## 1marea2024001

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [1marea2024001](https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/cr/2024/english/1marea2024001.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/files/publications/cr/2024/english/1marea2024001.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/files/publications/cr/2024/english/1marea2024001.pdf.json)

---

### EXECUTIVE SUMMARY — Context and near-term outlook
- Moroccan economy showed resilience in 2023 despite water scarcity, the September 2023 earthquake, and lower growth in the Euro Area.
- Economic activity accelerated, inflation slowed, and the current account deficit narrowed.
- Ambitious infrastructure plan (including water and energy sectors) expected to boost investment and growth in the next few years; current account gradually converging towards the medium-term norm.
- Fiscal deficit in 2023 was below the level projected in the Budget; authorities reiterated commitment to a gradual fiscal consolidation over the next three years.
- Structural reform implementation continued, particularly on social protection, health care, and education.
- Mission conducted during January 30th - February 15th, 2024, in Casablanca and Rabat; mission head: Roberto Cardarelli.

### Growth outlook and macro projections
- Growth projections and drivers:
  - Growth expected to remain around 3 percent in 2024 and gradually increase to about 3½ percent over the medium term.
  - Drivers: normalization of agricultural output, lower inflation, generalization of the social protection system, post-earthquake reconstruction plan, infrastructure plans (water and energy), and pro-business reforms.
  - Authorities’ Budget 2024 forecasts real output growth of 3.7 and 3.5 percent in 2024-2025, respectively.
- External balance and inflation:
  - Stronger domestic demand expected to gradually widen the current account deficit towards its estimated medium-term norm of around 3 percent of GDP.
  - Food price inflation projected to continue to fall; overall CPI inflation projected at 2.3 percent (y/y) by the end of 2025 (2.6 percent annual average) after accounting for gradual removal of subsidies starting this year.
- Key macro projections (selected figures):
  - Real GDP: 3.0 (2023), 3.1 (2024), 3.3 (2025), 3.4 (2026).
  - Consumer prices (end of period): 3.4 (2023), 2.5 (2024), 2.2 (2025).
  - Unemployment rate (end of period): 13.0 (2023), 12.0 (2024), 11.5 (2025).
  - Current account (billions USD): -2.0 (2023), -3.8 (2024), -4.5 (2025).
  - Gross reserves (billions USD): 36.3 (2023), 38.2 (2024), 40.0 (2025).

### Risks
- Risks tilted to the downside:
  - External risks: escalation of conflicts in Gaza and in Ukraine, negative terms-of-trade shocks, compressed investment, reignited inflation.
  - Domestic risks: further droughts and reduced agricultural production.
  - Structural reforms risk profile: growth pick-up and unemployment decline depend on successful reform implementation, implying both downside and upside uncertainty.
- External Economic Stress Index (EESI):
  - Baseline suggests external stress would decrease slightly over 2024-2025 versus last year.
  - Downside scenario (weaker euro area, higher oil prices, higher US 10-year yield) would raise stress to a scale similar to the Eurozone sovereign debt crisis in 2012.

### Fiscal policy: consolidation, composition, and risks
- Recent outcomes and commitments:
  - Central government overall deficit for 2023 closed at 4.4 percent of GDP, about ½ percent of GDP less than projected in the 2023 Budget.
  - Central government debt closed 2022 at 70.6 percent of GDP (vs. 69.8 percent projected in the 2023 Budget).
  - Authorities announced a 120-billion-dirham reconstruction plan over a 5-year period (about 8 percent of GDP); about half expected from domestic resources and loans and the rest from grants.
- Fiscal path and targets:
  - Fiscal deficit projected to decrease to 4.3 percent of GDP in 2024 and reach 3.2 percent of GDP in 2026.
  - Central government debt-to-GDP ratio expected to decline to about 68½ percent by 2026; authorities’ Medium-Term Fiscal Framework intention to bring ratio to 65 percent by 2030.
- Subsidy and VAT reforms:
  - New cash transfer scheme (aide social directe) estimated to cost about 1¾ percent of GDP annually.
  - Subsidy reform over 2024-2026: price of a twelve (three) kilogram gas cylinder will increase by 10 (2.5) dirhams per year; price of one kilogram of sugar will increase by 1 dirham per year; volume of wheat purchased by the state and sold at subsidized prices will be gradually eliminated.
  - Expected budget saving of 1½ percent of GDP over 2024-2026, 80 percent explained by increase in price of gas butane.
  - VAT rates reduced from five (0, 7, 10, 14, and 20 percent) to three (0, 10 and 20 percent) over the next three years; staff estimates VAT potential at close to 12 percent of GDP (actual VAT revenues around 8 percent of GDP in 2022).
- Uncollected tax stocks (end-2022 estimates):
  - DGI: 100 billion dirhams (6.9 percent of GDP).
  - ADII: 697 billion dirhams (48 percent of GDP), 97 percent of which are fines that would need reclassification as irrecoverable.
- Revenue from mobilization of central government real assets:
  - Generated 74.3 billion dirhams between 2019 and 2023.
  - Expected to generate 35 billion dirhams of revenues per year over the next three years.

### Fiscal policy recommendations (staff advice)
- Complete VAT reform: gradually extend the standard 20 percent rate to a broader range of goods and services (including fossil fuels).
- Enhance tax administration:
  - Adopt a medium-term revenue strategy (MTRS) linked to fiscal consolidation.
  - Digitalize and simplify tax procedures; operationalize compliance risk management; merge regional large taxpayer units into a national one; enhance information systems and inter-agency collaboration; use data analytics and risk-based audits.
- Rationalize current spending:
  - Measures could include elimination of remaining subsidies on gas butane, generalization of the RSU to all social programs, continued public administration digitalization, and implementation of SOE reform to reduce transfers.
- Reinforce MTFF and fiscal transparency:
  - Add drivers of fiscal balance changes, costs (dirham and share of GDP) of new policy measures, and quantitative assessments of fiscal risks (state guarantees, SOEs, climate).
- Assess and monitor PPP fiscal implications:
  - Strengthen capacity to evaluate, monitor and transparently report PPP budget implications; set a global annual envelope for new PPPs.
- Provide details on financements innovants:
  - Add specifics in MTFF on assets expected to be sold and terms of sales to add credibility to revenue projections.

### Monetary policy and inflation
- Recent developments:
  - Headline inflation declined from 10.1 percent y/y in February 2023 to 2.3 percent in January 2024; core inflation was 2.9 percent in January.
  - Bank Al-Maghrib (BAM) kept policy rate unchanged at 3 percent after three consecutive hikes totaling 150 basis points between September 2022 and March 2023.
  - Two-year ahead inflation expectations fell to 3.3 percent in Q4:2023 (from 3.9 percent in Q3); ex-ante real policy rate remains slightly negative and below staff’s estimate of the neutral level (between 1 and 1.5 percent).
- Staff guidance:
  - Future policy changes should remain data-dependent.
  - As inflation falls, BAM should resume transition to an inflation-targeting regime to cushion real external shocks, keep the exchange rate in line with fundamentals, strengthen transmission, and contribute to private sector development.
  - Authorities should prepare to remove the peg and subsequently phase out remaining limitations to capital outflows on Moroccan residents when ready.
- Policy risks and mitigation:
  - Upside inflation risks from persistent food price pressures associated with water scarcity, removal of subsidies to agricultural and transport sectors, and projected rebound of domestic demand.
  - Authorities introduced subsidies to the agricultural sector and to transport professionals for about 0.4 percent of GDP in each of 2022 and 2023.

### Financial sector resilience and policies
- Banking sector soundness:
  - Banks’ profitability improved: ROE improved to 11.8 percent in the first half of 2023 from 10.9 percent last year.
  - Regulatory capital to risk-weighted assets: 15.6 (Dec 2023); Tier 1 capital to risk-weighted assets: 12.9 (Dec 2023).
  - NPLs to total loans: 8.4 (Dec 2023); specific provisions to NPLs: 68.9 (Dec 2023).
  - Liquid assets to total assets: 14.6 (Dec 2023); deposits to loans: 104.8 (Dec 2023).
- Regulatory and supervisory measures:
  - SREP expected to be gradually implemented by 2027.
  - Capital surcharges for the three systemically important banks: Tier 1 capital ratio raised from 9 to 11 percent by 2025 at the latest.
  - BAM set to adopt a Net Stable Funding Ratio (NFSR) in 2024 and an ILAAP under Basel Pillar 2.
  - Progress on secondary market for NPLs; draft legislation expected to be sent to Parliament this year.
  - Reinforced bank resolution framework: new legislation being finalized to reinforce BAM's powers and introduce a bail-in option.
- Greening the financial sector:
  - BAM developing guidelines for banks to gather and report large borrower exposures to climate risks; guidelines expected to be finalized by the end of 2024.
  - Ministry of Economy and Finance developing a National Climate Finance Strategy; first draft set to be prepared by mid-2024.

### RSF and FCL arrangements — status and recommendations
- FCL:
  - Morocco continues to meet the FCL qualification criteria; staff recommends completion of the review under the FCL arrangement.
  - Morocco’s two-year FCL arrangement approved April 3, 2023 in amount of SDR 3.7262 billion (About 417 percent of quota, or US$5 billion). Authorities intend to treat FCL as precautionary and to gradually exit it depending on external risks.
- RSF:
  - RSF approved Sep 28, 2023; total RMs: 16; total access: 112% of quota = 1000 SDR (Million).
  - Four of five reform measures scheduled for first review implemented; RM10 (planned VAT increase on fossil fuels) postponed to third review.
  - RM3, RM11, RM12, RM13 implemented; RM10 postponed; authorities proposed bringing RM7 forward to second review and staff supports proposal.
  - Disbursement implications with postponement of RM10:
    - Disbursement under completion of first review falls from SDR 312.5 million (35 percent of quota) to SDR 250 million (28 percent of quota).
    - If RM7 moved to second review, disbursement under second review increases from SDR 250 million (28 percent) to SDR 312.5 million (35 percent).
  - RSF disbursement projections (Billions of U.S. dollars): 0.0 (2023), 0.8 (2024), 0.6 (2025).
- Safeguards:
  - Safeguards procedures for the 2023 FCL arrangement completed with no significant issue; Deloitte Morocco issued an unmodified audit opinion on BAM’s 2022 financial statements.

### Structural reforms, private sector development, and SOE governance
- Key reform priorities:
  - Accelerate SOE reform, Mohammed VI Fund implementation, and the new Charter of Investment to boost private investment and reduce unemployment.
  - Generalize social protection and overhaul health care and education to reduce inequalities and enhance human capital.
  - Revamp active labor market policies (ALMP) to address high unemployment in short run.
  - Improve water infrastructure and continue liberalizing the electricity market to attract renewable energy investment.
- SOE and investment reforms:
  - Agence Nationale de Gestion Stratégique des Participations de l'État (ANGSPE) began elaborating the state shareholder policy; ANGPE has until 2026 to fully implement SOE sector reform.
  - Mohammed VI Fund selected seventeen management companies and signed partnership agreements with international actors.
- SME and entrepreneurship support:
  - Mohammed VI Fund and new Charter of Investment to facilitate SME access to private equity and senior debt; need for additional support in business planning, technology, marketing, and networking.
  - Scope to consolidate and simplify many existing entrepreneurship programs and agencies.

### Governance, competition, and anti-corruption
- Competition and enforcement:
  - Merger notification filings doubled in the last 3 years.
  - Competition Council increased enforcement; 2023 modification of competition legislation simplified merger regulation, clarified penalty criteria, and introduced settlement-based penalty reductions.
  - Resulted in a fine of 1.84 billion dirhams (about USD 200 million) on the largest 9 oil distributor companies.
  - Published first sectoral study (data centers); further sectoral studies planned (automotive sector expected 2024).
- Anti-corruption framework:
  - Law 46-19 (approved 2021) expanded powers of INPPLC.
  - 2023 public procurement legislation seeks to strengthen transparency and tackle corruption and conflicts of interest.
- Recommended priority reforms:
  - Reform penal code and penal procedural code; resubmit bill on illicit enrichment; introduce whistleblower legislation; introduce conflict-of-interest legislation; reinforce asset declaration law amendments.

### Labor market and social protection
- Labor market outcomes and dynamics:
  - GDP growth: 1.3 percent in 2022; average 2.9 percent in first three quarters of 2023.
  - Unemployment rose to 13.3 percent at end-2023 (against average pre-Covid of 9.4 percent).
  - Box statistics: unemployment rate rose to 13 percent on average in 2023; female unemployment about 20 percent.
  - Labor force participation fell: Q3:2023 participation about 2½ pps below 2019; female participation 18.4 percent in Q3:2023, down 3¼ pps since 2019; male participation down 1¾ pps since 2019.
  - Job losses concentrated in agriculture due to droughts.
  - NEET rate remained at about 29 percent over past decade.
- Social protection reform (four pillars) and fiscal implications:
  - Pillars: extension of compulsory basic health insurance (AMO Tadamon, AMO TNS, AMO Achamil); extension of family allowances (December 2023); extension of old-age pension coverage by 2025; extension of unemployment benefit scheme by 2025.
  - AMO Tadamon surpassed 10 million beneficiaries by September 2023; AMO TNS nearly 4 million beneficiaries.
  - In total, 22 additional million people expected to be eventually covered.
  - Financing: contribution-based mechanisms and state-subsidized contributions for low-income people.
  - Fiscal cost: By 2025, reform estimated to require a total annual expenditure of around US$5 billion.
- Labor market policies and ALMPs:
  - Multiple active employment programs over two decades; impact limited.
  - Recommendation: integrated ALMP strategy to coordinate national and local players and target specific labor market needs.
  - Consideration: temporarily extend unemployment benefit to all workers losing a job with low RSU scoring conditional on participation in up/re-skilling programs.

### Health and education reforms
- Health system reform measures supported by staff:
  - Update national reference pricing via agreements with providers and pharmaceutical industry.
  - Link healthcare professional remuneration to productivity and allow dual practice.
  - Integrate health information systems and create national patient identity card with medical history.
  - Upgrade medical facilities: build three new university hospitals and twelve new medical centers.
  - Remove legal barriers to investment in health sector; create territorial health groups; set a new High Health Authority.
- Education reform progress:
  - Preschool enrollment reached 90 percent (objective: 100 percent in 2028).
  - More than 600 “pioneer” schools operational using new teaching methods; target to reach 2,600 at start of next school year covering 30 percent of students (from 8 percent in first year).
  - Launch of new training program for future primary and secondary teachers.
  - Key requirement: set up an efficient national evaluation system to monitor and assess reform results.

### Climate change, water scarcity, and energy strategy
- Water infrastructure and financing:
  - PNAEPI received extra 28 billion dirhams, bringing envelope to 143 billion.
  - New roadmap for desalination plants for 2023-2027 to provide additional capacity of over 1 billion cubic meters of desalinated water per year.
  - Emergency program (end-2023) acquired 20 desalination mobile stations.
  - Projects announced for 6 additional large and mid-size dams.
  - National Water Plan 2020-2050 envisages further investments for total envelope around 383 billion dirhams (about USD 40 billion).
- Water tariff reform and studies:
  - Water tariffs kept artificially low; two initiatives: World Bank-assisted review of public expenditure in water sector and strategic study on true cost of water by Ministry of Water and Equipment expected to be concluded by early 2025.
- Climate and energy targets:
  - Authorities committed to achieve net-zero GHG emissions by 2050.
  - 2023 Long-Term Low Carbon Strategy builds on 2021 NDC target of reducing GHG emissions by 45.5 percent by 2030.
  - Strategy envisages 96 percent of electricity generated from carbon-neutral sources by 2050 and complete elimination of coal-fired power generation by 2040 (coal currently about 60 percent of overall electricity generation).
  - Strategy envisages scope to reduce energy consumption by 35 percent by 2050.
- Electricity market restructuring and SRMs:
  - Separation of ONEE’s activities and creation of a national Transmission System Operator; ANRE to examine ONEE proposal for unbundling transmission financial accounts (RM2).
  - Creation of Sociétés Régionales Multiservices (SRM) in each of 12 regions; four SRMs (Casablanca-Settat, Marrakech-Safi, Souss-Massa, Oriental) to be set up in 2024.
  - ANRE published tariffs for transmission use and renewable hosting capacity for 2024–2028 (RM3 implemented).
- Energy efficiency and carbon pricing:
  - Legal framework completion for energy efficiency (RM7) and ambition to improve energy efficiency by 20 percent by 2030.
  - MEF to produce design document for introduction of a carbon tax (RM9).
- Green finance:
  - National Climate Finance Strategy (RM14), climate budget tagging, national green taxonomy, framework for sovereign green bond issuances, and gradual environmental impact requirements for publicly guaranteed projects (RM15).
  - BAM to issue supervisory guidelines on climate risk disclosure and reporting for banks (RM16).

### Debt dynamics and sustainability
- Central government debt ratio stabilized around 70 percent of GDP since 2021 (72.2 percent in 2020).
- Gross financing needs (GFN) increased to about 21.3 percent of GDP in 2023.
- Debt composition and mitigating factors:
  - About a quarter denominated in foreign currency.
  - More than three quarters held by domestic institutional investors.
  - Average maturity about 6 years and 10 months as of mid-2023 (6.8 years cited for 2023 elsewhere).
  - About 90 percent at fixed rates.
- Sustainability assessment:
  - Central government debt continues to be sustainable with high probability; overall risk of sovereign stress moderate.
  - Debt fan chart index score: 1.7 (moderate).
- Contingent liabilities:
  - Guarantees to commercial SOEs’ external debt about 8 percent of GDP; subsidized credit schemes about 3 percent of GDP.
- Policy recommendations:
  - Accelerate fiscal consolidation, reinforce MTFF, implement fiscal rule anchored on public debt, continue active debt management, pursue privatization receipts, and implement reforms in pension and health systems.

### Implementation, timelines, and next steps
- Article IV consultation: next consultation expected on standard 12-month cycle.
- RSF reviews and Board dates:
  - FCL Mid-Term Review Board Date: March 2024.
  - RSF Approval Board Date: November 2024.
  - RSF 1st Review Board Date: March 2025.
  - RSF availability dates: "All the availability dates are on 15th of each month."
- RSF reform measures schedule (selected availability and status):
  - RM3 Availability Date: 24-Feb (Implemented).
  - RM10 Availability Date: February-24 (Not Implemented. Delayed).
  - RM11, RM12, RM13 Availability Date: February-24 (Implemented).
  - RM7 proposed to be moved to 2nd review (Administrative note).
- Staff recommendation:
  - Completion of the review under the FCL arrangement; continue RSF implementation with RM10 postponed and RM7 rephased as proposed.

*Source: IMF staff report — EXECUTIVE SUMMARY and selected sections (1marea2024001) — March 11, 2024.*

### EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

### EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

### Context and near-term outlook
- The Moroccan economy showed resilience in 2023 despite water scarcity, the September 2023 earthquake, and lower growth in the Euro Area.
- Economic activity accelerated, inflation slowed, and the current account deficit narrowed.
- An ambitious infrastructure plan (including water and energy sectors) is expected to boost investment and growth in the next few years, with the current account gradually converging towards the medium-term norm.
- The fiscal deficit in 2023 was below the level projected in the Budget; authorities reiterated commitment to a gradual fiscal consolidation over the next three years.
- Structural reform implementation continued, particularly on social protection, health care, and education.

### Article IV Consultation — policy focus and reform priorities
- Discussions focused on policies to secure the recent decline of inflation and advance fiscal consolidation while financing structural reforms to create more jobs and enhance inclusiveness.
- Key reform priorities:
  - Accelerate SOE reform, Mohammed VI Fund implementation, and the new Charter of Investment to boost private investment and reduce unemployment.
  - Generalize social protection and overhaul health care and education to reduce inequalities and enhance human capital.
  - Revamp active labor market policies to address high unemployment in the short run.
  - Improve water infrastructure to mitigate water scarcity.
  - Continue liberalizing the electricity market to attract investment in renewable energy.
- Financing reforms while rebuilding fiscal space requires efforts to extend the tax base and rationalize spending.
- Reporting budgetary implications of planned public-private investment projects and mobilization of real government assets would reinforce confidence in fiscal stability.

### Flexible Credit Line (FCL) and Resilience and Sustainability Facility (RSF)
- Staff assessment: Morocco continues to meet the qualification criteria for access to the FCL arrangement; staff recommends completion of the review under the FCL arrangement.
- Authorities intend to treat the FCL arrangement as precautionary and to gradually exit it, depending on external risks.
- RSF implementation: authorities have implemented four of the five reform measures scheduled for the first review.
  - The planned increase in the VAT on fossil fuels was not implemented and postponed to the third and final review due to concerns about its impact given still high inflation (particularly of food items), the reform of subsidies on gas butane, and weak labor markets.
  - Authorities proposed bringing forward to the second review the reform measure on changes to the legal framework for energy efficiency; staff supports these proposals.

### Mission and timeline
- Mission head: Roberto Cardarelli; team members included Marzie Taheri Sanjani, Sahra Sakha, Hector Perez-Saiz, and Hussein Bidawi; assistance from Hannah Brown, Vaishnavi Rupavatharam, Rodrigo Huguet, and Abigail Korman.
- Meetings with a broad set of ministries, Bank Al-Maghrib, social partners, regulatory and state entities, and international partners.
- Mission conducted during January 30th - February 15th, 2024, in Casablanca and Rabat, Morocco.

### Recent economic developments — key findings
- Output and labor market
  - GDP growth: after 1.3 percent in 2022, economic activity grew at an average of 2.9 percent in the first three quarters of 2023.
  - Unemployment rose to 13.3 percent at the end of 2023 (against an average pre-Covid of 9.4 percent).
  - Fall in employment driven by severe job losses in the agricultural sector due to low water availability for irrigation.
- Inflation and monetary policy
  - Headline inflation declined from 10.1 percent y/y in February 2023 to 2.3 percent in January (core inflation was 2.9 percent).
  - Food inflation was 4.2 percent in January (y/y); fresh food products rose about 5.2 percent y/y in January, down from 32 percent in February 2023.
  - Bank Al-Maghrib kept the policy rate unchanged at 3 percent after three consecutive hikes totaling 150 basis points between September 2022 and March 2023.
  - Two-year ahead inflation expectations fell to 3.3 percent in Q4:2023 (from 3.9 percent in Q3); ex-ante real policy rate remains slightly negative and below staff’s estimate of the neutral level (between 1 and 1.5 percent).
  - Bank lending rates on average about 120 bps higher in Q4:2023 compared to Q3:2022; credit growth slowed to about 5.2 percent y/y in December 2023 from about 7 percent in 2022.
  - The dirham appreciated by about 5⅓ percent against the USD and 2 percent against the Euro in 2023 and remained within the fluctuation band.
- External sector and reserves
  - Current account deficit narrowed significantly due to reduced trade deficit, robust exports (automotive and electronics), buoyant services exports (tourism and non-tourism), and expanded inward remittances.
  - International reserves increased to about USD 36.3 billion in December, about USD 4 billion above end-2022.
  - REER relatively unchanged on average in 2023 versus 2022.
- Fiscal developments and public finances
  - Central government overall deficit for 2023 closed at 4.4 percent of GDP, about ½ percent of GDP less than projected in the 2023 Budget.
  - Tax revenues fell less than projected (by 0.4 percent of GDP) after exceptional 2022 performance; positive impact from recent tax reforms (with some personal and corporate taxes imposed as withholding tax).
  - Non-tax revenues were boosted by the Earthquake Fund, which gathered voluntary contributions of about 20 billion dirhams (about 1½ percent of GDP).
  - Higher-than-planned spending by 0.9 percent of GDP, especially capital spending in water, health, and education.
  - Authorities announced a 120-billion-dirham reconstruction plan over a 5-year period (about 8 percent of GDP), with about half expected from domestic resources and loans and the rest from grants from international donors.
  - Central government debt closed 2022 at 70.6 percent of GDP (vs. 69.8 percent projected in the 2023 Budget).
- Financial sector
  - Banks’ profitability improved in 2023; return on equity (ROE) improved to 11.8 percent in the first half of 2023 from 10.9 percent last year.
  - Low-cost current and savings accounts represent about 77 percent of all deposits and grew 3.3 percent y/y in 2023.
  - Higher provisioning for asset-quality risk (about 69 percent of NPLs in December 2023) limited profit gains but increased buffers.
  - NPLs increased slightly in 2023, partly due to repayment difficulties on subsidized loans extended during the pandemic.
    - About 60 billion dirhams of loans were extended in 2020 under two state-guaranteed loan programs; as of end-2023, about 10 percent of these loans were showing repayment difficulties and were counted among NPLs.
- Structural reforms progress
  - First two pillars of the generalization of the social protection system introduced; as of end-2023 about 3 million households (about 10 million people) registered to the Unified Social Registry (Registre Social Unifié-RSU).
  - Registry used to validate transfers from free healthcare beneficiaries to the new mandatory health insurance scheme (AMO Tadamon).
  - December 2023 reform of the teachers’ statute announced to link remuneration to continuous formation and performance.
  - Agence Nationale de Gestion Stratégique des Participations de l'État (ANGSPE) began elaborating the state shareholder policy for SOE restructuring.
  - Mohammed VI Fund selected seventeen management companies and signed partnership agreements with international actors (including the IFC, the African Development Bank, and the EIB).

### Labor market details (Box 1) — key statistics and findings
- On average in 2023 the unemployment rate rose to 13 percent, a level not seen since the late 1990s; female unemployment reached about 20 percent.
- Labor force participation fell; Q3:2023 participation was about 2½ pps below 2019.
  - Female labor force participation fell to 18.4 percent in Q3:2023, a decline of 3¼ pps compared to 2019.
  - Male participation decline was 1¾ pps compared to 2019.
- Rise in unemployment reflects a fall in the employment rate to the lowest level since Q2:2018; job losses in the first three quarters of 2023 mainly from agriculture due to droughts.
- Women disproportionately affected: in 2021 about 52 percent of working women were employed in agriculture versus 29 percent for men.
- Estimated NAIRU shows an increasing trend since 2019, accounting for most of the increase in the actual unemployment rate.

### Social protection reform highlights (Box 2) — pillars and fiscal implications
- The reform (begun in 2021) envisages four pillars:
  - Extension of compulsory basic health insurance: AMO Tadamon operational by end-2022; AMO TNS for self-employed; AMO Achamil launched January 2024 for those not engaged in activity but exceeding RSU threshold.
    - By September 2023, AMO Tadamon surpassed 10 million beneficiaries (6.7 million dependents); AMO TNS reached nearly 4 million beneficiaries (about 2 million insured workers and 2 million dependents).
    - In total, 22 additional million people are expected to be eventually covered with the same basic healthcare services.
  - Extension of family allowances came into force in December 2023: means-tested flat rate benefits for households below an RSU-scored threshold; a means-tested premium for newborns included for the first two children.
  - Extension of old-age pension coverage by 2025: launch of a new contributory scheme dedicated to self-employed; reform expected to increase subscribers by 5 million.
  - Extension of unemployment benefit scheme by 2025: relax qualifying conditions and legally extend coverage to all people in stable employment, including self-employed and non-salaried workers.
- Financing: the reform builds on contribution-based mechanisms and state-subsidized contributions for low-income people.
- Fiscal cost: By 2025, the reform is estimated to require a total annual expenditure of around US$5 billion.

*Source: IMF staff report — EXECUTIVE SUMMARY (1marea2024001) — March 11, 2024.*

### 8.      Growth is expected to remain around 3 percent in 2024 and gradually increase to

### 1marea2024001 - 8.      Growth is expected to remain around 3 percent in 2024 and gradually increase to

### Growth outlook and macro projections
- Growth is expected to remain around 3 percent in 2024 and gradually increase to about 3½ percent over the medium term.
- Drivers:
  - Normalization of agricultural output, lower inflation, and the generalization of the social protection system expected to sustain private consumption.
  - Post-earthquake reconstruction plan, implementation of infrastructure plans (including in water and energy sectors), and continued pro-business sector reforms expected to gradually boost private investment.
- External and external-balance outlook:
  - Stronger domestic demand is expected to gradually widen the current account deficit towards its estimated medium-term norm of around 3 percent of GDP.
- Inflation and prices:
  - Food price inflation is projected to continue to fall.
  - Overall CPI inflation projected at 2.3 percent (y/y) by the end of 2025 (2.6 percent annual average) after considering the price impact of the gradual removal of subsidies starting this year.

### Risks
- Risks are tilted to the downside.
- External risks:
  - An escalation of the conflicts in Gaza and in Ukraine could disrupt external demand, generate a negative terms-of-trade shock, compress investment prospects and growth, and reignite inflationary pressures.
- Domestic risks:
  - Further episodes of droughts and reduced agricultural production remain the biggest risk to growth.
- Structural reforms risk profile:
  - The pick-up of growth and decline of the unemployment rate is predicated on successful implementation of structural reforms; the ultimate impact depends on how successful they are in closing gaps with higher income economies, implying risks both on the downside and on the upside.

### Authorities’ views on growth
- Authorities expect a more vigorous and dynamic acceleration of economic activity.
- Budget 2024 forecasts real output growth of 3.7 and 3.5 percent in 2024-2025, respectively.
- Authorities expect growth to be driven by a significant increase in domestic demand: consumption boosted by social transfers and investment fueled by better prospects for the construction sector after entry into force of the direct housing subsidy scheme.
- Continuous expansion of tourism and investment in infrastructure (spurred by hosting the African soccer cup in 2025 and the World Soccer Cup in 2030) and structural reforms (particularly strengthening human capital) are expected to support medium-term growth at rates above staff projections.

### Fiscal policy: consolidation, composition, and risks
- Fiscal consolidation path:
  - Fiscal deficit projected to decrease slightly to 4.3 percent of GDP in 2024 and then more rapidly, reaching 3.2 percent of GDP in 2026.
  - Central government debt-to-GDP ratio expected to decline to about 68½ percent by 2026.
  - Authorities’ Medium-Term Fiscal Framework intention to bring central government debt-to-GDP ratio to 65 percent by 2030.
- Reallocation of spending and new social transfers:
  - New scheme of cash transfers to vulnerable households (aide social directe) estimated to cost about 1¾ percent of GDP annually.
  - To a large extent, this cost will be covered by reduction of subsidies on gas butane, wheat, and sugar over the next three years, starting from April 2024, and gradual elimination of various preexisting social programs.
- Subsidy reform fiscal impact:
  - Over the next three years (2024-2026), the price of a twelve (three) kilogram gas cylinder will increase by 10 (2.5) dirhams per year, the price of one kilogram of sugar will increase by 1 dirham per year, while the volume of wheat purchased by the state and sold at subsidized prices will be gradually eliminated.
  - These measures are expected to generate a budget saving of 1½ percent of GDP, 80 percent of which is explained by the increase in the price of gas butane.
- VAT reform and revenue potential:
  - VAT rates reduced from five (0, 7, 10, 14, and 20 percent) to three (0, 10 and 20 percent) over the next three years.
  - Actual VAT revenues were around 8 percent of GDP in 2022; staff estimates Morocco’s VAT (annual) potential at close to 12 percent of GDP.
- Uncollected tax stocks (end-2022 estimates):
  - Direction General des Impots (DGI) end-2022 stock of uncollected tax revenues estimated at 100 billion dirhams (6.9 percent of GDP).
  - Administration des Douanes et des Impots Indirect (ADII) end-2022 stock estimated at 697 billion dirhams (48 percent of GDP), 97 percent of which are fines that would need to be reclassified as irrecoverable.
- Revenue from mobilization of central government real assets:
  - Generated 74.3 billion dirhams of revenues between 2019 and 2023.
  - Expected to generate 35 billion dirhams of revenues per year over the next three years.

### Fiscal policy recommendations (staff advice)
- Completing the VAT reform:
  - Gradually extend the standard rate of 20 percent to a broader range of goods and services (including fossil fuels) to improve VAT neutrality and reduce the estimated VAT tax gap.
- Further enhance tax administration:
  - Adopt a medium-term revenue strategy (MTRS) centered around a revenue target linked to planned fiscal consolidation.
  - Modernize revenue administration: digitalize and simplify tax procedures, adapt governance to digital functions, operationalize compliance risk management, merge regional large taxpayer units into a national one, enhance information systems and inter-agency collaboration, and use data analytics and risk-based approaches to prioritize audits and collections.
- Further rationalize current spending:
  - Possible measures include i) elimination of remaining subsidies on gas butane, ii) generalization of the RSU to all social programs, iii) continued progress in the digitalization of the public administration, and iv) implementation of SOE reform to reduce capital and current transfers to SOEs.
- Reinforce the Medium-Term Fiscal Framework (MTFF) and fiscal transparency:
  - Improve MTFF by adding drivers of fiscal balance changes, costs (dirham and share of GDP) of all new policy measures, and quantitative assessments of fiscal risks related to state guarantees, SOEs and climate-related fiscal risks.
- Assessing and monitoring PPP fiscal implications:
  - Strengthen institutional capacity to evaluate, monitor and transparently report budget implications of PPPs, including coordination improvements, setting a global annual envelope for new PPPs, and adding an annex listing projects and updating stock and potential fiscal risks.
- Provide more details on financements innovants:
  - Add details in the MTFF on assets expected to be sold and terms of sales to add credibility to revenue projections.

### Authorities’ stance on fiscal reforms
- Authorities plan to eliminate progressively gas butane subsidies and better link budget appropriation to the RSU starting from the next Budget Law.
- Action plan to recover tax credits based on modernization of information systems; legislation being finalized to allow electronic notifications and automatic sharing of data with third parties.
- Commitment to strengthen the MTFF, including introducing a new fiscal rule based on a medium-term fiscal anchor.
- Mobilization of real government assets: assets currently in Organismes de Placement Collectif Immobilier owned by institutional investors (CMR and CDG); authorities envisage opening them to private investors to develop domestic capital market.

### Monetary policy
- Current stance:
  - BAM pausing its tightening cycle since March 2023 is justified given fall of inflation and inflation expectations.
- Inflation outlook and risks:
  - Staff expects inflation to gradually return to 2 percent, but upside risks remain from more persistent food price pressures associated with water scarcity, removal of subsidies to agricultural and transport sectors, and projected rebound of domestic demand.
  - To help maintain price stability and supply of essentials, authorities introduced subsidies to the agricultural sector (mainly fertilizers and seeds) and to professionals in the transport sector, for about 0.4 percent of GDP in each of 2022 and 2023.
- Policy guidance:
  - Future policy changes should remain data-dependent.
  - As inflation falls, BAM should resume transition to an inflation targeting regime to cushion real external shocks, keep the exchange rate in line with fundamentals, strengthen transmission, and contribute to private sector development.
  - Authorities should prepare to remove the peg and subsequently phase out remaining limitations to capital outflows on Moroccan residents when ready.
- Authorities’ views:
  - Agreed monetary policy should remain data-dependent.
  - Noted need to re-tool macro forecasting models at BAM given recent rapid succession of shocks to support decisions under a new regime.

### Financial sector policy and resilience
- Regulatory and supervisory measures:
  - Implementation of Supervisory Review and Evaluation Process (SREP) expected to be gradually implemented by 2027.
  - Capital surcharges introduced for the three systemically important banks: Tier 1 capital ratio raised from 9 to 11 percent by 2025 at the latest.
  - BAM set to adopt a Net Stable Funding Ratio (NFSR) in 2024 and an Internal Liquidity Adequacy Assessment Process (ILAAP) under Basel Pillar 2.
- Non-performing loans and market measures:
  - Progress to develop a secondary market for NPLs; draft legislation expected to be sent to Parliament this year.
  - Reinforcement of banks resolution framework: new legislation being finalized to reinforce BAM's powers, distinguish recovery and resolution phases, and introduce a bail-in option.
- Greening the financial sector:
  - BAM working on guidelines for banks to gather data and report development and risk metrics related to large borrowers' exposures to climate risks; guidelines expected to be finalized by the end of 2024.
  - Ministry of Economy and Finance developing a comprehensive climate finance strategy with BAM and other regulators; a first draft set to be prepared by mid-2024.
- Authorities’ assessment:
  - Banking sector remains resilient; credit risk is main source of risk.
  - Anticipated deceleration in NPLs in next few years due to expected rebound in investment.
  - Concentration risk increased but remains well below levels of a decade ago and mitigated by a 20 percent equity limit on credit exposures to a single borrower.
  - Diversification to Sub-Saharan Africa seen as positive for profits with risks mitigated by strong provisioning.
  - Authorities working to better integrate climate risks into stress testing, particularly physical risks related to persistent water scarcity.

### Structural reforms for inclusive development and private-sector growth
- Private sector development and SOE reform:
  - Developing the private sector is necessary to boost job creation.
  - ANGPE has until 2026 to fully implement SOE sector reform; acceleration of approval of the state's shareholding policy is important.
  - State shareholder policy should identify sectors for state presence to promote diversification and productivity, and reduce presence where private firms can operate autonomously.
  - State shareholder policy should be consistent with initiatives to boost private investment (new Charter of Investment and Mohammed VI Fund).
- Support for SMEs and entrepreneurship:
  - To help SMEs access private equity and senior debt under the Mohammed VI Fund and investment subsidies under the new Charter, more efforts are needed to help them develop business plans and investment projects (including technology, marketing, and networking needs).
  - Many programs and agencies support entrepreneurship, but there is scope to consolidate and simplify through a more structured and integrated approach.

*International Monetary Fund — Morocco, selected sections from the provided content unit.*

### 24.      The development of the private sector also hinges on further efforts to strengthen

### 24.      The development of the private sector also hinges on further efforts to strengthen governance. This mainly requires stepping up the fight against corruption and anti-competitive practices.

### Anti-competitive practices — recent enforcement and planned actions
- Merger notification filings have doubled in the last 3 years.
- Competition Council actions:
  - Increased enforcement in both merger control and investigations of anti-competitive practices.
  - Higher volume of penalties to sanction predatory and anti-competitive practices.
  - 2023 modification of competition legislation to:
    - simplify the merger regulation framework,
    - clarify the criteria for determining penalties,
    - introduce a procedure allowing a reduction in the financial penalty for companies that accept settlements.
  - Resulted in a fine of 1.84 billion dirhams (about USD 200 million) on the largest 9 oil distributor companies.
  - Published a first sectoral study (on data centers) with plans to publish further sectoral studies (a study on the automotive sector is expected to be released in 2024).
  - Plans to publish a series of Opinions assessing the presence of anti-competitive practices in key sectors (such as food product distribution and the provisions of private health care, education and financial services) and include recommendations to remove them.

### Anti-corruption framework and recommended reforms
- Law 46-19 (approved in 2021) expanded powers of the National Authority for Probity, Prevention and the Fight Against Corruption (INPPLC).
- 2023 public procurement legislation seeks to strengthen transparency and tackle corruption and conflicts of interest.
- Recommended priority reforms to accelerate effective anti-corruption enforcement:
  - i) reform of the penal code and the penal procedural code to ensure effective law enforcement and appropriate sanctions,
  - ii) resubmission of a bill on illicit enrichment,
  - iii) introduction of whistleblower legislation,
  - iv) introduction of legislation on the conflict of interest,
  - v) reinforcement of the asset declaration law currently being amended.

### Labor market, social safety net, and active labor market policies (ALMP)
- Structural reforms take time to boost job creation; short-run measures:
  - Expand the social safety net and improve ALMPs.
- Unemployment insurance reform:
  - Reform announced by the authorities in 2021; contours remain to be detailed.
  - Consideration: extend for a limited period the unemployment benefit to all workers (formal and informal) losing a job, with a low enough RSU scoring and conditional on participation in up/re-skilling programs.
- ALMP challenges and reform needs:
  - Multiple active employment programs deployed over past two decades; impact remains limited.
  - Need for a more integrated ALMP strategy to better coordinate national and local players and target specific labor market requirements and structural transformation.
- Contextual statistic:
  - Over the past decade, the rate of NEET (not in education, employment, or training) has remained at about 29 percent.

### Gender and female labor force participation
- Female labor force participation remains extremely low despite reforms over the last decade:
  - Constitutional and family code reforms, an annex to the Budget on gender impact, gender quota in Parliament and boards of listed companies.
- Policy measures:
  - New Charter of Investment includes greater subsidy to private investment that involves female employment.
  - New Model of Development proposes measures including incentives for childcare facilities within firms, laws on paternity leave and wage parity, and subsidized access for women to transport services.
- Recommendation:
  - Strengthen the institutional framework behind Morocco’s gender policy, including by establishing an agency to coordinate gender-related measures and evaluate and monitor progress.
- Authorities’ view: coordination of gender policies is ensured by a committee (National Committee for Gender Equality and the Advancement of Women) established in June 2022, chaired by the Head of Government.

### Healthcare insurance (AMO) rollout, formalization, and implementation issues
- Objective: incentivize formalization of non-wage (informal) workers by inducing small contributions in exchange for inclusion into AMO.
- Take-up so far:
  - Only about 13 percent of the non-salaried workers who have been registered to participate to the new scheme has begun to regularly contribute in 2023, with the vast majority of those working in the agriculture and small artisans still excluded.
- Suggested measures to boost take-up:
  - Allow workers with irregular or seasonal employment to contribute only at certain periods of the year.
  - Condition access to all forms of public support to contribution to AMO.
  - Avoid excluding non-salaried workers from free healthcare even if their RSU scoring is below the threshold as this may disincentivize formalization.
  - Consider allowing all those with an RSU scoring below the threshold to access free health care independently of work status, and ask those with an RSU scoring above the threshold to contribute according to their scoring.
- Authorities’ view: confident that more self-employed and non-salaried workers will start contributing regularly over time; legislation being prepared to link all forms of public supports to payment of contributions and to allow banks to enforce such payment. Priority is to stabilize the new system.

### Health system reform measures supported by staff
- Reforms to improve quality and financial sustainability of new health care insurance system include:
  - i) updating the national reference pricing system through a new national agreement with health care providers and the pharmaceutical industry,
  - ii) linking remunerations of healthcare professionals to their productivity and allowing them to work in both public and private sectors,
  - iii) integrating health information systems across medical facilities and creating a national identity card for patients that include their medical history,
  - iv) upgrading medical facilities by building three new university hospitals and twelve new medical centers,
  - v) removing legal barriers to investment into health care sector to attract foreign companies,
  - vi) creating new territorial health groups to develop regional health care plans,
  - vii) setting a new High Health Authority to develop standards and regulatory tools to ensure quality care and financial sustainability.

### Education reform progress and monitoring needs
- 2023 achievements:
  - Enrollment rate in preschool education reached 90 percent (objective: 100 percent in 2028).
  - More than 600 “pioneer” schools operational using new teaching methods; objective to increase to 2,600 at the start of the next school year, covering 30 percent of students (from 8 percent during the first year).
  - Launch of a new training program for future primary and secondary school teachers.
- Key requirement:
  - Set up an efficient national evaluation system to regularly monitor and assess reform results and propose adjustments.
- Authorities’ view: results of “pioneer” schools will be assessed by the Ministry of Education and independent institutions like the Superior Council of Education and a private foundation.

### Authorities’ overall views on reform implementation
- Authorities emphasize commitment to reforms for stronger and more inclusive growth; pace reflects inherent complexities and an inclusive step-by-step approach.
- Private sector development: consolidating programs to help SMEs and improve efficiency.
- ALMP: mid-term review of national employment strategy 2015-2025 led authorities to start an overhaul to consolidate training and hiring programs.
- INPPLC: strengthened capacities by hiring qualified investigative staff and developing better cooperation framework with other national authorities.
- Family code reform planned for 2024 to further reduce legal gender disparities.

### Climate change, water scarcity, and energy strategy
- Water infrastructure and financing:
  - Programme National pour l’Approvisionnement en Eau Potable et l’Irrigation (PNAEPI) received an extra budget of 28 billion dirhams, taking the overall envelope to 143 billion.
  - New roadmap for construction of desalination plants announced for 2023-2027 to provide additional capacity of over 1 billion cubic meters of desalinated water per year.
  - Emergency program launched end-2023 acquired 20 desalination mobile stations.
  - Projects announced for construction of 6 additional large and mid-size dams.
  - Further investments envisaged under National Water Plan 2020-2050, still awaiting approval, for a total envelope of around 383 billion dirhams (about USD 40 billion).
- Water tariff reform:
  - Water tariffs kept artificially low and not aligned with cost recovery or resource value.
  - Two initiatives to prepare reform:
    - ongoing review of public expenditure in the water sector with World Bank contribution,
    - launch of a strategic study on the true cost of water by the Ministry of Water and Equipment (a reform measure of the RSF arrangement), expected to be concluded by early 2025.
- Climate goals and strategy:
  - Authorities committed to achieve net-zero GHG emissions by 2050.
  - 2023 Long-Term Low Carbon Strategy builds on Morocco’s 2021 NDC target of reducing GHG emissions by 45.5 percent by 2030.
  - Strategy envisages 96 percent of electricity generated from carbon-neutral sources by 2050 and complete elimination of coal-fired power generation by 2040 (coal now accounts for about 60 percent of overall electricity generation).
  - Strategy envisages scope to reduce energy consumption by 35 percent by 2050.
- Institutional governance for climate policy:
  - Need for a "whole of government" approach to align national and territorial policies, monitor progress, evaluate results, and make adjustments.
  - Strategy envisages extension of responsibilities of the National Commission on Climate Change and Biodiversity to steer and monitor the Strategy and calls for supporting the commission with needed tools.
- Electricity and water distribution reform:
  - 2023 legislation advances gradual introduction of regional multiservice companies (Sociétés Régionales Multiservices, SRM) in each of the 12 administrative regions to supply electricity and potable water and collect/treat wastewater.
  - SRMs expected initially to be 100 percent public with possibility to include private companies later.
  - Delegation contracts should define minimum service standards and allow self-producers and private producers of renewable energy to access electricity distribution networks.
- Authorities’ view: strategic study on cost of water started in November 2023; decision to power all desalination plants with renewable energy to help keep costs and water tariffs low. National energy strategy coordination ensured via National Commission for Sustainable Development chaired by the Head of Government.

### FCL qualification review — Morocco’s macro-financial position and qualifications
- Morocco continues to meet the FCL qualification criteria; no substantive changes in the nine qualification criteria since the FCL request in April 2023.
- Key assessments and data:
  - Sustainable external position: 2023 External Sector Assessment assessed external position in 2023 to be “moderately stronger” than implied by medium-term fundamentals and desirable policies.
  - External debt: at the end of 2022, external debt was about 50 percent of GDP and projected to stabilize at around that level in the medium term.
  - Capital account: private capital flows estimated to average about 55 percent of total flows between 2020 and 2023.
  - Sovereign access: successful USD 2.5 billion issuance on international markets in March 2023; public sector raised a total of US$9 billion in international markets over 2019-2023.
  - Reserves: As of December 2023, international reserves are estimated at 122 percent of the adjusted ARA metric, having averaged about 124 percent over 2021-2023. As percent of unadjusted ARA, international reserves were 95 percent on average over 2021-2023 and an estimated 94 percent in 2023.
  - Public debt: central government debt-to-GDP ratio still above 70 percent at the end of 2023; staff assesses public debt sustainable with high probability. The 2024 MTFF states authorities’ intention to reduce debt-to-GDP ratio to 68.5 percent in 2026 and to 65 percent by 2030.
  - Public debt composition mitigating factors:
    - about a quarter denominated in foreign currency,
    - more than three quarters held by domestic institutional investors,
    - average maturity about 6 years and 10 months as of mid-2023,
    - about 90 percent at fixed rates.
  - Inflation and monetary policy: average annual inflation remained in single digits between 2018 and 2023; BAM increased policy interest rates between September 2022 and March 2023.
  - Banking sector soundness:
    - As of June 2023, aggregate capital adequacy ratios: solvency ratio 15.8 percent, Tier 1 capital ratio 12.9 percent (regulatory minimums: 12 and 9 percent, respectively).
    - Liquidity buffers above regulatory requirement.
    - BAM stress tests (December 2023) showed banking system can withstand severe shocks.
  - Financial sector supervision and AML/CFT:
    - BAM progress on Basel III requirements and supervisory tools (ICAAP, IRRBB directive, risk rating redesign toward SREP-like approach).
    - Morocco exited the FATF grey list in February 2023.
    - Preparation of a draft law on crypto assets to better define these assets, increase investor protection, and regulate governance and operationalization (including forbidding their use as means of payment).
  - Data transparency:
    - Morocco subscribes to the Special Data Dissemination Standard (SDDS).
    - Morocco exceeds SDDS publication timeliness requirement for labor market data (employment and unemployment), the Consumer Price Index, and merchandise trade.

*Source: IMF staff report text.*

### 38.      Morocco continues to show very strong macroeconomic policies and institutional

### 1marea2024001 - 38.      Morocco continues to show very strong macroeconomic policies and institutional

### Macroeconomic policies and institutional frameworks
- Morocco’s commitment to macro stability and ability to respond to shocks were confirmed over the past year, as authorities steered the economy through the earthquake and water stress while implementing structural reforms.
- The quality of macroeconomic institutions pertinent to FCL qualification is described as very strong, though reform efforts need to continue, particularly regarding the fight against corruption and anticompetitive practices.
- World Governance Indicator data for 2022 shows no significant change in Morocco’s institutional strength relative to the time of approval of the FCL arrangement (when staff used 2021 data).
- Staff concludes that the severity of governance and corruption vulnerabilities do not hamper Morocco’s ability to respond to shocks at this stage.

### FCL arrangement status and key qualification indicators
- Morocco’s two-year arrangement under the FCL was approved on April 3, 2023, in the amount of SDR 3.7262 billion (About 417 percent of quota, or US$5 billion).
- Authorities intend to treat the FCL arrangement as precautionary and to gradually exit it, depending on the evolution of external risks.
- Staff estimates a level of external stress that remains significant (although lower than at the time of the FCL request). Considering climate change risks, authorities intend to maintain the current level of access at this review.
- Selected qualification indicators (as reported at request and mid-term review):
  - Capital account position dominated by private flows: 52 percent → 55 percent
  - Track record of steady sovereign access to international capital markets: 549 percent → 765 percent (cumulative international bond issuance during last 5 years as percent of quota)
  - Comfortable reserve position: Reserves averaged 133 percent of the adjusted ARA metric for period 2020-2022, never below 80 percent in any of those three years → Reserves averaged 124 percent of the adjusted ARA metric for period 2021-2023, never below 80 percent in any of those three years
  - Sound public finances: Debt is sustainable with high probability → Debt is sustainable with high probability
  - Low and stable inflation: Average inflation was at single digit for each year between 2018 and 2022 → Average inflation was 6.1 percent in 2023
  - Financial sector soundness: Tier 1 capital ratio stood at 11.8 percent, no significant solvency risks, or recapitalization needs → Tier 1 capital ratio stood at 12.9 percent, no significant solvency risks, or recapitalization needs
  - Effective financial supervision: No substantial concern in supervisory framework → No substantial concern in supervisory framework
  - Data transparency: SDDS subscriber → SDDS subscriber

### RSF arrangement: reform measures and implementation
- Four of the five reform measures scheduled for this review have been implemented:
  - RM3: January 2024 — ANRE published national electricity system’s capacity to receive electricity from renewable sources for 2024–2028; February 2024 — ANRE published tariffs for the utilization of the national electricity transmission network and system service fees for 2024-2026. Intended effect: more transparent grid access costs and boost private production of solar and wind electricity.
  - RM11: February 2024 — ministerial decree detailing gradual removal of current subsidy on gas butane starting from April, in line with 2024 Budget Law and 2024-2026 MTFF.
  - RM12: Extension of cash transfers to families with income below a threshold began in December 2023; February 2024 — convention between Ministry of Economy and Finance and Ministry of Agriculture introduced subsidies for farmers replacing gas butane with solar pumps for irrigation. Convention specifics preserved in source: state subsidy to 30 percent of cost of purchasing and installing solar pumping kit, capped at 3,000 dirhams per irrigated hectare and 3,000 dirhams per Kilowatt peak installed, with a maximum of 30,000 dirhams per project; total budget envelope of 153 million dirham; targets total agricultural surface of 51,000 hectares.
  - RM13: February 2024 — Government Council approved draft decree modifying legislation on insurance against natural disasters by adding definition clause on catastrophic events and introducing an hourly limit for aggregation of damage within a single catastrophic event (enabling international reinsurers to better assess exposure).
- RM10 (planned gradual increase in VAT on fossil fuels) was postponed to the third review because of concerns about impact on the population amid still high inflation, subsidy reductions, and weak labor markets. Staff recommended postponement of gradual VAT increase to 2025 when inflation abates and social mitigation effects are clearer.
- Authorities proposed to bring forward RM7 (changes to legal framework for energy efficiency) to the second review given implementation progress; staff supports this proposal.

### Program modalities, Fund exposure, and financing
- Outstanding Fund credit is projected to peak at 4 percent of GDP or 10 percent of exports (of goods and services) in 2024 under the adverse scenario.
- Morocco’s current and prospective obligations to the Fund are broadly comparable to other GRA debtors: fluctuate around the median in percent of government revenue and exports while well below the median in percent of public external debt services.
- With postponement of RM10 to the third review:
  - Disbursement under the completion of first review falls from SDR 312.5 million (35 percent of quota) to SDR 250 million (28 percent of quota).
  - Considering authorities’ request to bring forward RM7 to the second review, disbursement under the second review would increase from SDR 250 million (28 percent of quota) to SDR 312.5 million (35 percent of quota); disbursement under the third review remains unchanged.
- RSF disbursement projections included in financing table: RSF disbursement 0.0 (2023), 0.8 (2024), 0.6 (2025) (Billions of U.S. dollars, unless otherwise specified).

### Risks to implementation and safeguards
- Risks to RSF implementation assessed as small despite delay in RM10; further geopolitical tensions and new terms-of-trade shocks could complicate transition to a more resilient and greener economy.
- These risks are moderated by Morocco’s very strong fundamentals, institutional policy frameworks, sustained track record of implementing very strong policies, and commitment to maintain such policies.
- Safeguards procedures for the 2023 FCL arrangement were completed with no significant issue identified: Deloitte Morocco issued an unmodified (clean) audit opinion on BAM’s financial statements for 2022, published in a timely manner; staff reviewed audit results and held discussions with the external auditor with no significant issues emerging.

### Staff appraisal, growth outlook, and policy recommendations
- 2023 performance:
  - Economic activity picked up to 3 percent in 2023, supported by strong tourism and automotive exports and rebound of domestic demand despite water scarcity, the September 2023 earthquake, and challenging external conditions.
  - The 2023 ESA assessed the external position in 2023 to be “moderately stronger” than the level implied by medium-term fundamentals and desirable policies.
- Growth and external outlook:
  - GDP growth is expected to gradually pick up to 3½ percent over the next few years, assuming stabilization of agricultural production and continued structural reforms.
  - Current account deficit is projected to widen toward its estimated norm of 3 percent of GDP.
  - Risks are tilted to the downside (further droughts, worsening geopolitical tensions); faster implementation of structural reforms poses upside risks.
- Monetary policy:
  - Sharp fall of inflation in 2023 suggests current monetary policy stance is appropriate; BAM paused interest rate tightening in June after three increases from September 2022.
  - Staff expects inflation to keep falling but notes upside risks from persistent food price pressures; future policy changes should remain data dependent.
  - As inflation declines, BAM should resume transition toward an inflation-targeting regime and remove the exchange rate peg.
- Financial sector and climate finance:
  - Authorities are strengthening supervision and regulation, including capital surcharges for domestically systemically important banks, secondary market for NPLs, and resolution framework.
  - Progress on guidelines for gathering data on climate change-related risks for banks and preparation of a national green financial strategy to estimate funding needs of Morocco’s green transition.
- Fiscal policy and structural reform priorities:
  - The 2024 Budget aims to rebuild fiscal buffers and finance structural reforms; fiscal deficit should gradually decline to 3.3 percent of GDP in 2026 on rationalization of spending.
  - Reallocation of expenditure from subsidies to targeted cash transfers and investments in health, education, water, and energy.
  - Additional measures suggested to ensure and possibly accelerate public debt reduction: complete VAT reform, expand tax base through better revenue administration, continue reducing butane subsidies, fully link social programs to the RSU.
  - Increase transparency and market confidence by reporting PPPs and mobilization of government real assets and their budgetary implications and risks in the MTFF.
  - Structural reform recommendations: accelerate SOE reform, operationalize the Mohammed VI Fund and new Charter of Investment, rationalize policies supporting entrepreneurship, continue progress against anticompetitive practices and corruption, generalize social protection system, reform health care and education sectors, reduce gender inequality in labor markets, reduce water scarcity via infrastructure and demand management (including tariff revision), and continue electricity market liberalization to tap renewable energy potential.
- Overall staff view and recommendation:
  - Morocco continues to meet the qualifications criteria for the FCL arrangement, with very strong macroeconomic policies, institutional policy frameworks, and economic fundamentals.
  - Staff recommends completion of the review under the FCL arrangement.
  - RSF arrangement progress is positive: four of five measures implemented; RM10 postponed to third review; proposal to bring RM7 forward to second review is supported by staff.

*International Monetary Fund — Morocco: 2024 mid-term review summary (extracted content).*

### 52.      The next Article IV consultation with Morocco is expected to be conducted on the

### 1marea2024001 - 52.      The next Article IV consultation with Morocco is expected to be conducted on the

### Article IV consultation timing
- The next Article IV consultation with Morocco is expected to be conducted on the standard 12-month cycle.

### RSF reviews timeline and Board dates
- FCL Mid-Term Review Board Date: March 2024
- RSF Approval Board Date: November 2024
- RSF 1st Review Board Date: March 2025
- RSF review availability dates noted: "All the availability dates are on 15th of each month."

### Pillars and selected reform measures (RM) — status highlights
- Pillar 1: Tackling Water Scarcity
  - RM1: The Ministry of Water and Equipment will:
    - submit to the Inter-Ministerial Water Commission a study that assesses the actual cost of water and presents principle of cost recovery that could inform a tariff-setting methodology based on international benchmarks.
    - adopt two ministerial decrees for the implementation of the Water Law (36-15) to reinforce protection of groundwater resources (the decree on the protection and prohibition perimeters; and the decree on immediate, close, or distant protection perimeters).
  - Availability Date: 25-Feb
  - Review: 3

- Pillar 2: Reforming Morocco’s Electricity Market
  - RM2: ANRE will approve the proposal presented by ONEE on the unbundling of its transmission financial accounts.
    - Availability Date: 25-Feb
    - Review: 3
  - RM3: ANRE will publish the tariffs for the utilization of the national electricity transmission network and the system service fees (by Oct 2023) and the capacity of the grid to receive electricity from renewable sources.
    - Availability Date: 24-Feb
    - Review: 1
    - Status: Implemented.
  - RM4: ANRE will publish the tariffs for the access of RE producers to the medium voltage electricity distribution network.
    - Availability Date: 25-Feb
    - Review: 3
  - RM5: The Ministry of Energy Transition and Sustainable Development will adopt gradually ministerial decrees for the implementation of legislation that regulates the electricity sector (law 48-15, 40-19, and 82-21) (in addition to the two decrees envisaged under the EU Energy Verte program).
    - Availability Date: 24-Sep
    - Review: 2
  - RM6: ANRE will approve and publish i) quality indicators to be met by the national transmission grid in terms of safety, reliability, and efficiency, to be updated regularly, and ii) the code of good conduct for the Transmission System Operator (TSO).
    - Availability Date: 24-Sep
    - Review: 2

- Pillar 3: Improving Energy Efficiency
  - RM7: The Ministry of Energy Transition and Sustainable Development will complete the legal framework for energy efficiency by:
    - i) adopting ministerial decrees specifying the labeling and minimum efficiency standards for a series of products;
    - ii) preparing a similar ministerial decree on lighting products;
    - iii) adopting the draft ministerial decree on ESCO (Energy Service Companies);
    - iv) prepare a study and regulatory texts on lowering the threshold of energy consumption associated with the obligatory audit.
  - Availability Date: 24-Sep
  - Review: 2
  - Administrative note: Proposed to be moved to 2nd review from 3rd review.

- Pillar 4: Integrating Climate into Fiscal Planning and Transfer System
  - RM8: The Ministry of Economy and Finance will publish on a regular basis, starting with the Document de programmation budgétaire triennale accompanying the 2025 Budget Law, an analysis of debt sustainability that will include the impact of climate change, with technical assistance from the Fund.
    - Availability Date: 25-Feb
    - Review: 3
  - RM9: The Ministry of Economy and Finance will produce and start adopting a design document for the introduction of a carbon tax, in line with the recommendations of International Financial Institutions, and in consultation with the Ministry of Energy Transition and Sustainable Development.
    - Availability Date: 25-Feb
    - Review: 3
  - RM10: The Ministry of Economy and Finance will introduce in the 2024 Budget Law a reform that gradually eliminates the existing brown tax expenditure by increasing the tax rate on polluting fuels products.
    - Availability Date: 24-Feb
    - Review: 1
    - Status: Not implemented. Expected to be implemented with delay in the context of the third review.

- Pillar 5: Strengthening Preparedness to Natural Disasters
  - RM11: The Ministry of Economy and Finance will issue a ministerial decree that gradually eliminates the subsidies on gas butane, starting from 2024.
    - Availability Date: 24-Feb
    - Review: 1
    - Status: Implemented.
  - RM12: The Ministry of Economy and Finance will mitigate the impact on the population from measure RM11 by expanding cash transfers under the new Unified Social Registry and helping farmers replace gas butane with solar pumps in small fields irrigation.
    - Availability Date: 24-Feb
    - Review: 1
    - Status: Implemented.
  - RM13: The Ministry of Economy and Finance will complete the legal framework for the coverage against the risks of natural disasters by amending the decree taken for the application of Law No. 110-14 establishing a regime for coverage of the consequences of catastrophic events.
    - Availability Date: 24-Feb
    - Review: 1
    - Status: Implemented.

- Pillar 6: Greening Morocco’s Financial System
  - RM14: The Ministry of Economy and Finance, BAM and the Capital Market and Insurance regulators will adopt and publish a National Climate Finance Strategy that estimates the funding potential to be mobilized to meet the country’s climate mitigation and adaptation targets and plans to close them, and that improve climate risk management in the financial sector.
    - Availability Date: 24-Sep
    - Review: 2
  - RM15: The Ministry of Economy and Finance will advance in greening the national support system for access to financing by implementing requirements for assessing the environmental impacts of funded projects exceeding a certain threshold.
    - Availability Date: 24-Sep
    - Review: 2
  - RM16: BAM will issue supervisory guidelines on disclosure and reporting for banks in relation to climate risks, based on the guidance issued by the International Sustainability Standards Board (ISSB) and issue specific guidance to banks on collecting and reporting large borrower exposures to major climate risks.
    - Availability Date: 25-Feb
    - Review: 3

### RSF reform measures — counts and availability
- Total number of RMs: 16
- Total access: 112% of quota = 1000 SDR (Million)
- Morocco's quota in millions of SDRs: 894.4

### Access and phasing under the RSF arrangement (per review and quota)
- Current Proposed
  - Review 1 (24-Feb): Number of RMs per Review: 5¹; Percent of Quota: 35%; Quota SDR (Million): 312.5
  - Review 2 (24-Sep): Number of RMs per Review: 4; Percent of Quota: 28%; Quota SDR (Million): 250
  - Review 3 (25-Feb): Number of RMs per Review: 7; Percent of Quota: 49%; Quota SDR (Million): 437.5
  - Total: 16 RMs; 112%; 1000
- Proposed (adjusted)
  - Review 1: 5¹; 35%; 312.5
  - Review 2: 5²; 35%; 312.5
  - Review 3: 6; 42%; 375
  - Total: 16; 112%; 1000

Notes included in source:
- 1. RM10 was initially scheduled for the 1st review but it is expected to be implemented with delay at the time of the 3rd review, thereby reducing the disbursements for the first RSF review by SDR 62.5 million. If RM10 is implemented in the context of the 3rd review, the disbursement of SDR 62.5 million will be made then.
- 2. RM7 is proposed to be moved to 2nd review from 3rd review.
- 3. All the availability dates are on 15th of each month.
- 4. Morocco's quota in millions of SDRs:   894.4

### Schedule of disbursements and RMs availability dates under the RSF (per-RM disbursements)
- Each listed RM corresponds to 6.99% of Quota = 62.5 SDR (Million)
- RM availability and status specifics (selected entries with exact dates and status from the schedule):
  - RM1 Availability Date: February-25; Percent of Quota: 6.99%; SDR (Million): 62.5; Status Condition: Completion of RSF review of reform measures 1 implementation
  - RM2 Availability Date: February-25; Percent of Quota: 6.99%; SDR (Million): 62.5; Status Condition: Completion of RSF review of reform measures 2 implementation
  - RM3 Availability Date: February-24; Percent of Quota: 6.99%; SDR (Million): 62.5; Status: Implemented; Status Condition: Completion of RSF review of reform measures 3 implementation
  - RM4 Availability Date: February-25; Percent of Quota: 6.99%; SDR (Million): 62.5; Status Condition: Completion of RSF review of reform measures 4 implementation
  - RM5 Availability Date: September-24; Percent of Quota: 6.99%; SDR (Million): 62.5; Status Condition: Completion of RSF review of reform measures 5 implementation
  - RM6 Availability Date: September-24; Percent of Quota: 6.99%; SDR (Million): 62.5; Status Condition: Completion of RSF review of reform measures 6 implementation
  - RM7 Availability Date: September-24; Percent of Quota: 6.99%; SDR (Million): 62.5; Administrative note: Proposed to be moved to 2nd review from 3rd review; Status Condition: Completion of RSF review of reform measures 7 implementation
  - RM8 Availability Date: February-25; Percent of Quota: 6.99%; SDR (Million): 62.5; Status Condition: Completion of RSF review of reform measures 8 implementation
  - RM9 Availability Date: February-25; Percent of Quota: 6.99%; SDR (Million): 62.5; Status Condition: Completion of RSF review of reform measures 9 implementation
  - RM10 Availability Date: February-24; Percent of Quota: 6.99%; SDR (Million): 62.5; Status: Not Implemented. Delayed; Status Condition: Completion of RSF review of reform measures 10 implementation
  - RM11 Availability Date: February-24; Percent of Quota: 6.99%; SDR (Million): 62.5; Status: Implemented; Status Condition: Completion of RSF review of reform measures 11 implementation
  - RM12 Availability Date: February-24; Percent of Quota: 6.99%; SDR (Million): 62.5; Status: Implemented; Status Condition: Completion of RSF review of reform measures 12 implementation
  - RM13 Availability Date: February-24; Percent of Quota: 6.99%; SDR (Million): 62.5; Status: Implemented; Status Condition: Completion of RSF review of reform measures 13 implementation
  - RM14 Availability Date: September-24; Percent of Quota: 6.99%; SDR (Million): 62.5; Status Condition: Completion of RSF review of reform measures 14 implementation
  - RM15 Availability Date: September-24; Percent of Quota: 6.99%; SDR (Million): 62.5; Status Condition: Completion of RSF review of reform measures 15 implementation
  - RM16 Availability Date: February-25; Percent of Quota: 6.99%; SDR (Million): 62.5; Status Condition: Completion of RSF review of reform measures 16 implementation
- Total: 112% of Quota = 1000 SDR (Million)

*Source: IMF staff.*

### 2. All the availability dates are on 15th of each month.

### 1marea2024001 - 2. All the availability dates are on 15th of each month.

### Real sector developments
- Real GDP growth accelerated to about 3 percent in 2023.
- Growth drivers in 2023:
  - Solid growth in services sector.
  - Modest rebound of agricultural sector from 2022.
  - Rebound in domestic demand, particularly investment.
- Real disposable income increased in 2023 due to lower inflation and fiscal support.
- Sentiment:
  - Business sentiment improved since the pandemic lows.
  - Household confidence remains weak.
- Time series indicator shown: Real GDP Growth (Percentage change, y-o-y, seasonally adjusted) covering 2018-Q1 through 2023-Q3.

### External developments
- Trade and external flows in 2023:
  - Trade balance improved in 2023 as import growth fell more than export growth.
  - Lower commodity prices reduced imports of energy, raw, food, and intermediate products.
  - Export growth strong for automobiles and electronics; phosphate exports declined.
  - Tourism revenues were much stronger than last year and unaffected by the earthquake.
  - Remittances continued to increase.
  - Net FDI was weak in 2023.

### Fiscal developments
- Fiscal outcomes and composition:
  - Fiscal deficit in December closed at 4.4 percent of GDP, better than projected in the 2023 budget.
  - “Other non-fiscal revenues” soared, due to the earthquake fund.
  - Subsidies were less expensive than in 2022.
  - Capital spending accelerated (also due to weak levels last year).
  - Authorities continued to remove the fiscal stimulus injected in 2020-2021.
  - Government debt is expected to fall very gradually.
  - Sovereign spreads compressed in 2023 and continued to fall in 2024.
- Selected fiscal aggregates (Table 6 and Table 7b, percent of GDP unless otherwise noted):
  - Budget balance: -3.6 (2019), -7.1 (2020), -6.0 (2021), -5.4 (2022), -4.4 (2023), -4.3 (2024), -3.8 (2025), -3.2 (2026), -3.1 (2027), -3.1 (2028), -3.0 (2029).
  - Revenue: 23.8 (2019), 27.0 (2020), 25.3 (2021), 28.7 (2022), 28.5 (2023), 28.2 (2024), 27.5 (2025), 26.9 (2026), 26.6 (2027), 26.5 (2028), 26.3 (2029).
  - Expenditure: 27.4 (2019), 31.4 (2020), 31.3 (2021), 34.1 (2022), 33.0 (2023), 32.5 (2024), 31.2 (2025), 30.1 (2026), 29.7 (2027), 29.5 (2028), 29.3 (2029).
  - Central government debt: 60.3 (2019), 72.2 (2020), 69.5 (2021), 71.6 (2022), 70.6 (2023), 70.4 (2024), 69.4 (2025), 68.2 (2026), 67.5 (2027), 66.8 (2028), 66.1 (2029).

### Monetary and financial developments
- Policy and exchange rate:
  - Bank Al-Maghrib (BAM) kept its policy rate unchanged since March 2023.
  - The dirham appreciated towards the middle of the band in 2023.
- Credit and banking sector:
  - Growth of credit to the private sector slowed in 2023, mainly due to a sharp fall of short-term (working capital) lending to private non-financial firms.
  - Nonperforming loans (NPLs) for non-financial firms increased slightly in 2023.
  - Banks’ holdings of Treasuries have fallen as a share of assets in 2023 but remain above pre-pandemic levels.
- Inflation expectations and policy rate snapshot (Q4-23): series for two-year ahead, three-year-ahead, and policy rate shown (percent).
- Financial soundness indicators highlights (selected values):
  - Regulatory capital to risk-weighted assets: 15.6 (Dec 2023).
  - Tier 1 capital to risk-weighted assets: 12.9 (Dec 2023).
  - Nonperforming Loans (NPLs) to total loans: 8.4 (Dec 2023).
  - Specific provisions to NPLs: 68.9 (Dec 2023).
  - Return on assets (ROA): 1.1 (Dec 2022 / Dec 2023 indicated as NA for 2023 in table).
  - Liquid assets to total assets: 14.6 (Dec 2023).
  - Deposits to loans: 104.8 (Dec 2023).

### Macroeconomic projections and key indicators (selected values from Tables 6, 8)
- Output and prices:
  - Real GDP: 2.9 (2019), -7.2 (2020), 8.0 (2021), 1.3 (2022), 3.0 (2023), 3.1 (2024), 3.3 (2025), 3.4 (2026), 3.4 (2027), 3.4 (2028), 3.4 (2029).
  - Consumer prices (end of period): 1.1 (2019), -0.3 (2020), 3.2 (2021), 8.3 (2022), 3.4 (2023), 2.5 (2024), 2.2 (2025), 2.3 (2026), 2.2 (2027), 2.1 (2028), 2.0 (2029).
  - Unemployment rate (end of period): 9.2 (2019), 11.9 (2020), 12.3 (2021), 11.8 (2022), 13.0 (2023), 12.0 (2024), 11.5 (2025), 11.0 (2026), 10.5 (2027), 10.5 (2028), 10.5 (2029).
- External sector (Table 8, billions of U.S. dollars unless indicated):
  - Current account: -4.4 (2019), -1.4 (2020), -3.3 (2021), -4.6 (2022), -2.0 (2023), -3.8 (2024), -4.5 (2025), -4.8 (2026), -5.2 (2027), -5.7 (2028), -6.0 (2029).
  - Trade balance: -19.8 (2019), -15.5 (2020), -20.0 (2021), -26.5 (2022), -25.2 (2023), -27.5 (2024), -29.3 (2025), -30.7 (2026), -32.0 (2027), -33.5 (2028), -34.2 (2029).
  - Exports: 24.7 (2019), 23.6 (2020), 31.7 (2021), 36.5 (2022), 36.2 (2023), 37.4 (2024), 39.1 (2025), 41.1 (2026), 43.0 (2027), 44.7 (2028), 46.9 (2029).
  - Imports: -44.5 (2019), -39.1 (2020), -51.7 (2021), -63.0 (2022), -61.4 (2023), -65.0 (2024), -68.5 (2025), -71.8 (2026), -74.9 (2027), -78.2 (2028), -81.1 (2029).
  - Tourism receipts (billions USD): 8.2 (2019), 3.8 (2020), 3.8 (2021), 9.2 (2022), 10.3 (2023), 11.2 (2024), 12.0 (2025), 13.0 (2026), 13.8 (2027), 14.5 (2028), 15.2 (2029).
  - Workers' remittances (billions USD): 6.8 (2019), 7.2 (2020), 10.4 (2021), 10.9 (2022), 11.4 (2023), 11.5 (2024), 11.7 (2025), 12.0 (2026), 12.2 (2027), 12.4 (2028), 12.7 (2029).
  - Gross reserves (in billions of U.S. dollars): 26.4 (2019), 36.0 (2020), 35.6 (2021), 32.3 (2022), 36.3 (2023), 38.2 (2024), 40.0 (2025), 42.0 (2026), 44.0 (2027), 45.9 (2028), 47.8 (2029).
  - In months of next year imports of goods and services: 6.9 (2019), 7.2 (2020), 5.8 (2021), 5.3 (2022), 5.6 (2023), 5.6 (2024), 5.6 (2025), 5.7 (2026), 5.7 (2027), 5.7 (2028), 6.8 (2029).

### IMF Fund credit and capacity-to-repay indicators (Adverse scenario)
- Table 11a: Assumed adverse scenario where the FCL is drawn in 2024.
- Existing and prospective Fund credit (SDR million) — disbursements listing (abridged presentation from table):
  - RSF disbursements and GRA/FCL components shown with initial disbursements: 4,289 (total disbursements row start), GRA (PLL) 3,726, RSF 563.
- Stock of existing and prospective Fund credit (SDR million), selected years:
  - 2024: 4,826
  - 2025: 4,726
  - 2026: 4,726
  - 2027: 3,329
  - 2028: 1,466
  - 2029: 1,000 and maintained at 1,000 for multiple subsequent years through 2033 in table.
- Obligations (SDR million) and principal repayments (SDR million), selected years:
  - Obligations: 1,026 (2024), 827 (2025), 282 (2026), 1,674 (2027), 2,022 (2028).
  - Principal (repayments/repurchases): 807 (2024), 538 (2025), 0 (2026), 1,397 (2027), 1,863 (2028).
- Charges and interest (SDR million), selected years:
  - 219.23 (2024), 289.45 (2025), 282.08 (2026), 277.15 (2027), 159.26 (2028), 63.63 (2029).
- Fund obligations (repurchases and charges) in percent of quota, GDP, exports, reserves, and government revenue (selected entries):
  - Percent of Quota: 114.7 (2024), 92.5 (2025), 31.5 (2026), 187.2 (2027), 226.1 (2028), 59.2 (2029).
  - Percent of GDP: 0.9 (2024), 0.7 (2025), 0.2 (2026), 1.2 (2027), 1.4 (2028), 0.4 (2029).
  - Percent of Gross international reserves: 3.6 (2024), 2.8 (2025), 0.9 (2026), 5.1 (2027), 5.9 (2028), 1.5 (2029).
  - Percent of Government revenue: 3.2 (2024), 2.5 (2025), 0.8 (2026), 4.6 (2027), 5.4 (2028), 1.3 (2029).
- Fund credit outstanding in percent of quota and GDP (selected entries):
  - In percent of Quota: 540 (2024), 528 (2025), 528 (2026), 372 (2027), 164 (2028), 112 (2029).
  - Memorandum: Quota (SDR million) = 894.4.

*Source: IMF staff calculations and tables in the supplied PDF content.*

### Annex I. External Economic Stress Index

### Annex I. External Economic Stress Index

### Background
- The External Economic Stress Index (EESI) is a composite indicator of vulnerability related to external shocks.
- Construction is based on: (i) key external risks facing Morocco, (ii) proxy variables capturing these risks, and (iii) the choice of weights to apply to each variable.

### External risks (drivers)
- Main external risks are based on the October 2023 World Economic Outlook (WEO) adverse scenario and include:
  - An economic downturn in advanced economies, particularly Morocco’s main trading partners (i.e., euro area countries), leading to a decline in exports, FDIs, tourism, and remittances.
  - Rising commodity prices, particularly of food and energy, fueling inflation and deteriorating domestic demand and the trade balance.
  - A tightening of global financial conditions that would negatively affect the volume and cost of external financing.

### Proxy variables used in the index
- Decline in exports, remittances, FDIs, and tourism receipts from Europe is proxied by the decline of GDP growth in the euro area (Morocco’s main trading partner, accounting for more than 50 percent of trade, FDIs, and remittances).
- Rise in commodity imports is proxied by an increase in global oil prices.
- Impact of tighter external financing conditions is proxied by the change in the US 10-year Treasury yield.

### Index construction and weights
- The index is calculated as the weighted sum of standardized deviations of each of these three variables from their means.
- Standardized weights:
  - Euro area growth: 0.69
  - Change in global oil prices: 0.23
  - Change in the US 10-year Treasury yield: 0.08
- These weights correspond to the impact of shocks on each variable on the Moroccan economy, estimated using the IMF’s Flexible System of Global Models (FSGM).

### Baseline scenario and projection
- Baseline inputs:
  - Eurozone growth and oil prices: October 2023 WEO projections.
  - Change in the US 10-year Treasury yield: consistent with the GAS assumptions, as of February 10, 2024.
- Projection result:
  - The EESI suggests that external economic stress would decrease slightly over 2024-2025 compared to last year. This reflects projections of a slightly better euro area growth outlook and lower oil prices in this period.

### Downside (tail-risk) scenario
- Assumptions relative to baseline:
  - GDP growth in advanced economies (proxy for euro area) declines by an additional one percentage point deviation on top of the WEO October 2023 risk scenario, implying a decline of about 1.4 and 1.8 percentage points below the baseline in 2024 and 2025, respectively.
  - Oil prices are assumed to be 10 percent and 5 percent higher than the baseline in 2024 and 2025, respectively.
  - The US 10-year Treasury yield is assumed to increase by two standard deviations above the baseline, to reflect heightened global uncertainty.
- Projected impact:
  - Under the downside scenario, external stress would increase in Morocco to a similar scale as experienced during the Eurozone sovereign debt crisis in 2012.
  - The index would rise less than experienced during the global financial crisis in 2009, but external pressures would persist for a much more extended period than after that episode.
  - The higher end of stress over the projection period would exceed by about twofold the levels observed at the approval of Morocco’s first PLL arrangement in August 2012.
  - Overall, the EESI indicates a level of stress which, although lower than at the time of the FCL request, remains significant.

### Key methodological and contextual notes
- Euro area is Morocco’s main trading partner, accounting for more than 50 percent of trade, FDIs, and remittances.
- Weights were estimated using the IMF’s Flexible System of Global Models (FSGM).
- Baseline relies on October 2023 WEO and GAS assumptions as of February 10, 2024.

*Source: IMF staff estimates and WEO projections as presented in Annex I. External Economic Stress Index.*

### 2.      The central government debt ratio has stabilized at around 70 percent of GDP since 2021

### 2.      The central government debt ratio has stabilized at around 70 percent of GDP since 2021

### Summary of recent developments
- Central government debt ratio stabilized at around 70 percent of GDP since 2021 after a large increase to 72.2 percent of GDP in 2020 due to the COVID crisis.
- Stabilization driven by progressive reduction in the primary fiscal deficit and high real GDP growth, with inflation also helping stabilize the ratio in 2022.
- Gross financing needs (GFN) for the central government increased to about 21 percent of GDP in 2023 after stabilizing to about 14 percent after the COVID crisis.

### Baseline projections
- Under the staff baseline scenario, public debt is expected to decline below 70 percent in the medium term.
- Central government debt-to-GDP ratio is expected to decline as fiscal consolidation continues, in line with the Medium-Term Fiscal Framework published as part of the 2023 Budget.
- At the general government level, public debt would hover around 65 percent of GDP until 2025 before falling to 61 percent in 2029.
- Projected fiscal consolidation efforts over the medium term are regarded as realistic relative to peer countries and previous episodes of fiscal consolidation in Morocco (for example, during 2012-17).

### Financing dynamics and debt management
- Gross financing needs increased to 21.3 percent in 2023 as the Treasury temporarily resorted to short-term domestic financing to strengthen buffers during a high-uncertainty period early in the year.
- In 2023, more than 80 percent of debt issued was domestic, and about forty percent of the external debt was issued to bilateral and multilateral creditors.
- The projected effective interest rate on debt has been revised up relative to the 2022 AIV report due to higher domestic and international rates; the interest rate burden is now expected to increase by ¼ percent of GDP in 2025 but is expected to gradually decrease over the longer term.
- Mitigating factors buffering the cost of public debt include:
  - Long average maturities for domestic and external borrowing (average maturity increased by 2 months compared to last year and is now at 6.8 years in 2023).
  - Continued active debt management swapping old debt for new at more favorable terms (longer maturities and lower interest rates).
  - A significant share of external borrowing on a concessional basis.
  - Privatization receipts projected at about 0.3 percent of GDP in 2024-26 to help reduce financing needs.

### Sustainability assessment and risk profile
- The central government debt continues to be sustainable with high probability; overall risk of sovereign stress is assessed as moderate.
- Medium-term risk is assessed as moderate based on mechanical signals; GFN and fan chart tools are firmly in moderate territory.
- Debt profile features that limit vulnerabilities:
  - Relatively long maturity (weighted average maturity of about 7 years).
  - Relatively low share denominated in FX (about 25 percent).
  - Investment base mainly local investors, many long-term investors.
- Morocco has maintained steady access to international capital markets at favorable terms over the last 10 years and more recently after the COVID crisis.

### Shocks, contingent liabilities, and long-term vulnerabilities
- Debt fan chart index (measuring medium-term solvency risks) has a score equal to 1.7, which is moderate.
- Baseline debt trajectory and fan are on a stable or slightly downward trend by the end of the period; probability of debt not stabilizing is assessed to be limited.
- Gross financing needs also resume a downward path or stabilize in the stress scenario.
- Key shocks and vulnerabilities that could affect the assessment:
  - More frequent droughts.
  - A global economic downturn.
  - New negative terms-of-trade shocks.
- Contingent liabilities that could represent additional vulnerabilities:
  - Unfunded public pension schemes.
  - Guarantees to commercial SOEs’ external debt (about 8 percent of GDP).
  - Subsidized credit schemes under the Covid-19 crisis (about 3 percent of GDP).
- The transmission of guarantees to a financial institution under BAM supervision—which will absorb the first layer of losses from potential activation of guarantees—represents a mitigating factor.
- Long-term vulnerabilities related to climate change and the sustainability of public pension and health care systems amid accelerated demographic transition.
- Recommendation to accelerate fiscal consolidation, reinforce the budgetary framework, and boost implementation of crucial structural reforms to reduce the debt-to-GDP ratio over the medium and longer term.

### Policy recommendations and planned reforms
- Reinforce the Medium-Term Fiscal Framework (MTFF).
- Analyze budget risks and strengthen the analysis of the sustainability of the debt.
- Implement a fiscal rule anchored on public debt.
- Continue active debt management and pursue privatization receipts as projected.
- Implement comprehensive reforms in the pension and health care systems to make them financially sustainable.
- Ongoing and future comprehensive reforms in the water or energy sectors to reduce climate-related vulnerabilities.

### Selected key statistics and projections (as reported)
- Central government debt: stabilized around 70 percent of GDP since 2021; 72.2 percent of GDP in 2020.
- Gross financing needs: about 21 percent of GDP in 2023 (21.3 percent in 2023 cited elsewhere).
- Share of debt issued domestically in 2023: more than 80 percent.
- Share of external debt issued to bilateral and multilateral creditors in 2023: about forty percent.
- Average maturity of debt in 2023: 6.8 years (increase of 2 months from prior year).
- Privatization receipts projected: about 0.3 percent of GDP in 2024-26.
- External debt-related contingent exposures: guarantees to commercial SOEs’ external debt about 8 percent of GDP; subsidized credit schemes about 3 percent of GDP.
- Debt fan chart index score: 1.7 (moderate).

*Source: Fund staff.*

### Annex V. Figure 1. Morocco: External Debt Sustainability: Bound Tests

### Annex V. Figure 1. Morocco: External Debt Sustainability: Bound Tests

### Figure notes and scenario design
- Shaded areas represent actual data.
- Individual shocks are permanent one-half standard deviation shocks.
- Figures in the boxes represent average projections for the respective variables in the baseline and scenario being presented. Ten-year historical average for the variable is also shown.
- For historical scenarios, the historical averages are calculated over the ten-year period, and the information is used to project debt dynamics five years ahead.
- Permanent 1/4 standard deviation shocks applied to real interest rate, growth rate, and current account balance.
- One-time real depreciation of 30 percent occurs in 2023.
- Sources: IMF country desk data, and IMF staff estimates.

### Key scenario values reported in the figure
- Growth: Baseline: 3.3; Scenario: 1.3; Historical: 2.5
- Current account (Non-interest Current Account Shock, Percent of GDP): Baseline: -4.0; Scenario: -5.1; Historical: -4.6
- Growth shock (Percent per year): Baseline: -3.2; Scenario: -3.2; Historical: -2.4
- Real depreciation shock: One-time real depreciation of 30 percent occurs in 2023
- Gross financing need under baseline (right scale) shown in figure (values presented graphically in the source)

### Macroeconomic developments and outlook (from Letter of Intent)
- Growth and inflation:
  - Economic growth rebound in 2023 to about 3 percent, after slowdown to 1.3 percent in 2022.
  - Inflation peaked at 10.1 percent in February 2023; eased to 3.4 percent in December 2023.
  - Average inflation in 2023: 6.1 percent; 2022: 6.6 percent.
  - Inflation decelerated to 2.3 percent in January 2024.
  - Bank Al-Maghrib raised its key rate by 150 basis points between September 2022 and March 2023; key rate kept unchanged at 3 percent at subsequent Board meetings.
  - Future policy changes to remain data-dependent; BAM committed to decisions to ensure rapid return of inflation to levels compatible with price stability.

- External sector and reserves:
  - Current account deficit expected not to have exceeded 1.5 percent of GDP in 2023, compared with 3.5 percent in 2022.
  - Foreign exchange reserves strengthened in 2023 to reach a comfortable level of over 5.5 months of imports, exceeding 120 percent of the adjusted ARA metric.
  - Exchange rate reform ongoing since 2018; dirham remains in the fluctuation band without BAM intervention and in line with fundamentals.

### Fiscal and financial sector outcomes and commitments
- Public finances:
  - Budget deficit reduced to 4.4 percent of GDP in 2023, an improvement of 1 point of GDP compared with 2022.
  - Treasury debt ratio: 70.9 percent of GDP at end-2023, compared with 71.6 percent in 2022.
  - Government reaffirms reduction of the budget deficit to 4 percent of GDP in 2024 and 3 percent in 2026.
  - Adoption of a three-year fiscal framework accompanying the Budget Law; draft amendment to the Organic Law related to the Finance Law to introduce a rule anchored on a medium-term debt target.
  - Measures to consolidate public finances include optimization of public spending, implementation of framework law on taxation, and recourse to non-debt-generating financing mechanisms with increased private sector participation.

- Financial sector resilience:
  - Moroccan banking system described as well-capitalized, profitable, and resilient.
  - BAM regularly stress-tests sector fundamentals and is integrating climate change effects in the climate finance strategy.
  - Progress on bank resolution framework; supervisory review and assessment process to be rolled out progressively until 2027.
  - Capital supplements introduced for the three systemically important banks.
  - In 2024, BAM expected to adopt a net stable funding ratio and an internal liquidity adequacy assessment process.

### Climate, water, and energy priorities, targets, and financing needs
- Climate commitments and financing:
  - Revised National Determined Contribution (NDC) target: reduce greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions by 45.5 percent by 2030.
  - Estimated financing needed to meet NDC ambitions: USD 78.8 billion.
  - RSF arrangement intended to help implement energy and climate strategies and complement financing from other donors.

- Water sector:
  - Draft National Water Plan (PNE) envisages major investments for 2020-2050 to bridge supply-demand gap.
  - National Program for Drinking Water Supply and Irrigation 2020-2027 (PNAEPI) estimated cost: USD14 billion.
  - Target for seawater desalination using renewable energies: 1 billion m3 by 2030.
  - November 2023: Ministry of Equipment and Water launched strategic study on the cost of water (RM1, February 2025) to identify true cost (CAPEX-OPEX) and propose pricing and cost recovery reforms.
  - Two decrees implementing Law 36-15 on water to be adopted (RM1, February 2025): procedural rules for safeguard/prohibition perimeters and criteria/procedures for protection perimeters.

- Energy sector:
  - National Energy Strategy 2009-2030 target: reach 52 percent of installed renewable energy capacity by 2030.
  - 2023-2027 Electricity Equipment Plan: convert oil-fired gas turbines at Kenitra and Mohammedia to natural gas by 2027.
  - Reinforcement of transmission network to bring large quantities of wind power: 3,000 MW over 1,600 km.
  - Development of green hydrogen through preparation of a "Moroccan offer" covering the entire value chain.

### RSF reform measures and sequencing
- RSF reform measures aim to:
  - Preserve water resources and develop them at the right price.
  - Overhaul the electricity sector to increase the share of renewable energies and reduce dependence on fossil fuels.
  - Channel private investment toward climate-friendly activities, by greening the financial system and aligning it with sustainable development objectives.
  - Strengthen systems of coverage against natural disasters.
- Implementation status:
  - First series of reform measures completed by mid-February 2024, except RM10 (increase in taxation of polluting petroleum products) postponed to next year.
  - RM7 (changes to legal framework for energy efficiency) proposed to be brought forward to the second review given implementation progress.

### Program and policy stance toward IMF instruments
- The government considers the Flexible Credit Line (FCL) well suited for Morocco as a precautionary device against extreme risks and severe balance-of-payments shocks.
- Morocco intends to treat the FCL arrangement as precautionary while continuing to strengthen fiscal and external buffers and diversify the economy to enable eventual exit from the FCL once exogenous risks decline significantly.
- Authorities commit to consult the IMF prior to any revision of reform measures in the MEFP and to provide information on progress in implementation.

*Source: Annex V. Figure 1 and accompanying Letter of Intent and Attachment I from the provided IMF content unit.*

### 7. To achieve the objectives set by the energy strategy and attract more private investment, the

### 7. To achieve the objectives set by the energy strategy and attract more private investment, the government is committed to continue the in-depth restructuring of the electricity market, notably through:

### Electricity market restructuring and distribution reform
- Separation of ONEE's generation, transmission, and distribution activities; creation of a national Transmission System Operator as stipulated by Law 48.15 on electricity sector regulation, supported by the WB and the European Union (EU).
  - ANRE will begin by examining and approving the proposal put forward by ONEE for the separation of its transmission-related financial accounts (RM2, February 2025).
- Reform of the distribution sector via creation of Sociétés Régionales Multiservices (SRM) with exclusive rights to distribute electricity, drinking water, and liquid sanitation.
  - Objectives: optimize investment, reduce operating costs via territorial continuity and pooling of resources and infrastructure; secure supply of drinking water and electricity; save water and energy; meet climate change and sustainable development challenges.
  - Law 83.21 on creation of SRMs adopted on July 13, 2023.
  - Implementing decrees for Article 2 (list of regions concerned) and Article 14 (transfer of assets belonging to ONEE) adopted by the Government Council on February 1, 2024.
  - Progressive implementation: four SRMs for Casablanca-Settat, Marrakech-Safi, Souss-Massa, and Oriental regions to be set up in 2024.
- Strong private sector involvement in electricity generation through continuation of regulatory process for setting service tariffs (essential for investor commitment).
  - ANRE (created in 2021; Laws no. 82-21 and no. 40-19) published in February 2024:
    - tariff for the use of the national electricity transmission network and the tariff for system services for the period 2024-2026;
    - national electricity system's renewable energy hosting capacity for the period 2024-2028 (RM3, February 2024).
  - ANRE will publish tariff(s) for access to the medium-voltage electricity distribution network by renewable energy producers (RM4, February 2025).
- Implementation of electricity sector legislation (Laws 48-15, 40-19, and 82-21) via gradual adoption of regulatory texts, with at least one decree in addition to the two planned for 2024 under the program with the EU (RM5, February 2025).
- Effective implementation of new provisions in Law 48-15:
  - ANRE approval and publication of quality indicators for the national transmission system (safety, reliability, efficiency) to be updated regularly (Art 12 of Law 48.15).
  - Publication of the Transmission System Operator's code of conduct (Art 13 of Law 48.15) (RM6, September 2024).

### Energy efficiency and related regulatory measures
- National ambition: improve energy efficiency by 20 percent by 2030.
- Completion of legislative framework relating to energy efficiency (Law 47-09) through adoption of ministerial decrees specifying labeling and minimum energy efficiency standards for:
  - electric motors,
  - air conditioners,
  - refrigerators.
  - These products and standards identified based on impact studies and preliminary analyses by MTEDD.
- Similar order to be prepared for lighting products following the same procedure.
- Draft decree on energy service companies (ESCOs) to be adopted, providing framework and promoting energy performance contracts to address financing difficulties for energy efficiency investment.
- Preliminary studies and legal texts on lowering the energy consumption threshold for mandatory audit are being drawn up to increase proportion of entities subject to audits (RM7, February 2025).
  - Given good progress, expected completion date proposed to be brought forward from February 2025 to September 2024.

### Public finance, climate risk, and budget tagging
- MEF will publish annually, starting with the three-year budget programming document accompanying the 2025 Budget Law and with IMF technical assistance, a debt sustainability analysis that integrates the impact of climate change (RM8, February 2025).
- Climate Budget Tagging being set up with support from the WB and AFD to better identify, assess, and monitor climate-related public programs and expenditures, optimize resources, and determine financing required to achieve climate objectives.

### Carbon pricing and environmental taxation
- Government committed to developing and progressively adopting a roadmap for introduction of a carbon tax (RM9, February 2025).
  - Roadmap will analyze current situation (inventory and assessment of effectiveness of existing environmental tax measures) and identify prerequisites for adoption, scope (could concern the 5 sectors covered by the European Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism, CBAM), generating event, and tax level.
  - Work supported by WB using international best practices, simulations and modeling of macroeconomic and microeconomic impacts.
- Existing environmental tax reforms and incentives:
  - exemption for electric and hybrid vehicles from proportional stamp duty on first registration and the special annual vehicle tax (TSAV);
  - reduced VAT rate (10 percent) for photovoltaic panels and solar water heaters;
  - introduction of a consumption tax on energy-consuming equipment.
- Fuel subsidy reforms:
  - Morocco began eliminating fuel subsidies in 2013, except gas butane which is planned to be phased out gradually.
  - In February 2024, MEF amended decree no. 1242-16 to ratify increase in butane gas prices over next three years starting in May 2024 (RM11, February 2024).
  - Measure envisaging gradual increase of VAT rate on petroleum products (RM10, scheduled for February 2024) postponed to the next Budget Law (2025).
  - Accompanying mitigation measures: extension of cash transfers under the new Unified Social Register (action began in December 2023) and support for farmers to replace butane with solar pumps via agreement between MEF and Ministry of Agriculture (RM12, February 2024).

### Tariff policy and trade measures
- MEF will prepare and approve a list to distinguish climate-friendly products from polluting ones in the WCO Harmonized System (HS) and introduce climate-sensitive tariff policy changes into the Finance Act based on this list.
  - Aim: adapt tariff policy to environmental objectives to promote or discourage cross-border circulation of products according to environmental impact.
  - Government will ensure proposed tariff adjustments comply with WTO rules.

### Disaster risk coverage and insurance framework
- Two-pronged coverage scheme established in 2020:
  - insurance component covering bodily injury and insured property;
  - allocation component via Fonds de solidarité contre les événements catastrophiques (FSEC) guaranteeing uninsured individuals minimum compensation for catastrophic events.
- February 2024 Government Council approved draft amendment to decree no. 2-18-785 of April 29, 2019, application of Law no. 110-14 instituting coverage against catastrophic events, presented by MEF (RM13, February 2024).
  - Amendment defines time clause for catastrophic events by type, aligned with international best practice, improving conditions for transferring risk to international reinsurance market.

### Green finance, financial sector greening, and mobilizing private climate finance
- Background: COP22 (Marrakech, 2016) spurred a process to green the financial system; MEF, BAM, AMMC, ACAPS, and others agreed on a climate finance roadmap.
- BAM actions and supervisory framework:
  - BAM included climate change in its missions to ensure banking sector robustness to climate risks, promote green finance, and reduce environmental footprint.
  - Publication in 2021 of a directive on management of financial risks linked to climate change and environment, drawing on NGFS and TCFD recommendations.
  - Memorandum in 2022 between BAM, GPBM, and EBRD to converge Moroccan banks' climate risk management practices with 2021 regulatory directives and international best practices.
  - With WB support, BAM finalized first climate risk assessment exercise for Moroccan banking sector in 2022.
- Concrete measures committed to accelerate private sector financing of green transition:
  - Introduction of a National Climate Finance Strategy to estimate potential financing mobilizable by financial sector for mitigation and adaptation objectives and improve climate risk management (RM14, September 2024).
    - Scoping workshop held in January 2024 with MEF, BAM, AMMC, ACAPS and WB; steering committee established; roundtable with IMF to explore options for attracting private financing for climate programs.
  - Introduction of a national green financial taxonomy with WB support, coordinated by MEF and financial regulators (BAM, AMMC, ACAPS); framework note prepared defining milestones for preparation and implementation.
  - Definition of framework for sovereign green bond issuances with WB support, potentially facilitating international issuance if conditions are met.
  - Gradual introduction by MEF, through TAMWILCOM, of requirements to assess environmental impacts of investment projects benefiting from State credit guarantees and exceeding a threshold; technical modalities to be discussed among MEF, TAMWILCOM, and others to define assessment criteria (RM15, September 2024).
    - Expected demonstration effect: encourage banks to integrate environmental dimension into decision-making and companies to assess environmental impact; enable State to catalyze greening of financial sector.
  - Publication by BAM, by the end of February 2025, of supervisory guidelines on climate risk disclosure and reporting for banks, based on ISSB guidelines, and bank-specific guidelines on collection and reporting of large borrowers' exposures to key climate risks (RM16).
    - This will complement measures in place or being implemented with donor support.

*Source: IMF chapter content (1marea2024001).*

### 16. An inter-ministerial committee, comprising representatives of all stakeholders, has been set

### 1marea2024001 - 16. An inter-ministerial committee, comprising representatives of all stakeholders, has been set up by MEF to coordinate and monitor the implementation of the reform measures under the RSF arrangement.

### Inter-ministerial coordination
- An inter-ministerial committee, comprising representatives of all stakeholders, has been set up by MEF to coordinate and monitor the implementation of the reform measures under the RSF arrangement.

### Reform measures under the RSF arrangement (selected items, availability dates, reviews, implementation status)
- RM 1
  - Measure: Ministry of Water and Equipment to submit to the Inter-Ministerial Water Commission a study assessing the actual cost of water and present principle of cost recovery to inform a tariff-setting methodology based on international benchmarks; adopt two ministerial decrees for implementation of the Water Law (36-15) reinforcing protection of groundwater resources (decree on protection and prohibition perimeters; decree on immediate, close, or distant protection perimeters).
  - Availability Date: 25-Feb
  - Review: 3
- RM 2
  - Measure: ANRE will approve the proposal presented by ONEE on the unbundling of its transmission financial accounts.
  - Availability Date: 25-Feb
  - Review: 3
- RM 3
  - Measure: ANRE will publish the tariffs for the utilization of the national electricity transmission network and the system service fees (by Oct 2023) and the capacity of the grid to receive electricity from renewable sources.
  - Availability Date: 24-Feb
  - Review: 1
  - Implementation Status: Implemented
- RM 4
  - Measure: ANRE will publish the tariffs for the access of RE producers to the medium voltage electricity distribution network.
  - Availability Date: 25-Feb
  - Review: 3
- RM 5
  - Measure: Ministry of Energy Transition and Sustainable Development will adopt gradually ministerial decrees for implementation of legislation that regulates the electricity sector (laws 48-15, 40-19, and 82-21) (in addition to the two decrees envisaged under the EU Energy Verte program).
  - Availability Date: 24-Sep
  - Review: 2
- RM 6
  - Measure: ANRE will approve and publish i) quality indicators to be met by the national transmission grid in terms of safety, reliability, and efficiency, to be updated regularly, and ii) the code of good conduct for the Transmission System Operator.
  - Availability Date: 24-Sep
  - Review: 2
- RM 7
  - Measure: Ministry of Energy Transition and Sustainable Development will complete the legal framework for energy efficiency by i) adopting ministerial decrees specifying labeling and minimum efficiency standards for a series of products; ii) preparing a similar ministerial decree on lighting products; iii) adopting the draft ministerial decree on ESCO (Energy Service Companies); and iv) prepare a study and regulatory texts on lowering the threshold of energy consumption associated with the obligatory audit.
  - Availability Date: 24-Sep
  - Review: 2
  - Note: Proposed to be moved to 2nd review from 3rd review
- RM 8
  - Measure: Ministry of Economy and Finance will publish on a regular basis, starting with the Document de programmation budgétaire triennale accompanying the 2025 Budget Law, an analysis of debt sustainability that will include the impact of climate change, with technical assistance from the Fund.
  - Availability Date: 25-Feb
  - Review: 3
- RM 9
  - Measure: Ministry of Economy and Finance will produce and start adopting a design document for the introduction of a carbon tax, in line with the recommendations of International Financial Institutions, and in consultation with the Ministry of Energy Transition and Sustainable Development.
  - Availability Date: 25-Feb
  - Review: 3
- RM 10
  - Measure: Ministry of Economy and Finance will introduce in the 2024 Budget Law a reform that gradually eliminates the existing brown tax expenditure by increasing the tax rate on polluting fuels products.
  - Availability Date: 24-Feb
  - Review: 1
  - Implementation Status: Not implemented. Expected to be implemented with delay in the context of the third review.
- RM 11
  - Measure: Ministry of Economy and Finance will issue a ministerial decree that gradually eliminates the subsidies on gas butane, starting from 2024.
  - Availability Date: 24-Feb
  - Review: 1
  - Implementation Status: Implemented
- RM 12
  - Measure: Ministry of Economy and Finance will mitigate the impact on the population from measure RM11 by expanding cash transfers under the new Unified Social Registry and helping farmers replace gas butane with solar pumps in small fields irrigation.
  - Availability Date: 24-Feb
  - Review: 1
  - Implementation Status: Implemented
- RM 13
  - Measure: Ministry of Economy and Finance will complete the legal framework for the coverage against the risks of natural disasters by amending the decree taken for the application of Law No. 110-14 establishing a regime for coverage of the consequences of catastrophic events.
  - Availability Date: 24-Feb
  - Review: 1
  - Implementation Status: Implemented
- RM 14
  - Measure: Ministry of Economy and Finance, BAM, and the Capital Market and Insurance regulators will adopt and publish a National Climate Finance Strategy that estimates the funding potential to be mobilized to meet the country’s climate mitigation and adaptation targets and plans to close them, and that improve climate risk management in the financial sector.
  - Availability Date: 24-Sep
  - Review: 2
- RM 15
  - Measure: Ministry of Economy and Finance will advance in greening the national support system for access to financing by implementing requirements for assessing the environmental impacts of funded projects exceeding a certain threshold.
  - Availability Date: 24-Sep
  - Review: 2
- RM 16
  - Measure: BAM will issue supervisory guidelines on disclosure and reporting for banks in relation to climate risks, based on the guidance issued by the International Sustainability Standards Board (ISSB) and issue specific guidance to banks on collecting and reporting large borrower exposures to major climate risks.
  - Availability Date: 25-Feb
  - Review: 3

### Key macro-financial figures and institutional arrangements (as reported)
- IMF-related financial positions and arrangements
  - Quota: 894.401 SDR Million = 100.00 percent
  - IMF's Holdings of Currency (Holdings Rate): 2,244.99 SDR Million = 251.01 percent
  - Reserve Tranche Position: 150.08 SDR Million = 16.78 percent
  - Net cumulative allocation (SDR Department): 1,418.66 SDR Million = 100.00 percent
  - Holdings (SDR Department): 1,465.32 SDR Million = 103.29 percent
  - Precautionary and Liquidity Line outstanding purchases and loans: 1,499.80 SDR Million = 167.69 percent
- Latest financial commitments (Arrangements)
  - FCL: Type FCL, Date Approved Apr 03, 2023, Date of Expiration Apr 02, 2025, Amount Approved 3,726.20 (SDR Million), Amount Drawn 0.00 (SDR Million)
  - RSF: Type RSF, Date Approved Sep 28, 2023, Date of Expiration Apr 02, 2025, Amount Approved 1,000.00 (SDR Million), Amount Drawn 0.00 (SDR Million)
  - PLL: Type PLL, Date Approved Dec 17, 2018, Date of Expiration Apr 07, 2020, Amount Approved 2,150.80 (SDR Million), Amount Drawn 2,150.80 (SDR Million)
- Overdue obligations and projected payments to Fund (SDR Million; based on existing use of resources and present holdings of SDRs)
  - Principal forthcoming: 962.10 537.70
  - Charges/Interest forthcoming: 56.85 8.43 0.02 0.02 0.02
  - Total forthcoming: 1,018.95 546.13 0.02 0.02 0.02
- Exchange rate and exchange regime
  - Dirham fluctuation band broadened to ±5 percent on March 6, 2020 (from ±2.5 percent) on either side of a reference parity, based on a Euro/US dollar basket with respective weights of 60 and 40 percent.
  - As of February 1, 2024, the USD/dirham exchange rate was USD 1=DH 10.006.
- Statistical and surveillance notes
  - Morocco compiles annual and quarterly GDP; base year for constant price estimates is 2014.
  - CPI weight reference period is 2017.
  - Morocco has been an SDDS subscriber since December 2005.
- Selected growth and labor market indicators (from Statement by Mr. El Qorchi)
  - Growth in 2023 rebounded to 3 percent, from 1.3 percent in 2022.
  - Unemployment has risen to 13 percent—compared with an average pre-COVID of 9.4 percent.
  - Growth is expected to accelerate in 2024. 

*Source: STAFF REPORT FOR THE 2024 ARTICLE IV CONSULTATION, REVIEW UNDER THE FLEXIBLE CREDIT LINE ARRANGEMENT, FIRST REVIEW UNDER THE RESILIENCE AND SUSTAINABILITY ARRANGEMENT, AND REPHASING OF ACCESS UNDER THE RESILIENCE AND SUSTAINABILITY FACILITY—INFORMATIONAL ANNEX, March 11, 2024.*

### 3.7 percent owing to the impact of investment and the generalization of social protection.

### 1marea2024001 - 3.7 percent owing to the impact of investment and the generalization of social protection.

### Macroeconomic performance and outlook
- Growth projection headline: "3.7 percent owing to the impact of investment and the generalization of social protection."
- Inflation trajectory:
  - Peak of 10.1 percent in February 2023.
  - Fell to 3.4 percent in December and 2.3 percent in January 2024.
  - Inflation expectations have followed a similar downward trend since the third quarter of 2023.

### Monetary policy and financial sector resilience
- Bank Al-Maghrib (BAM) actions:
  - Conducted a data-dependent monetary policy leading to three consecutive hikes of its policy interest for a cumulative 150 bps between September 2022 and March 2023.
  - Maintained its policy rate at 3 percent since March 2023 in a context of abating inflation.
- Banking system:
  - Described as resilient, profitable, and well-capitalized.
  - Supervision anchored on risk-based framework and best international standards.
  - BAM conducts regular stress tests and is integrating climate change effects into a comprehensive climate finance strategy.
  - Strengthening bank resolution framework and introduced capital surcharges for systemically important banks, raising their Tier 1 capital ratio from 9 to 11 percent before 2025.
- BAM preparing guidelines for banks to gather data and report development and risks metrics about large borrowers’ exposers to climate risks.

### External sector and exchange rate
- 2023 external performance:
  - Current account deficit improved significantly owing to a reduced trade deficit, stronger exports services mainly from tourism and sustained remittances.
  - International reserves exceeded 5.5 months of goods and services imports and represented more than 120 percent of the adjusted ARA metric.
  - The dirham continued to move within the fluctuation band without BAM intervention and its value remains in line with economic fundamentals.

### Fiscal outcomes, debt, and reconstruction spending
- Fiscal balances and debt:
  - Overall fiscal deficit decreased in 2023 by about 1 percent from 2022 to reach 4.4 percent of GDP.
  - Central government debt reduced to 70.9 percent of GDP from 71.6 percent in 2022.
  - General government debt was at 65 percent of GDP in 2023.
  - Central government’s debt is assessed as sustainable with high probability and the overall risk of sovereign stress is assessed to be moderate.
- Fiscal policy priorities and commitments:
  - Government adopted a three-year fiscal framework accompanying the Budget Law.
  - Fiscal targets: bring the fiscal deficit to 4 percent of GDP in 2024 and 3 percent in 2026.
- Earthquake reconstruction:
  - Authorities announced a reconstruction plan amounting to about 8 percent of GDP over a 5-year period for rebuilding villages and infrastructure and improving living conditions in affected regions.
  - About half of the financing is expected to be raised through domestic resources.
- Fiscal performance drivers:
  - Improvement in fiscal revenues coupled with continued investment programs and exceptional expenditures to support activity, household purchasing power, and urgent needs of earthquake victims.

### Structural reforms and social protection
- Social protection expansion:
  - Generalization of the social protection system started in 2021.
  - Extension of mandatory basic health insurance (AMO) became operational by the end of 2022.
  - At the end of 2023, about 10 million people were registered in the Unified Social Registry (RSU).
  - In addition to the 10 million people already included in the compulsory basic health insurance, it is expected that 22 additional million people will eventually be covered with the same healthcare services.
  - Extension of family allowance started in December 2023; extension of the pension system and the existing unemployment benefit scheme envisaged by 2025.
  - RSU used to validate transfers from free healthcare to the new mandatory health insurance and will serve as an integrated information system to optimize public spending and steer social programs and budgetary decisions.
- Education and labor:
  - Ongoing education sector reform with a new phase announced linking remuneration to continuous formation and performance for teachers.
- SOE reform and private investment:
  - New agency for restructuring SOEs began elaboration of the state shareholder policy.
  - Private investment to be bolstered by implementation of the New Investment Charter and operationalization of the Mohammed VI Fund for investment.
- Business environment, governance, and judiciary:
  - New decree on public procurement enacted in September 2023 to improve procurement management and promote investment.
  - Competition Council increasing enforcement against anti-competitive practices; number of cases reviewed and sanctions imposed have increased.
  - National Authority for Probity, Prevention, and the Fight Against Corruption is strengthening capacity by hiring investigative staff and enhancing cooperation frameworks.
  - Modernization of the Judiciary system with focus on digital transformation of administrative procedures.

### Climate, energy, and water policies
- Climate commitments and targets:
  - Authorities committed to achieving net-zero GHG emission by 2050.
  - Strategy aims at reducing GHG emissions by 45.5 percent by 2030 and envisages a gradual reduction in the use of fossil fuels.
- Adaptation and mitigation measures:
  - Legislative, regulatory, and institutional reforms launched to lower carbon economy, enhance energy security, and improve management and protection of water resources.
  - Major electricity sector reform to increase the share of renewable energies and reduce dependence on fossil fuels while mobilizing private investment toward climate-friendly activities.
- Water security actions:
  - Investment projects for new dams, water basins interconnection projects, and desalination plants completed or being finalized.
  - Policies targeting improved demand management for saving and reusing water.

### IMF arrangements, reviews, and conditionality
- Flexible Credit Line (FCL):
  - Morocco continues to demonstrate a sustained track record of implementing very strong policies and meet the nine qualification criteria.
  - FCL serves as a precautionary buffer; Morocco treats the FCL arrangement as precautionary and may exit once exogenous risks have subsided significantly.
- Resilience and Sustainability Facility (RSF) first review:
  - Of 5 reform measures, 4 implemented and the fifth proposed to be postponed to the third review.
  - Authorities propose to bring forward one measure to the second review given implementation progress.
  - Postponement of reform measure 10 (increasing VAT on fossil fuels) predicated on concern about adverse impact on most vulnerable population amid higher cost of living and subsidy reductions.
- Sectoral climate-related measures:
  - Multiple measures implemented across agriculture, industry, services, administration, and fiscal operations to align policy with climate change and green growth objectives.

### Key policy recommendations and priorities (implied by authorities’ actions)
- Reinforce credibility and transparency of fiscal policy through multi-year frameworks and fiscal targets (4 percent of GDP in 2024; 3 percent in 2026).
- Continue prioritizing investment and social protection generalization to support growth and reduce informality.
- Continue banking sector reforms: integrate climate risk, strengthen resolution frameworks, and implement capital surcharge requirements (Tier 1 ratio from 9 to 11 percent before 2025).
- Advance SOE restructuring, implement the New Investment Charter, and operationalize the Mohammed VI Fund to boost private investment.
- Maintain FCL as a precautionary buffer while pursuing reforms and reducing exogenous risks to enable eventual exit.
- Prioritize targeted sequencing of fiscal measures sensitive to vulnerable populations (illustrated by postponement of VAT increase on fossil fuels).

*1marea2024001 - 3.7 percent owing to the impact of investment and the generalization of social protection.*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/cr/2024/english/1marea2024001.pdf_
