## cr1809

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [cr1809](https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/cr/2018/cr1809.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/files/publications/cr/2018/cr1809.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/files/publications/cr/2018/cr1809.pdf.json)

---

### Rebasing of National Accounts
- In July 2017 Cameroon published rebased national accounts.
- Base year moved from 1989/90 to 2005; SNA changed from 1968 to 1993.
- Rebasing started in 2008 with support from AFRITAC-Centre, AFRISTAT, and INSEE of France.
- Quantitative revisions and historical growth:
  - 2005-base nominal GDP is 8.2 percent higher than the previous one.
  - Average growth for 1993–2013 revised up to 4.1 percent from 3.8 percent under the old base.
- Sectoral composition (new base vs. previous):
  - Primary sector value added: 16 percent (from 23 percent).
  - Tertiary sector value added: 54 percent (from 46 percent).
  - Financial sector share: 2.3 percent (from 1.3 percent).
  - Non-profit institutions serving households: 1.5 percent (from 0.1 percent).
  - Non-financial sector share: 29.4 percent (from 32.1 percent).
  - Informal sector: 46 percent (from 49 percent).
- Interpretation: rebasing raises nominal GDP level and modestly revises historical growth, increasing tertiary and financial shares and lowering primary and informal shares; these statistical changes affect policy indicator interpretation.

### Fiscal developments, 2017 adjustments, and 2018 budget
- Revenue shortfall in 2017: projected 0.7 percent of GDP below program owing to:
  - weaker oil receipts: 0.3 percent of GDP
  - lower customs and direct taxes (non-oil revenue): 0.4 percent of GDP
- Authorities’ 2017 response:
  - contained budget execution while protecting social spending (social spending preserved at 11.2 percent of GDP)
  - plan to lower domestically-financed investment by about CFAF 90 billion (½ percent of GDP)
- Cash management and end-2017 liquidity measures:
  - scale up issuance of short-term treasury bills
  - limited and temporary drawings on statutory advances, to be reimbursed by year-end when budget support disbursements materialize
  - consolidation of statutory advances in a special account at the BEAC within existing program parameters
- Key macro-fiscal projections (selected figures):
  - Real GDP: 2016 Est.: 4.5; 2017 Prog.: 4.0; 2018 Proj.: 3.7; 2019 Prog.: 4.6; 2020 Proj.: 4.2; 2021 Prog.: 5.0; 2022 Proj.: 4.8
  - Inflation (period average): 2016 Est.: 0.9; 2017 Prog.: 0.7; 2018 Proj.: 0.5; 2019 Prog.: 1.1; 2020 Proj.: 1.0
  - Overall fiscal balance (payment order basis, incl. grants): 2016 Est.: -6.2; 2017 Prog.: -3.1; 2018 Proj.: -3.1; 2019 Prog.: -2.3; 2020 Proj.: -2.3; 2021 Prog.: -1.8
  - Public debt (percent of GDP): 2016 Est.: 31.6; 2017 Prog.: 33.3; 2018 Proj.: 33.7; 2019 Prog.: 33.5; 2020 Proj.: 34.5; 2021 Proj.: 33.7; 2022 Proj.: 34.4
- 2018 draft budget consolidation: 0.8 percent of GDP in 2018.
- Lower projected revenue in 2018: 0.9 percent of GDP shortfall (half from lower oil revenue).
- To reach initial 2018 deficit target required measures:
  - raise non-oil revenue by 0.6 percent of GDP
  - consolidate spending by a further 0.3 percent of GDP

### Revenue measures, tax expenditures, and staff assessment
- Authorities’ estimate of yield from new tax policy and administration measures: around 0.4 percent of GDP.
- Staff view: estimate falls short of the 0.6 percent of GDP increase in non-oil revenue envisaged in the budget.
- Encouraged actions: exploit enhanced cooperation between tax and customs administrations (cross-checking tax and customs databases).
- Text Table 4: Revenue Measures, 2018 (CFAF billions / Percent of GDP)
  - New domestic tax policy measures: 5.0 / 0.02
  - New tax administration measures: 10.0 / 0.05
  - Existing tax administration measures: 15.0 / 0.07
  - Strengthened custom collections: 46.6 / 0.22
  - Other efficiency gains: 39.2 / 0.19
  - Total: 115.8 / 0.56
- Fund technical assistance estimate: additional revenue of about 0.15–0.2 percent of GDP
- Tax expenditures, 2016 (Text Table 5, CFAF billions / Percent of GDP)
  - Food and health related: 187 / 0.98
  - Agricultural sector: 20 / 0.10
  - Rice imports: 29 / 0.15
  - Fish exemptions: 71 / 0.37
  - Investments: 61 / 0.32
  - Other: 83 / 0.43
  - Total: 451 / 2.36
  - VAT related: 330 / 1.73
  - Tariff: 107 / 0.56
  - Excise: 9 / 0.05
- Tax policy milestones:
  - authorities will attach a report on tax expenditures to the 2018 budget law
  - starting with the 2019 budget, gradually phase out some exemptions and amend the 2013 law on investment incentives (in collaboration with the World Bank)

### Expenditure consolidation and public investment prioritization
- 2018 expenditure posture:
  - contain current spending while preserving social spending at 11.2 percent of GDP
  - budget extra 0.3 percent of GDP for goods and services for election and CAN-related expenses, offset by lower transfers and subsidies
  - rationalize investment spending to generate budgetary savings of about 0.3 percent of GDP in 2018
- Investment prioritization criteria:
  - projects with high socio-economic impact and/or contributing to gross fixed capital formation
  - ongoing priority infrastructure and related projects
  - projects related to the 2019 CAN

### Financing, contingency measures, and staff recommendations for 2018
- Financing reliance: disbursements of the second round of budget support operations.
- Staff recommendations:
  - continue structural reforms underpinning budget support
  - encourage development partners to phase disbursements through 2018 to avoid end-year bunching
  - use market-based instruments for domestic financing to deepen financial market and accompany modernization of regional monetary policy operations
  - any further use of deposits from consolidated statutory advances should remain strictly for transitory liquidity management within existing program parameters
- Contingencies identified: contingent expenditure items mainly in domestically-financed capital spending; election and CAN spending included in budget and borrowing plan.

### Public Financial Management (PFM) reforms and cash management
- PFM actions and timing:
  - finalized decrees to transpose the six CEMAC PFM Directives; transposition finalization envisaged by end-2018 and implementation starting with the 2019 budget cycle
  - shorten complementary period from de-facto three months to two months, and ultimately to one month
  - limit exceptional budgetary procedures and gradually reduce direct off-budget spending by SNH
  - prohibit new budget appropriations to Treasury correspondent accounts; require all investment projects follow regular budgeting and execution procedures
  - strategy to broaden coverage of the Treasury Single Account (TSA) elaborated
- Cash budget execution issues:
  - budget appropriations considered executed with no payment complicate cash execution calculation
  - cash adjustment of CFAF 203 billion (1.1 percent of GDP) was made for 2016 to account for irregular operations
  - adjustment based on historical level of correspondent account financing to domestically financed investment (16 percent average for 2011–15)
- Annex III findings on correspondent accounts:
  - as of December 2016, balance of correspondent accounts amounted to 5.8 percent of GDP (3.9 percent of GDP in 2015), with 5.2 percent of GDP held by EPAs
  - end-September 2017 balance decreased by 0.7 percent of GDP mainly due to net reduction in EPAs’ accounts
  - problems: subsidies transferred to EPAs’ correspondent accounts beyond absorption capacities; some accounts created in violation of Organic Law on Finance Laws; accumulation of large accounting balances in the road fund while regular road maintenance underfunded

### Debt policy, contracted but undisbursed loans, and ceilings
- Staff recommendations:
  - resist pressures to sign new loans given deviation from 2017 ceiling on new non-concessional borrowing and slow disbursement of existing contracted loans
  - align new loans with absorption capacity and ensure only loans backed by mature projects are signed
  - strengthen transparency in debt reporting and accounting; comprehensive and timely debt reporting
  - increase cooperation between CNDP and Ministry of Economy, Planning and Regional Development so CNDP examines all new borrowing requests before final authorization
- Contracted but undisbursed debt: amounted to 24.7 percent of GDP in September 2017
  - identified CFAF 1,490 billion (about a third of the current stock) in projects not disbursing as scheduled or not performing well
  - authorities to cap disbursements of foreign project financing on non-concessional loans contracted before program start at CFAF 596 billion, in line with the budget
- Program ceilings and limits:
  - 2018 continuous performance criterion on new non-concessional external borrowing lowered to annual level of CFAF 436 billion (from CFAF 500 billion initially envisaged)
  - ceiling on net BEAC financing of the government remains based on program’s deposit accumulation target and maximum drawings of statutory advances at CFAF 300 billion
  - ceiling on SNH interventions set at 50 percent of total oil revenue for the year
- Authorities requested a waiver for nonobservance of continuous performance criterion on non-concessional borrowing for 2017 (breach of CFAF 64 billion); corrective measure proposed to lower 2018 limit by CFAF 64 billion

### Public debt and repayment capacity
- Public debt stock:
  - CFAF 6,031 billion at end-2016 (31.6 percent of GDP)
  - CFAF 6,165 billion at end-September 2017 (31.1 percent of GDP), including:
    - balance of unpaid government obligations: 3 percent of GDP
    - SONARA’s supplier debt: 0.3 percent of GDP
- Cameroon’s capacity to repay the Fund:
  - Repayments under the ECF-supported program will remain below 0.2 percent of GDP during the program period, and peak at 1.3 percent of exports as well as revenue in 2025–26
- Table 9 highlights (selected memoranda):
  - Nominal GDP (CFA F billions): 19,105; 19,810; 20,758; 21,941; 23,392; 25,030; 26,862; 28,885; 31,206; 33,854; 36,865; 40,302; 44,239; 48,763; 53,964; 59,960
  - Government revenue (CFA F billions): 2,866; 2,897; 3,141; 3,405; 3,693; 3,984; 4,408; 4,591; 4,973; 5,407; 5,899; 6,465; 7,108; 7,832; 8,684; 9,642
  - Debt service (CFA F billions): 183.1; 233.8; 276.3; 324.8; 336.3; 352.2; 384.5; 576.0; 603.0; 656.7; 557.1; 580.6; 574.5; 599.2; 616.6; 643.8

### Financial sector indicators, bank resolution, and NPL strategy
- Selected banking indicators (2014–Aug. 2017)
  - Capital/Risk-weighted Assets: 2014: 11.4; 2015: 10.1; 2016: 9.0; Q1-17: 9.5; Q2-17: 9.5; Aug.17: 10.2
  - Non-Performing Loans/Total Loans: 2014: 9.7; 2015: 9.3; 2016: 10.7; Q1-17: 11.1; Q2-17: 10.9; Aug.17: 10.9
  - Loans in Arrears/Total Loans: 2016: 14.1; Q1-17: 13.9; Q2-17: 14.0; Aug.17: 13.3
  - Return on Assets (ROA): 2014: 0.8; 2015: 0.7; 2016: 0.7; Q1-17: 0.9; Q2-17: 0.7; Aug.17: 0.7
  - Reserves/Total Deposits: 2014: 27.7; 2015: 24.3; 2016: 18.0; Q1-17: 17.4; Q2-17: 16.4; Aug.17: 21.7
- Bank resolution and NPLs:
  - Authorities agreed to enhance the bank resolution plan while aiming to limit fiscal costs
  - Plan submitted to COBAC in September had gaps, notably lack of a sound methodology to value impaired assets
  - Reprogram structural benchmark from August 2017 to June 2018 to:
    - enhance SRC capacity through Fund technical assistance
    - add in-depth analysis of all options to minimize fiscal costs
  - Authorities prepared a strategy to address NPLs and will prepare time-bound action plans covering:
    - mechanisms to encourage renegotiation of overdue loans
    - role of SRC including pricing neutral for State’s budget
    - improvements in judicial system; development of arbitration solutions
  - Intermediate action: train a number of judges on banking disputes and deploy them in the largest business centers before December 2018
- Financial inclusion and SME finance:
  - staff urged authorities to provide a timeline to update business model of public SME bank and evaluate replacing direct financing by indirect financing
  - authorities to reinforce credit risk assessments via expansion of financial information database; liaise with BEAC for national-regional consistency

### State-Owned Enterprises (SOEs), PPPs, and contingent liabilities
- SOE scale and distress:
  - SOEs collectively employ over 34 thousand people
  - In 2016, 27 of the main SOEs reported financial statements
  - SOE debt rose to 17 percent of GDP in 2016 (from 4 percent in 2015), driven by a 290 percent rise in SONARA debt
  - Magnitude of SOEs short-term debt equals 6 percent of GDP; 73 percent of short-term debt owed by four SOEs (SONARA, Camtel, Chantier naval et industriel du Cameroun, Port Autonome de Douala)
  - Fiscal arrears of SOEs (tax liabilities) increased by over 1 percent of GDP since 2013; SONARA accumulated tax arrears of 0.9 percent of GDP and debt to banking system of 0.8 percent of GDP
  - Three of the four SOEs with large short-term debt have negative operating margins
- SOE financial ratios (18 SOEs classified as financially at risk, 2016)
  - average debt-to-asset ratio: 66 percent
  - operating profit ratio (operating income to revenue): -48 percent
  - average default ratio (equity/share capital): -4
  - ratio of salaries to revenue: 100 percent (and to operating profit of 38 percent)
- PPP portfolio (as of October 2017)
  - 36 projects at various stages
  - Immediate government investment costs:
    - Completed projects (1 project): CFAF 220 million (0.001 percent of GDP)
    - Projects under execution (6 projects): CFAF 280 billion (1.4 percent of GDP)
    - Projects with contracts signed but not started (7 projects): CFAF 261 billion (1.3 percent of GDP)
  - Conditional liabilities: CFAF 76 billion (0.38 percent of GDP)
  - Firm liabilities: CFAF 31.182 billion (0.16 percent of GDP)
- Monitoring and policy recommendations:
  - first financial analysis and risk assessment of SOEs in 2018 Finance Law
  - new requirement: CNDP opinion before any external borrowing by SOEs
  - next steps: effective implementation of 2018 Finance Law, improve coverage of public debt to incorporate all claims on the State, maintain permanent monitoring via oversight committee

### Growth strategy (Interim GESP 2018–20), macro outlook and risks
- Interim GESP objectives and indicators:
  - increase growth progressively to reach 5 percent in 2020
  - reduce underemployment from 71.1 percent in 2007 to 50 percent in 2020
  - reduce poverty rate from 39.9 percent in 2007 to less than 25 percent in 2020
- Observed outcomes and constraints (2010–17):
  - average growth 2010–14: 4.7 percent (expected 5.2 percent)
  - primary fiscal deficit deteriorated to 5.4 percent of GDP in 2016; debt-to-GDP: 31.6 percent in 2016
- Macro projections and risks:
  - Growth: estimated 3.7 percent in 2017; projected 4.2 percent in 2018; expected to increase to 5.1 percent in 2020 and level out at 5–6 percent medium term
  - Monetary and reserves: end-2017 money supply growth decline to 5 percent; credit to private sector growth to 5.6 percent
  - Public debt outlook: likely around 33.8 percent of GDP (increase of 2 percentage points vs end-2016) due to disbursement of budget support, project implementation, and conversion of statutory advances
  - Risks to baseline: regional imbalances, resurgence of terrorist threat, persistent sluggish external demand; government prepared to implement additional measures if risks materialize

### External sector, financing needs, and IMF ECF arrangement
- External sector developments:
  - trade balance improving driven mostly by declining imports
  - overall balance of payments improved; reserves stabilized and started to increase in July
- Total financing requirements (selected rows, aggregate presentation preserved):
  - Current account deficit (selected series): 689.1 694.1 613.0 518.0 520.4 511.6 396.0 316.8 310.5
  - Debt amortization (selected series): 99.9 169.5 122.7 174.9 195.2 228.4 229.4 234.0 238.1
  - Repayment to the Fund (selected): 2.6 18.4 17.7 17.2 16.2 15.3 0.8 0.8 0.8
  - Change in gross reserves (increase=+): 26.3 464.6 -842.0 215.9 36.6 79.7 98.4 189.7 257.9
- Total financing sources summary (selected):
  - Foreign direct investment (net): 455.1 352.3 324.7 309.8 331.3 369.2 407.9 520.5 629.2
  - Debt financing (total): 344.8 971.3 -462.0 80.8 51.8 74.6 224.0 170.2 127.1
- Expected financing and residual gap:
  - Expected financing: 319.2 250.5 256.3 (selected presentation)
    - AFDB: 117.6 112.8 112.2
    - WB: 116.3 55.8 55.5
    - France: 65.6 65.6 65.6
    - EU: 19.7 16.4 23.0
  - Residual financing gap: 167.3 85.6 85.2 42.5
  - IMF ECF financing 1/: 167.3 85.6 85.2 42.5 (includes IMF ECF disbursement of CFAF 99 billion in July 2017)
- Proposed Schedule of Disbursements Under the ECF Arrangement, 2017–20 (Table 8)
  - 16/26/2017 / 124.245 / Executive Board approval of the ECF arrangement.
  - 12/20/2017 / 82.830 / Observance of continuous and end-June 2017 performance criteria, and completion of the first review.
  - 6/30/2018 / 55.220 / Observance of continuous and end-December 2017 performance criteria, and completion of the second review.
  - 12/15/2018 / 55.220 / Observance of continuous and end-June 2018 performance criteria, and completion of the third review.
  - 6/15/2019 / 55.220 / Observance of continuous and end-December 2018 performance criteria, and completion of the fourth review.
  - 12/15/2019 / 55.220 / Observance of continuous and end-June 2019 performance criteria, and completion of the fifth review.
  - 5/31/2020 / 55.220 / Observance of continuous and end-December 2019 performance criteria, and completion of the sixth review.
  - Total: 483.0175.0
- Program financing and requests:
  - Financing gap after Fund disbursements for 2018 projected at CFAF 251 billion (can be filled based on development partners’ commitments)
  - Staff supports authorities’ request to modify program adjustor to net domestic and net BEAC financing for budget support shortfalls (from CFAF 70 billion to 120 billion)
  - Authorities request completion of first review and disbursement of SDR 82.8 million; staff supports waiver of breach of continuous performance criterion on new non-concessional external debt for 2017 and proposed modifications to performance criteria and structural benchmarks

### BEAC monetary policy reforms and liquidity management (Annex I highlights)
- Regional policy commitments: tighten monetary policy and liquidity management consistent with external stability; strengthen financial sector
- BEAC policy changes and effects:
  - policy rate increase by 50 basis points to 2.95 percent in March 2017 moved bond yield curve up
  - decision to eliminate statutory advances by end-2017; outstanding statutory advances to be consolidated into a 14-year loan with 4-year grace period and 2 percent interest rate
  - outstanding balance available to Cameroon: CFAF 296 billion (end-August) with terms: full amount drawn before end 2017; amount withdrawn deposited in remunerated account at BEAC at 2 percent interest; IMF program requirements met
  - 2015 ceiling for BEAC refinancing government securities (CFAF 200 billion for Cameroon) became binding in late 2016 and H1-2017, contributing to tighter liquidity and decline in new credit appetite
- BEAC measures adopted in August and October 2017 (to take effect in 2018):
  - targeting policy rate; new liquidity framework; primary refinancing via open market operations; two permanent facilities; intraday advances; medium-term refinancing operations; collateral admissions; emergency liquidity facility
  - move to average reserve requirement rule and development of interbank market expected to facilitate liquidity management and credit growth

### Program implementation, structural benchmarks, and reporting requirements
- Program performance to mid-2017:
  - all quantitative performance criteria and indicative targets at end-June 2017 were met except continuous performance criterion on contracting new non-concessional external borrowings (exceeded by CFAF 64 billion)
- Structural benchmarks status (selected):
  - Monthly TOFE disclosure of total petroleum receipts and SNH direct interventions — Met
  - Publish petroleum product price structure monthly — Met
  - Quarterly publication of budget execution reports — Met
  - Joint DGI/DGD quarterly reports — Met
  - Strategy to clear commercial banks’ NPL portfolio — submitted to COBAC
  - Inventory and confirmation of all unpaid obligations by central government rescheduled to end-March 2018
  - Adopt resolution plan for distressed banks rephased to June 2018
- Reporting cutoffs and timelines (selected):
  - Government financial operations (TOFE) and related monthly reporting: Monthly, reporting lag 6 weeks
  - Detailed listing of external debt contracted and guaranteed: Monthly, 6 weeks; contracting/guaranteeing of external debt and occurrence of external arrears should be immediately reported
  - Real sector: quarterly national accounts quarterly 3 months; provisional national accounts annual 7 months after year-end
  - Structural reforms and other data: any official report or study devoted to Cameroon’s economy: 2 weeks

*International Monetary Fund staff report excerpt (Cameroon).*

### 1.   Rebasing of National Accounts________________________________________________________________ 7

### 1.   Rebasing of National Accounts

### Summary of the rebasing exercise
- In July 2017 Cameroon published rebased national accounts.
- The base year moved from 1989/90 to 2005.
- The system of National Accounts (SNA) changed from 1968 to 1993.
- The rebasing process started in 2008 and was supported by AFRITAC-Centre, AFRISTAT, and INSEE of France.

### Quantitative revisions and historical growth
- The 2005-base nominal GDP is 8.2 percent higher than the previous one.
- Average growth for 1993–2013 was revised up to 4.1 percent from 3.8 percent under the old base.

### Sectoral composition changes (under the new base)
- Primary sector value added: 16 percent (from 23 percent).
- Tertiary sector value added: 54 percent (from 46 percent).
- Financial sector share: 2.3 percent (from 1.3 percent).
- Share of non-profit institutions serving households: 1.5 percent (from 0.1 percent).
- Non-financial sector share: 29.4 percent (from 32.1 percent).
- Share of the informal sector: 46 percent (from 49 percent).

### Comparative context and interpretation
- The revision in Cameroon is characterized in the source as "mild" relative to other SSA countries that recently rebased their national accounts (Box 1 Table lists other country revisions for context).

### Implications highlighted in the source
- The rebasing results in a higher nominal GDP level and modest upward revision of historical growth rates, altering the relative size of sectors in the economy (notably an increase in tertiary and financial shares and a decline in the primary and informal sector shares).
- These statistical changes affect the interpretation of macroeconomic indicators and trends used in policy analysis and program design.

*Source: Cameroonian authorities (Box 1, "Rebasing of National Accounts").*

### 13.      Revenue shortfalls in 2017 have required a larger spending consolidation than initially

### 13.      Revenue shortfalls in 2017 have required a larger spending consolidation than initially envisaged

### Fiscal developments and 2017 adjustments
- Revenue is projected to fall short by 0.7 percent of GDP compared with the program, owing to:
  - weaker oil receipts: 0.3 percent of GDP
  - lower customs and direct taxes collection (non-oil revenue): 0.4 percent of GDP
- Authorities’ response in 2017:
  - contained budget execution while protecting social spending (Text table 3, MEFP ¶18)
  - plan to lower domestically-financed investment by about CFAF 90 billion (½ percent of GDP) to accommodate over-execution of foreign-financed capital spending

### Cash management and end-2017 liquidity
- 2017 overall deficit remains fully financed
- Authorities note last-quarter liquidity would be extremely tight due to:
  - budget support disbursements all expected in December
  - lower-than-programmed domestic issuances of T-bills and bonds
  - somewhat higher-than-anticipated execution of past year’s commitments (Annex III)
- Agreed measures:
  - scale up issuance of short-term treasury bills
  - limited and temporary drawings on statutory advances, to be reimbursed by year-end when budget support disbursements materialize (MEFP ¶19)
  - consolidation of statutory advances in a special account at the BEAC within existing program parameters

### Key macro-fiscal projections (selected figures from Text Table)
- Real GDP:
  - 2016 Est.: 4.5
  - 2017 Prog.: 4.0
  - 2018 Proj.: 3.7
  - 2019 Prog.: 4.6
  - 2020 Proj.: 4.2
  - 2021 Prog.: 5.0
  - 2022 Proj.: 4.8
- Inflation (period average):
  - 2016 Est.: 0.9
  - 2017 Prog.: 0.7
  - 2018 Proj.: 0.5
  - 2019 Prog.: 1.1
  - 2020 Proj.: 1.0
- Overall fiscal balance (payment order basis, incl. grants):
  - 2016 Est.: -6.2
  - 2017 Prog.: -3.1
  - 2018 Proj.: -3.1
  - 2019 Prog.: -2.3
  - 2020 Proj.: -2.3
  - 2021 Prog.: -1.8
- Public debt (percent of GDP):
  - 2016 Est.: 31.6
  - 2017 Prog.: 33.3
  - 2018 Proj.: 33.7
  - 2019 Prog.: 33.5
  - 2020 Proj.: 34.5
  - 2021 Proj.: 33.7
  - 2022 Proj.: 34.4

### 2018 draft budget, revenue challenges, and required consolidation
- Draft 2018 budget entails consolidation of 0.8 percent of GDP in 2018 (MEFP ¶20)
- Lower projected revenue in 2018: 0.9 percent of GDP (half from lower oil revenue)
- To reach initial deficit target for 2018, required measures:
  - raise non-oil revenue by 0.6 percent of GDP
  - consolidate spending by a further 0.3 percent of GDP

### Revenue collection measures and staff assessment
- Authorities' estimate of yield from new tax policy and administration measures: around 0.4 percent of GDP (Text Table 4, Annex II, MEFP ¶23)
- Staff note this falls short of the 0.6 percent of GDP increase in non-oil revenue envisaged in the budget
- Encouraged actions:
  - exploit enhanced cooperation between tax and customs administrations, particularly cross-checking of tax and customs databases (MEFP ¶10)
- Text Table 4: Revenue Measures, 2018 (CFAF billions / Percent of GDP)
  - New domestic tax policy measures: 5.0 / 0.02
  - New tax administration measures: 10.0 / 0.05
  - Existing tax administration measures: 15.0 / 0.07
  - Strengthened custom collections: 46.6 / 0.22
  - Other efficiency gains: 39.2 / 0.19
  - Total: 115.8 / 0.56
- Fund technical assistance estimate: additional revenue of about 0.15–0.2 percent of GDP

### Expenditure consolidation strategy for 2018
- Focus: rationalization of lower-priority investment spending (staff and authorities agreement)
- Authorities’ 2018 posture:
  - contain current spending while preserving social spending at 11.2 percent of GDP as in 2017
  - budget extra 0.3 percent of GDP in goods and services for election and CAN-related expenses, offset by lower transfers and subsidies
  - rationalize investment spending to generate budgetary savings of about 0.3 percent of GDP in 2018
- Investment prioritization criteria:
  - projects with high socio-economic impact and/or contributing to gross fixed capital formation
  - ongoing priority infrastructure and related projects
  - projects related to the 2019 CAN (MEFP ¶21, ¶27)

### Financing and contingency measures for 2018
- Financing reliance:
  - disbursements of the second round of budget support operations (MEFP ¶28)
- Staff recommendations:
  - continue structural reforms underpinning budget support
  - encourage development partners to phase disbursements through 2018 to avoid end-year bunching
  - use market-based instruments for domestic financing to deepen financial market and accompany modernization of regional monetary policy operations
  - any further use of deposits from consolidated statutory advances should remain strictly for transitory liquidity management within existing program parameters (MEFP ¶19)
- Contingencies identified by authorities for fiscal risks in 2018:
  - contingent expenditure items mainly in domestically-financed capital spending
  - spending and borrowing for election and the CAN included in the budget and the 2018 borrowing plan (MEFP Text Table 2)

### Structural fiscal reforms: revenue mobilization
- Medium-term revenue mobilization strategy centers on expanding non-oil revenue base and enhancing tax equity; four main components:
  - Reviewing and reducing tax expenditures:
    - total tax expenditures amounted to about 20 percent of total revenue in 2016 (2.4 percent of GDP, Text Table 5)
    - authorities will attach a report on tax expenditures to the 2018 budget law
    - starting with the 2019 budget, gradually phase out some exemptions and amend the 2013 law on investment incentives (in collaboration with the World Bank) (MEFP ¶10)
  - Enhancing VAT efficiency:
    - increase VAT threshold to optimize taxpayer segmentation and simplify SME tax regime
    - continue improving reimbursement procedures and eliminate VAT withholding for large enterprises
  - Developing personal income taxation potential:
    - build on progress with the land tax and integrate the single taxpayer identification number into tax administration IT system (reformulated SB, MEFP ¶23, 34)
  - Improve tax and customs administration:
    - operationalize new medium-sized enterprises tax administration centers and expand electronic payments
    - upgrade customs IT system to improve tracking of imported products and merchandises in transit and enhance customs clearance efficiency
    - accelerate collection of tax arrears (MEFP ¶23)
- Text Table 5: Tax Expenditures, 2016 (CFAF billions / Percent of GDP)
  - Food and health related: 187 / 0.98
  - Agricultural sector: 20 / 0.10
  - Rice imports: 29 / 0.15
  - Fish exemptions: 71 / 0.37
  - Investments: 61 / 0.32
  - Other: 83 / 0.43
  - Total: 451 / 2.36
  - VAT related: 330 / 1.73
  - Tariff: 107 / 0.56
  - Excise: 9 / 0.05

### Public Financial Management (PFM) reforms
- Progress and planned actions:
  - finalized decrees to transpose the six CEMAC PFM Directives; envisaged transposition finalization by end-2018 and implementation starting with the 2019 budget cycle (Box 2, MEFP ¶24, 25)
  - intend to shorten the complementary period from current de-facto three months to two months, and ultimately to one month, in line with the Finance Laws Directive (new SB, MEFP ¶25)
  - limit exceptional budgetary procedures and gradually reduce direct off-budget spending by the national oil company (SNH) to safeguard budget integrity and increase transparency (IT)
    - 2017 program objective was to cap direct SNH interventions under 50 percent of total SNH projected oil revenue; with lower production, staff estimates the program ceiling of CFAF 168 billion will represent 55 percent of oil revenue
  - prohibit new budget appropriations to Treasury correspondent accounts and require all investment projects follow regular budgeting and execution procedures (new SB, MEFP ¶25)
  - strategy to broaden coverage of the Treasury Single Account (TSA) elaborated (September SB, MEFP ¶25)
  - measures to enhance investment efficiency:
    - closer integration of annual budget with MTBF to support multi-year project planning and program budgeting (PIMA recommendation)
    - project maturation guide to improve prioritization and selection prior to MTBF inclusion
    - encouraged reforms: procurement procedures, ensuring availability of counterpart funds, strengthen coordination between Ministries (MEFP ¶24)

### Debt policy and monitoring risks
- Staff recommendations:
  - resist pressures to sign new loans given large deviation from the 2017 ceiling on new non-concessional borrowing and slow disbursement of existing contracted loans
  - align new loans with absorption capacity and ensure only loans backed by mature projects are signed (MEFP ¶26–27)
  - strengthen transparency in debt reporting and accounting; ensure debt reporting is comprehensive and timely
  - increase cooperation between National Public Debt Committee (CNDP) and Ministry of Economy, Planning and Regional Development so CNDP examines all new borrowing requests before final authorization (MEFP ¶26)
- Undisbursed contracted debt review:
  - contracted but undisbursed debt amounted to 24.7 percent of GDP in September 2017
  - identified CFAF 1,490 billion (about a third of the current stock) in projects not disbursing as scheduled or not performing well
  - CNDP to review report and recommend cancellations or redirections to more mature projects (MEFP ¶29)
  - authorities to cap disbursements of foreign project financing on non-concessional loans contracted before the program start at CFAF 596 billion, in line with the budget
- SOE fiscal risks:
  - recording and monitoring of fiscal risks linked with public enterprises need strengthening (MEFP ¶25, Annex IV)
  - two framework laws adopted in June 2017 to address SOE competitiveness and performance; implementing regulations to require regular standardized financial reporting, audits, oversight and governance (with WB cooperation)
  - staff urged fast action on 3–4 SOEs holding bulk of short-term debt and on strategy to avoid further subsidies to SONARA and reduce its liabilities
    - SONARA accumulated tax arrears of 0.9 percent of GDP and debt to banking system of 0.8 percent of GDP
  - enhanced budget annex on fiscal risks linked to SOEs and PPPs shows significant fiscal costs: 2.7 percent of GDP at end-October, of which 1.4 percent of GDP for projects already completed or under way

### Financial sector: recent indicators and policy priorities
- Financial sector performance relative to CEMAC peers: more resilient, reflecting less acute crisis and more diverse economy
- Trends (selected indicators, 2014–Aug. 2017, Text Table 6):
  - Capital/Risk-weighted Assets:
    - 2014: 11.4
    - 2015: 10.1
    - 2016: 9.0
    - Q1-17: 9.5
    - Q2-17: 9.5
    - Aug.17: 10.2
  - Non-Performing Loans/Total Loans:
    - 2014: 9.7
    - 2015: 9.3
    - 2016: 10.7
    - Q1-17: 11.1
    - Q2-17: 10.9
    - Aug.17: 10.9
  - Loans in Arrears/Total Loans:
    - 2016: 14.1
    - Q1-17: 13.9
    - Q2-17: 14.0
    - Aug.17: 13.3
  - Return on Assets (ROA):
    - 2014: 0.8
    - 2015: 0.7
    - 2016: 0.7
    - Q1-17: 0.9
    - Q2-17: 0.7
    - Aug.17: 0.7
  - Reserves/Total Deposits:
    - 2014: 27.7
    - 2015: 24.3
    - 2016: 18.0
    - Q1-17: 17.4
    - Q2-17: 16.4
    - Aug.17: 21.7
- Staff observations and measures:
  - excluding banks in distress, banks remain well capitalized
  - exposure to increased risk-weighting of government securities portfolios likely mitigated by COBAC derogation rules limiting potential reduction in capital ratios and breaches of concentration ratio obligations (Annex I)
  - staff encouraged addressing banking sector vulnerabilities and continuing reforms to expand access and resilience

*Source: IMF staff report (Cameroonian authorities; BEAC; and IMF staff estimates and projections).*

### 26.      The authorities agreed that the plan for the resolution of distressed banks ought to be

### cr1809 - 26.      The authorities agreed that the plan for the resolution of distressed banks ought to be

### Bank resolution, asset recovery, and non-performing loans (NPLs)
- Authorities agreed the bank resolution plan should be enhanced while aiming at limiting fiscal costs.
- The plan sent to the COBAC in September had gaps, including the lack of a sound methodology to value impaired assets.
- Staff and authorities proposed to reprogram a structural benchmark from August 2017 to June 2018 to:
  - help enhance the asset recovery company (SRC) capacity through Fund technical assistance;
  - add to the strategy an in-depth analysis of all possible options in order to minimize fiscal costs (MEFP ¶31).
- Authorities prepared a strategy to address NPLs (September SB) and will prepare time-bound action plans covering:
  - mechanisms to encourage renegotiation of overdue loans (in collaboration with the banking association);
  - the role of the SRC, including the setting of pricing neutral for the State’s budget;
  - improvements in the judicial system;
  - development of arbitration solutions (MEFP ¶32).
- Intermediate step: authorities agreed to train a number of judges on addressing banking disputes and deploy them in the largest business centers before December 2018 (new SB).
- Staff welcomes the authorities’ commitment to upgrade the asset valuation methodology and to consider all available options to resolve distressed banks.

### Financial inclusion, SME finance, and financial information
- Broader access to financial services, particularly for SMEs, remains elusive.
- Staff urged authorities to provide a timeline to update the business model of the public SME bank to ensure its viability and to evaluate replacing direct financing by indirect financing (funding lines to commercial banks or partial credit guarantees) (MEFP ¶33).
- Authorities will support reinforcement of credit risk assessments by further implementing and expanding the financial information database.
- Given progress on a regional financial information database, authorities agreed to liaise with the BEAC to work on consistency between national and regional initiatives (MEFP ¶32).

### Structural reforms, social policy, and business environment
- Authorities updated their growth and employment strategy for 2018–20 and are strengthening social policies; the update presents interim objectives and strategies to get back on course by 2020.
- Social spending:
  - Target met in both June and September 2017 despite low budget execution.
  - Social spending target set at 3.2 percent of GDP in 2018 (3.1 percent of GDP in 2017).
  - 2018 budget will scale-up two donor-supported pilot programs: social safety nets and performance-based financing in health.
  - Authorities finalizing national social protection strategy through a participatory process (December 2017 SB).
- Business environment and private investment:
  - Cameroon’s Doing Business ranking improved to 163 (out of 190 countries) in 2018, from 166 in 2014.
  - Improvements driven by reduction in minimum capital requirements and establishment of a credit bureau.
  - Training judges in resolution of banking disputes should enhance the business environment (MEFP ¶32).
  - Authorities implementing measures to simplify and computerize tax procedures, reduce payment processing time for government bills to suppliers, and finalize land reforms (MEFP ¶34).

### Program modalities, financing, and fiscal targets
- Balance-of-payments need for 2017–18 expected to remain unchanged; authorities adjusting to lower oil revenue while maintaining fiscal consolidation path.
- Current account projected narrower than in the program as lower imports compensate for weaker oil and non-oil exports; fiscal and external buffers being rebuilt somewhat faster than initially envisaged.
- Donor support and budget support:
  - Budget support commitments for 2017 (CFAF 319 billion) expected to mostly materialize by end-year, though some disbursements could slide into early 2018.
  - Staff supports authorities’ request to modify the program adjustor to net domestic and net BEAC financing for budget support shortfalls (from CFAF 70 billion to 120 billion).
  - For 2018, the financing gap after Fund disbursements is projected at CFAF 251 billion which can be filled based on development partners’ budget support commitments.
- Program ceilings and limits:
  - 2018 continuous performance criterion on new non-concessional external borrowing lowered to an annual level of CFAF 436 billion compared to the CFAF 500 billion initially envisaged based on the June 2017 debt sustainability analysis.
  - Ceiling on net BEAC financing of the government remains set based on the program’s deposit accumulation target and maximum drawings of statutory advances at CFAF 300 billion (MEFP ¶19, ¶30).
  - Ceiling on SNH interventions set at 50 percent of total oil revenue for the year (Appendix I, Table 1, MEFP ¶25).
- Authorities requested a waiver for nonobservance of the continuous performance criterion on non-concessional borrowing for 2017; as corrective measure they proposed to lower the 2018 non-concessional borrowing limit in the 2018 budget law by the amount of the breach (CFAF 64 billion).
- Authorities proposed modifications to two end-December 2017 performance criteria, March 2018 ITs, and structural benchmarks (reprogramming of four existing SBs and four new SBs, Appendix I, Table 2).

### Debt, safeguards, and program sustainability
- Cameroon’s capacity to repay the Fund remains strong:
  - Repayments under the ECF-supported program will remain below 0.2 percent of GDP during the program period, and peak at 1.3 percent of exports as well as revenue in 2025–26 (Table 9).
- A full safeguards assessment for regional central banks was completed in August 2017; assessment noted positive steps by the BEAC to amend its Charter to strengthen governance and plans to strengthen financial reporting transparency.
- Staff views and priorities:
  - Program is on track; end-June quantitative performance criteria and indicative targets were observed with comfortable margins, though the continuous performance criterion on new non-concessional external debt was missed significantly in November.
  - Staff will work with authorities to improve debt transparency and reporting, including reflecting disbursed and contracted but not yet disbursed debt, concessional and non-concessional debt, and other classifications; report on this in next review.
  - Extremely cautious cash budget execution and stepped-up efforts to mobilize additional resources will be needed ahead of budget support disbursements planned for end-year.
  - Elimination of BEAC statutory advances as of end-2017 will support rebuilding reserves and deepen money and financial markets; authorities committed to use these resources for short-term liquidity management only as a last resort.
  - From 2018, enhanced revenue collection expected to drive fiscal adjustment; staff regrets tax-base broadening measures are delayed to 2019 and urges identification of additional contingency measures to ensure deficit target is met.
  - Staff encourages effective transposition and implementation of the CEMAC PFM Directives to limit exceptional procedures and facilitate treasury management.
  - Debt management should focus on limiting new non-concessional loans, closely monitoring contingent liabilities, strengthening project preparation and execution, enhancing debt reporting transparency and coordination across agencies, and addressing backlog of already-contracted but undisbursed loans.
  - Contingent liabilities from state-owned enterprises and PPPs need closer monitoring and containment through comprehensive and standardized reporting, enhanced capacity to assess related risks, and deeper structural reforms.
  - Interim growth and employment strategy aims to boost inclusive and private-sector led growth; measures to support financial stability and broader access to financial services should prioritize resolving ailing banks and addressing NPLs while minimizing fiscal costs.

_International Monetary Fund staff report excerpt (Cameroon)._

### 43.      Staff supports the authorities’ request for the completion of the first review under the

### cr1809 - 43.

### Program approval and conditional requests
- Staff supports the authorities’ request for the completion of the first review under the Extended Credit Facility.
- Staff supports the authorities’ requests for:
  - (i) a waiver of the non-observance of the continuous performance criterion on the contracting or guaranteeing of new non-concessional external debt;
  - (ii) a modification of the continuous performance criterion on the contracting or guaranteeing of new non-concessional external debt;
  - (iii) a modification of the end-December 2017 performance criteria on the ceiling on the net domestic financing of the central government and the ceiling on the net borrowing of the central government from the central bank and of the end-March 2018 ITs.
- The attached LOI and MEFP set out appropriate policies to pursue the program objectives.

### Real sector developments (1999–2017)
- Growth has decelerated, driven by weaker oil output.
- Rebased GDP series were published in 2017, raising nominal GDP by 8.2 percent on average.
- Rebasing only marginally impacted nominal and real GDP growth since 2010.
- Selected chart indicators (2015–17):
  - Growth Composition, 2015–17 (percent, yoy): primary, secondary excl. oil, oil, tertiary, taxes and duties, GDP (displayed by quarter Q1 2015–Q2 2017).
  - Consumer Price Indices, 2015–17 (percent, yoy): overall consumer prices, food, non-food — after a significant decline, inflation is stabilizing in 2017, albeit at a low level.
  - Export Volume, 2016–17 (million tons, unless otherwise noted): exports and petrol. products; value (CFAF billion, RHS) — lower oil production is leading to lower export volumes.
  - Import Volume, 2016–17 (million tons, unless otherwise noted): imports and petrol. products; value (CFAF billion, RHS) — import volumes have remained relatively constant despite lower prices in 2017.

### Fiscal sector developments (2013–17)
- Revenues are weakening due to lower oil receipts.
- Expenditure has started to adjust; the fiscal deficit has narrowed.
- Financing composition and indicators:
  - Financing (percent of GDP) components shown: external financing, BEAC statutory advances, non-bank financing, financing from banks.
  - Unpaid government obligations are declining (percent of GDP).
  - Public debt and interest payments remain high (percent of GDP).
- Key numeric highlights from Table 1 and Tables 2a/2b:
  - Total revenue (including grants): 16.6, 16.5, 14.9, 15.0, 15.7, 15.4, 14.6, 15.0, 16.0, 15.5, 15.8, 16.0 (percent of GDP across 2014–2025 horizon as presented).
  - Oil revenue: 3.9, 3.0, 2.2, 2.2, 2.3, 2.1, 1.9, 1.7, 2.3, 1.8, 1.8, 1.8 (percent of GDP).
  - Non-oil revenue: 12.4, 13.4, 12.3, 12.5, 13.0, 12.8, 12.4, 13.0, 13.5, 13.8, 14.0, 14.2 (percent of GDP).
  - Total expenditure: 20.8, 20.9, 20.8, 21.2, 19.4, 18.5, 17.7, 17.6, 18.4, 17.5, 17.3, 17.0 (percent of GDP).
  - Overall fiscal balance (payment order basis, excluding grants): -4.4, -4.5, -6.2, -6.4, -3.5, -3.5, -2.6, -2.6, -2.1, -1.7, -1.3, -1.2 (percent of GDP).
  - Non-oil primary balance (payment basis, percent of non-oil GDP): -8.2, -7.4, -7.6, -7.9, -4.7, -4.1, -4.0, -3.5, -2.9, -2.6, -2.3, -2.0.

### Monetary and financial sector developments (2014–17)
- Banks' liquidity improved in Q3.
- Broad money and credit growth are trending down.
- Credits to SMEs have been falling; SMEs' share of deposits and credits tracked (2014–17).
- Banks' excess liquidity at BEAC increased after central bank refinancing; banks' refinancing requests and BEAC refinancing tracked in 2017 (CFAF billions).
- The rollover of Tbills has declined while yield curve costs have been rising (yields across tenors noted for Oct-17, Sep-16, Jan-17, Jun-16).
- Financial sector indicators:
  - Capital Adequacy (percent): banks remain adequately capitalized (time series 2014–Aug. 17).
  - Profitability (percent): Return on Equity (ROE) and Return on Assets (ROA) show banks are profitable.
  - Liquidity (percent): liquid assets/total assets improved; liquid assets/ST liabilities tracked.
  - Asset Quality (percent): non-performing loans/total loans remain poor.
  - Credit-to-deposit ratio is stabilizing (percent time series Jan-14–Jul-17).
  - Financial deepening is slowing: credit to the private sector and total bank assets as percent of GDP tracked.

- Monetary aggregates and credit (Table 3 highlights):
  - Broad money (M2) annual changes: 10.8, 9.2, 5.6, 5.5, 3.3, 5.0, 5.7, 5.3, 5.9, 7.1, 7.4, 8.3 (percent for listed periods).
  - Credit to the private sector annual percentage change examples: 7.2, 9.5, 10.8, 10.1, 4.9, 5.8, 5.6, 8.3, 8.1, 9.3, 11.5, 11.7, 12.6, 12.6.
  - Broad money (levels): 4,345; 4,291; 4,306; 4,382; 4,377; 4,490; 4,561; 4,640; 4,719; 4,743; 4,802; 5,087; 5,449; 5,851; 6,338 (CFAF billions across reported dates).

### External sector developments (2011–17)
- Effective exchange rates are appreciating while the USD is depreciating (NEER/REER and CFAF/US$ trends for 2015–17).
- The trade balance is improving, driven mostly by declining imports.
- The overall balance of payments has improved; reserves stabilized and started to increase in July (BEAC and CEMAC reserves, months of imports and USD millions shown).
- Sectoral import and export shifts (2016–17):
  - Imports decline in 2017 driven by lower metals, consumption and machinery sectors.
  - Export decline driven by reduction in agriculture and agri-food products; crude oil and non-oil sector dynamics tracked.
- Balance of payments summary (Table 4 key numbers, CFAF billions):
  - Current account balance: -689.1, -694, -613, -563, -518, -578, -520, -512, -396, -317, -311 (levels/estimates across years).
  - Trade balance (goods): -222, -220, -137, -91, -143, -117, -162, -173, -130, -113, -122.
  - Exports, goods: 3,244; 3,085; 2,725; 3,064; 2,733; 3,214; 2,715; 2,846; 3,012; 3,204; 3,377.
  - Imports, goods: -3,466; -3,306; -2,862; -3,155; -2,877; -3,331; -2,877; -3,019; -3,142; -3,317; -3,499.
  - Overall balance: 294; 83; -824; -370; -253; -233; -283; -246; 571; 90; 259.

### Risk assessment and policy recommendations
- Major risks identified (Table 5):
  - Policy and geopolitical uncertainties — Relative Likelihood: Medium; Recommended policy response: Improve CEMAC integration and economic relationship with Nigeria; improve business environment; implement structural reforms to improve competitiveness.
  - Tighter global financial conditions — Relative Likelihood: High; Recommended policy response: Continue necessary fiscal consolidation and structural reforms to reduce external imbalances and boost investor confidence.
  - Weaker than projected global growth — Relative Likelihood: Medium; Recommended policy response: Improve regional integration and facilitate intra-regional trade; implement structural reforms to improve business climate and competitiveness.
  - Lower energy prices — Relative Likelihood: High; Impact if Realized: further decline in oil revenues; Recommended policy response: Widen the non-oil tax base, increase efficiency of the national oil refinery (SONARA) and spur competition in the oil import sector.
  - Spillovers from worsening economic situation of other CEMAC countries — Relative Likelihood: High; Recommended policy response: Coordinate with other CEMAC countries to build additional buffers through fiscal consolidation and structural reforms.
  - Spillovers of regional security deterioration — Relative Likelihood: High; Recommended policy response: Provide space for higher security expenditure in the budget by curtailing unproductive public investments; prepare contingency plans for refugees with UNHCR.
  - Contingent risks from state-owned enterprises — Relative Likelihood: High; Recommended policy response: Enhanced monitoring and timely reporting of SOE risks and developing strategies to reduce state aid to these companies.

### External financing and public debt indicators
- Public debt trajectory (Table 1):
  - Stock of public debt (percent of GDP): 21.5, 30.9, 31.0, 31.6, 33.3, 33.7, 33.5, 34.5, 34.4, 33.7, 32.4, 31.1 (across reported years and projections).
  - Of which: external debt (percent of GDP): 14.6, 19.8, 20.7, 21.1, 24.5, 23.8, 27.2, 26.0, 27.7, 27.8, 27.7, 27.3.
- External financing requirements and financing composition are detailed in Table 6 (CFAF billions).

*International Monetary Fund — Cameroon country documents and staff analysis as presented in the supplied content.*

### 1. Total financing requirements817.91346.6-88.6926.1768.5835.1724.6741.3807.3

### cr1809 - 1. Total financing requirements817.91346.6-88.6926.1768.5835.1724.6741.3807.3

### Total financing requirements (summary rows)
- Current account deficit: 689.1694.1613.0518.0520.4511.6396.0316.8310.5
- Debt amortization: 99.9169.5122.7174.9195.2228.4229.4234.0238.1
- Repayment to the Fund: 2.618.417.717.216.215.30.80.80.8
- Change in gross reserves (increase=+): 26.3464.6-842.0215.936.679.798.4189.7257.9

### Total financing sources (summary rows)
- Capital transfers: 6.411.136.336.336.336.336.336.336.3
- Foreign direct investment (net): 455.1352.3324.7309.8331.3369.2407.9520.5629.2
- Portfolio investment (net): 11.612.012.312.713.113.513.914.314.7
- Debt financing (total): 344.8971.3-462.080.851.874.6224.0170.2127.1
  - Public sector: 582.8990.3458.0638.9565.5577.0614.4660.3713.1
  - Non-public sector: -237.9-19.1-920.0-558.0-513.7-502.3-390.4-490.2-586.0
  - Short-term debt: -237.9-19.1-920.0-558.0-513.7-502.3-390.4-490.2-586.0
- Other net capital inflows: -23.50.00.00.00.00.00.00.00.0

### Total financing needs; expected and residual financing
- Total financing needs (detailed row): 0.00.00.0486.5336.1341.542.50.00.0
- Expected financing: 319.2250.5256.3
  - AFDB: 117.6112.8112.2
  - WB: 116.355.855.5
  - France: 65.665.665.6
  - EU: 19.716.423.0
- Residual financing gap: 167.385.685.242.5
- IMF ECF financing 1/: 167.385.685.242.5
  - Amortization (repeated): 99.9169.5122.7174.9195.2228.4229.4234.0238.1
- Note: Sources: IMF staff estimates and projections.
- Note 1/: Including IMF ECF disbursement of CFAF 99 billion in July 2017.

### Table 7. Cameroon: Gross Fiscal Financing Needs, 2016–22 (selected entries)
- A. Overall fiscal deficit (cash basis, including grants): 977774732538479276270
- B. Other financing needs: 394863423580427578466
  - Amortization (including arrears): 367271329331298285307
  - External: 131186228243229234259
    - o/w Amortization (excl. IMF): 113170213228229234250
    - o/w Repayment of IMF credit: 181715150010
  - Domestic: 2378510088685148
  - Banking System: 2759194249129293158
- C = A+B Total financing needs: 1372163611541117906854735
- D. Identified sources of financing: 13121150819776863854736
  - External: 453634560571608654636
    - Drawing: 453634560571608654636
    - o/w Project financing (ext.): 453544560571608654706
  - Domestic: 859516259205255200100
    - Banking System: 65534600000
    - BEAC Statutory advances: 9334600000
    - Government deposits: 475000000
    - Bank loans: 83000000
    - Other bank financing: 4000000
    - Other non-bank financing: 205170259205255200100
      - o/w Bond issuance: 82000000
- E = C - D Financing gap: 594863353414200
- Errors and omissions: 59000000
- F. Exceptional external financing: 319251256000
  - Multilateral: 254185191000
  - Bilateral: 666666000
- E - F Residual financing needs
  - IMF -ECF 1/: 16786854300
- Sources: IMF staff estimates and projections.
- Note 1/: Including IMF ECF disbursement of CFAF 99 billion in July 2017.

### Table 8. Proposed Schedule of Disbursements Under the ECF Arrangement, 2017–20
- Date of Availability / Amount (in millions of SDR) / In percent of quota / Conditions for Disbursement
  - 16/26/2017 / 124.245 / Executive Board approval of the ECF arrangement.
  - 12/20/2017 / 82.830 / Observance of continuous and end-June 2017 performance criteria, and completion of the first review.
  - 6/30/2018 / 55.220 / Observance of continuous and end-December 2017 performance criteria, and completion of the second review.
  - 12/15/2018 / 55.220 / Observance of continuous and end-June 2018 performance criteria, and completion of the third review.
  - 6/15/2019 / 55.220 / Observance of continuous and end-December 2018 performance criteria, and completion of the fourth review.
  - 12/15/2019 / 55.220 / Observance of continuous and end-June 2019 performance criteria, and completion of the fifth review.
  - 5/31/2020 / 55.220 / Observance of continuous and end-December 2019 performance criteria, and completion of the sixth review.
- Total: 483.0175.0
- Source: IMF staff calculations.
- Note 1/: Cameroon's current quota is SDR 276.0 million, of which 162.936 million was outstanding credit as of December 31, 2017.

### Table 9. Cameroon: Capacity to Repay the Fund, 2016–31 (selected figures)
- Principal (SDR millions): 21.5          20.7             19.9             18.8            -             -          -           24.8          24.8           24.8            24.8           24.8            -             
- Charges and interest (selected): -           0.6              1.0              1.0             1.0              1.0           1.0            1.0            1.0             1.0             1.0             1.0             1.0
- SDR millions (aggregate row): 21.5          21.3             20.9             19.9            1.0              1.0           1.0            48.0          70.0           92.1            97.6           97.6            50.7            28.6          6.6          1.0
- CFA F billions (aggregate row): 17.7          17.2             16.2             15.3            0.8              0.8           0.8            37.2          54.4           71.5            75.8           75.8            39.4            22.2          5.1          0.8
- Percent of government revenue (selected): 0.6            0.6              0.5              0.5             0.0              0.0           0.0            0.8            1.1             1.3             1.3             1.2             0.6             0.3           0.1          0.0
- Outstanding Fund credit (SDR millions): 59.4245.7336.2427.8483.0483.0483.0436.1367.1276.0179.482.833.15.50.00.0
- Net use of Fund credit (SDR millions): -21.5186.390.591.655.20.00.0-46.9-69.0-91.1-96.6-96.6-49.7-27.6-5.50.0
- Disbursements (selected): -       207.0      110.4      110.4     55.2       -       -      -
- Repayments and repurchases (selected): 21.520.719.9             18.8            -             -          -           46.9          69.0           91.1            96.6           96.6            49.7            27.6          5.5          -
- Memorandum items (CFA F billions):
  - Nominal GDP: 19,105       19,810         20,758         21,941        23,392        25,030      26,862       28,885      31,206       33,854        36,865       40,302        44,239        48,763      53,964     59,960
  - Exports of goods and services: 3,710        3,777           3,767           3,923          4,144          4,419       4,677        4,917        5,208         5,531          5,860         6,250          6,681          7,140        7,628       8,138
  - Government revenue: 2,866        2,897           3,141           3,405          3,693          3,984       4,408        4,591        4,973         5,407          5,899         6,465          7,108          7,832        8,684       9,642
  - Debt service 2/: 183.1        233.8           276.3           324.8          336.3          352.2       384.5        576.0        603.0         656.7          557.1         580.6          574.5          599.2        616.6       643.8
  - CFA francs/SDR (period average): 823.8        808.3           775.0           771.5          770.2          772.9       776.2        776.2        776.2         776.2          776.2         776.2          776.2          776.2        776.2       776.2
- Sources: IMF staff estimates and projections.
- Note 2/: Total debt service includes IMF repurchases and repayments.
- Note 1/: On October 3, 2016, the IMF Executive Board approved a modified interest rate setting mechanism which effectively sets interest rates to zero on ECF and SCF through December 31, 2018 and possibly longer. The Board also decided to extend zero interest rate on ESF till end 2018 while interest rate on RCF was set to zero in July 2015. Based on these decisions and current projections of SDR rate, the following interest rates are assumed beyond 2018: projected interest charges between 2019 and 2020 are based on 0/0/0/0.25 percent per annum for the ECF, SCF, RCF and ESF, respectively, and beyond 2020 0/0.25/0/0.25 percent per annum. The Executive Board will review the interest rates on concessional lending by end-2018 and every two years thereafter.

### Annex I. Impact of the BEAC Monetary Policy and Liquidity Management Reforms (key points)
- Regional policy commitments: (i) tightening monetary policy and liquidity management consistent with external stability and (ii) strengthening of the financial sector.
- Increase in the policy rate by 50 basis points to 2.95 percent in March 2017 caused the Cameroonian bonds yield curve to move up and could have affected credit growth.
- BEAC decision to eliminate statutory advances by end-2017; outstanding BEAC statutory advances to be consolidated into a 14-year loan, with a 4-year grace period and a 2 percent interest rate.
  - Cameroon allowed to access remaining balance (CFAF 296 billion, at end-August) on terms: (i) full amount drawn before end 2017; (ii) amount withdrawn immediately deposited in a remunerated account at the BEAC with a 2 percent interest; (iii) IMF program requirements fully met.
- 2015 ceiling for refinancing government securities by the BEAC (CFAF 200 billion for Cameroon) became binding in late 2016 and H1-2017, contributing to tighter liquidity conditions and a decline in banks’ appetite to extend new credit.
- Supervisory requirement: non-zero risk weight on sovereign exposures to countries not compliant with regional convergence criteria could increase risk weight to 85 percent for Cameroon; COBAC derogation allows banks in countries with an IMF program to request up to three years of relief (0 percent weight for two years, 50 percent of the regulatory rate for the third year) subject to qualifying conditions.
- BEAC monetary policy and liquidity measures adopted in August and October 2017 (to come into effect in 2018) include:
  - Targeting the policy rate and ensuring the interbank rate remains close to it.
  - New liquidity management framework: primary refinancing via open market operations; two permanent facilities (deposit and lending); intraday advances; medium-term refinancing operations; primary refinancing provided through auctions up to a regional ceiling.
  - Admission of larger set of loan instruments as collateral while limiting government securities used as collateral.
  - Creation of an emergency liquidity facility for banks.
- Development of the interbank market and move to an average reserve requirement rule expected to facilitate liquidity management, reduce need to hold large excess liquidity, provide room for credit growth, and enhance monetary policy transmission.

### Annex II. 2018 Finance Law—Key Measures (selected)
- Customs: exemption of the 2% export tax on certain goods; export duty of 5% on certain products; levy on exported timber raised from 20% to 30%; customs duty exemptions for domestically refined petroleum products; harmonization of excise duties on weapons and ammunition from 12.5% to 25%; reduction in customs duties of 5% on imports of capital goods intended for investment; abolition of exemptions of the prepayment of liquidity on imports of vehicles by private persons; exemptions on import VAT for 2018 on gas cylinders for domestic use, certain pharmaceutical products, and sprinklers for agriculture.
- Administration: clarification of payment and appeals processes to be in accordance with CEMAC codes; common external CEMAC tariff implemented.
- Domestic Taxes — Direct taxes: requirement to provide transfer pricing documentation; all public contracts must be inclusive of all taxes.
- VAT Taxes: exemption of interest payments on loans of less than CFAF 2 million from first class microfinance institutions; additional excise taxes on imported wine and non-reusable packaging; electronic submission of VAT refund requests; automatic refunds for low-risk companies.
- Misc. Taxes: 15% tax on gambling and entertainment; 15% special income tax on certain non-domiciled persons or companies; restrictions on exporting timber products unless all taxes and duties can be proven paid; airport stamp duty of CFAF 25,000 per person per trip for international flights and CFAF 1,000 per person per trip for domestic flights.
- Source: Cameroonian Authorities.

### Annex III. Correspondent Accounts and the Need for Cash Adjustment (key findings)
- TSA reform led to creation of many correspondent accounts at the Treasury after transfer of EPAs accounts from commercial banks; correspondent accounts are third parties’ accounts held at the Treasury to transfer resources of EPAs.
- As of December 2016, balance of correspondent accounts amounted to 5.8 percent of GDP (3.9 percent of GDP in 2015), with 5.2 percent of GDP held by EPAs.
- At end-September 2017, balance decreased by 0.7 percent of GDP, mainly due to net reduction in EPAs’ accounts.
- Issues identified:
  - Subsidies transferred to EPAs’ correspondent accounts beyond absorption capacities, causing accumulation of unused budget appropriations.
  - Accounts created for some line ministries and projects in violation of the Organic Law on Finance Laws.
  - Some budgetary transfers to correspondent accounts made without availability of cash revenue for corresponding spending, leading to accumulation of large accounting balances in the road fund while budgetary funding for regular road maintenance remains insufficient.

*Sources: IMF staff estimates and projections; Cameroonian Authorities.*

### 3.      These practices complicate the calculation of the cash budget execution, as budget

### 3.      These practices complicate the calculation of the cash budget execution, as budget

### Cash budget execution and cash adjustment
- Budget appropriations are considered executed with no payment or cash transaction involved, complicating calculation of cash budget execution and increasing liquidity management constraints by the time the corresponding spending will be truly executed.
- A cash adjustment of CFAF 203 billion (1.1 percent of GDP) was made for 2016 to account for these irregular operations.
- The adjustment was based on the historical level of correspondent account financing to domestically financed investment, which is 16 percent on average for 2011–15.
- The cash adjustment for 2017–19 projects the disbursement of these amounts, taking into account the execution rate observed in 2017 H1.

### State-Owned Enterprises (SOEs): stature, indebtedness, and arrears
- SOEs collectively employ over 34 thousand people.
- In 2016, 27 of the main SOEs reported their financial statements.
- SOE indebtedness and related fiscal risk:
  - SOE debt rose to 17 percent of GDP in 2016 (from 4 percent in 2015), driven by a 290 percent rise in debt of SONARA.
  - The magnitude of SOEs short-term debt equals 6 percent of GDP.
  - Of short-term debt, 73 percent is owed by only four SOEs (the four most indebted SOEs in the short-term debt category are SONARA, Camtel, Chantier naval et industriel du Cameroun, and the Port Autonome de Douala).
  - In the medium to long term debt category, the four most indebted SOEs are SONARA, Camtel, Camwater, and the Electricity Development Corporation.
  - Three of the four SOEs with large short-term debt have negative operating margins.
- Arrears and accounts receivable:
  - Fiscal arrears of SOEs (tax liabilities) have increased by over 1 percent of GDP since 2013, driven by SONARA, the Cameroon Petroleum Deposit Society, and the Electricity Development Corporation whose tax liabilities each increased by over 200 percent.
  - Non-pension and non-fiscal arrears doubled in 2016 to about 1.2 percent of GDP.
  - Arrears to suppliers equaled 2.5 percent of GDP in 2016.
  - A large rise in accounts receivable may be attributable to non-payments between SOEs and non-payment of subsidies by the central government.
- Classification and financial ratios for financially at-risk SOEs:
  - The government classifies 18 SOEs as financially at risk; the 2018 Finance Law classifies 14 SOEs as highly unprofitable and 4 as unprofitable.
  - In 2016 these 18 SOEs had:
    - average debt-to-asset ratio of 66 percent;
    - operating profit ratio (operating income to revenue) of -48 percent;
    - average default ratio (equity/share capital) of -4;
    - ratio of salaries to revenue of 100 percent (and to operating profit of 38 percent).

### Public-Private Partnerships (PPPs): portfolio, costs, and contingent liabilities
- As of October 2017, Cameroon’s PPP portfolio consists of 36 projects at various stages.
- Immediate investment costs to the government:
  - Completed projects (1 project): CFAF 220 million (0.001 percent of GDP);
  - Projects under execution (6 projects): CFAF 280 billion (1.4 percent of GDP);
  - Projects with contracts signed but not started (7 projects): CFAF 261 billion (1.3 percent of GDP).
- The remaining 22 projects do not have confirmed investment costs.
- Government liabilities to private partners:
  - Conditional liabilities: CFAF 76 billion, or 0.38 percent of GDP (include loan guarantees to private partners, surety with creditors of a percentage of total costs, and a guarantee of a minimum passage through a pipeline).
  - Firm liabilities: CFAF 31.182 billion, or 0.16 percent of GDP (include reimbursement of pre-financing or investments made by private partners, subsidies to guaranteed low user fees, and guaranteed rent payments).

### Monitoring and policy recommendations on SOEs and PPPs
- Monitoring the risks associated with contingent liabilities of SOEs and PPPs is imperative for fiscal sustainability.
- Critical improvements instituted:
  - The first financial analysis and risk assessment of SOEs in the 2018 Finance Law.
  - A new requirement for the national debt policy committee’s (CNDP) opinion before any external borrowing by SOEs.
- Important next steps:
  - Effective implementation of the 2018 Finance Law measures.
  - Improve the coverage of public debt by systematically incorporating all claims on the State to avoid substantial revisions of the stock of debt.
  - Maintain the permanent monitoring mechanism via the oversight committee the government has established to limit fiscal risks related to PPPs.

### Key financial indicators for SOEs, 2009–16 (selected figures from Annex IV. Table 1)
- Gross Sales (2009–2016): 7.3, 9.0, 10.9, 9.8, 8.7, 6.9, 4.8, 5.7
- Net Income (2009–2016): 0.1, 0.2, 0.3, 0.0, -0.1, -0.4, -0.3, -0.4
- Gross arrears (2009–2016): 1.3, 1.9, 3.7, 2.0, 2.1, 2.9, 3.0, 3.9
- Liabilities owed to the SOE (2009–2016): 1.1, 2.8, 4.4, 5.6, 5.7, 5.6, 3.5, 6.1
- Gross debt (2009–2016): 7.1, 8.1, 15.2, 11.7, 12.3, 8.0, 3.7, 17.6
- Number of SOEs covered (2009–2016): 21, 21, 22, 22, 21, 13, 27

### Interim Growth and Employment Strategy Paper (GESP) 2018–20: objectives and priorities
- Purpose: interim document aligns GESP 2010–20 objectives to recent challenges; reference framework for 2018–20 with intention of attaining emerging country status by 2035 and the SDGs; aims to maintain sustainable macroeconomic framework via consolidation and reform efforts in the ECF-supported program.
- Observed outcomes and constraints (2010–17):
  - Average growth over the period was 4.7 percent compared to 5.2 percent expected.
  - The primary fiscal deficit deteriorated to 5.4 percent of GDP in 2016.
  - Debt-to-GDP ratio reached 31.6 percent in 2016, pushing the risk of debt distress to high.
  - Implementation suffered from falling petroleum revenue, security threats, and lower-than-expected investment execution.
- Main objectives of the interim strategy:
  - Increasing growth progressively to reach 5 percent in 2020;
  - Reducing underemployment from 71.1 percent in 2007 to 50 percent in 2020;
  - Reducing the poverty rate from 39.9 percent in 2007 to less than 25 percent in 2020.
- Sectoral and reform priorities:
  - Development of large public infrastructure projects to promote private sector investment and growth;
  - Modernization of production systems in agriculture and livestock to move up the value chain;
  - Promotion of regional integration and trade diversification;
  - Improving social policies in health, education, gender and social protection;
  - Promoting job creation;
  - Improving governance and public financial management.
- Monitoring: the interim document will be subject to semi-annual and annual assessments and an annual progress report to redefine targets.

### Letter of Intent and Memorandum of Economic and Financial Policies (MEFP) — selected statements and targets
- Date of Letter of Intent: December 13, 2017.
- The government’s ECF-supported program period: 2017 to 2020 (ECF approved June 26, 2017).
- Program performance and fiscal targets:
  - The 2018 budget law aims to reduce the deficit from 3.1 percent of GDP in 2017 to 2.3 percent of GDP in 2018.
  - Targeted additional non-oil revenue mobilization of up to 0.6 percent of GDP and better control of public expenditure of 0.33 percent of GDP.
- Recent macroeconomic developments and projections (from the MEFP supplement):
  - Growth: 4.5 percent in 2016 (revised), 3.7 percent expected in 2017.
  - GDP rebasing in July 2017 resulted in an 8.2 percent upward revision of GDP.
  - Inflation: 0.8 percent at end-September (y/y).
  - Fiscal balances:
    - Budget deficit (commitments basis) in 2016 revised to 6.2 percent of GDP.
    - Overall deficit declined to 0.8 percent of GDP (1.2 percent of GDP projected), then at end-September 2017 increased to 1.6 percent of GDP.
    - Non-oil primary balance stood at CFAF 528 billion in compliance with the floor of CFAF 708 billion set in the program.
- Program implementation notes and requests:
  - All quantitative performance criteria and indicative targets for end-June 2017 were met, except the continuous performance criterion on contracting new non-concessional external borrowings, which was exceeded by CFAF 64 billion.
  - The government requests IMF completion of the first review under the ECF-supported program and disbursement of SDR 82.8 million.
  - The government requests a waiver for non-observance of the continuous ceiling on new non-concessional external debt for 2017 and proposes reducing the new non-concessional borrowing limit by CFAF 64 billion in the 2018 budget law.
  - Two structural benchmarks (audit and verification of outstanding balances and arrears; strategy for resolution of ailing banks) were not met and are proposed to be reset for end-March 2018 and end-June 2018.

*Source: IMF staff report excerpts (Annexes III–V, Annex IV Table 1, Letter of Intent and MEFP, December 13, 2017).*

### 5.      Slower growth, as well as a tighter monetary policy, weighed on the monetary

### 5.      Slower growth, as well as a tighter monetary policy, weighed on the monetary

### Monetary aggregates and banking liquidity
- At end-October 2017:
  - money supply increased by 5 percent year-on-year.
  - credit to the economy increased by 4.4 percent (1.4 percent since end-2016).
  - bank deposits increased by 3.3 percent.
- Bank liquidity tightened; the BEAC refinancing ceiling is binding, with weekly demands exceeding CFAF 200 billion.
- Bank liquidity conditions improved since August 2017 following the advance repayment of CFAF 80 billion in securitized debt with the banks.
- Government indebtedness with the banking system remains lower than expected.

### Public debt and contingent obligations
- Public debt stock:
  - CFAF 6,031 billion at end-2016 (31.6 percent of GDP).
  - CFAF 6,165 billion at end-September 2017 (31.1 percent of GDP), including:
    - balance of unpaid government obligations: 3 percent of GDP.
    - SONARA’s supplier debt: 0.3 percent of GDP.
- Loans contracted but not yet disbursed increased from CFAF 3,842 billion at end-2016 to CFAF 4,844 billion at end-September 2017, reflecting financing needs for major infrastructure projects (including PLANUT).
- Note: Debt monitored by the CAA amounts to CFAF 5,500 billion (28 percent of GDP) at end-September 2017 and does not include the balance of unpaid government obligations and arrears on SONARA’s commercial loans.

### Update of the Growth and Employment Strategy (2018–20)
- Strategic framework updated in September 2017 covers 2018–20 and remains aligned with the GESP.
- Central objective for 2018–20: “maintain a stable macroeconomic framework by capitalizing on the investment efforts made since 2010, so that they might deliver their full benefits on the development of the private sector, and pursue social and poverty reduction policies.”
- ECAM-4 (2014) findings:
  - poverty rate fell by 2.4 percentage points to 37.5 percent (from 39.9 percent in 2007 and 40.2 percent in 2001).
  - average annual real GDP growth 2010–14: 4.7 percent, per capita income increase: 2.1 percent per year on average.
  - if inequalities had remained unchanged, poverty would have declined from 39.9 percent in 2007 to 21.8 percent in 2014 (decrease of 18 percentage points); growing inequalities had a negative impact of 15.7 percentage points.
- Priorities for 2018–20:
  - Infrastructure development (energy, water, roads, transportation, ICTs, post offices and postal financial services, urban and housing infrastructure).
  - Modernization of production capacity.
  - Regional integration and trade diversification.
  - Social policies (health, education and vocational training, gender, social protection).
  - Employment.
  - Governance and strategic public management.

### Implementation of the economic and financial program (performance to mid-2017)
- All quantitative performance criteria and indicative targets at end-June 2017 met, except the ceiling on new non-concessional borrowing was missed.
- End-June results:
  - non-oil primary balance: CFAF -307 billion (floor: CFAF -392 billion).
  - government net domestic financing excluding net IMF financing: CFAF -79 billion (ceiling: CFAF -18 billion).
  - disbursement of non-concessional external debt contracted prior to program approval: CFAF 205 billion (ceiling: CFAF 280 billion).
  - continuous performance criterion on contracting new non-concessional external debt was exceeded by CFAF 64 billion (mainly due to a November 2017 loan initially planned in the 2018 borrowing plan); government committed to reduce the new non-concessional borrowing limit by CFAF 64 billion in 2018.
- No arrears toward external creditors as of reporting date (zero ceiling).

### Structural benchmarks — implementation status (as of end-November 2017)
- Structural benchmarks respected:
  - Submission to the CEMAC Commission of a draft law transposing the CEMAC Directive on Finance Laws; five other CEMAC directives also sent for validation.
  - Strengthened information exchanges and collaboration between tax and customs administrations, yielding:
    - suspension of customs operations from September 15, 2017 for importers identified as inactive in the DGI registry.
    - assessment and report on tax expenditure on indirect taxation for 2016, and a plan for rationalization for 2019–21.
    - draft guidance note submitted to the Prime Minister on derogation regimes.
    - joint assessment (MINFI/MINEPAT/INS/API) of the April 2013 law on tax incentives for investment initiated; report expected end-2017.
    - organization of joint controls and investigations (sectors: cement, forests, hardware, ICTs).
    - harmonization of VAT tariff positions and dematerialization of tax registration for used car imports.
  - Monthly publication of the petroleum product price structure.
  - Indication in the TOFE of total oil revenues from SNH and of direct interventions; 2016 direct interventions amounted to 60 percent of total petroleum royalties; government intends to limit SNH direct interventions to 50 percent of SNH royalty in 2018 and thereafter gradually reduce.
  - Development of a strategy for progressive expansion of the TSA and inventory of EPA accounts in commercial banks; strict limitation on opening new bank accounts.
  - Adoption and submission to COBAC of a strategy to clear the commercial banks’ non-performing loans portfolio (strategy document sent to COBAC).
- Modified and rephased structural benchmarks:
  - Inventory and confirmation of all unpaid obligations by central government: rescheduled to end-March 2018 (original: end-September 2017); related gradual clearance plan rescheduled to March 2018; quarterly monitoring reports rescheduled to July 2018 (from April 2018).
  - Adopt resolution plan for distressed banks and submit to COBAC: submitted in September (one month late); plan to be completed by June 2018.
  - Strengthen land tax collection linked to electricity distribution and share proceeds with local governments: postponed from December 2017 to December 2018 for inclusion in the 2019 budget; since 2016 pre-filled land tax declarations included in electricity bills.

### Macroeconomic framework, projections, and risks
- Growth:
  - Growth estimated at 3.7 percent in 2017.
  - Projected at 4.2 percent in 2018.
  - Expected to increase to 5.1 percent in 2020 and level out at 5–6 percent over the medium term.
  - Growth drivers: agro-pastoral and manufacturing buoyancy, sustained construction growth (public investment, CAN 2019 preparations), coming into operation of natural gas production, reinvigoration of manufacturing and agriculture.
- Fiscal consolidation:
  - Government reaffirms commitment to lower fiscal deficit from 6.2 percent of GDP in 2016 to 2.1 percent of GDP in 2019 (commitments basis, including grants) through non-oil revenue collection and expenditure control.
- Monetary aggregates and reserves:
  - End-2017 expectations:
    - money supply growth to decline to 5 percent.
    - credit to the private sector growth to 5.6 percent.
  - Regional monetary policy causes difficulties for government financing on the money market and could result in lower-than-expected accumulation of Treasury deposits at the BEAC compared to initial projections (but still in line with program objectives).
  - Rapid increase in banks’ reserves, if sustained, could help maintain or exceed expected reserves.
  - Current account deficit expected at 2.6 percent of GDP (down from 3.2 percent of GDP in 2016), contributing to larger-than-initially envisaged buildup of net foreign assets.
- Public debt outlook:
  - Public debt likely around 33.8 percent of GDP (increase of 2 percentage points of GDP compared to end-2016), driven by disbursement of budget support, planned investment project implementation, and conversion of statutory advances.
  - Almost half of the increase attributed to conversion of statutory advances into deposits at the BEAC; remainder from project loan drawdowns and expected budget supports.
  - Over the medium term, public debt expected to stabilize in 2018–19 before gradually declining under fiscal consolidation and growth resumption.
- Risks to baseline scenario:
  - (i) Rapid widening of regional imbalances following insufficient member-state adjustment or insufficient BEAC control of “free riders”, leading to further decline in foreign exchange reserves.
  - (ii) Potential resurgence of the terrorist threat in the Lake Chad Basin entailing additional security costs and draining budget resources.
  - (iii) Persistent sluggish external demand reducing non-oil exports (partially mitigated if oil prices increase).
  - Government commitment: prepared to implement additional measures if risks materialize; to budget a larger part of security expenses and seek funding, with UN support, for additional humanitarian costs.

### Fiscal policy — remainder of 2017 and 2018–19 objectives
- Fiscal challenge:
  - Low oil revenues require increased effort to mobilize non-oil revenue and recalibrate spending to maintain the 2017 deficit target.
  - Expected shortfall: about 0.7 percent of GDP on tax revenues compared with program projections, mainly driven by a decline in oil revenues (0.3 percent of GDP).
- Revenue mobilization measures:
  - Tax and customs administrations to enhance collection of tax arrears and complete joint tax controls and investigations in selected sectors.
  - Use results of cross-checking customs and tax files; strengthen taxpayer reporting monitoring.
  - Maximize customs revenue collection on end-year imports; finalize ongoing controls and strengthen arrears collection.
- Expenditure and financing management:
  - Government committed to creating fiscal space on current expenditure, restructuring expenses, and some capital expenditures to maintain overall deficit target by end-2017.
  - Effort to keep disbursement of non-concessional external financing within program limits; at end-October 2017 disbursements amounted to CFAF 447 billion (including CFAF 356.5 billion on non-concessional loans), in line with program limit of CFAF 540 billion.
- Cash management for November–December 2017:
  - Cash need estimated at some CFAF 130 billion to cover budget execution for November and December 2017.
  - Improved bank liquidity in Q3 envisaged to support more substantial and frequent Treasury bill issuances to limit liquidity needs.
  - Government could make limited and temporary recourse to statutory advances, not exceeding a total of CFAF 100 billion, reimbursed by budget support disbursements; will continue to observe program commitments and UMAC obligations.
  - BEAC Board decision of August 5, 2017: by 31 December, 2017, Cameroon to draw the available remaining balance up to the ceiling of CFAF 577 billion, to be deposited at the BEAC remunerated at the consolidation rate; consolidation will not affect program objectives regarding net accumulation of government deposits at the BEAC.

*IMF staff report excerpt (Cameroon).*

### 20.      The 2018 budget law is in line with program objectives. It envisages, in particular, the

### The 2018 budget law is in line with program objectives. It envisages, in particular, the

### Fiscal outlook and overall targets
- Reduction of the deficit from 3.1 percent of GDP in 2017 to 2.3 percent of GDP in 2018.
- Deficit reduction to be achieved through:
  - Increased mobilization efforts of non-oil revenue, which would expand by 0.6 percent of GDP.
  - Further prioritization of expenditure for around 0.3 percent of GDP.

### Revenue measures (key items in the 2018 budget law)
- Planned tax and non-tax measures starting in 2018:
  - Increase of the airport stamps duty rate.
  - Increase in the excise tax on arms and ammunitions and in the export tax on processed timber.
  - Elimination of the exemption of the pre-payment of duties on tourism vehicles’ imports.
  - Institution of excise duties in the gambling sector, inter alia.
- Broadening the tax base:
  - Inclusion of the land tax in the electricity bill and sharing its proceeds between the central government and the decentralized local governments.
  - Starting with the 2019 budget law, link payment of the land tax to that of the electricity bill (reprogrammed structural benchmark).
- Tax expenditures:
  - A study on tax expenditures has been carried out; its report is attached to the draft 2018 budget law.
  - Exemptions that are not pertinent will be subject to a gradual phasing out starting with the 2019 budget law.
- DGD (customs) measures for 2018:
  - Overhaul of the overall export taxation policy.
  - Renewed taxation of certain goods which were exempted in 2008.
  - Improvement of the customs clearance procedures for petroleum products at the SONARA.
  - Submission of some products to excise duties on imports.
- Non-tax revenue measures:
  - Creation of revenue boards at organizations that do not already have one.
  - Securing collected revenues through controls of their actual payment to the Treasury.

### Expenditure projections and commitments
- Current spending containment and priority investment projects:
  - Government commitments under current expenditure:
    - (i) strengthen the control of personnel costs;
    - (ii) review the lists of reference prices (for public procurement) [mercuriale des prix] including that for rents;
    - (iii) control expenditures on goods and services;
    - (iv) rationalize the subsidies granted to public entities.
  - Investment spending: continue to prioritize projects with the greatest impact on growth, based on pre-established criteria defined in the memorandum of June 2017.

### SONARA pricing and petroleum sector vulnerability (structural benchmark)
- Government preparing a strategy to:
  - Ensure the sustainability of the petroleum price structure.
  - Reduce the financial vulnerability of SONARA to fluctuations in world oil prices.
- Strategy includes:
  - Simulations of the impact of a fixed mark-up coefficient for SONARA to reduce the volatility of its revenues.
  - Other options to make the pricing structure more transparent and equitable.

### Tax and customs administration reforms (implementation and operational measures)
- Tax administration measures in 2018:
  - Continuation of administrative measures aimed at improving VAT efficiency.
  - Operationalization of seven new Tax Centers for Medium-Size Enterprises (CIMEs) starting in January 2018.
  - Improvement of revenues from registration fees via extension of the computerized procedure for registering ownership transfers of used vehicles to other tax regions.
  - Strengthening collection of tax arrears.
- Strengthening information exchanges and collaboration between DGI and DGD to:
  - Tax importers unknown to the DGI registry.
  - Exert optimal control over derogatory regimes.
  - Finalize joint DGI/DGD investigations and controls.
- Measures on importers unknown to the DGI registry:
  - Locate and retain these taxpayers to ensure compliance with spontaneous tax payments.
  - Subject previous operations to investigation and control procedures.
  - These taxpayers will no longer be able to import through customs unless registered in the DGI database; a measure in the 2018 budget law will confirm this prohibition.
- DGD-specific reforms and improvements:
  - Consolidate achievements of 2017, including good performance of new measures of the 2017 budget law.
  - Strengthen monitoring to reduce fraud.
  - Clarify taxation of software.
  - Set up warehouses for vehicles less than 10 years old.
  - Secure revenue and improve costs and transit times through 100 percent scanning of merchandise.
  - Accelerate move to paperless procedures before and after customs clearance through the e-force application.

### Structural public finance reforms (PEFA assessment and actions)
- Governance and institutional dynamics:
  - Steering Committee for Public Finance Reforms and the Committee of the Platform for Dialogue on Public Finance Reforms have held sessions guiding reform.
- Achievements and ongoing actions:
  - Six draft texts to transpose the 2011 CEMAC Guidelines of the Harmonized Framework of Public Financial Management have been sent to the CEMAC Commission for a notice of compliance.
  - Streamlining of budget preparation and integration of the Medium-Term Budget Framework (MTBF) with the 2018 budget law, including first Extended Programming Conferences and changeover of the MTBF in the budget preparation module for PROBMIS.
  - Regular production and publication of mid-term budget execution reports.
  - Creation and initiation of work by the committee for the migration of the TOFE from the cash basis to the payment order basis.
  - Amplification of implementation of management control with rollout of the management dialogue in ministerial departments.
- Public investment management optimization measures:
  - (i) Strengthening the system for monitoring implementation of the government investment budget (put in place in 2017).
  - (ii) Consolidation of the bank of projects with support of AfDB and the World Bank.
  - (iii) Improvements in reliability of management in Commitment Authorizations and Payment Credits.
  - (iv) Consolidation of approach to reducing “disguised operating” expenditure in the Public Investment Budget.
  - (v) Actions to anticipate procurement procedures to reduce project preparation times.
  - (vi) Strengthening preparation of public investment projects per Guide of Maturation of Public Investment Projects revised at end-2017.
  - (vii) Pursuing review of the procurement code and professionalization of actors involved in procurement.

### Additional planned measures (program-related)
- Continue transposition of CEMAC Directives into national legal system after receiving opinion from the CEMAC Commission, including adoption by Parliament of draft laws on:
  - Revision of the government financial regime.
  - Code of transparency and good governance.
  - Conduct study on institutional and regulatory impact of reforms induced by transposition.
- Revisit performance frameworks of ministerial departments and institutions ahead of third triennium of program-based budgeting 2019–21.
- Effectively migrate to a TOFE on a payment order basis.
- Strengthen budget controls by gradually reducing the supplementary period:
  - Reduce to two months in accordance with the 2019 budget law (new structural benchmark).
  - Reduce to one month in 2020, in line with the CEMAC directive.
- Continue to reduce direct interventions of the Société Nationale des Hydrocarbures (SNH).
- Improve cash management by increasing coverage of the TSA:
  - Inventory of bank accounts of the Administrative Public Entities (EPAs) completed.
  - Strategy for broadening coverage of the TSA prepared.
  - Government to prepare a schedule for implementation of actions and enabling conditions (legal framework and technical assistance); deadlines to be defined in 2018 following technical assistance and legal framework review.
- Reduce exceptional procedures:
  - Prohibit any new replenishment of the correspondent 450 accounts from budget allocations.
  - Prohibit replenishment of 420 accounts that do not have a senior accounting officer.
  - Make all investment projects subject to normal budget procedures (new structural benchmark; circular of the Minister of Finance).
- Strengthen monitoring of fiscal risks linked to state-owned enterprises (SOEs):
  - Undertake audits of the largest structurally loss-making public enterprises.
  - Government platform set up to monitor performance of SOEs.
  - Assessment of certified financial statements of SOEs carried out using ratios (debt ratio, default ratio, operating margin).
  - Classification of SOEs into four groups: (i) heavily loss-making companies; (ii) loss-making companies; (iii) profit-making companies; (iv) strongly profit-making companies.
  - Analysis of fiscal risks from companies engaged in PPP contracts conducted.

### Debt policy, ceilings, and recent borrowing
- Debt policy priorities:
  - Avoid risk of overindebtedness and place public debt on a sustainable path.
  - Continue to limit non-concessional borrowing in line with program limits consistent with the debt sustainability analysis.
- For 2018–19, non-concessional borrowing ceilings set in line with:
  - (i) execution rate for the three previous years;
  - (ii) volume of projects regarded as mature;
  - (iii) disbursements envisaged under the committed but non-disbursed balances (“soldes engagés non-décaissés”—SENDs).
- Strengthen CNDP control over all new borrowing proposals, including by state-owned enterprises, early in the process and before ratification and signing authorization decrees.
- Commitments and ceilings:
  - Commitments signed in first half of 2017 amount to CFAF 1,369 billion on an annual ceiling of CFAF 1,700 billion allocated in the budget.
  - Non-concessional loans contracted since start of the program are valued at CFAF 164 billion, on a CFAF 100 billion ceiling adopted under the program (mainly due to signing in November 2017 of a loan initially planned in the 2018 borrowing plan).
  - For 2018, limit on non-concessional debt reduced from CFAF 500 billion to CFAF 436 billion.
- Prioritization criteria for projects under indebtedness threshold:
  - (i) projects with high socio-economic impact and that contribute to gross fixed capital formation;
  - (ii) completion of the first-generation projects;
  - (iii) bridging projects for the commissioning of the first-generation projects;
  - (iv) projects with concessional financing;
  - (v) urgent tourism and sports infrastructure projects in the context of the 2019 CAN.

### Concessional and non-concessional borrowing, January–November 2017 (summary from Text Table 1)
- Total I (before approval of the program with the IMF): 1,369 (of which: concessional 417; non-concessional 952).
- Total II (after approval of the program with the IMF): 183 (of which: concessional 19; non-concessional 164).
- Total (I+II): 1,551 (of which: concessional 436; non-concessional 1,116).
- Selected project entries (amounts in CFAF bn; details preserved exactly as in source):
  - Development Project for the Transport Sector, IBRD, Transport, 113, Grace Period 7, Maturity 30, Concessional.
  - Project to upgrade the electricity tranmission network and to reform the sector (SONATREL), IBRD, Energy, 191, Grace Period 7, Maturity 30, Concessional.
  - Construction project for the deep-water port of Kribi, phase 2, Eximbank China, Infrastructure, 322, Grace Period 5, Maturity 20, Non-concessional.
  - Transport sector support program Phase II, AfDB, Transport, 177, Grace Period 5, Maturity 25, Non-concessional.
  - (Full table entries preserved in source but not repeated here in full per pipeline content inventory rules.)

### Financing of the 2018 budget and SENDs
- 2018 budget financing mix:
  - Domestic disbursements projected at CFAF 356 billion, including CFAF 260 billion in government securities and CFAF 96 billion in direct borrowing with domestic banks.
  - External financing expected in 2018 includes loan disbursements of CFAF 560 billion, deriving mostly from project loans already signed (in addition to budget support).
  - List of projects selected mainly covers road infrastructure, the energy sector and the CAN.
- SENDs (committed but non-disbursed balances) management:
  - CNDP identified projects subject to SENDs of more than four years, worth approximately CFAF 1,000 billion, for elimination or reorientation if no longer justified.
  - Expected significant reduction in stock of SENDs by end-2019.
  - Reduction of SENDs could enable controlled increase in disbursements on projects with strong financial and socio-economic return, helping contain the budget deficit within program constraints.

*Source: Cameroonian authorities (excerpts from the IMF country report).*

### 30.      The government is committed to continuing to implement policies that are consistent

### cr1809 - 30.      The government is committed to continuing to implement policies that are consistent

### Monetary arrangement, central government financing, and debt management
- The government is committed to continuing to implement policies consistent with maintaining the stability of the monetary arrangement.
- The government takes note of the BEAC’s Board of Directors decision to eliminate the statutory advances by December 31, 2017, and is committed to continuing to comply with the parameters of the program in terms of net central government financing by the BEAC.
- The government intends to continue to promote development of the financial market by financing itself mainly through the issuance of government securities.
- Program review timetable:
  - Second review: based on end-December 2017 targets; expected to be completed on or after June 30, 2018.
  - Third review: based on end-June 2018 targets; expected to be completed on or after December 15, 2018.

### Planned public investment projects and financing structure
- Projects (selected), lenders, sector, amount (billion CFAF), and type:
  - Inclusive and resilient cities project — World Bank — Infrastructure — 94 — Concessional
  - Logone bridge — EU and AfDB — Infrastructure — 69 — Concessional
  - Rural electrification project — OPEP Fund — Energy — 8 — Concessional
  - Credit line for the import of fertilizer — Arab Bank — Agriculture — 16 — Semi-concessional
  - Olama-Kribi road — Kuwaiti Fund and AfDB — Infrastructure — 16 — Semi-concessional
  - 2019 Africa Soccer Cup — BMCE Bank international, Eximbank USA — Infrastructure — 76 — Non-concessional
  - Ebolowa-Kribi and Mbalmayo-Mekin electricity distribution lines — Bank of China — Energy — 104 — Non-concessional
  - Electricity distribution lines for Kribi port — China Development Bank — Energy — 18 — Non-concessional
  - Urban security project (phase 1) — Bank of China — Infrastructure — 23 — Non-concessional
  - Oil import by SONARA — Islamic Development Bank — Energy — 45 — Non-concessional
  - Project to strengthen and stabilize electricity transmission in Douala — Societe Generale — Energy — 119 — Non-concessional
  - Train cars for CAMRAIL (phase 1) — Standard Chartered Bank — Transport — 8 — Non-concessional
- Aggregated financing by type (as reported):
  - Total — 595
  - concessional — 171
  - semi-concessional — 32
  - non-concessional — 393
- Source of project list: Cameroonian authorities.

### Financial sector resolution, bad loans, and bank restructuring
- Plan for resolution of distressed banks aims to limit fiscal cost; government will strengthen plan submitted to COBAC on September 27, 2017 by incorporating:
  - (i) Upgrade of the public asset recovery company’s (Société de recouvrement des créances—SRC) methodology for assessing the transfer price of impaired assets to avoid additional costs for the government.
  - (ii) Assessment (feasibility and cost) of options for distressed private banks (from orderly liquidation to continuation of operations) and establishment of strong principles governing support to private banks so they may be recapitalized by June 2018. Otherwise, implement a solution according to parameters defined in paragraph 43 of the memorandum of June 2017.
  - (iii) Evaluation of the cost for restructuring the public bank, accompanied by a detailed restructuring plan (including financial projections, underlying assumptions, assessment of management capacity, investment needs), and putting in place a performance contract with bank management specifying main goals (staff costs, intermediation margin, introduction of risk management tools, etc.).
- The reprogrammed structural benchmark will be finalized in consultation with IMF staff by June 2018.
- Strategy for clearance of bad loans:
  - Detailed action plans to be prepared by June 2018, identifying authorities responsible, initiatives, and timetable; plans to cover renegotiation terms and strengthening judicial and extrajudicial procedures.
  - By December 2018, the Ministry of Justice will have trained judges in the resolution of bank conflicts who sit in commercial chambers of the main business centers (new structural benchmark).
  - These actions will supplement ongoing measures: development of the CIP-FIBANE-CASEMF platform and digitization of the movable collateral registry (structural benchmarks for March 2018).
  - The National Credit Council will liaise with the BEAC to reconcile and ensure consistency between national and regional initiatives for financial information databases (Centrale des incidents de paiements—CIP, credit risk bureau—centrale des risques, balance sheet information center—centrale des bilans).
- SMEs’ bank:
  - The business model will be reviewed and the business plan updated.
  - Study the possibility of promoting issuance of guarantees or financing facilities to commercial banks, rather than direct lending.

### Competitiveness, private sector development, and business climate reforms
- Government committed to accelerating measures to support private sector development and economic diversification; commissioning of large transport and energy projects starting in 2018 expected to remove bottlenecks and promote private investment.
- Planned support measures include: business upgrade program, establishment of land reserves for agro-industries, structuring of production areas, better supply of inputs, and continued reforms to improve the business climate in coordination with technical and financial partners.
- Ongoing and planned reforms (selected):
  - Modernization of legislative framework: revision of the CEMAC Customs Code and implementation of the CEMAC Customs Tariff in line with the 2017 version of the Harmonized System (HS). The CEMAC Customs Code has been revised and awaits ratification by the Ministerial Committee; the CEMAC Customs Tariff in the 2017 version of the HS will be implemented in Cameroon starting from January 1, 2018.
  - Finalization in 2017 of the digitized land registry map of Douala, Yaoundé, Garoua and Maroua, as well as the national map.
  - Computerization of the commerce and equipment credit registry.
  - Establishment of an escrow account dedicated to reimbursement of VAT credits: reduction of the stock of credits due for reimbursement from CFAF 51 billion on December 31, 2016 to CFAF 19 billion on October 20, 2017. An assessment of the mechanism to be carried out by December 31, 2017. For 2018, authorities intend to generalize online tracking of reimbursement requests and consider reimbursement without prior checking for honest taxpayers in the 2018 budget law.
  - Implementation of mobile phone declaration and payment procedure for micro and small-sized enterprises in departmental tax centers.
  - Reduction of processing times for government invoices between commitment and acceptance for payment by the Treasury to ease liquidity constraints for service providers (structural benchmark).
  - Finalization of land reform to reduce transaction times and facilitate access to ownership.

### Program arrangements, conditionality, and selected quantitative targets
- The program will be subject to semiannual reviews and performance criteria, indicative targets and structural benchmarks as set out in Tables 1 and 2 of the Memorandum and the Technical Memorandum of Understanding (TMU).
- TMU defines quantitative performance criteria and indicative objectives for end-December 2017 and end-June 2018, and sets reporting deadlines to IMF staff.
- Selected items and projections from program tables and memoranda (as presented):
  - Floor on the non-oil primary fiscal balance (commitment basis): multiple quarterly and year-end values reported in Table 1 (see program tables for full series).
  - Ceiling on the disbursement of non-concessional external debt contracted as of the date of program approval: values shown in Table 1 include 280, 205, Met, 540, 540, 350, 350, 596, 596 (as presented).
  - Continuous quantitative performance criteria include a ceiling on the accumulation of new external payments arrears: 0 values reported (Table 1).
  - Cumulative external budget support, excluding IMF (memorandum item): series values reported in Table 1 include 0, 0, 0, 443, 370, 131, 131, 261 (as presented).
  - New concessional external debt contracted or guaranteed by the government (memorandum): series values include 3,100,0,0,100,100,152,152,152,152 (as presented).
- The TMU and MEFP definitions clarify government and public enterprise scope, revenue definitions (cash basis recording), and oil revenue definition (transferable balance of SNH and income tax on petroleum companies and gas operators).

### Structural benchmarks and timelines (selected)
- Key structural benchmarks and status (Table 2 highlights, deadlines preserved as presented):
  - Monthly starting in June 2017: Include the total petroleum receipts of SNH and direct interventions in the table of government financial operations (TOFE). Status: Monthly TOFE — Met.
  - Monthly starting in June 2017: Publish the petroleum product price structure. Status: Publication on line and in newspapers — Met.
  - Quarterly starting in June 2017: Publish quarterly budget execution reports. Status: Publication on line and in newspapers — Met.
  - Quarterly starting in June 2017: Strengthen information sharing between DGI and DGD with joint quarterly reports. Status: Report submitted to Fund staff — Met.
  - September 2017: Submit to the CEMAC Commission a draft law transposing the CAEMC directive on budget laws. Status: Revised draft law presented to the CEMAC Commission — Met.
  - December 2017: Prepare a report evaluating the effectiveness of the new VAT escrow account funding mechanism and propose a plan to clear the stock of credits identified at December 31, 2016. Status: Report being prepared.
  - March 2018: Computerize the register of movable collateral. Status: In progress.
  - June 2018: Implement the interface between taxpayer registration database (NIU) and tax management application (MESURE). Status: Preparatory work in progress.
  - June 2018: Revise the plan for dealing with troubled banks; Plan finalized in consultation with Fund staff. Status: Planned (new structural benchmark).
  - December 2018: Provide training in banking dispute resolution for commercial court judges in major business centers — At least 10 judges trained in the fiscal year (new structural benchmark).
- Additional structural benchmark actions include verification of stock of domestic arrears at end-2016 by an external audit (March 2018), adoption of a plan for gradual clearance of domestic arrears (March 2018), and prohibitions and procedural changes to funding of certain correspondent accounts (January 2018 circular).

*Source: Cameroonian authorities; Memorandum of Economic and Financial Policies and Technical Memorandum of Understanding (as presented in the supplied content).*

### 7. Non-oil revenue includes all the government's (tax and nontax) revenue, with the exception

### cr1809 - 7. Non-oil revenue includes all the government's (tax and nontax) revenue, with the exception

### Definitions of revenue and privatization receipts
- Non-oil revenue: all the government's (tax and nontax) revenue, with the exception of oil revenue as defined under paragraph 6. Value-added tax (VAT) is recorded net of VAT reimbursements. Pipeline fees paid by Cameroon Oil Transportation Company (COTCO) are recorded under nontax revenue.
- Privatization revenue: all funds paid to the government in connection with the sale or transfer of the management of a public enterprise (concession), agency, or facility to private entities, including proceeds from sale of government-held shares. All privatization revenue must be recorded on a gross basis; any costs involved in the sale or concession must be recorded separately under expenditure.

### Expenditure classification and social spending
- Total government expenditure and net lending include:
  - wage and salary expenditure for civil servants;
  - goods and services;
  - transfers (including subsidies, grants, social security benefits, and other expenditure);
  - interest payments; and
  - capital expenditure.
- These items are recorded in the accounting system on a payment authorization basis, unless otherwise indicated, and include expenditure items executed without prior authorization that are pending regularization.
- Spending advances [interventions directes] by SNH (National Hydrocarbon Society) are part of government expenditure and include emergency payments made by SNH on behalf of the government to cover exceptional security and sovereignty outlays.
- Social expenditure: public expenditure in the budget linked to priority programs. Includes:
  - education sector: total (current and capital) expenditure of the Ministries of Elementary Education, Secondary Education, and Employment and Professional Training;
  - health sector: current expenditure of the Ministry of Public Health;
  - other social sectors: current expenditure of the Ministries of Labor and Social Security, Youth and Citizenship Education, Social Affairs, and Promotion of Women and the Family.

### Fiscal balance and debt concepts
- Primary balance: total government revenue (paragraph 5) minus total government expenditure and net lending (paragraph 9), not including interest payments on external and domestic debt.
- Debt (per Guidelines on Public Debt Conditionality): direct, non-contingent liability created under a contractual arrangement through provision of assets or services and requiring one or more payments of assets or services according to an established schedule; includes penalties or damages awarded by a court as a result of nonpayment of a contractual obligation that constitutes debt.
- External debt: any borrowing or debt service in a currency other than the CFA franc; applies also to debt between CEMAC countries and to government-guaranteed private debt that constitutes a contingent liability. Guaranteed debt: explicit legal obligation on the government to reimburse a debt in the event of default.
- Concessional external debt: external debt is considered concessional if it comprises a grant component of at least 35 percent. The grant component is the difference between the face value of the loan and its present value expressed as a percentage of face value. The present value at arrangement date is calculated by discounting debt service payments at contract date using a discount rate of 5 percent. The calculation of concessionality reflects maturity, grace period, schedule of maturities, commitment fees, and management fees; concessionality of IsDB loans will reflect the existing agreement between the IsDB and the IMF.

### Domestic debt taxonomy and balances (end-2016 stocks)
- Domestic debt: all government debts and obligations in CFA francs, including unreimbursed balances, advances from BEAC, Treasury bills and bonds, structured debt, nonstructured debt, domestic payment arrears, and debt to SONARAs suppliers.
- Structured debt: subject to a formal agreement [convention] or securitization [titrisation].
  - Structured bank debt: all claims of local banks on the government, except treasury bills and bonds; includes securitized bank debt with an outstanding balance at end-2016 of CFAF 86.36 billion, plus direct advance arrangements.
  - Structured nonbank debt: government balances payable to local nonbank institutions or individuals or the CEMAC that have been securitized or subject to a formal reimbursement agreement according to a clearly defined schedule.
- Nonstructured debt: balances payable transferred to the national amortization fund [Caisse Autonome d’Amortissement] (CAA) not subject to a formal reimbursement agreement or securitization; outstanding balance of nonstructured debt was CFAF 113.96 billion at end-2016. Under the program, nonstructured debt is part of domestic payment arrears; payments on nonstructured debt are deducted from the stock of domestic payment arrears and affect the primary balance on a cash basis.

### Net domestic financing and its components
- Net domestic financing of the government: sum of (i) net bank credit to the government; and (ii) net nonbank financing.
- Net bank credit to the government: change in the balance between government’s liabilities and assets with the national banking system. Assets include:
  - cash resources on hand with the treasury;
  - treasury deposits with the central bank, not including the HIPC account and the C2D account;
  - credit balance of the accounts of the Caisse Autonome d'Amortissement with commercial banks earmarked for reimbursement of government debt obligations.
  - Government outstanding balances include: financing from the central bank (statutory advances; net IMF financing disbursements net of reimbursements; refinancing of guaranteed bonds; treasury paper held by the central bank) and financing from commercial banks (direct advances and loans; securities; and treasury bills and bonds held by local banks).
- Net nonbank financing includes:
  - change in outstanding balance of government securities (treasury bills and bonds) issued in CFA francs on the regional market and not held by the local banking system;
  - change in outstanding balance of structured nonbank domestic debt;
  - privatization revenue (paragraph 8);
  - change in the balance of correspondent bank accounts (including Account 42) and consignment accounts;
  - change in the balance of outstanding claims on the government abandoned by the private sector.
- Net bank credit data calculated from BEAC-provided data; monthly reconciliations between the treasury and the BEAC are required. Government’s net nonbank financing is calculated by the public treasury.

### Definitions and treatment of arrears
- Domestic payment arrears = (i) payment arrears on expenditure + (ii) payment arrears on domestic debt.
  - Payment arrears on expenditure: "balances payable" with payment lag exceeding the regulatory period of 90 days; include unpaid obligations for which normal expenditure execution procedures were followed and invoices due and not paid with public and private enterprises; exclude domestic financial debt service (principal and interest). Balances payable under 90 days represent payments in progress. Information to determine balances payable is provided in Table 3 of TABORD; the treasury monitors monthly.
  - Payment arrears on domestic debt: difference between amount due under a domestic debt arrangement or matured treasury securities and the amount effectively paid after the payment deadline or maturity date.
- External payment arrears: external debt obligations of the government not paid when due under contractual terms (accounting for contractual grace periods). The performance criterion excludes arrears on external financial obligations subject to rescheduling.

### Quantitative program objectives (QO) — overview and reporting
- Quantitative objectives are specified in Table 1 of the MEFP and are assessed on a cumulative basis from the beginning of the calendar year unless noted otherwise. Detailed assessment provisions follow.

Cutoff and reporting timelines:
- Detailed data on government financial operations indicating the primary balance, oil revenue, and the level of miscellaneous expenditure not otherwise classified: transmitted monthly within six weeks from the end of the month.
- Detailed data on net domestic financing of the government (bank and nonbank), status of budget support disbursements, reimbursement of external debt service, and status of external arrears: submitted monthly within six weeks after the end of the month.
- Detailed information on disbursements of external debts contracted by the government: reported within six weeks after the end of the month, indicating loan signature dates and distinguishing concessional vs non-concessional.
- Detailed information on all financing from the BEAC to the government: reported within six weeks after the end of the month.
- Data on balances, accumulation, and reimbursement of external arrears: reported within six weeks after the end of each month; any occurrence of new external arrears should be immediately reported to the Fund.

### Specific quantitative performance criteria and adjustments
- Non-oil primary balance:
  - A floor for the non-oil primary balance (commitment basis) is defined as a quantitative objective. Non-oil primary balance = primary balance (paragraph 12) minus oil revenue (paragraph 6).
  - Consistency requirement: cumulative miscellaneous expenditure not otherwise classified (including errors and omissions in the TOFE) for a given month should not exceed 5 percent of the cumulative expenditure for that month, in absolute value. If exceeded, a comprehensive reconciliation exercise for all TOFE source data will be undertaken in consultation with IMF staff.
- Net domestic financing excluding net IMF financing:
  - A ceiling on net domestic financing of the government excluding net financing from the IMF is defined as a quantitative objective.
  - Adjustment: ceiling will be adjusted if disbursements of external budget support are below the programmed levels.
  - Quarterly adjustment mechanism: at the end of each quarter, if disbursements of external budget support are below (above) programmed amounts, the relevant quarterly ceilings will be adjusted upward (downward) commensurately, within the limit of CFAF 120 billion starting from 2017 Q4 onwards. This ceiling may be revised to reflect the rate of budget aid disbursements during the year.
- Disbursement of non-concessional external loans signed before program approval:
  - A ceiling on disbursements of non-concessional external debt contracted before the date the program was approved is defined as a quantitative objective; applicable to contractual debt arranged but not disbursed at program approval. Uses definitions in paragraphs 14 and 15.
- Net borrowing of the central government from the central bank (BEAC):
  - A ceiling on net claims of the central government from the BEAC is defined as a quantitative objective. Defined as Central Bank’s claims on the government (excluding IMF financing, including unpaid balances of statutory advances capped at CFAF 300 billion, refinancing of guaranteed bonds, and treasury securities held by the Central bank) minus deposits of the Treasury with the Central Bank and cash balances.
  - Adjustment: ceiling on net borrowing will be adjusted if disbursements in connection with external budget support are below (above) programmed levels.
  - Quarterly adjustment mechanism: at the end of each quarter, if disbursements of external budget support are below (above) programmed amounts, the relevant quarterly ceilings will be adjusted upward (downward) commensurately, within the limit of CFAF 120 billion starting from 2017 Q4 onwards. This ceiling may be revised to reflect the rate of budget aid disbursements during the year.
- Non-accumulation of external payment arrears:
  - Performance criterion: a ceiling of zero on the accumulation of external payment arrears is defined as a continuous quantitative objective. Government undertakes not to accumulate any new external payment arrears on its debt, except arrears subject to rescheduling. The PC is measured cumulatively from program approval and monitored continuously.
- New non-concessional external debt contracted or guaranteed by the government:
  - Continuous performance criterion: a ceiling on new non-concessional external debt contracted or guaranteed by the government. Applies to external debt as defined in paragraph 14 and uses the concept of concessionality in paragraph 15. Applies to public enterprises receiving government transfers, municipalities, and other public sector entities. Not applicable to borrowing in CFA francs, treasury bills and bonds issued in CFA francs on the CEMAC regional market, regular short-term supplier loans, regular import credits, loans from the IMF, or debt relief by rescheduling/refinancing.
  - Measurement period: applies to new debt contracted or guaranteed per calendar year (not cumulative from program approval). The 2017 ceiling applies to new non-concessional external debt contracted or guaranteed between program approval and December 31st, 2017. The 2018 ceiling will apply to new non-concessional debt contracted or guaranteed in 2018.
  - 2018 ceiling for new non-concessional external debt: CFAF 436 billion.

*International Monetary Fund — Cameroon: Selected program definitions, classifications, and quantitative objectives (excerpts).*

### 37. The ceiling on new non-concessional external debt contracted or guaranteed by the

### 37. The ceiling on new non-concessional external debt contracted or guaranteed by the

### Debt ceiling adjustment
- The ceiling on new non-concessional external debt contracted or guaranteed by the government will be adjusted upwards to accommodate budget support from the World Bank, the AFDB and France for debt management purposes, up to the amounts indicated in memorandum item Nr 1 of MEFP Table 1.
- Footnote in table: "The ceiling will be adjusted upwards by the amount of non-concessional budget support excluding IMF financing for debt management purposes, up to the amounts specified in memorandum item No. 1 below."

### Cutoff dates and immediate reporting obligations
- The monthly situation of all loans (conditions and creditors) contracted by the government must be reported within six weeks after the end of the month.
- Guarantees issued by the government are subject to the same six-week reporting requirement.
- The contracting or guaranteeing of external debt, and the occurrence of external arrears, should be immediately reported to IMF staff. (Table 1: "The contracting or guaranteeing of external debt, and the occurrence of external arrears should be immediately reported")

### Other indicative quantitative objectives (as defined in MEFP and TMU)
- Floor on non-oil revenue (paragraph 7) is defined as an indicative objective in Table 1 of the MEFP.
- Ceiling on net accumulations of domestic payment arrears (paragraph 18) is defined as an indicative objective in Table 1 of the MEFP.
- Floor on social expenditure (paragraph 11) is defined as an indicative objective in Table 1 of the MEFP and is monitored regularly.

### Reporting cutoffs for government financial and program monitoring
- Data on the government's financial position (government financial operations table), detailed listing of revenue highlighting oil revenue, domestic payment arrears, and status of social expenditure execution must be reported within six weeks after the end of the month.

### Data submission requirements and periodicity (high-level summary from Table 1)
- Quantitative data on the government's quantitative and indicative objectives will be reported to IMF staff with the periodicity described in Table 1; all data revisions will be reported immediately.
- Government finances (TOFE and customary annex tables): Monthly, reporting lag 6 weeks.
- Domestic budget financing (net bank credit to the government, stock of treasury bills and bonds pending reimbursement, domestic debt reimbursement status, privatization revenue, and abandoned claims): MINFI/BEAC, Monthly, 6 weeks.
- Implementation status of social expenditure defined in Paragraph 11: MINFI, Monthly, 6 weeks.
- Status of balances payable for the current fiscal year (orders unpaid) over/under 90 days: MINFI, Monthly, 6 weeks.
- Domestic debt reimbursement status: MINFI/BEAC, Monthly, 6 weeks.
- Statistics on external debt contracted and guaranteed (detailed listing of external debt service matured/paid, list of new loans specifying the financial conditions, loans guaranteed and external arrears, and list of arrangements in the process of negotiation): MINFI/CAA, Monthly, reporting lag 6 weeks; contracting/guaranteeing of external debt and occurrence of external arrears should be immediately reported.
- Quarterly reconciliation report on monetary statistics and external debt/net external financing: MINFI/BEAC, Quarterly, 8 weeks.
- Data on implementation of the public investment program (including detailed listing of financing sources): MINFI/MINEPAT/CAA, Quarterly, 6 weeks.
- Prices, consumption, and taxation of petroleum products (comprehensive monthly breakdown): MINFI, Monthly, 4 weeks.
- Monthly statement of the correspondent accounts and consignment deposits with the treasury (broken down): MINFI, Monthly, 6 weeks.
- Revenue forecasts and outturn (DGI, DGD, DGTCFM): Monthly, 6 weeks.
- VAT reimbursement balance (requests, payments, status of account): MINFI/DGI, Monthly, 6 weeks.
- Status of the SNH (volumes exported, prices, exchange rates, operating costs, spending advances, commitments to government, balance transferable to the Treasury): MINFI, Monthly, 6 weeks.
- Status of payment of invoices from the government to public enterprises (subsidies and tax liabilities): MINFI, Quarterly, 6 weeks.
- Monetary sector: consolidated balance sheet of monetary institutions (BEAC) Monthly 6 weeks; provisional comprehensive monetary survey BEAC Monthly 6 weeks; final comprehensive monetary survey BEAC Monthly 10 weeks; government net position BEAC Monthly 6 weeks; intervention rate and borrowing and lending interest rates BEAC Monthly 6 weeks.
- Balance of Payments: preliminary annual balance of payments MINFI Annual 9 months; foreign trade statistics MINFI/INS Monthly 3 months; any revision of balance of payments data BEAC/MINFI On revision 2 weeks.
- Real sector: provisional national accounts INS Annual 7 months after year-end; quarterly national accounts INS Quarterly 3 months; disaggregated consumer price indices (Yaoundé and Douala) INS Monthly 2 weeks; quarterly inflation note INS Quarterly 3 months.
- Structural reforms and other data: any official report or study devoted to Cameroon’s economy MINEPAT 2 weeks; any decision, decree, law, order, or circular having economic or financial implications MINFI/MINEPAT 2 weeks.

### Program implementation, recent economic developments, and performance
- Economic growth: 4.5 percent last year; expected to reach 3.7 percent in the current year (due to lower-than-expected oil production).
- Public debt: estimated to be about 31 percent of GDP as of end-September 2017.
- Program performance: All quantitative performance criteria (QPCs) at end-June 2017 and indicative targets (ITs) were met, including the zero ceiling on the accumulation of new external payment arrears. The continuous QPC ceiling on new non-concessional borrowing was exceeded as a loan was advanced to November 2017; authorities proposed to reduce the 2018 budget ceiling to keep overall new non-concessional external borrowing for both years unchanged.
- Structural benchmarks: All but two structural benchmarks met at end-November 2017. Missed benchmarks were modified and rephrased (related to unpaid government obligations, submission to COBAC of a resolution plan for distressed banks, and collection of the land tax).
- Program objectives noted: maintain macroeconomic stability, promote private sector-led growth, reduce poverty; maintain adequate social spending while pursuing fiscal consolidation.

### Policies and reforms going forward (key measures)
- Fiscal consolidation: continue to mobilize more non-oil revenue and reprioritize spending; enhance collection of tax arrears by end-2017 through joint tax controls and investigations; enhance domestic revenue mobilization through greater coordination of revenue agencies.
- Expenditure restraint: curb current spending and some capital outlays; address cash management complications from delays in budget support with adequate Treasury bills issuances and prudent cash flow management; limited and temporary use of statutory advances to be reimbursed by budget support disbursements when available.
- 2018 budget law measures: broaden tax base, rationalize tax expenditures, increases in various airport duty and excise taxes, higher excise duties on gambling activities, and implement efficiency-improving revenue administration measures as laid out in the MEFP.
- Public financial management (PFM) strengthening: build on transposition of 2011 CEMAC PFM guidelines, streamline budget preparation, integrate the Medium-Term Budget Framework with budget laws, publish mid-term budget execution reports, and strengthen public investment management; reduce exceptional procedures, subject investment projects to normal budget procedures, enhance monitoring of fiscal risks linked to state-owned enterprises and PPPs.
- Debt management: pursue prudent debt management to keep public debt on a sustainable path; financing of the 2018 budget balances domestic and external lending with attention to absorptive capacity; most externally financed 2018 projects are road and energy infrastructure.
- Financial sector stability: collaborate with regional supervisor to resolve distressed banks and limit fiscal costs; strengthen plan submitted to COBAC and develop detailed time-bound action plans to clear bad loans; train judges on banking disputes and assign them to main business centers.
- Private sector-led growth and diversification: 2018–20 strategy under GESP pillars—(i) infrastructure development; (ii) modernization of production capacity; (iii) regional integration and trade diversification; (iv) social progress (health, education, gender, social safety nets); (v) employment; and (vi) governance and strategic public management. Planned measures include transportation and energy projects, agro-industries, and further business climate reforms (customs tariffs, land registry, credit registry, VAT credit reimbursement, government processing times, and land reform).

### Selected quantitative figures from Update to Attachment 1, Table 1 (2017–18; Billions of CFA francs, cumulative)
- Floor on the non-oil primary fiscal balance (commitment basis):
  - End-Mar PC: -61; Actual: -392; Status: -307 Met
  - End-Sep IT Prel: -708; Status: -327 Met
  - End-Dec PC: -974; IT Proj: -53; PC Proj: -320; further: -519 -777
- Ceiling on the net domestic financing of the central government excluding IMF financing:
  - End-Mar PC: -73; Actual: -18; End-Sep: -79 Met; End-Dec PC: 78; Actual: -88 Met; projections: -200 -43 -153 -76 5
- Ceiling on net borrowing of the central government from the central bank excluding IMF financing:
  - End-Mar PC: -35; Actual: 0; End-Sep: -61 Met; End-Dec PC: 85; Actual: -4 Met; projections: -253 -304 -403 -316 -376
- Ceiling on the disbursement of non-concessional external debt contracted as of the date of program approval:
  - PC values: 280 205 Met; 540 340 Met; 540 350 350 596 596
- Continuous QPCs:
  - Ceiling on the accumulation of new external payments arrears: 0 0 Met (through projections 0 0 0 0)
  - Ceiling on new non-concessional external debt contracted or guaranteed by the government:
    - PC End-Mar: 100; Actual: 0 Met
    - End-Sep: 100; Actual: 101 Not met
    - Projections: 100 436 436 436 436
- Indicative targets:
  - Floor on non-oil revenue:
    - End-Mar: 599; End-Sep: 1,231 Met; End-Dec: 1,811 1,822 Met; projections: 2,457 689 1,331 1,958 2,616
  - Ceiling on the net accumulation of domestic payment arrears:
    - End-Mar: -115; End-Sep: -97 Met; End-Dec: 0 -171 Met; projections: -57 0 0 0 -146
  - Floor on social spending:
    - End-Mar: 253; End-Sep: 265 Met; End-Dec: 406 417 Met; projections: 624 144 288 460 657
- Memorandum items:
  - Cumulative external budget support, excluding IMF (earliest disbursement): 0 0 0 44 0 337 0 131 131 261
  - New concessional external debt contracted or guaranteed by the government:
    - Values: 3 100 0 100 19 100 152 152 152 152

*Source: IMF staff report extract and tables (Update to Attachment 1, Table 1; TMU; MEFP) as presented in the supplied content.*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/cr/2018/cr1809.pdf_
