## Benin — Second ECF/EFF Review (1benea2023001)

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [Benin — Second ECF/EFF Review (1benea2023001)](https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/cr/2023/english/1benea2023001.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/files/publications/cr/2023/english/1benea2023001.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/files/publications/cr/2023/english/1benea2023001.pdf.json)

---

### Executive summary: program performance and recent developments
- Frontloaded financing under the 42-month EFF and ECF (approved July 2022) supported a balanced policy response and recovery.
- Overall program performance: Robust.
- Targets and benchmarks met:
  - All quantitative performance criteria (QPCs) and indicative targets (ITs) for end-September and end-December 2022 were met.
  - All Structural Benchmarks (SBs) due end-February, end-March, and end-April 2023 were met (governance diagnostic published; financial inclusion strategy adopted; digitalizing land title requests; draft law to ensure sustainability of school feeding program submitted to Parliament).
- Recent macro outcomes:
  - Economic activity expanded by an estimated average of 6.3 percent in 2022.
  - Inflation: 1.4 percent in 2022; inflation rose to 5 percent (y/y) in 2023:Q1.
  - Current account deficit: estimated widened to 6.3 percent of GDP in 2022.
  - Private credit growth: 21 percent (y/y) at end-December 2022.
  - NPLs declining: 7.2 percent at end-December 2022 (from 11.1 percent at end-June 2022).
  - Benin’s EMBI spreads: declined to 727 bps at mid-April after peaking around 1,000 bps in mid-2022.

### Fiscal outturns, composition, and 2023 adjustment
- 2022 fiscal deficit: 5.5 percent of GDP.
- Debt: 2 ppts of GDP higher than previously projected due to additional regional issuances totaling 3 ppts of GDP.
- Text Table 1 (commitment-basis, CFAF billions):
  - Total revenue and grants: First Review 1,509.2 / Actual 1,553.2 / Difference 44.0
  - Total revenue: First Review 1,454.6 / Actual 1,498.6 / Difference 44.0
  - Tax revenue: First Review 1,241.4 / Actual 1,320.7 / Difference 79.3
  - Nontax revenue: First Review 213.1 / Actual 177.8 / Difference -35.3
  - Total expenditure and net lending: First Review 2,114.5 / Actual 2,149.4 / Difference 34.9
  - Capital expenditure: First Review 867.8 / Actual 954.9 / Difference 87.1
  - Overall balance (commitment basis, incl. grants): First Review -605.3 / Actual -596.2 / Difference 9.1
- Fiscal adjustment 2022–2023:
  - Overall adjustment: 1.2 (Percent of GDP).
  - Components (Text Table 4):
    - A. New spending pressures: -0.7 (Security risk spending scale up: -0.2; Wage bill increase: -0.5)
    - B. Tax revenue mobilization (net): 0.6
    - C. Correction for exceptional non-tax revenues: -0.3
    - D. Spending Measures: 1.6 (Reduction in one-off spending: 0.2; Spending reprioritization: 1.3)
    - E. Grants: 0.1
  - Fiscal space headline: 4.3 percent of GDP (with potential to increase up to 4.7 ppts of GDP if external budget support adjustor kicks in).
- Fuel subsidies (No Adjustment Scenario, 2022–2024, CFAF billions and percent of GDP):
  - Diesel: 2022 Prel 94.4 (0.87); 2023 22.5 (0.19); 2024 13.4 (0.10)
  - Gasoline: 2022 Prel 17.1 (0.16); 2023 3.6 (0.03); 2024 1.8 (0.01)
  - Total (A+B): 2022 Prel 111.5 (1.03); 2023 26.0 (0.22); 2024 15.2 (0.12)

### Revenue mobilization and MTRS
- Key objectives:
  - Maintain 2022 tax momentum and accelerate design of Medium-Term Revenue Mobilization Strategy (MTRS) (SB for end-September 2023).
  - Improvement in tax-to-GDP ratio for 2023–25 maintained at 1.5 ppts of GDP.
- Box 1 highlights:
  - Benin’s tax-to-GDP ratio: 11.5 percent in 2022.
  - Additional 2022 yields: tax arrears collection 0.6 ppt of GDP; changes in taxation of gambling, electronic communication, and corporate income about 0.2 ppt of GDP.
  - Tax giveaways related to the war in Ukraine: 1 ppt of GDP (compensatory measures limited budgetary impact and exceeded end-September and end-December 2022 tax targets).
- Identified additional tax measures for 2023:
  - Move to transactional values at customs.
  - Expansion of standardized invoices.
  - Application of minimum tax on the sale of used vehicles.
- Box 1 Table: Net additional yields (A+B+C) — 2022 Outturns / 2023 Projected: 0.5 / 0.6
  - A. Domestic taxation: 0.9 / 1.0 (clearance of domestic tax arrears: 0.6 / 0.4)
  - B. International taxation: 1.0 / 0.3
  - C. Tax giveaways and other revenue-reducing effects: -1.3 / -0.7
  - Memo: Identified contingency measures for 2023: 0.5

### Spending priorities, borrowing strategy, and public investment
- 2022 capital expenditure: 0.8 ppt of GDP higher than anticipated.
- 2023 policy:
  - Sharper moderation of non-priority capital expenditure; rephasing of projects advanced to 2022.
  - Security spending scale-up for 2023 budgeted at 1.0 ppt of GDP (civilian approach).
- Borrowing and financing:
  - Prudent borrowing strategy; baseline relies on domestic financing.
  - Pre-emptive issuances in prior year totaled 2.9 percent of GDP.
  - Importance of maximizing concessional external borrowing and securing additional budget support.
  - Authorities open to climate-related financing building on SDG Bond Framework.

### Social safety nets, food security, human capital
- Social registry expansion planned to cover all social assistance programs, including ARCH.
- School feeding program:
  - Provides daily hot meals to almost 1.2 million students in 75 percent of public primary schools; plan to reach 100 percent by 2026.
  - Draft law submitted to ensure sustainability (end-April 2023 SB met).
- Food security and agriculture:
  - Food security fragile; vulnerabilities from weather and productivity constraints.
  - Agriculture employs > two-thirds of active population but accounts for ~one quarter of GDP.
  - Irrigated areas estimated <2 percent (53,000 ha) of cropped area in 2019.
  - Cotton production nearly tripled since 2015; cotton production ~800,000 tons in 2021; cotton accounts for over three-quarters of export proceeds.
  - Government agriculture budget in 2023: 100 billion CFA francs (0.9 percent of GDP), a 13.5 percent increase vs 2022.
  - PAG-II objective: national rice self-sufficiency by 2026.

### Governance, AML/CFT, PFM, and rule of law
- IMF governance diagnostic completed and published (end-February 2023); homegrown action plan to be completed by end-June 2023.
- New and proposed SBs:
  - Operationalize Commercial Court of Appeal (staffing/funding/equipment) — end-November 2023 (newly proposed).
  - Operationalize HCPC and strengthen legal framework — end-June 2024 (newly proposed).
  - Update list of public organizations’ bank accounts and close at least half by end-June 2024 (newly proposed).
- AML/CFT priorities:
  - Mitigate money laundering risks in real estate; develop legal framework for collection/verification/publication of transferees’ beneficial ownership information for land transfers.
- Public procurement and transparency:
  - BO information publication for companies awarded public procurement contracts consistent with September 2022 regulation.
  - ARMP to conduct and publish independent audits of awarded contracts.

### Financial sector and inclusion
- Two undercapitalized banks being addressed:
  - One bank preliminarily recapitalized pending approval.
  - BCEAO and Banking Commission assessing scenarios for second bank.
- National financial inclusion strategy (2023–27) adopted.
- Financial indicators (selected):
  - Regulatory capital to risk-weighted assets (percent): e.g., 13.4 (2022 June).
  - Gross NPLs to total loans (percent): 12.6 (2022 June).
  - Provisioning rate (percent): 74.3 (2022 June).
  - Credit to the private sector: projected 21.4 percent (2023); credit growth actuals: 21 percent (end-December 2022).

### Outlook, projections, and DSA findings
- Baseline macro projections:
  - Near-term growth forecast: unchanged at 6 percent for 2023; medium-term growth at potential of 6 percent.
  - Inflation expected: 3.5 percent in 2023; stabilize at 2 percent medium-term.
  - Current account deficit: in range of 4–5 percent of GDP medium-term; estimated -6.3 percent of GDP in 2022.
- Key macro projection table (selected):
  - Real GDP (annual percent change): 2019 6.9; 2020 3.8; 2021 7.2; 2022 (Est.) 6.0; 2023 (Proj.) 6.3; 2024–2028 (Proj.) 6.0 each year.
  - Consumer price index (average): 2019 -0.9; 2020 3.0; 2021 1.7; 2022 (Est.) 2.5; 2023 (Proj.) 1.4.
  - Total public debt (end period, percent of GDP): 2019 41.2; 2020 46.1; 2021 50.3; 2022 (Est.) 52.8; 2023 (Proj.) 54.2; 2024–2028 (Proj.) 53.2; 53.8; 53.5; 52.4; 51.4; 50.5; 49.6.
  - Current account balance (percent of GDP): 2019 -4.0; 2020 -1.7; 2021 -4.2; 2022 (Est.) -6.1; 2023 (Proj.) -6.3; 2024–2028 (Proj.) -5.5; -5.9; -5.6; -5.1; -4.9; -4.4; -4.2.
- DSA key findings:
  - Benin assessed at moderate risk of external and overall debt distress.
  - Public debt projected around 54 percent of GDP at end-2023; projected to decline to 46 percent of GDP by 2033 under baseline.
  - Contingent liabilities shock calibrated at 9.6 percent of GDP (1.9 SOE debt; 0.3 local government; 2.4 PPPs; 5.0 financial market risk).
  - Debt vulnerabilities pronounced under stress tests, especially commodity price and natural disaster shocks; some indicators breach thresholds in stress scenarios.
  - Policy emphasis: sustained revenue mobilization, prudent borrowing, active liability management, maximize concessional financing.

### Program financing, monitoring, and conditionality
- Program financing status:
  - Program fully financed for next 12 months with strong prospects through end of program and upside potential on budget support.
  - Expected 2023 budget support:
    - World Bank: $150 million in loans (linked to upcoming DPO).
    - European Union: about $10 million in grants.
    - Potential additional support could allow higher fiscal deficit by up to 0.4 ppt of GDP per program adjustor.
- Schedule of disbursements under ECF/EFF (SDR million):
  - July 8, 2022: Total 108.30 (ECF 36.10; EFF 72.20)
  - November 21, 2022: Total 108.30 (ECF 36.10; EFF 72.20)
  - May 1, 2023: Total 50.82 (ECF 16.94; EFF 33.88)
  - November 1, 2023: Total 101.58 (ECF 33.86; EFF 67.72)
  - Subsequent scheduled disbursements through October 31, 2025 total 484.05 SDR million (ECF 161.349; EFF 322.709)
- Monitoring and conditionality:
  - Program performance monitored via semi-annual reviews based on QPCs, ITs, and SBs.
  - Continuous performance criteria: no accumulation of external or domestic arrears; ceiling on present value of new external debt contracted or guaranteed (CFAF 620 billion in 2023).
  - Indicative targets include tax revenue and priority social expenditure floors.

### Risks, contingency measures, and mitigation
- Major downside external risks (Annex I):
  - More protracted war in Ukraine; higher food and oil prices; intensification of regional conflicts; adverse developments in Nigeria; higher frequency of extreme climate events.
- Domestic risks:
  - Policy implementation risks from social discontent; increased systemic financial instability from NPLs.
- Recommended policy responses and contingency plans:
  - Maintain security spending within budgeted envelope; delay non-priority capital expenditure if shocks materialize.
  - Stand ready to adopt additional revenue measures if yields fall short.
  - In event of Nigerian fuel subsidy reform, adjust pump prices further to limit Benin’s subsidy bill.
  - Continue focus on social safety nets, targeted transfers, and emergency assistance to protect the poor.

### Staff appraisal and program recommendation
- Staff appraisal highlights:
  - Balanced policy response and frontloaded financing boosted confidence and recovery.
  - Robust fiscal performance amid shocks; progress on structural reforms.
  - Risks from geoeconomic fragmentation, food insecurity, and regional security remain.
  - Continued commitment to debt sustainability and structural reforms recommended.
- Program recommendation:
  - Given continued strong program performance and commitment to reforms, staff recommends completion of the second review under the EFF and ECF arrangements.

*Source: IMF—Benin: Second ECF/EFF Review and Request for Waivers and Augmentation (Executive Summary) and related staff report excerpts (1benea2023001).*

### EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

### EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

### Backdrop
- Frontloaded financing under the 42-month Extended Fund Facility (EFF) and Extended Credit Facility (ECF) arrangements—approved by the IMF Executive Board in July 2022—has:
  - Supported the authorities’ balanced policy response to exogenous shocks.
  - Helped boost business confidence and support the economic recovery.
- Important socio-economic headwinds remain:
  - Geoeconomic fragmentation, food insecurity, and the regional security situation.
- Authorities’ commitment to reform is expected to help keep the economy on a sustainable path.

### Policy discussions (Second EFF/ECF review)
- Focus areas:
  - Delivering on the 2023 budget—the program’s first year of fiscal consolidation.
  - Strengthening social safety nets and tackling food insecurity.
  - Enhancing the anti-corruption and AML/CFT frameworks, building on the recent IMF governance diagnostic.
  - Gauging the authorities’ climate agenda.

### Program performance
- Overall performance: Robust.
- Targets met:
  - All quantitative performance criteria (QPCs) and indicative targets (ITs) for end-September and end-December 2022 were met.
- Structural reform progress:
  - IMF governance diagnostic completed and published by the authorities.
  - Financial inclusion strategy adopted.
  - Two end-April structural benchmarks met: digitalizing land title requests and submitting to Parliament a draft law to ensure sustainability of the school feeding program.

### Recent economic developments
- Growth and activity:
  - Economic activity expanded by an estimated average of 6.3 percent in 2022, lifted by construction, agriculture, transport, and trade.
  - Growing activity around the new Special Economic Zone (SEZ) with clothing lines and new factories to transform locally produced cashews and soy operational.
- Food security and security threats:
  - Food security is fragile, compounded by weather-related vulnerabilities and productivity constraints (Annex V).
  - Security threats at Benin’s northern border; fear of terrorism has led to school closures, undermining human capital accumulation.
- Inflation and external sector:
  - Decoupling in 2022: inflation 1.4 percent and deflator 4.1 percent in 2022; inflation rose to 5 percent (y/y) in 2023:Q1, mainly driven by food prices, housing and transport.
  - Current account deficit estimated to have widened to 6.3 percent of GDP in 2022 reflecting Terms of Trade deterioration, sharp drop in cotton production amid floods, and increased public spending.
  - Large current account deficit partly financed by FDI in construction and higher-than-expected external project loans.
- Financial sector and markets:
  - Private credit grew 21 percent (y/y) at end-December 2022.
  - NPLs on a downward trend: 7.2 percent (y/y) at end-December 2022, from 11.1 percent at end-June 2022.
  - Benin’s EMBI spreads declined to 727 bps at mid-April after peaking around 1,000 bps in mid-2022.

### Fiscal developments and 2022 outturn
- Fiscal stance and adjustments:
  - 2022 fiscal deficit was 5.5 percent of GDP, in line with the program.
  - Debt was 2 ppts of GDP higher than previously projected, driven by additional regional issuances totaling 3 ppts of GDP.
- Revenue and spending:
  - Tax collection strong in 2022 despite fuel-related tax giveaways and reclassification of around 0.7 ppt of GDP from non-tax to tax revenue; non-tax revenue also improved by 0.3 ppt of GDP outside the reclassification.
  - Authorities re-prioritized spending: additional space from stronger revenues and lower current expenditure was channeled to capital expenditure and priority social spending.
- Text Table 1 highlights (commitment-basis, billions of CFA francs and percent GDP):
  - Total revenue and grants: First Review 1,509.2 / Actual 1,553.2 / Difference 44.0 (Billions of CFA francs)
  - Total revenue: First Review 1,454.6 / Actual 1,498.6 / Difference 44.0
  - Tax revenue: First Review 1,241.4 / Actual 1,320.7 / Difference 79.3
  - Nontax revenue: First Review 213.1 / Actual 177.8 / Difference -35.3
  - Total expenditure and net lending: First Review 2,114.5 / Actual 2,149.4 / Difference 34.9
  - Capital expenditure: First Review 867.8 / Actual 954.9 / Difference 87.1
  - Overall balance (commitment basis, incl. grants): First Review -605.3 / Actual -596.2 / Difference 9.1

### Outlook and risks
- Baseline projections:
  - Near-term growth forecast unchanged at 6 percent for 2023.
  - Inflation expected to increase to 3.5 percent in 2023.
  - Medium-term: growth at potential of 6 percent; inflation expected to stabilize at 2 percent; current account deficit in the range of 4–5 percent of GDP.
  - Benin assessed at moderate risk of external and overall debt distress (see DSA).
- Downside risks (Annex I):
  - More protracted war in Ukraine straining external accounts.
  - Further pressure on international oil and food prices leading to purchasing power erosion and social discontent.
  - Intensification of regional conflicts disrupting transit trade.
  - Uncertainty in Nigeria potentially disrupting transit trade and international tax revenue.
  - Vulnerability to extreme climate events with severe damage to infrastructure, cotton export proceeds and food security (Annex IV).
- Upside possibilities:
  - Orderly development of the SEZ could boost agroindustry and textiles, increase incomes (including for farmers), and attract SEZ-related FDI that fosters diversification and strengthens the external position.
  - Modernization and expansion of the Port of Cotonou could enhance competitiveness and complement industrial development.

### Program risks and mitigation
- Risk assessment:
  - Risks to the program are elevated but manageable.
  - Specific risks include higher-than-expected security spending, prolonged impact of the war in Ukraine, spillovers from weaker global demand, and social discontent.
- Mitigating factors:
  - Authorities’ continued commitment to fiscal responsibility.
  - Renewed focus on social issues.

### Program implementation details and safeguards
- Quantitative performance and safeguards:
  - All end-September 2022 ITs and end-December 2022 QPCs and ITs were met (Text Table 3).
  - The contracting and guaranteeing of external debt remained within the present value QPC.
  - Benin has not accumulated external or domestic arrears.
  - Priority social spending was well above the program floor, driven in part by expansion of the school feeding program and higher spending under the Insurance for Human Capital Development (ARCH).
- Structural benchmarks and reforms:
  - All Structural Benchmarks (SBs) were met.
  - Governance diagnostic conducted and published by the authorities; financial inclusion strategy adopted.
  - Draft law to ensure sustainability of the flagship school feeding program finalized (end-April 2023 SB).
  - Digitalization of processing land title requests to reduce delays met (end-April 2023 SB), building on the online land registry (e-cadaster) and new law establishing the Land Court.

### Policy priorities and recommendations
- Entrench revenue-based fiscal consolidation to preserve debt sustainability:
  - Convergence to an overall fiscal deficit of 3 percent of GDP postponed to 2025 (from 2024), consistent with WAEMU stance and program debt sustainability objective.
  - Strong Medium-Term Revenue Mobilization Strategy (MTRS) to anchor tax collection from 2024 onwards.
- Strengthen social safety nets and contain food insecurity:
  - Scale up priority social spending, sustain flagship school feeding program, and enhance targeted social protection to address fragile food security and climate-related vulnerabilities.
- Leverage governance diagnostic to strengthen institutions:
  - Develop and implement a homegrown action plan to operationalize key recommendations from the IMF governance diagnostic.
- Reform energy subsidies and enhance climate agenda:
  - Continue reforms to rationalize energy subsidies and integrate climate considerations into policy frameworks.

*Source: IMF—Benin: Second ECF/EFF Review and Request for Waivers and Augmentation (Executive Summary), May 4, 2023.*

### 4.3 percent of GDP (with the potential to

### 1benea2023001 - 4.3 percent of GDP (with the potential to

### Fiscal adjustment: size, composition, and targets
- Overall adjustment between 2022 and 2023: 1.2 (Percent of GDP).
- Adjustment components (Text Table 4):
  - A. New spending pressures: -0.7
    - Security risk spending scale up: -0.2
    - Wage bill increase: -0.5
  - B. Tax revenue mobilization (net): 0.6
  - C. Correction for exceptional non-tax revenues1: -0.3
  - D. Spending Measures: 1.6
    - Reduction in one-off spending2: 0.2
    - Spending reprioritization3: 1.3
  - E. Grants: 0.1
- Fiscal space headline: 4.3 percent of GDP (with the potential to increase up to 4.7 ppts of GDP should the external budget support adjustor kick-in; TMU ¶7).
- Achieving the implied 1.2 ppts of GDP in fiscal consolidation requires sustained tax efforts and further spending reprioritization to shield priority social spending.

### Revenue-based consolidation and tax mobilization
- Key objective: maintain 2022 tax collection momentum in 2023 and accelerate design of the MTRS.
- Rationale:
  - Part of 2022 tax overperformance reflected clearance of tax arrears, whose yields would normalize overtime.
  - The improvement in the tax-to-GDP ratio for 2023–25 is maintained at 1.5 ppts of GDP, implying additional tax effort.
  - Nominal tax ITs have been raised accordingly, compared to the First Review.
- Specific measures and milestones:
  - Ensure implementation of all tax measures planned in the 2023 budget and newly identified measures.
  - Accelerate development of a MTRS (SB for end-September 2023) to expand the tax base and improve system efficiency.
  - MTRS will inform tax policy measures under next year’s budget, to be submitted to Parliament by mid-October 2024.
- Box 1 summary points:
  - Benin’s tax-to-GDP ratio: 11.5 percent in 2022, below WAEMU peers and below the country’s tax potential.
  - Additional 2022 yields included tax arrears collection (0.6 ppt of GDP) and changes in taxation of gambling, electronic communication, and corporate income (about 0.2 ppt of GDP).
  - Benin adopted tax exemptions related to the war in Ukraine amounting to 1 ppt of GDP; compensatory measures limited the budgetary impact and exceeded end-September and end-December 2022 tax targets under the program.
- Identified additional tax measures to limit spending cuts in 2023 include:
  - Move to transactional values at customs.
  - Expansion of standardized invoices.
  - Application of the minimum tax on the sale of used vehicles.
- Box 1 Table: Net additional yields relative to the previous year (A+B+C)
  - 2022 Outturns / 2023 Projected: 0.5 / 0.6
  - A. Domestic taxation: 0.9 / 1.0
    - Taxes on gambling: 0.1 / 0.0
    - CIT reform: 0.1 / 0.1
    - Expansion of standardized invoices reform: 0.1 / (blank)
    - Minimum tax on the sale of used vehicles: 0.1 / (blank)
    - Clearance of domestic tax arrears: 0.6 / 0.4
    - Other domestic tax measures: 0.1 / 0.2
  - B. International taxation: 1.0 / 0.3
    - Continued application of transaction values: 0.2 / 0.1
    - Improved control of customs valuation: 0.3 / 0.2
    - Clearance of custom duties arrears: 0.0 / 0.1
    - Other int'l tax measures: 0.5 / -0.1
  - C. Tax giveaways and other revenue-reducing effects: -1.3 / -0.7
  - Memo item: Identified contingency measures for 2023: 0.5

### Spending prioritization, capital expenditure, and borrowing strategy
- Spending prioritization:
  - In 2022 capital expenditure was 0.8 ppt of GDP higher than anticipated as authorities advanced projects using additional revenue and recurrent spending efficiency gains.
  - For 2023, authorities will implement a sharper moderation of non-priority capital expenditure than envisaged at the time of the First Review to support overall adjustment.
  - The planned moderation reflects rephasing of projects advanced to 2022 and expected reduction in recurrent expenditure partly falling on one-off items.
  - Strategy for tackling security risks will rely on a “civilian approach” with budgeted spending scale-up for 2023 at 1.0 ppt of GDP over pre-existing spending.
- Borrowing and financing:
  - Benin to maintain a prudent borrowing strategy to contain borrowing costs and mitigate refinancing risks.
  - Baseline continues to rely on domestic financing; liquidity conditions have tightened on the regional secondary market.
  - Pre-emptive issuances last year totaled 2.9 percent of GDP and could be used for budget financing or liability management this year.
  - Continued efforts to maximize concessional external borrowing and secure additional budget support from development partners are important.
  - Authorities open to climate-related financing opportunities, building on existing SDG Bond Framework (Annex IV).

### Fuel subsidies, administrative controls, and social protection
- Fuel subsidy cost projections (Text Table 5, No Adjustment Scenario, 2022–2024):
  - A. Diesel:
    - 2022 Prel: CFAF billions 94.4 ; Percent of GDP 0.87
    - 2023: CFAF billions 22.5 ; Percent of GDP 0.19
    - 2024: CFAF billions 13.4 ; Percent of GDP 0.10
  - B. Gasoline:
    - 2022 Prel: CFAF billions 17.1 ; Percent of GDP 0.16
    - 2023: CFAF billions 3.6 ; Percent of GDP 0.03
    - 2024: CFAF billions 1.8 ; Percent of GDP 0.01
  - C. Total (A+B):
    - 2022 Prel: CFAF billions 111.5 ; Percent of GDP 1.03
    - 2023: CFAF billions 26.0 ; Percent of GDP 0.22
    - 2024: CFAF billions 15.2 ; Percent of GDP 0.12
- Policy stance on fuel subsidies:
  - 2023 fuel subsidy bill projected to be contained at 0.22 ppt of GDP before receding further to 0.12 in 2024, mainly reflecting normalization of international oil prices and the US dollar.
  - Budget exposed to international oil prices and changes in fuel pricing in Nigeria; a Nigerian reform could increase Benin’s subsidy bill unless pump prices are adjusted.
  - Government will assess alignment of pricing mechanism to international standards with IMF support and develop a medium-term plan for reforming fuel subsidies that includes compensation mechanisms for the vulnerable.
- Administrative controls and efficiency:
  - Phasing out administrative price controls and moving to transactional values at customs (implemented October 2022) and suspension of the pause on electricity tariffs adjustment.
  - While these could exert near-term inflationary pressure, they are expected to improve resource allocation and efficiency.

### Social safety nets, food security, and human capital
- Social protection:
  - Authorities plan to expand the social registry to all social assistance programs, including Insurance for Human Capital Development (ARCH).
  - Social registry currently used for targeting in some programs; strengthening institutional framework and human resources to update data is crucial.
  - Continued improvements in health-related spending effectiveness, addressing audit-identified shortcomings in COVID-19-related spending, maintenance of medical equipment, and training for healthcare personnel.
- Education and food programs:
  - School feeding program provides daily hot meals to almost 1.2 million students in 75 percent of public primary schools, with plans to reach 100 percent by 2026.
  - SB on submitting a draft school feeding law was recently met and will ensure sustainability through legal/institutional framework, local procurement strategy, and financing strategy (MEFP, ¶21).
- Food security strategy:
  - Sustainable alleviation of food insecurity requires increased efforts to boost productivity of staples and agricultural resilience to climate shocks; climate reforms could be supported under the RSF (Annex IV).

### Governance diagnostic, rule of law, anti-corruption, AML/CFT, and public financial management
- Authorities developing a homegrown action plan to implement IMF governance diagnostic recommendations, intended to be completed by end-June 2023; diagnostic published end-February.
- Program conditionality augmented with new SBs responding to diagnostic findings.
- Key governance and institutional actions:
  - Rule of law: operationalize the Commercial Court of Appeals with staffing, funding, and equipment (newly proposed SB for end-November 2023).
  - Anti-corruption: operationalize the High Commission for the Prevention of Corruption (HCPC) and strengthen its legal framework (newly proposed SB for end-June 2024).
  - AML/CFT: mitigate money laundering risks in the real estate sector, develop legal framework for collection/verification/publication of transferees’ beneficial ownership information for land transfers (MEFP ¶25).
  - Transparency: continue publication of beneficial ownership information for companies awarded public procurement contracts in line with September 2022 regulation.
  - Public accounts: update list of bank accounts of public organizations before end-August 2023 and close at least half of those obligated to deposit funds in the Treasury, repatriating balances by end-June 2024 (newly proposed SB for end-June 2024).
  - Procurement and SOEs: systematically conduct and publish audits of public contracts and regularize publication of SOEs financial statements (MEFP ¶19).
  - Special Economic Zone: SEZ law adopted December 2022; staff encouraged enhanced transparency in selection/monitoring and accounting for tax administration challenges.
  - Financial sector: efforts to bring two undercapitalized banks into compliance; first bank preliminarily recapitalized pending approval; BCEAO and Banking Commission assessing scenarios for second bank; national financial inclusion strategy (2023–27) adopted.

### Program financing, burden sharing, and monitoring
- Program financing assurances and projections:
  - Program fully financed for the next 12 months with strong financing prospects through end of program and upside potential on budget support.
  - For 2023, expected budget support:
    - World Bank: $150 million in loans linked to an upcoming Development Policy Operation.
    - European Union: about $10 million in grants.
    - Potential additional support from African Development Bank or EU could allow for a higher fiscal deficit by up to 0.4 ppt of GDP as per the program adjustor (TMU ¶7).
  - Continued efforts to secure additional budget support from development partners recommended.
- Program monitoring and conditionality:
  - Program performance monitored through semi-annual program reviews based on QPCs, ITs (Table 7), and SBs (Table 11).
  - Structural conditionality augmented with new SBs on operationalizing the Commercial Court of Appeal and HCPC and streamlining government accounts in commercial banks to support reforms to the Treasury Single Account (TSA) (¶20).

*Source: 1benea2023001.*

### 23. The authorities’ 2018-25 National Development Plan (NDP) fulfills the Poverty

### 23. The authorities’ 2018-25 National Development Plan (NDP) fulfills the Poverty

### NDP alignment and development priorities
- The NDP was developed in consultation with multiple stakeholders (including the World Bank).
- The plan identifies priorities consistent with program objectives, including:
  - inclusive growth through job creation; and
  - human capital accumulation, particularly for vulnerable groups, including girls.

### Key findings of the IMF Governance Diagnostic
- At the authorities’ request, a joint FAD/LEG/MCM governance diagnostic was conducted to identify vulnerabilities to corruption and areas for improvement.
- Perceptions and indicators:
  - Benin’s score for control of corruption in the Worldwide Governance Indicators improved from 35.58 in 2016 to 50.48 in 2021.
  - According to the 2022 Afrobarometer, 70 percent of Beninese citizens believe corruption is decreasing.
  - Survey perceptions of corruption in judiciary and public procurement and customs fell from 48 to 32 percent and from 52 to 41 percent, respectively (2021 to 2022).
  - Benin scored 61.7 out of 100 in the “Justice and the Rule of Law” sub-index of the 2022 Ibrahim Index of African Governance.
  - Benin scored 65 out of 100 in the 2021 Open Budget Survey, placing Benin second in Africa (after South Africa) in budget transparency.
- Notable recent reforms and progress:
  - Fiscal governance: successful implementation of program budgets, initiation of an internal audit and control reform, creation of a Court of Auditors.
  - Tax policy: strengthening of governance of tax expenditures.
  - AML/CFT: strengthening of the legal framework and adoption of an action plan following the GIABA report.
  - Rule of law: accessibility of legislation, creation of a commercial court, and development of e-procedures.
- Areas needing sustained effort:
  - (i) weaknesses in the legal and institutional anti-corruption framework;
  - (ii) limitations in effectiveness of AML/CFT preventive measures, risk-based supervision in higher risk sectors (e.g., real estate), and investigation and prosecution of money laundering;
  - (iii) lack of transparency on specific procedures (e.g., disciplinary framework and appointment processes for magistrates, follow-up on private investment projects benefiting from tax expenditures);
  - (iv) multiple instances of lack of capacity and/or resources.

### Capacity to repay the Fund and Fund exposure
- The capacity to repay the Fund is assessed as adequate.
- Outstanding credit and obligations:
  - The total amount of outstanding credit from the Fund will amount to 543.9 percent of quota in 2023 and increases to 549.8 percent of quota in 2024 (Table 9).
  - Total obligations based on existing and prospective credit will peak at 0.5 percent of GDP in 2029.
  - This peak corresponds to 3 percent of total revenues excluding grants and 2 percent of exports in 2029.
- Financial risk assessment:
  - Financial risks to the Fund are limited given adequate capacity to repay the Fund and moderate risk of overall debt distress.
  - The overall financing envelope of the program is less than 4 percent of Benin’s GDP.
  - Program performance has been robust, with authorities remaining committed to their reform agenda.
  - The IMF Fiscal Safeguards Review (FSR) and governance diagnostic, frontloaded under the program, were reassuring.
  - Following the temporary increase in the GRA access limits (SM/23/44), Benin is no longer subject to the High Combined Credit Exposure (HCCE) procedure.
  - Operational risks: Benin faces security threats at its Northern borders, but safety risks to Fund staff are low given that the Fund’s local office is located in Cotonou.

### Contingency plans and safeguards
- Contingency recommendations:
  - Authorities should continue to maintain security spending within the budgeted envelope and reprioritize spending, including by delaying non-priority capital expenditure on new projects, should exogenous shocks materialize and prompt additional spending.
  - Authorities should stand ready to adopt additional revenue measures should the yields of the budgeted ones fall below expectations.
  - In the event of a fuel subsidy reform in Nigeria, Benin should adjust pump prices further in the near-term to limit budgetary cost of fuel subsidies (see ¶15).
- Safeguards assessment:
  - The BCEAO has implemented all recommendations provided in the 2018 safeguards assessment.
  - The 2018 assessment found that the BCEAO had broadly appropriate governance arrangements and a robust control environment.
  - An update assessment is currently in progress.

### Capacity development priorities
- Capacity development (CD) remains well-aligned with program objectives and continues to prioritize:
  - governance;
  - revenue mobilization;
  - public financial management (PFM); and
  - upgrading the statistical system.

### Staff appraisal: outlook, fiscal strategy, and reforms
- Macroeconomic outlook and performance:
  - Balanced policy response, supported by frontloaded financing under the EFF/ECF, has boosted business confidence and bolstered the recovery.
  - Macroeconomic conditions are expected to improve gradually.
  - Robust fiscal performance amid significant shocks and steady progress in structural reform agenda are highlighted.
  - Risks noted include geoeconomic fragmentation and social challenges like food insecurity.
  - Continued commitment to debt sustainability and structural reforms is warranted.
- Fiscal consolidation and revenue strategy:
  - Maintain momentum in tax collection and spending reprioritization to support revenue-based fiscal consolidation from this year.
  - Preserve gains from tax policy measures implemented in 2022 and press ahead with planned measures in the 2023 budget.
  - Maintain a high-quality composition of fiscal adjustment that preserves priority social spending.
  - The fiscal strategy converges to the WAEMU regional fiscal norm shifted to 2025 and aims for an overall fiscal deficit of 3 percent of GDP by 2025.
  - Maintaining a prudent borrowing strategy will be important for fiscal sustainability.
  - Develop a Medium-Term Revenue Strategy (MTRS) to expand the tax base and enhance tax system efficiency, underpinned by technical analysis tailored to Benin and consultation with taxpayers.
- Energy subsidies and social protection:
  - Authorities have significantly reduced energy subsidies; more comprehensive reforms are needed to durably create additional fiscal space.
  - Authorities plan to assess the current pricing mechanism for petroleum products, with IMF technical assistance.
  - Develop a predictable mechanism for adequately compensating the most vulnerable as an integral part of fuel-pricing reform.
  - Strengthen social safety nets:
    - Accelerate operationalization of the recently established social registry and integrate it into all social programs.
    - Bolster the registry’s institutional framework and ensure adequate human resources.
    - Operationalize the new draft law on improving the organization and governance of the school feeding program as the government expands it to more schools.
- Governance, AML/CFT, PFM, and SEZs:
  - Enhance the rule of law, anti-corruption and AML/CFT frameworks in line with IMF Governance Diagnostic recommendations.
  - Steadfastly implement the authorities’ national action plan being developed through a consultative process.
  - Operationalize the commercial court of appeal and the anti-corruption agency.
  - Continue efforts to address deficiencies in the AML/CFT framework with particular focus on mitigating money laundering in the real estate sector, including through developing a legal framework for the collection, verification, and publication of transferees’ beneficial ownership (BO) information for land transfers.
  - Sustain improvements in public financial management (PFM), including streamlining public bank accounts in commercial banks to support TSA reform, consistent with recommendations from the recent IMF Fiscal Safeguards Review.
  - Ensure transparency in the implementation of the SEZ regime to level the playing field among participants and limit revenue leakages, and account for associated revenue administration challenges.
  - Permanently phase out administrative price controls in the economy to promote efficiency.
- Financial sector and inclusion:
  - Remain vigilant against financial sector risks and continue to promote financial inclusion.
  - Bring two under-capitalized banks back to prudential norms.
  - Implement the recently adopted national financial inclusion strategy.

*International Monetary Fund staff appraisal excerpt.*

### 37. Given the continued strong program performance and commitment to reforms, staff

### 1benea2023001 - 37. Given the continued strong program performance and commitment to reforms, staff recommends the completion of the second review under the EFF and ECF arrangements.

### Program recommendation
- Staff recommends the completion of the second review under the EFF and ECF arrangements.

### Recent macroeconomic developments (2015–23)
- Private demand recovered in 2021–22 following the collapse during COVID-19, more than offsetting the drop in net external demand amid the war in Ukraine and supply chains disruption.
- Inflation dynamics:
  - After decreasing markedly (and even going in negative territory in 2022), inflation has picked up in early 2023.
- Terms of trade and external balances:
  - The terms of trade deteriorated sharply in 2022 amid the war in Ukraine, contributing to widening the trade and current account deficits.
- High-frequency indicators:
  - The high frequency trade turnover index remains on an upward trend, while services are steady.

### Fiscal developments and public debt (2014–22)
- Revenue and spending patterns:
  - Tax revenue continued its upward trajectory after a decrease in 2020 which was partially induced by lower trade taxes as a result of the Nigeria border closure.
  - The government increased capital expenditure to support aggregate demand while closing the country's infrastructure gap.
- Public debt and debt service ratios:
  - While public debt has trended up, mainly due to warranted fiscal accommodation in the face of severe and repeated shocks, the interest-to-tax revenue ratio has declined, falling below the program anchor.
- Financing of capital expenditure in 2022:
  - The increase in capital expenditure in 2022 was mostly domestically financed, while the deficit was mostly externally financed.

### Real and external sector (2015–23)
- Cotton sector:
  - Cotton production dropped in 2022—due to floods—after having nearly tripled in volume since 2015.
  - Cotton export receipts increased in 2022, contributing to overall higher exports.
  - International cotton prices (Cotlook "A" Index) reported in Table 4: 77.97 (2019), 71.9 (2020), 101.2 (2021), 140.0 (2022), 130.1 (2023 projection).
- Trade and current account:
  - Imports increased in 2022, partly reflecting persistent food and energy prices pressures as well as increased public spending to meet security-related needs, contributing to a widening current account deficit.
- Exchange rate:
  - The CFA franc depreciated against the US dollar in 2022, helping revert some of its recent real appreciation.

### Financial sector developments (2014–22)
- Capitalization and asset quality:
  - The banking system remains well capitalized overall, although two banks are undercapitalized.
  - Credit portfolio quality continues improving, with still high provisioning.
- Concentration, liquidity, and credit allocation:
  - Lending concentration decreased slightly in 2022 but remained elevated.
  - Liquidity ratios stabilized in June 2022 after a decline in recent years.
  - Lending to the trade sector expanded in 2022; lending to the construction sector slightly down.
- Access and usage:
  - Notable improvements in access to and use of banking sector services in recent years.

### Key macro projections and statistics (selected figures from Table 1)
- Real GDP (annual percent change):
  - 2019: 6.9
  - 2020: 3.8
  - 2021: 7.2
  - 2022 (Est.): 6.0
  - 2023 (Proj.): 6.3
  - 2024–2028 (Proj.): 6.0 each year (2024–2028 listed as 6.0)
- Consumer price index (average):
  - 2019: -0.9
  - 2020: 3.0
  - 2021: 1.7
  - 2022 (Est.): 2.5
  - 2023 (Proj.): 1.4
- Total public debt (end period, percent of GDP):
  - 2019: 41.2
  - 2020: 46.1
  - 2021: 50.3
  - 2022 (Est.): 52.8
  - 2023 (Proj.): 54.2
  - 2024–2028 (Proj.): 53.2, 53.8, 53.5, 52.4, 51.4, 50.5, 49.6 (as listed)
- Current account balance (percent of GDP):
  - 2019: -4.0
  - 2020: -1.7
  - 2021: -4.2
  - 2022 (Est.): -6.1
  - 2023 (Proj.): -6.3
  - 2024–2028 (Proj.): -5.5, -5.9, -5.6, -5.1, -4.9, -4.4, -4.2

### Consolidated central government operations (selected levels from Tables 2–3)
- Total revenue and grants (CFAF billions):
  - 2019: 1,185.7
  - 2022 (Est.): 1,509.2
  - 2023 (Proj., First Review): 1,553.2
  - 2024–2028 (Proj.): 1,699.5; 1,742.3; 1,949.2; 2,171.5; 2,397.8; 2,672.7; 2,959.2
- Total expenditure and net lending (CFAF billions):
  - 2019: 1,227.3
  - 2022 (Est.): 2,114.5
  - 2023 (Proj., First Review): 2,149.4
  - 2024–2028 (Proj.): 2,205.7; 2,253.6; 2,424.9; 2,574.4; 2,833.5; 3,143.6; 3,468.2
- Overall balance (commitment basis, including grants, CFAF billions and percent of GDP):
  - 2019: -41.6 (-0.5 percent of GDP)
  - 2020: -423.6 (-4.7 percent of GDP)
  - 2021: -561.7 (-5.7 percent of GDP)
  - 2022 (Est.): -605.3 (-5.6 percent of GDP)
  - 2023 (Proj., First Review): -596.2 (-5.5 percent of GDP)
  - 2024–2028 (Proj., percent of GDP): -4.3; -4.3; -3.7; -2.9; -2.9; -2.9; -2.9

### Balance of payments and external financing (selected items from Tables 4 and 6)
- Current account balance (CFAF billions):
  - 2019: -337.3
  - 2022 (Est.): -664.6
  - 2023 (Proj., First Review): -680.6
  - 2024–2028 (Proj.): -647.0; -697.2; -725.0; -702.6; -731.7; -713.9; -729.6
- Exports of goods and services (CFAF billions):
  - 2019: 1,790.9
  - 2022 (Est.): 2,562.3
  - 2023 (Proj., First Review): 2,389.5
- Imports of goods and services (CFAF billions):
  - 2019: -2,051.4
  - 2022 (Est.): -2,952.2
  - 2023 (Proj., First Review): -2,831.7
- External financing requirements and sources (Table 6, cumulative 2022–25):
  - Gross financing requirements (cumulative 2022-25): 3,881 (CFAF billion)
  - Available financing (cumulative 2022-25): 3,060 (CFAF billion)
  - Financing Gap (cumulative 2022-25): 821 (CFAF billion)

### Monetary and credit developments (selected items from Table 5)
- Broad money (M2) growth:
  - 2019: 6.0 percent (annual percent change)
  - 2020: 17.3 percent
  - 2021: 16.7 percent
  - 2022 (Est.): 10.5 percent
  - 2023 (Proj.): 13.0 percent
- Credit to the private sector (annual percent change):
  - 2019: 11.9
  - 2020: -5.7
  - 2021: 9.2
  - 2022 (Est.): 8.0
  - 2023 (Proj.): 21.4

### Program financing and disbursements (Tables 10 and 6)
- Schedule of disbursements under the ECF/EFF arrangements (amounts in SDR million):
  - July 8, 2022 (Executive Board approval): Total 108.30 (ECF 36.10; EFF 72.20)
  - November 21, 2022 (first review completion): Total 108.30 (ECF 36.10; EFF 72.20)
  - May 1, 2023 (second review completion): Total 50.82 (ECF 16.94; EFF 33.88)
  - November 1, 2023 (third review completion): Total 101.58 (ECF 33.86; EFF 67.72)
  - Subsequent scheduled disbursements through October 31, 2025 total 484.05 SDR million (ECF 161.349; EFF 322.709)
- External financing contributions in projections (Table 6, selected 2023–25 items, CFAF billion):
  - Project (official external) cumulative 2022-25: 1,678
  - Loans (2022–25 cumulative): 1,423
  - IMF (IMF EFF/ECF) financing included in projections: noted as part of financing gap coverage.

### Quantitative performance criteria and structural benchmarks (Tables 7 and 11)
- Quantitative performance criteria (selected for 2023, CFAF billions, cumulative):
  - Basic primary balance (floor) — various cumulative targets shown (e.g., 3.8; -1.6; -97.6; -13.1; 17.5; 26.6)
  - Net domestic financing (ceiling) — e.g., 130; 205; 372; 348; 104; 200 (as date-specific program targets)
  - Continuous criteria: accumulation of external payments arrears = 0.0; accumulation of domestic payments arrears = 0.0; ceiling on present value of new external debt contracted or guaranteed by government = 620 (annual limit)
- Indicative targets (selected):
  - Tax revenue (floor) — e.g., 321.5; 669.5; 694.5; 1,071.9; 1,480.0; 398.5; 826.8 (date-specific cumulative floors)
  - Priority social expenditure (floor) — e.g., 16.4; 50.9; 105.9; 170.1; 22.1; 56.0
- Structural benchmarks (status as listed):
  - Governance and Transparency: Conduct and publish a governance diagnostic. Due end-February 2023. Status: Met.
  - Financial Inclusion: Transpose WAEMU regional financial inclusion strategy and design a comprehensive national financial inclusion strategy. Due end-March 2023. Status: Met.
  - Food security: Submit draft law to improve organization and governance of the school feeding program (PNASI). Due end-April 2023. Status: Met.
  - Land titling: Digitalize processing of land titles requests (design e-terre, develop functionalities, train ANDF staff). Due end-April 2023. Status: Met.
  - Revenue Mobilization: Develop a medium-term revenue mobilization strategy (MTRS). Due end-September 2023. Status: (listed, no status indicated).
  - Public Financial Management: Prepare a statement containing a quantitative analysis of fiscal risks as part of the 2024 draft budget law documentation. Due end-October 2023. Status: (listed).
  - Publish appraisal and selection criteria for major investment projects, along with feasibility studies. Due end-December 2023. Status: (listed).
  - Rule of law: Operationalize the Commercial Court of Appeal (staffing, funding, equipment). Due end-November 2023. Status: Newly proposed.
  - Anti-corruption: Operationalize the HCPC and strengthen its legal framework, in consultation with IMF staff. Due end-June 2024. Status: Newly proposed.
  - Public Financial Management: Update the list of bank accounts of public organizations and close at least half of those subject to obligation to deposit funds in the Treasury; repatriate balances to the public Treasury. Due end-June 2024. Status: Newly proposed.

### Financial stability indicators (selected, Table 8, 2016–22)
- Regulatory capital to risk-weighted assets (percent): ranges reported, e.g., 9.3 (2016), 14.2 (2020 Dec.), 13.4 (2022 June).
- Gross NPLs to total loans (percent): 21.8 (2016), 14.9 (2020 Dec.), 12.6 (2022 June).
- Provisioning rate (percent): 64.0 (2016), 70.9 (2020 Dec.), 74.3 (2022 June).
- Liquid assets to total assets (percent): 16.2 (2016), 9.0 (2020 Dec.), 9.8 (2022 June).
- Concentration: Credit to the 5 largest borrowers (percent of total assets): 99.6 (2016), 64.7 (2020 Dec.), 67.8 (2022 June).

### Indicators of capacity to repay the IMF (Table 9, selected)
- Outstanding IMF credit (billions of CFA francs):
  - 2023: 554.2
  - 2024: 564.4
  - 2025: 554.5
  - 2026: 520.5
  - 2027: 463.3
  - 2028: 381.2
- Total obligations based on existing and prospective credit (billions of CFA francs, selected years):
  - 2023: 6.6 (principal, based on presented conversion)
  - 2024: 45.7
  - 2025: 58.1
  - 2026: 38.5
  - 2027: 61.7
  - 2028: 82.1

*Sources: Beninese authorities; BCEAO; and IMF staff calculations.*

### Annex I. Risk Assessment Matrix

### Annex I. Risk Assessment Matrix

### External Risks
- Increased security risks, including due to intensification of regional conflicts
  - Relative Likelihood/Time Horizon: High / Short to Medium Term
  - Expected Impact if Realized: High
    - Escalation of Russia’s war in Ukraine and intensification of regional security threats could potentially result on disruptions of trade, remittances, FDI and financial flows with large adverse effects on activity and public finances, and complicate policy implementation.
  - Recommended Policy Response:
    - Enhance State presence in communities at risk through improved access to basic public services; improve public spending efficiency and commit to a credible medium-term fiscal consolidation.

- Abrupt global slowdown or recession
  - Relative Likelihood/Time Horizon: Medium / Short to Medium Term
  - Expected Impact if Realized: High
    - A new bout of global financial tightening, possibly combined with volatile commodity prices could lead to spiking risk premia, debt distress, widening of external imbalances and fiscal pressures.
  - Recommended Policy Response:
    - Bolster the institutional foundations of private sector led inclusive growth; accelerate business environment reforms to support economic diversification; seek highly concessional financing.

- Sharp rise in food and energy prices amid the war in Ukraine
  - Relative Likelihood/Time Horizon: Medium / Short to Medium Term
  - Expected Impact if Realized: High
    - A succession of supply disruptions and demand fluctuations could lead to recurrent commodity price volatility, external and fiscal pressures, and social and economic that could exacerbate purchasing power erosion and delay addressing pre-existing social challenges.
  - Recommended Policy Response:
    - Rely on cost-effective targeted measures in response to the food and energy price shock and reduce non-priority spending to preserve programmed fiscal targets; bolster investors’ confidence through careful communication on policy actions, and maintain prudent debt policy and management; mobilize more concessional financing.

- Adverse developments in Nigeria
  - Relative Likelihood/Time Horizon: Medium / Short to Medium Term
  - Expected Impact if Realized: High
    - Slower recovery and adverse security situation would reduce trade revenues, and growth in Nigeria, Benin’s main trading partner, with adverse impact on Benin’s re-exports, customs revenue, and informal trade.
  - Recommended Policy Response:
    - Reduce trade dependence vis-à-vis Nigeria by moving away gradually from the transit-centered “entrepot” growth model; improve the business environment to support economic diversification and private sector development.

- Higher frequency of extreme climate events
  - Relative Likelihood/Time Horizon: Medium / Medium Term
  - Expected Impact if Realized: High
    - Extreme climate events could cause more severe damage to infrastructure and loss of human lives and livelihoods, amplifying supply chain disruptions and inflationary pressures and increasing food insecurity risks.
  - Recommended Policy Response:
    - Accelerate reforms to strengthen resilience through irrigation and improved productivity in agriculture; mitigate the immediate impact on the poor including through targeted transfers and emergency assistance.

### Domestic Risks
- Policy implementation risks, due to widespread social discontent and political instability
  - Relative Likelihood/Time Horizon: Medium / Short Term
  - Expected Impact if Realized: High
    - Social tensions could increase political polarization, undermine economic activity, disrupt the reform agenda, and exert pressure on the budget.
  - Recommended Policy Response:
    - Strengthen social safety nets to mitigate the impact on the poor; enhance the delivery of basic public services; ensure transparency and accountability in public spending and improve the efficiency of public investment.

- Increased systemic financial instability
  - Relative Likelihood/Time Horizon: Medium / Short to Medium Term
  - Expected Impact if Realized: Medium
    - A surge in non-performing loans could deteriorate confidence and lower capital, affecting banking sector stability and credit to the private sector.
  - Recommended Policy Response:
    - Enhance monitoring of financial sector developments; consult with the WAEMU banking commission and communicate with banks on measures needed to ensure a prompt resolution of NPLs and adequate capitalization.

*Annex I. Risk Assessment Matrix.*

### 3. Although Benin compares favorably with regional peers on the prevalence of acute hunger,

### 1benea2023001 - 3. Although Benin compares favorably with regional peers on the prevalence of acute hunger,

### Food-security status and nutrition
- At 2.3 percent in November 2022, Benin recorded the lowest proportion of population in (food) crisis among the 17 West African nations analyzed in the Cadre Harmonisé (regional average of 7.4 percent in Phases 3–5 of the Integrated Food Security Phase Classification).
- FAO data (2019–2021) show, on average, a higher proportion of the population in Benin was moderately food insecure than in structural and regional peers, highlighting the need for structural changes.
- High prevalence of stunting amongst children under five suggests nutrient-deficient diets and elevated risks of potentially irreversible loss of growth and cognitive functions, with long-term consequences including poor educational performance, low adult wages, and lost productivity.
- The Global Food Security Index identifies quality, safety, sustainability and adaptation as areas of substantial vulnerability in Benin.

### Structural constraints in the agricultural sector
- The agricultural sector employs more than two-thirds of the active population but accounts for only about one quarter of GDP (and over three-quarters of export proceeds, the latter driven by cotton).
- Productivity remains relatively low due to structural bottlenecks, strong dependence on weather, and weak recourse to climate-resistant technologies.
- Irrigated areas were estimated to represent less than 2 percent (53,000 ha) of Benin’s total cropped area in 2019, compared with an estimated range of 4–7 percent in SSA (and 30–45 percent in South Asia).
- FAO estimates suggest some 9,000 tractors are needed to meet the labor force demand in agriculture.
- Deterioration of the security situation, with conflict-related fatalities nearly tripling since 2019, compounds vulnerabilities through displacement and disruption of agricultural livelihoods.

### Organization of farmers, inputs, mechanization, and financing
- Poor organization of subsistence and staple crop farmers compared with cash-crop agriculturalists leads to sub-optimal allocation of inputs (improved seeds, fertilizer, pesticides), low mechanization, limited irrigation, and relatively low access to finance.
- Seed system weaknesses: poor coordination and compliance with norms, weak estimation of seed demand, lack of quality control, and capacity issues.
- In 2021 only 2.3 and 8.3 percent of certified seed demand was met for maize and rice, respectively.
- Cotton received the bulk of inputs in 2021: 88.6 percent of fertilizers and 43 percent of pesticides (noting that in 2020 cotton benefitted from 94 percent of fertilizers and 99.6 percent of pesticides).
- Empirical evidence points to positive spillovers from cotton fertilizer use to staple production, suggesting residual effects or fertilizer diversion.

### Crop performance and import dependence
- Cotton production almost tripled since 2015, reaching nearly 800,000 tons in 2021; harvested cotton area doubled from 2015/2016 to 600,000 ha in 2021 (compared to 1.5 million ha for all cereals), consolidating Benin as lead cotton producer in West Africa.
- Yields of main staples (maize, yam, cassava) have been stagnant or declining in recent years; Benin outperforms WAEMU peers in rice yields but compares less favorably on cassava and maize.
- Most staple foods are produced domestically and domestically produced items make up over 70 percent of the consumption basket; food consumption represents about 37 percent of the representative household consumption basket.
- Rice and yams are major staples by daily caloric intake, followed by cassava and maize. Cassava, yams, and maize are almost fully supplied domestically; reliance on imported rice is higher in Benin compared to regional peers despite relatively high rice yields and strong rice production (~520,000 tons, an increase of almost 40 percent compared to the average of the last five years).

### Opportunities for spillovers, diversification, and value addition
- Leveraging the well-functioning organization of the cotton sector could generate positive spillovers to staples (e.g., Beyond Cotton program encouraging crop rotation such as maize).
- Promoting local transformation of cottonseed into cottonseed oil is an opportunity to integrate the cotton sector into food production chains and move up the value chain.
- Diversification is recommended to reduce vulnerability to climate risks and commodity cycles.

### Recent programs, targets, and government actions
- Integrated School Feeding Program: smallholder farmers contributed 300 tons of foodstuffs in 2021; WFP expects to procure 7,000 tons from such farmers in 2023, reducing reliance on imports for the program.
- Performance of major staples during the most recent harvest season saw an overall production increase of 2.7 compared to the 2020/21 agricultural campaign.
- Government plans and measures include:
  - Enhance yields of main staples by instilling best farming practices through the Conseil Agricole and encouraging better organization of farmers.
  - Leverage the Fonds National de Développement Agricole (FNDA) to accelerate access to finance.
  - Avoid distortional government interventions in pricing mechanisms to support inclusive agro-industrial development.
- The agricultural sector is expected to benefit from a budget of 100 billion CFA francs (0.9 percent of GDP) in the 2023 budget law, an increase of 13.5 percent compared to 2022.
- PAG-II aims to ensure national food self-sufficiency for rice by 2026, which would reduce smuggling to Nigeria and leverage regional trade integration.
- Ongoing efforts to mobilize investment for climate change adaptation, enhance processing, storage and conservation of agricultural products, and leverage SEZs to accelerate value-chain upgrading.
- The recently established social registry provides infrastructure for social assistance programs to protect vulnerable populations.

*International Monetary Fund — Benin country chapter excerpt*

### 1. Memorandum of Economic and Financial Policies

### 1. Memorandum of Economic and Financial Policies

### Background
- Government places economic and social resilience at the heart of public policy within the Government's Action Program (PAG 2021–26), consistent with the National Development Program (PND; 2018-2025).
- Reforms are supported by the IMF through the Extended Fund Facility (EFF) and Extended Credit Facility (ECF) arrangements for 2022–25.
- EFF/ECF quantitative targets for end-September and end-December 2022 were fully met; structural benchmarks implemented, including finalization and publication of the IMF governance diagnostic and adoption of a financial inclusion strategy (SBs due by March 31, 2023).
- Implementation of two end-April 2023 SBs related to the school feeding program and land titling completed.

### Recent economic developments and outlook
- Key macroeconomic outcomes and drivers:
  - Economic activity expanded by 6.3 percent in 2022, driven by a good harvest season and strong momentum in the construction sector and development of the glo-djigbé special economic zone.
  - Inflation was contained at 1.4 percent in 2022, supported by tax exemptions on energy products, fertilizers and selected foodstuffs, and a rebate on freight.
  - Current account deficit estimated to have widened, driven by higher international food and oil prices, expansion in economic activity, and imports related to infrastructure projects.
  - FDI is estimated to have increased by 21.9 percent in 2022, reaching CFAF 205 billion after CFAF 168 billion in 2021, linked to the Niger-Benin oil pipeline construction and new firms in the special economic zone.
- 2023 and medium-term outlook:
  - Economic growth in 2023 and the medium term expected to be in line with the program's initial projections; domestic activity supported by industrial expansion in the GDIZ, acceleration of major PAG 2021–2026 projects (port of Cotonou expansion, road network extension, rainwater sanitation program), and development of cultural tourism.
- Downside risks identified:
  - Deterioration of Sahel security could increase terrorist attacks, aggravate food insecurity, and exacerbate social tensions.
  - Substantial tightening of financing conditions in the regional government securities market could adversely affect debt dynamics.
  - Difficulty accessing foreign exchange reserves could hinder private sector development.
  - A significant drop in cotton prices could reduce agricultural sector income and worsen the balance of payments.
  - Sustained increases in food and energy prices (if the war in Ukraine persists) would increase household cost of living.
  - Vulnerability to climate change risks such as recurrent floods and droughts.

### Consolidating fiscal consolidation to preserve debt sustainability
- Context:
  - After three years of warranted flexibility, fiscal consolidation in 2023 aims to strengthen macroeconomic stability and preserve debt sustainability.
  - Public expenditure stood at 19.8 percent of GDP in 2022.
  - Overall budget deficit in 2022 was 5.5 percent of GDP.
  - Deficit projected at 4.3 percent of GDP in 2023, with a possibility for an additional deficit of 0.4 percent of GDP if budget support exceeds the envelope initially foreseen under the EFF/ECF.
- Implementation and results:
  - All quantitative targets of the EFF/ECF for end-December 2022 were met; basic primary balance, net domestic financing, ceiling on new external commitments, and avoidance of arrears accumulation were met.
  - Tax revenue at end-2022 was well above the budget law forecast, driven by stronger arrears collection, anti-evasion actions, and specific tax measures.
- Specific tax measures and reclassifications cited:
  - Revamping the tax on salaries and wages.
  - Expanding the levy on sales of electronic communications services to include domestic money withdrawals and transfers.
  - Increase in the rate of the gambling tax.
  - Phasing out VAT exemptions on rice and motorbikes and removing VAT exemption on rice and four-stroke motorcycles.
  - Review of fees and levies, in line with WAEMU and GFS norms, reclassified non-tax revenues amounting to 0.7 percent of GDP as tax revenues.
- Public spending drivers in 2022:
  - Support to households (subsidies for energy products, agricultural inputs), consolidation of delegated contracting authority projects, recruitment of police and defense officers, gradual clearance of past salary arrears, and accelerated capital spending (rural roads, local markets).

### 2023 Finance Law and medium-term fiscal path
- Fiscal consolidation path:
  - 2023 deficit target: 4.3 percent of GDP.
  - 2024 deficit target: 3.7 percent of GDP.
  - 2025 deficit target: 2.9 percent of GDP (below the regional norm of 3 percent).
  - Convergence to overall deficit below 3 percent postponed to 2025 (from 2024) consistent with WAEMU-wide stance.
- Revenue mobilization:
  - Medium Term Revenue Mobilization Strategy (MTRS) to the 2028 horizon will sequence actions and identify tax policy and administration measures for inclusion in the tax reform matrix.
  - Action plan established to complete the MTRS by end of September 2023 (structural benchmark for end-September 2023) with IMF and AFD technical support.
- Tax expenditure rationalization actions already carried out (Text Table 1):
  - Revision of the SEZ law and proposal for a tiered exemption.
  - Removal of the exemption on salaries for SEZ employees.
  - Proposal to remove the exemption on the salary and wages tax.
  - Revising SEZ scope: minimum export share of turnover and reporting requirements covering beneficial owners and related party transactions between the SEZ and the domestic economy.
  - Decrees implementing the SEZ law set a 20% import quota for products manufactured on the market.
  - Removal of the measure of free and penalty-free registration of acts prior to the Amending Finance Law for the 2016 management and the Amending Finance Law for the 2020 management.
- Fiscal policy levers and spending efficiency:
  - Broadening the tax base, digitization of services, revitalization of unpaid tax collection policies, and shift to accrual accounting to increase revenues.
  - Credit allocations to ministries remain linked to economic policy; general operations appropriations almost stable versus 2022; investment appropriations expected to increase to enhance resilience.
  - Wage-bill trajectory designed to initiate a gradual return to compliance with the Community ratio.
  - Current expenditures set to ensure efficiency and to gradually unwind pandemic- and war-related protective measures (tax exemptions, electricity tariff subsidies).
- Petroleum subsidies reform:
  - Government requested IMF technical assistance to evaluate current petroleum pricing mechanism (dating from 2004) to assess alignment with international standards while accounting for crisis constraints and local market specificities.
- Public investment management and transparency:
  - All evaluation and selection criteria for major investment projects and related feasibility studies to be published starting end-December 2023 (Structural benchmark for end-December 2023).
  - Migration to program-based budget management and development of internal budgetary control mechanisms for better monitoring of appropriations.
- Cash management and Treasury Single Account (TSA):
  - Strengthen TSA technical and operational framework with IMF support.
  - Update list of bank accounts of public organizations by end-August 2023 and close at least half of those subject to the obligation to deposit funds in the Treasury and not benefiting from derogatory authorization, repatriating balances to the public treasury by end-June 2024 at the latest (New Structural Benchmark for end-June 2024).
- Financing strategy and debt management:
  - Emphasis on diversification of financing sources and active debt management for 2023–2026.
  - Precautionary policies include liability management operations and creation of precautionary lines of credit in response to tighter financing conditions following BCEAO monetary policy rate increases and rising external yields.
  - Pursuit of innovative financing options focusing on ESG criteria.
- Budget support prospects:
  - Good prospects for mobilizing additional budget support relative to initial 2023 budget law projections, allowing increased public and social spending in line with the technical memorandum of understanding under the EFF/ECF.

### Transparency and fiscal risk management
- Actions to improve public financial management transparency:
  - Accelerate review of the organic law on finance laws (LOLF) to align publication deadlines for management and audit reports with international standards.
  - Prepare a statement on quantitative analysis of fiscal risks in key areas by end-October 2023 with IMF technical support and annex it to the 2024 draft Budget Law (Structural Benchmark for end-October 2023).
  - Regularly publish, starting from June 2023, the approved financial balance sheets of public enterprises and disseminate information on liquidations and privatizations.
  - TSA account update and repatriation measures as noted above.

### Strengthening social protection mechanisms and containing food insecurity
- Reaffirming the “Highly Social Mandate” and SDG progress:
  - Generalization of health insurance under the Insurance for Human Capital Development (ARCH) project has increased beneficiaries (extreme poor) holding the national biometric card to approximately 791,000 people across 61 communes.
  - Targeting of social programs improved via capitalization on the Social Registry (RSU); plan to expand RSU to account for vulnerability to climate change; contractor recruitment underway to complete RSU operationalization.
  - Current revision of the holistic social protection policy to refine social priorities with support from technical and financial partners.
- School feeding and food insecurity measures:
  - Cabinet adopted a draft law on April 26 to improve organization and governance of the National Integrated School Feeding Program (PNASI) to ensure sustainable financing, prioritization of food-insecure areas, and involvement of local farmers; submitted to the National Assembly (structural benchmark at the end of April 2023).
  - Emphasis on urgent measures to contain food insecurity and keep children in school.

### Building resilience to climate change
- Climate resilience is a key government policy pillar:
  - Strengthen adaptation and mitigation measures in public policies based on C-PIMA assessment and the Climate Change and Development Report (CCDR) conducted with IMF and World Bank support.
  - Government has requested IMF support under the Resilience and Sustainability Trust (RST) to anchor climate reforms.

### Strengthen governance, transparency, rule of law and the AML/CFT framework
- Governance actions:
  - Published governance diagnostic report conducted with IMF technical support.
  - Developing an action plan based on diagnostic recommendations to be finalized by end-June 2023.
  - Operationalization of the High Commission for the Prevention of Corruption (HCPC) and strengthening its legal framework to ensure independence and powers in consultation with IMF staff by the end of June 2024 (new structural benchmark proposed for end-June 2024).

*Source: 1. Memorandum of Economic and Financial Policies (Attachment I).*

### 24. We will pursue reforms aimed at transparency in public spending.

### 24. We will pursue reforms aimed at transparency in public spending.

### Transparency in public procurement and public spending
- Regulation allowing procurement agencies to collect beneficial ownership (BO) information adopted in September 2022; BO information has been published regularly.
- Mobilized technical assistance to facilitate implementation of e-procurement.
- Public Procurement Regulatory Authority (ARMP) will:
  - Carry out annual technical and independent audits of contracts awarded by contracting authorities, ensuring representative sampling by monetary volume, procedures used, level of execution of contracts concluded, and specificity of the mission entrusted to these contracting authorities.
  - Publish the results of these audits regularly on its website and disseminate them to all contracting authorities; audits could lead to in-depth investigations by the ARMP.
- Strengthened human and financial resources of the Audit Court to enable full mission execution.
- Legal framework for collection, verification, and publication of beneficial ownership information of transferees at the time of land title transfers to be in place by the end of November 2023.
- Adopt an action plan for operationalization of this legal instrument by end November 2023, setting timelines for commencement of collection and verification by notaries and for regular publication of this information.

### AML/CFT and anti-corruption measures
- Continue to strengthen AML/CFT framework to comply with international standards and support anti-corruption efforts.
- Steps include:
  - Finalize sectoral ML/TF risk assessments.
  - Commence risk-based supervision of higher-risk designated non-financial sectors.
  - Correct gaps in the legal framework related to criminalization of money laundering and terrorism financing and the confiscation of proceeds and instrumentalities of crime.
- Operationalization and strengthening (newly proposed) of the HCPC (Haut Commissariat à la Prévention de la Corruption) and its legal framework to ensure independence and powers, in consultation with IMF staff — due end-June 2024.

### Financial sector stability and inclusion
- Continue efforts to strengthen stability of the financial system:
  - Process to bring two banks that do not meet minimum capital adequacy standard into compliance with the core capital requirement is well underway.
  - One bank completed recapitalization and is in compliance with prudential rules, pending approval from auditors and the Abidjan-based WAMU Banking Commission.
  - For the second undercapitalized bank, BCEAO and the Banking Commission, with auditors, are assessing alternative scenarios including new capital injections.
- Adopted a regional financial inclusion strategy (last March) to correct market failures and eliminate non-market barriers to accessing financial services; national transposition and design of comprehensive financial inclusion strategy for Benin — End-March 2023 — Met.

### Private sector–led growth and business climate reforms
- Adopted new law on promotion of small and medium-sized enterprises, creating Agency for the Development of Small and Medium-sized Enterprises (ADPME).
- Reviewed legal and regulatory framework for promotion of special economic zones to improve operation and flexibility.
- Actions to improve business climate and property rights:
  - Strengthen Inter-ministerial Committee for Investment Promotion (CIPI) and Investment and Export Promotion Agency (APIEX).
  - Dematerialize land titles and modernize land and property administration: finalize efforts before the end of April 2023 by (1) designing land management application and developing functionalities; (2) providing training to ANDF staff on new system; (3) embedding data management tools in e-land (structural benchmark for the end of April 2023) — Met.
  - Make special court of land affairs operational with appointment of staff and judges, budget, and premises at the beginning of April 2023.
  - Operationalize the Commercial Court of Appeal with staffing, funding, and equipment — new structural benchmark proposed for the end of November 2023.
  - Establish a commercial registry, making information available to the public by the end of October 2023, to comply with OHADA standards.

### Modernizing the statistical system
- Improve availability and timely publication of reliable data to inform economic policy.
- Steps to improve compliance with e-GDDS and accelerate adherence to SDDS with IMF support:
  - Clarify institutional framework for administration of National Summary Data Pages (NSDPs).
  - Strengthen technical, human, and financial resources of the National Statistical System (NSS).
  - (i) Deepen NSS actors’ knowledge about the SDDS; (ii) take stock of the NSS to evaluate gaps; (iii) set up a monitoring unit to ensure regular publication of the data.

### Key quantitative program figures and timelines (selected)
- Legal/operational deadlines:
  - End-November 2023: legal framework and action plan for BO of transferees for land transfers.
  - End-April 2023: dematerialize land titles (e-terre) — Met.
  - End-October 2023: commercial registry to be public.
  - End-December 2023: publish all criteria for appraisal and selection of major investment projects, along with feasibility studies.
  - End-June 2024: update list of bank accounts of public organizations and close at least half of those subject to obligation to deposit funds in the Treasury; repatriate balances to the public Treasury — End-June 2024 (Newly proposed).
- Exchange rates (end of period, 2021):
  - CFAF/US$ 580.3
  - CFAF/€ 655.96
  - CFAF/SDR 811.4
- TMU program reference rate and spreads:
  - Program reference rate for the six-month USD SOFR is 2.73 percent and will remain fixed for the duration of the program.
  - The spread of six-month Euro LIBOR over six-month USD SOFR is -500 basis points.
  - The spread of six-month GBP SONIA over six-month USD SOFR is -0.0 basis point.
  - For interest rates on currencies other than Euro and GBP, the spread over six months USD SOFR is -500 basis points.
- Definitions and program mechanics highlighted:
  - “Government” refers to the central government of the Republic of Benin, excluding local governments, the Central Bank, and other autonomous public entities not included in the TOFE.
  - Debt definition follows IMF Executive Board Decision No. 6230-(79/140) as amended, with present value of loans calculated using a single discount rate set at 5 percent.
  - Net domestic financing includes (i) the net position vis-à-vis the central bank and commercial banks and (ii) net issuance of securities to individuals/legal entities outside the banking system or to nonresident banks domiciled in WAEMU.
- Fiscal adjustor:
  - For 2023, the floor on the basic primary fiscal balance will be adjusted downward by the amount of additional budget support beyond the programmed 100.7 CFAF billion, for an amount up to CFAF 46 billion at end-December 2023.

*Source: Benin — IMF Staff Report (selected sections).*

### 9. Gross external budgetary assistance is defined as grants, loans, and non-earmarked debt

### 1benea2023001 - 9. Gross external budgetary assistance is defined as grants, loans, and non-earmarked debt

### Definitions: External Budgetary Assistance and Net External Budgetary Assistance
- Gross external budgetary assistance: grants, loans, and non-earmarked debt relief operations (excluding project-related loans and grants, use of IMF resources, and debt relief under the Heavily Indebted Poor Countries (HIPC) and Multilateral Debt Relief (MDRI) Initiatives).
- Net external budgetary assistance: the difference between gross external budgetary assistance and the sum of:
  - total debt service obligations on all external debt (defined as the sum of interest payments and amortizations on all external loans, including interest payments and other charges to the IMF and on project-related loans, but excluding repayment obligations to the IMF), and
  - all payments of external arrears.

### Performance Criteria and Indicative Targets
- Net domestic financing (NDF) performance criteria (PCs) and indicative targets (ITs):
  - Net domestic financing at end-June and end-December 2023 (both PCs) and net domestic financing at end-September 2023, end-March and end-June 2024 (both ITs) must be equal to or less than the amounts indicated in Table 1 attached to the MEFP.
- Adjustor for NDF based on net external budgetary assistance:
  - If, at the end of a quarter, net external budgetary assistance exceeds cumulative program projections (since January 1 of the same year) by more than CFAF 5 billion, the NDF ceiling will be lowered by an amount equivalent to that excess, minus CFAF 5 billion.
  - If, at the end of a quarter, net external budgetary assistance falls short of cumulative program projections, the NDF ceiling will be raised pro tanto, up to a maximum of CFAF 50 billion.

### Arrears: Domestic and External Payment Arrears
- Domestic payment arrears:
  - Defined as domestic payments due but not paid by the government after a 90-day grace period, unless payment arrangements specify a longer repayment period.
  - The Autonomous Amortization Fund (CAA) and the Treasury record and update accumulation and reduction of domestic payment arrears.
  - Continuous performance criterion: the government undertakes not to accumulate any new domestic payment arrears; monitored continuously throughout the program.
- External public payment arrears:
  - Defined as payments due but not paid by the government as of the due date specified in the contract, taking into account any applicable grace periods, on external debt of the government or external debt guaranteed by the government.
  - Continuous performance criterion: the government undertakes not to accumulate any external public payment arrears, with the exception of arrears related to debt that is the subject of renegotiation or rescheduling; monitored continuously throughout the program.

### Table of Expected Net External Budgetary Assistance (Table 2) — Billions of CFA francs
- December 31, 2022 -120.1
- March 31, 2023 -126.9
- June 30, 2023 -168.0
- September 30, 2023 -127.6
- December 31, 2023 -154.0
- March 31, 2024 -91.2
- June 30, 2024 -163.1
- September 30, 2024 -142.3

### Ceiling on the Present Value of New External Debt (Maturity ≥ 1 Year)
- Scope and coverage:
  - Applies to debt defined in paragraph 4a, commitments contracted or guaranteed by the government (including lease-purchase contracts) for which no value has been received, private sector debt guaranteed by the government, government-guaranteed debt of local governments and all public enterprises (including EPA and other agencies).
  - External debt excludes Treasury bills and bonds issued in CFA francs on the WAEMU regional market.
- Adjustor for 2023:
  - Ceiling on the present value of new external debt contracted or guaranteed by the government (cumulative since January 1, 2023) will be adjusted upward by the present value equivalent of additional budget support beyond the programmed 100.7 CFA billion, for an amount up to CFA 46 billion at end-December 2023.
- Continuous performance criterion:
  - The present value of new external borrowing contracted or guaranteed by the government should not exceed CFAF 620 billion in 2023 (Table 3). Changes to this ceiling may be made (subject to IMF Executive Board approval) based on the results of the joint IMF–World Bank public debt sustainability analysis.

### Indicative Targets: Tax Revenue and Priority Social Spending
- Tax revenue floor:
  - Tax revenue includes revenues collected on a cash basis by revenue-collection departments; reported in the Government Financial Operations Table (TOFE).
  - Revenue calculated cumulatively from the beginning of the calendar year.
  - Revenue collections at end-June, end-September, and end-December 2023 as well as end-March and end-June 2024 must be equal to or greater than the amounts indicated in Table 1 attached to the MEFP.
  - The tax revenue floor is an IT for the entire duration of the program.
- Priority Social Expenditure (PSE):
  - Includes expenditure executed from the State budget (domestic and external resources), excluding salary expenditure, and relating mainly to education, health and nutrition, social safety nets, access to electricity, water and sanitation, microfinance (SMEs), security and civil protection.
  - PSE is selective and captures only spending that directly reduces poverty.
  - PSE monitored on a payment order basis; the indicative target applies to execution of expenditure (not allocation).
  - Indicative target for central government PSE floor calculated cumulatively from the beginning of the calendar year.
  - PSE monitored via quarterly expenditure table provided by the Ministry of Economy and Finance; detailed list in Table 4.

### Table 3: Benin Borrowing Plan in 2023 (Billions of CFA francs and Percent)
- By sources of debt financing 909.5 100 619.9 100
- Concessional debt, of which 530.8 58 269.0 43
- Multilateral debt 408.3 45 193.7 31
- Bilateral debt 122.4 13 75.3 12
- Non-concessional debt, of which 378.7 42 350.9 57
- Semi-concessional 118.2 13 90.4 15
- Commercial terms 260.5 29 260.5 42
- PPG external debt
- Volume of new debt in 2023
- PV of new debt in 2023 (program purposes)

(Note: table preserved as provided; some labels and values are on same line as presented in the source.)

### Table 4: Priority Social Spending Coverage (Selected sectors and interventions)
- Agriculture: National Agricultural Development Fund; Food safety; Control of fishery products exploitation standards; Support for rural economic growth; Support for agricultural productivity of small farms; Support for agricultural diversification and food production; Development of market gardening; Development of agricultural infrastructure in grassroots communities; Development of irrigated areas in rural areas; Soil protection and rehabilitation; Development of lowlands; Strengthening storage capacities; Food security and resilience building; Nutrition.
- Education: School canteen program; Free schooling at the primary level; Provision of school books; Free schooling for girls in secondary school; Scholarships for students in technical and vocational high schools and colleges; Construction and equipment of educational infrastructures in the three levels of education; University works (catering, transport, accommodation, etc.); Scholarships and university assistance; Support program for doctoral students; Scholarships for the training of trainers; Reinforcement of social infrastructures.
- Social Affairs: Cash transfer to the household; Micro-credits to the poorest for the promotion of income generating activities; Support to national solidarity; Promotion of the family; Regulation and management of child adoption processes; Promotion at the base; Support for people with disabilities; Capacity strengthening, training and learning center for people with disabilities; Support for the elderly; Social welfare.
- Health: Vaccination and primary health care; Blood transfusion; Screening and treatment of diseases covered by the State*; Construction and equipment of hospitals; Development of traditional medicine and pharmacopoeia; Reproductive health; Health care for the indigent; Community health.
- Sanitation and nature protection: Modernization of the efficient waste collection system; Storm water sanitation; Protection against coastal erosion; Social housing development; Forest protection expenditures; Incentives for reforestation; Expenditures to promote the substitution of wood energy for domestic gas.
- Energy: Electrification of rural localities; Development of renewable energy and energy efficiency; Development of conventional energy; Reinforcement and extension of electrical networks; Biomass electricity; Strengthening resilience to climate change impacts.
- Sport: Development of the practice of sport at the grassroots level; Promotion of school and university sports; Sports competitions; Leisure and association life.
- Security and civil protection: Disaster prevention and management; Integrated management of border areas; Maintenance and management of the population register.
- Infrastructure and Transportation: Development of rural roads; Small bridges and various works of crossing of lowlands and others.
- Water and mining: Drinking water supply; Water supply system; Development of multifunctional hydraulic infrastructures.
- Justice: Child and youth safeguarding expenses; Food for prisoners; Social reintegration of prisoners.
- Employment: Various internship programs managed by the ANPE; Training-entrepreneurship of young people.
- Health footnote: Assistance to hemodialysis patients; screening and treatment of ulcer, pneumo-pathobiology, fight against tuberculosis, AIDS, hepatitis, non-communicable diseases, leprosy, malaria, sickle cell anemia, subsidies to hospitals, etc.

### Monitoring and Data Requirements for Program Monitoring
- Monthly data (to be provided in excel format):
  - Data on any loan (terms and creditors) contracted or guaranteed by the government, in the first week after the end of the month of entry into force.
  - Monthly consumer price index, within two weeks of the end of the month.
  - The TOFE, including revenue on a cash basis, detailed data on net domestic financing of the government (bank and nonbank domestic financing, including claims held by the nonbank private sector); and data on the basic primary fiscal balance, within six weeks of the end of the month.
  - Data on the balance, accumulation, amount (stock), and repayment of public domestic and external payment arrears, including when arrears amount to zero, within six weeks of the end of the month.
  - The monetary survey, produced by the BCEAO, within eight weeks of the end of the month.
- Quarterly data:
  - The price structure of petroleum products.
  - The employment index and the traffic of merchandise at the Port of Cotonou, within 25 days of the end of the month.
  - The Industrial production index and the turnover index, within three months of the end of the quarter.
  - High priority social spending (Table 4) by functional classification, within eight weeks after the end of the quarter.
  - Data on exceptional payment orders or other exceptional measures, within six weeks of the end of the quarter.
  - Stock-flow adjustment table.
  - National account statistics, within three months of the end of the quarter.
  - Total new Eurobond issuances provided on quarterly basis, within two weeks after the end of the quarter.
- Other information (periodic):
  - Financial soundness indicators, produced semi-annually by the BCEAO, within eight weeks of the end of the semester.
  - Data on implementation of the public investment program, including detailed information on sources of financing within eight weeks of the end of the quarter.
  - Update of the PPP projects catalog and amounts of contracted projects, within eight weeks of the end of the quarter.
  - Execution of the investment budget, within eight weeks of the end of the quarter.
  - Data on the stock of external debt, external debt service, the signing of external loan agreements and disbursements of external loans, within twelve weeks of the end of the quarter.
  - Data on military and security spending, within eight weeks of the end of the quarter.
  - Balance of payments data, produced by the BCEAO, within ten months of the end of the year.
  - Authorities will report any information needed for effective monitoring of economic policies.

### Debt Sustainability Analysis (DSA) — Key Findings and Metrics
- Risk ratings:
  - Risk of external debt distress: Moderate (unchanged from previous DSA, December 2022).
  - Overall risk of debt distress: Moderate.
  - Granularity: Limited space to absorb shocks.
  - Application of judgment: No.
  - Date: May 4, 2023.
- Summary observations:
  - All projected external debt burden indicators remain below high-risk thresholds under the baseline scenario.
  - External debt burden indicators breach high-risk thresholds in select stress tests, particularly commodity price and export-related shocks.
  - High debt service-to-revenue ratio leaves debt vulnerable to revenue underperformance or shifts in market sentiment that could increase rollover costs.
  - Baseline present value (PV) of the public debt-to-GDP ratio remains below its prudent benchmark but is vulnerable to natural disasters as illustrated by the shock scenario.
  - Policy emphasis: sustained revenue mobilization, continued prudent borrowing, and active debt management strategy to mitigate debt distress risks.
- Debt-carrying capacity:
  - Benin retains a medium-rated debt-carrying capacity, with a 2.99 Composite Indicator (based on October 2022 WEO and the 2021 CPIA).
- Public debt coverage and related fiscal data:
  - DSA covers central government and central bank debt as well as guarantees provided by the central government.
  - Central bank debt borrowed on behalf of the government (i.e., debt to the IMF) is included as external debt.
  - External debt is defined on a currency basis except for debt from BOAD, included as external debt for DSA purposes.
  - Debt coverage does not include non-guaranteed SOE debt and non-financial debts of other government entities.
  - Authorities published outstanding stock of non-guaranteed SOE debt (13 SOEs) at 1.9 percent of GDP at end-2021.
  - Non-financial debt held by local governments, including communes, estimated at 0.3 ppt of GDP at end-2021.
  - Authorities view consolidating general government fiscal accounts and incorporating SOE financial statements as prerequisites for broadening debt coverage.
  - Expanding fiscal account coverage is a medium-term capacity development priority supported by AFRITAC-West.

*Source: Benin — IMF staff report chapter on external budgetary assistance, performance criteria, monitoring, and DSA (extracted from the provided document).*

### 3. The contingent liabilities shock has been calibrated to reflect risk associated with debt

### 3. The contingent liabilities shock has been calibrated to reflect risk associated with debt 

### Contingent liabilities calibration
- Total contingent liabilities shock: 9.6 percent of GDP.
- Breakdown of the 9.6 percent of GDP shock:
  - 1.9 percent of GDP in SOE debt (based on the latest available data (end-2021)).
  - 0.3 percent of GDP for local government debt (based on the latest reported estimate).
  - 2.4 percent of GDP for PPPs (based on the capital stock from the World Bank’s PPP database (6.8 ppts of GDP)).
  - Default setting for financial market risk: 5.0 percent of GDP (Text Table 2).
- Benin’s debt policy and management score: 4.5 out of 6 in the 2020 and 2021 CPIA evaluations.

### Recent debt developments and liability management
- Public debt trajectory:
  - Public debt rose to 54.2 percent of GDP in 2022 (from 50.3 percent of GDP in 2021).
- Issuances, adjustments, and relief:
  - Authorities issued FCFA 300 billion (2.9 percent of GDP) on the regional security market; resources currently held at the BCEAO.
  - In January 2023, Benin agreed with China on the cancelation of the outstanding debt on two interest-free loans totaling FCFA 3 .5 billion (or 0.3 percent of GDP).
- Liability management outcomes:
  - Overall public debt service-to-revenue ratio expected to average 35 percent in 2023-27.
  - Near-term domestic debt service averaging 4.3 percent of GDP in 2023–25.
  - One-third of FCFA-denominated debt stock has time to maturity of over seven years (end-2022).
- 2022 local currency debt issuance and characteristics:
  - Gross bond FCFA issuances in 2022: around 5.1 percent of GDP.
  - Average interest rate on 2022 issuances: 5.2 percent.
  - Average maturity on 2022 issuances: 6 years.
  - Improvement versus March 2020–December 2021 issuances (average interest rate 6.0 percent, maturity 5 years).
  - As of end-2022, FCFA-denominated debt composition: 34 percent of bonds with maturities of seven years or more.
- Local currency denominated debt by time to maturity (as of end-2022, percent of GDP):
  - Less than one year: 3.1
  - 1-3 years: 5.0
  - 4-7 years: 4.1
  - More than 7 years: 6.3
  - Total (percent GDP): 18.5

### Composition of debt and borrowing strategy
- Debt composition (end-2022):
  - Multilateral creditors: 38 percent.
  - International bond holders: 19 percent.
  - Domestic public debt: about 31 percent of the debt stock (large portion of securities on the regional financial market).
- Market innovation:
  - Issued Africa’s first ever SDG bond in 2021: €500 million, 12.5-year maturity at 4.95 percent.
- Baseline borrowing strategy assumptions:
  - Continue to maximize concessional resources; baseline includes IMF-supported program financing and higher World Bank financing in line with latest IDA allocations.
  - Improved nominal interest rate on public debt: averages 3.7 percent (compared with 4.0 percent in the previous DSA).
  - External borrowing plan for 2023 consists mostly of concessional and semi-concessional loans from multilateral and bilateral creditors.
  - Assumes regular market access following program conclusion, including a US$500 million Eurobond issuance in 2025 and assumption that existing Eurobond repayments will be rolled over in 2030-42.
  - Assumes an average of around 40 percent of gross financing needs per year will be filled by domestic financing.
  - Domestic financing assumed mostly in the form of one-to-seven-year bonds with a small portion of longer maturities at rates from 6 to 7 percent.

### Macroeconomic and fiscal assumptions underlying the DSA
- Growth and inflation:
  - Near-term Real GDP Growth: 6 percent.
  - Medium/longer-term growth: expected to remain around potential at 6 percent; longer-term projections conservative at 5.7 percent converging to steady-state.
  - Inflation for 2023: 3.5 percent.
  - GDP deflator: averaging 2.2 percent over 2022-26 (compared with 2.1 percent in previous DSA); expected to converge around 2 percent over the long term.
- Fiscal balances and revenues:
  - Primary fiscal balance: primary deficit (including grants) expected to narrow to 2.6 percent of GDP in 2023.
  - Baseline assumes overall fiscal deficit converges to 3 percent of GDP in 2025 (shifted from 2024 in previous DSA).
  - Medium-term fiscal primary deficit averages 1.7 percent of GDP (compared with 1.5 percent in previous DSA).
  - Revenues and grants for 2023: 14.7 percent of GDP (compared with 14.4 percent in previous DSA).
  - Measures to lock in revenue gains: corporate and personal income tax reforms, move to transactional values at customs, expansion of standardized invoices, application of minimum tax on sale of used vehicles.
  - Total expenditure in 2023: 19.0 percent of GDP (compared with 18.7 percent in previous DSA).
- Fiscal adjustor:
  - Baseline overall deficit remains at 4.3 percent of GDP in 2023 but could increase up to 4.7 ppt of GDP if additional external budget support is mobilized under the IMF program.
- External sector:
  - Current account deficit: expected to widen to 5.9 percent of GDP in 2023 (compared with 5.5 percent in previous DSA).
  - Current account deficit expected to improve over medium/long term, hovering close to 4 percent of GDP.
  - FDI: expected to increase modestly from 1.6 percent of GDP in 2023 to 1.8 percent of GDP in 2028.
- Financing terms and assumptions:
  - International market borrowing assumed at 6 percent interest rate (consistent with attractive borrowing conditions).
  - Regional market borrowing assumed at 5.5-6.9 percent depending on maturity.

### Debt trajectory and projections
- Debt projections:
  - Public debt projected around 54 percent of GDP at end-2023.
  - Public debt projected to decline to 46 percent of GDP by 2033, contingent on contained fiscal deficits and growth converging to potential.
- Drivers of debt dynamics:
  - GDP growth: expected to be debt-reducing in projections.
  - Real interest rate and primary deficit: expected to be debt-increasing.
  - Historical large changes in public debt over last 5 years explained by shocks (Nigeria border closure, COVID-19), primary deficit, real exchange rate depreciation, and other debt-creating flows.

### Policy implications and recommended stances
- Maintain a prudent borrowing strategy, maximizing concessional resources to the extent possible.
- Implement revenue-based fiscal consolidation to ensure convergence to WAEMU regional fiscal norms.
- Support fiscal consolidation with:
  - Revenue mobilization (including pending Medium-Term Revenue Mobilization Strategy as a structural benchmark for end-September 2023).
  - Spending prioritization and efficiency gains in public investment.
  - Unwinding of temporary spending measures related to COVID-19 and Russia’s invasion of Ukraine.
- Continue proactive liability management to smooth debt service profile, reduce costs, and mitigate rollover risks (including issuance of longer maturities on the regional market and pre-emptive issuances).

*Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/cr/2023/english/1benea2023001.pdf*

### 11. The macroeconomic outlook is subject to a number of risks, which remain tilted to the

### 11. The macroeconomic outlook is subject to a number of risks, which remain tilted to the downside.

### Downside risks and vulnerabilities
- Further increases in international food and oil prices—amidst the ongoing war in Ukraine—would exert pressure on external accounts and erode purchasing power of the vulnerable, potentially fueling social tensions.
- Negative shocks from Nigeria could disrupt transit trade and reduce revenues (including taxes).
- A shift in global risk appetite or further tightening of liquidity conditions on the regional security market could complicate medium-term rollover risks.
- Higher than anticipated security outlays could weigh heavily on the budget.
- Benin remains susceptible to natural disasters and acute and chronic climate change risks.

### Country classification and stress test design
- Benin’s debt carrying capacity is classified as medium.
- Composite indicator (reflecting 2021 WB CPIA index and October 2022 WEO variables: real growth rates, reserve coverage, remittances, and world growth) yields a CI score of 2.99.
- DSA uses external debt burden thresholds and total public benchmarks for countries with medium debt carrying capacity.
- Stress tests follow standardized settings with tailored tests for contingent liabilities, natural disasters, commodity prices, and market financing.
  - Standard natural disaster shock applied due to high vulnerability to flooding and coastal erosion.
  - Commodity exposure: cotton accounts for 35 percent of exports excluding reexported products in 2021.
  - Outstanding Eurobonds expose Benin to rollover risk in the event of adverse global risk sentiment, although the current maturity profile mitigates this risk over the next two years.

### External debt sustainability: baseline outcomes and stress-test results
- Baseline:
  - All external debt burden indicators are below policy-dependent thresholds in the baseline.
  - PV of total PPG external debt to GDP:
    - Expected to remain well below the threshold throughout the projection period.
    - Averaging 29 percent of GDP in 2023-27 and 28 percent of GDP in the long-term.
    - Will peak at 30 percent of GDP in 2025 (compared with a peak of 33 percent of GDP in the previous DSA).
  - Debt service-to-revenue ratio will temporarily near the threshold in 2030 (when large Eurobond repayments are falling due).
  - PV of debt-to-exports and PV of debt service-to-exports ratios remain below thresholds, peaking in 2025 and 2030, respectively.
- Stress tests:
  - Highlight vulnerability to shocks, particularly commodity prices and exports.
  - Three out of four debt-burden indicators breach thresholds under certain stress tests.
  - Commodity price shock is the most severe for:
    - PV of debt-to-GDP
    - PV of debt-to-exports
    - Debt service-to-revenue indicators
  - Export shock is the most severe for the debt service-to-exports ratio.
  - Debt service-to-revenue breaches in several stress tests are largely related to large Eurobond repayments; these risks could be managed via prudent debt management.
  - Historical scenario (calibration period 2013–2022) is relatively more severe, capturing COVID-19, the Nigeria border closure, and the 2015 downturn.
  - Continued revenue mobilization and active debt management are expected to help stabilize debt levels.

### Granularity and market-financing assessments
- Granularity assessment:
  - Indicates Benin has limited space to absorb shocks.
  - Under the module allowing qualification of moderate risk, Benin is assessed as having limited space because the debt service-to-revenue ratio would breach the threshold under a median observed shock scenario, resulting in a downgrade to high-risk.
- Market-financing module:
  - Suggests market risks are moderate.
  - EMBI spreads are above the benchmark (reflecting recent global financial market volatility).
  - Gross financing needs remain well below the respective benchmark; potential for heightened liquidity needs is moderate.
  - Debt-service to revenue and debt service-to-export ratios would exceed thresholds in 2030 under the market financing shock, given the repayment profile (which does not incorporate possible liability management operations).

### Total public debt sustainability
- Baseline:
  - Total public PPG remains below its respective benchmark.
  - Present value of public debt averages 41 percent of GDP over the projection period, well below the 55 percent benchmark.
  - Present value of public debt at end of projection period is 39 percent of GDP (compared with 43 percent in the previous DSA), driven by slightly improved financing terms given the increase in World Bank financing.
- Stress tests:
  - Public debt most vulnerable to commodity price shocks and natural disasters.
  - For PV of debt-to-GDP ratio:
    - Commodity price shock would be the most extreme, with PV of debt-to-GDP breaching the benchmark in 2033 and significant increases in the debt-to-revenue ratio.
    - Natural disaster shock would also have a significant negative impact with debt service-to-revenue ratios reaching 46 percent in 2028.

### Debt burden thresholds and benchmarks (as reported)
- EXTERNAL debt burden thresholds (Weak / Medium / Strong)
  - PV of debt in % of Exports: 140 / 180 / 240
  - PV of debt in % of GDP: 30 / 40 / 55
  - Debt service in % of Exports: 10 / 15 / 21
  - Debt service in % of Revenue: 14 / 18 / 23
- TOTAL public debt benchmark (Weak / Medium / Strong)
  - PV of total public debt in percent of GDP: 35 / 55 / 70

### Risk rating, vulnerabilities, and policy recommendations
- Risk rating:
  - Benin remains at moderate risk of external and overall debt distress (unchanged from previous DSA).
  - All external debt indicators remain below high-risk thresholds and benchmarks in the baseline.
- Vulnerabilities:
  - Debt levels remain vulnerable to shocks.
  - High debt service to revenues ratio, large amortization payments, and a low revenue base may pose liquidity risks.
  - Lower-than-expected revenues (including due to policy implementation lags) or a shift in market sentiment increasing borrowing and rollover costs could heighten debt risks.
- Policy recommendations to mitigate debt-distress risk:
  - Sustained revenue mobilization efforts.
  - Prudent borrowing and debt management strategy.
  - Continue proactive liability management to facilitate rollover of large Eurobond bullet repayments.
  - Maximize concessional borrowing.
  - Implement measures to bring tax revenues closer to Benin’s potential.
- Actions already taken by authorities:
  - Pre-emptive issuances to hedge against adverse market conditions in 2022.
  - Additional measures to maintain revenue collection momentum under the 2023 budget.
  - Adoption of a tax expenditure rationalization strategy in November 2022.
  - Ongoing development of a medium-term revenue mobilization strategy.

*Source: IMF staff analysis (Benin DSA chapter).*

### 22. The authorities agree with the assessment that Benin remains at a moderate risk of

### 1benea2023001 - 22. The authorities agree with the assessment that Benin remains at a moderate risk of

### Authorities' assessment and policy stance
- Authorities agree Benin "remains at a moderate risk of external debt distress" but "see more space to absorb shocks."
- Authorities' views and actions:
  - They consider debt from BOAD should be classified as domestic debt given the institution’s governance structure and the regional arrangement that makes the FCFA currency union a consolidated unit (noting that "classifying such debt as domestic would further improve the external debt profile").
  - They see "a greater scope for domestic financing and at longer maturities and lower cost in the medium term."
  - They remain committed to "preserving debt sustainability, mitigating refinancing risks, and containing borrowing costs through a combination of revenue mobilization, active debt management, and prudent borrowing."

### Key external debt and balance of payments indicators (Table 1, Baseline Scenario)
- External debt (nominal) 1/ (percent of GDP): 28.4; 36.8; 37.6; 38.1; 38.3; 39.4; 38.6; 37.9; 37.6; 33.9; 23.7; 22.2; 37.0
- Change in external debt (percent of GDP): 3.2; 8.4; 0.8; 0.6; 0.2; 1.1; -0.8; -0.7; -0.3; -0.6; -1.4
- Identified net debt-creating flows (percent of GDP): -1.3; -0.8; 5.2; 2.2; 2.0; 1.4; 1.0; 0.5; 0.3; 0.2; 0.2; 2.2; 0.8
- Non-interest current account deficit (percent of GDP): 1.3; 3.4; 5.5; 5.0; 4.8; 4.3; 4.0; 3.6; 3.3; 3.3; 3.4; 4.2; 3.8
- Deficit in balance of goods and services (percent of GDP): 2.8; 4.4; 6.4; 6.2; 6.1; 5.5; 5.3; 4.9; 4.8; 4.8; 4.8; 5.6; 5.2
- Exports (percent of GDP): 22.4; 23.5; 24.9; 23.1; 23.2; 23.0; 22.9; 22.9; 22.8; 22.8; 22.8; 22.8
- Imports (percent of GDP): 25.1; 27.8; 31.4; 29.3; 29.3; 28.5; 28.2; 27.8; 27.6; 27.6; 27.6; 27.6
- Net FDI (negative = inflow, percent of GDP): -1.0; -1.7; -1.6; -1.6; -1.6; -1.5; -1.6; -1.8; -1.8; -2.1; -2.7; -1.6; -1.8
- Endogenous debt dynamics (percent of GDP): -1.6; -2.5; 1.3; -1.2; -1.3; -1.3; -1.3; -1.3; -1.3; -1.0; -0.5; -0.4; -1.2
  - Contribution from nominal interest rate: 0.5; 0.7; 0.8; 0.8; 0.8; 0.8; 0.9; 0.8; 0.8; 0.8; 0.8; 0.4; 0.8
  - Contribution from real GDP growth: -0.9; -1.8; -2.3; -2.0; -2.1; -2.1; -2.2; -2.1; -2.1; -1.9; -1.3; -1.0; -2.1
- Residual (percent of GDP): 4.5; 9.2; -4.4; -1.7; -1.8; -0.3; -1.9; -1.2; -0.5; -0.8; -1.6; 0.4; -1.1
- PPG debt service-to-exports ratio (percent): 5.5; 8.7; 8.3; 8.9; 10.7; 10.7; 10.1; 9.0; 9.0; 10.3; 10.4
- PPG debt service-to-revenue ratio (percent): 9.7; 15.5; 15.0; 14.7; 17.1; 16.5; 15.2; 13.1; 12.6; 12.6; 11.1
- Gross external financing need (Billion of U.S. dollars): 0.5; 1.3; 1.6; 1.7; 1.8; 1.8; 1.9; 1.9; 2.0; 3.2; 7.2

### Key macroeconomic assumptions (Table 1)
- Real GDP growth (in percent): 3.8; 7.2; 6.3; 6.0; 6.0; 6.0; 6.0; 6.0; 6.0; 5.9; 5.4; 5.5; 5.9
- GDP deflator in US dollar terms (change in percent): 4.9; 5.4; -7.3; 4.2; 1.2; 1.7; 1.6; 1.5; 2.0; 2.0; 2.0; -0.6; 2.0
- Effective interest rate (percent) 4/: 2.1; 3.0; 2.0; 2.5; 2.3; 2.2; 2.4; 2.4; 2.3; 2.6; 3.3; 1.9; 2.4
- Growth of exports of G&S (US dollar terms, in percent): -2.3; 18.6; 4.5; 2.3; 7.9; 6.8; 7.3; 7.3; 7.8; 8.0; 7.5; 9.5; 7.2
- Growth of imports of G&S (US dollar terms, in percent): -8.6; 25.1; 10.9; 3.1; 7.2; 4.8; 6.8; 5.9; 7.5; 8.0; 7.5; 8.8; 6.9
- Government revenues (excluding grants, in percent of GDP): 12.7; 13.2; 13.8; 14.0; 14.5; 15.0; 15.3; 15.8; 16.2; 18.6; 21.4; 12.6; 16.3

### Public sector debt and fiscal dynamics (Table 2, Baseline Scenario)
- Public sector debt 1/ (percent of GDP): 46.1; 50.3; 54.2; 53.8; 53.5; 52.4; 51.4; 50.5; 49.6; 46.2; 43.4; 38.0; 49.9
  - Of which: external debt (percent of GDP): 28.4; 36.8; 37.6; 38.1; 38.3; 39.4; 38.6; 37.9; 37.6; 33.9; 23.7; 22.2; 37.0
- Change in public sector debt (percent of GDP): 4.9; 4.1; 3.9; -0.4; -0.3; -1.1; -1.0; -0.9; -0.9; -0.6; -0.1
- Identified debt-creating flows (percent of GDP): 1.4; 3.9; 7.1; -0.6; -0.5; -1.1; -1.0; -0.9; -0.8; -0.5; -0.1; 2.4; -0.7
- Primary deficit (percent of GDP): 2.7; 3.5; 3.9; 2.6; 2.1; 1.3; 1.3; 1.4; 1.4; 1.4; 1.0; 2.4; 1.6
- Revenue and grants (percent of GDP): 14.4; 14.1; 14.3; 14.7; 15.2; 15.6; 16.0; 16.5; 16.9; 19.3; 22.0; 13.4; 16.9
- Primary (noninterest) expenditure (percent of GDP): 17.1; 17.6; 18.2; 17.3; 17.2; 16.9; 17.3; 17.8; 18.2; 20.6; 23.0; 15.8; 18.5
- Automatic debt dynamics (percent of GDP): -3.3; 0.5; -0.2; -3.3; -2.6; -2.4; -2.3; -2.3; -2.2; -1.9; -1.1; -0.5; -2.3
  - Contribution from interest rate/growth differential: -0.9; -2.0; -2.9; -3.3; -2.6; -2.4; -2.3; -2.3; -2.2; -1.9; -1.1; -1.1; -2.3
- Debt service-to-revenue and grants ratio 3/ (percent): 42.5; 76.7; 60.7; 40.5; 34.6; 37.8; 30.0; 33.7; 26.7; 26.3; 30.1
- Gross financing need 4/ (percent of GDP): 10.8; 14.2; 16.0; 8.6; 7.3; 7.2; 6.1; 6.9; 5.9; 6.4; 7.7

### Stress tests, sensitivity analysis, and risk indicators
- PV of debt-to-GDP, baseline (2023–2033): 29; 29; 30; 29; 29; 28; 28; 27; 27; 27; 27
- Table 3 (sensitivity): Several tailored and bound stress tests show higher ratios under shocks:
  - Example: C3. Commodity price (PV debt-to-GDP): 33; 40; 39; 40; 39; 38; 37; 35; 34; 33; 32 (series across 2023–2033 as presented in the sensitivity table)
- Figure 1 and Figure 2 stress-test notes:
  - All additional financing needs generated by stress-test shocks are assumed to be covered by PPG external MLT debt in the external DSA.
  - Default terms of marginal debt are based on baseline 10-year projections.
- Market-financing risk indicators (Figure 6):
  - EMBI spread as of April 13, 2023: 570
  - GFN benchmarks and values: Benchmarks 14; Values 9732 (as presented in Figure 6)
  - The report flags "Potential heightened liquidity needs" and "Moderate" market-financing risk with an indicated "Breach of benchmark: Yes" for some indicators.

### Indicators qualifying the "Moderate" category (Figure 5)
- The classification juxtaposes baseline trajectories of:
  - Debt service-to-revenue ratio
  - PV of debt-to-exports ratio
  - PV of debt-to-GDP ratio
  - Debt service-to-exports ratio
- Visual thresholds and bands distinguish "Some space," "Substantial space," and "Limited space" relative to the threshold lines used to qualify the moderate risk category (threshold parameters noted in figure footnote: PV debt/GDP and PV debt/exports thresholds x = 20 percent and y = 40 percent; debt service/Exports and debt service/revenue thresholds x = 12 percent and y = 35 percent).

### Key takeaways for policy
- Classification and accounting treatment:
  - Reclassifying BOAD debt as domestic (per authorities) would "further improve the external debt profile."
- Policy priorities emphasized by the authorities:
  - Revenue mobilization.
  - Active debt management to mitigate refinancing risks and contain borrowing costs.
  - Prudent borrowing and expanding scope for domestic financing at longer maturities and lower cost in the medium term.
- Vulnerabilities identified by staff analysis:
  - External debt and public debt trajectories under various stress tests (commodity price shocks, natural disasters, combined contingent liability shocks) can materially increase debt and debt-service ratios, underscoring the need for continued fiscal and debt-management vigilance.

*Sources: Country authorities; and staff estimates and projections (excerpts from the Benin DSA tables, figures, and accompanying text).*

### Introduction

### Introduction

### Overview
- The Beninese authorities express appreciation for the Fund’s continued engagement under the Extended Fund Facility (EFF) and the Extended Credit Facility (ECF) program approved in July 2022.
- The program supports macroeconomic stability, structural transformation, and progress towards the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), and plays a catalytic role to mobilize external resources for pressing and development financing needs.
- The IMF staff report for the second review under the ECF/EFF highlights significant achievements and the policies being implemented to address current economic challenges.

### Program Performance
- All end-September and end-December 2022 performance criteria (PCs), continuous PCs and indicative targets (ITs) were met, some with comfortable margins.
- Drivers of outperformance:
  - Overperformance in tax collection.
  - Re-prioritization of spending.
- Social spending:
  - Priority social expenditure was well above the program floor due to expansion of the school feeding program and increased spending under Assurance pour le Renforcement du Capital Humain (ARCH).
- Structural progress:
  - All structural benchmarks (SBs) set for end-February, March, and April 2023 were implemented, including:
    - Completion of an IMF governance diagnostic and publication of the related report.
    - Adoption of a financial inclusion strategy.
    - Submission to parliament of a draft law to strengthen the Programme National d'Alimentation Scolaire Intégré (PNASI).
    - Digitalization of the processing of land title requests.

### Macroeconomic Developments and Outlook
- Growth and activity:
  - Economic activity is estimated to have expanded by 6.3 percent in 2022.
  - Growth is described as "almost returning to pre-crisis levels at above 6 percent" and surpassing the sub-Saharan African average.
  - Growth supported by a broadly good harvest season, higher construction activity under PAG-II, and the Glo-Djigbé Special Economic Zone / Glo-Djigbé Industrial Zone (GDIZ).
- Inflation:
  - Inflation was 1.4 percent in 2022, reflecting measures to mitigate war-in-Ukraine effects on prices of key imports.
  - Inflationary pressures are expected in 2023 notably due to rises in public sector wages and the minimum wage in December 2022.
- Fiscal and debt developments:
  - Tax revenue overperformance reflects improvements in domestic arrears collection, the fight against tax evasion, and other tax measures.
  - Public expenditure has risen to protect household purchasing power and implement the “civilian approach” to northern security threats.
  - Public debt has increased, but Benin remains at moderate risk of debt distress due to prudent and active debt management.
  - Authorities implemented precautionary policies including preemptive issuances for the equivalent of 2.9 percent of GDP last year.
- Financial sector:
  - Credit to the private sector grew, driven by construction and trade.
  - Non-performing loans continued to decline.
- Risks:
  - Downside risks identified include: heightened economic uncertainty, tightening financing conditions in global and regional markets, increased food insecurity, social discontent, regional security threats, and vulnerability to climate-related shocks (recurrent floods and droughts).
  - Positive prospects cited include GDIZ development, related FDI, spillovers from major socio-economic infrastructure projects under PAG II, and the Niger-Benin oil pipeline.

### Policies and Reforms for 2023 and Beyond

#### Strengthening Macroeconomic Stability and Preserving Debt Sustainability
- Fiscal consolidation:
  - Fiscal consolidation has started as envisaged in the 2023 budget law after 3 years of supportive fiscal measures.
  - Medium-term measures include intensifying domestic revenue mobilization, withdrawing shock-related expenditures, improving public spending efficiency, and prioritizing public investments and social spending.
  - Aim to gradually converge to WAEMU’s fiscal deficit target of 3 percent of GDP by 2025.
- Revenue mobilization:
  - The 2024-2028 Medium-Term Revenue Mobilization Strategy (MTRS) will anchor efforts to raise the tax-to-GDP ratio.
  - Strong tax policy and administrative measures introduced in 2023 aim to increase the tax-to-GDP ratio by 0.6 percentage points.
  - Additional revenue gains expected from clearance of tax arrears, Corporate Income Tax reform, and the minimum tax on used vehicles.
  - A January 2023 decree establishes a clear regime for special economic zones to support rationalizing tax expenditures.
- Expenditure management and PFM:
  - Lowering non-priority capital expenditure growth through efficiency gains, unwinding supportive fiscal measures, and reducing recurrent spending is warranted after accelerated capital expenditure in 2022.
  - Further PFM improvements include measures in tax and customs administrations, progress toward the Treasury Single Account (TSA), and enhanced public procurement processes.
- Petroleum subsidy reform:
  - Authorities plan to assess alignment of petroleum product pricing to international standards and have sought IMF technical assistance (TA) to review the 2004 pricing mechanism.
  - Authorities will consider Benin’s local fuel market specificities, including Nigeria, and social circumstances.
- Debt management:
  - Active debt management will continue with emphasis on diversifying financing sources.
  - Precautionary measures implemented given expectations of tighter financing conditions in the regional security market, including liability management and creation of precautionary lines of credit.

#### Reinforcing Social Protection
- Social protection priorities:
  - Strengthening social safety nets is critical to address poverty and inequality and is a top priority under the Poverty Reduction and Growth Strategy (PRGS) aligned with PND 2018-25.
  - Objective to reduce the income poverty rate from 40 percent in 2015 to 23.2 percent by 2025.
- Recent measures:
  - Expansion of ARCH health insurance for the extremely poor.
  - Well-targeted social programs supported by the recently completed Régistre Social Unique (RSU).
  - These programs will be sustained and strengthened.

#### Building Resilience to Climate Change
- Climate priorities:
  - Given high vulnerability to adverse climate events, strengthening resilience is a government priority.
  - Authorities intend to build on existing legislative and regulatory frameworks: a law on climate change, a national policy on climate change management, and a national climate change adaptation plan.
  - Authorities welcomed the IMF C-PIMA assessment and the World Bank’s Climate Change and Development Report (CCDR) and will use their results to identify reforms.
  - Authorities look forward to IMF support under the Resilience and Sustainability Facility (RSF) in the near future.

#### Further Improving Governance, Transparency, and the AML/CFT Framework
- Governance reforms:
  - Promoting good governance, enhancing transparency, and addressing corruption are foundational to PAG II.
  - An IMF diagnostic of governance vulnerabilities was completed in 2022 and published in Q1 2023.
  - An action plan to address findings and recommendations is being developed to be completed by end-June 2023; implementation of key recommendations is proposed as new SBs under the IMF-supported program.
- PFM and procurement:
  - Progress in PFM includes improving regulation and supervision of public procurement and public contracts.
  - Beneficial ownership information is being published consistent with the September 2022 regulation.
  - Technical assistance in e-procurement is provided by development partners.
  - Public Procurement Regulatory Authority (ARMP) conducts regular technical and independent audits of awarded contracts and makes audit reports public on the ARMP website.

#### Preserving Financial Stability and Advancing Other Structural Reforms
- Financial stability and banking sector:
  - As a WAEMU member, safeguarding financial stability is a priority.
  - Progress on two troubled banks: one has been recapitalized and brought into compliance with prudential rules, subject to auditor and WAMU Banking Commission approval.
- Financial inclusion and market development:
  - Authorities transposed the WAEMU regional financial inclusion strategy and adopted a 2023-2027 national financial inclusion strategy.
- Business environment and private sector development:
  - Reforms to improve the business environment include adoption of a new law supporting SMEs and the establishment of the Agency for the Development of SMEs.
  - Legal and regulatory frameworks for special economic zones have been revisited to attract investors.

### Conclusion
- Benin has maintained strong growth and an unwavering implementation of its economic and financial reform program.
- Program performance over the review period has been robust.
- Authorities reaffirm commitment to the EFF/ECF program to achieve objectives of the 2018-2025 NDP while preserving macroeconomic stability.
- Authorities seek the Executive Directors' support for completion of the second review under the EFF and ECF arrangements.

*Source: Introduction (1benea2023001)*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/cr/2023/english/1benea2023001.pdf_
