## cr1825 - Executive Summary

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [cr1825 - Executive Summary](https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/cr/2018/cr1825.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/files/publications/cr/2018/cr1825.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/files/publications/cr/2018/cr1825.pdf.json)

---

### Executive summary and mission scope
- TA mission on GFS conducted by Mr. Léonard Haakman visited Sarajevo, Bosnia and Herzegovina, during April 24–28, 2017.
- Mission part of second phase of the SECO GFS capacity building project and a follow-up of previous TA missions during the period 2015–17.
- Main objective: assist the Central Bank of Bosnia and Herzegovina (CBBH) with compilation of GFS in accordance with GFSM 2014 and ESA 2010.

### Key findings
- The mission reviewed the full chart of accounts (COA) of the Federation of Bosnia and Herzegovina and its bridging to ESA 2010; review coordinated with IMF long-term expert Mr. Deon Tanzer.
- Some items in the COA of the Federation of Bosnia and Herzegovina need clarification by the CBBH in cooperation with the Federation of Bosnia and Herzegovina Ministry of Finance to assign correct ESA 2010 codes; this may also affect current GFSM 2014 codes.
- Data compilation for the IMF-World Bank Quarterly Public Sector Debt (QPSD) statistics database has been completed by the CBBH for the time series 2007:Q1–2016:Q4.
- The mission agreed on the method to estimate missing quarterly data, suggested minor adjustments, and advised the CBBH to provide explanations on variables estimated when transmitting QPSD data to the World Bank.
- The mission sees nothing hampering regular data transmission to the World Bank; transmission can proceed when CBBH senior management approves.
- The mission encourages better understanding by the CBBH of the specific accounting standards used by the Federation of Bosnia and Herzegovina and improved cooperation between the Federation Ministry of Finance and the CBBH.
- The mission provided feedback on the recording of interest and other issues such as consolidation of general government data; progress noted in reducing the unexplained discrepancy in the EDP Table 3 (stock-flow adjustments to Maastricht debt) compared to the March 2016 TA mission.

### Follow-up actions identified for the CBBH
- Examine budget items in the COA for which no unique GFS code could be assigned during the mission.
- Review the draft bridging tables to ESA 2010 codes discussed during the mission and check consistency with GFSM 2014 codes.
- Seek high-level management approval to transmit QPSD statistics data to the World Bank.

### Accounting and statistical systems — institutional and accounting features
- Bosnia and Herzegovina structure:
  - Two entities: Federation of Bosnia and Herzegovina and Republic of Srpska.
  - Federation subdivided into cantons and municipalities and cities.
  - High degree of autonomy for the two entities; many government tasks are at entity and cantonal levels.
  - Budget shares: national level (Bosnia and Herzegovina institutions) about 10 percent; Federation of Bosnia and Herzegovina, 60 percent; Republic of Srpska, 30 percent.
- Federation accounting standards and COA features:
  - All government entities within the Federation use the same accounting standards.
  - Accounting base for expenditure: (modified) accrual; exception: interest recorded on a cash basis.
  - Depreciation of fixed assets (consumption of fixed capital in ESA 2010 and GFSM 2014) is not recorded.
  - Revenues are recorded on a cash basis.
  - All government entities share the same COA; some COA items apply only to specific entities (and are nil elsewhere).
  - COA uses a 7-digit coding system with about more than 1,400 individual items divided into 10 classes:
    - Class 0: stocks of fixed assets;
    - Class 1: stocks of current assets;
    - Class 2: inventories;
    - Class 3: stocks of short-term liabilities;
    - Class 4: stocks of long-term liabilities;
    - Class 5: reserves;
    - Class 6: expenses;
    - Class 7: revenues;
    - Class 8: transactions in assets and liabilities;
    - Class 9: commitments/ contingent liabilities.
  - COA data provided in six columns: two represent increases and decreases and four relate to opening and closing stocks of assets or liabilities (if applicable).
  - Mission constructed a balance sheet based on the COA where the class of stocks of fixed assets, currents assets, reserves, expenses, and capital transactions equal the sum of stocks for long-term liabilities, short-term liabilities, and revenues; increase minus decrease for every class equals the change in stocks. The balance sheet for 2016 is shown in Appendix II.
  - No complete balance sheet based on the COA is published for the Federation to the knowledge of the CBBH; no published comprehensive revenues and expenditures based on the COA.
  - No memorandum of understanding exists between the ministries of finance (the statistical institutes) and the CBBH regarding compilation of GFS.

### Chart of Accounts and bridge tables — review and issues
- Mission reviewed Classes 0–8 line by line for the Federation COA; Classes 5 and 9 deemed not relevant for GFS though:
  - Class 5 may be analyzed for producing derivation tables and reconciliation.
  - Class 9 may be relevant for compiling memorandum items related to contingent liabilities in accordance with the Public Sector Debt Statistics—Guide for Compilers and Users (paragraphs 4.03–4.26).
- EU reporting context:
  - Member states must disseminate data on contingent liabilities according to Directive 2011/85/EU.
  - MGDD Chapter VII.4 provides guidelines for cases when debt guarantees should be directly recorded as government debt.
- Consolidation differences and recommendations:
  - Consolidation of nonfinancial accounts in ESA 2010 differs from GFSM 2014:
    - ESA 2010 consolidation only eliminates transactions between government entities for property income (D.4), other current transfers (D.73) and capital transfers (D.9 excluding capital taxes).
    - GFSM 2014 (paragraphs 3.152–3.162) recommends consolidation for almost all transaction categories.
  - In financial accounts, all transaction categories should be consolidated in both ESA 2010 and GFSM 2014.
  - Mission advised including counterparty sector codes in bridge tables for transactions where ESA 2010 consolidation is required; counterparty information is useful for sector accounts and other macro-economic statistics.
  - CBBH noted transfers from paying government entities may not match amounts recorded by receiving entities; large differences need close cooperation and examination; for smaller amounts standard approaches or assumptions may be used with reliable data and adjusted counterparty sector data.
  - Verify adjustments do not create statistical discrepancies between above-the-line and below-the-line transactions.
- COA coding and documentation:
  - Mission proposed ESA 2010 coding based on COA descriptions and identified issues needing further analysis.
  - COA includes several correction items usually coded by 9; often zero but need examination when amounts appear.
  - CBBH lacks a comprehensive handbook with extensive descriptions of all COA codes; mission recommends the Federation Ministry of Finance share internal coding instructions or produce a handbook if none exists.

### Revenues (Class 7) — classification issues and recording
- Class 7 corresponds to revenues but may contain entries that should be recorded as negative expenditures (e.g., disposal of gross fixed capital formation or land).
- Taxes and social contributions:
  - Further discussed after March 2016 TA mission and EU Instrument for Pre-Accession Assistance Pilot Project 3 in March 2017.
  - Few changes to the bridging to ESA 2010 from March 2016; major change concerns current transfers between social security funds which regard employers’ actual social contributions (D.121) rather than current transfers within general government; mission confirmed this is appropriate.
- Production and inventories:
  - ESA 2010 uses the concept of production rather than sales; production includes sales and goods produced but not sold or added to inventories. Recording of transactions related to inventories may require further checking.
- Output produced for own final use (P.12, ESA 2010 3.20–22):
  - ESA 2010 requires recording on a gross basis: production of investment goods for own final use should be recorded as gross fixed capital formation (P.51g) and related costs (compensation of employees and intermediate consumption) recorded as well; revenues should be recorded to balance the double recording.
  - This differs from GFSM 2014 where only gross fixed capital formation is booked and not concomitant costs.
  - The COA does not provide information to estimate output produced for own final use.
- Licenses, permits, and fees:
  - COA contains many entries related to proceeds from use of natural resources, permits, and administrative fees.
  - Some items may be classified as taxes if licenses are granted automatically (see ESA 2010 4.23e); if payments are for regulated services and not in excess of the service granted, they should be recorded as payments for non-market output (P.131).
  - ESA 2010 Chapter 15 (contracts, leases, and licenses) and Tables 15.3 and 15.4 are useful for recording permits to use natural resources and permits for specific activities.
- Dividends:
  - Dividends should exclude superdividends (dividends disproportionally large relative to recent levels of earnings and dividends) per GFSM 2014 paragraph 5.111.
  - MGDD (Chapter III.5) provides stricter guidelines for recording superdividends.

### Expenditures (Class 6) — classification and borderline cases
- Expenses are recorded under Class 6; some expenditures are recorded as revenues such as disposal of gross fixed capital formation or land.
- Borderline cases:
  - Distinguishing between compensation of employees and intermediate consumption discussed.
  - Expenditures by employees during duties and compensated by government (e.g., business travel costs) should be seen as intermediate consumption.
  - Compensation for food or free food should be recorded as wages (in kind).

### Compensation of employees: exclusions and related records
- Wages and salaries, part of compensation of employees, should exclude payments to employees that are not related to work done such as family allowances, payments to workers absent from work, and severance payments to workers who lose their job.
- These excluded payments should be recorded as other social insurance benefits (D.622).
- They give rise to employers’ imputed social contributions recorded as D.122 expenditures and D.612 revenues.
- Although the imputed social contributions should be based on actuarial calculations, they may also be roughly estimated to equal D.622 (ESA 2010 4.10).

### Interest recording and treatment
- Interest in the COA is recorded on a cash basis; previous TA missions advised recording interest on an accrual basis.
- For loans:
  - Interest accrued but not yet paid should be recorded as expenses, with a simultaneous recording of a transaction with the same amount in loans (double entry bookkeeping).
  - When interest is paid, it leads to a negative transaction in loans (and a decrease of deposits).
- For debt securities:
  - Premium and discount are considered as interest under GFSM 2014 and ESA 2010 and should be spread over the lifetime of the security.
- Conceptual note:
  - Concepts of interest in GFSM 2014 and ESA 2010 are not equivalent.
  - For interest on loans paid to banks and interest on deposits received from banks, part of the interest should be recorded as a payment for a financial intermediation service indirectly measured (FISIM).
- Implementation progress and specific interest items:
  - The CBBH reduced the unexplained residual in the reconciliation for EDP Table 3 to only 3 million Bosnian convertible marka.
  - Penalty interest related to early redemption of loans:
    - MGDD, Chapter II.4 paragraph 50 indicates penalty interest should be recorded as interest (D.41) or holding gains/losses (no revenues/expenses transaction) depending on fee features.
    - An alternate recording of penalty interest is under discussion in a Task Force led by Eurostat.

### Classification guidance for transfers and subsidies
- For transactions possibly classifiable as other current transfers, subsidies, or capital transfers:
  - First check if the transaction satisfies the features of capital transfers.
  - If not capital, check whether it should be classified as subsidies or other current transfers n.e.c.
  - If the beneficiary is a market producer, record as subsidies (D.3).
  - If the beneficiary is a non-market producer, record as other current transfer (D.75).
  - Only if a specific subsidy scheme is open to both market and non-market producers may one record subsidies for non-market producers (ESA 2010 4.36).
- Need for institutional sector classifications:
  - Proper classification requires access to statistical business registers containing classifications to institutional sectors according to ESA 2010.
  - Statistical institutes in Bosnia and Herzegovina have been working on a sectorization project, but a list with government entities has not yet been published.

### Financial transactions (Class 8) and related issues
- Financial transactions are recorded under Class 8, including capital transactions related to nonfinancial assets (produced assets P.5 or non-produced assets NP).
- CBBH cannot yet reconcile all financial transactions with banking statistics; banking statistics are considered more reliable and are used for deposits.
- Short-term vs long-term distinction:
  - During the mission the breakdown into short-term and long-term was unclear; some short-term assets and liabilities were in fact long-term.
- Promissory notes and liabilities related to frozen deposits and war claims:
  - Promissory notes must be recorded as debt securities (F.3) (see ESA 2010 5.96 or GFSM 2014 7.144 and 7.225).
- Long-term trade credits:
  - Recording under ESA 2010 is unclear and under discussion in a Eurostat Task Force.
  - ESA 2010 5.239 distinguishes short-term and long-term trade credits; ESA 2010 20.132 stipulates long-term credits be recorded as loans.
  - Eurostat’s interpretation: paragraph 20.132 is specific guidance applicable only to government entities; mission recommends recording long-term trade credits as loans.
  - Distinction matters because loans are included in Maastricht debt whereas trade credits are not.
- Capital injections into public entities:
  - CBBH should verify whether such injections are financial transactions (equity F.5 or sometimes loans F.4) with an expected return or capital transfers (D.99).
  - Apply the capital injection test as presented in page 172 of the MGDD.

### Derivation tables and reconciliation process
- CBBH started work on derivation tables for Table 2 of the EDP transmission.
- CBBH will take the balance of revenues and expenses reported in the COA (Classes 6 and 7) as the national working balance and list adjustments to arrive at net lending / net borrowing according to ESA 2010.
- Due to other priorities, further work on derivation tables will continue as of August 2017.
- Building blocks for EDP Table 2 for the Federation of Bosnia and Herzegovina are available:
  - COA has separate columns for increases and decreases, aiding compilation of EDP Table 2.
  - Important adjustment is accrual adjustments for interest produced in the context of EDP Table 3.
- Reconciliation of flows and stocks:
  - Mission suggested reconciling transactions in Class 9 with changes in stock in Classes 0, 1, 3, and 4.
  - CBBH uses indirect data sources for financial transactions and balance sheets.

### Quarterly Public Sector Debt (QPSD) statistics
- CBBH compiles QPSD statistics using methods similar to financial accounts and balance sheets: partially indirect data sources (monetary statistics for domestic debt and securities) and direct sources (external debt).
- Data on other accounts payable are not available quarterly and are estimated by interpolating and extrapolating annual data.
- CBBH uses estimation procedures to break down quarterly general government debt to central government debt and budgetary central government; indirect sources lack subsector detail.
- Mission agreed on method to estimate missing quarterly data and suggested minor adjustments.
- CBBH can compile QPSD statistics for the period 2007–16 and provide QPSD statistics for the last quarter within the World Bank deadline.
- The mission recommends including an explanation of estimation procedures when transmitting data to the World Bank.
- Senior management approval at CBBH is still needed for regular transmission of QPSD statistics to the World Bank; mission considers no serious issues justify delay.

### Conclusions and recommendations (summary)
- Clarify COA items with Federation Ministry of Finance to assign correct ESA 2010 and GFSM 2014 codes.
- Improve documentation: obtain or produce a comprehensive COA handbook or internal coding instructions.
- Strengthen cooperation and communication between CBBH and ministries of finance/statistical institutes for coding queries and data needs.
- Finalize and transmit QPSD data for 2007:Q1–2016:Q4 to the World Bank after senior management approval, documenting estimations made for missing quarterly data.
- Design reconciliation process and derivation tables for entity ledger data to enhance GFS quality and to derive net lending / net borrowing consistent with ESA 2010 and GFSM 2014.
- Examine correction items (coded by 9) and entries that appear in revenues but are negative expenditures.
- Ensure consolidation and counterparty coding in bridge tables are aligned with ESA 2010 and GFSM 2014 requirements to avoid statistical discrepancies.
- Address recording of interest and continue work to reduce discrepancies in EDP Table 3.
- CBBH indicated it would welcome further GFS TA in the autumn of 2017 to assist with derivation tables and to provide an ESA 2010 course for ministries of finance, statistical institutes, and CBBH staff.

### Key figures from Appendix II: Balance Sheet based on the COA (selected entries)
- Fixed Assets:
  - Opening: 1,282,870
  - Closing: 1,113,130
  - Increase: 942,663
  - Decrease: 1,112,403
- Long-term:
  - Opening: 6,389,414
  - Closing: 6,315,266
  - Increase: 1,372,475
  - Decrease: 1,446,623
- Current Assets:
  - Opening: 319,339
  - Closing: 402,209
- Short-term:
  - Opening: 507,651
  - Closing: 517,830
  - Increase: 3,260,788
  - Decrease: 3,250,609
- Reserves:
  - Opening/Closing figures shown: 5,294,856 and 5,402,725
  - Increase: 892,215
  - Decrease: 784,346
- Expenses (Class 6):
  - Opening/Closing: 1,378,910 and 1,392,608
  - Increase/Decrease: 13,698
- Revenues (Class 7):
  - Opening/Closing: 1,810,652 and 1,868,887
  - Increase/Decrease: 58,235
- Capital transactions (Class 8):
  - Opening/Closing related entries: 346,773 and 910,882
  - Change: 564,109
- Aggregate stock/flow entries shown:
  - 6,897,065   8,643,748
  - 12,890,730   11,144,047
  - 6,897,065   8,643,748
  - 6,502,151   4,755,468
- Inventories:
  - Increase/Decrease: 25,361
- Commitments:
  - Opening/Closing: 6,512,190 and 6,512,190

*Source: cr1825 - Executive Summary (IMF TA mission report, April 24–28, 2017).*

### Executive Summary ......................................................................................................

### cr1825 - Executive Summary

### Executive summary and mission scope
- TA mission on GFS conducted by Mr. Léonard Haakman visited Sarajevo, Bosnia and Herzegovina, during April 24–28, 2017.
- Mission part of second phase of the SECO GFS capacity building project and a follow-up of previous TA missions during the period 2015–17.
- Main objective: assist the Central Bank of Bosnia and Herzegovina (CBBH) with compilation of GFS in accordance with GFSM 2014 and ESA 2010.

### Key findings
- The mission reviewed the full chart of accounts (COA) of the Federation of Bosnia and Herzegovina and its bridging to ESA 2010; review coordinated with IMF long-term expert Mr. Deon Tanzer.
- Some items in the COA of the Federation of Bosnia and Herzegovina need clarification by the CBBH in cooperation with the Federation of Bosnia and Herzegovina Ministry of Finance to assign correct ESA 2010 codes; this may also affect current GFSM 2014 codes.
- Data compilation for the IMF-World Bank Quarterly Public Sector Debt (QPSD) statistics database has been completed by the CBBH for the time series 2007:Q1–2016:Q4.
- The mission agreed on the method to estimate missing quarterly data, suggested minor adjustments, and advised the CBBH to provide explanations on variables estimated when transmitting QPSD data to the World Bank.
- The mission sees nothing hampering regular data transmission to the World Bank; transmission can proceed when CBBH senior management approves.
- The mission encourages better understanding by the CBBH of the specific accounting standards used by the Federation of Bosnia and Herzegovina and improved cooperation between the Federation Ministry of Finance and the CBBH.
- The mission provided feedback on the recording of interest and other issues such as consolidation of general government data; progress noted in reducing the unexplained discrepancy in the EDP Table 3 (stock-flow adjustments to Maastricht debt) compared to the March 2016 TA mission.

### Follow-up actions identified for the CBBH
- Examine budget items in the COA for which no unique GFS code could be assigned during the mission.
- Review the draft bridging tables to ESA 2010 codes discussed during the mission and check consistency with GFSM 2014 codes.
- Seek high-level management approval to transmit QPSD statistics data to the World Bank.

### Introduction (mission tasks and context)
- Major tasks:
  - Review COA of the Federation and its bridging to ESA 2010 and GFSM 2014 codes.
  - Assist development of a reconciliation process and aligned derivation table for the Republic of Srpska and Federation ledger data.
  - Discuss status of QPSD statistics to facilitate short-notice transmission to the World Bank.
  - Discuss other requested assistance including recording of interest in EDP notifications to the European Commission.
- Tasks coordinated with SECO’s long-term expert, Mr. Deon Tanzer.
- COA of the Republic of Srpska was reviewed during a GFS TA mission in 2016.

### Accounting and statistical systems — institutional and accounting features
- Bosnia and Herzegovina structure:
  - Two entities: Federation of Bosnia and Herzegovina and Republic of Srpska.
  - Federation subdivided into cantons and municipalities and cities.
  - High degree of autonomy for the two entities; many government tasks are at entity and cantonal levels.
  - Budget shares: national level (Bosnia and Herzegovina institutions) about 10 percent; Federation of Bosnia and Herzegovina, 60 percent; Republic of Srpska, 30 percent.
- Federation accounting standards and COA features:
  - All government entities within the Federation use the same accounting standards.
  - Accounting base for expenditure: (modified) accrual; exception: interest recorded on a cash basis.
  - Depreciation of fixed assets (consumption of fixed capital in ESA 2010 and GFSM 2014) is not recorded.
  - Revenues are recorded on a cash basis.
  - All government entities share the same COA; some COA items apply only to specific entities (and are nil elsewhere).
  - COA uses a 7-digit coding system with about more than 1,400 individual items divided into 10 classes:
    - Class 0: stocks of fixed assets;
    - Class 1: stocks of current assets;
    - Class 2: inventories;
    - Class 3: stocks of short-term liabilities;
    - Class 4: stocks of long-term liabilities;
    - Class 5: reserves;
    - Class 6: expenses;
    - Class 7: revenues;
    - Class 8: transactions in assets and liabilities;
    - Class 9: commitments/ contingent liabilities.
  - COA data provided in six columns: two represent increases and decreases and four relate to opening and closing stocks of assets or liabilities (if applicable).
  - Mission constructed a balance sheet based on the COA where the class of stocks of fixed assets, currents assets, reserves, expenses, and capital transactions equal the sum of stocks for long-term liabilities, short-term liabilities, and revenues; increase minus decrease for every class equals the change in stocks. The balance sheet for 2016 is shown in Appendix II.
  - No complete balance sheet based on the COA is published for the Federation to the knowledge of the CBBH; no published comprehensive revenues and expenditures based on the COA.
  - No memorandum of understanding exists between the ministries of finance (the statistical institutes) and the CBBH regarding compilation of GFS.

### Chart of Accounts and bridge tables — review and issues
- Mission reviewed Classes 0–8 line by line for the Federation COA; Classes 5 and 9 deemed not relevant for GFS though:
  - Class 5 may be analyzed for producing derivation tables and reconciliation.
  - Class 9 may be relevant for compiling memorandum items related to contingent liabilities in accordance with the Public Sector Debt Statistics—Guide for Compilers and Users (paragraphs 4.03–4.26).
- EU reporting context:
  - Member states must disseminate data on contingent liabilities according to Directive 2011/85/EU.
  - MGDD Chapter VII.4 provides guidelines for cases when debt guarantees should be directly recorded as government debt.
- Consolidation differences and recommendations:
  - Consolidation of nonfinancial accounts in ESA 2010 differs from GFSM 2014:
    - ESA 2010 consolidation only eliminates transactions between government entities for property income (D.4), other current transfers (D.73) and capital transfers (D.9 excluding capital taxes).
    - GFSM 2014 (paragraphs 3.152–3.162) recommends consolidation for almost all transaction categories.
  - In financial accounts, all transaction categories should be consolidated in both ESA 2010 and GFSM 2014.
  - Mission advised including counterparty sector codes in bridge tables for transactions where ESA 2010 consolidation is required; counterparty information is useful for sector accounts and other macro-economic statistics.
  - CBBH noted transfers from paying government entities may not match amounts recorded by receiving entities; large differences need close cooperation and examination; for smaller amounts standard approaches or assumptions may be used with reliable data and adjusted counterparty sector data.
  - Verify adjustments do not create statistical discrepancies between above-the-line and below-the-line transactions.
- COA coding and documentation:
  - Mission proposed ESA 2010 coding based on COA descriptions and identified issues needing further analysis.
  - COA includes several correction items usually coded by 9; often zero but need examination when amounts appear.
  - CBBH lacks a comprehensive handbook with extensive descriptions of all COA codes; mission recommends the Federation Ministry of Finance share internal coding instructions or produce a handbook if none exists.

### Revenues (Class 7) — classification issues and recording
- Class 7 corresponds to revenues but may contain entries that should be recorded as negative expenditures (e.g., disposal of gross fixed capital formation or land).
- Taxes and social contributions:
  - Further discussed after March 2016 TA mission and EU Instrument for Pre-Accession Assistance Pilot Project 3 in March 2017.
  - Few changes to the bridging to ESA 2010 from March 2016; major change concerns current transfers between social security funds which regard employers’ actual social contributions (D.121) rather than current transfers within general government; mission confirmed this is appropriate.
- Production and inventories:
  - ESA 2010 uses the concept of production rather than sales; production includes sales and goods produced but not sold or added to inventories. Recording of transactions related to inventories may require further checking.
- Output produced for own final use (P.12, ESA 2010 3.20–22):
  - ESA 2010 requires recording on a gross basis: production of investment goods for own final use should be recorded as gross fixed capital formation (P.51g) and related costs (compensation of employees and intermediate consumption) recorded as well; revenues should be recorded to balance the double recording.
  - This differs from GFSM 2014 where only gross fixed capital formation is booked and not concomitant costs.
  - The COA does not provide information to estimate output produced for own final use.
- Licenses, permits, and fees:
  - COA contains many entries related to proceeds from use of natural resources, permits, and administrative fees.
  - Some items may be classified as taxes if licenses are granted automatically (see ESA 2010 4.23e); if payments are for regulated services and not in excess of the service granted, they should be recorded as payments for non-market output (P.131).
  - ESA 2010 Chapter 15 (contracts, leases, and licenses) and Tables 15.3 and 15.4 are useful for recording permits to use natural resources and permits for specific activities.
- Dividends:
  - Dividends should exclude superdividends (dividends disproportionally large relative to recent levels of earnings and dividends) per GFSM 2014 paragraph 5.111.
  - MGDD (Chapter III.5) provides stricter guidelines for recording superdividends.

### Expenditures (Class 6) — classification and borderline cases
- Expenses are recorded under Class 6; some expenditures are recorded as revenues such as disposal of gross fixed capital formation or land.
- Borderline cases:
  - Distinguishing between compensation of employees and intermediate consumption discussed.
  - Expenditures by employees during duties and compensated by government (e.g., business travel costs) should be seen as intermediate consumption.
  - Compensation for food or free food should be recorded as wages (in kind).

### Conclusions and recommendations (summary)
- Clarify COA items with Federation Ministry of Finance to assign correct ESA 2010 and GFSM 2014 codes.
- Improve documentation: obtain or produce a comprehensive COA handbook or internal coding instructions.
- Strengthen cooperation and communication between CBBH and ministries of finance/statistical institutes for coding queries and data needs.
- Finalize and transmit QPSD data for 2007:Q1–2016:Q4 to the World Bank after senior management approval, documenting estimations made for missing quarterly data.
- Design reconciliation process and derivation tables for entity ledger data to enhance GFS quality and to derive net lending / net borrowing consistent with ESA 2010 and GFSM 2014.
- Examine correction items (coded by 9) and entries that appear in revenues but are negative expenditures.
- Ensure consolidation and counterparty coding in bridge tables are aligned with ESA 2010 and GFSM 2014 requirements to avoid statistical discrepancies.
- Address recording of interest and continue work to reduce discrepancies in EDP Table 3.

*Source: cr1825 - Executive Summary (IMF TA mission report, April 24–28, 2017).*

### 23. Wages and salaries, part of compensation of employees, should exclude payments to

### 23. Wages and salaries, part of compensation of employees, should exclude payments to

### Compensation of employees: exclusions and related records
- Wages and salaries, part of compensation of employees, should exclude payments to employees that are not related to work done such as family allowances, payments to workers absent from work, and severance payments to workers who lose their job.
- These excluded payments should be recorded as other social insurance benefits (D.622).
- They give rise to employers’ imputed social contributions recorded as D.122 expenditures and D.612 revenues.
- Although the imputed social contributions should be based on actuarial calculations, they may also be roughly estimated to equal D.622 (ESA 2010 4.10).

### Interest recording and treatment
- Interest in the COA is recorded on a cash basis; previous TA missions advised recording interest on an accrual basis.
- For loans:
  - Interest accrued but not yet paid should be recorded as expenses, with a simultaneous recording of a transaction with the same amount in loans (double entry bookkeeping).
  - When interest is paid, it leads to a negative transaction in loans (and a decrease of deposits).
- For debt securities:
  - Premium and discount are considered as interest under GFSM 2014 and ESA 2010 and should be spread over the lifetime of the security.
- Conceptual note:
  - Concepts of interest in GFSM 2014 and ESA 2010 are not equivalent.
  - For interest on loans paid to banks and interest on deposits received from banks, part of the interest should be recorded as a payment for a financial intermediation service indirectly measured (FISIM).

### Implementation progress and specific interest items
- The CBBH reduced the unexplained residual in the reconciliation for EDP Table 3 to only 3 million Bosnian convertible marka.
- Penalty interest related to early redemption of loans:
  - MGDD, Chapter II.4 paragraph 50 indicates penalty interest should be recorded as interest (D.41) or holding gains/losses (no revenues/expenses transaction) depending on fee features.
  - An alternate recording of penalty interest is under discussion in a Task Force led by Eurostat.

### Classification guidance for transfers and subsidies
- For transactions possibly classifiable as other current transfers, subsidies, or capital transfers:
  - First check if the transaction satisfies the features of capital transfers.
  - If not capital, check whether it should be classified as subsidies or other current transfers n.e.c.
  - If the beneficiary is a market producer, record as subsidies (D.3).
  - If the beneficiary is a non-market producer, record as other current transfer (D.75).
  - Only if a specific subsidy scheme is open to both market and non-market producers may one record subsidies for non-market producers (ESA 2010 4.36).

### Need for institutional sector classifications
- Proper classification requires access to statistical business registers containing classifications to institutional sectors according to ESA 2010.
- Statistical institutes in Bosnia and Herzegovina have been working on a sectorization project, but a list with government entities has not yet been published.

### Financial transactions (Class 8) and related issues
- Financial transactions are recorded under Class 8, including capital transactions related to nonfinancial assets (produced assets P.5 or non-produced assets NP).
- CBBH cannot yet reconcile all financial transactions with banking statistics; banking statistics are considered more reliable and are used for deposits.
- Short-term vs long-term distinction:
  - During the mission the breakdown into short-term and long-term was unclear; some short-term assets and liabilities were in fact long-term.
- Promissory notes and liabilities related to frozen deposits and war claims:
  - Promissory notes must be recorded as debt securities (F.3) (see ESA 2010 5.96 or GFSM 2014 7.144 and 7.225).
- Long-term trade credits:
  - Recording under ESA 2010 is unclear and under discussion in a Eurostat Task Force.
  - ESA 2010 5.239 distinguishes short-term and long-term trade credits; ESA 2010 20.132 stipulates long-term credits be recorded as loans.
  - Eurostat’s interpretation: paragraph 20.132 is specific guidance applicable only to government entities; mission recommends recording long-term trade credits as loans.
  - Distinction matters because loans are included in Maastricht debt whereas trade credits are not.
- Capital injections into public entities:
  - CBBH should verify whether such injections are financial transactions (equity F.5 or sometimes loans F.4) with an expected return or capital transfers (D.99).
  - Apply the capital injection test as presented in page 172 of the MGDD.

### Derivation tables and reconciliation process
- CBBH started work on derivation tables for Table 2 of the EDP transmission.
- CBBH will take the balance of revenues and expenses reported in the COA (Classes 6 and 7) as the national working balance and list adjustments to arrive at net lending / net borrowing according to ESA 2010.
- Due to other priorities, further work on derivation tables will continue as of August 2017.
- Building blocks for EDP Table 2 for the Federation of Bosnia and Herzegovina are available:
  - COA has separate columns for increases and decreases, aiding compilation of EDP Table 2.
  - Important adjustment is accrual adjustments for interest produced in the context of EDP Table 3.
- Reconciliation of flows and stocks:
  - Mission suggested reconciling transactions in Class 9 with changes in stock in Classes 0, 1, 3, and 4.
  - CBBH uses indirect data sources for financial transactions and balance sheets.

### Quarterly Public Sector Debt (QPSD) statistics
- CBBH compiles QPSD statistics using methods similar to financial accounts and balance sheets: partially indirect data sources (monetary statistics for domestic debt and securities) and direct sources (external debt).
- Data on other accounts payable are not available quarterly and are estimated by interpolating and extrapolating annual data.
- CBBH uses estimation procedures to break down quarterly general government debt to central government debt and budgetary central government; indirect sources lack subsector detail.
- Mission agreed on method to estimate missing quarterly data and suggested minor adjustments.
- CBBH can compile QPSD statistics for the period 2007–16 and provide QPSD statistics for the last quarter within the World Bank deadline.
- The mission recommends including an explanation of estimation procedures when transmitting data to the World Bank.
- Senior management approval at CBBH is still needed for regular transmission of QPSD statistics to the World Bank; mission considers no serious issues justify delay.

### Conclusions and recommendations (mission summary)
- As a result of the mission, the full COA (except reserves and contingent liabilities) has been classified to ESA 2010 codes.
- COA used by the Federation of Bosnia and Herzegovina is comprehensive and facilitates bridging national codes to GFSM 2014 and ESA 2010; some amendments and extensions may further improve bridging.
- Recommendation: CBBH and the statistical office of the Federation of Bosnia and Herzegovina should coordinate coding to ESA 2010 to ensure consistency between GFS according to GFSM 2014, GFS according to ESA 2010, and national accounts.
- Follow-up actions identified for CBBH:
  - (i) Examine budget items in the COA for which no unique GFS code could be assigned during the mission.
  - (ii) Review draft bridging tables to ESA 2010 codes discussed during the mission and check consistency with GFSM 2014 codes.
  - (iii) Seek high-level management approval to transmit QPSD statistics data to the World Bank.
- CBBH indicated it would welcome further GFS TA in the autumn of 2017 to assist with derivation tables and to provide an ESA 2010 course for ministries of finance, statistical institutes, and CBBH staff.

### Key figures from Appendix II: Balance Sheet based on the COA (selected entries)
- Fixed Assets:
  - Opening: 1,282,870
  - Closing: 1,113,130
  - Increase: 942,663
  - Decrease: 1,112,403
- Long-term:
  - Opening: 6,389,414
  - Closing: 6,315,266
  - Increase: 1,372,475
  - Decrease: 1,446,623
- Current Assets:
  - Opening: 319,339
  - Closing: 402,209
- Short-term:
  - Opening: 507,651
  - Closing: 517,830
  - Increase: 3,260,788
  - Decrease: 3,250,609
- Reserves:
  - Opening/Closing figures shown: 5,294,856 and 5,402,725
  - Increase: 892,215
  - Decrease: 784,346
- Expenses (Class 6):
  - Opening/Closing: 1,378,910 and 1,392,608
  - Increase/Decrease: 13,698
- Revenues (Class 7):
  - Opening/Closing: 1,810,652 and 1,868,887
  - Increase/Decrease: 58,235
- Capital transactions (Class 8):
  - Opening/Closing related entries: 346,773 and 910,882
  - Change: 564,109
- Aggregate stock/flow entries shown:
  - 6,897,065   8,643,748
  - 12,890,730   11,144,047
  - 6,897,065   8,643,748
  - 6,502,151   4,755,468
- Inventories:
  - Increase/Decrease: 25,361
- Commitments:
  - Opening/Closing: 6,512,190 and 6,512,190

*Source: IMF staff estimates*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/cr/2018/cr1825.pdf_
