## 1. Growth-Enhancing Tax Reform

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [1. Growth-Enhancing Tax Reform](https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/cr/2019/1svnea2019001.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/files/publications/cr/2019/1svnea2019001.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/files/publications/cr/2019/1svnea2019001.pdf.json)

---

### Context and Outlook
- Post-crisis recovery continues.
  - Growth: 4.9 percent in 2017; estimated 4.5 percent in 2018.
  - Domestic demand and public investment have picked up, complementing exports.
- Labor market and wages.
  - Unemployment rate: about 5 percent (lowest in a decade).
  - Real wage growth: 2 percent in 2018.
  - Skills shortages emerging.
- Inflation.
  - Headline inflation: estimated 1.9 percent in 2018.
  - Core inflation: around 1 percent, slightly above euro area average.
- Fiscal and financial context.
  - Fiscal deficit halved in 2017 to 0.8 percent of GDP; fiscal surplus about ½ percent of GDP in 2018.
  - Financial sector soundness improving; SME NPLs remain elevated.
- Social and political context.
  - GINI index: 0.24 (OECD average: 0.32).
  - Share at risk of poverty and social exclusion: 19.9 percent in 2016 (EU average: 17.7 percent).
  - First minority coalition government took office in September 2018; five-party coalition supported by another opposition party.
- Near-term projections.
  - Growth: 3.4 percent in 2019.
  - Current account surplus: about 5 percent of GDP in 2019.
  - Inflation: 2.2 percent in 2019.
- Medium-term projections (Selected Economic Indicators, 2018–23; percent unless noted):
  - Real GDP (annual % change): 2018: 4.5; 2019: 3.4; 2020: 2.8; 2021: 2.7; 2022: 2.3; 2023: 2.1
  - Potential output growth (annual % change): 2018: 2.7; 2019: 2.8; 2020: 2.8; 2021: 2.8; 2022: 2.7; 2023: 2.5
  - Output gap (percent of potential GDP): 2018: 1.2; 2019: 1.8; 2020: 1.9; 2021: 1.7; 2022: 1.3; 2023: 0.9
  - Headline inflation (percent, period average): 2018: 1.9; 2019: 2.2; 2020: 2.2; 2021: 2.1; 2022: 2.0; 2023: 2.0
  - Core inflation (percent, period average): 2018: 1.1; 2019: 1.3; 2020: 1.4; 2021: 1.4; 2022: 1.4; 2023: 1.4
  - Unemployment rate (ILO): 2018: 5.1; 2019: 4.8; 2020: 4.9; 2021: 5.0; 2022: 5.1; 2023: 5.1
  - General government balance (percent of GDP): 2018: 0.4; 2019: 0.0; 2020: -0.1; 2021: -0.1; 2022: -0.1; 2023: 0.0
  - Structural balance (percent of GDP): 2018: 0.0; 2019: -0.7; 2020: -0.8; 2021: -0.8; 2022: -0.6; 2023: -0.4
  - General government debt (percent of GDP): 2018: 68.8; 2019: 66.1; 2020: 64.0; 2021: 62.1; 2022: 60.4; 2023: 58.7
  - Current account balance (percent of GDP): 2018: 6.4; 2019: 5.2; 2020: 4.3; 2021: 3.5; 2022: 2.5; 2023: 1.5
- Risks.
  - Downside: rising protectionism, policy uncertainty in Europe, weaker global demand, faster-than-expected euro area monetary normalization.
  - Domestic political fragmentation may slow structural reforms.
- External position assessment.
  - Current account: -4.1 percent of GDP in 2007 → 6.4 percent of GDP in 2018.
  - CA norm (Fund methodology): about 1.9 percent of GDP in 2018; CA gap: 4.5 percent of GDP.
  - Policy gap: -0.02 percent of GDP.
  - REER undervaluation at standard elasticities: 8 percent.

### Fiscal Policy: Rebuild Fiscal Buffers and Ensure Sustainability
- Consolidation since 2013.
  - Structural fiscal balance improved by 2.3 percentage points of GDP between 2013 and 2017.
  - Consolidation mix: structural measures (pension reform, VAT rate increases, debt reprofiling) and temporary crisis measures (wage freezes, indexation freezes, cut in non-EU-financed public investment).
  - Slovenia exited the Excessive Deficit Procedure in 2016.
- Remaining vulnerabilities.
  - Public debt about 69 percent of GDP; above Stability and Growth Pact rule of 60 percent.
  - Large projected long-run increase in age-related public spending; public debt will start growing rapidly in the medium term.
- 2019 Draft Budgetary Plan (DBP) concerns.
  - Amended DBP envisages fiscal expansion.
  - Headline fiscal surplus: 0.4 percent of GDP in 2018; structural position: balanced.
  - Amended DBP likely to increase structural deficit by 0.7 percent of GDP in 2019, mainly from increased social transfers and wages without offsets.
  - Staff estimates public sector wages will increase by about 0.3 percent of GDP in 2019, followed by further increases in 2020.
- Staff recommendations.
  - Avoid pro-cyclical fiscal expansion; preserve structural fiscal balance in 2019.
  - Maintain the Medium-Term Objective (MTO) of structural balance as fiscal anchor.
  - Reverse or postpone additional spending until offset by spending cuts or tax-base broadening.
  - Fiscal Council urged government to keep public finances in structural balance in 2019 and adopt measures to address long-term fiscal challenges.
- Fiscal reform priorities to prepare for ageing: pension, health, education, and wage bill.
  - Pension recommendations:
    - Adopt White Paper proposals to raise retirement age to 67 and automatically adjust to demographics; restrict early retirement further.
    - Additional reforms: (i) index pensions to inflation only rather than wages; (ii) abolish pension bonus.
    - Increase effective retirement age by gradually eliminating long-service early retirement (40 years rule) and discontinuing arrangement to purchase up to 5 years of service time prior to retirement.
  - Health and education reforms:
    - Close efficiency gaps vs. euro area peers.
    - Potential reforms: expand centralized procurement; improve means-testing for tertiary student support; link university funding to students’ labor market outcomes.
  - Wage bill reforms:
    - Undertake functional and institutional review for public employment reform.
    - Link public wage dynamics to economic conditions and reward performance over automatic seniority increases.
    - Adopt multi-annual remuneration framework with separate limits for number of employees and for wage increases by sector.

### Growth-Enhancing Tax Reform: Rationale and Quantified Impact
- Rationale.
  - Slovenia has a relatively high tax wedge.
  - Tax expenditures are generous and erode PIT, VAT, and CIT bases; property tax revenue well below EU average.
  - Tax expenditures: 4.9 percent of GDP (compared to 0.6 percent in Germany).
  - Revenue-neutral tax reform can raise revenue more efficiently, incentivize work, and boost growth by shifting tax burden to less distortive sources and rationalizing tax expenditures.
- Options for reform.
  - Cut social security contributions and broaden VAT and PIT bases.
  - Increase market value-based property taxes and environmental taxes.
  - Rationalize tax expenditures and immovable property tax and capital net gains tax.
- Quantified potential fiscal impact (Potential Fiscal Savings by 2020; in percent of GDP):
  - Cumulative Revenue: 0.5
    - Real estate tax: 0.8
    - Indexation of excises: 0.2
    - Broadening of VAT, CIT, PIT bases: 0.7
    - Labor tax wedge reform 1/-1.2
  - Expenditure: 1.2
    - Health care 2/: 0.3
    - Education 2/: 0.2
    - Pensions: 0.5
    - Transfers and subsidies: 0.2
  - Total Savings: 1.7
  - Notes:
    - 1/ Based on OECD (2018) estimate on cutting labor tax wedge by 5 percentage points.
    - 2/ By closing part of the gap to the efficiency frontier of OECD countries, including lower wage bill.
- Growth effect.
  - A revenue-neutral reform shifting the tax burden from labor to consumption and other taxes could increase Slovenia’s output level by 0.5 percent in the medium- to long-term.
- Specific empirical points.
  - Tax wedge: 42.7 percent in 2016 (EU28: 40.3 percent).
  - PIT base erosion noted due to PIT tax expenditure costs.
  - Measure equivalent to 2.1 percent of GDP could be broadened by withdrawing exemptions for reimbursement of home-to-work travel expenses and tax-free meals provided during work.

### Tax Policy: Options to Raise Revenue and Rebalance Taxation
- Broadening VAT base by applying the standard rate (22 percent) to poorly-targeted reduced-rate (9.5 percent) supplies could raise revenue by 0.5 percent of GDP.
- Rationalizing PIT allowances: convert multiple tax allowances into cost-effective tax credits to finance downward PIT rate adjustments.
- Reduce tax exemption on benefits: make performance, Christmas, and holiday bonuses taxable as ordinary income.
- Reform capital gains tax (CGT): current CGT flat rate: 25 percent with taper to zero percent after 20 years of holding; eliminating the taper relief would make capital income taxes more progressive.
- Other instruments:
  - Introduce a value-based property tax.
  - Tighten application of flat-rate business tax.
  - Adopt stricter debt/equity limits for tax purposes.
- Reiterated growth simulation: shifting tax burden from labor to consumption and other taxes in a revenue-neutral way could increase output level by 0.5 percent in the medium- to long-term.

### Authorities’ Fiscal Stance and Plans
- Authorities committed to fiscal consolidation through structural reforms; target to reduce public debt below 60 percent of GDP in medium term.
- Short-term: headline surplus to help public debt reduction in 2019 despite public wage negotiations.
- Structural balance: authorities noted structural balance could not improve in 2019 due to decisions to increase civil servants’ incomes and social transfers to boost consumption.
- Fiscal reforms anticipated in 2020 include revenue-neutral tax rebalancing.
- On pensions: current annual bonus cited as addressing pension adequacy for poor pensioners.
- On health: priority to reduce waiting times, including through digitalization.
- On wages: wage negotiations seen as basis for broader mid-term public wage reform.
- Political constraint: broad consensus needed within the five-party coalition for structural reforms in 2019.

### Financial Policy, Banking Sector, and Macroprudential Concerns
- Post-2013 banking crisis: financial stability improved though legacy problems remain.
- Privatization progress:
  - Government sold 65 percent of Nova Ljubljanska Banka (NLB) in 2018; planned sale of another 10 percent in 2019.
  - Abanka expected to be privatized in 2019.
- Banking revenue pressure: net interest income declined markedly since 2012 and likely to fall further with low policy interest rate and uneven lending recovery.
- Nonperforming loans (NPLs):
  - Overall NPLs improved; SME NPLs remain elevated in the low double digits.
  - Staff welcomed toolkit and handbook for resolving SME NPLs and ECB measures for three directly supervised banks.
  - Supervisors should push banks to speed up SME NPL resolution and strengthen insolvency procedures for SMEs.
- Housing market and credit risks:
  - Housing price growth: 13.4 percent in 2018: Q2 (one of highest in euro area).
  - Share of households with mortgage: about 10 percent (19 percent in the euro area).
  - About a third of recent housing transactions carried out with equity.
- Macroprudential guidance by Bank of Slovenia (BoS) (recommendations):
  - Loan-to-value ratio not to exceed 80 percent.
  - Debt service to income (DSTI) ratio limits: 50 percent for lower incomes and 67 percent for higher incomes.
  - Consumer credit maturities recommended not to exceed 120 months.
  - Staff view: limits could be made mandatory and more binding when needed.
- AML/CFT: address shortcomings from 2017 Moneyval report; enhance targeted financial sanctions related to proliferation financing; BoS should strengthen supervision of banks’ implementation of national requirements.

### Structural Reforms: Labor Markets, Skills, SOEs, and Product Market Regulation
- Demographic challenge: ageing population requires higher productivity and skills (IT specialists, scientists, engineers).
- Labor market and skills:
  - Recent reforms: Apprenticeship Act, amended Vocational Education Act, new Adult Education Act to re-establish public training network.
  - New Labor Market Act incentives:
    - Taking a full-time job: worker enjoys additional 20 percent of last unemployment benefit on top of salary until unemployment benefit expiration.
    - For older workers, wages exempt from social security contributions.
  - Replacement rate of unemployment benefits: above 80 percent in the first months for low-wage earners (EU average: 67 percent).
  - Recommended reforms:
    - Reform tax-benefit system, rebalance taxation from labor to consumption and wealth, bring replacement rate closer to EU average.
    - Increase labor market flexibility; reduce perceived excessive protection of open-ended contracts and high layoff costs.
    - Reform unemployment benefits to “protect workers rather than jobs.”
    - Develop training in entrepreneurship and new technologies; entrepreneurship education currently well below EU average.
- SOEs:
  - SOEs account for 20 percent of non-financial employment.
  - SOEs dominant in network sectors and present in competitive sectors; total factor productivity of large SOEs lags private companies.
  - Slovenia underperformed in large-scale privatization relative to other CESEE countries.
  - Recommendations: accelerate privatization program; reduce list of “strategic” and “important” companies; monitor SOE governance focusing on financial reporting, disclosure rules, supervisory board, and equitable treatment of minority and foreign shareholders.
- Product and service-market reforms:
  - Regulatory burden more restrictive than OECD average; Slovenia maintains 220 regulated professions.
  - Recommendations: reduce number of regulated professions; implement mid-2018 legislation simplifying building permits and streamline spatial planning and construction regulation to benefit housing market and investment.
- Authorities’ implementation plans:
  - No new structural reforms planned in 2019 on these fronts while consultations continue.
  - Government will implement active employment measures to activate long-term unemployed, younger and older unemployed, and low-education groups.
  - Authorities plan to pursue privatization program and noted IPO of NLB will provide momentum.
  - SME test and one-stop shop program to reduce administrative burden.

### Staff Appraisal: Macroeconomic Context and Policy Priorities
- Use positive cycle to deepen fiscal and structural reforms, rebuild fiscal buffers, and increase productivity growth.
- Preserve gains from past consolidation; avoid procyclical fiscal expansion.
- Authorities’ MTO of structural fiscal balance is an appropriate anchor to bring public debt toward 60 percent of GDP.
- Amended DBP for 2019 envisages higher spending and sizable structural deterioration; higher spending should be accommodated through fiscal savings as part of structural reforms.
- Scope for fiscal reforms generating permanent savings while modernizing government operations: focus on pensions, health, education, wage bill; complement with tax rebalancing away from social security contributions toward property taxes and rationalizing tax expenditures.
- External sector: external position in 2018 assessed as substantially stronger than fundamentals and desirable policies suggest; large CA surplus helps reduce external vulnerabilities but expected to moderate.
- Financial stability: improved following bank restructuring; supervisors should continue encouraging proactive NPL management; monitor emerging housing market risks.
- Structural reforms reiterated as key to long-term prosperity: vocational training, apprenticeship, adult education, labor market flexibility, tax-benefit reform, reduce administrative/regulatory burden, accelerate privatization.

### Key Quantitative Indicators Cited
- VAT standard rate: 22 percent.
- Reduced VAT rate referenced: 9.5 percent.
- CGT flat rate: 25 percent; taper to zero percent after 20 years.
- Potential output uplift from tax shift (revenue-neutral): 0.5 percent increase in output level in the medium- to long-term.
- Housing price growth: 13.4 percent in 2018: Q2.
- Share of households with mortgage: about 10 percent (19 percent in the euro area).
- Share of recent housing transactions carried out with equity: about a third.
- Bank privatization sales: 65 percent of NLB sold in 2018; another 10 percent planned in 2019.
- Replacement rate of unemployment benefits for low-wage earners: above 80 percent in first months (EU average: 67 percent).
- SOEs share of non-financial employment: 20 percent.

### Risk Assessment and External Position (Annexes I–II Highlights)
- External risks: rising protectionism (Likelihood: High; Time Horizon: Short to Medium Term; Expected Impact: High); weaker global growth (Likelihood: Medium for Euro Area and US; Expected Impact: High); sharp tightening of global financial conditions (Likelihood: High; Expected Impact: Low).
- Domestic risks: failure to implement reform-based consolidation (Likelihood: Medium; Expected Impact: Medium); delays in resolving SME NPLs (Likelihood: Low; Expected Impact: Medium).
- Foreign assets and liabilities:
  - NIIP: about -20 percent of GDP at end-2018; gross external debt about 94 percent of GDP.
  - CA actual: 6.4; CA Norm: 1.9; CA gap: 4.5; Policy Gap: -0.02; Implied REER gap: -8
  - Actual REER: 4.59; REER Norm: 4.56; REER gap: 0.03
- Capital and financial accounts: inward FDI flows near zero percent of GDP in 2012; projected below 3 percent of GDP in 2018. Government external debt peaked at 64 percent of GDP in 2015 and trending down.

### External Debt Sustainability (Annex III Highlights)
- Baseline projection: gross external debt ratio falls from 100 percent of GDP in 2017 to 76 percent of GDP in 2023.
- Public external debt projected to decline to 45 percent of GDP in 2023.
- NIIP: from trough of -50 percent of GDP in 2012 to about -30 percent at end-2017; improving.
- Vulnerability to shocks:
  - CA shock (about 1.8 percent of GDP) would push external debt up by about 9 percentage points to 85 percent of GDP in 2023.
  - Growth shock (about 1.9 percentage points) or combination of shocks would push external debt up by about 8 percentage points.
  - Scenario with historical averages: external debt-to-GDP would rise above 99 percent in 2023.
- Selected baseline external debt series (percent of GDP):
  - External debt: 2013: 114.9; 2014: 125.8; 2015: 120.0; 2016: 111.0; 2017: 100.3; 2018: 94.3; 2019: 89.9; 2020: 85.9; 2021: 82.4; 2022: 79.2; 2023: 76.2
  - External public debt: 2013: 42.6; 2014: 62.0; 2015: 63.9; 2016: 56.9; 2017: 51.2; 2018: 49.5; 2019: 48.1; 2020: 47.0; 2021: 45.8; 2022: 44.8; 2023: 44.8
  - Debt-stabilizing non-interest current account: -1.7

### Public Debt Sustainability and Stress Tests (Annex IV and Section 3 Highlights)
- Key findings:
  - Public debt-to-GDP fell from 79 percent in 2016 to 74 percent in 2017; projected to decline below 60 percent by 2023 under baseline.
  - Contingent liabilities estimated at 12.7 percent of GDP in 2018.
  - Public debt held by non-residents: 69 percent of total public debt in 2017.
- Stress-test findings:
  - Two-year negative one-standard-deviation growth shock would push debt-to-GDP close to 80 percent by 2020 and keep it above 70 percent in the medium term.
  - Contingent liability shock based on 12.7 percent estimate could push public debt above 80 percent of GDP by 2023.
  - Combined macro-fiscal shock could keep public debt above 70 percent for prolonged period.
- Policy recommendations:
  - Build fiscal buffers while recovery continues.
  - Maintain MTO and implement structural reforms to achieve structural balance by 2020 and bring debt-to-GDP below 60 percent by 2021 under active adjustment.
  - Continue debt management, re-profiling, and privatization to lower contingent liability and non-resident holding risks.
- Relevant indicators:
  - Contingent liabilities: 12.7 percent of GDP in 2018.
  - Public debt held by non-residents: 69 percent in 2017.
  - Demographic impact: rapid ageing could reduce potential growth by about 0.5 percentage point by 2035.

### Housing Market Developments (Annex VII Highlights)
- Overview.
  - Housing prices recovered from crisis slump (2008–14) and continue to grow robustly; current valuations do not point to overheating.
  - Authorities adopted macroprudential tools preemptively; supply easing could moderate future price increases.
- Price developments and transactions.
  - Prices of used apartments in Ljubljana: +14.8 percent in 2017 (national average: +11.8 percent).
  - Overall housing price index: +13.4 percent during the year to 2018: Q2.
  - Number of residential transactions rising since 2013; sales of newly-built units remain very low.
- Affordability and demand drivers.
  - Housing remains affordable in historical and international comparison; further appreciation likely.
  - Owner-occupied housing: 77 percent of households (euro area: 60 percent).
  - Continued urbanization and income growth expected to fuel further price appreciation.
  - Urbanization rate: 54.4 percent (second-lowest in EU).
- Supply constraints and housing stock.
  - Housing stock: 410 units per 1000 residents (Austria: 547; Croatia: 524).
  - Supply constraints caused by bankruptcy of major construction firms, reluctance of banks to finance new construction, and urban planning/regulatory constraints.
- Mortgage financing and household balance sheets.
  - Share of households with a mortgage: about 10 percent (19 percent in the euro area).
  - About a third of recent housing transactions carried out with equity.
  - Mortgage lending growth: positive since 2013, nearly 5 percent year-on-year in 2017; since fallen below 4 percent.
- Macroprudential policy.
  - BoS measures: guidance on loan-to-value and DSTI ratios; countercyclical capital buffer implemented in 2016.
  - 2018 expansion: applicability of ratios expanded to include all household debt due to consumer lending growth.
  - Current data do not point to overheating, but continued increases and inflexible supply warrant close monitoring.
- Social housing and planning.
  - National Housing Program 2015–25 calls for new rental policy and increased social housing for vulnerable groups.
  - National Housing Fund could become direct supplier to alleviate affordable housing shortages.
  - Urban planning and permitting reforms recommended to increase supply and moderate price/rent increases.

*Source: 1svnea2019001 - 1. Growth-Enhancing Tax Reform (IMF staff report chapter and annexes).*

### 1. Growth-Enhancing Tax Reform ________________________________________________________________ 10

### 1. Growth-Enhancing Tax Reform

### Context
- Post-crisis recovery continues.
  - Growth accelerated to 4.9 percent in 2017 and is estimated to have reached 4.5 percent in 2018, still well above potential growth.
  - Domestic demand, particularly public investment, has picked up recently, complementing exports as a key driver of growth.
- Labor market and wages.
  - Unemployment rate has declined to about 5 percent, the lowest level in a decade.
  - Real wage grew by 2 percent in 2018.
  - Skills shortages are emerging.
- Inflation.
  - Average headline inflation estimated at 1.9 percent in 2018.
  - Core inflation remained low at around 1 percent, slightly above the euro area average.
- Fiscal and financial context.
  - Fiscal deficit was halved in 2017 to 0.8 percent of GDP, followed by a fiscal surplus of about ½ percent of GDP in 2018.
  - Financial sector soundness continues to improve; SME NPLs remain elevated.
- Social indicators.
  - GINI index at 0.24, compared to the OECD average of 0.32.
  - Share of people at risk of poverty and social exclusion was 19.9 percent in 2016, above the EU average of 17.7 percent.
- Political context.
  - The first minority coalition government in history took office in September 2018; supported by a five-party coalition and another opposition party.

### Outlook
- Near-term projections.
  - Staff expects growth to slow moderately to 3.4 percent in 2019 as export demand eases and capacity limitations and skill shortages become more severe.
  - Current account surplus projected to decline to about 5 percent of GDP in 2019.
  - Inflation projected to reach 2.2 percent in 2019.
- Medium-term projections (Text Table 1: Selected Economic Indicators, 2018–23; percent of GDP, unless noted otherwise):
  - Real GDP (annual percentage change): 2018: 4.5; 2019: 3.4; 2020: 2.8; 2021: 2.7; 2022: 2.3; 2023: 2.1
  - Potential output growth (annual percentage change): 2018: 2.7; 2019: 2.8; 2020: 2.8; 2021: 2.8; 2022: 2.7; 2023: 2.5
  - Output gap (in percent of potential GDP): 2018: 1.2; 2019: 1.8; 2020: 1.9; 2021: 1.7; 2022: 1.3; 2023: 0.9
  - Headline inflation (percent, period average): 2018: 1.9; 2019: 2.2; 2020: 2.2; 2021: 2.1; 2022: 2.0; 2023: 2.0
  - Core inflation (percent, period average): 2018: 1.1; 2019: 1.3; 2020: 1.4; 2021: 1.4; 2022: 1.4; 2023: 1.4
  - Unemployment rate (in percent, ILO definition): 2018: 5.1; 2019: 4.8; 2020: 4.9; 2021: 5.0; 2022: 5.1; 2023: 5.1
  - General government balance: 2018: 0.4; 2019: 0.0; 2020: -0.1; 2021: -0.1; 2022: -0.1; 2023: 0.0
  - Structural balance: 2018: 0.0; 2019: -0.7; 2020: -0.8; 2021: -0.8; 2022: -0.6; 2023: -0.4
  - General government debt: 2018: 68.8; 2019: 66.1; 2020: 64.0; 2021: 62.1; 2022: 60.4; 2023: 58.7
  - Current account balance: 2018: 6.4; 2019: 5.2; 2020: 4.3; 2021: 3.5; 2022: 2.5; 2023: 1.5
- Risks.
  - Downside risks from rising protectionism, intensified policy uncertainty in Europe, weaker-than-expected global demand, and faster-than-expected euro area monetary normalization.
  - Domestic political fragmentation (five-party minority government) may slow structural reforms.
- External position assessment.
  - Current account rose from a deficit of 4.1 percent of GDP in 2007 to a surplus of 6.4 percent of GDP in 2018.
  - Fund methodology implies a normative current account surplus of about 1.9 percent of GDP in 2018, implying a gap of 4.5 percent of GDP.
  - Policy gap estimated at -0.02 percent of GDP.
  - The current account gap translates into an 8 percent REER undervaluation at standard elasticities.
  - Large external surplus helps reduce external vulnerabilities and reflects desirable private sector deleveraging; surplus expected to moderate as consumption and investment recover.

### Authorities’ Views
- Authorities broadly agreed with staff’s outlook and risks.
- Central bank’s growth and inflation projections for 2019 coincide with staff views.
- Authorities highlighted rising trade conflicts and political tensions in three largest euro area economies as main risks.
- IMAD saw persistent high current account in the medium term due to strong private sector savings and uncertainty on investment, but noted risks to the current account balance are tilted to the downside.

### Policy Discussions — Fiscal Policy: Rebuild Fiscal Buffers and Ensure Sustainability
- Fiscal consolidation since 2013.
  - Structural fiscal balance improved by 2.3 percentage points of GDP between 2013 and 2017.
  - Consolidation mix: structural measures (pension reform, VAT rate increases, debt reprofiling) and temporary crisis measures (one-off freeze on wages and social transfers indexation, cut in non-EU-financed public investment).
  - Slovenia exited the Excessive Deficit Procedure in 2016.
- Remaining fiscal vulnerabilities.
  - Public debt about 69 percent of GDP constrains fiscal space.
  - Public debt above the Stability and Growth Pact rule of 60 percent of GDP.
  - Large projected long-run increase in age-related public spending; public debt will start growing rapidly in the medium term.
- 2019 Draft Budgetary Plan (DBP).
  - Amended DBP envisages fiscal expansion.
  - Headline fiscal surplus estimated at 0.4 percent of GDP in 2018, corresponding to a balanced structural position.
  - Amended DBP likely to increase structural deficit by 0.7 percent of GDP in 2019, mostly because of increased social transfers and wages with no offsetting measures.
  - Staff estimates public sector wages will increase by about 0.3 percent of GDP in 2019, followed by further wage increases in 2020.
- Staff recommendation: avoid pro-cyclical fiscal expansion and preserve structural fiscal balance in 2019.
  - Maintain the Medium-Term Objective (MTO) of structural balance as fiscal anchor.
  - Reverse or postpone additional spending plans until accommodated through spending cuts elsewhere or tax-base broadening as part of structural fiscal reforms.
  - Fiscal Council urged government to keep public finances in structural balance in 2019 and adopt measures to address long-term fiscal challenges.
- Fiscal policy areas for reform to prepare for ageing pressures: pension, health, education, and wage bill.
  - Pension system recommendations:
    - Adopt government White Paper proposals to raise retirement age to 67 and automatically adjust it to demographic trends; restrict early retirement further.
    - Additional reforms suggested: (i) indexing pensions to inflation only rather than wages; (ii) abolishing the pension bonus.
    - To increase effective retirement age: gradually eliminate the long-service early retirement provision (40 years rule) and discontinue arrangement whereby up to 5 years of service time can be purchased prior to retirement.
  - Health and education reforms:
    - Close efficiency gaps vs. euro area peers.
    - Potential reforms: (i) expand centralized procurement; (ii) improve means-testing for tertiary student financial support; (iii) link university funding to students’ labor market outcomes.
  - Wage bill reforms:
    - Undertake functional and institutional review to prepare reform of public employment.
    - Link public wage dynamics to economic conditions and reward good performance instead of automatic seniority-based increases.
    - Adopt a multi-annual remuneration framework with separate limits for number of employees and for wage increases by sector.

### Growth-Enhancing Tax Reform
- Rationale.
  - Slovenia has a relatively high tax wedge.
  - Growth-enhancing tax reform can raise revenue more efficiently while incentivizing work and boosting growth.
  - Tax expenditures are generous and erode PIT, VAT, and CIT bases; property tax revenue is well below EU average.
  - Tax expenditures stand at 4.9 percent of GDP (compared to 0.6 percent in Germany).
  - Revenue-neutral tax reform could accelerate employment growth by shifting the tax burden to less distortive sources and rationalizing tax expenditures; would improve resource allocation, encourage labor participation, and reduce informality.
- Options for reform include:
  - Cutting social security contributions and broadening VAT and PIT bases.
  - Increasing market value-based property taxes and environmental taxes.
  - Rationalizing tax expenditures and immovable property tax and capital net gains tax.
- Quantified potential fiscal impact (Text Table 3: Potential Fiscal Savings by 2020; in percent of GDP):
  - Cumulative Revenue: 0.5
    - Real estate tax: 0.8
    - Indexation of excises: 0.2
    - Broadening of VAT, CIT, PIT bases: 0.7
    - Labor tax wedge reform 1/-1.2
  - Expenditure: 1.2
    - Health care 2/: 0.3
    - Education 2/: 0.2
    - Pensions: 0.5
    - Transfers and subsidies: 0.2
  - Total Savings: 1.7
  - Notes in table:
    - 1/ Based on the OECD (2018) estimate on the option of cutting the labor tax wedge by 5 percentage points.
    - 2/ By closing part of the gap to the efficiency frontier of OECD countries, including lower wage bill.
- Growth effect.
  - A reform shifting the tax burden from labor to consumption and other taxes in a revenue-neutral way could increase Slovenia’s output level by 0.5 percent in the medium- to long-term.
- Specific Box 1 points (excerpted):
  - Tax wedge was 42.7 percent in 2016 compared to 40.3 percent in the EU28.
  - Tax reform strategies: broaden PIT base (PIT base currently eroded by PIT tax expenditure costs).

*Source: 1svnea2019001 - 1. Growth-Enhancing Tax Reform (IMF staff chapter).*

### 2.1 percent of GDP, could be broadened by withdrawing the exemptions for the reimbursement of home-to-

### 1svnea2019001 - 2.1 percent of GDP, could be broadened by withdrawing the exemptions for the reimbursement of home-to-

### Tax policy: options to raise revenue and rebalance taxation
- Broadening the VAT base by applying the standard rate (22 percent) to poorly-targeted reduced-rate (9.5 percent) supplies could raise revenue by 0.5 percent of GDP.
- Rationalizing PIT allowances: converting multiple tax allowances into cost-effective tax credits could finance downward PIT rate adjustments.
- Reducing tax exemption on benefits: performance, Christmas, and holiday bonuses could be made taxable as ordinary income.
- Reforming the capital gains tax (CGT): current CGT taxed at a flat rate of 25 percent with taper to zero percent after 20 years of holding; eliminating the CGT taper relief would make capital income taxes more progressive.
- Other revenue-raising instruments mentioned:
  - Introducing a value-based property tax.
  - Tightening the application of the flat-rate business tax.
  - Adopting stricter debt/equity limits for tax purposes.
- Quantified impact and simulation:
  - Shifting the tax burden from labor to consumption and other taxes in a revenue-neutral way could increase Slovenia’s output level by 0.5 percent in the medium- to long-term.
- Specific earlier point: a measure equivalent to 2.1 percent of GDP could be broadened by withdrawing exemptions for reimbursement of home-to-work travel expenses and the tax-free meals provided during work.

### Authorities’ fiscal stance and plans
- Authorities reiterated commitment to fiscal consolidation through structural fiscal reforms.
- They aim to reduce public debt below 60 percent of GDP in the medium term and plan to further improve fiscal space.
- Short-term: headline surplus expected to help advance public debt reduction in 2019 despite fiscal impact of public wage negotiations.
- Structural balance: authorities noted structural balance could not improve in 2019 due to decisions to improve incomes of civil servants and social transfers recipients to boost growth through consumption.
- Fiscal reforms anticipated in 2020 include revenue-neutral tax rebalancing.
- On pensions: current annual bonus cited as addressing pension adequacy for poor pensioners.
- On health: priority to reduce waiting times, including through digitalization.
- On wages: wage negotiations seen as a basis for broader mid-term public wage reform.
- Political constraint: envisaged structural reforms in 2019 would need broad consensus within the five-party coalition.

### Financial policy: legacy problems, banking sector, and macroprudential concerns
- Post-2013 banking crisis: financial sector stability improved though some legacy problems remain.
- Privatization progress:
  - Government sold 65 percent of Nova Ljubljanska Banka (NLB) in 2018 and plans to sell another 10 percent in 2019.
  - Abanka expected to be privatized in 2019.
- Banking revenue pressure: since 2012, banks’ net interest income has declined markedly and likely to fall further as policy interest rate remains low and lending recovery is uneven.
- Nonperforming loans (NPLs):
  - Overall NPLs improved, but SME NPLs remain elevated in the low double digits.
  - Staff welcomed adoption of toolkit and handbook for resolving SME NPLs and ECB measures for three directly supervised banks.
  - Supervisors should push banks to speed up resolution of SME NPLs and strengthen insolvency procedures for SMEs.
- Housing market and credit risks:
  - Housing price growth at 13.4 percent in 2018: Q2 was one of the highest in the euro area.
  - Only about 10 percent of households have a mortgage (19 percent in the euro area).
  - About a third of recent housing transactions carried out with equity (without bank financing).
- Macroprudential guidance by Bank of Slovenia (BoS) (as recommendations):
  - Loan to value ratio not to exceed 80 percent.
  - Debt service to income (DSTI) ratio limits: 50 percent for lower incomes and 67 percent for higher incomes.
  - Consumer credit maturities recommended not to exceed 120 months.
  - Staff view: limits could be made mandatory and more binding when needed.
- AML/CFT framework: shortcomings from 2017 Moneyval report should be addressed, notably enhancing targeted financial sanctions related to proliferation financing; BoS should strengthen supervision of banks’ implementation of national requirements.

### Structural reforms: labor markets, skills, SOEs, and product market regulation
- Demographic challenge: ageing population requires higher productivity and higher levels of supportive skills (information technology specialists, scientists, and engineers).
- Labor market and skills:
  - Recent reforms: Apprenticeship Act, amended Vocational Education Act, new Adult Education Act to re-establish public training network.
  - New Labor Market Act incentives:
    - When taking a full-time job, a worker will enjoy an additional 20 percent of the last unemployment benefit on top of salary until expiration of the unemployment benefit.
    - For older workers, wages are exempt from social security contributions.
  - Replacement rate context: replacement rate of unemployment benefits has been above 80 percent in the first months for low-wage earners, higher than the EU average (67 percent).
  - Recommended additional reforms:
    - Further reforming the tax-benefit system, including rebalancing taxation from labor to consumption and wealth and bringing down replacement rate closer to the EU average.
    - Increasing labor market flexibility; reduce perceived excessive protection of open-ended contracts and high layoff costs.
    - Reform unemployment benefits to “protect workers rather than jobs.”
    - Develop training in entrepreneurship and new technologies; entrepreneurship education currently well below the EU average.
- SOEs:
  - SOEs account for 20 percent of non-financial employment and make the government the largest asset holder.
  - SOEs dominant in network sectors and present in competitive sectors.
  - EC analysis suggests total factor productivity of large SOEs lags that of private companies.
  - Slovenia has underperformed in large-scale privatization relative to other CESEE countries.
  - Recommendation: accelerate privatization program; reduce list of companies classified as “strategic” and “important”; monitor SOE governance framework focusing on (i) financial reporting and auditing standards; (ii) timely and accurate disclosure rules; (iii) supervisory board; and (iv) equitable treatment of minority and foreign shareholders.
- Product and service-market reforms:
  - Regulatory burden is more restrictive than OECD average; Slovenia maintains 220 regulated professions.
  - Recommendation: reduce number of regulated professions; implement new mid-2018 legislation simplifying building permits and streamline spatial planning and construction regulation to benefit housing market and investment.
- Authorities’ views on reforms:
  - No new structural reforms planned in 2019 on these fronts while consultations continue.
  - Government will implement active employment measures to activate long-term unemployed, younger and older unemployed, and low-education groups.
  - Authorities plan to pursue privatization program and noted IPO of NLB will provide momentum.
  - Authorities highlighted SME test and one-stop shop program to reduce administrative burden.

### Staff appraisal: macroeconomic context and policy priorities
- Growth and outlook:
  - Growth continues post-crisis recovery and remains well above the euro area average in recent years.
  - Medium-term prospects constrained by adverse demographic outlook.
  - Recommendation to use positive cycle to deepen fiscal and structural reforms, rebuild fiscal buffers, and increase productivity growth.
- Fiscal stance:
  - Preserve gains from past fiscal consolidation; avoid procyclical fiscal expansion.
  - Authorities’ MTO of structural fiscal balance is an appropriate anchor to bring public debt gradually toward 60 percent of GDP.
  - Amended DBP for 2019 envisages higher spending resulting in a sizable structural deterioration; higher spending should be accommodated through fiscal savings as part of structural reforms.
  - Scope for fiscal reforms that generate permanent savings while modernizing government operations, focusing on pensions, health, education, and the wage bill; complemented by growth-enhancing tax rebalancing away from social security contributions towards property taxes and rationalizing tax expenditures.
- External sector:
  - Slovenia’s external position in 2018 assessed as substantially stronger than fundamentals and desirable policies suggest.
  - Large current account surplus is helping reduce external vulnerabilities and reflects private sector deleveraging.
  - Current account surplus expected to moderate as consumption and investment recover and NIIP improves.
- Financial stability:
  - Improved following bank restructuring and prudent macroeconomic policies.
  - BoS NPL guideline and ECB measures helped reduce NPLs; supervisory authorities should continue encouraging proactive NPL management.
  - Emerging housing market risks warrant enhanced vigilance; BoS’s proactive macroprudential toolkit build is welcome.
- Structural reforms reiterated as key to long-term prosperity and resilience:
  - Implement vocational training, apprenticeship, and adult education reforms.
  - Further increase labor market flexibility and reform tax-benefit system to make work pay.
  - Reduce administrative and regulatory burden to support investment and firm growth.
  - Accelerate privatization program to inject capital and technological know-how.

### Selected key quantitative indicators from the content
- VAT standard rate: 22 percent.
- Reduced VAT rate referenced: 9.5 percent.
- CGT flat rate: 25 percent; taper to zero after 20 years.
- Potential output uplift from tax shift (revenue-neutral): 0.5 percent increase in output level in the medium- to long-term.
- Housing price growth: 13.4 percent in 2018: Q2.
- Share of households with mortgage: about 10 percent (19 percent in the euro area).
- Share of recent housing transactions carried out with equity: about a third.
- Bank privatization sales: 65 percent of NLB sold in 2018; another 10 percent planned in 2019.
- Replacement rate of unemployment benefits for low-wage earners: above 80 percent in first months; EU average cited as 67 percent.
- SOEs share of non-financial employment: 20 percent.

*Source: Republic of Slovenia — IMF staff report content provided in the supplied PDF excerpt.*

### Annex I. Risk Assessment Matrix

### Annex I. Risk Assessment Matrix

### External risks
- Rising protectionism and retreat from multilateralism  
  - Likelihood: High  
  - Time Horizon: Short to Medium Term  
  - Expected Impact: High: Large impact on growth, given Slovenia’s integration in global supply chains and high exports. Mainly indirect as Slovenia’s EU partners with higher global trade exposure are affected.  
  - Policy Response: Accelerate structural reforms that strengthen competitiveness and raise potential growth, including labor market reforms. Step up retraining and vocational education to reduce skills mismatches. Accelerate privatization to cut public debt and raise productivity.

- Unsustainable macroeconomic policies in systemically important countries  
  - Likelihood: Medium  
  - Time Horizon: Short to Medium Term  
  - Expected Impact: Medium: Mainly indirect effects through Slovenia’s EU partners, except in case of Italy, a core trade and investment partner.  
  - Policy Response: Strengthen domestic investment if externally financed investment declines. Accelerate absorption of available EU funds.

- Sharp tightening of global financial conditions  
  - Likelihood: High  
  - Time Horizon: Short Term  
  - Expected Impact: Low: Tightening of export financing possible. Public debt servicing cost would rise, but impact mitigated by long debt maturities.  
  - Policy Response: Accelerate development of equity and bond financing. Accelerate bank and enterprise balance sheet repair.

- Weaker global growth (Euro Area; US; China)  
  - Likelihood: Medium (Euro Area), Medium (US), Low to Medium (China)  
  - Time Horizon: Medium Term (Euro Area, US), Short to medium Term (China)  
  - Expected Impact: High: Slower EU growth directly depresses growth potential and lowers export growth. Growth shocks from US and China would mainly be indirect.  
  - Policy Response: Accelerate structural reforms to spur investment, productivity and competitiveness, including labor market reforms. Accelerate privatization to cut public debt and raise productivity. Step up efforts to reduce skills mismatches.

- Intensification of risks of security dislocation → sharp rise in migrant flows into Europe  
  - Likelihood: High  
  - Time Horizon: Short to medium term  
  - Expected Impact: Low: Fiscal impact of migrant flows has so far been manageable.  
  - Policy Response: Rebuild fiscal buffers to accommodate shock within broader consolidation envelope.

- Sizeable deviation from baseline energy prices  
  - Likelihood: Medium  
  - Time Horizon: Short to medium term  
  - Expected Impact: Medium: energy prices affect costs and prices; low impact on relative competitiveness versus regional peers.  
  - Policy Response: Maintain market-determined energy prices and encourage sufficient buffers to absorb price shocks.

- Cyber-attacks on critical global infrastructure  
  - Likelihood: Medium  
  - Time Horizon: Short to medium term  
  - Expected Impact: Low: as an open, trade-dependent economy, disruptions in the Euro Area would be directly felt.  
  - Policy Response: Strengthen domestic defenses including back-up systems and financial cushions and promote international cooperation.

### Domestic Risks
- Failure to design and implement credible reform-based fiscal consolidation; unsustainable expenditure commitments (e.g., public pensions)  
  - Likelihood: Medium  
  - Time Horizon: Medium Term  
  - Expected Impact: Medium: Insufficient capacity to counter growth shocks and to finance pro-growth investment, inability to prepare adequately for ageing.  
  - Policy Response: Announce and implement a reform-based consolidation strategy with measures that optimize spending in health care and education, further reform the pension system, and close revenue gaps.

- Delays in resolving NPLs, especially of SMEs, and cleaning bank and company balance sheets  
  - Likelihood: Low  
  - Time Horizon: Short/Medium term  
  - Expected Impact: Medium: Companies with burdened balance sheets will continue to be cut off bank financing.  
  - Policy Response: Closely monitor implementation of guidelines for SME NPL resolution. Let the BAMC restructure companies under its control.

### Foreign Assets and Liabilities — Key findings and assessments
- Background: Slovenia’s NIIP is estimated at about -20 percent of GDP at the end of 2018 (with gross external debt at about 94 percent of GDP). With the global financial crisis (GFC), Slovenia’s NIIP plummeted rapidly to -50 percent of GDP as external debt rose to about 119 percent of GDP. The relative improvement in the NIIP during 2012–18 was supported by the current account surplus as investment and consumption were reduced.  
- Assessment: As the NIIP is still relatively large and negative, the current account surplus should be viewed from this perspective. Overall Assessment: The external position was substantially stronger than implied by medium-term fundamentals and desirable policies. As the NIIP is still relatively large and negative, the large external surplus helps reduce external vulnerabilities.  
- Policy Responses: Slovenia’s current account surplus is expected to moderate as consumption and investment fully recover from the global financial crisis and the NIIP improves and becomes positive. Policies to address legacy problems (¶15) and product and service-market reforms (¶26) could boost investment and help reduce the current account surplus.

### Annex II — External Sector Assessment: current account, REER, capital and financial accounts
- Current Account: Background: current account balance shifted from -4.1 percent of GDP to 6.4 percent of GDP between 2007 and 2018. The surplus reflects temporary rise in private sector saving to deleverage and improve the negative NIIP.  
  - Assessment (EBA-lite): current account surplus is 4.5 percentage points higher than expected. As NIIP is still relatively large and negative, the current surplus is helping to deleverage the private sector.  
  - Actual CA: 6.4  
  - CA Norm: 1.9  
  - CA gap: 4.5  
  - Policy Gap: -0.02  
  - Implied REER gap: -8

- Real Exchange Rate (REER): Background: REER relatively stable; REER appreciated 0.4 percent during 2018, mostly due to slightly lower inflation in Slovenia. Using standard elasticities, current account norm implies an 8 percent REER undervaluation, while REER model shows minor REER gap of 0.03.  
  - Assessment: Exchange rate appears in line with medium-term fundamentals and desirable policies; overall assessment relies on current account model due to poor fit of REER model for Slovenia.  
  - Actual REER: 4.59  
  - REER Norm: 4.56  
  - REER gap: 0.03

- Capital and Financial Accounts: Background: Current account surpluses since 2012 allowed bank and corporate sectors to accumulate assets and reduce investment liabilities. Inward FDI flows, near zero percent of GDP in 2012, projected to be below 3 percent of GDP in 2018. Government external debt peaked at 64 percent of GDP in 2015 and is now trending down.  
  - Assessment: Slovenia has reduced net external liabilities, particularly through acquisition of portfolio assets abroad. As demand and imports pick up and current account surplus declines, net financial outflows should also decline.

- Foreign Exchange Intervention and Reserves: Background and Assessment: the euro is a global reserve currency. Reserves held by the euro area are typically low relative to standard metrics, but the currency is free floating.

### Annex III — External Debt Sustainability Analysis: key points and projections
- Projection summary: gross external debt ratio projected to fall gradually from 100 percent of GDP in 2017 to 76 percent of GDP in 2023. Between end-2016 and end-2017, external debt fell by 11 percentage points of GDP, contributed by falling public external debt and external liabilities of banks. Over the medium term, private sector expected to continue to reduce external debt significantly while public external debt is projected to decline by about 6 percentage points to 45 percent of GDP in 2023.

- NIIP: remains negative but improving. NIIP increased from trough of -50 percent of GDP in 2012 to about -30 percent of GDP at end-2017. Projected sizable, albeit declining, current account surpluses over the medium term will further support closing gap toward a balanced NIIP.

- Vulnerability to shocks: External debt dynamics show moderate vulnerability to standard shocks. With low interest rates and most debt euro-denominated, an increase in nominal interest rates or a depreciation are not expected to materially affect outlook.  
  - A shock to current account (about 1.8 percent of GDP) would push external debt up by about 9 percentage points to 85 percent of GDP in 2023.  
  - A shock to real GDP growth (about 1.9 percentage points) or a combination of smaller shocks to interest rates, growth, and the current account would push external debt up by about 8 percentage points.  
  - Scenario with key variables at their historical averages shows external debt-to-GDP would rise above 99 percent in 2023, mainly driven by historical debt accumulation by financial institutions during the GFC and 2012–13 banking crisis; repeat appears unlikely given past authorities’ responses.

- Table 1 (selected baseline projections and indicators):  
  - Baseline: External debt — 2013: 114.9; 2014: 125.8; 2015: 120.0; 2016: 111.0; 2017: 100.3; 2018: 94.3; 2019: 89.9; 2020: 85.9; 2021: 82.4; 2022: 79.2; 2023: 76.2. Debt-stabilizing non-interest current account: -1.7.  
  - Of which: external public debt — 2013: 42.6; 2014: 62.0; 2015: 63.9; 2016: 56.9; 2017: 51.2; 2018: 49.5; 2019: 48.1; 2020: 47.0; 2021: 45.8; 2022: 44.8; 2023: 44.8.  
  - Change in external debt (selected years): 2013: -3.9; 2014: 10.8; 2015: -5.8; 2016: -8.9; 2017: -10.7; 2018: -6.1; 2019: -4.4; 2020: -3.9; 2021: -3.5; 2022: -3.2; 2023: -3.0.  
  - Identified external debt-creating flows (4+8+9) (selected years): 2013: -5.0; 2014: -11.9; 2015: -7.6; 2016: -12.6; 2017: -15.3; 2018: -12.0; 2019: -9.1; 2020: -7.5; 2021: -6.1; 2022: -4.8; 2023: -3.6.  
  - Current account deficit, excluding interest payments (selected years): 2013: -6.9; 2014: -8.7; 2015: -7.3; 2016: -8.5; 2017: -9.6; 2018: -8.7; 2019: -7.5; 2020: -6.6; 2021: -5.7; 2022: -4.6; 2023: -3.6.  
  - Exports (selected years): 2013: 74.5; 2014: 75.8; 2015: 77.1; 2016: 78.0; 2017: 83.1; 2018: 83.5; 2019: 85.6; 2020: 86.4; 2021: 87.2; 2022: 87.4; 2023: 87.8.  
  - Imports (selected years): 2013: 67.8; 2014: 68.2; 2015: 68.4; 2016: 68.6; 2017: 73.2; 2018: 73.8; 2019: 77.2; 2020: 79.2; 2021: 80.8; 2022: 82.1; 2023: 83.5.  
  - External debt-to-exports ratio (selected years): 2013: 154.2; 2014: 165.8; 2015: 155.6; 2016: 142.4; 2017: 120.7; 2018: 112.9; 2019: 105.1; 2020: 99.4; 2021: 94.5; 2022: 90.6; 2023: 86.8.  
  - Gross external financing need (in billions of US dollars) (selected years): 2013: 14.2; 2014: 10.4; 2015: 9.7; 2016: 11.2; 2017: 2.8; 2018: 2.5; 2019: 2.9; 2020: 2.2; 2021: 3.0; 2022: 2.2; 2023: 2.3.

- External Debt Sustainability: Bound tests (figure summary): Baseline external debt in 2023: 76 (percent of GDP). Scenario impacts: CA shock pushes to 85; combined shock to 85; real depreciation shock to 82; growth shock to 84. Individual and combined permanent shocks applied per note specifications.

### Annex IV — Public Sector Debt Sustainability Analysis: summary and projections
- Key finding: Slovenia’s elevated public debt decreased due to continued fiscal consolidation and favorable growth developments, but substantial vulnerabilities remain. Public debt-to-GDP ratio fell from 79 percent in 2016 to 74 percent in 2017 and is projected to further decline to below 60 percent by 2023. Combined macro-fiscal shocks and shocks to growth or contingent liabilities pose major risks to the baseline scenario.

- Narrative: Fiscal consolidation and favorable growth reduced debt after the 2013 banking-sector-related spike (public debt peaked at 83 percent of GDP in 2015). Measures included VAT increase and restraining spending from pension reforms and one-off measures. Robust exports to the EU drove growth recovery, boosting revenue and lowering the debt-to-GDP ratio; Slovenia exited the EC’s EDP in 2016.

- Baseline scenario assumptions:  
  - Real GDP Growth is forecasted to slow from 4.5 percent in 2018 to 2.1 percent in 2023. Domestic demand projected to gradually replace net exports in contributing to growth. Inflation is to remain moderate at around 2 percent. Despite a structural fiscal expansion in 2019, some gradual fiscal consolidation would resume in the medium term.  
  - Authorities continue to implement ongoing structural reforms in the medium term, including completing planned bank privatization and strengthening implementation of labor market reforms; these are not sufficient to achieve structural balance by 2020.  
  - Baseline projections underpinned by realistic assumptions within ranges achieved by similar countries. Over 2008–17, staff projections remained close to or more conservative than the median, except around 2012–13 crisis. Recent years after the crisis saw growth and fiscal outturns exceed projections. Projected fiscal adjustments close to median of comparator countries.

_Republished from Annexes I–IV of the IMF staff report for the Republic of Slovenia._

### 3.      Despite improvements, Slovenia’s debt dynamics are vulnerable to specific shocks as

### 3.      Despite improvements, Slovenia’s debt dynamics are vulnerable to specific shocks as

### Stress-test findings and shock scenarios
- Growth shock
  - A negative one-standard-deviation growth shock over two years would push the debt-to-GDP ratio close to 80 percent by 2020 and remain above 70 percent in the medium term.
  - Illustrates importance of structural reforms to achieve a high and sustainable growth path, especially given rapid ageing in the medium to long term.
- Contingent liabilities shock
  - Authorities estimate contingent liabilities are about 12.7 percent of GDP in 2018, including guarantees provided to SOEs.
  - A specific contingent liability shock based on this estimate could create a rising public debt trajectory that would exceed 80 percent of GDP by 2023.
  - Mitigating factors: privatization progress of the largest state-owned bank, NLB; the third largest state-owned bank planned to be privatized in 2019; the Single Resolution Mechanism would help mitigate potential banking-sector contingent liability impacts similar to the 2013–14 crisis.
- Combined macro-fiscal shock
  - A combination of shocks to GDP growth, inflation, fiscal balance, exchange rate, and interest rate spread could result in public debt remaining above 70 percent of GDP for a prolonged period.
  - Recent estimates suggest rapid population ageing could reduce potential growth by about 0.5 percentage point by 2035, making such a shock more likely.
- Non-resident holdings vulnerability
  - Public debt held by non-residents was 69 percent of total public debt in 2017, higher than cross-country benchmarks.
  - Authorities’ debt re-profiling and continued prudent debt management would help reduce this risk over time.

### Key debt-sustainability projections and scenarios
- Staff assessment and baseline/alternative outcomes:
  - An active fiscal adjustment consistent with staff recommendations would achieve structural fiscal balance by 2020 and bring the debt-to-GDP ratio to below 60 percent by 2021.
  - Without such adjustment or under adverse shocks (growth, contingent liabilities, combined macro-fiscal), public debt could reach or exceed 80 percent of GDP in stressed scenarios (by 2020–2023 depending on shock).
- Stress-test types reported (as presented by staff)
  - Primary Balance Shock
  - Real GDP Growth Shock (including the two-year one-standard-deviation scenario)
  - Real Interest Rate Shock
  - Real Exchange Rate Shock
  - Combined Macro-Fiscal Shock
  - Contingent Liabilities Shock

### Policy recommendations and fiscal strategy
- Build fiscal buffers now given a matured recovery and rapid ageing pressures.
- Maintain the authorities’ MTO as appropriate.
- Accelerate structural reforms to:
  - Achieve structural balance by 2020.
  - Further cut public debt to below 60 percent to meet Stability and Growth Pact requirements.
  - Implement structural fiscal reforms on taxes, wages, and other public spending as discussed in the staff report.
  - Improve the labor market, privatize SOEs, and stimulate private investment and productivity growth to enhance growth, economic resilience, and reduce public debt.
- Continue debt management measures, re-profiling, and privatization to lower contingent liability and non-resident holding risks.

### Relevant fiscal and macro indicators cited
- Contingent liabilities: 12.7 percent of GDP in 2018.
- Public debt held by non-residents: 69 percent of total public debt in 2017.
- Stress outcomes:
  - Debt-to-GDP close to 80 percent by 2020 under a two-year negative one-standard-deviation growth shock.
  - Debt could exceed 80 percent of GDP by 2023 under a contingent liability shock based on the 12.7 percent estimate.
- Staff fiscal-outcome objective:
  - Structural fiscal balance by 2020.
  - Debt-to-GDP below 60 percent by 2021 under active adjustment per staff recommendations.
- Demographic impact on potential growth:
  - Rapid population ageing could reduce potential growth by about 0.5 percentage point by 2035.

### Output gap, potential growth, and reform implications (Annex V highlights)
- Output gap assessment methods: production function (PF) approach, Hodrick-Prescott (HP) filter, and multivariate filter (MVF).
- Output gap dynamics:
  - Negative output gap closed in 2017; a positive gap emerged in 2018.
  - Positive gap projected to remain significant in 2019–20 and gradually decline through the medium term.
  - Output gap estimates exhibit high volatility; PF estimates have higher standard deviations compared to euro area countries.
- Drivers of volatility and uncertainty:
  - High openness in trade and small size of the economy.
  - Short time-series constraints for MVF (housing price data available after 2008).
  - Real-time estimates subject to sizable revisions and optimism bias.
- Policy implication: advancing structural reforms, diversifying the economy, and building buffers would help address volatility of actual and potential output.

### Implementation progress reported by authorities (Annex VI excerpts)
- Bank privatization: privatization of the largest bank advanced in 2018; privatization of the third largest bank planned for 2019.
- Consolidation and reforms: consolidation continued with some revenue measures, one-off restraints on wages, pensions, and benefits, and debt management operations that reduced interest costs.
- NPLs and financial sector: an independent Bank Asset Management Company continued to reduce NPLs; progress less pronounced for SMEs.
- Structural reforms: measures to reduce rigidity of open-ended contracts and programs for life-long learning, vocational training, and apprenticeships; corporate-sector deleveraging advanced and banks’ overall asset quality improved.
- Slovenia Sovereign Holding: strengthened operational targets for SOEs, but no new strategy to reduce number of companies classified as “strategic” or “important.”

*Source: IMF staff report (as contained in the PDF chapter).*

### Annex VII. Housing Market Developments

### Annex VII. Housing Market Developments

### Overview
- Housing prices have completed their recovery from the deep slump during the double-dip crisis (2008–14) and continue to grow robustly, but current valuations do not point to overheating.
- Authorities have adopted macroprudential policy tools preemptively and continue to monitor developments.
- Easing supply constraints on the housing market could help to moderate future price increases.

### Price developments and transactions
- Residential real estate prices rose at their fastest pace in 2017 since the outbreak of the crisis, recording the third highest rate in the euro area and a record number of transactions.
- Prices of used apartments in Ljubljana increased by 14.8 percent during 2017, compared to the national average increase of 11.8 percent.
- The overall housing price index rose 13.4 percent during the year to 2018: Q2.
- The number of residential real estate transactions has been rising after 2013, yet sales of newly-built units has dropped further from very low levels.

### Affordability and demand drivers
- Housing remains affordable in historical and international comparison, and further appreciation in real house prices is likely.
- Wages and disposable incomes have increased since 2008, while real estate prices have only just reached their pre-crisis level.
- By some measures, the ratio of real estate prices to incomes stood at their long-term average in 2018.
- At 54.4 percent, Slovenia has the second-lowest urbanization rate in the EU.
- Continued urbanization and growth in household incomes are expected to fuel continued appreciation of real estate prices.

### Supply constraints and housing stock
- The supply of new residential housing has failed to keep pace with demand.
- The stock of housing in Slovenia is low by regional standards with 410 units per 1000 residents (compared to 547 in Austria and 524 in Croatia).
- The lack of supply response is related to:
  - bankruptcy of major construction companies during the crisis years,
  - reluctance of banks to finance new construction,
  - constraints placed on new construction by urban planning and regulation.

### Mortgage financing and household balance sheets
- Mortgage financing is not a significant driver of housing price developments.
- Ownership and mortgage statistics:
  - Owner-occupied housing: 77 percent of households (compared to 60 percent in the euro area).
  - Share of households with a mortgage: about 10 percent (19 percent in the euro area).
  - About a third of recent housing transactions was carried out with equity (i.e., without bank financing).
- Mortgage lending growth:
  - Positive since 2013, nearly reaching 5 percent year-on-year in 2017, but has since fallen back to below 4 percent.

### Macroprudential policy and banking sector monitoring
- The Bank of Slovenia (BoS) has adopted macro-prudential policy tools as a preemptive step.
- Current data do not point to an overheating housing market or exposure by the banking sector, but continued price increases and the inflexible supply response warrant close monitoring.
- Measures implemented:
  - Guidance to banks on loan-to-value and DSTI ratios related to residential real estate transactions and a countercyclical capital buffer were implemented in 2016.
  - In 2018, the applicability of the ratios was expanded to include not only mortgages but all household debt, prompted by rapidly growing consumer lending (albeit from a low level).
- Rationale: Early adoption of the tools affords the banking sector time to adjust and monitor lending practices accordingly.

### Social housing policy
- The government seeks to improve the supply of social housing.
- National Housing Program 2015–25 (adopted in 2015) calls for a new rental policy and an increase in social housing stock for vulnerable groups, including young families and the elderly.
- The National Housing Fund, currently financing social housing investments by municipalities, could become a direct supplier, alleviating shortages of affordable housing.

### Urban planning and regulatory reform
- Urban planning practices impede the market response to rising house prices:
  - Zoning restrictions and the effort and time required to obtain all required permits before starting new construction projects slow supply response.
- Regulatory reform of urban planning and permitting could help increase supply and slow increases in real estate prices and rents.

*Source: Annex VII. Housing Market Developments (1svnea2019001).*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/cr/2019/1svnea2019001.pdf_
