## Embracing the Gift of Global Talent

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [Embracing the Gift of Global Talent](https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/fandd/article/2021/march/en/embracing-the-gift-of-global-talent-agarwal-en.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/files/publications/fandd/article/2021/march/en/embracing-the-gift-of-global-talent-agarwal-en.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/files/publications/fandd/article/2021/march/en/embracing-the-gift-of-global-talent-agarwal-en.pdf.json)

---

### Background and motivation
- Talent is globally distributed but concentrated nurturing is uneven; since World War II the United States has been a hub for foreign talent and plays an outsized role in the global knowledge network of scientific activity.
- Recent disruptions and policy changes affecting cross-border flows:
  - The number of student (F-1) visas issued by the United States fell 70 percent between fiscal years 2019 and 2020.
  - On September 25, 2020, the Department of Homeland Security proposed a rule to end the “duration of status” on visas for foreign students and exchange visitors (and journalists).
- The study examines how US immigration barriers affect the global advancement of science and quantifies potential gains from easing barriers and expanding scholarships, especially for those born in developing economies.

### Evidence and data sources used
- International Mathematical Olympiad (IMO) as a natural laboratory:
  - IMO held annually since 1959 and includes more than 100 countries.
  - Hand-collected career data on all IMO participants competing between 1981 and 2000: 4,710 participants, of which 2,272 received a medal.
- Additional datasets:
  - 89,068 math PhD recipients used in comparative analysis.
  - Career histories of Nobel laureates, Fields medalists, and IMO participants.
  - New survey data of 610 recent IMO participants on university applications, admissions, attendance, and hypothetical choice tradeoffs (funded vs unfunded).
- Prior work referenced: “Invisible Geniuses: Could the Knowledge Frontier Advance Faster?” (American Economic Review: Insights, December 2020).

### Key empirical findings
- Talent signal and long-term productivity:
  - Success in the IMO strongly correlates with indicators of scientific productivity, including winning the Fields Medal.
  - On average about 8 percent of IMO participants earn a gold medal, 16 percent earn a silver medal, and 24 percent earn a bronze medal.
  - The probability of an IMO gold medalist winning a Fields Medal is 50 times greater than the probability of a PhD graduate from a top-10 mathematics program doing so.
- Developing-economy penalty:
  - A participant born in a low-income country produces 34 percent fewer mathematics publications than an equally talented participant from a high-income country.
  - A participant born in a low-income country receives 56 percent fewer mathematics citations than an equally talented participant from a high-income country.
- Role of migrants to the United States:
  - Migrants to the United States represent 20–33 percent of frontier knowledge producers (documented using Nobel Prize winners and Fields medalists).
  - Foreign-born people who relocated to the United States represent 21 percent of the world’s Nobel Prizes in science and 33 percent of the world’s Fields Medals.
  - Migrants to the United States are four to six times more productive than stayers (those who remained in their country of birth).
  - Migrants to the United Kingdom are more than twice as productive as stayers.
  - The US productivity premium arises roughly equally from the extensive margin (migrants are more likely to choose academic careers) and the intensive margin (among academics, migrants to the US are more productive).
- Financing and access constraints:
  - Among developing-economy IMO participants in the survey, 66 percent dream of studying in the United States, while only 25 percent manage to do so.
  - Forty percent of respondents report that the availability of financial assistance was “very important” or “extremely important” to their decision to attend their particular undergraduate institution rather than a different one.
  - The share reporting financial assistance as “very important” or “extremely important” rises to 56 percent for developing-economy participants.

### Quantified impact and scenarios
- Policy counterfactual:
  - Certain policy changes that reduce immigration barriers to the United States—by addressing financing constraints for top foreign talent—could increase the global scientific output of future cohorts of talent by up to 42 percent.
  - This estimated improvement combines:
    - The large US productivity premium for talented migrants.
    - The sizeable unmet aspiration among talented youth to study in the United States due to financing constraints.

### Policy implications and recommended actions
- Reduce immigration barriers to allow talented individuals to move to environments that best nurture their abilities.
- Expand scholarships and financial assistance targeted at top foreign students, especially those born in developing economies, to bridge the gap between aspiration and actual migration.
- Invest in strengthening research institutions in more countries to nurture domestic talent and provide high-quality options for those who prefer not to emigrate or cannot do so.
- Timely action by global policymakers and the scientific community is needed to ensure equal opportunities for talented individuals and to accelerate the global advancement of science and knowledge.

*Source: Embracing the Gift of Global Talent — Ruchir Agarwal, Ina Ganguli, and Patrick Gaule (Finance & Development, March 2021).*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/fandd/article/2021/march/en/embracing-the-gift-of-global-talent-agarwal-en.pdf_
