## What Is Inclusive Growth?

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [What Is Inclusive Growth?](https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/fandd/article/2024/03/b2b0324.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/files/publications/fandd/article/2024/03/b2b0324.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/files/publications/fandd/article/2024/03/b2b0324.pdf.json)

---

### Definition and framing
- Inclusive growth seeks to boost national wealth and well-being while reducing poverty, ensuring equity across generations, and preserving economic freedoms.
- Different interpretations of freedom shape policy:
  - Libertarian view: minimal state intervention and free markets.
  - Capabilities approach (Amartya Sen): emphasizes the presence of opportunities to be healthy, educated, and secure, not just absence of restrictions.
- Trade-offs pervade policy choices: every policy involves balancing economic freedom, equality, and growth.

### Wealth redistribution: scenarios and trade-offs
- Baseline scenario described: a flat income tax of 30 percent on all.
- Policy scenario: increase the tax rate for the richest to 50 percent.
- Representative positions:
  - Conservative approach:
    - Oppose raising the top rate from 30 percent to 50 percent.
    - Prioritizes economic freedom and growth; favors a uniform tax.
  - Broader inclusive-growth approach:
    - Support a top rate of 50 percent if extra revenue is targeted to poverty reduction.
    - Willing to trade some economic freedom for targeted anti-poverty initiatives.
  - Progressive approach:
    - Support a top rate of 50 percent to reduce wealth inequality regardless of specific spending uses.
- Additional progressive proposals discussed:
  - More labor rights, antitrust laws, higher minimum wages, subsidies, and industrial policies to counter corporate dominance and target job creation in neglected areas.
- Concerns about industrial policies:
  - Potential negative growth effects.
  - Governments’ limited ability to implement such policies.
  - Risk of a global shift toward protectionist trade.

### Future generations and climate policy
- Intergenerational considerations: how current actions affect children, grandchildren, and other species.
- Climate policy scenario:
  - Carbon tax proposal of $35 a metric ton.
  - Estimated effect: would raise costs on electricity, gasoline, and heating by about 20 percent for everyone.
- Representative positions:
  - Oppose the carbon tax:
    - Prioritizes current economic growth and freedoms.
    - Skeptical of sacrificing present resources for uncertain future gains.
    - Concern for immediate impacts on poorer households; reflects views of some developing economies.
  - Support the carbon tax:
    - Prioritizes well-being of future generations and safeguards freedoms and choices of those yet to come.
    - Aligns with carbon pricing policies considered by several advanced economies.
    - May reflect broader valuation of the intrinsic worth of nature and biodiversity beyond human-centric benefits.
- Inclusive growth requires balancing needs of current and future generations; existential threats and long-term sustainability can shift typical stances on taxation and regulation.

### Public goods, market failures, and government capacity
- Public goods considered: education, health care, and nonmarket well-being (e.g., clean air) not measured in GDP.
- Market failures motivating government action:
  - Externalities (e.g., polluters not paying for environmental damage).
  - Underinvestment in education and health care.
  - Greater need for intervention in developing economies due to poor infrastructure and limited access to quality services.
- Views on government provision:
  - Supporters: trust government to provide public goods and fix market imbalances.
  - Skeptics: fear government failure, corruption, and unintended consequences; prefer market-based solutions.
  - Market-based alternative referenced: Ronald Coase’s idea that clear property rights and minimal transaction costs can lead to efficient outcomes without government intervention.
- Core choice reflects trust in government versus faith in market mechanisms.

### Synthesis: what inclusive growth emphasizes
- Inclusive growth focuses on creating a level playing field where futures are determined by talent and effort rather than background.
- It differs from policies aimed primarily at redistributing wealth across individuals or regions; instead it emphasizes equal opportunity alongside wealth creation and economic freedom.
- The appropriate role of government depends on individual values, trust in political actors, and local realities.

*Ruchir Agarwal is a research fellow at the Harvard Kennedy School and cofounder of the Global Talent Network and the Global Talent Lab.*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/fandd/article/2024/03/b2b0324.pdf_