## 1. The Pandemic’s Impact on Diaspora Flows

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [1. The Pandemic’s Impact on Diaspora Flows](https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/cr/2021/english/1kosea2021001.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/files/publications/cr/2021/english/1kosea2021001.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/files/publications/cr/2021/english/1kosea2021001.pdf.json)

---

### Context: The pandemic’s high socio-economic toll
- Health and pandemic:
  - Three waves through 2020; third (since late October) strongest in cases and mortality.
  - Health system broadly adequate but capacity stretched; health infrastructure compares unfavorably with the region.
- GDP and activity:
  - GDP: estimated to have contracted by about 6 percent in 2020.
  - Q2:2020: -10 percent y/y.
  - Q3:2020: GDP increased about 3 percent on a sequential seasonally adjusted basis (recovered about 1/3rd of Q2 losses).
- Diaspora-related activity and external:
  - Diaspora-related travel contracted by about 60 percent in summer 2020.
  - Diaspora flows (tourism receipts, remittances and real estate purchases) declined from around 38 percent of GDP in 2019 to less than 30 percent of GDP in 2020.
  - Inter-annual net travel receipts through Q3:2020 decreased by 11 percent of GDP.
  - Remittances through formal channels about 10 percent y/y through October 2020.
  - Current account deficit estimated to have widened to 7.5 percent of GDP in 2020.
  - Financing included increased foreign debt and IMF RFI purchase of €51 million (0.8 percent of GDP).
- Inflation:
  - Inflation declined to about -0.3 percent (y/y) in November 2020.
- Fiscal developments:
  - Fiscal revenues in 2020 declined by about 9 percent.
  - Primary spending increased by more than 6 percent; subsidies and transfers rose about 40 percent.
  - Fiscal deficit: 7.7 percent of GDP (8.2 percent of GDP excluding grants).
  - “Fiscal rule” deficit posted 5.8 percent of GDP, above the 2 percent of GDP ceiling.
  - Deficit financed by net external financing ~2.5 percent of GDP, net domestic debt placements of 2.5 percent of GDP, and decreases in government deposits of about €200 million (3 percent of GDP).
  - Public debt increased to 24.5 percent of GDP at end-2020 (17.6 percent of GDP in 2019).
  - Extra-budgetary transfers through KPST about 1.8 percent of GDP.
- Banking and financial stability:
  - Bank deposits grew by around 11 percent in 2020; about 40 percent of such increase due to KPST pension account withdrawals authorized as COVID-19 relief.
  - Lending expected to have grown by around 6 percent.
  - NPLs through November 2020 remained low at 2.5 percent given forbearance through end-September.
  - Large foreign-owned bank share, high liquidity and capital buffers; vulnerabilities may emerge as forbearance is lifted.
- Structural and political:
  - Public investment down close to 30 percent in 2020.
  - Informality about 30 percent of GDP.
  - Per-capita income about 30 percent of the EU average (PPP terms).
  - Political uncertainty: Constitutional Court ruling in December 2020 led to fall of government and elections called for mid-February 2021; Parliament needs special quorum of 80 MPs to elect a new President.

### Outlook: Growth to resume in 2021 amid high uncertainty
- Baseline staff projection and assumptions:
  - Economic activity to rebound by 4.5 percent in 2021.
  - Assumptions include: fiscal support as in 2021 budget; contracting additional debt of around €160 million (2.3 percent of GDP) to preserve buffers; vaccine rollout in first half of 2021 allowing diaspora travel recovery in H2:2021; political stabilization after February elections.
- Key projections:
  - Current account deficit expected to decrease to 6.4 percent of GDP in 2021.
  - International reserves projected to fall to about 95 percent of the IMF RA metric.
  - Consumer inflation projected to tick up but remain subdued.
- Medium-term scarring and potential:
  - Nominal GDP forecast to return to pre-crisis levels by 2022 but remain below pre-crisis trend.
  - Potential GDP growth projected to average about 2 percent per year over 2020-22 (compared to 4 percent before the crisis).
  - Staff expect potential growth to slowly return to 4 percent per year in the medium term.
  - Expected output loss = 7 percent.
  - Current account deficit expected to converge to about 5 percent of GDP by 2025.

### Adverse scenarios and recommended policy response
- Two adverse scenarios:
  - Temporary shock: GDP growth recovers quickly beginning in 2022.
  - Persistent shock: growth remains persistently below baseline over 2021-23.
- Fiscal implications and staff recommendations:
  - If shock is temporary: accommodate larger fiscal deficit through additional financing to support the economy and preserve international reserves.
  - If shock is persistent: partially accommodate the larger fiscal deficit over 2021–22 through additional financing, and converge to the baseline fiscal deficit by 2023 to protect reserves and contain public debt growth.
  - Staff advised authorities to seek independent analysis on shock duration and nature if adverse scenario materializes.

### Authorities’ views
- Authorities broadly concurred with staff on outlook and uncertainty; initially more optimistic on 2020 GDP impact but revised down after diaspora travel reductions.
- Agreed on cautious policy reaction if 2021 GDP growth disappoints and expect to firm up still-uncommitted financing for 2021.
- Committed to ex-post audit of MRP-related spending and publication in 2020 and 2021 budget audit reports.

### Fiscal policy: Mitigating the health crisis and cushioning income losses
- 2020 Mitigation and Recovery Package (MRP): about 4.3 percent of GDP.
  - Allocations:
    - Health system: 0.4 percent of GDP.
    - Wage bonuses for health and security workers: 0.5 percent of GDP.
    - Social transfers and subsidies to vulnerable households: 1.6 percent of GDP.
    - Support to firms: around 1.7 percent of GDP.
    - Capital spending: less than 0.1 percent of GDP.
  - Early KPST withdrawals: 2.6 percent of GDP (majority, 1.8 percent of GDP, to be gradually reimbursed by the budget beginning in 2023).
  - MRP implementation: almost fully implemented despite political delays.
- 2021 budget MRP: 3.1 percent of GDP.
  - Components:
    - Goods and services in health: 0.7 percent of GDP (of which €40 million = 0.6 percent of GDP for vaccines).
    - Transfers to households and firms: 1.7 percent of GDP.
    - Capital spending in health and education: 0.4 percent of GDP.
    - Contingency allocation: 0.3 percent of GDP.
  - Overall deficit projected at 5.9 percent of GDP (4.9 percent of GDP according to fiscal rule definition).
- Fiscal design and transparency recommendations:
  - Mitigation and recovery measures should be well-designed, transparent, and targeted.
  - Some 2020 transfers to private firms (€60 million, 1 percent of GDP) were not sufficiently targeted; staff advised monitoring via representative firm survey.
  - Strengthen design of large agricultural subsidies (about 1 percent of GDP in 2020).
  - Early KPST withdrawals undermine “Pillar 2”, reduce future pensions, and limit domestic capital market development.
  - Auditor General should conduct a special audit of all MRP-related spending.
  - Publish beneficial ownership information online for awarded procurement contracts.

### Kosovo mitigation and recovery measures (selected implemented measures)
- Crisis management: €10 million to Ministry of Health for PPE; salary supplements (€300) to health and security workers; €100 supplements to grocery, bakery, pharmacy employees in lockdown.
- Tax relief: postponed filings/payments for CIT, PIT, VAT; option to reschedule tax debts; VAT exemptions on wheat and flour for March 25 - May 8.
- Subsidies and firm support: employer pension contribution coverage for 2 months; salary subsidies; increased agricultural subsidies.
- Support to vulnerable households: double Social Assistance Scheme benefits in April-June; additional €30 per month to beneficiaries in April-June.
- KPST early withdrawals: legislation allowed early tax-free withdrawals up to 10 percent of KPST accounts (estimated at €200 million), about €120 million to be gradually reimbursed by budget beginning in 2023.
- Macroprudential: CBK allowed 3-month loan payment moratorium (reached ~50% of loans); up to 1-year loan restructurings in June-September.

### Financing program and fiscal buffers
- Financing program includes:
  - Ambitious net domestic debt placements of 2.4 percent of GDP;
  - Confirmed EU budget support lending of €50 million, and grants €11 million;
  - Confirmed Council of Europe lending €17 million;
  - Still-uncommitted IFI lending €160 million (2.3 percent of GDP).
- Securing financing is essential for MRP implementation and to preserve fiscal buffers underpinning Kosovo’s GIRs.
- Staff recommendations on cash management and contingent plans:
  - Formulate contingent plans if uncommitted financing does not materialize.
  - MOF to require pre-approval of large-ticket spending at commitment stage.
  - Strengthen cash management to mitigate arrears risk.
  - If uncommitted financing absent, reduce fiscal deficit by decreasing tax expenditures and reprioritizing spending; preserve government deposits.

### Public debt, fiscal rule, and debt ceilings
- Fiscal rule allows exclusion of “investment clause” spending if public debt remains below 30 percent of GDP.
- Staff projections suggest public debt will hit 30 percent of GDP in 2022.
- Staff suggested raising “investment clause” debt ceiling to general debt ceiling of 40 percent of GDP to preserve investment space through 2025.
- Staff strongly advised against increasing general debt ceiling to 50 percent of GDP.

### Public debt projections and management (DSA highlights)
- Public gross debt trajectory (percent of GDP):
  - 2019: 17.6
  - 2020: 24.5
  - 2021: 28.7
  - 2022: 30.4
  - 2023: 31.7
  - 2024: 32.9
  - 2025: 34.1
- Public gross financing needs:
  - Peak close to 14 percent of GDP in 2020; 9.4 percent of GDP in 2021; 7 - 8 percent of GDP over 2022–25.
- Staff urged:
  - Implement fiscal rule beyond 2021.
  - Increase average maturity of domestic debt (from about 3.5 years in 2019 to 4.5 years in 2025).
  - Diversify investor base (individuals, private businesses, insurance companies currently hold less than 5 percent of total domestic debt).
  - Gradually reduce CBK holdings of government securities.
  - Limit KPST’s exposure to no more than 30 percent of its assets.

### Public and external DSA stress tests and contingent liabilities
- Contingent liabilities modeled: POEs at 5 percent of GDP; PAK at 1.5 percent of GDP.
- Contingent liabilities could lift debt ratio to 36 percent of GDP.
- In stress tests, public debt does not breach high-risk threshold of 65 percent of GDP.
- External debt-to-GDP ratio expected to increase by 10 pp through 2025.
- External debt (percent of GDP):
  - 2020: 25.3
  - 2025: 31.4
- Gross external financing need (USD millions and % of GDP) 2020: 1,658 (21.4%); 2025: 2,068 (18.9%).

### Financial sector policy response and stability risks
- CBK measures:
  - March 2020: 3-month loan moratorium reaching about 50 percent of loans.
  - June decision: applications for up to 1-year loan extensions and restructuring; by September reached around 20 percent of loans.
  - Measures helped bank credit to grow by around 6 percent (y/y) through November 2020.
- Forbearance and supervision:
  - Regulatory forbearance allowed on classification of reprogrammed/restructured loans; dividend payments suspended.
  - Staff encouraged lifting forbearance before end-2020 so provisions reflect loan portfolio developments.
  - Advised against weakening capital standards; recommend flexibility with time-bound plans to replenish capital buffers and engagement with parent banks.
- Liquidity and ELA:
  - ELA reserves around €100 million, insufficient for systemic shock.
  - CBK negotiated a €100 million repo line with ECB via Deutsche Bundesbank available through March 2022.
- Accounting and NPLs:
  - Transition to IFRS9 in 2020 created challenges; staff recommended assessing credit quality under IFRS9 and the prior five-bucket classification to flag deviations.
  - Authorities expect NPLs to rise in 2021 but anticipate existing capital buffers sufficient.

### Fiscal governance, public employment, procurement, social protection, and pensions
- Revenue mobilization and tax policy:
  - Revenue base weakened by exemptions and special tax regimes; staff recommended a tax expenditure review and stronger tax administration.
- Procurement:
  - Finalize e-procurement implementation; target at least 20 percent of goods and services via centralized procurement by end-2021.
- Public employment and compensation:
  - Revise repealed 2019 law to improve transparency and fairness while avoiding unsustainably large wage bill; MOF to have veto power on new vacancies and collective agreements.
- Social protection:
  - Current transfers: people with disabilities 0.3 percent of GDP; SAS general transfer 0.5 percent of GDP.
  - Recommend poverty-test compliance checks and relaxing qualifying child age limit in low-income, low-opportunity households at annual cost 0.2 percent of GDP starting in 2022.
- Pensions and social security:
  - Multiplicity of untargeted pension benefits threatens fiscal sustainability.
  - Example: pensions to war veterans totalling 1.1 percent of GDP exceed legal ceiling 0.7 percent of GDP.
  - Staff urged holistic analysis to assess long-term costs, fairness, double payments, and ways to streamline and integrate the system; preserve integrity and independence of “Pillar 2”.
- Public investment management:
  - PIP unfocused with low growth impact; recommend formalizing appraisal, selection, monitoring; consolidate sector strategies; report PPPs and POEs’ investment in budget annex; record PPP contingent liabilities.

### Financial governance, CBK oversight, and macroprudential powers
- Fill CBK Board vacancies (appointments await new Parliament) to restore quorum.
- Strengthen legal basis for CBK macroprudential powers via amendments to banking law and regulations.
- Integrate stress tests and communicate results; develop tools using granular Credit Registry data.
- Continue implementation of FSAP recommendations.

### POEs and energy sector risks
- POEs inefficient and loss-making; weak oversight and fiscal risk reporting.
- Staff urged performance agreements, quarterly risk assessments for high-risk POEs, MOF-led functional review, and restructuring plans.
- Energy sector recommendations:
  - Create working group (regulator, ministries of finance and economy) to assess expected tariff impact of PPAs, plans to reduce non-commercial losses, scope to increase RE share through wholesale market, and potential contingent fiscal costs in PPAs.

### International integration, trade liberalization, and governance
- SAA (effective April 2016) to progressively align Kosovo with EU acquis and eliminate most tariffs by 2026.
- Tariff and trade facts:
  - Kosovo’s tariff code comprises 10,191 tariff lines at 10-digit level.
  - FTAs’ rules apply to about 80 percent of trade.
  - For other countries, 10 percent uniform import tariff on 79 percent of tariff lines; no tariff on remaining lines.
  - Implementation of EU-SAA and Turkey FTA expected to reduce fiscal revenues by 0.6 percent of GDP by 2025.
- Governance and anti-corruption: continue improvements in fiscal governance, rule of law, anti-corruption, financial sector oversight, AML/CFT.

### Risk Assessment Matrix — selected risks and policy responses
- Prolonged pandemic and asynchronous progress (Medium likelihood): strengthen contingency planning; use external support; accelerate structural reforms to boost competitiveness and reduce diaspora dependency.
- Widespread social discontent and political instability (High likelihood): continue EU-SAA implementation; improve business environment.
- Widened fiscal deficit (High likelihood): secure additional financing; allow fiscal stabilizers to work.
- Domestic political stalemate (High likelihood): careful caretaker budget implementation; continue technical work on pending reforms.
- Intensification of financial sector vulnerabilities (Medium likelihood): CBK to tightly monitor loan portfolio quality and restore Board quorum.

### Annex III — External Sector Assessment (highlights)
- Current account deficit increased from 5.5 percent of GDP in 2019 to 7.5 percent in 2020.
- Goods and services:
  - Trade deficit in goods estimated to have declined to 37.5 percent of GDP (40 percent in 2019).
  - Surplus in services contracted to 5.8 percent of GDP (13.1 percent in 2019).
- Financing of 2020 deficit:
  - Remittances: 13.6 percent of GDP in 2020.
  - Compensation of employees: 3.7 percent of GDP in 2020.
  - Net FDI inflows: 3.2 percent of GDP in 2020.
  - CBK GIRs estimated to have decreased by 1.2 percent of GDP in 2020.
- EBA-lite REER assessment (2020):
  - CA (Projected at end-2020) = -7.5 percent of GDP.
  - CA norm = -4.8 percent of GDP.
  - CA-Gap = -2.9 percent of GDP (Policy gap = 5.3).
  - REER Gap = 10.7 percent (indicative REER overvaluation).
  - External Sustainability approach: CA gap = -1.3 percent of GDP and REER overvaluation = 4.5 percent.
- Reserve adequacy:
  - Standard GIR (millions of euros): 2019 = 1,164; 2020 = 1,142; 2020 Prel. = 1,142.
  - Percent of RA metric (Standard GIR): 2019 = 136; 2020 = 121; 2020 Prel. = 103.
  - Conservative GIR (millions of euros): 2019 = 864; 2020 = 781; 2020 Prel. = 798.
  - Fiscal buffer rule of thumb: minimum fiscal reserves ≈ €299 million (4.4 percent of GDP); actual fiscal reserves in 2020 = €278 million (4 percent of GDP).
  - ELA reserves around €100 million in 2020; CBK repo line €100 million available through March 2022.

### Annex V — Implementation Status of 2018 Article IV Recommendations (selected)
- Public investment and spending efficiency: Weak compliance; low absorption of donor-financed investment; no ex-post audits of major investment projects.
- Revenue administration: Partial compliance; TAK progressed in risk-based work but comprehensive cost-benefit assessment of tax expenditures pending.
- Fiscal institutions and governance: Partial compliance; MTEF improved but revenue projections unrealistic; e-procurement rollout mostly done but centralized procurement coverage stalled.
- Labor market and skills: Weak compliance; reforms at early stage.
- Rule of law and judiciary: Mixed/partial compliance; progress on some laws but limited progress in anti-corruption effectiveness.
- Financial sector and AML/CFT: Mixed compliance; AML/CFT effectiveness highly unsatisfactory.

### Appendix III — Kosovo’s Pension System: Challenges and Areas for Reform
- Pension architecture:
  - Three pillars: Pillar 0 (budget-financed), Pillar 2 (KPST individual DC scheme), Pillar 3 (voluntary).
  - Pillar 0 reaches about 200,000 beneficiaries at cost ~5.7 percent of GDP.
  - Pillar 2 pension accounts represented 30 percent of GDP in 2019; KPST assets about €2 billion at end-2020 after 10 percent early withdrawals.
- Fiscal pressures and special regimes:
  - Subsidies and transfers increased to 12.73 percent of GDP in 2020 (excluding COVID measures 9.39).
  - Pensions to war veterans: 1.1 percent of GDP in 2020 (legal ceiling 0.7 percent of GDP).
- Distributional and design issues:
  - KPST contributor distribution skewed: 80 percent of contributors account for less than 30 percent of KPST assets; half of contributors have savings below €1,000.
  - Early withdrawals (10 percent) are regressive and undermine Pillar 2 integrity.
- Policy recommendations:
  - Moratorium on further expansions of special regimes.
  - Conduct actuarial and fiscal analysis before reforms; 3-year costing projection mandated by law is insufficient.
  - Contribution increases only after comprehensive tax policy diagnostic.
  - Reform war-related pension regulations to preserve fiscal space and curtail inequities.
  - Protect Pillar 2 integrity; avoid repeated early withdrawals.

### Staff appraisal — macroeconomic and fiscal assessment (summary)
- Pandemic hit Kosovo hard; dependence on services and diaspora-related inflows amplified the shock.
- Fiscal and financial policies mitigated the shock; MRP broadly appropriate but targeting and transparency must improve.
- Preserve fiscal buffers; firm up uncommitted borrowing for 2021 or reprioritize spending.
- Social security reforms should be actuarially sound; avoid creating additional medium-term budgetary costs before recovery is entrenched.
- Unifying “investment clause” and general debt ceilings at 40 percent of GDP is essential; avoid raising ceiling to 50 percent.
- CBK governance: safeguards sound but Board vacancies pose significant risks; restore quorum.
- Banking system remains strong but close supervision needed as forbearance is lifted.
- External position weaker than implied by fundamentals; GIRs decreased in 2020 and are just at the IMF RA level.

_Italic: Source: IMF staff report excerpt (1kosea2021001)._

### 1. The Pandemic’s Impact on Diaspora Flows ____________________________________________________ 20

### 1. The Pandemic’s Impact on Diaspora Flows

### Context: The pandemic’s high socio-economic toll
- Kosovo hit hard by COVID-19; three waves through 2020 with the third (since late October) strongest in cases and mortality. Health system broadly adequate but capacity stretched; health infrastructure compares unfavorably with the region.
- GDP: estimated to have contracted by about 6 percent in 2020.
  - Q2:2020: -10 percent y/y (sharp fall due to mobility restrictions).
  - Q3:2020: GDP increased about 3 percent on a sequential seasonally adjusted basis (recovered about 1/3rd of Q2 losses).
- Diaspora-related activity:
  - Diaspora-related travel contracted by about 60 percent in summer 2020.
  - Diaspora flows (tourism receipts, remittances and real estate purchases) declined from around 38 percent of GDP in 2019 to less than 30 percent of GDP in 2020.
  - Inter-annual net travel receipts through Q3:2020 decreased by 11 percent of GDP.
- Inflation: declined to about -0.3 percent (y/y) in November 2020 (weak activity, lower energy prices, elimination of import tariffs from Serbia and Bosnia and Herzegovina in April 2020).
- Remittances and external sector:
  - Remittances through formal channels about 10 percent y/y through October 2020.
  - Current account deficit estimated to have widened to 7.5 percent of GDP in 2020.
  - Financing included increased foreign debt and IMF RFI purchase of €51 million (0.8 percent of GDP).
  - Central Bank international reserves projected to end 2020 at about the level considered appropriate by IMF reserve adequacy (RA) metrics; EBA-lite suggests external position weaker than implied by fundamentals (Annex III).
- Fiscal and public debt developments:
  - Fiscal revenues in 2020 declined by about 9 percent.
  - Primary spending increased by more than 6 percent; subsidies and transfers rose about 40 percent.
  - Fiscal deficit: soared to 7.7 percent of GDP (8.2 percent of GDP excluding grants).
  - “Fiscal rule” deficit (excludes certain IFI-financed capital investment) posted 5.8 percent of GDP, above the 2 percent of GDP deficit ceiling.
  - Deficit financed by net external financing around 2.5 percent of GDP, net domestic debt placements of 2.5 percent of GDP, and decreases in government deposits of about €200 million (3 percent of GDP).
  - Public debt increased to 24.5 percent of GDP at end-2020 (17.6 percent of GDP in 2019).
  - Extra-budgetary transfers through KPST about 1.8 percent of GDP.
- Banking sector and financial stability:
  - Bank deposits estimated to have grown by around 11 percent in 2020; about 40 percent of such increase due to KPST pension account withdrawals authorized as COVID-19 relief.
  - Lending expected to have grown by around 6 percent.
  - NPLs through November 2020 remained low (at 2.5 percent) given forbearance on loan classification through end-September.
  - Large foreign-owned bank share, high liquidity and capital buffers support stability, but vulnerabilities may emerge as forbearance is lifted.
- Structural challenges exacerbated:
  - Public investment down close to 30 percent in 2020.
  - Education gap likely to widen due to weak infrastructure and lack of equipment for remote learning.
  - Informality about 30 percent of GDP; disproportionate impact on high-contact sectors (hospitality, tourism).
  - Per-capita income about 30 percent of the EU average (PPP terms).
- Political uncertainty:
  - Successive short-lived governments and caretaker administrations in 2019-20 delayed key legislation.
  - Constitutional Court ruling in December 2020 led to fall of government and elections called for mid-February 2021.
  - Parliament needs special quorum of 80 MPs to elect a new President; failure could force repeat elections and add uncertainty.

### Outlook: Growth to resume in 2021 amid high uncertainty
- Baseline staff projection: economic activity to rebound by 4.5 percent in 2021.
  - Assumptions:
    - Fiscal support proceeds as envisaged in the 2021 budget; contracting of additional debt of around €160 million (2.3 percent of GDP) needed if fiscal buffers are to be preserved.
    - Vaccine rollout in the first half of 2021 allows diaspora-related travel recovery in the second half of 2021.
    - Political stabilization after February elections.
  - Current account deficit expected to decrease to 6.4 percent of GDP in 2021.
  - International reserves projected to fall to about 95 percent of the IMF RA metric.
  - Consumer inflation projected to tick up but remain subdued, mirroring Euro area developments.
- Medium-term projections and scars:
  - Nominal GDP forecast to return to pre-crisis levels by 2022 but remain below pre-crisis trend.
  - Potential GDP growth projected to average about 2 percent per year over 2020-22 (compared to 4 percent before the crisis).
  - Causes: destruction of firm-specific organizational capital (bankruptcies, especially hospitality), slower capital accumulation, hysteresis for laid-off workers, slower structural reform implementation.
  - Staff expect potential growth to slowly return to 4 percent per year in the medium term.
  - Expected output loss = 7 percent.
  - Current account deficit expected to converge to about 5 percent of GDP by 2025 (in line with current account norm).

### Adverse scenarios and recommended policy response
- Two staff-characterized adverse scenarios (both more protracted pandemic):
  - Temporary shock: GDP growth recovers quickly beginning in 2022.
  - Persistent shock: growth remains persistently below baseline over 2021-23.
- Fiscal and policy implications:
  - Absent policy response, lower GDP growth leads to lower fiscal revenues and larger budget deficit in 2021; if temporary, deficit returns to baseline in 2022; if persistent, deficit stays above baseline.
  - Staff recommendations:
    - If shock is temporary: accommodate larger fiscal deficit through additional financing to support the economy and preserve international reserves.
    - If shock is persistent: partially accommodate the larger fiscal deficit over 2021–22 through additional financing, and converge to the baseline fiscal deficit by 2023 to protect reserves and contain public debt growth.
  - Staff advised authorities to seek independent analysis on the duration and nature of the shock if an adverse scenario materializes in 2021.

### Authorities’ views
- Authorities broadly concurred with staff on the outlook and uncertainty.
  - Initially more optimistic on 2020 GDP impact; revised down after stronger-than-expected reduction in diaspora-related travel.
  - For 2021, they concurred with staff views as reflected in the budget’s macroeconomic framework.
  - Agreed on cautious policy reaction if 2021 GDP growth disappoints, while noting difficulty in assessing temporary vs persistent shock amid COVID-19 uncertainty.

### Fiscal policy: Mitigating the health crisis and cushioning income losses
- 2020 Mitigation and Recovery Package (MRP): about 4.3 percent of GDP.
  - Allocations:
    - Health system: 0.4 percent of GDP.
    - Wage bonuses for health and security workers: 0.5 percent of GDP.
    - Social transfers and subsidies to vulnerable households: 1.6 percent of GDP.
    - Support to firms (salary subsidies, easier access to borrowing, including POEs and farms): around 1.7 percent of GDP.
    - Capital spending: less than 0.1 percent of GDP.
  - Early withdrawals of up to 10 percent from KPST pension accounts: 2.6 percent of GDP (a majority, 1.8 percent of GDP, to be gradually reimbursed by the budget beginning in 2023).
  - MRP implementation: almost fully implemented despite political delays; KPST withdrawals occurred late in 2020 and should primarily affect demand in 2021.
- 2021 budget MRP: 3.1 percent of GDP.
  - Components:
    - Goods and services in health sector: 0.7 percent of GDP (out of which €40 million – or 0.6 percent of GDP – for procurement of COVID-19 vaccines).
    - Transfers to households and firms: 1.7 percent of GDP.
    - Capital spending in health and education: 0.4 percent of GDP.
    - Contingency allocation: 0.3 percent of GDP.
  - Overall deficit projected at 5.9 percent of GDP (4.9 percent of GDP according to fiscal rule definition).
- Staff recommendations on fiscal design and transparency:
  - Mitigation and recovery measures should be well-designed, transparent, and targeted to those most in need.
  - Some 2020 transfers to private firms (€60 million, 1 percent of GDP) were not sufficiently targeted; staff advised monitoring their use via a representative firm survey.
  - Design of large agricultural subsidies (about 1 percent of GDP in 2020, including planned recovery measures) needs strengthening for transparency and effectiveness.
  - Early withdrawal from KPST undermines “Pillar 2”, reduces future pensions, and limits domestic capital market development — a key source of budgetary financing.
  - Auditor General should conduct a special audit of all MRP-related spending to ensure procurement conflict-of-interest legislation is respected.
  - While progress has been made in centrally publishing awarded procurement contracts, stronger action needed to publish associated beneficial ownership information online.

### Kosovo mitigation and recovery measures (selected measures summarized)
- Crisis management: €10 million allocation to Ministry of Health for PPE; salary supplements (€300) to public sector health and security workers during periods; €100 supplements to grocery, bakery, pharmacy employees in lockdown.
- Tax relief to firms: postponed filings/payments for CIT, PIT, VAT; option to reschedule tax debts; VAT exemptions on wheat and flour for March 25 - May 8.
- Subsidies to firms: government covered employers’ pension contributions for 2 months; salary subsidies to retain employment; increased agricultural subsidies.
- Support to vulnerable households: Social Assistance Scheme beneficiaries received double benefits in April-June; additional €30 per month to all beneficiaries of social and pension schemes in April-June.
- Support to POEs: budgetary support through subsidies, lending, and sovereign guarantees.
- Macroprudential measures: CBK allowed a 3-month loan payment moratorium (reached about 50 percent of loans); decision allowed up to 1-year loan restructurings in June-September.
- Stimulate aggregate demand: December 2020 legislation allowed early tax-free withdrawals of up to 10 percent of KPST individual pension accounts (estimated at €200 million), out of which around €120 million will be gradually reimbursed by the budget beginning in 2023.

*REPUBLIC OF KOSOVO INTERNATIONAL MONETARY FUND*

### 16.      Firming up the financing program for 2021 is essential for budget implementation and

### 16.      Firming up the financing program for 2021 is essential for budget implementation and 

### Financing program and fiscal buffers
- Financing program includes:
  - ambitious net domestic debt placements for 2.4 percent of GDP;
  - confirmed external financing from the EU: budget support lending of €50 million, and grants for €11 million;
  - confirmed external financing from the Council of Europe: lending of €17 million;
  - still-uncommitted IFI lending for €160 million (2.3 percent of GDP).
- Securing the financing program is essential to allow for MRP implementation and to preserve fiscal buffers underpinning Kosovo’s gross international reserves (GIRs).

### Contingent plans and cash management (staff recommendations)
- Formulate contingent plans if still-uncommitted financing does not materialize.
- Ministry of Finance (MOF) to issue instructions requiring pre-approval of spending on large ticket items at the commitment stage.
- Strengthen cash management to mitigate the risk of accumulating arrears.
- If uncommitted financing is not forthcoming, reduce the fiscal deficit by:
  - decreasing tax expenditures; and
  - reprioritizing spending to reach those most affected by the pandemic while minimizing the use of government deposits.
- Preserve government deposits at appropriate levels as an instrument if downside risks materialize.

### Public debt, the “investment clause”, and debt ceilings
- The fiscal rule allows exclusion of “investment clause” spending (capital investment financed by IFIs and bilateral sources contracted after 2015) provided public debt remains below 30 percent of GDP.
- Staff projections suggest public debt will hit 30 percent of GDP already in 2022.
- To preserve the “investment clause” through 2025 and keep room for infrastructure investment, staff suggested raising the “investment clause” debt ceiling to the general debt ceiling of 40 percent of GDP.
- Staff strongly advised against increasing the general debt ceiling to 50 percent of GDP as proposed by the government, citing risks of risky behavior and contingent liabilities from PPAs or PPPs.

### Fiscal rule suspension (2020–21) and medium-term consolidation
- Suspension of the fiscal rule over 2020–21 is warranted to allow fiscal stabilizers to work and create room for MRP implementation.
- Beyond 2021, staff advised returning to the fiscal rule as the anchor for policy.
- Key measures to support consolidation:
  - enlarge the revenue base;
  - gradually remove targeted support and refocus social spending to protect the most vulnerable;
  - explore ways to offset loss of fiscal revenues from trade integration agreements (of around 0.6 percent of GDP by 2025), including reducing tax expenditures and improving progressivity of income taxes;
  - increase capacity to absorb externally financed public investment to limit negative change in fiscal stance.

### Public debt projections and debt management
- Public debt projected to drift slowly upwards over 2022-25 driven by use of the “investment clause” before its expiration in 2025.
- Staff project that public debt should stabilize around the legal ceiling of 40 percent of GDP after 2025, when the 2 percent of GDP deficit ceiling becomes fully binding.
- Though public debt remains sustainable, financing needs are relatively large.
- Staff urged strengthening public debt management to limit vulnerabilities from absence of external market access.
- Recent progress: increase in average maturity of domestic debt.
- Need to further diversify investor base to include individuals (including the diaspora), private businesses, and insurance companies, which currently hold less than 5 percent of total domestic debt.

### Authorities’ views (summary)
- Authorities agreed with most staff messages but noted policy design challenges during the pandemic.
- KPST early withdrawals were characterized by authorities as a one-off action to inject liquidity.
- Authorities committed to conducting an ex-post audit of all resources spent in response to COVID-19 and to publish results in the audit reports of the 2020 and 2021 budgets.
- Authorities requested IMF assistance to analyze the legal procurement framework to allow collection and publication of beneficial ownership information in public procurement.
- Authorities expect to firm up still-uncommitted financing for 2021.
- Authorities agreed that beyond 2021 and after recovery is well entrenched, a reversal to the fiscal rule deficit should take place to anchor the public debt path.

### Financial sector policy response and stability risks
- CBK measures:
  - March 2020: 3-month loan payment moratorium reaching about 50 percent of bank loans.
  - June decision: applications for up to 1-year loan extensions and restructuring; by closing of window in September reached around 20 percent of loans.
  - These measures helped bank credit to grow by around 6 percent (y/y) through November 2020.
- Regulatory forbearance allowed on classification of reprogrammed and restructured loans to alleviate impact on banks’ balance sheets; dividend payments were suspended to safeguard capital.
- Staff encouraged lifting forbearance before end-2020 so provisions transparently reflect loan portfolio developments.
- Staff advised against weakening capital standards; recommended flexibility in supervisory action with time-bound plans to replenish capital buffers and engagement with parent banks for capital injections if needed.
- Need to strengthen operational procedures for Emergency Liquidity Assistance (ELA).
  - ELA reserves stand at around €100 million, insufficient to respond to a systemic shock.
  - CBK negotiated a €100 million repo line to borrow euro liquidity from the ECB against collateral consisting of euro-denominated marketable debt securities; this line will be available through March 2022.

### Accounting standards, NPLs, and supervisory recommendations
- Transition to IFRS9 at beginning of 2020 created challenges in computing NPLs and provisioning.
- Staff recommended CBK continue developing capacity to analyze banks’ risk models.
- Credit quality should be assessed both according to IFRS9 and the five-bucket credit quality classification used until 2019 to flag large deviations.
- Authorities expect NPLs to rise during 2021 but anticipate existing capital buffers will be enough to absorb expected credit write-offs without extra capital injections.
- Authorities agreed on need to refine understanding of banks’ models and on establishing operational procedures for optimal policy response, particularly for ELA.

### Fiscal governance: revenue, procurement, public employment, social protection, pensions, and public investment
- Revenue mobilization and tax policy:
  - Kosovo’s revenue base weakened by numerous exemptions and special tax regimes.
  - Staff recommended producing a tax expenditure review quantifying revenue forgone from exemptions and reduced rates.
  - Strengthen tax administration and intensify efforts to collect tax debt, including consolidating collection processes into one office and writing off uncollectible debt.
- Procurement:
  - Finalize implementation of e-procurement and expand centralized procurement coverage.
  - Staff urged at least 20 percent of all goods and services be purchased via centralized procurement by end-2021.
- Public employment and compensation:
  - Public employment and compensation policies are lax and uncoordinated; wage bill has increased steadily.
  - Staff urged revision of the repealed 2019 law to salvage elements improving transparency and compensation fairness while avoiding an unsustainably large wage bill.
  - MOF should have veto power on filling new vacancies and approval of new collective agreements.
- Social protection:
  - Current transfers: people with disabilities 0.3 percent of GDP; social assistance scheme (SAS) general transfer for low income households 0.5 percent of GDP.
  - Conduct a poverty-test to ensure compliance with eligibility criteria.
  - As part of poverty alleviation, staff recommended relaxing the qualifying child age limit in low-income, low-opportunity households covered by SAS at an annual cost of 0.2 percent of GDP, starting in 2022.
  - Balance investment in early education and paid maternity leave to foster equal opportunity for women.
- Pensions and social security:
  - Multiplicity of disparate and untargeted pension benefits threatens fiscal sustainability.
  - Example: pensions to war veterans totalling 1.1 percent of GDP have largely exceeded their legal spending ceiling of 0.7 percent of GDP.
  - Staff urged a holistic analysis to: (i) assess long-term budgetary cost of existing pension benefits; (ii) assess fairness of eligibility criteria and identify double payments; (iii) analyze ways to streamline and integrate the system; and (iv) preserve integrity and independence of “Pillar 2”.
- Public investment management:
  - Public investment strategy unfocused with low growth impact.
  - Staff urged improving planning, execution and ex-post audits of the Public Investment Program (PIP) by formalizing appraisal, selection, and monitoring procedures.
  - Recommendations include consolidating sector strategies in the Integrated Planning System; reporting PPPs and POEs’ investment through a budget annex; recording assets, liabilities and fiscal risks related to PPPs and contingent liabilities from POEs’ investments in annual financial statements; including multiannual commitments in the budget and financial statements; planning maintenance costs explicitly; quality control checks by the Budget Department; and creating a centralized executing unit for externally financed projects at the MOF.

### Financial governance, CBK oversight, and macroprudential powers
- Authorities are taking steps to fill CBK Board vacancies and review CBK organizational structure.
- Filling vacancies is essential for oversight and institutional backing of CBK policies; appointments await constitution of a new Parliament.
- Once CBK Board resumes operations, ensure financial stability and macroprudential policy functions are adequately represented on the Executive Board.
- Strengthen legal basis for CBK’s macroprudential policy powers via amendments to law on banks and associated regulations.
- Integrate stress tests within the financial stability area and communicate results to banks.
- Develop tools to assess credit risk using granular Credit Registry data.
- Move ahead with implementation of FSAP recommendations.

### Public Sector Enterprises (POEs) and energy sector risks
- POEs are inefficient, loss-making, and oversight and fiscal risk reporting remain weak.
- Staff urged establishing performance agreements and quarterly risk assessments for high risk POEs and strengthening institutional arrangements for POE oversight through an MOF-led functional review.
- All POEs need restructuring plans to ensure cost competitiveness, financial viability, and capacity to cover investment needs.
- Energy sector:
  - Need an energy sector strategy jointly assessing economic and environmental issues.
  - Staff recommended creating a working group (regulator, ministries of finance and economy) to assess:
    - expected impact on electricity tariffs of existing PPAs;
    - plans to reduce large non-commercial losses;
    - scope to increase share of RE supplied through the wholesale (competitive) market;
    - potential contingent fiscal costs embedded in current and planned PPAs.

*IMF staff report: Republic of Kosovo (excerpts).*

### 37.      International integration will promote competition and pave the way to stronger

### International integration will promote competition and pave the way to stronger

### International integration and trade liberalization
- The implementation of the Stabilization and Association Agreement (SAA) should allow for a gradual alignment of Kosovo’s institutional framework with that of the EU, paving the way for better resolution of commercial disputes, a stronger cadaster system, lower informality, and less cumbersome administrative procedures and inspections.
- Kosovo’s tariff code is based on the 2017 Harmonized Commodity Description and Coding System (HS) and the EU Combined Nomenclature, and comprises 10,191 tariff lines at the 10-digit level.
- FTAs’ rules apply to about 80 percent of Kosovo’s trade.
- For all other countries, Kosovo applies a 10 percent uniform import tariff on 79 percent of tariff lines, and no tariff on the remaining lines.
- Kosovo is beneficiary of the generalized systems of preferences applied by Belarus, Japan, Kazakhstan, Norway, the Russian Federation, Switzerland, and the U.S.
- The SAA (effective April 2016) sets to eliminate most tariffs by 2026; in 2020, 87 percent of Kosovo’s tariff lines on imports from the EU are duty-free.
- The Autonomous Trade Measures (ATM) previously granted duty-free access to 90 percent of goods exported to the EU.
- Following Brexit, Kosovo signed an FTA with the U.K. in December 2019, expected to enter into force in 2021.
- CEFTA trade was fully liberalized in 2015; Kosovo’s 100 percent import tariff on Serbia and Bosnia and Herzegovina (imposed in 2018) was eliminated in April 2020.
- An FTA with Turkey (signed 2013) became effective in 2019; Turkey removed import tariffs on Kosovo immediately for all industrial and most agricultural goods, while Kosovo will eliminate tariffs over a 10-year period.
- The implementation of the EU-SAA and Turkey FTA will reduce fiscal revenues by 0.6 percent of GDP by 2025.
- Custom duties amounted to €130 million in 2019; VAT and excise duties are calculated on import values that include custom duties.

### Strengthening governance and fighting corruption
- Efforts to enhance governance and reduce corruption should continue, including improving:
  - fiscal governance and institutions (transparency, public investment and procurement, revenue administration, POE oversight),
  - the rule of law,
  - the anti-corruption apparatus,
  - financial sector oversight,
  - remaining deficiencies in the AML/CFT framework (Annex V).
- Staff urged authorities, in line with previous Article IV and SAA recommendations, to strengthen these areas.

### Authorities’ views and requested technical assistance
- Authorities agreed on the need to rekindle the reform process and expect the pace of reforms to accelerate in the coming months.
- Before introducing any new major tax initiatives, a diagnostic of the tax system is needed; the authorities requested IMF assistance for this diagnostic.
- The Tax agency (TAK) is committed to advance to “compliance risk management” and to set strategic performance targets.
- Authorities plan to roll out remaining e-procurement modules to cover the full procurement process, enabling transparent tracking of order fulfillment and receipts of goods and services under tenders.
- Authorities requested IMF assistance for holistic approaches to wage and compensation policies and to social security.
- Authorities concurred with staff on the need for the wage bill to operate within the existing legal ceiling, while noting challenges from wage pressures.
- Authorities noted challenges to keep social security spending at bay amid numerous social demands.
- Authorities agreed that establishing and developing performance agreements and quarterly risk assessments for high risk POEs is important to improve their efficiency and sustainability.
- In line with commitments under the RFI, the authorities have shared information about MRP contents and implementation on a monthly basis, and plan to conduct special audits of MRP-related spending.

### Staff appraisal — macroeconomic and fiscal assessment
- Kosovo’s economy and population have been hit hard by the pandemic; dependence on services and diaspora-related inflows amplified the shock.
- The health system coped reasonably well but its capacity is stretched, indicating need for further investment in the sector.
- Fiscal and financial policies mitigated the shock’s impact on households and firms; Kosovo used available fiscal space to accommodate fiscal stabilizers and mitigation and recovery measures.
- Measures supported the health sector’s response, targeted those most affected, and reduced risk of avoidable bankruptcies.
- Design and targeting of most interventions was broadly appropriate, but efforts must intensify to ensure scarce fiscal resources are used effectively:
  - Transfers to firms need to be well-targeted, transparent, and their use strongly regulated to avoid abuses and maximize impact on sustaining employment, preventing bankruptcies, and preserving the payment chain.
  - The Auditor General should conduct a special audit of all MRP-related spending to ensure that legislation preventing conflicts of interest in procurement is respected.
- Policy support should not be withdrawn prematurely; the budget for 2021 strikes an appropriate balance between supporting the economy and preserving fiscal buffers.
- Authorities need to firm up uncommitted borrowing in the financing program for 2021; if not forthcoming, they will need to reduce the fiscal deficit by reprioritizing spending to reach those most affected while minimizing use of fiscal buffers.
- Preserving fiscal buffers is essential in case downside risks materialize.
- Social security reforms should be actuarially sound; changes to public wage and employment policies should respect the legal wage bill ceiling.
  - Creating additional pension benefits without an actuarial analysis or reforming public sector wage policies without proper budgetary impact analysis should be avoided.
  - Any changes in wage or employment policies should respect the legal wage bill ceiling.
  - Reforms to refocus social spending to protect the most vulnerable should start in earnest.
  - Additional early withdrawals from KPST must be avoided.
  - Implementation of reforms with significant medium-term budgetary costs should wait until the recovery is well entrenched.
- Fiscal policy needs a credible consolidation path as recovery is entrenched; a clear communication strategy should highlight the temporary nature of current bonuses and transfers.
- Unifying the “investment clause” and general debt ceilings at 40 percent of GDP is essential to create room to close the infrastructure gap.
- Increasing the debt ceiling to 50 percent of GDP should be avoided, as it can create risky behavior.
- The CBK has maintained broadly adequate operational controls; a safeguards assessment found a sound legal framework but governance arrangements disrupted by Board vacancies resulting in lack of quorum.
  - The absence of a functioning Board poses significant risks and requires proactive engagement to expedite filling vacancies.
  - External audit arrangements and financial reporting continue to align with international standards.
- The banking system remains strong but close supervision is needed:
  - Banks have been generally conservative and forward-looking in increasing provisions, so lifting of forbearance should not result in financial stability risks.
  - As forbearance is lifted, supervision should ensure losses are transparently reflected.
  - Flexibility should be introduced for banks to use capital buffers to continue lending to viable firms, without diluting prudential standards or accounting requirements.
- Kosovo’s external position remained weaker than implied by fundamentals and desirable policy settings; gross international reserves (GIRs) decreased in 2020 and are just at the level considered appropriate by IMF RA metrics.
  - Use of government deposits to finance the 2021 fiscal deficit would further weaken GIRs and increase vulnerability to shocks.
  - EBA-lite results suggest the external position was weaker than warranted by fundamentals in 2020, though much of the current account gap was explained by policy actions to address the pandemic and should be gradually reversed in the next few years.
- Structural constraints limiting income convergence persist and were exacerbated by the pandemic:
  - Public investment impact remains low.
  - Quality of health and education spending lags regional standards.
  - Strengthening budget effectiveness, reducing human capital and infrastructure gaps, improving governance, and further enhancing international integration would improve the growth environment.
- The next Article IV consultation with Kosovo is expected to be conducted on the standard 12-month cycle.

### Diaspora flows and the pandemic (Box 1 key findings)
- Travel restrictions and the global economic contraction will cost Kosovo about 8 percent of GDP in diaspora flows in 2020.
- Migrant-resident ratio is within the 30 – 40 percent range.
- Over 2018–19, staff assess that the deficit in residents’ transactions in the balance of payments (37 percent of GDP) was financed by an equivalent inflow from the diaspora via tourism receipts, remittances, real estate purchases (recorded as FDI), and compensation of employees by repeated migrants.
- Kosovo’s tourism receipts accounted for close to 70 percent of its exports of goods and services in 2019.
- With data through Q3:2020, staff project that diaspora flows will contract to 29 percent of GDP in 2020.
- Lower diaspora flows reduce real estate market transactions.
- Staff project diaspora flows will recover only gradually; recovery speed depends on the pandemic and mobility restrictions, with a partial recovery in 2021 and a more forceful recovery in 2022 if vaccine rollout allows increased international mobility.
- Household Budget Survey suggests 10 – 15 percent of the typical household’s income originates in remittances, increasing the reservation wage and resulting in lower labor force participation and higher unemployment rates.
- Real estate investment by the diaspora fueled a construction boom in the capital over 2018 – 19 and increased banking sector exposure to the sector.

### Adverse scenarios and recommended policy response (Box 2 key findings)
- Two adverse scenarios considered:
  - Adverse Scenario – Persistent: assumes the virus is more difficult to contain, leading to longer social distancing and partial lockdown measures; results in GDP growth weaker than the baseline by 2 pp/year in 2021-23.
  - Adverse Scenario – Temporary: assumes GDP growth in 2021 disappoints but normalizes thereafter, with a strong rebound in 2022 and GDP converging to the baseline in the medium term.
- No-policy-response effects (assumed): increased fiscal deficit accommodated using fiscal buffers in 2021 and through increased debt beyond that.
- Policy responses:
  - Policy Response – Temporary Shock: increased fiscal deficit can be accommodated through increased financing; relaxed fiscal stance supports the economy, helps preserve international reserve buffers, and contains public debt increase.
  - Policy Response – Persistent Shock: increased fiscal deficit over 2021 – 22 should be only partially accommodated through increased debt contracting, with a view to converge to the baseline fiscal deficit by 2023; this preserves some short-term fiscal accommodation, protects international reserve buffers, and contains public debt growth in the medium term.

*Source: IMF staff report excerpt (1kosea2021001).*

### Box 4. European Union Accession Process

### Box 4. European Union Accession Process

### SAA framework and timelines
- The European Union-Kosovo Stabilization and Association Agreement (SAA) entered into force in April 2016.
- The SAA is the first contractual relationship between the European Union (EU) and Kosovo and provides a framework for dialogue and cooperation on good governance and the rule of law, competitiveness and investment climate, and employment and education, among others, consistent with the EU’s acquis.
- The SAA is expected to be progressively realized in 10 years.
- Annual reviews of implementation result in recommendations.
  - The fifth-year review (in 2021) may modify the ensuing process of association based on a thorough progress evaluation.
  - The 10th-year review (in 2026) may extend the process up to five years, through 2031.
- The SAA establishes that the EU and Kosovo should gradually establish a free trade area over a maximum of 10 years (i.e., by 2026).
- To guide SAA implementation, the European Commission (EC) and Kosovo adopted the European Reform Agenda (ERA) in November 2016.

### 2020 SAA progress report: findings
- Recognizes advancement in reform implementation but highlights that Kosovo is still in an early stage in several areas.
- The report recognizes the impact of COVID-19 in the Western Balkans and the EU and highlights EU’s efforts to support Kosovo and the region.
- Specific areas highlighted as early-stage or needing more effective action:
  - Kosovo is at an early stage in developing a functioning market economy and in its capacity to cope with competitive pressure and market forces in the EU.
  - The excessive size of the government hampers its effectiveness and credibility.
  - The judicial system is still at an early stage.
  - The Assembly continues to operate in a polarized context resulting in frequent lack of quorum and delays in legislative activity.
  - Efforts in the fight against corruption, organized crime and money laundering need to be more effective.

### Normalization with Serbia and regional developments
- The SAA commits Kosovo to continue engaging towards a sustainable improvement in relations with Serbia.
- The SAA states that policies should ensure both countries continue their respective European paths and gradual normalization of relations, while avoiding that either can block the other in these efforts.
- Kosovo’s decision in early 2020 to lift the 100 percent tariff on imports from Serbia and Bosnia and Herzegovina was welcomed by the EC and allowed a resumption of the EU-facilitated Belgrade-Pristina dialogue.
- Kosovo and Serbia signed several economic agreements under the auspices of the U.S. in September 2020, which are expected to unlock bilateral infrastructure financing.

### Visa liberalization status
- Kosovo remains the only Western Balkan Country with no visa-free access to the Schengen Area despite having met all benchmarks of the Visa Liberalization Roadmap.
- The EC started the process of visa liberalization for Kosovo in 2012.
- In July 2018, the EC confirmed that Kosovo had met the two outstanding visa liberalization requirements (the ratification of the border demarcation agreement with Montenegro, and a strengthened track-record in the fight against crime and corruption), thus fulfilling all benchmarks set out in the Visa Liberalization Roadmap.
- In March 2019, the European Parliament voted in support of the Commission’s proposal in its first reading.
- The proposal is still pending for final approval at the European Council, where a few countries continue to express reservations.

### Risk Assessment Matrix — selected risks and recommended policy responses
- Prolonged pandemic and asynchronous progress. (Medium likelihood)
  - Impact if realized: High — costly containment efforts, persistent behavioral changes, limited access and longer-than-expected vaccine deployment prompting reassessment of Kosovo’s growth prospects.
  - Recommended policy response:
    - Strengthen contingency planning.
    - Use external support where possible to finance additional healthcare spending and other support measures but be prepared to reprioritize spending and reduce tax expenditures if deficit reducing measures are needed.
    - Accelerate broad-based structural reforms to boost competitiveness and gradually reduce dependency on diaspora-related flows by increasing exports and domestic production.
- Widespread social discontent and political instability. (High likelihood)
  - Impact if realized: High — socio-economic hardship, unequal access to vaccines, growing political polarization weakening policymaking and confidence; could lead to a more difficult European path.
  - Recommended policy response:
    - Continue to implement the EU-SAA and diversify export markets.
    - Improve the business environment to support growth in exports and investment.
- Widened fiscal deficit due to pandemic-related recovery measures and/or lower revenues. (High likelihood)
  - Impact if realized: Medium — rising debt levels, lower fiscal buffers, potential emergence of expenditure arrears.
  - Recommended policy response:
    - Secure additional financing to preserve fiscal buffers at reasonable levels.
    - Allow fiscal stabilizers to work and provide space to implement needed mitigation and recovery measures.
- Domestic political stalemate intensifies. (High likelihood)
  - Impact if realized: High — absence of Parliament slows structural reforms and complicates securing new financing and recovery measures.
  - Recommended policy response:
    - Careful caretaker government budget implementation until clarity regarding uncommitted financing.
    - Continue technical work required as a foundation for pending reforms in PIM, wage policy and employment, and social security.
- Intensification of financial sector vulnerabilities. (Medium likelihood)
  - Impact if realized: High — surge in non-performing loans could lower capital adequacy and affect smaller banks' stability and lending capacity.
  - Recommended policy response:
    - CBK needs to tightly monitor loan portfolio quality and show flexibility if gaps arise in bank capital positions.
    - Restore quorum in the CBK Board to allow swift implementation or adaptation of regulations if needed.

- Note on likelihood terminology: “low” indicates a probability below 10 percent, “medium” a probability between 10 and 30 percent, and “high” a probability between 30 and 50 percent.

### Debt Sustainability Analysis — key assumptions and financing facts
- Macroeconomic assumptions:
  - Real GDP is expected to contract by 6 percent in 2020, 9.5 pp below the pre-pandemic baseline.
  - Projected medium-term recovery toward the pre-COVID-19 baseline of 4 percent, with a permanent output loss of about 7 percent relative to the pre-crisis trend.
  - Headline average inflation is projected at 0.2 percent in 2020, gradually increasing to 1.9 percent over the medium term.
  - Headline fiscal deficit is projected to increase to 7.7 and 5.9 percent of GDP in 2020 and 2021, respectively, and to gradually converge to the 2 percent of GDP fiscal rule deficit through the medium-term (expected for 2026, after the expiration of the fiscal rule’s “investment clause” in 2025).
- Public debt composition and items:
  - Public debt includes general government debt and explicit guarantees issued by the government.
  - Contingent liabilities from the privatization process (about 1.5 percent of GDP) and POE debt (around 2–3 percent of GDP) are not included in the public debt stock.
  - Beginning in 2020, the public debt stock includes €120 million of debt with KPST.
  - At end-2020, domestic debt made up about 2/3 of total debt.
  - External public debt is largely with multilaterals (IDA, EIB, EBRD, EU, and the IMF), and is denominated either in SDRs or Euros.
- Financing assumptions and 2020 financing package:
  - 2020 fiscal financing needs covered by:
    - Drawdowns from government bank balances: €200 million
    - IMF RFI financing: €51 million
    - World Bank financing: €44 million
    - EU financing (first tranche under MFA of €100 million): €50 million
    - Council of Europe (first tranche under total lending assistance of €35 million): €17.5 million
    - EU grants: €34 million
    - Sizable issuance of domestic government bonds (net): €170 million
  - The financing program for 2021 includes the second tranche of both EU and Council of Europe lending, and about €160 million of still-uncommitted financing from multilateral sources.
  - Beyond 2021, gross financing needs are expected to decrease in line with fiscal consolidation.
  - Analysis assumes additional budget support from IFIs of €57 million and €37 million in 2022 and 2023 respectively, while most external financing is expected to be associated with investment projects.
  - The budget is expected to primarily rely on domestic financing sources; the analysis assumes that over the forecast period, the average maturity of domestic debt would gradually increase from about 3.5 years in 2019 to

*Source: Box 4. European Union Accession Process, 1kosea2021001.*

### 4.5 years in 2025.

### 1kosea2021001 - 4.5 years in 2025.

### Public DSA — debt trajectory and vulnerabilities
- General government debt is projected to almost double from 17.6 percent of GDP in 2019 to around 34.1 percent of GDP in 2025.
- The debt increase reflects sizable fiscal deficits in 2020 – 21 and a moderate increase in absorption capacity of IFI financing for new capital investments beyond 2021.
- Analysis assumes the “investment clause” under the fiscal rule will remain in effect, requiring unification of the “investment clause” debt ceiling (currently at 30 percent of GDP) with the legal ceiling of 40 percent of GDP on total debt.
- Gross financing needs:
  - Peak close to 14 percent of GDP in 2020.
  - Expected to moderate to 9.4 percent of GDP in 2021.
  - Then decline and situate within the 7 - 8 percent of GDP range over 2022 – 25.
- Recommended policy actions to limit vulnerabilities from absence of external market access:
  - Implement the fiscal rule beyond 2021.
  - Increase the average maturity of domestic debt.
  - Diversify the investor base to include individuals, private businesses, and insurance companies (currently hold less than 5 percent of the total domestic debt).
  - Gradually reduce CBK holdings of government securities.
  - Limit KPST’s exposure to no more than 30 percent of its assets, in line with its legal ceiling.
  - Explore new instruments such as retail or external bonds, provided progress in strengthening public financial management.

### Public DSA — stress tests and contingent liabilities
- Contingent liabilities modeled:
  - POEs at 5 percent of GDP.
  - PAK at 1.5 percent of GDP.
- Contingent liabilities could lift the debt ratio to 36 percent of GDP.
- In none of the stress test scenarios does public debt breach the high-risk threshold of 65 percent of GDP.
- Gross financing needs do not exceed the sustainability threshold in stress tests.
- Debt composition vulnerabilities:
  - Public debt held by non-residents constitutes a limited vulnerability at the beginning of the forecast period, declining over time as debt composition shifts toward domestic debt (baseline scenario).
- Gross external requirements are above the upper early warning threshold of 15 percent of GDP for 2019 and over the projection period; this largely reflects short-term trade debt and intra-firm financing of around 9 percent of GDP.
- Staff projections indicate fiscal adjustment largely occurs only after the recovery is entrenched, with fiscal policy supportive during the worst of the downturn and adjustment postponed for 2022 and beyond.

### External DSA — external debt path and risks
- External debt-to-GDP ratio is expected to increase by 10 pp of GDP through 2025.
- Cumulated net external public borrowing in 2020 – 23 is expected at more than 9 percent of GDP reflecting a sharp step-up in IFI and other multilateral loans contracted in response to the pandemic.
- Public external debt will increase to about 10 percent of GDP by 2025 on account of moderate absorption of IFIs-financed investment.
- Creditor and currency composition at end-2020:
  - 85 percent of external public debt held by IFIs and other multilateral creditors.
  - About ½ of external public debt denominated in euros, followed by SDRs (IMF and IDA loans).
- External private debt composition:
  - Mainly short-term trade financing and FDI intercompany lending.

### External DSA — shock sensitivities and outcomes
- Non-interest current account shock:
  - A one-half standard deviation shock in 2021 – 25 (around 1½ percent of GDP) would increase external debt by about 7 pp relative to baseline, to 41 percent of GDP by 2025.
- Combined macroeconomic shock:
  - A permanent shock of one-fourth standard deviation to interest rates, growth, and current account balance would increase external debt by 4 pp.
- Overall, external debt remains sustainable under a range of shocks tested.

### Selected baseline projections and indicators (percent of GDP unless otherwise indicated)
- Nominal gross public debt:
  - 2019: 17.6
  - 2020: 24.5
  - 2021: 28.7
  - 2022: 30.4
  - 2023: 31.7
  - 2024: 32.9
  - 2025: 34.1
- Public gross financing needs:
  - 2018: 7.6
  - 2019: 7.9
  - 2020: 13.7
  - 2021: 9.4
  - 2022: 7.1
  - 2023: 7.4
  - 2024: 7.2
  - 2025: 7.8
- Real GDP growth (in percent):
  - 2018: 3.4
  - 2019: 3.8
  - 2020: 4.9
  - 2021: -6.0
  - 2022: 4.5
  - 2023: 5.5
  - 2024: 4.0
  - 2025: 4.0
- Inflation (GDP deflator, in percent):
  - 2018: 1.4
  - 2019: 1.0
  - 2020: 0.6
  - 2021: 2.1
  - 2022: -0.3
  - 2023: 1.5
  - 2024: 1.8
  - 2025: 1.9
- Change in gross public sector debt (percent of GDP, yearly):
  - 2018: 1.6
  - 2019: 0.7
  - 2020: 0.6
  - 2021: 6.9
  - 2022: 4.2
  - 2023: 1.7
  - 2024: 1.3
  - 2025: 1.2
  - Cumulative (2020–25): 16.5
- Identified debt-creating flows (percent of GDP, yearly):
  - Cumulative (2020–25): 17.0
  - Primary deficit contributions (percent of GDP, yearly): 1.9 (2018), 2.6 (2019), 2.5 (2020), 9.1 (2021), 5.5 (2022), 2.4 (2023), 2.0 (2024), 2.1 (2025); cumulative 22.9
- Automatic debt dynamics (contribution, percent of GDP):
  - 2018: -0.2
  - 2019: -0.3
  - 2020: -0.4
  - 2021: 1.2
  - 2022: -0.4
  - 2023: -1.3
  - 2024: -1.1
  - 2025: -1.2
  - Cumulative: -4.2

### External debt statistics and projections (selected)
- External debt (percent of GDP):
  - 2017: 21.6
  - 2018: 21.5
  - 2019: 21.9
  - 2020: 25.3
  - 2021: 27.8
  - 2022: 30.1
  - 2023: 31.0
  - 2024: 31.2
  - 2025: 31.4
- Change in external debt (percent of GDP):
  - 2017: 2.3
  - 2018: -0.1
  - 2019: 0.4
  - 2020: 3.7
  - 2021: 2.4
  - 2022: 2.3
  - 2023: 0.9
  - 2024: 0.2
  - 2025: 0.3
- Identified external debt-creating flows (percent of GDP, yearly):
  - 2017: 1.0
  - 2018: 2.9
  - 2019: 1.9
  - 2020: 5.8
  - 2021: 2.1
  - 2022: 1.4
  - 2023: 0.8
  - 2024: 0.5
  - 2025: 0.4
- Current account deficit, excluding interest payments (percent of GDP):
  - 2017: 5.2
  - 2018: 7.4
  - 2019: 5.3
  - 2020: 7.2
  - 2021: 6.1
  - 2022: 5.8
  - 2023: 4.9
  - 2024: 4.6
  - 2025: 4.5
- Gross external financing need (in millions of USD and percent of GDP):
  - 2017: 1215 (16.8 percent of GDP)
  - 2018: 1531 (19.3 percent of GDP)
  - 2019: 1444 (18.2 percent of GDP)
  - 2020: 1658 (21.4 percent of GDP)
  - 2021: 1661 (19.6 percent of GDP)
  - 2022: 1767 (19.3 percent of GDP)
  - 2023: 1797 (18.4 percent of GDP)
  - 2024: 1911 (18.5 percent of GDP)
  - 2025: 2068 (18.9 percent of GDP)

*Source: IMF staff.*

### Annex III. External Sector Assessment

### Annex III. External Sector Assessment

### A. External Balance
- Kosovo’s current account deficit increased from 5.5 percent of GDP in 2019 to 7.5 percent in 2020, reflecting COVID-19 mitigation and recovery measures and a significant decrease in diaspora-related flows.
- Current account structure is mainly shaped by flows originating in the Kosovar diaspora: large trade deficit in goods financed by diaspora-related inflows in tourism, remittances, compensation of employees, FDI in real estate, and other unaccounted diaspora-related flows reflected in relatively large errors and omissions.
- Goods and services balance developments in 2020:
  - Trade deficit in goods estimated to have declined to 37.5 percent of GDP (40 percent in 2019), driven by decreasing imports and increasing exports.
  - Goods imports estimated to have decreased by close to 7 percent; import volumes fell by about 2 percent and import prices were lower.
  - Goods exports recovered in 2020, with external sales of metals rebounding; Ferronickel (an Albanian company) strongly increased production and redirected exports to Albania.
  - Surplus in the services balance contracted to 5.8 percent of GDP (13.1 percent in 2019), mainly reflecting a decrease in diaspora-related tourism as visitors declined by about 60 percent through Q3:2020.
  - Pre-crisis deficit in the balance of goods and services was 26.9 percent of GDP in 2019, larger than the regional average of 15.3 percent of GDP.
- Financing of the 2020 deficit in goods and services:
  - Recorded remittances increased and offset the decrease in unrecorded remittances; remittances were 13.6 percent of GDP in 2020 (almost unchanged with respect to 2019).
  - Compensation of employees assessed to have remained virtually unchanged at 3.7 percent of GDP in 2020.
  - Net FDI inflows estimated at 3.2 percent of GDP (3 percent of GDP in 2019), benefiting from reinvested earnings by foreign bank subsidiaries and some real-estate investment.
  - Net portfolio investment estimated at 0.5 percent of GDP in 2020 (compared to outflows of 0.8 percent of GDP in 2019) as KPST repatriated funds to finance early withdrawals authorized for COVID-19 relief.
  - Financing of the fiscal deficit resulted in inflows of 3.1 percent of GDP in 2020 (up from 2 percent of GDP in 2019).
  - CBK Gross International Reserves (GIRs, CBK definition) estimated to have decreased by 1.2 percent of GDP in 2020 (compared to an increase of 1.5 percent of GDP in 2019).
- Net International Investment Position (NIIP):
  - Negative NIIP assessed to have further deteriorated in 2020, mainly due to decreases of KPST and CBK external assets and increases in public debt.
- Outlook:
  - Current account projected to improve in 2021 as travel restrictions are gradually lifted and growth rebounds in Advanced Europe, pushing tourism receipts upwards.
  - Rebound of growth expected to result in a slight deterioration in the balance of goods as both imports and exports increase.
  - Financing structure expected to continue relying on multilateral official sources and FDI.
  - NIIP expected to continue deteriorating partly on account of IFI disbursements for budget support and project financing.

### B. Real Exchange Rate (EBA-Lite) Assessment
- EBA-lite findings for 2020:
  - CA model results in a CA norm of -4.8 percent of GDP, yielding a CA gap of -2.9 percent of GDP for 2020.
  - CA (Projected at end-2020) = -7.5 (percent of GDP).
  - Cyclical Contributions (from model) = 0.4.
  - Cyclically adjusted CA = -7.7.
  - CA (Norm, from model) = -4.8.
  - Cyclically adjusted CA Norm = -5.2.
  - CA-Gap = -2.9 (of which, Policy gap = 5.3).
  - Elasticity = -0.27.
  - REER Gap = 10.7 (percent).
- Interpretation:
  - Assessment indicates external position remained weaker than implied by medium-term fundamentals and desirable policy settings in 2020, suggesting a REER overvaluation of about 10 percent (similar to that in the 2018 Article IV).
  - A large portion of the current account gap is attributed to the cost of COVID-19 relief measures (driving fiscal and current account deficits upwards) and mobility restrictions constraining tourism flows. Staff assess a large part of the gap will self-correct as the pandemic is brought under control, as suggested by medium-term projections.
  - The External Sustainability (ES) approach yields a lower current account gap and REER overvaluation: CA gap = -1.3 percent of GDP and REER overvaluation = 4.5 percent.
- Data limitation:
  - Short time series available for Kosovo (13 years of data) do not allow estimation of a reliable REER model for Kosovo.

### C. Reserve Adequacy Assessment
- Composition of liability counterpart of CBK reserves at end-2019 (16 percent of GDP):
  - PAK deposits = €275 million.
  - TSA deposits = €444 million.
  - Banks’ mandatory and excess reserves = €415 million.
- GIR adequacy and definitions:
  - Standard definition: GIR includes nonresidents’ currency and deposits, securities, monetary gold and SDR, reserve position in the Fund, and other items.
  - CBK’s (Conservative) definition: Standard GIR net of PAK and KPST deposits.
  - Staff’s alternative definition: Standard GIR net of banks’ excess reserves.
- GIR adequacy developments:
  - Using the standard definition, GIRs declined from around 120 percent of the IMF RA metric in 2019 to 103 percent in 2020. The main driver was the use of about €200 million of government deposits to finance the 2020 fiscal deficit.
- IMF (2011) Reserve Adequacy (RA) metric for fixed exchange rate economies:
  - RA = 10% X + 30% STD + 10% BM + 20% OPL, where X is export revenues, STD is short-term external debt, BM is broad money and OPL is other external liabilities.
- Modified RA metric for Kosovo (to reflect remittance inflows and deposit outflow risk in a euroized economy):
  - RA = 10% (X+R) + 30% STD + 15% D + 20% OPL.
  - Using this modified RA metric suggests Kosovo’s GIRs are at a lower-than-adequate level.
- Quantitative reserve adequacy metrics (selected figures from Table 4):
  - Standard GIR (millions of euros): 2019 = 1,164; 2020 = 1,142 (Prel.).
  - Percent of RA metric (Standard GIR): 2019 = 136; 2020 = 121; 2020 Prel. = 103.
  - Percent of RA modified metric (Standard GIR): 2019 = 106; 2020 = 94; 2020 Prel. = 79.
  - Conservative GIR (millions of euros): 2019 = 864; 2020 = 781; 2020 Prel. = 798.
  - Percent of RA metric (Conservative GIR): 2019 = 92; 2020 = 82; 2020 Prel. = 77.
  - GIR, net of excess reserves (millions of euros): 2019 = 899; 2020 = 734; 2020 Prel. = 726.
  - Percent of RA metric (GIR net of excess reserves): 2019 = 112; 2020 = 96; 2020 Prel. = 76.
  - Percent of RA modified metric (GIR net of excess reserves): 2019 = 88; 2020 = 74; 2020 Prel. = 58.
- Fiscal and bank liquidity buffers:
  - Fiscal buffer rule of thumb (IMF 2013): minimum fiscal reserves = one month of spending plus debt service ≈ €299 million (4.4 percent of GDP) for Kosovo.
  - Actual fiscal reserves in 2020 = €278 million (excluding ELA) or 4 percent of GDP.
  - Banks’ own liquid assets were 30 percent of short-term liabilities in 2019 (first line of defense against banking shocks).
  - ELA reserves around €100 million in 2020, insufficient to respond to a systemic shock.
  - CBK negotiated a repo line to borrow euro liquidity from the ECB (via Deutsche Bundesbank) against collateral of euro-denominated marketable debt securities issued by Euro Area governments and supranational institutions of €100 million; repo line remains in place until March 2022 unless an extension is decided.
  - Capacity of foreign subsidiaries to withstand a deposit run is stronger than that of domestically owned banks.

Italic: Source: Annex III. External Sector Assessment, 1kosea2021001.

### Annex V. Implementation Status of the 2018 Article IV Recommendations

### Annex V. Implementation Status of the 2018 Article IV Recommendations

### Public investment and spending efficiency
- Implementation status: Weak compliance.
- Key findings:
  - In 2019, absorption of donor-financed investment under the “investment clause” was small.
  - Overall execution of capital projects continued to be slow, with high seasonality in the last quarter of the year.
  - No ex-post audits of major investment projects have been initiated.
  - The public investment framework needs strengthening to ensure alignment of national strategies with the budget through multi-annual planning.

### Revenue administration and mobilization
- Implementation status: Partial compliance.
- Key findings:
  - TAK progressed in streamlining function-based organizational structures, adopted modern compliance risk management (pilot in the construction sector), scaled up tax debt compliance, strengthened tax audit, and improved the VAT refund process.
  - Changes to CIT legislation allowing tax credits for sponsorship activities introduced a window for revenue risks in 2020.
  - Authorities are yet to engage in a comprehensive cost-benefit assessment of tax expenditures.

### Fiscal institutions and governance
- Implementation status: Partial compliance.
- Key findings:
  - The 2019 MTEF enhanced fiscal risk analysis and included reconciliations between MTEF vintages but continued to rely on unrealistic revenue projections.
  - A draft law on POEs was submitted to the government but returned.
  - Most modules of e-procurement have been rolled out in full, but coverage of centralized procurement has stalled; progress is needed to ensure value-for-money.

### Labor market, skills, and social benefits
- Implementation status: Weak compliance.
- Key findings:
  - Enrollment in Vocational Training Centers and gross child enrolment at pre-school and pre-primary levels increased since the last Article IV.
  - Action plans and sector strategies exist, but reforms to increase preschool enrollment rates, improve teacher quality, modernize curricula and textbooks, upgrade vocational education and training programs, strengthen accreditation and professional standards, and improve labor market intermediation remain at an early stage.
  - No progress made to re-establish the rules-based minimum wage setting mechanism established in 2013; authorities have abstained from discretionary increases to date.

### Rule of law, property rights, and judiciary reforms
- Implementation status: Mixed compliance for business environment; partial compliance for rule of law and judiciary reforms.
- Key findings:
  - Progress on private enforcement agents (PEAs) and amendments to the Law on Execution Procedure, but no new recruitment of PEAs to fill remaining positions and the PEA monitoring unit is yet to be created.
  - Creation of a commercial court is still under consideration.
  - Property registration and cadaster reforms advanced with implementation of the Kosovo Geoportal; more is needed to strengthen the Kosovo Cadaster Agency’s institutional framework and technical infrastructure and complete privatization of public houses.
  - The revised law on asset confiscation and whistle-blowers was adopted in 2019 in line with EC recommendations.
  - The amended Law on the State Prosecutor has been partially implemented: 15 prosecutors recruited to the Special Prosecution Office out of a planned number.
  - The Assembly adopted the revised Criminal Code but has yet to adopt the new Criminal Procedure Code (which includes provisions on suspension of public officials indicted for corruption).
  - Limited progress in fight against corruption: delays in investigation/prosecution of high-level cases and confiscation of assets originating from corruption activities.

### Financial sector: access to credit and AML/CFT
- Implementation status: Mixed compliance overall.
- Reduce structural impediments to lending:
  - Status: Partial compliance.
  - Broad-based credit growth prior to the 2020 COVID-19 pandemic reflected easing of supply constraints as claims enforcement became more effective.
  - Further steps needed: create a commercial court and develop a housing price index to strengthen contract enforcement and reduce information asymmetries.
- Address AML/CFT deficiencies:
  - Status: Weak compliance.
  - Technical compliance improved in some areas and progress under PECK II on drafting/implementing legal and institutional reforms.
  - Effectiveness of AML/CFT regime remains highly unsatisfactory:
    - Divided supervisory framework impedes AML/CFT supervision effectiveness in the financial sector.
    - Volume of ML/TF cases ultimately prosecuted and adjudicated remains negligibly low.
    - Continuous non-compliance with international sanctions regimes persists regarding TF and proliferation.
    - Legislative framework still needs alignment with FATF standards and the EU acquis: introduction of sanctions for TF, beneficial owner identification requirements, and implementation of targeted financial sanctions mechanisms.

### Appendix I — COVID-19: Health impact (comparative)
- Containment and infection dynamics:
  - Kosovo implemented strict early lockdown measures; lockdown measures started in early March when daily new cases were below 10 per million.
  - Average daily infection rate peaked in April at less than half the peak rate observed in advanced European economies (AE).
  - After relaxation in May-June, a second more severe wave emerged in summer; a third stronger wave ongoing since late October with containment measures reintroduced.
  - As of mid-January 2021, the number of daily new cases stood at 147 per million (higher than the summer’s peak of 132, but below the most recent peak of 412 in November).
  - This compares to a recent average of 234 per million in WBCs.
- Testing and mortality:
  - Kosovo’s testing rate is less than half of the WBC’s average (231,000 per million). Testing in AE averages 597,000 per million.
  - Kosovo’s mortality rate increased to 2.5 percent of reported cases, above averages for both WBCs and AE.
  - As of mid-January, the 7-day average of daily confirmed COVID-19 deaths stood at 5 per million in WBCs compared to around 8 per million in AE and 4 per million in Europe’s emerging market economies (EE).
- Health infrastructure:
  - Kosovo falls behind regional peers on health infrastructure: number of ICU beds is lower per capita than in other WBCs and only a fraction of those in Germany and other AE countries.
  - Respirator numbers increased in some WBCs (including Kosovo) but remain insufficient.
  - Strengthening health infrastructure is crucial to improve service quality during the pandemic and curb spread.

### Appendix I — COVID-19: Macroeconomic impact
- Output and sectoral effects:
  - Real GDP through Q3:2020 declined by a median of 4.9 percent (y/y) in the WBCs; Kosovo’s GDP contracted by 7.3 percent (y/y).
  - Available data suggests recovery rebounded on a sequential seasonally adjusted basis in Q3:2020 but subsided in Q4:2020.
  - Hospitality and construction were among hardest hit sectors:
    - Business turnover in Kosovo’s hospitality sector dropped by about 40 percent (y/y) through November 2020.
    - Construction sector turnover decreased 10 percent (y/y) over the same period; construction activity broadly held up in H2:2020.
- GDP projections and output losses:
  - Kosovo’s GDP is expected to contract 6 percent in 2020 (WBCs median 6.2 percent).
  - Comparators: AE expected contraction 7.3 percent; EE 2.8 percent.
  - For 2021, Kosovo’s GDP rebound projected at 4.5 percent (WBCs median 5.2 percent).
  - Relative to pre-COVID projections, output loss in Kosovo through 2021 is projected at 9.2 percentage points (pp); WBCs median 8.4 pp; AE 6.2 pp; EE 3.9 pp.
- Banking, fiscal, reserves:
  - Banking sector deposits have remained stable in Kosovo and other WBCs; lending levels withheld relatively well due to regulatory forbearance.
  - Kosovo’s emergency fiscal package in 2020 comprised measures amounting to 4.3 percent of GDP (broadly in line with median fiscal support in other WBCs).
  - Kosovo’s COVID-19 package contained fewer guarantees (contingent costs) compared to peers.
  - Kosovo’s 2021 budget includes additional measures for about 3 percent of GDP.
  - Implementation of relief packages and fiscal revenue losses (median of 11.4 percent for WBCs) pushed fiscal deficits and public debt ratios higher.
  - Kosovo’s public debt is estimated to have reached 24.5 percent of GDP at end-2020 (up from 17.5 percent of GDP in 2019); regional median about 55 percent in 2020 (up from 46.5 percent in 2019).
  - Unlike other WBCs, Kosovo does not have a sovereign rating and thus has no access to the Eurobond market.
  - Use of government deposits in Kosovo (for about 3 percent of GDP) to finance the 2020 fiscal deficit led to a decrease in gross international reserves to a level just in line with the IMF reserve adequacy metric.

### Appendix II — Policy response to COVID-19 (measures and amounts)
- Initial fiscal package and later additions:
  - At onset (March 2020) government announced a €180 million emergency fiscal package to support firms and households.
  - In June 2020 additional allocations in the 2020 mid-year budget review to mitigate the pandemic and jumpstart recovery.
  - Measures to support credit included increasing guaranteed portion of loans by Kosovo Credit Guarantee Fund from 50 percent to 80 percent and improving selection criteria.
  - Measures allowed early withdrawals of up to 10 percent of KPST individual pension accounts (estimated at €200 million), a majority of which will be gradually reimbursed by the budget beginning in 2023.
  - Despite delays, the MRP was largely implemented in 2020.
  - At end-2020, total budgetary spending on COVID-19 measures amounted to €288 million while extra-budgetary spending with KPST withdrawals was €184 million.
- Central Bank (CBK) measures:
  - March: allowed a 3-month loan payment moratorium, which reached about 50 percent of loans.
  - June: allowed loan restructurings of up to one year.
- Summary financial table (as reported in source):
  - Euro million  % of GDP  Euro million  % of GDP
  - Total Mitigation and Recovery Measures
  - Total294.64.3287.34.2
  - Goods and Services27.70.423.80.3
  - Wages and salaries34.00.534.00.5
  - Capital expenditures1.50.00.60.0
  - Utilities0.20.00.20.0
  - Subsidies and transfers231.13.4228.83.4
  - Recovery Package (August ‐ December 2020)
  - Total122.41.8118.21.7
  - Goods and Services6.80.14.00.1
  - Wages and salaries0.20.00.20.0
  - Capital expenditures0.00.00.00.0
  - Utilities0.10.00.10.0
  - Subsidies and transfers115.31.7113.91.7
  - Mitigation Package (March ‐ July 2020)
  - Total172.22.5169.12.5
  - Goods and Services20.90.319.70.3
  - Wages and salaries33.80.533.80.5
  - Capital expenditures1.50.00.60.0
  - Utilities0.10.00.10.0
  - Subsidies and transfers115.81.7114.81.7
  - Source: IMF staff calculations and Kosovar authorities (Executed Budget)
- Selected implemented measures and amounts:
  - Tax revenue measures: postponement of tax declarations until end-April 2020 for specified taxes; VAT exemptions on imports of wheat and flour during March 25 - May 8, 2020.
  - Health and social sector allocations:
    - PPE and facilities: €11 million.
    - Other goods and services: €18 million.
    - Financial support for youth employment, civil society, cultural/artistic/sports activities: €2.5 million.
    - Regional development transfers: €1 million.
    - Transfers to minority communities: €1 million.
    - Support for projects to improve position of women: €1 million.
    - Support to municipalities: €1 million.
  - Measures supporting individuals and households:
    - Subsidies to businesses to pay salaries in March-April: €170 per month/worker, €47 million.
    - Additional payment (€30/month) to beneficiaries of social and pension schemes receiving < €100/month for April-June: €7.5 million and October-December: €7.5 million.
    - Salary bonus for health and security sector workers (April-June and August-December): €34 million.
    - Salary bonus €100/month for grocery stores, bakeries and pharmacies (April-May): €3 million.
    - Subsidies to businesses to pay salaries for new employees hired: €5 million.
    - Financial support to cover insurance premiums: €3 million.
  - Measures supporting firms:
    - Recapitalization of Kosovo Credit Guarantee Fund: €21 million.
    - Unconditional subsidies to formal businesses (allocated proportionally by business size): €60 million.
    - Subsidies to cover rental expenses during April-May: €10 million.
    - Subsidies to cover employer’s pension contribution (5 percent of gross wages) for April-May: €5 million.
    - Increased transfers to support agriculture programs: €12 million.
    - Subsidies to POEs to cover minimum operating costs: €11.5 million.
    - Other subsidies and transfers: €26 million.
    - Support for POE investments through sovereign guarantees for loans by financial institutions.
  - Monetary and financial measures:
    - Postponement of loan installment payments for businesses and individuals for March – June 2020; regulatory forbearance on loan provisions and capital requirements on reprogrammed loans.
    - Up to 1-year bank loan reprogramming allowed for July – September 2020.

*Annex V. Implementation Status of the 2018 Article IV Recommendations — IMF staff summary as presented in source PDF*

### Appendix III. Kosovo’s Pension System: Challenges and Areas for

### Appendix III. Kosovo’s Pension System: Challenges and Areas for Reform

### Background
- Structure:
  - Three pillars: Pillar 0 (budget-financed uniform benefit), Pillar 2 (individual account defined contribution scheme managed by the Kosovo Pension Savings Trust — KPST), Pillar 3 (voluntary individual or employer-sponsored schemes).
  - Pillar 0 is covered by the law “On Pension Schemes Financed by the State” No.04/L-131. Since 2016, the law disallows beneficiaries of any of these pensions to receive more than one pension (Art 16).
- Fiscal trajectory and scale:
  - Subsidies and transfers increased from about 5.5 percent of GDP in 2010 to 9.4 percent of GDP in 2020 (excluding COVID-19 related measures).
  - The share of Pillar 0 in subsidies and transfers increased from 40 to 60 percent.
  - Pillar 0 currently reaches about 200,000 beneficiaries at a cost of about 5.7 percent of GDP.
  - Pillar 2’s pension accounts represented 30 percent of GDP in 2019.
- Pillar 0 composition and figures (in percent of GDP, selected aggregates):
  - Social Security: 2007‐10 2.11; 2011‐15 2.73; 2016‐19 4.53; 2020 5.66
  - Old‐age Pensions: 2007‐10 2.03; 2011‐15 2.61; 2016‐19 3.36; 2020 4.33
  - Basic pensions: 2007‐10 1.37; 2011‐15 1.67; 2016‐19 1.87; 2020 2.43
  - "Contributory" pensions: 2007‐10 0.66; 2011‐15 0.94; 2016‐19 1.49; 2020 1.90
  - Special regimes: 2007‐10 0.08; 2011‐15 0.12; 2016‐19 1.17; 2020 1.33
  - Trepça pensions: 2007‐10 0.07; 2011‐15 0.07; 2016‐19 0.06; 2020 0.05
  - KPC and KSF Pensions: 2007‐10 0.01; 2011‐15 0.02; 2016‐19 0.04; 2020 0.07
  - Pensions for war veterans: 2007‐10 0.00; 2011‐15 0.00; 2016‐19 0.02; 2020 1.13
  - Early retirement due to work‐related disability: 0.00 across periods shown
  - Payments to survivors of "contributory" pensions: 2007‐10 0.00; 2011‐15 0.00; 2016‐19 0.04; 2020 0.06
  - Memorandum: Subsidies and Transfers: 2007‐10 5.49; 2011‐15 6.12; 2016‐19 8.23; 2020 12.73 (excluding COVID‑19 mitigation and recovery measures -- -- -- 9.39)
- Pillar 0 benefit types and eligibility:
  - Basic pension (€90/month): Resident citizens aged 65 and older without any other transfers paid through the Ministry of Labor and Social Welfare (MLSW). Semi-annual, in-person registration required.
  - “Contributory” pension (avg. €206/month): Resident citizens aged 65 and older who made social security contributions for at least 15 years prior to 1999. Before 2016 flat €140/month; from 2016 beneficiaries receive €158–230 depending on educational attainment. Semi-annual, in-person registration required. Fully budget‑funded.
  - Special regimes expanded markedly; combined budgetary cost rose from 0.2 percent of GDP in 2015 to about 1.3 percent of GDP in 2020.
  - Examples of special regimes and typical payments:
    - Early pension for Trepča miners (€150/month): Former miners aged 50–65 with at least 10 years of contributions and work-related disability >50 percent.
    - Kosovo Protection Corps (KPC) pension (avg. €236/month): Payable to individuals aged 45 and older with at least 5 years of service at KPC; pensions amount to 50 percent of the 3-year average salary for ages 45–50 and 70 percent for those above 50.
    - Kosovo Security Forces (KSF) pension (avg. €386/month): Payable to individuals aged 50 and older with at least 20 years of service at KSF; pensions amount to 40 percent of last gross salary plus 2 percent for each year of service up to 60 percent maximum.
    - KLA war veteran pension (€170/month): Payable regardless of age to KLA members who remained active until the end of the war; those with active employment are not eligible per law, but categorization incomplete and pensions currently paid regardless of continued work.
    - Work disability pension (€75/month): Individuals with a 100 percent work-related disability eligible for early retirement since 2018.
    - Family pension (€75/month): Available since 2018 to surviving family members of individuals who either contributed 15 years before 1999 or had a 100 percent work-related disability.
- Special regimes and war-related benefits:
  - KLA war veteran pensions dominated special regimes spending; legislated cap 0.7 percent of GDP but actual payments exceeded the cap (1.1 percent of GDP in 2020).
  - Expenditures on war-related benefits payable to working age people represented about 20 percent of Subsidies and Transfers in 2020 (up from about 5 percent a decade ago).
  - Additional war-related transfers (outside pensions) include compensation to families of those fallen in the war; compensation to war invalids (0.6 percent of GDP in 2020); compensation to civilian war invalids.
- Pillar 2 (KPST) specifics:
  - Mandatory DC scheme: worker contribution 5 percent of gross salary matched by 5 percent employer contribution.
  - KPST comprises 380,000 active contributors, average age 41 years (as of December 2019); about 26 percent of contributors are employees of budget organizations.
  - Distribution skew: 80 percent of total contributors account for less than 30 percent of KPST’s total assets; average savings balance for this group less than €4,800. Half of contributors have savings below €1,000.
  - In 2019, about 7,900 pension beneficiaries were already withdrawing from accounts.
  - KPST assets: about €2 billion at end-2020 after government decision to allow 10 percent early withdrawals. In absence of early withdrawals, end-2020 assets would have been about €2.2 billion (or more than 32 percent of GDP).
  - KPST asset management: regulated by bylaws to minimize concentration, liquidity and solvency risks; quarterly reporting on accounts, beneficiaries and assets; low operational costs and administration fees.
- Pillar 3: Two types of supplementary funds (Supplementary Employee Fund and Supplementary Individual Fund FONDI), but assets are very small.

### Current Challenges
- Multiplicity and proliferation of non-contributory Pillar 0 schemes:
  - Has endangered sustainability of public finances through unfunded liabilities.
  - Negatively affected income distribution and reduced system simplicity and efficiency.
  - KLA War Veterans’ Pension cost 1.1 percent of GDP in 2020, making it the third largest item in subsidies and transfers behind basic pensions (2.4 percent of GDP) and contributory pensions (1.9 percent of GDP).
- Political economy and governance:
  - Different schemes primarily reflect political bargaining power; socio-economic needs play a limited role.
  - Existing and planned schemes lack an overarching social policy vision and architecture; regulations are often inconsistent and contradictory.
  - Despite the law, many beneficiaries receive duplicate benefits. Controls over benefits paid to Kosovars residing abroad are inadequate (notably for special pensions).
- Pressures for new regimes and relaxed eligibility:
  - Demand to create new special regimes or relax existing eligibility (e.g., early retirement and special pensions for police; lowering contribution years for contributory pension) poses short- and medium-term fiscal risks.
  - Proposed initiatives (e.g., MLSW consideration of a pay-as-you-go Pillar 1 funded by an increase of contributions of 1.5 pp paid by both workers and employers) have not been analyzed with long-term actuarial tables.
- Disability assessment and eligibility inconsistencies:
  - Disability assessment methods and eligibility benchmarks are not uniformly applied.
  - Permanent disability pension beneficiaries need reassessment every 1, 3, and 5 years; war disability beneficiaries need only a one-time assessment for partial disability at application.
  - Family pensions provide permanent (instead of temporary) benefits to working-age survivors.
  - Pensions for former KSF and KPC are not determined based on contributions.
- Pillar 2 payout design and longevity risk:
  - Current KPST payout period: typically 10 years; recommendation to align payout with life-expectancy at retirement could extend payout period to possibly 15 years, with longevity risk covered by basic and contributory pensions.
  - Low benefits and short payout period for today’s recipients reflect short contribution histories and weak enforcement of contribution payments more than design flaws.
- Short-term policy risks:
  - Allowing 10 percent early withdrawals undermined Pillar 2 integrity and is regressive; further similar actions should be avoided.

### Policy Recommendations: A Summary
- Moratorium on further expansions:
  - In the short-term, refrain from introducing new special regimes or relaxing eligibility criteria of existing regimes, especially given pandemic-related uncertainty and fiscal constraints.
  - Further special regimes would reduce room for targeted basic pensions, social assistance, and other spending including capital projects.
- Actuarial and fiscal analysis before reforms:
  - Any reforms to social security (including new benefits) should await analysis assessing medium- to long-term budgetary cost of existing schemes.
  - Kosovo’s legislation currently mandates a 3-year costing projection before introducing new social security schemes; this is insufficient given multi‑decadal fiscal commitments.
  - Reforms should be holistic, fit in a well-articulated policy vision, and not be piecemeal. Consider objectives: encouraging employment, protecting the poor, ensuring fiscal sustainability, enabling fast and effective administration.
- Contribution increases conditional on broader diagnostic:
  - Increases in pension contributions should proceed only after a comprehensive tax policy diagnostic is updated (last such analysis in 2012).
  - Any contribution increases should consider impacts on employment informality and the space needed to finance planned health insurance scheme increases.
- Reform war-related pension regulations to preserve fiscal space and curtail inequities:
  - Revise eligibility periods, introduce a nominal ceiling on total benefits received, place a cap on monthly withdrawals to ensure longer withdrawal eligibility.
  - Complete pending categorization of veterans to ensure budgetary cost abides by the 0.7 percent of GDP ceiling.
  - Limit eligibility to resident citizens and introduce strict residency controls, especially for special pensions.
  - For contributory pensions, assess the fixed number of possible beneficiaries to estimate timing of budgetary cost peak.
- Protect Pillar 2 integrity:
  - Avoid policy actions that undermine Pillar 2 (e.g., repeated early withdrawals). Such actions are regressive and undermine long-term pension adequacy.

*Prepared by Oana Luca and Selim Thaci. Source: Appendix III. Kosovo’s Pension System: Challenges and Areas for Reform.*

### References

### References — Republic of Kosovo Staff Report for the 2020 Article IV Consultation — Informational Annex

### Fund relations (as of July 31, 2020)
- Membership: Joined June 29, 2009; Article XIV.
- Quota: 82.60 (SDR Million) — 100.00 percent.
- Fund holdings of currency: 180.17 (SDR Million) — 218.12 percent.
- Reserve Tranche Position: 20.07 (SDR Million) — 24.29 percent.
- SDR Department net cumulative allocation: 55.37 (SDR Million) — 100.00 percent.
- SDR Department holdings: 50.0890.45 (note: preserved exactly as in source).
- Outstanding Purchases and Loans: Stand-By Arrangements 76.33 (SDR Million) — 92.4 percent quota.
- Emergency Assistance: 41.350.00 (note: preserved exactly as in source).
- Recent arrangements and drawings (as presented):
  - Stand-By arrangements with various dates and amounts (examples preserved in source table format):
    - Amounts approved/drawn (SDR Million) include: 147.50 / 90.97; 135.40 / 78.22; 92.66 / 18.76.
  - RFI: Apr 10, 2020 — Apr 15, 2020; Amount Approved 41.30 (SDR Million); Amount Drawn 41.30 (SDR Million).
- Overdue obligations and projected payments (SDR Million; forthcoming):
  - 2020: Principal 23.31; Charges/Interest 0.65; Total 23.96.
  - 2021: Principal 43.11; Charges/Interest 0.87; Total 43.98.
  - 2022: Principal 9.90; Charges/Interest 0.50; Total 10.40.
  - 2023: Principal 10.33; Charges/Interest 0.43; Total 10.75.
  - 2024: Principal 20.65; Charges/Interest 0.24; Total 20.89.
- Implementation: HIPC Initiative — Not Applicable; MDRI — Not Applicable; CCR — Not Applicable.
- Safeguards assessment findings:
  - CBK maintains broad operational controls.
  - All recommendations from previous safeguards assessment have been implemented.
  - Recent Board vacancies resulted in lack of a quorum; absence of a functioning Board poses substantial governance and oversight risks.
  - CBK Act protects autonomy; audit mechanisms and financial reporting aligned with international standards.
  - Implementation of the risk management framework is advancing.
- Exchange arrangements:
  - De jure and de facto arrangement: one of no separate legal tender.
  - Euro is legal tender in Kosovo; Kosovo is not part of the euro area and CBK is not part of the European System of Central Banks.
  - Kosovo is an Article VIII member and does not maintain exchange restrictions or multiple currency practices (except security-related restrictions notified pursuant to Decision No. 144).
- Previous Article IV consultation concluded October 8th, 2020; expected 12-month cycle going forward.
- FSAP and ROSC participation:
  - FSAP mission: September 19–October 2, 2012.
  - FSSA included ROSC for compliance with Basel Core Principles.
  - Kosovo has not had a data or fiscal transparency ROSC.
- Technical assistance highlights since 1999, including to UNMIK and Kosovo since September 2008, in areas: fiscal policy, banking and payments systems, macroeconomic statistics, legal and institutional frameworks.
- Resident Representative: Ms. Eble took post June 14, 2019.

### Relations to other international financial institutions
- References to institution pages preserved as in source:
  - EBRD: link as provided in source.
  - European Investment Bank: link as provided in source.
  - World Bank: link as provided in source.

### Statistical issues — Assessment of data adequacy for surveillance
- General: Data provision adequate for surveillance; statistical agencies face considerable shortages of financial and human resources.
- National Accounts:
  - Compilation methods broadly in line with the 2008 SNA/ESA2010.
  - Data on GDP by economic activity and by expenditure published simultaneously in excel with a delay of 10 months.
  - Quarterly national accounts provide a first estimate of annual GDP by April every year, but time lag in ANA dissemination should be reduced.
  - Quarterly GDP data can be inconsistent with annual data, requiring significant revisions; methodology improvements needed.
  - Need to improve and develop high-frequency (monthly) indicators, prioritizing wholesale and retail trade data and services.
- Labor markets: Reliable labor force data challenging due to large informal economy; quarterly labor data published since 2016.
- Consumer Price Index (CPI) and HICP:
  - Monthly CPI produced since 2002; published monthly with a lag of 13 days.
  - CPI uses COICOP-compatible item classification with 352 elementary aggregates.
  - New index introduced December 2014; HICP available from January 2010 onward.
  - HICP rebased from 2002 to 2015 in January 2016.
  - Kosovo receives TA from Eurostat.
- Government Finance Statistics (GFS):
  - Monthly budget execution reports on cash basis provided five weeks after month end.
  - GFS broadly follow GFSM 2001/GFSM 2014, but budget classification not consistent with GFSM 2014 because:
    - (i) data is on cash basis, not accrual;
    - (ii) lending for policy purposes (similar to subsidies) is included after calculating the primary balance;
    - (iii) capital transfers should be included in current expenditure instead of capital expenditure;
    - (iv) memorandum of understanding (MOU) should be properly classified depending on final purpose;
    - (v) annual budget documents should specify both current and capital spending related to individual projects.
  - Strengthening monitoring and disclosure of arrears is important.
- Monetary and Financial Statistics:
  - Monetary data broadly consistent with MFSMCG 2016.
  - CBK reports monetary data monthly using Standardized Report Forms; published in International Financial Statistics.
  - CBK ceased compiling currency in circulation in 2006 due to difficulties estimating Euro currency in circulation, underreporting broad money.
- Financial Sector Surveillance:
  - CBK reports Financial Soundness Indicators (FSIs) monthly; all 12 core and 7 encouraged indicators for deposit takers are available.
- External Sector Statistics:
  - CBK provides quarterly BOP and IIP data following BPM6 starting with 2013: Q1.
  - Participates in Coordinated Direct Investment Survey (inward and outward from 2010), Coordinated Portfolio Investment Survey (annual from December 2010; semiannual from June 2013), and Quarterly External Debt Statistics.
  - Direction of trade data available monthly.
  - Authorities working towards reporting the international reserves and foreign currency liquidity template.
- Data standards and quality:
  - Kosovo participates in the enhanced General Data Dissemination System (e-GDDS); National Summary Data Page disseminates e-GDDS data since May 11, 2017.
  - Kosovo has not had a Data ROSC.

### Table of Common Indicators Required for Surveillance (As of January 21, 2021)
- Dates of latest observation and date received/reported online are preserved in source table for multiple indicators (examples include):
  - International Reserve Assets and Reserve Liabilities of the Monetary Authorities: Jul 31/2020 — Nov/2020; Frequency: M (monthly).
  - Reserve/Base Money: Jul 31/2020 — Nov/2020; Frequency: M.
  - Broad Money: Jul 31/2020 — Nov/2020; Frequency: M.
  - Central Bank Balance Sheet: Jul 31/2020 — Nov/2020; Frequency: M.
  - Consolidated Balance Sheet of the Banking System: Jul 31/2020 — Nov/2020; Frequency: M.
  - Consumer Price Index: Nov30/2020 — Dec/2020; Frequency: M.
  - Revenue, Expenditure, Balance and Composition of Financing — General Government: Dec 31/2020 — Dec/2020; Frequency: D/D/M (preserved formatting).
  - Stocks of Central Government and Central Government-Guaranteed Debt: Oct 30/2020 — Dec/2020; Frequency: Q.
  - External Current Account Balance: Sep 30/2020 — Nov/2020; Frequency: Q.
  - GDP/GNP: Sept 30/2020 — Dec/2020; Frequency: Q.
  - Gross External Debt: Sep 30/2020 — Nov/2020; Frequency: Q.
  - International Investment Position: Sep 30/2020 — Nov/2020; Frequency: Q.
- Notes preserved exactly as in source relating to revisions, definitions, and frequency codes.

### Statement by Mr. Daniel Palotai, Executive Director (February 12, 2021) — Key points
- Acknowledgement of constructive and productive discussions with Mission Chief Gabriel Di Bella and team.
- Authorities broadly share staff’s assessments and recommendations; many opportunities for further reforms identified.

COVID-19 response
- Government measures: decisive containment measures including domestic and international travel restrictions; restrictions eased and re-introduced as infections rose.
- Targeted support schemes implemented to limit economic and social impact, leading to significant increase in government spending and higher budget deficit and public debt.
- Fiscal position described as healthy with public debt around 24.5 percent of GDP (well below regional median).
- Financial sector performance remains strong; structural reform agenda continues despite political challenges.

Economic performance
- 2019 growth: 4.9 percent.
- 2020 estimates:
  - Authorities estimate GDP growth around -6.7 percent.
  - Fund staff estimates GDP growth of -6 percent.
- Sectoral and demand impacts in 2020:
  - Investments estimated to have dropped by almost 20 percent.
  - Exports estimated to have dropped by 18 percent.
  - Imports estimated to have dropped by around 10 percent.
  - Consumption remained stable due to government targeted cash support.
  - Services, particularly diaspora-tourism receipts, suffered most.
- Remittances: inflow increased by 14.8 percent.
- Current account deficit: increased from 5.5 percent to around 7.5 percent of GDP.
- Financing of the increased current account deficit included external borrowing and IMF RFI purchase of Euro 51 million, 0.8 percent of GDP, and drawing down international reserves.
- Outlook:
  - Authorities project a speedy recovery driven by planned budget spending in recovery programs.
  - Fund staff estimates differ: authorities project GDP growth of 5.2 percent for 2021; Fund staff estimates 4.5 percent for 2021. Difference partly due to timing of projections.
  - Main drivers: exports (especially services) and private investments supported by projected increase in credit activity.
  - Beyond 2021, growth expected to stabilize at around 4 percent.
  - Inflation: expected to increase to 2.0 percent in 2021 as economy and imports recover.

Public finances
- Budget revenues in 2020: close to 9 percent lower than in 2019.
- Border tax collection: 11 percent lower than in 2019.
- Primary spending: increased by around 6.5 percent in 2020 compared with 2019.
- Subsidies and transfers: 38 percent higher than in 2019 due to COVID-related expenditures included under this category.
- Capital investment execution: significantly lower than budgeted, due to COVID-restrictions and political environment.
- Primary deficit:
  - Surpassed the 2 percent deficit rule (temporarily relaxed by the Assembly) with primary deficit above 7 percent (this includes spending financed externally by IFIs and by privatization proceeds).
  - Deficit as per legal rule (excluding externally financed spending and privatization-funded spending): 5.8 percent.
- Pension policy change:
  - Legal changes allow contributors of the second pillar pension system (managed by KPST) to withdraw 10 percent of their assets (roughly EUR 200 million).
  - KPST assets under management not included in consolidated government financial accounts.
  - Government pledged to reimburse a portion of withdrawn assets in future years, creating a future liability.
- 2021 budget: continued targeted support via the ‘economic recovery program’; additional financing needed to close deficit gap and keep adequate fiscal buffers.
- Investment clause amendment:
  - Authorities agreed to amend the ‘investment clause’ to allow budgeting beyond the 2 percent deficit rule for capital projects financed by IFIs.
  - Existing clause expires if stock of debt reaches 30 percent; threshold to be increased to 40 percent given pandemic risks.
  - Authorities committed to gradually return to original 2 percent deficit rule for the regular deficit.

Financial sector
- CBK reforms strengthened financial safety net and banking supervisory framework, mitigating pandemic pressures.
- Banking sector performance in 2020:
  - Banking sector grew by more than 12 percent.
  - Deposits increased by 11.5 percent (deposits comprise more than 90 percent of liabilities).
  - Outstanding loans increased by 7 percent.
  - Capital adequacy ratio at end-2020: 16.7 percent.
- CBK measures:
  - Temporary moratorium on loan repayments.
  - Relaxation of restructuring requirements: restructurings allowed based on individual requests and exempted from requirement to lower grade for NPL classification and from provisioning.
  - In December 2020, banks required to apply pre-COVID requirements.
- Non-performing loans (end-2020):
  - NPL ratio: 2.63 percent.
  - Ratio of provisions to NPL: 143.27 percent.
  - Preliminary data signal a healthy loan portfolio with probability of a slight increase in NPLs in coming months.

Economic governance and financial sector reforms — policy priorities and commitments
- Authorities committed to continuing structural reforms and designing new reforms.
- Tax policy: authorities interested in a general review of current tax policy in collaboration with Fund staff.
- Revenue administration: focus on digitalization and shifting to risk-based auditing.
- Social protection: commitment to review multiple social schemes to ensure consistency, consider long-term implications, ensure fair treatment, and avoid ad-hoc approaches.
- E-procurement: progress made; priority to improve operational aspects and transparency in public procurement.
- Public sector compensation: Constitutional Court decision repealed law on salaries; priority to make compensation policy more transparent and fair in line with staff recommendations.
- Publicly Owned Enterprises (POE): POEs pose large fiscal risks; authorities agreed with staff to:
  - Establish and develop performance and quarterly risk assessments for high risk POEs.
  - Strengthen institutional arrangements for POE oversight.

Possible request for a program
- December 2020: technical discussions for a UCT program successfully concluded with staff.
- Discussions put on hold due to political developments until new institutions are created.
- Likely that following general elections in mid-February, the new government will approach the Fund to negotiate a possible program.

*Source: Republic of Kosovo — Staff Report for the 2020 Article IV Consultation — Informational Annex (February 1, 2021).*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/cr/2021/english/1kosea2021001.pdf_
