## distributional-effects-of-monetary-policy-budina-fratto-igan-poirson

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [distributional-effects-of-monetary-policy-budina-fratto-igan-poirson](https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/fandd/article/2021/june/distributional-effects-of-monetary-policy-budina-fratto-igan-poirson.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/files/publications/fandd/article/2021/june/distributional-effects-of-monetary-policy-budina-fratto-igan-poirson.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/files/publications/fandd/article/2021/june/distributional-effects-of-monetary-policy-budina-fratto-igan-poirson.pdf.json)

---

### Overview
- Central banks have used extensive monetary easing during the COVID-19 pandemic, including interest rate cuts and asset purchases, which have helped limit the economic fallout.
- Monetary easing can both exacerbate and reduce inequality depending on channels and household characteristics.
- Key empirical context:
  - Chart data period: 2000–19.
  - Unemployment volatility comparisons use ages 15–24 for youth and ages 55–65 for old-age unemployment.

### Illustration: The Sampsons (household-level effects)
- Lisa (early twenties, low-skilled waitress, nursing student)
  - More likely to become unemployed in recessions (youth unemployment is more sensitive to economic cycles).
  - Benefits from monetary easing via the labor earnings channel (reduced unemployment risk) and from lower debt servicing costs if loans are adjustable or refinanced.
  - Does not benefit directly from higher capital income or higher asset prices if she owns no assets.
- Arturo (accountant in his fifties)
  - Earns wages, has capital income from bonds and stocks, and owns a house.
  - Benefits from higher capital income and higher asset values via the balance sheet channel.
  - If a net saver, lower interest rates reduce his interest income (savings redistribution channel).
- Margarita and Homero (retired savers)
  - Rely on retirement income and bank deposit interest.
  - Lose from lower interest income when rates fall; real retirement income could fall if inflation rises.
  - Losses on interest income could be offset by higher home values or by reduced need to support family members if employment improves.

### Distributional channels of monetary policy (enumerated)
- Labor earnings channel
  - Monetary easing stimulates economic activity and reduces unemployment, disproportionately benefiting younger, less experienced, and lower-paid workers.
- Balance sheet channel
  - Higher asset prices (stocks, bonds, real estate) increase wealth for asset holders.
- Income composition (capital income) channel
  - Owners of financial assets gain from higher capital income; this matters most for the wealthiest households.
- Savings redistribution channel
  - Monetary easing redistributes from savers to borrowers by lowering interest income for savers and lowering borrowing costs for debtors.
- Cross-country modifiers
  - Financial inclusion: greater access to credit means poorer households can benefit from lower rates (e.g., mortgages).
  - Financial system type: bank-based systems concentrate deposits among savers who may lose from rate cuts.
  - Social protection: extensive social protection can mute the employment-related benefits for lower-income workers.

### Empirical patterns and key statistics
- Asset composition highlights:
  - In the United States, almost two-thirds of the assets of the wealthiest 10 percent are in bonds (16 percent) and stocks (46 percent).
  - Except for the wealthiest 10 percent, real estate is the largest asset for most households in both the European Union and the United States.
- Pre–COVID-19 studies combining channels:
  - Find mixed and often economically negligible net distributional effects overall from transitory monetary policy easing.
  - U.S. evidence: income inequality rises and consumption inequality falls following monetary easing; effects are small and temporary (Kaplan, Moll, and Violante 2018).
- Chart context:
  - Youth unemployment volatility measured for ages 15–24 and old-age unemployment volatility for ages 55–65 over 2000–19.

### Policy implications and recommendations
- Monetary policy is a blunt tool for addressing long-term or group-specific inequality; structural factors driving inequality are better addressed by fiscal and structural policies.
- Central banks should remain focused on primary mandates (price and output stability) to effectively counter downturns and protect jobs.
- Within existing frameworks, central banks should:
  - Better understand and factor household heterogeneity into policy analysis (modeling and analysis of the distribution of income and wealth that affects policy transmission).
  - Communicate explicitly about the distributional effects of monetary policy actions—both positive and negative—through speeches, official reports, and community outreach.
  - Highlight counterfactuals showing overall welfare gains from monetary actions (for example, improved employment prospects for the poorest and reductions in consumption inequality).
- Complementary policies:
  - Supportive fiscal policy and well-sequenced structural reforms (including active labor market policies, job search assistance, and retraining) can improve both macroeconomic and distributional outcomes.
- Institutional developments:
  - Major central banks have begun to explicitly discuss distributional effects (Carney 2016; Lane 2019).
  - The Federal Reserve has revised its mandate to emphasize maximum employment as a broad-based, inclusive goal.

### Role during and beyond COVID-19
- The pandemic has considerable distributional effects; the relative importance of monetary policy channels may change if the pandemic persistently alters income and wealth distributions.
- Central banks should monitor, analyze, and communicate distributional effects while clarifying that long-term increases in inequality and declines in interest rates are largely driven by structural factors addressable mainly by other government policies.

*Authors: Nina Budina, Chiara Fratto, Deniz Igan, and Hélène Poirson — Finance & Development, June 2021*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/fandd/article/2021/june/distributional-effects-of-monetary-policy-budina-fratto-igan-poirson.pdf_