## 1. Downside Scenario

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [1. Downside Scenario](https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/cr/2023/english/1plwea2023001.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/files/publications/cr/2023/english/1plwea2023001.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/files/publications/cr/2023/english/1plwea2023001.pdf.json)

---

### Context and post-pandemic landscape
- Economic structure and vulnerabilities:
  - Tourism constituted about 40 percent of GDP and 25 percent of employment pre-pandemic.
  - Palau is heavily dependent on grants, primarily under a Compact of Free Association Agreement with the United States.
- Pandemic impact and fiscal position:
  - COVID-related isolation resulted in the loss of a fifth of the pre-pandemic level of GDP.
  - General government debt surged to 70.7 percent of GDP in FY2020-FY2021 from about 30 percent of GDP before the pandemic.
  - Palau’s public debt is 100 percent external and mostly concessional (from ADB); public sector debt includes the subnational levels and SOEs.
- Demographics and migration:
  - Elderly dependency ratio increased from 8 percent in 2005 to 13 percent in 2020 and is projected to increase to 19 percent by 2030 (United Nations Population Projections).
  - Anecdotal evidence of increased outward migration since the pandemic; the COFA allows Palauan citizens by birth to move to and work in the US without visa.
- Policy reforms since the pandemic:
  - The Fiscal Responsibility and Debt Management Act (FRDMA) was signed into law in 2021.
  - A major tax reform introducing the Palau Goods and Service Tax (PGST) was adopted in 2021 and came into effect in January 2023.

### Recent developments
- Growth and sectoral developments:
  - Real GDP contracted by 2.0 percent in FY2022 and is estimated to have stalled in FY2023 (+0.8 percent).
  - Tourism arrivals were about 35 thousand in FY2023, well below pre-pandemic levels.
  - Construction activity declined due to winding down of big infrastructure projects and delays in new projects.
- Inflation:
  - Inflation hit 13.2 percent (y/y) in FY2022 and is projected to remain elevated at 13 percent in FY2023.
  - The CPI surged by 17 percent (y/y) in 2023Q1, reflecting PGST-related pass-through, higher food and fuel import prices, and a one-off utility tariff adjustment in May 2023.
- Fiscal developments:
  - Fiscal deficit peaked at 13.1 percent in FY2020 and declined to 3.2 percent in FY2022.
  - The fiscal deficit is projected to turn into a small surplus (0.3 percent of GDP) in FY2023, driven by higher tax revenues and early gains from tax reform; PGST alone yielded some 6.5 percent of GDP already in the first year of implementation.
  - Total expenditure is estimated to have declined by 17.5 percentage points of GDP, driven primarily by a 15.4 percentage points of GDP decline in project grants including related to the expiration of the US CARES Act support.
  - The wage bill increased by about 1.5 percentage points of GDP, reflecting an across-the-board increase of 75 cents in the public sector hourly wage—a 20 and 7 percent increase relative to the minimum wage and the average public sector salary, respectively.
- External sector:
  - The current account deficit peaked at about 55 percent of GDP in FY2022 and is estimated to have declined to about 41 percent of GDP in FY2023.
  - The REER appreciated by 13 percent in 2022, driven by US dollar strength and Palau’s relatively high inflation.
- Credit and financial sector:
  - Total private sector credit grew at an average rate of 3 percent between FY2019 and FY2022.
  - The National Development Bank of Palau (NDBP) expanded lending by 9 and 16 percent in FY2020 and FY2021 respectively and now accounts for about half of overall credit, up from 10 percent pre-pandemic.
  - Commercial bank credit contracted by 8 percent in FY2021 and expanded 4 percent in FY2022.

### Outlook and risks
- Baseline expectations and key projections:
  - Baseline assumes the new CRA-23 will take effect in late FY2024.
  - Growth:
    - Output is expected to accelerate to 12.4 percent in FY2024.
    - Visitor arrivals are projected to double to about 70 thousand.
    - Construction activity and planned major infrastructure projects are expected to accelerate in FY2024.
  - Inflation:
    - Projected to moderate to 5.9 percent in FY2024; over the medium term inflation is projected to return to a 2.0-2.5 percent range.
  - External sector:
    - Current account deficit is projected to narrow in FY2024 to 26.2 percent of GDP and continue to decline over the medium term.
  - Fiscal position:
    - FY2024 budget envisions a broadly flat expenditure envelope (excluding expenditures financed through non-Compact grants) and accommodates an additional 7 percent increase in the public sector hourly wage.
    - Fiscal surplus is projected to increase to 2.0 percent of GDP in FY2024, up from 0.3 percent of GDP projected for FY2023.
- Key downside risks:
  - Delays in US Congress approval of CRA-23 constitute the key near-term risk.
  - Recovery in tourism could underperform expectations.
  - Extreme climate events, including potential droughts related to El Niño, could adversely affect growth and push up inflation.
  - Global risks: abrupt global slowdown and commodity price volatility.
  - Longer-term constraints: small size, geographical isolation, and potential higher outward migration exacerbating adverse demographic trends.

### Debt and sustainability under CRA-23
- Under draft CRA-23, Palau would receive additional US$899 million in grants over 20 years (FY2024-43), which includes 5-6 percent of GDP per year in budgetary grants (excluding infrastructure grants) and an additional 3 percent of GDP per year (for six years) as fiscal consolidation grants.
- Based on the new Sovereign Risk and Debt Sustainability Framework, Palau’s debt is sustainable with high probability, and public debt is projected to decline to 33.7 percent of GDP by FY2028.
- Contingency and interim financing:
  - Additional CTF withdrawals of up to US$30 million (approved in the budget).
  - A concessional US$25 million loan from ADB expected to be approved in 2024Q1.
  - Use existing cash buffers.
- Under a risk scenario with no Compact disbursements over the medium-term and a weaker tourism recovery, debt sustainability risks would remain elevated; a gradual fiscal consolidation over the medium- to long-term (of about 4 percentage points) through revenue mobilization and improved expenditure efficiency can place debt on a downward trajectory and safeguard the CTF.

### Authorities’ views
- Authorities agreed with staff on the macroeconomic outlook and risks and expect recovery from FY2024 supported by gradual resumption of tourism.
- They remain cautious: tourism-related activities are expected to remain below pre-pandemic levels through FY2026.
- Authorities attribute recent high inflation to multiple shocks, including PGST pass-through and commodity price shocks; they expect inflation to come down in FY2024 but emphasize high uncertainty.
- Authorities expect CRA-23 to be important for macroeconomic prospects and anticipate it to come into effect in FY2024, while noting timing uncertainty.
- Authorities concurred that the current account deficit should narrow over the medium-term with tourism recovery and that structural reforms to diversify export-related services and using Compact funding to build fiscal buffers would enhance the external position.

### Policies for the post-pandemic recovery — Fiscal policy
- CRA-23 fiscal impact and policy implications:
  - CRA-23 grants would help reduce pandemic debt, increase cash buffers, and maintain budgetary surpluses over the medium term.
  - Given uncertainty on timing, a prudent contractionary fiscal stance in FY2024 is appropriate while protecting the most vulnerable from cost-of-living shocks.
- Interim financing options and contingent measures:
  - Options if Compact grants are temporarily delayed: CTF withdrawals (up to US$30 million); concessional US$25 million loan from ADB expected 2024Q1; use existing cash buffers.
  - A prolonged delay would require prioritizing fiscal consolidation over the medium-term.
- Medium- to long-term fiscal strategy:
  - A gradual fiscal consolidation of about 4 percentage points, underpinned by revenue mobilization and improvements in expenditure efficiency, can put debt on a firmly downward trajectory and create fiscal space for priority spending while safeguarding the CTF.

*Source: IMF staff report — 1. Downside Scenario*

---

### Box 1. Downside Scenario

### Downside scenario description
- Approval of the Compact agreement delayed (assumed long delay in CRA-23 approval beyond FY2028) would significantly lower grant revenues relative to the baseline.
- Drawdowns of US$15 million per year from the Compact Trust Fund are assumed to continue as in the baseline from FY2025 onwards while lower grants would lead to partial spending cuts, particularly on capital projects.
- Under the no-Compact scenario, primary balance in FY2024 would not be impacted reflecting the assumption of additional CTF withdrawals (stopgap measure).
- A more severe scenario combines no Compact agreement with a weaker tourism recovery (tourism weaker by 20-30 percent relative to baseline).

### Key quantitative impacts
- Primary balance: lower primary surpluses under downside scenarios.
- Public debt:
  - No-Compact scenario: debt-to-GDP ratio projected at 46.3 percent of GDP in FY2028 versus 33.7 percent under the baseline.
  - No-Compact and protracted tourism recovery: debt would stabilize at over 60 percent of GDP despite favorable interest rate-growth differentials.
- Growth and output:
  - Weaker tourism (20-30 percent below baseline) yields significantly lower growth and primary balances over the medium term (by about 2 percent of GDP).
- Cash accumulation: lower cash accumulation relative to the baseline under downside scenarios.
- Notes on modelling: Impact of a delay in Compact approval on debt is lower than the additional budget and debt consolidation grants as CTF withdrawal would be higher in FY2024, expenditure would be adjusted over the medium-term, containing the deterioration in primary balance and cash accumulation would be lower.

### Fiscal strategy and expenditure policy recommendations
- Adopt a medium-term fiscal strategy integrating concrete policies and projects to support Palau’s development objectives while rebuilding fiscal buffers.
- Maintain a prudent fiscal stance aligned with the Fiscal Responsibility Framework and staff’s baseline projections.
- Conduct a full review of government saving vehicles and implement a new debt management strategy to:
  - Set target contributions to the Cyclical Reserve Fund and Climate Resilience Fund.
  - Manage cash deposits and debt service after the Compact fiscal consolidation assistance expires.
- Create fiscal space by enhancing expenditure efficiency and solidifying tax reforms.
- Expenditure policy under higher Compact resources should focus on:
  - Investments in infrastructure, health, and education.
  - Improving expenditure efficiency by streamlining subsidies and transfers.
  - Assess social assistance needs and programs (informed by the ongoing Household Consumption and Income Survey).
- Revenue mobilization:
  - Continue prioritizing revenue administration, enhance regulations, develop and implement a digital roadmap, and pursue capacity building.
  - Consider additional tax policy measures in the medium-term once recovery is entrenched and recent reforms are effectively implemented (examples cited: implementation of a comprehensive income tax regime, and raising the carbon tax rate).

### Pension system, public employment, and wage bill reforms
- Focus on pension system—particularly the Civil Service Pension Plan (CSPP)—and on public sector employment and wage bill management.
- Encourage government to conclude preparation of CSPP reform bill that:
  - Honors past pension rights.
  - Curtails growth of unfunded liabilities.
  - Reduces the budget’s exposure to underwriting risks.
- Review public sector employment and compensation policies to align payroll with required skill mix and address emigration.
- Establish an Employment and Compensation Committee—to review hiring, promotion, and compensation policies.

### Public financial management (PFM) improvements
- Further PFM improvements needed; FRBM Act provides solid basis but PEFA identified gaps.
- PFM Reform Roadmap (under government review) will focus on:
  - Improving transparency of budgeting, debt reporting, and public procurement.
  - Completing prior years and current audit reports and establishing an action plan for timely audit of the Annual Financial Statement.
  - Establishing legal and institutional framework for oversight of state-owned enterprises.
  - Continuing rollout of the Financial Management Information System.
  - Improving PFM skills at state governments.
- Incorporate climate and natural disaster risks into the budget process.

### Financial sector risks, supervision, and digital initiatives
- Systemic risk assessed as moderate but subject to significant uncertainty as pandemic support measures expire.
- Banking asset quality:
  - Non-performing loans in the banking system remained stable and low at around 0.6 percent in 2022.
  - NDBP has significantly higher NPLs (estimated at around 13 percent), contributing to fiscal and systemic risks.
- Recommendations:
  - Upgrade NDBP’s risk management, reporting, and governance frameworks.
  - Enhance supervisory capacity and resources of the Financial Institutions Commission (FIC) in line with expanded mandate (including VA/VASP regulation and supervision).
  - Bring NDBP under FIC supervision (e.g., obtain a bank license).
  - Strengthen contingency planning and crisis preparedness for natural disasters.
  - Address structural impediments to private sector lending (lack of collateral, record-keeping); consider establishing a credit bureau.
  - Improve payment system: reduce high transaction fees and address reliance on cash and checks; three US banks play critical role and are sole correspondent banking relationships (CBRs).

### Fintech initiatives and financial integrity risks
- Digital Residency Program (DRP):
  - Rolled out in January 2022.
  - Registered about 10 thousand digital residents as of August 2023.
  - Generated fiscal revenues of about US$1.4 million in FY2023.
  - Digital Residency Act provision on legal name change poses serious misuse risk; authorities encouraged to repeal this provision and implement enhanced risk mitigation (robust vetting, sanctions, PEP screening, periodic reviews).
- State-backed stablecoin:
  - Proposed as US dollar-backed, fully collateralized with safe assets held at a custodian bank; proof-of-concept launched.
  - Intended use cases: low-fee person-to-business payments, person-to-person payments for local customs, remittances, and payments related to crypto tourism.
  - Significant macro-financial, legal, financial integrity, regulatory, cybersecurity and reputational risks if not developed and regulated well.
  - Recommendation: proceed cautiously; undertake a full-fledged feasibility study, stakeholder engagement, assess ML/TF risks, and develop measures to manage and mitigate risks prior to launch.

### AML/CFT and regulatory priorities
- Continue improving AML/CFT frameworks and take cautious approach to Fintech until regulatory/governance gaps are closed.
- Address gaps identified in legal and AML/CFT frameworks and FATF/APG-related recommendations, including:
  - Improving AML/CFT preventive measures.
  - Undertaking sectoral risk assessments.
  - Implementing VA/VASP requirements of FATF Recommendation 15 (e.g., AML/CFT regulations specific to VA/VASPs and finalizing system for registering VASPs).
  - Strengthening risk-based AML/CFT supervision for financial institutions and DNFBPs (e.g., real estate agents and lawyers).
  - Strengthening collection and publication of beneficial ownership information by companies.
- Authorities’ related views:
  - Authorities reported DRP KYC checks are conducted by SUMSUB with additional domestic checks and that there are no plans to implement legal name change provision.
  - Authorities plan further pilots and feasibility assessments before any decision on the stablecoin, and seek TA for ML/TF risk assessment related to VAs/VASPs.

### Structural policies, human capital, and climate change
- Structural reforms to diversify economy and encourage private investment:
  - Prepare and implement National Development Plan (NDP) with actions and priorities.
  - Enable private investment and attract FDI by streamlining processes, improving regulatory framework and land-use planning, enforcing property rights and contracts, and improving infrastructure.
  - Achieve higher value-added within tourism (diversify offerings, expand in-land and cultural tourism, small-scale handcraft manufacturing); increase entrepreneurship, diversify source tourism markets, and enhance coordination between government and private sector.
- Human capital investments:
  - Focus education on teacher training, skills, upgrading school infrastructure, and vocational training.
  - Investing in education and health can reduce outward migration, raise labor force participation (including of females), and incentivize return of Palauan citizens abroad.
- Climate change:
  - Climate change is macro-critical due to adaptation costs and extreme weather impacts.
  - Modelling estimates: potential losses from sea-level rise of about 3 percent of GDP annually, on average, between 2020 and 2049, along an upward trend.
  - Cost-effective adaptation with a balanced mix of protection and planned retreat can reduce these losses to 1 percent of GDP per year.
  - Adaptation strategies include rendering infrastructure more climate resilient, retreating from coastal areas by transferring infrastructure to better protected regions, and introducing building codes for resilient construction standards.
  - Periodic droughts pose risks due to limited catchment/retention capacity and dilapidated infrastructure; major investments (potentially with external support) will be needed to ensure stable drinking water supply.

*Source: IMF staff calculations.*

---

### Climate and adaptation, data, and staff appraisal (selected findings)

### Integration of adaptation and mitigation into development planning
- Cost-benefit analyses, including monetization of externalities, recommended for efficient resource allocation and quantification of distributional effects.
- Removing barriers to efficient adaptation by the private sector will help unlock private investment.
- Completion of the National Disaster Preparedness Baseline Assessment and the ongoing update of the Palau Climate Change Policy are welcome.

### Energy, carbon pricing, and private sector entry
- PPUC’s targets:
  - 10 percent of energy generation via solar farms by 2024.
  - 25 percent of energy generation via solar farms by 2025.
- Authorities are on track to implement strategy to increase reliance on renewable (solar) energy and upgrade power distribution infrastructure.
- Palau’s second NDC will emphasize transportation and waste management.

### Statistical capacity and data improvements
- Priority areas:
  - Improving GDP deflators.
  - Broadening coverage of fiscal data to the general government level.
  - Development of quarterly statistics for BOP, real, and fiscal sectors.
- Implemented e-GDDS in February 2022; GDP rebasing in FY22.
- Finalize Household Expenditure and Income Survey in early-2024 to update demographics, socio-economic indicators, and provide new CPI weights.

### Staff appraisal — macroeconomic and fiscal outlook (selected)
- Pandemic reduced GDP by over 20 percent and led to significant increase in public debt.
- Inflation reached historically high levels driven by high food and fuel import prices, PGST introduction and one-off utility tariff adjustments.
- CRA-23, while pending US Congress approval, under better financial terms improves macroeconomic prospects and is expected to:
  - Enhance fiscal space, pay down debt, rebuild fiscal buffers, and expand spending in priority areas.
- Fiscal policy stance:
  - Fiscal balance (including grants) projected to return to a surplus in FY2023 and improve further in FY2024.
  - Given high uncertainty and lingering inflationary environment, a contractionary fiscal stance in FY2024 is appropriate while protecting the most vulnerable from cost-of-living shocks.
- Medium-term fiscal strategy recommendations:
  - Integrate concrete policies and projects to support development objectives while rebuilding fiscal buffers.
  - Conduct a full review of government saving vehicles and adopt a new debt management strategy.
  - Ensure uninterrupted future revenue mobilization while improving expenditure efficiency.

*Source: Staff appraisal and Box 2 (selected excerpts).*

---

### Annex I. A New Compact of Free Association Agreement — key fiscal features

- Total financing over FY2024-2043: 888.9 (millions of US$).
- Annual disbursement in 2024 (millions of US$) and totals (2024-2043, millions of US$):
  - Budget Grants: 20 ; 486.0
  - Infrastructure Grants: 10 ; 243.0
  - Debt Relief (2024-2029): 10 ; 60.0
  - Contribution to CTF (2024-2025): 50 ; 100.0
  - Total Financing: 90 ; 888.9
- Allowed annual withdrawal from CTF (2024-2043): Capped at 15 million during 2024-26 but can be increased to up to 4 percent of the three-year moving average of the CTF value beyond 2026.
- The renewed compact will deliver about 30 million in the first year (FY2024) (excluding the Compact Trust Fund withdrawals), compared with about US$17 million projected to get in for the same year under the current CRA.
- Estimated annual average support: about 38-44 million per annum (16 percent of FY2023 projected GDP) in financial support (including budget support, contributions to the Compact Trust Fund, support for debt payment).

Policy implications and risks:
- Risks of delayed approval by US Congress remain elevated.
- Interim arrangements in past delays included drawing US$5 million a year from the original CTF and continued benefit from some US Federal programs.
- Policy recommendations: secure alternative financing sources, accelerate revenue mobilization and fiscal reforms to secure debt sustainability.

*Source: Annex I. A New Compact of Free Association Agreement*

---

*Source: IMF staff report — 1plwea2023001*

### 1. Downside Scenario __________________________________________________________________________ 10

### 1. Downside Scenario

### Context and post-pandemic landscape
- Economic structure and vulnerabilities:
  - Tourism constituted about 40 percent of GDP and 25 percent of employment pre-pandemic.
  - Palau is heavily dependent on grants, primarily under a Compact of Free Association Agreement with the United States.
- Pandemic impact and fiscal position:
  - COVID-related isolation resulted in the loss of a fifth of the pre-pandemic level of GDP.
  - General government debt surged to 70.7 percent of GDP in FY2020-FY2021 from about 30 percent of GDP before the pandemic.
  - Palau’s public debt is 100 percent external and mostly concessional (from ADB); public sector debt includes the subnational levels and SOEs.
- Demographics and migration:
  - Palau’s elderly dependency ratio increased from 8 percent in 2005 to 13 percent in 2020 and is projected to increase to 19 percent by 2030 (United Nations Population Projections).
  - There is anecdotal evidence of increased outward migration since the pandemic; the COFA allows Palauan citizens by birth to move to and work in the US without visa.
- Policy reforms since the pandemic:
  - The Fiscal Responsibility and Debt Management Act (FRDMA) was signed into law in 2021.
  - A major tax reform introducing the Palau Goods and Service Tax (PGST) was adopted in 2021 and came into effect in January 2023.

### Recent developments
- Growth and sectoral developments:
  - Real GDP contracted by 2.0 percent in FY2022 and is estimated to have stalled in FY2023 (+0.8 percent).
  - Tourism arrivals were about 35 thousand in FY2023, well below pre-pandemic levels.
  - Construction activity declined due to winding down of big infrastructure projects and delays in new projects.
- Inflation:
  - Palau’s inflation rate hit 13.2 percent (y/y) in FY2022 and is projected to remain elevated at 13 percent in FY2023.
  - The CPI surged by 17 percent (y/y) in 2023Q1, reflecting PGST-related pass-through, higher food and fuel import prices, and a one-off utility tariff adjustment in May 2023.
- Fiscal developments:
  - Fiscal deficit peaked at 13.1 percent in FY2020 and declined to 3.2 percent in FY2022.
  - The fiscal deficit is projected to turn into a small surplus (0.3 percent of GDP) in FY2023, driven by higher tax revenues and early gains from tax reform; PGST alone yielded some 6.5 percent of GDP already in the first year of implementation.
  - Total expenditure is estimated to have declined by 17.5 percentage points of GDP, driven primarily by a 15.4 percentage points of GDP decline in project grants including related to the expiration of the US CARES Act support.
  - The wage bill increased by about 1.5 percentage points of GDP, reflecting an across-the-board increase of 75 cents in the public sector hourly wage—a 20 and 7 percent increase relative to the minimum wage and the average public sector salary, respectively.
- External sector:
  - The current account deficit peaked at about 55 percent of GDP in FY2022 and is estimated to have declined to about 41 percent of GDP in FY2023.
  - The REER appreciated by 13 percent in 2022, driven by US dollar strength and Palau’s relatively high inflation.
- Credit and financial sector:
  - Total private sector credit grew at an average rate of 3 percent between FY2019 and FY2022.
  - The National Development Bank of Palau (NDBP) expanded lending by 9 and 16 percent in FY2020 and FY2021 respectively and now accounts for about half of overall credit, up from 10 percent pre-pandemic.
  - Commercial bank credit contracted by 8 percent in FY2021 and expanded 4 percent in FY2022.

### Outlook and risks
- Baseline expectations and key projections:
  - The baseline assumes the new CRA-23 will take effect in late FY2024.
  - Growth: Output is expected to accelerate to 12.4 percent in FY2024.
    - Visitor arrivals are projected to double to about 70 thousand.
    - Construction activity and planned major infrastructure projects are expected to accelerate in FY2024.
  - Inflation: Projected to moderate to 5.9 percent in FY2024; over the medium term inflation is projected to return to a 2.0-2.5 percent range.
  - External sector: The current account deficit is projected to narrow in FY2024 to 26.2 percent of GDP and continue to decline over the medium term.
  - Fiscal position: The FY2024 budget envisions a broadly flat expenditure envelope (excluding expenditures financed through non-Compact grants) and accommodates an additional 7 percent increase in the public sector hourly wage. The fiscal surplus is projected to increase to 2.0 percent of GDP in FY2024, up from 0.3 percent of GDP projected for FY2023.
- Key downside risks:
  - Delays in US Congress approval of CRA-23 constitute the key near-term risk.
  - Recovery in tourism could underperform expectations.
  - Extreme climate events, including potential droughts related to El Niño, could adversely affect growth and push up inflation.
  - Global risks: abrupt global slowdown and commodity price volatility.
  - Longer-term constraints: small size, geographical isolation, and potential higher outward migration exacerbating adverse demographic trends.
- Debt and sustainability under CRA-23:
  - Under draft CRA-23, Palau would receive additional US$899 million in grants over 20 years (FY2024-43), which includes 5-6 percent of GDP per year in budgetary grants (excluding infrastructure grants) and an additional 3 percent of GDP per year (for six years) as fiscal consolidation grants.
  - Based on the new Sovereign Risk and Debt Sustainability Framework, Palau’s debt is sustainable with high probability, and public debt is projected to decline to 33.7 percent of GDP by FY2028.
- Contingency and risk scenarios:
  - If Compact grant financing is delayed, interim financing options include additional Compact Trust Fund (CTF) withdrawals of up to US$30 million (approved in the budget), a concessional US$25 million loan from ADB expected to be approved in 2024Q1, and using existing cash buffers.
  - Under a risk scenario with no Compact disbursements over the medium-term and a weaker tourism recovery, debt sustainability risks would remain elevated; a gradual fiscal consolidation over the medium- to long-term (of about 4 percentage points) through revenue mobilization and improved expenditure efficiency can place debt on a downward trajectory and safeguard the CTF.

### Authorities’ views
- The authorities agreed with staff on the macroeconomic outlook and risks and expect recovery from FY2024 supported by gradual resumption of tourism.
- They remain cautious: tourism-related activities are expected to remain below pre-pandemic levels through FY2026.
- The authorities attribute recent high inflation to multiple shocks, including PGST pass-through and commodity price shocks; they expect inflation to come down in FY2024 but emphasize high uncertainty.
- The authorities expect CRA-23 to be important for macroeconomic prospects and anticipate it to come into effect in FY2024, while noting timing uncertainty.
- The authorities concurred that the current account deficit should narrow over the medium-term with tourism recovery and that structural reforms to diversify export-related services and using Compact funding to build fiscal buffers would enhance the external position.

### Policies for the post-pandemic recovery — Fiscal policy
- CRA-23 fiscal impact and policy implications:
  - CRA-23 grants would help reduce pandemic debt, increase cash buffers, and maintain budgetary surpluses over the medium term.
  - Given uncertainty on timing, a prudent contractionary fiscal stance in FY2024 is appropriate while protecting the most vulnerable from cost-of-living shocks.
- Interim financing options and contingent measures:
  - Options if Compact grants are temporarily delayed: CTF withdrawals (up to US$30 million); concessional US$25 million loan from ADB expected 2024Q1; use existing cash buffers.
  - A prolonged delay would require prioritizing fiscal consolidation over the medium-term.
- Medium- to long-term fiscal strategy:
  - A gradual fiscal consolidation of about 4 percentage points, underpinned by revenue mobilization and improvements in expenditure efficiency, can put debt on a firmly downward trajectory and create fiscal space for priority spending while safeguarding the CTF.

*Source: IMF staff report — 1. Downside Scenario*

### Box 1. Downside Scenario

### Box 1. Downside Scenario

### Downside scenario description
- Approval of the Compact agreement delayed (assumed long delay in CRA-23 approval beyond FY2028) would significantly lower grant revenues relative to the baseline.
- Drawdowns of US$15 million per year from the Compact Trust Fund are assumed to continue as in the baseline from FY2025 onwards while lower grants would lead to partial spending cuts, particularly on capital projects.
- Under the no-Compact scenario, primary balance in FY2024 would not be impacted reflecting the assumption of additional CTF withdrawals (stopgap measure).
- A more severe scenario combines no Compact agreement with a weaker tourism recovery (tourism weaker by 20-30 percent relative to baseline).

### Key quantitative impacts
- Primary balance: lower primary surpluses under downside scenarios; charting indicates substantial deviations (figure caption: Downside Scenario: Primary Balance (In percent of GDP), General government).
- Public debt:
  - No-Compact scenario: debt-to-GDP ratio projected at 46.3 percent of GDP in FY2028 versus 33.7 percent under the baseline.
  - No-Compact and protracted tourism recovery: debt would stabilize at over 60 percent of GDP despite favorable interest rate-growth differentials.
- Growth and output:
  - Weaker tourism (20-30 percent below baseline) yields significantly lower growth and primary balances over the medium term (by about 2 percent of GDP).
  - Charts indicate real GDP deviations by fiscal year (Downside Scenario: Level of Real GDP, In percent deviation from baseline).
- Cash accumulation: lower cash accumulation relative to the baseline under downside scenarios.
- Notes on modelling: The impact of a delay in Compact approval on debt is lower than the additional budget and debt consolidation grants as CTF withdrawal would be higher in FY2024, expenditure would be adjusted over the medium-term, containing the deterioration in primary balance and cash accumulation would be lower.

### Fiscal strategy and expenditure policy recommendations
- Adopt a medium-term fiscal strategy integrating concrete policies and projects to support Palau’s development objectives while rebuilding fiscal buffers.
- Maintain a prudent fiscal stance aligned with the Fiscal Responsibility Framework and staff’s baseline projections.
- Conduct a full review of government saving vehicles and implement a new debt management strategy to:
  - Set target contributions to the Cyclical Reserve Fund and Climate Resilience Fund.
  - Manage cash deposits and debt service after the Compact fiscal consolidation assistance expires.
- Create fiscal space by enhancing expenditure efficiency and solidifying tax reforms.
- Expenditure policy under higher Compact resources should focus on:
  - Investments in infrastructure, health, and education.
  - Improving expenditure efficiency by streamlining subsidies and transfers.
  - Assess social assistance needs and programs (informed by the ongoing Household Consumption and Income Survey).
- Revenue mobilization:
  - Continue prioritizing revenue administration, enhance regulations, develop and implement a digital roadmap, and pursue capacity building.
  - Consider additional tax policy measures in the medium-term once recovery is entrenched and recent reforms are effectively implemented (examples cited: implementation of a comprehensive income tax regime, and raising the carbon tax rate).

### Pension system, public employment, and wage bill reforms
- Focus reforms on the pension system—particularly the Civil Service Pension Plan (CSPP)—and on public sector employment and wage bill management.
- Encourage government to conclude preparation of CSPP reform bill that:
  - Honors past pension rights.
  - Curtails growth of unfunded liabilities.
  - Reduces the budget’s exposure to underwriting risks.
- Review public sector employment and compensation policies to align payroll with required skill mix and address emigration.
- Establish an Employment and Compensation Committee—in line with FAD technical advice—to review hiring, promotion, and compensation policies.

### Public financial management (PFM) improvements
- Despite generally good practice, further PFM improvements needed; FRBM Act provides solid basis but PEFA identified gaps.
- PFM Reform Roadmap (under government review) will focus on:
  - Improving transparency of budgeting, debt reporting, and public procurement.
  - Completing prior years and current audit reports and establishing an action plan for timely audit of the Annual Financial Statement.
  - Establishing legal and institutional framework for oversight of state-owned enterprises.
  - Continuing rollout of the Financial Management Information System.
  - Improving PFM skills at state governments.
- Incorporate climate and natural disaster risks into the budget process.

### Authorities’ fiscal views (as reported)
- Authorities commit to fiscal responsibility and agree a tightening fiscal stance is appropriate in the near term while protecting vulnerable households from cost-of-living shocks.
- Authorities see enhanced domestic revenues from 2023 tax reform, recovery, and higher grants under CRA-23 generating large fiscal surpluses to pay down debt and rebuild buffers while expanding priority spending.
- Authorities expect climate-related spending to increase considerably over time and note infrastructure gaps requiring additional financing; the Palau Development Plan (being drafted) can inform priorities.
- Authorities acknowledge importance of Social Security System and CSPP reforms and report significant progress drafting reform proposals.

### Financial sector risks, supervision, and digital initiatives
- Systemic risk assessed as moderate but subject to significant uncertainty as pandemic support measures expire.
- Banking asset quality:
  - Non-performing loans in the banking system remained stable and low at around 0.6 percent in 2022.
  - NDBP has significantly higher NPLs (estimated at around 13 percent), contributing to fiscal and systemic risks.
- Recommendations:
  - Upgrade NDBP’s risk management, reporting, and governance frameworks.
  - Enhance supervisory capacity and resources of the Financial Institutions Commission (FIC) in line with expanded mandate (including VA/VASP regulation and supervision).
  - Bring NDBP under FIC supervision (e.g., obtain a bank license).
  - Strengthen contingency planning and crisis preparedness for natural disasters.
  - Address structural impediments to private sector lending (lack of collateral, record-keeping); consider establishing a credit bureau.
  - Improve payment system: reduce high transaction fees and address reliance on cash and checks; three US banks play critical role and are sole correspondent banking relationships (CBRs).

### Fintech initiatives and financial integrity risks
- Two main Fintech initiatives under consideration:
  - Digital Residency Program (DRP):
    - Rolled out in January 2022.
    - Registered about 10 thousand digital residents as of August 2023.
    - Generated fiscal revenues of about US$1.4 million in FY2023.
    - Digital Residency Act provision on legal name change poses serious misuse risk; authorities encouraged to repeal this provision and implement enhanced risk mitigation (robust vetting, sanctions, PEP screening, periodic reviews).
  - State-backed stablecoin:
    - Proposed as US dollar-backed, fully collateralized with safe assets held at a custodian bank; proof-of-concept launched.
    - Intended use cases: low-fee person-to-business payments, person-to-person payments for local customs, remittances, and payments related to crypto tourism.
    - Significant macro-financial, legal, financial integrity, regulatory, cybersecurity and reputational risks if not developed and regulated well.
    - Recommendation: proceed cautiously; undertake a full-fledged feasibility study, stakeholder engagement, assess ML/TF risks, and develop measures to manage and mitigate risks prior to launch.

### AML/CFT and regulatory priorities
- Continue improving AML/CFT frameworks and take cautious approach to Fintech until regulatory/gov ernance gaps are closed.
- Address gaps identified in legal and AML/CFT frameworks and FATF/APG-related recommendations, including:
  - Improving AML/CFT preventive measures.
  - Undertaking sectoral risk assessments.
  - Implementing VA/VASP requirements of FATF Recommendation 15 (e.g., AML/CFT regulations specific to VA/VASPs and finalizing system for registering VASPs).
  - Strengthening risk-based AML/CFT supervision for financial institutions and DNFBPs (e.g., real estate agents and lawyers).
  - Strengthening collection and publication of beneficial ownership information by companies.
- Authorities’ related views:
  - Authorities concurred on need to strengthen supervision, increase FIC resources, and draft payment system legislation.
  - Authorities reported that DRP KYC checks are conducted by SUMSUB with additional domestic checks and that there are no plans to implement legal name change provision.
  - Authorities plan further pilots and feasibility assessments before any decision on the stablecoin, and seek TA for ML/TF risk assessment related to VAs/VASPs.

### Structural policies, human capital, and climate change
- Structural reforms needed to diversify economy and encourage private investment:
  - Prepare and implement National Development Plan (NDP) with actions and priorities.
  - Enable private investment and attract FDI by streamlining processes, improving regulatory framework and land-use planning, enforcing property rights and contracts, and improving infrastructure.
  - Achieve higher value-added within tourism (diversify offerings, expand in-land and cultural tourism, small-scale handcraft manufacturing); increase entrepreneurship, diversify source tourism markets, and enhance coordination between government and private sector.
- Human capital investments:
  - Focus education on teacher training, skills, upgrading school infrastructure, and vocational training.
  - Investing in education and health can reduce outward migration, raise labor force participation (including of females), and incentivize return of Palauan citizens abroad.
- Climate change:
  - Climate change is macro-critical due to adaptation costs and extreme weather impacts.
  - Modelling estimates: potential losses from sea-level rise of about 3 percent of GDP annually, on average, between 2020 and 2049, along an upward trend.
  - Cost-effective adaptation with a balanced mix of protection and planned retreat can reduce these losses to 1 percent of GDP per year.
  - Adaptation strategies include rendering infrastructure more climate resilient, retreating from coastal areas by transferring infrastructure to better protected regions, and introducing building codes for resilient construction standards.
  - Despite high average precipitation, periodic droughts pose risks due to limited catchment/retention capacity and dilapidated infrastructure; major investments (potentially with external support) will be needed to ensure stable drinking water supply.

*Source: IMF staff calculations.*

### 30.      Adaptation and mitigation will be most effective if integrated into the development

### 30.      Adaptation and mitigation will be most effective if integrated into the development planning.

### Integration of adaptation and mitigation into development planning
- Cost-benefit analyses, including monetization of externalities, will be useful for efficiently allocating resources across competing spending needs and the quantification of distributional effects.
- Removing barriers to efficient adaptation by the private sector will help unlock private investment.
- Completion of the National Disaster Preparedness Baseline Assessment and the ongoing update of the Palau Climate Change Policy are welcome.

### Energy, carbon pricing, and private sector entry
- Palau’s NDC targets appear ambitious given the small share of its renewable energy production.
- There is room to improve the energy generation mix through carbon pricing and the ongoing reform of the PPUC, which may facilitate market entry of private renewable energy producers.
- Reducing reliance on imported fuel could support external balance.
- PPUC’s targets:
  - 10 percent of energy generation via solar farms by 2024.
  - 25 percent of energy generation via solar farms by 2025.
- Authorities are on track to implement their strategy of significantly increasing the economy’s reliance on renewable (solar) energy and upgrading the power distribution infrastructure to improve reliability of supply.
- The authorities are formulating Palau’s second NDC, which will emphasize transportation and waste management.
- Energy costs are already relatively high in Palau given its remote location; any adjustments to the carbon tax would depend on the level of current prices and local incomes.

### Public financial management (PFM) and fiscal integration of climate risks
- Incorporate climate considerations in the budgeting process.
- Integrate climate and natural disaster risks into fiscal risks assessments.
- Strengthen assessment criteria for public investment planning and project appraisal to ensure:
  - adherence to resilient building codes, and
  - incorporation of vulnerability to climate events.
- These PFM reforms can help access climate risk financing from multilateral climate funds.
- Authorities plan to complete and issue a building code to promote more weather-resistant and climate-friendly technologies.

### Authorities’ views on development and investment facilitation
- Pivot toward becoming a higher value tourism destination is underway; strategy to attract digital nomads and other longer stay visitors contracted with a consulting company.
- Upgrading the Port of Malakal to accommodate larger vessels for commercial and military use is being pursued.
- A One-Stop-Shop concept for business license and permit applications for foreign investment is near completion.

### Statistical capacity and data improvements
- Palau’s statistics are broadly adequate for surveillance but need further capacity and TA to strengthen quality and timeliness of macroeconomic data.
- Priority areas for improvement:
  - improving GDP deflators,
  - broadening the coverage of fiscal data to the general government level,
  - development of quarterly statistics for BOP, real, and fiscal sectors.
- Palau implemented the enhanced General Data Dissemination System (e-GDDS) in February 2022, with support from the IMF Statistics Department; the rebasing of GDP in FY22 was an important step.
- Efforts underway:
  - enhance monitoring and analysis of climate change data,
  - introduction of PGST offers an opportunity to collect comprehensive corporate data,
  - finalize the ongoing Household Expenditure and Income Survey in early-2024 to update demographics, socio-economic indicators, and provide new CPI weights,
  - develop new statistical indicators for environmental and climate statistics and greater use of Geographical Information Systems (GIS) to assess vulnerabilities.

### Staff appraisal — macroeconomic and fiscal outlook
- Pandemic impacts and recovery:
  - The pandemic reduced GDP by over 20 percent and led to a significant increase in public debt.
  - Inflation reached historically high levels driven by high food and fuel import prices, PGST introduction and one-off utility tariff adjustments.
  - Palau’s external position was substantially weaker than implied by fundamentals and desirable policies in FY2022.
- CRA-23:
  - While still subject to approval in the U.S. Congress, the signing of CRA-23, under better financial terms, improves macroeconomic prospects.
  - The new CRA-23, once approved, is expected to significantly enhance fiscal space, pay down debt, rebuild fiscal buffers, and expand spending in priority areas including education, health, social security, infrastructure, and adaptation to climate change.
- Risks to the outlook:
  - Delays in US Congress approval of CRA-23,
  - a weaker recovery in the tourism sector,
  - commodity price volatility,
  - extreme climate events, such as potential droughts related to El Nino.
- Fiscal policy stance:
  - The fiscal balance (including grants) is projected to return to a surplus in FY2023 and improve further in FY2024.
  - Given high uncertainty and lingering inflationary environment, a contractionary fiscal stance in FY2024 is appropriate while further protecting the most vulnerable from cost-of-living shocks.
  - Historical loss of purchasing power may call for a larger—and more targeted—support for the most vulnerable.
- Medium-term fiscal strategy recommendations:
  - Integrate concrete policies and projects to support development objectives while rebuilding fiscal buffers.
  - Adopt a prudent fiscal stance in line with the Fiscal Responsibility Framework.
  - Conduct a full review of government saving vehicles and adopt a new debt management strategy.
  - Ensure uninterrupted future revenue mobilization while improving expenditure efficiency.
- Fiscal risks and PFM reforms needed:
  - Focus reforms on the pension system (in particular the civil service scheme), public sector employment and wage bill management, and policies to address emigration challenges.
  - Improve transparency, audit reports, oversight of state-owned enterprises, and capacity building.
- Financial sector and fintech:
  - Monitor asset quality as pandemic support measures expire; potential increase of non-performing loans at NDBP warrants attention.
  - Enhance financial sector supervision with a focus on FIC resources and international standards.
  - Address structural impediments (collateral issues, record keeping) and establish a credit bureau.
  - Approach fintech initiatives cautiously: first close gaps in legal and AML/CFT frameworks and strengthen regulatory and governance frameworks before expanding digital financial services.
- Structural reforms:
  - Streamline business processes, diversify and increase value-added in tourism.
  - Improve the regulatory framework and land-use planning, rule of law in property rights and contracts, and infrastructure.
  - Invest in education and health to close skill gaps and raise productivity and incomes.

### Adaptation strategy guidance (from staff appraisal and Box 2)
- Adaptation strategies should consider:
  - rendering existing infrastructure more climate resilient, or
  - retreating from coastal areas by transferring infrastructure (such as health care and education facilities) to better protected regions.
- Cost-benefit analyses will be useful for efficiently allocating resources across competing spending needs.
- Standard practices of cost-benefit analysis (CBA) must apply to adaptation projects; challenges to CBA implementation in adaptation projects are noted.

### Box 2 — Climate Change Impacts and Adaptation Policies in Palau (scenarios and estimated impacts)
- Climate risks highlighted:
  - sea-level rise, ocean acidification, and increased frequency and intensity of extreme rainfall events.
- Sea-level projections (Australian Bureau of Meteorology and CSIRO estimates relative to 1986–2005 average):
  - by 2030: an additional 8 to 18 cm.
  - by 2070 (if emissions follow present trends, SSP2-4.5): 23 to 48 cm.
- Vulnerability:
  - About 30 percent of Palau’s population would be impacted by sea level rise and storm surge (Pacific Disaster Center estimate).
- CIAM scenarios under baseline assumption that global emissions follow present trends:
  - (i) No planned adaptation:
    - cost of sea-level rise estimated to be as high as 4 percent of GDP in 2040 annually.
    - major contributors: inundation-related loss of land, relocation, and storm damages.
  - (ii) Full protection:
    - would require an investment of approximately 2 percent of annual GDP in 2040.
    - would require an upfront investment of up to 5 percent of annual GDP during the present decade.
  - (iii) Efficient adaptation:
    - involves costs approximately equal to 1 percent of GDP, annually, throughout the century.
- Model caveats:
  - Estimates subject to significant uncertainty related to modelling assumptions and projected trajectory of sea-level rise.
  - Discontinuity in adaptation costs between 2040 and 2050 is due to the optimization problem treating adaptation up to 2050 and after as distinct problems.
- Policy takeaway:
  - Sea-level rise costs can be greatly contained with careful planning and a balanced mix of protection and planned retreat.
  - Investment in seawalls and similar expensive infrastructure should be assessed case-by-case using high-resolution analysis.
  - Planned retreat can minimize losses without large capital investment but requires assessing distributional effects; cost-benefit analysis provides a framework to estimate social costs and benefits.

### Recent climate-related events affecting Palau (estimated impacts)
- Typhoon Bopha, 2012 — 15-20 (millions of USD)
- Typoom Haiyan, 2013 — 9.7 (millions of USD)
- Drought from El Nino, 2016-17 — 3.2 (millions of USD)
- Tropical Cycline Surigae, 2021 — 4.8 (millions of USD)

*REPUBLIC OF PALAU  INTERNATIONAL MONETARY FUND*

### Box 2. Climate Change Impacts and Adaptation Policies in Palau (concluded)

### Box 2. Climate Change Impacts and Adaptation Policies in Palau (concluded)

### Climate change impacts and adaptation challenges
- Other impacts of climate change are harder to quantify and could be sizable.
- Additional outlays may be necessary to accommodate rising temperatures, and intensifying rainfall but the cost implications of these climate phenomena are difficult to estimate with the available models.
- The risk of coral bleaching, acidity of sea water, and sea-water temperature will intensify with potential negative effects on biodiversity, fisheries, and tourism.
- Events like the strong 1998 and 2016 El Niño that contributed to massive coral bleaching and decline of sea life in near shore areas become more likely with increasing temperatures.

### Demographics and labor market findings
- Palau’s population has declined over the past decades and elderly dependency ratio has increased.
- Palau’s population is concentrated mainly in Koror, with the rest of the country not densely populated.
- Palau’s population is composed of a large share of non-Palauan workers, mainly from Asia.
- Labor force participation and employment ratios of females are slightly lower than males.
- Employment declined during the pandemic, mainly reflecting the tourism-related sectors.
- Foreign workers experienced the largest drop in employment.

Key demographic and macroeconomic statistics
- Nominal GDP for FY2022: US$246 million
- Population (2022): 17,674
- GDP per capita for FY2022: US$13,941
- Quota: SDR 4.9 million

### Tourism and real sector impacts
- The COVID-19 pandemic severely contracted Palau’s tourism industry.
- Despite fully reopening in July 2022 a recovery in tourism arrivals has been impacted by travel restrictions in source markets.
- Recovery in Palau has been slower compared to other PICs.
- Inflation has surged to regional highs driven by high import prices.
- Credit to the private sector remained stable driven by higher lending from the National Development Bank.

Selected tourism indicators (from Table 1)
- Tourist arrivals (number of visitors) in past years: 115,997; 89,726; 41,753; 3,412; 9,247; 35,052; 70,509; 91,681; 106,686; 110,954; 115,392
- Expenditure per Tourist Arrival (US$): 909; 971; 1,009; 1,261; 1,765; 1,194; 1,241; 1,265; 1,289; 1,315; 1,341

### External sector developments
- After successive declines since FY2016, associated with lower tourist arrivals, exports plummeted in FY2020-21 due to the pandemic.
- While imports fell during the pandemic, reflecting lower economic activity, imports picked up more recently due to higher commodity prices, primarily on fuel.
- Palau’s real exchange rate appreciated significantly, higher than in other pacific island countries, contributing to the widening of the current account deficit.
- External debt increased sharply during FY2020-22, mainly driven by borrowing from ADB but is projected to decline thanks to the recovery and the fiscal consolidation grants.
- The current account deficit is expected to rapidly improve from FY2022 onwards as tourism activities resume.

Selected external sector figures (from Table 2)
- Current account balance (millions US$): -54.8; -86.8; -121.5; -100.6; -134.9; -109.2; -82.1; -75.1; -60.2; -56.9; -53.0
- Goods balance (millions US$): -138.2; -140.9; -149.7; -127.1; -157.2; -149.0; -171.7; -191.4; -201.1; -206.3; -211.2
- Services balance (millions US$): 44.9; 30.8; -7.5; -33.7; -39.5; -20.4; 13.8; 36.6; 57.3; 63.3; 69.8
- Exports of services (millions US$): 107.8; 95.3; 47.2; 9.7; 22.1; 47.7; 88.7; 115.0; 135.3; 143.8; 152.6
- Travel receipts (millions US$): 95.7; 83.4; 39.2; 4.1; 15.4; 37.5; 78.8; 104.6; 124.3; 132.1; 140.4
- External debt (percent of GDP): 29.5; 30.5; 52.4; 70.7; 68.4; 66.2; 53.8; 45.4; 41.7; 37.4; 33.7
- International Investment Position (percent of GDP): -21.6; -47.6; -66.2; -74.0; -151.4; -155.9; -119.2; -102.5; -106.0; -108.0; -109.3

### Fiscal sector developments
- Domestic tax and other revenue are recovering from a prolonged economic contraction and a deep loss of tourism-related revenues.
- Current spending (expense) soared, mainly driven by one-off subsidies, social benefits, and transfers.
- Palau has the largest public sector in the Pacific; recent public sector wage raises have pushed up its share in overall expenditures.
- Palau’s fiscal balance widened more than that of peers in the Pacific, reflecting its heavy reliance on tourism and a large pandemic support to the private sector.
- The pandemic resulted in the second highest jump in public debt relative to the region.
- Government deposits are accumulating as the pandemic-related financing needs diminish.

Selected fiscal figures (from Table 1 and Table 3)
- Central government revenue (percent of GDP) by year: 43.9; 42.4; 45.4; 57.6; 57.7; 48.9; 51.7; 48.2; 47.5; 47.0; 46.7
- Grants (percent of GDP) by year: 17.1; 17.8; 21.7; 33.6; 35.0; 22.1; 24.9; 22.4; 21.8; 21.4; 21.2
- Expenditure (percent of GDP) by year: 37.7; 42.7; 58.6; 65.3; 61.0; 48.6; 49.8; 47.6; 47.2; 46.7; 46.5
- Expense (percent of GDP) by year: 35.4; 36.7; 52.1; 56.9; 52.5; 44.1; 41.3; 40.0; 39.9; 39.8; 39.7
- Current fiscal balance (excluding grants, percent of GDP) by year: -8.6; -12.2; -28.4; -32.9; -29.8; -17.3; -14.4; -14.2; -14.1; -14.2; -14.1
- General government debt (percent of GDP) by year: 29.5; 30.5; 52.4; 70.7; 68.4; 66.2; 53.8; 45.4; 41.7; 37.4; 33.7
- Compact Trust Fund (in percent of GDP) by year: 103.1; 101.6; 108.7; 136.6; 100.1; 99.4; 105.8; 110.9; 109.4; 109.2; 109.6

### Financial sector and banking soundness
- Credit to the private sector (in percent of GDP) recent values: 20.3; 20.6; 23.1; 26.3; 25.5
- Commercial bank loans (in percent of GDP) memorandum: 10.5; 12.5; 12.7; 11.9; 12.7; 13.0; 12.8
- Banking sector indicators (Table 5) include Tier 1 capital to assets: 1.25; 1.27; 1.39; 1.10; 1.08; 1.15 and Return on assets: 1.55; 1.94; 2.11; 1.03; 1.05; 1.54.
- Liquid assets to total assets (liquid asset ratio): 85.95; 86.15; 85.00; 88.18; 89.02; 87.50.

### Policy recommendations and implementation (from 2021 Article IV consultation)
Fiscal policy recommendations and actions taken
- Recommendation: Extend fiscal relief measures until recovery is firmly entrenched; improve targeting and taper unemployment benefits; avoid across-the-board cuts except for priority areas.
  - Action: Spending under the CROSS Act was accelerated during FY2022. Support measures expired in FY2022.
- Recommendation: Enhance governance safeguards to improve spending efficiency (timely reporting and integration of COVID-related spending, ex-post audits, publish beneficial ownership information).
  - Action: Authorities published detailed information on COVID-related spending in their 2022 Fiscal Update; progress with ex-post audits and plan to publish all reports as soon as possible.
- Recommendation: Implement tax reform with supporting regulations and IT modernization to prevent abuse of PGST refunds and enhance revenue.
  - Action: The tax reform was implemented successfully in January 2023; authorities are prioritizing adopting a new IT system and digitalization in the next phase.
- Recommendation: Strengthen public financial management (PFM) and public investment management; conduct PEFA assessment; implement Fiscal Responsibility and Debt Management Act with safeguards and escape clauses.
  - Action: Authorities conducted an agile PEFA assessment and are outlining a PFM roadmap; the Fiscal Responsibility and Debt Management Act was passed in November 2021; the PFM Roadmap will support effective implementation of the Fiscal Responsibility Framework.
- Recommendation: Swift comprehensive reforms for sustainability of CSPF and SSF.
  - Action: Some reform proposals are under discussion for CSPF, and new legislation is submitted to OEK for SSF.

Financial sector recommendations and actions taken
- Recommendation: Support distressed but viable businesses with targeted temporary measures (extension of lending schemes and credit guarantees), avoid relaxation of loan classification and provisioning rules.
  - Action: Pandemic support measures have been phased out.
- Recommendation: Boost credit creation by supporting SMEs to prepare business plans and strengthen NDBP lending capacity, including possibly allowing NDBP to take deposits.
  - Action: Implementation of tax reform in 2023 is expected to help improve financial reporting among SMEs. There is interest in having NDBP take deposits, though bank license process can be involved.
- Recommendation: Maintain moratorium on crypto-asset activities and strengthen AML/CFT supervision and designate supervisors for non-bank financial institutions and DNFBPs.
  - Action: The moratorium applies to financial institutions regulated by FIC and has limited coverage. Authorities intend to adopt regulations to bring VA/VASPs under FIC regulation and are working to enhance capacity of FIC/FIU with technical assistance.

Structural policy recommendations and actions taken
- Recommendation: Streamline foreign investment processes, improve regulatory framework and land-use planning, upgrade climate-resilient infrastructure, enhance human capital, and tap climate risk financing.
  - Action: Authorities are finalizing their National Development Plan to identify priorities. Palau is keen to tap into more climate risk financing; a new ADB loan includes financing for climate change adaptation policies. The new COFA agreement allows grants to be used to address climate change risks.
- Recommendation: Reform PPUC to improve financial sustainability and facilitate entry of private renewable energy producers.
  - Action: Authorities initiated reform of PPUC; in 2021 an independent regulatory process was adopted to assist in establishing cost recovery tariffs and gradually eliminating tariff caps. Governance and management reforms were undertaken to improve profitability.

*Source: Box 2. Climate Change Impacts and Adaptation Policies in Palau (concluded), 1plwea2023001.*

### Annex I. A New Compact of Free Association Agreement

### Annex I. A New Compact of Free Association Agreement

### Overview
- Palau’s 2023 Compact Review Agreement (CRA) with the US for the next 20 years is estimated to total US$889 million dollars, or 367 percent of FY2022 GDP.
- The draft legislation for the new CRA, signed by Palau and the US on May 2023, is currently with the US Congress for approval.
- Palau will continue to be eligible for US Federal programs and services under the new CRA.
- The baseline scenario assumes approval and enactment sometime in FY2024; previous Compact approvals experienced lengthy delays (2010 CRA approval took until FY2018 and required an increase of US$229 million for FY2019-24).

### Proposed Financial Support and Annual Profile
- Total financing over FY2024-2043: 888.9 (millions of US$).
- Annual disbursement in 2024 (millions of US$) and totals (2024-2043, millions of US$):
  - Budget Grants: 20 ; 486.0
  - Infrastructure Grants: 10 ; 243.0
  - Debt Relief (2024-2029): 10 ; 60.0
  - Contribution to CTF (2024-2025): 50 ; 100.0
  - Total Financing: 90 ; 888.9
- Allowed annual withdrawal from CTF (2024-2043): Capped at 15 million during 2024-26 but can be increased to up to 4 percent of the three-year moving average of the CTF value beyond 2026.
- The renewed compact will deliver about 30 million in the first year (FY2024) (excluding the Compact Trust Fund withdrawals), compared with about US$17 million projected to get in for the same year under the current CRA.
- Estimated annual average support: about 38-44 million per annum (16 percent of FY2023 projected GDP) in financial support (including budget support, contributions to the Compact Trust Fund, support for debt payment).

### CRA Components and Conditions
- Increase in annual grants: from US$15 million previously to US$20 million in FY2024 (an additional 2.1 percent of GDP over FY2023), indexed to increase by 2 percent a year. Eligible uses: education, health, climate adaptation, justice, public safety, and CRA-related audits (new rule).
- Infrastructure grants: US$5 million (indexed at 2 percent per year) in infrastructure grants, project-by-project, only for projects identified in Palau’s National Infrastructure Investment Plan 2021-30 or a similar updated plan; monitored annually as part of the budget process.
- Infrastructure maintenance requirement: mandatory budget of at least US$1 million a year for infrastructure maintenance; US contribution of US$5 million a year through FY2033, indexed at 2 percent, to the Infrastructure Maintenance Fund for US-government financed projects.
- Fiscal Consolidation Fund: annual US contributions of US$10 million in FY2024-29, exclusively to discharge government debts owed to ADB (prior to April 1, 2023) and possibly Taiwan, Province of China, subject to special approval.
- Compact Trust Fund (CTF): US$100 million over FY2024-25 contribution; annual withdrawals capped at US$15 million during FY2024-26 (as at present) and can be increased to up to 4 percent of the three-year moving average of the CTF value thereafter. Use of funds limited as under the budget grant eligibility. Additional withdrawals, including for emergencies, can be negotiated.

### Eligibility for Federal Services and New Provisions
- Potential extension of Palau’s eligibility for federal services and programs normally available to US state and local governments, and possible introduction of new ones under separate negotiation (examples under consideration: FEMA disaster relief, extending FDIC coverage to Palauan banks).
- Introduction of fiscal procedures tied to CRA: development of an annual implementation plan, grant administration, preparation of annual financial reports, and contracts and procurement.

### Risks to Timeliness and Interim Arrangements
- Risks of delayed approval by US Congress remain elevated.
- During years awaiting US final approval, Palau previously drew US$5 million a year from the original CTF and continued to benefit from some US Federal programs.
- In the absence of budgetary assistance grants, Palau’s response to negative shocks entailed a significant spike in external borrowing, primarily from ADB.
- Policy recommendations to mitigate delay risk:
  - Secure alternative financing sources and interim arrangements to avoid a large fiscal contraction and maintain spending on priority areas.
  - Accelerate efforts to enhance revenue mobilization and fiscal reforms to secure debt sustainability.

*Source: Annex I. A New Compact of Free Association Agreement*

### Annex I

### 1plwea2023001 - Annex I

### Risk Assessment Matrix (RAM) and Overview
- The RAM shows events that could materially alter the baseline path; staff subjective likelihood categories: "low" = probability below 10 percent, "medium" = probability between 10 and 30 percent, and "high" = probability between 30 and 50 percent.
- The RAM reflects staff views as of the time of discussions with the authorities; non-mutually exclusive risks may interact and materialize jointly.
- Overall risk of sovereign stress: Moderate.
  - Near-term: Medium (note on publication: the near-term assessment is not applicable in cases with a disbursing IMF arrangement; in surveillance-only or precautionary cases it is performed but not published).
  - Medium-term: Low (supported by significant financial support through a new Compact Agreement with the United States).
  - Long-term: Moderate (reflecting large spending needs due to climate change and pensions).
- If the Compact were approved, overall risk assessment would have been Low.
- Key risk: potential delay in Compact funding constitutes a key risk.
- Staff view: Palau will continue to operate under its Fiscal Responsibility and Debt Management Act to help maintain fiscal surpluses.

### Debt Sustainability Analysis (DSA) — Summary Assessment and Commentary
- Debt dynamics:
  - Debt declines over the medium-term in the baseline and under risk scenarios, largely due to the new Compact agreement.
  - Debt stabilization in the baseline.
- DSA summary points:
  - Compact agreement with the United States involves significantly higher budget and infrastructure grants and debt consolidation grants.
  - Most indicators have started to normalize as the recovery proceeds after the COVID-related economic contraction.
  - Compact debt consolidation grants during FY2024-2029 will ensure that debt declines at a solid pace and cash buffers are built up.
  - Medium-term liquidity risks will be offset by the increase in grants under the signed Compact.
  - Debt reduction will help free up fiscal space, but reforms to tackle pension liabilities remain critical to secure long-term fiscal sustainability.

### Debt Coverage, Structure, and Disclosures
- Coverage: General government debt consistent with GFS 2014.
- Subsector inclusion in baseline:
  - Budgetary central government: Yes
  - Extra budgetary funds (EBFs): No
  - Social security funds (SSFs): Yes
  - State governments: Yes
  - Local governments: Yes
  - Public nonfinancial corporations: Yes
  - Central bank: No
  - Other public financial corporations: Yes
- Commentary on portfolio composition: Palau's debt portfolio is extremely prudent and consists of only external, highly concessional, multilateral (mostly ADB) long-term debt denominated in domestic currency (U.S. dollars).

### Baseline Scenario — Key Projections (percent of GDP unless indicated)
- Public debt trajectory (actual and projections):
  - 2022: 68.4
  - 2023: 66.2
  - 2024: 53.8
  - 2025: 45.4
  - 2026: 41.7
  - 2027: 37.4
  - 2028: 33.7
  - 2029: 30.3
  - 2030: 29.4
  - 2031: 28.5
  - 2032: 27.6
- Change in public debt:
  - 2022: -2.3
  - 2023: -2.2
  - 2024: -12.3
  - 2025: -8.4
  - 2026: -3.8
  - 2027: -4.3
  - 2028: -3.7
  - 2029: -3.4
  - 2030: -0.9
  - 2031: -0.9
  - 2032: -0.9
- Primary deficit (percent of GDP):
  - 2022: 1.5
  - 2023: -2.9
  - 2024: -4.5
  - 2025: -2.6
  - 2026: -2.0
  - 2027: -1.8
  - 2028: -1.5
  - 2029: -1.5
  - 2030: -1.5
  - 2031: -1.4
  - 2032: -1.4
- Noninterest revenues (percent of GDP):
  - 2022: 57.7
  - 2023: 48.9
  - 2024: 51.7
  - 2025: 48.2
  - 2026: 47.5
  - 2027: 47.0
  - 2028: 46.7
  - 2029: 45.4
  - 2030: 44.0
  - 2031: 42.8
  - 2032: 41.5
- Noninterest expenditures (percent of GDP):
  - 2022: 59.2
  - 2023: 46.0
  - 2024: 47.2
  - 2025: 45.6
  - 2026: 45.6
  - 2027: 45.2
  - 2028: 45.2
  - 2029: 43.9
  - 2030: 42.6
  - 2031: 41.4
  - 2032: 40.1
- Automatic debt dynamics:
  - 2022: -2.2
  - 2023: -2.2
  - 2024: -6.9
  - 2025: -4.4
  - 2026: -0.5
  - 2027: 0.1
  - 2028: 0.3
  - 2029: 0.5
  - 2030: 0.5
  - 2031: 0.5
  - 2032: 0.5
- Real interest rate and relative inflation (percent):
  - 2022: -3.6
  - 2023: -1.6
  - 2024: 0.4
  - 2025: 1.3
  - 2026: 1.1
  - 2027: 0.9
  - 2028: 0.8
  - 2029: 0.8
  - 2030: 0.8
  - 2031: 0.8
  - 2032: 0.8
- Real GDP growth (percent):
  - Memo: Real GDP growth (percent):
    - 2022: -2.0
    - 2023: 0.8
    - 2024: 12.4
    - 2025: 11.9
    - 2026: 3.5
    - 2027: 2.0
    - 2028: 1.5
    - 2029: 1.0
    - 2030: 1.0
    - 2031: 1.0
    - 2032: 1.0
- Inflation (GDP deflator; percent):
  - 2022: 8.1
  - 2023: 8.0
  - 2024: 4.0
  - 2025: 1.9
  - 2026: 1.9
  - 2027: 2.0
  - 2028: 2.0
  - 2029: 2.0
  - 2030: 2.0
  - 2031: 2.0
  - 2032: 2.0
- Effective interest rate (percent):
  - 2022: 2.7
  - 2023: 5.4
  - 2024: 4.7
  - 2025: 4.7
  - 2026: 4.4
  - 2027: 4.2
  - 2028: 4.2
  - 2029: 4.5
  - 2030: 4.9
  - 2031: 4.8
  - 2032: 4.8
- Commentary: Public debt will be declining due to fiscal consolidation grants FY2024-29, improving primary balances and growth recovery.

### Near-Term Risk Analysis (Figure 5)
- Logit stress probability (LSP) to predict stress in [t+1, t+2]:
  - 2019 (to predict 2020-21): 0.133
  - 2020 (to predict 2021-22): 0.547
  - 2021 (to predict 2022-23): 0.694
  - 2022 (to predict 2023-24): 0.520
- Change in LSP:
  - 2020-21: 0.032
  - 2021-22: 0.414
  - 2022-23: 0.148
  - 2023-24: -0.174
- Contributions to change in LSP (selected):
  - Institutional quality (examples): -0.001, -0.007, 0.010, 0.000 (by year)
  - Stress history: 0.000, 0.109, 0.122, -0.025
  - Cyclical position: 0.040, 0.082, 0.083, 0.109
  - Debt burden & buffers: -0.008, 0.249, -0.067, -0.260
  - Global conditions: 0.000 across listed years
- Probabilities (2023-2024):
  - Prob. of missed crisis, 2023-2024 (if stress not predicted): 86.3 pct.
  - Prob. of false alarm, 2023-2024 (if stress predicted): 1.3 pct.
- Commentary: Near-term risk is moderate reflecting the reversal of one-off expenditures and ongoing economic recovery. High mechanical signal reflects COVID-related sovereign stress due to a large output loss coupled with one-off fiscal support financed by ADB loans.

### Realism of Baseline Assumptions (Figure 6)
- Commentary highlights:
  - Under the new Compact agreement with the US, projected recovery coupled with debt relief will undo the pandemic debt accumulation.
  - Excluding debt relief, realism analysis does not point to major concerns.
  - Palau issues no bonds.
  - As cyclically-adjusted primary balance estimates are not available, primary balances are used instead.
- Selected metrics and percentiles cited (no numerical percentile values supplied beyond references to percentile bands).

### Medium-Term Risk Assessment (Figure 7)
- Fanchart and indices:
  - Fanchart width (percent of GDP): 67.8 1.0 (presented as "67.81.0" in source)
  - Probability of debt non-stabilization (percent): 28.7 0.2 (presented as "28.70.2")
  - Terminal debt-to-GDP x: 33.5 0.7 (presented as "33.50.7")
  - Debt fanchart index (DFI): 2.0
  - Risk signal (DFI-based): Moderate (signal thresholds noted: low if DFI < 1.13; high if DFI > 2.08; otherwise moderate)
- Gross Financing Needs (GFN) module:
  - Average baseline GFN (percent of GDP): 1.3 0.4 (presented as "1.30.4")
  - GFN financeability index (GFI): 0.4
  - Risk signal (GFI-based): Low (signal thresholds noted: low if GFI < 7.6; high if GFI > 17.9; otherwise moderate)
- Medium-term index final assessment: Low risk (final assessment provided in text: "Palau’s risk of sovereign stress in the medium term is low.")
- Probabilities 2023-2028:
  - Prob. of missed crisis, 2023-2028, if stress not predicted: 9.1 pct.
  - Prob. of false alarms, 2023-2028, if stress predicted: 48.9 pct.
- Commentary: Width of fanchart triggers a moderate mechanical signal mainly due to a very large output loss relative to peers during COVID-related border closures; financing risks assessed as low under baseline.

### Climate Change Adaptation — Long-Term Scenarios (Figure 8)
- Key finding: Long-term climate adaptation needs are compatible with stable or declining debt and GFN ratios.
- Financing composition: Most required financing is projected to come in the form of external grants under the new Compact Agreement with the US.
- Scenario presentation:
  - Baseline: Extension of fifth projection year.
  - With climate adaptation (standardized scenario).
  - With climate adaptation (customized scenario).
- Charts indicate trajectories for GFN-to-GDP Ratio and Total Public Debt-to-GDP Ratio under baseline and climate adaptation scenarios (no additional numeric series values provided beyond chart labels).

### Reforming the Pension System in Palau — Annex VI (Summary and Key Statistics)
- Problem statement:
  - Palau’s two publicly underwritten pension schemes are running out of their reserves, implying substantially higher annual budget subsidies (pay-as-you-go financing) in the future.
  - SSRF reserve exhaustion: projected by the mid-2040s.
  - CSPP reserve exhaustion: projected by 2027-28.
- Accrued-to-date liabilities as of 2020:
  - SSRF: approximately US$550 million (250 percent of GDP).
  - CSPP: approximately US$220 million (101 percent of GDP).
  - Of the total (gross) accrued liabilities, unfunded (net) liabilities:
    - SSRF net unfunded liabilities: US$438 million.
    - CSPP net unfunded liabilities: US$189 million.
- Reform objectives and approach:
  - Government aims to reverse or arrest growth of the schemes’ net liabilities while maintaining adequacy of pension benefits.
  - Reconciliation of objectives requires increased revenues for the schemes—higher taxes earmarked for ROPSS and CSPP are an important part of the strategy.
  - The government’s reform concepts have been finalized and translated into draft legislation submitted to legislature in the case of SSRF; CSPP reform details remain under discussion.
- Figure (Reserves over time): SSRF and CSPP reserves plotted 2022–2045 in million USD (chart shown; numeric series not repeated beyond general timing and exhaustion dates).
- Prepared by Csaba Feher (FAD).

*Source: IMF staff (Annex I, 1plwea2023001).*

### 3.      The Social Security Scheme is a contributory, defined benefit scheme where

### 1plwea2023001 - 3.      The Social Security Scheme is a contributory, defined benefit scheme where

### Social Security Retirement Fund (SSRF) — Design and Coverage
- SSRF is a contributory, defined benefit scheme with mandatory participation for all workers, including the self-employed and public sector employees.
- Benefits paid: old age, disability, and survivor pensions in the form of full life annuities.
- Contribution rate: 14 percent, equally split between employers and employees, levied on actual full remuneration or presumed labor income (for self-employed and various entrepreneurs).
- Coverage: universal; high coverage and contribution compliance driven by stable employment in the public sector, SOs and public corporations.
- Contributor counts (2022):
  - SSRF’s active contributors numbered approximately 10.5 thousand in 2022.
  - Currently, the scheme has 12 thousand citizen contributors and 38 thousand non-citizen contributors registered (i.e., people who have contributed at least once during their lifetime).
  - Of those, 4.7 and 4.8 thousand citizen and non-citizen contributors respectively were active (i.e., having at least one salary record in the year).
- Beneficiaries: 3.7 thousand.

### SSRF — Eligibility, Benefits, and Indexation
- Normal retirement age: 60.
- Minimum contribution history ensuring eligibility: 9.5 years.
- Replacement rate schedule: progressive (higher income brackets replaced to a lesser extent).
- Cumulative lifetime earnings calculation: adding nominal values without valorizing them in line with past wage dynamics.
- Benefits are not indexed; subject to a contributory minimum of US$148 per month which is not indexed.
- To compensate for lack of indexation, ad-hoc supplemental benefits (three supplements at US$50 per month each) awarded over the past 10 years effectively raised the minimum pension to US$298 per month.

### SSRF — Funding Position and Projections
- Funding ratio on an accrued-to-date liability basis: estimated at 20 percent as of 2020.
- Benefit expenditures systematically exceed contribution revenues by approximately 30 percent.
- Reserves: currently at US$115 million, equal to approximately 50 percent of GDP.
- Projection: reserves predicted to be exhausted by 2044. Once reserves are depleted, SSRF will become pay-as-you-go and will require additional resources to stay current on benefit obligations — options include higher contribution rates or direct deficit financing by the treasury.
- Additional note: migrant workers’ contributions usually don’t lead to vested pension rights and benefit payment; decline in overseas workers can profoundly negatively affect SSRF contribution revenues.

### Civil Service Pension Plan (CSPP) — Design and Current Finances
- CSPP is a contributory, occupational, defined benefit pension scheme for public sector employees.
- Membership and beneficiaries: 3300 active contributors and 1600 pensioners.
- Dual contributions: Active CSPP members also contribute to SSRF and receive pensions from both schemes.
- Contribution rate: 12 percent of gross wages, split equally between employees and the government (as employer).
- Eligibility: age 60 and at least five years of contributions.
- Accrual: benefits accrue at 2 percent per year, applied to the best three years’ salary (final salary scheme characteristic).
- Past earnings in pension formula: not valorized to historic wage dynamics; benefits are not indexed.
- Replacement outcomes:
  - CSPP benefits combined with SSRF pensions are over 70 percent of best (or final) salaries in the case of more than 90 percent of CSPP retirees.
  - Close to 30 percent of retiring civil servants receive a combined pension which is over 125 percent of their best (final) average salaries.
- Finances and reserves:
  - CSPP contribution revenues cover approximately two-thirds of its expenditures, with the shortfall financed by drawing down reserves.
  - CSPP reserves are equal to approximately 14 percent of its accrued-to-date liabilities and are declining at a rate which implies total reserve depletion by 202 .
  - After reserve depletion, limiting benefits to contribution revenues implies either a benefit reduction of between 50 and 58 percent or a contribution rate increase from today’s 12 percent to between 20 and 25 percent.
  - Alternatively, the scheme would need significant annual budget transfers equal to roughly half of its benefit expenditures.

### Reform Objectives and Overview
- Government reform objectives:
  (i) improve the pension schemes’ financial sustainability and curtail the government’s exposure to underwriting risks;
  (ii) improve SSRF’s generosity and make its pension formula more progressive;
  (iii) bring SSRF regulations in line with good practice;
  (iv) transform CSPP into a defined contribution scheme.
- SSRF reform measures have been submitted as the “Social Security Continuity Bill”; CSPP reform is in preparatory phase.
- Government is considering expanding the reformed CSPP coverage to the private sector, making it an additional component of universal, mandatory pension insurance.

### Proposed SSRF Reforms — Key Elements
- Normal retirement age proposed to increase from 60 to 65 years for both men and women, starting immediately after the amendment’s effectiveness.
- Early retirement: available from no more than five years prior to the normal retirement age, with high, nonlinear early retirement penalties designed to exceed the actuarially neutral deduction.
- Deferred retirement: rewarded with nonlinear benefit increases; incomes earned after normal retirement age won’t be liable to contributions and will not generate additional pension entitlements.
- Introduction of systematic, rule-based indexing of pension benefits (bill proposes indexing to wages; authorities may wish to consider indexing to prices).
- Benefit formula transformation:
  - Move from relatively low minimum plus higher earnings-related component to a more generous minimum complemented by earnings-related pensions calculated along lower replacement rates.
  - New minimum paid in full to everyone retiring with at least 38 quarters of contributions (full career defined as 140 quarters (35 years)).
  - Earnings-related component pro-rated according to contribution history relative to full career.
- Valorization and indexation:
  - Past wages considered in pension formula will be valorized to economy-wide wage dynamics (rather than adding nominal values).
  - Benefits, the US$4,000 per annum minimum pension, and the brackets determining the replacement rate schedule will be indexed annually to wages.
- Transition rules:
  - Until 2027, newly awarded pensions will be calculated according to both old and new formulae, paying the higher of the two; recalculation expected regularly during its five years of implementation.
- Revenue measures:
  - Contribution rate increase from today’s 14 percent to 18 percent proposed.
  - The authorities note that increasing retirement age and contribution rate may be difficult to secure legislatively.
- New basic pension:
  - Introduces a new, basic pension benefit of 4,000 dollars per year, replacing current minimum and pension supplements.
  - Eligibility conditional on a full career of 38 quarters of contribution history (to increase gradually, in line with retirement age increase); shorter careers merit proportionally smaller basic pension.
  - Workers with less than 38 quarters will be ineligible for the basic pension.
  - Expected effects: greater internal redistribution, higher average pensions due to valorization, annual indexation, and a 10 percent one-off increase of the minimum pension (from today’s US$298 to US$333 per month).

### Proposed CSPP Reforms — Key Elements
- Structural reform: close current DB scheme to new accruals and collect future contributions in individual pension accounts — transition from defined benefit to defined contribution.
- Government commitment: honor accrued rights (pensions already in service and active workers’ entitlements).
- Differentiated applicability by contribution history and age:
  - Pensions already in payment remain unchanged.
  - Employees with less than 10 years of contributions: employee contributions credited to DC accounts.
  - Workers with more than 10 but less than 20 years: both employee and employer contributions credited immediately to DC accounts.
  - Workers with more than 20 years of service but further than 5 years from retirement: option for two pensions (one DB for accruals up to reform and one DC) or past contributions plus interest credited to DC individual account.
  - People closer than 5 years to retirement: not impacted by structural reform but benefits subjected to a reduction (combined limit or straight deduction of between 0 and 20 percent).
- Transitional deficit (double-financing issue): entitlements in current DB scheme must be financed while new revenues redirected to DC accounts.
- Proposed measures to address transitional deficit include:
  - Increasing the recently introduced value-added tax (PGST) by 20 percent, from 10 to 12 percent.
  - Cutting in half the employer (government) contributions to the new DC account (from today’s   to 3 percent).
- Additional parametric adjustments under consideration: increase retirement age to 65, reduce accrual rate, impose a joint ceiling on publicly underwritten pension benefits (SSRF + CSPP).

### Assessment and Recommendations — SSRF
- Reforms align SSRF with best practice and government social policy objectives of greater redistribution toward lower earners and shorter careers.
- Gaps and recommended clarifications in the bill:
  - Missing provisions: conditions of eligibility, benefit level, and other regulations pertaining to the basic pension are omitted from the bill and should be added.
  - Treatment of workers with contribution histories falling short of minimum eligibility is unclear; regulatory completeness requires coverage of short careers consistent with social policy and fiscal space.
  - Treatment of foreign contributors is silent; equity considerations argue for:
    - establishing international social security agreements with home countries of foreign workers, or
    - if home countries operate no pension schemes, compensation payable either as past contributions or proportional pensions at retirement.
- Pace of retirement age increase: proposed one year each year may be fast; options to improve acceptability include slower increase (e.g., six or three months per year), deferred commencement, or a combination.

### Assessment and Recommendations — CSPP
- Reform objective of stopping build-up of unfunded liabilities is addressed by shifting to DC, but accrued-to-date liabilities remain and must be financed by government after DB reserves are depleted.
- Parametric measures to consider augmenting reforms:
  - Lower the accrual rate from 2 percent to between 1.4 and 1.8 percent could cut benefit expenditures by 10 to 30 percent.
  - Expand the calculation base from best three years to full earning career and valorize past earnings with economywide wage index to reduce expenditures and increase equity; retroactive application needed for tangible impact.
- Payout phase clarification: social policy considerations argue for mandating annuity purchase at retirement; while no life insurers exist in Palau, dollar use and access to US financial markets mitigates the challenge.
- Note on reform options: replacing the current DB scheme with a reformed DB arrangement could avoid the double-financing problem; government preference for DC is understood but a reformed DB could permit a more gradual shift.

*Source: 1plwea2023001*

### Annex VII. Palau’s Fiscal Responsibility Framework

### Annex VII. Palau’s Fiscal Responsibility Framework

### Principles of Fiscal Responsibility (FRDMA §105)
- Managing operating expenditures over the medium-term within operating revenues and in relation to the rate of growth of the economy.
- Managing net capital and financial assets, including the COFA Trust Fund, to achieve rising real national net worth over time.
- Managing debt prudently.
- Managing the revenue regime to best fit the structure of the economy, to provide for an equitable allocation of tax burdens, and to allow for predictability over time.
- Managing reserves and insurance coverage to offset cyclical volatility, the costs of natural disasters, and the impact of climate change.
- Managing the non-primary government public sector prudently, including ensuring State-Owned Enterprises (SOEs) and Public Financial Institutions (PIFs) are managed to deliver services on an effective and financially sustainable basis.
- Managing fiscal risks and contingent liabilities prudently.

### Temporary Departures and Disclosure Requirements
- The Government may depart from the principles of responsibility provided the departure is temporary.
- The President must state the reason for the departure and indicate the timeline to return to adherence to the principles.
- Any such departures during the fiscal year must be timely disclosed in accordance with the provisions of the FRDMA.

### Fiscal Strategy Submission Requirement
- The President is required to submit to the OEK at the start of each administration—or as circumstances dictate—a Fiscal Strategy that outlines Palau’s fiscal goals and policies and that clearly demonstrates adherence to the principles of fiscal responsibility.

### Economic and Fiscal Update: Recent Departures, Causes, and Offsetting Measures
- The authorities publish an Economic and Fiscal Update to discuss recent departures from the principles and to highlight key reasons and proposed offsetting measures.

Findings and causes of departure:
- Managing Operating Expenditures:
  - Temporary departure due to the unforeseen impact of the COVID-19 pandemic.
  - Increased spending to support affected businesses, households, and employees while revenues contracted.
  - Authorities aim to gradually return to adherence, maintaining fiscal discipline by ensuring tax rate stability and predictability and controlling expenditures until economic recovery is fully entrenched and the CRA-23 is approved by the US Congress.
- Managing Net Capital and Financial Assets:
  - Net public sector national wealth has declined significantly since the onset of the pandemic.
  - Contributing factors: reduced investment and increased external debt to finance deficit spending during the pandemic.
  - Measures to reverse trend: infrastructure development, grants from the Compact of Free Association (CRA-23), Public-Private Partnerships (PPPs), bond issuances, and additional funding for the COFA Trust Fund.
  - Expectation: successful implementation of tax reform and economic recovery to generate surpluses for infrastructure investment and future development.
- Managing Debt Prudently:
  - Historically cautious external debt policies, with debt-to-GDP ratios around 30 percent before the COVID-19 pandemic.
  - The crisis led to a substantial increase in debt levels.
  - Planned mechanisms: debt sustainability analysis (DSA), software for debt recording, and a debt management unit to review and assess risks of proposed borrowing and guarantees issuance.
  - Consideration: paying down variable-interest-rate and short-duration loans using fiscal consolidation grants from CRA-23.
- Managing the Revenue Regime:
  - Tax reform achievement: introduction of the Palau Goods and Services Tax (PGST).
  - PGST, excise taxes, and other reforms have modernized Palau's tax system.
  - Ongoing initiatives: evaluating the tax reform program, upgrading the Tax Information System, and implementing customs reforms.
- Managing Reserves and Insurance Coverage:
  - General Fund Reserve replaced with a Cyclical Reserve and a Climate Resilience Fund to address fiscal risks related to economic cycles, climate events, and natural disasters.
  - Contributions to these funds are made from domestic revenues; withdrawals permitted under specific conditions.
  - Authorities are seeking technical assistance to determine appropriate reserve targets.
- Managing SOEs and PFIs:
  - SOEs and PFIs have presented fiscal challenges; progress made in improving financial stability.
  - Example: PPUC implemented full cost recovery tariffs, reducing fiscal risk.
  - Reforms for the Social Security System and Civil Service Pension Plan are underway to ensure long-term sustainability.
  - Successful implementation of tax reform, CRA-23, and economic recovery expected to create fiscal opportunities to address these challenges.
- Managing Fiscal Risks and Contingent Liabilities:
  - Palau faces fiscal risks including economic volatility, financial sector crises, changing debt interest rates, demographic changes, natural disasters, government guarantees, litigation, public-private partnerships, environmental degradation, and local government deficits.
  - Authorities plan to continue monitoring and managing these risks to ensure fiscal sustainability.

*Annex VII. Palau’s Fiscal Responsibility Framework — Prepared by Irina Yakadina (APD).*

### Box 1. Lessons from Curacao, Iceland, and Costa Rica

### Box 1. Lessons from Curacao, Iceland, and Costa Rica

### Curacao: Diversification of tourism source markets
- Refocused the tourism demand structure toward the North American market without replacing the established Dutch and Venezuelan markets.
- Increased airlift from North America to 20 additional flights per week.
- Simultaneously increased the quality of tourism experiences through human capital development.
- Allocated additional finances for marketing efforts and tourism product development for the new demand structure.
- Revamped attractive heritage sites to attract North American tourists.

### Iceland: Tourism Roadmap and sustainability tools
- Implemented a Tourism Roadmap supporting sustainable development of tourism focused on seven key elements:
  - (i) Coordination among stakeholders;
  - (ii) Providing a positive visitor experience;
  - (iii) Reliable data;
  - (iv) Nature conservation;
  - (v) Labor skills and quality;
  - (vi) Increased sector profitability;
  - (vii) Better distribution of tourists across the country.
- Key policy priority: implementation of a Tourism Balance Axis, a tool to measure the carrying capacity of tourism via its impact on social welfare, on public services, and the environment.

### Costa Rica: Certificate for Sustainable Tourism (CST)
- The CST program identifies eco-friendly tour operators and accommodations.
- Evaluates and recognizes tourism businesses that demonstrate commitment to sustainable practices, environmental conservation, and responsible tourism.
- CST assesses criteria including waste management, energy efficiency, community involvement, and cultural preservation.
- Certified establishments are intended to minimize environmental impact and contribute positively to local communities.
- Travelers seeking eco-conscious experiences in Costa Rica can rely on the CST program as a guide to make environmentally responsible choices.

### Policy recommendations for Palau to shift toward high-value, low-impact tourism
- Build upon current achievements by enhancing coordination and planning within government and with the private sector.
- Address lack of specificity in the Responsible Tourism Policy Framework and the uncertainty of stakeholder commitment by establishing a centralized government agency dedicated to planning and coordination to:
  - facilitate more efficient interagency collaboration;
  - establish performance metrics;
  - enable prioritization and sequencing of projects to ensure successful realization of goals.
- Additional measures could include:

  - Enhance human capital with focused vocational training for Palauan nationals by creating job training and apprenticeship programs that target skilled labor categories that are in high demand.
    - Rationale: Higher paid vocational jobs in construction and the hospitality sector are largely performed by foreign workers.
    - Aim: Apprenticeship and vocational programs for Palauan nationals should focus on improving skills in the labor force and increase opportunities in the private sector, which may slow demographic pressures from youth migration.

  - Establish requirements for customer service training of workers in the tourism economy.
    - Rationale: Successful implementation of a high-value tourism strategy is dependent on the quality of visitor experiences.
    - Measures: Guidelines for service workers, combined with regular visitor perception surveys, intended to benchmark current perceptions and build Palau’s value as a destination.

  - Improve access to financing for micro and small enterprises.
    - Status quo: The Palau National Development Bank currently provides micro-loans to individuals and businesses, but pricing does not reflect portfolio risk.
    - Policy option: Establishment of a credit bureau—currently under consideration by the authorities—could reduce information asymmetries and help banks better manage credit risk.

  - Target new tourism source markets by collaborating with airlines and travel agencies, investing in infrastructure, and promoting sustainability practices.
    - Measures: Create diverse tourism products and simplify visa and entry procedures to enhance appeal to a wider range of travelers.
    - Monitoring: Closely monitor marketing performance and adapt strategies as needed to ensure successful expansion of tourism source markets.

*Source: Box 1 and E. Policy Recommendations, STAFF REPORT FOR THE 2023 ARTICLE IV CONSULTATION—INFORMATIONAL ANNEX*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/cr/2023/english/1plwea2023001.pdf_
