## Embrace Debate — Karnit Flug

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [Embrace Debate — Karnit Flug](https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/fandd/article/2023/march/trenches-karnit-flug.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/files/publications/fandd/article/2023/march/trenches-karnit-flug.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/files/publications/fandd/article/2023/march/trenches-karnit-flug.pdf.json)

---

### Central bank accountability and transparency
- Central banks face "unprecedented scrutiny" as they attempt to fend off inflation and global recession.
- Accountability can be advanced by:
  - "the requirement for transparency"
  - "expert evaluations"
  - "lively public debate"
- Flug’s practice as governor: be "transparent and professional in your analysis" and "active in public debate on the basis of high-quality research."
- Institutional role note: under the original 1954 central bank law, the Bank of Israel governor is also an economic advisor to the government; that advisory role is traditionally public and contributes to public discourse.

### Lessons from past inflation and policy responses
- Comparison with 1984 peak inflation:
  - Prices had increased by "445 percent" at the 1984 peak.
  - Public deficit was "about 15 percent of GDP."
  - Debt was "280 percent of GDP."
  - There was no central bank independence then; the "no printing clause" was introduced as part of the stabilization program to prevent the central bank from financing government deficits.
- On the 1970s–80s experience: politicians had an "inflation bias" believing they could tolerate "a little more inflation" for "a little more economic activity and employment," which proved hard to control and risked initiating a spiral of inflation expectations with high welfare costs.
- On the global financial crisis and COVID-19 responses:
  - The monetary policy response to the global financial crisis was "broadly correct" and "saved the world from a much deeper and longer recession."
  - After COVID-19, massive monetary and fiscal expansion was again necessary, but "the withdrawal of the extreme fiscal and monetary support came too late" in some places.
  - Continued extremely expansionary fiscal policy combined with "extremely accommodative" monetary policy, when met with supply constraints (factory closures in China and elsewhere, and the war in the Ukraine), contributed to rapid inflation.
  - There was "a delay in the realization that demand was playing an important role, and it wasn’t just supply shocks," necessitating a faster withdrawal of expansion that "has still not been achieved everywhere."

### Advice for central bankers and interaction with policymakers
- When at odds with policymakers, central bankers should:
  - Remain transparent and professional.
  - Use high-quality research to inform and participate in public debate.
- Political pressures in Israel: some Knesset members seek initiatives (example given: exempting single homeowners from increases in mortgage interest rates). Flug warns such initiatives "are not helpful" because they may:
  - Reduce the effectiveness of monetary policy via self-restraint.
  - Affect expectations and thereby make monetary policy less effective.
- On the trade-off between inflation and activity: Flug rejects exploiting a trade-off to engineer "just slightly higher inflation for higher activity," stressing that once inflation accelerates "it’s very hard to control."

### Use of research in policymaking
- Flug’s research background and "managing the research department at the Bank of Israel for 10 years" helped her:
  - Understand what questions models can answer and their limitations.
  - Assess where to use models versus relying on basic theory or simple analysis of recent data.

### Personal progression and representation
- Flug’s career path: first governor "from the ranks" at the Bank of Israel, having "started as a young economist at the bank and rose all the way to the top"; previous governors had been "well-known economists appointed from the outside."
- Gender and role-modeling:
  - She "was always asked" about being the first female governor and "realized that I served as some kind of role model."
  - At international governors’ meetings she was sometimes "the only woman in a room with 35 or 40 male governors," which could be "a little intimidating," though representation increased over time.

*Source: Interview with Karnit Flug, Finance & Development, March 2023 (edited for length and clarity).*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/fandd/article/2023/march/trenches-karnit-flug.pdf_