## 1. Evolution of Social Spending and Public Investment Since 2014, and Comparative SDG Performance

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [1. Evolution of Social Spending and Public Investment Since 2014, and Comparative SDG Performance](https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/cr/2025/english/1gtmea2025002-source-pdf.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/files/publications/cr/2025/english/1gtmea2025002-source-pdf.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/files/publications/cr/2025/english/1gtmea2025002-source-pdf.pdf.json)

---

### Overview and motivation
- Guatemala faces persistent social and infrastructure gaps with one of the lowest public spending levels among developing economies: combined spending on education, health, and social assistance remained below 6 percent of GDP in 2024, and capital spending reached just 2.4 percent of GDP.
- Low spending has limited the state’s capacity to expand service coverage, improve quality, and reduce long-standing disparities in secondary school attendance, maternal and child health, and access to water and sanitation.
- The paper provides a diagnostic of spending adequacy and efficiency in education, health, social assistance, and infrastructure, and assesses institutional and PFM constraints that hinder planning, execution and evaluation of public resources.

### Macro-fiscal context
- General government expenditure stood at just 14.6 percent of GDP in 2024, while revenues were barely above 12 percent.
- Fiscal space is constrained, with little prospect of tax reform and rigidities that limit reallocations within the budget.
- Despite prudent macro management and maintained debt sustainability, fragmented politics has limited approval of structural reforms.
- The new administration aims to use buffers to increase investment in human and physical capital, prioritizing infrastructure in the 2025 budget and seeking gradual increases in education, health, and social protection without undermining fiscal sustainability.

### Efficiency frontiers and strategic implications
- Efficiency frontier analyses show Guatemala falls significantly below the efficiency frontier in health, education, social assistance and infrastructure, underperforming in healthy life expectancy, years of schooling, poverty reduction, and infrastructure access.
- Underperformance reflects that modest spending levels are far from technically achievable results rather than necessarily wasteful spending.
- Analysis explores how gradual spending increases through 2029 or 2032 could move outcomes closer to the efficiency frontier (examples: greater investment in secondary schooling and quality improvements in education; strengthening primary care and prevention in health).
- Use of frontiers intended to inform a medium-term strategy within the medium-term fiscal framework (MTFP, or MFMP in Guatemala).

### Data and methodological notes
- Spending numbers for 2024 are based on data provided by the authorities; previous years from IMF GFS-COFOG.
- Latest outcome data used: 2022 for average years of schooling, 2023 for life expectancy, 2023 for estimated poverty reduction, and 2017 for infrastructure index.
- Physical infrastructure indicator combines economic infrastructure (length of road network, electricity production, access to water) and social infrastructure (number of secondary teachers and hospital beds).

### Key aggregate figures (preserved exactly)
- Combined spending on education, health, and social assistance: below 6 percent of GDP (2024).
- Capital spending: 2.4 percent of GDP (2024).
- General government expenditure: 14.6 percent of GDP (2024).
- Revenues: barely above 12 percent of GDP (2024).
- Public spending on education: between 3.0 and 3.5 percent of GDP (over past decade).
- Health spending: between 2 and 2.5 percent of GDP.
- Social assistance: around 0.5 percent of GDP (except COVID-19 uptick where it tripled).
- Public investment average: 2.4 percent of GDP.
- Overlap between public investment and public spending on health and education: between 5 and 10% of public investment corresponds to health and education infrastructure.
- Estimated 1.7 million secondary school–aged adolescents remain outside the education system.

### Government priorities and stated policies
- General Government Policy (PGG) 2024-28 core objectives: expansion of coverage and quality in education and health, reduction of chronic malnutrition, investments in rural infrastructure, and a more coherent approach to social protection.
- Priorities align with the National Development Plan (K’atun 2032) and SDG framework.
- Government seeks improvements in planning and prioritization of infrastructure projects and stronger execution capacity at the local level, emphasizing results-based execution and tools to monitor public spending and institutionalize accountability.

### Sectoral adequacy and efficiency gaps — Education
- Education spending has hovered around 3 percent of GDP over two decades, well below international benchmarks and insufficient for meaningful gains in access or quality.
- Primary enrolment is near universal; secondary education shows little progress since 2010: net enrolment rates stagnating and dropout rates remaining high.
- Tertiary enrolment has tripled despite limited improvements in upper-secondary completion.
- Budget structure heavily concentrated in primary education; secondary education structurally underfunded.
- Less than 40 percent net enrolment in secondary education; fewer than one in three aged 15-18 continue to upper secondary.
- Public spending composition: tertiary absorbs a share equal to that of secondary, partly driven by a constitutional mandate that allocates at least 5 percent of ordinary revenues to the University of San Carlos.
- Distributional issues: public spending on secondary mostly benefits wealthier households; adolescents from rural, poor, and indigenous backgrounds are disproportionately excluded.
- National education strategy flagship actions: school construction and rehabilitation, expansion of early childhood care, nationwide maintenance program, creation of regional technical institutes.
- Cost-effective measures mentioned but not yet scaled: introducing secondary shifts in existing primary schools, subsidizing transportation; scholarship programs for secondary students remain modest.

### Sectoral adequacy and efficiency gaps — Health
- Health policy priorities: expand coverage through primary healthcare network (RISS), improve infrastructure and human resources, enhance access to essential medicines.
- Primary care allocations are difficult to track due to many executing units and overlapping activities.
- Recent increases in budget allocations for infrastructure investments in community health centers and hospitals.
- Strengthening composition of spending to staff and equip primary care centers and improving rural service delivery are critical to achieve SDG 3.
- Health outcomes and financing trends:
  - Increase in health expenditure largely driven by household direct spending (out-of-pocket) rather than government financing.
  - UHC index: 50 in 2005, 58 in 2010, 59 in latest available outcome data.

### Health outcomes and service delivery (additional findings)
- Life expectancy has risen since 2005 and is “currently at a level expected for its’ GDP per capita.”
- Share of births attended by skilled staff “has significantly increased since 2005,” but experienced “a temporary fall during the pandemic.”
- Stunting rates have seen only “modest decreases in the past 20 years.”
- Key outcome gaps:
  - UHC index remains below the regional average.
  - Healthy life expectancy “trails Central America and EMEs by 6-8 years.”
  - Maternal mortality is “30-50 percent above peer countries.”
  - “Nearly half of children under five are chronically malnourished.”
- Service delivery constraints:
  - Shortage of trained personnel; many rural health posts staffed by auxiliary nurses with limited training.
  - Advanced services concentrated in Guatemala City.
  - Cultural and logistical barriers: “more than one-third of births still occurring at home with comadronas.”
  - Deficiencies particularly acute in rural and indigenous communities.

### Health financing and budget composition
- Public general government health spending: “2.4 percent of GDP in 2022.”
- Regional and peer benchmarks: Central America average “4.2 percent”; EMEs “3.6 percent.”
- Private out-of-pocket spending: “4.9 percent of GDP.”
- Pharmaceuticals: highly concentrated market, high prices, uneven public availability; recent reforms (centralized procurement through MSPAS and farmacias populares (PROAM)) are at early stages and market concentration persists.
- Latest data note: “Latest available data are from 2022 for health expenditure, 2023 for life expectancy, 2021 for UHC Index and stunting rates, and 2017 for births attended by skilled staff.”
- 2025 MSPAS budget allocates “around one-fourth of resources to the Redes Integradas de Servicios de Salud (RISS).”
- Estimated PHC spending: “around 0.6 percent” of GDP (below WHO recommended “1 percent”).
- RISS territorial allocations (per capita):
  - Alta Verapaz: “162 Quetzales per capita.”
  - National average: “Q213 per capita.”
  - Santa Rosa: “Q444 per capita.”
- Hospitals absorb “over 40 percent of the health budget,” and one-third of that hospital budget goes “exclusively to the two large urban hospitals, Roosevelt and San Juan de Dios.”
- Policy implication: need to rebalance spending toward prevention, frontline services, and underserved regions to improve equity and cost-effectiveness.

### Social assistance: coverage, adequacy, and reforms
- Social assistance spending: “0.6 percent of GDP.”
- Comparators: spending is “roughly one-third of the LAC average and one-quarter of that of EMEs.”
- Impact and coverage:
  - Social assistance reduces poverty by “less than 5 percent in Guatemala,” versus “35–50 percent in peer countries.”
  - Only “2-4 percent” of the poorest households receive conditional cash transfers, compared to “10-20 percent in the region.”
- Program scale and recent developments:
  - Key programs: Bono Social (“Q500 monthly to poor households with children or prenatal needs”) and Bolsa Social (“Q250 monthly for food insecure households in Guatemala City”).
  - By mid-2024, CCT beneficiaries “more than doubled”; government target “500,000 by 2027.”
  - By mid-2024, over “200,000 households had been registered” in the Registro Social de Hogares (RSH); goal to reach “500,000 by 2027,” prioritizing “114 high-poverty municipalities.”
  - RSH supported inclusion of “24,000 new Bono Social beneficiaries.”
- Persistent coverage shortfalls (as of 2023):
  - Only “about 3 percent” of households received support from either Bono or Bolsa Social.
  - Departmental coverage ranged from “less than 1 percent” (Escuintla and Sacatepéquez) to “nearly 7 percent” (Chiquimula).
  - Coverage among poorest quintile: “3 percent”; richest quintile: “2 percent.”
  - Adulto Mayor pension reaches “just 16 percent of poor elderly.”
- Institutional constraints:
  - RSH lacks a formal legal framework and faces interoperability issues with RNB, RENAP, MSPAS databases.
  - Mano a Mano strategy seeks integration across seven vulnerability dimensions but needs clarification on territorial implementation.
  - Budget rigidity and operational fragmentation hinder scale-up.

### Infrastructure, public investment, and spatial disparities
- 2025 capital allocations increased “by over 50 percent from 2024 spending,” reaching “about 3.8 percent of GDP.”
- Historical averages and targets:
  - Public investment averaged “just 2.4 percent of GDP between 2022 and 2024.”
  - Projected to reach “3 percent by 2025-29.”
  - Estimated required level to maximize GDP growth and crowd in private investment: “5-6 percent of GDP.”
- Capital stock and service coverage:
  - Public capital stock amounts to “only 41 percent of GDP,” compared to “60 to 80 percent in similar countries.”
  - Drinking water and sanitation: sanitation reaches “just half the population,” below the “70 percent benchmark in similar economies.”
- Territorial disparities and budget execution:
  - Only “20 percent” of rural households access drainage networks.
  - 2024 execution: “only half of the transport budget and less than 20 percent of the energy budget were executed.”
  - Subnational execution rates ranged from “49 to 68 percent” across departments.
  - SEGEPLAN data: infrastructure projects add to “only around 0.6 percent of GDP” (while total capital spending amounts to “2.4 percent of GDP executed public investment”).

### Public investment planning, monitoring, and PFM weaknesses
- Planning gaps:
  - Absence of a prioritized, quantified list of projects in planning documents.
  - Weak multi-year fiscal framework limits clear envelopes for short- and medium-term investments.
  - Need for stronger dialogue between MINFIN, SEGEPLAN, and line ministries to ensure financial viability and alignment with priorities.
- Budget approval and project addition risks:
  - During legislative budget approval, new projects often introduced by Congress “without thorough examination or prioritization,” frequently outside SINIP, creating unfunded commitments.
  - Mid-year project additions by MICIVI complicate coherence of investment strategy.
- Monitoring and information system fragmentation:
  - Lack of coordination between SINIP, Guatecompras and SICOIN “severely hinders real-time project monitoring.”
  - SEGEPLAN’s role in monitoring, evaluation, reporting, and external communication is crucial but constrained by system fragmentation.

### Effectiveness of public expenditure, results-based budgeting, and evaluation
- Structural weaknesses in planning, execution, and evaluation constrain the impact of public investment and social spending.
- Q499 million added by Congress in 2023 represented 11 percent of the investment projects included in the budget bill presented by the Executive.
- Results-based budgeting adopted over a decade ago remains fragmented and disconnected from decision-making.
- Many institutions define annual output indicators and targets, but these are rarely linked to outcomes or used to assess progress toward PGG priority results indicators.
- Execution reports often focus on activity levels rather than whether spending contributes to closing service gaps.
- No institutionalized process to evaluate whether programs achieve intended outcomes; targets and indicators often lack baseline data, cost-effectiveness analysis, or mechanisms to track progress against coverage gaps.
- Monitoring system gaps: no linkage between budget execution and strategic PGG goals; under current framework, results monitoring is expected only at the end of the PGG period in 2029 with no intermediate assessments.
- Recent development: partnership signed with J-PAL to evaluate Mano a Mano.
- Policy recommendation: institutionalize ex-ante and ex-post evaluations, regular spending reviews, and a value-for-money function (possible lead: Directorate of Fiscal Policy Analysis, DAPF).

### Planning–budget linkages, budget rigidities and reallocations
- Allocations remain largely incremental and based on historical trends and input targets rather than coverage goals, cost structures, or performance indicators.
- Nutrition case: allocations to high-need municipalities under the child malnutrition program declined from 31 percent in 2019 to 11.5 percent in 2025.
- Medium-Term Fiscal Framework (MFMP) and multiannual budget processes are used largely procedurally; expenditure projections rely on baseline adjustments rather than rigorous costing of sectoral strategies.
- MINFIN estimates that 93 percent of the 2025 budget is considered “rigid”, tied to earmarked revenues, legal mandates, or pre-existing commitments such as public sector wages and pensions.
- The 2025 budget includes an extraordinary increase for local development councils (CODEDEs) of around 0.5 percent of GDP, in part accommodated by reallocating funds away from education, labor, and agriculture.
- Authorities note constitutionally mandated transfers make up only 11.8 percent of the approved budget.
- Recommendation: strengthen ex-ante controls and transparency around budget modifications and reduce discretionary reallocations.

### Reform momentum and implementation strategy
- Reforms underway include strengthening local public investment planning through CODEDEs, improving transparency and fiscal forecasting via MFMP revisions, and enhancing performance monitoring through results-based budgeting.
- Legal framework assigns SEGEPLAN roles for evaluation and MINFIN roles for budget integration; Article 35 of the Organic Law of the Executive assigns joint responsibilities for investment project policies.
- Recommended actions to achieve PGG and multiyear budget targets through 2029:
  - Updating baselines and reviewing/sequencing expected results for 2026–29.
  - Aligning results with realistic expenditure projections.
  - Clearly assigning responsibilities across relevant ministries and programs.
  - Institutionalizing a results-oriented budgeting culture anchored in stronger data systems, clearer accountability, and strategic leadership from MINFIN.
- Risk noted: weak implementation capacity in institutions such as MICIVI threatens achievement of goals.

### Quantitative assessment: expected macroeconomic effects of higher spending efficiency
- Improving public spending efficiency to levels comparable with Costa Rica (approximately 20 percent) could produce:
  - a 2.3 percent increase in consumption and GDP,
  - a 0.7 percent increase in debt-to-GDP with no increases in sovereign spreads.
- Higher levels of efficiency improvements generally help sustain higher long-run public debt-to-GDP without negative effects on sovereign spreads and the current account balance.

### Recent macro-fiscal context and key statistics
- GDP growth: Guatemala’s gross domestic product increased by 3.5 percent on average from 2012 to 2023.
- COVID-19 impact: GDP fell by 1.8 percent in the pandemic period and recovered strongly in 2021–2023.
- Public debt-to-GDP: around 27 percent of GDP.
- Sovereign spreads: neighborhood of 2.4 percent, with a peak of 2.8 percent in 2020 and end-2024 spreads below 2 percent.
- Primary balance: at end-2024 Guatemala recorded a primary surplus close to 0.6 percent of GDP; COVID-19 pandemic primary deficit was -3.2 percent.
- Fiscal balance: average fiscal balance-to-GDP ratio close to -2 percent over 2012–2024, with a peak deficit of -4.9 percent in 2020.

### Strategic priorities for policy makers
- Strengthen coordination between MINFIN, SEGEPLAN, and Congress to reinforce accountability and ensure spending on priority areas delivers concrete results.
- Review and institutionalize results-based budgeting with clearer responsibilities and integrated data systems.
- Improve planning–budget linkages and the strategic use of the MFMP, including rigorous costing of sector strategies and validation of sectoral spending paths.
- Reduce discretionary reallocations and address budget rigidities through stronger ex-ante controls and transparency.
- Institutionalize evaluation mechanisms (value-for-money function, regular spending reviews) to reallocate resources toward interventions with the highest social returns.

---

### Public Investment Efficiency, Growth and Debt Sustainability in Guatemala

### Objective and empirical motivation
- Study the effects of a permanent increment in Public Investment Efficiency (PIE) on GDP, government debt and sovereign spreads for Guatemala.
- Guatemala’s Physical Public Investment Efficiency Score is 0.49 for the period 2000-2019.
- Counterfactual target: increase Guatemala’s PIE by 20 percent to reach levels comparable with Costa Rica (roughly 20 percent higher).

### Model and methodological approach
- Construct a structural small open economy sovereign default model (adaptation of Arellano (2008)) that:
  - Produces a final tradable good using labor, private capital, and public capital.
  - Distinguishes public and private capital by productivity; PIE (e) converts public investment into public capital.
  - Features households, a sovereign that issues/defaults on Eurobonds, and international investors buying one-period defaultable claims.
- Analyze transitional dynamics with impulse response functions to trace GDP, consumption, government spending, government debt, sovereign spreads, CA balance, and other outcomes.
- PIE increment modeled as a permanent and unexpected shock.
- Calibration targets:
  - Replicate observed levels of debt-to-GDP and sovereign spreads for 2012-2024.
  - Match long-run ratio of public to private capital in Guatemala.
- Numerical solution:
  - Value function iteration with linear interpolation over a grid of bonds and TFP realizations.
  - Expectations computed using Gauss-Hermite polinomials.
  - Long-run statistics computed by simulating the model for 5,000,000 periods and eliminating the first 50,000 periods; statistics computed in repayment states only.

### Key quantitative findings (20 percent PIE increase)
- GDP:
  - Model generates an estimated 2.3 percent increase in GDP.
  - Mechanism: higher PIE makes public investment relatively more productive, inducing higher public investment and complementary higher private investment.
- Government debt:
  - Predicted long-run increase in government debt of 0.6 percent.
  - Increase arises from additional external borrowing as the sovereign frontloads gains and finances higher future consumption.
- Sovereign spreads:
  - No significant changes in sovereign spreads in equilibrium; sovereign risk premia are not affected.
  - Rationale: default more costly for a government with higher levels of GDP.
- External balance and consumption dynamics:
  - Current Account (CA) Balance temporarily deteriorates by 1 percent to finance extra consumption.
  - Private consumption temporarily increases by 4 percent, then converges to 2.3 percent above pre-shock values.
  - In the long-run, CA balance is not affected.

### Sensitivity and higher-PIE scenarios
- Simulated PIE increments range from 0 to 100 percent of the baseline economy.
- Comparative references for thresholds: 40 percent (Cyprus), 60 percent (Czech Republic), 100 percent (Norway).
- Findings across magnitudes:
  - GDP gains increase with larger PIE improvements.
  - Higher PIE allows sustaining higher long-run levels of debt:
    - 20 percent PIE increase → 0.6 percent higher long-run debt.
    - 100 percent PIE increase → 2.5 percent higher long-run debt.
  - Sovereign spreads and CA balance remain essentially unchanged in the long run across PIE magnitudes.

### Model structure and fit
- Production function (specification):
  - y = z (e g)^γ s^α (1−γ) l^(1−α)
  - z, α, γ denote total factor productivity, capital share, and public capital share’s contribution respectively.
  - Aggregate productivity follows a log-normal AR(1) process.
- Agents and constraints summarized for repayment and default states; bond pricing condition q(z,e,b') = β* E(1 − d').
- Model fit and statistics (targets and model moments):
  - Targeted moments (Data vs Model):
    - Average Debt/GDP (%) — 26.7 vs 26.6
    - Average Spreads (p.p.) — 2.4 vs 2.5
  - Untargeted moments (Data vs Model):
    - Average Fiscal Balance/GDP (%) — -1.9 vs -1.0
    - Average CA Balance/GDP (%) — 0.6 vs 0.2
  - Standard deviation (Data vs Model):
    - Debt/GDP (%) — 2.2 vs 5.1
    - Spreads (p.p.) — 0.3 vs 2.7
  - Correlations (Data vs Model):
    - Debt/GDP, Spreads — 0.1 vs 0.3
    - Debt/GDP, GDP — -0.7 vs -0.1
    - GDP, Spreads — -0.4 vs -0.8
    - GDP, CA Balance/GDP — -0.6 vs -0.1

### Conclusions and policy implications
- Improving PIE to levels comparable with Costa Rica (20 percent increase) could:
  - Raise long-run GDP by 2.3 percent.
  - Permanently increase consumption and deliver a permanent welfare gain for Guatemalans.
  - Allow the government to sustain permanently higher levels of public debt (0.6 percent higher for 20 percent PIE increase) without market punishment in sovereign spreads.
  - Temporarily deteriorate the fiscal balance and CA balance due to increased Eurobond issuance and frontloaded borrowing, but not raise default premia in equilibrium.
- General result across scenarios: higher PIE catalyzes public and private investment, increases GDP, and permits higher optimal debt levels while leaving sovereign spreads and long-run external balance broadly unaffected.

*Prepared by an FAD team; findings reflect inputs from a scoping mission on public spending review carried out in April 2025. Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/cr/2025/english/1gtmea2025002-source-pdf.pdf*

### 1. Evolution of Social Spending and Public Investment Since 2014, and Comparative

### 1. Evolution of Social Spending and Public Investment Since 2014, and Comparative SDG Performance

### Overview and motivation
- Guatemala faces persistent social and infrastructure gaps with one of the lowest public spending levels among developing economies: combined spending on education, health, and social assistance remained below 6 percent of GDP in 2024, and capital spending reached just 2.4 percent of GDP.
- Low spending has limited the state’s capacity to expand service coverage, improve quality, and reduce long-standing disparities in secondary school attendance, maternal and child health, and access to water and sanitation.
- The paper provides a diagnostic of spending adequacy and efficiency in education, health, social assistance, and infrastructure, and assesses institutional and PFM constraints that hinder planning, execution and evaluation of public resources.

### Macro-fiscal context
- General government expenditure stood at just 14.6 percent of GDP in 2024, while revenues were barely above 12 percent.
- Fiscal space is constrained, with little prospect of tax reform and rigidities that limit reallocations within the budget.
- Despite prudent macro management and maintained debt sustainability, fragmented politics has limited approval of structural reforms.
- The new administration aims to use buffers to increase investment in human and physical capital, prioritizing infrastructure in the 2025 budget and seeking gradual increases in education, health, and social protection without undermining fiscal sustainability.

### Efficiency frontiers and implications
- Efficiency frontier analyses show Guatemala falls significantly below the efficiency frontier in health, education, social assistance and infrastructure, underperforming in healthy life expectancy, years of schooling, poverty reduction, and infrastructure access.
- This underperformance reflects not necessarily waste, but that modest spending levels are far from technically achievable results.
- The analysis asks how gradual spending increases through 2029 or 2032 could be used to move closer to the efficiency frontier — e.g., greater investment in secondary schooling and quality improvements in education; strengthening primary care and prevention in health.
- The frontiers provide a reference for a medium-term strategy to improve outcomes within realistic fiscal space, to be used in the medium-term fiscal framework (MTFP, or MFMP in Guatemala).

### Data and methodological notes
- Spending numbers for 2024 are based on data provided by the authorities; previous years from IMF GFS-COFOG.
- Latest outcome data used: 2022 for average years of schooling, 2023 for life expectancy, 2023 for estimated poverty reduction, and 2017 for infrastructure index.
- Physical infrastructure indicator combines economic infrastructure (length of road network, electricity production, access to water) and social infrastructure (number of secondary teachers and hospital beds).

### Key aggregate figures (preserved exactly)
- Combined spending on education, health, and social assistance: below 6 percent of GDP (2024).
- Capital spending: 2.4 percent of GDP (2024).
- General government expenditure: 14.6 percent of GDP (2024).
- Revenues: barely above 12 percent of GDP (2024).
- Public spending on education: between 3.0 and 3.5 percent of GDP (over past decade).
- Health spending: between 2 and 2.5 percent of GDP.
- Social assistance: around 0.5 percent of GDP (except COVID-19 uptick where it tripled).
- Public investment average: 2.4 percent of GDP.
- Overlap between public investment and public spending on health and education: between 5 and 10% of public investment corresponds to health and education infrastructure.
- Estimated 1.7 million secondary school–aged adolescents remain outside the education system.

### Government priorities and stated policies
- General Government Policy (PGG) 2024-28 core objectives: expansion of coverage and quality in education and health, reduction of chronic malnutrition, investments in rural infrastructure, and a more coherent approach to social protection.
- Priorities align with the National Development Plan (K’atun 2032) and SDG framework.
- Government seeks improvements in planning and prioritization of infrastructure projects and stronger execution capacity at the local level, emphasizing results-based execution and tools to monitor public spending and institutionalize accountability.

### Sectoral adequacy and efficiency gaps — Education
- Over two decades, education spending has hovered around 3 percent of GDP, well below international benchmarks and insufficient for meaningful gains in access or quality.
- Primary enrolment is near universal; secondary education shows little progress since 2010: net enrolment rates stagnating and dropout rates remaining high.
- Tertiary enrolment has tripled despite limited improvements in upper-secondary completion.
- Budget structure heavily concentrated in primary education; secondary education structurally underfunded.
- Less than 40 percent net enrolment in secondary education; fewer than one in three aged 15-18 continue to upper secondary.
- Public spending composition: tertiary absorbs a share equal to that of secondary, partly driven by a constitutional mandate that allocates at least 5 percent of ordinary revenues to the University of San Carlos.
- Distributional issues: public spending on secondary mostly benefits wealthier households; adolescents from rural, poor, and indigenous backgrounds are disproportionately excluded.
- National education strategy flagship actions: school construction and rehabilitation, expansion of early childhood care, nationwide maintenance program, creation of regional technical institutes.
- Cost-effective measures mentioned but not yet scaled: introducing secondary shifts in existing primary schools, subsidizing transportation; scholarship programs for secondary students remain modest.

### Sectoral adequacy and efficiency gaps — Health
- Health policy priorities: expand coverage through primary healthcare network (RISS), improve infrastructure and human resources, enhance access to essential medicines.
- Primary care allocations are difficult to track due to many executing units and overlapping activities.
- Recent increases in budget allocations for infrastructure investments in community health centers and hospitals.
- Strengthening composition of spending to staff and equip primary care centers and improving rural service delivery are critical to achieve SDG 3.
- Health outcomes and financing trends:
  - Increase in health expenditure largely driven by household direct spending (out-of-pocket) rather than government financing.
  - UHC index: 50 in 2005, 58 in 2010, 59 in latest available outcome data.

### Social assistance and public investment
- Social assistance spending around 0.5 percent of GDP (pre-COVID baseline); it tripled during the COVID-19 pandemic.
- Social assistance excludes contributory pensions, unemployment, disability and survivor benefits.
- Public investment averaged just 2.4 percent of GDP, insufficient to close infrastructure gaps; physical infrastructure index used to benchmark coverage.
- The analysis highlights the need to reprioritize and scale up spending where returns to human and physical capital are highest and to address execution bottlenecks.

### Institutional and PFM constraints
- Rigidities in the budget limit flexibility for reallocating resources in response to policy priorities.
- Fragmented political landscape constrains approval of structural reforms.
- Bottlenecks in spending planning, execution, and evaluation, including challenges in tracking primary care allocations and multiple executing units.
- Constitutional and structural rigidities (e.g., 5 percent of ordinary revenues to University of San Carlos) affect discretionary policy choices and raise equity and efficiency concerns.

### Diagnostic implications and next steps
- Countries that have narrowed gaps combined incremental spending increases with institutional reforms to improve efficiency and equity of service delivery.
- Cross-country benchmarking and distributional analysis identify options to reallocate and scale up spending to bring Guatemala closer to the efficiency frontier within realistic fiscal space.
- This analysis should support discussions on future spending trajectories within the medium-term fiscal framework.

*Prepared by an FAD team; findings reflect inputs from a scoping mission on public spending review carried out in April 2025.*

### 2021. The resulting picture in terms of outcomes is mixed. Trends since 2005 show that over the last

### 1gtmea2025002-source-pdf - 2021. The resulting picture in terms of outcomes is mixed. Trends since 2005 show that over the last

### Health outcomes and service delivery
- Life expectancy has risen since 2005 and is “currently at a level expected for its’ GDP per capita.”
- Share of births attended by skilled staff “has significantly increased since 2005,” but experienced “a temporary fall during the pandemic.”
- Stunting rates have seen only “modest decreases in the past 20 years.”
- Key outcome gaps:
  - UHC index remains below the regional average.
  - Healthy life expectancy “trails Central America and EMEs by 6-8 years.”
  - Maternal mortality is “30-50 percent above peer countries.”
  - “Nearly half of children under five are chronically malnourished.”
- Service delivery constraints:
  - Shortage of trained personnel; many rural health posts staffed by auxiliary nurses with limited training.
  - Advanced services concentrated in Guatemala City.
  - Cultural and logistical barriers: “more than one-third of births still occurring at home with comadronas.”
  - Deficiencies particularly acute in rural and indigenous communities.

### Health financing and expenditure structure
- Public general government health spending: “2.4 percent of GDP in 2022.”
- Regional and peer benchmarks: Central America average “4.2 percent”; EMEs “3.6 percent.”
- Private out-of-pocket spending: “4.9 percent of GDP.”
- Pharmaceuticals: highly concentrated market, high prices, uneven public availability; recent reforms (centralized procurement through MSPAS and farmacias populares (PROAM)) are at early stages and market concentration persists.
- Latest data note: “Latest available data are from 2022 for health expenditure, 2023 for life expectancy, 2021 for UHC Index and stunting rates, and 2017 for births attended by skilled staff.”

### Budget composition, primary health care (PHC) and equity
- 2025 MSPAS budget allocates “around one-fourth of resources to the Redes Integradas de Servicios de Salud (RISS).”
- Estimated PHC spending: “around 0.6 percent” of GDP (below WHO recommended “1 percent”).
- RISS territorial allocations (per capita):
  - Alta Verapaz: “162 Quetzales per capita.”
  - National average: “Q213 per capita.”
  - Santa Rosa: “Q444 per capita.”
- Hospitals absorb “over 40 percent of the health budget,” and one-third of that hospital budget goes “exclusively to the two large urban hospitals, Roosevelt and San Juan de Dios.”
- Policy implication: need to rebalance spending toward prevention, frontline services, and underserved regions to improve equity and cost-effectiveness.

### Social assistance: coverage, adequacy, and reforms
- Social assistance spending: “0.6 percent of GDP.”
- Comparators: spending is “roughly one-third of the LAC average and one-quarter of that of EMEs.”
- Impact and coverage:
  - Social assistance reduces poverty by “less than 5 percent in Guatemala,” versus “35–50 percent in peer countries.”
  - Only “2-4 percent” of the poorest households receive conditional cash transfers, compared to “10-20 percent in the region.”
- Program scale and recent developments:
  - Key programs: Bono Social (“Q500 monthly to poor households with children or prenatal needs”) and Bolsa Social (“Q250 monthly for food insecure households in Guatemala City”).
  - By mid-2024, CCT beneficiaries “more than doubled”; government target “500,000 by 2027.”
  - By mid-2024, over “200,000 households had been registered” in the Registro Social de Hogares (RSH); goal to reach “500,000 by 2027,” prioritizing “114 high-poverty municipalities.”
  - RSH supported inclusion of “24,000 new Bono Social beneficiaries.”
- Persistent coverage shortfalls (as of 2023):
  - Only “about 3 percent” of households received support from either Bono or Bolsa Social.
  - Departmental coverage ranged from “less than 1 percent” (Escuintla and Sacatepéquez) to “nearly 7 percent” (Chiquimula).
  - Coverage among poorest quintile: “3 percent”; richest quintile: “2 percent.”
  - Adulto Mayor pension reaches “just 16 percent of poor elderly.”
- Institutional constraints:
  - RSH lacks a formal legal framework and faces interoperability issues with RNB, RENAP, MSPAS databases.
  - Mano a Mano strategy seeks integration across seven vulnerability dimensions but needs clarification on territorial implementation.
  - Budget rigidity and operational fragmentation hinder scale-up.

### Infrastructure, public investment, and spatial disparities
- 2025 capital allocations increased “by over 50 percent from 2024 spending,” reaching “about 3.8 percent of GDP.”
- Historical averages and targets:
  - Public investment averaged “just 2.4 percent of GDP between 2022 and 2024.”
  - Projected to reach “3 percent by 2025-29.”
  - Estimated required level to maximize GDP growth and crowd in private investment: “5-6 percent of GDP.”
- Capital stock and service coverage:
  - Public capital stock amounts to “only 41 percent of GDP,” compared to “60 to 80 percent in similar countries.”
  - Drinking water and sanitation: sanitation reaches “just half the population,” below the “70 percent benchmark in similar economies.”
- Territorial disparities and budget execution:
  - Only “20 percent” of rural households access drainage networks.
  - 2024 execution: “only half of the transport budget and less than 20 percent of the energy budget were executed.”
  - Subnational execution rates ranged from “49 to 68 percent” across departments.
  - SEGEPLAN data: infrastructure projects add to “only around 0.6 percent of GDP” (while total capital spending amounts to “2.4 percent of GDP executed public investment”).

### Public investment planning, monitoring, and PFM weaknesses
- Planning gaps:
  - Absence of a prioritized, quantified list of projects in planning documents.
  - Weak multi-year fiscal framework limits clear envelopes for short- and medium-term investments.
  - Need for stronger dialogue between MINFIN, SEGEPLAN, and line ministries to ensure financial viability and alignment with priorities.
- Budget approval and project addition risks:
  - During legislative budget approval, new projects often introduced by Congress “without thorough examination or prioritization,” frequently outside SINIP, creating unfunded commitments.
  - Mid-year project additions by MICIVI complicate coherence of investment strategy.
- Monitoring and information system fragmentation:
  - Lack of coordination between SINIP, Guatecompras and SICOIN “severely hinders real-time project monitoring.”
  - SEGEPLAN’s role in monitoring, evaluation, reporting, and external communication is crucial but constrained by system fragmentation.

*IMF staff calculations using data from WB WDI, WHO GHE and Guatemalan authorities.*

### 26.      Beyond spending levels, the effectiveness of Guatemala’s public expenditure is shaped

### Public Investment Efficiency, Growth and Debt Sustainability in Guatemala

### Effectiveness of public expenditure: institutional constraints and execution
- Structural weaknesses in planning, execution, and evaluation constrain the impact of public investment and social spending.
- Q499 million added by Congress in 2023 represented 11 percent of the investment projects included in the budget bill presented by the Executive.
- Limited resources invested in health, education, social assistance and infrastructure have not consistently translated into improved service delivery or outcomes.
- Institutional fragmentation and limited integration between SEGEPLAN and MINFIN reduce the visibility of whether public resources translate into tangible progress.

### Results-based budgeting: design and implementation gaps
- Results-based budgeting adopted over a decade ago remains fragmented and disconnected from decision-making.
- Many institutions define annual output indicators and targets, but these are rarely linked to outcomes or used to assess progress toward PGG priority results indicators.
- Execution reports often focus on activity levels rather than whether spending contributes to closing service gaps (example: Ministry of Health reports number of women receiving prenatal care but not whether services reach priority populations or improve maternal health outcomes).
- Policy recommendation: Review and strengthen the results-based budgeting model through clearer responsibilities, better data systems, and more consistent use of results information across the budget process.

### Planning–budget linkages and medium-term frameworks
- Despite planning instruments (K’atun 2032, PGG 2024–28, sectoral PEIs), allocations remain largely incremental and based on historical trends and input targets rather than coverage goals, cost structures, or performance indicators.
- Nutrition case: allocations to high-need municipalities under the child malnutrition program declined from 31 percent in 2019 to 11.5 percent in 2025.
- Medium-Term Fiscal Framework (MFMP) and multiannual budget processes are used largely procedurally: expenditure projections rely on baseline adjustments (e.g., salary or inflation growth) rather than rigorous costing of sectoral strategies.
- Ongoing effort: authorities are aligning revenue paths with tax policy and revenue administration measures to improve MFMP realism.
- Policy recommendation: Reconcile technical and political priorities, validate sectoral results and spending paths jointly with line ministries, and ensure resource allocations reflect measurable efforts to close coverage and quality gaps.

### Budget rigidities and politically driven reallocations
- MINFIN estimates that 93 percent of the 2025 budget is considered “rigid”, tied to earmarked revenues, legal mandates, or pre-existing commitments such as public sector wages and pensions.
- The 2025 budget includes an extraordinary increase for local development councils (CODEDEs) of around 0.5 percent of GDP, in part accommodated by reallocating funds away from education, labor, and agriculture.
- Authorities note the 2025 allocation increase to CODEDEs is part of constitutionally mandated transfers, which make up only 11.8 percent of the approved budget.
- Administrative reallocations remain broad and largely discretionary despite legal rules (Article 32, Decree 101-97); strengthening ex-ante controls and transparency around budget modifications is recommended.

### Evaluation, monitoring, and use of performance data
- There is no institutionalized process to evaluate whether programs achieve intended outcomes; targets and indicators often lack baseline data, cost-effectiveness analysis, or mechanisms to track progress against coverage gaps.
- Monitoring system gaps: no linkage between budget execution and strategic PGG goals (e.g., reductions in maternal mortality, chronic malnutrition, implementation of “Mano a Mano”).
- Under current framework, results monitoring is expected only at the end of the PGG period in 2029 with no intermediate assessments.
- Recent development: partnership signed with J-PAL to evaluate Mano a Mano.
- Policy recommendation: Institutionalize ex-ante and ex-post evaluations, regular spending reviews, and a value-for-money function (possible lead: Directorate of Fiscal Policy Analysis, DAPF).

### Reform momentum and implementation strategy
- Reforms underway include strengthening local public investment planning through CODEDEs, improving transparency and fiscal forecasting via MFMP revisions, and enhancing performance monitoring through results-based budgeting.
- Legal framework assigns SEGEPLAN roles for evaluation and MINFIN roles for budget integration; Article 35 of the Organic Law of the Executive assigns joint responsibilities for investment project policies.
- To achieve PGG and multiyear budget targets through 2029, recommended actions include:
  - Updating baselines and reviewing/sequencing expected results for 2026–29.
  - Aligning results with realistic expenditure projections.
  - Clearly assigning responsibilities across relevant ministries and programs.
  - Institutionalizing a results-oriented budgeting culture anchored in stronger data systems, clearer accountability, and strategic leadership from MINFIN.
- Risk noted: weak implementation capacity in institutions such as MICIVI threatens achievement of goals.

### Quantitative assessment: expected macroeconomic effects of higher spending efficiency
- Improving public spending efficiency to levels comparable with Costa Rica (approximately 20 percent) could produce:
  - a 2.3 percent increase in consumption and GDP,
  - a 0.7 percent increase in debt-to-GDP with no increases in sovereign spreads.
- Higher levels of efficiency improvements generally help sustain higher long-run public debt-to-GDP without negative effects on sovereign spreads and the current account balance.

### Recent macro-fiscal context and key statistics
- GDP growth: Guatemala’s gross domestic product increased by 3.5 percent on average from 2012 to 2023.
- COVID-19 impact: GDP fell by 1.8 percent in the pandemic period and recovered strongly in 2021–2023.
- Public debt-to-GDP: around 27 percent of GDP.
- Sovereign spreads: neighborhood of 2.4 percent, with a peak of 2.8 percent in 2020 and end-2024 spreads below 2 percent.
- Primary balance: at end-2024 Guatemala recorded a primary surplus close to 0.6 percent of GDP; COVID-19 pandemic primary deficit was -3.2 percent.
- Fiscal balance: average fiscal balance-to-GDP ratio close to -2 percent over 2012–2024, with a peak deficit of -4.9 percent in 2020.

### Strategic priorities for policy makers
- Strengthen coordination between MINFIN, SEGEPLAN, and Congress to reinforce accountability and ensure spending on priority areas delivers concrete results.
- Review and institutionalize results-based budgeting with clearer responsibilities and integrated data systems.
- Improve planning–budget linkages and the strategic use of the MFMP, including rigorous costing of sector strategies and validation of sectoral spending paths.
- Reduce discretionary reallocations and address budget rigidities through stronger ex-ante controls and transparency.
- Institutionalize evaluation mechanisms (value-for-money function, regular spending reviews) to reallocate resources toward interventions with the highest social returns.

*Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/cr/2025/english/1gtmea2025002-source-pdf.pdf*

### 4.      This paper aims at studying the effects of a permanent increment in Public Investment

### 4.      This paper aims at studying the effects of a permanent increment in Public Investment Efficiency (PIE) on GDP, government debt and sovereign spreads

### Objective and empirical motivation
- Study the effects of a permanent increment in Public Investment Efficiency (PIE) on GDP, government debt and sovereign spreads for Guatemala.
- Guatemala’s Physical Public Investment Efficiency Score is 0.49 for the period 2000-2019.
- Counterfactual target: increase Guatemala’s PIE by 20 percent to reach levels comparable with Costa Rica (roughly 20 percent higher).

### Model and methodological approach
- Construct a structural small open economy sovereign default model (adaptation of Arellano (2008)) that:
  - Produces a final tradable good using labor, private capital, and public capital.
  - Distinguishes public and private capital by productivity; PIE (e) converts public investment into public capital.
  - Features households, a sovereign that issues/defaults on Eurobonds, and international investors buying one-period defaultable claims.
- Analyze transitional dynamics with impulse response functions to trace GDP, consumption, government spending, government debt, sovereign spreads, CA balance, and other outcomes.
- PIE increment modeled as a permanent and unexpected shock.
- Calibration targets:
  - Replicate observed levels of debt-to-GDP and sovereign spreads for 2012-2024.
  - Match long-run ratio of public to private capital in Guatemala.
- Numerical solution:
  - Value function iteration with linear interpolation over a grid of bonds and TFP realizations.
  - Expectations computed using Gauss-Hermite polinomials.
  - Long-run statistics computed by simulating the model for 5,000,000 periods and eliminating the first 50,000 periods; statistics computed in repayment states only.

### Key quantitative findings (20 percent PIE increase)
- GDP:
  - Model generates an estimated 2.3 percent increase in GDP.
  - Mechanism: higher PIE makes public investment relatively more productive, inducing higher public investment and complementary higher private investment.
- Government debt:
  - Predicted long-run increase in government debt of 0.6 percent.
  - Increase arises from additional external borrowing as the sovereign frontloads gains and finances higher future consumption.
- Sovereign spreads:
  - No significant changes in sovereign spreads in equilibrium; sovereign risk premia are not affected.
  - Rationale: default more costly for a government with higher levels of GDP.
- External balance and consumption dynamics:
  - Current Account (CA) Balance temporarily deteriorates by 1 percent to finance extra consumption.
  - Private consumption temporarily increases by 4 percent, then converges to 2.3 percent above pre-shock values.
  - In the long-run, CA balance is not affected.

### Sensitivity and higher-PIE scenarios
- Simulated PIE increments range from 0 to 100 percent of the baseline economy.
- Comparative references for thresholds: 40 percent (Cyprus), 60 percent (Czech Republic), 100 percent (Norway).
- Findings across magnitudes:
  - GDP gains increase with larger PIE improvements.
  - Higher PIE allows sustaining higher long-run levels of debt:
    - 20 percent PIE increase → 0.6 percent higher long-run debt.
    - 100 percent PIE increase → 2.5 percent higher long-run debt.
  - Sovereign spreads and CA balance remain essentially unchanged in the long run across PIE magnitudes.

### Model structure and agent problems (summary)
- Production function (specification):
  - y = z (e g)^γ s^α (1−γ) l^(1−α)
  - z, α, γ denote total factor productivity, capital share, and public capital share’s contribution respectively.
  - Aggregate productivity follows a log-normal AR(1) process.
- Agents:
  - Households: consume c, supply labor l, invest in private capital s, pay lump-sum taxes T; budget constraint c = y − s − T; utility with risk aversion σ and discount factor β.
  - International investors: price government bonds q_t = β* E_t(1 − d_{t+1}).
  - Sovereign: chooses repayment or default; value functions specified for default (V_D) and repayment (V_R) states including default disutility φ(z) and probability of re-entry θ.
- Market clearing in default: c = y − s − g; in repayment: budget constraint includes q(z,e,b') b' − b and the bond pricing condition q(z,e,b') = β* E(1 − d').

### Model fit and statistics (targets and model moments)
- Targeted moments (Data vs Model):
  - Average Debt/GDP (%) — 26.7 vs 26.6
  - Average Spreads (p.p.) — 2.4 vs 2.5
- Untargeted moments (Data vs Model):
  - Average Fiscal Balance/GDP (%) — -1.9 vs -1.0
  - Average CA Balance/GDP (%) — 0.6 vs 0.2
- Standard deviation (Data vs Model):
  - Debt/GDP (%) — 2.2 vs 5.1
  - Spreads (p.p.) — 0.3 vs 2.7
- Correlations (Data vs Model):
  - Debt/GDP, Spreads — 0.1 vs 0.3
  - Debt/GDP, GDP — -0.7 vs -0.1
  - GDP, Spreads — -0.4 vs -0.8
  - GDP, CA Balance/GDP — -0.6 vs -0.1

### Conclusions and policy implications
- Improving PIE to levels comparable with Costa Rica (20 percent increase) could:
  - Raise long-run GDP by 2.3 percent.
  - Permanently increase consumption and deliver a permanent welfare gain for Guatemalans.
  - Allow the government to sustain permanently higher levels of public debt (0.6 percent higher for 20 percent PIE increase) without market punishment in sovereign spreads.
  - Temporarily deteriorate the fiscal balance and CA balance due to increased Eurobond issuance and frontloaded borrowing, but not raise default premia in equilibrium.
- General result across scenarios: higher PIE catalyzes public and private investment, increases GDP, and permits higher optimal debt levels while leaving sovereign spreads and long-run external balance broadly unaffected.

*Source: IMF Staff elaborations (content unit: 1gtmea2025002-source-pdf - 4.      This paper aims at studying the effects of a permanent increment in Public Investment)*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/cr/2025/english/1gtmea2025002-source-pdf.pdf_
