## 1. Growth and Exports

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [1. Growth and Exports](https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/cr/2022/english/1mysea2022001.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/files/publications/cr/2022/english/1mysea2022001.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/files/publications/cr/2022/english/1mysea2022001.pdf.json)

---

### Context: Malaysia navigating a multi-speed global recovery
- Pre-pandemic performance and institutions:
  - GDP growth averaged around 5 percent in 2015-2019.
  - Persistent current account surpluses reflecting a surplus of private saving over investments.
  - Long-standing fiscal prudence kept debt levels fairly contained.
  - Bank Negara Malaysia (BNM) is not an inflation targeter; it has a broad mandate and policy toolkit.
- COVID-19 and reopening:
  - About 44¾ percent of the population have received a booster shot by February 28, 2022.
  - Authorities progressed with judicious reopening to avoid repeat strict lockdowns.
- 12th Malaysia Plan (12MP) 2021-25 goals:
  - Aims for high-income status and a carbon-neutral economy.
  - Focus on boosting labor productivity, transport infrastructure, innovation, digital and green economies, narrowing regional disparities, strengthening fiscal governance, and increasing MSME contribution.

### Recent developments: a steady but unbalanced recovery
- Growth, inflation and labor:
  - Real GDP growth limited to about 3 percent in 2021.
  - Inflation contained at 2½ percent in 2021.
  - Unemployment rate: about 4¼ percent in 2021Q4 (2021: 4½ percent).
  - Unemployment for women: 4½ percent; youth unemployment: about 11¾ percent.
  - Only 40 percent of higher-skilled displaced workers are re-employed; over 57 percent of new placements were in jobs earning lower wages.
- Fiscal response and outcomes:
  - Total COVID-related fiscal spending in 2021: RM39 billion (2½ percent of GDP).
  - Initially budgeted RM17 billion; 2020 spending was RM38 billion.
  - Federal government deficit estimated at about 6½ percent of GDP in 2021 (higher than the 5½ percent foreseen in the 2021 Budget).
  - Federal government debt estimated at 63 percent of GDP.
- Monetary and banking sector:
  - BNM overnight policy rate unchanged at 1¾ percent through early 2022.
  - Banking system soundness (end-November 2021):
    - Total capital ratio: 18 percent.
    - Liquidity Coverage Ratio: 145 percent (minimum requirement 100 percent).
    - Non-performing loans (NPLs): 1½ percent of total loans.
    - SME loans under repayment assistance: about 36¾ percent.
    - Total provisions for potential credit losses: around 2 percent of total banking system loans in November 2021.
    - Banks increased provisions by about 60 percent compared to pre-pandemic levels.
- Capital flows and reserves:
  - Net portfolio flows: around $7½ billion by December 2021 (primarily net debt inflows of $8¼ billion).
  - Non-resident holdings of government securities increased by 15¾ percent compared to end-2020.
  - Gross FX reserves increased by US$9¼ billion in 2021, helped by the US$5 billion SDR allocation (about 1¼ percent of GDP).
  - Reserves adequate at 126 percent of the ARA metric.
- External position:
  - 2021 external position preliminarily assessed as moderately stronger than warranted; current account surplus gap of 1.1 percent.
  - External debt declined in 2021 versus 2020 but remains above pre-pandemic levels.
  - One-third of external debt denominated in local currency; about half of short-term external debt is intragroup borrowings.

### Outlook: projections, scarring and risks
- Growth and inflation projections:
  - 2022 growth projected at 5¾ percent.
  - Output gap expected to narrow to -3½ percent in 2022 and -2¼ percent in 2023.
  - Inflation projected to stabilize at 2½ percent.
  - Current account surplus expected to decline gradually over the medium term.
- Scarring and distributional impacts:
  - Pandemic could lead to permanent GDP losses; persistent negative impact on trade and GVC patterns.
  - Pandemic-related loss of schooling estimated by the World Bank at 1.3 years.
  - Distributional risks concentrated on SMEs, contact-intensive sectors, low-skilled workers, and informal sector.
- Risks (GRAM—Appendix VI):
  - Downside risks include: re-intensification of the pandemic with vaccine-resistant variants; fiscal risks from contingent liabilities; long-standing political and policy uncertainty; sharper slowdown in China; disorderly monetary policy normalization in advanced economies; conflict in Ukraine raising volatile and higher food and fuel prices.
  - Upside risk: higher-than-expected pent-up domestic demand.

### Authorities’ views
- Authorities view growth at 5½–6½ percent in 2022, with inflation normalizing towards its long-term average.
- They expect no further lockdowns and a significant narrowing of the output gap in 2022 as the economy reopens.
- Authorities questioned aspects of the external balance assessment and highlighted mitigating factors for external debt: sustained current account surplus, generally stable intragroup borrowings, and sizable net foreign currency-denominated external asset positions held by domestic entities.

---

### Policy discussions: calibrating macro policies and accelerating reforms
- General guidance:
  - Calibrate macro policies to address sizeable economic slack, high uncertainty, and medium-term scarring while preserving policy space.
  - Accelerate structural reforms, including governance and anti-corruption measures, to boost medium-term growth, reduce inequality, and enhance external rebalancing.
  - Consider temporary additional fiscal support and further easing of monetary policy if downside risks materialize.
- Fiscal policy objectives:
  - Sustain recovery, minimize scarring, rebuild buffers, and enhance external rebalancing.
  - 2022 Budget COVID Fund allocation: RM23 billion (1.4 percent of GDP), with increased spending on upskilling, social assistance, and SME financing.
- Staff fiscal recommendation (sequencing and magnitude):
  - Provide modest additional fiscal support by about 2 percentage points cumulatively in 2022 and 2023 above the 2022 budget plans.
  - Delay the start of consolidation by one year to 2023.
  - Additional stimulus to move fiscal impulse in 2022 from negative to moderately positive.
  - Targeted spending priorities: protect vulnerable households (notably low-income highly-indebted households), support viable SMEs in hard-hit sectors, limit scarring on inequality, and increase productive capacity via green and climate-resilient public investment, training and education, strengthened health policies, and digital transformation.
  - Medium-term consolidation to be growth-friendly and primarily revenue-based, starting once the output gap is sufficiently closed.
  - Embed changes to the debt ceiling and ex ante escape clauses within the Fiscal Responsibility Act (FRA) to specify large shocks and temporary breaches, while setting a clear framework to bring debt back under the limit.
  - Authorities’ aim to bring debt below 60 percent of GDP in the medium to long term is appropriate.
  - Staff recommend a larger consolidation (by about 3 percentage points) in the medium term compared to the passive baseline to put debt on a firm downward trend.
- Debt ceiling and limits:
  - Federal government debt remains below the effective debt limit (of 67 percent of GDP) implied by the twice-raised 65 percent of GDP limit on domestic debt under both baseline and staff recommended fiscal paths.
- Governance:
  - Continue implementing fiscal governance reforms with focus on reducing vulnerabilities to corruption.
  - Staff welcome planned reforms to government guarantees under the medium-term debt management strategy.

---

### 18. Embarking on the medium-term revenue strategy (MTRS) is an urgent priority

### Revenue challenges and MTRS priorities
- Tax revenue context:
  - Malaysia’s tax revenues have been on a declining trend and are low compared to peers; the pandemic highlighted the need for revenue mobilization.
  - The 2022 Budget called for bold and effective reforms through adoption of a MTRS to ensure sufficient funding for expenditure needs under the 12MP.
  - A review of the tax incentive system is underway under the MTRS umbrella.
  - Meeting the 3½ percent of GDP targeted deficit will require measures beyond improving tax compliance.
  - Staff estimates suggest that the 2018 GST removal created a revenue loss of 1¼ percent of GDP.
  - Carbon taxation could generate 1 to 3 percent of GDP in fiscal revenues by 2030; staff welcome authorities’ feasibility studies on a carbon tax.
  - Low-income households, workers, and firms vulnerable to higher energy prices implied by a carbon tax could be identified and compensated adequately, including through higher social transfers.
- Policy sequencing:
  - Front-load efficiency- and equity-enhancing tax reforms that do not raise the average tax burden to support expansionary fiscal stance.
  - Consider reinstating the GST once recovery is entrenched.
  - Continue MTRS workstream including review of tax incentives and carbon tax feasibility studies.
  - Optimize expenditures via public expenditure review, targeted subsidies, and pension and civil service reforms.
  - Finalize and introduce the FRA to enhance governance, accountability, and transparency.

### Fiscal path: Baseline vs. Staff recommendation (key indicators)
- Structural Primary Deficit to Potential GDP (2021–2027)
  - Baseline: -3.3, -2.9, -1.4, -1.1, -0.9, -0.7, -0.7
  - Staff recommended: -3.3, -3.6, -2.8, -1.3, -0.2, 0.4, 0.6
- Fiscal Impulse (2021–2027)
  - Baseline: 1.0, -0.4, -1.5, -0.3, -0.3, -0.2, 0.0
  - Staff recommended: 1.0, 0.3, -0.8, -1.5, -1.1, -0.6, -0.2
- Overall Deficit to GDP (2021–2027)
  - Baseline: -6.4, -6.1, -4.6, -4.4, -4.3, -4.2, -4.2
  - Staff recommended: -6.4, -7.0, -5.9, -4.4, -3.4, -3.0, -2.9
- Federal Government Debt to GDP (2021–2027)
  - Baseline: 63.4, 65.0, 64.3, 64.3, 64.2, 63.9, 63.8
  - Staff recommended: 63.4, 65.7, 66.1, 66.1, 65.9, 64.9, 63.8
- Output Gap (2021–2027)
  - Baseline: -3.8, -3.6, -2.2, -1.5, -1.1, -0.7, 0.0
  - Staff recommended: -3.5, -2.8, -1.0, -0.1, -0.2, -0.3, -0.3

---

### 34. Fund capacity development (CD) work aims to be supportive of surveillance advice and the authorities’ policy agenda

### CD and surveillance nexus: priority linkages
- CD priorities aligned with surveillance advice:
  - Fiscal Responsibility Act (FRA): key to putting debt on a firm downward trend, rebuilding fiscal buffers and enhancing governance and transparency.
  - Medium-Term Revenue Strategy (MTRS): central pillar to address declining tax revenues and support medium-term consolidation.
  - Social safety nets: strengthen coverage, address fragmentation, and raise benefits to adequate levels.
  - Integrated Policy Framework (IPF): strengthen macroeconomic modelling, operationalize IPF tools and explore interactions between FXI and other IPF tools.
- Staff appraisal: macro outlook and risks
  - Recovery steady but uneven; manufacturing-led rebound while contact-intensive sectors remain weak.
  - Malaysia’s 2021 external position moderately stronger than warranted.
  - Downside risks include vaccine-resistant variants, monetary policy normalization in advanced economies, and spillovers from the conflict in Ukraine.
  - Macro policies should be more accommodative if downside risks materialize.

### Policy guidance: fiscal, monetary, financial sector, structural
- Fiscal:
  - Nimble and targeted near-term support; well-specified medium-term revenue-based consolidation once recovery entrenched.
  - Additional targeted support in 2022-23 to minimize scarring; preserve policy space for future shocks.
- Monetary:
  - Current accommodative stance appropriate; ample liquidity, anchored inflation expectations, and slack in the economy.
  - Monetary policy should remain data dependent.
  - Flexible ringgit exchange rate welcomed as first line of defense.
- Financial sector:
  - Authorities' commitment to safeguard financial stability while unwinding pandemic measures is welcome.
  - Pockets of vulnerability among low-income borrowers; strengthen personal bankruptcy and repayment frameworks.
  - Targeted financial sector support and progressive unwinding recommended.
- Structural:
  - Determined implementation of 12MP to minimize scarring, enhance resilience and inclusive growth.
  - Strengthen social safety nets, liberalize non-tariff barriers, and implement governance and anti-corruption reforms.

---

### Article IV recommendation and selected macro-financial indicators

### Recommendation
- It is recommended that the next Article IV consultation with Malaysia be held on the standard 12-month cycle.

### Key macro-financial indicators and medium-term projections (selected)
- Nominal GDP (2021): US$372.8 billion
- Population (2020): 32.6 million
- GDP per capita (2021, current prices): US$10,350
- Poverty rate (2019, national poverty line): 0.2 percent
- Unemployment rate (2021, end-of-period): 4.2 percent
- Real GDP (percent change), selected years: 5.8 (2017), 4.8 (2018), 4.4 (2019), -5.6 (2020), 3.1 (2021), 5.7 (2022 proj.), 5.7 (2023 proj.), 5.0 (2024 proj.).
- Current account balance (in billions of U.S. dollars): 8.9 (2017), 8.0 (2018), 12.8 (2019), 14.3 (2020), 12.9 (2021).
- Total external debt (in billions of U.S. dollars): 218.8 (2017), 223.5 (2018), 231.5 (2019), 238.5 (2020), 256.4 (2021).
- Household debt (in percent of GDP): 82.6 (2017), 82.0 (2018), 82.7 (2019), 93.2 (2020).

### Fiscal and monetary developments (selected series)
- Overnight policy rate (in percent) historical values: 3.00, 3.25, 3.00, 1.75, 1.75.
- Broad money (percentage change, end-of-period): 4.8, 7.7, 2.7, 4.9, 5.6 (2017–2021).
- Federal government overall balance (in percent of GDP): -2.9 (2017), -3.7 (2018), -3.4 (2019), -6.2 (2020), -6.4 (2021).
- Revenue (percent of GDP): 16.1 (2017), 16.1 (2018), 17.5 (2019), 15.9 (2020), 14.3 (2021).
- Federal government debt (percent of GDP): 50.0 (2017), 51.2 (2018), 52.4 (2019), 62.1 (2020), 63.4 (2021).
- Goods exports, f.o.b., value growth (in U.S. dollars, percent): 12.3 (2017), 10.4 (2018), -4.1 (2019), -6.2 (2020), 27.4 (2021).
- Gross official reserves (in billions of U.S. dollars): 102.4 (2017), 101.4 (2018), 103.6 (2019), 107.6 (2020), 116.9 (2021).

---

### Appendix highlights

### Financial Sector Blueprint: 2022-2026 (Appendix I)
- Strategy focus: foster financial inclusion, economic transformation, and a sustainable economy aligned with 12MP.
- COVID-19 financial support:
  - Fund for SMEs enhanced by RM4.5 billion, total RM11.2 billion as of mid-September 2021.
  - Under enhanced TRRF, SMEs can utilize up to 30 percent of approved financing to repay existing business financing.
  - Six-month loan moratorium available to all individuals, microenterprises, and affected SMEs effective July 7, 2021.
- Five strategic thrusts:
  - Fund economic transformation; elevate household and business financial well-being; advance digitalization; facilitate orderly green transition; advance value-based Islamic finance leadership.

### Public Debt Sustainability Analysis (Appendix II, selected)
- Starting conditions and outlook:
  - Malaysia started the pandemic with at-risk fiscal space.
  - Under current policies, federal government debt projected to stabilize around 64 percent of GDP in the medium term.
  - Credible medium-term consolidation required to place debt on a clear downward path.
- Debt profile vulnerabilities (MAC-DSA):
  - Annual change in short-term public debt: 1.2 percent (upper benchmark 1 percent).
  - Share of debt held externally: 26 percent of total debt.
  - Share of debt denominated in foreign currency: 3 percent of total debt.
  - External financing requirement: 31 percent of GDP in 2020.
- Debt limits and ceilings:
  - Domestic debt ceiling raised to 65 percent of GDP in 2020-2021; effective federal government debt ceiling stands at 67.9 percent of GDP in 2021 and 67.7 percent of GDP in 2022.
- Stress tests:
  - Under a contingent liability shock (committed guarantees totaling 13 percent of GDP over 5 years) debt-to-GDP would rise to 77.2 percent of GDP in the medium term.

### External Sector Assessment (Appendix III, selected)
- Overall: 2021 external position assessed as moderately stronger than warranted.
- NIIP and external debt:
  - NIIP: 5.9 percent of GDP in 2021.
  - Total external debt: about 68 percent of GDP in 2021.
  - One third of external debt in foreign currency; 37 percent short-term by original maturity.
- Current account:
  - CA account surplus narrowed slightly to 3.5 percent of GDP in 2021 (compared to 4.2 percent in 2020).
  - After adjusting for transitory COVID-19 effects, IMF staff CA gap estimated about 1.1 percent of GDP (±1 percent of GDP).
- REER assessment:
  - IMF staff CA gap implies a REER undervaluation of −2.4 percent in 2021; staff assesses REER undervaluation in range −0.4 to −4.4 percent, midpoint −2.4 percent.
- Reserves and FX policy:
  - Gross official reserves: US$116.9 billion as of December 2021.
  - Reserves about 126 percent of the ARA metric; FX interventions should be limited to preventing disorderly market conditions.

### Capital flows, volatility and CFMs (Appendix IX)
- Foreign capital and volatility:
  - FDI just above 3 percent of GDP per annum.
  - Non-resident portfolio investments added about 1.6 percent of GDP on average.
  - Other investment account balance about 0.6 percent of GDP per annum on average in 2002-2021.
- Spillovers from AE policy normalization:
  - "100-basis-point tightening of US monetary policy leads to an immediate 1 percentage point depreciation of EM currencies vis-à-vis the US dollar and portfolio outflows from EM of 7 basis points of annual GDP (IMF 2021a)."
- Policy implications:
  - Exchange rate should remain the first line of defense; FXI appropriate for preventing excessive volatility; CFMs to be phased out gradually with regard to market conditions.

### External debt medium-term projection (section 4)
- Medium-term baseline:
  - External debt-to-GDP ratio projected to fall to about 55 percent by 2027.
  - Gross external financing needs: 28 percent of GDP in 2021; about 22 percent of GDP by 2027.
  - Short-term debt share projected to stabilize at about 35 percent of total external debt.
- Stress-test outcomes (external debt as percent of GDP):
  - Baseline: 55
  - Historical: around 73
  - One-time real depreciation of 30 percent: 75
  - CA shock: 57
  - Combined shock: 59
  - Growth shock: 61
  - Interest rate shock: 56
- Reserves and coverage:
  - Gross official reserves (Dec 2021): US$116.9 billion.
  - Reserves coverage of short-term external debt: about 120 percent.
  - Reserves vs. ARA metric: about 126 percent.

---

### Trade, scarring, NTBs and structural policies (Chapter 13 and related)
- NTB reductions and GVCs:
  - EMDEs receive larger benefits from reducing NTBs; gains are especially pronounced for GVC-intensive countries.
  - Malaysia is GVC-intensive and could achieve large gains from NTB reductions.
  - Trade liberalization can counter medium-term scarring by boosting growth, productivity, and investment; gains amplified when coupled with other structural reforms.
- Scarring estimates (sample of 39 EMs, 1980-2019):
  - Potential output more than 4 percent lower after a recession compared to no recession.
  - When recessions coincide with pandemics, central estimate of losses is 15 percent (wide confidence interval).
  - After 5 years: labor productivity more than 5 percent lower; investment more than 2 percent lower.
  - A one percent of GDP increase in public investment associated with around 5 percentage points higher potential output after five years.
- Malaysia-specific scarring and policy implications:
  - Historical scarring in Malaysia larger than median EM due to relatively large pre-crisis debt accumulation.
  - Mitigating factors: flexible business and labor market regulations.
  - Recommended policy directions: credible growth-friendly medium-term consolidation, proactive policies to address household debt overhang, complementary structural reforms to amplify gains from NTB reductions.

---

### Climate mitigation and carbon pricing (Appendices on climate and simulations)
- Emissions and commitments:
  - Malaysia emits approximately 0.7 percent of annual global CO2; accounts for 0.35 percent of cumulative historical CO2 emissions.
  - Sectoral energy-related CO2 emissions (2018): Power generation 48 percent; Transportation 25 percent; Industry 25 percent; Residential 1 percent.
  - Government commitments: unconditional 35 percent reduction in greenhouse gas intensity by 2030 updated to 45 percent; PM pledged net zero emissions as early as 2050.
- Carbon pricing simulation results (IMF/World Bank CPAT):
  - Emissions reduction in 2030 relative to BAU:
    - US$25/tCO2 → 8 percent reduction
    - US$50/tCO2 → 12 percent reduction
    - US$75/tCO2 → 15 percent reduction
  - Fiscal revenue potential in 2030:
    - US$25/tCO2 → 1 percent of GDP
    - US$50/tCO2 → 2 percent of GDP
    - US$75/tCO2 → 3 percent of GDP
- Distributional and price impacts (US$75/tCO2 in 2030; percent changes shown):
  - Coal: 111%
  - Natural gas: 75%
  - Diesel: 65%
  - Oil: 54%
  - Electricity: 39%
  - Kerosene: 31%
  - LPG: 28%
  - Gasoline: 27%
- Revenue recycling simulations:
  - Recycling 100 percent of carbon tax revenues to public investment yields highest net GDP gains; 50/50 investment/transfers could raise GDP growth by about 1 percentage point higher than baseline in medium/long run.
- Policy recommendations:
  - Implement carbon pricing as central mitigation tool with rising predictable price path and broad coverage; consider carbon tax for revenue and predictability.
  - Recycle revenues to compensate vulnerable households and fund green/public investment, including adaptation.
  - Design compensatory transfers carefully to reach informal sector and vulnerable groups.
  - Align COVID-19 recovery spending with environmental goals; condition firm support on environmental compliance.

---

### Support to firms, SME targeting and insolvency frameworks
- Support design principles:
  - Non-viable pre-pandemic firms should exit.
  - Solvent but illiquid firms get liquidity assistance (soft loans, deferrals, moratoria).
  - Insolvent but viable firms may receive loans or equity injections; otherwise restructuring or liquidation.
  - Simplify and incentivize informal out-of-court resolution frameworks for efficient restructuring.
- Malaysia context:
  - SMEs: 1.52 million establishments (97.2 percent of total); 7.25 million jobs (about 48 percent of employment); 38.2 percent of GDP; 13.5 percent of exports; SMEs represent 85.5 percent of the service sector.
  - High informality and information constraints imply staged support and eligibility linked to social value/externalities and objective markers.
- Policy recommendations for corporate support:
  - Link support to firm condition, require compliance terms and clear exit strategies to limit moral hazard and adverse selection.
  - Strengthen insolvency frameworks and facilitate resource reallocation.

---

Final source attribution:
*Source: 1mysea2022001 — Selected excerpts from IMF staff report and appendices as provided in the supplied content unit.*

### 1. Growth and Exports _________________________________________________________________________ 19

### 1. Growth and Exports

### Context: Malaysia navigating a multi-speed global recovery
- Pre-pandemic performance:
  - GDP growth averaged around 5 percent in 2015-2019.
  - Persistent current account surpluses reflecting a surplus of private saving over investments.
  - Long-standing fiscal prudence kept debt levels fairly contained.
  - Bank Negara Malaysia (BNM) is not an inflation targeter; it has a broad mandate and policy toolkit.
- COVID-19 and reopening:
  - About 44¾ percent of the population have received a booster shot by February 28, 2022.
  - Authorities progressed with judicious reopening to avoid repeat strict lockdowns.
- 12th Malaysia Plan (12MP) 2021-25 goals:
  - Aims for high-income status and a carbon-neutral economy.
  - Focus on boosting labor productivity, transport infrastructure, innovation, digital and green economies, narrowing regional disparities, strengthening fiscal governance, and increasing MSME contribution.

### Recent developments: a steady but unbalanced recovery
- Growth and inflation:
  - Real GDP growth limited to about 3 percent in 2021.
  - Inflation contained at 2½ percent in 2021.
- Pandemic fiscal response:
  - Total COVID-related fiscal spending in 2021: RM39 billion (2½ percent of GDP).
  - Initially budgeted RM17 billion; 2020 spending was RM38 billion.
  - Federal government deficit estimated at about 6½ percent of GDP in 2021 (higher than the 5½ percent foreseen in the 2021 Budget).
  - Federal government debt estimated at 63 percent of GDP.
- Monetary policy and banking measures:
  - BNM overnight policy rate unchanged at 1¾ percent through early 2022.
  - Additional lending facilities for SMEs; six-month loan moratorium extended to individuals, micro enterprises and SMEs in July 2021.
- Labor market:
  - Unemployment rate: about 4¼ percent in 2021Q4 (2021: 4½ percent).
  - Unemployment for women: 4½ percent; youth unemployment: about 11¾ percent.
  - Only 40 percent of higher-skilled displaced workers are re-employed; over 57 percent of new placements were in jobs earning lower wages.
- Banking sector soundness (end-November 2021):
  - Total capital ratio: 18 percent.
  - Liquidity Coverage Ratio: 145 percent (minimum requirement 100 percent).
  - Non-performing loans (NPLs): 1½ percent of total loans.
  - SME loans under repayment assistance: about 36¾ percent.
  - Total provisions for potential credit losses: around 2 percent of total banking system loans in November 2021.
  - Banks increased provisions by about 60 percent compared to pre-pandemic levels.
- Capital flows and reserves:
  - Net portfolio flows: around $7½ billion by December 2021 (primarily net debt inflows of $8¼ billion).
  - Non-resident holdings of government securities increased by 15¾ percent compared to end-2020.
  - Gross FX reserves increased by US$9¼ billion in 2021, helped by the US$5 billion SDR allocation (about 1¼ percent of GDP).
  - Reserves adequate at 126 percent of the ARA metric.
- External position:
  - 2021 external position preliminarily assessed as moderately stronger than warranted; current account surplus gap of 1.1 percent.
  - External debt declined in 2021 versus 2020 but remains above pre-pandemic levels.
  - One-third of external debt denominated in local currency; about half of short-term external debt is intragroup borrowings.

### Outlook: solid growth with lingering scarring and downside risks
- Growth and inflation projections:
  - 2022 growth projected at 5¾ percent.
  - Output gap expected to narrow to -3½ percent in 2022 and -2¼ percent in 2023.
  - Inflation projected to stabilize at 2½ percent.
  - Current account surplus expected to decline gradually over the medium term.
- Scarring and distributional impacts:
  - Pandemic could lead to permanent GDP losses; persistent negative impact on trade and GVC patterns.
  - Pandemic-related loss of schooling estimated by the World Bank at 1.3 years.
  - Distributional risks concentrated on SMEs, contact-intensive sectors, low-skilled workers, and informal sector.
- Risks (GRAM—Appendix VI):
  - Downside risks:
    - Re-intensification of the pandemic with vaccine-resistant variants.
    - Fiscal risks from contingent liabilities.
    - Long-standing political and policy uncertainty affecting reform momentum and public investment.
    - Sharper slowdown in China; disorderly monetary policy normalization in advanced economies.
    - Conflict in Ukraine raising volatile and higher food and fuel prices.
  - Upside risk:
    - Higher-than-expected pent-up domestic demand.

### Authorities’ views
- Authorities view growth at 5½–6½ percent in 2022, with inflation normalizing towards its long-term average.
- They expect no further lockdowns and a significant narrowing of the output gap in 2022 as the economy reopens.
- Authorities questioned aspects of the external balance assessment and highlighted mitigating factors for external debt: sustained current account surplus, generally stable intragroup borrowings, and sizable net foreign currency-denominated external asset positions held by domestic entities.

### Policy discussions: calibrating macro policies and accelerating reforms
- General guidance:
  - Calibrate macro policies to address sizeable economic slack, high uncertainty, and medium-term scarring while preserving policy space.
  - Accelerate structural reforms, including governance and anti-corruption measures, to boost medium-term growth, reduce inequality, and enhance external rebalancing.
  - Consider temporary additional fiscal support and further easing of monetary policy if downside risks materialize.
- Fiscal policy: sustaining recovery, minimizing scarring, rebuilding buffers, and enhancing external rebalancing
  - 2022 Budget COVID Fund allocation: RM23 billion (1.4 percent of GDP), with increased spending on upskilling, social assistance, and SME financing.
  - Staff recommendation:
    - Provide modest additional fiscal support by about 2 percentage points cumulatively in 2022 and 2023 above the 2022 budget plans.
    - Delay the start of consolidation by one year to 2023.
    - Additional stimulus to move fiscal impulse in 2022 from negative to moderately positive.
    - Targeted spending priorities: protect vulnerable households (notably low-income highly-indebted households), support viable SMEs in hard-hit sectors, limit scarring on inequality, and increase productive capacity via green and climate-resilient public investment, training and education, strengthened health policies, and digital transformation.
    - Medium-term consolidation to be growth-friendly and primarily revenue-based, starting once the output gap is sufficiently closed.
    - Embed changes to the debt ceiling and ex ante escape clauses within the Fiscal Responsibility Act (FRA) to specify large shocks and temporary breaches, while setting a clear framework to bring debt back under the limit.
    - Authorities’ aim to bring debt below 60 percent of GDP in the medium to long term is appropriate.
    - Staff recommend a larger consolidation (by about 3 percentage points) in the medium term compared to the passive baseline to put debt on a firm downward trend.
  - Debt ceiling and limits:
    - Federal government debt remains below the effective debt limit (of 67 percent of GDP) implied by the twice-raised 65 percent of GDP limit on domestic debt under both baseline and staff recommended fiscal paths.
  - Governance:
    - Continue implementing fiscal governance reforms with focus on reducing vulnerabilities to corruption.
    - Staff welcome planned reforms to government guarantees under the medium-term debt management strategy.

*Source: 1. Growth and Exports — Malaysia, International Monetary Fund.*

### 18.      Embarking on the medium-term revenue strategy (MTRS) is an urgent priority.

### 18.      Embarking on the medium-term revenue strategy (MTRS) is an urgent priority.

### Revenue challenges and MTRS priorities
- Malaysia’s tax revenues have been on a declining trend and are low compared to peers; the pandemic highlighted the need for revenue mobilization.
- The 2022 Budget called for bold and effective reforms through adoption of a MTRS to ensure sufficient funding for expenditure needs under the 12MP.
- A review of the tax incentive system is underway under the MTRS umbrella.
- Meeting the 3½ percent of GDP targeted deficit will require measures beyond improving tax compliance.
- Policy reforms that increase the efficiency and equity of the tax system without imposing a higher average tax burden should be front-loaded to support the recommended expansionary fiscal stance.
- Once the recovery is entrenched, tax policy options include reinstatement of the goods and services tax (GST).
- Staff estimates suggest that the 2018 GST removal created a revenue loss of 1¼ percent of GDP.
- Carbon taxation should be considered in the context of a comprehensive climate mitigation strategy that could generate 1 to 3 percent of GDP in fiscal revenues by 2030; staff welcome the authorities’ ongoing feasibility studies on a carbon tax.
- Low-income households, workers, and firms vulnerable to higher energy prices implied by a carbon tax could be identified and compensated adequately, including through higher social transfers.

### Fiscal path: Baseline vs. Staff recommendation (key indicators)
- Structural Primary Deficit to Potential GDP (2021–2027)
  - Baseline: -3.3, -2.9, -1.4, -1.1, -0.9, -0.7, -0.7
  - Staff recommended: -3.3, -3.6, -2.8, -1.3, -0.2, 0.4, 0.6
- Fiscal Impulse (2021–2027)
  - Baseline: 1.0, -0.4, -1.5, -0.3, -0.3, -0.2, 0.0
  - Staff recommended: 1.0, 0.3, -0.8, -1.5, -1.1, -0.6, -0.2
- Overall Deficit to GDP (2021–2027)
  - Baseline: -6.4, -6.1, -4.6, -4.4, -4.3, -4.2, -4.2
  - Staff recommended: -6.4, -7.0, -5.9, -4.4, -3.4, -3.0, -2.9
- Federal Government Debt to GDP (2021–2027)
  - Baseline: 63.4, 65.0, 64.3, 64.3, 64.2, 63.9, 63.8
  - Staff recommended: 63.4, 65.7, 66.1, 66.1, 65.9, 64.9, 63.8
- Output Gap (2021–2027)
  - Baseline: -3.8, -3.6, -2.2, -1.5, -1.1, -0.7, 0.0
  - Staff recommended: -3.5, -2.8, -1.0, -0.1, -0.2, -0.3, -0.3

### Policy recommendations and sequencing
- Front-load efficiency- and equity-enhancing tax reforms that do not raise the average tax burden to support expansionary fiscal stance.
- Consider reinstating the GST once recovery is entrenched to help reach fiscal targets.
- Consider carbon taxation as part of a broader mitigation strategy; design compensatory measures for vulnerable households, workers, and firms (including higher social transfers).
- Continue the MTRS workstream including review of tax incentives and studies on feasibility of carbon tax implementation.
- Optimize expenditures to enhance spending efficiency through public expenditure review, targeted subsidies, and pension and civil service reforms.
- Finalize and introduce the FRA to enhance governance, accountability, and transparency in fiscal management.

### Fiscal-space assessment and implications
- Malaysia exhibits several favorable debt-dynamics features: high share of debt held domestically, issued in local currency, at longer maturities; negative interest rate growth differentials; low public gross financing needs; reasonable market access costs; and lack of demographic pressures.
- Increase in debt post-pandemic and high contingent liabilities are relevant considerations.
- Model advice, baseline, and staff-recommended paths show differing trajectories for structural primary balance and output gap, informing the recommended pace of consolidation.

### Authorities’ stance on MTRS and fiscal policy
- Authorities view the policy response as having averted a deeper downturn and consider resuming fiscal consolidation appropriate given cyclical improvement in 2022.
- A domestic debt ceiling of 65 percent of GDP is envisaged to remain until 2025, with a goal of reducing debt below 60 percent by then.
- Authorities will advance the MTRS and consider reintroduction of GST, carbon tax, and capital gains tax once the recovery is entrenched.
- Authorities are optimizing expenditures, finalizing the FRA, and pursuing pension and civil service reforms to enhance fiscal governance and efficiency.

*Source: 1mysea2022001 - 18.      Embarking on the medium-term revenue strategy (MTRS) is an urgent priority.*

### 34.      Fund capacity development (CD) work aims to be supportive of surveillance advice and

### 34.      Fund capacity development (CD) work aims to be supportive of surveillance advice and the authorities’ policy agenda.

### CD and Surveillance Nexus
- Progress on finalizing the FRA and developing the MTRS is welcome; authorities could consider engaging the Fund for any remaining capacity development needs on both fronts, as needed.
- The pandemic highlighted the need to strengthen the targeting of welfare programs, especially given its likely impact on inequality.
- Ongoing joint technical work with the BNM on macro-modelling has gained traction with the BNM and supports the Fund’s workstream in the operationalization of the integrated policy framework (IPF).

- Text Table — The Nexus Between CD Priorities and Surveillance Advice:
  - Fiscal Responsibility Act (FRA)
    - FRA is key to putting debt on a firm downward trend, rebuild fiscal buffers necessary to respond to future shocks and ensure robust fiscal governance and transparency to enhance management of the public finances.
  - Medium-Term Revenue Strategy (MTRS)
    - A MTRS is needed as a central pillar of medium-term fiscal consolidation as Malaysia’s tax revenues have been on a declining trend and are low compared to peers.
  - Social safety nets
    - Social safety nets should be strengthened to expand the coverage of the system, address its fragmentation, and raise benefits to adequate levels, a high priority that has been laid bare by the pandemic.
  - Integrated Policy Framework (IPF)
    - Strengthen macroeconomic modelling, operationalize IPF tools and explore interactions between FXI and other IPF tools.

### Staff appraisal — macroeconomic outlook and risks
- The recovery is steady but remains uneven.
  - After being hard hit in 2020, the Malaysian economy rebounded in 2021 with growth driven by the manufacturing sector on the back of strong external demand.
  - Contact-intensive and the agriculture sectors however remained weak.
  - Malaysia’s 2021 external position was moderately stronger than warranted relative to fundamentals and desirable policies.
- Downside risks cloud the near-term outlook.
  - These include vaccine-resistant COVID-19 variants, amid the recent uptick in Omicron cases, monetary policy normalization in advanced economies and spillovers from the ongoing conflict in Ukraine.
  - Distributional risks of the pandemic threaten progress toward reducing inequality over the last decades.
  - Macro policies need to be more accommodative if downside risks materialize.

### Fiscal and monetary policy guidance
- Fiscal policy
  - Fiscal policy needs to be nimble and targeted to buttress the recovery in the near term, followed by well-specified fiscal consolidation centered on revenue mobilization over the medium term.
  - Additional targeted support is warranted in 2022-23 with a focus on the vulnerable and hard-hit sectors to minimize scarring.
  - Policy space should be preserved for future shocks, including a protracted pandemic.
  - Fiscal consolidation should start once the recovery is entrenched, be primarily revenue-based and support spending priorities to facilitate external rebalancing.
  - Staff welcome the authorities’ commitment to fiscal sustainability.
- Monetary policy
  - The current accommodative monetary policy stance is appropriate.
  - There is ample liquidity in the financial system, inflation expectations are well anchored, and there remains slack in the economy.
  - Monetary policy should remain data dependent, guided by close monitoring of pandemic developments, inflation expectations and wage growth.
  - Staff welcome the authorities’ ongoing joint work with the Fund towards operationalizing the IPF tools, an example of effective CD-surveillance integration.
  - The flexible ringgit exchange rate has served Malaysia well, and the authorities’ continued commitment to exchange rate flexibility is welcome.

### Financial sector and structural policies
- Financial sector stability
  - The authorities’ commitment to safeguarding the stability of the financial sector as pandemic measures are being unwound is welcome.
  - While aggregate household net financial asset position remains comfortable, pockets of vulnerabilities remain in the low-income borrowers’ segment.
  - Continued efforts to strengthen personal bankruptcy liquidation and bankruptcy repayment plans could support orderly deleveraging.
  - Staff welcomes the authorities’ continued targeting of financial sector support measures and their progressive unwinding in line with the recovery, while paying close attention to financial stability risks.
- Structural and inclusive growth policies
  - Determined implementation of 12MP will help minimize pandemic-related economic scarring and enhance economic resilience while promoting inclusive growth and job creation.
  - The 12th Malaysia Plan focus on labor market reskilling and boosting productivity would help lift up potential growth.
  - Strengthening social safety nets would support inclusive recovery and staff sees scope for additional CD support to improve the targeting of welfare programs especially given the likely impact of the pandemic on inequality.
  - Liberalizing non-tariff barriers could provide a welcome fillip to growth.
  - A holistic and multi-pronged strategy is needed to adapt the national tourism model to the post-pandemic new normal.
  - Robust governance and anti-corruption reforms, including the implementation of the strategies outlined in the National Anti-Corruption Plan, would strengthen the management of the public finances.

*Source: 1mysea2022001 - 34.      Fund capacity development (CD) work aims to be supportive of surveillance advice and the authorities’ policy agenda.*

### 41.      It is recommended that the next Article IV consultation with Malaysia be held on the

### 1mysea2022001 - 41.      It is recommended that the next Article IV consultation with Malaysia be held on the

### Recommendation
- It is recommended that the next Article IV consultation with Malaysia be held on the standard 12-month cycle.

### Growth and exports
- Growth rebounded since its 2020 lows, but momentum stalled in 2021Q2 following a severe COVID-19 Delta wave.
- Private domestic demand recovered, while strong net exports continued given strong pandemic-related external demand.
- The export-oriented manufacturing sector underpinned growth; lockdown measures affected other sectors.
- Exports remained strong, supported by external demand for pharmaceutical and electric equipment, but declined somewhat in Q3 following lockdown measures.
- Import volumes rebounded as investment sentiment recovered, led by machinery, manufactured goods, and chemicals.
- The current account surplus narrowed relative to 2020 despite strong exports, as imports gradually recovered.

### Inflation and domestic resource constraints
- Inflation remained contained in 2021 despite strong base effects in Q2.
- Core inflation remained benign given slack in the economy and labor markets.
- Producer prices increased reflecting a rebound in global demand, higher commodity prices and supply disruptions.
- Industrial production resumed its recovery following a decline during the COVID wave in Q3.
- Unemployment remained high as pandemic-prompted lockdowns stalled growth in most sectors.
- Growth in manufacturing and services wages remains modest.

### Monetary developments
- Bank Negara Malaysia (BNM) maintained the policy rate at historical low while lending rates also remain low.
- The real policy rate and the real deposit entered negative territory but are close to zero.
- Demand deposits and currency in circulation have picked up after declining, partly driving a pick-up in broad money growth.
- Banking system deposits have picked up, while financial conditions have eased since the significant tightening in early 2020.
- Overnight policy rate (in percent) historical values: 3.00, 3.25, 3.00, 1.75, 1.75 (presented in the source).
- Broad money (percentage change, end-of-period): 4.8, 7.7, 2.7, 4.9, 5.6 (2017–2021).

### Capital flows and external sector
- Capital flows returned in 2021 as portfolio debt inflows persisted.
- Foreign holdings of ringgit-denominated government securities increased; BNM’s gross reserves steadily increased in 2021.
- Real-effective exchange rate appreciated in 2021H2, but remains below pre-pandemic levels as the ringgit weakened vis-à-vis US dollar.
- The stock market remained volatile and closed in modest losses in 2021.
- Goods exports, f.o.b., value growth (in U.S. dollars, percent): 12.3 (2017), 10.4 (2018), -4.1 (2019), -6.2 (2020), 27.4 (2021).
- Gross official reserves (in billions of U.S. dollars): 102.4 (2017), 101.4 (2018), 103.6 (2019), 107.6 (2020), 116.9 (2021).

### Fiscal policy developments
- The pandemic led to a large fiscal deficit in 2020 and 2021 while revenues continued their pre-pandemic weakening trend.
- Current expenditures increased, particularly on subsidies; development expenditure has been on a rising trend since 2019.
- Federal government deficit and debt levels have continued rising in 2021 following the step increase in 2020.
- Guarantees remain close to 20 percent of GDP after a sharp increase during the pandemic.
- Federal government overall balance (in percent of GDP): -2.9 (2017), -3.7 (2018), -3.4 (2019), -6.2 (2020), -6.4 (2021).
- Revenue (percent of GDP): 16.1 (2017), 16.1 (2018), 17.5 (2019), 15.9 (2020), 14.3 (2021).
- Expenditure and net lending (percent of GDP): 19.0 (2017), 19.8 (2018), 18.4 (2019), 22.1 (2020), 20.7 (2021).
- Federal government debt (percent of GDP): 50.0 (2017), 51.2 (2018), 52.4 (2019), 62.1 (2020), 63.4 (2021).

### Public sector fiscal stance and prospects
- Prior to the pandemic, the Non-Financial Public Sector (NFPS) deficit had been improving since 2015.
- Public companies’ surpluses have been sustained.
- General government development spending has recently picked up, with Petronas’ share lower than before.

### Banking sector developments and financial soundness
- Credit growth remains stable but credit has declined as a share of GDP as GDP partially recovered.
- Credit to the private sector remains subdued but credit to households has increased.
- Corporate leverage compares favorably to peers.
- The banking system remains well capitalized while non-performing loans remain low.
- The banking system continues to rely on short-term external debt; banks’ net external asset position remains weak.
- Regulatory capital to risk-weighted assets: 17.8 (2017), 18.1 (2018), 18.6 (2019), 18.9 (2020), 18.2 (2021Q3).
- Nonperforming loans to total gross loans: 1.5 (2017), 1.5 (2018), 1.5 (2019), 1.6 (2020), 1.6 (2021Q3).
- Return on assets: 1.4 (2017), 1.4 (2018), 1.5 (2019), 1.1 (2020), 1.2 (2021Q3).
- Liquidity coverage ratio: 134.9 (2017), 143.2 (2018), 149.1 (2019), 148.2 (2020), 154.4 (2021Q3).

### Household debt and property market
- Household debt as share of GDP moderates but remains high compared to ASEAN peers and above levels observed in countries with similar GDP per capita.
- Housing loans remained broadly stable.
- Household non-performing loans after a decline on the back of loan moratoria have picked up but remain low.
- Household financial assets increased in 2020 as share of GDP.
- House prices have declined in Q3 2021.
- Price-to-income ratio has begun to stabilize after a surge on the back of the collapse in income in 2020Q2.
- Residential supply has been increasing; construction starts are on a recovery path.

### Key indicators and medium-term projections (selected)
- Nominal GDP (2021): US$372.8 billion
- Population (2020): 32.6 million
- GDP per capita (2021, current prices): US$10,350
- Poverty rate (2019, national poverty line): 0.2 percent
- Unemployment rate (2021, end-of-period): 4.2 percent
- Adult literacy rate (2019): 95.0 percent
- Real GDP (percent change), selected years: 5.8 (2017), 4.8 (2018), 4.4 (2019), -5.6 (2020), 3.1 (2021), 5.7 (2022 proj.), 5.7 (2023 proj.), 5.0 (2024 proj.).
- Current account balance (in billions of U.S. dollars): 8.9 (2017), 8.0 (2018), 12.8 (2019), 14.3 (2020), 12.9 (2021).
- Total external debt (in billions of U.S. dollars): 218.8 (2017), 223.5 (2018), 231.5 (2019), 238.5 (2020), 256.4 (2021).
- Household debt (in percent of GDP): 82.6 (2017), 82.0 (2018), 82.7 (2019), 93.2 (2020).

*International Monetary Fund — Malaysia country material as presented in the supplied content unit.*

### Appendix I. The Financial Sector Blueprint: 2022-2026

### Appendix I. The Financial Sector Blueprint: 2022-2026

### Overview
- Strategy focus: fostering financial inclusion, economic transformation, and a sustainable economy.
- The Blueprint sets the sector’s strategic orientation for 2022–2026 and aligns with the 12MP’s recognition of the financial sector’s role in channeling resources to productive sectors.

### COVID-19 financial sector support and relief measures
- Fund for small and medium enterprises (SMEs) was enhanced by RM4.5 billion, bringing the total available funds as of mid-September 2021 to RM11.2 billion.
- Additional facilities provided following the 2022 budget announcement.
- Under the enhanced Targeted Relief and Recovery Facility, SMEs can now utilize up to 30 percent of the approved financing to repay existing business financing. (Refinement: refinancing of existing business financing under BNM’s Fund for SMEs is not allowed.)
- A six-month loan moratorium available to all individuals (B40, M40 and T20), microenterprises, and affected SMEs was established effective July 7, 2021.

### Five strategic thrusts (as identified by the Blueprint)
- Fund Malaysia’s economic transformation
  - Continued support to the recovery of the economy.
  - Regulatory actions to promote the aspiration of becoming a high-income country.
  - Enhancing the intermediation role of domestic financial markets.
- Elevate the financial well-being of households and businesses
  - Improve financial inclusion (including through mobile banking).
  - Strengthen financial resilience for household and corporate sectors.
  - Enhance financial ethics.
- Advance digitalization of the financial sector
  - Develop digital infrastructure for improved digital financial services.
  - Strengthen cybersecurity risk management and regulatory practices.
- Position the financial system to facilitate an orderly transition to a greener economy
  - Integrate climate risks in BNM’s internal processes and supervisory/prudential regulatory roles.
  - Support an orderly and just transition to a low-carbon economy.
- Advance value-based finance through Islamic finance leadership
  - Position Malaysia as an international gateway for Islamic finance.
  - Enhance policy enablers of value-based finance and promote the social finance aspect of Islamic finance.

### Prepared by
- Prepared by Kodjovi Eklou.

### Appendix II — Public Debt Sustainability Analysis (selected findings included in the same unit)
- Starting conditions and outlook
  - Malaysia started the pandemic with at-risk fiscal space.
  - Under current policies, federal government debt is projected to stabilize at around 64 percent of GDP in the medium term.
  - A credible medium-term consolidation plan is required to place debt on a clear downward path and ensure fiscal sustainability.

- Baseline macro-fiscal assumptions
  - 2021: economy recovering and expand at 3.1/9 percent in real/nominal terms.
  - 2022 real growth projected at 5.7 percent.
  - Fiscal deficit: increased to 6.2 percent of GDP in 2020; expected to widen to 6.4 percent in 2021.
  - Under current policies: deficit expected to decrease to 6.1 percent in 2022 and average at 5 percent of GDP over 2022-24; remain at 4.3 percent in 2025.
  - Authorities’ 12th Malaysia Plan (12MP) target: 3 to 3.5 percent of GDP deficit for 2025.

- Financing needs
  - Gross financing needs (fiscal deficit + maturing debt): projected at 11.4 percent of GDP in 2021 and decline to 10.8 in 2022; decline towards the pre-2020 average by 2026.

- Debt profile vulnerabilities (MAC-DSA assessment; first two assessed as high risk)
  - Annual change in short-term public debt slightly exceeded the upper early-warning benchmark: 1.2 percent (upper benchmark 1 percent).
  - Share of debt held externally: 26 percent of total debt (moderately high; above lower threshold). About 90 percent of external debt is in local currency.
  - Share of debt denominated in foreign currency: 3 percent of total debt.
  - Market perception: bond spreads below the lower MAC-DSA threshold of 200 bps.
  - External financing requirement: 31 percent of GDP in 2020 (above the upper threshold of early-warning benchmarks).

- Debt limits and ceilings
  - Domestic debt ceiling for MGS+MGII+MITBs raised from 55 percent of GDP to 60 then to 65 percent of GDP in 2020 and 2021.
  - Debt limit for Malaysia Treasury Bills (MTBs) and offshore borrowing: RM10 billion and RM35 billion, respectively.
  - Federal government debt ceiling (taking into account limits) stands at 67.9 percent of GDP in 2021 and 67.7 percent of GDP in 2022.
  - Authorities confirmed the 65 percent of GDP ceiling will remain effective until 2025; baseline debt remains below the effective limit until then.

- Realism of baseline assumptions
  - Past assumptions on real growth and primary balance are neither too optimistic nor pessimistic.
  - Highest median forecast error for the GDP deflator is -1.8 percent (staff forecasts relatively optimistic); forecast bias has improved in recent years.
  - Projected 3-year adjustment in the cyclically adjusted primary balance (CAPB) is relatively small, with a percentile rank of 27 percent compared to historical experience for high-debt market access countries.
  - CAPB level is in a percentile rank of 77 percent.

- Stress tests and risks
  - Under baseline, federal government debt remains within the authorities’ new debt anchor until 2025 and under the DSA’s debt burden benchmark of 70 percent in the medium term.
  - Macro-fiscal stress tests:
    - Debt remains below the 70 percent benchmark under real interest rate shock and primary balance shocks.
    - Debt profile improves under a real depreciation shock (low share of foreign-denominated debt).
    - Real growth shock and combined shocks would cause debt to increase over 70 percent of GDP in the medium term.
    - Gross financing needs remain below the DSA’s 15 percent benchmark under all shock scenarios.
  - Contingent liability shock:
    - Assumes government obliged to absorb all committed guarantees totaling 13 percent of GDP over 5 years and negative feedback on interest rate.
    - Debt-to-GDP ratio would rise to 77.2 percent of GDP in the medium term, breaching DSA and debt limit benchmarks.

- Illustrative fiscal consolidation scenarios and recommendations
  - 2022 Budget confirmed the authorities’ 3.5 percent of GDP deficit target for 2025 as per the 12MP.
  - Reaching that target would require fiscal consolidation measures of about 1.3 pp relative to the baseline, optimally starting once the recovery is entrenched.
  - The adjustment should be more heavily based on revenue measures.
  - Consolidation is necessary to rebuild buffers, maintain ability to respond to shocks, and finance development expenditure under the 12MP.
  - Structural fiscal issues to address: (i) persistent revenue weakness, (ii) increasing burden of debt servicing costs, (iii) uncertainty and crowding-out costs of heavy reliance on domestic market financing.
  - Fiscal policy role in climate change mitigation:
    - Carbon pricing initiatives can achieve climate mitigation goals and generate significant revenue.
    - Staff analysis shows scope to integrate mitigation and adaptation by hypothecating some share of revenues from a potential carbon tax for adaptation-related public investment spending, which would boost growth and provide additional fiscal space.

*Source: IMF staff.*

### Appendix III. External Sector Assessment

### Appendix III. External Sector Assessment

### Overall Assessment
- On a preliminary basis and adjusting for transitory factors, Malaysia’s external position in 2021 is assessed as moderately stronger than the level implied by medium-term fundamentals and desirable policies.
- During the COVID-19 pandemic, Malaysia’s CA surplus increased given strong external demand for pandemic related exports, including personal protective equipment (PPE) and electronic and electrical (E&E) equipment.
- A decline in the surplus is projected over the medium-term as domestic private demand gradually recovers and as Malaysia moves from the pandemic to the endemic phase of COVID-19.

### Potential Policy Responses
- Near-term: continue to support the nascent recovery through a targeted fiscal expansion combined with an accommodative monetary policy stance (given Malaysia almost fully vaccinated).
- Medium-term: fiscal policy should target a gradual and growth-friendly consolidation.
- Priority structural policies: strengthen social safety nets and encourage private investment and productivity growth to support external rebalancing and help bring the current account balance closer to its norm.

### Foreign Asset and Liability Position and Trajectory
- Background:
  - Malaysia’s NIIP has averaged around 1 percent since 2010 and was 5.9 percent of GDP in 2021 (compared with 4.8 percent of GDP at the end of 2020).
  - Increase reflects higher gross and reserve assets, and an increase in net portfolio investment.
  - Direct investment and portfolio investment abroad contribute most to assets; direct investment and portfolio liabilities contribute most to liabilities.
  - Total external debt, measured in US dollars, was about 68 percent of GDP in 2021 (compared with 71 percent at the end of 2020).
  - One third of external debt is in foreign currency.
  - 37 percent of external debt is in short-term debt by original maturity (half of which held by intragroup borrowings among banks and corporations which have been generally stable during the pandemic).
- Assessment:
  - Malaysia’s NIIP is projected to rise over the medium term, reflecting projected CA surpluses.
  - Balance sheet strength, exchange rate flexibility, and increased domestic investor participation should continue to help withstand shocks.
- 2021 (percent GDP) key figures:
  - NIIP: 5.9
  - Gross Assets: 137.1
  - Res. Assets: 31.5
  - Gross Liab.: 131.2
  - Debt Liab.: 29.7

### Current Account
- Background:
  - Between 2010 and 2019 Malaysia’s CA surplus contracted by 7 percentage points, underpinned by lower national savings and robust domestic demand.
  - In 2021 the CA account surplus narrowed slightly to 3.5 percent of GDP (compared to 4.2 percent of GDP in 2020) as a recovery in overall imports has partly offset exports.
  - Pandemic-related transitory factors affecting the CA surplus include:
    - decline in travel income given continued international travel restrictions;
    - sustained strong external demand for pandemic-related exports, including rubber glove products and electronic and electrical equipment;
    - decline in outward remittances from the crisis and lockdown measures in 2021.
- Assessment and adjustments:
  - The EBA CA model estimates a cyclically adjusted CA of 1.7 percent of GDP and a CA norm at −0.1 percent of GDP for 2021.
  - Transitory COVID-19 effects on the CA (percent of GDP):
    - net exports of pandemic-related medical goods, including rubber glove products: 1.3 percent of GDP
    - global household consumption composition shift: 0.9 percent of GDP
    - lower net remittances: 0.2 percent of GDP
    - decline in receipts from travel services including tourism: −1.5 percent of GDP
    - transport: −0.12 percent of GDP
  - After factoring in these effects the estimate of the IMF staff CA gap is about 1.1 percent of GDP (±1 percent of GDP).
  - Relative policy gaps contributing to the CA gap:
    - low public health care expenditure compared to the rest of the world contributes 0.9 percentage point to the CA gap;
    - looser fiscal policies adopted in 2021 in the rest of the world relative to Malaysia also contribute 0.9 percentage points to the excess surplus.
- 2021 (percent GDP) key figures:
  - CA: 3.5
  - Cycl. Adj. CA: 1.7
  - EBA Norm: −0.1
  - EBA Gap: 1.8
  - COVID-19 Adj.: −0.7
  - Other Adj. Staff Gap: 1.1

### Real Exchange Rate
- Background:
  - In 2021 the REER depreciated by 0.5 percent relative to the 2020 average and is about 6 percent lower than in 2015.
  - The mild depreciation in 2021 compared to 2020 (−3 percent) reflects a stabilization in capital outflows and the effect of the weakened economic outlook and new COVID-19 waves on the NEER.
- Assessment:
  - The IMF staff CA gap implies a REER undervaluation of −2.4 percent in 2021, applying an estimated elasticity of 0.46.
  - The EBA REER index and level models estimate Malaysia’s REER to be undervalued by −30 percent and −41 percent, respectively.
  - Considering the lack of underlying macroeconomic stresses and the broad stability of FX reserves, the IMF staff assesses the REER to be undervalued in the range of −0.4 to −4.4 percent, with a midpoint of −2.4 percent.

### Capital and Financial Accounts: Flows and Policy Measures
- Background:
  - Since the global financial crisis, Malaysia has experienced periods of significant capital flow volatility, largely driven by portfolio flows in and out of the local-currency debt market.
  - In 2020 Malaysia saw capital outflows during the March 2020 global risk-off episode, but capital flows stabilized afterward.
  - Capital flows remained broadly stable in 2021 despite the resurgence of COVID-19 waves and the renewal of lockdowns.
  - Net portfolio flows reached US$5.9 billion by September 2021, primarily driven by sustained net debt inflows (US$6.8 billion).
  - Since late 2016 the Financial Markets Committee has implemented measures to develop the onshore FX market and increase hedging opportunities.
- Assessment:
  - Continued exchange rate flexibility and macroeconomic policy adjustments, such as those prescribed by the IPF, are necessary to manage capital flow volatility.
  - CFMs should be gradually phased out, with due regard for market conditions.

### FX Intervention and Reserves Level
- Background:
  - Reserve levels have steadily increased during the COVID-19 pandemic after capital outflows stabilized following the March 2020 risk-off episode.
  - Reserve levels stood at US$116.9 billion as of December 2021 (compared to US$107.6 billion at the end of December 2020).
- Assessment:
  - Under the IMF’s composite ARA metric, reserves remain broadly adequate; therefore further accumulation is uncalled for.
  - Gross official reserves were about 126 percent of the ARA metric at the end of December 2021.
  - FX interventions should continue to be limited to preventing disorderly market conditions (DMC), while the exchange rate should continue to adjust as a first line of defense and to serve as a shock absorber in case of DMCs.

*Prepared by Nour Tawk.*

### 13.      Gains from NTBI reforms can vary significantly, depending on country characteristics.

### 13.      Gains from NTBI reforms can vary significantly, depending on country characteristics.

### Effects of reducing Non-Tariff Barriers (NTBs)
- Emerging market and developing economies (EMDEs) seemingly receive larger benefits from reducing NTBs, reflecting potential gains from technology transfers; gains are smaller for advanced economies (AEs) who are generally further on the technology frontier.
- Effects of NTB reductions on GDP are especially more pronounced in countries that are more integrated in value chains (GVC-intensive countries).
- Gains from NTB reforms appear larger in countries which rank higher on the structural reform index (signaling more liberalized domestic and labor markets for instance).
- Empirical specification note: Figure corresponds to the IRF to a one standard deviation increase in NTB at the fifth (medium term) horizon. Structural Reform Index is an average between labor, financial and product market reforms index. Heterogenous effects for Income and Tariffs are calculated using the interaction of the Income/Tariffs dummy above and below median with the NTB index. For GVC and Structural Reforms Index, smooth transition function are used. Light shaded bars indicate that results are not significant at 90% CI. Standard errors are calculated using Driscoll-Kraay.

### Malaysia: potential gains from NTB reductions and trade liberalization
- Malaysia could be well positioned to achieve large gains from NTB reductions, given that it is GVC-intensive and that NTBs remain somewhat high.
- Trade liberalization in the form of a reduction in NTBs could counter some of the medium-term scarring effects of the COVID-19 pandemic by boosting growth, productivity, and investment.
- The effect of trade liberalization on growth is further enhanced when coupled with other structural reforms, highlighting the importance of a comprehensive reform agenda.

### Trade and COVID-19: patterns and impacts (summary of chapter figures)
- Before the pandemic, trade openness in Malaysia had been on a declining trend, alongside GVC participation for Malaysia and the region.
- Despite having achieved low tariff levels, non-tariff barriers remain high for Malaysia.
- Trade in goods remained resilient during COVID-19 compared to the GFC, while services exports suffered.
- External demand for pharmaceuticals, PPE and electrical equipment supported Malaysian exports.
- Recessions have a large and persistent impact on GVCs, as do recessions and slowdowns in partner countries.
- Container/port metrics (as presented): Median time in port (days) and median time in port per container (minutes) were plotted for 2018H1 through 2021H1 (figure axis labels and series retained from source).

### Economic scarring from recessions and pandemics (empirical estimates)
- Using a sample of 39 emerging markets (1980-2019), past recessions led to substantial medium-term scarring:
  - Potential output was more than 4 percent lower after a recession compared to no recession scenarios.
  - When recessions coincide with pandemics, central estimate of losses is 15 percent (with a wide confidence interval).
  - Scarring occurs mainly through labor productivity and investment channels: after 5 years, labor productivity was more than 5 percent lower while investment was more than 2 percent lower compared to a no recession scenario.
- Initial conditions, structural characteristics and policy response shape scarring magnitude:
  - Countries with large debt (public, corporate, and household) experience disproportionately large scarring effects.
  - A one percent of GDP increase in public investment is associated with around 5 percentage points higher potential output after five years.
  - Structural reforms—more flexible labor markets and business regulation, better insolvency frameworks, and a smaller shadow economy—contribute to mitigating scarring effects.

### Pandemics and inequality
- Evidence from past epidemics (SARS 2003, H1N1 2009, MERS 2012, Ebola 2014, Zika 2016) indicates increases in inequality driven by output contractions and job losses for low-educated workers, redistributing income toward less vulnerable and richer parts of the population.
- Findings for COVID-19 and related research:
  - COVID-19 could lead to a rise in inequality through inequities in risk of contagion, access to hospitalization, ability to work remotely, and risk of longer-term job loss.
  - The rise in inequality after pandemics has been higher in episodes with a lack of fiscal support (lower fiscal deficits, lower public health expenditures, and lower redistribution).
  - Countries with strong initial conditions (low informality, high family benefit and high health expenditure per capita) experience lower pandemic-induced inequality.

### Malaysia-specific scarring and policy implications
- Medium-term output losses from the pandemic are projected to be substantial; 2024 global output is projected to be three percent below the pre-COVID forecast, with relatively large projected impact for Malaysia driven by the initial COVID shock plus downgrades due to the delta and omicron variants.
- Malaysia entered the pandemic with relatively higher public and private debt compared to emerging market peers, which amplifies scarring concerns:
  - Historical analysis shows scarring effects from past recessions in Malaysia were larger than in the median EM in the sample, owing to relatively large debt accumulation pre-crisis.
  - The impact of pre-crisis public debt accumulation on potential output in Malaysia was mostly driven by a larger public consumption accumulation than peers.
  - Household debt can induce larger drag on future GDP growth than corporate debt due to higher propensity to consume among debtors.
- Mitigating factors and recommended policy directions:
  - Malaysia benefits from relatively flexible business and labor market regulations.
  - A credible and growth-friendly medium-term fiscal consolidation strategy is needed to put debt on a downward trend and rebuild fiscal buffers.
  - Proactive policies to address household debt overhang will be essential.
  - Complementary structural reforms can amplify the gains from NTB reductions and trade liberalization.

*Source: INTERNATIONAL MONETARY FUND*

### 13.      The pandemic and related lockdown measures have substantial direct and spillover

### 13. The pandemic and related lockdown measures have substantial direct and spillover effects across sectors through supply chains

### Transmission through supply chains and exposure measures
- Direct exposure concentrated in contact-intensive services (e.g., hotels and restaurants) transmits negative spillovers to input suppliers (e.g., food, beverages, and tobacco).
- Aggregate exposure metric (as summarised in the text) captures importance of non-teleworkable, non-essential and social sectors: Exposure_j = (1 − Teleworkable_j) × (1 − Essential_j) × Social_j.
- Upstream and downstream exposure measures use OECD inter-country input-output tables (OECD 2018) and are defined as weighted averages of customer- or supplier-industry exposure:
  - UpstreamDomestic_i = sum_j ( n_{M i M j} / sum_k ( n_{M i M k} + n_{M i F k} ) × Exposure_j )
  - UpstreamForeign_i = sum_j ( n_{M i F j} / sum_k ( n_{M i M k} + n_{M i F k} ) × Exposure_j )
  - DownstreamDomestic_i = sum_j ( n_{M j M i} / sum_k ( n_{M k M i} + n_{F k M i} ) × Exposure_j )
  - DownstreamForeign_i = sum_j ( n_{F j M i} / sum_k ( n_{M k M i} + n_{F k M i} ) × Exposure_j )
- Exposure is generally greatest through domestic relationships, except for sectors with high export shares (e.g., electrical equipment, computers, and business services) where foreign exposure is more important.
- Almost all sectors face downstream effects, since nearly all are customers of an exposed sector (example: computer and electronics purchasing from wholesale trade).

### Sectoral impacts and SMEs
- The COVID-19 pandemic disproportionately affected SMEs in the contact-intensive service sector.
- SME statistics (SME Corporation Malaysia, 2020):
  - 1.52 million business establishments, or 97.2 percent of the total.
  - 7.25 million jobs (about 48 percent of total employment).
  - 38.2 percent of GDP.
  - 13.5 percent of exports.
  - SMEs represent 85.5 percent of the service sector.
- SME definition since 2013:
  - Manufacturing: sales turnover not exceeding RM50 million or full-time employees not exceeding 200.
  - Services and other sectors: sales turnover not exceeding RM20 million or full-time employees not exceeding 75.

### Education, human capital, and long-run scarring
- School closures between 11 Mar 2020 and 2 Feb 2021:
  - Closed for 46 percent of instruction days (i.e., non-holidays).
  - Operated with limited capacity for a further 18 percent of instruction days.
- Reduced labor productivity is a significant scarring channel; interrupted learning without broad catch-up programs risks long-term human capital losses, with the poorest 40 percent and rural students least able to access remote learning substitutes.

### Distributional effects and labor-market impacts
- Household income and employment effects:
  - Paid employment declined by 16.1 percent.
  - Self-employment declined by 9.7 percent.
  - Household average gross income decreased by 10.3 percent.
- Income distribution by decile and movements:
  - Bottom 40 percent (B40) income share: 15.9 percent.
  - Middle 40 percent (M40) income share: 36.9 percent.
  - Top 20 percent (T20) income share rose by 0.4 ppt to 47.2 percent (compared to 2019); 12.8 percent moved to M40.
- Sectoral job and income losses (DOSM online survey, 23-31 March 2020; 168,182 respondents; caveat: not fully generalizable):
  - Service sector: share of respondents that lost their jobs 54.2 percent; experienced severe income loss (more than 50 percent) 53.6 percent.
  - Agriculture sector: lost jobs 21.9 percent; severe income loss 50 percent.
- Self-employed:
  - About 47 percent reported losing their jobs in early 2020 (about twice the average proportion for all employment types).
- Teleworkability and vulnerability:
  - Respondents unable to work from home were most likely to report severe income loss, reductions in hours worked, and job losses.
  - Rahman et al. (2020) estimates:
    - 64.5 percent of jobs in Malaysia cannot be performed from home (after adjusting for internet access).
    - 50.9 percent of jobs require high levels of physical proximity.
  - The ability to work from home is positively correlated with non-routine cognitive analytical skills.

### Pre-pandemic structural characteristics and inequality risks
- Structural features pointing to upside risk for inequality post-pandemic:
  - High informality.
  - Low health spending and low social protection spending (below the average of Asian EMs in pre-pandemic data).
  - Low absolute redistribution (difference between market Gini and net Gini) relative to ASEAN and EM averages in 2019 (after excluding Indonesia).
- The main mitigating factor is large fiscal support, estimated to reach 9.6 percent of GDP by end- 2021.
- Given the balance of risks and the observed increase in the Gini index in 2020, a prudent assumption is that inequality may rise.

### Policy recommendations to mitigate output scarring and inequality
- Near-term targeted fiscal support:
  - Target sectors with limited capacity to work from home.
  - Scale up public investment with higher fiscal multipliers.
  - Pursue active labor market policies to facilitate labor reallocation and limit skills mismatch.
  - Target those who suffered severe income loss in service and agriculture sectors to boost aggregate demand.
- Social assistance:
  - Target the poorest, liquidity-constrained households, self-employed and SMEs disproportionately hit by the pandemic.
  - Use rigorous means-testing, monitoring and reporting, explicit sunset clauses, and exclude unviable debtors.
- Structural reforms:
  - Strengthen insolvency frameworks to address debt overhang while avoiding formal bankruptcy where possible.
  - Reduce regulatory burden in labor and product markets to lower informality.
  - Expand coverage given the rise of temporary, gig jobs, and self-employment; unemployment insurance introduced in 2018 covers a significant share but many remain uncovered.
  - Calibrated R&D incentives to boost innovative capacity.
- Skills and reskilling:
  - Enhance Penjana incentives for upskilling and reskilling by focusing on non-routine cognitive analytical skills, non-routine interpersonal skills, and digital skills to improve resilience and work-from-home capability.
- Corporate-sector support principles:
  - Limit moral hazard via compliance terms and clear exit strategies.
  - Articulate clear eligibility to limit adverse selection and preserve fiscal space.
  - Facilitate efficient resource reallocation to raise aggregate productivity and enable firm adaptation to the post-COVID-19 environment.
- Targeted support preferred over broad support as recovery proceeds to minimize fiscal costs, preserve fiscal space, and limit governance challenges.

### Conclusions (medium-term outlook)
- The COVID-19 pandemic is expected to have significant scarring effects on Malaysia’s potential output and to increase inequality.
- Concentrated negative impacts in some sectors will have broader repercussions through input-output linkages.
- Vulnerable households (self-employed, agriculture, services) face disproportionate income and job losses.
- Structural characteristics (low social protection and health spending, limited redistribution, large informal sector) could amplify inequality effects, despite large fiscal support.

*Source: IMF staff analysis as presented in content unit 1mysea2022001, Chapter 13.*

### 27.      The type of support should be linked to the nature of the problem firms are facing. The

### 1mysea2022001 - 27.      The type of support should be linked to the nature of the problem firms are facing. The

### Support design: matching support to firm condition
- General principles (from literature):  
  - Firms that were not viable prior to the COVID-19 shock should be encouraged to exit through liquidation.  
  - Solvent firms facing liquidity difficulties due to the pandemic should be provided liquidity assistance, such as through soft loans, expenditure deferrals, or debt moratoria.  
  - Firms that have become insolvent due to the pandemic, but are expected to recover post-pandemic, can be assisted through loans or equity injections.  
  - For firms that cannot be supported through liquidity or solvency support, there needs to be efficient restructuring (to restore viability) or liquidation (where firms should exit) to encourage a reallocation of resources across the economy. To facilitate quick and low-cost restructurings, informal out of court resolution frameworks could be simplified and incentivized.

### Considerations for Malaysia: SMEs and informality
- Key contextual factors:  
  - High prevalence of SMEs in affected sectors.  
  - High degree of informality in business practices, making ascertaining true financial position difficult and opening room for misdirection and misuse of funds.  
  - Need to preserve employment for low-skilled labor and address geographic concentration of firms (e.g., in tourism-dependent areas).  
  - Systemic importance of some larger firms and social costs of employment loss.  
  - Prevailing high uncertainty due to the pandemic.
- Policy design implications and recommendations:  
  - Eligibility criteria could consider firms that generate high social value through externalities based on their interlinkages with the local economy, particularly employment (for instance SMEs in the services sector).  
  - For firms where information on financial health is limited, the size of support could be gradually extended over the support period, based on the requirement to keep and meet objective markers.

### Risk Assessment Matrix (selected implications for policy)
- Staff probability interpretation: “low” indicates probability below 10 percent; “medium” indicates probability between 10 and 30 percent; “high” indicates probability of 30 percent or more.  
- External risks and policy responses (selected):  
  - Outbreaks of lethal and highly contagious COVID-19 variants — Likelihood: High. Expected impact: High. Recommended: targeted fiscal support to directly impacted households and firms; credible medium-term fiscal consolidation plan; critical infrastructure and structural reforms; allow FX flexibility; ensure sufficient liquidity and accommodative monetary policy; monitor asset quality; BNM has room to further cut its policy rate if downside risks materialize.  
  - Extended global supply chain disruptions — Likelihood: High. Expected impact: High on Manufacturing/Electronics and trade. Recommended: careful and orderly reopening targeting sectors integrated into global value chains.  
  - Abrupt growth slowdown in China — Likelihood: Medium. Historical staff estimate (2012 Spillover Report): a 1 percentage point investment slowdown in China would reduce Malaysia’s growth by 0.6 percentage points. Recommended: allow exchange rate to absorb shock, use reserves to smooth volatility; consider monetary easing consistent with inflation-output trade-off; targeted fiscal support if space allows; implement structural policies to rebalance growth toward domestic demand.  
  - De-anchoring of inflation expectations in the U.S. and/or advanced European economies — Likelihood: Medium/Low. Expected impact: Medium/High. Recommended: allow exchange rate to act as shock absorber; calibrate monetary policy between supporting growth and managing capital outflows; provide FX liquidity support to maintain financial stability; temporary outflow CFMs could be considered under imminent crisis circumstances as part of a broader policy package.

- Domestic risks and recommended responses (selected):  
  - Fiscal risks from public debt and contingent liabilities (Short- to medium-term) — Likelihood: Medium. Expected impact: Medium/High. Recommended: pursue medium-term fiscal consolidation notably through a medium-term revenue strategy (MTRS); improve fiscal risks management framework and publish annual fiscal risks statement; increase transparency of GLC operations.  
  - Global information infrastructure failure — Likelihood: Medium. Expected impact: Medium/High. Recommended: continue investment in cyber security strategy; strengthen IT security frameworks and build new defensive lines in line with recent FinTIP.

### Optimal fiscal policy in Malaysia — framing and key figures
- Short-run vs medium-run challenge: high vaccination rates support recovery momentum, but recovery is uneven, output remains well below potential, and scarring risks are large. Analysis from a stochastic structural model calibrated for Malaysia suggests:  
  - Near term: need to continue supporting the recovery through a well-designed and targeted fiscal expansion.  
  - Beyond near term: embark on a credible and growth-friendly fiscal consolidation path to put debt on a downward trend and rebuild fiscal buffers.
- Pre-pandemic fiscal vulnerabilities and mitigating factors:  
  - Pre-existing contingent liabilities: 20 percent of GDP, out of which 13 percent of GDP are committed.  
  - Debt service constituted an increasing share of revenues, reaching 15 percent in 2020 and projected to use further in 2021 and 2022, in part due to Malaysia’s narrow revenue base.  
  - Debt profile favorable: majority of debt issued domestically, at long maturities, and in local currency.
- Historical fiscal reaction: examining the reaction of the cyclically adjusted primary balance (CAPB) to lagged public debt during 1992–2019 indicates a weak positive relationship: higher public debt is associated with higher CAPB primary balances, with a stronger relationship in the pre-global financial crisis period.

*Prepared from IMF staff text in the supplied content unit.*

### 3.      Despite at-risk fiscal space, the authorities responded boldly to the pandemic. To

### 1mysea2022001 - 3. Despite at-risk fiscal space, the authorities responded boldly to the pandemic. To

### Fiscal response to COVID-19: COVID-19 Fund and spending allocations
- COVID-19 Fund established in September 2020 with a limit of RM45 billion, increased in December 2020 to 65 billion and later to 110 billion to account for COVID-related spending commitments in the 2022 Budget.
- Allocations and outturns:
  - RM38 billion spent in 2020 under five stimulus packages.
  - RM39 billion envisaged to be spent in 2021 (original RM17 billion allocated in the 2021 Budget plus four additional spending packages).
  - RM23 billion allocated for 2022.
  - Total RM100 billion to be spent from the fund over 2020-2022, leaving a RM10 billion buffer for contingencies or additional needed spending in 2022.
- Composition of spending:
  - Most spending on cash transfer programs and wage subsidies, accounting for more than half of total spending.
  - In 2022, an increasing share allocated to upskilling programs, social assistance support to vulnerable groups, and SME financing.
- Below-the-line financing:
  - Included 3.5 percent of GDP in loan guarantees in 2020 of up to 80 per cent of loan amounts for financing working capital requirements for businesses affected by the pandemic.
- Revenue foregone:
  - With several tax relief/exemption measures extended, including in the 2022 Budget, foregone revenues are estimated to have reached about 0.8 percent of GDP over 2020 and 2021.

### Fiscal outcomes: deficits, debt, and ceiling adjustments
- The strong fiscal response widened deficit and debt levels; the debt ceiling was twice raised by a total 10 percentage points.
- The increase in deficit and debt by about 3 and 10 percentage points of GDP is similar in magnitude to the Global Financial Crisis (GFC) and comparable to emerging market post-COVID increases.
- Both the GFC and the current crisis saw increases in the debt ceiling by a total 10 percentage points, keeping actual debt below the effective limit in the baseline.

### 2022 Budget: objectives, allocations, and tax measures
- Overarching themes: recovery, resilience and reforms; focused on supporting nascent recovery, minimizing pandemic long-term scarring, and lifting-off a cautious adjustment path.
- Fiscal projections and stance:
  - Overall deficit narrowed to 6.1 percent of GDP in 2022, down from 6.4 percent in 2021, implying a mildly contractionary fiscal stance in 2022.
  - Underlying decline driven by conservative revenue projections and a new, lower COVID-19 allocation for 2022 compared to prior years.
- Spending emphasis:
  - Bulk of 2022 spending on cash assistance to vulnerable groups and wage subsidies to hard-hit sectors, which also benefit from tax relief measures.
  - Development expenditure projected to rise significantly in 2022 and average 4.5 percent of GDP over the medium term, mostly directed into environmentally friendly projects with high multiplier effect (in line with the 12th Malaysia Plan).
- Tax measures:
  - 2022 Budget introduced targeted, mostly one-off, tax measures to raise revenues; these are to be complemented by more permanent measures under the medium-term revenue strategy (MTRS).
  - Windfalls from such measures, estimated at 0.3 percent of GDP, were conservatively excluded from revenue projections and are planned to be used to reduce the deficit if they materialize.
  - Measures include a one-time special tax for high-income companies and a Special Voluntary Disclosure Program (SVDP) for indirect taxes.
  - Tax compliance measures: tax compliance certificate as a pre-condition on tenderers for government procurement, implementation of the Tax Identification Number.
  - One-time special tax detail: the tax will be introduced for companies that generate in 2022 income above RM100 million, which will be taxed at 33 percent instead of the blanket 24 percent rate.
- Medium-term fiscal targets and clarity:
  - Overall fiscal deficit projected to average at 5 percent of GDP for 2022 – 2024, compared to a target 4.5 percent during 2021-2023 as per 2021 Budget.
  - Deficit targeted to decline to 3.5 percent by 2025 as per the 12MP targets; achieving the 3.5 deficit target by 2025 will require additional measures.
  - Government noted aims to gradually reduce debt levels and affordability with realistic but firm debt reduction targets, however no quantification of such targets was provided.

### Optimal fiscal stance: model, assumptions, and calibration
- Model description:
  - A stochastic structural model where a forward-looking government maximizes utility under a debt constraint; fiscal stance defined as change in structural primary balance.
  - Model features: feedback effects between fiscal policy and output (cycle-dependent fiscal multiplier), hysteresis effects (recessions reducing potential output), interest rate as a rising function of debt with stochastic market-access risk at high debt, implementation lag (government decides one year ahead), cost of changing fiscal policy (implementation/spending reform costs or tax uncertainty), and supply constraints.
- Key calibration assumptions for Malaysia:
  - Elasticity of interest rate to debt level: conservatively assume 1.5 (noting regional estimates showing decline from about 1.5 after GFC to 0.5 in 2021).
  - Debt limit: effective debt limit in long run stands at 67 percent of GDP.
  - Fiscal multiplier: set at 0.6 (Malaysia placed in “medium-multiplier” group).
  - Long-run potential growth: 2 percent.
  - Real effective interest rates: 3.5.
  - Population growth rates: 1 percent.
  - Automatic stabilizer: 0.2 (historical semi-elasticity of the primary balance to the output gap for Malaysia).
  - Adjustment cost parameter: 3 (moderate).
  - Hysteresis parameters: size of hysteresis 10 percent and output gap threshold -1 percent.
  - Other welfare function parameters (discount factor, risk aversion, labor elasticity etc.) are standard in the literature.

### Model results and staff recommendations
- Model recommendations:
  - Support for additional short-run stimulus followed by medium-term consolidation.
  - Model recommends more stimulus by about 4 pp of GDP in the near term relative to the baseline, focusing on narrowing the very negative output gap in 2022 and 2023 and minimizing hysteresis.
  - After 2023, the model advises gradual fiscal adjustment to anchor public debt on a downward path and rebuild fiscal buffers.
  - The model’s recommended consolidation is about 2.9 pp steeper than the passive baseline.
- Staff recommended path (alternative to model optimal):
  - Smaller stimulus and consolidation relative to model’s optimal path.
  - Fiscal stance would be looser than baseline by about 2 p.p. cumulatively in 2022 and 2023, and tighter in the medium term relative to baseline by about 3 p.p.
  - Rationale: cognizant of Malaysia’s at-risk fiscal space amid a protracted pandemic, potential future spending needs, and practical feasibility challenges of a large stimulus and its later unwinding.
- Sensitivity and robustness:
  - Results generally robust to sensitivity checks across key parameters.
  - Model results not particularly sensitive to parameters governing market access risk (sensitivity of interest rate to debt) nor to the debt limit.
  - Model recommendation for primary structural balance for 2022 in an alternative scenario without scarring is very similar to baseline (just 0.35 pp difference), underscoring hysteresis as main motivation for additional stimulus.
  - If fiscal multiplier is higher (lower), same economic output can be achieved with less (more) fiscal stimulus.

### Fiscal space assessment and implications
- Staff view: despite fiscal space assessed to be at risk, Malaysia has enough room to embark on recommended marginal near-term expansion.
- Positive dynamics supporting near-term room to maneuver:
  - Low gross financing needs.
  - Favorable debt profile including extended debt maturities and greater share of domestic and local currency borrowing.
  - Historically favorable negative interest rate-growth differentials.
  - Lack of demographic pressures.
- Caveats and prudence:
  - Malaysia started the pandemic with a fiscal space at-risk assessment; twice-increased debt ceiling and ample domestic liquidity allowed a strong fiscal response so far without endangering market access or debt sustainability.
  - Staff recommends a cautious near-term stimulus to safeguard space for potential future spending needs.
- Trade-off highlighted:
  - In the aftermath of a severe negative shock and lingering negative output gap, fiscal inaction or abrupt consolidation could reduce fiscal space by dampening growth.
  - Temporary stimulus, if well-targeted (targeted transfers, investment in productive infrastructure, support for structural reforms, repair of private balance sheets), could create fiscal space and improve medium-term debt prospects.
  - As growth returns to potential, stimulus loses effectiveness while cost of consolidation diminishes, making medium-term fiscal adjustment optimal to rebuild space and put debt on a firm downward trend.

*Italic: IMF staff analysis drawn from content unit 1mysea2022001 - 3.*

### 16.      Malaysia’s fiscal prudence over the last decades has afforded it space for a strong

### 1mysea2022001 - 16.      Malaysia’s fiscal prudence over the last decades has afforded it space for a strong

### Fiscal stance and model-based assessment
- A stochastic structural model calibrated for Malaysia suggests the optimal fiscal stance:
  - Higher spending in the near term relative to the 2022 Budget baseline.
  - More consolidation effort over the long term to put debt on a firm downward trend and rebuild fiscal buffers.

### Fiscal strengths and vulnerabilities (Fiscal Space Assessment: Relevant Indicators for Malaysia)
- Favorable debt dynamics:
  - High share of debt:
    - Held domestically
    - Issued in local currency
    - At longer maturites
  - Negative interest rate growth differentials
  - Low public gross financing needs
  - Reasonable market access costs
  - Track record of fiscal prudence
- Vulnerabilities and challenges:
  - High contingent liabilities
  - Large external financing requirements
  - Increase in debt post-pandemic
  - Lack of demographic pressures

### Climate risks and exposure (Appendix VIII: Fighting Climate Change in Malaysia — Context)
- Major climate risks:
  - Flooding, cyclones and chronic heat stress.
  - Urban Heat Island (UHI) effect observed to push the temperature in Kuala Lumpur 4-6°C above rural surroundings (Elsayed, 2012).
- Regional loss estimates:
  - Current annual losses in the Asia-Pacific from hydrometeorological and geophysical hazards estimated around US$780 billion, rising to US$1.4 trillion in the worst-case scenario (ESCAP, 2021).
- Sea-level and health impacts:
  - One meter of sea-level rise could increase the 1 in 100-year storm surge impact zone in Malaysia by around 24 percent, and increase the population affected by around 34 percent (Dasgupta et al., 2009).
  - Under IPCC RCP 8.5, average daily maximum temperatures surpass 33°C by the end of the century (WBG Climate Change Knowledge Portal, 2021).
  - Temperature rises could place up to 43 million people in Malaysia at risk of malaria, up from a 1961-2000 baseline of 17.6 million (WHO, 2015).
- Socioeconomic exposure:
  - Travel and tourism sector constituted 11.7 percent of GDP and accounted for 15.1 percent of total employment in 2019 (WTTC, 2021).
  - Poorer communities face disproportionate risks due to limited capacity to invest in defenses or cooling and higher representation in manual labor occupations.

### Malaysia’s emissions and commitments
- Contribution:
  - Malaysia emits approximately 0.7 percent of annual global CO2.
  - Malaysia accounts for 0.35 percent of cumulative historical CO2 emissions globally.
- Sectoral breakdown of energy-related CO2 emissions (2018):
  - Power generation: 48 percent
  - Transportation: 25 percent
  - Industry (manufacturing and construction): 25 percent
  - Residential: 1 percent
  - Combustion fuel shares: coal 39 percent, natural gas 29 percent, gasoline 16 percent
- Policy commitments:
  - Twelfth Malaysia Plan aims for transformation to a high-income carbon-neutral economy.
  - Government initially committed to an unconditional 35 percent reduction in greenhouse gas intensity by 2030, relative to 2005, before strengthening this to 45 percent in July 2021.
  - PM pledged in September 2021 to achieve net zero emissions as early as 2050 and to cease construction of new coal-fired power plants.
- Projection vs pledge:
  - Malaysia is projected to overachieve on its updated commitment of 45 percent unconditional reduction in emission intensity under the Paris Agreement in the BAU baseline: emission intensity in 2030 is projected to be 39 percent lower than the target.

### Mitigation policy options and model simulations
- Carbon pricing instruments considered:
  - Carbon tax (supply-side, proportional to carbon content).
  - Emissions Trading Scheme (ETS).
- Comparative features:
  - Carbon tax: revenue generation capacity, price predictability under a clear pricing path, low administrative burden (can build on existing tax systems).
  - ETS: usually offers no price predictability, generates less revenues and requires new infrastructure and capacity to monitor trading markets. In practice ETS coverage has often been limited to power generators and large industrial firms.
  - Note: In absence of exemptions, with a price floor, and with auctioned allowances, an ETS can achieve similar outcomes to an equivalent carbon tax; in practice this has not commonly occurred.
- Regional context:
  - Asia-Pacific has seen greater use of ETSs (China, Korea, New Zealand) while Japan and Singapore have implemented a carbon tax; Indonesia scheduled carbon tax in 2022.
  - Prospect of border carbon adjustments (BCAs) from trading partners increases the case for carbon pricing domestically.

### Quantitative simulation results (using IMF/World Bank CPAT)
- Emissions reduction from carbon tax (2030, relative to IMF-projected BAU levels):
  - US$25/tCO2 → 8 percent reduction
  - US$50/tCO2 → 12 percent reduction
  - US$75/tCO2 → 15 percent reduction
  - A carbon tax larger than US$75/tCO2 would be needed to achieve carbon neutrality by 2050.
- ETS effectiveness (fraction of CO2 reductions from a carbon tax at US$70 per ton) — Malaysia:
  - ETS achieves 79 percent of the CO2 reduction attained from a carbon tax at US$70 per ton.
- Fiscal revenue potential from carbon taxation in 2030:
  - US$25/tCO2 → 1 percent of GDP
  - US$50/tCO2 → 2 percent of GDP
  - US$75/tCO2 → 3 percent of GDP

### Distributional and price impacts from carbon taxation
- Energy price changes for US$75/tCO2 in 2030 (weighted by consumption; baseline → carbon tax; percent change):
  - Coal: US$ per gigajoule (GJ) 6.78 → 14.35; 111%
  - Natural gas: US$ per gigajoule (GJ) 7.83 → 13.66; 75%
  - Diesel: US$ per liter 0.62 → 1.02; 65%
  - Oil: US$ per barrel 69.57 → 107.22; 54%
  - Electricity: US$ per kwh 0.10 → 0.15; 39%
  - Kerosene: US$ per liter 0.70 → 0.91; 31%
  - LPG: US$ per liter 0.53 → 0.68; 28%
  - Gasoline: US$ per liter 0.70 → 0.89; 27%
- Distributional concerns:
  - Carbon taxation raises energy prices significantly and can have regressive consequences since energy products often account for a higher share of consumption for low-income households.
  - Malaysia’s large informal sector implies targeted cash transfers are preferable to reductions in labor taxes, but careful design is required to reach all relevant groups.

### Policy recommendations and implementation considerations
- Near-term fiscal policy:
  - Use higher near-term spending to minimize scarring from the pandemic while planning for longer-term consolidation to rebuild buffers and place debt on a downward trajectory.
- Climate mitigation and fiscal policy:
  - Implement carbon pricing as a central mitigation tool; a carbon tax has advantages for revenue generation, predictability, and administrative simplicity.
  - Ensure carbon pricing is comprehensive in coverage and embodies a rising and predictable price path; avoid exemptions from the start.
  - Consider complementing carbon pricing with sector-specific measures (energy efficiency regulations, feebates) and public provision of green infrastructure where the private sector underprovides.
- Revenue use and distributional mitigation:
  - Recycle carbon tax revenues to:
    - Compensate firms and low-income households affected by higher energy prices via targeted transfers.
    - Fund public investments under the 12MP, including adaptation measures to close financing gaps for resilience-enhancing projects.
  - Design compensatory transfers carefully given imperfect coverage of existing social safety nets to ensure uptake by informal sector and other vulnerable groups.
- ETS considerations:
  - If pursuing an ETS, broaden coverage beyond power generators and large industries to approach the mitigation effectiveness of a carbon tax, and consider auctioning allowances to generate revenues.
- Strategic alignment:
  - Integrate NDC roadmap and the Ministry of Environment and Water’s Long-Term Low Emission Development Strategy (due by the end of 2022) with fiscal tools and the 12MP’s development investment priorities.

*Prepared by IMF staff; chapter and appendix material as presented in the source PDF.*

### 12.      Simulations suggest that recycling fiscal

### 12.      Simulations suggest that recycling fiscal

### Recycling carbon tax revenues and GDP growth
- Simulations indicate that recycling fiscal revenues on transfers and on public investment has the potential to raise GDP growth in Malaysia in the medium term.
- The negative effect from carbon taxation on growth will be more than compensated if revenues from carbon taxation are recycled between transfers and public investment.
- Investment into green activities could have a particularly large positive impact on GDP, as the associated fiscal multiplier tends to be significantly higher (Batini et al., 2021).
- Net gains are highest if 100 percent of revenues are recycled towards public investment, and lowest if all are spent on transfers.
- Recycling half of revenues on investment and the other half on transfers has the potential to raise GDP growth by about 1 percentage point higher than the baseline growth in the medium and long run.
- Given the initial costs, the imposition of a carbon tax must be carefully timed to ensure that it does not undermine the post-pandemic recovery.
- Figure (Net effect on GDP Growth from Carbon Tax Revenue recycling) presents scenarios: 100% Transfers; 100% Public Investment; 50% Transfers and 50% Public Investment, with year markers 2022 through 2035.

### Adaptation: objectives, costs, and gaps
- Effective adaptation has preventative, alleviative and financial elements (IMF 2019): public information, new technologies and infrastructure, policies to discourage inefficient risk-taking; contingency plans and social safety nets; and financial sector funding for preventative investment and post-disaster liquidity.
- Adaptation investment can be very costly (Figure 2) but is critical in limiting post-disaster debt increases by improving resilience ex-ante (Marto et al., 2018).
- Malaysia’s recent climate-related events and trends:
  - Major floods in 2010, 2012, 2014 and 2021.
  - A particularly strong El Niño in 2016 led to water shortages, heatwaves and wildfires.
  - Minimum, mean and maximum air temperatures have increased, along with rainfall intensity.
- The 2018 Third National Communication to the UNFCCC assesses vulnerability of six sectors (water and coastal resources, food security and agriculture, forestry and biodiversity, infrastructure, energy and public health) to four major risks (flooding, dry spells, higher sea levels, and higher sea temperatures) and identifies key gaps and improvement plans.
- The 11th Malaysia Plan introduced flood mitigation projects protecting 1.6 million people.
- The 12th Malaysia Plan outlines measures to promote green and resilient cities, assess and publicize hydro-climatic hazards, and improve early warning systems and disaster response and recovery measures; creation of a Policy on Disaster Risk Management is among eight priority KPIs under ‘Advancing Sustainability’.
- The Ministry of Environment and Water is developing a comprehensive National Adaptation Action Plan and has applied to the UN Green Climate Fund for financial support.
- Remaining needs and priorities:
  - Substantial further work to assess cost-effectiveness of measures and address risks identified in assessments.
  - Revenues from mitigation measures, such as a carbon tax, could be recycled to targeted investments in adaptation that also create jobs and support growth.
  - Progress toward a full National Adaptation Plan has been slower than some neighbors, underscoring the need for fiscal reform and coordinated efforts across government and private sector partners.

### Extracted adaptation gaps and improvement plans (Table 2)
- Flood:
  - Gap: Lack of projected flood maps covering all the flood prone basins.
  - Improvement plan: Establish comprehensive flood maps covering all flood prone basins in Malaysia.
- Dry Spell:
  - Gaps: Analysis of projected dry spells for vulnerability assessments needs seasonal rather than annual scale with high spatial resolution; insufficient priority and detailed analysis of impacts of dry spell on dams and reservoirs.
  - Improvement plans: Develop seasonal projected dry spell maps suitable for sub-basin and local scales; conduct studies on the impact of climate change on dams for electricity generation and water supply.
- Sea Level Rise:
  - Gap: Insufficient coastal hydrodynamic simulation that incorporates sea level rise impacts for vulnerable coastal regions.
  - Improvement plan: Develop high resolution coastal inundation maps based on coastal hydrodynamic simulation that incorporates sea level rise for 20-year time intervals up to 2100, and carry out detailed coastal erosion and sedimentation studies.
- Integrated hazards:
  - Gaps: Combined impacts of sea level rise, storm surges, abnormally high tides and high rainfall not well understood; inadequate information of assets in vulnerable areas for each sector.
  - Improvement plans: Develop integrated models for early warning and assessment; develop a comprehensive database for each sector.
- Capacity Building and Awareness:
  - Gaps: Insufficient capacity to conduct impact assessments in all key sectors; lack of awareness and understanding of the full chain of implications of climate change by key stakeholders.
  - Improvement plans: Develop required capacity in each key sector for Vulnerability & Adaptation analysis; conduct detailed studies on the full chain impacts and awareness and capacity building programs targeted at stakeholders.

### Finance: role of financial sector and policy initiatives
- The financial sector is exposed to climate risks and is important for supporting the sustainability transition.
- In 2019 approximately 12 percent of all assets held by financial players in Malaysia were in sectors exposed to climate change (BNM, 2021).
- Green debt issuance and ESG products have expanded rapidly in Malaysia; Malaysia issued the world’s first sovereign dollar sustainability sukuk, a US$800 million offering in April 2021.
- Bank Negara Malaysia (BNM) actions:
  - Transition to a greener financial system is a substantial element of Bank Negara Malaysia’s 2022-2026 Financial Sector Blueprint.
  - BNM is working across five broad areas: (i) integrating climate risk within macroeconomic and financial stability assessments; (ii) strengthening regulatory and supervisory expectations for managing climate risks; (iii) creating an enabling environment for green financing and investment; (iv) greening its own operations; and (v) engagement and capacity building across government and the financial sector.
  - Plans to include climate risks in financial sector stress tests by 2024; released an Exposure Draft in late 2021 setting out proposed principles for climate risk management; planned publication of a discussion paper on potential stress test methodology in 2022 Q1.
  - Issued a taxonomy for classifying economic activities as ‘climate supporting’, ‘transitioning’ or ‘watchlist’.
  - Published guidance on assessing climate risk for Islamic financial institutions and planned a guide in 2022 to facilitate voluntary disclosure in line with the G20’s TCFD, with a view to mandatory disclosure by 2024.
  - Internally introduced ESG and SRI criteria into investment processes and measures to reduce carbon footprint of operations.
- Coordination and international engagement:
  - Domestic: The Joint Committee on Climate Change (JC3) brings together BNM, the Securities Commission, Bursa Malaysia, and 19 industry players; Malaysia Climate Action Council chaired by the Prime Minister coordinates national climate action.
  - International: ASEAN Taxonomy Board established in 2021; BNM joined the Network of Central Banks and Supervisors for Greening the Financial System (NGFS) in 2018 and liaises with more than 80 countries.
- Implementation challenge:
  - Transitioning from institution-building and principles to binding regulation and concrete actions requires careful pacing to ensure effective execution and industry buy-in.
  - Authorities should engage with global frontrunners to examine innovative measures, e.g., using disclosure of climate-risk exposure for favorable treatment of collateral and asset purchases or developing minimum standards for climate risk assessment methodologies.

### Conclusion and policy recommendations
- Acceleration of mitigation and adaptation measures is required despite welcome recent policy proposals and the 12MP’s focus on sustainability.
- The target of net zero GHG emissions by 2050 will require substantial structural reform and green investment.
- Carbon taxation is a promising option alongside sector-specific reinforcing measures; careful calibration of actions and compensatory transfers is critical to avoid regressive outcomes, especially given Malaysia’s large informal sector.
- Substantial expenditures on adaptation are required, underscored by recent floods and heatwaves.
- Financial authorities have taken early steps to assess exposure to physical, liability and transition risks; the government’s first sustainability sukuk issuance is welcome, but substantial work remains.
- There is scope for integrating mitigation and adaptation, for instance by hypothecating some share of revenues from a potential carbon tax for adaptation-related spending.

### Short-term policy alignment with COVID recovery
- COVID-related recovery spending should be aligned with environmental goals.
- Support to firms and industries should not be provided through weakening environmental regulations; firm-specific support can be conditional on compliance with environmental standards and disclosure of climate-related risks.
- Stimulus spending should include support for green investment; many green investments have large fiscal multipliers (Hepburn et al., 2020; Batini et al., 2021).
- Nature-related jobs such as ecosystem restoration can provide new sources of employment.
- The Twelfth Malaysia Plan’s emphasis on sustainability alongside resetting the economy is promising.

*Source: IMF staff calculations; Malaysia Third National Communication to the UNFCCC, Chapter 4; content extracted from 1mysea2022001.*

### Appendix IX. Capital Flows Volatility and Spillovers in Malaysia

### Appendix IX. Capital Flows Volatility and Spillovers in Malaysia

### Overview
- Potential inward spillovers to Malaysian financial markets from changes in global risk appetite and investor preferences could be significant.
- Monetary policy normalization in advanced economies may affect Malaysia via higher borrowing costs and more volatile capital flows and FX markets.
- This appendix discusses recent trends in the structure and volatility of capital flows to Malaysia and explores factors that could amplify and mitigate shock transmissions, including reforms introduced by the BNM aimed at improving Malaysia’s resilience to external shocks.

### A. Capital Flows Volatility in Malaysia
- Foreign capital became an important source of funding for Malaysia.
  - Foreign direct investment (FDI) in Malaysia stood "just above 3 percent of GDP per annum", the highest among regional peers.
  - Non-resident portfolio investments (PI) added "about 1.6 percent of GDP on average", with over a third of that inflow going into public debt.
  - Other investment account balance, mainly driven by non-resident deposits in domestic banks and interbank funding, stood at "about 0.6 percent of GDP per annum on average in 2002-2021".
- Compared to regional peers, Malaysia has high volatilities of portfolio flows and other investment, driven by non-resident deposits and interbank lending; banks’ external liabilities reflect Malaysia’s integration into the regional financial system.
- After the GFC, global liquidity became an important capital flows driver for Malaysia.
- More recently:
  - The magnitude and length of Malaysia’s total capital flow cycle have moderated.
  - The two most volatile components — PI debt inflows and non-resident deposits — often offset each other outside of crisis episodes.
  - Volatility of deposit flows continues to increase steeply.
- Capital outflows by residents have increased:
  - Domestic investment abroad (DIA) averaged "3.4 percent of GDP".
  - Residents’ portfolio investments (PI) abroad averaged "about 1.8 percent of GDP" and have been relatively stable.
  - Between end-2018 and Q3 2021, cumulative portfolio investment by residents stood at "US$33 billion", reflecting investments by domestic institutional investors in equities primarily, and debt securities, exceeding corresponding foreign inflows.

### B. Spillovers from Policy Normalization in Advanced Economies
- Channels through which AE policy normalization affects EMs:
  - Higher level of rates globally due to tapering of asset purchases and interest rate hikes by AEs’ central banks; tighter global liquidity may translate to higher borrowing costs for EM issuers.
  - Appreciation of the US dollar, with implications for EM balance sheets that have a high share of foreign currency debt or reliance on external financing; financial channels operate in the opposite direction to the competitiveness channel.
  - Capital flow and exchange rate volatility: higher uncertainty may amplify impact of financial shocks via banks’ balance sheet effects and the “risk channel” where surprise AE monetary policy changes affect perceptions of risk.
- Empirical/interpretive notes:
  - Evidence shows that "100-basis-point tightening of US monetary policy leads to an immediate 1 percentage point depreciation of EM currencies vis-à-vis the US dollar and portfolio outflows from EM of 7 basis points of annual GDP (IMF 2021a)".
  - The financial channel has strengthened over recent years and during periods of volatility as compared to trade competitiveness and pass-through to inflation channels (BIS 2020).
- Factors increasing negative spillovers:
  - Higher perceived sovereign risk (speculative sovereign debt credit rating, higher proportion of debt held externally or with higher currency volatility).
  - Presence of financial frictions.
  - Weak domestic economic conditions and limited policy space.
  - Weak macroeconomic fundamentals and policy institutions.
- Malaysia-specific assessments:
  - Malaysia’s general government debt is projected to remain below "70 percent of GDP over the medium term".
  - If contingent liabilities are included, Malaysia’s general government debt lies above some of its similarly rated peers.
  - Fund public debt sustainability analysis finds federal government debt, which covers more than "90 percent of general government debt", to be sustainable including under macro-fiscal stress tests.
  - Malaysia’s financial market and financial institution depth scores are on par with the median level in advanced economies.
  - Over "60 percent of sovereign debt is held by a diverse domestic investor base", including about "one third held by social security institutions".
  - Active buying by domestic institutional investors has helped mitigate excessive adjustments in bond yields during earlier periods of heightened capital outflows.
- Inclusion in global bond indices and credit rating implications:
  - Foreign holdings of conventional government debt increased from "8.2 percent in mid-2005" to "about 22 percent during the GFC", rebounded to a "35 percent high in mid-2016", declined to "about 23 percent before the COVID pandemic" and reached "about 25 percent at end-2021".
  - Foreign holdings are concentrated in conventional MGS, with only "about 11 percent of MGII being held by foreign investors at end-2021".
  - Share of benchmark-driven investors in Malaysia’s local currency government debt stood on average at "50 percent of total foreign holdings of public debt".
  - The share of unconstrained multi sector bond funds (MSBFs) declined from "above 30 percent in mid-2011 to less than 3 percent in 2020".
- External financing and vulnerabilities:
  - Sizable external financing needs of about "one third of GDP" represent a potential amplifying factor.
  - About "65 percent of external debt" is denominated in foreign currency.
  - External financing dependency includes "24 percent of GDP related to bank liabilities" and "16 percent of GDP related to government debt".
  - About "37 percent of external debt remains short-term at origin".
  - Coverage of short-term external liabilities by FX reserves and a flexible exchange rate regime, plus availability and widespread use of FX hedging, mitigate risks.
- BNM policy framework and past actions:
  - Excessive exchange rate volatility during periods of disorderly market corrections can be a source of financial stability risk.
  - BNM developed and refined FX and capital flow management frameworks aimed at reducing speculative flows and deepening the FX market.
  - BNM views the exchange rate as the first line of defense and a shock absorber; FX interventions are driven by assessment that excessive and volatile FX movements create risks.
  - Examples of policy responses:
    - During 2014–15 terms-of-trade shock with large non-resident capital flows, authorities allowed exchange rate to adjust flexibly as a shock absorber.
    - During the capital flow reversal of late 2016, authorities reinforced rules by requiring attestation for banks’ non-facilitation of ringgit NDF (assessed as a Capital Flow Management under the Institutional View).
    - In Q1 2020, amid significant non-resident portfolio outflows and FX volatility due to COVID-19, the ringgit depreciated "by about 5 percent vis-à-vis the US dollar". BNM employed a targeted FX intervention (FXI) to mitigate excessive FX volatility and provide FX liquidity while allowing continued ringgit flexibility.
    - BNM increased outright purchases of government securities as part of open market operations to support orderly domestic market adjustment amid portfolio outflows and signs of market stress.
  - BNM framework requires corporate borrowings to be used for productive purposes and supported by foreign currency earnings.
  - Under the dynamic hedging program, registered non-resident investors can actively manage FX risk via forward onshore without documentation.
  - Recent hedging instruments developed by BNM, including initiatives to deepen the Interest Rate Swap market, may help make capital flows more resilient to external shocks.

### C. Capital Flows-at-Risk
- Purpose:
  - The capital flows-at-risk framework is applied to model the distribution of net non-resident portfolio debt inflows to Malaysia.
  - The analysis builds on the growth-at-risk (GaR) methodology by Prasad et al (2019) and adopts approach modifications for gross capital inflows by Goel and Miyajima (2021) and Gelos et al (2019).
- Methodology:
  - A quantile regression framework is applied to model average four-quarter-ahead net non-resident portfolio debt inflows, in percent of GDP (termed APDI), as a function of financial conditions, domestic macro conditions, domestic financial openness, and global commodity price fluctuations.
  - The quantile regressions are specified as follows:
    - 푦̅_{푡+1:푡+4}^{푞} = 푎^{푞} + 훽_{1}^{푞} 퐹퐶퐼_{푡} + 훽_{2}^{푞} 퐷표푚푒푠푡푖푐 푀푎푐푟표_{푡} + 훽_{3}^{푞} 퐹푖푛푎푛푐푖푎푙 푂푝푒푛푛푒푠푠_{푡} + 훽_{4}^{푞} 퐶표푚푚표푑푖푡푦 푅푒푡푢푟푛_{푡} + 휖_{푡}^{푞}
  - Where, for quantile 푞:
    - 푦̅_{푡+1:푡+4}^{푞} is the APDI reading at time 푡,
    - 푎^{푞} is the intercept term,
    - 훽_{i}^{푞} is the coefficient corresponding to the i-th factor (for example, 훽_{2}^{푞} corresponds to 퐷표푚푒푠푡푖푐 푀푎푐푟표),
    - 휖_{푡}^{푞} is the residual term at time 푡.

*Appendix IX. Capital Flows Volatility and Spillovers in Malaysia (IMF staff prepared by Kodjovi Eklou, Natalia Novikova and Tian Yong Woon).*

### 15.      A Financial Conditions Index (FCI) was constructed via principal component analysis

### 15. A Financial Conditions Index (FCI) was constructed via principal component analysis using a group of global and domestic variables.

### Construction of the FCI
- Method: Principal component analysis.
- Global variables included:
  - VIX Index (proxy for global investor risk appetite).
  - 10-year US government bond yield.
- Domestic variables included:
  - Malaysia's 10-year to 1-year term spread.
  - 1-year interbank spread.
  - 10-year sovereign spread.
  - 5-year senior sovereign CDS US dollar spread.
  - Malaysia ringgit's returns against the US dollar.
- Note: Multiple model specifications were tested, including specifications separating the FCI into global and domestic components; issues such as severe multicollinearity were encountered during the process.

### Control variables in quantile regressions
- Domestic macro conditions:
  - Malaysia’s real year-on-year GDP growth.
- Domestic financial openness:
  - Chinn-Ito Index for Malaysia.
- Global commodity price fluctuations:
  - Returns of the Bloomberg Commodity Index.

### Interpretation: what higher FCI levels mean
- Higher FCI levels correspond to tighter financial conditions.
- Underlying variable movements that increase the FCI:
  - Increased readings for: VIX Index; Malaysia's 1-year interbank spread; Malaysia's 10-year sovereign spread; Malaysia's 5-year senior sovereign CDS US dollar spread.
  - Lower readings for: 10-year US government bond yield; Malaysia's 10-year to 1-year term spread; the ringgit’s returns against the US dollar.

### Simulation of APDI response to FCI tightening (Q3 2021 base)
- Shock: a two-standard deviation FCI tightening shock that would have elevated the base-period FCI reading beyond Q1 2020 pandemic highs.
- Effects of the shock:
  - Induces a leftward shift to the simulated APDI distribution relative to the baseline scenario, indicating broad deterioration in APDI outcomes.
  - Raises the probability of Malaysia recording APDI outflows to about 70 percent, compared to about 32 percent under baseline conditions.
  - Malaysia's 5 percent APDI-at-risk would worsen to an outflow of at least 5.2 percent of GDP, compared to 3.2 percent of GDP under baseline conditions.

### Policy conclusions and recommendations
- Malaysia is well prepared to face an increase in global interest rates implied by the baseline scenario of an orderly and well-telegraphed policy normalization in AEs, but careful calibration of policy responses is important.
- Exchange rate guidance:
  - The exchange rate should remain the first line of defense, especially when AE monetary policy tightening is driven by better economic conditions with positive trade spillovers.
  - If exchange rate remains a shock absorber in the face of unexpected AE tightening driven by inflation, policy could combine exchange rate flexibility with liquidity support (including in foreign currency) and monetary policy easing; the goal is to balance supporting growth and managing capital outflows.
  - If the exchange rate becomes a shock amplifier with financial frictions and excessive exchange rate volatility, FXI would be appropriate.
- In imminent crisis conditions, temporary outflow CFMs as part of a broader policy package could be considered, in line with the Fund’s Institutional View (IV).
- Bank Negara Malaysia (BNM) actions:
  - BNM’s steps to liberalize foreign exchange policy and to deepen the FX market are welcomed.
  - Existing CFMs should be gradually phased out with due regard to market conditions, consistent with previous Fund advice.

*Source: IMF staff calculations and related text in the provided content unit.*

### 4.      Over the medium term, external debt-to-GDP ratio is projected to return to a steady

### 1mysea2022001 - 4.      Over the medium term, external debt-to-GDP ratio is projected to return to a steady

### Medium-term baseline projection
- External debt-to-GDP ratio projected to fall to about 55 percent by 2027.
- Baseline drivers:
  - Sustained current account (CA) surpluses (excluding interest payments).
  - A recovery in economic growth supported by domestic demand.
  - Capital inflows.
  - Low external financing rates.
- Share of short-term debt (by original maturity) projected to stabilize at about 35 percent of total external debt by end of the medium term.
- Gross external financing needs:
  - Estimated to have reached 28 percent of GDP in 2021.
  - Expected to moderate to about 22 percent of GDP by 2027.

### External debt vulnerability and stress-test results
- Standard stress tests indicate external debt is most vulnerable to an exchange rate depreciation.
- Scenario outcomes (external debt in percent of GDP):
  - Baseline: 55.
  - Historical (persistent historical shock, including COVID-19): around 73 in the outer years.
  - One-time real depreciation of 30 percent in 2021: could push external debt over 75 percent of GDP by 2025 (figure shows 75).
  - Non-Interest Current Account (CA) shock: 57.
  - Combined shock: 59.
  - Growth shock: 61.
  - Interest rate shock: 56.
- Other scenarios (deceleration in real GDP growth, rise in interest rate) would lead to moderate increases in external debt.

### Mitigating factors and absorbers
- Currency and liability composition:
  - High share of ringgit-denominated external debt: about 35 percent of total external debt.
  - Intercompany loans: 15 percent of external debt.
  - Interbank borrowings: 25 percent of external debt (about four-fifth are intragroup borrowings from related offices abroad).
- Policy and institutional buffers:
  - The central bank uses an approval framework to ascertain that corporate external borrowings are utilized for productive purposes and that they are supported by foreign currency earnings.
  - Prudential requirements apply to banks’ exposure in the form of interbank borrowings, NR deposits and debt issuances, addressing liquidity and funding risk management.
  - Continued development of local and foreign currency markets has helped shield the economy from external shocks.
  - Exchange rate flexibility and a moderate CA surplus serve as shock absorbers.

### Reserve adequacy and liquidity metrics
- Gross official reserves as of December 2021: US$116.9 billion.
- Reserves coverage:
  - About 120 percent of short-term external debt by original maturity.
  - About 126 percent of the IMF reserve adequacy metric (ARA).

### Key numeric statistics (as presented)
- External debt baseline level by 2027: 55 percent of GDP.
- Short-term debt share: about 35 percent of total external debt.
- Gross external financing needs: 28 percent of GDP in 2021; about 22 percent of GDP by 2027.
- Ringgit-denominated external debt: about 35 percent of total external debt.
- Intercompany loans: 15 percent of external debt.
- Interbank borrowings: 25 percent of external debt (about four-fifth intragroup).
- Gross official reserves (Dec 2021): US$116.9 billion.
- Reserves coverage of short-term external debt: about 120 percent.
- Reserves vs. ARA metric: about 126 percent.
- Stress-test scenario outcomes (external debt as percent of GDP): Baseline 55; Historical 73; 30% real depreciation 75; CA shock 57; Combined shock 59; Growth shock 61; Interest rate shock 56.
- Gross external financing needs under baseline (chart reference): right scale values shown in staff figures.

*Source: 1mysea2022001 (excerpt from IMF staff report).*

### Introduction

### Introduction

### Appreciation and policy stance
- Authorities convey appreciation to the mission team led by Mission Chief Mr. Lamin Leigh for the constructive 2022 Article IV consultation and comprehensive report.  
- Authorities broadly agree with the thrust of staff’s appraisal and will carefully consider key policy recommendations.  
- Macroeconomic policies should be calibrated to the pace of the recovery while preserving policy space, given uneven recovery and ongoing pandemic uncertainties.  
- Stronger-than-expected recovery provides opportunity to shift focus toward longer-term structural reforms while maintaining immediate support for more vulnerable segments.

### Latest economic developments and outlook
- GDP growth: 3.1 percent in 2021 (2020: -5.6 percent).  
- Recovery drivers: rapid domestic vaccinations and phased lifting of restrictions under the National Recovery Plan (NRP).  
- Headline inflation: 2.5 percent in 2021, driven mainly by base effects from low retail fuel prices in 2020.  
- Core inflation: averaged at 0.7 percent in 2021 (2020: 1.1 percent), reflecting spare capacity; increased slightly toward year-end.  
- 2022 growth projection: expand by between 5.3 to 6.3 percent, supported by global demand expansion, lifting of domestic containment measures, reopening of international borders, and improved labor market conditions.  
- 2022 headline inflation projection: average between 2.2 to 3.2 percent; core inflation expected to average higher due to improved demand and lingering cost pressures.  
- Balance of risks: assessed as tilted to the downside, mainly from COVID-19 related domestic and external factors; upside risks include higher-than-expected global growth and stronger-than-expected tourism recovery.  
- Targeted policy support: continuation and tailoring of measures for adversely affected sectors (e.g., tourism), low-income households, SMEs, and different labor market dimensions.  
- Vaccination statistics (as of March 31, 2022): 97.6 percent of the adult population fully vaccinated; 67.2 percent have received booster doses.

### Fiscal policy
- Budget 2022: largest to date with allocation of RM332.1 billion or 20.3 percent of GDP, geared toward near-term revitalization and structural reform strategies under the Twelfth Malaysia Plan, 2021-2025 (12MP).  
- COVID-19 Fund: additional RM23 billion or 1.4 percent of GDP dedicated to stimulus and recovery measures (targeted cash assistance, wage subsidies, grants for SMEs, re-skilling and upskilling programs, other measures).  
- Statutory debt limit: raised from 60 to 65 percent of GDP in October 2021 to provide fiscal space.  
- Medium-term fiscal consolidation: authorities committed to consolidation and guided by the Medium-Term Fiscal Framework (MTFF). Authorities propose commencing gradual consolidation in 2022 instead of 2023.  
- 2022–2024 MTFF: revised to a more gradual fiscal consolidation; overall fiscal deficit averaging at 5 percent of GDP for the three-year period (2021 – 2023 MTFF: 4.5 percent).  
- Fiscal deficit projections: decline to 6 percent of GDP in 2022 (2021: 6.5 percent) and to 3.5 percent in the medium-term.  
- Debt target: aim to reduce overall debt-to-GDP ratio to below 60 percent in the medium-term.  
- Fiscal governance and revenue measures:
  - Fiscal Responsibility Act (FRA) expected to be tabled to Parliament this year; includes some staff recommendations via technical assistance.  
  - Medium-Term Revenue Strategy (MTRS) to guide revenue base enhancement; feasibility studies on capital gains, value added and carbon taxes are in the pipeline.  
  - Tax Expenditure Statement to be published to determine costs of tax incentives and exemptions.  
  - Collaboration with the World Bank on a Public Expenditure Review.  
- Other reforms: strengthen governance of government-linked companies (GLCs) and government-linked investment companies (GLICs); progress on National Anti-Corruption Plan (NACP) initiatives.

### Monetary, exchange rate and financial market policies
- Monetary stance: Bank Negara Malaysia (BNM) kept the Overnight Policy Rate (OPR) unchanged at the historical low of 1.75 percent throughout 2021.  
- Monetary operations: aimed to ensure conducive domestic liquidity, orderly functioning of financial markets, and continued intermediation to the real economy; domestic banking system liquidity remained ample.  
- Statutory Reserve Requirement (SRR) flexibility: provided sustained liquidity support; SRR flexibility originally available until May 31, 2021, and subsequently extended to December 31, 2022.  
- Liquidity injections: reverse repos, outright purchase of Government securities and foreign exchange swaps used during periods of heightened volatility.  
- March 3, 2022 MPC decision: maintain OPR at 1.75 percent; policy to remain data-driven and mindful of potential financial imbalances; any adjustments to accommodation to be measured and gradual.  
- Exchange rate: flexibility remains first line of defense; de-facto exchange rate arrangement classified as floating.  
- Foreign exchange intervention (FXI): targeted at managing excessive volatility and maintaining orderly domestic FX market conditions; authorities cautious about publishing FXI data due to confidentiality and market-sensitive concerns.  
- Capital flow management (CFM) and liberalization: authorities view remaining FX market and prudential measures as crucial for stability and development; disagree with staff recommendation to gradually phase out these measures at this stage.

### External sector and debt
- Current account (CA) surplus: viewed as a sign of strength; authorities caution interpreting EBA findings without domestic context due to limitations and weak explanatory power of the EBA model for Malaysia.  
- External debt sustainability: authorities view current level of external debt as manageable in presence of mitigating factors highlighted in staff report.

### Financial sector
- Financial buffers: resilient financial sector maintaining sufficient buffers; banks prudently set aside provisions for potential credit losses as repayment assistance programs unwind.  
- Macro stress tests: BNM results affirm banks can withstand potential losses from severe macroeconomic and financial shocks while supporting recovery.  
- Household sector risks:
  - Household debt-to-GDP ratio: declined slightly to 89.0 percent as at end-2021.  
  - Household debt growth: 4.1 percent in 2021.  
  - Authorities disagree with characterization of a ‘household debt overhang’; limited evidence households cannot take on more debt.  
  - Households have maintained financial buffers “at least twice the size of their debt.”  
  - Vulnerable groups: highly leveraged borrowers with low buffers, particularly lower-income groups, warrant closer attention; assistance remains available (banks, Credit Counselling and Debt Management Agency (AKPK), Financial Management and Resilience Programme (URUS) for bottom 50 percent of household income distribution).  
- Corporate sector risks:
  - Non-financial corporates: generally improved financial performance; share of firms-at-risk declined.  
  - SMEs: more vulnerable due to smaller cash buffers and thinner margins; new rescheduling and restructuring (R&R) applications decelerated from peak in July 2021.  
  - BNM measures: additional funds for SMEs (additional allocations to Fund for SMEs, Targeted Relief and Recovery Facility (TRRF), creation of two new funds for recapitalization and transition to low carbon practices).  
  - TRRF enhancement: SMEs may utilize up to 30 percent of financing approved to repay existing business financing.  
  - Credit guarantee schemes and ongoing R&R support business recovery and mitigate impairment risks.

### Structural and governance reforms
- Authorities committed to structural and institutional reforms to enhance economic dynamism, mitigate scarring, and secure sustainable and inclusive medium- to long-term growth.  
- Twelfth Malaysia Plan (12MP) priorities: Budget 2022 aligned with 12MP; significant allocations for education quality, labor market support, social protection expansion, and sustainable economy transition.  
- Investment and digital agendas:
  - National Investment Aspirations (NIA) adopted into national strategies; New Investment Policy reforms to accelerate quality investments.  
  - Malaysia Digital Economic Blueprint (MyDIGITAL) launched to catalyze digital economy and inclusiveness.  
  - BNM Financial Sector Blueprint 2022-2026 (FSB) published to elevate household and business well-being, advance digitalization, and position financial system for orderly green transition.  
- Climate and green initiatives:
  - 12MP reaffirms aspiration to achieve net zero carbon emissions by 2050.  
  - Ministry of Environment and Water to finalize Long-Term Low Emission Development Strategy by end-2022.  
  - Updated Nationally Determined Contribution (NDC): reduce carbon emissions by 45 percent compared to 35 percent, driving NDC roadmap until 2030 in alignment with Paris Agreement commitments.  
  - Feasibility study on introducing a carbon tax underway.  
  - BNM plans to integrate climate-related and environmental risks into prudential regulation and supervision, including stress-testing requirements.  
  - BNM issued the Climate Change and Principles-based Taxonomy in April 2021 to facilitate consistent assessments; climate-related risk disclosures will be mandatory for all banks.  
- Governance and AML/CFT:
  - Strengthening governance and AML/CFT framework is a priority.  
  - NACP progress: 8 out of 82 initiatives implemented; another 14 initiatives expected by mid-2022; commitment to implement more NACP initiatives throughout the year.  
  - Medium-term priorities in the FSB to preserve financial system integrity and mitigate ML/TF risks identified in the National Risk Assessment 2020.

### Final remarks
- Authorities remain committed to sound macroeconomic management and continued structural reforms, citing the economy’s good performance track record and resilience to shocks.  
- Authorities look forward to continued engagement and strong collaboration with the Fund, including ongoing and future technical assistance programs.

*Source: Introduction (1mysea2022001).*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/cr/2022/english/1mysea2022001.pdf_
