## The Specter of Versailles

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [The Specter of Versailles](https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/fandd/article/2019/june/specter-of-versailles-eichengreen.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/files/publications/fandd/article/2019/june/specter-of-versailles-eichengreen.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/files/publications/fandd/article/2019/june/specter-of-versailles-eichengreen.pdf.json)

---

### Failures of the Treaty of Versailles and immediate aftermath
- Treaty signed on June 29, 1919, officially ending World War I.
- Failed to achieve its aims:
  - Did not seal an enduring peace.
  - Did not inaugurate an era of prosperity in Europe or worldwide.
  - Did not create an effective institutional framework for governing international economic and political relations.
- Its failure led to a different approach after World War II: more forceful US leadership and construction of encompassing institutions in Europe and globally, contributing to unprecedented economic growth in the third quarter of the 20th century.

### United States inward turn and isolationism
- After World War I the United States largely washed its hands of treaty results:
  - Refused to join the League of Nations.
  - Was not an active participant in the 1922 Genoa Conference intended to strengthen the international monetary and financial system.
  - Did not support the League’s efforts to negotiate a tariff truce and provocatively raised import duties in 1923 and 1930.
  - Did not forgive war debts owed by its European allies, compounding the German reparations issue.
- Geographic separation cited: separated from Europe by more than 2,000 miles of ocean, fostering belief in avoiding entanglement.
- Postwar domestic measures included erecting new tariffs and adopting restrictive immigration laws.

### Economic dislocation, tariffs, and technological change
- Economic dislocation in the 1920s paralleled contemporary economic change:
  - In the 1920s, American farmers—grain growers in particular—suffered from expansion of acreage in Argentina, Canada, and elsewhere.
  - The Smoot-Hawley Tariff of 1930 was initially conceived to protect US farmers from cheap imports.
  - The article emphasizes that mechanization—“the tractor”—was the more important explanation for low US farm-gate prices than import competition, but policy response blamed foreigners.
- Contemporary parallel: declining manufacturing employment and robotics are the modern analogues to 1920s agricultural distress and mechanization.

### Immigration, identity politics, and exclusionary policies
- Identity politics fueled isolationist tendencies:
  - Earlier immigrants from the British Isles and Scandinavia were disquieted by immigration from southern and eastern Europe, whose populations were heavily Catholic.
  - The sensational 1921 trial and conviction of Nicola Sacco and Bartolomeo Vanzetti symbolized suspicion of “new immigrants.”
  - The Immigration Act of 1924 based immigrant quotas on shares in 1890 rather than current population shares.
- Economic hardship reinforced hostility toward immigrants:
  - Mexican Repatriation from 1929 through 1936 targeted as many as 2 million Mexicans and Mexican-Americans for deportation.

### Exclusion of rising powers and geopolitical consequences
- Versailles denied rising powers a seat at the table:
  - Germany was excluded from the League of Nations until 1926.
  - Germany faced indefinite restrictions on its military and limits on economic autonomy, including prohibition against forming a customs union with Austria.
  - These impositions fueled destructive nationalism and contributed to the collapse of the Weimar Republic.
- Russia/Soviet Union:
  - A weakened Russia negotiated a separate peace with Germany in 1918; Bolsheviks were excluded from Versailles negotiations.
  - The Soviet Union came into existence in 1922 and was in no position to participate in reconstruction of the international system.
  - The USSR joined the League of Nations—temporarily—in 1934, by which time it was effectively kept out of Western economic and financial arrangements, contributing to bifurcation of the world economy into Soviet and Western blocs.
- Contemporary parallel: China is actively seeking a global role and may exert influence either through existing multilateral institutions such as the International Monetary Fund and the World Bank or through China-designed vehicles such as the Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank and the Belt and Road Initiative.
  - If China invests and provides assistance through the IMF and World Bank, it will be subject to existing institutional constraints and counterbalanced by other members.
  - If it does not, it will be freer to act unilaterally.
  - The article notes the reluctance of the United States and other countries to give China a greater voice in the Bretton Woods institutions heightens this danger.

### Lessons and policy implications
- Leadership and inclusion:
  - The failure of the Treaty of Versailles underscores the indispensability of leadership by the dominant power in crafting and sustaining stabilizing alliances and institutions.
  - It highlights the need to incorporate rising powers constructively into international arrangements.
- Contemporary warning:
  - The article argues the United States seems to have forgotten these lessons, exhibiting an inward turn similar to the post–World War I era.
  - The central question posed: whether the current isolationist tendencies will prove temporary or enduring.

*Barry Eichengreen, Finance & Development, June 2019.*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/fandd/article/2019/june/specter-of-versailles-eichengreen.pdf_
