## Distribution Matters

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [Distribution Matters](https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/fandd/article/2020/december/economics-must-make-room-for-other-disciplines-appelbaum.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/files/publications/fandd/article/2020/december/economics-must-make-room-for-other-disciplines-appelbaum.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/files/publications/fandd/article/2020/december/economics-must-make-room-for-other-disciplines-appelbaum.pdf.json)

---

### Main thesis
- Economics must explicitly confront distributional issues rather than treating them as peripheral or purely normative.
- The distribution of wealth and income significantly affects opportunity, business cycles, innovation, public policy, and the social fabric of liberal democracy.
- The discipline's lack of diversity and its historical indifference to distributional outcomes have disproportionately harmed minorities and narrowed the range of considered solutions.

### Evidence and findings
- A quarter millennium of industrial revolution has produced "almost 8 billion people and enough wealth for every one of them to live lives of unprecedented comfort," but the problem lies in distribution.
- Over the past half century, rising inequality has weighed on growth and strained liberal democracy.
- Recent studies, including work by Jonathan D. Ostry, Prakash Loungani, and Andrew Berg (2019), find that high levels of inequality "actually impede growth."
- Historical example: In the 1980s, many mainstream economists favored eliminating minimum wage laws; a 1987 editorial cited a "virtual consensus among economists that the minimum wage is an idea whose time has passed." Subsequent evidence contradicted that consensus.
- Trade advocacy often relies on net-benefit calculations while deferring redistribution; in practice, promised compensation to losers frequently does not occur (example: Huffy moved production to China in 1998 after building "about 2 million bikes a year" in Celina, Ohio, leading to local job losses despite cheaper consumer prices).
- Psychological research documents that economic inequality "mimics the effects of absolute poverty on physical and mental health," an insight that does not fit easily into standard economic models but matters for policy.

### Discipline norms and limitations
- Many economists view their role as advocates for efficiency and are reluctant to engage in normative distributional debates; notable views include Charles Schultze’s description of economists as "the partisan advocate for efficiency" and Paul Romer’s suggestion that economists should "say ‘No’ when government officials look to economists for an answer to a normative question."
- This stance, even when well-intentioned, often results in distributional issues being excluded from public debate, with distribution treated as a remedial afterthought rather than a primary policy goal.
- Milton Friedman’s claim that political views of economists cannot be discerned in their academic work is critiqued as lacking self-awareness: interests, methods, and conclusions are informed by life experience.

### Cross-pollination and recommendations for practice
- Cross-pollination with other disciplines (psychology, demography, history of economic ideas) has enriched economics and should continue, but the objective is not to create a "hybrid super social science"—rather to make space for other perspectives in policy deliberation.
- Economists should:
  - Emphasize distribution as an explicit policy objective alongside efficiency.
  - Incorporate non-economic evidence (for example, psychological and health impacts of inequality) into policy advice and decision-making.
  - Recognize that political feasibility, perceptions of equity, and stability often precede and enable support for efficiency-enhancing measures (citing Gustav Ranis’ observation about reversed priorities).
  - Be cautious about advocating policies based solely on aggregate efficiency gains when mechanisms for broad distribution of benefits are absent or unlikely to occur.

### Implications for policymaking
- Treat distributional equity as a primary goal to secure political stability and public support for efficiency-enhancing policies.
- Ensure mechanisms for compensation or redistribution are credible and likely to be implemented when promoting policies with uneven distributional impacts (for example, trade liberalization).
- Broaden the evidence base informing policy to include psychological and demographic findings that document the societal costs of inequality.

*Source: "Distribution Matters" by Binyamin Appelbaum, FINANCE & DEVELOPMENT, December 2020.*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/fandd/article/2020/december/economics-must-make-room-for-other-disciplines-appelbaum.pdf_
