## 1nzlea2023001

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [1nzlea2023001](https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/cr/2023/english/1nzlea2023001.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/files/publications/cr/2023/english/1nzlea2023001.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/files/publications/cr/2023/english/1nzlea2023001.pdf.json)

---

### BOTTOMING OUT AMID HIGH INFLATION — Context and Recent Developments
- Growth and recent output:
  - Recovered by 10 percent since the middle of 2020.
  - Real GDP declined by 0.1 percent q/q (SA) in 2023Q1, following a 0.7 percent decline in 2022Q4 GDP.
- Inflation and labor market:
  - CPI inflation at 6.7 percent in 2023Q1, above the RBNZ’s 1–3 target range.
  - Labor markets tight with record high labor force participation and historically low unemployment and underemployment.
  - Wage pressures concentrated in services and construction.
- Natural disasters and fiscal impact:
  - North Island weather events (Auckland flash floods and Cyclone Gabrielle) added inflationary pressures.
  - Damages from the North Island weather events are estimated to be NZ$9–14.5 billion.
  - Gross public debt at 45 percent of GDP; substantial fiscal space remains.
- Monetary policy and financial conditions:
  - RBNZ raised the official cash rate (OCR) by 525 bps cumulatively (including a 25 bps increase in May).
  - Wholesale and retail interest rates have risen significantly since mid-2021; longer-term rates now below OCR and short-term rates.
  - RBNZ continues to shrink LSAP holdings through off-market operations with Treasury.
- External sector and housing:
  - Current account deficit expanded rapidly, driven by a large output gap, strong domestic economy, expansionary fiscal policy, and one-off COVID import factors.
  - House prices peaked in November 2021 and have fallen by around 13 percent relative to the peak.
  - Rental market remains tight; affordability (mortgage interest payments relative to income) has worsened.
  - Around half of mortgages in New Zealand are fixed for less than 1 year and will reset over the next 12 months.
  - May 2023 Financial Stability Report indicated an increase in household loan delinquency rates, but not for mortgages.

### Outlook: Ongoing Low Growth and an Uncertain Inflation Path
- Growth and inflation projections:
  - Staff expect growth to slow to around 1 percent y/y in 2023 and 2024.
  - Inflation is likely to decline gradually, coming into the 1–3 percent target range only in 2025.
  - Unemployment is expected to rise to 5 percent by 2024.
- Drivers of near-term performance:
  - Slowdown led by weakness in domestic private demand (consumption and investment).
  - Some boost from reconstruction activity and recovery in tourism; higher goods imports related to reconstruction needs.
  - Net migration has picked up and should further alleviate labor market tightness, though the net demand effect is unclear.
- Uncertainty:
  - Outlook remains highly uncertain given stickiness of nontradeable prices and external developments.

### Risks and Alternative Scenario
- Key risk categories:
  - External environment shocks (global growth, geo-economic fragmentation, financial stability shocks).
  - Policy missteps and lack of coordination (monetary policy miscalibration domestically and abroad).
  - Domestic housing market disruptions due to high household debt and banks’ high exposure to housing.
- Downside alternative scenario:
  - Persistent high inflation and rapid wage growth could force RBNZ to tighten further or keep rates high for longer.
  - Tighter financial conditions could create disorderly housing market conditions, amplifying household distress and banking system risks, prolonging or deepening a recession.
  - Rate rises will trigger pockets of household distress, particularly among lower income borrowers and recent purchasers near the housing cycle peak.
- Upside risk:
  - Rising net migration could ease labor constraints and potentially speed return of inflation to target.

### Policies for Sustainable Growth — Overview
- Policy stance:
  - Fiscal-monetary mix should retain a restrictive bias to rebalance the economy internally and externally while relying on automatic stabilizers.
  - Monetary policy has appropriately turned tight to address risks of high and prolonged inflation.
  - New discretionary spending without offsets will work against monetary tightening and delay fiscal consolidation.
- Structural priorities:
  - Fiscal policy should prioritize addressing overheating while managing short-term demand pressures.
  - With prioritization, fiscal policy should also address long-term needs: closing productivity gaps and climate-related investments.
  - Systemic assessment shows housing and household-related vulnerabilities have declined slightly since 2022 but remain elevated.

### A Need for Fiscal Consolidation Amid High Cost of Living and Reconstruction
- FY2023/24 fiscal stance and measures:
  - Operating allowances increased in Budget 2023 to NZ$4.8 billion per year (1.1 percent of average GDP).
  - Additional NZ$1.1 billion toward infrastructure reconstruction and capital expenditure in FY2023/24.
  - National Resilience Plan established with NZ$6 billion over 10 years for asset repair and replacement.
  - Several new spending and cost-of-living initiatives (examples: extension of early childhood education, scrapping prescription co-payments, extending free public transport to children and half-price fares to young adults, lowering energy bills for lower income households).
- Fiscal outcomes and near-term path:
  - Identified savings and reprioritization netted off only a small share of new spending initiatives.
  - General government cyclically adjusted primary balance (CAPB) expected at -4.4 percent of potential GDP for FY2023/24.
  - Fiscal impulse of 1.8 percent of potential GDP for FY2023/24.
  - Fiscal consolidation projected to begin from FY2025/26; CAPB will turn positive in the medium term.
- Staff recommendations for fiscal execution:
  - Prioritize productive and cost-efficient post-disaster reconstruction and climate adaptation projects that provide high positive externalities.
  - Frontload fiscal consolidation while prioritizing reconstruction without unduly adding to demand.
  - New spending initiatives should identify cost savings and reductions in public consumption.
  - Cost-of-living support should be targeted and temporary, better focused on vulnerable households and viable businesses using means testing.
  - These measures will reduce demand, support monetary policy in achieving price stability, and allow automatic stabilizers to function countercyclically.

### Tax Policy Findings and Recommendations
- Key findings:
  - New Zealand has adequate overall revenue and suitably-broad tax bases, but the role of the tax system in economic policy needs reconsideration.
  - The tax preference design merits careful debate.
- Policy options and recommendations:
  - Enhancing tax revenue options (for example, by introducing capital and land value taxes) would yield fairer and more equitable tax revenue outcomes.
  - Reforming the corporate income tax would:
    - boost business investment,
    - encourage entry of new businesses,
    - lead to higher productivity growth, and
    - produce more efficient revenue outturns that do not crowd out investment.
  - Addressing the tradeoff posed by higher inflation and ad-hoc cost-of-living adjustments: periodically (or systemically) raising income brackets can limit distributional implications of inflation and partly limit the need for more transfers.
- Fiscal rules and disaster resilience:
  - Reinstated fiscal rules: a net core Crown debt ceiling of 50 percent of GDP and fiscal surpluses are described as well calibrated.
  - Footnote: The debt ceiling is equal to 30 percent of GDP when excluding the New Zealand Superannuation Fund.
  - Recommendation: Given New Zealand’s exposure to climate shocks, natural disaster costs should be explicitly incorporated into the Budget framework.

### Public Investment, Infrastructure, and Aging
- Long-term fiscal challenges:
  - Large infrastructure gaps and aging underscore need for strategic public investment in the medium term.
  - Adoption of a “golden-rule” style operating balance is appropriate to support borrowing for long-term investments which grow capital stock.
    - Footnote: A “golden-rule” style operating balance means that operating expenses (including day-to-day consumption and transfer payments) are paid out of operating revenues.
- Specific recommendations:
  - Policymakers need a pipeline of projects with clearly defined goals and tradeoffs to help financing and delivery of infrastructure.
  - Reconstruction post-North Island weather events provides a chance to strengthen infrastructure resilience and bridge infrastructure gaps.
  - Expected higher spending on pension and healthcare from aging demographics implies continued medium-term investment in health system reform, capital expenditure for physical health infrastructure, and superannuation reforms.

### Authorities’ Views (fiscal, tax, housing)
- Authorities view a frontloaded fiscal expansion with backloaded consolidation as appropriate to respond to rebuilding needs and cost pressures.
- Authorities agreed with staff on need for a tighter stance in line with fiscal rules and expect consolidation will be achieved in the forecast period (four years).
- On tax reforms:
  - Authorities acknowledged potential fiscal and integrity benefits to new tax bases but noted economic trade-offs and that accessing new tax bases is not on the tax policy work program at this time.
  - Authorities pointed to the new top personal income tax rate in 2021 and the increase in the trustee tax rate announced in Budget 2023.
- Authorities agreed on need to bridge infrastructure gaps; new capital expenditure in Budget 2023 is earmarked for disaster resilience and housing supply.

### Monetary Policy Stance, Framework Reviews, and Data Gaps
- Current stance and outlook:
  - Monetary policy has turned very restrictive; absence of slack suggests it is not yet time to cut rates.
  - Standard estimates of output and employment gaps indicate they are likely to remain positive into 2024, limiting scope for lowering the OCR.
  - Inflation appears to have peaked; headline inflation is moderating due to decline in prices of tradeable goods and significant monetary tightening since 2021.
- Bank health:
  - No indication that bank health has been adversely affected by rate hikes: capital and liquidity positions remain strong; asset quality and earnings have been maintained.
  - Rapid rate rises will have a contractionary impact on household consumption over the next 24 months—a period in which interest rates on more than ¾ of mortgages outstanding by value are scheduled to reset.
- Policy flexibility and recommendation:
  - If funding markets experience stress, the RBNZ can utilize macroprudential and other financial stability tools rather than change the monetary policy stance; the RBNZ should use its liquidity windows as needed.
  - A reignition of inflation pressures, including due to insufficient fiscal consolidation, would call for further monetary tightening; OCR path should be calibrated to developments.
  - Recommendation: Stats NZ could re-examine prospects for compiling a monthly inflation index, concurrently with its standard quarterly measure, to support RBNZ decision-making during exceptionally high uncertainty.
- Framework reviews:
  - The RAFIMP reviewed conduct of monetary policy in 2017-22 and recommended improving monitoring and analysis of supply shocks, interaction with fiscal policy, and strengthening communication.
  - The statutory review of the monetary policy Remit and Charter (finished June 2023) concluded the monetary policy framework remains appropriate.
  - The new Remit asks the MPC to “seek to understand and communicate” house price considerations alongside interactions between monetary and fiscal policies, financial stability implications, and risks to the RBNZ’s own financial position.
  - Data gap: Lack of a monthly CPI series is an important gap; Stats NZ is examining publishing more price data but a monthly CPI series would require additional resources.

### Housing Market, Household Debt, and Financial Sector Resilience
- Housing outlook and affordability:
  - Staff expect the housing market to stabilize by Q1 2024, representing a decline of 20 percent relative to the November 2021 peak, with a gradual recovery thereafter.
  - A borrowing-capacity approach suggests median housing prices are 50 percent above the price the median household could afford to finance with a debt service-to-income ratio of 30 percent.
  - Urgent need to expand supply, particularly in fast-growing regions.
  - Continuing reforms to the Resource Management Act (RMA) are welcome and would allow for higher density construction and better planning.
- Household liabilities and vulnerabilities:
  - Household debt peaked at 175 percent of disposable income in March 2022 and is projected to fall to 161 percent by end-2023.
  - Elevated vulnerabilities remain if households’ debt repayment capacity is severely impaired; ongoing monitoring (such as stress tests) and policy adjustments (including stronger safety nets such as the income insurance scheme) are required.
- Financial sector and macroprudential policy:
  - Credit growth peaked in November 2021 and has since slowed, driven by mortgages.
  - New mortgages approved declined on a year-on-year basis for 21 months in a row—the longest such stretch on record.
  - Financial stability indicators:
    - NPL ratio remains low at 0.5 percent as of May 2023.
    - Additional capital buffer for D-SIBs came into effect in July 2022, raising their minimum capital requirements to 10 percent; all commercial banks exceed this threshold.
  - RBNZ eased existing loan-to-value (LVR) restrictions in May 2023 and added debt-to-income (DTI) restrictions to the macroprudential toolkit in 2023, consulting before deciding settings (likely in 2024).
  - Deposit Takers Act (DTA) will provide deposit insurance up to NZ$100,000 per account, per institution once fully implemented by 2024.

### AML/CFT, Migration, Inequality, and Digitalization
- AML/CFT:
  - New Zealand’s 2nd Enhanced Follow-Up Report in May 2023 did not request re-ratings; New Zealand remains in enhanced follow-up and will report back to the FATF in June 2024.
  - Authorities implemented measures to strengthen transparency of beneficial ownership and AML/CFT supervision.
- Migration and labor supply:
  - Net migration has picked up but will take time to catch up; a rapid influx would increase labor supply and short-term demand pressures in housing and rental markets.
- Inequality and labor market integration:
  - Inequality exceeds the OECD median; Māori and Pacific peoples have persistently higher unemployment and concentration in lower income quintiles.
  - Women earn about 88 cents for each dollar that men earn across all professions.
  - Tackling inequality and labor market integration should remain a priority.
- Digital technologies:
  - New Zealand has the smallest ICT sector among OECD countries; boosting ICT development requires addressing ICT skills shortages and increasing investment.
  - The 2022 Digital Strategy for New Zealand includes 11 initiatives; the Digital Technologies Industry Transformation Plan aims to grow the digital workforce and increase under-represented group participation.

### Climate Policy, Emissions Trends, and ETS Issues
- Emissions and ETS developments:
  - The decoupling of greenhouse gas emissions and economic growth continued; GHG emissions remain below 2019 levels even as the economy recovered strongly.
  - The emissions price peaked in mid-November 2022 but declined sharply by around 36 percent in June 2023.
  - The ETS auction did not clear in March 2023 and repeated in June 2023, raising fiscal concerns for the Climate Emergency Response Fund (CERF).
  - Authorities launched a review of the ETS in June 2023; consultations close in August and final proposals and decisions are expected soon after.
- Policy actions and design:
  - June 2022: first Emissions Reduction Plan (ERP) and first 3 emissions budgets covering 2022-35 published.
  - December 2022: authorities proposed pricing agriculture emissions by pricing biogenic methane and nitrous oxide separately at the farm level.
  - Mitigation policies with ETS as centerpiece: using an average price of NZ$75 per NZ unit, the ETS is envisaged to contribute around a third of the emissions reduction over 2022-25.
  - Authorities note agriculture would default into the ETS in 2025 if no agreement is reached; they remain committed to pricing agricultural greenhouse gas emissions starting with standardized, mandatory reporting in the near term.
- Adaptation and reconstruction:
  - Preliminary estimates suggest around 700 homes (provisionally) where rebuilding after floods is not advisable; work with regional councils to ensure rebuilding is consistent with adaptation goals is underway.

### Key Quantitative Projections and Indicators (selected series as reported)
- Official cash rate (policy rate, percent, avg) projections: 5.0 (2023), 4.8 (2024), 4.3 (2025), 3.5 (2026), 2.5 (2027), 2.5 (2028).
- Current account (percent of GDP): -2.9 (2019), -1.0 (2020), -6.0 (2021), -9.0 (2022), -7.8 (2023), -6.6 (2024), -5.8 (2025), -5.2 (2026), -4.7 (2027), -3.9 (2028).
- Net international investment position: -53.7 (2019), -55.8 (2020), -46.4 (2021), -51.2 (2022), -53.1 (2023), projected -58.8 (2024) to -66.2 (2028).
- Real GDP (production): 3.1 (2019), -1.5 (2020), 6.1 (2021), 2.7 (2022), 1.1 (2023), projected 1.0 (2024), 2.1 (2025), 2.2 (2026), 2.4 (2027), 2.4 (2028).
- Consumer prices (avg, % change): 1.6 (2019), 1.7 (2020), 3.9 (2021), 7.2 (2022), 4.9 (2023), projected 2.6 (2024), 2.5 (2025), 2.3 (2026), 2.1 (2027), 2.0 (2028).
- Household debt (percent of disposable income): 169 (2019), 170 (2020), 173 (2021), 170 (2022), 156 (2023), 147 (2024), 143 (2025), 141 (2026), 140 (2027), 126 (2028).
- Interest payments (percent of disposable income): 8.0 (2019), 6.0 (2020), 5.0 (2021), 8.4 (2022), 9.4 (2023), projected 8.3 (2024), 8.4 (2025), 7.0 (2026), 6.5 (2027), 6.5 (2028).
- Financial soundness indicators:
  - Regulatory capital to risk-weighted assets: 14.4 (2019), 15.2 (2020), 16.2 (2021), 15.4 (2022), 15.0 (2023).
  - Non-performing loans to total loans: 0.6 (2019), 0.6 (2020), 0.4 (2021), 0.4 (2022), 0.5 (2023).
  - Return on assets: 0.8 (2019), 0.9 (2020), 1.0 (2021), 1.1 (2022), 1.0 (2023).

### Staff Appraisal and Consolidated Policy Recommendations
- Macroeconomic guidance:
  - Fiscal policy should prioritize reconstruction post weather events without unduly adding to demand.
  - Limit discretionary spending to reduce inflation pressures; prioritize careful budget execution via reprioritization and identification of cost savings.
  - The planned fiscal consolidation over the medium term should be preserved and frontloaded to reduce demand pressures.
- Monetary policy guidance:
  - Rapid tightening is starting to cool the economy and lower inflation; the output gap is projected to remain positive into 2024 so there is little scope to lower the OCR at this juncture.
  - If new data confirm a durable downward path of inflation, a pause in tightening could be warranted; a reignition of demand or stalled inflation above target would call for further tightening.
  - Greater recognition of fiscal–monetary interaction is needed.
- Financial stability and housing:
  - Financial stresses from monetary tightening should be addressed through financial stability tools; RBNZ should monitor household and financial balance sheets and be ready to provide liquidity if funding markets come under stress.
  - Housing affordability remains a concern; expand supply including social housing and pursue land, planning and construction reforms to improve long-term affordability.

*Source: 1nzlea2023001 - IMF staff report excerpts.*

### 2023. The mission team comprised Evan Papageorgiou (h ead),

### BOTTOMING OUT AMID HIGH INFLATION

### Context and Recent Developments
- New Zealand’s economy is now in a recession after a strong post-pandemic recovery:
  - Recovered by 10 percent since the middle of 2020.
  - Real GDP declined by 0.1 percent q/q (SA) in 2023Q1, following a 0.7 percent decline in 2022Q4 GDP.
- Inflation and labor market:
  - CPI inflation at 6.7 percent in 2023Q1, above the RBNZ’s 1–3 target range.
  - Labor markets tight with record high labor force participation and historically low unemployment and underemployment.
  - Wage pressures concentrated in services and construction.
- Natural disasters and fiscal impact:
  - North Island weather events (Auckland flash floods and Cyclone Gabrielle) added inflationary pressures.
  - Damages from the North Island weather events are estimated to be NZ$9–14.5 billion.
  - Gross public debt at 45 percent of GDP; substantial fiscal space remains.
- Monetary policy and financial conditions:
  - RBNZ raised the official cash rate (OCR) by 525 bps cumulatively (including a 25 bps increase in May).
  - Wholesale and retail interest rates have risen significantly since mid-2021; longer-term rates now below OCR and short-term rates.
  - RBNZ continues to shrink LSAP holdings through off-market operations with Treasury.
- External sector and housing:
  - Current account deficit expanded rapidly, driven by a large output gap, strong domestic economy, expansionary fiscal policy, and one-off COVID import factors.
  - House prices peaked in November 2021 and have fallen by around 13 percent relative to the peak.
  - Rental market remains tight; affordability (mortgage interest payments relative to income) has worsened.
  - Around half of mortgages in New Zealand are fixed for less than 1 year and will reset over the next 12 months.
  - May 2023 Financial Stability Report indicated an increase in household loan delinquency rates, but not for mortgages.

### Outlook: Ongoing Low Growth and an Uncertain Inflation Path
- Growth and inflation projections:
  - Staff expect growth to slow to around 1 percent y/y in 2023 and 2024.
  - Inflation is likely to decline gradually, coming into the 1–3 percent target range only in 2025.
  - Unemployment is expected to rise to 5 percent by 2024.
- Drivers of near-term performance:
  - Slowdown led by weakness in domestic private demand (consumption and investment).
  - Some boost from reconstruction activity and recovery in tourism; higher goods imports related to reconstruction needs.
  - Net migration has picked up and should further alleviate labor market tightness, though the net demand effect is unclear.
- Uncertainty:
  - Outlook remains highly uncertain given stickiness of nontradeable prices and external developments.

### Risks and Alternative Scenario
- Key risk categories:
  - External environment shocks (global growth, geo-economic fragmentation, financial stability shocks).
  - Policy missteps and lack of coordination (monetary policy miscalibration domestically and abroad).
  - Domestic housing market disruptions due to high household debt and banks’ high exposure to housing.
- Downside alternative scenario:
  - Persistent high inflation and rapid wage growth could force RBNZ to tighten further or keep rates high for longer.
  - Tighter financial conditions could create disorderly housing market conditions, amplifying household distress and banking system risks, prolonging or deepening a recession.
  - Rate rises will trigger pockets of household distress, particularly among lower income borrowers and recent purchasers near the housing cycle peak.
- Upside risks:
  - Rising net migration could ease labor constraints and potentially speed return of inflation to target.
- Authorities’ views:
  - Authorities broadly agreed with staff’s assessment and noted downside risks.
  - Authorities project a marginally faster decline in inflation and the current account deficit than staff but acknowledged wide outcome ranges.
  - New Zealand’s net foreign liabilities remain just under 50 percent of GDP.

### Policies for Sustainable Growth — Overview
- Policy stance:
  - Fiscal-monetary mix should retain a restrictive bias to rebalance the economy internally and externally while relying on automatic stabilizers.
  - Monetary policy has appropriately turned tight to address risks of high and prolonged inflation.
  - New discretionary spending without offsets will work against monetary tightening and delay fiscal consolidation.
- Structural priorities:
  - Fiscal policy should prioritize addressing overheating while managing short-term demand pressures.
  - With prioritization, fiscal policy should also address long-term needs: closing productivity gaps and climate-related investments.
  - Systemic assessment shows housing and household-related vulnerabilities have declined slightly since 2022 but remain elevated.

### A Need for Fiscal Consolidation Amid High Cost of Living and Reconstruction
- FY2023/24 fiscal stance and measures:
  - Operating allowances increased in Budget 2023 to NZ$4.8 billion per year (1.1 percent of average GDP).
  - Additional NZ$1.1 billion toward infrastructure reconstruction and capital expenditure in FY2023/24.
  - National Resilience Plan established with NZ$6 billion over 10 years for asset repair and replacement.
  - Several new spending and cost-of-living initiatives (e.g., extension of early childhood education, scrapping prescription co-payments, extending free public transport to children and half-price fares to young adults, lowering energy bills for lower income households).
- Fiscal outcomes and near-term path:
  - Identified savings and reprioritization netted off only a small share of new spending initiatives.
  - General government cyclically adjusted primary balance (CAPB) expected at -4.4 percent of potential GDP for FY2023/24.
  - Fiscal impulse of 1.8 percent of potential GDP for FY2023/24.
  - Fiscal consolidation projected to begin from FY2025/26; CAPB will turn positive in the medium term.
- Staff recommendations for fiscal execution:
  - Prioritize productive and cost-efficient post-disaster reconstruction and climate adaptation projects that provide high positive externalities.
  - Frontload fiscal consolidation while prioritizing reconstruction without unduly adding to demand.
  - New spending initiatives should identify cost savings and reductions in public consumption.
  - Cost-of-living support should be targeted and temporary, better focused on vulnerable households and viable businesses using means testing.
  - These measures will reduce demand, support monetary policy in achieving price stability, and allow automatic stabilizers to function countercyclically.

*International Monetary Fund staff report (excerpt).*

### 13.      Tax reforms should remain a priority to improve efficiency, equity, and sustainability

### 13.      Tax reforms should remain a priority to improve efficiency, equity, and sustainability

### Tax policy findings and recommendations
- New Zealand has adequate overall revenue and suitably-broad tax bases, but the role of the tax system in economic policy needs reconsideration.
- The tax preference design merits careful debate.
- Enhancing tax revenue options (for example, by introducing capital and land value taxes) would yield fairer and more equitable tax revenue outcomes, given that capital gains tend to accrue to wealthier households.
- Reforming the corporate income tax would:
  - boost business investment,
  - encourage entry of new businesses,
  - lead to higher productivity growth, and
  - produce more efficient revenue outturns that do not crowd out investment.
- Address the tradeoff posed by higher inflation and ad-hoc cost-of-living adjustments that counteract fiscal drag:
  - Periodically (or systemically) raising income brackets can limit distributional implications of inflation, especially for lower income and vulnerable households, and partly limit the need for more transfers.

### Fiscal rules, debt ceiling, and disaster resilience
- Reinstated fiscal rules: a net core Crown debt ceiling of 50 percent of GDP and fiscal surpluses are described as well calibrated (Annex VII) to ensure sufficient buffers.
- Footnote: The debt ceiling is equal to 30 percent of GDP when excluding the New Zealand Superannuation Fund.
- Recommendation: Given New Zealand’s exposure to climate shocks, natural disaster costs should be explicitly incorporated into the Budget framework.

### Public investment, infrastructure gaps, and aging
- Long-term fiscal challenges from large infrastructure gaps and aging underscore need for strategic public investment in the medium term.
- Adoption of a “golden-rule” style operating balance is appropriate to support borrowing for long-term investments which grow capital stock.
  - Footnote: A “golden-rule” style operating balance means that operating expenses (including day-to-day consumption and transfer payments) are paid out of operating revenues. This approach supports intergenerational equity; long-term investments lead to future generations receiving both an asset and a liability.
- Policymakers need a pipeline of projects with clearly defined goals and tradeoffs to help financing and delivery of infrastructure.
- Reconstruction post-North Island weather events provides a chance to strengthen infrastructure resilience and bridge infrastructure gaps.
- Expected higher spending on pension and healthcare from aging demographics implies:
  - continued medium-term investment in reforming the health system by creating a national health service to replace existing district health boards,
  - capital expenditure to boost physical health infrastructure,
  - superannuation reforms to address intertemporal challenges of funding public pension payments from current revenues while the taxpayer base is affected by the aging population.

### Authorities’ views on fiscal stance and tax bases
- Authorities view a frontloaded fiscal expansion with backloaded consolidation as appropriate to respond to New Zealand’s needs.
- Planned spending for FY2023/24 is considered necessary given rebuilding needs after North Island weather events, new cost-of-living measures, and funding of cost pressures.
- Authorities agreed with staff on need for a tighter stance in line with fiscal rules and expect consolidation will be achieved in the forecast period (four years).
- On tax reforms:
  - Authorities acknowledged potential fiscal and integrity benefits to new tax bases (such as capital gains) but noted economic trade-offs and that accessing new tax bases is not on the tax policy work program at this time.
  - They pointed to New Zealand’s comparatively broad tax base, the introduction of a new top personal income tax rate in 2021, and the increase in the trustee tax rate announced in Budget 2023.
- Authorities agreed on need to bridge infrastructure gaps; new capital expenditure in Budget 2023 is earmarked for boosting disaster resilience and housing supply.

### Monetary policy stance and inflation outlook
- Monetary policy has turned very restrictive; absence of slack suggests it is not yet time to cut rates.
- Standard estimates of output and employment gaps indicate they are likely to remain positive into 2024, limiting scope for lowering the OCR.
- Inflation appears to have peaked; headline inflation is moderating due to a decline in prices of tradeable goods (particularly global fuel prices) and the impact of significant monetary tightening since 2021.
- No indication that bank health has been adversely affected by rate hikes: capital and liquidity positions remain strong; asset quality and earnings have been maintained.
- Rapid rate rises to date will have a contractionary impact on household consumption over the next 24 months—a period in which interest rates on more than ¾ of mortgages outstanding by value are scheduled to reset—potentially affecting household balance sheets.
- Policy flexibility:
  - If funding markets experience stress, the RBNZ can utilize macroprudential and other financial stability tools rather than change the monetary policy stance; the RBNZ should use its liquidity windows as needed.
- A reignition of inflation pressures, including due to insufficient fiscal consolidation, would call for further monetary tightening:
  - The OCR path should be calibrated to developments in the economy, including external shocks and fiscal and other policy responses.
  - Shocks that directly impact inflation or spur a pick-up in domestic demand (such as a slower pace of fiscal consolidation than envisaged in the baseline) would require reassessment of the tightening path, including reverting to a more aggressive pattern of increases, to put inflation durably on a path to the RBNZ’s 1–3 percent target.
- Recommendation: Stats NZ could re-examine prospects for compiling a monthly inflation index, concurrently with its standard quarterly measure, to support RBNZ decision-making during exceptionally high uncertainty.

### Monetary policy framework reviews and data gaps
- The RBNZ undertook two reviews of its monetary policy framework in 2022-23 (Annex VIII).
  - The RAFIMP reviewed conduct of monetary policy in 2017-22 and recommended improving monitoring and analysis of supply shocks, interaction with fiscal policy, and strengthening communication.
  - The statutory review of the monetary policy Remit and Charter (finished June 2023) concluded the monetary policy framework remains appropriate.
- The new Remit:
  - Notes the pursuit of monetary policy objectives to financial stability and seeks to avoid unnecessary volatility in output, interest rates and the exchange rate.
  - Asks the MPC to “seek to understand and communicate” house price considerations alongside interactions between monetary and fiscal policies, financial stability implications of monetary policy decisions, and risks to the RBNZ’s own financial position.
- Data gap: Lack of a monthly CPI series is an important gap that holds back timelier formulation and assessment of monetary policy; Stats NZ is examining publishing more price data but a monthly CPI series would require additional resources.
- A review of the financial resources of the RBNZ is ongoing.

### Housing market, household debt, and systemic risk
- Staff expect the housing market to stabilize by Q1 2024, representing a decline of 20 percent relative to the November 2021 peak, with a gradual recovery thereafter.
- Household liabilities trajectory:
  - Household debt peaked at 175 percent of disposable income in March 2022 and is projected to fall to 161 percent by end-2023.
- Near-term adjustment will weigh on household consumption and GDP growth, but longer-term financial resilience should strengthen.
- Elevated vulnerabilities remain if households’ debt repayment capacity is severely impaired (for example, via a marked and prolonged increase in unemployment); ongoing monitoring (such as stress tests) and policy adjustments (including stronger safety nets such as the income insurance scheme) are required.

### Housing affordability and supply-side reforms
- Housing affordability remains a near-term concern despite price declines; higher mortgage rates have raised mortgage payments and hampered affordability.
- A borrowing-capacity approach suggests median housing prices are 50 percent above the price the median household could afford to finance with a debt service-to-income ratio of 30 percent.
- In 2022 this measure rose to the same level as before the global financial crisis as interest rates increased and is expected to remain elevated.
- Urgent need to expand supply, particularly in fast-growing regions.
- Continuing reforms to the Resource Management Act (RMA), with the introduction of the Natural and Built Environment and the Spatial Planning bills in parliament in 2022, are welcome and would allow for higher density construction and better planning for climate change and natural disasters.

### Financial sector resilience and macroprudential policy
- Credit growth:
  - Growth in overall credit outstanding peaked in November 2021 and has since slowed, driven by slowdown in mortgages.
  - New mortgages approved declined on a year-on-year basis for 21 months in a row—the longest such stretch on record.
- Financial stability indicators remain strong:
  - Non-performing loan (NPL) ratio remains low at 0.5 percent as of May 2023.
  - Banks remain well-capitalized and liquid; profitability is close to historical norms.
  - Additional capital buffer for domestic systemically important banks (D-SIBs) came into effect in July 2022, raising their minimum capital requirements to 10 percent; all commercial banks in New Zealand exceed this threshold.
- Banking system stress tests:
  - The November 2022 RBNZ stress test showed loan impairments would rise significantly, but the banking system would be able to meet regulatory capital minimums, though D-SIBs could face difficulties meeting their higher capital requirements.
  - Footnote: The stress test considered a stagflation scenario combining an economic downturn, sharp asset price corrections, high interest rates due to lingering inflation and a 1-in-25-year cyber event.
- Structure of bank capital: Tier-1 capital is almost entirely composed of common equity; additional Tier-1 instruments play a small role.
- Funding exposures: New Zealand banks and customers report very small exposures to US banks at the center of recent volatility; funding appears unaffected so far.
- Macroprudential policy stance:
  - Slowing credit growth and falling house prices suggest tightening macroprudential restrictions is not called for at this time.
  - Falling house prices and decline in new mortgage approvals allowed the RBNZ to ease existing loan-to-value (LVR) restrictions in May 2023; the easing is an appropriate countercyclical application, though restrictions remain tighter than pre-pandemic settings.
  - RBNZ expanded its macroprudential toolkit to add debt-to-income restrictions (DTIs) in 2023 and is consulting before deciding when and at what level they might be introduced, likely in 2024.
  - Financial sector policies focus on medium- to long-term issues, including enacting and implementing the new Deposit Takers Act (DTA), which would provide deposit insurance for up to NZ$100,000 per account, per institution once fully implemented by 2024.

*Source: 1nzlea2023001 - 13.      Tax reforms should remain a priority to improve efficiency, equity, and sustainability*

### 26.      New Zealand continues to strengthen its AML/CFT framework. New Zealand’s 2nd

### 1nzlea2023001 - 26.      New Zealand continues to strengthen its AML/CFT framework. New Zealand’s 2nd

### AML/CFT framework and correspondent banking
- New Zealand’s 2nd Enhanced Follow-Up Report in May 2023 did not request re-ratings of technical compliance with the FATF standard.
- New Zealand remains in enhanced follow-up and will report back to the FATF in June 2024.
- Authorities have implemented legislative and operational changes to strengthen technical compliance and effectiveness, including measures to strengthen transparency of beneficial ownership information and AML/CFT supervision.
- New Zealand continues to express concern about loss of correspondent banking relationships (CBRs) among the Pacific Island Countries (PICs).
- The Reserve Bank of New Zealand (RBNZ) examined options to set up safe payment corridors but has ceased most work, noting a collaborative international approach is needed; authorities reaffirmed New Zealand’s commitment to support such efforts.

*Authorities’ Views related to housing and financial stability are summarized below.*

### Housing market, affordability, and related policy actions
- Recent house price falls are in part due to higher interest rates but only partially reverse very large increases of recent years; affordability remains a significant concern, especially for affordable rental housing for low-income households.
- A comprehensive approach is underway, including reform of the RMA and actions in the National Policy Statement on Urban Development.
- Authorities emphasized commitment to invest in social housing, including via greater allocation under Budget 2023.
- NZ$ 100,000 deposit insurance limit is estimated to fully protect 93 percent of depositors in New Zealand.

### Financial system stability and macroprudential measures
- Authorities concurred the financial system remains stable: banks’ strong capital and liquidity positions and strong labor market conditions have kept credit defaults low.
- RBNZ will closely monitor the system in light of slowing growth, rapid tightening of financial conditions and elevated international uncertainty.
- Retail interest rates have surpassed rates that 2020 and 2021 borrowers were stress tested for, but mortgage arrears remain lower than pre-COVID levels and risk of widespread default is considered low.
- Debt-to-income (DTI) has been added to the macroprudential toolkit; RBNZ is establishing long-run settings alongside LVR restrictions.
- With the enactment of the DTA in July 2023, authorities have started preparing to implement the new regulatory regime for deposit takers and the depositor compensation scheme.
- Staff appraisal: with slowing credit growth and falling house prices, additional macroprudential measures are not called for at this time; the RBNZ should stand ready to provide liquidity if funding markets come under stress.

### Inequality and labor market integration (Fixing Today’s Problems)
- Inequality in New Zealand exceeds the OECD median; Māori and Pacific peoples have persistently higher unemployment than the national average and are concentrated in the lowest and second lowest household income quintiles.
- Women earn about 88 cents for each dollar that men earn across all professions.
- The minimum wage has become more binding over time and does not appear to conclusively reduce pay inequities across ethnicities; pass-through of the minimum wage to men is higher than women.
- Tackling inequality and labor market integration should remain a priority.

### Migration and labor supply
- Return of migrants can help alleviate labor supply shortages after pandemic border closures removed migrant labor.
- Net migration has picked up in recent months but will take time to catch up due to a global shortage of skilled migrants and competition among countries.
- A rapid influx of immigrants will increase labor supply but will also add to demand pressures in the short term, particularly in housing and rental markets; the net demand effect is not immediately clear.

### Digital technologies and productivity
- New Zealand has the smallest ICT sector among OECD countries despite having the highest labor productivity growth compared to other sectors.
- Limited use of advanced technologies among firms constrains productivity spillovers.
- Boosting ICT development requires tackling chronic ICT skills shortages and increasing investment in digital innovation above current moderate levels.
- The 2022 Digital Strategy for New Zealand includes 11 initiatives (cyber security, improving rural connectivity, Digital Technologies Industry Transformation Plan, etc.) aiming to improve digital inclusion through skills training, reduced infrastructure costs, and access to non-digital government services.
- Authorities expect the Digital Technologies Industry Transformation Plan to help grow the digital workforce, address labor shortages and skills mismatches, and increase under-represented group participation (Māori, Pacific Peoples, women, disabled people).

### Infrastructure, resilience to natural disasters, and spending priorities
- New Zealand has historical infrastructure deficits and exposure to natural disaster shocks necessitating further infrastructure spending; infrastructure gaps are estimated to be around NZ$104 billion (Sense Partners, 2021).
- Planned infrastructure spending post Cyclone Gabrielle is necessary but should prioritize resilience and adaptation to climate shocks and address being significantly backloaded.
- Efficient spending should be prioritized and further allocated towards the construction sector to boost resilience and capacity; improved planning, sequencing, and a clear pipeline of investments are needed to overcome supply bottlenecks and ensure timelier project implementation.
- Labor policies should prioritize alleviating labor shortages.

### Greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, ETS developments, and climate policy
- Economic activity and GHG emissions continue to decouple; GHG emissions remain below 2019 levels even as the economy recovered strongly.
- The gap between projected emissions and targets narrowed; the 2050 target is now expected to be fully met even under the ambitious reductions target for biogenic methane.
- The emissions price peaked in mid-November 2022 but declined sharply by around 36 percent in June 2023.
- As a result, the Emissions Trading Scheme (ETS) auction did not clear for the first time in March 2023 and repeated in June 2023.
- Factors cited for the price correction: uncertainty about the government’s commitment to climate goals, impact of higher emissions prices on inflation, and concerns about oversupply of units (including from afforestation).
- Auction underperformance raises fiscal concerns because auction proceeds are intended for the Climate Emergency Response Fund (CERF).
- Authorities launched a review of the ETS in June 2023 to strengthen the mechanism and sought public feedback on options to increase demand and lower supply of credits; consultations close in August and final proposals and decisions are expected soon after.

### Recent climate policy actions and design considerations
- In June 2022, New Zealand published the first Emissions Reduction Plan (ERP) and the first 3 emissions budgets covering 2022-35.
- The National Adaptation Plan was released in August 2022.
- In December 2022, authorities proposed pricing agriculture emissions by pricing biogenic methane and nitrous oxide separately at the farm level and recycling levies to support mitigation efforts.
- The full impact depends on how quickly prices rise to levels consistent with agriculture emissions targets.
- To address the cost-of-living crisis, authorities largely reduced incentives for zero emissions vehicles, temporarily cut the fuel excise and road user charges, delayed a biofuels mandate and introduced discounted public transit fares in 2022; the fuel excise cuts expired from July 2023.
- Mitigation policies with ETS as centerpiece: using an average price of NZ$75 per NZ unit, the ETS is envisaged to contribute around a third of the emissions reduction over 2022-25.
- A more ambitious price scenario could close the gap to targets more quickly; price-based framework should be strengthened (including pricing agriculture emissions and ensuring ETS supports gross emissions reductions) and complemented by green public investment and sector-specific measures.
- Authorities note domestic legislation specifies agriculture would default into the ETS in 2025 if no agreement is reached; they remain committed to pricing agricultural greenhouse gas emissions starting with standardized, mandatory reporting in the near term.
- Preliminary estimates suggest around 700 homes (provisionally) where rebuilding after floods is not advisable; work with regional councils to ensure rebuilding is consistent with adaptation goals is underway.

### Staff appraisal and policy recommendations
- Macroeconomic outlook:
  - New Zealand’s economy is in a policy-induced slowdown; bulk of monetary tightening impact will be felt in 2023 and 2024.
  - Inflation is likely to decline gradually to the 1–3 percent target range only in 2025 given the pick-up in non-tradeable inflation.
  - The current account deficit is high; New Zealand’s external position in 2022 was weaker than implied by medium-term fundamentals and desirable policies but partly reflects post-pandemic import boost and foregone education and tourism exports.
- Fiscal policy guidance:
  - Fiscal policy should prioritize reconstruction post weather events without unduly adding to demand.
  - Limit discretionary spending to reduce inflation pressures; prioritize careful budget execution via reprioritization (e.g., planned reduction in personnel expenses) and identification of cost savings.
  - Measures to defray higher cost of living should be better targeted to vulnerable households using means testing where possible.
  - The planned fiscal consolidation over the medium term should be preserved and frontloaded to reduce demand pressures.
- Monetary policy guidance:
  - Rapid tightening is starting to cool the economy and lower inflation; the output gap is projected to remain positive into 2024 so there is little scope to lower the OCR at this juncture.
  - If new data confirm durable downward path of inflation, a pause in tightening could be warranted; a reignition of demand or stalled inflation above target would call for further tightening.
  - Greater recognition of fiscal–monetary interaction is needed.
- Financial stability:
  - Financial stresses from monetary tightening should be addressed through financial stability tools; RBNZ should monitor household and financial balance sheets and be ready to provide liquidity if funding markets come under stress.
- Housing supply:
  - Housing affordability remains a concern; expand supply including social housing.
  - Long-term affordability depends on freeing up land supply, improving planning and zoning, fostering infrastructure investment to enable fast-track housing developments, and reducing construction costs and delays.

*Source: IMF staff report excerpts for New Zealand (content unit 1nzlea2023001).*

### 44.      The decoupling of greenhouse gas emissions and economic growth continued,

### The decoupling of greenhouse gas emissions and economic growth continued

### Emissions trends and risks
- The decoupling of greenhouse gas emissions and economic growth continued, narrowing the gap between projected emissions and targets.
- The sharp decline in the emissions price could put the emissions targets and financing for needed investment at risk and should be addressed urgently.
- The decision to allow the cuts in fuel duties and excise to expire from July 2023 is welcome because the cuts were costly and would have resulted in higher demand for fossil fuels, leaving emissions higher than in the baseline if made permanent.

### Climate goals, planning, and gaps
- The Emissions Reduction Plan and National Adaptation Plan provide a useful high-level view of climate goals and targets.
- These plans should be complemented with more detail on targets and costs to enable the prioritization of policies.

### Public investment and structural policies
- Efforts to enhance and improve public investment should continue, and structural policies should promote durable growth.
- Long-term challenges highlighted include large infrastructure deficits, climate change, and ageing demographics, underscoring the need for further public investment.
- Priorities for public investment and policy:
  - Delivering high value infrastructure, including transport and housing.
  - Strengthening resilience against natural disasters.
  - Tax reforms to broaden the tax base to other more progressive sources, such as capital gains and land taxes, to help align tax collection with long-term economic priorities.
  - Boosting digitalization and development of the information and communications technology sector to improve productivity.

*Source: 1nzlea2023001 - 44. The decoupling of greenhouse gas emissions and economic growth continued*

### 46.      It is recommended that the next Article IV consultation be held on the standard 12-

### 1nzlea2023001 - 46.      It is recommended that the next Article IV consultation be held on the standard 12-

### Rapid Recovery After the Pandemic (Figure 1)
- Real GDP growth "bounced back after the pandemic" despite a recent slowdown; recovery driven by strong demand from government, private consumption, and investment.
- Business sentiment is weak, though business investment "has held up so far."
- Household consumption has held up, while net wealth "has declined significantly given correction in housing."
- Labor markets described as "historically tight"; resource pressures "are however extreme" and "will take time to correct despite the recent pickup in immigration as borders reopen."

### Monetary Conditions and Inflation (Figure 2)
- Headline inflation "has risen rapidly, well above the target band."
- Short-term inflation expectations "may be peaking and long-term ones are in check."
- Hourly earnings "rebounded recently" with strong increases particularly in services and construction.
- Wage growth expectations remain high.
- Short-term rates have risen alongside the OCR; longer-term rates "stabilized at lower levels."
- Interest rate context (selected values shown in figures and tables):
  - Official cash rate (policy rate, percent, avg) projections: 5.0 (2023), 4.8 (2024), 4.3 (2025), 3.5 (2026), 2.5 (2027), 2.5 (2028).
  - 90-day bank bill rate: 1.5 (2019), 0.5 (2020), 0.5 (2021), 4.5 (2022), 5.2 (2023).

### Current Account and External Sector (Figure 3; Table 3)
- Current account has deteriorated: Current account (percent of GDP) series: -2.9 (2019), -1.0 (2020), -6.0 (2021), -9.0 (2022), -7.8 (2023), -6.6 (2024), -5.8 (2025), -5.2 (2026), -4.7 (2027), -3.9 (2028).
- Deterioration reflects higher international prices and overheating; surge in import volumes, particularly services.
- Services exports (tourism and education) "have driven the weakness in overall exports" despite a recent pickup.
- Exports and imports (percent of GDP):
  - Exports of goods and services: 27.4 (2019), 24.0 (2020), 22.0 (2021), 23.8 (2022), 23.7 (2023).
  - Imports of goods and services: 27.4 (2019), 22.9 (2020), 25.3 (2021), 29.7 (2022), 29.4 (2023).
- Net international investment position: -53.7 (2019), -55.8 (2020), -46.4 (2021), -51.2 (2022), -53.1 (2023), projected -58.8 (2024) to -66.2 (2028).

### Fiscal Position and Projections (Figure 4; Table 2)
- Expenditure projected to grow due to post-Cyclone reconstruction needs, leading to slower consolidation in the medium term.
- Discretionary flood-related support measures expected to loosen fiscal policy, leading to an expansionary stance in FY2023/24.
- Government debt ratio projected to stabilize after peaking in the medium term and "is expected to remain low compared to other advanced economies."
- Key fiscal numbers (percent of GDP):
  - Revenue: 37.8 (2019), 36.2 (2020), 37.7 (2021), 39.3 (2022), 39.0 (2023), projected 38.6 (2024), 39.6 (2025), 40.1 (2026), 40.2 (2027), 40.4 (2028).
  - Expenditure: 36.6 (2019), 42.5 (2020), 40.1 (2021), 43.9 (2022), 41.6 (2023), projected 42.9 (2024), 42.4 (2025), 41.8 (2026), 41.2 (2027), 40.4 (2028).
  - Net lending/borrowing: 1.3 (2019), 1.2 (2020), -6.2 (2021), -2.5 (2022), -4.6 (2023), projected -2.6 (2024), -4.2 (2025), -2.8 (2026), -1.6 (2027), -0.9 (2028), 0.0 (2028 in Table 1 projection).
  - Gross debt: 26.2 (2019), 38.5 (2020), 46.0 (2021), 48.6 (2022), 44.6 (2023), projected 48.1 (2024), 51.3 (2025), 53.0 (2026), 51.0 (2027), 48.7 (2028).
- Cyclically adjusted primary balance (percent of potential GDP): 2.4 (2019), 2.3 (2020), -3.9 (2021), -2.3 (2022), -4.1 (2023), projected -2.6 (2024), -4.4 (2025), -2.2 (2026), -0.1 (2027), 1.6 (2028), 2.6 (2028 as listed in Table 1).

### Housing Market Correction (Figure 5)
- House prices are correcting but remain above pre-pandemic levels and show signs of bottoming out.
- Sentiment appears to be bottoming out with expectations of a modest price recovery in 2025.
- Sales volumes have declined sharply and remain low; rents have rebounded and are increasing rapidly.
- Residential investment volatile amid declining building consents.

### Household Debt and Balance Sheet Risks (Figure 6; Table 1)
- House prices increased strongly by international comparison.
- Household debt remains elevated; debt servicing ratio has started rising.
- Household debt rising relative to assets due to falling house prices and drawdown of savings.
- High debt-to-income loans now account for a smaller share of new loans among all borrowers.
- High loan-to-value ratio (LVR) trend: downward overall but picking up in first-time homebuyer segment; share of outstanding interest-only loans stabilized below pre-pandemic level.
- Household debt (percent of disposable income) series in Table 1: 169 (2019), 170 (2020), 173 (2021), 170 (2022), 156 (2023), 147 (2024), 143 (2025), 141 (2026), 140 (2027), 126 (2028).
- Interest payments (percent of disposable income): 8.0 (2019), 6.0 (2020), 5.0 (2021), 8.4 (2022), 9.4 (2023), projected 8.3 (2024), 8.4 (2025), 7.0 (2026), 6.5 (2027), 6.5 (2028).

### Financial Stability and Banking Sector (Figure 7; Table 5)
- Banks maintain capital in excess of new capital requirements even as new requirements are phased in; profitability remains close to historical norms.
- Core funding ratio "well above the regulatory minimum."
- Household credit slowing while deposits shifting away from transaction balances.
- Banks are tapping the domestic market to meet wholesale funding needs; net offshore funding has turned negative.
- Banks’ exposure to the housing sector continues to increase.
- Financial soundness indicators (selected):
  - Regulatory capital to risk-weighted assets: 14.4 (2019), 15.2 (2020), 16.2 (2021), 15.4 (2022), 15.0 (2023).
  - Non-performing loans to total loans: 0.6 (2019), 0.6 (2020), 0.4 (2021), 0.4 (2022), 0.5 (2023).
  - Return on assets: 0.8 (2019), 0.9 (2020), 1.0 (2021), 1.1 (2022), 1.0 (2023).
  - Core funding ratio: 86.8 (2019), 88.5 (2020), 89.1 (2021), 91.2 (2022), 89.7 (2023).

### Inequality, Education, and Social Indicators (Figure 8)
- Inequality described as a long-standing issue, persistently affecting ethnic groups in New Zealand and contributing to income inequality across genders.
- Tertiary education levels have increased; public expenditure towards education grows.
- Gini coefficient context: New Zealand appears among countries listed (figure), with "Latest available data, 2017-2019."
- Household disposable income by ethnicity and quintiles shown in figures (exact series and category labels preserved in source visuals).

### Main Economic Indicators and Projections (Table 1)
- Real GDP (production): 3.1 (2019), -1.5 (2020), 6.1 (2021), 2.7 (2022), 1.1 (2023), projected 1.0 (2024), 2.1 (2025), 2.2 (2026), 2.4 (2027), 2.4 (2028).
- Private consumption: 3.2 (2019), -2.2 (2020), 7.9 (2021), 2.9 (2022), -0.5 (2023), projected -2.2 (2024), 1.9 (2025), 2.3 (2026), 2.3 (2027), 2.2 (2028).
- Investment (percent of GDP): 24.0 (2019), 22.2 (2020), 25.2 (2021), 26.6 (2022), 26.6 (2023), projected 26.4 (2024), 26.1 (2025), 25.9 (2026), 25.8 (2027), 26.0 (2028).
- Consumer prices (avg, % change): 1.6 (2019), 1.7 (2020), 3.9 (2021), 7.2 (2022), 4.9 (2023), projected 2.6 (2024), 2.5 (2025), 2.3 (2026), 2.1 (2027), 2.0 (2028).
- Employment and unemployment: Employment growth 1.3 (2019), 1.3 (2020), 2.2 (2021), 1.7 (2022), 1.4 (2023); Unemployment (percent of labor force, ann. average) 4.1 (2019), 4.6 (2020), 3.8 (2021), 3.3 (2022), 3.8 (2023), projected 5.0 (2024), 4.6 (2025), 4.5 (2026), 4.5 (2027), 4.4 (2028).

### Monetary and Financial Sector Aggregates (Table 4)
- Broad money levels: 326 (2019), 366 (2020), 392 (2021), 399 (2022), 416 (2023), projected 417 (2024), 435 (2025), 456 (2026), 478 (2027), 499 (2028) (in billions of NZ$).
- Private sector credit (memo series, levels and percent change reported in table): private sector credit levels 477 (2019), 496 (2020), 526 (2021), 549 (2022), 554 (2023), projected 556 (2024), 572 (2025), 592 (2026), 616 (2027), 642 (2028) (in billions of NZ$); percent change series also provided.

### Select Policy-Relevant Observations and Implications (sourced from figures/tables)
- Monetary policy has tightened materially (OCR and short-term rates up) in response to inflation rising "well above the target band"; longer-term rates have been more stable.
- Fiscal stance is projected to loosen in FY2023/24 (discretionary flood-related/flood reconstruction support) and consolidation is expected to proceed more slowly in the medium term.
- External imbalances widened sharply in 2021–22 driven by import volumes and services dynamics; current account deficits persist in projections through 2028.
- Household balance sheet vulnerabilities: household debt elevated (household debt percent of disposable income peaked around 173 in 2021), rising debt servicing, and falling house prices contribute to elevated balance-sheet risk.
- Banking sector remains well-capitalized with robust liquidity and core funding metrics, but exposure to housing continues to increase.

*Source: Authorities' data and IMF staff estimates and projections (content unit: 1nzlea2023001).*

### Annex I. Past Recommendations (2022 Article IV Consultation)

### Annex I. Past Recommendations (2022 Article IV Consultation)

### Monetary Policy
- Recommendation: Monetary policy should remain data dependent, and continued, swift policy normalization will be appropriate under baseline conditions.
- Authority action: The RBNZ tightened monetary policy aggressively to address the above-target inflation, raising the OCR by 525 bps cumulatively.

### Fiscal Policy
- Recommendations:
  - Tightening of fiscal policy is appropriate, and the fiscal stance should be calibrated to evolution of the pandemic and economic conditions.
  - Remove fuel excise duty reduction.
  - Authorities should update their fiscal targets to provide an anchor for fiscal policy and manage long-term spending pressures needed for promoting long-term growth.
- Authority actions and outcomes:
  - Fiscal policy contracted in FY2022/23, as reprioritized expenditure partly offset costs from the early-2023 natural disasters.
  - Fuel excise duty reduction expired in June 2023.
  - New fiscal rules mandate that the operating balance before gains and losses returns to a small surplus over time, while the net core crown debt remains below 50 percent of GDP.

### Housing and Financial Sector
- Recommendations:
  - Continued focus is needed on addressing housing imbalances.
  - Increasing the stock of social housing remains important as a durable solution to housing affordability is achieved over time by addressing supply constraints.
  - Raising bank capital requirements and enlarging the MPM toolkit will help the system weather future shocks.
- Authority actions and developments:
  - The authorities emphasized their commitment to invest in social housing, including via greater allocation under Budget 2023.
  - Continuing reform, including to the RMA, underway to address supply.
  - RBNZ appropriately expanded its macroprudential toolkit to add DTIs.

### Climate
- Recommendations:
  - Prices on agricultural emissions (New Zealand’s largest emissions source) will be important to incentivizing adoption of new technologies and methods to lower emissions.
  - Proceeds of higher carbon prices should be invested in emissions reduction and compensate those adversely affected by price increases, particularly vulnerable groups.
- Authority actions and developments:
  - Authorities’ proposal for pricing agriculture emissions was released in December 2022.
  - ERP was published in June 2022 and National Adaptation Plan was released in August 2022.
  - The authorities have committed to channeling ETS proceeds into the Climate Emergency Response Fund to support multi-year climate investments.

### Structural Policies
- Recommendations:
  - Promote innovation and digitalization, and tax reforms would support long-term growth.
  - Infrastructure spending should aim at reducing the infrastructure gap and supporting the transition to a net zero carbon growth path.
  - Minimum wage increases should be aligned with underlying labor productivity growth.
- Authority actions and developments:
  - Digital Technologies Industry Transformation Plan aims to grow the digital workforce and addressing labor shortages and skills mismatches.
  - Focus is on project prioritization for infrastructure investment.
  - Adult minimum wage increased from NZ$21.20 to NZ$22.70 per hour in April 2023.

*Source: Annex I. Past Recommendations (2022 Article IV Consultation).*

### Annex V. Risk Assessment Matrix

### Annex V. Risk Assessment Matrix

### Conjunctural risks
- Monetary policy miscalibration  
  - Likelihood: M  
  - Time horizon: Short to medium term  
  - Impact: H  
  - Finding: Amid high economic uncertainty and volatility, central banks slow monetary policy tightening or pivot to loosen monetary policy stance prematurely, de-anchoring inflation expectations and triggering a wage-price spiral in tight labor markets. On the flip side, policy could remain too tight, resulting in unnecessary economic hardship.  
  - Policies to reduce impact: Keep policy on a nimble footing, paying close attention to data. Monetary policy decisions should focus on the inflation outlook and the output gap, while addressing financial volatility with macroprudential and financial stability tools. Strengthen communication.

- Systemic financial instability  
  - Likelihood: M  
  - Time horizon: Short to medium term  
  - Impact: M  
  - Finding: Sharp swings in global interest rates, risk premia, and assets repricing, causing markets dislocations and adverse cross-border spillovers.  
  - Policies to reduce impact: Stand ready to use liquidity windows in the event funding stress. Continue to monitor banks’ balance sheets.

- Abrupt growth slowdown or recession in China  
  - Likelihood: M  
  - Time horizon: Short to medium term  
  - Impact: M  
  - Finding: Greater-than-expected economic disruptions in China from COVID resurgence, rising geopolitical tensions, and/or slowdown in the property sector will result in trade and tourism spillovers to New Zealand.  
  - Policies to reduce impact: Combined monetary, fiscal policy easing.

### Other Risks: Domestic and Structural
- Unexpectedly large or disorderly housing market disruptions  
  - Likelihood: M  
  - Time horizon: Short to medium term  
  - Impact: M  
  - Finding: Larger than expected declines in housing prices alongside tightening of financial conditions would adversely affect household wealth and consumption and could expose pockets of financial vulnerabilities.  
  - Policies to reduce impact: Adjust interest rates if the correction puts inflation on a rapid path to the RBNZ’s target. Provide targeted economic support to vulnerable households.

- Cyberthreats  
  - Likelihood: M  
  - Time horizon: Short to medium term  
  - Impact: M  
  - Finding: An escalation of attacks could destabilize banks and affect critical facilities, slowing the recovery and disrupting financial markets.  
  - Policies to reduce impact: Preventative investment in strengthening critical infrastructure; fast liquidity provision in case of financial market disruptions.

- Extreme Climate Events  
  - Likelihood: M  
  - Time horizon: Medium term  
  - Impact: H  
  - Finding: Stronger and more frequent economic disruptions. Larger fiscal costs related to disaster recovery and adaptation.  
  - Policies to reduce impact: Combined monetary, fiscal policy easing; review medium-term fiscal framework to explicitly build in buffers for this risk going forward.

### Other Risks: External
- Stronger economic outcomes than assumed  
  - Likelihood: M  
  - Time horizon: Short to medium term  
  - Impact: L  
  - Finding: Inflation could moderate faster than expected allowing for easing of financial conditions. Tradeable goods prices could fall faster. Recovery in tourism and education sectors could be faster than assumed under the baseline.  
  - Policies to reduce impact: Policy needs to be agile to changing circumstances.

- Deepening geo-economic fragmentation  
  - Likelihood: M  
  - Time horizon: Short to medium term  
  - Impact: M  
  - Finding: Geopolitical tensions could impact New Zealand’s export performance, impacting growth.  
  - Policies to reduce impact: Combined monetary, fiscal policy easing.

*Based on the February 2023 Global Risk Assessment Matrix (G-RAM).*

### Annex VII. New Zealand’s New Fiscal Rules

### Annex VII. New Zealand’s New Fiscal Rules

### Background and history of fiscal rules
- The Public Finance Act of 1989 established the core legislative framework for public financial management and was amended notably in 2004 and 2013.
- A first version of fiscal rules was introduced with the Fiscal Responsibility Act of 1994.
- The 2004 amendment to the Public Finance Act incorporated the Fiscal Responsibility Act and added principles requiring reductions in total debt to prudent levels and, once achieved, maintaining those levels by ensuring, on average, total operating expenses do not exceed total operating revenues.

### 2022 reform: rules adopted and coverage
- In 2022 the New Zealand Treasury recommended and the government adopted a new set of fiscal rules after suspending the debt target range at the start of the COVID-19 pandemic.
- Two new fiscal rules:
  - Operating rule: the operating balance before gains and losses (OBEGAL) is to return to a small surplus over time and be maintained on average.
  - Debt ceiling: net core Crown debt is to remain below 50 percent of GDP (or 30 percent of GDP based on the new net debt indicator that includes the NZSF, advances, and crown entity borrowings).

### Design principles and objectives
- Primary objectives:
  - Ensure fiscal sustainability over time.
  - Ensure buffers are sufficient to counter significant macroeconomic shocks and adequately fund natural disaster costs.
- Additional criteria used in setting the rules:
  - Simplicity: rules should be easily understood by policymakers and the public.
  - Operational guidance: ability to translate the rule into clear guidance in the annual budget process and keep the rule under policymakers’ control.
  - Flexibility: strict enough to support sustainability while allowing the Crown balance sheet to respond to shocks.
  - Resilience: the fiscal rule should remain for a sustained time and not be abandoned after a shock.

### Rationale for the operating-balance rule (golden-rule style)
- Treasury recommended a “golden-rule” style operating balance: operating expenses paid from operating revenues to support intergenerational equity and living standards.
- Under the golden-rule approach:
  - The current generation pays for its own consumption; borrowing is for long-term investments whose costs are spread across generations.
  - Net investment financed by debt increases the capital stock and the asset component of net worth.
  - Depreciation and write-downs are paid out of operating revenue, ensuring consumption of capital is paid by the generation consuming it.
- The debt ceiling acts as a backstop to counter deficit bias and ensure sufficient buffers for shocks and natural disasters; temporary breaches may occur but should be reduced over time through prudent spending and return to operating surpluses.

### Calibration of the OBEGAL rule (Treasury calculations)
- An OBEGAL of -1.3 percent of GDP was estimated to not contribute to a rise in net debt-to-GDP.
- Adjustments and considerations:
  - Average cost contributions to the NZSF estimated at approximately 0.3 percent of GDP.
  - Allowing for significant macroeconomic shocks would roughly require an operating balance surplus of 1.5 percentage points of GDP to ensure net debt does not rise.
- Treasury’s optimal calibration: an OBEGAL surplus of 0.5 percent.
- Two recommended rule formulations to maximize prudence:
  - Option 1: OBEGAL target range of 0–2 percent of GDP over the 10-year period to provide flexibility for cyclical and other fluctuations.
  - Option 2: A broader target of achieving “small surpluses,” subject to economic and fiscal conditions, with less precision on the definition of small surpluses.

### Calibration of the net debt ceiling (Treasury calculations)
- Treasury considered:
  - Maximum feasible primary balance based on historical performance: a primary surplus of 1-3 percent.
  - Conservative estimates of differentials between debt interest rates and GDP growth rates, with 3 percent being the most conservative based on historical evidence.
  - Historical macroeconomic shocks averaging 10 percent of GDP, and Treasury recommended an additional and more fiscally conservative buffer of 40 percent of GDP to absorb medium or large shocks.
- Assuming a maximum net debt level of 90 percent of GDP, Treasury found a net debt ceiling between 40-60 percent of GDP to be prudent.
- Treasury recommendation:
  - Net core crown debt ceiling of 50 percent of GDP.
  - Or 30 percent of GDP based on the new net debt indicator including the NZSF.
- Expected outcomes of the ceiling:
  - This ceiling is expected to provide over 40 percent of fiscal buffers for shocks, conditional on running sustained primary surpluses over time.
  - Treasury noted running primary surpluses will become more challenging over time given rising costs associated with aging demographics.

### Implications and shift from prior advice
- The new net debt ceiling is less constraining relative to 2019 Treasury advice that recommended a net debt target of 30 percent of GDP.
- The less constraining ceiling is intended to accommodate large infrastructure gaps and needs for greater capital investment in the years ahead.

*Source: Annex VII. New Zealand’s New Fiscal Rules (IMF country report).*

### Annex IX. Fiscal Implications of Large-Scale Asset Purchases by

### Annex IX. Fiscal Implications of Large-Scale Asset Purchases by the RBNZ

### Background and motivation
- Conventional monetary easing improves the fiscal position by reducing debt servicing costs, boosting aggregate demand, and increasing tax revenues.
- Fiscal implications of large-scale asset purchases (LSAP) are less clear because LSAP can adversely affect central bank profits, especially if policy normalizes earlier than expected.
- New Zealand context:
  - RBNZ purchases of assets worth around 16 percent of annual GDP.
  - Policy rate rose quickly above 4 percent during post-pandemic normalization.

### Model, calibration, and shock scenarios
- Methodology:
  - A two-country New Keynesian model with bond market segmentation is used, augmented with detailed fiscal policy and government debt dynamics.
  - Calibrated to reflect key features, initial conditions, and recent developments of the New Zealand economy.
- Shock design:
  - A large, negative demand shock simulating a severe fall in global economic activity drives the RBNZ policy rate to its effective lower bound.
  - Alternative scenario introduces faster recovery shocks: about 1.5 years after the LSAPs, positive demand and negative supply shocks (capturing post-pandemic recovery and a sharp increase in energy prices) trigger faster global recovery and a sharp rise in inflation.

### Main findings on macroeconomic and fiscal effects
- Macroeconomic effects of LSAPs:
  - By lowering long-term rates, LSAPs mitigated the contraction in economic activity and deflationary pressures.
  - LSAPs created room for an earlier policy lift-off compared with no-LSAP scenario.
- Fiscal effects under the baseline recovery (as forecasted at time of purchases):
  - Reduction in government debt by more than 2 percent of annual GDP in the 8-year horizon.
  - Central bank profits decline cumulate to less than 1 percent of annual GDP; this loss is more than offset by increased tax revenues and lower debt service costs.
- Fiscal effects under earlier-than-expected monetary tightening:
  - Simulated earlier monetary tightening (driven by faster recovery and energy-price driven inflation) leads to a cumulative decrease in central bank profits due to LSAPs of about 2.5 percent of annual GDP.
  - Ex post fiscal gains from LSAPs are significantly reduced in this scenario, though the overall impact on the medium-run level of public debt remains likely favorable, though small.

### Comparative policy insight
- LSAPs versus fiscal stimulus:
  - If fiscal stimulus delivered a similar boost to economic activity as LSAP, it would clearly increase the medium-run level of government debt for realistic values of fiscal multipliers.
  - By contrast, LSAPs provided macroeconomic support while, on balance, producing favorable effects on the fiscal stance even when accounting for earlier-than-expected monetary policy normalization.

*Prepared by Marcin Kolasa, Jesper Linde and Pawel Zabczyk.*

### Annex IX. Figure 2. Covid-19 Recession with Earlier Policy Tightening

### Annex IX. Figure 2. Covid-19 Recession with Earlier Policy Tightening

### Overview
- Source: Reserve Bank of New Zealand; and IMF staff calculations.
- Timeline shown: 2020–2027.

### Inflation (APR, Dev. from SS)
- Vertical axis tick labels preserved as shown: -2, -1, 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8.
- Two scenarios plotted: Baseline; Baseline with QE.
- Horizontal axis years preserved: 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027.

### Policy Rate (APR, Level)
- Vertical axis tick labels preserved as shown: 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6.
- Two scenarios plotted: Baseline; Baseline with QE.
- Horizontal axis years preserved: 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027.

### Central Bank Profit (% of Ann. SS GDP, Cumulative)
- Vertical axis tick labels preserved as shown: -3, -2.5, -2, -1.5, -1, -0.5, 0.
- Two scenarios plotted: Baseline; Baseline with QE.
- Horizontal axis years preserved: 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027.

### Key graphical elements and comparisons
- The figure presents three panels aligned by year (2020–2027): Inflation deviations from steady state, Policy Rate levels, and cumulative Central Bank Profit (% of Ann. SS GDP).
- Each panel contrasts two model scenarios: "Baseline" and "Baseline with QE".
- Axes and years are reported exactly as labeled in the figure to preserve numeric fidelity and temporal scope.

*Sources: Reserve Bank of New Zealand; and IMF staff calculations.*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/cr/2023/english/1nzlea2023001.pdf_
