## 1. Multi-Year Rolli ng Budget Frame work Integrated i n FY P

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [1. Multi-Year Rolli ng Budget Frame work Integrated i n FY P](https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/cr/2022/english/1btnea2022001.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/files/publications/cr/2022/english/1btnea2022001.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/files/publications/cr/2022/english/1btnea2022001.pdf.json)

---

### CONTEXT AND RECENT DEVELOPMENTS
- Pre-pandemic progress and LDC graduation:
  - Significant strides in improving per capita income and reducing poverty; qualified for graduation from the Least Developed Country (LDC) status in 2023.
- Pandemic macro impacts:
  - GDP contracted by 2.4 percent in FY2019/20 and 3.7 percent in FY2020/21.
  - Hydropower accounts for around 17 percent of GDP.
  - Overall and youth unemployment roughly doubled to around 5 and 22.6 percent at end-2020.
  - Inflation: 5.3 percent (year-over-year) in February 2022.
  - Fiscal deficit: increased to 6.3 percent of GDP in FY2020/21.
  - Current account deficit (CAD): narrowed marginally to 11.8 percent of GDP in FY2020/21.
  - Private sector credit growth: slowed to 6.5 percent in June 2021.
  - Non-performing loans (NPLs): 14.1 percent in June 2021.
- Policy responses:
  - Deployment of the National Resilience Fund (NRF), the Economic Contingency Plan (ECP), and fiscal, monetary, financial, and labor market measures.
  - Vaccination milestones: full vaccination of the adult population by end-July 2021; children aged five and older by end-March 2022; booster doses for population aged twelve and older starting December 2021.
  - Programs: “Desuung” Guardians of Peace and Kidu income support.

### OUTLOOK AND RISKS
- Near-term projections and drivers:
  - Growth in FY2021/22 projected at 4.4 percent.
  - Inflation projected at 7.9 percent in FY2021/22 (average).
  - Overall fiscal deficit expected to widen to 10.2 percent in FY2021/22.
  - Current account deficit projected to moderate to 10.6 percent of GDP in FY2021/22; reserve coverage reaching about 19 months of imports.
- Medium-term expectations:
  - Growth driven by recovery in services and manufacturing and hydropower; generation capacity expected to more than double by FY26/27.
  - Inflation to remain in line with India due to the ngultrum’s peg to the rupee.
  - Fiscal deficit expected to moderate as pandemic-related measures are phased out and revenue reforms deepen.
  - CAD and reserve coverage expected to improve from declining hydropower-related imports and rising hydropower exports.
- Risk assessment:
  - Balance of risks tilted to the downside.
  - External risks: sharper-than-expected global slowdown and/or slowdown in India, future pandemic waves, intensification of geopolitical tensions, prolonged decline in tourism.
  - Domestic risks: pandemic-related uncertainties, prolonged financial sector strains amid limited fiscal space, contingent liabilities in the financial sector, delays in hydro projects.

### POLICIES TO SECURE THE RECOVERY AND STRENGTHEN THE OUTLOOK — OVERARCHING
- Emphasize balancing support for vulnerable populations with fiscal sustainability.
- Target measures and ensure predictable, well-communicated phasing out of support.
- Strengthen revenue mobilization and expenditure efficiency to increase policy space.
- Integrate a transparent, rolling, multi-year budget framework within the FYP cycle.

### A. Fiscal Policy — findings and recommendations
- FY2021/22 budget priorities:
  - Health, education, and infrastructure.
  - About 33 percent of the capital outlay in the Twelfth FYP (19 percent of GDP) allocated to FY2021/22.
- Fiscal trajectory and GST:
  - Fiscal deficit projected to rise to 10.2 percent of GDP in FY2021/22.
  - GST scheduled for July 2022; GST rate set at 7 percent.
  - Preliminary revenue boost: about 0.4 percent of GDP initially, and about 2 percent of GDP in the medium term.
- Debt and sustainability:
  - Stock of public and publicly guaranteed (PPG) debt increased to 135 percent of GDP in FY2020/21.
  - Judgment applied to rate risk as "moderate" because almost three quarters of PPG external debt is linked to hydropower project loans from India with mitigating contractual features.
  - Stress tests indicate vulnerability to exchange rate and export shocks; susceptibility to contingent liability shocks.
- Fiscal policy recommendations:
  - Gradual medium-term fiscal consolidation underpinned by revenue mobilization and greater expenditure efficiency.
  - Smooth GST implementation; broaden tax base (direct tax and property tax reforms).
  - Update base of land/property taxes and gradually rationalize tax exemptions.
  - Target pandemic-related fiscal expenditures from FY2022/23 to support the most vulnerable and priority items: education, health, infrastructure.
  - Strengthen governance of crisis-related spending, including publication of contracts and beneficial ownership information.
  - Develop domestic debt market via a medium-term debt management strategy:
    - Domestic debt financing currently limited at 7 percent of total PPG debt.
    - RMA to implement liquidity management framework, establish active interbank market and reference rate.
    - Ministry of Finance to introduce a more regular issuance calendar.

### B. Monetary Policy — findings and recommendations
- Monetary stance and tools:
  - Cash Reserve Ratio (CRR) reduced by 300 basis points to 7 percent in 2020.
  - Accommodative stance appropriate amid uncertainties but should be gradually normalized as recovery strengthens and inflation pressures rise.
  - Recommendation: gradually increase the CRR, with forward-looking communication and close monitoring of excess liquidity and prices.
- Money and liquidity:
  - Money supply growth in FY2020/21 driven by deposits amid pandemic-relief measures and limited investment opportunities.
  - Excess liquidity has stalled operationalization of the Domestic Liquidity Management Framework (DLMF).
- Policy framework modernization:
  - Support for DLMF announced December 2020: overnight, weekly, and long-term (90-day) operations for liquidity forecasting and management.
  - Overnight marginal lending facility to help establish interest rate corridor, deepen interbank market, and facilitate policy transmission.
  - Debt market development will increase supply of risk-free assets and build a benchmark yield curve.
- Financial market digitalization:
  - Continue digitalization reforms; CBDC pilot should initially focus on capacity building and be tailored to development needs.

### Monetary Policy and Liquidity — authorities’ stance and staff operational priorities
- Authorities concurred the pandemic warranted accommodative monetary policy; excess liquidity strained modernization of the monetary policy framework.
- CRR remains RMA’s main monetary policy instrument until the new liquidity framework is fully operationalized.
- Staff priorities:
  - Gradually normalize accommodative monetary policy as recovery strengthens and inflation rises.
  - Plan phased withdrawal of support as unemployment declines and credit growth picks up.
  - Operationalize DLMF and overnight marginal lending facility to support interbank market development.
  - Continue financial system digitalization to support productivity and diversification.

### Financial Sector — findings, vulnerabilities, and supervisory priorities
- Pre-pandemic vulnerabilities: high NPLs and low profitability; return on assets, return on equity, and system-wide NPL ratios weakened in 2019.
- Pandemic-era measures: loan repayment moratorium, interest waiver on NRF-supported loans, and NPL resolution framework.
- Take-up and outcomes:
  - Less than half of borrowers have taken advantage of the incentive scheme to repay loans, straining profitability.
  - NPLs remain elevated with increasing substandard classification and decreasing provisioning.
  - Banking system liquidity: statutory liquidity ratio rose to over 30 percent; deposits increased 26 percent in June 2021.
  - Private sector credit growth: 6.5 percent in June 2021.
- Stress test indicator:
  - RMA results suggest a doubling of NPL ratio (to 30 percent) would reduce the system-wide capital adequacy ratio to 9.2 percent, below the minimum requirement (10 percent).
- Policy and supervisory recommendations:
  - Urgently address NPLs while balancing near-term targeted support.
  - Well-communicated withdrawal plan for broad-based support; banks to monitor cash flows, assess corporate viability, and target viable but illiquid firms.
  - Consider moratorium on dividend payments if needed to support capitalization.
  - Avoid extensions of broad-based moratoria that mask risks and create contingent fiscal liabilities.
  - Implement NPL resolution framework with improved asset valuation.
  - Roll out risk-based supervisory (RBS) framework proportionate to institution size and complexity.
  - Strengthen insolvency and bankruptcy processes, including for cottage and small industries.

### External Sector and Exchange Rate Policy
- Exchange rate anchor:
  - Ngultrum pegged to the Indian rupee at par; peg assessed appropriate and adequate nominal anchor.
- External exposure and reserves:
  - Seventy percent of public external debt denominated in Indian rupees.
  - Over 90 percent of trade is with India.
  - Rupee reserves: about 26 percent of total reserves in FY2020/21, up from around 16 percent two years earlier.
  - Total reserves at end-2021: $1.6 billion (65 percent of GDP), covering 21 months of merchandise imports and 18 months of merchandise and services imports.
- Staff recommendations:
  - Further increase share of rupee reserves.
  - Keep recent SDR allocation as part of international reserves.
  - Support recent relaxation on foreign exchange restrictions, including access to foreign currency by industries.
- External assessment:
  - NIIP: $-2.8 billion (116 percent of GDP) by end-2021.
  - External assets: $1.5 billion (61 percent of GDP); reserve assets: $1.3 billion; other assets: $0.2 billion.
  - External liabilities: $4.2 billion (177 percent of GDP); loans: $4 billion; direct investment: $0.1 billion.
  - Hydropower debt constitutes 73 percent of external debt.
  - CAD narrowed to around 11.8 percent in 2021 from an average of 21.9 percent during 2015-20.
  - Assessment: external position broadly in line with fundamentals; reserve coverage adequate.

### Structural Reforms and Development Priorities
- Diversification and digitalization:
  - Recovery window to advance diversification toward higher value-added activities.
  - Digital Drukyul Flagship Program targets digitalization of health care, broadband to 1,000 schools/hospitals/offices, One Digital Identity, integrated business licensing and customs-trade systems, digital public services, ICT certification and digital literacy, and e-learning platforms.
- Financial inclusion and digital payments:
  - As of 2020, 76 percent of the adult population had a bank account; 21 percent had accessed credit; 25 percent had an insurance policy.
  - Progress in payment systems: Bhutan Intermediate Payment Service, Global Interchange for Financial Transactions, RuPay access, QR-code payment system.
- Labor, skills, and social policies:
  - Continue skilling and re-skilling programs; maintain fiscal allocation for vocational education, teachers’ training, and remedial education.
  - Subsidized childcare to raise female labor force participation in urban centers.
- Tourism and trade:
  - Prioritize "High Value, Low Volume" tourism; improve export market access via digital platforms.
- Infrastructure and logistics:
  - Bhutan ranked 149th among 160 economies in the World Bank’s 2018 Logistics Performance Index.
- Climate change and resilience:
  - Support climate change adaptation, disaster risk management, greening energy sources, climate-resilient budgeting, and resilient infrastructure.

### Debt Dynamics, DSA Findings, and Policy Implications
- Drivers and composition:
  - Rapid public-sector-led hydropower development drove external debt accumulation.
  - Hydropower loans mostly supplied by the Government of India (GoI) and on-lent to SOEs.
- Key debt statistics (FY2016/17 to FY2020/21 highlights):
  - Overall PPG debt increased by about 23 percent of GDP compared with FY2016/17.
  - Hydropower debt increased from about 81 percent to 92 percent of GDP.
  - Hydropower debt: 73 percent of the PPG external debt stock in FY2020/21.
  - Non-hydropower external PPG debt: rose from about 24 percent to 33 percent of GDP.
  - Domestic PPG debt rose from 6.6 percent to 9.7 percent of GDP.
  - Total PPG debt: 135 percent of GDP in FY2020/21.
  - External debt accounted for 93 percent of total PPG debt; domestic 7 percent.
  - About 70 percent of PPG external debt denominated in India rupees.
  - About 93 percent of total external PPG debt from official creditors (GoI: 65 percent; ADB: 12.5 percent; IDA: 11.4 percent).
  - About 96 percent of total PPG debt fixed interest rate; 4 percent floating.
- GoI hydropower financing features that mitigate risk:
  - GoI covers construction and financial risks and commits to buy surplus electricity at cost-plus-margin pricing.
  - Debt service begins only after project commissioning.
  - Hydropower projects are insured and re-insured for natural disaster.
  - Denomination in rupees aligns export receipts and debt service with the rupee peg.
- DSA outcomes and projections:
  - Debt carrying capacity assessed as medium; Composite Indicator: 3.08.
  - DSA thresholds (medium DCC): PV external debt to exports: 180 percent; PV external debt to GDP: 40 percent; Debt service to exports: 15 percent; Debt service to revenue: 18 percent; Application benchmark for public debt: 55 percent PV of total public debt/GDP.
  - Baseline: PPG external debt indicators exceed thresholds for several years before falling below in later years.
  - Total PPG debt to GDP expected to moderate from around 135 percent in 2021 to about 105 in the medium term (by 2027) and to about 37 percent in the long term (by 2042).
  - External debt to GDP expected to fall from around 125 percent in 2021 to 102 percent in the medium term and to 35 percent in the long term.
- Vulnerabilities and stress tests:
  - Stress tests show vulnerability to exchange rate and export shocks; exchange rate depreciation and export shocks could keep key ratios above thresholds for extended periods.
  - Climate-related shocks and delays in hydropower projects are material risks.
- Policy directions for debt sustainability:
  - Gradual fiscal consolidation and revenue mobilization.
  - Maintain stable peg with the Indian rupee.
  - Reforms to improve productivity and competitiveness of the non-hydropower sector.
  - Further develop domestic bond market and improve debt transparency and reporting.

### Key Numerical Indicators and Projections (selected, preserved as in source)
- Growth and inflation:
  - Growth expected to expand by 4.4 percent in FY2021/22.
  - Long-term growth projected around 5.8 percent.
  - Pre-COVID ten-year historical average growth: 6.2 percent.
  - Inflation rose from 3 percent in FY2019/20 to 8.2 percent in FY2020/21.
  - Average inflation in FY2021/22 expected at 7.9 percent (6.5 percent end-of-period).
- Hydropower capacity additions (projects and timing):
  - Nikachhu: 118 MW, expected in 2023.
  - Punatsangchhu 2: 1,020 MW, expected in 2023.
  - Kholongchhu: 600 MW, expected in 2025.
  - Punatshangchhu 1: 1,200 MW, expected in 2025.
  - Installed generation capacity expansion: from 2,334 MW to 5,273 MW between 2023 and 2026.
- Fiscal and external balances:
  - Fiscal (primary) deficit projected to peak at 10.2 (8.8) percent of GDP in FY2021/22.
  - Primary fiscal balance expected to stabilize at around 1.7 percent of GDP in the long term.
  - Current account deficit expected to narrow slightly to 10.6 percent in FY2021/22.
  - Non-interest CAD projected at 8.9 percent in FY2021/22.
- Public and external debt series (selected entries from projections table):
  - External debt (nominal, in percent of GDP): 2019: 105.7; 2020: 123.6; 2021: 125.3; 2022: 127.0; 2023: 125.0; 2024: 120.2; 2025: 113.1; 2026: 107.5; 2032: 74.2; 2042: 35.1.
  - PV of PPG external debt-to-GDP ratio (selected): 112.4; 113.0; 112.3; 108.5; 103.3; 97.7; 92.1; 63.9; 27.0.
  - PPG debt service-to-exports ratio (selected): 9.4; 5.5; 11.5; 21.7; 18.0; 17.8; 17.0; 19.4; 19.1.
  - Gross external financing need (Million of U.S. dollars, selected): 550.7; 331.7; 334.0; 410.6; 395.2; 304.3; 168.9; 189.4; 145.5.
  - Public sector debt (percent of GDP, selected): 106.5; 131.2; 134.9; 133.5; 130.9; 124.2; 116.4; 110.7; 105.4; 77.2; 36.9; 109.4; 105.4.
- Financing mix assumptions:
  - External loans to finance around 80 percent of gross financing needs in the medium term; 20 percent by domestic borrowing.
  - Long-term domestic financing share expected to rise to around 40 percent of total financing needs by 2042.
  - Cost of domestic debt assumed around 6.5 percent for longer-dated bonds.
  - Share of concessional external debt expected to decline as Bhutan graduates from LDC status.

### Implementation and Capacity Development
- Fund CD activities recalibrated to online delivery during the pandemic; SARTTAC delivered extensive TA and training.
- Ongoing CD workplans: medium-term budget frameworks, rebasing, updating PPI, high frequency indicators, finalizing GST implementation, risk-based supervisory framework, liquidity management, local debt market development.
- Authorities appreciate CD support and seek collaboration on CBDC, bond market development, and data coverage.

### Staff Appraisal and Administrative Recommendation
- Staff appraisal:
  - Pandemic caused two years of contraction; transport, construction, and tourism most affected.
  - Growth projection: 4.4 percent in FY2021/22.
  - Inflation elevated in FY2021/22; medium-term inflation to track India.
  - Fiscal policy appropriately supported pandemic response; medium-term consolidation and revenue mobilization critical.
  - Financial sector: address banking risks while supporting recovery; implement NPL resolution and RBS framework.
  - External: peg appropriate; reserve coverage adequate; recommend increasing rupee reserves.
  - Structural: recovery offers opportunity for diversification, digitalization, infrastructure, and climate resilience.
- Administrative recommendation:
  - Staff recommends that the Article IV consultation with Bhutan remain on a 24-month cycle.

_Italic line: Source: 1btnea2022001 - 1. Multi-Year Rolli ng Budget Frame work Integrated i n FY P_

### 1. Multi-Year Rolli ng Budget Frame work Integrated i n FY P _________________________________________ 16

### 1. Multi-Year Rolli ng Budget Frame work Integrated i n FY P _________________________________________ 16

### CONTEXT AND RECENT DEVELOPMENTS
- Prior to the pandemic, Bhutan made significant strides in improving per capita income and reducing poverty, qualifying for its graduation from the Least Developed Country (LDC) status in 2023.
- The pandemic had a broad-based adverse impact on the economy:
  - GDP contracted by 2.4 percent in FY2019/20 and 3.7 percent in FY2020/21.
  - Hydropower accounts for around 17 percent of GDP and partly offset sectoral declines.
  - Overall and youth unemployment roughly doubled to around 5 and 22.6 percent at end-2020.
  - Inflation remained elevated at 5.3 percent (year-over-year) in February 2022.
  - The fiscal deficit increased to 6.3 percent of GDP in FY2020/21.
  - Current account deficit (CAD) narrowed marginally to 11.8 percent of GDP in FY2020/21.
  - Private sector credit growth slowed to 6.5 percent in June 2021, an 8-year low.
  - Non-performing loans were elevated at 14.1 percent in June 2021.
- Policy responses:
  - Deployment of the National Resilience Fund (NRF), the Economic Contingency Plan (ECP), and fiscal, monetary, financial, and labor market measures.
  - Rapid vaccination: full vaccination of the adult population by end-July 2021 and of children aged five and older by end-March 2022; booster doses for population aged twelve and older starting December 2021.
  - Programs include the “Desuung” Guardians of Peace and Kidu income support for those affected by COVID-19.

### OUTLOOK AND RISKS
- Near-term projections and drivers:
  - Growth in FY2021/22 projected at 4.4 percent, supported by vaccination, higher electricity exports, ongoing fiscal support, and base effects.
  - Inflation projected at 7.9 percent in FY2021/22 (average).
  - Overall fiscal deficit expected to widen to 10.2 percent in FY2021/22.
  - Current account deficit projected to moderate to 10.6 percent of GDP in FY2021/22, with reserve coverage reaching about 19 months of imports.
- Medium-term expectations:
  - Growth driven by recovery in services and manufacturing and hydropower, with generation capacity expected to more than double by FY26/27.
  - Inflation projected to remain in line with India due to the ngultrum’s peg to the rupee.
  - Fiscal deficit expected to moderate as pandemic-related measures are phased out and revenue reforms deepen.
  - CAD and reserve coverage expected to improve from declining hydropower-related imports and rising hydropower exports.
- Risk assessment:
  - Balance of risks tilted to the downside.
  - External risks: sharper-than-expected global slowdown and/or slowdown in India, future pandemic waves, intensification of geopolitical tensions, prolonged decline in tourism.
  - Domestic risks: pandemic-related uncertainties, prolonged financial sector strains amid limited fiscal space, contingent liabilities in the financial sector, delays in hydro projects.
  - Recent increases in hydropower production and remittances have supported reserves.

### POLICIES TO SECURE THE RECOVERY AND STRENGTHEN THE OUTLOOK
- Overarching policy emphasis:
  - Balance support for vulnerable populations with fiscal sustainability.
  - Focus on targeted measures and predictable, well-communicated phasing out of support.
  - Strengthen revenue mobilization and expenditure efficiency to increase policy space.

- A. Fiscal Policy — findings and recommendations
  - FY2021/22 budget prioritized health, education, and infrastructure.
    - About 33 percent of the capital outlay in the Twelfth FYP (19 percent of GDP) allocated to FY2021/22.
  - Projected fiscal deficit rise to 10.2 percent of GDP in FY2021/22 due to front-loaded capital spending and stimulus.
  - Goods and Services Tax (GST) implementation:
    - GST scheduled for July 2022.
    - GST rate set at 7 percent.
    - Preliminary analysis: revenue boost could amount to about 0.4 percent of GDP initially, and to about 2 percent of GDP in the medium term.
  - Debt and sustainability:
    - Stock of public and publicly guaranteed (PPG) debt increased to 135 percent of GDP in FY2020/21.
    - Mechanical results point to high risk of overall and external debt distress, but judgment applied to rate risk as "moderate" due to mitigating factors:
      - Almost three quarters of Bhutan’s PPG external debt is linked to hydropower project loans from India, which cover financial and construction risks and buy surplus electricity at cost-plus profits.
      - Expected medium-term improvement in debt dynamics from increased electricity exports and completion of hydropower projects.
    - Stress tests indicate vulnerability to exchange rate and export shocks; overall debt sustainability could be susceptible to contingent liability shocks.
  - Policy recommendations:
    - Gradual medium-term fiscal consolidation underpinned by revenue mobilization and greater expenditure efficiency.
    - Smooth implementation of the GST and broaden tax base (including direct tax and property tax reforms).
    - Update base of land/property taxes and gradually rationalize tax exemptions.
    - Target pandemic-related fiscal expenditures from FY2022/23 to support the most vulnerable and priority items: education, health, infrastructure.
    - Continue improving access to quality health care; strengthen education quality including vocational training and digitalization; provide subsidized childcare to raise female labor force participation in urban centers.
    - Integrate a transparent, rolling, multi-year budget framework within the FYP cycle:
      - Provide indicative fiscal targets for the next five years during the mid-term review.
      - Reflect pandemic support measures on-budget (e.g., the NRF) and ensure timely evaluation of project implementation.
      - Ensure governance safeguards and accountability of crisis-related spending, including transparency in procurement (publication of contracts and beneficial ownership information of awarded companies).
    - Develop domestic debt market based on a medium-term debt management strategy:
      - Domestic debt financing currently limited at 7 percent of total PPG debt.
      - RMA should implement liquidity management framework, establish an active interbank market and reference rate.
      - Ministry of Finance should introduce a more regular issuance calendar.

- B. Monetary Policy — findings and recommendations
  - Monetary policy stance and tools:
    - Cash Reserve Ratio (CRR) reduced by 300 basis points to 7 percent in 2020 (first easing since 2015).
    - Accommodative stance appropriate amid uncertainties but should be gradually normalized as recovery strengthens and inflation pressures rise.
    - Recommendation to gradually increase the CRR, with forward-looking communication and close monitoring of excess liquidity and prices.
  - Money and liquidity developments:
    - Money supply growth in FY2020/21 driven by deposits amid pandemic-relief measures and limited investment opportunities.
    - Excess liquidity has stalled operationalization of the Domestic Liquidity Management Framework (DLMF).
  - Policy framework modernization:
    - Support for DLMF announced December 2020: overnight, weekly, and long-term (90-day) operations for liquidity forecasting and management.
    - Overnight marginal lending facility should help establish an interest rate corridor, deepen interbank market, and facilitate policy transmission.
    - Debt market development will increase supply of risk-free assets, build a benchmark yield curve, and help monetary policy implementation.
  - Financial market digitalization:
    - Further reforms, including liquidity management framework and digitalization, would support market development.
    - Phased reduction in excess liquidity would foster interbank market development.
    - Authorities’ advances in payment systems and financial market digitalization can deliver significant benefits given Bhutan’s topography.
    - Central bank digital currency (CBDC) pilot should initially focus on capacity building and be tailored to development needs.

*Source: 1btnea2022001 - 1. Multi-Year Rolli ng Budget Frame work Integrated i n FY P*

### 19.      The authorities concurred that the pandemic warranted accommodative monetary

### 1btnea2022001 - 19.      The authorities concurred that the pandemic warranted accommodative monetary

### Monetary Policy and Liquidity
- Authorities judged the pandemic warranted accommodative monetary policy; excess liquidity has strained modernization of the monetary policy framework.
- Monetary measures, including the reduction in CRR, helped banks extend short-term concessional bridge loans for businesses’ working capital.
- Excess liquidity is mainly driven by a mismatch between strong growth in (short-term) deposits and tepid (long-term) credit demand, including from a saturated housing market and construction-related demand.
- Authorities expressed willingness to continue making progress on the DLMF and digitalization of the financial system, including exploring a CBDC through a pilot program focused on capacity building.
- "The CRR remains the RMA’s main monetary policy instrument until the new liquidity framework is fully operationalized."
- Staff advice and operational priorities:
  - Gradually normalize accommodative monetary policy as the recovery strengthens and inflationary pressures mount.
  - Plan for a phased withdrawal of support as recovery takes hold, unemployment declines, and credit growth picks up amid elevated inflationary pressures.
  - Gradual increase in the CRR, aided by forward-looking communication and close monitoring of excess liquidity and inflation, will be necessary.
  - As liquidity conditions normalize, prioritize operationalizing the DLMF and overnight marginal lending facility to support interbank market development and monetary policy transmission.
  - Continue financial system digitalization to support productivity and diversification.

### Financial Sector Findings and Recommendations
- Pre-pandemic vulnerabilities: high NPLs and low profitability; in 2019 return on assets, return on equity, and system-wide NPL ratios weakened relative to recent historical averages.
- Credit quality is expected to worsen when policy support expires.
- RMA measures during the pandemic included a loan repayment moratorium, an interest waiver on loans supported by the NRF, and a comprehensive NPL resolution framework.
- Less than half of borrowers have taken advantage of the incentive scheme to repay loans, straining bank profitability.
- NPLs remain elevated with increasing substandard classification and decreasing provisioning.
- Banking system liquidity remained elevated: statutory liquidity ratio rose to over 30 percent and deposits increased 26 percent in June 2021.
- Private sector credit growth was 6.5 percent in June 2021.
- Stress test indicator: "RMA results suggests a doubling of NPL ratio (to 30 percent) would reduce the system-wide capital adequacy ratio to 9.2 percent, below the minimum requirement (10 percent)."
- Policy recommendations and supervisory priorities:
  - Urgently address NPLs while balancing need for continued near-term targeted support.
  - Well-communicated plan for withdrawing broad-based policy support; banks should focus on monitoring cash flows, assessing corporate viability, and targeting resources to viable but illiquid firms.
  - Consider a moratorium on dividend payments to support bank capitalization if needed.
  - Avoid extensions of broad-based moratoria that could mask financial sector risks, weaken medium-term growth potential, increase inequality, and create contingent fiscal liabilities.
  - Steadfast implementation of the new NPL resolution framework, requiring improved asset valuation.
  - Continue implementing a risk-based supervisory (RBS) framework across all financial institutions, proportionate to size and complexity.
  - Future supervisory actions: monitor loan performance (cash-collection rate and NPL migration); require detailed large-loan exposure reports; enforce loan origination, provisioning standards and loan loss classifications; conduct stress tests; roll out prudential and AML/CFT RBS; strengthen internal risk management.
  - Modernize insolvency and bankruptcy processes, including for cottage and small industries, to improve timely resolution of stressed assets.

### External Sector and Exchange Rate Policy
- Bhutan’s exchange rate peg has been an adequate nominal anchor and remains appropriate.
- External exposure and reserves:
  - Seventy percent of public external debt is denominated in Indian rupees.
  - Over 90 percent of trade is with India.
  - Rupee reserves constituted about 26 percent of total reserves in FY2020/21, up from around 16 percent two years ago.
- Staff recommendations:
  - Further increase the share of rupee reserves, consistent with trade and financial flows.
  - Keep recent SDR allocation as part of Bhutan’s international reserves, given a lack of near-term financing pressures.
  - Support authorities’ recent relaxation on foreign exchange restrictions, including access to foreign currency by industries.
- Staff assessment:
  - External position broadly in line with fundamentals and desirable policies (Appendix III).
  - The CAD has narrowed as hydropower exports picked up and construction-related imports declined; overall balance remains positive supported in part by grant financing.
  - NIIP projected to narrow gradually in the medium term under current policies.
  - Given concessional grant financing and long-term FDI-like loan liability structure, risks of imminent external financing stress are low.
  - Reserve coverage remains adequate.
  - Higher electricity exports and medium-term fiscal consolidation should further support improvement in CAD and NIIP.

### Structural Reforms and Development Priorities
- Recovery window to advance diversification toward higher value-added activities.
- Digital Drukyul Flagship Program aims to leverage digitalization to promote inclusion and transform the economy.
- Tourism: prioritize 'High Value, Low Volume' tourism to address revenue and sustainability concerns.
- Improving export market access through digital platforms can increase agribusiness demand and output.
- Financial inclusion progress noted but gaps remain:
  - As of 2020, 76 percent of the adult population had a bank account, but only 21 percent had accessed credit facilities and 25 percent had an insurance policy.
- Digitalization priorities: expand digital payments and digital IDs to deepen access to finance.
- Labor market and skills:
  - Continue skilling and re-skilling programs initiated during the pandemic.
  - Maintain fiscal allocation for vocational education, teachers’ training, and remedial education for lost schooling.
  - To meet short-term labor needs, continue training, job-matching assistance, and lower barriers for skilled immigration; improve access to subsidized childcare to increase female labor force participation in urban areas.
- Infrastructure and logistics:
  - Bhutan ranked 149th among 160 economies in the World Bank’s 2018 Logistics Performance Index (latest publication).
  - Further developing digital and physical infrastructure can support transition to a knowledge-based economy.
- Climate change and resilience:
  - Bhutan faces pressing need for climate change adaptation; most population lives in river valleys and economic activity is heavily reliant on water sources.
  - Staff supports plans for climate change adaptation, disaster risk management, and greening energy sources, including climate-resilient budgeting and resilient infrastructure.

### Staff Appraisal and Outlook
- Pandemic impact: Real GDP contracted for two fiscal years; transport, construction, and tourism most affected.
- Growth projection: 4.4 percent in FY2021/22, with negative impacts from the omicron outbreak and rising commodity prices partially offset by vaccination, higher electricity exports, ongoing fiscal support, and base effects.
- Inflation: projected to remain elevated in FY2021/22 due to higher oil, food, and commodity prices and supply disruptions; over the medium term inflation projected to remain in line with India given the ngultrum’s peg to the rupee.
- Fiscal stance:
  - Fiscal policy appropriately supported pandemic response; medium-term consolidation underpinned by revenue mobilization is critical.
  - Staff welcomes budget focus on health, education, and infrastructure.
  - Fiscal policy should balance support for the vulnerable with sustainability by focusing on more targeted measures.
  - Recommend anchoring fiscal policy within a transparent, rolling, multi-year budget framework integrated with the FYP cycle.
  - Revenue mobilization, including smooth GST implementation, is needed amid higher debt levels and limited fiscal space.
  - Further developing the domestic debt market would help public financing and provide risk-free instruments for domestic investors.
- Financial sector policy summary:
  - Address banking sector risks while supporting recovery with a well-communicated withdrawal plan for broad-based support.
  - Banks should monitor cash flows, assess corporate viability, and target resources to viable but illiquid firms.
  - Renewed moratorium on dividend payments could be implemented if further capitalization support is needed.
  - Steadfast implementation of the NPL resolution and risk-based supervisory frameworks is important.
- External and structural priorities:
  - Peg assessed appropriate; reserve coverage adequate; recommend further increasing rupee reserves.
  - Post-pandemic recovery is an opportunity for diversification, digitalization, and infrastructure improvements.
  - Support for climate adaptation and resilient infrastructure endorsed.
- Administrative recommendation: Staff recommends that the Article IV consultation with Bhutan remain on a 24-month cycle.

*Source: IMF staff report excerpt (content unit: 1btnea2022001).*

### Box  2.  Digitalization  for  Economic  Transformation

### Box 2. Digitalization for Economic Transformation

### Digital adoption and constraints
- Access to the internet has risen and the cost of access, particularly through mobile-cellular devices, has been steadily declining.
- Internet access is highly concentrated in urban areas.
- Given the country’s topography and population distribution, improving connectivity infrastructure remains difficult and costly.
- The legal and regulatory framework relating to the digital economy remains incomplete.
- Improving digital literacy is a key constraint.

### Government-led initiatives and scope (Digital Drukyul Flagship Program)
- Introduced as part of the Twelfth FYP to use information and communication technology (ICT) to transform Bhutan into a digital and inclusive society.
- Program focuses on seven areas:
  - i) digitalization of health care;
  - ii) provision of broadband connection to 1,000 schools, hospitals, and offices;
  - iii) One Digital Identity (biometric ID);
  - iv) integration of digital business licensing and single customs-trade systems;
  - v) digitalization of key public services;
  - vi) professional ICT certification and digital literacy for non-ICT workers;
  - vii) digitalization schools through e-learning platforms and education management information systems.

### Financial system digitalization progress
- Bhutan made important progress in the digitalization of the financial system from 2017-20, including:
  - the Bhutan Intermediate Payment Service (interbank transfers via internet, mobile, and ATMs instantaneously 24/7);
  - the Global Interchange for Financial Transactions (large value fund transfer between banks on a real-time gross settlement basis);
  - RuPay (Indian banks cards to be used a local ATMs);
  - the QR-code payment system.
- Since the onset of the pandemic, Bhutan has witnessed a sharp rise in both value and volume of transaction through electronic means and in major cities all vendors now accept some form of digital payment.

### Policy recommendations and priority actions
- Continue efforts to expand digitalization.
- Advance major initiatives under the Digital Drukyul program, including the digital ID, which have been delayed during pandemic lockdowns.
- Prioritize continued fiscal support for investment in physical infrastructure needed for digitalization.
- Continue to explore digitalization of the payment systems, particularly elements connecting Bhutan with international payments systems, in line with Bhutan’s export diversification strategy and the return of international tourism.

*Source: Box 2. Digitalization for Economic Transformation.*

### Appendix III. External  Sector Assessment

### Appendix III. External Sector Assessment

### External position: summary
- The external position of Bhutan in 2020-21 was broadly in line with the level implied by fundamentals and desirable policies.
- The current account deficit has narrowed in recent years as hydropower exports started to pick up, coupled with a decline in hydropower construction-related imports.
- The overall balance remains positive supported in part by grant financing.
- Bhutan’s peg has been an adequate nominal anchor and remains appropriate, as India is Bhutan’s largest trade and development partner.
- Going forward, a continued increase in electricity exports, together with medium-term fiscal consolidation, should further support an improvement in the current account balance and net international investment position.

### Foreign assets and liabilities: position and trajectory
- NIIP was $-2.8 billion (116 percent of GDP) by end-2021, $0.5 billion lower than by end-2020.
- External assets: $1.5 billion (61 percent of GDP), mainly consisting of:
  - reserve assets: $1.3 billion
  - other assets: $0.2 billion (including currency and deposits and trade credit)
- External liabilities: $4.2 billion (177 percent of GDP), mainly consisting of:
  - loans: $4 billion
  - direct investment: $0.1 billion
- Loans are mostly long-term debt held by non-financial corporations, households and NPISHs, followed by general government and central bank.
- Hydropower debt constitutes 73 percent of external debt, financed by India under an intergovernmental agreement with contractual obligations for India to purchase electricity at tariffs based on cost-plus-margin pricing.
- Over the past five years, the net NIIP was broadly stable, largely driven by developments in the financial account balance.
- Assessment: NIIP is projected to narrow gradually in the medium term under current policies; the current account deficit is expected to taper as hydropower-related exports pick up, supporting NIIP improvement.

### Current account: developments and assessment
- The current account deficit (CAD) narrowed to around 11.8 percent in 2021 from an average of 21.9 percent of GDP during 2015-20 due to lower hydropower construction-related imports and increased electricity exports.
- Pandemic impacts: non-hydropower exports and services exports (tourism sector) were temporarily impacted; the decline was partially offset by a pickup in hydropower exports in 2021.
- Primary and secondary income balances have remained relatively stable over time.
- Outlook: CAD is expected to narrow further with a rise in electricity exports in coming years.
- Assessment by methodologies:
  - EBA-lite CA approach:
    - Adjusted CA: -8.9 percent of GDP (reflecting cyclical contributions (0.9 percent) and a COVID-19 adjustor (0.7 percent) capturing a temporary decline of tourism; natural disasters and conflicts: -0.1)
    - CA norm (from regression model): -8.2 percent of GDP
    - CA gap: -0.7 percent of GDP
    - Relative policy gap: 3.4 percent of GDP (largely reflecting positive contributions of a change in reserves due to a pick-up in hydropower related exports, fiscal policy, and private credit growth)
    - Elasticity: -0.28
    - Implied REER gap: 2.4 percent
  - EBA-lite IREER methodology:
    - CA gap: 0.1 percent of GDP
    - Implied REER gap: -0.2 percent
- Given that the current account gap is estimated to be between -1 percent and 1 percent using both the EBA-lite CA and IREER methodologies, the external position is assessed to be broadly in line with the level implied by fundamentals and desirable policies.

### Real exchange rate
- The ngultrum is pegged to the rupee at par and has been depreciating in real effective terms in recent years.
- REER movements:
  - REER depreciated by 0.9 percent in 2021
  - REER depreciated by 6 percent compared with 2015
- The peg has been an adequate nominal anchor and remains appropriate given India’s role as Bhutan’s largest trade and development partner.
- Assessment:
  - EBA-lite CA implied REER gap: 2.4 percent
  - EBA-lite IREER implied REER gap: -0.2 percent
  - Policy gap: 2.8 percent of GDP (partly reflecting a recent pick up in private credit and a change in reserves due to an increase in hydropower-related exports)
  - Overall, the REER gap is estimated to be between -0.2 percent and 2.4 percent of GDP in 2021.

### Capital and financial accounts: flows and policy measures
- Capital account at end-2021: $89.5 million (3.7 percent of GDP), lower than an average of 7.8 percent of GDP during 2015-20.
  - Capital account largely consists of:
    - budgetary grants for investment: $83 million
    - grants for hydropower development: $6 million
- Financial account at end-2021: $-514 million (21.5 percent of GDP), broadly in line with the 5-year average during 2015-20.
  - Financial account balance reflects:
    - net direct investment: $0.8 million
    - net other investment: $418 million (includes hydropower related long-term loan liabilities in rupees and Royal Government of Bhutan convertible currency loans)
- Overall balance at end-2021: $-84 million (3.5 percent of GDP)
- Assessment: capital and financial accounts are projected to decline gradually over the medium term as debt disbursements and grants related to hydropower projects decline and electricity exports boost the current account balance.
- Given the concessional nature of grant financing and the long-term FDI-type of loan liability structure, the risks of imminent external financing stress related to capital flows are low in both the short- and medium-term.

### FX intervention and reserves level
- Total reserves at end-2021: $1.6 billion (65 percent of GDP), covering:
  - 21 months of merchandise imports
  - 18 months of merchandise and services imports
- Reserve accumulation in recent years explained by a gradual pick-up in hydropower related exports, improving the current account balance.
- The ngultrum is pegged to the rupee at par.
- Assessment:
  - According to the reserve adequacy template for credit constrained economies and accounting for Bhutan’s classification as a resource rich economy, the fixed exchange rate regime, and the estimated cost of holding reserves of 6.2 percent (based on the marginal product of capital), reserve adequacy is assessed to be around 6.1 months of current imports.
  - Bhutan’s actual reserve is above the assessed reserve adequacy level.

### Capacity development (Appendix IV): recent activity
- The Fund’s capacity development (CD) activities in Bhutan continued through the pandemic, recalibrated towards online delivery and focused on major policy reforms.
- Online delivery allowed high-level participation and aided by the participation of a local resident advisor.
- SARTTAC is the main deliverer of CD in Bhutan (and the region); it provided extensive training and TA in core Fund areas such as macro-fiscal forecasting, financial programming, national accounts, and public financial management.
- Ongoing workplans included medium-term budget frameworks, rebasing, updating PPI, development of high frequency indicators, finalizing the GST implementation, risk-based supervisory framework, liquidity management.
- CD from functional departments (MCM) is planned (e.g., development of local debt markets).
- CD activities have been integrated with surveillance and IMF policy advice; APD and functional departments (e.g., FAD, MCM, STA) have worked with authorities on specific queries to aid policy formulation amid pandemic-related uncertainties and other developments.

### Uptake of previous IMF advice (Appendix V): key points
- Policies since the last Article IV have been broadly consistent with IMF advice despite the COVID-19 shock; challenges remain related to financial sector reforms and some structural reforms have been delayed.
- Fiscal policy:
  - Focused on supporting the vulnerable and the economy amid the COVID-19 shock, consistent with Fund advice.
  - As pandemic-related restrictions ease, fiscal spending should be targeted with a medium-term rolling framework to help reduce volatilities.
  - A shift towards capital expenditure projects will help address Bhutan’s significant infrastructure needs, aligning with past Fund advice.
- GST implementation:
  - Continued despite pandemic-related delay; implementation in June 2022 continues to be supported by Fund technical assistance.
  - Following past staff advice, the GST will be relatively broad-based and have a simple rate structure.
- Monetary policy:
  - A new liquidity management framework has been developed with Fund support, but its operation is delayed.
  - With SARTTAC support, the RMA’s liquidity management and forecasting capabilities have been enhanced, along with a structure to establish an interest rate corridor.
  - Given ample liquidity during the pandemic from fiscal and financial sector policy support, demand for overnight lending facilities has yet to materialize; they are expected to become operational as policy support is withdrawn and liquidity declines.

*Source: Appendix III. External Sector Assessment (fiscal year 2020/21 refers to July 2020 to June 2021; end-2021 refers to June 2021).*

### 5. Loan moratoria and other borrower relief measures have taken pressure off the

### 5. Loan moratoria and other borrower relief measures have taken pressure off the financial sector during the pandemic but must be wound down.

### Key findings on financial sector measures and policy advice
- Loan moratoria and other borrower relief measures have taken pressure off the financial sector during the pandemic but must be wound down.
- Staff past advice on financial sector reforms remains relevant, including:
  - Strengthening resilience and modernizing the regulatory regime.
  - Tighten loan classification requirements for banks.
  - Mandate risk-based provisioning.
- The RMA is making progress towards risk-based supervision, consistent with Fund advice and with TA support.

### Exchange system and recent liberalization measures
- Since 1974, the ngultrum has been pegged to the Indian rupee at par.
- Bhutan avails transitional arrangements under Article XIV, Section 2, maintaining exchange restrictions in connection with:
  - A foreign exchange balancing requirement on remittances of income in convertible currencies or other foreign currencies from FDI.
  - Availability of FX for importers who have not provided evidence that goods for which payments have been made were actually imported.
- Bhutan maintains exchange restrictions subject to Fund approval under Article VIII, Section 2(a) in connection with:
  - Foreign exchange balancing requirements for imports of capital goods (for projects involving FDI) and primary raw materials (for certain industrial projects).
  - Requiring FDI companies to pay for operational expenses (including insurance payments) from their own foreign exchange resources.
  - Requiring Bhutanese companies to pay the interest on and amortization of external loans from their own foreign currency resources.
- Foreign Exchange Rules and Regulations 2020 and other initiatives introduced:
  - RMA shall provide convertible currency (CC) requirement for the import of raw materials (up to 6-months) for newly established companies as a start-up support and proprietary raw materials (10 percent of actual sales) approved by the RGoB.
  - CC eligibility for local industries was increased from 80 to100 percent for their exports.
  - Prepayment of ECB loans aligned with the ECB guidelines 2019.
  - Foreign currency operational expenses requirement of FDI companies aligned with the FDI Investment Rules and Regulations 2019.
  - New provision to streamline FC account operations held by local NGOs and CSOs.
- Incentive on Inward Remittance Pilot Project:
  - RMA facilitated 1 percent incentive amount on every converted convertible currency remitted to Bhutan by non-resident Bhutanese (NRB).
  - RMA support for authorized banks and money transfer agents with infrastructure/setup or annual AML/CFT compliance/statutory costs for 1 year on a cost-sharing basis.

### Fund relations, membership, and financial positions (as of February 28, 2022)
- Membership Status: Joined: September 28, 1981; Article XIV.
- Quota: 20.40 SDR Million 100.00 percent of Quota.
- Fund Holdings of Currency (Exchange Rate): 15.85 SDR Million 77.72 percent of Quota.
- Reserve Tranche Position: 4.55 SDR Million 22.29 percent of Quota.
- Net cumulative allocation (SDR Department): 25.54 SDR Million 100.00 percent allocation.
- Holdings (SDR Department): 25.68 SDR Million 100.56 percent.
- Outstanding Purchases and Loans: None.
- Latest Financial Arrangements: None.
- Projected Payments to Fund (SDR million): Principal 0.00 for 2022, 2023, 2024, 2025, 2026; Charges/interest 0.00 for 2022, 2023, 2024, 2025, 2026; Total 0.00 for 2022, 2023, 2024, 2025, 2026.

### Statistics, data adequacy, and technical assistance (as of April 4, 2022)
- General: Data provision is broadly adequate for surveillance but has areas for improvements in national accounts, balance of payments, and fiscal data.
- National accounts:
  - Current base year of the national accounts is 2000.
  - NSB is rebasing GDP from 2000 to 2017 with TA through SARTTAC, including an Economic Census and supply and use tables.
  - Bhutan does not produce quarterly national accounts data.
- Price statistics:
  - CPI compiled monthly starting January 2013; weights based on the 2017 Bhutan Living Standard Survey (BLSS).
  - Producer Price Index compiled monthly but disseminated quarterly; current index weights reference period 2010; TA to update weights using the 2017 Economic Census.
- Government finance statistics:
  - Authorities started producing and publishing quarterly budget performance report since FY2020/21.
  - Issues remain with consolidation of GFS, particularly the treatment of SOE debt.
  - Ongoing SARTTAC TA on fiscal data expected to bring further improvements.
- Monetary statistics:
  - Compiled broadly in line with the Monetary and Financial Statistics Manual.
  - RMA reports monetary and financial statistics monthly using Standardized Report Forms (SRFs).
  - Some shortcomings include valuation of financial assets recorded at acquisition cost rather than market price or fair value.
- Financial Sector Surveillance:
  - RMA reports Financial Soundness Indicators (FSI) quarterly, including 12 core and 7 encouraged indicators for deposit takers; FSIs are published on the IMF’s FSI webpage.
- Balance of payments:
  - RMA compiles and disseminates quarterly BOP and IIP data (published and updated at a monthly frequency) and participates in the CDIS.
  - RMA expected soon to start reporting external debt statistics to the World Bank’s Quarterly External Debt Statistics Database.
  - Some gaps remain between the BOP and the IIP and some BOP components.
- Data Standards and Quality:
  - Bhutan participates in the enhanced General Data Dissemination System and maintains a regularly updated National Summary Data Page.
  - No data ROSC is available.

### Table of Common Indicators Required for Surveillance (as of April 4, 2022) — selected entries
- Exchange rates: Latest Observation Mar-22; Date Received Mar-22; Frequency of Data D; Frequency of Reporting D; Frequency of Publication D.
- International reserve assets and reserve liabilities of the Monetary Authorities: Latest Observation Sep-21; Date Received Mar-22; Frequency M M M.
- Reserve/base money: Latest Observation Nov-21; Date Received Mar-22; Frequency M M M.
- Broad money: Latest Observation Nov-21; Date Received Jan-22; Frequency M M M.
- Central bank balance sheet: Latest Observation Nov-21; Date Received Nov-21; Frequency M M M.
- Consolidated balance sheet of the banking system: Latest Observation NA; Date Received NA; Frequency M M M.
- Interest rates: Latest Observation Mar-22; Date Received Mar-22; Frequency M M M.
- Consumer price index: Latest Observation Feb-22; Date Received Mar-22; Frequency Q/M M M.
- Revenue, expenditure, balance and composition of financing — general government: Latest Observation FY2020/21; Date Received Nov-21; Frequency A A A.
- Revenue, expenditure, balance and composition of financing — central government: Latest Observation Dec-21; Date Received Dec-21; Frequency M M M.
- Stocks of central government and central government-guaranteed debt: Latest Observation Q4 2021; Date Received Feb-22; Frequency Q Q Q.
- External current account balance: Latest Observation Q4 2021; Date Received Feb-22; Frequency Q Q M.
- Exports and imports of goods and services: Latest Observation Q2 2021; Date Received Sep-21; Frequency Q Q Q.
- GDP/GNP: Latest Observation Q4 2021; Date Received Mar-22; Frequency Q Q M.
- Gross external debt: Latest Observation FY2020/21; Date Received Mar-22; Frequency A A M.
- International investment position: Latest Observation Sep 2021; Date Received Mar-22; Frequency M M M.

### Debt sustainability analysis — headline outcomes and judgment (April 26, 2022)
- Risk of external debt distress: Moderate.
- Overall risk of debt distress: Moderate.
- Granularity in the risk rating: Limited space to absorb shocks.
- Application of judgment: Yes. The risk assessment of moderate reflects:
  - The FDI nature of hydro-related loans.
  - Projected improvement of medium-term dynamics due to hydro exports and revenues.
- Although mechanical results point to a high risk with breaches under the baseline scenario, judgment applied because:
  - Majority of outstanding public and publicly guaranteed debt is linked to hydropower project loans from the government of India (GoI).
  - Projects implemented under intergovernmental agreement where GoI covers financial and construction risks and commits to buy all surplus electricity at a price reflecting cost plus margin.
  - Debt dynamics projected to improve over the medium term driven by significant increase in electricity exports and a decline in imports associated with hydropower construction.
- Vulnerabilities:
  - External debt sustainability could be vulnerable to export and depreciation shocks.
  - Overall debt sustainability could be susceptible to contingent liabilities shocks.
- Policy directions highlighted:
  - Gradual fiscal consolidation and revenue mobilization.
  - Maintain a stable peg with the Indian rupee.
  - Reforms to improve productivity and competitiveness of the non-hydropower sector.

### Public debt coverage in the 2022 DSA
- Coverage includes public and publicly guaranteed (PPG) debt:
  - Central government debt.
  - Central government borrowing on-lent to state-owned enterprises (SOEs) (including for hydropower-related projects).
  - External guaranteed debt contracted by SOEs.
  - Central bank debt (standby credit facilities).
- Local governments, social security fund and extra budgetary funds do not have any outstanding debt.
- Calibration of the contingent liability shock based on default values accounting for:
  - Domestic non-guaranteed SOE debt (2 percent of GDP).
  - Financial market component (5 percent of GDP).
  - Public private partnerships (PPPs) (2 percent of GDP).
- Table entries and default shock parameters used in analysis:
  - Other elements of the general government not captured in 1.: 0.0 percent of GDP.
  - SoE's debt (guaranteed and not guaranteed by the government) 1/: 2.0 percent of GDP (used for the analysis).
  - PPP: 2.0 percent of GDP (used for the analysis).
  - Financial market (default value minimum): 5.0 percent of GDP (used for the analysis).
  - Total (2+3+4+5) (in percent of GDP): 9.0.
- Notes:
  - All external debt contracted directly by the SOEs is guaranteed by the government.
  - Non-guaranteed domestic SOE debt is limited; government working to standardize reporting of SOE debt.
  - As part of IDA Sustainable Development Policy Financing (SDFP), Performance and Policy Actions (PPAs) are being implemented to improve debt management and transparency, including quarterly public debt reports and the Medium-Term Debt Management Strategy (FY2020/21 to FY2022/23).

*Source: Staff report for the 2022 Article IV Consultation — informational annex (April 26, 2022).*

### 2. The stock of PPG debt has increased significantly over the past decade, driven by

### 2. The stock of PPG debt has increased significantly over the past decade, driven by

### Drivers and composition of PPG debt
- Rapid economic growth in the last decade supported by public sector-led hydropower development.
- Large investments in hydropower resulted in substantial external debt accumulation.
- Hydropower loans are mostly supplied by the Government of India (GoI) and on-lent to SOEs that finance and manage hydropower infrastructure on behalf of the government.
- Non-hydropower external PPG debt financed infrastructure projects focusing on urban development, rural electrification, and the agriculture sector, with most owed to external creditors in concessional terms.
- Domestic debt: successful issuances of government bonds recently, but domestic debt is mostly in shorter-term T-Bills for cash management purposes.

### Key statistics on debt levels and composition (comparative FY2016/17 to FY2020/21)
- Overall PPG debt increased by about 23 percent of GDP compared with FY2016/17.
- Hydropower debt:
  - Increased from about 81 percent to 92 percent of GDP (reflecting loan disbursements from the GoI).
  - Hydropower debt comprised 73 percent of the PPG external debt stock in FY2020/21.
- Non-hydropower external PPG debt:
  - Rose from about 24 percent to 33 percent of GDP, remaining within the government’s public debt policy threshold of 35 percent of GDP.
  - In FY2020/21, non-hydropower external debt comprised 27 percent of the total external PPG debt stock, and was predominantly owed to multilateral creditors (87 percent) and bilateral creditors (12 percent), with some guaranteed SOE debt (2 percent).
- Domestic PPG debt rose from 6.6 percent to 9.7 percent of GDP in the same period.
  - Domestic PPG debt was mostly in the form of treasury bills (5.5 percent of total PPG debt) and 3-year and 10-year government bonds (1.6 percent of total PPG debt).
- Total PPG debt stood at 135 percent of GDP in FY2020/21.
  - External debt accounted for 93 percent of total PPG debt; the remaining 7 percent was domestic debt.
  - About 70 percent of PPG external debt was denominated in India rupees.
  - About 93 percent of the total external PPG debt was from official creditors:
    - GoI lending share: 65 percent.
    - Asian Development Bank (ADB): 12.5 percent.
    - International Development Association (IDA): 11.4 percent.
  - About 96 percent of total PPG debt was based on a fixed interest rate; the remaining 4 percent pegged to a floating rate.

### Characteristics and risk mitigation of GoI hydropower financing
- GoI financing under an intergovernmental agreement guarantees returns from electricity exports and mitigates exchange rate risks.
- GoI bears construction and financial risks and commits to buy all surplus electricity at a purchase price at cost (including costs of the project, financing costs, and operation and maintenance charges) plus a margin.
- Electricity price is set at time of project commissioning and revisited every three years to incorporate changes in costs.
- Hydropower projects are insured (and re-insured) for natural disaster.
- Debt service begins only after hydropower projects are commissioned.
- Financing arrangements mitigate exchange rate risks because both electricity export receipts and hydropower debt services are denominated in Indian Rupees, to which the Ngultrum is pegged.
- Consequently, risks associated with hydropower-related project and debt are largely mitigated by the guarantees provided by the GoI.

### Recent drivers of higher debt and fiscal impacts
- The increase in non-hydropower external PPG debt and domestic debt in FY2019/20 and FY2020/21 reflects higher gross financing needs driven by the impact of and responses to the COVID-19 pandemic.
- Growth outcomes:
  - GDP contracted by 2.4 percent in FY2019/20 and 3.7 percent in FY2020/21.
  - Hydropower sector accounted for about 27 percent of GDP in 2020 (including electricity and construction related to hydropower).
  - Hydropower-related revenues accounted for about 37 percent of total domestic revenues in FY20/21.
- Fiscal policy and public support:
  - Expansionary fiscal policy supported pandemic response and recovery; 12th Five Year Plan reprioritized and front-loaded with higher expenditures on health, essential food and fuel, and income support.
  - National Resilience Fund (NRF) provided income support and interest payment support to individuals and businesses.
  - Pandemic-related current and capital expenditure contributed to fiscal deficits and a higher starting debt stock of 135 percent of GDP in FY2020/21.

### Macroeconomic assumptions linked to debt projections
- Growth and inflation assumptions:
  - Growth expected to expand by 4.4 percent in FY2021/22 after two consecutive years of contraction.
  - Long-term growth projected around 5.8 percent.
  - Pre-COVID ten-year historical average growth: 6.2 percent.
  - Inflation rose from 3 percent in FY2019/20 to 8.2 percent in FY2020/21.
  - Average inflation in FY2021/22 expected at 7.9 percent (6.5 percent end-of-period).
- Hydropower capacity and timing:
  - Four hydropower projects—Nikachhu (118 MW, expected in 2023), Punatsangchhu 2 (1,020 MW, expected in 2023), Kholongchhu (600 MW, expected in 2025), and Punatshangchhu 1 (1,200 MW, expected in 2025)—will expand installed generation capacity between 2023 and 2026 from 2,334 MW to 5,273 MW.
- Fiscal balance:
  - Fiscal (primary) deficit projected to peak at 10.2 (8.8) percent of GDP in FY2021/22.
  - Primary fiscal balance expected to stabilize at around 1.7 percent of GDP in the long term.
- External balance:
  - Current account deficit (CAD) expected to narrow slightly to 10.6 percent in FY2021/22.
  - Non-interest CAD projected at 8.9 percent in FY2021/22.
  - Starting from FY2022/23, CAD projected to moderate further due to a sharp increase in electricity exports associated with doubling hydropower capacity and gradual decline in hydropower-related imports.
- Financing mix:
  - External loans (including from IDA) would finance around 80 percent of gross financing needs in the medium term; remaining 20 percent financed by domestic borrowing.
  - In the long term, share of domestic financing expected to increase gradually to around 40 percent of total financing needs by 2042.
  - Cost of domestic debt assumed around 6.5 percent for longer-dated bonds.
  - Share of concessional external debt expected to decline over the long term as Bhutan graduates from LDC status.

### Debt carrying capacity, thresholds, and DSA outcomes
- Debt carrying capacity (DCC) assessed as medium based on October 2021 WEO and 2020 World Bank CPIA; Composite Indicator (CI) for current vintage: 3.08.
- DSA thresholds for Bhutan (medium DCC):
  - PV of external debt to exports: 180 percent.
  - PV of external debt to GDP: 40 percent.
  - Debt service to exports: 15 percent.
  - Debt service to revenue: 18 percent.
  - Application benchmark for public debt: 55 percent for PV of total public debt in percent of GDP.
- Baseline DSA projections:
  - PPG external debt indicators exceed thresholds for several years before falling below thresholds in later years.
  - PV of debt to GDP ratio would exceed the threshold until 2039; PV of debt to exports falling below threshold in 2034.
  - Debt service to exports ratio and debt service to revenue ratio would fall below thresholds from 2039.
  - Total PPG debt to GDP ratio expected to moderate from around 135 percent in 2021 to about 105 in the medium term (by 2027) and to about 37 percent in the long term (by 2042).
  - External debt to GDP ratio expected to fall from around 125 percent in 2021 to 102 percent in the medium term and to 35 percent in the long term.

### Vulnerabilities and stress test results
- Stress tests indicate vulnerability to exchange rate and export shocks:
  - Depreciation in the ngultrum could increase the value of external liabilities (largely denominated in foreign currency, particularly rupees), raising debt stock and debt service; PV of debt to GDP ratio and debt service to revenue ratio would fall below thresholds later in 2040 under an exchange rate shock.
  - Export shocks (e.g., delays in onboarding or construction of hydropower projects) would worsen repayment capacity; PV of debt to exports ratio and debt service to exports ratio would remain above thresholds even toward the end of the horizon.
- Additional risks:
  - Bhutan is vulnerable to climate-related shocks (e.g., climate-induced changes to glacial-fed rivers and adverse weather patterns reducing hydropower generation and exports).
  - External risks include a sharper-than-expected global slowdown and/or a slowdown in India, pandemic waves, intensification of geopolitical tensions, and prolonged decline in tourism.
  - Domestic risks include pandemic-related uncertainties, prolonged financial sector strains, and contingent liabilities in the financial sector.

*Source: 1btnea2022001 - 2. The stock of PPG debt has increased significantly over the past decade, driven by (IMF PDF chapter).*

### 12. Similar to the 2018 DSA, Bhutan’s public debt follows closely the dynamics of external

### 1btnea2022001 - 12. Similar to the 2018 DSA, Bhutan’s public debt follows closely the dynamics of external

### Debt composition and dynamics
- Domestic debt only accounted for about 7 percent of total outstanding debt in FY2020/21.
- The 2022 DSA assumes a gradual increase in domestic financing to about 40 percent of new debt.
- External debt remains the most important source of financing.
- Under both baseline and stress scenarios, the PV of the debt to GDP ratio would exceed the threshold until around 2035.
- The PV of debt to revenue ratio and debt service to revenue ratio would also be on a downward trajectory.
- Authorities plan to further develop the domestic debt market, including through the issuance of longer-term domestic bonds.

### Exchange rate, reserves, and external sector
- The ngultrum is pegged to the rupee at par and has been depreciating in real effective terms in recent years.
- Movements in the real effective exchange rate (REER) are heavily influenced by the rupee.
- The peg has been an adequate nominal anchor and remains appropriate as India is Bhutan’s largest trade and development partner.
- A stable peg could help mitigate the impact of exchange rate shocks on the economy.
- Bhutan’s reserve coverage is assessed to be adequate based on the External Sector Assessment of the 2022 Article IV.

### Scenarios and drivers of projections
- The historical scenario is based on the 10-year historical average of key macroeconomic variables, instead of the baseline projection.
- The historical scenario differs from the baseline scenario due to several factors, including:
  - a contraction in growth due to the COVID shock,
  - higher government spending, and
  - weaker current account position in recent years.
- These factors resulted in an increase in higher future gross financing needs and total PPG debt levels under the historical scenario.
- In contrast, the baseline scenario envisages:
  - a recovery in GDP growth following the pandemic shock,
  - a gradual consolidation of fiscal deficit, and
  - more favorable current account dynamics, reflecting the increase in electricity exports and a gradual decline in hydropower-related imports.

### Risk rating and vulnerabilities
- The 2022 DSA assesses Bhutan at moderate risk of external and overall debt distress, similarly to the 2018 DSA.
- Mechanical results point to a high risk of overall and external debt distress, with breaches in the indicators under the baseline scenario, but judgment was applied given unique mitigating factors.
- Almost three quarters of Bhutan’s PPG external debt is linked to hydropower project loans from GoI, which covers both financial and construction risks of the projects and commits to buy all surplus electricity at a price reflecting cost plus profits.
- Debt dynamics are set to improve further over the medium term driven by a significant increase in electricity exports and a decline of imports associated with hydropower construction.
- Overall analysis shows:
  - external debt sustainability could be vulnerable to export and depreciation shocks, and
  - overall debt sustainability could be susceptible to contingent liabilities shocks.
- Within the moderate rating, Bhutan is assessed to have limited space to absorb additional shocks without being downgraded to a high risk of debt distress.
- Key risks to the baseline include:
  - uncertainties related to the pandemic and geopolitical tensions,
  - further delays in the completion of hydropower plants, and
  - the materialization of financial sector contingent liabilities.

### Policy recommendations and authorities’ view
- Going forward, measures that could help support debt sustainability include:
  - a gradual fiscal consolidation and revenue mobilization,
  - a stable peg with the Indian rupee, and
  - reforms to improve productivity and competitiveness of the non-hydropower sector.
- The authorities broadly agreed with staff’s assessment of debt sustainability and the need for revenue mobilization, and fiscal consolidation over the medium term.
- The authorities noted that although public debt ratio has increased to relatively high levels, the risk of debt distress remained moderate due to the unique mitigating factors supporting the sustainability of Bhutan’s debt stock.
- The authorities expect a gradual fiscal consolidation and a moderation in the debt-to-GDP ratio over the medium-term, driven by a significant increase in electricity exports and the completion of hydropower construction.

*Source: 1btnea2022001 - 12. Similar to the 2018 DSA, Bhutan’s public debt follows closely the dynamics of external*

### introduction  of the  GST in July 2022, the authorities are planning on direct tax and property tax

### 1btnea2022001 - introduction  of the  GST in July 2022, the authorities are planning on direct tax and property tax

### Fiscal policy and reform intentions
- The authorities introduced the GST in July 2022 and are planning direct tax and property tax reforms to further broaden the tax base and increase revenue.
- The authorities concurred that pandemic support measures would need to be more targeted going forward given sustainability and financial stability considerations.
- The authorities reiterated the importance of further developing the domestic bond market as an alternative source of funding and to strengthen fiscal-monetary coordination.

### Key public and external debt indicators (selected)
- External debt (nominal, in percent of GDP):
  - 2019: 105.7
  - 2020: 123.6
  - 2021: 125.3
  - 2022: 127.0
  - 2023: 125.0
  - 2024: 120.2
  - 2025: 113.1
  - 2026: 107.5
  - 2032: 74.2
  - 2042: 35.1
- Of which: public and publicly guaranteed (PPG) external debt broadly follows total external debt (examples: 2019: 103.6; 2020: 121.9; 2021: 125.3; 2022: 127.0).
- Change in external debt (percent of GDP):
  - 2019: -4.9
  - 2020: 17.9
  - 2021: 1.7
  - 2022: 1.7
  - 2023: -2.0
- Identified net debt-creating flows (percent of GDP):
  - 2019: 23.1
  - 2020: 13.9
  - 2021: 12.8
  - 2022: 5.6
  - 2023: 4.4
  - 2024: -1.9
- Sustainability indicators (selected):
  - PV of PPG external debt-to-GDP ratio (selected years): 112.4, 113.0, 112.3, 108.5, 103.3, 97.7, 92.1, 63.9, 27.0
  - PV of PPG external debt-to-exports ratio (selected): 363.1, 374.6, 351.3, 301.1, 268.2, 248.2, 232.0, 186.3, 99.5
  - PPG debt service-to-exports ratio (selected): 9.4, 5.5, 11.5, 21.7, 18.0, 17.8, 17.0, 19.4, 19.1
  - PPG debt service-to-revenue ratio (selected): 16.3, 8.1, 14.0, 36.6, 29.1, 29.7, 28.4, 32.2, 31.6
  - Gross external financing need (Million of U.S. dollars, selected): 550.7, 331.7, 334.0, 410.6, 395.2, 304.3, 168.9, 189.4, 145.5

### Fiscal aggregates and macro assumptions (selected)
- Government revenues (excluding grants, percent of GDP; selected sequence as in source): 18.2, 21.8, 25.4, 17.9, 19.8, 21.5, 23.0, 23.7, 24.1, 24.6, 26.6, 21.7, 22.9
- Aid flows (Million of US dollars, selected): 633.7, 845.4, 201.9, 336.2, 173.2, 172.3, 198.3, 195.4, 192.5, 207.8, 373.7
- Real GDP growth (in percent, selected): 4.4, -2.4, -3.7, 4.4, 4.5, 6.7, 6.2, 5.9, 5.8, 5.8, 5.8, 3.6, 5.7
- GDP deflator in US dollar terms (change in percent, selected): -6.4, 0.9, 3.1, 6.0, 3.9, 3.4, 2.9, 2.6, 2.4, 2.2, 2.2, 0.0, 3.0
- Effective interest rate (percent, selected): 1.2, 0.8, 1.1, 1.4, 1.5, 2.2, 2.8, 3.4, 3.9, 3.9, 2.2, 2.0, 3.2
- Growth of exports of G&S (US dollar terms, in percent, selected): -1.9, 0.8, -5.3, 7.9, 15.1, 24.4, 16.8, 11.0, 9.3, 4.1, 6.1, 0.2, 10.0
- Growth of imports of G&S (US dollar terms, in percent, selected): -1.2, -10.9, -6.2, 15.2, 3.9, 5.6, 6.0, 7.7, 6.0, 5.2, 6.4, -2.2, 5.2

### Public sector debt (selected)
- Public sector debt (percent of GDP, selected): 106.5, 131.2, 134.9, 133.5, 130.9, 124.2, 116.4, 110.7, 105.4, 77.2, 36.9, 109.4, 105.4
- Of which: external debt (percent of GDP) mirrors external series (examples given earlier).
- Primary deficit and primary expenditure (selected):
  - Primary deficit (percent of GDP, selected): 0.7, 1.5, 5.3, 8.8, 6.0, 2.8, 0.4, -0.1, -0.7, -1.6, -2.1, 0.9, 0.6
  - Primary (noninterest) expenditure (percent of GDP, selected): 25.0, 32.6, 39.0, 37.5, 30.1, 29.0, 28.4, 28.1, 27.4, 26.4, 27.3, 32.1, 28.3
- PV of public debt-to-GDP ratio (selected): ...122.2, 120.6, 119.2, 113.5, 106.6, 100.9, 95.3, 66.9, 28.8
- Debt service-to-revenue and grants ratio (selected): 13.0, 6.5, 12.1, 46.5, 38.8, 42.0, 33.8, 35.3, 34.9, 32.5, 16.0
- Gross financing need (percent of GDP, selected): 3.8, 3.5, 9.3, 22.1, 15.4, 13.8, 9.8, 9.8, 9.1, 7.5, 2.6

### Stress tests, sensitivity analysis and risks
- The most extreme stress test identified is a one-off depreciation (noted as the most extreme shock in the analysis).
- Table 3 (sensitivity analysis for public and PPG external debt, 2022–32) highlights:
  - Baseline PV of debt-to-GDP (2022): 113
  - Alternative scenarios and bound tests show large breaches under historical averages and depreciation shocks (e.g., A1 scenario drives PV ratios substantially higher across the projection period).
- Table 4 (sensitivity analysis for public debt, 2022–32) highlights:
  - Baseline PV of public debt-to-GDP (2022): 121
  - Bound tests (B1–B6) produce higher PV outcomes under real GDP growth shocks, depreciation, and combinations of adverse shocks.
- Figures summarize drivers of debt dynamics and contributions from:
  - Nominal interest rate, real GDP growth, price and exchange rate changes, non-interest current account, and unexpected residuals.
- Realism and qualification tools indicate Bhutan’s debt metrics fall within a “Moderate” category across 2022–2042, with graphical thresholds shown for PV debt/GDP, PV debt/exports, debt service/exports, and debt service/revenue.

### Policy implications and priorities highlighted in the text
- Implement planned direct tax and property tax reforms to broaden the tax base and increase revenue following GST introduction.
- Make pandemic support measures more targeted to preserve fiscal sustainability and financial stability.
- Further develop the domestic bond market to diversify funding sources and strengthen fiscal-monetary coordination.
- Monitor debt vulnerabilities under stress scenarios (notably exchange rate depreciation and adverse growth reversals) and ensure contingency planning for financing needs.

_Italic line: Source: 1btnea2022001 - introduction  of the  GST in July 2022, the authorities are planning on direct tax and property tax (IMF staff report content provided in the source PDF)._

### 1. Economic activity was severely impacted due to the COVID-19 pandemic and the adoption

### 1. Economic activity was severely impacted due to the COVID-19 pandemic and the adoption

### Economic impact and recovery
- GDP contracted by 2.4 percent in 2019-20 and 3.7 percent in 2020-21 compared to a growth of 4.4 percent in 2018-19.
- The 2018 Article IV Report had estimated growth of 6.3 and 6 percent for 2019-20 and 2020-21, illustrating the extent of the pandemic shock.
- Contraction was most pronounced in construction, transportation, and tourism sectors.
- Agriculture and electricity sectors witnessed notable performance during the period.
- Supported by an effective vaccination campaign and strong hydroelectricity exports, the economy is expected to witness gradual recovery in 2021-22 and is projected to grow at 4.4 percent.

### Public health response and vaccination
- Bhutan achieved full vaccination of the adult population by July 2021 and of children above 5 years by March 2022.
- Decisive policy measures helped contain the pandemic and loss of lives and mitigate socio-economic costs.

### Inflation and demand-side risks
- Overall annual CPI inflation stood at 5.3 percent in February 2022 compared to 9.5 percent during the same month of the previous year.
- Non-food prices recorded an increase of 6.4 percent; food prices recorded a growth of 4.1 percent.
- The non-food price increase accounted for 62 percent of the overall inflation rate while the remaining was contributed by food prices.
- Continuing uncertainties from the omicron variant, geopolitical conflicts, supply disruptions, and high oil and commodity prices are expected to weaken demand.

### External sector, hydropower, and medium-term outlook
- Hydropower sector constitutes 17 percent of Bhutan’s GDP.
- Share of electricity exports:
  - 26 percent of exports in 2018-19;
  - estimated to increase to 49 percent in 2021-22;
  - projected to further increase to 57 percent in 2026-27.
- Current account deficit and reserve coverage are expected to improve due to an increase in hydropower exports and a decrease in hydropower-related imports.
- With adequate reserve coverage and expected increase in electricity exports, external financing risk is assessed to be low.

### Gross National Happiness (GNH) and human development
- GNH is underpinned by 4 pillars: sustainable & equitable socio-economic development, good governance, environmental conservation, and preservation & promotion of culture.
- Gross National Happiness Commission plays a central role in national planning with emphasis on education, health, and finance.
- Human Development Index improvements:
  - 0.52 in 2005;
  - 0.628 in 2015;
  - 0.654 in 2019.
- Bhutan qualified for graduation from least developed country status by 2023 prior to the pandemic.
- Share of population living on less than $ 3.20 per day:
  - 14.7 percent in 2012;
  - 10.7 percent in 2019;
  - 11.2 percent in 2020.

### Tourism
- International tourism receipts declined from about US $120 million in 2019 to 84 million in 2020.
- International tourism receipts as a share of exports declined from 15.4 to 10.7 percent during the same period, significantly impacting employment and livelihood.
- Authorities are promoting a ‘Brand Bhutan’ with a ‘high value and low volume’ approach: wellness, agro-tourism, community, and eco-tourism products.

### Fiscal policy and public investment
- Five-Year Plans (FYP) provide the blueprint for long-term planning; integrating a rolling budget framework within FYP can help reduce volatility in managing long-term projects.
- About 33 percent of the capital outlay in the 12th FYP has been allocated to budget 2021-22 with a focus on health, education, and infrastructure.
- Capital expenditure:
  - 12.6 percent of GDP in 2019-20;
  - expected to increase to 18.2 percent in 2021-22.
- Fiscal deficit increased to about 6.3 percent in 2020-21 compared to 1.9 percent in 2019-20 due to pandemic-related expenditure.
- Authorities plan to ramp up revenue mobilization and pursue medium-term fiscal consolidation.
- Implementation of GST is expected to kickstart soon; combined with proposed direct tax and property tax reforms it is expected to boost revenue mobilization.
- Preliminary assessments indicate an increase in tax revenue by about 0.4 percent of GDP initially and increasing to 2 percent in the medium-term.

### Debt and debt sustainability
- Debt-to-GDP ratio increased by about 29 percent, reaching about 135 percent in 2020-21.
- Authorities note mitigating factors supporting debt sustainability: tax revenue mobilization measures, significant increase in electricity exports, and completion of hydropower construction.
- External debt risk is expected to remain moderate as most external debt is linked to hydropower loans from India which covers the financial and construction risks.

### Monetary policy and liquidity
- Monetary measures during the pandemic enhanced liquidity and credit and helped banks extend concessional loans to businesses.
- Excess liquidity resulted from strong growth in deposits and weak credit demand.
- Broad money grew by 17.0 percent in November 2021 compared to 21.4 percent in the previous year.
- Aggregate deposits held by commercial banks grew by 18.7 percent in November 2021 compared to 22.3 percent in the previous period.
- Domestic credit witnessed an increase in growth by 23.9 percent compared to only 2.3 percent in the previous period.
- Authorities concur on the need for a Domestic Liquidity Management Framework (DLMF) and digitalization of the financial system.

### Financial sector stability and supervision
- Authorities recognize pre-pandemic vulnerabilities and the need to move from broad-based support to targeted support for sectors, individuals, and businesses most affected by the pandemic.
- Commitment to continue implementation of the NPL resolution framework and Risk-based Supervisory framework (RBS) to boost long-term financial stability.
- Measures include implementation of RBS across all financial institutions and establishing an efficient risk management framework.

### Structural reforms and climate resilience
- Structural reforms are critical for diversifying the economy and boosting long-term growth, including development of high value-added activities.
- Bhutan is one of three carbon negative countries and is exposed to natural disaster risks from climate change, particularly in water-dependent sectors.
- Climate-resilient budgeting aims to support climate change adaptation, disaster risk management, and further greening of energy sources.
- Special attention to tourism through improved infrastructure, skills training, and dissemination of digital content.
- Digital Drukyul Flagship program aims to promote inclusion by leveraging digitalization.
- Pandemic-era programs addressing skill mismatches and unemployment were executed and many could continue post-pandemic.
- Measures for enhancing physical and digital infrastructure with a focus on productivity would be a priority in the 13th FYP.

### Capacity development and IMF collaboration
- Authorities appreciate ongoing CD support provided by the Fund.
- Authorities expressed keenness in strengthening collaboration in digital currency, bond market development, and data coverage.

*Source: IMF country chapter content provided in the supplied PDF excerpt.*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/cr/2022/english/1btnea2022001.pdf_
