment Bank (EIB).
- 2015 approval: Results-Based Loan of $88.5 million for the Seismic Safety Improvement Program for seismic strengthening and renovation of priority school buildings.
- 2014 approval: $37 million loan for the Power Transmission Rehabilitation Project.
- 2014 approval: Infrastructure Sustainability Support Program ($49 million) approved in August 2014.
- 2012 approvals:
  - Women's Entrepreneurship Support Sector Development Program: program loan ($20 million) and financial intermediation loan ($20 million) through the German-Armenian Fund.
  - $40 million additional financing for the Water Sector and Sanitation Sector Project (approved in 2007).
- 2011 approval: $400 million multi-tranche financing facility (MFF) for the Sustainable Urban Development Investment Program; Tranche 1 for $48.64 million (2011) and Tranche 2 for $112.97 million (2015).
- 2009 approval: $500 million MFF for the North–South Road Corridor Investment Program; Tranche 1 ($60 million), Tranche 2 ($170 million), Tranche 3 ($100 million in 2013) with additional co-financing from EIB.

### Non-sovereign financing and trade support
- AsDB approved $136 million in non-sovereign financing in Armenia for four private sector transactions.
- 2016: $6 million loan to a universal credit organization to expand lending to SMEs and agriculture outside Yerevan.
- 2013: $25 million loan with International Energy Corporation to rehabilitate Sevan-Hrazdan Cascade Hydropower (cofinanced with EBRD).
- 2011: $65 million non-sovereign lending program for four commercial banks to expand SME lending.
- 2010: $40 million non-sovereign loan to Armenia International Airports for Zvartnots Airport Expansion Project (Phase 2).
- AsDB’s Trade Finance Program has supported over $47 million in trade through 103 transactions.

*REPUBLIC OF ARMENIA — INTERNATIONAL MONETARY FUND (excerpt)*

### 9.      In addition to financing projects and programs, the AsDB is also involved in advisory

### 9.      In addition to financing projects and programs, the AsDB is also involved in advisory

### AsDB advisory services (opening paragraph)
- AsDB provides advisory services and capacity development in Armenia, including technical assistance (TA) programs for:
  - urban development in secondary cities,
  - export- and innovation-led industrial development,
  - schools seismic strengthening,
  - infrastructure sustainability.
- Armenia participates in a number of AsDB multi-country TA projects, providing assessments and development plans on topics of common interest across countries.

### Statistical issues — Background
- Data provision by Armenia has shortcomings, but is broadly adequate for surveillance.
- Armenia subscribed to the Special Data Dissemination Standard (SDDS) in November 2003.
- IMF support has included TA from the Statistics Department (STA), the Fiscal Affairs Department (FAD), and the Monetary and Capital Markets Department (MCM).
- Major missions and actions cited:
  - April 2008 data ROSC mission prepared a detailed evaluation of macroeconomic statistics.
  - Multi-topic statistics mission in February 2010 reviewed implementation of past recommendations.
  - STA follow-up mission in September 2010 focused on improving accuracy of annual and quarterly GDP estimates.
- Conclusion: Further improvements in real, fiscal, and external sector statistics would be desirable to facilitate enhanced design and monitoring of economic policies.

### Data provision for program monitoring
- Data provision is adequate and sufficient for program monitoring.
- Program series, as defined in the Technical Memorandum of Understanding (TMU), are provided with the required timeliness.
- Monetary statistics include data on one bank’s headquarters and some branches in Nagorno-Karabakh (as identified in the April 2008 ROSC).
- Program monetary variables specified in the TMU have been defined in a consistent manner over the program period since Board approval.

### Real sector statistics — National accounts and price indicators
- The National Statistics Service (NSS) compiles and disseminates annual and quarterly national accounts and annually a full set of accounts (up to financial accounts) for the total economy and by institutional sectors.
- As of 2015, NSS prepares national accounts under the System of National Accounts 2008 (2008 SNA).
- GDP under the 2008 SNA methodology has been extended back to 2012, with plans to cover earlier years.

Key issues and actions:
- Accuracy of annual national accounts estimates undermined by lack of exhaustive source data for informal activities and of appropriate price and volume indicators, particularly for construction.
- Construction output volume measures currently derived by deflating current values with a price index using weights and base year prices from a survey in 1984.
- NSS has started compiling a new construction output price index based on more sound methodology.
- Until the new construction price index becomes available, NSS should use other indicators for deriving construction aggregates at constant prices and implement new surveys to benchmark informal activities.

Quarterly and monthly compilation practices:
- Production-side estimates at current prices are derived partially from cumulative source data and partially from discrete sources; de-cumulation problems distort the quarterly pattern.
- NSS received IMF TA on estimating quarterly GDP from discrete data sources and is using statistical techniques conforming to international standards.
- NSS discontinued compiling GDP volume measures at prices of the corresponding quarter of the previous year and adopted recommendation to compile only one set of quarterly GDP estimates—quarterly GDP at previous-year average prices—and derive time series through chain-linking.
- Since 2012, NSS discontinued compiling GDP on average prices of 2005 and instead published GDP for 2009–12 on average prices of year 2008.
- As of January 2011, NSS started compiling a monthly indicator of economic activity (IEA) following international best practices; the monthly GDP compilation was discontinued. The monthly IEA is an implicit volume index aggregated using gross output weights.
- CPI covers 11 large population centers and Yerevan and is computed using 2015 weights. NSS compiles a ten-day and a monthly CPI; both are disseminated jointly.
- A February 2009 data ROSC mission recommended developing an approach to include household expenditure on owner-occupied dwellings in CPI calculations.

### Government finance statistics
- Budget execution reporting system compiles government finance data on a cash basis, supplemented with monthly reports on arrears and quarterly reports on receivables and payables.
- Daily revenue and cash expenditure data for the central government are available with a lag of one to two days; monthly data on central government operations are disseminated one month after the reporting period.
- Ministry of Finance (MoF) is undertaking comprehensive treasury reforms, including introduction of internal auditing in line ministries and respective budgetary institutions.
- Treasury single account (TSA) introduced in 1996; all bank accounts held by budgetary institutions were closed except project implementation units (PIU) required by donors. Since 2010 PIU accounts are being moved gradually to the TSA.
- Since 2002 some budgetary institutions converted into “noncommercial organizations” (NCOs) and were taken out of the treasury system but report cash flows and balances to MoF since 2003.
- February 2009 ROSC recommended including NCOs in government finance statistics data published on national websites.
- Shortcomings remain on timeliness and quality of local government operations data.
- Budget presentation and classification need greater transparency; data have been subject to frequent reclassification and some wages are misclassified under goods and services and other expense rather than as wage items.
- February 2009 ROSC recommended using market value rather than face value for financial assets other than loans and for nonfinancial assets.
- Since 2008, government finance statistics meet GFSM 2001 classification requirements for the central government.
- Reconciliation of central government with general government operations is done by the NSS in cooperation with MoF.

### Monetary and financial statistics
- Monetary and financial statistics are provided on a timely basis:
  - Accounts of the CBA: daily with a one-day lag.
  - Monthly monetary survey: provided with a three-week lag (preliminary weekly data with a one-week lag).
  - Monthly interest rate data: provided with a one-week lag.
- Balance sheets of the CBA and deposit money banks follow IAS methodology.
- In response to an IMF STA request, the CBA compiled and submitted a complete set of monetary data beginning from December 2001 using standardized report forms (SRF).
- STA validated monetary aggregates; data published since December 2006 issue of IFS Supplement and used to update IFS.
- An integrated monetary database established by STA to share SRF data with the IMF’s Middle East and Central Asia Department.
- CBA produces financial soundness indicator table monthly, published on the IMF and CBA websites.

### External sector statistics
- In 2009 authorities decided to transfer responsibility for compiling balance of payments, international investment position (IIP), and external debt statistics from NSS to CBA.
- February 2010 STA mission advised on action plan for smooth institutional transfer; responsibilities de facto transferred to CBA in January 2011.
- Since the transfer, CBA compiled balance of payments, external debt, and IIP data for 2011 and undertook actions to improve compilation system.
- October 2011 STA follow-up mission assessed institutional arrangements, data sources, methodology, and compilation practices; advised on further improvements.

Coverage and data issues:
- Coverage of external sector data improved, although delays emerged with transition towards the Eurasian Economic Union (EEU).
- Trade statistics provided timely; trade data by origin, destination, and commodity generally available within a month.
- Reporting problems in 2015 with EEU trade data.
- Price data for exports and imports are less readily available.
- Quarterly balance of payments statistics generally available with a three-month lag.
- Remittance data exhibit considerable discrepancies among source data: survey-based remittances considerably lower than money transfer system data.
- Absence of a comprehensive, continuously updated business register hampers coverage of transactions and institutional units, notably financial account items for the private nonbank sector.
- Concerns exist regarding collection of data on international trade in services, especially import of services.
- CBA considering implementation of an international transactions reporting system to collect data on all cross-border payments and receipts going through the banking system.
- Quarterly IIP data published by CBA within one quarter after the reference period; annual data within two quarters; data provided for publication in IFS.

### Armenia: Common Indicators Required for Surveillance (as of May 15, 2017) — Selected timing and frequency facts
- Exchange Rates: Date of latest observation April 2017; Date received 5/1/2017; Frequency of Data D; Frequency of Reporting D; Frequency of Publication D.
- International Reserve Assets and Reserve Liabilities of the Monetary Authorities: Date of latest observation April 2017; Date received 5/1/2017; Frequency of Data D; Frequency of Reporting D; Frequency of Publication M.
- Reserve/Base Money: Date of latest observation April 2017; Date received 5/1/2017; Frequency of Data D; Frequency of Reporting D; Frequency of Publication D.
- Broad Money: Date of latest observation April 2017; Date received 5/1/2017; Frequency of Data M; Frequency of Reporting M; Frequency of Publication M.
- Central Bank Balance Sheet: Date of latest observation April 2017; Date received 5/1/2017; Frequency of Data D; Frequency of Reporting M; Frequency of Publication M.
- Consolidated Balance Sheet of the Banking System: Date of latest observation April 2017; Date received 5/1/2017; Frequency of Data M; Frequency of Reporting M; Frequency of Publication M.
- Interest Rates: Date of latest observation April 2016; Date received 5/1/2017; Frequency of Data W; Frequency of Reporting W; Frequency of Publication M.
- Consumer Price Index: Date of latest observation April 2017; Date received 5/5/2017; Frequency of Data M; Frequency of Reporting M; Frequency of Publication M.
- Revenue, Expenditure, Balance and Composition of Financing — General Government: Date of latest observation Q1 2017; Date received 5/5/2017; Frequency of Data Q; Frequency of Reporting Q; Frequency of Publication Q.
- Revenue, Expenditure, Balance and Composition of Financing — Central Government: Date of latest observation Q1 2017; Date received 5/5/2017; Frequency of Data M; Frequency of Reporting M; Frequency of Publication Q.
- Stocks of Central Government and Central Government-Guaranteed Debt: Date of latest observation March 2017; Date received 4/30/2017; Frequency of Data M; Frequency of Reporting M; Frequency of Publication Q.
- External Current Account Balance: Date of latest observation Q4 2016; Date received 3/31/2017; Frequency of Data Q; Frequency of Reporting Q; Frequency of Publication Q.
- Exports and Imports of Goods and Services: Date of latest observation Q1 2017; Date received 5/10/2017; Frequency of Data M; Frequency of Reporting M; Frequency of Publication Q.
- GDP/GNP: Date of latest observation Q4 2016; Date received 3/2/2017; Frequency of Data Q; Frequency of Reporting Q; Frequency of Publication Q.
- Gross External Debt: Date of latest observation Q4 2016; Date received 3/31/2017; Frequency of Data Q; Frequency of Reporting Q; Frequency of Publication Q.
- International Investment Position: Date of latest observation Q4 2016; Date received 3/31/2017; Frequency of Data Q; Frequency of Reporting Q; Frequency of Publication Q.

### Statement by Armenian authorities (Richard Doornbosch and Yosef Yakhin) — June 20, 2017
- Authorities thanked the IMF team headed by Mr. Hossein Samiei for candid, constructive dialogue and valuable advice.
- Authorities broadly agree with staff’s assessment and recommendations.
- Main challenges identified: strengthening the fiscal position, modernizing the fiscal framework, improving the business environment, and reducing poverty.
- Program performance since previous review: satisfactory; all quantitative performance criteria, indicative targets, and structural benchmarks met.
- Specific implementation highlights:
  - Mechanism to strengthen monitoring and prioritizing of foreign-financed capital projects established (December 2016 SB).
  - Centralized database of all ongoing, planned, and pledged projects built (March 2017 SB).
  - 2017 budget secured funding for the Pension System Awareness Center (December 2016 SB).
  - CBA prepared a plan for divestment of PanArmenian Bank (December 2016 SB).

Economic activity (authorities' view and facts)
- Economy remains vulnerable to external shocks due to exports accounting for 30 percent of GDP and domestic consumption relying heavily on remittances.
- Remittances:
  - In 2016 remittances inflow fell 6.9 percent (in dollar terms) relative to 2015, and by 34.3 percent relative to 2014.
  - Remittances financed domestic consumption amounting to 12.6 percent of GDP in 2016.
- 2016 macro outcomes:
  - Real GDP growth in 2016: 0.2 percent.
  - CPI inflation in 2016: -1.1 percent (deflation).
  - Current account deficit in 2016: 2.7 percent of GDP.
  - Fiscal deficit widened to 5.6 percent in 2016.
  - CBA continued to ease monetary conditions.
- 2017 outlook and indicators:
  - Economic activity index recovered since late 2016.
  - Better-than-expected tax revenues since the beginning of 2017.
  - Exports continued growing and remittances appear to be picking up.
  - Headline CPI inflation reached 1.5 percent yoy in May.
  - Rising copper price and better outlook in major trading partners, especially Russia, support the positive outlook.

Fiscal policy
- In 2017 a debt-brake mechanism was activated, imposing sharp fiscal consolidation measures.
- Law on Public Debt prevents general government debt from exceeding 60 percent of GDP; once debt ratio reaches 50 percent a braking mechanism limits the fiscal deficit in the following year to three percent of the average GDP in the previous three years.
- 2016 outcomes triggered activation: general government debt rose over 50 percent of GDP and fiscal deficit widened to 5.6 percent of GDP (relative to revised program target of 5.9 percent of GDP).
- 2017 budget target deficit: 2.8 percent of 2017 GDP.
- Authorities’ consolidation measures:
  - Substantial reduction in foreign-financed capital expenditure.
  - Moratorium on signing new foreign-financed projects.
  - Discussions with donors to postpone or restructure some projects.
- Revenue outturns and flexibility:
  - Overperformance in tax collection since the beginning of 2017 approximately 0.25 percent of GDP in the first quarter.
  - Authorities estimate overperformance of tax collection for the year to reach 1 percent of GDP, allowing limited increase in foreign-financed capital expenditure while complying with the target deficit.
  - Authorities acknowledge downside risks and stand ready to scale down expenditure if adverse risks materialize.
- Authorities and staff view the current fiscal rule (relying only on a debt ceiling) as overly contractionary and procyclical when binding; IMF TA is assisting to revise and modernize the fiscal rule with objective to send a draft of a new fiscal rule to the National Assembly by October 2017 alongside the draft budget for 2018.

Monetary and financial sector policies
- CBA balancing monetary expansion to increase inflation and financial stability considerations.
- Policy rate actions:
  - In mid-February the CBA’s governing board cut the policy rate by additional 0.25 percentage points to 6.0 percent, the lowest level in seven years.
- Inflation and policy stance:
  - Inflation at 1.5 percent YoY in May is below the target of 4 percent but has picked up from negative territory.
  - CBA evaluating impact of recent rate cuts and stands ready to adjust monetary conditions to keep inflation path on track.
  - Concern that too fast rate reduction could cause rapid exchange rate depreciation, a fast rise in inflation expectations, undermine long-term price stability and financial stability, and aggravate dollarization.
- Exchange rate policy:
  - Authorities ensure two-way flexibility of the exchange rate, using limited intervention to smooth excessive fluctuations and offset transitory pressures.
  - Exchange rate flexibility is important to improve monetary policy transmission.
- Reserves:
  - CBA rebuilt foreign reserves to $2.2 billion at end-2016 (5.2 months of 2017 projected imports); reserves now considered at an adequate level.
- Financial sector soundness:
  - Banking system well capitalized.
  - NPL ratio and banks’ profitability remain a challenge but both have been improving over the past year.
  - High dollarization remains a challenge for financial stability and monetary policy effectiveness.
  - CBA requested a Financial Sector Assessment Program (FSAP) for 2018 to improve monitoring and risk assessment and ensure soundness.

Structural reforms
- Progress reported on promoting competition, improving international integration, fighting corruption, and strengthening the energy sector.
- Energy sector measures:
  - Encouraging greater private sector involvement,
  - Strengthening financial soundness of the sector,
  - Modernization of the nuclear power plant,
  - Exploring options for building new thermal power plants to replace maturing facilities — expected to improve supply reliability and reduce electricity costs.
- Competition and regulatory framework:
  - Amendments to the law on protection of economic competition submitted to the National Assembly in late 2016; expected adoption by end of the year.
- International integration:
  - Improving connectivity via “open skies” policy and economic cooperation with EEU and EU.
  - Establishment of the Center for Strategic Initiatives to encourage and analyze key reforms to attract FDI and foster public-private partnerships.
- Anti-corruption and administrative reforms:
  - Strengthened law on procurement and substantially improved procurement transparency.
  - Improved tax and customs administration.
  - Criminalized illicit enrichment and established new investigatory approach to corruption crimes.
  - Developed legislative amendments to reduce cash transactions and tackle the shadow economy.

*IMF staff report and Armenian authorities’ statement (as provided in the source).*

### Conclusion

### Conclusion

### Progress under the EFF program
- Armenia has made substantial progress under the EFF program: public financial management has improved through a review of lending operations and the strengthening of the monitoring system of foreign financed projects; a pension reform to enhance long-term fiscal sustainability is underway; a new tax code was adopted; progress has been made in legislation for promoting domestic competition and developing the financial markets; the CBA is in the process of incorporating financial stability considerations into the operational policy framework, and the inflation targeting regime has been strengthen.

### Remaining challenges and next steps
- Nevertheless, challenges remain, including a revision of the medium-term fiscal framework, reducing dollarization, further integration into the global economy and reducing poverty.
- The authorities greatly appreciate the long-lasting cooperation with the Fund and its valuable advice and are considering the possibility of a successor program. They look forward to initiating discussions on this matter later this year.

*Source: cr17226 - Conclusion*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/cr/2017/cr17226.pdf_
