## 1tunea2019001 - EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [1tunea2019001 - EXECUTIVE SUMMARY](https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/cr/2019/1tunea2019001.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/files/publications/cr/2019/1tunea2019001.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/files/publications/cr/2019/1tunea2019001.pdf.json)

---

### Macroeconomic developments and near-term outlook
- Growth and labor:
  - Real GDP growth: 2.6 percent in 2018.
  - Growth projection (staff baseline): 2016: 1.1; 2017: 2.0; 2018: 2.6; 2019: 2.7; 2020: 3.2; 2021: 3.4; 2022: 3.9; 2023: 4.0; 2024: 4.0 (percent).
  - Unemployment rate persisted above 15 percent; unemployment: 15.4 percent in 2018.
- Prices and monetary:
  - Inflation: peak of 7.7 percent in June 2018; declined to 6.9 percent in April 2019.
  - Underlying inflation: 8.8 percent in December 2018 to 7.6 percent in April 2019.
  - Policy interest rate: most recent 100 bps hike in February 2019 increased the policy interest rate to 7.75 percent.
  - Broad money growth halved; credit growth to the economy: 13 percent in 2017 to 8 percent in 2018; credit to the economy further decelerated to 7 percent in Q1 2019.
- External sector and reserves:
  - Current account deficit: widened to 11.2 percent of GDP in 2018.
  - Export volumes: annualized decline of 3.4 percent in Q1 2019; import volumes fell by 5.1 percent in Q1 2019.
  - International reserves: dropped to 72 days of imports at end-June 2018, recovered to 83 days in March 2019; gross official reserves (billions of US$): 2016: 5.9; 2017: 5.6; 2018: 5.2; 2019: 5.9; 2020: 6.4; 2021: 6.7; 2022: 7.3; 2023: 7.9; 2024: 8.9.
  - Reserve coverage (months of next year's imports): 2016: 3.4; 2017: 3.0; 2018: 2.8; 2019: 3.2; 2020: 3.3; 2021: 3.4; 2022: 3.6; 2023: 3.8; 2024: 3.9.
- Public debt and fiscal:
  - Central government debt: increased to 77 percent of GDP at end-2018.
  - Gross central government debt (percent of GDP): 2016: 62.3; 2017: 70.6; 2018: 77.1; 2019: 83.1; 2020: 84.7; 2021: 82.2; 2022: 78.0; 2023: 73.2; 2024: 68.7.
  - External debt (percent of GDP): 2016: 72.9; 2017: 84.2; 2018: 94.1; 2019: 104.5; 2020: 107.8; 2021: 105.2; 2022: 101.2; 2023: 96.2; 2024: 91.0.
- Financial markets:
  - Stock market index declining since August 2018; credit spreads trended upwards since early 2018.

### Program performance and conditionality
- Quantitative performance:
  - End-March quantitative targets: all but two were met.
  - QPCs met: primary fiscal balance and current primary expenditures (by wide margins), social spending, and net FX interventions of the CBT (aided by increased private FX inflows in Q1).
  - QPCs missed: net domestic assets (NDA) and net international reserves (NIR). NDA missed because CBT accommodated all commercial bank refinancing in a negative real interest rate environment; NIR missed due to lower-than-expected external financing since June 2018.
- Indicative Targets and Structural Benchmarks:
  - All ITs met up to April 2019 except the monthly IT on CBT’s FX interventions in August–November 2018 and January 2019.
  - Structural Benchmarks (SBs) for the Fifth Review: four of nine achieved; two SBs implemented with delay; four of nine SBs not met and need reprogramming; one SB remained unachievable amid social pressures.
- Prior Actions (all achieved in May):
  - A price increase of 6 percent on average for the main fuels.
  - Electricity and gas tariff hikes reducing subsidies by TD 74 million.
  - Measures worth TD 100 million to strengthen public health care for low-income families.
- Fund support and access:
  - Completion of the Fifth Review would make available SDR 176.7824 million (about US$245 million).
  - Proposed rephasing of remaining access; staff supports waivers of nonobservance of performance criteria and the rephasing of access.

### Key near-term indicators (selected)
- Real GDP growth: 2.6 percent in 2018; projected to reach 4 percent under sustained policies.
- Consumer price index growth (period average): 2016: 3.6; 2017: 5.3; 2018: 7.3; 2019: 7.2; 2020: 5.9; 2021: 4.5; 2022: 4.3; 2023: 4.1; 2024: 4.0 (percent).
- Current account balance (percent of GDP): 2016: -9.3; 2017: -10.2; 2018: -11.2; 2019: -10.1; 2020: -9.1; 2021: -8.2; 2022: -7.3; 2023: -6.4; 2024: -5.8.
- Gross official reserves (billions of US$): 2016: 5.9; 2017: 5.6; 2018: 5.2; 2019: 5.9; 2020: 6.4; 2021: 6.7; 2022: 7.3; 2023: 7.9; 2024: 8.9.

### Major risks to the baseline
- Domestic risks: socio-political tensions, deterioration in security, policy and reform slippages ahead of elections.
- External risks: higher oil prices, spillovers from regional conflicts, further slowing of EU growth, rising trade tensions, adverse investor sentiment.
- Oil price sensitivity:
  - A US$10 increase in the international oil price would worsen the energy subsidy bill by about 1.2 percent of GDP.
  - A hedge for one-third of Tunisia’s 2019 energy import needs at US$65 per barrel would reduce expected budget cost.

---

### Fiscal policy — objectives, pressures, and measures
- Medium-term anchor and targets:
  - Authorities seek to limit the 2019 deficit to 3.9 percent of GDP (excluding grants).
  - Primary balance deficit target of 1.0 percent of GDP in 2019.
  - Medium-term anchor: improve the primary fiscal balance to a surplus of 2.9 percent of GDP by 2023 and push public debt back below 70 percent of GDP.
- Key fiscal levers:
  - Wage bill growth significantly below nominal GDP.
  - Phase out energy subsidies.
  - Reduce budget outlays on pensions.
  - Contain contingent risks from SOEs.
- Near-term pressures:
  - Pre-election unanticipated wage increases and withdrawal of planned energy price hikes threaten the 2019 deficit target.
  - Revenue overperformance totaling 2.6 (percent of GDP) decomposed as: Direct taxes 1.2; Indirect taxes 0.8; Non-taxes 0.4; Grants 0.2.
  - Current spending pressures total -2.2 (percent of GDP) including: Wage bill -0.8 (percent of GDP) (of which wage increase -0.5); goods and services -0.1; interest bill -0.2; food subsidy -0.2; energy subsidy -0.4; other transfers -0.6; social -0.3; CNRPS -0.2; civil servants -0.1.
- Specific fiscal measures implemented or planned:
  - 2018 revenue package: 2.2 percent of GDP and reinforcement of tax administration.
  - Elimination of the preferential tax regime for off-shore companies in December 2018.
  - Authorities aim to cap the 2019 energy subsidy bill at 2.3 percent of GDP.
  - First set of energy subsidy measures (0.5 percent of GDP) implemented between March and May 2019.
  - New social measures worth 0.3 percent of GDP to protect low-income families.
  - Two social electricity tariffs: up to 50 kWh at TD 0.075 per kWh; 51–100 kWh at TD 0.108 per kWh.
  - Pension reform (CNRPS): increase retirement age from 60 to 62 and higher contributions (additional 2 and 1 percentage points from employers and employees, respectively); 2019 budget must absorb a one-off transfer of 0.2 percent of GDP due to delayed adoption.
  - Unallocated spending buffer of 0.3 percent of GDP.
  - Hedging one-third of oil import needs proposed to mitigate oil-price risk.
- Social protection and targeting:
  - AMEN social database established (March 2019); at end-March covers some 600,000 households (about 20 percent of total households), half with validated income/expenditure data.
  - Objective to increase systems’ coverage of low-income households with verified needs and in possession of a payments card from 9 percent to at least 12 percent by end-2019.
  - Social measures package in 2019 (excluding social security funds) totals 367 TD millions — 0.32 Percent of GDP: current expenditure 250 TD millions — 0.22 Percent of GDP; capital expenditure 117 TD millions — 0.10 Percent of GDP.
  - Specific allocations: TD 100 million health fund; TD 50 million medicine purchases; TD 50 million unpaid energy invoices assistance; TD 35 million one-off transfers; TD 117 million health infrastructure investment.

### Fiscal medium-term priorities
- Growth-friendly revenue mobilization:
  - Eliminate preferential tax regime for off-shore companies by 2021.
  - Raise the VAT rate for liberal professions from 13 to 19 percent (reprogrammed SB for December 2019).
  - Improve tax administration, information exchange, targeted audits, AML/CFT efforts, and IT-supported processes.
- Public financial management:
  - Organic budget law enacted (implemented with delay in January).
  - Improve cash management and coordination with CBT on central government liquidity needs.
  - Finalize performance contract for TUNISAIR (reprogrammed SB for July 2019).

---

### Monetary policy, banking sector, and exchange rate stance
- Monetary stance and operations:
  - CBT policy tightening: three policy rate hikes: +100 bps in June 2018, +75 bps in March 2018, and +100 bps in February 2019; cumulative 275 basis points in 12 months.
  - Broadening interest rate corridor from +/- 25 bps to +/- 100 bps in January 2018.
  - Reduce CBT refinancing target: from TD 16.5 billion at end-March to TD 14.0 billion by December (target); CBT committed to reducing refinancing to TD 13.9 billion by end-2019 (from TD 16.4 billion in March 2019 in other text references).
  - Reduction in CBT FX swaps used for dinar liquidity injections: from TD 2.9 billion in August 2018 to TD 1.6 billion as of March 29, 2019; gradual reduction of FX swaps to TD 500 million by Q4 2019.
  - Raise share of Treasury bills in eligible collateral from 40 percent to 50 percent (new SB for September 2019).
  - Gradual reduction of loan-to-deposit (LTD) ratios by 2 percent each quarter for banks with ratios above 120 percent; maintain LTD ratio imposed since November 2018.
- Financial soundness indicators:
  - System-wide capital adequacy ratio: 11.7 (December 2018).
  - Nonperforming loans: 13.4 percent of total loans in December 2018 (down from 14.2 in September 2018).
  - Liquid assets to total assets: 4.5 percent at end-2018 (from 5.7 percent at end-2017).
  - Ratio of liquid assets to short-term liabilities: 75.2 percent (down from 91.7 percent).
  - As of March 2019, five banks not compliant with LCR increased to 100 percent in January.
- Exchange rate policy and FX market:
  - Start of competitive FX auctions in August 2018 and increase of auction frequency in 2019.
  - Maintain competitive FX auctions with a reduced FX intervention budget and effective communication to market-making commercial banks.
  - Staff assessment: real exchange rate remains overvalued by about 15 percent at end-2018 according to the IMF EBA methodology.
  - Policy objective: turn around the current account deficit by at least 1 percent of GDP in 2019 and strengthen international reserve cover to 3.2 months of imports.
  - Continue using auctions to purchase FX to help replenish reserves; reduce ceiling on net FX interventions (e.g., reduce intervention ceiling to US$100 million on average during May–December 2019 compared to average US$126 million in 2018).

### Financial sector reform and stability measures
- Strengthen banking supervision and risk management; prepare for Basel III and IFRS adoption.
- Restructure state-owned banks and reduce NPLs using new laws for out-of-court workouts and write-offs.
- Improve monitoring of banks’ financial soundness via internal CBT committee and enforce market access sanctions.
- Implement decashing strategy: launch e-payment institutions and interoperable mobile payment solution; mandate tax administration and SOEs to accept credit cards and e-payments.
- Improve SOE governance and surveillance: require monthly balance sheets on treasury operations and indebtedness from SOEs; reduce STEG losses via "smart meters" and collect unpaid invoices (TD 140 million arrears collection target; expected savings TD 300 million in 2019 including collection).

---

### Debt sustainability and stress tests
- Baseline public debt projections:
  - Nominal gross public debt (percent of GDP): 2017: 47.6; 2018: 70.6; 2019: 77.1; 2020: 83.2; 2021: 84.7; 2022: 82.2; 2023: 78.1; 2024: 73.2.
  - Public gross financing needs (percent of GDP): 2017: 7.8; 2018: 10.9; 2019: 10.8; 2020: 10.6; 2021: 9.1; 2022: 9.6; 2023: 7.5; 2024: 7.5.
  - Net public debt (percent of GDP): 2017: 43.2; 2018: 67.9; 2019: 74.5; 2020: 80.4; 2021: 82.0; 2022: 79.5; 2023: 75.3; 2024: 70.5.
- External debt dynamics and vulnerabilities:
  - External debt (percent of GDP): 2018: 94.1; 2019: 104.5; 2020: 107.8; 2021: 105.2; 2022: 101.2; 2023: 96.2; 2024: 91.0.
  - Total external debt stock (2018): TD Mio: 99,261; US$ Mio: 33,149; %GDP: 94.1.
  - By maturity (2018): MLT: TD 78,454 | US$ 26,200 | %GDP 74.4 | % of total 79.0; ST: TD 20,807 | US$ 6,949 | %GDP 19.7 | % of total 21.0.
  - By currency (2018): US$ share TD 22,036 | US$ 7,359 | %GDP 20.9 | % of total 22.2; EUR share TD 55,189 | US$ 18,431 | %GDP 52.3 | % of total 55.6; JPY share TD 9,231 | US$ 3,083 | %GDP 8.8 | % of total 9.3.
  - By creditor (2018): Official TD 45,323 | US$ 15,136 | %GDP 43.0 | % of total 45.7; Private (market) TD 17,198 | US$ 5,744 | %GDP 16.3 | % of total 17.3; Other (incl. sukuk) TD 18,335 | US$ 6,123 | %GDP 17.4 | % of total 18.5.
- Stress-test results:
  - Debt dynamics vulnerable to interest rate shocks, growth shocks, and real exchange rate depreciation.
  - One-time 30 percent real exchange rate depreciation in projection period would raise external debt ratio to 155 percent of GDP in 2020 and to 131 percent at end of projection horizon.
  - Contingent liability shock (one-off 10 percent of GDP) implies additional bank recapitalization costs of 3 percent of GDP and realization of about 7 percent of GDP of government contingent liabilities to public enterprises.
- DSA conclusion:
  - Public debt remains sustainable with strong policies but is vulnerable to exchange rate depreciation and contingent liabilities.
  - External debt generally resilient to shocks except for strong dinar depreciation, aided by low average interest rate, relatively long maturities, a substantial share of concessional debt, and a large grant element in new loans.

---

### Structural reforms, private sector, and governance
- Priorities to boost private sector and jobs:
  - Strengthen governance and reduce corruption: establish High Anti-Corruption Authority; Parliament to consider shortlist of candidates for its Board (reprogrammed SB for September 2019).
  - Improve business climate: adopt secondary legislation for recent laws, simplify administrative procedures, update product/service/labor regulations, modernize infrastructure, address skill mismatches.
  - Improve access to finance: reduce NPL portfolios in public banks; progress on de-cashing and acceptance of electronic payments by tax administration and SOEs; adopt laws on credit bureaus and modern collateral registry.
  - Complete FATF action plan to exit FATF grey list by demonstrating a functional targeted financial sanctions regime against terrorism and proliferation financing.
  - Encourage trade: repeal 2017 exchange restriction banning trade credits for imports deemed non-essential (already removed).
- Structural measures implemented 2018–19 (selected):
  - Civil service hiring limit: 3,000 new recruits in 2018 and 2019 (25 percent replacement ratio).
  - Departure of about 6,600 civil servants in 2018 (5,000 early retirement; 1,600 voluntary separations).
  - Creation of one-stop shop for investors (March 2018).
  - Parliamentary passage of organic budget law (January 2019).
  - Reform of public pension fund (April 2019).
  - Functional reviews of four key ministries completed (Health, Education, Finance, Infrastructure, June 2018).

---

### Program monitoring, conditionality adjustments, and financing
- Proposed adjustments to conditionality:
  - Modify QPCs for end-June 2019 to reflect wage increases and frontloaded spending: increase ceiling on current primary expenditures; lower floor on primary balance; increase floor on social spending; increase ceiling on NDA but consistent with monetary tightening; reduce floor on NIR; reduce ceilings on net FX interventions; adjust monthly IT on net FX interventions.
  - Reprogram four SBs and set four new SBs (including targeted transfers to low-income households; financial support for unpaid energy bills; arrears collection of STEG; increase share of government paper to 50 percent in collateral for CBT refinancing).
- Financing status:
  - Financing needs for next 12 months fully covered, aided by unanticipated budget support loan from Saudi Arabia disbursed in January 2019 (US$500 million, 7 years maturity, 2-year grace period).
  - An Aramco trade credit of US$200 million to STEG could reduce sovereign market access needs by the same amount.
  - Pledges from traditional partners remain significantly below past levels; continued engagement needed.
- Fund access and schedule:
  - Proposed revised total purchases under the EFF: 1,952.2533 Millions of SDR; Percent of quota: 358.080; Millions of US$: 22,713.3686.
  - Quota: SDR 545.2 million.
  - Purchases by review (selected exact figures): Board approval May 20, 2016: 227.2920 Millions of SDR; First Review Sept 30, 2016: 227.2917; Second Review Sept 30, 2017: 176.7824; Third Review June 15, 2018: 176.7824; Fourth Review Sept 17, 2018: 176.7824; Fifth Review Dec 17, 2018: 176.7824; Sixth Review Sept 18, 2019: 294.6373; Seventh Review Dec 18, 2019: 294.6373; Eighth Review Apr 29, 2020: 201.2654 (Millions of SDR).

---

### Policy recommendations and priorities
- Macro and fiscal:
  - Prioritize socially-balanced macroeconomic stabilization for 2019: fiscal consolidation while protecting investment and social spending; disinflation; exchange rate flexibility.
  - Maintain strong revenue mobilization and improved tax collection to spread tax burden more equitably.
  - Continue energy subsidy reforms while strengthening safety nets for low-income households (AMEN database and enhanced public health measures).
  - Preserve monetary tightening and more flexible exchange rate to rebuild reserves and reduce inflation.
  - No room to relax revenue effort ahead of elections; avoid regressive measures such as higher indirect taxation.
- Social protection:
  - Quickly follow recent measures to improve access to public health care for low-income households with increased transfers, including scheme to assume outstanding debts to STEG.
  - Maintain reform momentum on pension law and databank of low-income households.
  - Staff does not support reforms of subsidies for basic food staples until a more effective social safety net is in place.
- Financial sector and governance:
  - Adopt law on excessive lending rates to enable lending rates to respond to policy rate changes.
  - Accelerate reforms to generate more and better jobs; swift appointment of High Anti-Corruption Authority members.
  - Improve communication of policy and reform objectives to build buy-in for energy subsidy reforms and policy rate hikes.
- Donor engagement and technical assistance:
  - Secure sizeable financing from external partners—grants or highly concessional loans—during the transition.
  - Continue technical assistance engagement (Annex IV TA priorities across FAD, MCM, LEG, STA, ICD) to address capacity constraints in policy frameworks and institutions.

### Risks and contingency measures
- Program risks:
  - Political stalemate over reforms and security incidents threaten adjustment path, especially ahead of parliamentary and presidential elections.
  - External risks from oil prices, regional security, EU slowdown, trade tensions, and investor sentiment.
- Mitigation:
  - Authorities’ commitment to the program, close monitoring via quarterly reviews (test dates: end-June, end-September, end-December 2019), and adequate donor engagement are essential.
  - Use of contingency buffers: unallocated spending of 0.3 percent of GDP; hedging one-third of oil import needs; strengthen oversight of SOEs and data collection on cash flows and foreign currency liabilities.

---

### Capacity building priorities (Annex IV, selected TA objectives)
- Fiscal Affairs Department (FAD): Treasury Single Account and cash management; SOE management and consolidated public sector monitoring; budget preparation and medium-term perspective; tax equity and progressive rebalance.
- Monetary and Capital Markets Department (MCM): FX regulations and capital account strategy; move to interest rate-based monetary policy and inflation targeting; central bank governance; FX intervention calibration; banking supervision and Basel III transition; stress testing.
- Legal Department (LEG): AML/CFT national risk assessment; strengthen AML/CFT and anti-corruption legal frameworks; NPL resolution framework.
- Statistics Department (STA): GFS public sector consolidation including SOEs; SDDS platform reforms; consolidated reporting of financial institutions.
- Institute for Capacity Development (ICD): financial programming; monetary policy implementation; exchange rate policy options.

*Source: EXECUTIVE SUMMARY and selected annexes, 1tunea2019001 - EXECUTIVE SUMMARY (IMF).*

### EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

### 1tunea2019001 - EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

### A subdued recovery in a difficult context
- Growth reached 2.6 percent in 2018.  
- The unemployment rate persisted above 15 percent.  
- The current account deficit widened to 11.2 percent of GDP in 2018.  
- Inflation stopped its upward trend but stood at 6.9 percent in April.  
- Strong revenue performance reduced the fiscal deficit to 4.6 percent of GDP in 2018 from 6.0 percent in 2017.  
- All but two Quantitative Performance Criteria and four of the nine Structural Benchmarks for the Fifth Review were met.  
- Recent policy slippages: civil service wage hikes and a pause in energy price hikes relative to policies agreed at the Fourth Review.  
- Key policy pillars identified: strong revenues (including improved collection), continued energy subsidy reforms with improved safety nets for low-income households, a tighter monetary policy stance, and a more flexible exchange rate.  
- More ambitious structural reforms are deferred until after the elections.

Key reforms and measures implemented in 2018–19 (selected, as cited)
- Fiscal policy:
  - Ambitious 2018 revenue package (2.2 percent of GDP) and reinforcement of tax administration.
  - Elimination of the preferential tax regime for off-shore companies in December 2018.
- Energy subsidy reforms:
  - Fuel price adjustments in January, March, June, September 2018, and March 2019; fuel prices remain about 20 percent below market prices at end-March 2019.
  - Reduction in electricity and gas subsidies in January, June, August, and September 2018.
  - 10 percent increase in electricity and gas tariffs for higher volume-users among low tension/customers in May 2019.
  - Phasing in of a price increase of 24 percent for medium tension/pressure customers over January to December 2019.
- Civil service reforms:
  - Limitation of new recruits to the civil service to 3,000 in 2018 and 2019 (25 percent replacement ratio).
  - Departure of about 6,600 civil servants from the service, of which 5,000 through the early retirement scheme and 1,600 through voluntary separations during 2018.
- Monetary, FX, and macroprudential policies:
  - Three policy rate hikes: +100 bps in February 2019, +100 bps in June 2018, and +75 bps in March 2018.
  - Broadening the interest rate corridor from +/- 25 bps to +/- 100 bps in January 2018.
  - Reduction of CBT FX swaps used for dinar liquidity injections: from TD 2.9 billion in August 2018 to TD 1.6 billion as of March 29, 2019.
  - Start of competitive FX auctions in August 2018 and increase of auction frequency in 2019.
  - Gradual reduction of loan-to-deposit (LTD) ratios by 2 percent each quarter for banks with ratios above 120 percent.
- Structural and social measures:
  - Extension of the National Program of Assistance to Vulnerable Families in January and June 2018.
  - Improved access to public health care for low-income households announced in March 2019.
  - Establishment of the AMEN social database of low-income households in March 2019.
  - Creation of a one-stop shop for investors in March 2018.
  - Resolution committee’s decision on the orderly resolution of the BFT in November 2018; laws supporting public bank restructuring adopted in May 2018.
  - Parliamentary passage of the organic budget law in January 2019 and reform of the public pension fund in April 2019.
  - Completion of functional reviews of four key ministries (Health, Education, Finance, and Infrastructure, June 2018).

Selected macroeconomic developments and indicators (2018 and near-term)
- Real GDP growth: 2.6 percent in 2018; growth would gradually reach 4 percent under sustained policies.  
- Inflation: peak of 7.7 percent in June 2018; declined to 6.9 percent in April; underlying inflation fell from 8.8 percent in December 2018 to 7.6 percent in April.  
- Policy interest rate: most recent 100 bps hike in February increased the policy interest rate to 7.75 percent.  
- Broad money growth halved; credit growth to the economy decreased from 13 percent in 2017 to 8 percent in 2018; credit to the economy further decelerated to 7 percent in Q1 2019.  
- Central government debt increased to 77 percent of GDP at end-2018.  
- International reserves: dropped to 72 days of imports at end-June 2018, recovered to 83 days in March (on donor disbursements and pick-up in private capital inflows).  
- External imbalances: export volumes declined year-on-year by an annualized 3.4 percent in Q1 2019; import volumes fell by 5.1 percent over the same period.  
- Financial markets: stock market index declining since August 2018; credit spreads trended upwards since early 2018.

Program performance and conditionality
- End-March quantitative targets: all but two were met.  
  - QPCs met: primary fiscal balance and current primary expenditures (by wide margins), social spending, and net FX interventions of the CBT (the latter aided by increased private FX inflows in Q1).  
  - QPCs missed: net domestic assets (NDA) and net international reserves (NIR). NDA missed because CBT accommodated all commercial bank refinancing in a negative real interest rate environment; NIR missed due to lower-than-expected external financing since June 2018.  
- All Indicative Targets (IT) met up to April 2019 except for the monthly IT on CBT’s FX interventions in August–November 2018 and January 2019.  
- Structural Benchmarks (SBs) for the Fifth Review: four of nine achieved. Two SBs were met (vote on BFT resolution and adoption of budget law eliminating preferential offshore regime). Seven SBs not met: two implemented with delay (AMEN database and organic budget law), four need reprogramming, and one remained unachievable amid social pressures (fuel price hikes and October–November utility tariff increases).  
- All three Prior Actions (PA) for this Review were achieved in May:
  - A price increase of 6 percent on average for the main fuels.
  - A set of electricity and gas tariff hikes that reduce subsidies by TD 74 million.
  - A set of measures worth TD 100 million to strengthen public health care for low-income families.

### Prospects for a better outlook, but high risks
- Baseline projection highlights (staff projections, 2016–24 table excerpt):
  - Real GDP growth: 2016: 1.1, 2017: 2.0, 2018: 2.6, 2019: 2.7, 2020: 3.2, 2021: 3.4, 2022: 3.9, 2023: 4.0, 2024: 4.0 (percent).
  - Consumer price index growth (period average): 2016: 3.6, 2017: 5.3, 2018: 7.3, 2019: 7.2, 2020: 5.9, 2021: 4.5, 2022: 4.3, 2023: 4.1, 2024: 4.0 (percent).
  - Gross central government debt (percent of GDP): 2016: 62.3, 2017: 70.6, 2018: 77.1, 2019: 83.1, 2020: 84.7, 2021: 82.2, 2022: 78.0, 2023: 73.2, 2024: 68.7.
  - External debt (percent of GDP): 2016: 72.9, 2017: 84.2, 2018: 94.1, 2019: 104.5, 2020: 107.8, 2021: 105.2, 2022: 101.2, 2023: 96.2, 2024: 91.0.
  - Current account balance (percent of GDP): 2016: -9.3, 2017: -10.2, 2018: -11.2, 2019: -10.1, 2020: -9.1, 2021: -8.2, 2022: -7.3, 2023: -6.4, 2024: -5.8.
  - Gross official reserves (billions of US$): 2016: 5.9, 2017: 5.6, 2018: 5.2, 2019: 5.9, 2020: 6.4, 2021: 6.7, 2022: 7.3, 2023: 7.9, 2024: 8.9.
  - Gross official reserves (months of next year's imports of goods): 2016: 3.4, 2017: 3.0, 2018: 2.8, 2019: 3.2, 2020: 3.3, 2021: 3.4, 2022: 3.6, 2023: 3.8, 2024: 3.9.
  - Gross official reserves (percent of IMF reserve adequacy metrics) 1/: 2016: 97.7, 2017: 88.8, 2018: 78.7, 2019: 90.7, 2020: 93.0, 2021: 96.2, 2022: 99.8, 2023: 102.4, 2024: 120.5.
- Under the staff baseline with sustained policies:
  - Growth would gradually reach 4 percent.
  - Inflation would fall to 4 percent.
  - The current account deficit would reach 5.8 percent of GDP by 2024.
  - Reserve cover would strengthen to 3.2 months of goods imports in 2019.
  - External and central government debt would peak at 108 and 85 percent of GDP in 2020, respectively, before declining.
- Major risks to the baseline (Risk Assessment Matrix, Annex II):
  - Domestic: socio-political tensions, deterioration in security, policy and reform slippages ahead of elections.
  - External: higher oil prices, spillovers from regional conflicts, further slowing of EU growth, rising trade tensions, adverse investor sentiment.
  - A US$10 increase in the international oil price would worsen the energy subsidy bill by about 1.2 percent of GDP; a hedge for one-third of Tunisia’s 2019 energy import needs at US$65 per barrel would reduce expected budget cost.
- Debt Sustainability Analysis (Annex III) conclusions:
  - Public debt remains sustainable with strong policies but is vulnerable to exchange rate depreciation and contingent liabilities.
  - External debt is resilient to shocks except for strong dinar depreciation, aided by a low average interest rate, relatively long maturities, a substantial share of concessional debt, and a large grant element in new loans.

### Agenda to foster macroeconomic stability
- Priority for 2019: socially-balanced macroeconomic stabilization focusing on fiscal consolidation while protecting investment and social spending; disinflation; and exchange rate flexibility to improve competitiveness and protect reserves.  
- Key policy directions emphasized:
  - Maintain strong revenue mobilization and improved tax collection to spread tax burden more equitably.
  - Continue energy subsidy reforms while strengthening safety nets for low-income households (AMEN database and enhanced public health measures cited).
  - Preserve monetary tightening and more flexible exchange rate to rebuild reserves and reduce inflation.
  - Defer more ambitious structural reforms until after elections, while continuing measures to support private sector development and job creation.
- Program financing and support:
  - Staff supports completion of the Fifth Review; completion would make available SDR 176.7824 million (about US$245 million) and catalyze financing from other official partners and international markets.
  - Staff supports waivers of nonobservance of performance criteria and the rephasing of access.

Final operational and institutional notes
- Discussions took place in Tunis during March 27–April 9, 2019, and continued from headquarters until April 17, 2019. The mission team comprised named IMF staff and participants; senior Tunisian officials and a range of stakeholders were consulted.  
- Annexes and appendices listed include: Trends in the Civil Service Wage Bill; Risk Assessment Matrix; Debt Sustainability Analysis; Capacity Building Priorities; Letter of Intent; Memorandum of Economic and Financial Policies; Technical Memorandum of Understanding.

*Source: EXECUTIVE SUMMARY, 1tunea2019001 - EXECUTIVE SUMMARY (IMF).*

### Annex IV will facilitate structural reforms over the medium term.

### Annex IV will facilitate structural reforms over the medium term.

### Fiscal Policy — Background and objectives
- Continued fiscal discipline is imperative to break the unsustainable debt dynamics.
- Authorities seek to limit the 2019 deficit to 3.9 percent of GDP (excluding grants).
- This is consistent with a primary balance deficit of 1.0 percent of GDP in 2019.
- Medium-term policy anchor: improve the primary fiscal balance to a surplus of 2.9 percent of GDP by 2023 and push public debt back below 70 percent of GDP.
- Key fiscal levers identified:
  - Wage bill growth significantly below nominal GDP.
  - Phase out energy subsidies.
  - Reduce budget outlays on pensions.
  - Contain contingent risks from SOEs.

### Fiscal Policy — Near-term pressures and measures
- Pre-election unanticipated wage increases and withdrawal of planned energy price hikes threaten the 2019 deficit target.
- Need for further measures to stabilize debt and reduce large financing needs in the context of volatile international oil prices and a more flexible exchange rate.
- Revenue revisions for 2019 reflect:
  - Unanticipated revenue overperformance totaling 2.6 (percent of GDP), decomposed in Text Table 3 as:
    - Direct taxes 1.2
    - Indirect taxes 0.8
    - Non-taxes 0.4
    - Grants 0.2
- Current spending pressures total -2.2 (percent of GDP) including:
  - Wage bill -0.8 (percent of GDP), of which wage increase -0.5 (percent of GDP)
  - Other current spending items listed in Text Table 3 (goods and services -0.1; interest bill -0.2; food subsidy -0.2; energy subsidy -0.4; other transfers -0.6; social -0.3; CNRPS -0.2; civil servants -0.1)
- Net operating balance impact 0.3; net overall balance impact 0.2; grants 0.2; net overall balance impact, excl. grants 0.0.

### Fiscal Policy — Specific reform actions and social protection
- Energy subsidy reforms and social protection:
  - Authorities aim to cap the 2019 energy subsidy bill at 2.3 percent of GDP.
  - A first set of energy subsidy measures (0.5 percent of GDP) implemented between March and May 2019, including increases of fuel prices and utility tariffs for low tension/low pressure customers (PAs).
  - Social tariffs for electricity were reduced by 10 percent while prices for subsidized gas bottles were left unchanged.
  - New social measures worth 0.3 percent of GDP to protect low-income families’ purchasing power.
  - Two social electricity tariffs: up to 50 kWh at TD 0.075 per kWh; 51–100 kWh at TD 0.108 per kWh.
- Wage bill containment:
  - Limit new recruitments into the civil service to an overall replacement ratio of no more than 25 percent.
  - Refrain from any additional civil service wage increases over the time covered under the agreement with UGTT (until 2021).
- Pension reform:
  - CNRPS reform law approved in April 2019: increase retirement age from 60 to 62 and higher contributions (additional 2 and 1 percentage points from employers and employees, respectively).
  - Eliminates need for budget transfers from 2020, but 2019 budget must absorb a one-off transfer of 0.2 percent of GDP due to delayed adoption and start of higher employee contributions in 2020.
- Buffer and risk mitigation:
  - Unallocated spending of 0.3 percent of GDP.
  - Hedging of one-third of Tunisia’s oil import needs.
  - Strengthen financial oversight of SOEs; improve data collection on cash flows and debt, including foreign currency liabilities.

### Fiscal Policy — Medium-term reform priorities
- Growth-friendly and equitable revenue mobilization:
  - Eliminate the preferential tax regime for off-shore companies by 2021.
  - Raise the VAT rate for liberal professions from 13 to 19 percent (reprogrammed SB for December 2019).
  - Improve tax administration, information exchange, targeted audits, AML/CFT efforts, and IT-supported processes.
- Public financial management (PFM) and fiscal risk mitigation:
  - Organic budget law (December SB, implemented with delay in January) to enable a formal medium-term framework and broader coverage of public sector in fiscal planning.
  - Urgent need for improved cash management and coordination with CBT on central government liquidity needs.
  - Finalize performance contract for TUNISAIR (reprogrammed SB for July 2019).

### Monetary Policy and Financial Sector Stability — Background and stance
- Tighter monetary policy has started to reduce inflation after sharp dinar depreciation and broad money growth from January 2016 to June 2018.
- Overall CBT refinancing broadly stabilized at about TD 16 billion, fluctuating with autonomous factors.
- Distortions in monetary transmission persist:
  - Money market rate stable within interest rate corridor since mid-2018.
  - Delays passing policy rate changes to lending rates; agreement among commercial banks to shield some loan categories from interest adjustments.
- Banking system indicators:
  - System-wide capital adequacy ratio 11.7 (December 2018).
  - Nonperforming loans decreased to 13.4 percent of total loans in December 2018 from 14.2 in September 2018.
  - System-wide ratio of liquid assets to total assets decreased to 4.5 percent at end-2018 from 5.7 percent at end-2017.
  - Ratio of liquid assets to short-term liabilities decreased to 75.2 percent from 91.7 percent.
  - As of March 2019, five banks were not compliant with the minimum liquidity coverage ratio (LCR) that was increased to 100 percent in January.

### Monetary Policy — Policy commitments and measures
- Reduce CBT refinancing to decelerate money growth:
  - Target reduction of outstanding net refinancing to TD 14.0 billion in December from TD 16.5 billion at end-March, including lower FX swaps and open market purchases.
  - Tighten LTD ratios and collateral policy; raise the share of Treasury bills in eligible collateral from 40 percent to 50 percent (new SB for September 2019).
- Further policy rate hikes if disinflation stalls; deviation of quarterly inflation forecasts from baseline to trigger discussions on further increases.
- Financial stability monitoring:
  - Improve capacity to monitor and stress-test impact of monetary tightening and exchange rate depreciation on bank balance sheets.
  - Use emergency liquidity assistance framework to distinguish between standard monetary operations and liquidity support for financial stability (including collateral and pricing).
- Strengthen monetary policy framework via:
  - More explicit communication of the CBT’s medium-term inflation objective.
  - Upgrading the CBT’s monetary policy report and projection models.
  - Progress towards a quarterly inflation expectations survey.
  - IMF TA priorities (Annex IV) aligned with this agenda.

### Exchange Rate Policy — Background and objectives
- More frequent and competitive FX auctions since December to support price discovery and respect monthly net intervention limits.
- Strong depreciation in Q4 2018, then stabilization supported by FX inflows (privatization receipts, external borrowing, profit repatriations).
- Real exchange rate depreciation since 2016 strengthened price competitiveness but has not yet improved the current account due to:
  - Higher oil prices and inelastic import demand.
  - Disappointing phosphate exports through end-2018.
  - Tourism revenue increase below expectations despite highest number of visitors since 2010.
- International reserves recovered to around 90 percent of the IMF’s ARA metrics from 79 percent at end-2018 (as of March 2019).

### Exchange Rate Policy — Policy recommendations
- Maintain competitive FX auctions with a reduced FX intervention budget and effective communication to market-making commercial banks to:
  - Turn around the current account deficit by at least 1 percent of GDP in 2019.
  - Strengthen international reserve cover to 3.2 months of imports.
- Continue using auctions to purchase FX to help replenish reserves.
- Staff assessment: real exchange rate remains overvalued by about 15 percent at end-2018 according to the IMF EBA methodology.

### Ensuring Adequate Social Protection
- Social spending increased in 2018, notably through expansion of PNAFN (main social program for vulnerable families).
- Progress on identifying low-income households:
  - Established a database of low-income households (December 2018 SB, implemented with delay in March 2019).
  - Started issuing new medical and payments cards with a unique social identifier.
- Parliamentary adoption of the CNRPS reform law effective as of May 6, limiting short-term need for government support.
- PNAFN coverage note: 15 percent of the population live below the poverty line but only 9 percent are covered under the PNAFN program; PNAFN beneficiaries also benefit from free healthcare through AMG 1, while other households with limited income access subsidized healthcare under AMG 2.

*Source: 1tunea2019001 - Annex IV will facilitate structural reforms over the medium term.*

### 19. Strengthening social safety nets is critical to protect the reform agenda in 2019. A loss

### 19. Strengthening social safety nets is critical to protect the reform agenda in 2019. A loss

### Social safety nets — findings and measures
- Context and challenge:
  - Informal sector represents between 35 and 50 percent of GDP.
  - 15 percent of Tunisians (about 1.8 million people) live below the poverty line.
  - Loss of purchasing power and higher consumer prices are eroding public buy-in for reforms.
- Immediate and planned measures:
  - Authorities intend to increase social spending by 0.3 percent of GDP in 2019 (MEFP¶5).
  - New resources already made available: TD 100 million (met SB) to improve supply of free or subsidized health care to low-income households prior to the energy price increases implemented between March and May.
  - Additional package under preparation worth TD 270 million, including:
    - Financial support for low-income households’ unpaid energy bills: TD 50 million (new SB for September 2019).
    - Targeted cash benefits to an enlarged group of low-income households: TD 35 million (new SB for September 2019).
    - Investment in health care infrastructure: TD 117 million.
- Better targeting and data:
  - Leverage the AMEN database to increase coverage of low-income population with verified needs and in possession of a payments card for social transfers from the current 9 percent to at least 12 percent by end-2019 (MEFP¶6).
  - At end-March, the AMEN social database covers some 600,000 households (about 20 percent of total households), half of which with validated income and expenditure data.
- Pensions and social security:
  - Ensuring financial sustainability of social security system remains a priority, including to help the middle class.
  - Staff emphasized the importance of more ambitious parametric reforms to close the structural gap between the financial needs and available resources of the public and private pension plans and improve equity.
  - Authorities confirmed discussions with social partners on next pension reform steps have already started.

### Creating more opportunity for the private sector — background and policy steps
- Rationale:
  - More ambitious growth and jobs creation depends on a stronger private sector; acceleration of reforms needed to address structural deficiencies that hamper private sector development, especially in the interior regions.
- Key policy priorities:
  - Strengthening governance and reducing corruption (MEFP¶15):
    - Establish the High Anti-Corruption Authority; Parliament to consider the shortlist of candidates for its Board (reprogrammed SB for September 2019).
    - Implement outstanding safeguards recommendations at the CBT.
  - Improving the business climate:
    - Adopt secondary legislation for recently passed laws to strengthen Tunisia’s attractiveness for investment, including public-private partnerships (MEFP¶14).
    - Simplify administrative procedures; update product, service, and labor market regulations; modernize infrastructure (energy, communication, transport); address skill mismatches.
  - Improving access to finance (MEFP¶18):
    - Reduce non-performing loan portfolios among public banks to enhance lending capacity.
    - Progress on de-cashing: mandate tax administration and SOEs to accept credit cards and e-payments.
    - Adopt pending legislation such as laws on credit bureaus and a modern collateral registry.
  - Completing the FATF action plan (MEFP¶15) to support exit from FATF list by demonstrating a functional targeted financial sanctions regime against terrorism and proliferation financing.
  - Encouraging trade (MEFP¶19): repeal of the 2017 exchange restriction banning trade credits for imports deemed non-essential.

### Program implementation, conditionality, and financing
- Program monitoring and conditionality:
  - Staff supports authorities’ request for waivers of nonobservance of QPCs; corrective actions taken for missed end-March QPCs on NDA and NIR.
  - Quarterly review framework remains adequate.
- Proposed adjustments to quantitative and structural conditionality:
  - Modify QPCs for end-June 2019 to reflect recent wage increases and frontloaded spending:
    - Increase ceiling on current primary expenditures and lower floor on primary balance.
    - Increase floor on social spending to reflect recently announced measures (¶¶9 and 19).
    - Increase ceiling on NDA but remain consistent with strong monetary tightening over 2019 (MEFP¶10).
    - Reduce floor on NIR to reflect FX inflow shortfall.
    - Reduce ceilings on net FX interventions to support greater exchange rate flexibility and reserves accumulation; monthly IT on net FX interventions adjusted accordingly.
  - Structural benchmarks:
    - Reprogram four SBs (nomination of High Anti-Corruption Authority board members; law on excessive lending rates; VAT increase for liberal professions; performance contract for TUNISAIR).
    - Set four new SBs (targeted transfers to low-income households; financial support for unpaid energy bills of low-income households; arrears collection of the STEG energy utility; increase share of government paper to 50 percent in collateral for CBT refinancing operations).
  - Access and financing:
    - Propose rephasing remaining access evenly starting from the Sixth Review; all funds to be made available for budget support.
- Financing status and partner engagement:
  - Financing needs for next 12 months are fully covered, aided by an unanticipated budget support loan from Saudi Arabia disbursed in January 2019.
  - The authorities received US$500 million in budget support (with a reported 7 years maturity and a 2-year grace period).
  - An Aramco trade credit of US$200 million to STEG could reduce sovereign market access needs by the same amount.
  - Pledges from traditional partners remain significantly below levels observed in recent years; continued engagement with external partners is needed.

### Macroeconomic assessment and staff appraisal
- Growth and macro performance:
  - Recovery remains subdued; growth likely to record a marginal improvement in 2019 as investment and exports remain weak; unemployment will persist at high levels.
  - 2018 fiscal deficit reduction was strong; monetary tightening has started to tame credit growth and speculation against the dinar; lower FX interventions have allowed exchange rates to better reflect fundamentals.
  - Policy mix helped break upward trend in inflation and contain the rise in debt ratios; structural reforms progressed but at too slow a pace.
- Debt and IMF exposure:
  - Credit outstanding to the IMF will peak at 371 percent of quota and 45 percent of gross reserves in 2020.
  - Obligations to the IMF reached a maximum of 1.4 percent of GDP or 23.1 percent of external debt service in 2018.
  - Tunisia’s public debt is sustainable only with strong policy implementation; capacity to repay would deteriorate significantly in adverse scenarios.
- Fiscal stance and social balance:
  - Staff supports reducing the fiscal deficit to 3.9 percent of GDP (excluding grants) while carving out growth-enhancing investment and allowing higher social spending to protect low-income households.
  - Strategy relies on strong revenue collection, targeted energy subsidy reforms, and tight wage bill management.
  - No room for relaxing the revenue effort in the run-up to elections; avoid further regressive policies such as higher indirect taxation.
- Monetary policy and inflation:
  - Inflation at almost twice its historical level reduces purchasing power; additional policy rate hikes warranted if quarterly inflation projections deviate from downward trend towards 6.8 percent by December 2019.
  - Adoption of the law on excessive lending rates is critical for lending rates to respond better to policy rate changes.
  - Success with disinflation depends on containing central bank refinancing, tighter collateral framework, and reinforced banking supervision including improved stress-testing.
- External adjustment:
  - Reducing external imbalances hinges on a market-determined exchange rate; sustain lower FX interventions and competitive FX auctions to improve current account and rebuild reserve cover.
  - Authorities’ recent step to also purchase FX is critical to help replenish reserves.

### Policy recommendations and priorities
- Social protection:
  - Quickly follow recent measures to improve access to public health care for low-income households with increased transfers to low-income households, including scheme to assume outstanding debts to STEG.
  - Maintain reform momentum on pension law and databank of low-income households.
  - Staff does not support reforms of subsidies for basic food staples until a more effective social safety net is in place.
- Private sector and governance:
  - Accelerate reforms to generate more and better jobs; swift appointment of High Anti-Corruption Authority members to address structural corruption concerns.
  - Continue enabling business climate reforms and improve access to finance by reducing public banks’ nonperforming loans and strengthening AML/CFT regime.
- Communication and sequencing:
  - Improve communication of policy and reform objectives to build buy-in for energy subsidy reforms and policy rate hikes; provide adequate time for population adjustment.
  - Communicate reform needs of SOEs and the unsustainability of further public sector wage increases; link reforms to a medium-term vision underpinned by stronger private sector activity.
- Donor engagement and TA:
  - Secure sizeable financing from external partners—grants or highly concessional loans—during the transition; commitment levels for 2019 and beyond often below past envelopes.
  - Continue technical assistance engagement to address capacity constraints in upgrading policy frameworks and economic institutions.

### Risks and contingencies
- Program risks remain very high:
  - Political stalemate over reforms and security incidents threaten Tunisia’s adjustment path, especially ahead of parliamentary and presidential elections.
  - External and fiscal balances exposed to higher oil prices, regional security spillovers, further slowdown in Europe, rising trade tensions, and adverse shifts in investor sentiment.
- Mitigation:
  - Continued authorities’ commitment to the program, close monitoring through quarterly reviews, and adequate donor engagement are essential to mitigate risks.

*Source: IMF country report chapter (content unit 1tunea2019001).*

### 36. Staff supports the authorities’ request for the completion of the Fifth EFF Review. It

### 1tunea2019001 - 36. Staff supports the authorities’ request for the completion of the Fifth EFF Review. It

### Program decision and immediate actions
- Staff supports the authorities’ request for the completion of the Fifth EFF Review.
- Staff also supports:
  - waivers of non-observance on the QPCs for NIR and NDA for end-March based on corrective action;
  - modification of quantitative targets for end-June and setting of new targets for end-September and end-December 2019;
  - rephasing of access consistent with the remaining review schedule;
  - making all funds available for budget support.

### Real sector developments (2010–18) — key findings
- Services were temporarily wiped out as the main source of growth in 2015.
- Demand has relied almost exclusively on consumption.
- Inflation has accelerated since 2017, fueled by broad money growth and dinar depreciation; recent readings have stabilized at elevated levels.
- Tunisia faces major and persistent unemployment, especially among youth and women.
- The environment for doing business worsened, before recording some progress in 2018.
- Sectoral/contribution indicators (selected visuals and metrics in source):
  - Real GDP and sectoral contributions shown for 2010–18 (percent, annual growth).
  - Demand contributions to growth by component: private consumption, investment, public consumption, net exports, change in stocks (percent, annual growth).
  - CPI inflation and components (headline, food, core, underlying) shown for 2011–19 (percent, year-on-year).
  - Unemployment rate: Overall, Male, Female, Graduates, Youth (percent of labor force) with high youth unemployment highlighted.

### External sector developments (2010–18) — key findings
- The current account deteriorated since 2016, despite significant real exchange rate depreciation.
- Tourism and remittances help cover a large trade deficit.
- Exports have shown stronger growth recently, helped by real exchange rate depreciation.
- Higher domestic prices have not yet led to an adjustment in consumption or energy imports.
- Reserve coverage slightly improved in 2018, but further reserve accumulation remains essential.
- Depreciation accelerated since mid-2017, despite strong central bank FX interventions that weighed on reserves.
- Key metrics and indicators (2010–18 visuals and tables):
  - Balance on current account (Percent of GDP) and REER (REER base year 2010 = 100).
  - Current account dynamics by component: trade balance, tourism, remittances, other (Percent of GDP).
  - Exports and imports by type of good (U.S. dollars, billions).
  - Reserve coverage: Net reserves and Gross reserves; ARA metric adjustments noted.

### Fiscal sector developments (2010–18) — key findings
- The EFF has supported fiscal consolidation since 2017.
- Debt dynamics in 2018 were mostly driven by exchange rate depreciation.
- Expenditures dominated by current outlays, including an energy subsidy bill that increased in 2018.
- Revenue mobilization is strong and leaves little scope for further tax hikes.
- The wage bill continues to be one of the world’s highest.
- The EFF supports an increase in social transfers to low-income households.
- Fiscal indicators (selected values and projections):
  - Overall balance and primary balance trends (Percent of GDP).
  - Composition of government expenditures: wage bill, transfers and subsidies, investment, goods and services (Percent of GDP).
  - Government revenues: indirect taxes, direct taxes, non-tax, grants (Percent of GDP).
  - Wage bill and social transfers levels and trends (Percent of GDP).

### Monetary sector developments (2010–19) — key findings
- Monetary tightening has responded to accelerating inflation.
- Growth of key monetary aggregates has recently started to slow.
- Refinancing increased since early 2017 to mitigate the impact of NFA losses on base money.
- Spreads remained benign through most of 2018; the stock market peaked in October 2018.
- As broad money and credit growth started to decrease in 2018, inflation stabilized supported by CBT’s tightening monetary policy since March 2018.
- Monetary/financial metrics:
  - Policy and money market rates (percent, nominal).
  - Broad money (M3), credit to the private sector, savings and time deposits (Percent, year-on-year growth).
  - Central Bank money market operations by instrument (Tunisian dinars, billions).
  - 5Y CDS spread and TUNINDEX (Basis points; index thousands).

### Selected economic and financial indicators (Table highlights)
- Real GDP (at 2010 prices): 2016 Est. 1.1; 2017 2.0; 2018 2.6; 2019 (Proj.) 2.6; 2020 2.7; 2021 3.1; 2022 3.2; 2023 3.4; 2024 3.4.
- CPI inflation (average): 2016 3.6; 2017 5.3; 2018 7.3; 2019 (Proj.) 7.8; 2020 7.2; 2021 5.0; 2022 5.8; 2023 5.2; 2024 4.5; 2024 (later row) 4.1; 2024 final row 4.0.
- Gross national savings: 2016 9.1; 2017 9.1; 2018 8.1; 2019 (Proj.) 10.1; 2020 9.2; 2021 12.1; 2022 11.5; 2023 15.2; 2024 14.1; later years 15.0 15.7 16.3 (table contains multiple series).
- Gross central government debt: 2016 62.3; 2017 70.6; 2018 77.1; 2019 (Proj.) 72.0; 2020 83.1; 2021 71.8; 2022 84.7; 2023 70.8; 2024 82.2; additional rows show 78.0 73.2 68.7 for subsequent projections.
- Current account balance (Percent of GDP): 2016 -9.3; 2017 -10.2; 2018 -11.2; 2019 (Proj.) -9.7; 2020 -10.1; 2021 -8.5; 2022 -9.1; 2023 -7.8; 2024 -8.2; further projections show -7.3 -6.4 -5.8.
- Gross official reserves (eop, billions of US$): 2016 5.9; 2017 5.6; 2018 5.2; 2019 (Proj.) 6.3; 2020 5.9; 2021 7.3; 2022 6.4; 2023 7.8; 2024 6.7; further series: 7.3 7.9 8.9.
- Reserve coverage (months of next year's imports of goods): 2016 3.4; 2017 3.0; 2018 2.8; 2019 (Proj.) 3.4; 2020 3.2; 2021 3.8; 2022 3.3; 2023 4.0; 2024 3.4; extended series 3.6 3.8 3.9.
- Money and credit (selected): Broad money growth 2016 8.1; 2017 11.4; 2018 6.4; 2019 (Proj.) 9.0; 2020 5.4; 2021 8.7; 2022 6.0; 2023 7.4; 2024 7.7; later values 7.9 8.8 9.9.
- Credit to the economy growth: 2016 9.7; 2017 12.7; 2018 8.4; 2019 (Proj.) 10.1; 2020 5.4; 2021 6.9; 2022 6.2; 2023 7.0; 2024 7.1; later 7.1 7.1 7.2.

### Balance of payments and external financing (selected projections)
- Current account balance (millions of US$): 2018 Est. -3,901; 2019 Rev -4,080; 2019 Q1 -1,164; Q2 -1,122; Q3 -1,135; Q4 -1,053; 2019 Annual -4,474; 2020 Proj. -3,909; later projections through 2024 show annual balances moving toward smaller deficits (e.g., 2024 -2,644).
- Exports (2019 Annual projection): 15,485 (millions of US$); 2020 Proj. 16,135; further growth through 2024 to 19,503.
- Imports (2019 Annual projection): -21,435; 2020 Proj. -21,609; trend shown through 2024 with large import levels.
- Tourism (services, selected): 2016 1,105; 2017 1,170; 2018 1,546; 2019 Annual 1,464; 2020 Proj. 1,607; later years shown.
- Workers' remittances (selected): 2016 1,794; 2017 1,861; 2018 1,845; 2019 Annual 2,006; 2020 Proj. 1,683; subsequent values included.
- Gross international reserves (billions of US$) (selected): 2016 5.9; 2017 5.6; 2018 5.1; 2019 projections and memorandum items list multiple eop values across years (e.g., 5.9 5.6 5.1 4.7 4.7 5.2 5.2 5.5 5.6 etc.).

### Fiscal operations (central government) — selected fiscal metrics (2016–20)
- Total revenue and grants (millions of dinars): 2016 20,269; 2017 23,500; 2018 27,589; 2019 (4th Rev) 26,723; 2019 Proj. 33,007; 2020 Proj. 30,286; 2020 Proj. 36,541; additional quarterly and annual flows provided.
- Total expenditure and net lending (millions of dinars): 2016 25,930; 2017 29,303; 2018 32,403; 2019 (4th Rev) 32,277; 2019 Proj. 37,074; 2020 Proj. 34,590; 2020 Proj. 40,113.
- Wage bill (millions of dinars): 2016 13,117; 2017 14,352; 2018 14,863; 2019 (4th Rev) 14,903; 2019 Proj. 17,215; 2020 Proj. 16,385; further projections shown.
- Energy subsidies (millions of dinars): 2016 0; 2017 1,183; 2018 3,382; 2019 quarterly flows show large energy-related subsidy outlays.

### Monetary and central bank balances (selected)
- Broad money (M3, end-of-period stocks, millions of dinars): 2016 66,883; 2017 74,485; 2018 75,073; 2019 Proj. 76,355; 2020 Proj. 77,413; extended series to 2020 show 79,271 81,188 etc.
- Net foreign assets (NFA, millions of dinars): 2016 -949; 2017 -2,385; 2018 -4,484; 2019 Q1 -5,388; projections show varying NFA positions.
- Net domestic assets (NDA, millions of dinars): 2016 67,832; 2017 76,869; 2018 79,557; 2019 81,742; 2020 82,719.
- Reserve money (millions of dinars): Central Bank levels and changes shown across 2016–20 (e.g., 2016 12,622; 2017 15,236; 2018 19,605; 2019 16,557; 2020 21,550).

### External financing and Fund support (program financing schedule and Fund credit indicators)
- Proposed schedule of purchases under the EFF (selected review purchases and totals):
  - May 20, 2016 Board approval of the EFF: 227.29 (Millions of SDR).
  - First Review (September 30, 2016): 227.29 (Millions of SDR).
  - Second Review (September 30, 2017): 176.78 (Millions of SDR).
  - Third Review (June 15, 2018): 176.78 (Millions of SDR).
  - Fourth Review (September 17, 2018): 176.78 (Millions of SDR).
  - Fifth Review (December 17, 2018): 176.78 (Millions of SDR) — note applying end-March 2019 performance criteria because Board meeting for Fifth Review scheduled for May 31, 2019.
  - Sixth, Seventh, Eighth Reviews listed with 294.63 (Millions of SDR) for later reviews.
  - Total: 2,045.62 (Millions of SDR); Total in US$ 632,843.14 (indicative based on program exchange rate).
- Indicators of Fund credit (existing and prospective Fund credit, selected):
  - Stock (millions of SDR): 2016 1,205.3; 2017 1,205.6; 2018 1,366.7; 2019 1,563.8; 2020 2,026.7; 2021 1,969.8; 2022 1,879.3; 2023 1,700.5; 2024 1,408.6.
  - Stock in percent of quota: 221.1; 221.1; 250.7; 286.3; 371.0; 360.6; 344.1; 311.3; 257.9.
  - Stock in percent of GDP: 4.0; 4.2; 4.9; 6.0; 8.1; 7.7; 6.9; 5.8; 4.4.
  - Stock in percent of gross reserves: 27.3; 30.5; 36.5; 36.9; 44.6; 41.9; 36.8; 30.7; 23.0.

### Financial sector soundness (selected banking indicators, 2010–18)
- Regulatory capital to risk-weighted assets: 2010 11.6; 2011 11.9; 2012 11.8; 2013 8.2; 2014 9.4; 2015 12.0; 2016 11.3; 2017 11.9; 2018 11.7.
- Nonperforming Loans (NPLs) to total loans: 2010 13.0; 2011 13.3; 2012 14.9; 2013 16.5; 2014 15.8; 2015 16.6; 2016 15.6; 2017 13.9; 2018 13.4.
- Specific provisions to NPLs: 2011 48.6; 2012 45.7; 2013 56.4; 2014 58.0; 2015 56.9; 2016 57.9; 2017 57.0; 2018 56.5.
- Return on assets (ROA): 2010 0.9; 2011 0.6; 2012 0.6; 2013 0.3; 2014 0.9; 2015 0.9; 2016 1.0; 2017 1.2; 2018 1.2.
- Deposits to loans: 2010 94.6; 2011 87.4; 2012 89.5; 2013 89.6; 2014 88.8; 2015 87.4; 2016 86.8; 2017 85.7; 2018 85.3.

### Medium-term outlook (illustrative)
- Real GDP growth path: 2019 2.7; 2020 3.2; 2021 3.4; 2022 3.9; 2023 4.0; 2024 4.0.
- Gross national savings trajectory: 2019 9.2; 2020 11.5; 2021 14.1; 2022 15.0; 2023 15.7; 2024 16.3.
- Gross public debt (percent of GDP): 2016 62.3; 2017 70.6; 2018 77.1; 2019 72.0; 2020 83.1; 2021 71.8; 2022 84.7; 2023 70.8; 2024 73.2; illustrative series continues to 68.7.

*Sources: Tunisian authorities; World Bank Development Indicators; World Economic Forum; IMF staff calculations and estimates; IMF staff projections.*

### Annex I. Trends in the Civil Service Wage Bill

### Annex I. Trends in the Civil Service Wage Bill

### Overview
- Tunisia’s civil service wage bill increased from 10.7 percent of GDP in 2010 to 15.2 percent of GDP in 2018 (including wage components paid out as tax credits to public sector workers).
- The wage bill consumes more than half of the budget, two thirds of tax revenues, and represents the equivalent of three times public investment.

### Drivers of Wage Bill Growth
- Headcount additions:
  - Effective strength rose from about 500,000 to 700,000 in the first years after the revolution (2011–15).
  - Additional recruitment of security personnel occurred after 2015 to address higher threat levels.
- Salary hikes:
  - Wage increases since the revolution accounted for most of the wage bill rise.
  - Public sector salaries are on average about twice as high as those in the private sector.
  - Under the EFF, a package of legacy—and unanticipated—wage hikes for 2016–18 totaling 1.2 percent of GDP was legally agreed in December 2016.
  - The authorities presented a strategy to maintain a path towards the 12 percent of GDP wage bill target for 2020 that relied on the absence of new wage increases through 2020, voluntary departure schemes, and strict hiring limits to achieve a 2-percent-of-GDP reduction over three years.
  - Authorities deviated from the no-increase policy in February 2019, accepting wage increases totaling about 1.3 percent of GDP after two general strikes:
    - First tranche of 0.6 percent of GDP to be paid out in 2019, with a part of this tranche (0.1 percent of GDP) taking the form of a transfer to civil servants.
    - Second tranche of 0.7 percent of GDP to be implemented in the 2020 budget.
    - These increases are equivalent to a 3.5 percent average wage hike for each year, about half the rate of inflation.
  - There is a risk of further wage increases for 2019 of some 0.2 percent of GDP: the UGTT labor union seeks to open negotiations on additional hikes for 35,000 higher-level civil servants.
- Relative measures and composition:
  - Wage spending in the social sector comprises Ministries of Education, Higher Education, Health, and Social Affairs; in the security sector that of the Ministries of Defense and Interior.
  - Wage bill growth reflects both salary and headcount contributions.

### Policy Measures, Outcomes, and Constraints under the EFF
- Effective measures:
  - Strict hiring limits proved effective; new recruitments were limited to 3,000 in 2018 and a similar number in 2019.
- Less effective measures:
  - Voluntary departure and early retirement schemes yielded 6,600 civil servants leaving versus an expected 20,000–25,000, reflecting the poor state of the private sector job market.
- Structural constraints:
  - Streamlining benefits is slow because benefits represent up to 60 percent of total compensation and Tunisia has more than 100 different civil service functional pay lines.
  - Most benefit changes require union consent, limiting unilateral reform capacity.
- IMF staff position:
  - Staff consistently advised against the new civil service increase, arguing the increases are unfair, unaffordable, and detrimental to macroeconomic stability.
  - Staff highlighted that civil servants earn significantly more than private sector counterparts and enjoy job stability.
  - Wage increases required additional energy price measures to maintain the deficit ceiling for 2019 and mitigate adverse debt dynamics, thereby burdening the broader population.
  - Wage hikes (coming on top of about 2 percent of GDP in hikes for the private sector and public enterprises) negatively affect inflation and the current account.
  - Staff opposes the UGTT demand for additional hikes, warning about potential implications for macroeconomic stability.

### Key statistics and facts
- Wage bill: 10.7 percent of GDP in 2010; 15.2 percent of GDP in 2018.
- Effective civil service strength: about 500,000 before the revolution; about 700,000 after (2011–15).
- Legacy wage hikes agreed December 2016: 1.2 percent of GDP (for 2016–18).
- Target wage bill under strategy: 12 percent of GDP for 2020.
- Planned reduction under strategy: 2-percent-of-GDP reduction over three years.
- Accepted increases in February 2019: about 1.3 percent of GDP total (0.6 percent of GDP in 2019 including 0.1 percent of GDP as a transfer; 0.7 percent of GDP in 2020).
- Average wage hike implied by those increases: 3.5 percent per year (about half the rate of inflation).
- Hiring limits: 3,000 new recruitments in 2018 and similar number in 2019.
- Voluntary departures achieved: 6,600 (expected 20,000–25,000).
- Benefits share of total compensation: up to 60 percent.
- Number of civil service functional pay lines: more than 100.
- Additional potential 2019 spending risk from UGTT demand: some 0.2 percent of GDP for 35,000 higher-level civil servants.
- Additional hikes for private sector and public enterprises: about 2 percent of GDP.

*Sources: Tunisian authorities, and IMF staff calculations and estimates.*

### 8.      A series of plausible stress tests highlights risks to debt sustainability. Tunisia’s debt-to-

### 8. A series of plausible stress tests highlights risks to debt sustainability. Tunisia’s debt-to-

### Stress-test findings and risks to public debt sustainability
- Tunisia’s debt-to-GDP ratio exceeds the emerging market debt burden benchmark of 70 percent of GDP, signaling the need for cautious policies to maintain investor confidence.
- Stress tests confirm vulnerability of public debt to:
  - interest rate risk,
  - a growth shock,
  - real exchange rate depreciation.
- Several standard tests plus two customized scenarios signal significant deterioration of the debt-to-GDP ratio relative to the baseline, and in some cases push it above 90 percent.
  - Customized scenarios:
    - maintaining loose fiscal and monetary policies due to strong political pressure;
    - impact of a major security incident (like the 2015 terrorist attacks) starting from weaker initial conditions.
- A test including contingent liabilities highlights risks from government guarantees to SOEs.
  - The one-off 10 percent of GDP shock to contingent liabilities reflects an additional three percent of GDP in bank recapitalization costs and the realization of about 7 percent of GDP of the government’s contingent liabilities to public enterprises.

### Baseline public debt projections and key fiscal indicators (from Public Sector DSA)
- Nominal gross public debt (in percent of GDP):
  - 2017: 47.6
  - 2018: 70.6
  - 2019: 77.1
  - 2020: 83.2
  - 2021: 84.7
  - 2022: 82.2
  - 2023: 78.1
  - 2024: 73.2
- Public gross financing needs (in percent of GDP):
  - 2017: 7.8
  - 2018: 10.9
  - 2019: 10.8
  - 2020: 10.6
  - 2021: 9.1
  - 2022: 9.6
  - 2023: 7.5
  - 2024: 7.5
- Net public debt (in percent of GDP):
  - 2017: 43.2
  - 2018: 67.9
  - 2019: 74.5
  - 2020: 80.4
  - 2021: 82.0
  - 2022: 79.5
  - 2023: 75.3
  - 2024: 70.5
- Public debt (in percent of potential GDP):
  - 2017: 48.0
  - 2018: 69.3
  - 2019: 75.7
  - 2020: 81.6
  - 2021: 83.3
  - 2022: 81.0
  - 2023: 77.3
  - 2024: 72.8
- Real GDP growth (in percent):
  - 2017: 2.3
  - 2018: 2.0
  - 2019: 2.6
  - 2020: 2.7
  - 2021: 3.2
  - 2022: 3.4
  - 2023: 3.9
  - 2024: 4.0
- Inflation (GDP deflator, in percent):
  - 2017: 4.3
  - 2018: 5.2
  - 2019: 6.8
  - 2020: 6.9
  - 2021: 5.8
  - 2022: 4.5
  - 2023: 4.3
  - 2024: 4.1
- Nominal GDP growth (in percent):
  - 2017: 6.8
  - 2018: 7.3
  - 2019: 9.5
  - 2020: 9.8
  - 2021: 9.2
  - 2022: 8.1
  - 2023: 8.4
  - 2024: 8.3
- Effective interest rate (in percent):
  - 2017: 4.6
  - 2018: 4.0
  - 2019: 4.1
  - 2020: 4.2
  - 2021: 4.2
  - 2022: 4.5
  - 2023: 4.8
  - 2024: 5.1
- Ratings (as reported):
  - Moody's: Ba3 (foreign and local)
  - S&Ps: DD
  - Fitch: B+

### Composition of public debt and alternative scenario assumptions
- Alternative scenarios (selected assumptions):
  - Baseline 2019–2024:
    - Real GDP growth: 2.7 | 3.2 | 3.4 | 3.9 | 4.0 | 4.0 (2019–2024)
    - Inflation: 6.9 | 5.8 | 4.5 | 4.3 | 4.1 | 4.0 (2019–2024)
    - Primary Balance: -0.6 | 0.4 | 1.3 | 2.0 | 3.0 | 3.0 (2019–2024)
    - Effective interest rate: 4.1 | 4.2 | 4.6 | 4.9 | 5.2 | 5.5 (2019–2024)
  - Historical scenario:
    - Primary Balance: -0.6 | -2.5 | -2.5 | -2.5 | -2.5 | -2.5 (2019–2024)
    - Effective interest rate higher in 2021–2024 compared with baseline.
  - Constant Primary Balance scenario:
    - Primary Balance: -0.6 for 2019–2024
    - Effective interest rate: 4.1 | 4.2 | 4.6 | 4.9 | 5.2 | 5.5 (2019–2024)
- Debt dynamics under alternative scenarios illustrated by:
  - Gross nominal public debt and public gross financing needs trajectories through 2024.
  - Debt by maturity (medium and long-term vs short-term) and by currency (local vs foreign).

### Public DSA stress-test scenarios and specific parameter paths
- Primary Balance Shock scenario (2019–2024) key variables:
  - Real GDP growth: 2.7 | 3.2 | 3.4 | 3.9 | 4.0 | 4.0
  - Inflation: 6.9 | 5.8 | 4.5 | 4.3 | 4.1 | 4.0
  - Primary balance: -0.6 | -0.6 | 0.3 | 2.0 | 3.0 | 3.0
  - Effective interest rate: 4.1 | 4.2 | 4.6 | 4.9 | 5.2 | 5.4
- Real GDP Growth Shock scenario:
  - Real GDP growth: 2.7 | 1.5 | 1.7 | 3.9 | 4.0 | 4.0
  - Primary balance: -0.6 | -0.2 | 0.1 | 2.0 | 3.0 | 3.0
  - Effective interest rate similar to baseline: 4.1 | 4.2 | 4.6 | 4.9 | 5.2 | 5.4
- Real Interest Rate Shock scenario:
  - Effective interest rate: 4.1 | 4.2 | 4.8 | 5.3 | 5.8 | 6.3 (2019–2024)
- Real Exchange Rate Shock scenario:
  - Inflation path includes a spike: 6.9 | 5.4 | 12.7 | 4.5 | 4.3 | 4.1
  - Effective interest rate: 4.1 | 5.0 | 4.4 | 4.7 | 5.0 | 5.3
- Combined Shock and Contingent Liability Shock presented with corresponding variable paths (see DSA tables).
- Contingent Liability Shock sample parameter:
  - Primary balance in 2020 drops to -9.2 (in the contingent liability shock scenario) before recovering.

### External debt dynamics, vulnerabilities, and stress-test outcomes
- External debt has been rising since 2011; at end-2018 external debt-to-GDP ratio reached 94 percent.
- Drivers of rise in external debt: dinar depreciation, lower-than-expected growth, higher fiscal and current account deficits.
- Recent and past Eurobond issuances noted (no new data beyond descriptive mention).
- Baseline external debt trajectory (percent of GDP):
  - 2018: 94.1
  - 2019: 104.5
  - 2020: 107.8 (peaks at 108 percent of GDP in text)
  - 2021: 105.2
  - 2022: 101.2
  - 2023: 96.2
  - 2024: 91.0
- The 2019 and 2020 increases reflect recent market issuance and continued official funding.
- External debt is generally resilient to most shocks because of:
  - low average interest rate,
  - relatively long maturities,
  - substantial share of concessional debt,
  - large grant element on new external debt.
- Exceptions: large real exchange rate depreciation is a key vulnerability.
  - A negative combined shock to real interest rate, growth, and current account increases the external debt ratio to 97 percent of GDP by end-2024 (versus 91 percent under baseline).
  - A one-time sharp real exchange rate depreciation (one-time 30 percent in the second year of projection) would propel external debt ratio to 155 percent of GDP in 2020 and to 131 percent at the end of the projection horizon.

### External debt stock composition (2018)
- Total external debt stock:
  - TD Mio: 99,261
  - US$ Mio: 33,149
  - %GDP: 94.1
  - % of total: 100
- By maturity:
  - MLT: TD 78,454 | US$ 26,200 | %GDP 74.4 | % of total 79.0
  - ST: TD 20,807 | US$ 6,949 | %GDP 19.7 | % of total 21.0
- By currency (selected):
  - US$: TD 22,036 | US$ 7,359 | %GDP 20.9 | % of total 22.2
  - EUR: TD 55,189 | US$ 18,431 | %GDP 52.3 | % of total 55.6
  - JPY: TD 9,231 | US$ 3,083 | %GDP 8.8 | % of total 9.3
- By creditor (2018):
  - Official: TD 45,323 | US$ 15,136 | %GDP 43.0 | % of total 45.7
    - Multilateral: TD 32,852 | US$ 10,971 | %GDP 31.1 | % of total 33.1
      - o/w AfDB: TD 7,937 | US$ 2,651 | %GDP 7.5 | % of total 8.0
      - o/w EIB: TD 6,755 | US$ 2,256 | %GDP 6.4 | % of total 6.8
      - o/w IMF: TD 4,238 | US$ 1,415 | %GDP 4.0 | % of total 4.3
      - o/w World Bank: TD 8,117 | US$ 2,711 | %GDP 7.7 | % of total 8.2
    - Bilateral: TD 12,471 | US$ 4,165 | %GDP 11.8 | % of total 12.6
      - o/w France: TD 4,448 | US$ 1,485 | %GDP 4.2 | % of total 4.5
      - o/w Japan: TD 1,590 | US$ 531 | %GDP 1.5 | % of total 1.6
  - Private (market): TD 17,198 | US$ 5,744 | %GDP 16.3 | % of total 17.3
    - o/w guaranteed: TD 5,769 | US$ 1,927 | %GDP 5.5 | % of total 5.8
  - Other (incl. sukuk): TD 18,335 | US$ 6,123 | %GDP 17.4 | % of total 18.5
- Memo:
  - GDP (Mio TD): 105,479
  - TD/US$ (eop): 2.99

### External Debt Sustainability Framework (2014–2024) — selected indicators and projections
- Baseline external debt (percent of GDP):
  - 2014: 60.7
  - 2015: 65.4
  - 2016: 72.9
  - 2017: 84.2
  - 2018: 94.1
  - 2019: 104.5
  - 2020: 107.8
  - 2021: 105.2
  - 2022: 101.2
  - 2023: 96.2
  - 2024: 91.0
- Change in external debt (percent of GDP):
  - 2014: 4.6
  - 2015: 4.7
  - 2016: 7.5
  - 2017: 11.3
  - 2018: 9.9
  - 2019: 10.4
  - 2020: 3.3
  - 2021: -2.6
  - 2022: -3.9
  - 2023: -5.0
  - 2024: -5.2
- Identified external debt-creating flows (in percent of GDP):
  - 2018: 17.3
  - 2019: 4.6
  - 2020: 2.6
  - 2021: 1.7
  - 2022: 0.5
  - 2023: -0.4
  - 2024: -0.7
- Current account deficit, excluding interest payments (percent of GDP):
  - 2014: -8.4
  - 2015: -8.1
  - 2016: -7.5
  - 2017: -8.7
  - 2018: -9.5
  - 2019: -7.2
  - 2020: -5.8
  - 2021: -4.6
  - 2022: -3.6
  - 2023: -2.8
  - 2024: -2.2
- External debt-to-exports ratio (percent):
  - 2014: 133.2
  - 2015: 160.9
  - 2016: 179.3
  - 2017: 189.7
  - 2018: 192.9
  - 2019: 204.3
  - 2020–2024: above 199 in projections (see table for annual values)
- Gross external financing need (in billions of US dollars and percent of GDP):
  - 2014: 12.5 (26.3 percent of GDP)
  - 2015: 12.2
  - 2016: 12.2
  - 2017: 13.2
  - 2018: 14.2
  - 2019: 13.4
  - 2020: 12.4
  - 2021: 12.9
  - 2022: 12.4
  - 2023: 13.1
  - 2024: 14.1

### Bound tests and shock scenarios for external debt
- Scenario results (selected):
  - B1. Nominal interest rate at historical average plus one standard deviation: external debt path remains elevated (table values show series starting 104.5 becoming 108.2 etc.).
  - B2. Real GDP growth at historical average minus one standard deviation: elevated external debt path (values in table).
  - B3. Non-interest current account at historical average minus one standard deviation: elevated external debt path.
  - B4. Combination of B1–B3 using 1/2 standard deviation shocks: elevated but manageable path.
  - B5. One-time 30 percent real depreciation in 2016 (illustrative): external debt rises sharply (e.g., to 154.8 in one reported year and remains elevated thereafter).
- Shocks applied in bound tests include permanent one-half standard deviation shocks (except for growth which is a 3/4th standard deviation), and a one-time real depreciation of 30 percent in 2019 in some DSA figures.

### Key vulnerability and policy signal
- Main vulnerability: large real exchange rate depreciation can dramatically increase external debt ratios (e.g., to 155 percent of GDP under a one-time 30 percent real depreciation).
- Other risks: realization of contingent liabilities (government guarantees to SOEs), weak fiscal consolidation or politically-driven loosened fiscal and monetary policies.
- Policy implication explicitly stated: caution in policies is needed to maintain investor confidence.

*Source: IMF staff (Tunisia Public Sector DSA and External Debt Sustainability Framework, as presented in the supplied content).*

### Annex IV. Capacity Building Priorities

### Annex IV. Capacity Building Priorities

### Technical Assistance Key Objective — Fiscal Affairs Department (FAD)
- Treasury Single Account (TSA) and cash management: Improve fiscal and monetary policy coordination
- Management of state-owned enterprises (SoEs): Improve consolidated public sector monitoring
- Budget preparation: Improve budget preparation procedures and transparency, including by introducing a medium-term perspective
- Tax equity: Rebalance the tax structure to make in more progressive

### Technical Assistance Key Objective — Monetary and Capital Markets Department (MCM)
- Foreign exchange (FX) regulations: Help defining a strategy for capital account flows
- Monetary policy framework: Help moving to interest rate-based monetary policy and introduction of inflation targeting
- Central bank governance and strategic planning: Improve central bank efficiency and operations
- FX interventions: Strengthen intervention calibration and procedures
- Banking supervision: Accelerate transition to Basle III
- Stress testing: Reinforce tools for testing resilience of the banking system

### Technical Assistance Key Objective — Legal Department (LEG)
- AML/CFT national risk assessment: Improve procedures for risk assessment
- Anti-Money Laundering and Countering Financing of Terrorism (AML/CFT) and anti-corruption measures: legal framework: Strengthen the legal framework for AML/CFT
- Framework for non-performing loans (NPL) resolution: Improve procedures for NPL resolution

### Technical Assistance Key Objective — Statistics Department (STA)
- Government Finance Statistics (GFS) public sector consolidation: Consolidate SOEs balance sheets in the public sector statistic for consolidated monitoring
- Special Data Dissemination Standard (SDDS) platform reforms: Review internal CBT procedures for data submissions
- Financial institutions: Improve consolidated reporting of financial institutions

### Technical Assistance Key Objective — Institute for Capacity Development (ICD)
- Financial programming: Improve macroeconomic monitoring and policy implementation capabilities
- Monetary policy: Strengthen the implementation of monetary policy instruments
- Exchange rate policy: Explore options and trade-offs in selecting exchange rate regiments

### Letter of Intent — Key macroeconomic developments and program performance
- 2018 GDP growth: 2.6 percent (at 2010 prices)
- Unemployment: 15.4 percent in 2018
- Inflation: stabilized at around 7.3 percent in the second half of 2018
- Current account deficit: 11.2 percent of GDP in 2018 (record level)
- Fiscal deficit (including grants): 4.6 percent of GDP in 2018
- Central government (CG) debt: 77 percent of GDP (compared with 72 percent planned in the supplementary 2018 budget)
- Program performance (end-March 2019): met 4 of 6 quantitative performance criteria (QPCs)
  - Met QPCs:
    - Floor on the CG’s primary balance (on a cash basis, excluding grants)
    - Ceiling on the CG’s total current primary expenditure
    - Floor on social expenditures
    - Quarterly ceiling on the Central Bank of Tunisia’s (CBT) net FX interventions
  - Continuous criteria respected:
    - Zero ceiling on accumulation of arrears on the CG’s external debt service
    - Indicative target of zero ceiling on the accumulation of new arrears on domestic payments
  - Not met QPCs:
    - Ceiling on CBT’s net domestic assets (NDA): exceeded due to refinancing needs amid weak bank reserves
    - Floor on net international reserves (NIR): missed due to lower-than-expected external financing flows since June 2018
  - Monthly IT on ceiling on CBT’s net FX interventions: respected in December 2018, February and March 2019; missed during August and November 2018 and in January 2019 (attributed to SOEs’ significant FX purchases, especially in the energy sector)
- Structural benchmarks (SBs) for the Fifth Review (9 SBs):
  - Achieved (2): BFT resolution committee voted on orderly resolution plan for the BFT; 2019 budget law provides for convergence between the preferential taxation regime for offshore companies and the normal regime
  - Implemented with delay (2): database on vulnerable households established; organic budget law adopted
  - Reprogrammed (4): nomination of Board of the High Anticorruption and Good Governance Authority (reprogrammed for September 2019); adoption of the law on excessive lending rates (reprogrammed for September 2019); increase in the VAT for the liberal professions (reprogrammed for December 2019); performance contract for Tunisair (reprogrammed for July 2019)
  - Not achieved (1 quarterly SB): quarterly SB on fuel price hikes not met for last quarter of 2018; compensatory measures implemented:
    - Fuel prices raised by around 6% as of March 31, 2019, and prices of other oil products raised, achieving annual savings of around TD 250 million
    - Prices for low-pressure natural gas and low-voltage electricity raised in May, achieving annual savings of TD 74 million

### Fiscal policy intentions and measures (2019)
- 2019 target overall budget deficit (excluding grants): 3.9 percent of GDP
- Public investment level to be maintained at 5.6 percent of GDP (2018 level)
- Social spending: to be boosted
- Unallocated contingency: TD 300 million (0.3 percent of GDP)
- Energy subsidy reforms — implemented and planned measures:
  - Implemented price measures:
    - Fuel prices: raised by 6 percent on average end-March (met Prior Action)
    - Selected electricity and natural gas tariffs: raised in May (met Prior Action)
    - Electricity increases apply to consumption tariffs of more than 300 kWh per month (represent 4 percent of households and 2.6 percent of non-residential clients)
    - Social tariffs for electricity (monthly consumption < 100 kWh): adjusted downward by around 10 percent
    - Tariffs for tranche 100 kWh to 300 kWh: maintained
    - Result: 94 percent of energy consumers protected; measures generate savings of TD 74 million
  - Implemented quantitative measures:
    - Progressive cuts in supply of ordinary diesel and increase in supply of sulfur-free diesel
    - Rebalancing of import volumes notified to STIR in April
    - Expected increase in revenue of TD 100 million due to heavier taxation of sulfur-free fuels (higher excise tax of around 0.3 dinar per liter vs 0.1 dinar for ordinary diesel)
  - Planned price measures for remainder of 2019:
    - Maintain scheduled adjustment of 2 percent per month started in January 2019 for tariffs for medium voltage electricity and medium pressure natural gas
    - Planned fuel increases: June 1, 2019 and October 1, 2019 (consistent with SB on quarterly adjustments of fuel prices)
  - Communication: link between energy price/quantity adjustments and measures to improve social protection for low-income households
  - Other measures to reduce energy weight and improve efficiency:
    - Rationalize domestic LPG consumption; campaign to combat diversion of subsidized domestic LPG for commercial purposes; rebalancing quantities of domestic and industrial LPG; decree reorganizing distribution channels for domestic LPG
    - Reduce losses from STEG via "smart meters" (see Section III.B)
    - Reduce unpaid invoices to STEG: TD 140 million; STEG intends to discontinue service for customers who do not pay their bills, facilitated by "smart meters" allowing automated and remote disconnection (new SB for June 2019)

### Program requests and commitments
- Request completion of the Fifth Review under the EFF arrangement
- Request approval of related purchase of SDR 176,782,400
- Request waivers of nonobservance of the two QPCs on NIR and NDA, and a modification of end-June QPCs
- Request re-phasing of remaining access under the program
- Commitments:
  - Respect quantitative targets and implement measures in schedule of SBs as described in the MEFP (Tables 1 and 2) and TMU
  - Provide IMF staff with all information and data needed for monitoring and technical assistance within agreed deadlines
  - Discuss adoption of supplementary measures with IMF staff prior to any revision of macroeconomic policies in the MEFP

*Source: Annex IV. Capacity Building Priorities; Letter of Intent and Attachment I. Memorandum of Economic and Financial Policies (excerpts) from the provided PDF content.*

### 5. The government is strengthening the existing social safety nets, particularly to offset the

### 1tunea2019001 - 5. The government is strengthening the existing social safety nets, particularly to offset the

### Social safety net measures (2019)
- Access to health care services:
  - Allocated overall amount of TD 150 million to public hospitals for low-income households (20 percent of the population).
  - Dotation of a health fund to subsidize health care for low-income households (categories AMG1 and AMG2): TD 100 million; met Prior Action.
  - Supply of medications and settlement of arrears owed to the central pharmacy: annual envelope of TD 50 million, over four years.
- Other measures to help low-income households in 2019:
  - Improved social integration: TD 15 million for measures benefiting children from underprivileged families and handicapped persons (school transport, financing for small projects).
  - Social transfers for AMG1 and AMG2 beneficiaries:
    - Registration in the new AMEN database enabled partial budget coverage of unpaid energy invoices for a total amount of TD 50 million (new SB for September 2019).
    - Government will pay, for a total cost of TD 35 million (new SB for September 2019): (1) an additional one-off transfer for the month of Ramadan of TD 80 per vulnerable household (category PNAFN); and (2) a one-off transfer in support of the back-to-school period for other low-income households (category AMG2).

### Key statistics — Table B. Social Measures, 2019 (Excluding support to the social security funds)
- Total social measures: 367 TD millions — 0.32 Percent of GDP
- Current expenditure: 250 TD millions — 0.22 Percent of GDP
  - Dotation of a health fund to subsidize health care for low-income households (i.e. AMG1 and AMG2): 100 TD millions — 0.09 Percent of GDP
  - Higher budget allocation for medicine purchases in the public sector 1/: 50 TD millions — 0.04 Percent of GDP
  - Promotion of social integration: 15 TD millions — 0.01 Percent of GDP
    - Free school transportation for kids form vulnerable households (i.e. PNAFN): 5 TD millions — 0.00 Percent of GDP
    - Measures to help social insertion of deprived or disabled people: 10 TD millions — 0.01 Percent of GDP
  - Payment support by the budget for unpaid energy bills of low-income households (i.e. AMG1 and AMG2, registered in the new AMEN database): 50 TD millions — 0.04 Percent of GDP
  - One-off transfers (1) for Ramadan to each vulnerable household (PNAFN); and (2) for the new school year to other low-income households (AMG2): 35 TD millions — 0.03 Percent of GDP
- Capital expenditure: 117 TD millions — 0.10 Percent of GDP
  - Purchase of light equipment for hospitals: 35 TD millions — 0.03 Percent of GDP
  - Purchase of heavy equipment for hospitals: 82 TD millions — 0.07 Percent of GDP
- Annual cost note: 1/ This program represents a total amount of TND 200 million, to be spent over 4 years.

### Targeting infrastructure and operational timeline
- AMEN database progress:
  - Registered 575,000 families; 475,000 have already been surveyed and processed; 375,000 validated.
  - Payment card ("smart card") general use by June 2019.
  - Health card (“AMEN card”) operational for providing health care by November 2019.
- End-2019 targets and operational steps:
  - Registration could cover up to 800,000 households by November 2019, of which 400,000 will have been surveyed.
  - Sustained pace: around 20,000 surveys completed per month.
  - Immediate allocation of around TD 2 million from the Ministry of Social Affairs to cover transportation for social workers.
  - Expand distribution of payment cards from current two regions to the entire country.
  - Systems’ coverage of low-income households with verified needs and in procession of a payments card to increase from current 9 percent to at least 12 percent of the population by end-2019 and 15 percent in 2020.
- Medium-term measures:
  - Reinforce transfers in favor of school enrollment for children from the most disadvantaged households.
  - Develop action plan to boost resources in support of school enrollment, particularly transfers for AMG2 beneficiaries with terms similar to PNAFN, and extend PNAFN benefits to children up to the age of five years.
  - Technical support received from UNICEF and the World Bank.
  - Possible implementation of these measures as of 2020 depending on the action plan.

### Public wage bill management
- Commitment to reduce the public wage bill and maintain strict hiring limits for 2019 and 2020 (replacement rate of 25 percent).
- No planned new salary increases in 2019 or 2020 beyond previously decided measures.
- Selected figures from Table C. Public Wage Bill, 2018–19:
  - Wage bill: 14,863 TD millions — 14.1 Percent of GDP (2018) and 17,215 TD millions — 14.9 Percent of GDP (2019)
  - Base (previous year after corrections 1/): 14,776 TD millions — 14.0 Percent of GDP (2018) and 14,814 TD millions — 12.8 Percent of GDP (2019)
  - Increases in wages 2/: 1,727 TD millions — 1.5 Percent of GDP
  - 2019 salary increases: 580 TD millions — 0.5 Percent of GDP
  - Tax credits: 1,147 TD millions — 1.0 Percent of GDP
  - Savings 3/: 900 TD millions — 0.1 Percent of GDP
  - Transfers reclassified in the wage bill in line with the program 5/: 870.1 TD millions — 0.0 Percent of GDP
  - Memo items: GDP = 105,479 (2018); GDP = 115,828 (2019)

### Social security funds and pension reform
- Reform law for the public pension fund CNRPS (adopted by Parliament on April 3, 2019):
  - Increases the retirement age from 60 years to 61 in 2019, and to 62 years in 2020.
  - Rises contributions by 1 percentage point for the employee and 2 percentage points for the employer.
- Budgetary transfer due to delays: TD 230 million (0.2 percent of GDP) to the CNRPS.
- A government decree with similar reform elements for the private pension fund CNSS will be published shortly.

### Financing program for 2019
- External financing target: mobilize TD 10.3 billion in external financing in 2019, of which around TD 2.6 billion (US$0.8 billion) will come from the international market in the second quarter.
- Domestic financing: reduce domestic needs to facilitate the Central Bank of Tunisia (CBT) objective of reducing both the monetary base and commercial banks’ refinancing.

### Monetary policy
- CBT policy rate actions and outlook:
  - Policy rate raised three times in 12 months for a total of 275 basis points, bringing it to 7.75 percent in February 2019.
  - Expectation: inflation will slow in 2019 to a level of 6.8 percent at the end of the year.
  - CBT committed to further rate increases if quarterly projections deviate from the programmed inflation path.
- Refinancing and liquidity management:
  - CBT committed to reducing refinancing to TD 13.9 billion by the end of 2019, compared to TD 16.4 billion in March 2019.
  - Increase share of public securities accepted as collateral in monetary policy operations from 40 percent currently to 50 percent of the volume of refinancing (new SB for September 2019).
  - Gradually reduce overall volume of FX swap operations to TD 500 million by the fourth quarter of 2019.
  - CBT will not raise the ceiling of the main 7-day refinancing operations until a credible quarterly path for reducing refinancing is established and not without consultation with the IMF.
- Monetary programming and framework improvements:
  - NDA target at end-December 2018 missed by nearly TD 510 million.
  - Monetary base and NDA assets expected to shrink in line with policy to reduce global refinancing volume.
  - CBT committed to: (1) communicate a medium-term inflation target as soon as possible; (2) continue publishing the monetary policy report; (3) improve inflation forecasting tools (for example, by including a credit variable); and (4) introduce a quarterly survey of inflation expectations.
  - CBT will request technical assistance from the IMF to strengthen monetary policy framework, governance and strategic planning, FX intervention framework, reform FX regulations, and implement an inflation expectations survey.
  - Preparations planned for the monetary policy consultation clause (MPCC) for possible implementation during a subsequent stage of the reform program.
- Monitoring and supervision:
  - Banking sector liquidity situation to be monitored monthly; sanctions to be imposed on banks that do not respect prudential rules.
  - Corresponding data to be transmitted monthly to IMF staff in accordance with the Technical Memorandum of Understanding (TMU).
  - Request technical assistance to strengthen CBT’s capacity to manage macro-prudential risks.

### Exchange rate policy
- CBT commitments on FX intervention framework:
  - Pursue regular competitive auctions to support price discovery and allow the dinar to adjust.
  - Avoid any intervention outside the auction mechanism.
  - Strengthen communications and ensure strict respect of FX intervention limits.
  - Reduce intervention ceiling to US$100 million on average during May and December 2019, compared to an average US$126 million in 2018.
  - Terminate practice of direct FX sales by the CBT intended to satisfy the demand of public enterprises in support of energy imports.

### Structural reforms — Promoting the private sector
- Measures to enhance business climate:
  - Draft cross-cutting law for promotion of investment and improvement of the business climate adopted by a parliament committee and to be debated in full session; intent to simplify procedures, reduce prior authorizations, alleviate administrative costs, and computerize procedures on an integrated platform.
  - Start-up Act operationalization: implementation started; preparing a second plan of action, Doing Business, to simplify procedures for construction permits, creating a business, and selling property.
  - Pursue simplification of administrative authorizations based on government decree no. 2018-417.

### Structural reforms — Governance, AML/CFT, and public financial management
- Governance and anticorruption:
  - Make operational the National Anticorruption and Good Governance Authority; finalize appointment of Board members to be named by September 2019 (reprogrammed SB for September 2019).
- AML/CFT:
  - Aim to have Tunisia removed from FATF “gray list”; continue measures in action plan adopted on January 22, 2018.
  - Prior to April 26: finalize prior audit arrangements for lawyers, notaries and accountants; launch the national business registry and make beneficiary information available; apply penalties stipulated by decree 2019/72.
  - Continue sharing fiscal information with other jurisdictions through provisions in the 2019 budget law and the organic budget law.
- State-owned enterprises (SOEs) governance and surveillance:
  - Implement performance contracts for certain public enterprises; step up financial surveillance over all state-owned firms.
  - Tunisair: performance contract being implemented (reprogrammed SB for July 2019); comprehensive restructuring plan prepared by management.
  - Require monthly balance sheets on treasury operations and indebtedness (including arrears) from SOEs to the Direction Générale des Participations (DGP) and budget office.
  - Improve STEG governance: reduce technical losses and fraud through electronic meters; achieve savings of some TD 300 million in 2019 (including collection of unpaid invoices); rely on "smart grid" technology and World Bank assistance to STEG.
  - Study on impact of raising energy rates on enterprise profitability to be available by end-2019; monitor impact on disadvantaged households.

### Strengthening tax administration and public financial management
- Tax administration initiatives:
  - Strengthen international cooperation; Tunisia undertook to adhere to the multilateral agreement on automatic sharing of information on financial accounts.
  - Create in 2019 an international unit for exchange of tax information.
  - Introduce one-off audit controls in tax legislation via amendment to the code of fiscal procedures proposed in the context of the supplementary budget law for 2019.
  - Implement monthly and automatic sharing of information between customs and the tax administration; system to be fully operational by December 2019.
  - Pursue computerization of the tax administration; by December 2019 operational information system to include: (1) new electronic taxpayer registry; (2) automatic reminders of tax obligations; (3) electronic payments; and (4) online tax filing.
  - Electronic tax filing made obligatory for enterprises with a turnover of at least TD 500,000 (previously 750,000).
  - Introduce automatic electronic reminder system for non-filers by end-2019.
  - Public commercial registry now publishes online information indicating whether registered enterprises are up to date with tax obligations (law approved in October 2018 and application decrees published on February 7, 2019).
  - Develop price indices for residential real estate coordinated with the National Statistics Institute (INS) to improve property tax collection; supported by technical assistance.

*Source: Tunisian authorities; IMF staff summary of measures and commitments as presented in the provided content.*

### 18. To bolster financial sector stability and improve access to finance, we are planning to:

### 18. To bolster financial sector stability and improve access to finance, we are planning to:

### Strengthen banking supervision
- Monitor the impact and the observance of the tightening of the CBT’s refinancing policy, as well as prudential requirements (i.e. the loan-to-deposit and liquidity ratios).
- Continue strengthening the solvency requirements: since 2018 the capital adequacy ratio covers market risk requirements in addition to credit and operational risks.
- Improve the monitoring of banks' financial soundness, in particular as it concerns the impact of policy rate hikes on bank balance sheets.

### Strengthen risk management
- CBT’s objectives for 2019:
  - Review the credit risk approach and adopt prudential standards on a consolidated basis.
  - Prepare for the adoption of Basel III tools and IFRS rules.

### Restructure state-owned banks and reduce nonperforming loans (NPLs)
- Implement recent laws allowing out-of-court workouts and softening the conditions for writing off unrecoverable bank loans.
- Speeding NPL resolution requires a concerted, global approach involving all stakeholders (government, CBT, banks, the judiciary).
- The approach must combine measures to support certain economic sectors, promote financial recovery, and improve the business climate.
- CBT will benefit from World Bank technical assistance on this subject.

### Improve monitoring of banks’ financial soundness
- Constitute an internal committee of the CBT to carry out a more detailed and more frequent assessment of the situation of each bank, based on in-depth analysis of soundness and liquidity indicators.
- Banks that no longer fulfill the conditions of access to the money market must be excluded from that market and handled through the emergency liquidity assistance mechanism.

### Implement the decashing strategy
- Launch e-payment institutions and a new interoperable mobile payment solution for the banking community.
- Tax administration and state-owned enterprises will accept new modes of payment.
- Expected effect: reduce cash in circulation in the economy and relieve pressures on the overall volume of refinancing.

### Trade policy
- Non-tariff measures recently implemented with respect to trade policy have been removed.
- At the end of 2018, the exchange restriction introduced in 2017 (prohibiting the granting of loans for imports deemed nonessential) was withdrawn.
- Capital account liberalization will be conditional on domestic financial market development and the strengthening of prudential regulation.

### Program monitoring and implementation
- Progress in the implementation of IMF-supported policies will be monitored through quarterly reviews.
- Related test dates: end-June, end-September, and end-December 2019.
- The related QPCs, continuous PCs, ITs, and SBs for these test dates are detailed in Tables 1a, 1b, and 2, with definitions and data requirements provided in the attached TMU (including a clarification of the QPC on NIR in TMU¶¶21–22 that does not change the existing coverage).
- The authorities continue to intend not to keep IMF disbursements with the CBT, but to on-lend to the government.

*Source: IMF staff and Tunisian authorities (excerpt).*

### 11.      Net government borrowing from the banking system is defined as the change in the

### 1tunea2019001 - 11. Net government borrowing from the banking system is defined as the change in the

### Definitions of financing and borrowing
- Net government borrowing from the banking system
  - Defined as the change in the stock of government securities (i.e. Treasury bills and bonds) held by banks and any other central government borrowing from banks, less repayments.
- Net domestic nonbank financing
  - Includes the change in the stock of government securities (Treasury bills and bonds) held by nonbanks (including social security funds) and any other central government borrowing from nonbanks, less repayments.
  - Any use of cash from non-banking institutions (including La Poste) to finance the Treasury is counted as domestic non-bank financing.
  - Total Treasury bills and other public debt instruments are calculated at the nominal/face value shown on the institutions’ balance sheet and do not include accrued interest.

### Ceiling on Total Current Primary Expenditure of the Central Government (Excluding Interest Payments on Public Debt)
- Total current primary expenditure of the central government is defined as the sum of:
  - (1) personnel wages and salaries;
  - (2) goods and services;
  - (3) transfers and subsidies;
  - (4) other unallocated current expenditure.

### Floor on Social Spending
- Social spending under the program includes:
  - Capital expenditures (development expenditures) on education;
  - Health;
  - Social transfers to low-income families;
  - Employment training programs (and university scholarships);
  - Union Tunisienne de Solidarité Sociale (UTSS) indemnities;
  - Family allocation;
  - Development expenditures of the Ministries of Women and Family Affairs, Youth and Sports and Social Affairs;
  - All new targeted cash transfers in support of low-income households.
- Excluded:
  - All current expenditures (“dépenses de gestion”) of the above-mentioned sectors and programs;
  - Food and energy subsidies.

### Ceiling on Net Domestic Assets (NDA) of the Central Bank of Tunisia (CBT)
- NDA defined as the difference between the monetary base and the net foreign assets of the CBT.
- Monetary base includes:
  - (1) fiduciary money (money in circulation excluding cash balances of banks and the Treasury);
  - (2) deposits of banks at the CBT (including foreign currency and deposit facility);
  - (3) deposits of all other sectors at the CBT (other financial enterprises, households, and companies).
- Net foreign assets of the CBT
  - Defined as the difference between gross foreign assets (including foreign assets that are not part of the reserve assets) and all foreign liabilities.
  - Valued at the program exchange rate defined in the above table.
- Operational responsibility
  - The Directorate General of Statistics (Directorate of Monetary and Financial Statistics) will prepare monthly forecasts of reserve money and calculate NDA projections for the next six months; projections submitted to IMF staff after consultation with the Directorate General of Monetary Policy.

### Floor on the Net International Reserves (NIR) of the CBT
- NIR defined as the difference between the CBT’s reserve assets and its liabilities in foreign currency to nonresidents.
- Reserve assets include (per IMF Balance of Payments Manual, fifth edition):
  - Gold, SDR assets, reserve position at the IMF, convertible foreign currencies, liquid balances held outside Tunisia, negotiable foreign securities and bills purchased and discounted.
- Liabilities in foreign currency to nonresidents include:
  - Commitments to sell foreign currencies associated with financial derivative transactions (e.g., swaps, futures, options);
  - Any portion of CBT assets (e.g., gold) used as collateral;
  - IMF and Arab Monetary Fund (AMF) credits outstanding for reasons of balance of payment support or budget support onlent to the central government;
  - Deposits at the CBT of international organizations, foreign governments, and foreign bank and nonbank institutions.
  - Exclusions: government’s foreign currency deposits at the CBT, and any SDR allocation received after March 31, 2017.
- Treatment of international capital market debt
  - All debt instruments issued on international capital markets in foreign currency by the CBT on behalf of the government after May 15, 2013 will be treated as CBT liabilities, unless the prospectus clearly states that:
    - (1) the CBT is acting as an agent to execute sovereign debt instruments in foreign currency raised for general budgetary purposes of the Republic of Tunisia;
    - (2) debt is a liability of the central government;
    - (3) all charges and expenses arising from issued debt securities are the responsibility of the State.
  - Minister of Finance authorizes reimbursement of costs, interest and capital by debiting the Treasury account after informing the Treasurer General of Tunisia, supported by necessary supporting documents (Article 32, new organic law of the CBT 2016-35).
- Valuation and stock as of December 31, 2017 (at program exchange rates)
  - Stock of NIR reserves: US$3,120.2 million
  - Stock of reserve assets: US$5,480.6 million
  - Stock of CBT liabilities in foreign currency: US$2,360.4 million

### Ceiling on Net Foreign Exchange Interventions of the CBT
- Defined as the difference between outright foreign exchange sales (including conversions) and outright foreign exchange purchases (including conversions) via channels: Reuters, auctions, and the interbank market.
- Computation may include CBT net sales in other formal or informal markets or instruments (e.g., transactions in derivatives) that the CBT may substitute for outright net sales.
- Transactions of the CBT with the central government in the context of budget operations are not considered net sales unless they take place through one of the channels listed above.
- Purchases of foreign currency proceeds of a potential Eurobond or other official financing cannot be interpreted as CBT purchases of foreign exchange for computation of net sales total.

### Ceilings on Accumulation of Arrears
- External arrears
  - Defined as late payments (principal and interest) on external debt or guarantees as defined in External Debt Statistics: Guide for compilers by the central government or the CBT from the due date or the expiration of the applicable grace period.
- Domestic arrears
  - Defined as amounts owed to domestic financial and commercial creditors that are 90 days or more overdue with respect to a specific maturity date (or as defined in the contractual grace period, if any).
  - If no maturity date specified, arrears are amounts owed to domestic creditors unpaid beyond 90 days or more after contract signing or receipt of invoice.

### Adjustment Factors for the Quarterly Performance Criteria (QPCs)
- Primary fiscal balance targets (cash basis, excluding grants) adjusted upward/downward based on amounts used to:
  - (1) recapitalize public banks;
  - (2) finance severance pay of voluntary departures that may be part of civil service reform.
- NDA targets adjusted upward (downward) if:
  - (1) cumulative sum (at program exchange rate) of external budget financing (including grants and loans, excluding from the IMF) and privatization receipts received by the central government in foreign currency is lower (greater) than levels in MEFP Table 1;
  - (2) total amount of cash payments on external debt service of the central government (at the program exchange rate) are greater (lower) than levels included in MEFP Table 1;
  - (3) NDA ceiling converted into Tunisian dinars at program exchange rate and adjusted downward (upward) based on amount of CBT reserves released (mobilized) because of a possible decrease (increase) in the reserve requirement.
- NIR targets adjusted upward (downward) if:
  - (1) cumulative sum (at program exchange rate) of external budget financing (including grants and loans, excluding from the IMF) and privatization receipts received by the central government in foreign currency is greater (lower) than levels observed in MEFP Table 1;
  - (2) total amount of cash payments on external debt service of the central government (at the program exchange rate) is lower (greater) than levels included in MEFP Table 1.

### Monitoring and Reporting Requirements (summary of reporting obligations and timelines)
- Authorities to transmit data and any revisions promptly to IMF staff; Directorate responsibilities cited throughout.
- Selected reporting items, periodicity, delay (in days), and responsible department (excerpted from Table 1):
  - Real Sector
    - GDP: supply and demand at current, constant, and the previous year’s prices, including sectoral indices — quarterly — 45 days — INS
    - Inflation: including underlying inflation of non-administered and administered prices — monthly — 14 days — INS
  - Fiscal Sector
    - Total revenue of the central government: tax and nontax revenue breakdown — monthly — 30 days — MoF
    - Disbursement of foreign grants, by donor and currency and equivalent in Tunisian dinars converted at the current exchange rate at the time of each transaction — monthly — 45 days — MoF/CBT
    - Total expenditures of the central government — monthly — 30 days — MoF
      - Current expenditure, by type: wages, goods and services, transfers and subsidies — monthly — 45 days — MoF
      - Capital expenditure, by type of financing and by main sectors and projects — monthly — 45 days — MoF
      - Social expenditure — quarterly — 45 days — MoF
    - Domestic and foreign debt stocks and flows, arrears, disbursements, domestic borrowing from banks and nonbanks, debt guaranteed by government, and debt service — periodicities ranging from monthly to quarterly — delays ranging from 30 to 90 days — MoF and MoF/CBT responsibilities as specified in Table 1
    - Debt guaranteed by the government, by instrument and currency — monthly — 60 days — MoF
  - Consolidated accounts of the central government at the CBT — monthly — 30 days — CBT (MoF/TGT for sub-account)
  - External Sector
    - Imports of petroleum products: average import price and volume of main petroleum products — monthly — 30 days — CBT
    - Deposits: stock of FX deposits by residence — monthly — 14 days — CBT
    - External debt stocks and flows and overall net external position — periodicities and delays up to annually — CBT
    - Balance of payments — quarterly — 30 days — CBT
    - FX market operations and CBT FX reserves and interventions, with detailed disclosures — monthly — 7 days — CBT
  - Monetary and Financial Sector
    - CBT accounts at the current exchange rate: monthly situation by sector — monthly — 15 days — CBT
    - Reserve money and NDA: monthly forecast — monthly — 15 days — CBT
    - Monetary policy operations and liquidity factors: daily and monthly balances, detailed table of instruments and facilities — monthly — 15 days — CBT
    - Monetary survey and banking sector balances — monthly — 30 and 45 days — CBT
    - Interest rates, credit data, IMF account statements, banks’ financial soundness ratios, direct refinancing by CBT, NPLs, balance sheets of commercial banks — periodicities monthly or quarterly, delays ranging from 14 to 60 days — CBT
  - Other information
    - Decrees or circulars newly adopted or revised concerning fiscal, monetary, and financial policy, changes in gas and electricity rates, and prices of petroleum products and levies/surcharges — daily — 3 days — CBT/MoF
    - Petroleum: price structure of petroleum products and data to monitor the automatic adjustment mechanism — daily — 15 days — Min. of Energy

### Administrative note at end of document
- Approved by Taline Koranchelian (MCD) and Vitaliy Kramarenko (SPR).
- The authorities have requested a reduction in access under Tunisia’s Extended Fund Facility (EFF) to maintain access within normal access limits during the remainder of the program. This request does not alter the thrust of the staff report and staff continues to recommend completion of the Fifth Review.

*Source: 1tunea2019001 (PDF chapter/section).*

### 1.      The scheduled purchases for the last year of the arrangement as presented in

### 1tunea2019001 - 1.      The scheduled purchases for the last year of the arrangement as presented in

### Exceptional access / Access rescheduling
- Combined scheduled seventh, eighth and ninth purchases in Table 11 of EBS/19/41 amount to 162.1261 percent of quota.
- The proposed rescheduling would exceed the annual threshold of 145 percent of quota that determines exceptional access.
- The excess resulted from delays in completing quarterly reviews that left a large access amount for remaining reviews that could not be spaced out further before the arrangement’s expiration in May 2020.
- The staff report (EBS/19/41) did not include a discussion of exceptional access considerations as it was not intended to provide financing support in excess of normal access limits.

### Authorities’ request and staff response
- Authorities request a reduction in access from SDR 2.045625 billion (375 percent of quota at the time of program approval) to SDR 1.9522533 billion (358 percent of quota).
- The reduction affects the scheduled ninth purchase, which would decline to SDR 201.2654 million from SDR 294.6371 million envisaged in EBS/19/41.
- The program remains fully financed through its expiration date; the reduction of Fund financing is to be compensated by an increase in market financing.
- Staff supports the authorities’ request as stated in the supplemental letter of intent; a revised set of tables reflecting the new access level and a revised proposed decision are included in the supplement.
- The authorities’ request does not alter the thrust of the staff report; staff continues to support the completion of the Fifth Review.

### Indicators of Fund credit and schedule of purchases (selected exact figures)
- Quota is SDR 545.2 million.
- Revised total proposed purchases under the EFF (Table 5, total): 1,952.2533 Millions of SDR; Percent of quota: 358.080; Millions of US$: 22,713.3686.
- Original (at approval) total access: SDR 2.045625 billion (375 percent of quota).
- Purchases by review (Table 5, exact per review figures):
  - Board approval of the EFF (May 20, 2016): 227.2920 Millions of SDR (41.6897 percent of quota); Millions of US$: 3,159.052.
  - First Review (Sept 30, 2016): 227.2917 Millions of SDR (41.6896 percent of quota); Millions of US$: 3,159.048.
  - Second Review (Sept 30, 2017): 176.7824 Millions of SDR (32.4252 percent of quota); Millions of US$: 2,245.7036.
  - Third Review (June 15, 2018): 176.7824 Millions of SDR (32.4252 percent of quota); Millions of US$: 2,245.7036.
  - Fourth Review (Sept 17, 2018): 176.7824 Millions of SDR (32.4252 percent of quota); Millions of US$: 2,245.7036.
  - Fifth Review (Dec 17, 2018): 176.7824 Millions of SDR (32.4252 percent of quota); Millions of US$: 2,245.7037.
  - Sixth Review (Sept 18, 2019): 294.6373 Millions of SDR (54.0421 percent of quota); Millions of US$: 4,091.5061.
  - Seventh Review (Dec 18, 2019): 294.6373 Millions of SDR (54.0421 percent of quota); Millions of US$: 4,091.5061.
  - Eighth Review (Apr 29, 2020): 201.2654 Millions of SDR (36.9159 percent of quota); Millions of US$: 2,279.7318.
- Stock of existing and prospective Fund credit (selected exact percent and levels):
  - Stock (Millions of SDR) by year: 1,205.3; 1,205.6; 1,366.7; 1,563.8; 1,933.3; 1,876.5; 1,786.0; 1,607.1; 1,298.5.
  - Stock in percent of quota by year: 221.1; 221.1; 250.7; 286.3; 354.0; 343.5; 327.0; 294.2; 237.7.
  - Stock in percent of GDP by year: 4.0; 4.2; 4.9; 6.0; 7.7; 7.3; 6.5; 5.5; 4.1.

### Macroeconomic findings, projections, and program targets (text preserved)
- Recent performance:
  - GDP growth increased from 2.0 to 2.6 percent in 2018.
  - Inflation decelerated from a record of 7.7 percent in June 2018 to 6.9 percent in April 2019.
  - The current account deficit climbed to over 11 percent of GDP.
  - Central government debt climbed to 77 percent of GDP.
- Outlook and expectations:
  - Authorities expect growth to pick up in 2020 and average 4 percent during 2022-24.
  - Inflation is expected to trend down from 7 percent in 2019 to 4 percent by 2024.
  - The current account deficit is projected to fall to 5.8 percent of GDP by 2024.
  - Reserves cover is projected to rise to almost 4 months of imports by 2024.
- Fiscal policy and targets:
  - Target overall fiscal deficit (excluding grants) of 3.9 percent of GDP in 2019.
  - Maintain investment spending at 5.6 percent of GDP in 2019.
  - Authorities increased social spending by 0.3 percent of GDP in 2019.
- Energy subsidy reform:
  - Energy subsidy reform is central to fiscal consolidation in 2019, with targeted social programs and preferential energy tariffs to protect low-income households.
  - Progress in 2018 included elimination of fuel subsidies to cement companies and the increase of electricity tariffs.

### Financing and external financing tables (selected exact figures)
- Table 1 (Cumulative External Financing of the Central Government Budget, selected figures):
  - Total budget grants and loans (various quarterly and annual entries present in table — source data preserved in the original tables).
- Table 2 (Balance of Payments, selected projections and levels preserved in source):
  - Current account balance (selected annual levels): -3,901; -4,080; projections and quarterly series as in Table 2.
  - Trade balance (selected annual levels): -4,806; -5,308; subsequent quarterly/annual series as in Table 2.
  - Exports (annual totals and quarterly breakdowns) and Imports (annual totals and quarterly breakdowns) and Services and transfers (net) detailed in Table 2.
  - Gross international reserves (billions of US$) series: 5.9; 5.6; 5.1; 4.7; 4.7; 5.2; 5.2; 5.4; 5.5; 5.3; 5.9; 5.9; 7.3; 6.4; 7.8; 6.7; 7.3; 7.9; 8.8 (as displayed in Table 2).
- Table 3 (External Financing Needs, selected totals):
  - Total gross financing requirements (annual): 5,364; 6,385; quarterly and annual breakdowns as in Table 3.
  - Total gross financing sources (annual): 5,364; 6,385; breakdown includes foreign direct investment and portfolio (net) 638; 746; disbursements 2,521; 4,741; short-term debt and other capital flows (net) 1,010; 869.
  - Drawdown of gross reserves ("-": buildup): 1,460; 348; 488; 424; -23; -488; 402; -293; -70; 227; -612; -748; -461.

### Program implementation status (qualitative points preserved)
- All three prior actions were carried out.
- Four out of six end-March quantitative performance criteria (QPC) were met comfortably.
- Two QPCs were missed; the floor on net international reserves was missed because the adjuster corrected only for lower-than-expected external financing in the last quarter rather than since the last review.
- Four of nine structural benchmarks (SBs) were met (two with short delay); 4 SBs will be reprogrammed; implementation of the remaining SB proved very difficult due to strong social pressure.

_ Supplementary Letter of Intent, Tunis, June 11, 2019; IMF staff report and tables included in the supplement._

### 2019. Fuel prices were hiked by 6 percent at the end of March and electricity tariffs for

### 1tunea2019001 - 2019. Fuel prices were hiked by 6 percent at the end of March and electricity tariffs for

### Energy pricing and subsidy adjustments
- Fuel prices were hiked by 6 percent at the end of March.
- Electricity tariffs for consumption exceeding 300kWh per month as well as gas prices were increased by more than 10 percent in May (prior action).
- Social electricity tariffs for consumption up to 100kWh per month were decreased by 10 percent to protect low-income consumers.
- There were no changes in tariffs for consumption between 100kWh to 300kWh per month—these two categories cover 94 percent of consumers.
- To comply with international environmental standards, the government will:
  - Gradually adjust hydrocarbon consumption structure by reducing the supply of high polluting ordinary gas oil.
  - Increase the supply of sulfur-free diesel which is subject to a higher excise tax.
- Tariff adjustment schedule and mechanisms:
  - Authorities are determined to maintain, for the remainder of 2019, the monthly tariff adjustments of 2 percent for medium voltage electricity and medium pressure natural gas, a process that started in January.
  - Quarterly fuel price adjustments will take place in June and October 2019.

### Monetary and exchange rate policies
- Monetary policy objectives:
  - Geared towards price stability and preserving international reserves, while providing adequate liquidity to the banking system to support productive economic activity.
- Recent policy tightening:
  - The CBT has increased its policy rate three times in the last 12 months—the last time in February 2019—for a cumulative total of 275 bps.
  - While all interest rates are currently positive in real terms, deposit rates are an exception (not positive in real terms).
  - The CBT will remain vigilant and stands ready to tighten the monetary stance, if and when needed.
- Improvements to the monetary policy framework:
  - Maintain the loan-to-deposit (LTD) ratio imposed on banks in November 2018.
  - Gradually reduce the stock of central bank refinancing to TD13.9 billion by end-December 2019 from TD16.4 billion at end-March 2019.
  - Tighten LTD and collateral policy for refinancing operations by raising the share of government securities used as collateral from 40 to 50 percent.
- Exchange rate policy:
  - Greater exchange rate flexibility has allowed the dinar to better reflect market conditions and act as the main shock absorber.
  - The CBT is committed to maintaining competitive FX auctions and significantly reducing its FX intervention budget, supported by an effective public communication strategy.

### Financial sector stability and structural reforms
- Banking sector status:
  - Tunisia’s banking sector is well capitalized.
  - Non-performing loans (NPLs) are declining and are well provisioned.
  - Regulatory and supervisory reforms implemented since the inception of the program have enhanced banking sector resilience.
- Ongoing priorities and actions:
  - Further strengthen bank supervision and risk management to address remaining vulnerabilities.
  - In the context of the action plan agreed with FATF in November 2017, significant progress has been made to strengthen the AML/CFT framework and accelerate Tunisia’s exit from the FATF grey list.
- Private sector and investment environment:
  - Authorities remain strongly supportive of private sector growth and focus on measures to improve the business environment, including streamlining the regulatory environment and strengthening governance and transparency.
  - Established the new investment governance structure under the new investment code, as well as the Strategic Investment Council (CSI) and the Tunisian Authority for Investment as a one-stop shop for investors.

### Conclusion and social considerations
- Despite a very challenging socio-political environment, regional tensions and global uncertainties, the authorities are pressing ahead with the implementation of their ambitious reform agenda with the critical support of the IMF and other development partners.
- Authorities are fully committed to the program objectives and believe there will be light at the end of what has proved to be a long tunnel.
- The palpable social costs of the program are heavy.
- Social cohesion can only be maintained if the public is convinced there will be an early end to its sacrifices and that the reforms will make a major difference in people’s livelihood in a not too distant future.

*Source: 1tunea2019001 - 2019.*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/cr/2019/1tunea2019001.pdf_
