## Lessons from Singapore on Raising Fertility Rates

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [Lessons from Singapore on Raising Fertility Rates](https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/fandd/article/2020/march/lessons-from-singapore-on-raising-fertility-rates-tan.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/files/publications/fandd/article/2020/march/lessons-from-singapore-on-raising-fertility-rates-tan.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/files/publications/fandd/article/2020/march/lessons-from-singapore-on-raising-fertility-rates-tan.pdf.json)

---

### Overview
- Singapore has experienced a relentless downward trend in fertility since the 1980s.
- Pronatalist policy package (introduced 2001 and enhanced over the years) includes paid maternity leave, childcare subsidies, tax relief and rebates, one-time cash gifts, and grants for companies that implement flexible work arrangements.
- Fertility rate: 1.41 in 2001 and 1.16 in 2018.
- Replacement fertility level: 2.1.

### Lesson 1: Address the rising age at childbearing
- Mean age of childbearing has increased by approximately one year a decade among OECD countries (Mills and others 2011).
- In Singapore:
  - Women ages 20–24 are now as likely to give birth as women ages 40–44 and far less likely than women ages 35–39.
  - The steep decline in fertility among women in their 20s has not been offset by higher birth rates among women in their 30s; missing births appear to be permanent rather than merely delayed.
- Policy implication:
  - Age-sensitive policies targeting couples already married and desiring at least two children are politically and economically easier and more effective than policies focused on matching singles or changing strongly held preferences.
  - Lack of instruments specifically designed to enable women to become mothers at peak childbearing ages is a missed opportunity.

### Lesson 2: Reproductive technologies are not a panacea
- Public misconceptions include beliefs that good health and IVF can offset age-related infertility (Daniluk, Koert, and Cheung 2012).
- Health risks and increased pregnancy complications associated with delayed childbearing are underappreciated.
- Singapore policy detail:
  - Government subsidizes up to 75 percent of assisted reproductive technology treatment costs for qualifying married couples.
  - Couples may use medical accounts under the national savings program to pay for procedures.
- Evidence:
  - High access to IVF does not ensure higher fertility—Japan has about 5 percent of babies born through IVF and one of the lowest fertility rates.
- Policy implication:
  - Subsidizing IVF and assisted reproduction alone cannot compensate for age-related fertility declines.

### Lesson 3: Household production cannot be fully outsourced
- Even with expanded female education and labor market opportunities, persistent gender inequality at home raises the opportunity cost of childbearing (McDonald 2006).
- Singapore’s formal-sector supports:
  - Government provides low-cost, high-quality formal childcare.
  - Working mothers receive childcare subsidies of S$300 a month for formal childcare; lower-income families receive more.
  - Families can hire relatively low-cost domestic workers from neighboring Southeast Asian countries.
- Finding:
  - Robust formal childcare and domestic help ease some burdens but do not substitute for parental time; institutional supports (parental leave, flexible work) that increase family time are necessary.
- Policy implication:
  - Combine formal provision with measures that enable parents to spend quality time with children.

### Lesson 4: Acknowledge human capital’s true cost
- Very low fertility countries (Japan, Singapore, others) score highly on human capital measures.
- Trade-off:
  - Emphasis on early-life achievement increases returns to investing in human capital, raising per-child costs and reducing desired family size (Tan, Morgan, and Zagheni 2016).
- Behavioral effects:
  - Many singles delay marriage to pursue education or careers; most married couples have children but stop at one or two due to education-related expenses and desire to invest heavily per child.
  - Concerns about the ethics of a stressful childhood and parents’ capacity to help children compete reduce willingness to have more children.
- Policy implication:
  - Raising fertility may require addressing broader systemic incentives—reducing excessive competition, building social cohesion, and shifting cultural attitudes that penalize risk-taking.

### Prospects and targets
- Singaporean Prime Minister noted that with immigration, a fertility rate of 1.3–1.4 may be sufficient to meet the country’s needs (Yong 2019).
- Author’s assessment:
  - Because of demographic momentum (fewer couples of childbearing age as population ages), time is limited; a higher fertility rate will yield diminishing returns as population ages.
  - A mix of age-sensitive policies and enhanced pronatalist incentives may push fertility toward a more modest target of 1.4, but raising fertility to replacement levels will require confronting deeper systemic issues.

*Poh Lin Tan, “Reversing Demographic Decline,” Finance & Development, March 2020.*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/fandd/article/2020/march/lessons-from-singapore-on-raising-fertility-rates-tan.pdf_
