## Knightmare Uncertainty

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [Knightmare Uncertainty](https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/fandd/article/2020/september/balancing-risk-and-resilience-geoffrey-okamoto.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/files/publications/fandd/article/2020/september/balancing-risk-and-resilience-geoffrey-okamoto.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/files/publications/fandd/article/2020/september/balancing-risk-and-resilience-geoffrey-okamoto.pdf.json)

---

### Risk versus Knightian uncertainty
- Frank Knight distinction: risk is “a quantity susceptible of measurement.” Uncertainty means there is not enough information to even narrow down the possibilities; when a situation is “not susceptible to measurement” economists call it Knightian uncertainty.
- The COVID-19 pandemic produces extreme Knightian uncertainty: harder to quantify risks of going to work, shopping, or attending events; uncertainty about treatments and a vaccine (when available, effectiveness, and willingness to take them).

### Impacts on households and consumption
- Behavioral shifts and long-term effects:
  - The 1920s economic chaos left many Germans traumatized about inflation; Americans who experienced the Great Depression remained frugal throughout their lives. This pandemic could fundamentally change how we view and manage risk and uncertainty.
  - Individuals may increase precautionary saving after sharp income loss, implying less debt in the short term and potential long-term changes (for example, less willingness to take on a 30-year mortgage).
  - In many countries, home ownership is low because long-term debt is seen more as a risk than an opportunity.
  - Consumption patterns may change as high-risk individuals avoid activities; consumers may hold more essential goods in fear of new lockdowns.
  - Heightened aversion to risk could prevent entrepreneurs from starting businesses, hiring employees, and launching products.

### Company-level operational and strategic responses
- Supply chain and production choices:
  - Example: US carmakers experienced parts shortages because the Mexican state of Chihuahua limited factory attendance to 50 percent of employees.
  - Possible corporate responses: diversify supply chains, keep more inventory, invest in automation or advanced machinery.
  - Trade-offs: changing suppliers, higher inventory, and capital investment raise costs for manufacturers operating on thin profit margins; raising prices during a recession is difficult.
  - For “essential” goods like medical supplies, countries may change regulations or subsidize domestic production, altering competitive landscapes.
- Liquidity and risk buffers:
  - Firms hit by a sharp revenue drop may maintain higher liquidity buffers; some changes may be quantifiable once production stabilizes, but uncertainty will persist for many companies.

### Financial sector and macroeconomic policy challenges
- Market and regulatory implications:
  - Extreme swings in market conditions and asset prices early in the outbreak will change risk management models, affecting liquidity and capital buffers.
  - Policymakers may change regulations to prevent volatility recurrence and reduce reliance on central bank interventions.
  - The recession will increase losses in the financial sector.
- Government finances and IMF role:
  - Policymakers face financing higher spending amid falling revenue and ballooning debt while health crisis uncertainty persists.
  - Private sector interventions (guarantees or direct ownership) may have lasting and hard-to-quantify implications for competition and private risk-taking beyond immediate public balance sheet effects.
  - The IMF provided emergency support to a record number of countries within a short time frame, introduced new support facilities, and expanded borrowing limits on existing ones.
  - Operational challenges for the IMF: many countries requested financial assistance; some have challenging debt loads where sustainability is hard to measure amid elevated uncertainties about growth and trade prospects.
  - If debt renegotiations are needed, the private sector must play a larger role in providing financing assurances given its increased importance as a creditor.
  - Members request policy advice and capacity development while IMF staff largely work remotely and cannot travel.

### Reinventing surveillance, data, and risk assessment
- Adapting analytical methods:
  - Traditional macroeconomic surveillance focuses on measuring and addressing quantifiable risks using macroeconomic data to create baseline scenarios and estimate likelihoods.
  - Post-global financial crisis, the approach broadened to use various scenarios and probability analysis to understand risks around numeric forecasts.
  - The pandemic’s size and simultaneity drive extreme Knightian uncertainty and require greater agility.
  - IMF actions: engaged epidemiologists to combine forecasting models; incorporated new sources of big data to understand consumer behavior where traditional statistics fell short; used military-style simulations to study escalating trade tensions.
- Cautionary example:
  - A US epidemiologist and a German reinsurance company developed a pandemic insurance product with health models, early warning systems, economic impact estimates for vulnerable industries, and risk-distribution plans. The policy became available in late 2018, but potential clients found it too expensive for such an unlikely event; when the catastrophe materialized in early 2020, it was too late to buy insurance.

### Policy implications and recommendations
- Balance between efficiency and resilience:
  - Manufacturers must balance just-in-time (cheaper but inflexible) and just-in-case (more resilient but costlier) supply-chain strategies while factoring trade, logistics, and sanitary conditions.
  - Reverting entirely to pre-pandemic approaches is reckless; erring too much on resilience could decrease productivity.
- Need for improved risk assessment and innovation:
  - Improve risk assessment and management across private and public sectors; develop early warning systems and better-distributed risk instruments.
- Global cooperation:
  - Finding a new equilibrium between risk and resilience amid uncertainty requires effort, patience, innovative thinking, and more global cooperation: “Everyone will be safe only when each one is safe.”

*GEOFFREY OKAMOTO is the first deputy managing director of the IMF.*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/fandd/article/2020/september/balancing-risk-and-resilience-geoffrey-okamoto.pdf_
