## 1. Recent Economic Developments, 2012-18 (cr18368)

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [1. Recent Economic Developments, 2012-18 (cr18368)](https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/cr/2018/cr18368.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/files/publications/cr/2018/cr18368.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/files/publications/cr/2018/cr18368.pdf.json)

---

### Macroeconomic snapshot and near-term outlook
- Growth and demand
  - Real GDP growth: 4 percent in 2018 (staff baseline).
  - Growth projected at 4.2 percent in 2019; medium-term growth under current policies projected to stay at potential of 4 percent.
  - Authorities project growth of 4¾ percent in 2019 and about 5 percent in the medium term.
  - Contributions to 2018 growth (percent points): Consumption 3.9; Investment 0.7; Exports 1.9; Imports -2.4.
- Inflation and credit
  - Headline inflation: 0.7 percent in the first nine months of 2018.
  - Inflation expected to average 0.9 percent in 2018 and 1.4 percent in 2019.
  - Bank credit to the private sector: robust growth due to lower borrowing rates and improved contract enforcement.
- External accounts and reserves
  - Current account balance (incl. official transfers): -6.4 percent of GDP in 2015; -6.9 in 2016; -8.3 in 2017; projected -7.9 in 2018; -7.2 in 2019; -7.0 in 2020; -6.6 by 2023.
  - Gross international reserves: 18 percent of GDP in 2017; expected to decline to around 14 percent of GDP by 2023 (driven by transfer of privatization proceeds held at the CBK to the budget).
- Fiscal execution
  - 2018 budget execution expected broadly on target.
  - Fiscal deficit (under the fiscal rule) expected around 1½ percent of GDP in 2018, within the 2 percent ceiling.
  - Including investment exempted from the fiscal rule, the overall deficit expected to reach 3 percent of GDP.
  - Draft 2019 budget targets a deficit of 1.9 percent of GDP (fiscal rule definition), keeps the wage bill constant as a share of GDP, and the bank balance at 4.5 percent of GDP.

### Key statistics (selected exact figures from staff tables)
- Real GDP growth: 4.2 (2015), 4.0 (2016), 4.2 (2017), 4.0 (2018), 4.0 (2019–2023 projected).
- CPI inflation (period avg.): 1.5 (2015), 0.9 (2018), 1.4 (2019), 1.7 (2020), 1.8 (2021), 1.9 (2022), 2.0 (2023).
- Bank credit to the private sector: 11.5 (2015), 10.3 (2016), 9.5 (2017), 8.9 (2018), 8.3 (2019), 7.5 (2020), 7.1 (2021).
- Fiscal balance ex-PAK ex-IFI capital projects: -1.2 (2017), -1.5 (2018), -1.9 (2019–2023).
- Total public debt: 16.3 (2015), 17.0 (2016), 19.6 (2017), 22.2 (2018), 24.2 (2019), 26.1 (2020), 27.4 (2021).
- Stock of government bank balances: 4.5 percent of GDP (2015–2023 assumed).

### Political and structural context
- Labor market: unemployment about 30 percent; labor force inactivity about 60 percent; labor force participation 40 percent (low).
- Structural vulnerabilities: high informality; heavy reliance on remittances; large trade deficits due to narrow domestic production and export bases.
- Political risks: thin ruling coalition majority; normalization talks with Serbia; 100 percent tariff on imports from Serbia and Bosnia; populist pressures and fiscally costly initiatives under consideration.

---

### Risks to the outlook
- Domestic risks
  - Spending pressures and tax revenue shortfalls could crowd out productive spending and increase the fiscal deficit.
  - Proposed new power plant (construction costs of about 20 percent of GDP) would widen the current account deficit during construction and—depending on financing—likely significantly increase public debt.
  - Renewed political uncertainty could undermine confidence and halt reforms.
- External risks
  - Weaker-than-expected EU growth could reduce remittance and FDI inflows.
  - Normalization of EU monetary policy or tighter global financial conditions could reduce domestic bank demand for government securities and increase government financing pressures.
- External position and competitiveness
  - External position at end-2017 assessed as moderately weaker than implied by fundamentals and desirable policies.
  - Real effective exchange rate estimated overvalued in the range of 9-10 percent (improved from 12-15 percent in the 2017 assessment).
  - Trade deficit: 26 percent of GDP (highest in the region).
  - Kosovo attracts the lowest FDI in the region.

---

### Fiscal policy: making efficient use of fiscal space and containing fiscal risks

### Fiscal context and projections
- Fiscal rule balance (percent of GDP): -1.8 (2015), -1.2 (2016), -1.2 (2017), -1.5 (2018), -1.9 (2019–2023 projected).
- IFI/donor financed investment (percent of GDP): 0.0 (2015–2018), 1.7 (2019), 1.1 (2020), 1.2 (2021), 1.1 (2022), 1.0 (2023).
- Privatization proceeds (PAK) financed investment (percent of GDP): 0.0 (2015–2018), 1.3 (2019), 2.0 (2020), 2.0 (2021), 0.8 (2022), 0.0 (2023).
- Overall balance: -1.9 (2015), -1.4 (2016), -1.3 (2017), -2.9 (2018), -5.8 (2019), -5.1 (2020), -4.0 (2021), -3.1 (2022–2023).
- Fiscal impulse: 4.0 (2015), -0.5 (2016), 0.1 (2017), 1.5 (2018), 3.0 (2019), 2.4 (2020), -1.3 (2021), -0.9 (2022), 0.0 (2023), -0.4 (2024).
- Total public debt (memo alternate series): 13.0 (2015), rising to projected 27.4 by 2023 in staff projections.

### Budget execution, 2018–2019 risks
- 2018 budget execution: deficit around 1½ percent of GDP under fiscal rule; overall deficit (including exempted investment) about 3 percent of GDP.
- Draft 2019 budget:
  - Deficit target 1.9 percent of GDP (fiscal rule).
  - Keeps wage bill constant; bank balance at 4.5 percent of GDP.
  - Increases allocations to health, education, judiciary; accommodates higher pension and other social spending.
  - Measures would increase consumption spending by 1½ percent of GDP at the expense of on-budget investment.
  - Budget relies on ambitious revenue gains from higher tax debt collection and compliance of 0.6 percent of GDP and a ¼ percent of GDP saving from war veteran reform.
  - Unbudgeted fiscal initiatives under pressure could cost between 3–4 percent of GDP in the short term.
- Investment acceleration implications
  - Acceleration in donor/PAK-financed investment in 2019 could add 4 percent of GDP to the overall deficit and bring total investment spending to 11 percent of GDP in 2019, implying a fiscal expansion of some 3 percent of potential GDP.
  - Past capacity constraints limited actual capital spending below plans; high import content and labor market slack may limit domestic demand pass-through.

### Fiscal risks and contingent liabilities (selected quantified items)
- Total tax debt: about 5 percent of GDP.
- Tax gaps: around 35 percent of GDP (World Bank and BSE estimates).
- Guarantees for the new power plant financing: sovereign guarantees possibly up to the full amount of the project (20 percent of GDP).
- Guarantees for debt contracted by POEs: fiscal impact 0.3-0.7 percent of GDP (short-term), 0.3-1.0 percent (medium-term).
- Transfers to POEs to cover losses/investment needs: 0.1-0.4 percent (short-term), 0.1-0.6 percent (medium-term).
- PAK financing reimbursement: 0.3 percent (short-term), 0.3-0.4 percent (medium-term).
- Specific spending/revenue measures (full year impact in percent of GDP where quantified):
  - Wage hike for PM, Cabinet and advisors, and judiciary (retroactive for 2018): 0.1-0.2 (short-term); 0.1-0.2 (medium-term).
  - Salary law for public sector (DL passed first reading): 0.8-1.3 (short-term); 0.9-1.0 (medium-term).
  - Child allowance (Resolution adopted by parliament): 0.7-0.8 (short-term); 0.6-0.8 (medium-term).
  - VAT collection reform (DL adopted by GoK): 1.0-1.1 percent of GDP expected revenue gain in short-term; 0.0 in medium-term.

### Policy advice and recommendations (staff)
- Preserve the fiscal rule as an anchor for fiscal sustainability and development.
- Revenue-side reforms
  - Implement revenue administration reforms to reduce informality, tax gaps, and tax debts (total tax debt ~5 percent of GDP; tax gaps ~35 percent of GDP).
  - Set quantitative and strategic performance targets to achieve 2019 revenue targets; widen tax filing requirements and late filing penalties; improve audit productivity.
  - Centralize tax debt collection in a single office at TAK headquarters; automatize write-off of uncollectible debt and timely enforcement.
  - Any changes to import VAT (about 1/3 of total revenue) should retain collection with Customs and include safeguards to minimize revenue risks.
  - Avoid granting new exemptions or tax holidays.
- Contain current spending pressures and protect productive spending
  - Proceed with war veteran benefit reform (spending in 2018 about ½ percent of GDP above the legal ceiling of 0.7 percent).
  - Avoid untargeted benefit schemes and limit pension increases to the basic pension.
  - Contain wage bill pressures: design public administration and health care reforms within the wage bill rule; reconsider the public salary law given large fiscal costs.
  - Widen the contribution base and implement efficiency reforms ahead of health insurance introduction in 2020.
- POEs and contingent liabilities
  - Accelerate restructuring of loss-making and inefficient POEs: right-size employment, align wages with productivity, improve oversight.
  - Carefully assess sovereign guarantees linked to large projects (notably the proposed power plant) given potential cumulative exposure up to 20 percent of GDP.
- Contingency and fiscal governance measures
  - Strengthen commitment to adjust spending for any revenue shortfalls by identifying non-priority spending upfront and releasing appropriations only upon realization of additional revenue.
  - Retain the government bank balance of 4.5 percent of GDP as a buffer.
- Improve spending efficiency
  - Strengthen public investment framework: better project selection, execution, cost-benefit analysis, and ex-post audits.
  - Spread spending of privatization proceeds over multiple years rather than frontloading to 2019.
  - Review social benefit amounts and eligibility to address double dipping and labor market disincentives.

---

### Debt Sustainability Analysis (Annex IV) and financing strategy

### DSA baseline assumptions and outcomes
- Baseline macro assumptions
  - Growth projected at 4 percent in 2018 and the medium term.
  - Fiscal deficit excluding IFI-financed projects and privatization proceeds expected to remain within the 2-percent of GDP fiscal rule deficit ceiling.
  - Public debt projected to increase from 16 percent of GDP in 2017 to 27 percent of GDP by 2023 under the baseline.
- Financing assumptions
  - Average maturity of domestic debt projected to increase from 2.2 to 3.5 years.
  - Short-term domestic debt projected to decrease from 15 percent of total debt to 3 percent.
  - Privatization fund PAK would transfer some 286 million of earlier privatization proceeds to the budget over 2018-2020.
  - Maintaining a buffer of 4.5 percent of GDP in government deposits at the CBK would require additional financing of 1.4 percent of GDP over the projected period.
- Gross financing needs
  - Average gross financing needs are 9.6 percent over 2018-2023, compared to 7.2 percent during 2013–2017.

### Vulnerabilities and contingent liability scenarios
- Market absorption and composition risks
  - Domestic market capacity to absorb higher government debt is increasingly reduced; current holders of domestic debt: public entities, individuals, private businesses, insurance companies hold less than 5 percent of total domestic debt.
  - Recommendation: reduce CBK holdings of government securities and not increase KPST exposure limit above 30 percent of its assets.
- Sensitivity to contingent liabilities
  - Guarantees for the new power plant project could lift debt above the 30 percent of GDP ceiling considered prudent.
  - Contingent liabilities modeled: POEs at 5 percent of GDP and PAK financing at 1.5 percent of GDP would have large impacts on the debt profile.
- Policy priorities from DSA
  - Continue compliance with the fiscal rule; extend maturity and diversify financing; explore new instruments (retail or external bonds) conditional on improved country risk and market access; consider well-designed private financing under a sound PPP framework.

### Stress-test findings (external and public debt)
- External debt sensitivity
  - A current account shock (permanently increases the non-interest current account by one-half standard deviation in 2019–23, around 1½ percent of GDP) raises external debt by about 7 percentage points to 29 percent of GDP by 2023 and increases gross financing needs in 2023 by 4 percentage points of GDP relative to baseline.
- Public debt stress tests
  - Alternative scenarios (primary balance, growth, interest rate, combined shocks) show higher debt and financing needs under adverse shocks; contingent liabilities (Power Plant Guarantees; POEs; PAK) raise projected gross nominal public debt and public gross financing needs.

---

### Structural reforms, labor market, governance, and financial sector

### Labor market and human capital (findings and recommendations)
- Labor market facts
  - Unemployment nearly 30 percent; inactivity rate 60 percent; labor force participation (2017) 42.8 percent; youth unemployment exceeding 50 percent.
  - Public-sector wage premium estimated around 30–43 percent (public sector estimated premium in 2017: 30–43 percent).
  - Kosovo has the highest monthly minimum wage to GDP per capita ratio: 4.8% (Kosovo) versus 3.4% (EU average).
- Empirical findings
  - Higher public-sector wage premium and higher minimum wage to GDP per capita ratio are negatively associated with employment outcomes in cross-country regressions; coefficients reported (e.g., minimum wage to GDP per capita coefficient -1.775*).
  - Family/children expenditure (as % of GDP) associated with lower employment (coefficient -2.189** in one specification).
  - Public-private wage gap: public sector coefficient 0.301*** (public only) and 0.428*** (public and SOE) in Mincerian wage regressions.
- Policy recommendations
  - Re-introduce rules-based minimum wage formula and binding preconditions to avoid large discretionary increases.
  - Set public sector wage increases mindful of competitiveness and wage bill rule; use wage bill rule as ceiling.
  - Strike balance on social benefits to avoid perverse labor incentives; limit pension increases to basic pension.
  - Design ALMPs focused on vocational training, job search assistance, and reducing regulatory burdens; promote female labor force participation via childcare and anti-discrimination measures.
  - Prioritize education reforms: preschool enrollment, teacher quality, curricula modernization, TVET strengthening, accreditation, and monitoring.

### Governance, public investment, POEs, and procurement
- Public procurement
  - Full implementation of the 2016 procurement law remains slow; in 2017, 98 percent of public contracts awarded by lowest-price criterion.
  - Recommendations: implement remaining e-procurement modules, widen centralized procurement coverage, make e-procurement mandatory, strengthen the Procurement Review Body.
- Publicly-Owned Enterprises (POEs)
  - 16 central and 44 local level POEs; POE debt approx. 5 percent of GDP; eight of 16 central level companies have accounting losses; dividend payments to the budget zero since 2015.
  - Recommendations: strengthen joint oversight by MoF and MED; enforce timely audited financial reporting; require MoF approval for POE debt issuance; improve corporate governance; publish financial statements.
- Public Investment Framework
  - Annual capital budget is 9 percent of GDP; capital stock 60 percent below EU average and 20 percent below Western Balkan average.
  - Absorption of donors/IFIs-financed projects under the investment clause has been zero for several years; capital spending under-executed by some 35 percent in 2017.
  - Recommendations: improve project appraisal and selection; require independent economic/financial viability studies; integrate donor-funded projects into the Treasury Single Account and PIP; require ex-post audits and quarterly monitoring; integrate PPPs into PIM framework.

### Financial sector: soundness, access, and supervisory enhancements
- Key indicators and findings
  - Financial sector broadly sound though liquidity is tightening.
  - NPLs below 3 percent of total loans (2.6 as of September 2018).
  - Regulatory capital to risk weighted assets: 16.1 (latest reported).
  - ROA: 2.1; Liquid assets to short-term liabilities: 36.3.
  - Banking sector lending growth strong; lending concentrated in trade and construction; property lending growth and possible supply overhang warrant close monitoring.
- Supervisory and structural recommendations
  - Fully implement enforcement law and accelerate resolution of commercial cases; increase specialized judges and prepare for a commercial court.
  - Strengthen property registration and cadaster completion.
  - CBK actions: incorporate Basel III, implement IFRS9 in 2019, develop macroprudential instruments for non-bank financial institutions, draft risk-based supervision manuals.
  - Improve AML/CFT implementation per PECK II findings; address third-party reliance and customer due diligence shortcomings.

---

### Data, statistical capacity, and implementation status

### Data adequacy and recommendations
- Data generally adequate for surveillance: fiscal and financial sector data good quality, timely and available.
- Further improvements needed in real sector data quality and timeliness; strengthen capacity of statistical agencies.
- Key data series and latest observations (selected)
  - Net foreign assets of CBK (millions of euros): 2015 1,046; 2016 895; 2017 939; 2018 937; 2019 856; 2020 887; 2021 967; 2022 1,000; 2023 1,021.
  - Gross international reserves (millions of euros): 2015 1,245; 2016 1,082; 2017 1,168; 2018 1,165; 2019 1,084; 2020 1,115; 2021 1,195; 2022 1,228; 2023 1,249.
  - Official unemployment (percent of workforce): 2015 32.9; 2016 27.5; 2017 30.5; 2018 29.4 (2018 as of June 2018).
  - NPL to total loans: 2015 6.2; 2016 4.9; 2017 3.1; 2018 2.6 (2018 as of September 2018).

### Implementation status highlights (2017 Article IV recommendations)
- Good compliance: comply with fiscal rule; diversify financing; bank balance maintained above 4.5 percent of GDP (except two months); PAK allowed to invest in government securities.
- Partial compliance: public investment framework and IFI-financed investment progress slow; tax administration reforms incomplete; VAT refund system automatized with risk-based audits.
- Weak compliance: containment of current spending; social benefit reforms not implemented; labor market and education reforms at early stage.

---

*IMF staff summary based on “1. Recent Economic Developments, 2012-18” (cr18368).*

### 1. Recent Economic Developments, 2012-18 ____________________________________________________ 23

### 1. Recent Economic Developments, 2012-18

### Context
- Kosovo faces significant structural challenges despite recent policy gains under the Fund-supported program that expired in August 2017:
  - Unemployment: about 30 percent.
  - Labor force inactivity: about 60 percent.
  - High informality, heavy reliance on remittances, and large trade deficits due to narrow domestic production and export bases.
  - Kosovo remains one of the poorest European countries and the only one classified as a “Fragile State” in Europe (World Bank classification), though it is an upside outlier within this group (CPIA at 3.6).

- Political environment:
  - Thin ruling coalition majority and divisions on key issues have stalled needed reforms.
  - Key political risks include normalization talks with Serbia, conversion of the Kosovo Security Force into a regular army, EU visa liberalization, impending indictments by a special war crimes tribunal, and a 100 percent tariff on imports from Serbia and Bosnia.
  - Populist pressures are rising with fiscally costly initiatives under consideration.

### Recent developments and near-term outlook
- Growth and demand:
  - Real GDP growth: 4 percent in 2018 (staff baseline), led by public investment, consumption, and services exports.
  - Growth projected at 4.2 percent in 2019, supported by a temporary increase in public investment.
  - Medium-term growth under current policies projected to stay at potential of 4 percent.
  - Authorities project higher growth: 4¾ percent in 2019 and about 5 percent in the medium term.

- Inflation and credit:
  - Headline inflation: 0.7 percent in the first nine months of 2018.
  - Inflation expected to average 0.9 percent in 2018 and 1.4 percent in 2019.
  - Bank credit to the private sector remained robust due to lower borrowing rates and improvements in contract enforcement.

- Fiscal execution and balance:
  - 2018 budget execution expected broadly on target; fiscal deficit (under the fiscal rule) expected to be around 1½ percent of GDP, within the 2 percent ceiling.
  - Including investment exempted from the fiscal rule, the overall deficit expected to reach 3 percent of GDP.
  - Draft 2019 budget targets a deficit of 1.9 percent of GDP (fiscal rule definition), keeps the wage bill constant as a share of GDP, and the bank balance at 4.5 percent of GDP.

- External accounts and reserves:
  - Current account balance (incl. official transfers): -6.4 percent of GDP in 2015; -6.9 in 2016; -8.3 in 2017; projected -7.9 in 2018; -7.2 in 2019; -7.0 in 2020; -6.6 by 2023.
  - Gross international reserves: 18 percent of GDP in 2017; expected to decline to around 14 percent of GDP by 2023 (driven by transfer of privatization proceeds held at the CBK to the budget).

### Risks to the outlook
- Downside risks are prominent (see Annex II – Risk Assessment Matrix):
  - Domestic risks:
    - Spending pressures and tax revenue shortfalls could crowd out productive spending, increase the fiscal deficit, and undermine confidence.
    - The proposed new power plant (construction costs of about 20 percent of GDP) would widen the current account deficit during construction and—depending on financing—likely significantly increase public debt.
    - Renewed political uncertainty could undermine confidence and halt reforms.
  - External risks:
    - Weaker-than-expected EU growth could reduce remittance and FDI inflows, slowing Kosovo’s growth.
    - Normalization of EU monetary policy or tighter global financial conditions could increase government financing pressures by reducing domestic bank demand for government securities.

### External stability and competitiveness
- External position:
  - External position at end-2017 assessed as moderately weaker than implied by fundamentals and desirable policies (Annex III).
  - Real effective exchange rate estimated overvalued in the range of 9-10 percent (improved from 12-15 percent in the 2017 assessment).
- Competitiveness indicators:
  - Trade deficit: 26 percent of GDP (highest in the region).
  - Goods export share lags other Western Balkan countries despite diversification.
  - Unemployment around 30 percent (highest in the region); labor force participation 40 percent (lowest in the region).
  - Increases in gross wages not matched by labor productivity gains.
  - Kosovo attracts the lowest FDI in the region.

- Reserve management:
  - Reserves at 18 percent of GDP in 2017 considered broadly adequate under traditional and IMF-developed metrics given full euroization.
  - Continued adequate reserve coverage will require redirecting CBK’s investments from Kosovo government securities to international reserve assets and retaining the government bank balance of 4.5 percent of GDP held at the CBK.

### Authorities’ views
- Authorities broadly concurred with staff’s risk and external assessments and agreed on competitiveness challenges.
- They expect stronger baseline growth (authorities’ projection: 4¾ percent in 2019, about 5 percent medium term).
- Regarding CBK holdings of Kosovo government securities, authorities emphasize the CBK’s investment strategy and a gradual reduction of those holdings as a medium-term priority, subject to a 25 percent single exposure limit.

### Key macroeconomic indicators (selected exact figures from staff tables)
- Real GDP growth: 4.2 (2015), 4.0 (2016), 4.2 (2017), 4.0 (2018), 4.0 (2019–2023 projected).
- Contributions to 2018 growth (percent points): Consumption 3.9; Investment 0.7; Exports 1.9; Imports -2.4.
- CPI inflation (period avg.): 1.5 (2015), 0.9 (2018), 1.4 (2019), 1.7 (2020), 1.8 (2021), 1.9 (2022), 2.0 (2023).
- Bank credit to the private sector: 11.5 (2015), 10.3 (2016), 9.5 (2017), 8.9 (2018), 8.3 (2019), 7.5 (2020), 7.1 (2021).
- Fiscal balance ex-PAK ex-IFI capital projects: -1.2 (2017), -1.5 (2018), -1.9 (2019–2023).
- Total public debt: 16.3 (2015), 17.0 (2016), 19.6 (2017), 22.2 (2018), 24.2 (2019), 26.1 (2020), 27.4 (2021).
- Stock of government bank balances: 4.5 percent of GDP (2015–2023 assumed).

---

### Fiscal policy: making efficient use of fiscal space and containing fiscal risks

Key fiscal context and numbers
- Fiscal rule balance (percent of GDP): -1.8 (2015), -1.2 (2016), -1.2 (2017), -1.5 (2018), -1.9 (2019–2023 projected).
- IFI/donor financed investment (percent of GDP): 0.0 (2015–2017), 0.0 (2018), 1.7 (2019), 1.1 (2020), 1.2 (2021), 1.1 (2022), 1.0 (2023).
- Privatization proceeds (PAK) financed investment (percent of GDP): 0.0 (2015–2017), 0.0 (2018), 1.3 (2019), 2.0 (2020), 2.0 (2021), 0.8 (2022), 0.0 (2023).
- Overall balance: -1.9 (2015), -1.4 (2016), -1.3 (2017), -2.9 (2018), -5.8 (2019), -5.1 (2020), -4.0 (2021), -3.1 (2022–2023).
- Fiscal impulse: 4.0 (2015), -0.5 (2016), 0.1 (2017), 1.5 (2018), 3.0 (2019), 2.4 (2020), -1.3 (2021), -0.9 (2022), 0.0 (2023), -0.4 (2024).
- Total public debt (memo): 13.0 (2015 in alternate series), rising to projected 27.4 by 2023 in staff projections.

Budget execution and risks
- 2018 budget execution: deficit around 1½ percent of GDP under fiscal rule; overall deficit (including exempted investment) about 3 percent of GDP.
- Draft 2019 budget: deficit target 1.9 percent of GDP (fiscal rule), keeps wage bill constant, bank balance at 4.5 percent of GDP, increases allocations to health, education, judiciary, and accommodates higher pension and other social spending.
  - Measures would increase consumption spending by 1½ percent of GDP at the expense of on-budget investment.
  - Budget relies on ambitious revenue gains from higher tax debt collection and compliance of 0.6 percent of GDP (assumed in staff note) and a ¼ percent of GDP saving from war veteran reform.
  - Unbudgeted fiscal initiatives under pressure could cost between 3–4 percent of GDP in the short term.

- Investment and fiscal expansion:
  - Acceleration in donor/PAK-financed investment in 2019 could add 4 percent of GDP to the overall deficit and bring total investment spending to 11 percent of GDP in 2019, implying a fiscal expansion of some 3 percent of potential GDP.
  - Past capacity constraints have limited actual capital spending below plans; high import content and labor market slack may limit domestic demand pass-through.

Fiscal risks table (selected items and staff estimates)
- Total tax debt: about 5 percent of GDP.
- Tax gaps: around 35 percent of GDP (World Bank and BSE estimates).
- Potential fiscal costs and contingent liabilities:
  - Guarantees for the new power plant financing: sovereign guarantees possibly up to the full amount of the project (20 percent of GDP); cumulative (not annual) share of 2018 GDP noted.
  - Guarantees for debt contracted by POEs: fiscal impact 0.3-0.7 percent of GDP (short-term), 0.3-1.0 percent (medium-term).
  - Transfers to POEs to cover losses/investment needs: 0.1-0.4 percent (short-term), 0.1-0.6 percent (medium-term).
  - PAK financing reimbursement: 0.3 percent (short-term), 0.3-0.4 percent (medium-term).
- Specific spending or revenue measures and estimated fiscal impacts (full year impact in percent of GDP where quantified):
  - Wage hike for PM, Cabinet and advisors, and judiciary (implemented retroactively for 2018): 0.1-0.2 (short-term); 0.1-0.2 (medium-term).
  - Salary law for public sector (DL passed first reading): 0.8-1.3 (short-term); 0.9-1.0 (medium-term).
  - Child allowance (Resolution adopted by parliament): 0.7-0.8 (short-term); 0.6-0.8 (medium-term).
  - VAT collection reform (DL adopted by GoK): 1.0-1.1 percent of GDP expected revenue gain in short-term; 0.0 in medium-term (staff notes).

Policy advice and recommendations (staff)
- Preserve the fiscal rule as an anchor for fiscal sustainability and development.
- Revenue-side reforms:
  - Implement revenue administration reforms to reduce informality, tax gaps, and tax debts.
    - Total tax debt ~5 percent of GDP; tax gaps ~35 percent of GDP.
  - To achieve the 2019 revenue targets, set quantitative and strategic performance targets, widen tax filing requirements and late filing penalties, and improve audit productivity.
  - Centralize tax debt collection in a single office at TAK headquarters; systematize the process with automatic write-off of uncollectible debt and timely enforcement.
  - Any changes to import VAT (about 1/3 of total revenue) should retain collection with Customs and include safeguards to minimize revenue risks.
  - Avoid granting new exemptions or tax holidays.

- Contain current spending pressures and protect productive spending:
  - Proceed with war veteran benefit reform (spending in 2018 about ½ percent of GDP above the legal ceiling of 0.7 percent).
  - Avoid untargeted benefit schemes (e.g., early retirement for police, pension supplements for teachers who worked during the 1990s).
  - Limit further pension increases to the basic pension to reduce old-age poverty and align with social assistance.
  - Contain wage bill pressures: design public administration and health care reforms within the wage bill rule; reconsider the public salary law given large fiscal costs and proliferation of discretionary allowances and grandfathering exemptions.
  - Widen the contribution base and implement efficiency reforms ahead of health insurance introduction in 2020 to ensure financial viability.

- Publicly-owned enterprises (POEs) and contingent liabilities:
  - Accelerate restructuring of loss-making and inefficient POEs: right-size employment, align wages with productivity, and improve oversight.
  - Carefully assess sovereign guarantees linked to large projects (notably the proposed power plant) given potential cumulative exposure up to 20 percent of GDP.

- Contingency and fiscal governance measures:
  - Strengthen commitment to adjust spending for any revenue shortfalls from tax administration reforms by identifying specific non-priority spending items upfront and releasing appropriations only upon realization of additional revenue, with continuous monitoring and verification.
  - Retain the government bank balance of 4.5 percent of GDP as a buffer.

- Improve spending efficiency:
  - Address low spending efficiency reflected in poor education, health, and social outcomes despite increased allocations.
  - Strengthen the public investment framework through better project selection, execution, cost-benefit analysis, and ex-post audits.
  - Spread the spending of privatization proceeds over multiple years rather than frontloading to 2019 to ensure efficient use and preserve financial buffers for counter-cyclical policy needs.
  - Review social benefit amounts and eligibility to address double dipping and labor market disincentives and to better target the poor.

- Implementation emphasis:
  - Tax administration gains assumed in the 2019 draft budget (0.6 percent of GDP) require strong implementation in revenue administration reforms.
  - The draft budget assumes a ¼ percent of GDP saving from war veteran benefit reform which may not materialize; staff advises prudence and contingency planning.

*IMF staff summary based on “1. Recent Economic Developments, 2012-18” (cr18368).*

### 16.      In the medium term, the fiscal space for priority donor/IFI-financed investment will

### 16.      In the medium term, the fiscal space for priority donor/IFI-financed investment will

### Fiscal space, debt ceilings, and guarantees
- Total debt approaching 30 percent of GDP will narrow fiscal space for priority donor/IFI-financed investment (debt ceiling under the investment clause).
- The 30 percent of GDP debt limit must be respected to keep public debt on a sustainable path, even under moderate shocks (see Annex IV—MAC DSA).
- Kosovo’s euroized economy has limited buffers and policy tools to deal with unforeseen events.
- Any issuing of guarantees should be:
  - Carefully considered.
  - Contingent debt from public enterprises and local government included under the ceiling.
  - Subject to the existing conservative approach in issuing and recording guarantees, including:
    - Requirement to obtain parliament approval.
    - Count guarantees in full as debt.

### Medium-term fiscal risks and policy-sensitive initiatives
- Pension and social benefit reform:
  - Plans to reform the first pillar pension and social benefit system need to be part of a comprehensive plan to rationalize costly categorical benefit schemes while strengthening social assistance for the poor.
  - Any changes to the first pillar should be carefully designed to avoid creating large unfunded liabilities in the medium to long-term given population aging.
  - The second pillar pension system should be protected and maintained independent.
  - Limit double dipping and eligibility to residents.
- Power plant project:
  - The power plant, though structured as a PPP, is a large investment equal to 20 percent of GDP.
  - Risk allocation is skewed towards the government; the commercial agreement envisages the government assuming supply, financing, and market risks (by guaranteeing to purchase all output and a fixed rate of return), leaving only construction and operational risks with the private party.
  - Explicit guarantees for the power purchase and supply agreements (lignite, water, ash and gypsum disposal) in case of payment or performance breaches alone are expected to add up to 5-6 percent of GDP.
  - The project carries significant fiscal risks and would crowd out fiscal space given:
    - Debt brake in the fiscal rule’s investment clause of 30 percent of GDP.
    - Overall debt ceiling of 40 percent of GDP.
  - Policy guidance:
    - Secure the most cost-effective solution for Kosovo’s energy supply, including improving energy efficiency.
    - Structure any project to ensure financial and economic viability.
    - Set tariffs at cost recovery levels to avoid subsidies.
    - Mitigate impact of tariff increases on the poor with well-targeted transfers under the social assistance scheme.
    - Minimize additional government support through financing or guarantees; any such support should be consistent with public debt sustainability without crowding out other priority investments.

### Infrastructure, social spending, education, health, and spending efficiency (selected recommendations)
- INFRASTRUCTURE
  - Improve project appraisal.
  - Ensure alignment with the MT infrastructure framework.
  - Centralize PIUs within each relevant budget organization.
  - Regularly monitor projects; externally audit large contracts.
- SOCIAL SPENDING
  - Rationalize existing and refrain from new untargeted schemes.
  - Reform war veterans pension and disability benefits.
  - Remove employment status eligibility criteria.
  - Increase allocation for poverty-targeted schemes.
  - Maintain the independence of the 2nd pillar pension.
- EDUCATION
  - Strengthen TVET to match labor market needs.
  - Improve teacher training and qualification combined with performance assessment.
  - Update curricula, standards, and text books.
  - Expand pre-primary education.
  - Establish independent accreditation agency.
  - Create database to monitor student and teacher performance.
- HEALTH
  - Strengthen primary and preventive care.
  - Centralize procurement and establish a competitive pricing mechanism for drugs and other supplies.
  - Update “essential list” to cover most cost-effective drugs and introduce co-payments.
  - Minimize health care treatment abroad.
  - Deploy health information system to control costs.
  - Move to diagnosis-related group payments in the medium term.

### Revenue mobilization, tax reform, and financing strategy
- Revenue context and reform scope:
  - Kosovo’s revenue collection is some 10 percentage points below the average for emerging Europe with a narrow tax base.
  - There is ample scope to mobilize more revenue beyond projected gains from tax administration reform.
  - Ongoing tax reforms provide an opportunity to review tax exemptions and rates as well as revenue collected at the municipal level, particularly from property tax.
- Financing diversification and risk reduction:
  - Until late 2017, government debt issuance was largely absorbed by the CBK through secondary market purchases; the pension fund KPST has absorbed the bulk since 2018.
  - With a normalization of EU monetary policy and banks already at their current exposure limits, it will be more difficult to place further government debt in the domestic market.
  - Financing should be diversified by:
    - Widening the investor base.
    - Exploring new instruments (e.g., retail or external bonds).
    - Further extending the maturity profile (averaging 2 years) of domestic debt.
  - Any external placement in the medium term needs to be preceded by careful assessment of market conditions, progress in reducing country risk, and development of a comprehensive debt management strategy.
  - CBK’s holdings of government securities should be gradually reduced.
  - The bank balance of 4.5 percent of GDP should be maintained (even though the draft budget envisages a drop in the bank balance to 3.5 percent of GDP in 2021).
  - Exposure limits of the private pension fund KPST should be respected.
  - The government may need to target a tighter fiscal deficit than currently mandated under the fiscal rule.
- Note on KPST: Per GFSM 2014, KPST contributions are not government revenue because KPST is an independent body and not a government unit.

### Strengthening fiscal institutions and governance (findings and recommendations)
- Strengthening fiscal institutions and governance will contribute to higher tax collection, spending efficiency, and reduced corruption vulnerabilities (see Governance Assessment—Annex V).
- The draft law on public enterprises aims to improve financial oversight, accountability, and financial performance of the sector and is a welcome step.
- Electronic procurement should be rolled out as envisaged; assess scope to widen coverage of centralized procurement and address capacity constraints to ensure value-for-money.
- Tax administration improvements:
  - Introduction of an automatic risk-based VAT refund system.
  - Plans to strengthen debt collection by setting performance targets and centralizing the collection function at HQ.
  - Undertake cost-benefit assessments of tax expenditures and annually publish estimates of revenue foregone from tax expenditures as part of budget documents to increase transparency.

Selected consolidated recommendations (excerpt)
- Tax expenditures:
  - Regulate all tax expenditures in primary legislation, with clear criteria, and rationalize existing ones.
  - Quantify costs of tax expenditure and report them annually with the budget.
  - Strengthen enforcement of public consultation procedures to increase transparency.
- Revenue administration:
  - Set publicly available performance targets and regularly publish outcomes.
  - Strengthen HQ control over key tax administration functions.
  - Scale up tax debt collection while ensuring equal treatment.
  - Align resources with compliance risk.
- Public procurement:
  - Widen coverage of centralized procurement and improve “value for money”.
  - Make e-procurement mandatory.
  - Strengthen capacity of the Central Procurement Agency and improve transparency and accountability of the Procurement Review Body.
- Publicly-Owned Enterprises (POEs):
  - Strengthen joint oversight of POEs by the Ministry of Finance and Ministry of Economic Development.
  - Improve timeliness and focus of the POE Monitoring Unit’s reports to deepen financial risk analysis and ensure such information is available for the budget process.
  - Ensure independent supervisory boards and run POEs on a commercial basis.
  - Publish POEs financial statements on a timely basis audited by reputable companies.
- Public Investment Framework:
  - Improve project appraisal and selection.
  - Undertake ex-post review and external audits of large-scale projects.
  - Ensure alignment of national strategies with the budget.

### Authorities’ views on fiscal policy and financing
- Concurrence with staff:
  - Authorities concurred with staff’s assessment and agreed that the fiscal rule (i.e., deficit and wage bill ceilings, and bank balance floor) remains an appropriate anchor and are firmly committed to preserving it, as reflected in the 2019 budget.
  - They welcomed staff recommendations on strengthening tax administration and committed to their implementation in 2019.
  - They viewed spending pressures as containable or absorptive by built-in buffers; safeguards are in place to reduce spending equivalent to any shortfall in revenues from tax administration reforms.
  - Any guarantees for the power plant, if deemed necessary, will be contained within existing debt limit rules.
- Differences and plans:
  - On ramp-up in public investment and possible financing pressures, authorities noted:
    - Use of privatization proceeds is tied to viable projects and demand pressures will be contained given spare capacity.
    - Confidence that new domestic debt issuance can be absorbed in the near term, albeit possibly at a higher cost.
    - Plans to diversify sources of financing in the medium term, possibly including tapping the Eurobond market in 2020.

### Structural reforms: labor market, competitiveness, and governance
- Labor market findings:
  - Kosovo’s labor market is characterized by low labor force participation and high unemployment rates.
  - Drivers include high public-sector wages, an above average minimum wage, reservation wages influenced by social benefit design and large remittances inflows.
- Recommended reforms:
  - Prioritize reforms to increase preschool enrollment rates, improve quality of teaching staff, modernize curricula and textbooks, upgrade vocational education and training (TVET) programs, and improve labor market intermediation.
  - Remove adverse labor market incentives in social benefits design (e.g., employment-linked eligibility criteria and high benefit amounts).
  - Promote female labor force participation by expanding affordable childcare and reducing gender bias in hiring.
  - Re-establish the rules-based minimum wage setting mechanism established in 2013 (staff advised this in light of proposed minimum wage hikes).
- Risks from fiscal initiatives:
  - Proposed excessively generous maternity/parental benefits could undermine women’s position in the labor market.
  - New public salary law will increase public-sector wages, raising pressure on private sector wages.
  - A proposed minimum wage hike risks pushing more low-skilled and young workers into informality.
  - Such initiatives could crowd out more productive spending and undermine competitiveness and growth.

- Business climate and governance:
  - Private sector development is held back by human and physical capital gaps and emigration of skilled labor.
  - Kosovo has a wide infrastructure gap relative to the region and the EU, including energy supply.
  - Governance improvements would improve the business climate and attract investment:
    - Reduce informality through revenue administration reforms.
    - Strengthen rule of law (contract enforcement, property rights).
    - Move forward with new law on risk-based inspections, implement law on licensing requirements, and reduce administrative burdens to lower the cost of doing business.

### Financial sector: stability and deepening (key findings and risks)
- Overall soundness and emerging liquidity concerns:
  - Kosovo’s financial sector remains broadly sound, though liquidity is tightening.
  - Reported capital and liquidity buffers are ample and banks’ capacity to absorb shocks remains strong.
  - NPLs are below 3 percent of total loans—the lowest in the region—reflecting robust growth in economic activity, dividends from past reforms to strengthen collateral enforcement, and continued write-off of NPLs.
  - Insurance sector is 3 percent of the financial system and has returned to profitability since mid-2017, though 3 out of 15 insurance companies are undercapitalized.
- Credit growth and monitoring needs:
  - Robust credit growth continues to support the economy; credit penetration remains low by regional standards but has continued to increase (mainly to trade and construction).
  - Factors facilitating credit growth: low interest rates, easing of credit standards, and KCGF guarantees of loans to SMEs.
  - With strong growth in property lending (beyond mortgages), amid signs of a supply overhang in the capital, authorities should:
    - Closely monitor the market.
    - Develop a housing price index or create a centralized registry of property valuations to convey the price signal of the property market.
- Additional indicators and metrics (as reported)
  - Regulatory capital to risk weighted assets: 16.1 (latest reported), 12.0, 17.5 (comparative entries shown in table).
  - NPL to total loans: 2.6 (latest reported), N.A., 7.9.
  - ROA: 2.1, N.A., 2.0.
  - Liquid assets to short-term liabilities: 36.3, 25.0, 35.1.
  - Bank balance target: maintain 4.5 percent of GDP; draft budget envisages a drop to 3.5 percent of GDP in 2021.

*Source: IMF staff report text as provided.*

### 31.      Remaining structural impediments to lending need to be reduced to facilitate further

### Remaining structural impediments to lending need to be reduced to facilitate further financial deepening

### Structural impediments to lending and legal/administrative reforms
- Fully implement the law on enforcement procedures.
- Accelerate resolution of commercial cases by:
  - having more specialized judges,
  - prioritizing commercial cases,
  - creating a commercial court.
- Strengthen property registration and the cadaster system (Annex V referenced).
- Ensure legislation regulating and widening the range of activities of micro-financial institutions (MFIs) and CBK regulation allowing for creation of investment funds:
  - are designed to ensure fair competition between MFIs and the banking system,
  - safeguard prudential and consumer protection standards.

### Supervisory framework and CBK initiatives
- Widened co-operation with regional authorities and the ECB for joint inspections of foreign owned banks and exchange of information.
- CBK actions and plans:
  - drafted a plan to incorporate the Basel III framework,
  - prepared for IFRS9 implementation in 2019,
  - intends to develop macroprudential instruments for non-bank financial institutions,
  - drafted risk-based supervision manuals for the pension and insurance sectors.
- CBK plans a new medium-term reform strategy:
  - With nearly all 2012 FSAP recommendations implemented (see 2017 Article IV), the CBK requested a Financial Sector Stability Review (FSSR) in early 2019 to inform a new 5-year strategy and planned legislative changes,
  - planned legislative changes include ongoing revisions to the banking law and possible revisions to the CBK law.

### AML/CFT (PECK II) assessment
- The PECK II assessment offers an opportunity to address remaining deficiencies and improve effectiveness.
- Preliminary outcome (shared with staff) signals:
  - legislative framework has improved since PECK I assessment in 2014,
  - outstanding shortcomings remain, including third-party reliance issues and customer due diligence process,
  - authorities have made progress in implementing the legal framework, but efforts should continue.
- Effective implementation of the regime would support anti-corruption efforts.

### Authorities’ views
- Authorities agreed with staff’s views on the health of the financial sector but are more sanguine on credit growth and risk.
- Authorities’ assessments:
  - credit growth reflects healthy financial deepening and low credit penetration relative to peers,
  - reduction in interest rates widened access to previously credit-constrained sectors such as agriculture and manufacturing,
  - expect interest rates to decline further amid strong competition and improvements in contract enforcement, which coupled with still ample deposits will facilitate continued strong credit growth,
  - closely monitoring developments in the real estate market but assess risks as contained given low NPL ratios in this sector and that loan growth comes from a low base,
  - expressed interest in developing a house price index.

### Data and statistical capacity
- Data remain adequate for surveillance purposes: fiscal and financial sector data are of good quality and are timely and available.
- Authorities need to make further efforts to implement past recommendations to improve quality and timeliness of real sector data.
- Strengthening capacity of statistical agencies is recommended.

### Staff appraisal — macro-financial stability and fiscal position
- Prudent fiscal and financial policies helped preserve macro-financial stability while growth remains robust.
- Key points:
  - the economy continues to grow at a healthy clip, outpacing Kosovo’s neighbors,
  - fiscal discipline has been maintained, reflected in a 2018 budget deficit that is expected to remain well-below the fiscal rule’s ceiling,
  - financial soundness indicators continued to improve,
  - external position remains moderately weaker than implied by fundamentals and desirable medium-term policy settings,
  - reserves are low in regional comparison but at comfortable levels using standard metrics,
  - together with a government bank balance of 4.5 percent of GDP at the CBK they provide sufficient cushion for external, fiscal or financial shocks.

### Structural challenges and policy priorities
- Persisting structural issues: underdeveloped private and export sector, widespread informality, reliance on remittances, high unemployment and inactivity rates, large trade deficit.
- Policy priorities:
  - tackle structural fiscal, financial sector, product and labor market reforms to create jobs and reduce unemployment and outward migration,
  - avoid stalling important structural reforms or introducing fiscally costly, populist initiatives.

### Fiscal rule, budget execution, and financing
- The fiscal rule remains an appropriate anchor for fiscal policy and underpins the 2019 budget, though execution risks are significant.
- The 2019 budget:
  - accommodates large pension increases and space for other wage and social benefit initiatives,
  - relies on large and uncertain gains from reforms in tax administration and war veteran benefits.
- Recommendations:
  - limit specific non-priority spending until targeted revenue gains are realized,
  - diversify financing needs to reduce roll-over risks and avoid crowding out credit to the private sector,
  - gradually reduce the central bank’s holdings of government securities.

### Revenue administration and tax policy
- Revenue remains some 10 percent below the regional average and the tax base is narrow.
- Recommended actions:
  - accelerate revenue administration reforms and overhaul tax and customs administration to reduce informality and large tax gaps and tax debts,
  - include strong safeguards when changing import VAT collection to protect tax revenues,
  - avoid granting new tax expenditures and review existing ones,
  - consider room to increase tax rates in the medium term given they are still low by regional standards.

### Fiscal risks and public finances
- To contain fiscal risks and avoid crowding out pro-growth spending within the fiscal rule:
  - move ahead with war veteran reforms and resist introducing new benefits schemes (teachers, police, others),
  - any pension increase should be limited to the basic pension only,
  - redesign public administration and health care reforms to fit within the wage bill rule,
  - advance plans to restructure public enterprises,
  - ensure any government support for the new power plant through guarantees or financing is consistent with the fiscal rule and public debt sustainability,
  - protect the second pension pillar in planned pension reforms and avoid creating sizeable unfunded liabilities in the medium term.

### Spending efficiency and governance
- Spending efficiency needs to be significantly enhanced to improve outcomes and support growth.
- Policy measures:
  - social benefit reform to create space for investment in education, health, judiciary, active labor market policies, and infrastructure,
  - complement additional spending with efficiency-enhancing reforms,
  - accelerate reforms strengthening fiscal institutions: tax administration, public procurement, public investment, and public enterprise management to improve spending efficiency, transparency, accountability and reduce corruption vulnerabilities.

### Policies to promote growth and job creation
- Reorient policies from spending initiatives toward removing structural constraints:
  - restrain wage and social benefit growth,
  - promote female labor force participation,
  - upgrade skills and reduce mismatches via better access and quality of education and vocational training,
  - reduce infrastructure bottlenecks,
  - strengthen the rule of law and reduce red tape.
- Avoid or redesign fiscal initiatives that would be costly and undermine reforms (examples cited: public salary law, excessively generous maternity/parental benefits, large minimum wage hike).

### Financial sector soundness and access
- The financial sector remains sound but access could be further improved.
- Observations and recommendations:
  - with double-digit credit growth, remain vigilant for possible pockets of risk and differentiate healthy financial deepening from potentially excessive credit growth,
  - credit depth remains low in regional comparison and structural impediments to lending should be further reduced,
  - repeat recommended actions: fully implement the law on enforcement procedures, accelerate resolution of commercial cases, and strengthen property rights.

*Source: cr18368 - IMF country report excerpt.*

### 45.      It is recommended that the next Article IV consultation takes place on the standard

### It is recommended that the next Article IV consultation takes place on the standard 12-month cycle.

### Article IV timing
- It is recommended that the next Article IV consultation takes place on the standard 12-month cycle.

### Recent economic developments (2012–18)
- Growth remains robust and broad-based, driven by consumption, investment and service exports.
- The current account deficit remains large due to a sizable negative trade balance, but continued to be financed by FDI and other investment.
- Unemployment has improved slightly, although employment has declined.
- Headline inflation has started to pick up, but core inflation remains slightly negative.
- Sources cited: Haver Analytics; Kosovo Agency of Statistics; Central Bank of Kosovo; Haver; WEO; IMF staff estimates.

### Fiscal developments and projections (2013–19; budget and fiscal rule)
- In 2018, the budget deficit is projected to widen, while remaining within the fiscal rule deficit limits.
- Total revenue collection is projected to stay close to the 2017 level.
- Current spending will continue to increase driven by higher social benefits and goods and services.
- Capital spending is projected to recover on the back of projects under the investment clause.
- The bank balance has been largely kept above the 4.5 percent of GDP floor, providing an important buffer.
- Domestic debt has been on a steady increase, reducing the capacity to absorb more debt.
- Sources: Kosovo authorities, IMF staff estimates.

### Fiscal policy assessment and recommendations (Areas / Recommendations / Status)
- Fiscal policy: Improve efficiency of spending and broaden revenue — Status: Mixed compliance.
  - Comply with the fiscal rule and diversify sources of financing — Status: Good compliance.
    - The 2018 budget is on track to meet the fiscal rule deficit and wage bill ceilings; and the bank balance has been kept above 4.5 percent of GDP (except for two months). PAK legislation was modified to allow it to invest in government securities.
  - Contain current spending (reform social benefits; resist wage and benefit pressures) — Status: Weak compliance.
    - Current spending is set to increase by ¾ percent of GDP this year, in part due to non-implementation of social benefit reforms, such as of the war veteran scheme. While the wage bill is expected to stay within the wage bill rule limit, wage hikes for high-level public officials absorbed the space for hiring in priority sectors such as the judiciary and health.
  - Strengthen public investment framework; Increase IFI-financed investment — Status: Partial compliance.
    - Progress slow despite adoption of a roadmap for the National Development Strategy and definition of procedures for selection/classification of capital projects (adoption pending technical issues). Existing tools and budget execution practices (PIP, KFMIS) need upgrading. No ex-post audits of major investment projects initiated. Absorption of donor-financed investment under the investment clause has been zero; staffing of PIUs and expropriation bottlenecks largely addressed.
  - Strengthen tax administration, avoid new exemptions, and explore scope for additional revenue — Status: Partial compliance.
    - Implementation slow in performance management, return filing enforcement, debt management, and risk-based audit. New tax exemptions for IT and spare parts introduced. VAT refund system automatized with risk-based audits; share of VAT refund requests processed claimed to have risen from 62 to 90 percent within the 30-day benchmark (could be improved for exporters).

### Labor market and human capital
- Improve labor productivity and reduce high unemployment — Status: Weak compliance.
- Advance reforms to reduce skill mismatches — Status: Weak compliance.
  - Action plans and sector strategies adopted, but reforms to increase preschool enrollment rates, improve quality of teaching staff, modernize curricula and textbooks, upgrade vocational education and training programs, strengthen accreditation and professional standards, and improve labor market intermediation remain at an early stage.
- From Figure 3: Kosovo has the lowest employment in the region, a large share employed in the public sector, very high inactivity and unemployment rates (particularly among youth and women), low education attainment, excessive social benefits, and a high minimum wage.
- Sources: KAS; OECD; ILO; Eurostat; SEE Jobs Gateway Database; WEO and IMF staff estimates.

### Banking sector and financial soundness (2014–18)
- Credit growth remains robust, mainly due to lending to the trade and construction sectors.
- Lending rates around 6 to 7 percent supported credit growth.
- With deposit growth lagging credit growth, liquidity in the banking system has started to decline.
- Asset quality further improved, and banks remain well-capitalized and profitable, despite some decline since the 2015 peak.
- Based on data available as of end of September 2018. Sources: Central Bank of Kosovo, IMF staff estimates.

### Key quantitative indicators and projections (selected extracts)
- Real GDP growth: 2015 4.1; 2016 4.1; 2017 4.2; 2018 4.0; 2019 4.2; 2020 4.0; 2021 4.0; 2022 4.0; 2023 4.0.
- Contribution to growth — Consumption (total): 2015 4.7; 2016 4.7; 2017 1.5; 2018 5.6; 2019 2.9; 2020 3.9; 2021 3.8; 2022 3.3; 2023 3.3.
- Official unemployment (percent of workforce) 1/: 2015 32.9; 2016 27.5; 2017 30.5; 2018 29.4. (1/ 2018 as of June 2018.)
- CPI, period average: 2015 -0.5; 2016 0.3; 2017 1.5; 2018 0.9; 2019 1.4; 2020 1.7; 2021 1.8; 2022 1.9; 2023 2.0.
- General government budget (percent of GDP) — Revenues and grants: 2015 25.1; 2016 26.3; 2017 26.2; 2018 26.1; 2019 26.9; 2020 26.1; 2021 26.2; 2022 25.7; 2023 25.5.
- Overall Balance Ex-PAK ex-IFI capital projects (Fiscal rule) 3/: 2015 -1.8; 2016 -1.2; 2017 -1.2; 2018 -1.5; 2019 -1.9; 2020 -1.9; 2021 -1.9; 2022 -1.9; 2023 -1.9. (3/ For fiscal rule purposes, only projects post-July 2015 apply.)
- Total public debt 4/: 2015 13.0; 2016 14.3; 2017 16.3; 2018 17.0; 2019 19.6; 2020 22.2; 2021 24.2; 2022 26.1; 2023 27.4. (4/ Includes guarantees, but no longer includes former Yugoslavia debt which has been reclassified as a contingent liability.)
- Current account balance, incl. official transfers (percent of GDP): 2015 -8.6; 2016 -7.9; 2017 -6.4; 2018 -6.9; 2019 -8.3; 2020 -7.9; 2021 -7.2; 2022 -7.0; 2023 -6.6.
- Net foreign assets of CBK (millions of euros): 2015 1,046; 2016 895; 2017 939; 2018 937; 2019 856; 2020 887; 2021 967; 2022 1,000; 2023 1,021.
- Gross international reserves (millions of euros): 2015 1,245; 2016 1,082; 2017 1,168; 2018 1,165; 2019 1,084; 2020 1,115; 2021 1,195; 2022 1,228; 2023 1,249.
- Banking sector indicators (selected): Regulatory capital to risk weighted assets: 2015 19.0; 2016 17.9; 2017 18.1; 2018 16.1. NPL to total loans 2/: 2015 6.2; 2016 4.9; 2017 3.1; 2018 2.6. (2/ 2018 as of September 2018.)
- Consolidated government budget (millions of euros, selected rows): Revenue and grants (2015) 1,456; (2016) 1,595; (2017) 1,682; (2018) 1,817; (2019) 1,763; (2020) 1,949; (2021) 1,910; (2022) 1,970; (2023) 2,070.
- Consolidated government budget (percent of GDP, selected rows): Revenue and grants: 2015 25.1; 2016 26.3; 2017 26.2; 2018 26.1; 2019 26.9; 2020 26.1; 2021 26.2; 2022 25.7; 2023 25.5.
- General government cashflow (millions of euros, Financing Needs): 2015 498; 2016 473; 2017 491; 2018 576; 2019 785; 2020 830; 2021 841; 2022 755; 2023 790.
- Balance of Payments (millions of euros, Current account): 2015 -497; 2016 -481; 2017 -413; 2018 -467; 2019 -591; 2020 -592; 2021 -570; 2022 -594; 2023 -590.
- Financial account (percent of GDP): 2015 -5.4; 2016 -3.3; 2017 -5.1; 2018 -5.6; 2019 -7.0; 2020 -6.6; 2021 -5.8; 2022 -5.7; 2023 -5.2.

### Implementation status highlights
- Good compliance: meeting fiscal rule deficit and wage bill ceilings in 2018; bank balance kept above 4.5 percent of GDP (except two months); PAK allowed to invest in government securities.
- Partial compliance: public investment framework and IFI-financed investment progress slow; tax administration reforms incomplete; VAT refund processing improved operationally.
- Weak compliance: containment of current spending; social benefit reforms not implemented; labor market and education reforms remain at an early stage.

*Source: Republic of Kosovo — IMF staff report (cr18368), selected figures and tables as presented in the source document.*

### Annex I. Implementation Status of the 2017 Article IV Recommendations

### Annex I. Implementation Status of the 2017 Article IV Recommendations

### Keep minimum wage increases in check
- Status: Partial compliance.
- Detail: The rules-based minimum wage setting mechanism has been abolished by removing the preconditions and formula from the 2013 administrative instruction (SB under the 2012-13 SBA), clearing the way for large discretionary increases. Notwithstanding, so far the authorities have abstained from any increases.

### Improve governance and business climate
- Status: Mixed compliance.

### Implement procurement and bankruptcy laws
- Status: Partial compliance.
- Detail: While capacity constraints (staff/IT) delayed the rollout of e-procurement and wider use of centralized procurement, these are being addressed with the support of donors. Paper bids will no longer be allowed as of 2019. With 2 out of 5 members suspended on corruption charges, the functioning of the Procurement Review Body (PRB) is at risk. The new bankruptcy law has been underutilized, in part due to limited professional capacities, unawareness among firms, and weak claims enforcement.

### Strengthen effectiveness of the anti-corruption regime
- Status: Partial compliance.
- Detail: A new law on the prevention of conflict of interest in public functions has been adopted. Revisions to the criminal code extending the statute of limitations and penalties for corruption and organized crime charges and increasing the ban from public office for convicts are awaiting second reading in parliament. Draft laws on asset confiscation and the protection of whistleblowers have been submitted to parliament. However, revisions to the criminal procedures code strengthening provisions on search and confiscation, admissibility of evidence, and time limit for investigations have yet to be submitted to parliament. A package of laws to strengthen asset declaration and give more robust powers to the Anti-Corruption Agency is pending the findings of the ongoing functional review of the justice system.

### Restructure POEs and improve their governance
- Status: Partial compliance.
- Detail: A draft law on POEs has been prepared that aims to tighten governance of POEs and give the government as shareholder the tools to restructure POEs, remove board members, harmonize remuneration, etc. The responsible ministry is working with donors to design a restructuring plan to contain losses in the public telecommunication company and restore its medium-term viability.

### Financial Sector: Access to credit
- Status: Mixed compliance.

### Reduce structural bottlenecks to lending
- Status: Mixed compliance.
- Detail: Broad-based credit growth in part reflects the easing of supply constraints as reforms make the claims enforcement system more effective. Yet, further steps are needed to strengthen contract enforcement and reduce information asymmetries.

*Source: Annex I. Implementation Status of the 2017 Article IV Recommendations*

### Annex IV. Debt Sustainability Analysis

### Annex IV. Debt Sustainability Analysis

### Key Assumptions
- The DSA analysis is fully consistent with the macroeconomic framework baseline.
- Growth is projected to be at 4 percent in 2018 and the medium term.
- The fiscal deficit, excluding IFI-financed projects and projects financed by non-debt creating financial flows (privatization proceeds), is expected to remain within the 2-percent of GDP fiscal rule deficit ceiling throughout the projection period.
- Public debt includes only general government debt and explicit guarantees issued by the government. Debt by POEs (estimated at around 5-7 percent of GDP) is not included.
- Contingent liabilities with respect to PAK financing (about 1.5 percent of GDP) or contingent liabilities associated with the possible development of the power plant project are not included.
- The share of the domestic debt is almost two-thirds of total debt.
- The external public debt is largely owed to multilaterals: IDA, EIB, EBRD and the IMF.
- Debt contracted under former Yugoslavia (estimated at 4.5 percent of GDP at end–2017) is not included in total debt but treated as a contingent liability.
- Financing assumptions:
  - Average maturity of domestic debt is projected to increase from 2.2 to 3.5 years.
  - Short-term domestic debt is projected to decrease from currently 15 percent of total debt to 3 percent.
  - The privatization fund PAK would transfer some 286 million of earlier privatization proceeds to the budget over the years 2018-2020.
  - Maintaining a prudent buffer of 4.5 percent of GDP in government deposits with the CBK would require additional financing of 1.4 percent of GDP over the projected period.
  - IFI financing reflects the financial terms currently provided.

### Public DSA — Findings and Vulnerabilities
- Debt trajectory:
  - General government debt is projected to increase from 16 percent of GDP in 2017 to 27 percent of GDP by 2023 under the baseline.
  - Increase is driven by rapid absorption of IFI financing for new capital investments, particularly regional connectivity projects within the Western Balkans Investment Framework.
- Gross financing needs:
  - Average gross financing needs are 9.6 percent over 2018-2023, compared to 7.2 percent during 2013–2017.
  - Gross financing needs rise despite assumed lengthening of maturity because of an increased public debt stock.
- Market absorption and financing composition risks:
  - Kosovo does not have external market access; the domestic market's capacity to absorb higher government debt is increasingly reduced.
  - Current holders of domestic debt: public entities, individuals, private businesses, and insurance companies currently hold less than 5 percent of total domestic debt.
  - Recommendation to reduce CBK holdings of government securities and not to increase the exposure limit for KPST to more than 30 percent of its assets.
  - Explore new instruments (retail or external bonds) contingent on progress in reducing country risk and improving international market access.
  - Private financing of public infrastructure projects is noted as an attractive option if supported by a sound PPP framework to limit fiscal risks.
- Sensitivity to contingent liabilities:
  - Guarantees requested for the new power plant project could lift debt above the 30 percent of GDP ceiling considered prudent.
  - Contingent liabilities shocks modeled:
    - POEs modeled at 5 percent of GDP would have a large impact on the debt profile.
    - Financing of PAK at 1.5 percent of GDP would have a large impact on the debt profile.
  - Materialization of former-Yugoslav debt (estimated at 4.5 percent of GDP at end–2017, assumed to decline over time) does not have a significant impact on the current debt path.
- Scenario notes:
  - The alternative scenarios of primary balances at the historical or 2017 level show a more favorable debt profile relative to the baseline, because the baseline assumes an increase in the primary deficit to accommodate higher investments.

### External DSA — Findings
- External debt-to-GDP ratio:
  - Expected to remain stable at around 22 percent of GDP over the medium term.
- External borrowing composition and projections:
  - External public borrowing will increase from 6.3 percent of GDP in 2018 to 7.4 percent of GDP by 2023, on account of IFIs-financed investments.
  - External private borrowing is expected to remain at 14.5 percent of GDP.
  - Most external public debt is held by multilateral creditors: 86 percent of total external public debt.
  - Currency composition: About 60 percent of external public debt is denominated in euros, followed by SDRs (IMF and IDA loans).
- Gross financing needs drivers:
  - Large gross financing needs reflect the assumption that all private debt is of a short-term nature, as it largely consists of short-term credit from foreign parent banks.

### Policy Priorities and Recommendations
- Continued compliance with the fiscal rule remains the key anchor to preserve fiscal sustainability.
- Extend the maturity of domestic debt and diversify sources of financing to contain financing risks.
- Increase average maturity of domestic debt stock and expand the domestic investor base (public entities, individuals, private businesses, insurance companies).
- Reduce CBK holdings of government securities while respecting the KPST exposure limit of not more than 30 percent of its assets.
- Explore new instruments (retail or external bonds) contingent on improved country risk and market access.
- Consider well-designed private financing of public infrastructure projects under a sound PPP framework to limit fiscal risks.

*Annex IV. Debt Sustainability Analysis (cr18368).*

### 8.      External debt remains sustainable under a range of shocks. Standardized stress tests

### 8.      External debt remains sustainable under a range of shocks. Standardized stress tests

### Summary of stress-test findings
- Standardized stress tests indicate external debt is mainly sensitive to a current account shock.
- The current account scenario: permanently increases the non-interest current account by one-half standard deviation in 2019–23 (around 1½ percent of GDP).
- Under that scenario, in the absence of offsetting non-debt-creating flows:
  - External debt increases by about 7 percentage points to 29 percent of GDP by 2023.
  - Gross financing needs in 2023 increase by 4 percentage points of GDP relative to the baseline.
- The current account shock highlights risks such as a sharp contraction in remittances and/or a drop in commodity exports; however, for remittances any decline is expected to be largely offset by a contextual decline in imports.

### Baseline public debt projections and key indicators (selected series)
- Nominal gross public debt (percent of GDP): 2016 9.2, 2017 14.3, 2018 16.3, 2019 17.0, 2020 19.7, 2021 22.2, 2022 24.2, 2023 26.1, 2023 (alternate cell) 27.4
- Public gross financing needs (percent of GDP): 2016 5.7, 2017 7.6, 2018 6.4, 2019 8.3, 2020 10.8, 2021 10.8, 2022 10.3, 2023 8.7, 2023 (alternate cell) 8.6, 5Y CDS (bp) N/A
- Real GDP growth (percent): 2016 3.2, 2017 4.1, 2018 4.2, 2019 4.0, 2020 4.2, 2021 4.0, 2022 4.0, 2023 4.0
- Inflation (GDP deflator, percent): 2016 2.4, 2017 0.4, 2018 1.4, 2019 1.3, 2020 1.0, 2021 1.6, 2022 1.8, 2023 1.9, 2.1 (last cell)
- Nominal GDP growth (percent): 2016 5.7, 2017 4.5, 2018 5.7, 2019 5.3, 2020 5.2, 2021 5.7, 2022 5.9, 2023 6.0, 6.2 (last cell)
- Effective interest rate (percent): 2016 3.0, 2017 2.6, 2018 2.2, 2019 2.4, 2020 2.5, 2021 2.6, 2022 2.7, 2023 2.7, 2.7 (last cell)
- Change in gross public sector debt (cumulative): 2016 1.4, 2017 1.3, 2018 2.0, 2019 0.7, 2020 2.6, 2021 2.5, 2022 2.0, 2023 1.8, cumulative 1.3, 11.1

### Composition of public debt, alternative scenarios, and realism checks
- Alternative scenarios shown: Baseline, Historical, Constant Primary Balance.
- Under "Composition of Public Debt" charts and projections, gross nominal public debt and public gross financing needs are tracked through 2016–2023 by maturity (short-term; medium and long-term) and by currency (local currency-denominated; foreign currency-denominated).
- Realism assessments and forecast track records show:
  - Real GDP growth and Primary Balance forecast errors and percentile ranks (Kosovo forecast errors presented versus interquartile ranges).
  - Kosovo has had a positive output gap for 3 consecutive years, 2015–2017.
  - Kosovo 3-year CAPB adjustment percentile rank: 27%.
  - Kosovo 3-year average CAPB level percentile rank: 84%.

### Stress-test scenarios and macro-fiscal impacts (selected scenario outputs)
- Primary Balance Shock (selected years): Real GDP growth 2018 4.0, 2019 4.2, 2020 4.0; Inflation 2018 1.3, 2019 1.0; Primary balance 2018 -2.5, 2019 -4.7, 2020 -4.1; Effective interest rate 2018 2.4, 2019 2.5, 2020 2.6.
- Real GDP Growth Shock: Real GDP growth 2018 4.0, 2019 3.2, 2020 3.0; Inflation 2018 1.3, 2019 0.7, 2020 1.4; Primary balance 2018 -2.5, 2019 -5.1, 2020 -4.2.
- Real Interest Rate Shock: Effective interest rate 2018 2.4, 2019 2.5, 2020 3.6, 2021 4.2, 2022 4.4, 2023 4.5.
- Real Exchange Rate Shock: Inflation 2019 6.0 (noted as shock), effective interest rates vary modestly.
- Combined Shock: Real GDP growth 2018 4.0, 2019 3.2, 2020 3.0; Primary balance 2018 -2.5, 2019 -5.1, 2020 -4.2; Effective interest rate 2018 2.4, 2019 2.6, 2020 3.5, 2021 4.1, 2022 4.4, 2023 4.5.
- Contingent liability scenarios (former‑Yugoslavia debt; Power Plant Guarantees; PAK/POEs) show higher projected gross nominal public debt and elevated public gross financing needs under specific contingent liability realizations.

### External Debt Sustainability Framework — key figures (Table 1 highlights)
- Baseline: External debt (percent of GDP): 2015 18.6, 2016 18.9, 2017 21.2, 2018 20.8, 2019 21.6, 2020 21.8, 2021 21.7, 2022 21.9, 2023 21.9; Debt-stabilizing non-interest current account -4.2.
- Change in external debt (percent of GDP): 2015 1.6, 2016 0.3, 2017 2.2, 2018 -0.4, 2019 0.8, 2020 0.2, 2021 -0.1, 2022 0.2, 2023 0.0.
- Identified external debt-creating flows (sum): 2015 4.3, 2016 4.2, 2017 1.4, 2018 4.1, 2019 4.4, 2020 4.0, 2021 3.2, 2022 3.2, 2023 2.8.
- Current account deficit, excluding interest payments (percent of GDP): 2015 8.4, 2016 7.8, 2017 6.3, 2018 6.7, 2019 8.1, 2020 7.7, 2021 7.0, 2022 6.9, 2023 6.5.
- Deficit in balance of goods and services (percent of GDP): 2015 28.5, 2016 27.2, 2017 25.9, 2018 28.7, 2019 29.6, 2020 29.2, 2021 28.5, 2022 28.0, 2023 27.4.
- Exports (percent of GDP): 2015 21.9, 2016 23.7, 2017 26.7, 2018 26.1, 2019 26.5, 2020 26.9, 2021 27.3, 2022 27.4, 2023 27.6.
- Imports (percent of GDP): 2015 50.4, 2016 50.9, 2017 52.5, 2018 54.8, 2019 56.1, 2020 56.1, 2021 55.7, 2022 55.4, 2023 55.0.
- Net non-debt creating capital inflows (negative, percent of GDP): 2015 -4.7, 2016 -2.9, 2017 -3.9, 2018 -2.1, 2019 -3.1, 2020 -3.1, 2021 -3.1, 2022 -3.0, 2023 -3.0.
- Automatic debt dynamics (percent of GDP contribution): 2015 0.6, 2016 -0.6, 2017 -0.9, 2018 -0.6, 2019 -0.7, 2020 -0.7, 2021 -0.7, 2022 -0.7, 2023 -0.7.
- External debt-to-exports ratio (percent): 2015 84.9, 2016 79.9, 2017 79.4, 2018 79.8, 2019 81.5, 2020 81.1, 2021 79.5, 2022 79.9, 2023 79.1.
- Gross external financing need (millions of EUR): 2015 1287, 2016 1241, 2017 1184, 2018 1380, 2019 1636, 2020 1724, 2021 1759, 2022 1814, 2023 1872.
- Gross external financing need (percent of GDP): 2015 20.0, 2016 18.5, 2017 16.4, 2018 17.2, 2019 19.7, 2020 19.4, 2021 18.5, 2022 17.9, 2023 17.3.

### Bound tests and scenario magnitudes (high-level)
- Bound tests apply permanent one-half standard deviation shocks to interest rate, growth rate, and current account balance; some scenarios apply permanent 1/4 standard deviation shocks or a one-time real depreciation of 30 percent in 2019.
- Representative scenario outcomes (labels from figures):
  - Interest rate shock: baseline 22; scenario 23.
  - CA shock: baseline 22; scenario 29.
  - Combined shock: baseline 22; scenario 26.
  - Real depreciation 30%: baseline 22; scenario 24.
  - Growth shock: baseline 22; scenario 23.
- Gross financing need under baseline is tracked on right scale in bound-test figures.

### Public DSA risk assessment (heat map highlights)
- Risk-assessment benchmarks and color-coding applied across indicators: bond spread (200 and 600 basis points thresholds), external financing requirement (5 and 15 percent of GDP), annual change in short-term public debt (0.5 and 1 percent), public debt held by non-residents (15 and 45 percent), share of foreign-currency denominated debt (20 and 60 percent).
- Selected indicator values (2017 or latest shown):
  - Bond spread: 20 / 60 (basis points) and country value 19% (context given in heat map table).
  - External financing requirement thresholds: 5 / 15 (percent of GDP); country value 12 (percent).
  - Annual change in short-term public debt thresholds: 0.5 / 1; country value -1% (annual change).
  - Public debt held by non-residents: thresholds 15 / 45; country value 41% (percent of total).
  - Public debt in foreign currency: thresholds 20 / 60; country value 12 (percent of total).

### Governance challenges with fiscal implications (Annex V excerpts)
- High-level vulnerabilities: deficiencies in tax policy, revenue administration, procurement, public investment, POEs; weak rule of law; large informal economy; weak institutional framework to fight high-level corruption.
- Tax Expenditures — Issues:
  - Current tax laws allow targeted discretionary tax expenditures (VAT exemptions; tax breaks and incentives under CIT/PIT laws) and flexibility implementing reduced VAT rate via secondary legislation.
  - Exemptions weaken VAT neutrality, distort production decisions, and take companies out of the VAT net; exemptions and income-tax incentives can cause revenue losses and inefficiencies.
- Tax Expenditures — Institutional weaknesses:
  - Some eligibility criteria for tax exemptions/incentives are relegated to secondary legislation, leaving de jure discretion for the Minister of Finance.
  - Secondary legislation generally requires public consultation and fiscal impact assessment (not consistently enforced).
  - Names of beneficiaries are currently published, but their costs are not regularly published; no requirement for a consistent policy gap/tax expenditure assessment.
- Tax Expenditures — Key recommendations:
  - Regulate all tax expenditures in primary legislation, with clear criteria; avoid introducing new tax expenditures and rationalize existing ones.
  - Strengthen enforcement of public consultation procedures, including publishing all underlying documentation and fiscal impact assessments for tax-code changes.
  - Continue to publish comprehensive lists of beneficiaries and the specific criteria under which they qualified.
  - As part of the annual budget, present a report of tax expenditures arising from exemptions and reduced rates as well as any other types of tax incentives given to businesses and households.
  - Every two to three years, review the costs and benefits of selected tax expenditures and whether beneficiaries still meet qualification criteria.
- Revenue Administration — Issues (excerpted):
  - Low domestic tax collection reflects high import dependency and a large tax gap.
  - World Bank (2014) found an estimated VAT gap of 34 percent of GDP attributed largely to low VAT collection from domestic suppliers; PIT gap was three times what was collected at that time.
  - A 2017 EU-funded study estimated the size of Kosovo’s informal economy (study mentioned but not quantified in the provided excerpt).

*Source: IMF staff (as presented in the supplied content).*

### 31.7 percent – showing a small reduction from a similar 2015 study (BSE 2017).

### cr18368 - 31.7 percent – showing a small reduction from a similar 2015 study (BSE 2017)

### Tax Administration: performance, weaknesses, and recommendations
- Key finding: Tax arrears to annual tax revenue collections ratio is almost three times higher than the international good practice benchmark.
- VAT refunds: Shift to a more risk-based approach started in June 2018 with faster refunds; as of end-August 2018, authorities claimed that 90 percent of VAT refund claims were paid out within the international good practice benchmark of 30 days, an improvement from 62 percent in 2017.
- Operational weaknesses and facts:
  - No monitoring of the net debt stock to accurately measure tax debt collection.
  - Problems maintaining accuracy of the taxpayer register despite new tax services and widespread e-filing.
  - In 2017, 38 percent of field staff were responsible for over 80 percent of the overall annual tax collections.
  - In 2017, TAK performed 1,444 tax audits and assessments resulting in €53 million and 37,240 compliance visits yielding €1.6 million.
  - Only some 70 percent of audit cases are selected at the central level based on risk analysis; many are reviewed regionally and not submitted to tax audit.
  - High number of low-value compliance visits; outcomes of verification checks are not measured.
  - Debt enforcement is widely distributed across regional offices; debt notices hand-delivered by inspectors increase collusion risk.
  - Debt collection processes are not sufficiently automated/systematized; reluctance to write off debts past statute of limitations; lack of a centralized stock and flow database.
  - Exporters still required to have a credit status for three consecutive months to qualify for a VAT refund.
  - Authorities claim only refund requests from high-risk taxpayers are audited, with reimbursement deadlines of 7 days (low-risk), 21 days (medium-risk), 30 days (high-risk).
- Key recommendations:
  - Set publicly available quantitative and strategic performance targets for TAK and customs and regularly publish outcomes.
  - Develop a comprehensive reporting and analysis framework to inform operational resource allocation and measure impact.
  - Redesign work processes to ensure strong management control guided by the four-eyes principle over operational decisions (assessment during audits, selection for audits and checks, penalties).
  - Align resource allocation to compliance risk and workload by consolidating TAK offices, rationalizing overhead, and reassigning staff; shorten credit-refund period for exporters.
  - Improve field verifications of VAT refunds to be narrowly risk-focused and completed quickly.
  - Significantly scale up tax debt collection, automatize and systematize collection processes into a single national office, and write-off uncollectible debts based on transparent criteria.
  - Improve public information campaigns about TAK and customs policies, laws, and regulations, including changes.

### Public Procurement: issues, institutional weaknesses, and recommendations
- Key findings:
  - Full implementation of the 2016 procurement law remains slow; full implementation is macro-critical to reduce costs and improve quality of public spending.
  - In 2017, 98 percent of public contracts were awarded according to the lowest-price criterion rather than best price-quality ratio.
- Institutional weaknesses and facts:
  - Rollout of e-procurement delayed to end-2018/beginning 2019; mandatory e-procurement since January 2017 still allows parallel hard-copy system.
  - Since July 2018, centralized procurement requires electronic submission; since September 2018, all high value contracts require electronic submission.
  - Most e-procurement modules in place (including e-tendering); monitoring of contract management, e-auctioning, and e-reverse auctioning not yet implemented.
  - Centralized procurement list (April 13, 2018) accounts for about 10 percent of total public procurement (2016 – AG report).
  - Delays in CPA procurements in 2018 partly because administrative instructions on centralized procurement were issued in April 2018 after a delay of more than 3 months.
  - Procurement Review Body (PRB) board functions with 3 out of 5 members after two members suspended in June 2017 on corruption charges.
- Key recommendations:
  - Implement remaining e-procurement modules.
  - Widen coverage of centralized procurement to include more economically meaningful goods and services; significantly increase CPA staff and resources.
  - Fully transpose EU criteria for price-quality rules in awarding contracts.
  - Strengthen PRB functioning by filling vacancies, improving transparency and accountability, and fast-tracking e-procurement module on bid protests.

### Publicly-Owned Enterprises (POEs): scale, weaknesses, and reform steps
- Key findings and facts:
  - 16 non-financial central level and 44 local level POEs manage public services; they account for around 5 percent of GDP in revenue and employ around 11,000 people (3.1 percent of total employment).
  - Eight of the 16 central level companies have accounting losses; dividend payments to the budget have been zero since 2015.
  - POE debt amounts to approximately 5 percent of GDP.
  - Under-investment in capital: 0.2 percent of GDP in 2017.
  - All 9 POEs audited by the Auditor General in 2017 received a modified opinion (NAO 2017).
- Institutional weaknesses:
  - Weak financial management and oversight (delays/inaccuracies in reporting, weak risk management, lack of strategic documents, minimal managerial accountability).
  - Limited coordination between MED and MoF to assess fiscal risks; MTEF and budget lack detailed POE fiscal risk information.
  - MED’s POE Policy and Monitoring Unit does not publish timely detailed information; consolidated reports limited and lack fiscal risk discussion.
  - MoF has no substantial oversight role; POE debt issuance neither requires government approval nor is centrally monitored.
  - Independence of POE boards could be improved; many POEs overstaffed; no robust process to require reforms although draft POE law seeks to address weaknesses.
- Key recommendations:
  - Enshrine oversight of POE financial risks as a joint MoF and MED function; differentiate oversight from ownership; codify inter-ministerial coordination.
  - Improve the timeliness and financial/fiscal risk focus of POE Monitoring Unit reports for budget use.
  - Enforce timely production by POEs of annual, bi-annual, quarterly, and monthly financial and operational statements compliant with international accounting standards and externally audited.
  - Include review and approval of POE annual financial plans, financial statements, requests for financial support, and any debt issuance under MoF oversight for fiscal and financial assessment; MoF to be given legal mandate to analyze data, propose limits and approve issuance of POE debt and guarantees, and disclose related fiscal risks in annual budget documents. Quasi-fiscal operations should be explicitly reported. Identify one MoF department with adequate staffing for financial oversight.
  - MED and planned POE agency to develop unified planning/reporting standards, oversee performance appraisals with power to dismiss board members, and require timely publication of financial statements.
  - Improve corporate governance by setting clear performance objectives linked to KPIs and management incentives; adopt transparent appointment/dismissal procedures; introduce public disclosure of nomination process; apply incentive-based remuneration; set professionalism and integrity requirements for boards and senior management.
  - Strengthen ability of inter-ministerial commission and proposed POE Agency to require reforms within timelines, including dismissal, restructuring, or privatization when targets fail.

### Public Investment Framework: investment scale, shortcomings, and reforms
- Key findings:
  - Annual capital budget is 9 percent of GDP and 35 percent of total public spending.
  - Overall capital stock remains 60 percent below the EU average and 20 percent below Western Balkan average.
  - Absorption of donors/IFIs-financed projects under the investment clause has been zero for several years; total capital spending was under-executed by some 35 percent in 2017 largely due to non-implementation of IFI projects.
- Institutional weaknesses:
  - Addition of new projects lacks thorough economic and fiscal cost-benefit analysis; draft administrative instruction on capital expenditure introducing a scoring system is being finalized.
  - Oversight of project implementation is weak at national and municipal levels.
  - No ex-post audits of major investment projects.
  - Donor assistance remains largely off-budget and not deposited into the Treasury Single Account or recorded in KFMIS despite Budget Law provisions.
  - Since expiration of the SBA in August 2017, only one semi-annual report on donor-financed projects under the investment clause was submitted to parliament (in April 2018; previous one in March 2017).
  - Donor-funded projects not integrated in the Public Investment Program (PIP) system; Budget Department lacks capacity for rigorous scrutiny and PIP data quality control.
  - Projects’ maintenance and operating costs not integrated in PIP.
  - PPP investments (currently only one with the airport) are not disclosed in the budget; PPP selection/approval not fully integrated with PIM framework and MTBF.
- Key recommendations:
  - Improve project appraisal and selection; finalize and adopt administrative instruction on capital expenditure and require economic and financial viability study by an independent, reputable agency.
  - Ensure donor-funded projects are appraised/selected within the same pipeline and financed through the Treasury Single Account in agreement with donors.
  - Move to multi-annual commitments; include projected operation and maintenance costs in total cost of new capital projects.
  - Ensure quarterly monitoring and ex-post reviews/audits of large-scale projects by reputable auditors and publish findings.
  - Reinforce strategic role of the budget process to align national strategies with the budget and strengthen budget department gatekeeping.
  - Reinstate monitoring and reporting procedures; ensure semi-annual reports and the budget disclose externally-financed projects under the investment clause, other externally-financed projects, and major domestically-financed projects.
  - Introduce rigorous scrutiny of capital investment proposals and PIP data entry, including publication of analysis.
  - Tighten criteria for use of the Contingency Reserve in Article 29 of the PFMA by precisely defining “urgent” or “unforeseen expenses”.
  - Integrate PPPs into overall PIM framework; improve budgeting, accounting, and reporting of PPP operations including long-term commitments and contingent liabilities; include PPP annex in budget documentation.

### Rule of Law: contract enforcement, cadaster, and anti-corruption/judiciary reforms
- Contract enforcement — findings and weaknesses:
  - Private bailiff system introduced in 2014 resolved close to 19,000 cases with recovery value of some €162 million (2½ percent of GDP) at an average recovery rate just above 22 percent.
  - Amended enforcement law came into force in May 2017 tightening appeal criteria, strengthening oversight of private bailiffs, and revising fee structure.
  - Courts backlog: 52,335 unenforced judgments as of end July 2018; 264,193 pending cases as of June 30, 2018 with backlog percent of inventories ranging from 25.7 to 71.7 percent in different case types.
  - During 2017-2018, 129 judges appointed (out of 450 positions).
  - Economic Department of Pristina’s Basic Court has only 5 specialized judges in the lower court and only 1 in the appellate court.
  - In 2017, only 20 percent of 36,850 received cases were resolved by PEAs, with recoveries amounting to 26 percent of total value of resolved cases.
  - 30-day time limit for courts to issue decisions on objections to enforcement decisions not respected; some 7,800 appeal cases await decision with a value of some €150 million.
  - Enforcement agents: 42 vs target of 72 implied by law (1 PEA per 25,000 inhabitants).
- Contract enforcement — key recommendations:
  - Implement amended enforcement law by adopting administrative instruction on PEA tariff structure and complete recruitment to staff independent PEA oversight unit at the Ministry of Justice.
  - Strengthen PEA oversight, deter malpractices by raising fines, and enforce suspension/disbarment for major offences.
  - Address capacity constraints by training and recruiting new PEAs to fill remaining 30 positions.
  - Prioritize resolution of large, complex commercial cases; increase number of specialized judges and support staff for Economic Department of Pristina’s Basic Court.
  - Prepare for creation of a commercial court by 2020.
  - Make transparency a principle in contract enforcement: use public registers, registers of bad debtors, increase openness of procedures, publish backlogs per judge/chamber, allow PEAs access to cadaster, civil registry, and tax administration data, and introduce electronic monitoring/oversight for the Council of Private Enforcement Agents.

- Property registration and cadaster — findings and recommendations:
  - Time to register a transaction dropped from 30 days before RECAP to under 10 days as of December 2017.
  - KCLIS implemented in all Municipal Cadastral Offices except three municipalities in the North.
  - Only 30 percent of cadaster zones reconstructed with World Bank support; plan to complete another 30 percent in next four years to cover all urban areas.
  - Key recommendations:
    - Establish a fully functioning cadaster system covering all of Kosovo; provide banks access to the recently-established agriculture registry.
    - Complete privatization of public houses and provide proper titles to homeowners.
    - Reform Kosovo Cadaster Agency’s institutional framework and upgrade technical infrastructure.

- Judiciary reforms to fight organized crime and high-level corruption — findings and recommendations:
  - ACA sent more than 900 cases to prosecution since 2006; in 2017 prosecution filed indictments in less than 30 cases out of more than 100 referrals.
  - Out of €101 million in assets seized, frozen, and confiscated during 2015–17, only €3 million were final confiscations.
  - Only 42 high level corruption cases recorded, resulting in 33 indictments (o/w 23 corruption and 10 organized crime) and 5 final convictions for corruption only (EC 2018b).
  - AML/CFT law adopted in June 2016; CBK progress includes guidance on beneficial ownership and movement toward risk-based supervision; AML/CFT law still not fully in line with EU acquis and international standards.
  - PECK II assessment final report expected by end-2018; PECK I conducted in 2013–14.
  - Institutional weaknesses: inadequate tools/resources at ACA to verify declarations; short investigation periods (2 years, occasionally extended by half year); SPO lacks specialized staff for high-level financial/procurement corruption; financial investigations not systematically launched; confiscation provisions cumbersome with short investigation terms.
  - PECK II preliminary findings show improvement but remaining gaps on third-party reliance and customer due diligence; legal framework shortcomings include unclear supervision by FIU and central bank, extensive NGO reporting requirements, lack of provision to continue freezing suspicious transaction in line with FIU orders, and narrower definitions than FATF/EU directives.
  - Key recommendations:
    - Adopt revised laws on extended power of asset confiscation and whistle-blowers in line with EC recommendations.
    - Improve quality of ACA reports to prosecution and strengthen inter-agency cooperation for asset declaration verification.
    - Implement newly adopted law on state prosecutor to promote merit-based recruitment to SPO, and the law on prevention of conflict of interest.
    - Adopt revisions to criminal code and criminal procedure code to strengthen search/confiscation, admissibility of evidence, increase investigation time limit to 2+2 years, ensure immediate suspension/removal of public officials indicted/convicted of corruption, and streamline appeals procedures (make court of appeals act as final court).
    - Amend asset declaration legal framework to align with international best practices and give more robust powers to ACA; incorporate results of the functional review of the justice system into reforms and the National Strategy for the Rule of Law Sector.
    - Address AML/CFT gaps: execute remaining PECK I recommendations and PECK II recommendations; regulate third-party reliance and conditions, enhance due diligence (wire transfers via non-bank financial institutions, reliable information for beneficial ownership, principal place of business info, risk management prior to customer verification, tipping-off prevention), clarify supervisory competencies and coordination between central bank and FIU, revisit NGO reporting requirements, strengthen court/prosecutor provisions to continue freezing assets on FIU orders, and align definitions with FATF standards.

*IMF staff report: Republic of Kosovo (selected chapter).*

### References

### References

### Bibliographic sources cited
- Business and Strategies Europe (BSE), 2017. “Assessment on the Extent of the Informal Economy in Kosovo”, EuropeAid/138064/DH/SER/XK
- European Commission (EC), 2018a. “Kosovo 2018 Report”, Commission Staff Working Document, 17 April 2018
- European Commission (EC), 2018b. “Update on the implementation of the remaining benchmarks of the visa liberalization roadmap by Kosovo”, Report from the Commission to the European Parliament and the Council, 18 July 2018
- International Monetary Fund (IMF), 2016. “Corruption: Costs and Mitigating Strategies”, IMF Staff Discussion Note SDN/16/05
- National Audit Office (NAO), 2017. “Audit Report: Management and Monitoring of Capital Investments within Publicly Owned Enterprises”, Pristina, April 2017
- Seiwald, Johann, Jacques Charaoui, Suzanne Flynn, Bojan Pogacar, and Gerhard Steger, 2017. “Republic of Kosovo. Public Investment Management and Medium-Term Expenditure Framework”, FAD Technical Assistance Report
- Seiwald, Johann, Richard Allen, Duncan Last, and Isabel Rial, 2016. “Republic of Kosovo. Public Investment Management Assessment”, IMF Country Report No. 16/100
- World Bank, 2014. “Republic of Kosovo. Public Sector Revenues: Tax Policies, Tax Evasion, and Tax Gaps”, Washington, DC. https://openknowledge.worldbank.org/handle/10986/22269

### Annex VI — Determinants of Labor Force Participation and Employment: Background
- Labor market context:
  - Unemployment rate: nearly 30 percent
  - Inactivity rate: 60 percent
  - Labor force participation (2017): 42.8 percent (employed 29.7 percent; actively looking 13.1 percent)
  - Rest of Western Balkans (WB) comparison (2017): participation 51.9 percent; actively looking 11.0 percent
  - New Member States (NMS) comparison (2017): participation 68.0 percent; actively looking 4.7 percent
  - Youth unemployment: exceeding 50 percent
- Key mechanisms discussed:
  - Public sector wage spillovers to private sector wages
  - Inactivity and unemployment positively correlated with household income from social benefits and remittances
- Determinants referenced from literature: age structure, expected return to work, minimum wage laws, employment protection regulation, unions, collective bargaining, mandated benefits; specific citations include Afonso et al. (2014), Lamo et al. (2011), Telegdy (2013)

### Empirical results — Aggregate cross-country analysis (31 European countries, 2006–2016)
- Model specification: L_{i,t} = β_Z Z_{it} + β_{M GDPpc} GDPpc_{it} + β_X X_{it} + c_i + τ_t + ε_{it}
  - L: participation rate or employment-to-population ratio
  - Z: determinants of labor supply (educational attainment, remittances, share of prime age population, number of children per working age population)
  - X: policies and institutions (public sector wage premium, minimum wages, duration of maternity leave, family/children expenditures)
  - Key policy variables are lagged by one period
- Main cross-country findings:
  - Higher education associated with higher employment and participation
  - Remittances: not statistically significant overall; negative sign for Western Balkans
  - Larger share of prime age population likely boosts employment and participation
  - Higher number of children per working age population associated with lower labor force participation
  - GDP per capita: weakly significant, positively associated with participation
  - Public sector wage premium:
    - Coefficient on public sector to average wage ratio: negative and statistically significant — higher public-sector wage premium could adversely affect employment
  - Minimum wage:
    - Estimated coefficient on monthly minimum wage to GDP per capita: negative and weakly significant
    - A one percent increase in the minimum wage to GDP per capita ratio decreases the employment-to-population ratio by 1.78 percent
    - Kosovo has the highest minimum wage to GDP per capita ratio (Figure 3 panel chart 6)
    - Proposed minimum wage increase from 170 to 250 euros per month could further put the minimum wage above desirable labor productivity level
  - Maternity leave:
    - No statistically significant relationship found between duration of maternity leave and labor market outcomes
    - Kosovo’s maternity leave duration: 52 weeks (EU average: 21 weeks); possible nonlinear effects and de-skilling concerns noted
  - Family/children expenditures (proxy for social benefits):
    - Higher public spending on family/children benefits associated with lower employment and participation
    - A one percent increase in family/children expenditures (as percent of GDP) expected to decrease the employment-to-population ratio by 2.19 percent
    - In Kosovo, nearly half of social benefit schemes are conditioned on being unemployed or having no stated labor income; households can receive multiple social benefits simultaneously

### Empirical results — Micro level analysis (Kosovo HBS 2017 and LFS 2017)
- Household Budget Survey (HBS) analysis:
  - Sample restrictions: unemployment regressions — prime age population aged 25-55; inactivity regressions — working age population aged 15-65
  - Logistic / OLS regression findings (unemployment and inactivity):
    - Higher probability of being unemployed: female, younger individuals, not married, living in Mitrovice, Ferizaj, Prishtine
    - Individuals in households with main income from public or private sector wages are less likely to be unemployed
    - Higher household labor income decreases likelihood of unemployment
    - Individuals in households with larger remittances income are more likely to be unemployed
    - Inactivity likelihood negatively correlated with age, being male, being married, higher education, living in urban areas, and certain regions (Mitrovice and Prishtine)
    - Individuals in households indicating social benefits or pensions as main income source are more likely to be inactive
    - Household composition has greater role for participation decision than for unemployment decision
- Labor Force Survey (LFS) 2017 — public-private wage gap (Mincerian wage regressions):
  - Dependent variable: natural logarithm of labor income
  - Public-sector dummy = 1 if employed in public sector, 0 otherwise
  - Estimated public-sector wage premium: around 30–40 percent
    - Public sector estimated premium in 2017: 30–43 percent
  - Results robust to specifications including restriction to formal sector and whether SOEs included or excluded

### Key numeric indicators (as presented in Table 1)
- Kosovo (2017) vs EU average (2017):
  - Higher education ratio: 1.7 (Kosovo); 3.4 (EU average)
  - Remittances inflows (% of GDP): 11.8% (Kosovo); 0.4% (EU average)
  - Prime age population (% of total population): 68.7% (Kosovo); 41.1% (EU average)
  - Number of children per working age population: 0.32 (Kosovo); 0.24 (EU average)
  - GDP per capita (EUR): 3,566 (Kosovo); 30,229 (EU average)
  - General government wage/ average wage: 1.2 (Kosovo); 1.4 (EU average)
  - Monthly minimum wage to GDP per capita: 4.8% (Kosovo); 3.4% (EU average)
  - Maternity leave duration (#. of weeks): 52 (Kosovo); 21 (EU average)
  - Family/ children expenditure (% of GDP): 0.5% (Kosovo); 2% (EU average)

### Table highlights (selected coefficients and statistics)
- Panel regressions (Table 3):
  - Prime age population share: positive and statistically significant in multiple specifications (coefficients reported)
  - Number of children per working age population: negative coefficients, with significance in several specifications
  - General government wage/ economy average wage, lagged: coefficient reported as -4.046*** in one specification
  - Minimum wage to GDP per capita, lagged: coefficient reported as -1.775* in one specification
  - Family/Children expenditure (% of GDP), lagged: coefficient reported as -2.189** in one specification
  - Note: Robust standard errors and significance levels reported in table
- HBS regressions (Table 4):
  - Age and age squared: age negative and significant; age squared positive and significant in unemployment and inactivity regressions
  - Male: large negative coefficients on unemployment and inactivity (male reduces likelihood)
  - Log labor income: negative and significant effect on unemployment and inactivity
  - Log remittances: positive and significant effect on unemployment in some specifications; mixed effects for inactivity
  - Pseudo R2 and observations reported (e.g., Unemployment observations: 3,416; Inactivity observations: 7,831)
- Public-private wage gap (Table 5):
  - Public sector coefficient: 0.301*** (public only) and 0.428*** (public and SOE)
  - Observations: 8,861; R-squared: 0.202 and 0.295 respectively

### Policy recommendations
- Minimum wage policy:
  - Set minimum wages based on developments in inflation and real effective exchange rate by re-introducing the formula setting and binding preconditions for minimum wage adjustments
  - Avoid large discretionary increases that would undermine efforts to reduce unemployment, competitiveness gap and informality
- Public sector wage policy:
  - Set public sector wage increases taking into account developments in living costs, private sector wages and competitiveness, and impact on the private sector labor market
  - Consistent with the wage bill rule that limits the growth in the wage bill to nominal GDP; the wage bill rule should be used as a policy ceiling and not as a target for public sector wage increases
- Social benefits:
  - Strike an appropriate balance between equity and efficiency
  - Recognize potential efficiency losses from mandated benefits (e.g., paid maternity leave) and possible unintended side effects such as increased part-time employment for women and lower female representation in high-level positions
- Active Labor Market Policies (ALMPs):
  - Design ALMPs to focus on:
    1. Specific vocational training to meet demand from employers
    2. Job search assistance to help workers overcome sectoral and spatial mismatches
    3. Streamlining onerous laws and regulations to facilitate job creation by firms
  - Emphasize education to address structural problems, including skill mismatches
  - International evidence referenced: McKenzie 2017; Blau and Lawrence (2013) noted for family-friendly policy effects

*Prepared by Brooks Evans (FAD), Shushanik Hakobyan (SPR) and Zhongxia Zhang (EUR).*

### References

### cr18368 - References

### Key References
- Afonso, António, and Pedro Gomes, 2014, “Interactions between private and public sector wages”, Journal of Macroeconomics 39(A): 97-112.
- Atoyan, Ruben and Jesmin Rahman, 2017, “Western Balkans: Increasing Women’s Role in the Economy”, IMF Working Paper 17/194.
- Betcherman, G., 2012, “Labor Market Institutions: A Review of the Literature”, World Bank Policy Research Working Paper No. 6276.
- Blau, Francine D., and Lawrence M. Kahn, 2013, “Female Labor Supply: Why Is the United States Falling Behind?” American Economic Review 103(3): 251-256.
- IMF, 2016, “Cross-Country Report on Minimum Wages”, IMF Country Report No. 16/151, June 2016.
- IMF, 2018, “Labor Force Participation in Advanced Economies: Drivers and Prospects”, in World Economic Outlook, April 2018, Chapter 2.
- Lamo, Ana, Javier J. Pérez, and Ludger Schuknecht, 2011, “Public or Private Sector Wage Leadership? An International Perspective”, The Scandinavian Journal of Economics 114(1): 228-244.
- McKenzie, David, 2017, “How Effective Are Active Labor Market Policies in Developing Countries? A Critical Review of Recent Evidence”, World Bank Policy Research Working Paper 8011.
- Telegdy, Álmos, 2013, “The Effect of Public Wages on Corporate Compensation in Hungary”, IZA Discussion Paper No. 7524.

### Fund relations — Membership and Financial Position
- Membership Status: Joined: June 29, 2009; Article VIII (as of January 11, 2018).
- Quota (General Resources Account): Quota 82.60 SDR Million 100.00 percent.
- Fund holdings of currency: 194.43 SDR Million 235.38 percent.
- Reserve Tranche Position: 20.07 SDR Million 24.29 percent.
- SDR Department: Net cumulative allocation 55.37 SDR Million 100.00 percent.
- SDR Holdings: 54.08 SDR Million 97.67 percent.
- Outstanding Purchases and Loans (SDR Million; Percent Quota): Stand-By Arrangements 131.89 SDR Million 159.67 percent.

Latest Financial Arrangements (as listed)
- Stand-By: Date of Arrangement July 29, 2015; Expiration August 4, 2017; Amount Approved (SDR Million) 147.50; Amount Drawn (SDR Million) 90.97.
- Stand-By: Date of Arrangement April 27, 2012; Expiration December 26, 2013; Amount Approved (SDR Million) 135.40; Amount Drawn (SDR Million) 78.22.
- Stand-By: Date of Arrangement July 21, 2010; Expiration January 20, 2012; Amount Approved (SDR Million) 92.66; Amount Drawn (SDR Million) 18.76.

Projected Payments to Fund (SDR Million; based on existing use of resources and present holdings of SDRs)
- Forthcoming 2018: Charges/Interest 0.68; Total 0.68.
- Forthcoming 2019: Principal 24.59; Charges/Interest 2.52; Total 27.11.
- Forthcoming 2020: Principal 54.29; Charges/Interest 1.87; Total 56.16.
- Forthcoming 2021: Principal 43.11; Charges/Interest 0.83; Total 43.94.
- Forthcoming 2022: Principal 9.90; Charges/Interest 0.11; Total 10.01.

Other governance and arrangements
- Implementation of HIPC Initiative: Not Applicable.
- Implementation of Multilateral Debt Relief Initiative (MDRI): Not Applicable.
- Implementation of Catastrophe Containment and Relief (CCR): Not Applicable.
- Safeguards Assessments: Update linked to the SBA approved in July 2015 found CBK governance practices appropriate; recommendations to strengthen internal audit, amend the CBK Law, and revise external auditor selection were implemented.

Exchange arrangements and membership notes
- De jure and de facto exchange rate arrangement: no separate legal tender; euro is legal tender following unilateral adoption.
- Kosovo is not part of the euro area and the CBK is not part of the European System of Central Banks.
- Kosovo is an Article VIII member and does not maintain exchange restrictions or multiple currency practices, except for security-related restrictions notified pursuant to Decision No. 144.

Previous consultations and surveillance
- Previous Article IV consultation concluded on February 2, 2018; Kosovo was on a 24-month cycle during the 2015-17 Stand-By Arrangement; expected to be on a 12-month cycle going forward.
- FSAP mission: conducted during September 19–October 2, 2012; FSSA included ROSC for Basel Core Principles; Kosovo has not had a data or fiscal transparency ROSC.

Technical Assistance (selected areas and dates)
- Statistics: Government Finance Statistics (September 2015, April and October 2016; February and April 2017; October-November 2017).
- E-GDDS: April 2017.
- Fiscal sector (tax administration, PFM, expenditure policy): Multiple TA events from January 2016 through November 2018 (examples include Tax Administration – Compliance Risk Management June 2017; IT Modernization June 2017 and April 2018; TADAT June 2018; Strengthening VAT Refund Procedures November 2018).
- Monetary and financial sectors: Risk-Based Supervision (November 2015 and March 2016); Insurance Sector supervision (October 2016 and September 2017); Macroprudential Policy and Early Warning System (October and November 2017); Strengthening forward-looking banking supervision (February 2018).

Resident Representative
- Mr. Vermeulen took up his post on August 1, 2015.

### Relations to other international financial institutions
- EBRD: (link listed in source).
- European Investment Bank: (link listed in source).
- World Bank: (link listed in source).

### Statistical issues — Assessment of data adequacy for surveillance
General
- Data provision is adequate for surveillance, though statistical agencies have considerable shortages of financial and human resources.

National Accounts
- Compilation methods for annual national accounts (ANA) broadly in line with the 2008 SNA/ESA2010.
- GDP by activity and expenditure published simultaneously in excel format with a delay of 10 months.
- Quarterly national accounts provide a first estimate of annual GDP by April every year; recommendation to further reduce time lag in ANA dissemination.
- Quarterly GDP data can be inconsistent with annual data and require significant revisions; need for methodological improvements.
- Priority to improve and develop additional high-frequency (monthly) indicators such as wholesale and retail trade data and services.

Labor Markets
- Reliable labor force data is challenging due to a large informal economy; quarterly labor data began to be published in 2016.

Consumer Price Index
- Monthly CPI produced since 2002; published monthly with a lag of 13 days.
- CPI uses COICOP-compatible item classification with 352 elementary aggregates.
- New index introduced in December 2014 with new weights based on National Accounts; targets all products and services purchased by all households (resident and non-resident).
- HICP available from January 2010 onward; HICP rebased from 2002 to 2015 in January 2016.
- Kosovo receives TA from Eurostat.

Government Finance Statistics
- Monthly reports on budget execution of general government on a cash basis provided five weeks after month-end.
- Budget classification not consistent with GFSM 2014 because: (i) data is on cash basis not accrual; (ii) lending for policy purposes included after calculating the primary balance; (iii) capital transfers should be included in current expenditure instead of capital expenditure; (iv) MOUs should be properly classified depending on final purpose; (v) annual budget documents should specify current and capital spending related to individual projects.
- Strengthening monitoring and disclosure of arrears recommended.

Monetary and Financial Statistics
- Monetary data compiled broadly consistent with the IMF’s Monetary and Financial Statistics Manual.
- CBK reports monetary data monthly using Standardized Report Forms; data published in International Financial Statistics.
- CBK ceased compiling currency in circulation in 2006 due to difficulties estimating Euro currency in circulation, resulting in underreporting broad money.

Financial Sector Surveillance
- CBK reports Financial Soundness Indicators (FSIs) monthly; all 12 core indicators and 7 encouraged indicators for deposit takers are available through IMF’s FSI webpage.

External Sector Statistics
- CBK provides quarterly balance of payments and international investment position data following BPM6 starting with 2013: Q1.
- Participation in Coordinated Direct Investment Survey (inward and outward data starting 2010), Coordinated Portfolio Investment Survey (annual data from December 2010, semiannual from June 2013), and Quarterly External Debt Statistics.
- Direction of trade data available monthly.
- Authorities working towards reporting the international reserves and foreign currency liquidity template.

Data Standards and Quality
- Country participates in the enhanced General Data Dissemination System (e-GDDS); National Summary Data Page has regularly disseminated e-GDDS data since May 11, 2017.
- Kosovo has not had a Data ROSC.

### Kosovo — Table of Common Indicators Required for Surveillance (As of November 13, 2018) — selected entries
- International Reserve Assets and Reserve Liabilities of the Monetary Authorities: Date of Latest Observation 09/30/2018; Date Received/Reported Online Oct/2018; Frequency of Data M; Frequency of Reporting M; Frequency of Publication M.
- Reserve/Base Money: Date of Latest Observation 09/30/2018; Date Received/Reported Online 10/29/2018; Frequency M/M/M.
- Broad Money: Date of Latest Observation 09/30/2018; Date Received/Reported Online 10/29/2018; Frequency M/M/M.
- Central Bank Balance Sheet: Date of Latest Observation 09/30/2018; Date Received/Reported Online 10/29/2018; Frequency M/M/M.
- Consolidated Balance Sheet of the Banking System: Date of Latest Observation 09/30/2018; Date Received/Reported Online 10/29/2018; Frequency M/M/M.
- Interest Rates: Date of Latest Observation Sept/2018; Date Received/Reported Online Oct/2018; Frequency M/M/M.
- Consumer Price Index: Date of Latest Observation Oct/2018; Date Received/Reported Online 11/13/2018; Frequency M/M/M.
- Revenue, Expenditure, Balance and Composition of Financing — General Government: Date of Latest Observation Sept/2018; Date Received/Reported Online 11/9/2018; Frequency M/M/M.
- Stocks of Central Government and Central Government-Guaranteed Debt: Date of Latest Observation 09/30/2018; Date Received/Reported Online 11/9/2018; Frequency Q/Q/Q.
- External Current Account Balance: Date of Latest Observation Aug/2018; Date Received/Reported Online Oct/2018; Frequency Q/Q/Q.
- Exports and Imports of Goods: Date of Latest Observation 09/30/2018; Date Received/Reported Online 10/29/2018; Frequency M/M/M.
- GDP/GNP: Date of Latest Observation 06/30/2018; Date Received/Reported Online 09/28/2018; Frequency Q/Q/Q.
- Gross External Debt: Date of Latest Observation 06/30/2018; Date Received/Reported Online Oct/2018; Frequency Q/Q/Q.
- International Investment Position: Date of Latest Observation 06/30/2018; Date Received/Reported Online Oct/2018; Frequency Q/Q/Q.

Selected explanatory notes from table
- CBK’s NFA and GIR data revised for the period 09/2015 - 07/2018 to exclude CBK’s holdings of Kosovar government securities; CBK balance sheet and survey data revised for the period 09/2015 - 07/2018 to reclassify CBK’s holdings of Kosovar government securities as claims on the central government.
- Frequency codes: Daily (D), weekly (W), monthly (M), quarterly (Q), annually (A), irregular (I), and not available (NA).
- GNDI data not available.

*International Monetary Fund — Republic of Kosovo: Staff Report for the 2018 Article IV Consultation — Informational Annex (content unit: cr18368 - References).*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/cr/2018/cr18368.pdf_
