## the-future-of-china-dollar-huang-yao

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [the-future-of-china-dollar-huang-yao](https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/fandd/article/2021/june/the-future-of-china-dollar-huang-yao.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/files/publications/fandd/article/2021/june/the-future-of-china-dollar-huang-yao.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/files/publications/fandd/article/2021/june/the-future-of-china-dollar-huang-yao.pdf.json)

---

### Aging population: scale, implications, and labor-force responses
- Total fertility has dropped to 1.7 births per woman, far below the replacement rate of 2.1.
- China’s population may have already peaked; the working-age population has already started to decline.
- The over-65 cohort will more than double to 400 million people by 2049.
- The “old-old,” 85 and over, will more than triple to about 150 million people, surpassing their peers in the United States and Europe combined.
- The only working-age bracket that will increase is the 55- to 64-year-olds.
- Social and economic consequences:
  - Greater demand for health care, long-term care, and assisted living.
  - Smaller families mean many elders may lack private family support, creating rationale to socialize care costs.
  - COVID-19 exposed strengths and weaknesses of the health care system and highlighted the need to strengthen and resource health care, especially in rural areas.
- Labor-force policy responses:
  - Retirement-age reform and gradual increases are needed (current norms cited: male civil servants can retire at 60, female civil servants at 55).
  - Policies to sustain and enhance female labor force participation, and enabling healthy older people to continue working, can mitigate labor-force decline.
- Demographic timing note: Even some increase in fertility would not affect the labor force for 20 years.

### Urban-rural divide and internal migration
- Urbanization trajectory:
  - Urban population rose from 20 percent at the beginning of reform to 60 percent today.
  - Urbanization has been driven by migration that includes more than 200 million urban migrant workers still registered as rural residents under the hukou system.
- Income and consumption gaps:
  - By 2007, urban workers were making 3.14 times as much as those in rural areas.
  - More recently the gap is described as urban workers making 2.71 times more.
- Social impacts of hukou and migration controls:
  - Migrants face constraints on bringing children or parents to cities because of limited access to education, health care, and pensions, producing divided families and care burdens on grandparents.
  - Restrictions are being relaxed in smaller cities (example: Jiangxi province), but remain strong in high-productivity centers such as Guangzhou and Shanghai.
- Land and productivity constraints:
  - China has about one-fifth of the world’s population but only 7 percent of its arable land, constraining rural livelihoods for about 500 million people.
  - China’s urbanization rate is low relative to its per capita income and population density; comparator example: South Korea had urbanization closer to 80 percent at a similar stage.
- Policy recommendation:
  - Fully scrapping internal migration restrictions would support social integration of the elderly and children, improve access to education and medical care, and help maintain an adequate urban workforce.

### Financial system, investment allocation, and innovation
- Financial repression and history:
  - An index of “financial repression” places China among the most repressed among major economies, similar to India; moderately more repressed than Russia and South Africa; considerably less liberalized than advanced economies.
  - Liberalization progressed until about 2000 but stalled thereafter.
- Role of financial repression historically:
  - Early liberalization helped channel high savings into export-oriented manufacturing and housing where lending relied on physical collateral.
  - The period 2001–2008 was a “golden age” with rapid credit growth and stable nonfinancial corporate debt to GDP metrics.
- Post-2008 dynamics:
  - Massive investment in infrastructure and lending to local governments and state-dominated upstream sectors (e.g., steel) increased overall indebtedness.
  - Central government channeled more resources into key state enterprises to build “global champions,” amplifying leverage.
  - A rapidly rising leverage ratio is interpreted as financing poor investments, indicating weak capital allocation in the new environment.
- Productivity and innovation indicators:
  - Total factor productivity (TFP) grew 2.6 percent a year in the early 2000s, accelerating to 3.9 percent in the later part of the past decade.
  - Since the global financial crisis disruption, TFP has not recovered, growing only 0.2 percent a year between 2015 and 2019.
  - China spends 2.4 percent of GDP on research and development.
  - China has many innovation inputs: a large domestic market; millions of scientists, engineers, and software developers graduating each year; gradually improving intellectual property protection; and strong fintech and artificial intelligence activity—but innovation output is inconsistent and economy-wide productivity is weak.
- Structural issue:
  - The financial system better funds firms with traditional assets (buildings, machinery) than dynamic start-ups based on intellectual property; state channels favor state enterprises while most patents are generated by private firms.
- Policy recommendation:
  - Strengthen the innovation ecosystem and diversify the financial system to support innovation rather than continue targeted industrial policies that favor specific firms or technologies.
  - Move toward a diversified, competitive financial system that does not favor state enterprises.

### Trade, investment, and external relations
- China’s global integration:
  - Transitioned from near self-sufficiency to the world’s largest trading nation and, in the referenced year, the largest recipient of foreign direct investment.
- External tensions and risks:
  - Concerns in partner countries about China’s leadership in specific technologies have led to trade and investment restrictions on Chinese tech firms, raising the risk of technological decoupling.
  - Technological decoupling would harm China and global productivity growth.
- Multilateral and bilateral engagement:
  - China joined the Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership and concluded the Comprehensive Agreement on Investment with the European Union.
  - China has engaged in dialogue with Trans-Pacific Partnership members about future membership, which would require reforms such as limits on state enterprises and subsidies and opening new sectors to foreign investment.
  - China has made overtures to the Biden administration about reducing trade and investment barriers.
- Policy recommendation:
  - Continue opening the economy and negotiating trade and investment agreements in all directions to sustain catch-up, while addressing domestic reforms that make such opening credible and sustainable.

### Integrated conclusion and policy priorities
- Central thesis:
  - China’s long-term success toward the 2049 goal depends primarily on addressing internal challenges.
- Interlinked domestic priorities:
  - The aging population and the rural-urban divide are interrelated: better integration and removal of migration restrictions can help care for the elderly and prevent an unnecessary decline in the urban labor force.
  - Financial reform and innovation policy are interrelated: shifting from targeted industrial policy to general support for innovation requires a diversified, competitive financial system that no longer favors state enterprises.
  - Innovation is essential to achieve the target of zero net carbon emissions by 2060 without compromising productivity or living standards.
- Policy package implied:
  - Reform retirement age and social policies to sustain labor-force participation.
  - Remove or relax hukou-based restrictions to integrate migrants socially and economically.
  - Diversify and liberalize financial markets to improve capital allocation toward innovation and private-sector patent generators.
  - Continue opening to global trade and investment while negotiating agreements that reinforce domestic reform commitments.

*Source: the-future-of-china-dollar-huang-yao (PDF chapter/section)*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/fandd/article/2021/june/the-future-of-china-dollar-huang-yao.pdf_
