## cr17245

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [cr17245](https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/cr/2017/cr17245.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/files/publications/cr/2017/cr17245.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/files/publications/cr/2017/cr17245.pdf.json)

---

### Background and Program
- A three-year arrangement under the Extended Credit Facility (ECF) was approved on July 20, 2016 in an amount of SDR 83.55 million (75 percent of quota).
- The ECF arrangement provides balance of payments support for the government’s reform agenda to restore macroeconomic stability, boost economic growth and job creation, reduce poverty, and build resilience towards exiting fragility.
- The first review was completed on December 21, 2016, bringing total disbursements under the arrangement to SDR 25.05 million (22.5 percent of quota).
- Authorities requested an augmentation of SDR 11.14 million (10 percent of quota) to cover additional balance of payments needs associated with accelerated clearance of arrears to small and medium sized government suppliers; augmentation to be disbursed upon completion of the third review.
- Completion of the second review will allow disbursement of SDR 11.7 million.
- Staff supports completion of the second review, the augmentation request, and recommends completion of the financing assurances review.

### Recent Developments and Outlook
- Security
  - Security deteriorated in many parts of the country; hundreds of casualties and thousands displaced.
  - All 14 armed groups participated in the last DDRR consultative meeting; progress on the ground remains scant.
  - Government proceeding with recruitment and training of 500 policemen and gendarmes and deployment of the gendarmerie in combat zones.
  - Special Criminal Court became operational; appointment of a special prosecutor on May 26 noted as important.
- Growth and inflation
  - Real GDP growth for 2016: 4.5 percent.
  - Inflation estimated at 4.6 percent in 2016.
  - Real GDP growth forecast for 2017: 4.7 percent (vs. 5 percent projected in December 2016).
  - Average inflation projected: 3.8 percent in 2017 and 3 percent by 2019.
  - GDP growth projected to average 5.3 percent in 2018–20.
- External sector and debt
  - 2016 current account deficit estimated at 9.1 percent of GDP.
  - Public external debt at end-2016: CFAF 185.1 billion (17.7 percent of GDP).
  - Medium-term balance of payments outlook revised with lower diamond exports and higher oil imports; overall balance expected to turn into a surplus from 2019.
- Donor support and investment program
  - Economic and financial partners pledged about US$2.2 billion in support of the National Plan for Recovery and Peace (NPRP) at November 2016 Brussels donor conference.
  - Secretariat to oversee and coordinate the investment program operational since May 2017.

### Program Performance (through end-2016 and Q1 2017)
- Overall assessment
  - Program implementation as of end-2016 was broadly satisfactory despite security challenges.
  - End-December and continuous quantitative performance criteria (PC) were met.
  - All quantitative PCs were met; two structural benchmarks missed.
- Fiscal and cash management outcomes (2016)
  - Domestic primary deficit in 2016: 1.1 percent of GDP (better than programmed).
  - Delayed disbursement of external budget support led to liquidity squeeze and reined in expenditure; indicative target on social spending was missed by a small margin.
  - Authorities accumulated external payments arrears in Q4 2016; these arrears have since been cleared or are under consideration for debt cancellation.
- Q1 2017 performance
  - All indicative targets for end-March 2017 met except for tax revenue and domestic government financing.
  - Cash expenditure far below projections; domestic primary deficit limited to 0.1 percent of GDP (within program target) despite revenue shortfall.
  - Domestic government financing higher than programmed to pay for additional arrears clearance.
  - Commitments for social spending reached CFAF 3.3 billion (indicative target CFAF 1.5 billion).
- Structural benchmarks
  - Delayed: closing non-donor related government accounts in commercial banks (end-March 2017) remains ongoing.
  - Delayed: repatriation of diplomats whose assignments ended (payments eliminated; prior action).
  - Completed on time: (i) restricting exemptions solely to those provided by law and freezing new tax exemptions (end-December 2016); (ii) launching audits of social debt, debt to suppliers, and cross-debt (end-February 2017).

### Outlook, Risks, and Contingency Measures
- Baseline and revisions
  - Medium-term outlook assumes improved security, higher public investment, and rising agriculture and mining production.
  - Implementation of government infrastructure program in water and electricity under NPRP could raise growth further.
- Key downside risks
  - Domestic: failure to progress on inclusive security-sector reform could lead to much lower growth, possibly higher inflation, and lower revenue mobilization.
  - Capacity and governance: lack of political will and weak capacity to address very low domestic resource mobilization and low transparency of budget execution.
  - External: unfavorable global/regional environment could reduce policy collaboration, depress commodity prices (cotton, forestry, mining), and dampen investment; delays in external budget support and project grants; regional BOP pressures and collective fiscal adjustments could have negative spillovers.
- Low-growth scenario and policy responses (selected staff calculations)
  - Real GDP Growth (percent): Baseline 4.7 (2017), 5.0 (2018), 5.2 (2019), 5.5 (2020); Low-growth 3.5 (2017), 2.0 (2018), 2.0 (2019), 2.0 (2020).
  - Domestic Revenues (percent of GDP): Baseline 8.8 (2017), 9.4 (2018), 9.9 (2019), 10.8 (2020); Low-growth 8.5 (2017–20).
  - Domestic Primary Balance (percent of GDP): Baseline -1.9 (2017), -1.5 (2018), -0.9 (2019), -0.2 (2020); Low-growth (non-adjustment) -2.3 (2017), -2.5 (2018), -2.6 (2019), -3.1 (2020).
  - Funding Gap (CFAF billion): Baseline 66.3 (2017), 57.4 (2018), 47.8 (2019), 36.4 (2020); Low-growth (non-adjustment) 71.0 (2017), 78.6 (2018), 75.4 (2019), 60.0 (2020).
  - Potential Adjustment Measures (CFAF billion): Primary Spending cuts 4.7–15.0; Investment Spending 5.0–10.0; Domestic Arrears Clearance 5.0–10.0.
- Authorities’ committed contingency measures
  - Reduce non-priority current spending: CFAF 5–15 billion per year.
  - Reduce domestically-financed capital spending: CFAF 5–10 billion per year.
  - Adopt a less-ambitious arrears clearance strategy: CFAF 5–10 billion per year.

### Fiscal Outlook for 2017
- 2017 budget consistent with program and anchored on domestic primary balance objective.
- Fiscal strategy targets:
  - Domestic revenue target: about 8.8 percent of GDP.
  - Current primary spending target: 9.6 percent of GDP.
  - Domestically-financed capital expenditure target: 1.2 percent of GDP.
  - Domestic primary deficit target: 1.9 percent of GDP.
- Financing needs for 2017 expected to be CFAF 66.3 billion (5.8 percent of GDP); covered by Fund disbursements totaling CFAF 28.1 billion and budgetary support CFAF 38.2 billion from EU, WB, AfDB, and France.

### Regaining Momentum in Fiscal Management: Enhancing Revenue Mobilization
- Revenue shortfalls and corrective measures (first four months of 2017)
  - Domestic revenues, particularly customs, significantly below target.
  - Total customs revenue shortfall: CFAF 5 billion (0.5 percent of GDP), mainly due to undervaluation of imports.
  - Savings from non-wage primary expenditure: CFAF 4.7 billion; offset revenue shortfall and kept domestic primary balance in line with program.
  - Authorities reduced domestic arrears to pension and government suppliers by CFAF 4.1 billion (higher than programmed).
- Additional measures agreed to yield CFAF 5.6 billion (C.A.R. authorities estimate)
  - Apply minimal valuation for goods imports as determined by pre-shipment inspection company: 0.8.
  - Audit imports’ valuation since January 2016 and require retroactive payments for undervaluation by importers: 1.7.
  - Correct erroneous entries in ASYCUDA of the CEMAC common external tariff and discounted rates of VAT: 0.1.
  - Increase number of convoys between Beloko and Bangui: 0.4.
  - Recover customs debts: 0.4.
  - Introduce new pre-payment procedures at the Douala Single Window: 0.4.
  - Step up VAT and personal income tax: 0.8.
  - Continue recovery actions: 1.0.
  - Total: 5.6 (C.A.R. authorities).
- Additional customs and compliance measures (program)
  - Process all customs transactions through ASYCUDA; publish ministerial decree clarifying IT unit responsibilities at customs regarding ASYCUDA.
  - Secure customs and transit operations from the port of Douala to destination; full utilization of ASYCUDA at Beloko (proposed structural benchmark, end-December 2017).
  - Apply deferred VAT payment mechanism for imports for significant investment projects and exports to prevent VAT credit accumulation.
  - Cancel comprehensive outsourcing of customs operations to a private company (prior action).

### Tax Administration Reforms and Para-fiscal Taxes
- Tax administration reforms (since November 2016)
  - Intensified identification of VAT stop filers among large- and medium-sized businesses; launched enforcement campaign to collect unpaid taxes and intensified controls of payments for unsettled imports.
  - Discontinued offsetting unpaid VAT credits against other taxes between oil importers and the State on March 1, 2017; government agencies required to budget and pay for oil consumption.
- Streamlining para-fiscal taxes
  - Inventory of para-fiscal taxes underway; action plan to eliminate unjustified ones and transfer others to the TSA (proposed structural benchmarks, end-December 2017).
  - Creation of new para-fiscal taxes forbidden; ordonnance abolished recent tax on telecommunication.

### Public Financial Management (PFM) and Civil Service
- PFM reform progress
  - TSA consolidation began; 256 bank accounts closed or frozen; remaining 113 bank accounts to be closed by end-June 2017.
  - GESCO not used optimally; authorities intend to deploy a new application by end of 2019 and, during transition, make best use of GESCO to ensure timely recording of budget transactions.
- Transparency and reporting
  - Accounting balances for 2010–15 established and under review by the court of audit.
  - Plan to finalize budget execution report for 2016 (structural benchmark, end-September 2017).
  - Commitment to quarterly production of budget execution reports within 30 days of end of quarter (proposed structural benchmark, quarterly, from end-September 2017).
  - Produced budget execution report for Q1 2017 (prior action).
- Exceptional payment procedures
  - 2016: use declined compared to previous years; preliminary end-March 2017 indicates increase to 19.5 percent of non-wage and non-debt spending.
  - Authorities committed to limit extraordinary expenditure procedure to a quarterly average of 5 percent in 2018 (proposed indicative target, from end-March 2018).
- Civil service reform
  - Cleaning and securitization of civil service roster underway.
  - Retirement of personnel exceeding retirement age complete except for army and police forces.
  - Payments of expatriation benefits to diplomats whose assignment ended have been eliminated (prior action).

### Reducing Domestic Payment Arrears and Augmentation Request
- Arrears audit and levels
  - Arrears to commercial banks and almost all arrears to small- and medium-sized government contractors audited and reviewed.
  - Arrears to SMEs revised downward from CFAF 14.2 billion (end-2016) to CFAF 9.4 billion (April 2017).
  - Social arrears (wages and pensions) amounted to CFAF 71.1 billion at end-April 2017, wage arrears revised up to CFAF 67 billion.
  - External audit expected before end-September.
- Arrears to commercial banks (CFAF 26 billion) to be securitized with BEAC technical assistance; comprehensive settlement plan to be adopted (structural benchmark, end-June 2017).
- Accelerated repayments of arrears (CFAF 9 billion) to SMEs planned to lower NPLs, relieve liquidity constraints, and rebuild production capacity.
- Authorities requested augmentation of access: SDR 11.14 million (CFAF 9 billion, 10 percent of quota) to be disbursed at time of third review; additional payments needs arise from clearing social arrears estimated at CFAF 71.1 billion (before auditing).

### Debt Management and External Arrears
- All post-HIPC external payment arrears accumulated in 2016 have been cleared, except for China; C.A.R. remained current on external debt service in 2017 so far.
- China indicated intention to cancel all outstanding debts; discussions underway.
- New York court ruled in January 2017 that an Export-Import Bank located in Taiwan Province of China has claims against C.A.R. from 1991–1992 loan agreements.
- C.A.R. still has arrears to private creditors and is making good-faith efforts to reach agreements.
- Fiscal cash buffer at end-March: CFAF 19.1 billion (1.6 percent of GDP), sufficient to cover 2017 external debt service.
- Updated DSA confirms high risk of debt distress; vulnerable to GDP, export and revenue shocks and contingent liabilities.
- Authorities and staff agree C.A.R. should rely on grant financing with strict limits on highly concessional financing to critical projects with assured profitability.

### Financial Supervision and Banking Sector
- Steps to improve financial supervision underway.
- Banking system broadly profitable and well capitalized despite challenging environment.
  - Average capital to asset ratio: almost 20 percent.
- COBAC conducted an in-depth inspection mission in June 2017 (first since 2012) focusing on two largest banks.

### Technical Assistance and Capacity Building
- From January 2017, under IMF Capacity Building Framework (CBF) pilot, C.A.R. benefited from IMF and AFRITAC Central TA on tax policy, domestic revenue collection, PFM, public debt management, and macroeconomic statistics.
- Objective: strengthen institutional framework coordinating TA and training to increase revenue, enhance spending efficiency, restore budget discipline and transparency, strengthen debt management and create core macro fiscal capacity.
- Steps taken to restore Economic and Financial Reform Monitoring Unit (CS-REF) to coordinate TA and training.
- Authorities intend to utilize additional TA in revenue mobilization, PFM, national accounting, public debt management and external trade data.

### Program Modalities, Financing, and Safeguards
- Program monitored semi-annually; PCs for end-June 2017 and end-December 2017 maintained; indicative targets for end-March 2018 and PCs for end-June 2018 proposed.
- Prior actions met: eliminating salaries and expatriation benefits to diplomats whose assignments ended; producing 2017 Q1 budget implementation report; canceling contract to delegate customs management.
- Limit for concessional borrowing increased from CFAF 6 billion to CFAF 8.8 billion to accommodate AfDB budget support loan.
- New indicative target: limit use of extraordinary expenditure procedures to a quarterly average of 5 percent in 2018.
- Program financing: program remains fully financed with firm commitments for upcoming 12 months; financing for 2017–2018 covered by World Bank (CFAF 8.8 billion), France (CFAF 6.6 billion), European Union (CFAF 13.1 billion) and African Development Bank (CFAF 8.8 billion) and programmed ECF disbursements.
- Authorities requested augmentation of access of 10 percent of quota (CFAF 9 billion) to cover additional BOP needs linked to accelerated payment of arrears to SMEs.
- C.A.R. capacity to repay the Fund: significant Fund repayments planned — SDR 12.2 million in 2017 and SDR 10.3 million in 2018; authorities making regular deposits at BEAC to safeguard payments.
- Safeguards assessment: full safeguards assessment under periodic four-year cycle for regional central banks in progress; governance-focused legal reforms concluded in early June 2017 with unanimous Board vote enacting end-March amendments to BEAC Charter; transition plan to adopt IFRS proceeding; BEAC needs to strengthen internal audit, financial reporting and risk management.

### Debt Sustainability Analysis (DSA) and Macroeconomic Assumptions
- Medium-term growth expected to average 5.3 percent; long-run growth 3.5 percent.
- Medium-term average inflation (GDP deflator): 4.9 percent; long-run inflation converge to 3 percent.
- Fiscal projections (selected)
  - Domestic primary balance: 2017 -1.9 percent of GDP; medium-term (2018–21 average) -0.5 percent of GDP; long-run primary deficit 2 percent (including grants and externally financed capital expenditure).
  - Overall fiscal balance (excl. grants): 2017 -5.7 percent; medium-term -4.8 percent.
  - Overall fiscal balance (incl. grants): 2017 -0.3 percent; medium-term 1.1 percent.
- External debt (percent of GDP)
  - Jul-17: 24.4 percent.
  - Medium-term projection (2018–21 average): 19.0 percent.
- DSA results
  - Baseline: one external debt indicator breaches policy threshold — PV of debt-to-exports ratio projected to breach threshold until 2019.
  - DSA confirms high risk of external debt distress.
  - Comparative projections show PV of debt-to-GDP decline in new DSA vs. 2016 DSA (selected values preserved in source).
- Stress tests and scenarios highlight vulnerabilities to lower growth, exports, and contingent liabilities.
- Policy implications: prioritize domestic revenue mobilization, fully implement tax and customs reforms, strengthen debt management, consolidate peace, and pursue structural policies to diversify exports.
- Financing approach: secure grants for investment program; limit highly concessional borrowing to exceptional cases with rigorous due diligence.

### Funding Overview and Residual Gap (figures preserved as in source)
- Funding gap (line 1): 66.357.447.8
- Budget support (grants) (line 2): 29.4 38.338.3
  - World Bank: 8.88.88.8
  - European Union: 13.113.113.1
  - African Development Bank: 8.88.8
  - France: 6.66.66.6
  - Other (CEMAC and Timor-Leste): 0.91.01.0
- Budget support (loans) (line 3): 8.80.00.0
  - African Development Bank: 8.8
- Residual financing gap (1-2-3): 28.119.19.5
- IMF financing (total 85 percent of quota, 22.5 percent disbursed in 2016): 28.119.19.5
- Percent of quota by year:
  - 2017: 31.0
  - 2018: 21.0
  - 2019: 10.5

### Key Program Recommendation and IMF Operational Decision
- Staff recommends completion of the second program ECF review based on C.A.R.’s program performance and decisive corrective actions to address the revenue shortfall.
- Staff supports authorities’ request for a 10 percent of quota augmentation of access (SDR 11.14 million).
- Third disbursement (upon observance of performance criteria for December 31, 2016 and completion of the second review): SDR 11.70 million (10.5 percent of quota), dated March 22, 2017.
- Total program disbursements (Table 10): Total SDR 94.69 million (85.0 percent of quota).

### Conclusion and Appeals
- Situation: C.A.R. remains fragile and requires sustained financial and technical assistance to restore peace, macroeconomic stability, and conditions for inclusive growth.
- Authorities committed to DDRR process and sound reform agenda.
- Call on Directors to support completion of the Second Review under the ECF and the requested augmentation of access.

*IMF staff report: Central African Republic — Executive Summary and excerpts from cr17245 (June 29, 2017).*

### EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

### EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

### Background and Program
- A three-year arrangement under the Extended Credit Facility (ECF) was approved on July 20, 2016 in an amount of SDR 83.55 million (75 percent of quota).
- The ECF arrangement provides balance of payments support for the government’s reform agenda to restore macroeconomic stability, boost economic growth and job creation, reduce poverty, and build resilience towards exiting fragility.
- The first review was completed on December 21, 2016, bringing total disbursements under the arrangement to SDR 25.05 million (22.5 percent of quota).
- To cover additional balance of payments needs associated with the accelerated clearance of arrears to small and medium sized government suppliers, the authorities are requesting an augmentation of SDR 11.14 million (10 percent of quota), to be disbursed upon the completion of the third review under the ECF arrangement.
- Completion of the second review will allow for the disbursement of an amount equivalent to SDR 11.7 million.
- Staff supports completion of the second review under the ECF arrangement, the authorities’ request for augmentation of access, and recommends that the financing assurances review be completed.

### Recent Developments and Outlook
- Security:
  - Security deteriorated in many parts of the country, resulting in hundreds of casualties and thousands of displaced people.
  - All 14 armed groups participated in the last consultative meeting of the disarmament, demobilization, reintegration, and repatriation (DDRR) process, but progress on the ground remains scant.
  - The government is proceeding with the recruitment and training of 500 policemen and gendarmes, as well as the deployment of the gendarmerie in combat zones.
  - A Special Criminal Court (established in 2015) became operational; appointment of a special prosecutor on May 26 was noted as important.
- Growth and inflation:
  - Real GDP growth for 2016 was 4.5 percent, lower than initially programmed.
  - Inflation is estimated at 4.6 percent in 2016.
  - Real GDP growth in 2017 is forecast at 4.7 percent, instead of 5 percent projected in December 2016.
  - Average inflation is projected to decline to 3.8 percent in 2017 and to 3 percent by 2019.
  - GDP growth is projected to average 5.3 percent in 2018–20.
- External sector and debt:
  - The 2016 current account deficit is estimated at 9.1 percent of GDP.
  - Public external debt at end-2016 stood at CFAF 185.1 billion (17.7 percent of GDP).
  - The medium-term balance of payments outlook was revised with lower and more conservative diamond exports and higher oil imports; overall balance is expected to turn into a surplus from 2019.
- Donor support and investment program:
  - Economic and financial partners pledged about US$2.2 billion in support of the National Plan for Recovery and Peace (NPRP) during the November 2016 Brussels donor conference.
  - The secretariat to oversee and coordinate the investment program is operational since May 2017.

### Program Performance (through end-2016 and Q1 2017)
- Overall assessment:
  - Program implementation as of end-2016 was broadly satisfactory despite the challenging security situation.
  - End-December and continuous quantitative performance criteria (PC) were met.
  - All quantitative performance criteria were met while two structural benchmarks were missed.
- Fiscal and cash management outcomes:
  - Domestic primary deficit in 2016 turned out at 1.1 percent of GDP, better than programmed.
  - Delayed disbursement of external budget support led to a liquidity squeeze and reined in expenditure on goods and services, transfers, and investments; an indicative target on social spending was missed by a small margin.
  - As reported in the first review, the authorities accumulated external payments arrears in the last quarter of 2016; these arrears have since been cleared or are being under consideration for debt cancellation.
- Q1 2017 performance:
  - All indicative targets for end-March 2017 were met except for tax revenue and domestic government financing.
  - Cash expenditure was far below projections, limiting the domestic primary deficit to 0.1 percent of GDP—well within the program target, despite the revenue shortfall.
  - Domestic government financing was higher than programmed to pay for additional arrears clearance.
  - Commitments for social spending reached CFAF 3.3 billion, higher than the indicative target of CFAF 1.5 billion.
- Structural benchmarks:
  - Delayed: closing non-donor related government accounts in commercial banks (end-March 2017) remains ongoing.
  - Delayed: repatriation of diplomats whose assignments ended (payments now eliminated; prior action).
  - Completed on time: (i) restricting exemptions solely on those provided by law and freezing new tax exemptions, by end-December 2016; and (ii) launching audits of the social debt, debt to suppliers, and cross-debt, by end-February 2017.

### Outlook, Risks, and Contingency Measures
- Baseline and revisions:
  - The medium-term outlook assumes improved security, higher public investment, and rising agriculture and mining production.
  - Implementation of the government infrastructure program in water and electricity under the NPRP could raise growth further.
- Key downside risks:
  - Domestic: failure to make progress on a broad-based and inclusive reform of the security sector could produce a much lower growth path, possibly higher inflation, and lower revenue mobilization.
  - Capacity and governance: lack of political will and weak capacity to address very low domestic resource mobilization and low transparency of budget execution.
  - External: unfavorable global/regional environment could reduce policy collaboration, depress commodity prices (cotton, forestry, mining), and dampen investment; delays in external budget support and project grants; regional balance of payments pressures and collective fiscal adjustments could have negative spillovers.
- Low-growth scenario and policy responses (Box 1):
  - Low-growth scenario projections (selected figures from staff calculations):
    - Real GDP Growth (percent): Baseline 4.7 (2017), 5.0 (2018), 5.2 (2019), 5.5 (2020); Low-growth 3.5 (2017), 2.0 (2018), 2.0 (2019), 2.0 (2020).
    - Domestic Revenues (percent of GDP): Baseline 8.8 (2017), 9.4 (2018), 9.9 (2019), 10.8 (2020); Low-growth 8.5 (2017–20).
    - Domestic Primary Balance (percent of GDP): Baseline -1.9 (2017), -1.5 (2018), -0.9 (2019), -0.2 (2020); Low-growth (non-adjustment) -2.3 (2017), -2.5 (2018), -2.6 (2019), -3.1 (2020).
    - Funding Gap (CFAF billion): Baseline 66.3 (2017), 57.4 (2018), 47.8 (2019), 36.4 (2020); Low-growth (non-adjustment) 71.0 (2017), 78.6 (2018), 75.4 (2019), 60.0 (2020).
    - Potential Adjustment Measures (CFAF billion): Primary Spending cuts 4.7–15.0; Investment Spending 5.0–10.0; Domestic Arrears Clearance 5.0–10.0.
  - Authorities’ committed contingency measures include reducing non-priority current spending (CFAF 5–15 billion per year), reducing domestically-financed capital spending (CFAF 5–10 billion per year), and adopting a less-ambitious arrears clearance strategy (CFAF 5–10 billion per year).

### Fiscal Outlook for 2017
- The 2017 budget is consistent with the program and anchored on the domestic primary balance objective.
- Fiscal strategy targets:
  - Domestic revenue target of about 8.8 percent of GDP.
  - Current primary spending target of 9.6 percent of GDP.
  - Domestically-financed capital expenditure target of 1.2 percent of GDP.
  - Domestic primary deficit target of 1.9 percent of GDP.

### Regaining Momentum in Improving Fiscal Management: Enhancing Revenue Mobilization
- Revenue shortfalls and corrective measures:
  - Domestic revenues, particularly customs revenues, were significantly below the target in the first four months of 2017.
  - Total customs revenue shortfall was CFAF 5 billion (0.5 percent of GDP), mainly due to widespread undervaluation of imports.
  - Savings from non-wage primary expenditure (CFAF 4.7 billion) offset the revenue shortfall, keeping the domestic primary balance in line with the program target.
  - The authorities reduced domestic arrears to pension and government suppliers by CFAF 4.1 billion, higher than programmed.
- Additional measures agreed to yield CFAF 5.6 billion:
  - Apply minimal valuation for goods imports as determined by the pre-shipment inspection company.
  - Audit imports’ valuation since January 2016 and require retroactive payments for any undervaluation by importers (proposed new structural benchmark, end-September 2017).
  - Streamline information sharing between customs and the Treasury to limit discrepancies between revenue reported by customs and recorded by the Treasury.
  - Strengthen controls of exemptions to ensure quality and quantity of exempted goods match authorizations and address abuse and fraud.
  - Secure customs and transit operations from the port of Douala to destination, including full utilization of ASYCUDA at the border station of Beloko (proposed new structural benchmark, end-December 2017).
  - Improve compliance management through systematic exchange of information between the tax and customs departments and cross-checks of customs and tax returns.
  - Process all customs transactions through ASYCUDA and immediately publish the ministerial decree that clarifies responsibilities of the unit in charge of the IT systems at customs regarding the use of ASYCUDA.
  - Apply the mechanism of deferred VAT payment for imports for significant investment projects and exports to prevent accumulation of VAT credits.
  - Cancel the comprehensive outsourcing of customs operations to a private company (prior action), as that contract was not consistent with the program and could jeopardize revenue mobilization.

*IMF staff report: Central African Republic — Executive Summary (June 29, 2017).*

### 15. The authorities continued to implement their tax administration reforms, with

### 15. The authorities continued to implement their tax administration reforms, with

### Tax administration reforms and revenue measures
- Since November 2016, intensified identification of VAT stop filers among large- and medium-sized businesses; launched enforcement campaign to collect unpaid taxes and intensified controls of payments for unsettled imports.
- Discontinued practice of offsetting unpaid VAT credits against other taxes between oil importers and the State on March 1, 2017; government agencies now required to budget and pay for their oil consumption (MEFP, ¶18).
- Measures and yields (C.A.R. authorities):
  - Total: 5.6
  - Application of minimal valuation for good imports as determined by the pre-shipment inspection company: 0.8
  - Audits of imports’ valuation since January 2016 and make retroactive payments for any undervaluation by importers: 1.7
  - Correct erroneous entries in ASYCUDA of the CEMAC common external tariff and the discounted rates of VAT: 0.1
  - Increase the number of convoys between Beloko and Bangui: 0.4
  - Recover customs debts: 0.4
  - Introduce new pre-payment procedures at the Douala Single Window: 0.4
  - Step up of VAT and personal income tax: 0.8
  - Continue recovery actions: 1.0
- Sources: C.A.R. authorities.

### Streamlining para-fiscal taxes
- Streamlining of numerous quasi-fiscal taxes and excessive levies is underway to eliminate unjustified taxes and bring revenue to the single treasury account (TSA).
- January 2017 tax policy TA mission recommended simplifying the tax system and streamlining para-fiscal taxation.
- Authorities are taking stock of all existing para-fiscal taxes and fees and intend to adopt an action plan to eliminate unjustified ones and transfer others to the TSA (proposed new structural benchmarks, end-December 2017).
- Creation of new para-fiscal taxes has been forbidden; a government ordonnance abolished a recently introduced tax on telecommunication (MEFP, ¶20).

### Improving public financial management (PFM)
- PFM reform agenda progressing at a slow pace; action plan updated during FAD’s March 2017 TA mission (MEFP, ¶21).
- Consolidation of the treasury single account (TSA) began, to be completed by end-June 2017; 256 bank accounts closed or frozen; remaining 113 bank accounts to be closed by end-June 2017.
- Treasury management system (GESCO) not used optimally; prevents timely accounting of revenues and expenditures and constrains budgetary and treasury operations.
  - Authorities intend to deploy a new application by end of 2019 based on a functional and technical assessment supported by development partners; during transition, make best use of GESCO to ensure timely and consistent recording of all budget transactions (MEFP, ¶22).
- Transparency in budget reporting:
  - Accounting balances for 2010–15 were established and are under review by the court of audit.
  - Plan to finalize the budget execution report for 2016 (structural benchmark, end-September 2017).
  - Commitment to quarterly production of budget execution reports within 30 days of the end of the quarter (proposed new structural benchmark, quarterly, from end-September 2017).
  - Produced the budget execution report for the first quarter of 2017 (prior action) (MEFP, ¶23).
- Use of exceptional payment procedures:
  - In 2016, use declined compared to previous years.
  - Preliminary data at end-March 2017 indicates increase to 19.5 percent of non-wage and non-debt spending.
  - Authorities committed to limit extraordinary expenditure procedure to a quarterly average of 5 percent in 2018 (proposed new indicative target, from end-March 2018) (MEFP, ¶24).
- Civil service reform:
  - Cleaning and securitization of civil service roster underway.
  - Retirement of personnel that have exceeded retirement age is complete except for army and police forces.
  - Payments of expatriation benefits to diplomats whose assignment ended have been eliminated (prior action) (MEFP, ¶25).

### Reducing domestic payment arrears and request for augmentation
- Audited and reviewed arrears to commercial banks and almost all arrears to small- and medium-sized government contractors (Text Table 2).
- Arrears to these companies revised downward from CFAF 14.2 billion in end 2016 to CFAF 9.4 billion in April 2017.
- Social arrears (on wages and pensions) amounted to CFAF 71.1 billion at the end of April 2017, of which wage arrears revised up to CFAF 67 billion.
- External audit expected before end-September.
- Arrears to commercial banks (CFAF 26 billion) will be securitized with technical assistance of BEAC; comprehensive settlement plan to be adopted (structural benchmark, end-June 2017) (MEFP, ¶26).
- Authorities requested an augmentation of access: SDR 11.14 million (CFAF 9 billion, 10 percent of quota) to be disbursed at the time of the third review to support additional balance of payments need linked to clearance of commercial arrears to SMEs (text).
- Additional payments needs arise from clearing social arrears estimated at CFAF 71.1 billion (before auditing); authorities may request another augmentation at time of the third review.
- Table excerpt: Domestic and External Debt (Billions of CFAF)
  - Total (Dec 16): 68.1 (Current Arrears) / 140.2 (Total) / 208.3 (Domestic/External Total)
  - Total (Apr 17): 68.1 (Current Arrears) / 134.3 (Total) / 202.4 (Total)
  - Total across categories: 253.4 (Total) / 37.3 (of which in arrears)
  - BEAC: 56.0 (Dec 16 current arrears) / 22.5 (Dec 16 total) / 78.5 (Dec 16 total)
  - Commercial Banks: 0.0 (Dec 16 current arrears) / 26.1 (Dec 16 total) / 26.1 (Dec 16 total)
  - Social Arrears: 0.0 (Dec 16 current arrears) / 72.2 (Dec 16 total) / 72.2 (Dec 16 total); Apr 17 social arrears: 0.0 (current) / 71.1 (total) / 71.1 (total)
  - T-Bills: 9.5 (Dec 16 current arrears) / 0.0 (Dec 16 total) / 9.5 (Dec 16 total)
  - Cross Debt and Other: 2.6 (Dec 16 current arrears) / 5.2 (Dec 16 total) / 7.8 (Dec 16 total)
  - Memo notes: Audit and validation of social arrears ongoing; audit of CFAF 9 billion of arrears to private suppliers almost complete.
- Accelerated repayments of arrears (CFAF 9 billion) to SMEs planned to lower NPLs, relieve liquidity constraints, and rebuild production capacity.
- Augmentation request (SDR 11.14 million / CFAF 9 billion) intended to support accelerated arrears clearance while preserving gross reserves import cover (Box 2 on regional strategy).

### Debt management and arrears to external creditors
- All post-HIPC external payment arrears accumulated in 2016 have been cleared, except for China; C.A.R. remained current on external debt service so far in 2017.
- China indicated intention to cancel all outstanding debts; discussions underway. Negotiations with India for post-HIPC arrears ongoing.
- New York court ruled in January 2017 that an Export-Import Bank located in Taiwan Province of China has claims against C.A.R. from loan agreements signed in 1991 and 1992.
- C.A.R. still has arrears to private creditors and is making good-faith efforts to reach collaborative agreements (MEFP, ¶30).
- Authorities have reached out to creditors in a timely manner, explained economic problems and program outlines; Fund may provide financing notwithstanding arrears to private creditors.
- Strengthening debt management with AFRITAC Central TA on portfolio analysis and reporting.
- Fiscal cash buffer at end-March: CFAF 19.1 billion (1.6 percent of GDP), sufficient to cover 2017 external debt service (MEFP, ¶29).
- At end-December 2016, pre-HIPC payment arrears totaled CFAF 123.6 billion to Argentina, Equatorial Guinea, Iraq, Libya, Montenegro, and Export-Import Bank located in Taiwan Province of China; authorities continue outreach to settle these arrears (MEFP, ¶25).
- Updated Debt Sustainability Analysis (DSA) confirms high risk of debt distress; vulnerable to GDP, export and revenue shocks and materializing contingent liabilities (MEFP, ¶31).
- Authorities and staff agree C.A.R. should rely on grant financing with strict limits on highly concessional financing to critical projects with assured profitability (Text Table 3).

### Improving financial supervision
- Steps to improve financial supervision underway.
- Banking system remains broadly profitable and well capitalized despite challenging environment.
  - Average capital to asset ratio: almost 20 percent.
  - Exposure concentrated on a few large international companies, limiting risks and operating costs (MEFP, ¶33).
- COBAC conducted an in-depth inspection mission in June 2017 (first since 2012) focusing on two largest banks, assessing internal risk management, valuation practices, governance and profitability.

### Technical assistance and capacity building
- From January 2017, under IMF’s Capacity Building Framework (CBF) pilot project, C.A.R. benefited from IMF and AFRITAC Central TA on tax policy, domestic revenue collection, PFM, public debt management, and macroeconomic statistics (Annex I).
- Objective: strengthen institutional framework coordinating TA and training to increase revenue, enhance spending efficiency, restore budget discipline and transparency, strengthen debt management and create core macro fiscal capacity.
- Steps taken to restore Economic and Financial Reform Monitoring Unit (CS-REF) in coordinating TA and training.
- Authorities intend to utilize additional technical assistance in revenue mobilization, public finance management, national accounting, public debt management and external trade data (MEFP, ¶35).

### Program modalities, financing, and safeguards
- Program monitored semi-annually; performance criteria for end-June 2017 and end-December 2017 maintained; indicative targets for end-March 2018 and performance criteria for end-June 2018 proposed (MEFP, Table 1).
- Prior actions met: eliminating salaries and expatriation benefits to diplomats whose assignments ended; producing 2017 Q1 budget implementation report; canceling a contract to delegate customs management (MEFP, Table 2).
- Limit for concessional borrowing (memorandum item) increased from CFAF 6 billion to CFAF 8.8 billion to accommodate African Development Bank budget support loan (MEFP, ¶38).
- New indicative target: limit use of extraordinary expenditure procedures to a quarterly average of 5 percent in 2018.
- Additional structural benchmarks for 2017 (MEFP, Table 2):
  - Undertake audits of imports’ valuation set from January 2016 to May 2017 based on pre-inspection values and make retroactive payments for undervaluation by importers (end-September 2017).
  - Quarterly production of budget execution reports within 30 days of end of quarter (quarterly, from end-September 2017).
  - Adoption of an action plan to eliminate unjustified para-fiscal taxes (end-December 2017).
  - Utilization of ASYCUDA at Beloko (end-December 2017) (MEFP, ¶39).
- Program financing:
  - Program remains fully financed with firm commitments of financing for upcoming 12 months and good prospects for remainder of program period.
  - For 2017 and 2018, financing needs covered by annual disbursements: World Bank (CFAF 8.8 billion), France (CFAF 6.6 billion), European Union (CFAF 13.1 billion) and African Development Bank (CFAF 8.8 billion); programmed ECF disbursements to close remaining balance of payments need (Text Table 4).
  - Authorities committed to delay spending if donor commitments not disbursed timely.
- Authorities requested augmentation of access to Fund resources of 10 percent of quota (CFAF 9 billion) to cover additional balance of payments needs linked to accelerated payment of arrears to small- and medium-sized suppliers (¶32).
- C.A.R. has capacity to repay the Fund; significant Fund repayments: SDR 12.2 million in 2017 and SDR 10.3 million in 2018. Authorities making regular deposits at the BEAC to safeguard these payments (¶33).
- Safeguards assessment:
  - Full safeguards assessment under periodic four-year cycle for regional central banks in progress.
  - Governance-focused legal reforms concluded in early June 2017 with unanimous Board vote enacting end-March amendments to BEAC Charter.
  - Transition plan to adopt IFRS proceeding well.
  - BEAC needs to strengthen capacity in internal audit, financial reporting and risk management; staff to maintain close engagement (¶34).

*Sources: C.A.R. authorities and IMF Staff calculations.*

### 1. Funding gap66.357.447.8

### 1. Funding gap66.357.447.8

### Funding overview and residual gap
- Funding gap (line 1): 66.357.447.8
- Budget support (grants) (line 2): 29.4 38.338.3
  - World Bank: 8.88.88.8
  - European Union: 13.113.113.1
  - African Development Bank: 8.88.8
  - France: 6.66.66.6
  - Other (CEMAC and Timor-Leste): 0.91.01.0
- Budget support (loans) (line 3): 8.80.00.0
  - African Development Bank: 8.8
- Residual financing gap (1-2-3): 28.119.19.5

### IMF financing
- IMF financing (total 85 percent of quota, 22.5 percent disbursed in 2016): 28.119.19.5
- Percent of quota by year:
  - 2017: 31.0
  - 2018: 21.0
  - 2019: 10.5

### Economic recovery and security risks
- Ongoing economic recovery is at risk due to significant degradation of security outside of Bangui.
- Resurging violence can weaken growth prospects if not addressed.
- Pursuance of the DDRR process to obtain a genuine and inclusive peace agreement with all armed groups is critical to maintain and consolidate peace and security.
- Economic reforms and improving the business environment are key to:
  - Spur private investment and job opportunities.
  - Lure youths away from armed groups.
- Faster channeling of available assistance from development partners into priority projects is recommended.
- Payment of suppliers and social arrears will:
  - Support the economy.
  - Improve social conditions.
  - Entrench peace in the country.

### Revenue mobilization and expenditure management
- Staff urges authorities to maintain and step up reform momentum in improving domestic revenue mobilization and expenditure management.
- Revenue mobilization, particularly at customs, has been disappointing.
- Implementation of envisaged measures is critical to safeguard fiscal space for priority infrastructure and social spending.
- Expenditure tracking and accounting, including full utilization of the computerized PFM system, should bolster spending efficiency and transparency.
- Recent increase of Fund TA on tax policy, revenue administration, and PFM provided relevant recommendations; staff encourages their swift implementation to create space to ramp up priority social spending and public investment essential for inclusive growth and political stability.

### Debt sustainability and borrowing recommendations
- Staff urges authorities to limit borrowing, including of highly concessional loans, to safeguard debt sustainability.
- Financing needs for security, infrastructure, and basic social needs are significant, as highlighted by the government’s NPRP.
- Given the high risk of debt distress, staff strongly recommends using all available sources of grant financing, including significant grant financing pledged at the Brussels donor conference.
- Government should restrain from borrowing, even when offered highly concessional loans.
- Staff encourages donors to disburse budget support on time, noting that delays complicate treasury management and program implementation.

*CENTRAL AFRICAN REPUBLIC — INTERNATIONAL MONETARY FUND STAFF APPRAISAL (page 17)*

### 38. Staff recommends completion of the second program ECF review based on C.A.R.’s

### 38. Staff recommends completion of the second program ECF review based on C.A.R.’s performance under the program and the authorities’ recent decisive actions to address the revenue shortfall.

### Program recommendation and rationale
- Staff recommends completion of the second program ECF review based on C.A.R.’s performance under the program and the authorities’ recent decisive actions to address the revenue shortfall.
- Staff supports the authorities’ request for a 10 percent of quota augmentation of access.
- This recommendation takes into account the satisfactory program performance as of end-2016 and decisive corrective measures in 2017, particularly in:
  - revenue mobilization,
  - public financial management (PFM),
  - debt management.
- The economic program is judged to remain appropriate, considering the challenging security environment and capacity constraints of the authorities.
- Staff also recommends that the financing assurances review be completed.

### Key operational decisions and financing figures
- Staff supports a 10 percent of quota augmentation of access.
- Third disbursement (upon observance of the performance criteria for December 31, 2016 and completion of the second review): SDR 11.70 million, 10.5 percent of quota, dated March 22, 2017.
- Total program disbursements (Table 10): Total SDR 94.69 million, 85.0 percent of quota.
- The amount for the fourth disbursement reflects the proposed augmentation; the originally phased amount was SDR 11.7 million.

### Contextual program considerations (selected points)
- Program performance was assessed as satisfactory as of end-2016.
- Authorities implemented decisive corrective measures in 2017 to address the revenue shortfall, with emphasis on revenue mobilization, PFM, and debt management.
- The program assessment explicitly accounts for:
  - a challenging security environment,
  - capacity constraints of the authorities,
  - the need to complete the financing assurances review to secure continued external financing.

*Source: IMF staff report excerpt (Central African Republic).*

### Annex I. Capacity Building Framework Strategy

### Annex I. Capacity Building Framework Strategy

### Policy Priorities
- Overarching policy priorities for the Central African Republic (C.A.R.) under the ECF arrangement approved July 20, 2016:
  - (i) enhancing domestic revenue collection and revenue performance;
  - (ii) returning to normal budget procedures and improving the efficiency of the public spending process, including the capital spending framework;
  - (iii) building debt management capacity and improving the debt management strategy;
  - (iv) improving data compilation in the national accounts, consumer prices government finance statistics, and the external sector.

### Assessment of Past Technical Assistance (TA) Effectiveness
- Timely TA delivery during the transition (January 2014–March 2016) was instrumental in rebuilding basic institutions.
- Donor support during that period:
  - Focused, limited TA in treasury management, public financial management (connecting key modules of the public finance management system), wage bill and macro fiscal capacity.
  - European Union, France, and the World Bank provided TA and posted long-term experts covering budget, customs, and aid management.
- Constraints:
  - Suspension of Fund TA missions due to deterioration of security conditions reduced delivery in the field.
  - AFRITAC Center organized offsite TA/training seminars on post-conflict public financial management, revenue mobilization, debt management and national accounts.

### TA Priorities Going Forward (IMF TA, 2016–18)
- Four Fund TA priority areas:
  - (i) revenue administration;
  - (ii) public financial management;
  - (iii) public debt management;
  - (iv) statistics: national accounts, government finance statistics, and external sector.

- Revenue Policy and Administration (2016–18)
  - Objective:
    - Achieve more effective and efficient mobilization of domestic resources by: (i) improve VAT and excises collection; (ii) rationalize tax and customs exemptions; (iii) reform the tax and customs administration; and (iv) rationalize the diamond, telecom and forestry taxation and para fiscal taxes.
  - Outcomes:
    - (i) VAT filing compliance is better enforced;
    - (ii) customs operation is strengthened;
    - (iii) tax exemptions are significantly reduced;
    - (iv) improve domestic revenue from 7.1 percent of GDP in 2015 to 9.5 percent in 2018.
  - Milestones:
    - (i) improve revenue from the downstream oil sector, forestry and mining sectors (2017);
    - (ii) streamline tax exemptions (2017);
    - (iii) streamline and modernize processes for large taxpayers/importers, secure revenue collection through commercial banks network, and prevent and fight against VAT fraud (2016 and 2017).
  - Input:
    - HQ-led diagnostic FAD TA mission on tax policy in FY17; follow-up mission by AFRITAC; and HQ-led missions to review the tax and customs administration.
  - Assumptions:
    - (i) improved tax and custom services to facilitate better compliance;
    - (ii) improved taxation on the diamond, telecom and forestry sector;
    - (iii) strong commitment to implementing potentially difficult reforms (e.g., rationalize para fiscal taxes and tax and customs exemptions).

- Public Finance Management (2016–18)
  - Objective:
    - Improving the accounting framework and the reporting system while building macro fiscal capacity; returning to normal budget procedures and improving the efficiency of the public spending process, including the capital spending framework.
  - Outcomes:
    - (i) improved financial reporting and improved cash management (2016-18) and production of the treasury balances on a quarterly basis, starting in 2016;
    - (ii) reduce the wage bill from 6 percent of GDP in 2015 to 5 of GDP in 2018, while allowing hiring new staff to meet the needs in the social sectors.
  - Milestone:
    - Link annual budget preparations and the medium-term macroeconomic framework underpinning the authorities‘ growth and poverty reduction strategy (2017).
  - Input:
    - HQ-led TA mission on Public Financial Management; and follow up mission from headquarters and AFRITAC in the PFM area.
  - Assumptions:
    - (i) continued political support to PFM reforms;
    - (ii) further enhancement of governance practices.

- Public Debt Management (2016–18)
  - Objective:
    - Building debt management capacity and improving the debt management strategy.
  - Outcomes:
    - (i) modernize the institutional and regulatory framework for public debt management;
    - (ii) improve debt management strategy;
    - (iii) strengthen analytical and operational capabilities of debt managers.
  - Milestone:
    - Review the institutional and regulatory framework for public debt management and improve debt management strategy (2017).
  - Input:
    - HQ-led TA mission on Public Debt Management; and follow up mission from headquarters in the debt management area (2016–18).
  - Assumption:
    - Strong commitment toward strengthening debt management.

- Statistics (National Accounts, Government Finance Statistics, External Sector) (2016–18)
  - Objective:
    - Produce more accurate statistics on prices, national accounts, government finance statistics, and external sector.
  - Outcomes:
    - Improve economic policy making and inform private sector decisions.
  - Milestones:
    - National accounts: improve compilation of the 2005-2015 annual national accounts in line with 1993 SNA and have it disseminated, and improve price collection and update the CPI.
    - External sector: improve compilation and dissemination of balance of payments and start producing the International Investment Position data.
    - Government finance statistics: start producing the statement of government operations following the GFSM 2001/2014 and implementing the CEMAC TOFE directive based GFSM 2001.
  - Input:
    - National accounts: visits by short term experts from AFRITAC Central to review national accounts and fix the CPI methodology.
    - External sector: a three-year project funded by the Japan government launched this year targeting 17 beneficiary francophone countries, including all CEMAC member states.
    - Government finance statistics: visits by long-term expert from AFRITAC Center to help implement the TOFE directive.
  - Assumptions:
    - (i) Human and financial resources are available;
    - (ii) good collaboration between national agencies involved in statistics.

### Risks and Mitigation Measures
- Key identified risks, probabilities, impacts, and mitigation measures:
  - Persistent delicate and fluid security situation
    - Probability: High
    - Impact: High
    - Mitigation: Authorities plan to send staff to outside locations for training.
  - Delayed support from development partners
    - Probability: Medium
    - Impact: High
    - Risk details: Lack of resources could delay or prevent implementation of TA recommendations requiring equipment purchase and/or hiring of staff.
    - Mitigation: Authorities are preparing a donor conference in Brussels in November.
  - Implementation capacity constraints
    - Probability: High
    - Impact: High
    - Risk details: Government units are understaffed, poorly equipped, and face operational difficulties (including insufficient energy to power computers and office equipment).
    - Mitigation:
      - Authorities committed under the CBF pilot to improve capacity and make best use of TA.
      - Plan to hire young college graduates and train them in specialties crucial to improve capacity.
      - Modernization of equipment is underway with donor support.

### Authorities’ Commitments
- Commitments to support the ECF program and TA utilization:
  - Continue to rebuild capacity to ensure successful implementation of the ECF program.
  - 2016 TA delivered by development partners focused on customs revenue collection, treasury management, strengthening interconnection between budget and accounting computerized modules (to ensure continuity of GESCO), and pursuing civil service reform.
  - For 2017, understandings reached with the Fund on a comprehensive capacity building strategy under the Capacity Building Framework (CBF) pilot project.
  - Priority TA areas: domestic revenue collection, PFM, public debt management, macroeconomic statistics, civil service reform and macro fiscal capacity.
  - Planned outcomes: strengthen institutional coordination of TA and training to increase revenue, enhance spending efficiency, restore budget discipline, strengthen debt management and create a core macro fiscal capacity.
  - If security risk heightens, authorities will send staff to outside locations for training.
  - Authorities plan to hire young college graduates and train them to offset lack of specialized local staff; modernization of equipment is underway with donor support.
  - Commitments included in the MEFP of the second review of the ECF program.

### Selected Program and Macro-Fiscal Figures and Actions (from attached MEFP and Letter of Intent)
- IMF/ECF financing and access requests:
  - Original arrangement approved July 20, 2016: SDR 83.55 million (75 percent of quota).
  - Request for disbursement of third tranche: SDR 11.70 million (10.5 percent of quota).
  - Request for augmentation of access: SDR 11.14 million (10 percent of quota).
- Recent economic performance and program implementation:
  - Economic growth in 2016: 4.5 percent.
  - Average inflation in 2016: 4.6 percent.
  - Revenue performance at end-December 2016: CFAF 84.9 billion.
  - Primary spending at end-December 2016: CFAF 96.2 billion.
  - Security-sector and DDRR actions noted: recruitment of five hundred police and gendarmes; deployment of gendarmerie to combat zones; a special criminal court starting prosecutions.

*Source: Annex I. Capacity Building Framework Strategy (cr17245).*

### 1.1 percent of GDP, below the programmed 3.3 percent of GDP. Investment spending fell short

### cr17245 - 1.1 percent of GDP, below the programmed 3.3 percent of GDP. Investment spending fell short

### Fiscal performance and program execution
- Investment spending fell short of projections to reach CFAF 32 billion, reflecting limited planning and implementation capacity.
- As a result, government deposits reached CFAF 30.7 billion.
- Program execution was broadly satisfactory: all end-December 2016 quantitative performance criteria (PCs) were met.
- Implementation delays affected structural benchmarks (end-December 2016 and end-February 2017), notably:
  - repatriation of diplomatic personnel whose assignments had ended; and
  - closure of non-essential accounts opened by public institutions in commercial banks.
- All indicative targets for end-March 2017 were met except for tax revenue and domestic government financing.
  - Revenue underperformance, mostly at customs, is explained by widespread undervaluation of imports.
  - Expenditure was contained, limiting the domestic primary deficit to 0.1 percent of GDP (within the program target).
  - Domestic government financing exceeded the target due to the withdrawal of government deposits for higher than programmed arrears repayments.

### External debt and disbursements
- External debt amounted to CFAF 185.1 billion at end-2016.
- New disbursements amounting to CFAF 5.1 billion came from WB and Saudi Development Fund loans, which had been contracted prior to the ECF program.

### Social spending and targets
- Additional efforts committed to meet social spending targets; non-wage social spending target considered particularly important for consolidation of social peace.
- In 2016, the CFAF 5 billion indicative benchmark for non-wage social spending was not met due to liquidity constraints.
- In the first quarter of 2017, expenditure already authorized amounted to CFAF 3.3 billion, higher than the indicative target for end-March 2017.
- The 2017 budget aims to increase social spending to at least CFAF 5 billion.

### National Development Strategy (RCPCA) — Pillars and implementation
- 2017–21 national development program: Recovery and Peacebuilding Plan for the C.A.R. (Stratégie de Relèvement et de Consolidation de la Paix en Centrafrique–RCPCA).
  - International community pledged US$2.2 billion at the November 17, 2016 donor conference in Brussels.
- Four guiding principles:
  - Regional growth zones to create conditions for balanced development.
  - Promote economic integration and diversification; sectors: agriculture, water and energy, transportation and telecommunications, health and education.
  - Develop labor-intensive activities to absorb unemployment and integrate youth.
  - Strengthen social resilience to accompany and strengthen economic development.
- Institutional framework for RCPCA implementation being put in place since May 2017; quick-yielding projects developed with support from WB and AfD.

### Medium-term outlook and macroeconomic objectives under the ECF-supported programs
- Assumptions: restoration of peace and security, sound macroeconomic policies, increased domestic revenues, improved public financial management and governance.
- Objectives and projections:
  - Economic growth to average an annual 5 percent over the medium term, driven largely by agriculture (including cotton and coffee), forestry and mining; inflation to come down to the CEMAC convergence level of 3 percent by 2019.
  - Domestic primary deficit to reach 0.9 percent in 2019, reflecting a steady rise in the domestic revenue-to-GDP ratio and tighter control over current expenditure.
  - External current account deficit, excluding grants, to persist at around 9 percent of GDP reflecting reconstruction needs and gradual recovery in traditional exports.
  - Financing needs to reach about 5.8 percent of GDP in 2017, 4.5 percent in 2018, and 3.4 percent in 2019.

### Investment program and business climate
- Public investment management framework described as weak and requiring comprehensive overhaul.
- New institutional framework for public investment management being implemented to increase efficiency across project selection to execution, including monitoring and control.
- Measures to improve business climate:
  - Consult on a revised law for public/private partnerships (PPP) and take stringent measures to limit fiscal risks.
  - Consult Fund staff on all PPP projects to assess fiscal impact.
  - Streamline public investment portfolio to promote private sector investment: combine small-scale rehabilitation projects with major infrastructure underpinning regional growth hubs.
- A list of 71 projects drawn up for inclusion in the 2018 budget, including 51 financed by grants, with efforts for rapid implementation.

### Economic and financial program for 2017 — Macroeconomic framework and financing
- 2017 budget adopted on time and consistent with ECF-supported program objectives; domestic primary deficit remains the anchor.
- Macroeconomic projections for 2017:
  - Real GDP growth to reach 4.7 percent.
  - Average annual inflation to be 3.8 percent.
  - Domestic primary deficit projected at 1.9 percent of GDP.
  - Public debt projected to decrease to 38.8 percent of GDP.
  - Domestic revenue expected to reach 8.9 percent of GDP.
  - Domestic primary spending 10.8 percent of GDP.
  - Domestically-financed capital expenditure 1.2 percent of GDP.
  - Social spending target: at least CFAF 5 billion.
- Financing needs for 2017 expected to be CFAF 66.3 billion (5.8 percent of GDP).
  - Covered by Fund disbursements totaling CFAF 28.1 billion.
  - Balance (CFAF 38.2 billion) to be covered by budgetary support from the European Union, the WB, the African Development Bank, and France.

### Revenue performance and reform measures
- Revenue collected amounting to CFAF 29 billion through April, below projected CFAF 34 billion.
  - Significant decline in customs revenue mainly due to undervaluation of imported goods; administrative weakness and underutilization of Asycuda also contributed.
  - Measures in the 2017 budget law (excise tax on telephone calls, increase of VAT and excise duties on certain consumer goods) and better tax base control contributed to better performance in other tax areas.
- Corrective measures adopted to recover shortfall; customs measures and estimated yields:
  - Use values certified by the pre-inspection company as mandatory minimum assessment values: estimated yield CFAF 800 million for the rest of 2017.
  - Regularize valuation discrepancies observed between January 2016 and May 2017: estimated CFAF 1.7 billion (proposed new structural benchmark, end-September 2017).
  - Correct erroneous entries in ASYCUDA of the CEMAC common external tariff and discounted VAT rates: estimated CFAF 100 million.
  - Increase number of convoys between Beloko and Bangui: CFAF 400 million.
  - Recover customs debts: about CFAF 335 million.
  - Introduce new pre-payment procedures at the Douala Single Window: CFAF 400 million.
  - Step up VAT and personal income tax controls: CFAF 800 million.
  - Continue recovery actions: CFAF 1 billion.
- Customs administration reform actions:
  - Terminated all contractual commitments with a private company (prior action) to focus on partner-supported reforms.
  - Updated action plan under implementation; intend to computerize the Beloko office (proposed new structural benchmark, end-December 2017) and enable all ASYCUDA features.
  - Ensure all customs transactions are registered in ASYCUDA; severe measures against tampering.
  - Intensified payment controls for deferred duties; discontinued practice of offsetting unpaid VAT credits against other taxes between importers of oil and the State on March 1, 2017.
  - Planned measures from TA recommendations:
    - adopt a ministerial order clarifying responsibilities of CSI and customs administration for ASYCUDA;
    - strengthen controls of exemptions and sanction leakages;
    - generalize, from January 1, 2018, deferred VAT payment for exporters and major investors;
    - secure customs and transit operations between the port of Douala and Bangui, utilize dedicated lot in Douala, connect customs departments with C.A.R.’s Single Window in Douala, and promote a commercial bank branch at Beloko;
    - improve compliance management through systematic exchange of information between tax and customs departments and cross-checking of returns;
    - conclude performance contracts with customs inspectors to hold them liable for import procedure stages;
    - ensure monthly publication of results of customs inspections on amounts collected after litigation.

### Tax exemptions, parafiscal taxes, and transparency
- Tax and customs exemptions strictly limited to those provided by law.
  - Inter-ministerial committee to focus on advisory and coordination role for drafting texts on exemptions and monitoring management of existing exemptions.
  - No new exemption granted since the start of the year.
  - All existing tax and customs exemptions and their revenue impact to be reviewed and published (structural benchmark, end-December 2017).
- Parafiscal taxation:
  - Will increase transparency and transfer all parafiscal revenues, estimated between 2 to 3 percent of GDP, to the TSA.
  - Instruction by the Prime Minister to prohibit immediately any new tax or levy.
  - Council of Ministers to adopt a decree to repeal the tax on incoming telephone calls before end-June.
  - Complete inventory of parafiscal taxes and levies underway; action plan to eliminate unjustified parafiscal taxes and transfer remaining revenues to the TSA (proposed new structural benchmark, end-December 2017).

### Public financial management (PFM) reforms
- Commitment to implement PFM reform agenda; action plan updated in March 2017 TA mission.
- TSA consolidation and limiting creation of new bank accounts in 2016; many government accounts at commercial banks identified and closed, though some remained open and balances not yet transferred (missed end-March 2017 structural benchmark).
- Audit of government financial management information system (Gesco): Gesco no longer meets needs of a modern PFM system.
  - Commitment to deploy by December 2019 a new application based on a functional and technical assessment.
  - During transition, continue using Gesco to fulfill statutory reporting and produce regular accounts and financial statements.
- Improve public accounting practices and budget execution monitoring:
  - Accounting balances for 2010–15 established and under review by the audit court.
  - Produce monthly balances in 2017 within 30 days after the end of the month.
  - Finalize budget execution report for 2016 (structural benchmark, end-September 2017).
  - Commit to producing quarterly budget execution reports based on Gesco within 30 days of quarter end (proposed new structural benchmark, quarterly, from end-September 2017).
  - Budget execution report as of March 31, 2017 already produced (prior action).
- Exceptional spending procedures:
  - In 2016, exceptional payment procedures reached 12 percent of total expenditure (excluding wages and debt service), above objective of 5 percent.
  - First quarter 2017 showed increase to 20 percent.
  - Commitment to limit use to at most 5 percent from 2018 onwards (proposed new indicative target, quarterly, from end-March 2018).
- Other expenditure management measures:
  - Strengthen treasury management: continue monthly treasury committee meetings and invite donor community to inform on disbursements.
  - Pursue civil service reform: clean civil service roster, secure final register, implement new hiring and management procedures; difficulties remain integrating security personnel.
  - Suspended expatriation benefits of diplomats whose assignments ended.
  - Maintain freeze on salary advances and keep allowances for official travel below CFAF 600 million in 2017.

### Domestic arrears payment strategy
- Clearance of domestic payment arrears prioritized to restore creditor confidence, government credibility, support the economy, and social cohesion.
- Arrears categories and amounts:
  - Social payments arrears: preliminary estimated amount CFAF 72 billion at end-2016; technical audit underway; approved claims subject to international audit and validation and payment schedule to be drawn up.
  - Commercial arrears: arrears to small and medium-sized enterprises through 2014 stood at CFAF 16.2 billion; based on payments and an audit, CFAF 9.3 billion remain outstanding. Arrears from 2015 and 2016 estimated at CFAF 1.8 billion as of end-March 2017 pending audit and validation.
  - Commercial banks arrears: final amount at end-2016 CFAF 26.1 billion approved by banks and validated by the Ministry of Finance and Budget; securitization underway under BEAC supervision with commercial banks participation; terms and conditions to be discussed with the IMF.
- Relations with BEAC:
  - April 2016 agreement consolidated liabilities and unpaid loans (excluding exceptional and statutory advances) to CFAF 55.9 billion at end-2016; repayments to start in 2018.
  - Exceptional and statutory advances amounted to CFAF 22.5 billion; plan to gradually repay these advances by 2027 at the latest in line with regional commitments, in coordination with BEAC.

*Central African Republic — International Monetary Fund (excerpts from the provided content unit).*

### 28.      We will update, on a quarterly basis, the list of all arrears by type of creditor, to

### 28.      We will update, on a quarterly basis, the list of all arrears by type of creditor, to

### Domestic arrears and immediate commitments
- The authorities will update, on a quarterly basis, the list of all arrears by type of creditor to better track the domestic and external arrears situation.
- The government is committed to not accumulating any new domestic payment arrears.
- Specifically, the government will honor all bills for current consumption of goods and services of state-owned enterprises to avoid the accumulation of new cross debts.

### External debt management and sustainability
- Accumulated external payment arrears toward the end of 2016 were due to late disbursement of budgetary support.
- All external payment arrears accumulated in 2016 were cleared to AfDB, BADEA, IFAD, India, the Saudi Development Fund, and COFACE for a total of CFAF 3.4 billion.
- China has expressed its intention to cancel all outstanding claims amounting to CFAF 43.5 billion.
- A New York court ruled in January that an Export-Import Bank located in Taiwan Province of China has claims against the C.A.R. stemming from loan agreements signed in 1991 and 1992; authorities are contacting the Chinese authorities to seek a resolution.
- The government has taken steps to prevent the accumulation of new external payment arrears and will constitute a cash buffer to honor commitments in the event of delays of donor funding.
- The C.A.R. owes pre-HIPC arrears to Argentina, Equatorial Guinea, Iraq, Libya, and Montenegro; authorities have reached out again to these creditors to resume discussions and seek debt relief.
- Arrears were also accumulated to certain private companies; negotiations continue to finalize debt rescheduling agreements.
- Authorities acknowledge the critical situation of debt sustainability and, consistent with the conclusions of the Debt Sustainability Analysis (DSA), remain committed to securing grants and, within the borrowing limit of the ECF arrangement, highly concessional financing to finance investments and the economic development plan.
- The government will abstain from contracting new loans, even on highly concessional terms, that do not comply with the limit set in the ECF; recourse to highly concessional loans remains limited to critical projects for which grants could not be secured.
- For 2017, the limit for concessional loans is CFAF 8.8 billion from the African Development Bank.
- Authorities state they are fully aware of the implications of the Fund’s debt limits policy for the program supported by the ECF.

### Other structural reforms (private sector and business environment)
- The government, in cooperation with the WB and IFC, developed a program of structural and institutional reforms to promote private sector development.
- Reforms focus on modernizing and updating the legal framework in key economic sectors, facilitating customs declarations and fiscal revenue collection, streamlining sectoral and parafiscal taxation, and reducing red tapes.
- The Joint Business Improvement Framework (CMC-AA) has been implemented to promote government-private sector dialogue.
  - A Permanent Technical Secretary was appointed; the draft internal regulations, action plan and budget of the CMC-AA have been approved.
  - Around 30 focal points organized into technical committees have been identified to work on some of the WB’s “Doing Business” indicators (initiative undertaken in conjunction with the IFC).
  - A one-stop shop will be established to facilitate administrative procedures for investors.

### Financial intermediation and supervision
- Authorities recognize the need to safeguard financial system health and enhance intermediation.
- The banking system remains stable in a challenging operational environment; prudential indicators suggest banks remain resilient.
- Three of the four major banks meet prudential capital requirements; the remaining one is actively searching for a new shareholder.
- The regional banking supervisor, COBAC, conducted its first mission to C.A.R. since 2012 and is inspecting internal risk management, valuation practices, governance and profitability of two major banks.
- The government is implementing the National Credit Council work plan to develop the financial system and strengthen intermediation.
- Priorities include strengthening the judicial system and modernizing banking services, including through mobile banking.
- Options are being explored to enable the agricultural sector to access bank financing, including the feasibility of an agricultural bank, with support of technical and financial partners.

### Capacity building and technical assistance
- Authorities continue to rebuild administrative and technical capacity to ensure successful implementation of the reform program.
- TA received from development partners aims to enhance customs revenue collection, improve treasury management, strengthen interconnection between budget and accounting computerized modules, and pursue civil service reform.
- In 2017 authorities will outline a strategy to rebuild administrative and technical capacity in close collaboration with technical partners to cover all priority areas.
- A comprehensive capacity building strategy has been agreed in the context of the Capacity Building Framework (CBF) pilot project; priorities include:
  - Domestic revenue collection;
  - Public financial management (PFM);
  - Public debt management;
  - Macroeconomic statistics;
  - Civil service reform;
  - Macro-fiscal capacity.
- The unit in charge of economic and financial reforms (CS-REF) has been reinstated to coordinate TA and training to increase revenue, enhance spending efficiency, restore budget discipline, strengthen debt management and create core macro-fiscal capacity.
- Authorities expect additional IMF TA on revenue administration, PFM, national accounts data compilation, public debt management and external trade data.
- The comprehensive capacity development strategy will define an institutional framework to coordinate external support, recruit and train young graduates to offset lack of locally qualified staff, and modernize available equipment.
- CBF pilot project will provide an anchor; authorities will consult other external partners on capacity development needs and will focus efforts on investment management development, youth employment, and agricultural and food security development.

### Program monitoring, performance criteria, and structural benchmarks
- Program performance will be monitored using quantitative performance criteria (PCs) and structural benchmarks.
- PCs for end-June 2017 and end-December 2017 have been maintained; indicative targets for end-March 2018 and PCs for end-June 2018 are proposed.
- Prior actions required for completion of the second ECF review (suspension of expatriate benefits to diplomats who have completed their assignments; publication of a budget execution report per end-March 2017; termination of a sub-contract for customs management) were met.
- The end-June 2017 PCs will be assessed in the third review in September 2017; the end-December 2017 PCs will be assessed in the fourth review in March 2018.
- New structural benchmarks for 2017 include:
  - Audits of all import transactions since January 1 2016 to assure correct customs procedures and application of the mandatory procedures (end-September 2017) to partially recover forgone revenues;
  - Adoption of an action plan to eliminate unjustified para-fiscal taxes and transfer of other revenues to the Single Treasury Account (end-December 2017);
  - Production of quarterly budget execution reports within 30 days of the end of the quarter (quarterly, from end-September 2017);
  - Full utilization of ASYCUDA at customs in Beloko (end-December 2017).
- Exchange restrictions: Throughout the program, authorities commit to not introducing or intensifying restrictions on payments and transfers related to current international transactions, nor to introducing multiple exchange rate practices, engaging in bilateral agreements that do not comply with Article VIII of the Articles of Agreement, or imposing or widening restrictions to influence the balance of payments.
- The government is committed to adopting, in consultation with Fund staff, any new measures, financial or structural, that may prove necessary to ensure the success of the program.

### Key numeric program figures and definitions (as presented)
- Cleared external payment arrears in 2016: CFAF 3.4 billion.
- China’s intended cancellation of outstanding claims: CFAF 43.5 billion.
- 2017 concessional loan limit from AfDB: CFAF 8.8 billion.
- Exchange rates used in TMU:
  - CFAF/US$: 585
  - CFAF/Euro: 656
  - CFAF/SDR: 815
- Definition highlights from TMU:
  - A debt is considered concessional if its grant element is at least 50 percent; discount rate used to compute present value at contracting is 5 percent.
  - External debt: borrowed or serviced in a currency other than CFAF.
  - Domestic debt: borrowed or serviced in CFAF.
  - Total government revenue is recorded on a cash basis and excludes proceeds from taxation on contracts, asset sales, revenue from privatization or from granting or renewal of licenses, placement proceeds on government assets and grants for program purposes.

*Central African Republic — extract from MEFP and Technical Memorandum of Understanding 2017.*

### 9. Total government expenditure is understood to be the sum of expenditure on wages

### 9. Total government expenditure is understood to be the sum of expenditure on wages and salaries of government employees, goods and services, transfers (including subsidies, grants, social benefits, and other expenses), interest payments, and capital expenditure.

### Definitions and accounting basis
- Total government expenditure includes:
  - expenditure on wages and salaries of government employees;
  - goods and services;
  - transfers (including subsidies, grants, social benefits, and other expenses);
  - interest payments; and
  - capital expenditure.
- All categories are recorded on a commitment basis, unless otherwise stated.
- Total government expenditure also includes expenditure executed before payment authorization (dépenses avant ordonnancement—DAO) and not yet regularized.
- Wages and salaries correspond to the compensation of government employees as described in paragraphs 6.8–6.18 of GFSM 2001 and include:
  - all employees (permanent and temporary), including civil servants and members of the armed and security forces;
  - compensation defined as the sum of wages and salaries, allowances, bonuses, pension fund contributions on behalf of civil servants, and any other form of monetary or non-monetary payment.
- Arrears are defined as any debt obligation (as defined in paragraph 5 above) that has not been amortized in conformity with the conditions specified in the pertinent contract establishing them.

### Domestic and external payment arrears: operational definitions
- Domestic payment arrears comprise:
  - (i) payment arrears on expenditure; and
  - (ii) payment arrears on domestic debt.
- Payment arrears on expenditures:
  - defined as all payment orders to the Treasury created by the entity responsible for authorizing expenditure payments but not yet paid 90 days after authorization to pay given by the treasury.
  - part of “balance payable” (or “amounts due”), which correspond to government unpaid financial obligations and include the domestic floating debt besides the expenditure arrears.
  - “Balance payable” defined as expenditure incurred, validated and certified by the financial controller and authorized by the public Treasury but which have not been paid yet. These obligations include bills payable but not paid to public and private companies, but do not include domestic debt financing (principal plus interest).
  - For the program target:
    - domestic payment arrears are “balances payables” whose maturity goes beyond the 90-day regulatory deadline;
    - floating debt represents “balances payable” whose maturity does not go beyond the 90-day deadline.
- Payment arrears on domestic debt:
  - defined as the difference between the amount required to be paid under the contract or legal document and the amount actually paid after the payment deadline specified in the pertinent contract.
- External payment arrears:
  - defined as arrears on external debt obligations;
  - the difference between the amount required to be paid under the contract or legal document and the amount actually paid after the payment deadline specified in the pertinent contract;
  - an obligation that has not been paid within 30 days after falling due is considered an external payments arrear.

### Quantitative targets (QTs) and definitions of fiscal aggregates
- The quantitative targets specified in Table 1 of the MEFP are subject to adjusters in Section D.
- Ceiling on domestic financing of the State budget:
  - Domestic public financing to the government is defined as the sum of:
    - (i) the bank credit to the government, defined below; and
    - (ii) non-bank financing to the government, including proceeds from the sale of government assets, which includes proceeds from the divestiture of parts of public enterprises (privatizations), Treasury bills, and other securitized obligations issued by the government and denominated in CFA Francs on the CEMAC regional financial market, and any Bank of Central African States (BEAC) credit to the government, including any drawings on the CFA Franc counterpart of the allocation of Special Drawing Rights (SDRs).
  - Bank credit to the government is defined as the balance between the debts and claims of the government vis-à-vis the central bank, excluding the use of IMF credit, and the national commercial banks.
  - Government claims include the CFA Franc cash balance, postal checking accounts, subordinated debt (obligations cautionnées), and all deposits with the BEAC and commercial banks of government owned entities, with the exception of industrial or commercial public agencies (établissements publics à caractère industriel et commercial—EPICs) and government corporations, which are excluded from the calculation.
  - Government debt to the banking system includes all debt to the central bank and the national commercial banks, including Treasury bills and other securitized debt.
- Floor for total domestic government revenue:
  - only cash revenues (tax and non-tax revenue) will be taken into account for the TOFE.
- Floor for government social spending:
  - Poverty-reducing social spending comprises public non-wage spending on primary and secondary education, health, social action, water and sanitation, microfinance, agriculture, and rural development.
  - Its execution is monitored on a payment-order basis during the program.
- Ceiling on domestic primary deficit:
  - Domestic primary fiscal balance (cash basis) is defined as the difference between government domestic revenue and government expenditure, less all interest payments and externally financed capital expenditure.
  - Payments on arrears are not included in the calculation of the domestic primary balance.
- Floor on reduction of domestic payments arrears:
  - The government undertakes to settle some priority arrears that were validated.
- Ceiling on contracting or guaranteeing of new external non-concessional debt:
  - The government undertakes not to contract or guarantee non-concessional debt.
  - Loans for financing projects must not exacerbate debt vulnerabilities according to the debt sustainability analysis prepared jointly by the staff of the WB and the IMF.
  - Financing from the IMF is excluded from this criterion.
- Non-Accumulation of New External Payment Arrears by the Government:
  - The government undertakes not to accumulate external payment arrears, with the exception of arrears relating to debt that is the subject of renegotiation or rescheduling.
  - This quantitative performance criterion applies on a continuous basis.
  - For the purposes of this performance criterion, an obligation that has not been paid within 30 days after falling due is considered an external payments arrear.
- Limitation of spending through extraordinary procedures:
  - All necessary provisions will be taken in the 2018 Budget Law and the total of all expenditure following extraordinary disbursement procedures (exceptional procedures, cash operations, etc.,) will not exceed 5 percent of total expenditure on non-salary spending or debt service (principal and interests) on average per quarter.
  - Observation of this indicative target will be assessed quarterly, starting from March 2018.

### Adjusters of quantitative targets (2017)
- To account for factors outside the government’s performance, the following adjustments apply for 2017:
  - a. If total revenue from privatization or renewal of telecommunication licenses or forestry or oil licenses is greater than programmed:
    - i. The floor for the primary budget balance can be adjusted downward by 50 percent of these additional receipts;
    - ii. The ceiling on net domestic financing of the government will be adjusted downward by the remainder of the additional receipts.
  - b. If total budget support is below the programmed amount:
    - i. The ceiling on net domestic financing of the government will be adjusted upward by 50 percent of disbursements programmed but not made;
    - ii. The floor for the primary budget balance will be adjusted downward by 50 percent of disbursements programmed but not made.
  - c. If total budget support is above the programmed amount:
    - i. The ceiling on net domestic financing of the government will be adjusted downward by 50 percent of disbursements above the programmed amounts;
    - ii. The floor for the primary budget balance will be adjusted upward by 50 percent of disbursements above the programmed amounts.

### Structural benchmarks and public financial management measures
- Consolidation of the Treasury Single Account (TSA) by closing accounts that do not belong to donors and non-essential government accounts open in commercial banks:
  - A decision will have to be made to close government bank accounts open in commercial banks and managed outside the government’s centralized cash flow management system, with the exception of accounts for projects, and to consolidate the TSA.
- Renegotiation of the convention with banks:
  - Renegotiation of agreements with commercial banks will have to begin before the end of June 2017 to ensure the daily transfer of balances to the TSA and to systematize the cost structures to strengthen treasury management.
- Adoption by the Ministry of Finance of a domestic arrears clearance plan:
  - A domestic arrears clearance plan should be adopted by the end of June 2017.
- Complete inventory of para-fiscal taxes and action plan to ensure timely transfer to the TSA:
  - An action plan will have to be developed and ensure the timely transfer of remaining para-fiscal taxes to the TSA by end of September 2017.
- Production and publication requirements:
  - The revenue and expenditure account for 2016 will have to be prepared and published by end of September 2017.
  - All existing tax exemptions should be identified and made public by the end of December 2017.
- Retrospective control of customs values:
  - By end of September 2017, values of imported goods set for the period January 1, 2016 to May 31, 2017 will have to be checked for compliance with minimum values and, if need be, impose specified customs clearance tariffs and related penalties.
- Quarterly budget execution report:
  - A quarterly budget execution report will be produced as from the end of September 2017, and thereafter every quarter within 30 days of the end of the quarter. The first report will cover the second quarter of 2017.
- Action plan to eliminate unjustified parafiscal fees and transfer proceeds to the TSA:
  - On the basis of an inventory of all parafiscal charges, an action plan will be adopted before the end of December 2017.
- Full utilization of ASYCUDA at the Beloko customs post:
  - All ASYCUDA modules will be fully deployed by end-December 2017.

### Reporting to the IMF: periodicity and deliverables (Table 1 highlights)
- Quantitative data on the government’s indicative targets will be reported to IMF staff according to the periodicity described in Table III.1.
- Key reporting deadlines:
  - Bi-annual report evaluating quantitative indicators and structural measures (tables 1 and 2 of MEFP), with supporting documents: Within four weeks of the end of each quarter.
  - Monetary position, monthly central bank and commercial bank accounts: Within four weeks of the end of each month.
  - Monthly cash flow operations table: Within ten days of the end of each month.
  - Government financial operations table: Within four weeks of the end of each month.
  - Total monthly amount of domestic payment arrears on goods and services and on wages, including unpaid pensions and bonuses: Within four weeks of the end of each month.
  - External debt stock at end of period: Within four weeks of the end of each month.
  - Breakdown of expenditures listed in TOFE (goods and services, wages, interest, etc.): Within four weeks of the end of each month.
  - Summary table of actual expenditures in priority areas (health, education, security): Within four weeks of the end of each quarter.
  - Breakdown of current expenditure and capital disbursements, financed with own and external resources: Within four weeks of the end of each quarter.
  - Breakdown of revenues by institution and economic classification: Within four weeks of the end of each quarter.
  - Revenues and expenditures recognized against one another without a cash settlement (by expenditure and revenue type): Within four weeks of the end of each quarter.
  - Breakdown of debt service and external arrears, particularly by interest and principal, and by main creditor: Within four weeks of the end of each month.
  - Amount of new non-concessional and concessional external debt contracted by the government: Within four weeks of the end of each month.
  - Actual disbursements for projects and programs receiving foreign financial assistance and relief of external debt granted by external creditors (including the date, amount, and creditor): Within four weeks of the end of each month.

### Debt sustainability and key debt statistics (summary from DSA)
- Debt sustainability assessment:
  - The DSA confirms that Central African Republic (C.A.R.) continues to be assessed at high risk of external debt distress.
  - Under the baseline scenario, one external debt indicator breaches the policy-related thresholds at end-2017.
  - Alternative scenarios underline vulnerabilities to slower GDP, revenue and export growth of both external and total public debt.
  - The proposed augmentation of access (10 percent of quota) has a minimal impact on all indicators, leaving the analysis unchanged.
  - To maintain debt sustainability, the government’s investment program requires grant financing; highly concessional debt financing to be considered only in very few exceptional cases.
- Key debt figures and developments:
  - C.A.R.’s total public debt stood at 44.4 percent of GDP in 2016, down from 50 percent at end-2015.
  - Decline driven by an increase in nominal GDP, net clearance of domestic arrears, and slightly revised numbers.
  - C.A.R.’s external public debt stands at 24.3 percent of GDP (CFAF 253.4 billion) in 2016.
  - No new external debt was contracted and disbursements were limited to balance of payments support from the IMF and project financing by Saudi Arabia, the World Bank, the African Development Bank and the International Fund for Agricultural Development.
  - C.A.R. owes CFAF 123.6 billion of pre-HIPC debt to Non-Paris Club Members.
  - The end-2016 stock of domestic arrears stands at CFAF 140.5 billion, of which:
    - CFAF 22.5 billion to BEAC;
    - CFAF 14.2 billion in commercial debts;
    - CFAF 72.2 billion in social debts;
    - CFAF 26.1 billion to banks; and
    - CFAF 4.7 billion in cross-debt and other debts.
  - Domestic debt mainly consists of credit from BEAC and payment arrears.
  - In 2016, domestic debt accounts for 45.1 percent of the total debt, of which more than half is domestic payments arrears.
- Creditor composition of 2016 external debt (high-level figures from Text Table 2):
  - Multilateral: 125.2 (CFAF billions) — 12.0 (Percent of GDP)
    - World Bank: 34.9 (3.4 percent of GDP)
    - IMF: 68.3 (6.6 percent of GDP)
    - Other: 22.0 (2.1 percent of GDP)
  - Bilateral and Private: 128.2 (12.3 percent of GDP)
    - Saudi Arabia: 9.9 (1.0 percent of GDP)
    - India: 24.5 (2.4 percent of GDP)
    - China: 43.5 (4.2 percent of GDP)
    - Congo: 18.2 (1.7 percent of GDP)
    - Kuwait: 12.1 (1.2 percent of GDP)
    - Private/Others: 20.0 (1.9 percent of GDP)

*Central African Republic: Extracted content from cr17245 - 9. Total government expenditure is understood to be the sum of expenditure on wages and salaries of government employees, goods and services, transfers (including subsidies, grants, social benefits, and other expenses), interest payments, and capital expenditure (IMF).*

### 7.      The baseline macroeconomic assumptions for this DSA have been updated based on

### 7.      The baseline macroeconomic assumptions for this DSA have been updated based on

### Macroeconomic baseline and projections
- Staff projects a more gradual recovery due to a delay in public investments and supporting reforms.
- Medium-term growth is expected to average 5.3 percent.
- Long-run growth is expected to register 3.5 percent, in line with previous DSAs.
- Medium-term average inflation (GDP deflator): 4.9 percent (Box 1 projection for 2018–21).
- Long-run inflation target: converge to 3 percent in line with CEMAC convergence criteria.

### Box 1: Central African Republic—Key macroeconomic assumptions for 2017–36
- Real GDP growth:
  - Expected to average 5.3 percent over 2018–21.
  - Longer-term growth rate maintained at 3.5 percent.
  - Growth drivers: rebound in agriculture, trade, forestry activities, investment, and gradual resumption of mining.
  - Constraints: volatile security situation, lasting damage from the conflict, lack of infrastructure and energy.
- Inflation:
  - Average inflation expected to stabilize over the medium term, converging to 3 percent.
- Fiscal balances:
  - Domestic primary deficit in 2017 expected to be 1.9 percent of GDP (after an exceptionally low level in 2016).
  - From 2018 onwards, domestic primary deficit projection will improve steadily.
  - Long-run primary deficit (including budget grants and externally financed capital expenditure) will increase gradually to 2 percent.
  - Domestic revenues expected to remain at 12 percent of GDP (current estimated potential).
  - Grant financing as a share of GDP diminishes gradually.
  - Primary expenditure projected to average around 15 percent of GDP in the long run.
- External current account and trade:
  - Medium-term non-interest current account deficit expectation: 5.6 percent.
  - Long-run non-interest current account deficit expected to average around 3 percent.
  - Exports expected to pick up from recovery in mining, forestry, and agricultural activities, boosted by improved security conditions and expected full lifting of the diamond export ban in the medium term.
  - Exports in percent of GDP will eventually decline due to narrow export base and increase in nominal GDP.
  - Imports projected to decline in percent of GDP as higher domestic production capacity lessens the need for imports.
- External assistance:
  - Grant-equivalent financing assumed to decline from an average of 6 percent of GDP in 2017–19 to about 2 percent of GDP in the long run.

### Fiscal and financing developments (selected figures)
- Domestic primary balance:
  - 2017: -1.9 percent of GDP.
  - Medium-term (2018–21 average per Text Table): -0.5 percent of GDP.
  - Long-run primary deficit: 2 percent (includes budget grants and externally financed capital expenditure; Box 1 wording).
- Overall fiscal balance (excl. grants):
  - 2017: -5.7 percent.
  - Medium-term (2018–21): -4.8 percent.
- Overall fiscal balance (incl. grants):
  - 2017: -0.3 percent.
  - Medium-term (2018–21): 1.1 percent.
- External debt (percent of GDP):
  - Jul-17: 24.4 percent.
  - Medium-term projection (2018–21 average): 19.0 percent.

### External debt sustainability results (baseline)
- Under the baseline scenario, one external debt indicator breaches the threshold: the PV of debt-to-exports ratio is projected to breach the policy threshold until 2019, reflecting C.A.R.’s narrow export base.
- The PV of debt-to-revenue ratio stands slightly below the policy threshold despite low revenue level.
- Ratios for debt service-to-exports and debt service-to-revenue remain well below thresholds due to concessionality of outstanding debt and low debt service burdens.
- The DSA shows an upward revision of the stock of the PV of external debt (mainly due to a re-classification of IMF debt as external) and updated projections for debt service payments.
- Despite revisions, improved macroeconomic management is expected to lead to decline and stabilization of PV of debt-to-exports and PV of debt-to-revenue ratios in the medium term.
- The current DSA confirms that C.A.R.’s risk of external debt distress is high.

### Alternative scenarios, stress tests, and vulnerabilities
- Extreme scenario:
  - All indicators breach thresholds; PV of debt-to-exports ratio remains above the policy threshold throughout the projection period.
  - PV of debt-to-revenue ratio stays above the policy threshold under the extreme scenario till 2025.
- Historical scenario may not adequately reflect baseline prospects as it captures the 2009 HIPC debt relief and the crisis years.
- Sensitivity analysis underscores vulnerabilities particularly to a combined shock or lower exports.
- Public debt (PV of debt-to-GDP) is vulnerable to lower growth.
  - Baseline projects substantial reduction in total public debt before PV of public debt-to-GDP ratio stabilizes below 20 percent.
  - Alternative scenarios suggest a one-standard deviation drop in the growth rate for 2018–19 would put PV of debt-to-GDP above the benchmark and on an unsustainable trajectory.
- Key risks:
  - Shocks to GDP growth and exports.
  - Materializing contingent liabilities given weak administrative capacity, lack of coordination within the public sector, and fiscal risks from state-owned enterprises.

### Comparative debt ratio changes (selected comparisons between 2016 DSA and new DSA)
- PV of debt to GDP ratio projections (percent):
  - 2016 DSA: 41.3 (2016), 37.9 (2017), 34.6 (2018), 31.3 (2019), 28.5 (2020)
  - New DSA: 35.3 (2016), 30.6 (2017), 26.0 (2018), 22.0 (2019), 19.2 (2020)
- PV debt to revenue and grants ratio (percent):
  - 2016 DSA: 318.3 (2016), 286.9 (2017), 251.8 (2018), 218.7 (2019), 183.3 (2020)
  - New DSA: 250.1 (2016), 215.9 (2017), 169.3 (2018), 138.3 (2019), 115.3 (2020)
- Debt service to revenue and grants ratio (percent):
  - 2016 DSA: 15.2 (2016), 10.3 (2017), 11.3 (2018), 11.3 (2019), 10.7 (2020)
  - New DSA: 12.6 (2016), 10.6 (2017), 13.1 (2018), 11.2 (2019), 8.6 (2020)
- Revenue and Grants (percent of GDP):
  - 2016 DSA: 13.0 (2016), 13.2 (2017), 13.7 (2018), 14.3 (2019), 15.5 (2020)
  - New DSA: 14.1 (2016), 14.2 (2017), 15.4 (2018), 15.9 (2019), 16.7 (2020)

### Policy implications and recommendations
- Priority actions:
  - Improve domestic revenue mobilization (government program envisages increase of domestic revenues to 10 percent of GDP by 2019).
  - Fully implement tax policy reforms and action plans to improve tax and customs administration.
  - Strengthen public debt management and continue efforts to resolve external arrears in a timely manner.
  - Consolidate peace and pursue structural policies to improve the business climate, boost productivity, and diversify the export base to strengthen debt sustainability.
- Financing approach:
  - Authorities agree to secure grants to finance investments and to contract highly concessional loans only in exceptional cases when grant financing cannot be secured and within limits of the ECF arrangement.

### Conclusion
- C.A.R.’s debt remains at high risk of distress under the DSA.
- Under the baseline scenario, the PV of external debt-to-exports ratio remains above the policy threshold for some time; other external indicators remain below benchmarks.
- Debt sustainability is vulnerable to shocks, especially slower GDP, revenue, and export growth.

*Source: IMF staff report section titled "The baseline macroeconomic assumptions for this DSA have been updated based on developments in 2016" (cr17245).*

### 19.      C.A.R. should pursue a financing strategy limited to grant and, only in very few exceptional

### 19.      C.A.R. should pursue a financing strategy limited to grant and, only in very few exceptional cases, highly concessional financing.

### Recommendation and operational conditions
- Staff urges the authorities to seek maximum concessionality in their external financing and to contract new concessional debt only in exceptional cases for critical projects when grant financing could not be secured.
- For any such project financed by concessional debt, requirements:
  - thoroughly and independently analyze the costs and benefits to ensure they are profitable and have no fiscal impact;
  - ensure adequate due diligence, including the respect of procurement law;
  - fully integrate them into the regular budget process.

### Rationale in the macro-fiscal context
- The country's financing strategy emphasizes grants and highly concessional resources to finance critical projects; authorities call on bilateral and multilateral development partners to avail CAR with such financing.
- Resolving public debt arrears is a top priority; most post-HIPC external payment arrears have been cleared, with dialogue ongoing with remaining creditors.
- CAR will rely on grants and highly concessional resources and requests technical and financial support to preserve fiscal sustainability while advancing the National Recovery and Peacebuilding Plan.

### Indicators of public and PPG external debt (selected projections and benchmarks)
- PV of PPG external debt (selected years, in percent of GDP): 15.3, 15.6, 14.5, 13.1, 11.6, 10.3, 9.0, 6.1, 9.6 (as presented in Table 1 projections).
- PV of PPG external debt (in percent of exports, selected values): 120.1, 121.6, 110.7, 97.5, 87.8, 79.4, 69.3, 53.7, 88.5.
- PV of PPG external debt (in percent of government revenues, selected values): 188.0, 176.4, 153.6, 132.7, 107.0, 85.7, 71.2, 51.4, 79.8.
- Debt service-to-exports ratio (in percent, selected values): 7.6, 8.5, 9.3, 6.8, 10.0, 8.4, 6.3, 6.2, 7.5, 6.2, 3.3.
- PPG debt service-to-revenue ratio (in percent, selected values): 20.2, 15.1, 14.6, 9.8, 13.9, 11.4, 7.7, 6.7, 7.7, 6.0, 2.9.
- Total gross financing need (Billions of U.S. dollars, selected values): 0.1, 0.2, 0.2, 0.2, 0.1, 0.1, 0.1, 0.1, 0.1, 0.1, 0.2.

### Grant-equivalent financing and grant element assumptions
- Grant element of new public sector borrowing (in percent, selected projection years): 38.0, 35.1, 39.5, 52.3, 52.3, 52.3, 44.9, 52.3, 52.3, 52.3 (Table 1).
- Grant-equivalent financing (in percent of GDP, selected projection years): 6.6, 6.6, 6.5, 6.0, 5.5, 5.5, 2.7, 1.9, 2.5.
- Grant-equivalent financing (in percent of external financing, selected projection years): 76.1, 85.0, 91.1, 97.1, 97.1, 97.3, 80.6, 69.5, 76.3.
- Memorandum item: Grant element assumed on residual financing (i.e., financing required above baseline): 50, 50, 50, 50, 50, 50, 50, 50, 50, 50, 50 (Table 2 memorandum).

### Key macroeconomic assumptions used in projections (selected)
- Real GDP growth (in percent): historical and projected series include 1.0, 4.8, 4.5, -0.7, 12.7, 4.7, 5.0, 5.2, 5.5, 5.6, 5.6, 5.3, 3.3, 3.4, 3.5 (Table 1 / Table 3).
- GDP deflator in US dollar terms (change in percent): 11.2, -10.9, 6.9, 4.1, 8.5, 6.8, 6.7, 6.2, 6.3, 6.2, 4.0, 6.1, 3.3, 3.3, 3.3.
- Effective interest rate (percent): 2.7, 1.2, 1.5, 1.9, 0.7, 0.8, 0.8, 0.9, 1.0, 1.1, 1.1, 0.9, 1.2, 0.9, 1.1.
- Government revenues (excluding grants, in percent of GDP): 4.9, 7.1, 8.2, 8.8, 9.4, 9.9, 10.8, 12.0, 12.7, 12.0, 12.0, 12.0.

### Debt dynamics, vulnerabilities, and stress tests
- Identified net debt-creating flows (selected values): 3.8, 10.8, 5.9, 7.0, 4.3, 3.3, 2.9, 2.6, 2.6, 0.8, 1.6.
- Endogenous debt dynamics contributions (selected): -1.3, 2.4, -2.4, -0.9, -0.9, -0.9, -0.8, -0.7, -0.6, -0.2, -0.4.
- Residual (including exceptional financing; selected): 10.8, -13.5, -8.0, -6.9, -6.2, -5.6, -5.3, -4.7, -4.5, -0.7, -1.2; of which exceptional financing: -0.8, 0.0, -0.2, 0.2, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0.
- Sensitivity analysis (Table 2 / Table 4) highlights scenarios and bound tests including:
  - A1. Key variables at historical averages in 2017-2037;
  - A2. New public sector loans on less favorable terms (interest rate on new borrowing by 2 percentage points higher than baseline);
  - B1–B6. Bound tests including Real GDP growth at historical average minus one standard deviation; Export value growth shocks; US dollar GDP deflator shocks; Net non-debt creating flows shocks; Combination shocks; One-time 30 percent nominal depreciation in 2018.
- Examples of stress outcomes (selected indicators in percent):
  - PV of debt-to-GDP ratio (baseline and shocks): baseline series and shocked values reported across 2017–2027–2037 in Table 2 and Table 4 (e.g., baseline and A/B scenarios produce values such as 16, 14, 13, 12, 10, 9, 6, etc., as tabulated).
  - Debt service-to-revenue and debt service-to-exports ratios show material variation across scenarios (Tables 2–4).

### Fiscal policy, public financial management, and debt management measures
- Fiscal priorities and measures:
  - Enhance domestic revenue mobilization through customs administration improvements, tax administration and VAT reforms.
  - Contain current expenditure by maintaining freeze on salary advances and capping official travel spending.
  - Continue civil service reform to contain spending; prioritize investments in basic infrastructure to unlock economic activity and job creation.
- Public financial management (PFM) measures:
  - Prohibit creation of new bank accounts of the treasury; bring revenue into the Treasury Single Account; reduce use of extraordinary expenditure procedures.
  - Implement production of budget execution reports and strengthen public accounting IT system.
  - Adopt a comprehensive settlement plan to reduce domestic payment arrears (audits completed for arrears to commercial banks, SMEs, and wages/pensions); securitize arrears to commercial banks with BEAC assistance.
- Debt management:
  - Strengthen debt management framework with Fund technical assistance and training.
  - Authorities will rely on grants and highly concessional resources for critical projects; seek donor support and sustained capacity building.

### Financial sector reforms and payment arrears
- Banking sector:
  - All but one banks meet prudential capital requirements and remain resilient.
  - Rapid clearance of payment arrears to commercial banks is a priority; clearance of arrears to SMEs is essential to lower NPLs and alleviate liquidity constraints.
  - Strengthening banking supervision with COBAC support, focusing on governance and risk management.
  - Promote financial intermediation and inclusion via a dedicated work plan, judicial system strengthening, modernization of banking services (notably mobile banking), and targeting agriculture for credit access.

### Program performance, external assistance, and capacity building
- Program implementation:
  - ECF-supported program performance broadly satisfactory; all quantitative performance criteria for the second review met.
  - Structural benchmarks and prior actions include consolidation of the Treasury Single Account, suspension of expatriation benefits for diplomats who completed assignments, publication of budget execution report per end-March 2017, and termination of a sub-contract for customs management.
- External assistance:
  - Development partners pledged about US$2.2 billion during the November 2016 Brussels donor conference in support of the National Plan for Recovery and Peace (NPRP).
  - Authorities stress that any shortfall or delay in external assistance risks adversely impacting reform momentum and the peacebuilding process.
- Capacity building:
  - Authorities welcome Fund TA and training on tax policy, revenue collection, PFM, public debt management, macro-fiscal capacity, and macroeconomic statistics; look forward to additional TA and to a comprehensive capacity building strategy under the Capacity Building Framework pilot project.

*Source: IMF staff report and associated tables and figures contained in the provided content unit.*

### Conclusion

### Conclusion

### Situation and needs
- Central African Republic is a country in fragile situation that requires sustained financial and technical assistance to make meaningful inroads in restoring peace and political stability, safeguarding macroeconomic stability, and putting in place conditions for sustainable and inclusive growth.
- The authorities remain fully committed to restoring peace and stability in a durable manner.

### Authorities' commitments and actions
- Efforts are being pursued tirelessly to maintain close dialogue with all armed groups which are currently participating in the disarmament, demobilization, reintegration, and repatriation (DDRR) process.
- The CAR authorities also continue to demonstrate strong commitment to sound reform agenda, building on recent progress.
- The authorities hope that they can continue to count on the international community, notably the Fund to assist their efforts.

### International assistance and request to Directors
- We call on Directors to support the completion of the Second Review under the ECF and the requested augmentation of access under the ECF.

*Source: cr17245 - Conclusion, https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/cr/2017/cr17245.pdf*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/cr/2017/cr17245.pdf_
