## TOWARD A SUSTAINABLE INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS AND FINANCIAL SERVICES SECTOR IN BARBADOS

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [TOWARD A SUSTAINABLE INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS AND FINANCIAL SERVICES SECTOR IN BARBADOS](https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/cr/2018/cr18134-barbadossi.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/files/publications/cr/2018/cr18134-barbadossi.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/files/publications/cr/2018/cr18134-barbadossi.pdf.json)

---

### A. Introduction
- IBFS sector in Barbados:
  - Ranks second to tourism in economic importance.
  - Important source of foreign exchange, tax revenue and employment.
  - Comprises a diversified set of business entities including non-financial sector companies (import-export, real estate, manufacturing, R&D, among others).
  - Tax revenues combined with operational and non-operational expenditure are around 9 percent of GDP.
  - Employs skilled labor accounting for about 3 percent of the labor force.
- Recent developments and challenges:
  - Sector’s contribution to the local economy relatively stable in recent years but contribution to fiscal revenues has declined.
  - Lower profitability since the global financial crisis.
  - Recent changes in Canadian tax legislation adversely affected the sector, contributing to lower tax revenues.
  - Faces risks from the loss of correspondent banking relationships (CBRs) that has affected most Caribbean countries.
- Scope of the review:
  - Reviews literature on offshore centers (OFCs), situates Barbados IBFS in the Caribbean context, describes Barbados IBFS and its contribution, and assesses CBR loss risks and policy recommendations.

### B. The Impact of OFCs on Host Jurisdictions — Key Findings from Literature
- OFC classifications (by sources and uses of funds):
  - Primary centers: serve as hubs for advanced-economy market areas; offer full spectrum of offshore financial services.
  - Booking centers: financial intermediation predominantly between non-residents; attract entities via favorable tax/regulatory regimes.
  - Funding centers: channel offshore funds from outside into local areas.
  - Collection centers: channel funds outside their market area, accumulate net foreign assets.
- Direct benefits:
  - License fees are the most common revenue source but affect only very small host economies.
  - Requirements to hold domestic financial assets via capital and reserve requirements exist in some jurisdictions, but impact is limited.
  - Tax revenues (withholding, profit taxes, income taxes on local employees, stamp duties) have limited impact due to tax competition.
  - Operational and non-operational expenditure (salaries and wages, office rent, administrative expenditures, telecom, auditing/accounting/legal fees) are the largest contributions and are proportional to number of licensed entities.
- Indirect benefits:
  - Higher capital inflows (onshore utilization of offshore funds) and higher FDI.
  - Know-how transfers and development of domestic financial sector expertise and internationalization of domestic banks.
  - Higher economic activity in related industries (insurance, money brokers, merchant banks, investment companies, legal/accounting firms, hotels, printing, telecom).
- Costs and risks:
  - Leakages between onshore and offshore sectors can impair monetary policy, cause inflationary effects, affect domestic economic policy, and cause capital leakage and speculative fund inflows.
  - Reputational costs and contagion risks are high when offshore entities originate from jurisdictions with weak supervision or when host jurisdiction applies weak fit-and-proper licensing tests.
  - Importance of costs relative to benefits depends on monetary policy autonomy and governance standards in licensing/supervision.

### C. The Size and Contribution of OFCs in the Caribbean
- General characteristics:
  - Caribbean OFCs mainly booking centers for intra-group funding and transact predominantly with non-residents.
  - Financial service companies often operate a central treasury model for group liquidity access.
  - OFCs in the region also include non-financial companies choosing Caribbean fiscal domicile for tax reasons.
- Scale and shares:
  - Caribbean OFCs attract around US$3 trillion, or 7 percent of global portfolio inflows.
  - Cayman Islands account for 82 percent of total inflows into the region.
  - As of 2016Q2, Barbados attracted about US$4 billion, or 0.1 percent of regional inflows.
- Relative size to host economies (BOP portfolio liabilities basis):
  - The Bahamas averaged 200 of 2015 GDP.
  - Bermuda: 7,800 percent of respective GDP.
  - Cayman Islands: 58,000 percent of respective GDP.
  - Barbados OFC increased threefold from 30 to 100 percent of 2015 GDP over the same period.
- Comparison with onshore banking:
  - Onshore banking sector in Barbados had assets amounting to 146 percent of 2016 GDP.
- Regional findings (selected):
  - Butkiewicz and Gordon (2013): presence of an OFC had a sizable and positive effect on national income growth across 15 Caribbean island economies.
  - González-Miranda et al. (2013): OFCs contributed about 1 percent of GDP in Antigua and Barbuda, 7.8 percent in Barbados, and 7.4-9.2 percent of GDP in The Bahamas.
  - Britton and Sacks (2007): offshore banking in The Bahamas directly accounts for about 3.5 percent of GDP and over a quarter of total banking sector employment; value added per OFC employee nearly twice that of onshore banks.
  - IMF (2017a): Bahamas offshore banks & trusts provide around 1,000 jobs with average wage about twice the average at domestic banks; in 2016 total wage bill and registration and license fees of offshore banks amounted to about 1.7 and 0.2 percent of GDP, respectively.
  - Suss, Williams, and Mendis (2002): OFC in The Bahamas contributed 2.5 percent of GDP in local expenditure and directly employed almost 1,000 workers at end-2000 (0.7 percent of labor force).

### D. The Barbados IBFS and Its Contribution to the Local Economy
- Composition (Box 1 summary):
  - International Business Companies (IBCs) and International Societies with Restricted Liability (ISRLs): non-banks and insurance companies, many asset managers, financial consultancy firms, import/export companies; several large employers with R&D in capital-intensive industries.
  - Exempt and Qualifying Insurance Companies (EICs and QICs): mainly captive companies; more than 80 percent of captive insurance companies domiciled in Barbados are from the United States and Canada.
  - International Banks (IBs): wholesale banking accounts for some 85 percent of assets of IBs; largest entities act as booking centers for intra-group funding and typically do not raise funds from external third parties; foreign currency lending and associated funding account for only 5 percent of total assets; private banking (wealth management) accounts for the remaining 10 percent.
- Typical IB activities and revenue model:
  - Wholesale banking dominates IBs’ balance sheets.
  - Central treasury model: parent grants branches/subsidiaries access to group global liquidity via Barbados.
  - Industry caters to sophisticated high net worth individuals globally; revenues stem from fee-based income; asset deterioration risks are borne by clients rather than financial institutions.
- Offshore bank activities not important in Barbados (Box 2 notes):
  - Foreign currency lending and associated funding (booked and funded in OFC) — not important in practice in Barbados.
  - Issuance of securities (Eurobonds and structured finance vehicles) — not considered important in Barbados.
  - OTC trading — concentrated in primary centers; not considered important in Barbados.
  - Wealth management — managed by financial institutions, law firms, and specialists but not highlighted as a major IB activity in Barbados.

### E. Drivers of Domicile Choice and Tax Considerations
- Advantages offered by Barbados:
  - Excellent infrastructure, skilled labor, responsive regulatory environment.
  - Tax treaties with the US and Canada (among other countries).
  - Lower operating costs for captives than in many other major domiciles.
  - Ease of incorporation, income tax and exchange control concessions for resident expatriate employees.
  - Limited investment restrictions and confidentiality of financial statements and statutory records including registers of shareholders.
- Importance of tax considerations:
  - Maintaining tax advantages under bilateral tax treaties is an important strategy to attract foreign reserves.
  - Historical examples:
    - Canada-Barbados context: In March 1996 the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) deemed profits of Canadian EICs domiciled in Barbados taxable under Canadian law; Barbados responded by creating the QIC under the Insurance (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act of 1998. A QIC is an EIC with up to 10 percent of premiums originating within CARICOM and is entitled to benefits including exemption from exchange control and a foreign currency tax credit applicable against tax on net income otherwise taxable at 40 percent.
    - 2008 signing and ratification of a tax treaty with Mexico created an opportunity to attract captives from Mexico.
    - Changes in Canadian legislation led the Government of Barbados to reduce applicable tax rates in 2012 to keep the Barbados domicile favorable for Canadian insurers.

### Box 3 — Tax and Regulatory Benefits Enjoyed by IBs in Barbados
- Licensing, governance, and operational requirements:
  - Proposed offshore banks must submit details to the Central Bank of Barbados for approval.
  - Offshore banking licenses are issued to qualified foreign banks by the Central Bank upon the approval of the Minister of Finance.
  - Minimum capital requirements:
    - US$2 million for banks which accept 3rd party deposits.
    - US$0.5 million for banks which do not accept 3rd party deposits.
  - Corporate governance and local presence requirements:
    - At least one of the directors must be a Barbadian resident.
    - An annual shareholder meeting must be held.
    - The bank's accounting records, minutes and resolutions must be maintained at the local office.
  - Offshore banks are subject to annual audits and license fees.
- Taxation and exchange control provisions:
  - Income tax is applied on a sliding scale of 0.25-2.5 percent.
  - The Offshore Banking Act provides that dividends, royalties, interest, foreign securities funds, gains and assets generated or managed by a licensee are automatically exempt from the provisions of the Exchange Control Act.
- Summary of benefits for international banks (IBs) in Barbados:
  - Tax at the rate of 0.25 percent (on profits over US$15 million) and up to 2.5 percent (on profits up to US$5 million)
  - No direct tax or capital gains
  - No withholding tax on interest, dividends, royalties or fees
  - No exchange control on foreign currencies
  - Income tax concessions for qualified foreign employees
  - Privacy protection via provisions for strong confidentiality

### Annex I — Recent Global Trends in Correspondent Bank Relationships (CBR)
- Role of CBR:
  - Bilateral cross border arrangements between banks, typically through SWIFT, for exchange of messages associated with payments, trade finance, FX, and securities transactions.
  - Linking a country’s payment system to the rest of the world; enables international trade and BoP flows.
- Global trends since the global financial crisis:
  - Global banks have selectively withdrawn from CBR with direct impact on only a limited number of countries.
  - During 2012-15, CBR withdrawal varied significantly across countries; no clear trend detected (CPMI 2016).
  - Over 2012-15: number of active correspondent banks and value of transactions decreased while transaction volume increased (IMF 2016a).
  - Between 2015-16, IMF staff reports found the issue macro-critical in the Caribbean, small islands of the Pacific, the MENA region, Central Asia and Africa.
- Macroeconomic and financial channels of impact:
  - Disruption of financial services and cross-border flows, including trade finance and remittances.
  - Potential undermining of financial stability, inclusion, growth, and development goals.
  - Reduced availability of banks’ funding from foreign sources and diminished ability to provide foreign currency loans for trade finance and/or service foreign currency–denominated debt.
  - In extreme cases, loss of CBR by a central bank would compromise its capacity to manage foreign reserves.
- Remittances and CBR withdrawal:
  - In 2015, estimated remittances amounted to US$580 billion.
  - Only 1 percent of world remittances reach the Caribbean, mainly from the US, Euro Area, and Canada.
  - Remittances represent more than 15 percent of respective GDP for Jamaica, Haiti and Bermuda.
  - For the ECCU countries and other jurisdictions around the Gulf of Mexico, remittances represent between 0 and 5 percent of respective GDP.
  - In Barbados, risk of withdrawal of CBRs has not been associated with changes in remittances, which have remained practically constant in recent years at around 2.5 percent of GDP.
- Selected country impacts and quantification examples:
  - The Bahamas: Six institutions, representing about 19 percent of domestic banking system assets, have recently lost CBRs.
  - Belize: Only 2 of the 10 domestic and international banks have CBRs with full banking services. The Central Bank of Belize lost three CBRs.
  - Liberia: All commercial banks have lost at least one CBR in the last 3 years, with the most affected losing about 78 percent of their CBR accounts.
  - Panama: Total number of CBRs remained stable at 463–464 between March 2015 and End-February 2016 (62 relationships were lost, but Panamanian banks managed to establish 63 new relationships).
  - Sudan: Sudan lost almost half of its CBRs between 2012 and 2015.
  - Adverse impact reported for Belize, Liberia, and Sudan.
  - No significant/moderate impact reported for The Bahamas, Barbados, Costa Rica, Grenada, Guatemala, St. Lucia, Tonga, El Salvador, Guyana, Jamaica, Panama, Saudi Arabia, Solomon Islands, Sri Lanka, and St. Vincent and the Grenadines.

### Key Statistics and Exact Figures
- Tax revenues combined with operational and non-operational expenditure: around 9 percent of GDP.
- IBFS sector employment: about 3 percent of the labor force.
- Caribbean OFCs attract around US$3 trillion, or 7 percent of global portfolio inflows.
- Cayman Islands share of regional inflows: 82 percent.
- Barbados attracted about US$4 billion as of 2016Q2, or 0.1 percent of regional inflows.
- OFC size relative to GDP (examples):
  - The Bahamas: averaged 200 of 2015 GDP.
  - Bermuda: 7,800 percent of GDP.
  - Cayman Islands: 58,000 percent of GDP.
  - Barbados OFC increased from 30 to 100 percent of 2015 GDP over 10 years.
- Onshore banking assets in Barbados: 146 percent of 2016 GDP.
- IBs asset composition:
  - Wholesale banking: some 85 percent of assets.
  - Foreign currency lending and associated funding: 5 percent of total assets.
  - Private banking (wealth management): 10 percent of total assets.
- QIC tax context: foreign currency tax credit can be applied against tax on net income otherwise taxable at 40 percent.
- Captive insurance composition: more than 80 percent of captive insurance companies domiciled in Barbados are from the United States and Canada.
- IMF publication date on document header: January 11, 2018.

*International Monetary Fund — BARBADOS: TOWARD A SUSTAINABLE INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS AND FINANCIAL SERVICES SECTOR IN BARBADOS (January 11, 2018).*

### References ____________________________________________________________________________ 15

### TOWARD A SUSTAINABLE INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS AND FINANCIAL SERVICES SECTOR IN BARBADOS

### A. Introduction
- The International Business and Financial Services (IBFS) sector in Barbados:
  - Ranks second to tourism in economic importance.
  - Is an important source of foreign exchange, tax revenue and employment.
  - Comprises a diversified set of business entities including non-financial sector companies (import-export, real estate, manufacturing, R&D, among others).
  - Tax revenues combined with operational and non-operational expenditure are around 9 percent of GDP.
  - Employs skilled labor accounting for about 3 percent of the labor force.
- Recent developments and challenges:
  - The sector’s contribution to the local economy has been relatively stable in recent years but its contribution to fiscal revenues has declined.
  - The sector has displayed lower profitability since the global financial crisis.
  - Recent changes in Canadian tax legislation adversely affected the sector, contributing to lower tax revenues.
  - The sector faces risks from the loss of correspondent banking relationships (CBRs) that has affected most Caribbean countries.
- Note scope:
  - Reviews literature on offshore centers (OFCs), situates Barbados IBFS in the Caribbean context, describes Barbados IBFS and its contribution, and assesses CBR loss risks and policy recommendations.

### B. The Impact of OFCs on Host Jurisdictions — Key Findings from Literature
- OFC classifications (by sources and uses of funds):
  - Primary centers: serve as hubs for advanced-economy market areas; offer full spectrum of offshore financial services.
  - Booking centers: financial intermediation predominantly between non-residents; attract entities via favorable tax/regulatory regimes.
  - Funding centers: channel offshore funds from outside into local areas.
  - Collection centers: channel funds outside their market area, accumulate net foreign assets.
- Direct benefits of OFCs:
  - License fees are the most common revenue source but affect only very small host economies.
  - Some jurisdictions require offshore entities to hold domestic financial assets via capital and reserve requirements, but impact is limited.
  - Tax revenues (withholding, profit taxes, income taxes on local employees, stamp duties) have limited impact due to tax competition.
  - Operational and non-operational expenditure (salaries and wages, office rent, administrative expenditures, telecom, auditing/accounting/legal fees) are the largest contributions to host economies and are proportional to number of licensed entities.
- Indirect benefits:
  - Higher capital inflows (onshore utilization of offshore funds) and higher FDI.
  - Know-how transfers and development of domestic financial sector expertise and internationalization of domestic banks.
  - Higher economic activity in related industries (insurance, money brokers, merchant banks, investment companies, legal/accounting firms, hotels, printing, telecom).
- Costs and risks:
  - Leakages between onshore and offshore sectors can impair monetary policy, cause inflationary effects, affect domestic economic policy, and cause capital leakage and speculative fund inflows.
  - Reputational costs and contagion risks are high when offshore entities originate from jurisdictions with weak supervision or when host jurisdiction applies weak fit-and-proper licensing tests.
  - Importance of costs relative to benefits depends on monetary policy autonomy and governance standards in licensing/supervision.

### C. The Size and Contribution of OFCs in the Caribbean
- General characteristics:
  - Caribbean OFCs are mainly booking centers for intra-group funding and transact predominantly with non-residents.
  - Financial service companies often operate a central treasury model for group liquidity access.
  - OFCs in the region also include non-financial companies choosing Caribbean fiscal domicile for tax reasons.
- Scale and shares:
  - OFCs in the Caribbean attract around US$3 trillion, or 7 percent of global portfolio inflows.
  - The Cayman Islands account for 82 percent of total inflows into the region.
  - As of 2016Q2, Barbados attracted about US$4 billion, or 0.1 percent of regional inflows.
- Relative size to host economies:
  - Over the last 10 years, OFC size measured by BOP portfolio liabilities:
    - The Bahamas averaged 200 of 2015 GDP.
    - Bermuda: 7,800 percent of respective GDP.
    - Cayman Islands: 58,000 percent of respective GDP.
  - The OFC in Barbados increased threefold from 30 to 100 percent of 2015 GDP over the same period.
  - The onshore banking sector in Barbados had assets amounting to 146 percent of 2016 GDP (comparison point).
- Regional economic contributions (selected findings):
  - Butkiewicz and Gordon (2013): presence of an OFC had a sizable and positive effect on national income growth across 15 Caribbean island economies.
  - González-Miranda et al. (2013): OFCs contributed about 1 percent of GDP in Antigua and Barbuda, 7.8 percent in Barbados, and 7.4-9.2 percent of GDP in The Bahamas.
  - Britton and Sacks (2007): offshore banking in The Bahamas directly accounts for about 3.5 percent of GDP and over a quarter of total banking sector employment; value added per OFC employee nearly twice that of onshore banks.
  - IMF (2017a): Bahamas offshore banks & trusts provide around 1,000 jobs with average wage about twice the average at domestic banks; in 2016 total wage bill and registration and license fees of offshore banks amounted to about 1.7 and 0.2 percent of GDP, respectively.
  - Suss, Williams, and Mendis (2002): OFC in The Bahamas contributed 2.5 percent of GDP in local expenditure and directly employed almost 1,000 workers at end-2000 (0.7 percent of labor force).

### D. The Barbados IBFS and Its Contribution to the Local Economy
- Composition of Barbados IBFS (Box 1 summary):
  - International Business Companies (IBCs) and International Societies with Restricted Liability (ISRLs): non-banks and insurance companies, many asset managers, financial consultancy firms, import/export companies; several large employers with R&D in capital-intensive industries.
  - Exempt and Qualifying Insurance Companies (EICs and QICs): mainly captive companies; more than 80 percent of captive insurance companies domiciled in Barbados are from the United States and Canada.
  - International Banks (IBs): wholesale banking accounts for some 85 percent of assets of IBs; largest entities act as booking centers for intra-group funding and typically do not raise funds from external third parties; foreign currency lending and associated funding account for only 5 percent of total assets; private banking (wealth management) accounts for the remaining 10 percent.
- Typical IB activities and revenue model:
  - Wholesale banking dominates IBs’ balance sheets.
  - Central treasury model: parent grants branches/subsidiaries access to group global liquidity via Barbados.
  - Industry caters to sophisticated high net worth individuals globally; revenues stem from fee-based income; asset deterioration risks are borne by clients rather than financial institutions.
- Box 2 — Typical Financial Services Provided by Offshore Banks (key activities noted as not important in Barbados in practice):
  - Foreign currency lending and associated funding (booked and funded in OFC).
  - Issuance of securities (Eurobonds and structured finance vehicles), though issuance is not considered important in Barbados.
  - OTC trading (concentrated in primary centers; not considered an important activity in Barbados).
  - Wealth management (use of trusts and other forms; managed by financial institutions, law firms, and specialists).

### E. Drivers of Domicile Choice and Tax Considerations
- Advantages Barbados offers to international companies:
  - Excellent infrastructure, skilled labor, responsive regulatory environment.
  - Tax treaties with the US and Canada (among other countries).
  - Lower operating costs for captives than in many other major domiciles.
  - Ease of incorporation, income tax and exchange control concessions for resident expatriate employees.
  - Limited investment restrictions and confidentiality of financial statements and statutory records including registers of shareholders.
- Tax considerations are critical in domicile choice:
  - Maintaining tax advantages under bilateral tax treaties is an important strategy to attract foreign reserves.
  - Examples:
    - Historically, Barbados was a domicile of choice for Canadian captive insurance companies and banks to generate tax exempt surplus from non-Canadian business. In March 1996 the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) deemed profits of Canadian EICs domiciled in Barbados taxable under Canadian law; Barbados responded by creating the QIC under the Insurance (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act of 1998. A QIC is an EIC with up to 10 percent of premiums originating within CARICOM and is entitled to benefits including exemption from exchange control and a foreign currency tax credit applicable against tax on net income otherwise taxable at 40 percent.
    - In 2008, signing and ratification of a tax treaty with Mexico created an opportunity to attract captives from Mexico.
    - Changes in Canadian legislation led the Government of Barbados to reduce applicable tax rates in 2012 to keep the Barbados domicile favorable for Canadian insurers.

### Key Statistics and Exact Figures (as presented)
- Tax revenues combined with operational and non-operational expenditure: around 9 percent of GDP.
- IBFS sector employment: about 3 percent of the labor force.
- Caribbean OFCs attract around US$3 trillion, or 7 percent of global portfolio inflows.
- Cayman Islands share of regional inflows: 82 percent.
- Barbados attracted about US$4 billion as of 2016Q2, or 0.1 percent of regional inflows.
- OFC size relative to GDP (examples):
  - The Bahamas: averaged 200 of 2015 GDP.
  - Bermuda: 7,800 percent of GDP.
  - Cayman Islands: 58,000 percent of GDP.
  - Barbados OFC increased from 30 to 100 percent of 2015 GDP over 10 years.
- Onshore banking assets in Barbados: 146 percent of 2016 GDP.
- IBs asset composition:
  - Wholesale banking: some 85 percent of assets.
  - Foreign currency lending and associated funding: 5 percent of total assets.
  - Private banking (wealth management): 10 percent of total assets.
- QIC tax context: foreign currency tax credit can be applied against tax on net income otherwise taxable at 40 percent.
- Captive insurance composition: more than 80 percent of captive insurance companies domiciled in Barbados are from the United States and Canada.
- IMF publication date on document header: January 11, 2018.

*International Monetary Fund — BARBADOS: TOWARD A SUSTAINABLE INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS AND FINANCIAL SERVICES SECTOR IN BARBADOS (January 11, 2018).*

### Box 3. Tax and Regulatory Benefits Enjoyed by IBs in Barbados

### Box 3. Tax and Regulatory Benefits Enjoyed by IBs in Barbados

### Licensing, governance, and operational requirements
- Proposed offshore banks must submit details to the Central Bank of Barbados for approval.
- Offshore banking licenses are issued to qualified foreign banks by the Central Bank upon the approval of the Minister of Finance.
- Minimum capital requirements:
  - US$2 million for banks which accept 3rd party deposits.
  - US$0.5 million for banks which do not accept 3rd party deposits.
- Corporate governance and local presence requirements:
  - At least one of the directors must be a Barbadian resident.
  - An annual shareholder meeting must be held.
  - The bank's accounting records, minutes and resolutions must be maintained at the local office.
- Offshore banks are subject to annual audits and license fees.

### Taxation and exchange control provisions
- Income tax is applied on a sliding scale of 0.25-2.5 percent.
- The Offshore Banking Act provides that dividends, royalties, interest, foreign securities funds, gains and assets generated or managed by a licensee are automatically exempt from the provisions of the Exchange Control Act.

### Summary of benefits for international banks (IBs) in Barbados
- Tax at the rate of 0.25 percent (on profits over US$15 million) and up to 2.5 percent (on profits up to US$5 million)
- No direct tax or capital gains
- No withholding tax on interest, dividends, royalties or fees
- No exchange control on foreign currencies
- Income tax concessions for qualified foreign employees
- Privacy protection via provisions for strong confidentiality

*Source: cr18134-barbadossi - Box 3. Tax and Regulatory Benefits Enjoyed by IBs in Barbados*

### Annex I. Recent Global Trends in Correspondent Bank Relationships

### Annex I. Recent Global Trends in Correspondent Bank Relationships

### Role of Correspondent Bank Relationships (CBR)
- CBR arrangements involve bilateral cross border arrangements between banks, typically through the Society for Worldwide Interbank Financial Telecommunication (SWIFT) network, for the exchange of messages that could be associated with payments, trade finance, FX, and securities transactions.
- By linking a country’s payment system to the rest of the world, CBR enables international trade and BoP flows.

### Global trends since the global financial crisis
- Since the global financial crisis, global banks have selectively withdrawn from CBR with direct impact on only a limited number of countries.
- During 2012-15, CBR withdrawal varied significantly across countries; no clear trend has been detected (CPMI 2016).
- Over 2012-15: the number of active correspondent banks, as well as the value of transactions decreased while the volume of transactions increased (IMF 2016a).
- Between 2015-16, IMF staff reports found the issue macro-critical in the Caribbean, small islands of the Pacific, the MENA region, Central Asia and Africa.

### Macroeconomic and financial channels of impact
- CBR withdrawal could affect domestic economies through multiple macro financial channels:
  - Disruption of financial services and cross-border flows, including trade finance and remittances.
  - Potential undermining of financial stability, inclusion, growth, and development goals.
  - Reduced availability of banks’ funding from foreign sources and diminished ability to provide foreign currency loans for trade finance and/or service foreign currency–denominated debt, compounding existing bank vulnerabilities.
  - In extreme cases, loss of CBR by a central bank would compromise its capacity to manage foreign reserves.

### Remittances and CBR withdrawal
- In 2015, estimated remittances amounted to US$580 billion and were concentrated in a few corridors such as US, Euro Area, Saudi Arabia, UAE, Hong Kong and Australia.
- Only 1 percent of world remittances reach the Caribbean, mainly from the US, Euro Area, and Canada.
- While absolute amounts are small, remittances represent a large share of GDP in select countries:
  - For Jamaica, Haiti and Bermuda remittances are more than 15 percent of respective GDP.
  - For the ECCU countries and other jurisdictions around the Gulf of Mexico, remittances represent between 0 and 5 percent of respective GDP.
- In Barbados, the risk of withdrawal of CBRs has not been associated with changes in remittances, which have remained practically constant in recent years at around 2.5 percent of GDP.

### Selected country impacts and quantification examples (as reported)
- The Bahamas: Six institutions, representing about 19 percent of domestic banking system assets, have recently lost CBRs.
- Belize: Only 2 of the 10 domestic and international banks have CBRs with full banking services. The Central Bank of Belize lost three CBRs.
- Liberia: All commercial banks have lost at least one CBR in the last 3 years, with the most affected losing about 78 percent of their CBR accounts.
- Panama: The total number of CBRs remained stable at 463–464 between March 2015 and End-February 2016 (62 relationships were lost, but Panamanian banks managed to establish 63 new relationships).
- Sudan: Sudan lost almost half of its CBRs between 2012 and 2015.
- Adverse Impact reported for Belize, Liberia, and Sudan.
- No significant/moderate impact reported for The Bahamas, Barbados, Costa Rica, Grenada, Guatemala, St. Lucia, Tonga, El Salvador, Guyana, Jamaica, Panama, Saudi Arabia, Solomon Islands, Sri Lanka, and St. Vincent and the Grenadines.

*Source: IMF (text and staff calculations as presented in the Annex).*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/cr/2018/cr18134-barbadossi.pdf_
