## Investment Need for Climate Policies (Ireland)

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [Investment Need for Climate Policies (Ireland)](https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/cr/2021/english/1irlea2021002.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/files/publications/cr/2021/english/1irlea2021002.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/files/publications/cr/2021/english/1irlea2021002.pdf.json)

---

### Overview and context
- Ireland approved the Climate Action and Low Carbon Development (Amendment) Bill 2021 (March 2021) to:
  - legislate a target to halve greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions by 2030; and
  - achieve net carbon neutrality no later than 2050.
- Ireland committed to a long-term trajectory of annual increases in the carbon tax rate leading to a rate of €100 per ton in 2030.
- Budget 2021 increased the carbon tax rate by €7.50 to €33.50 as an initial step.
- The law introduces a legal requirement to adhere to five-year carbon budgets and sets emission ceilings on all sectors; the Climate Change Advisory Council will propose the country’s first five-year carbon budget.
- Post-COVID recovery is an opportunity to accelerate climate-friendly policies including:
  - boosting public investment in transportation networks and electricity grids;
  - subsidizing building renovation for energy efficiency; and
  - supporting R&D in low-emission technologies and carbon sequestration (including agronomic measures and peatland restoration).
- Noted fact: peat bogs capture more CO2 than forests and act like sponges absorbing excessive rainfall.

### GHG emissions profile and recent performance
- Ireland missed 2020 EU climate targets; GHG emissions declined by merely 4 percent (required EU Effort Sharing Regulation target was 20 percent by 2020 relative to 1990).
- Projected GHG emissions in 2019 were about 15 percent below 2005 levels.
- To meet proposed targets, emissions need to decline at an average of 7 percent a year to 2030 (and reach net zero by 2050).
- Sectoral shares of Ireland’s GHG emissions:
  - Agriculture: 33%
  - Building: 13%
  - Industry: 13%
  - Transport: 20%
  - Power: 19%
  - Other: 2%
- EU27+UK sector shares (for contrast):
  - Agriculture: 12%
  - Building: 14%
  - Industry: 20%
  - Transport: 22%
  - Power: 27%
  - Other: 5%
- One-third of Ireland’s emissions come from agriculture, posing particular abatement challenges due to a high share of biogenic emissions.
- Over 90 percent of all energy used in 2017 came from fossil fuels, with heavy reliance on fossil fuels for transport, heating, and electricity production.

### Physical and transition risks
- Major climate-related physical risks:
  - Severe coastal flooding from rising sea levels and storm surges—especially in Dublin and Cork built on reclaimed saltwater marshes.
  - Greater weather variability: more frequent extreme rainfall, increased river flooding and water overflow, re-emergence of droughts with higher rainfall volatility affecting crop cycles.
- Sea level rise projection: an average sea level rise of between 0.5 to 1 meter by the end of the century, combined with storm surge events, could result in as much as 1,000km2 of coastal lands around Ireland being inundated if no protective measures are undertaken.
- Reported losses from natural disasters (1990-2014) frequency breakdown shown as: 23.5% and 76.5% (labels in figure: Flood / Storm).

### Policy mix and recommendations
- Central role for credible carbon pricing within a well-designed package of mutually reinforcing policies:
  - A predictable and progressive carbon price path creates incentives for households and firms to reduce emissions and steer consumption and investment toward sustainable activities and green technologies.
  - Carbon pricing will provide additional revenues to fund a just transition, support vulnerable groups, and allow the government to reduce distortionary taxes while bolstering public transport, energy-efficient housing, and renewable energy.
- Complement carbon pricing with sector-specific policies to reduce transition costs and protect vulnerable groups.
- Suggested public investment and policy priorities:
  - Investment in low-emission public transportation and personal mobility.
  - Investment in renewable energy, energy efficiency, energy storage, and smart power grids.
  - Subsidies and programs to increase building renovation for energy efficiency.
  - Support for R&D in low-emission technologies and carbon sequestration, including agronomic measures and peatland restoration.
  - Use carbon tax revenues to finance the transition and protect vulnerable households and firms.

### Co‑benefits and market failures
- Co-benefits of mitigation:
  - Less traffic congestion, active lifestyle and improved health, new jobs and higher productivity, fuel cost savings, energy security, food security, income for smallholders, restoration of natural capital and ecological systems.
- Market failures requiring policy remedies:
  - Externalities (GHG emissions not fully priced).
  - Information asymmetries.
  - Capital market failures impeding investment in low-emission technologies.
  - Distributional challenges in transitioning workers and communities.

### Key findings and priority sectors
- Ireland’s climate agenda is among the most ambitious worldwide, but achieving targets will require strong and sustained policy efforts and substantial investment.
- Critical sectors requiring intensified mitigation focus: agriculture, buildings, and transport.
- Ireland’s planned carbon tax path (to €100 per ton in 2030) is consistent with ambitious carbon-pricing approaches in Sweden, Finland, Denmark, Germany, and Canada, and aligns with the EU’s enhanced 2030 ambition to cut emissions to 55 percent below 1990 levels.
- Innovative solutions are needed for agricultural emissions, including incentives for carbon sequestration through agronomic measures and peatland restoration.
- A coordinated mix of carbon pricing, sector-specific measures, and targeted public investment can reduce transition costs, protect vulnerable groups, and capture co-benefits that support public acceptance.

### Transport: vehicle taxation, incentives, and targets
- Countries with CO2-differentiated vehicle taxes have typically achieved greater emissions reduction.
- Budget 2021 motor tax and vehicle registration tax changes favor electric vehicles and hybrids.
- Existing central government incentives (2019) for low-emission vehicles:
  - SEAI Grant Scheme: Grant of up to €5,000 for the purchase of a new BEV or PHEV (since 2011).
  - VRT Relief: Tax relief of up to €5,000 for new BEVs until end-2021 (and up to €2,500 for new PHEVs until end-2019).
  - Charging Supports: Grant of up to €600 for the installation of home charger points for buyers of new and second-hand EVs.
  - Toll Incentive Regime: BEVs and PHEVs qualify for 50 and 25 percent toll reductions, respectively, up to a maximum of €500 and €1,000 as annual threshold for private and commercial vehicles, respectively; higher discounts of 75 and 50 percent for BEVs and PHEVs, respectively, apply to off-peak travel on the M50.
  - Low Motor Tax: Electric vehicles qualify for the lowest motor tax band available.
  - Fuel Excise / Carbon Tax: No fuel excise duties applied to electricity consumption.
- Observed facts and targets:
  - More than 10 percent of new car sales are already electric or hybrid vehicles.
  - Government objective: increase the number of electric vehicles on Irish roads to one million by 2030.
- Recommended complementary measures:
  - Phase out fossil fuel allowances.
  - Implement tighter emissions standards for vehicles.
  - Deploy “feebates” (higher taxes on emission-intensive vehicles and subsidies for low-emission ones).
  - Make motor-vehicle tax changes more progressive compared to other countries.

### Residential buildings: retrofit scale-up, financing, and regulation
- Current state:
  - More than 95 percent of all buildings in Ireland are energy inefficient.
  - Enhancing energy efficiency to the highest level (EPC=A) through retrofitting and renovations would cost about 20 percent of GDP.
  - On average, such investment would amortize in less than 12 years due to significant energy cost savings and could reduce GHG emissions from buildings in Ireland by more than two-thirds.
- Government targets and plans:
  - Retrofit 500,000 homes to a Building Energy Rating (BER) of “B2” (or cost optimal equivalent) over the next ten years.
  - Install 400,000 heat pumps in existing buildings over the next ten years.
  - Currently committed exchequer funding would cover part of the investment costs.
- Constraints:
  - Scale and pace held back by liquidity constraints of poorer households and lack of consumer demand, including limited information on potential energy cost savings.
  - New construction alone will take too long to meet the required emission reduction trajectory.
- Policy levers and recommendations:
  - Introduce binding targets for energy efficiency improvements and/or make availability of energy efficiency ratings mandatory for all real estate transactions.
  - Subsidize retrofitting loans and increase energy efficiency of public buildings.
  - Design energy-dependent property taxes and options for “on-bill financing” to help overcome owner–renter cost-benefit mismatches, while fully assessing impacts on rental accommodation supply.
  - Note: energy-dependent property taxes are likely to have significant adverse distributional consequences.

### Agriculture: biogenic emissions, sequestration, and demand-side measures
- Key characteristics and challenges:
  - Biogenic emissions are difficult to reduce and have a relatively higher contribution to global warming over the near term.
  - Irish agriculture is emission-intensive due to high share of livestock; despite progress reducing emissions intensity, total agricultural emissions have not declined commensurately because of higher productivity.
- Supply-side mitigation and sequestration opportunities:
  - Land use and management measures: non-tilling, maintaining permanent pasture, protecting grassland.
  - Methane reductions via:
    - Diversifying away from beef toward non-ruminant animals (pigs and poultry).
    - Enhanced farm management practices and technologies: food additives, breeding programs, barn modernization, animal healthcare.
    - Methane digesters to turn manure into biogas.
  - Rewetting and rewilding peat bogs and protecting/restoring forests to create permanent carbon sinks and biodiversity co-benefits.
- Feasibility and caveats:
  - Soil carbon sequestration is relatively safe and economical but slow, potentially reversible, and depends on soil type; measurement remains challenging.
  - Food additives (e.g., red seaweed/asparagopsis) may lower methane by more than 80 percent in some research, but uncertainty remains on resource availability, sustainability, and human health effects.
- Demand-side measures:
  - Shift consumer choices away from emission-intensive products (dairy and beef).
  - Policy options include removing preferential VAT rates and introducing GHG emissions footprint labels on food.

### Costs, investment needs, and carbon pricing revenue
- Aggregate investment estimates:
  - Meeting Ireland’s Climate Action and Low Carbon Development (Amendment) Bill 2021 emission reduction target is estimated to require significant investment of close to €20 billion (or 5 percent of GDP) annually over the next 10 years.
  - Average capital spending for climate change mitigation and adaptation through 2030 is estimated to be about 1.5 percent of GDP per year (Box 1).
  - The remainder of the total required investment of about 5.0 percent of GDP per year would need to come from the private sector.
  - About one-third of the €20 billion annual investment would be public capital spending on climate-sensitive infrastructure (energy supply, transport, water & waste).
- Role of carbon pricing revenues:
  - Carbon pricing revenues could help fund essential public investment and financial support for greening Ireland’s economy.
  - Carbon tax revenues are likely to generate additional revenues of about 2.5 percent of GDP until 2030.
  - The gradual increase in the domestic carbon price will help catalyze private investment and provide financing to support vulnerable groups and businesses.
- Methodology notes:
  - Estimates based on projected sectoral investment needs published by the European Commission for the EU’s original 2030 emission reduction target (-40 percent relative to 1990) and updated for a 55 percent target under the EU Green Deal and Ireland’s 2021 Climate Bill.
  - Focus on investment in economic network infrastructure (clean personal mobility, public transport infrastructure, energy transmission/distribution, smart energy systems and grids, CO2 transportation and storage, refueling and recharging infrastructure in transport).
  - Estimates exclude some sectors/activities (industry manufacturing/process emissions, non-infrastructure-related mobility changes, agriculture, and some social infrastructure).

### Near-term recovery: prioritize green investment
- Rationale and macroeconomic implications:
  - Green transition requires substantial capital spending which could boost growth and jobs during recovery and help achieve EU emission reduction targets.
  - Ireland’s cumulative share of the NGEU’s Recovery and Resilience Facility (RRF) grants is 0.2 percent of GDP and is small relative to projected investment needs.
  - Ireland’s disproportionately high share of capital spending on green projects provides an important signal of commitment to the climate agenda.
- Key areas for accelerated climate-friendly policies:
  - Physical infrastructure: boost public investment in transportation and climate-friendly network infrastructure (smart power grids, especially for offshore wind; water and waste management).
  - Green finance:
    - Increase availability of low-interest rate “green mortgages” and “green home equity loans”.
    - Emphasize comprehensive and consistent data on energy efficiency and monitor financial risks to mitigate “greenwashing,” anchored to the EU Taxonomy on Sustainable Activities.
    - For analysis, homes with an energy performance certificate (EPC) rating of lower than “A” are deemed energy inefficient; some banks offer reduced-rate “green mortgages” for buildings with an energy efficiency rating of as low as EPC=”B3.”
  - Public support for technology and land-use measures:
    - Promote R&D in early-stage technologies such as hydrogen generation through renewable energy.
    - Encourage adoption of low-emission agronomic technologies.
    - Support carbon capture, peatland restoration, re-forestation, and new forms of energy storage.
  - Just transition measures:
    - Recycle some carbon tax revenues to support de-carbonization efforts, business restructuring, active labor market policies, and subsidies/grants focused on encouraging renewable energy use.
    - Consider impacts on international competitiveness and the burden of higher energy prices on households.

### Use of carbon tax revenues and distributional/efficiency considerations
- Summary of options and impacts (matrix):
  - Environmental investment:
    - Impacts on income distribution: May disproportionately benefit low-income households.
    - Impact on economic efficiency: Risk that may be less efficient than broader uses of revenue.
    - Administrative burden: Modest.
  - General investments:
    - Impacts on income distribution: May disproportionately benefit low-income households.
    - Impact on economic efficiency: Potentially significant.
    - Administrative burden: Modest.
  - Universal transfers:
    - Impacts on income distribution: Highly progressive.
    - Impact on economic efficiency: Forgoes efficiency benefits¹.
    - Administrative burden: New capacity needed (but should be manageable).
  - Payroll tax:
    - Impacts on income distribution: Benefits largely proportional across working households.
    - Impact on economic efficiency: Improves incentives for formal work effort.
    - Administrative burden: Minimal.
  - Personal income tax:
    - Impacts on income distribution: Typically benefits skewed to higher-income groups.
    - Impact on economic efficiency: Improves incentives for formal work effort and saving, reduces tax-sheltering.
    - Administrative burden: Minimal.
  - Consumption tax:
    - Impacts on income distribution: Largely proportional to household consumption.
    - Impact on economic efficiency: Reduces incentives for untaxed goods and activities.
    - Administrative burden: Minimal.
  - Corporate income tax:
    - Impacts on income distribution: Benefits skewed to higher-income groups.
    - Impact on economic efficiency: Improves incentives for investment.
    - Administrative burden: Minimal.
  - Deficit reduction:
    - Impacts on income distribution: Benefits accrue to future generations.
    - Impact on economic efficiency: Lowers future tax burdens and macro-financial risk.
    - Administrative burden: Minimal.
  - Means-tested cash, in-kind transfers:
    - Impacts on income distribution: Effective at helping low-income groups if social safety nets are comprehensive.
    - Impact on economic efficiency: Efficiency impacts unclear but likely modest¹.
    - Administrative burden: Low if builds on existing capacity, otherwise significant.
  - Assistance for household energy bills:
    - Impacts on income distribution: Provides partial relief for all households.
    - Impact on economic efficiency: Modest reduction in environmental effectiveness.
    - Administrative burden: Low if builds on existing capacity, otherwise significant.
- Notes:
  - Green areas indicate current use of carbon taxes in Ireland.
  - 1/ Transfers to low‑income households could lead to a small increase in human capital investment.

### Timing, financing, and fiscal considerations
- Given still low borrowing costs, it would be beneficial to make green investments now (in line with prudent fiscal policies), even before sufficient revenues from carbon pricing become available.
- Gradual increase of the carbon tax, accompanied by the reduction in fossil fuel allowances, will further boost private investment.
- Greater private sector participation in infrastructure projects might be required over time as fiscal consolidation is likely to constrain budget outlays for public investment.

### Infrastructure strategy and evaluation
- Public investment programs shape carbon emissions for decades; project cost-benefit analysis should include environmental, social, and governance (ESG) considerations to avoid locking in carbon-intensive growth.
- Investment in climate-sensitive infrastructure is costly but carries significant long-term benefits that reduce net cost overall.
- Ireland has suffered chronic under-investment in infrastructure for decades, so most investment will be in new projects; lower cost from renewable energy sources and greater energy efficiency are likely to offset investment cost over time.
- Government should adopt a strategic approach consistent with the National Development and Climate Action plans, accounting systematically for:
  - The climate impact of large projects (GHG emissions).
  - The sources, types, and sizes of damage/economic losses.
  - The project resilience to different natural hazards (“resilience score”).
  - The capacity to predict frequency/impact of future disaster shocks (“climate damage function”).
- The Irish government is working with the European Commission (DG REFORM) and the OECD to better incorporate climate impacts into infrastructure appraisal.

### Key programmatic details and existing grant schemes
- National Home Retrofit Scheme: grants covering 35 percent of the overall cost of home improvements for private and local authority housing and 50 percent for approved housing bodies.
- Better Energy Warmer Homes Scheme: 100 percent grants available for households at risk of energy poverty.
- Grants are provided from the Sustainable Energy Authority of Ireland (SEAI) as a key support measure under the Irish government’s Climate Action Plan 2019 and the Climate Action and Low Carbon Development (Amendment) Bill 2021.

*Source: IMF — Ireland country chapter (content unit 1irlea2021002).*

### 1. Investment Need for Climate Policies _______________________________________________ 12

### 1. Investment Need for Climate Policies

### Overview and context
- Ireland has approved the Climate Action and Low Carbon Development (Amendment) Bill 2021 (March 2021) to:
  - legislate a target to halve greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions by 2030; and
  - achieve net carbon neutrality no later than 2050.
- Ireland has committed to a long-term trajectory of annual increases in the carbon tax rate leading to a rate of €100 per ton in 2030.
- Budget 2021 increased the carbon tax rate by €7.50 to €33.50 as an initial step.
- The law introduces a legal requirement to adhere to five-year carbon budgets and sets emission ceilings on all sectors; the Climate Change Advisory Council will propose the country’s first five-year carbon budget.
- The post-COVID recovery is an opportunity to accelerate climate-friendly policies, including boosting public investment in transportation networks and electricity grids, subsidizing building renovation for energy efficiency, and supporting R&D in low-emission technologies and carbon sequestration (including agronomic measures and peatland restoration).
- Noted fact: peat bogs capture more CO2 than forests and act like sponges absorbing excessive rainfall.

### GHG emissions profile and recent performance
- Ireland has missed 2020 EU climate targets; GHG emissions declined by merely 4 percent (required EU Effort Sharing Regulation target was 20 percent by 2020 relative to 1990).
- Projected GHG emissions in 2019 were about 15 percent below 2005 levels.
- To meet proposed targets, emissions need to decline at an average of 7 percent a year to 2030 (and reach net zero by 2050).
- Sectoral shares of Ireland’s GHG emissions:
  - Agriculture: 33%
  - Building: 13%
  - Industry: 13%
  - Transport: 20%
  - Power: 19%
  - Other: 2%
- By contrast, EU27+UK sector shares:
  - Agriculture: 12%
  - Building: 14%
  - Industry: 20%
  - Transport: 22%
  - Power: 27%
  - Other: 5%
- One-third of Ireland’s emissions come from agriculture, imposing particular abatement challenges due to a high share of biogenic emissions.
- Over 90 percent of all energy used in 2017 came from fossil fuels, with heavy reliance on fossil fuels for transport, heating, and electricity production.

### Physical and transition risks
- Significant climate-related physical risks in Ireland include:
  - Severe coastal flooding due to rising sea levels, increasing the likelihood of storm surges coinciding with spring high tides—especially in Dublin and Cork built on reclaimed saltwater marshes.
  - Growing weather variability with more frequent extreme rainfall, increasing river flooding and water overflow in combination with storm surges, and a re-emergence of droughts with higher rainfall volatility affecting crop cycles.
- Sea level rise scenario: an average sea level rise of between 0.5 to 1 meter by the end of the century, combined with storm surge events, could result in as much as 1,000km2 of coastal lands around Ireland being inundated if no protective measures are undertaken.
- Reported losses from natural disasters (1990-2014) frequency breakdown shown as: 23.5% and 76.5% (labels in figure: Flood / Storm).

### Policy mix and recommendations
- Central role for credible carbon pricing within a well-designed package of mutually reinforcing policies:
  - A predictable and progressive carbon price path creates incentives for households and firms to reduce emissions and steer consumption and investment toward sustainable activities and green technologies.
  - Carbon pricing will provide additional revenues to fund a just transition, support vulnerable groups, and allow the government to reduce distortionary taxes while bolstering public transport, energy-efficient housing, and renewable energy.
- Complement carbon pricing with sector-specific policies to reduce transition costs and protect vulnerable groups.
- Suggested public investment and policy priorities:
  - Investment in low-emission public transportation and personal mobility.
  - Investment in renewable energy, energy efficiency, energy storage, and smart power grids.
  - Subsidies and programs to increase building renovation for energy efficiency.
  - Support for R&D in low-emission technologies and carbon sequestration, including agronomic measures and peatland restoration.
  - Use carbon tax revenues to finance the transition and protect vulnerable households and firms.

### Co-benefits and market failures
- Co-benefits of climate change mitigation highlighted:
  - Less traffic congestion, active lifestyle and improved health, new jobs and higher productivity, fuel cost savings, energy security, food security, income for smallholders, restoration of natural capital and ecological systems.
- Market failures of climate change mitigation (implicitly requiring policy remedies) include:
  - Externalities (GHG emissions not fully priced), information asymmetries, capital market failures that impede investment in low-emission technologies, and distributional challenges in transitioning workers and communities.

### Key findings and priorities for Ireland
- Ireland’s climate agenda is among the most ambitious worldwide, but achieving targets will require strong and sustained policy efforts and substantial investment.
- Critical sectors requiring intensified mitigation focus: agriculture, buildings, and transport.
- Ireland’s planned carbon tax path (to €100 per ton in 2030) is consistent with other ambitious carbon-pricing approaches in Sweden, Finland, Denmark, Germany, and Canada, and aligns with the EU’s enhanced 2030 ambition to cut emissions to 55 percent below 1990 levels.
- Innovative solutions are needed for agricultural emissions, including incentives for carbon sequestration through agronomic measures and peatland restoration.
- A coordinated mix of carbon pricing, sector-specific measures, and targeted public investment can reduce transition costs, protect vulnerable groups, and capture co-benefits that support public acceptance.

*Source: IMF staff; "Considerations for Climate Change Mitigation in Ireland" (May 25, 2021).*

### 6. Complementary sectoral policies will be needed where there are other market failures,

### 6. Complementary sectoral policies will be needed where there are other market failures

### Transport: vehicle taxation, incentives, and targets
- Countries with CO2-differentiated vehicle taxes have typically achieved a greater reduction in emissions.
- Ireland’s Budget 2021: motor tax and vehicle registration tax changes favoring electric vehicles and hybrids are a move in the right direction and complement existing financial support.
- Existing central government incentives (2019) for low-emission vehicles:
  - SEAI Grant Scheme: Grant of up to €5,000 for the purchase of a new BEV or PHEV (since 2011).
  - VRT Relief: Tax relief of up to €5,000 for new BEVs until end-2021 (and up to €2,500 for new PHEVs until end-2019).
  - Charging Supports: Grant of up to €600 for the installation of home charger points for buyers of new and second-hand EVs.
  - Toll Incentive Regime: BEVs and PHEVs qualify for 50 and 25 percent toll reductions, respectively, up to a maximum of €500 and €1,000 as annual threshold for private and commercial vehicles, respectively; higher discounts of 75 and 50 percent for BEVs and PHEVs, respectively, apply to off-peak travel on the M50.
  - Low Motor Tax: Electric vehicles qualify for the lowest motor tax band available.
  - Fuel Excise / Carbon Tax: No fuel excise duties applied to electricity consumption (whereas these duties represent a significant proportion of diesel and petrol prices).
- Observed facts and targets:
  - More than 10 percent of new car sales are already electric or hybrid vehicles.
  - Government objective: increase the number of electric vehicles on Irish roads to one million by 2030.
- Recommended complementary measures:
  - Phase out fossil fuel allowances (Figure 7).
  - Implement tighter emissions standards for vehicles.
  - Deploy incentives such as “feebates” (combine higher taxes on emission-intensive vehicles and subsidies for low-emission ones).
  - Make motor-vehicle tax changes more progressive compared to other countries.

### Residential buildings: retrofit scale-up, financing, and regulation
- Current state:
  - More than 95 percent of all buildings in Ireland are energy inefficient.
  - Enhancing energy efficiency to the highest level (EPC=A) through retrofitting and renovations would cost about 20 percent of GDP.
  - On average, such investment would amortize in less than 12 years due to significant energy cost savings and could reduce GHG emissions from buildings in Ireland by more than two-thirds.
- Government targets and plans:
  - Retrofit 500,000 homes to a Building Energy Rating (BER) of “B2” (or cost optimal equivalent) over the next ten years.
  - Install 400,000 heat pumps in existing buildings over the next ten years.
  - Currently committed exchequer funding would cover part of the investment costs.
- Constraints:
  - Scale and pace held back by liquidity constraints of poorer households and lack of consumer demand, including limited information on potential energy cost savings.
  - New construction alone will take too long to meet the required emission reduction trajectory.
- Policy levers and recommendations:
  - Introduce binding targets for energy efficiency improvements to accelerate renovation rate and/or make availability of energy efficiency ratings mandatory for all real estate transactions.
  - Subsidize retrofitting loans and increase energy efficiency of public buildings (government plans welcomed but insufficient).
  - Design energy-dependent property taxes and options for “on-bill financing” to help overcome owner–renter cost-benefit mismatches, while fully assessing impacts on rental accommodation supply.
  - Note: energy-dependent property taxes are likely to have significant adverse distributional consequences.

### Agriculture: biogenic emissions, sequestration, and demand-side measures
- Key characteristics and challenges:
  - Biogenic emissions are difficult to reduce and have a relatively higher contribution to global warming over the near term.
  - Agriculture in Ireland has high exposure to changing weather patterns but stands to benefit from effective climate change mitigation.
  - Irish agriculture is emission-intensive due to high share of livestock.
  - Despite progress reducing emissions intensity, total agricultural emissions have not declined commensurately because of higher productivity.
- Supply-side mitigation and sequestration opportunities:
  - Land use and management measures for carbon sequestration: non-tilling, maintaining permanent pasture, protecting grassland.
  - Methane reductions from livestock via:
    - Diversifying away from beef toward non-ruminant animals (pigs and poultry).
    - Enhanced farm management practices and technologies: food additives, breeding programs, barn modernization, animal healthcare.
    - Methane digesters to turn manure into biogas, substituting farm energy use and contributing to energy generation at scale.
  - Rewetting and rewilding peat bogs (making them more anaerobic) and protecting/restoring forests to create permanent carbon sinks and biodiversity co-benefits.
- Feasibility and caveats:
  - Soil carbon sequestration is relatively safe and economical but slow, potentially reversible, and depends on soil type; measurement remains challenging.
  - Food additives (e.g., red seaweed/asparagopsis) may lower methane by more than 80 percent in some research, but uncertainty remains on resource availability, sustainability, and human health effects.
- Demand-side measures:
  - Shift consumer choices away from emission-intensive products (dairy and beef).
  - Policy options include removing preferential VAT rates and introducing GHG emissions footprint labels on food (consistent with the EU Farm to Fork Strategy).

### Costs, investment needs, and carbon pricing revenue
- Aggregate investment estimates:
  - Meeting Ireland’s Climate Action and Low Carbon Development (Amendment) Bill 2021 emission reduction target is estimated to require significant investment of close to €20 billion (or 5 percent of GDP) annually over the next 10 years.
  - Average capital spending for climate change mitigation and adaptation through 2030 is estimated to be about 1.5 percent of GDP per year (Box 1).
  - The remainder of the total required investment of about 5.0 percent of GDP per year would need to come from the private sector.
  - About one-third of the €20 billion annual investment would be public capital spending on climate-sensitive infrastructure (energy supply, transport, water & waste).
- Role of carbon pricing revenues:
  - Carbon pricing revenues could help fund essential public investment and financial support for greening Ireland’s economy.
  - Carbon tax revenues are likely to generate additional revenues of about 2.5 percent of GDP until 2030.
  - The gradual increase in the domestic carbon price will help catalyze private investment and provide financing to support vulnerable groups and businesses.
- Methodology notes for investment estimates:
  - Based on projected sectoral investment needs published by the European Commission for the EU’s original 2030 emission reduction target (-40 percent relative to 1990) and updated for a 55 percent target under the EU Green Deal and Ireland’s 2021 Climate Bill.
  - Focus on investment in economic network infrastructure (clean personal mobility, public transport infrastructure, energy transmission/distribution, smart energy systems and grids, CO2 transportation and storage, refueling and recharging infrastructure in transport).
  - Estimates exclude some sectors/activities (industry manufacturing/process emissions, non-infrastructure-related mobility changes, agriculture, and some social infrastructure).

*Source: IMF staff summary of "6. Complementary sectoral policies will be needed where there are other market failures" from the provided PDF content.*

### 8. Over the near term, recovery policies should prioritize green investment that facilitates

### 8. Over the near term, recovery policies should prioritize green investment that facilitates Ireland’s transformation to a low-carbon economy

### Rationale and macroeconomic implications
- The green transition will require substantial capital spending, which could boost growth and jobs during the recovery phase and help achieve EU emission reduction targets.
- Ireland’s cumulative share of the NGEU’s Recovery and Resilience Facility (RRF) grants is 0.2 percent of GDP and is small relative to projected investment needs.
- Ireland’s disproportionately high share of capital spending on green projects provides an important signal of commitment to the climate agenda.

### Key areas for accelerated climate-friendly policies
- Physical infrastructure
  - Boost public investment in transportation and climate-friendly network infrastructure, such as smart power grids for cleaner energy (especially offshore wind power) as well as water and waste management.
  - Government already funds 65 percent of the cost of home electric vehicle charging, provides 90 percent funding for on-street chargers via local authorities, and has provided grant support for the rollout of fast chargers on public roads.
- Green finance
  - Current means-tested grants for energy efficiency improvements and electrified heating in residential buildings are essential but cover only a fraction of required renovation and retrofitting.
  - Increase availability of low-interest rate “green mortgages” (consistent with the principles developed by the Energy Efficiency Mortgage Initiative) and “green home equity loans” to boost private investment where liquidity constraints are less binding.
  - Emphasize comprehensive and consistent data on energy efficiency and develop active strategies to monitor financial risks from such instruments to mitigate the risk of “greenwashing,” anchored to the EU Taxonomy on Sustainable Activities.
  - For analysis, homes with an energy performance certificate (EPC) rating of lower than “A” are deemed energy inefficient; some banks offer reduced-rate “green mortgages” for buildings with an energy efficiency rating of as low as EPC=”B3.”
- Public support for technology and land-use measures
  - Promote R&D in early-stage technologies such as hydrogen generation through renewable energy (water and wind).
  - Encourage adoption of low-emission agronomic technologies.
  - Support carbon capture, including through peatland restoration and re-forestation, and new forms of energy storage.
- Just transition measures
  - Recycle some carbon tax revenues to support de-carbonization efforts, including business restructuring, active labor market policies, and subsidies and grants focused on encouraging greater use of renewable energy.
  - Consider impacts on international competitiveness and the burden of higher energy prices on households.

### Use of carbon tax revenues and distributional/efficiency considerations (summary of Table 2 matrix)
- Environmental investment
  - Impacts on income distribution: May disproportionately benefit low-income households (for example, if reduces their vulnerability to natural disasters)
  - Impact on economic efficiency: Risk that may be less efficient than broader uses of revenue
  - Administrative burden: Modest
- General investments
  - Impacts on income distribution: May disproportionately benefit low-income households (for example, if provides basic education, health, infrastructure)
  - Impact on economic efficiency: Potentially significant
  - Administrative burden: Modest
- Universal transfers
  - Impacts on income distribution: Highly progressive (disproportionately benefits the poor relative to income)
  - Impact on economic efficiency: Forgoes efficiency benefits¹
  - Administrative burden: New capacity needed (but should be manageable)
- Payroll tax
  - Impacts on income distribution: Benefits are largely proportional across working households
  - Impact on economic efficiency: Improves incentives for formal work effort
  - Administrative burden: Minimal
- Personal income tax
  - Impacts on income distribution: Typically benefits are skewed to higher-income groups
  - Impact on economic efficiency: Improves incentives for formal work effort and saving, reduces tax-sheltering
  - Administrative burden: Minimal
- Consumption tax
  - Impacts on income distribution: Largely proportional to household consumption
  - Impact on economic efficiency: Reduces incentives for untaxed goods and activities
  - Administrative burden: Minimal
- Corporate income tax
  - Impacts on income distribution: Benefits skewed to higher-income groups
  - Impact on economic efficiency: Improves incentives for investment
  - Administrative burden: Minimal
- Deficit reduction
  - Impacts on income distribution: Benefits accrue to future generations
  - Impact on economic efficiency: Lowers future tax burdens and macro-financial risk
  - Administrative burden: Minimal
- Means-tested cash, in-kind transfers
  - Impacts on income distribution: Effective at helping low-income groups if social safety nets are comprehensive
  - Impact on economic efficiency: Efficiency impacts unclear but likely modest¹
  - Administrative burden: Low if builds on existing capacity, otherwise significant
- Assistance for household energy bills
  - Impacts on income distribution: Provides partial relief for all households (for example, does not help with indirect pricing burden)
  - Impact on economic efficiency: Modest reduction in environmental effectiveness
  - Administrative burden: Low if builds on existing capacity, otherwise significant

Notes from Table 2:
- Green areas indicate current use of carbon taxes in Ireland.
- 1/ Transfers to low‑income households could lead to a small increase in human capital investment.

### Timing, financing, and fiscal considerations
- Given still low borrowing costs, it would be beneficial to make green investments now (in line with prudent fiscal policies), even before sufficient revenues from carbon pricing become available.
- Gradual increase of the carbon tax, accompanied by the reduction in fossil fuel allowances, will further boost private investment.
- Greater private sector participation in infrastructure projects might be required over time as fiscal consolidation is likely to constrain budget outlays for public investment.

### Infrastructure strategy and evaluation (Box 2 highlights)
- Public investment programs shape carbon emissions for decades; project cost-benefit analysis should include environmental, social, and governance (ESG) considerations to avoid locking in carbon-intensive growth.
- Investment in climate-sensitive infrastructure is costly but carries significant long-term benefits that reduce net cost overall.
- Ireland has suffered chronic under-investment in infrastructure for decades, so most investment will be in new projects; lower cost from renewable energy sources and greater energy efficiency are likely to offset investment cost over time.
- Government should adopt a strategic approach to public investment consistent with the National Development and Climate Action plans, accounting systematically for:
  - The climate impact of large projects (GHG emissions).
  - The sources, types, and sizes of damage/economic losses.
  - The project resilience to different natural hazards (“resilience score”).
  - The capacity to predict frequency/impact of future disaster shocks (“climate damage function”).
- The Irish government is working with the European Commission (DG REFORM) and the OECD to better incorporate climate impacts into infrastructure appraisal.

### Key programmatic details and existing grant schemes
- The National Home Retrofit Scheme provides grants covering 35 percent of the overall cost of home improvements for private and local authority housing and 50 percent for approved housing bodies.
- 100 percent grants are available for households at risk of energy poverty under the Better Energy Warmer Homes Scheme.
- These grants are provided from the Sustainable Energy Authority of Ireland (SEAI) as a key support measure under the Irish government’s Climate Action Plan 2019 and the Climate Action and Low Carbon Development (Amendment) Bill 2021.

*Source: IMF — Ireland country chapter (content unit 1irlea2021002).*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/cr/2021/english/1irlea2021002.pdf_
