## 1djiea2024001

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [1djiea2024001](https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/cr/2024/english/1djiea2024001.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/files/publications/cr/2024/english/1djiea2024001.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/files/publications/cr/2024/english/1djiea2024001.pdf.json)

---

### Recent developments and macro performance
- Growth and activity
  - Growth expected to have reached about 7 percent in 2023, supported by a rebound in port activity and construction.
  - Port activity grew by 31 percent y-o-y in the first three quarters of 2023.
  - Train traffic increased by 16 percent y-o-y in the first three quarters of 2023.
  - Construction activity: cement sales increased by 80 percent y-o-y in the first three quarters of 2023.
  - Energy production grew by 16.3 percent y-o-y in Q2 2023.
- Inflation
  - Inflation is estimated to have slowed to 1.8 percent in 2023.
  - Average inflation in 2022 was 5.2 percent; food inflation in 2022 reached 10.7 percent driven by a 14.8 percent increase in global food prices.
  - Food prices fell by 11.2 percent in June 2023; seasonal pick-ups occurred in Q4 2023 but overall price dynamics moved toward historical norms.
- Fiscal and debt developments
  - Primary deficit in 2023 is estimated to have increased to 1.3 percent of GDP from 0.7 percent of GDP in 2022, driven mostly by a one percentage point of GDP drop in revenues.
  - Revenues to GDP declined from 26.5 percent in 2013 to 18.6 percent in 2022.
  - External public debt to GDP increased from 33.9 percent at end 2013 to 68 percent at end 2022.
  - Water, port, and railway projects financed by a loan from Exim Bank China for a total of USD 1.2 billion (about 30 percent of 2023 GDP).
  - Djibouti stopped servicing part of its debt in 2021; total stock of external arrears reached 6 percent of GDP in Q2 2023. Domestic arrears totaled 0.6 percent of GDP.
  - Authorities reached a preliminary debt service moratorium agreement with Exim Bank China in October 2023; discussions are ongoing with India and the Paris Club.
- External sector and reserves
  - Current account balance estimated at 23.5 percent of GDP in 2023, up from 17.6 percent of GDP in 2022.
  - Trade balance estimated at 22.4 percent of GDP in 2023, up from 15.5 percent of GDP in 2022.
  - Reexports accounted for around 92 percent of export goods.
  - Official reserves estimated at USD 573 million as of end 2023, covering 4.7 months of imports (excluding reexports).
- Financial sector
  - Nonperforming loans (NPLs) dropped by two-thirds to around 4.5 percent in Q1 2023.
  - Bank capitalization increased to 17.5 percent by April 2023, from about 14 percent in end-2021.
  - Bank liquidity ratios declined to 50 percent in Q1 2023 from about 60 percent in 2021 on average.
  - Short-term deposit base is relatively large and mostly held overseas (in Ethiopia and Somalia), posing potential liquidity exposure.

### Outlook and risks
- Baseline projections and drivers
  - Growth projected at 6.5 percent in 2024.
  - Over the medium term, growth set to converge toward the pre-pandemic (2017–2019) average, stabilizing at 5.5 percent.
  - Inflation expected to converge upwards to about 2 percent.
  - About 95 percent of Djibouti’s port activity is fueled by Ethiopian trade; growth and external balance are largely driven by growth prospects in Ethiopia.
- Key risks
  - Adverse scenarios:
    - Ethiopia’s recent default on its debt could hamper trade through Djibouti.
    - Escalation of tensions in the Red Sea could affect transshipments via higher container or insurance prices and lower transshipments.
    - Ethiopia’s intention to diversify its ports could lower traffic to Djibouti in the medium term.
    - Increasing refugees/asylum seekers could strain resources (water, education, health) and social stability amid tight budgets.
  - Upside:
    - Stronger-than-expected trade from Ethiopia can support growth.
    - Fully addressing the debt burden could improve debt sustainability and create fiscal space.
- Authorities’ views
  - Authorities agreed with the outlook and risks and plan to diversify the economy (including construction and expanded port services such as transshipments, repairs, and refuel) and reduce trade concentration.

### Policy recommendations and priorities
- Short term
  - Conclude debt renegotiations and arrears clearance with all creditors to restore debt sustainability.
- Medium and long term
  - Pursue holistic revenue mobilization and governance reform programs to entrench sustainability.
  - Improve State-Owned Enterprise (SOE) governance:
    - Make SOEs a key contributor to central government revenues.
    - Contain risks of SOE borrowing.
    - Level the playing field to facilitate private sector development.
  - Prioritize investments in human capital, including health and education, to support inclusive and resilient growth based on a more diversified economy.
- Broader strategy elements (staff view)
  - A balanced mix of (i) fiscal and structural reforms, (ii) debt relief, (iii) new concessional financing, and (iv) strengthened public debt management is required to restore and entrench debt sustainability.
  - Ensure SOEs contribute to the central government budget and strengthen SOE governance.
  - Implement AML/CFT reforms and data improvements to enhance transparency and the business climate.
  - Diversify the economy and strengthen professional skills to boost formal employment.

### SOE borrowing and governance
- SOE borrowing and public debt
  - SOE borrowing accounted for 80 percent of external debt growth since 2013.
  - In 2023, the government provided guarantees to three loans contracted by the state-owned Djibouti Port and Free Zones Authority (DPFZA) totaling about USD 250 million:
    - USD 120 million with Afreximbank and USD 35 million with BCIMR for Damerjog Industrial Development Free Trade Zone.
    - USD 95.6 million from Afreximbank and FMO to develop the shipyard.
  - Staff supports revisions to the décret n° 2022-081/PR/MB defining the public sector debt committee’s responsibilities and composition; Direction of Public Debt of the Ministry of Budget is the secretariat.
- Policy recommendations to anchor debt
  - Impose controls over SOE borrowing and carefully weigh risks of non-concessional borrowing in times of high interest rates.
  - Consider an anchor for debt (e.g., a target debt level by a certain year or a targeted path for fiscal deficits).
  - Complement anchors with a ceiling on overall SOE debt and a requirement of a balance sheet analysis for each SOE borrowing request.
  - Explore developing a medium-term debt strategy and adopt a rules-based framework to prioritize investments and strengthen planning and budgeting.
- SOE fiscal contribution and dividend policy
  - Ensure profit-making SOEs contribute to the budget; limit transfers to loss-makers.
  - Recommend a clear dividend policy aligned with mutually agreed performance parameters.
- Transparency and oversight
  - 2023 PEFA: Djibouti received score D+ for overall management of assets; drivers of score C for management of financial assets include lack of a tally of SOEs, lack of performance reports, no comprehensive monitoring of financial relationships between the State and SOEs, and lack of the notion of financial performance.
  - Conduct a strategic review of more than 77 SOEs; staff supports plans to consolidate administrative SOEs (EPA) — 31 out of the estimated 77 SOEs — and urges accelerating technical work.
  - Improve financial transparency: SEPE only has accounts from 14 SOEs out of 77 and not for all years; consider penalties for SOEs that do not submit financial statements.

### Debt accumulation, sustainability, and DSA findings
- Debt accumulation and drivers
  - Debt-to-GDP grew from 34.9 percent in 2013 to 68 percent by end 2022.
  - Large infrastructure projects (Djibouti-Addis Ababa railway, Doraleh multi-purpose port, Port of Ghoubet, water pipeline) financed largely by Exim Bank China: USD 1.2 billion (about 59 percent of GDP).
  - Additional 2023 borrowing/guarantees: July 2023 EUR 79.2 million from EIB; government guarantees to Great Horn Investment Holding: USD 120 million (Afreximbank), USD 35 million (BCIMR), USD 95.5 million (Invest International). Total 2023 borrowing represents around 8 percent of GDP.
  - Contingent liability shock of 11.2 percent consists of: potential additional SOE external liability (2 percent of GDP), potential additional PPP liabilities (4.2 percent of GDP), and a financial sector contingent liability (5 percent of GDP).
- Debt service, interest rates, and arrears
  - Interest rates on selected 2023 loans: Afreximbank and BCMIR loan: 6.97 percent; Invest International loan: EURIBOR 3 months plus 1.85 percent; EIB loan: EURIBOR 3 months.
  - Weighted-average interest rate on Djibouti’s debt stock projected to rise from 0.9 percent in 2022 to an average of 2.8 percent over the ten-year projection horizon.
  - Total PPG debt service expected to increase from 1.3 percent of GDP in 2022 to an average of 4.6 percent over the ten-year horizon, with a peak at 5.5 percent in 2025.
  - By end June 2023, total stock of arrears reached around 6 percent of GDP; composition of arrears: Exim Bank China 78 percent, Exim Bank India 16 percent, other creditors including Paris Club 5 percent.
- DSA and stress tests
  - Composite indicator (CI) estimated at 2.16; debt-carrying capacity classified as weak.
  - PV of external debt-to-GDP ratio peaks at 61.1 percent in 2023 and declines to 29.4 percent in 2031.
  - Debt service-to-revenue ratio above threshold until 2032, below threshold from 2033 onward.
  - PV of total public debt peaks in 2023 at 67.9 percent, falls below 35 percent threshold in 2031 at 34.2 percent, and amounts to 27.5 percent of GDP in 2033.
  - Stress tests show indicators most sensitive to export shocks; under extreme export growth shock the PV of debt-to-GDP breaches the threshold over the entire medium-term projection.
  - Illustrative Exim Bank China agreement scenario assumes arrears of 5 percent of GDP (USD 160 million) refinanced into a bond with 23 years maturity at up to 4 percent; under this scenario PV of External Debt-to-GDP remains above sustainability threshold over the medium term.
  - Overall risk rating: Djibouti remains in debt distress and debt is deemed unsustainable.

### External sector and reserves (detailed indicators)
- Key indicators (2023)
  - NIIP: -82.8 percent of GDP.
  - Gross external assets: 54.5 percent of GDP.
  - Gross external liabilities: 137.3 percent of GDP.
  - External public and publicly guaranteed debt: 62.8 percent of GDP.
  - Reexports: 92 percent of export goods and 91.4 percent of import goods.
  - Official reserves coverage: 4.7 months of imports (excluding reexports); exceeds 3-month rule-of-thumb and recommended reserve adequacy metric (1.9) for a small state with a fixed exchange rate regime.
  - Current account estimated surplus: 23.5 percent of GDP in 2023.
- External position assessment
  - EBA-lite model results (2023) include CA-Actual: 23.6; Adjusted CA: 23.8; CA Norm: -3.8; CA Gap: 27.6; o/w Relative policy gap: 4.2; Elasticity: -1.0; REER Gap (in percent): -28.2.
  - REER Index model implies REER Gap (in percent): 3.0 and CA Gap based on REER model: -2.9 percent of GDP.
  - Real effective exchange rate (REER) change in 2023: minor increase of 1.5 percent.
  - Assessment: external position assessments diverge and are subject to considerable uncertainty given BoP statistical challenges.

### Structural issues, labor market, and statistics
- Growth model and labor market
  - Port activity accounts for 80 percent of variation in GDP growth, yet ports are capital-intensive and generate limited employment.
  - During 2015–2021, the transport sector generated less than seven thousand new jobs (in a working age population of 700,000), despite cumulated real GDP growth of more than 35 percent.
  - Last officially estimated unemployment rate remains elevated at 47 percent, while only 10 percent of the working age population is engaged in formal employment.
- Data and assessment issues
  - Staff assesses Djibouti’s external position in 2023 to be substantially stronger than the level implied by fundamentals and desirable policies, though the external sector analysis is greatly impacted by data quality.
  - High net errors and omissions (NEOs) have historically impacted external account analysis; linked to large reexports to Ethiopia that in some years exceed Djibouti’s total imports.
  - Reexports often held in FTZ warehouses for years awaiting price increases; liquidity constraints in Ethiopia mean some settlements are not captured by banks, understating the financial account and disconnecting BOP outturns and reserves.
- Statistics improvements and census
  - RGPH-3 census field data collection expected to begin in April 2024 to update population structure and socio-economic characteristics and to support unemployment data collection (not published since 2017).
  - Staff commends recent increase in human capital in the statistical agency and encourages acceleration of the ongoing census.

### Monetary, financial sector, AML/CFT, and safeguards
- Monetary and financial policy recommendations
  - CBD plans to introduce a reserve requirement; should be carefully designed and remunerated as a liquidity management tool and calibrated to liquidity needs under a bank stress scenario.
  - Parity of the Djibouti franc against the U.S. dollar remains appropriate; DJF 177.721 = US$1.
  - Improve banking regulation and central bank oversight: consider establishing and monitoring a regulatory liquidity coverage ratio (LCR), emergency liquidity assistance (ELA) financed by a bank levy or a private sector fund.
- AML/CFT and safeguards
  - MENAFATF assessment ongoing; passage of three draft legal amendments to AML/CFT Laws provided through IMF TA and decrees for implementing targeted financial sanctions and for organization and operation of the Financial Intelligence Unit are urged.
  - Address weaknesses in understanding of risk and adopt a risk-based approach; close gaps in effectiveness of AML/CFT supervision, the financial intelligence function, and investigations and prosecutions.
  - August 2023 safeguards assessment of Bank Centrale de Djibouti found significant capacity constraints; recommend strengthening governance arrangements, amending the BCD Law to strengthen autonomy, adopting IFRS, and timely publication of audited financial statements.

### Risk landscape and policy responses (RAM highlights, February 2024)
- Country-specific risks and suggested policy responses
  - Conflict resurgence in Ethiopia: Likelihood Medium; Economic Impact High. Policy response: adopt medium-term fiscal adjustment plan; accelerate structural reforms to diversify outside ports and free zones.
  - Increased competition from other regional ports: Likelihood Medium; Economic Impact High. Policy response: promote efficiency at ports; accelerate structural reforms for diversification.
- Conjunctural/global shocks
  - Intensification of regional conflicts: Likelihood High; Economic Impact Medium. Policy response: expand the budget envelope by reducing tax expenditures and increasing SOE contributions.
  - Abrupt global slowdown or recession: Likelihood Medium; Economic Impact Medium. Policy responses: expand budget envelope; adopt medium-term fiscal adjustment plan; pursue medium-term resilience reforms.
- Structural/global risks
  - Deepening geoeconomic fragmentation: Likelihood High; Economic Impact Medium. Policy responses: expand budget envelope; adopt medium-term fiscal adjustment plan.
  - Extreme climate events: Likelihood Medium; Economic Impact High. Policy responses: provide targeted support to the vulnerable; mobilize resources for adaptation; pursue PFM reforms to increase spending efficiency.

### Capacity development and technical assistance priorities
- Fiscal CD priorities
  - Support revenue mobilization, tax policy and revenue administration, and implementation of a holistic long-term vision toward revenue mobilization and debt sustainability.
  - Creation of a Large-Taxpayers’ Unit announced; implement digitalization and strengthen Ministry of Budget decision power and a tax policy unit.
- SOE governance CD
  - Facilitate SOE reform, enhance governance, ensure SOE contributions with taxes and dividends, and conduct strategic reviews of SOEs.
- Monetary/financial and AML/CFT CD
  - Support implementation of MENAFATF recommendations; enhance financial sector supervision, governance, and currency board operations.
  - Monetary/financial TA matrix priorities: Financial Supervision and Regulation — Regulatory & Prudential Framework (Priority 1, FY24–26) and Risk Based Supervision (FY27–29).
  - Legal TA priorities: AML/CFT legal and implementation support (FY24–29).
- Statistics CD
  - Improve compilation and dissemination of financial institutions and balance of payments statistics (Priority 1, FY24–29).

*Source: INTERNATIONAL MONETARY FUND*

### 6.5 percent in 2024. I nflation is expected to have averaged   around 1.8 percent in 2023

### 6.5 percent in 2024. Inflation is expected to have averaged around 1.8 percent in 2023

### Recent developments and macro performance
- Growth and activity
  - Growth is expected to have reached about 7 percent in 2023, supported by a rebound in port activity and construction.
  - Port activity grew by 31 percent y-o-y in the first three quarters of 2023.
  - Train traffic increased by 16 percent y-o-y in the first three quarters of 2023.
  - Construction activity: cement sales increased by 80 percent y-o-y in the first three quarters of 2023.
  - Energy production grew by 16.3 percent y-o-y in Q2 2023.
- Inflation
  - Inflation is estimated to have slowed to 1.8 percent in 2023.
  - Average inflation in 2022 was 5.2 percent; food inflation in 2022 reached 10.7 percent driven by a 14.8 percent increase in global food prices.
  - Food prices fell by 11.2 percent in June 2023; seasonal pick-ups occurred in Q4 2023 but overall price dynamics moved toward historical norms.
- Fiscal and debt developments
  - The primary deficit in 2023 is estimated to have increased to 1.3 percent of GDP from 0.7 percent of GDP in 2022, driven mostly by a one percentage point of GDP drop in revenues.
  - Revenues to GDP declined from 26.5 percent in 2013 to 18.6 percent in 2022.
  - External public debt to GDP increased from 33.9 percent at end 2013 to 68 percent at end 2022.
  - The water, port, and railway projects were financed by a loan from Exim Bank China for a total of USD 1.2 billion (about 30 percent of 2023 GDP).
  - Djibouti stopped servicing part of its debt in 2021; total stock of external arrears reached 6 percent of GDP in Q2 2023. Domestic arrears totaled 0.6 percent of GDP.
  - The authorities reached a preliminary debt service moratorium agreement with Exim Bank China in October 2023; discussions are ongoing with India and the Paris Club.
- External sector and reserves
  - Current account balance is estimated at 23.5 percent of GDP in 2023, up from 17.6 percent of GDP in 2022.
  - Trade balance is estimated at 22.4 percent of GDP in 2023, up from 15.5 percent of GDP in 2022.
  - Reexports accounted for around 92 percent of export goods.
  - Official reserves are estimated at USD 573 million as of end 2023, covering 4.7 months of imports (excluding reexports).
- Financial sector
  - Nonperforming loans (NPLs) dropped by two-thirds to around 4.5 percent in Q1 2023.
  - Bank capitalization increased to 17.5 percent by April 2023, from about 14 percent in end-2021.
  - Bank liquidity ratios declined to 50 percent in Q1 2023 from about 60 percent in 2021 on average.
  - Short-term deposit base is relatively large and mostly held overseas (in Ethiopia and Somalia), posing potential liquidity exposure.

### Outlook and risks
- Baseline projections and drivers
  - Growth is projected at 6.5 percent in 2024.
  - Over the medium term, growth is set to converge toward the pre-pandemic (2017–2019) average, stabilizing at 5.5 percent.
  - Inflation is expected to converge upwards to about 2 percent.
  - About 95 percent of Djibouti’s port activity is fueled by Ethiopian trade; growth and external balance are largely driven by growth prospects in Ethiopia.
- Key risks
  - Adverse scenarios:
    - Ethiopia’s recent default on its debt could hamper trade through Djibouti.
    - Escalation of tensions in the Red Sea could affect transshipments (a small portion of port activity) via higher container or insurance prices and lower transshipments.
    - Ethiopia’s intention to diversify its ports could lower traffic to Djibouti in the medium term.
    - Increasing refugees/asylum seekers could strain resources (water, education, health) and social stability amid tight budgets.
  - Upside:
    - Stronger-than-expected trade from Ethiopia can support growth.
    - Fully addressing the debt burden could improve debt sustainability and create fiscal space.
- Authorities’ views
  - Authorities agreed with the outlook and risks and plan to diversify the economy (including construction and expanded port services such as transshipments, repairs, and refuel) and reduce trade concentration.

### Policy recommendations and priorities
- Short term
  - Conclude debt renegotiations and arrears clearance with all creditors to restore debt sustainability.
- Medium and long term
  - Pursue holistic revenue mobilization and governance reform programs to entrench sustainability.
  - Improve State-Owned Enterprise (SOE) governance:
    - Make SOEs a key contributor to central government revenues.
    - Contain risks of SOE borrowing.
    - Level the playing field to facilitate private sector development.
  - Prioritize investments in human capital, including health and education, to support inclusive and resilient growth based on a more diversified economy.
- Broader strategy elements (staff view)
  - A balanced mix of (i) fiscal and structural reforms, (ii) debt relief, (iii) new concessional financing, and (iv) strengthened public debt management is required to restore and entrench debt sustainability.
  - Ensure SOEs contribute to the central government budget and strengthen SOE governance.
  - Implement AML/CFT reforms and data improvements to enhance transparency and the business climate.
  - Diversify the economy and strengthen professional skills to boost formal employment.

### Structural and sectoral issues highlighted
- Growth model and labor market
  - Port activity accounts for 80 percent of variation in GDP growth, yet ports are capital-intensive and generate limited employment.
  - During 2015–2021, the transport sector generated less than seven thousand new jobs (in a working age population of 700,000), despite cumulated real GDP growth of more than 35 percent.
  - Last officially estimated unemployment rate remains elevated at 47 percent, while only 10 percent of the working age population is engaged in formal employment.
- Data and assessment issues
  - Staff assesses Djibouti’s external position in 2023 to be substantially stronger than the level implied by fundamentals and desirable policies, though the external sector analysis is greatly impacted by data quality.
- Financial system monitoring
  - Growing exposure to SOEs warrants monitoring for credit quality and systemic risk.
  - Bank liquidity vulnerability stems from overseas short-term deposits and erosion of liquid assets.

*March 8, 2024 — IMF staff mission discussions conducted in Djibouti during January 14–25, 2024.*

### 17.      Control over SOE borrowing is key to anchor debt. SOE borrowing accounted for 80

### 17.      Control over SOE borrowing is key to anchor debt

### SOE borrowing and public debt
- SOE borrowing accounted for 80 percent of external debt growth since 2013.
- In 2023, the government provided guarantees to three loans contracted by the state-owned Djibouti Port and Free Zones Authority (DPFZA) totaling about USD 250 million.
  - USD 120 million with Afreximbank and USD 35 million with Banque pour le Commerce et l’Industrie Mer Rouge (BCIMR) to further develop the Damerjog Industrial Development Free Trade Zone.
  - USD 95.6 million from Afreximbank and FMO to develop the shipyard.
- Staff supports revisions to the decree defining the responsibilities of the public sector debt committee (Comité National d’Endettement Public), which issues a reasoned opinion on any borrowing project involving the state.
  - The décret n° 2022-081/PR/MB modified and replaced previous provisions and defines the committee’s composition (including the Prime Minister, the Minister of Economy and Finances, the minister of Budget, the Minister of Foreign Affairs and International Cooperation, the Governor of the Central Bank, the Secretary General of the Government, the economic adviser of the President of the Republic and the President of the Autorité des Ports et des Zones Franches). The Direction of Public Debt of the Ministry of Budget is the secretariat.

### Policy recommendations to anchor debt
- Impose controls over SOE borrowing and carefully weigh risks of non-concessional borrowing in times of high interest rates to avoid creating additional debt service challenges.
- Consider an anchor for debt, for instance:
  - a target debt level to be reached by a certain year, or
  - a targeted path for fiscal deficits—to ensure multiyear fiscal policy coherence.
- Complement anchors with:
  - a ceiling on overall SOE debt, and
  - a requirement of a balance sheet analysis for each SOE borrowing request.
- Explore developing a medium-term debt strategy.
- Such a rules-based framework would help prioritization of investment projects while strengthening planning and budgeting.

### SOE fiscal contribution and dividend policy
- Ensure that profit-making SOEs contribute to the budget, while limiting transfers to loss-makers, to support budgetary needs including health and education.
- Staff commended prudence in limiting transfers from the budget to the Sovereign Wealth Fund in recent years.
- Recommend a clear dividend policy, aligned with mutually agreed performance parameters, to support the budget while ensuring SOEs can fund operational and investment costs.

### Revenue mobilization and tax policy
- Recent measures improved the tax system at the margin but left core issues unaddressed, including tax incentives (including exemptions) and poor VAT performance.
- Given the moratorium on debt service, there is a window to design and implement a holistic plan for revenue mobilization with well-timed and consistent implementation.
- Suggested first steps:
  - Consolidate all tax provisions within a single legislation as the sole source of tax policies.
  - Submit all tax preferences for parliamentary approval with systematic inclusion in the tax expenditures report to end discretionary concessions and promote transparency and accountability.
  - Ongoing review of military base leases should ensure fair value today and include an indexation mechanism to protect future revenues; five foreign military bases occupy valuable real estate and payments have been fixed in nominal terms since 2016.

### Strengthening fiscal institutions and public finance management
- Welcome creation of a Large-Taxpayer Office in the Direction Générale des Impôts to focus scarce resources on high-return areas.
- Support electronic filing and digitalizing revenue administration.
- Urge reinforcing the decision power of the Ministry of Budget on tax policy issues and creation of a tax policy unit to ensure coherence in policy design and implementation.
- Strengthening fiscal institutions would provide essential buffers against downside shocks.

### Social spending and subsidy targeting
- Stabilizing energy prices involves tradeoffs: it protects the vulnerable but is costly and may disproportionately benefit the rich.
- Better targeting of support would increase efficiency, especially since spending on education and health remains below peers despite improvements in education.
- Increasing health spending would strengthen progress towards Sustainable Development Goals.

### SOE governance, transparency, and oversight
- 2023 PEFA: Djibouti received score D+ for overall management of assets; drivers of score C for management of financial assets include:
  - lack of a tally of SOEs with information on shares, value, other shareholders, and composition of capital;
  - lack of a report on performance of shares in SOEs and dividends perceived;
  - no comprehensive monitoring of financial relationships between the State and SOEs (subsidies, transfers, parafiscal taxes, taxes, dividends);
  - lack of the notion of financial performance.
- Accelerate efforts to close these gaps to enhance financial oversight and allow action against poorly performing SOEs that historically required subsidies.
- The Code of Good Governance of SOEs (2016) is important; accelerate implementation and empower the Executive Secretariat of the State Portfolio with political buy-in and resources.
- Conduct a strategic review of more than 77 SOEs to clarify role, rationale for ownership, and value-added.
- Staff supports plans to consolidate administrative SOEs (EPA) — 31 out of the estimated 77 SOEs — and urges accelerating technical work.
- Improve financial transparency:
  - Majority of SOEs do not produce timely financial accounts nor share them with supervisory body.
  - SEPE only has accounts from 14 SOEs out of 77 and not for all years.
  - Consider penalties for SOEs that do not submit financial statements, including making submission a precondition for budget approval or withholding budget transfers.

### Monetary and financial sector policies
- CBD plans to introduce a reserve requirement; should be carefully designed and remunerated as a liquidity management tool.
  - Level of reserve requirement could be calibrated to liquidity needs under a bank stress scenario.
  - Options to increase policy discretion include scaling up the currency coverage ratio through retained earnings, retained earnings on FX reserves, and a bank supervisory levy.
- Parity of the Djibouti franc against the U.S. dollar remains appropriate; no exchange restrictions or multiple currency practices introduced.
- Improve banking regulation and central bank oversight:
  - 2020 FSSR found oversight hampered by lack of strategic focus, resources, and inadequate internal processes.
  - Consider establishing and monitoring a regulatory liquidity coverage ratio (LCR), emergency liquidity assistance (ELA) financed by a bank levy in the context of the currency board or via a private sector fund.
- AML/CFT improvements are crucial with MENAFATF assessment ongoing:
  - Passage of three draft legal amendments to AML/CFT Laws provided through IMF TA, decrees for implementing targeted financial sanctions, and for organization and operation of the Financial Intelligence Unit are urged.
  - Address weaknesses in understanding of risk and adopt a risk-based approach.
  - Close gaps in effectiveness of AML/CFT supervision, the financial intelligence function, and investigations and prosecutions.
- August 2023 safeguards assessment of the Bank Centrale de Djibouti (BCD) found significant capacity constraints contributing to weak controls (currency management, cybersecurity); internal audit and risk management not yet operational.
  - Recommend strengthening governance arrangements, amending the BCD Law to strengthen autonomy, and enhancing transparency of financial statements through adoption of IFRS and timely publication of audited financial statements.

### Structural reforms, labor market, and statistics
- Key constraints to inclusive growth: high telecom and energy costs, informality, and weak private sector job creation.
  - Authorities plan to halve telecom costs by March 2024 and explore a minority stake sale of Djibouti Telecom; competition from AfriFiber and plans to open market to a second operator expected to help.
  - Informality: only 67,000 people are registered in social security among a working age population of about 700,000.
    - Recommend a multifaceted strategy to investigate barriers to formalization, including review of regulatory measures and tax policies with potential IMF TA support.
  - High capital investments in tertiary sectors have yielded limited job creation; gaps exist between skills demanded by large companies and those supplied by the education system.
    - Explore diversification into more labor-intensive sectors (construction, commerce and retail, tourism).
    - Expand vocational training, adult learning, work-based learning, and apprenticeships.
- Improve coverage and quality of statistics:
  - Invest in statistical capacity and skills and accelerate the ongoing census.
  - High net errors and omissions (NEOs) have historically impacted external account analysis; linked to large reexports to Ethiopia that in some years exceed Djibouti’s total imports.
  - Reexports are often held in free trade zone warehouses for years awaiting price increases; liquidity constraints in Ethiopia mean some settlements are not captured by banks, understating the financial account and disconnecting BOP outturns and reserves.
- Climate resilience:
  - Authorities acquired Djibouti’s inaugural sovereign insurance product to mitigate climatic shocks.
  - Authorities committed to generating 100 percent of its electricity from renewable energy under Vision 2035 and expect pending projects would allow the country to become an energy exporter in the medium term.

### Authorities’ views (selected)
- Authorities acknowledged the debt service moratorium provides flow relief but that debt sustainability rests on full restructuring outcomes with all creditors; repayment terms after moratorium will be central for DSA.
- Authorities noted methodological disagreements with the mission’s DSA calculations and tend to agree with the 2019 DSA methodology excluding sizable re-exports in reserve coverage calculation of CI scores; they noted re-exports are financed with FX in commercial banks rather than central bank reserves.
- Ongoing discussions with Exim Bank of India and contact with the Paris Club reported.
- Authorities agreed on need for a unified vision for tax policy but did not see parliamentary approval of all tax preferences as necessary; agreed that a tax policy unit would support informed decision-making and urged IMF support for implementation.
- Authorities welcomed recommendations to strengthen SOE governance, expect to accelerate Code of Governance implementation, plan to institute independent boards for ten pilot SOEs, and emphasized tallying, consolidating, and restructuring SOEs.
- CBD agreed with recommendations to expand supervisory and policy toolkits, committed to introducing a reserve requirement as a liquidity and prudential management tool, and recognized the need to implement FATF mutual evaluation recommendations and increase AML/CFT resources.

*Source: INTERNATIONAL MONETARY FUND*

### 37.      Djibouti stands at a critical juncture, navigating domestic, regional, and global

### Djibouti stands at a critical juncture, navigating domestic, regional, and global challenges

### Growth outlook and recent performance
- Growth rebounded strongly in 2023 following the November 2022 peace agreement in Ethiopia, driven by expansion in port activities, train traffic, construction, and energy production.
- Inflation closed 2023 at 3.3 percent.
- Staff projects the recovery will continue in 2024, albeit at a slower pace, converging down to potential in the medium-term.
- Outlook is cautiously optimistic and contingent on Ethiopian economic activity and the Addis-Djibouti corridor.

### Key external sector indicators and assessment
- Net international investment position (NIIP) in 2023: -82.8 percent of GDP.
- Gross external assets in 2023: 54.5 percent of GDP.
- Gross external liabilities in 2023: 137.3 percent of GDP.
- External public and publicly guaranteed debt in 2023: 62.8 percent of GDP.
- Reexports in 2023: 92 percent of export goods and 91.4 percent of import goods.
- Official reserves coverage in 2023: 4.7 months of imports (when imports for reexports are excluded); exceeds 3-months rule-of-thumb and recommended reserve adequacy metric (1.9) for a small state with a fixed exchange rate regime.
- Current account estimated surplus in 2023: 23.5 percent of GDP.
- EBA-lite model results (2023):
  - CA-Actual: 23.6 (in percent of GDP)
  - Cyclical contributions (from model): (-)-0.2
  - Adjusted CA: 23.8
  - CA Norm (from model): -3.8
  - Adjusted CA Norm: -3.8
  - CA Gap: 27.6
  - o/w Relative policy gap: 4.2
  - Elasticity: -1.0
  - REER Gap (in percent): -28.2
- REER Index model implies:
  - REER Gap (in percent): 3.0
  - CA Gap based on REER model: -2.9 percent of GDP
- Real effective exchange rate (REER) change in 2023: minor increase of 1.5 percent.
- Assessment: external position assessments diverge (EBA-lite implies sizable undervaluation; REER index implies modest overvaluation), and both are subject to considerable uncertainty given BoP statistical challenges.

### Fiscal vulnerabilities and debt strategy
- Sustained logistics investments have increased external debt; consecutive shocks (COVID-19, conflict in Ethiopia, commodity price increases) narrowed fiscal space.
- The debt service moratorium with China provides a window to engage creditors on a strategy to address the debt burden.
- Recommended components of a debt strategy:
  - Strengthened public debt management.
  - New non-concessional financing.
  - Debt relief aimed at durably restoring debt sustainability.
- Policy recommendation: adopt a medium-term fiscal adjustment plan covering the entire public sector, including SOEs.

### State-owned enterprise (SOE) reform
- Authorities’ commitment to SOE reform is commendable; political buy-in and resources will be key.
- Recommended three-pronged approach:
  - (i) Better financial oversight and a clear dividend strategy.
  - (ii) Stronger governance.
  - (iii) Review and restructuring of the numerous entities.
- Expected outcome: improved management of state-owned assets and better contribution of SOEs to Djibouti’s development.

### Revenue mobilization and fiscal policy reforms
- Need to accelerate design and implementation of a revenue mobilization plan centered on strengthening fiscal institutions.
- Specific measures:
  - Reinforce decision power of the Ministry of Budget on tax issues.
  - Review and consolidate tax laws to ensure coherent and consistent policy design and implementation.
  - Tackle tax incentives and VAT underperformance.
  - Ensure military base leases are adjusted to reflect their real value.
  - Improve targeting of fuel subsidies to increase efficiency and create fiscal space for human capital expenditure.
- Additional policy responses (from Risk Assessment Matrix): expand the budget envelope by reducing tax expenditures and increasing SOE contribution with taxes and dividends.

### Banking sector, monetary policy tools, and AML/CFT
- Systemic risk in banking has declined relative to the previous assessment, but improvements in banking regulation and oversight are imperative.
- Recommendation: careful design and introduction of a reserve requirement by the Central Bank of Djibouti (CBD) to strengthen liquidity management toolkit.
- The upcoming MENAFATF evaluation findings will provide a foundation for AML/CFT reforms; staff encourages swift passage of legal amendments.
- Authorities are beginning compilation of data on other financial institutions based on standardized report forms (4SR), to be supported by IMF TA.

### Private sector constraints, costs, and job creation
- Key constraints to inclusive growth:
  - High telecom and energy costs.
  - Large informality.
  - Skills gaps limiting private sector job creation.
- Staff welcomes authorities’ plans to halve the price of telecoms and explore private participation in Djibouti Telecom.
- Recommended measures:
  - Address informality through regulatory reviews and evaluation of tax policies and procedures.
  - Promote vocational training, expand adult learning programs and apprenticeships to fill skills gaps and support economic diversification outside ports and free zones.

### Data, statistics, and surveillance
- High-quality data coverage is essential to support policymaking and sector analysis.
- Gaps hamper evidence-based policymaking—especially in labor market, economic distribution of households, and financial sector data.
- Recent progress:
  - Djibouti’s General Census of the Population and Housing (RGPH-3) is underway to update the 2009 RGPH-2. Field data collection is expected to begin in April 2024.
  - Census will update population structure and socio-economic characteristics, classify nomads, migrants, refugees, and homeless, update sampling frames for EDAM and EDS, and create a national Geographic Information System (GIS).
  - Authorities expect the Census to kickstart work on collecting unemployment data, which has not been published since 2017.
  - Plans to begin compilation of data on other financial institutions, including insurance companies (Islamic "Takaful" and conventional) and specialized financial institutions (a Development Fund), with inclusion in monetary and financial statistics to be specified.
- Staff commends recent increase in human capital in the statistical agency and encourages acceleration of the ongoing census.
- Improved data will enable better assessment of climate shocks and more precise external sector analysis.

### Risk landscape (RAM highlights, February 2024)
- Country-specific risks:
  - Conflict resurgence in neighboring Ethiopia: Likelihood Medium; Economic Impact High. Channels: lower service exports, investment, external balance; rising budget and reserve pressures. Policy response: adopt medium-term fiscal adjustment plan; accelerate structural reforms to diversify outside ports and free zones.
  - Increased competition from other regional ports: Likelihood Medium; Economic Impact High. Channels: potential excess capacity and lower profitability of port-related activities. Policy response: promote efficiency at ports; accelerate structural reforms for diversification.
- Conjunctural/global shocks:
  - Intensification of regional conflicts (e.g., Gaza/Israel, Russia–Ukraine): Likelihood High; Economic Impact Medium. Channels: disrupted trade, remittances, FDI, payment systems; increased refugees. Policy response: expand budget envelope by reducing tax expenditures and increasing SOE contributions.
  - Abrupt global slowdown or recession (U.S., Europe, China scenarios): Likelihood Medium; Economic Impact Medium. Channels: lower service exports, investment, weaker external balance; rising budget/reserve pressure. Policy responses: expand budget envelope; adopt medium-term fiscal adjustment plan; pursue medium-term resilience reforms.
- Structural/global risks:
  - Deepening geoeconomic fragmentation: Likelihood High; Economic Impact Medium. Channels: reduced demand for trade services, higher security and social spending. Policy responses: expand budget envelope; adopt medium-term fiscal adjustment plan.
  - Extreme climate events: Likelihood Medium; Economic Impact High. Channels: drought, flooding, sea-level rise, regional migration. Policy responses: provide targeted support to the vulnerable; mobilize resources for adaptation; pursue PFM reforms to increase spending efficiency.

### Capacity development priorities
- Focus areas for capacity development (CD):
  - Support revenue mobilization, public and financial management, and medium-term debt management to entrench debt sustainability.
  - Facilitate SOE reform to align SOEs with revenue mobilization objectives and level the playing field for private sector development.
  - Assist implementation of recommendations from the MENA FATF evaluation and IMF CD recommendations to strengthen AML/CFT.
  - Increase data coverage and quality; CD to remain closely integrated with surveillance.

*International Monetary Fund*

### 1. Fiscal sector technical assistance should focus on supporting a holistic and long-term

### 1. Fiscal sector technical assistance should focus on supporting a holistic and long-term

### Fiscal technical assistance and revenue mobilization
- Recent frequent tax policy and revenue administration changes and reversals have increased uncertainty for businesses and households, while not resulting in the expected returns.
- Technical assistance (TA) from FAD and METAC, in close coordination with the country team, should pursue work on:
  - Tax policy and revenue administration.
  - Identification of specific reforms consistent with building and implementing a holistic and long-term vision toward revenue mobilization and debt sustainability.
- Implementation note: The creation of a Large-Taxpayers’ Unit has been announced.

### Governance reforms focused on SOEs
- SOEs are currently the largest contributor to Djibouti’s GDP.
- Numerous exemptions and low dividends from SOEs hamper their contribution to the authorities’ inclusive growth goals.
- Implementing the framework defined in the Code of Good Governance of State-Owned Enterprises would:
  - Enhance governance of SOEs.
  - Support revenue mobilization objectives by ensuring SOEs’ contributions with taxes and dividends.
  - Enhance transparency of SOEs’ financial accounts, allowing in-depth analysis of their possible role.
- Status: Authorities have so far not shared any request for technical assistance in the governance field, though the Executive Secretariat is working on choosing pilot institutions for board reforms.
- SOE borrowing: SOE borrowing has accounted for 80 percent of external borrowing since 2013; reining in SOE borrowing is key to restoring debt sustainability.
  - Policy options suggested: a ceiling on overall SOE debt and a requirement of a balance sheet analysis for each SOE borrowing request.

### Central bank, AML/CFT, and financial sector priorities
- Priorities include swift implementation of the recommendations of the ongoing MENAFATF evaluation, and enhanced financial sector supervision, governance, and currency board operations.
- Authorities received TA from LEG to improve principal AML/CFT laws and through simulated diagnostic exercises covering:
  - Understanding of risk and use of a risk-based approach.
  - AML/CFT supervision of financial and designated non-financial sectors.
  - The financial intelligence function.
- Staff recommendations:
  - Encourage authorities to swiftly enact legal amendments.
  - Address gaps identified on effectiveness by implementing the recommendations made.
  - Follow up on the status of proposed legal amendments and recommendations in preparation for the MENAFATF evaluation.
  - Implement the recommendations of the MENAFATF mutual evaluation report.
- Monetary/financial technical assistance priorities (FY24–26 and FY27–29):
  - Financial Supervision and Regulation — Regulatory & Prudential Framework (Priority 1, FY24–26)
  - Financial Supervision and Regulation — Risk Based Supervision (FY27–29)

### Capacity development priorities and technical assistance matrix (as presented)
- Fiscal – Priority 1:
  - FY24–26: Tax Policy-Tax Policy Efficiency; Revenue Administration-Revenue Administration and Governance
  - FY27–29: Tax Policy-Tax Policy Efficiency; Revenue Administration-Revenue Administration and Governance
- Monetary/Financial – Priority 1:
  - FY24–26: Financial Supervision and Regulation-Regulatory & Prudential Framework
  - FY27–29: Financial Supervision and Regulation-Risk Based Supervision
- Legal – Priority 1:
  - FY24–26: Financial Integrity-AML/CFT Measures: Legal and Regulatory Framework
  - FY27–29: Financial Integrity-AML/CFT Implementation: Financial Intelligence, Risk-based Supervision, ML Investigations & Prosecutions
- Statistics – Priority 1:
  - FY24–26: Compilation and dissemination-Financial Institutions
  - FY27–29: Compilation and dissemination-Balance of Payments

### Debt sustainability, policy space, and recommended debt strategy
- Debt assessment:
  - Risk of external debt distress: In debt distress
  - Overall risk of debt distress: In debt distress
  - Granularity in the risk rating: Unsustainable
  - Application of judgment: No
- Key findings:
  - Djibouti’s overall and external public debts are assessed to be in distress and unsustainable.
  - Assessment reflects accumulation of sizeable external arrears and large and protracted breaches of sustainability thresholds of the PV of Overall and External Debt-to-GDP and External Debt Service-to-Revenues ratios.
  - The DSA suggests susceptibility to export and primary balance shocks; more prolonged and protracted shocks would present downside risks to the debt outlook.
  - Djibouti’s current composite indicator (CI) is 2.16, which corresponds to a weak debt-carrying capacity.
- Recent developments:
  - According to preliminary information, the authorities have reached an agreement with Exim Bank China for a temporary debt service moratorium, which reopens important policy space.
- Policy recommendations to restore debt sustainability:
  - A balanced mix of structural and fiscal reforms.
  - Strengthened public debt management.
  - New concessional financing and debt relief.
  - Adoption of a Medium-Term Debt Strategy to entrench debt sustainability, including anchoring debt (e.g., a target debt level to be reached by a certain year or a targeted path for fiscal deficits).
  - Rules-based framework for SOE borrowing to strengthen prioritization of investment projects and planning/budgeting.
- Public debt coverage and data gaps:
  - The DSA uses public and publicly guaranteed (PPG) debt covering central government debt and government guarantees on external debt of SOEs.
  - Data on non-guaranteed external debt held by SOEs is not available; standard assumptions are used.
  - Information on domestic debt remains partial; domestic debt contracted by the central government is covered and remains small; SOEs’ domestic debt is not captured.
  - With World Bank support, authorities have enhanced debt transparency since 2022 by regularly publishing information on all new or restructured public or publicly guaranteed loans, including those extended to SOEs.

### Implementation of 2022 Article IV recommendations (select items and status)
- Restore Debt Sustainability and Open Fiscal Space:
  - Recommendations: Prioritize domestic revenue mobilization; rationalize expenditures and pursue public financial management reforms to create space for social spending; strengthen governance and oversight of SOEs; strengthen debt management; advance discussions with creditors.
  - Implementation examples:
    - Creation of a Large-Taxpayers’ Unit announced.
    - In process of renegotiating military base leases.
    - Implementation of the code of good governance has continued, with pilot institutions for board reforms being selected.
    - Agreement in principle reached with EXIM Bank of China.
- Monetary and Financial Sector Policies:
  - Recommendations: Finalize key prudential instruments; improve AML/CFT legislative framework and boost supervisory capacity of the central bank, including AML/CFT risk-based supervision.
  - Implementation examples:
    - Exploring the design and introduction of a reserve requirement.
    - Draft AML/CFT legislative amendments were provided through IMF TA; continued efforts needed to enhance AML/CFT supervision.
- Structural Reforms:
  - Recommendations: Seek ways to lower telecom prices including pursuing competition; continue to digitalize government services; improve coverage and quality of statistics.
  - Implementation examples:
    - Plans for cutting telecom costs by half.
    - Exploring a minority stake sale of Djibouti Telecom.
    - Expanding efforts towards e-filing and expanded human capital at the statistical agency.

### Statistical and data shortcomings relevant for policy and TA
- General: Data are broadly adequate for surveillance, but shortcomings remain; progress on national accounts, but weaknesses in data sources continue to hamper quality; shortcomings in balance of payments (BOP) data, including large errors and omissions; fiscal data reported with delays.
- National accounts:
  - Volume estimates use 2013 as the fixed base year (older than the five-year cycle recommended).
  - National account statistics revised for 2013–2019; actual data available up to 2022.
  - RGPH-3 census underway; field data collection expected to begin in April 2024.
- Price statistics:
  - CPI produced on a timely basis.
  - In 2023, CPI weight reference period updated to 2017; geographic coverage expanded to three geographical regions and five towns.
- External sector statistics:
  - Central Bank has improved BOP quality and coverage with IMF TA.
  - Authorities adopted the general trade system for trade in goods beginning in 2013 to incorporate large FTZ flows (mainly re-exports to Ethiopia).
  - Gaps remain between recorded imports and reexports of the FTZs, producing large swings in the headline current account.
  - Staff capacity needs enhancement to improve quality and timeliness of BOP statistics.
- Government finance statistics:
  - Fiscal data available monthly but often with significant delay; foreign-financed capital expenditure reported regularly.
  - TOFE remains aligned to GFSM 1986 despite chart of accounts aligned to GFSM 2001 since 2012.
  - Coverage limited to budgetary central government institutional units; does not include extrabudgetary entities such as SOEs, ports authority, sovereign wealth fund, or social security fund—though authorities have recently begun to provide detailed accounts of key SOEs.
  - No data currently submitted for the IMF’s annual GFS database and dissemination of fiscal statistics on the Ministry’s website has lapsed.
- Monetary and financial statistics:
  - Djibouti reports MFS for the central bank and other depository corporations based on SRFs in accordance with MFSMCG.
  - Reports some data to the Financial Access Survey (FAS), including two indicators adopted by the UN to monitor Target 8.10 of the SDGs.
  - Regular submission of Financial Soundness Indicators (FSIs) started in May 2018; Djibouti reports 12 core and 6 additional FSIs for deposit takers on a regular and timely basis.
- Exchange arrangement and safeguards:
  - Exchange rate arrangement: a currency board; the Djibouti franc is pegged to the U.S. dollar at the rate of DJF 177.721 = US$1.
  - A safeguards assessment update of the Bank Centrale de Djibouti (BCD) completed in August 2023 found capacity constraints contributing to weak controls (currency management, cybersecurity); internal audit and risk management functions not yet operational; recommended strengthening governance, amending the BCD Law to strengthen autonomy, and enhancing transparency of financial statements through adoption of IFRS and timely audited statements.

*Prepared by the staffs of the International Monetary Fund and the International Development Association (March 15, 2024).*

### 2.      Debt accumulated rapidly between 2013 and 2022 as Djibouti expanded its role as

### 2.      Debt accumulated rapidly between 2013 and 2022 as Djibouti expanded its role as 

### Debt accumulation and main drivers
- Debt-to-GDP grew from 34.9 percent in 2013 to 68 percent by end 2022.
- Large infrastructure projects drove most of the increase, notably:
  - Djibouti-Addis Ababa railway, Doraleh multi-purpose port, Port of Ghoubet, and a water pipeline from Ethiopia.
  - These three projects were financed by a loan from Exim Bank China for a total of USD 1.2 billion (about 59 percent of GDP).
- Additional 2023 borrowing and guarantees:
  - July 2023: central government borrowed EUR 79.2 million from the European Investment Bank (EIB) for water desalination, clean drinking water access, and wastewater treatment.
  - Government guarantees provided to SOE Great Horn Investment Holding:
    - USD 120 million with Afreximbank
    - USD 35 million with Banque pour le Commerce et l’Industrie Mer Rouge (BCIMR)
    - USD 95.5 million from Invest International to develop the Ship Repair Yard
  - Total 2023 borrowing represents around 8 percent of GDP.
- Policy framework and ceilings:
  - SDFP Committee authorized an ex ante exception to the SDFP zero-NCB ceiling for the Shipyard project.
  - Two other 2023 loans, contracted at non-concessional terms, do not comply with the SDFP zero-NCB ceiling.
  - In 2022, an ex ante waiver for the Afreximbank/BCIMR loan was not granted due to insufficient evidence of project viability and low loan concessionality.
- Contingent liabilities (footnote detail preserved in source):
  - The contingent liability shock of 11.2 percent consists of three components: (i) a potential additional SOE external liability at the default value given lack of more detailed information (2 percent of GDP); (iii) potential additional PPP liabilities (4.2 percent of GDP); and (iv) a financial sector contingent liability at the default value (5 percent of GDP).

### Debt service, interest rates, and arrears
- Non-concessional borrowing at a time of high interest rates increased debt service costs and exposure to variable rates:
  - Construction and railway electrification loans were tied to LIBOR.
  - Interest rates on selected 2023 loans:
    - Afreximbank and BCMIR loan: 6.97 percent
    - Loan from Invest International: EURIBOR 3 months plus 1.85 percent
    - Loan from the EIB: EURIBOR 3 months
  - Weighted-average interest rate on Djibouti’s debt stock projected to rise from 0.9 percent in 2022 to an average of 2.8 percent over the ten-year projection horizon.
- Expiration of pandemic-era relief increased debt service:
  - CCRT and DSSI reduced debt service in 2020–21; DSSI first round rescheduled about 2 percent of GDP in 2020 and second round about 1.6 percent in 2021.
  - Total PPG debt service expected to increase from 1.3 percent of GDP in 2022 to an average of 4.6 percent over the ten-year horizon, with a peak at 5.5 percent in 2025.
- Arrears accumulation:
  - By end June 2023, total stock of arrears reached around 6 percent of GDP.
  - Composition of arrears by creditor:
    - Exim Bank China: 78 percent of arrears
    - Exim Bank India: 16 percent
    - Other creditors, including Paris Club creditors: 5 percent

### Recent macroeconomic developments and outlook
- Growth rebound and activity indicators:
  - Growth expected to have reached about 7 percent in 2023, supported by rebound in port activity and construction.
  - Port activity: grew by 31 percent y-o-y in the first three quarters of 2023.
  - Train traffic: increased by 16 percent y-o-y in the first three quarters of 2023.
  - Cement sales: increased by 80 percent y-o-y in the first three quarters of 2023.
  - Energy production: grew by 16.3 percent y-o-y in Q2 2023.
- Outlook and projections:
  - Growth projected at 6.5 percent in 2024, subject to considerable uncertainty.
  - Medium-term growth expected to converge to pre-pandemic (2017–2019) average, stabilizing at 5.5 percent.
  - Inflation expected to converge upwards to about 2 percent in line with international trends.
- Dependence and risks:
  - About 95 percent of Djibouti’s port activity is fueled by Ethiopian trade; growth and external balance largely driven by Ethiopia’s economic activity and trading-partner decisions.
  - Significant regional risks:
    - Ethiopia’s recent default on its debt could hamper trade through Djibouti.
    - Escalation of tensions in the Red Sea could affect transshipments.
    - Increasing refugees/asylum seekers could strain resources and social services: as of August 2023, Djibouti hosted 22,031 refugees and 9,038 asylum seekers.
  - Upsides include stronger-than-expected trade from Ethiopia and addressing the legacy debt burden.

### Fiscal framework, financing assumptions, and reform measures
- Fiscal projections and assumptions:
  - Central government overall deficit expected to average around 2.2 percent on the 10-year projection horizon with a primary deficit at 0.8 percent of GDP.
  - Assumes gradual increase in revenues to GDP following implementation of technical assistance recommendations, including the implementation of the Large Taxpayers Office for the VAT, planned for Q1 2024.
  - No nominal increase assumed to military leases although authorities are renegotiating them.
  - Expenditures expected to decrease as a share of GDP through restraint on current expenditures and stabilization of capital expenditures.
- SOEs:
  - SOEs expected to remain broadly balanced in the medium term.
  - Primary balance projected negative in first two years due to 2023 investments, then positive from 2025 onward.
- Financing and pipeline:
  - Baseline financing assumes declining borrowing as most infrastructure projects completed.
  - Projections incorporate 2023 loans contracted for a total amount of USD 336.3 million, and a staff-projected pipeline of USD 30 million per year at concessional rates.
  - Some uncertainty around these assumptions given lack of a Medium-Term Debt Strategy.
- Debt resolution discussions:
  - Preliminary debt service moratorium with Exim Bank China in October 2023; discussions ongoing on terms, interest rates, and maturities during the moratorium.
  - Negotiations ongoing with India (second largest creditor) and discussions with the Paris Club.

### Debt sustainability assessment, scenarios, and stress tests
- Debt-carrying capacity:
  - Composite indicator (CI) estimated at 2.16, close to previous CI at 2.21; debt-carrying capacity classified as weak.
  - Note: Djibouti’s re-exports (about 95 percent to Ethiopia) affect the CI and may underestimate capacity.
- External debt burden baseline results:
  - Two of four external debt burden indicators breach thresholds through the medium term.
  - PV of external debt-to-GDP ratio peaks at 61.1 percent in 2023 and declines to reach 29.4 percent in 2031.
  - Debt service-to-revenue ratio above threshold until 2032, below threshold from 2033 onward.
  - PV of debt-to-exports and debt service-to-exports ratios are below thresholds throughout the projection horizon.
- Public debt dynamics:
  - PV of total public debt peaks in 2023 at 67.9 percent, falls below the 35 percent threshold in 2031 at 34.2 percent, and amounts to 27.5 percent of GDP in 2033.
- Stress test outcomes:
  - Indicators most sensitive to export shocks due to Djibouti’s re-exporting role.
  - Under the most extreme shock (export growth shock), the PV of debt-to-GDP breaches the threshold over the entire medium-term projection.
- Illustrative Exim Bank China agreement scenario:
  - Assumes arrears to Exim Bank China (5 percent of GDP or USD 160 million) are added to existing debt and refinanced into a bond with 23 years maturity at up to 4 percent; no penalties levied on arrears.
  - Arrears to other creditors, totaling USD 50 million, assumed to remain for now.
  - Under this scenario, PV of External Debt-to-GDP remains above the sustainability threshold over the medium term since the agreement provides flow relief and assumptions imply PV neutrality.
- Overall risk rating:
  - Djibouti remains in debt distress and debt is deemed unsustainable.
  - Restoring sustainability will require a balanced mix of fiscal and structural reforms, improved SOE contributions to revenues, strengthened public debt management, constrained non-concessional financing, and debt relief.

### Policy recommendations and reform priorities
- Fiscal and debt management reforms:
  - Use the moratorium window to design and implement a holistic plan for revenue mobilization with well-timed, consistent implementation.
  - Consolidate all tax provisions within a single legal instrument to make it the sole source of tax policies.
  - Reinforce the decision power of the Ministry of Budget on tax policy issues to ensure coherence and consistency in policy design and implementation.
  - Continue strengthening public debt management and develop a Medium-Term Debt Strategy.
- Revenue administration and mobilization:
  - Implement the Large Taxpayers Office for the VAT (planned for Q1 2024).
  - Continue digitalization of the revenue administration.
  - Continue engagement with FAD TA and other technical assistance on revenue mobilization and tax policy.
- SOE and expenditure management:
  - Enhance SOE fiscal discipline and contribution to public finances; SOE spending restraint is a key driver of medium-term fiscal consolidation.
- Debt restructuring and creditor engagement:
  - Continue negotiations and seek comprehensive agreements that improve flow profile, concessionality, and maturities while aiming to restore sustainability.

*Source: IMF staff summary of the DSA and accompanying chapters from the Djibouti country report.*

### 24.      SOEs will have to play a direct role contributing to revenues. SOEs are currently the

### SOEs will have to play a direct role contributing to revenues.

### Role of SOEs in the economy
- SOEs are currently the largest contributor to Djibouti’s GDP but benefit from numerous exemptions and pay little dividends.
- SOEs have accounted for 80 percent of external borrowing since 2013, and therefore largely contributed to the significant increase in debt levels.

### Borrowing practices and debt governance
- Staff supports the authorities’ revisions to the public sector debt committee (Comité National d’Endettement Public), which issues a reasoned opinion on any borrowing project involving the state.
- Going forward, the authorities are cognizant of the need to exert care when borrowing at non-concessional terms in times of high interest rates to avoid creating additional debt service challenges.

### Transparency and accountability
- Enhancing the transparency of SOEs’ financial accounts would allow for an in-depth analysis of their possible role and more accountability.

### Concessional financing and risk management
- Access to concessional loans and grants will be key to lower risks.
- The authorities would benefit from keeping new borrowing on concessional terms.
- Given the high risks and vulnerability to external shocks, including climate change, it would be prudent to build additional buffers and prepare contingency plans to return debt to the baseline should fiscal slippages and external shocks materialize.

### Authorities’ Views

*Source: IMF staff text from 1djiea2024001 - 24.*

### 26.      The authorities acknowledged that, while the debt service moratorium provides

### 1djiea2024001 - 26.

### Authorities’ assessment of the moratorium and restructuring
- The authorities acknowledged that, while the debt service moratorium provides important flow relief, Djibouti’s debt sustainability rests with the full outcome of the restructuring with all creditors.
- They recognized that the repayment terms after the moratorium will be central for any debt sustainability analysis.
- Both the government of Djibouti and Exim Bank of China are keen to continue negotiating on a long-term solution.
- The authorities do not agree on the methodology used in the calculation presented by the mission during the DSA and tend to agree with the 2019 DSA methodology which excludes Djibouti’s sizable re-exports in the reserve coverage calculation of CI scores.
- They noted that these re-exports are financed not with central bank reserves but with the FX in commercial banks.
- Discussions are ongoing with the Exim Bank of India and the authorities have also contacted the Paris Club.

### Baseline External Debt Sustainability Framework: headline numeric series (as presented)
- External debt (nominal) 1/: 74.071.465.867.965.861.957.153.147.727.510.060.547.9
- of which: public and publicly guaranteed (PPG): 74.0 71.465.867.965.861.957.153.147.727.510.060.547.9
- Change in external debt: 4.8 -2.6 -5.5 2.1 -2.1 -3.9 -4.8 -4.0 -5.4 -3.2 -0.8
- Identified net debt-creating flows: -18.6 -2.7 -29.1 -32.3 -13.6 -12.0 -10.3 -13.2 -12.6 -9.9 -7.3 -17.3 -13.5
- Non-interest current account deficit: -12.3 5.9 -18.2 -25.1 -7.3 -5.9 -4.6 -7.4 -7.3 -5.0 -3.0 -8.0 -7.8
- Deficit in balance of goods and services: -8.59.5 -15.5 -22.4 -4.1 -3.0 -2.0 -5.2 -4.9 -3.4 -1.8 -3.6 -5.6
- Exports: 116.0152.4152.3144.6134.2128.2125.5126.4123.7109.292.9
- Imports: 107.5161.9 136.8122.2130.0125.2123.5121.2118.8105.891.0
- Net current transfers (negative = inflow): -6.1-4.7 -0.3 -3.4 -3.3 -3.3 -3.2 -3.1 -3.1 -3.0 -3.0 -5.8 -3.1
- of which: official: -5.8 -4.40.0 -3.1 -3.0 -3.0 -2.9 -2.8 -2.8 -2.7 -2.7
- Other current account flows (negative = net inflow): 2.31.0-2.40.80.20.40.60.90.71.51.9 1.40.9
- Net FDI (negative = inflow): -5.0-4.9 -5.0 -4.5 -4.5 -4.4 -4.3 -4.2 -4.1 -4.0 -4.0 -6.5 -4.2
- Endogenous debt dynamics 2/: -1.3-3.7-6.0-2.7-1.9-1.8-1.5-1.6-1.2-0.9-0.3
- Contribution from nominal interest rate: 0.80.7 0.61.52.21.91.71.31.50.70.2
- Contribution from real GDP growth: -0.9 -3.1-2.5-4.3-4.1-3.7-3.1-2.9-2.7-1.6-0.6
- Contribution from price and exchange rate changes: -1.2-1.2 -4.0........................
- Residual 3/ 4/ 10/: 23.4 0.123.634.411.58.15.59.27.26.76.520.510.0
- of which: exceptional financing: 0.00.00.00.00.00.00.00.00.00.00.0
- Sustainability indicators (selected):
  - PV of PPG external debt-to-GDP ratio: ......59.161.158.153.949.345.941.223.68.1
  - PV of PPG external debt-to-exports ratio: ... 38.842.243.342.139.336.333.321.68.7
  - PPG debt service-to-exports ratio: 1.5 1.00.92.74.14.34.33.03.52.81.0
  - PPG debt service-to-revenue ratio: 6.66.6 5.617.024.524.523.816.719.213.84.5
- Gross external financing need (Million of U.S. dollars) 4/: -495.085.5-813.4-1035.8-270.7-220.9-174.6-425.6-417.9-464.8-806.9

### Key macroeconomic assumptions (as presented)
- Real GDP growth (in percent): 1.34.53.97.06.56.05.55.55.55.55.5 5.25.8
- GDP deflator in US dollar terms (change in percent): 1.8 1.75.90.91.81.92.62.12.20.00.0 1.71.2
- Effective interest rate (percent) 5/: 1.11.10.92.53.53.12.92.43.02.42.4 1.62.8
- Growth of exports of G&S (US dollar terms, in percent): -28.339.710.02.50.73.35.98.55.51.73.8 8.23.8
- Growth of imports of G&S (US dollar terms, in percent): -28.1 60.1-7.1-3.515.44.06.85.75.61.83.9 12.24.6
- Grant element of new public sector borrowing (in percent): .........19.228.431.632.729.225.130.530.5 ...29.0
- Government revenues (excluding grants, in percent of GDP): 25.723.623.722.722.622.622.722.722.622.521.8 20.922.6
- Aid flows (in Million of US dollars) 6/: 221.3 147.7164.5201.3232.7222.2200.6159.2106.4108.3163.8
- Grant-equivalent financing (in percent of GDP) 7/: .........2.82.82.52.21.81.31.21.1 ...1.8
- Grant-equivalent financing (in percent of external financing) 7/: ......27.037.943.747.248.857.669.878.5 ...54.7
- Nominal GDP (Million of US dollars): 3,185 3,386 3,726 4,023 4,364 4,715 5,103 5,498 5,926 7,832 13,378
- Nominal dollar GDP growth: 3.16.310.08.08.58.08.27.77.85.55.5 7.07.0

### Public Sector DSA: headline numeric series (as presented)
- Public sector debt 1/: 74.371.565.967.965.861.957.153.147.727.510.060.947.9
- of which: external debt: 74.071.465.867.965.861.957.153.147.727.510.060.547.9
- Change in public sector debt: 4.7-2.8-5.62.0-2.2-3.9-4.8-4.0-5.4-3.2-0.8
- Identified debt-creating flows: 4.9-0.9-5.70.8-1.6-2.4-3.3-1.9-3.0-2.1-0.510.6-2.1
- Primary deficit: 6.22.90.45.91.70.4-0.80.7-0.2-0.30.113.60.6
- Revenue and grants: 29.025.524.823.623.623.623.723.723.623.522.8 29.923.6
- of which: grants: 3.41.81.01.01.01.01.01.01.01.01.0
- Primary (noninterest) expenditure: 35.228.425.229.525.324.122.924.423.423.222.9 43.424.2
- Automatic debt dynamics: -1.3-3.7-6.0-5.0-3.3-2.9-2.5-2.6-2.8-1.8-0.6
  - Contribution from interest rate/growth differential: -1.0-5.6-6.6-5.0-3.3-2.9-2.5-2.6-2.8-1.8-0.6
  - of which: contribution from average real interest rate: -0.1-2.4-4.0-0.70.90.90.70.4-0.1-0.2-0.1
  - of which: contribution from real GDP growth: -0.9-3.2-2.7-4.3-4.2-3.7-3.2-3.0-2.8-1.6-0.6
- Contribution from real exchange rate depreciation: -0.31.90.7............
- Residual: -0.1-2.00.11.2-0.6-1.5-1.4-2.1-2.4-1.2-0.3-6.8-1.4
- Sustainability indicators (selected):
  - PV of public debt-to-GDP ratio: ......59.261.158.153.949.345.941.223.68.1
  - PV of public debt-to-revenue and grants ratio: ......239.2258.6246.3228.1208.0193.3174.9100.435.6
  - Debt service-to-revenue and grants ratio 3/: 6.77.05.616.423.623.622.816.018.413.24.3
  - Gross financing need 4/: 8.14.61.79.77.36.04.64.54.22.81.1

### Stress tests, sensitivity analyses, and indicators (as presented)
- Figure and table outputs present alternative scenarios, bound tests, and tailored tests for 2023–2033 with multiple scenario-specific numeric time series for:
  - PV of debt-to-GDP ratio, PV of debt-to-exports ratio, debt service-to-revenue ratio, debt service-to-exports ratio, and gross financing need.
- Table 3 and Table 4 provide sensitivity analysis entries for multiple scenarios (A1, B1–B6, C1–C4) with numeric sequences displayed for 2023–2033 across indicators including PV of debt-to-GDP, PV of debt-to-exports, debt service-to-revenue, and debt service-to-exports.
- Figures show drivers of external and public debt dynamics, realism tools (investment rates and fiscal adjustment multipliers), and stress-test customizations; numeric thresholds and stress-test parameter values are presented in the tables and figure notes.

*Source: 1djiea2024001 - 26.*

### Introduction

### 1djiea2024001 - Introduction

### Introduction and strategic positioning
- Djibouti has leveraged its geostrategic location and achieved remarkable economic growth over the past decade.
- The Container Ports Performance Index (World Bank Group and S&P Global Insight) ranked Djibouti as the most efficient port in Africa and 24th globally.
- Authorities aim to generate new revenue streams and diversify economic activities to create more jobs, enhance economic resilience, and foster a prosperous, inclusive, and sustainable growth.
- Policy priorities: strengthen fiscal sustainability, rein in public debt, advance SOE reforms, improve monetary policy, and shore up the AML/CFT regime.

### Recent macroeconomic developments, outlook, and risks
- Shocks experienced: COVID-19 pandemic, conflict in Ethiopia, flash floods, drought, escalating regional tensions, influx of refugees and asylum seekers.
- Recovery and growth drivers:
  - November 2022 peace agreement in Ethiopia contributed to resurgence of economic activity.
  - Port sector recorded a 34 percent y-o-y growth, reinforced by increased train freight traffic.
  - Construction and public works sector evidenced by an 80 percent increase in cement sales.
  - GDP growth rebounded strongly and is projected at 7 percent for 2023.
  - Local trade increased by 7 percent in 2023.
  - Energy consumption increased by 9 percent in 2023.
  - Trade and current account balances have substantially improved, driven primarily by reexports to Ethiopia.
  - Official reserves cover approximately 5 months of imports.
- Medium-term outlook and plans:
  - Transport and logistics sectors projected to strengthen in 2024, supported by Ethiopia’s anticipated robust economic recovery.
  - Demand for hospitality infrastructure, housing, and commercial real estate to boost construction and public works.
  - Medium-term diversification goals: boost human capital; reduce cost of electricity and telecommunications; develop labor-intensive tourism and manufacturing; accelerate development of port- and logistic-related sectors.
  - Djibouti Ship Repair Yard created; expected to generate over 3,000 direct and indirect jobs.
- Key risks:
  - Possible escalation of tensions in the Red Sea and the Horn of Africa that may reduce transshipment activities.
  - Negative impact of increasing asylum seekers on scarce resources, notably water and education and health services.

### Fiscal policy reforms and debt management
- Revenue mobilization measures:
  - Commitment to boost domestic revenue mobilization through holistic tax policies and sounder fiscal institutions.
  - Strengthening customs duties and domestic tax revenue collection is deemed essential.
  - Enhancing property and commercial real estate taxes will be important, balanced to avoid stifling construction sector activity.
  - Plans include creating a tax policy unit, establishing a Large-Taxpayer Office, and enhancing management capacity in the ministry of budget with Fund TA.
  - Focus on accelerated digitalization of revenue and tax incentives administration.
  - Ongoing review of military base leases; negotiations with key partners have commenced, including discussions on an indexation mechanism to protect future revenues.
- Public debt management and institutional reforms:
  - Development of a Debt and Public Investment Program aimed at strengthening debt statistics management and boosting debt management capacity of the Public Debt Department within the Ministry of Budget.
  - Progress on a Medium-Term Debt Strategy (MTDS).
  - National Debt Committee instituted by Presidential Decree in 2022 and chaired by the Prime Minister continues to coordinate national public debt policy.
- Debt restructuring developments:
  - Significant breakthrough with Exim Bank of China: a debt moratorium over the next four years (2024- 2027) for two large infrastructure undertakings, the rail and water supply projects.
  - Government notes significant reduction of public debt servicing burden and expects favorable longer-term restructuring terms to be achieved in due course.
  - Authorities committed to continue engagement with all creditors, including Exim Bank of India and the Paris Club, to address outstanding arrears.
- Debt sustainability stance and projections:
  - Authorities express reservations on the methodology used in the 2024 DSA and request consistency with the 2019 DSA methodology.
  - Projected reduction of the primary budget deficit to 0.7 percent of GDP by 2029 (from 1.3 percent of GDP in 2023).
  - Authorities emphasize enhanced fiscal restraint, promising debt rescheduling prospects, strong growth outlook, and prioritization of concessional funding to improve debt risk classification and call for comprehensive DSA and reclassification when conditions permit.

### State-Owned Enterprise (SOE) reforms
- Commitment to strengthen SOE oversight and governance and preserve debt carrying capacity of public state companies.
- Inter-ministerial debt committee, supported by the Public Debt Directorate and the Executive Secretariat in charge of the State Portfolio (SEPE), is refining diagnostic tools for SOE performance monitoring.
- Establishment of independent boards of directors for ten pilot enterprises.
- Commitment to implement the SOE Code of Governance this year and to advance reforms of Public Administrative Establishments (EPAs).
- Authorities welcome capacity development assistance from multilateral and bilateral partners for SOE reform program.

### Monetary policy and AML/CFT
- Central Bank of Djibouti (CBD) concurs with staff to further reinforce supervisory and policy toolkits and intensify AML/CFT reform efforts.
- Progress made:
  - Reduction of systemic risks in the banking sector since the last Article IV Consultations.
  - Upgraded supervisory and prudential risk oversight framework with IMF TA.
- Planned measures:
  - Introduction of a reserve requirement to enhance the effectiveness of liquidity management.
  - Improvement of Djibouti’s AML/CFT framework; implementation of recommendations from the first FATF mutual evaluation mission.
  - Creation of a national coordination unit and preparation of a draft national strategy for AML/CFT reform.
  - Enhancement of the effectiveness of the Financial Intelligence Unit for AML/CFT investigations in coordination with enforcement institutions.

### Structural reforms
- Authorities prioritize reducing high costs of electricity and telecommunications to support economic diversification beyond ports and transport.
- Revisiting of development framework: Djibouti 2035 Vision and the medium-term National Development Plan.
- Focus areas after infrastructure build-up:
  - Boost social and labor inclusiveness.
  - Increase human capital and strengthen health infrastructure.
  - Reduce operating costs (electricity and telecommunications) to boost competitiveness and diversification.
  - Enhance governance and address climate change challenges.

### Conclusion and international cooperation
- Djibouti continues reforms to strengthen macroeconomic stability and promote stronger growth amid a challenging external environment.
- Authorities will leverage the country’s geostrategic position while adapting to evolving geopolitical conditions and promoting economic diversification.
- Commitment to work closely with development partners and to deepen collaboration with the Fund going forward.

*Source: 1djiea2024001 - Introduction*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/cr/2024/english/1djiea2024001.pdf_
