## Box 1. The African Tax Institute

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [Box 1. The African Tax Institute](https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/howtonotes/howtonote1707.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/files/publications/howtonotes/howtonote1707.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/files/publications/howtonotes/howtonote1707.pdf.json)

---

### Interactions between the TPU and the Revenue Administration
- Tax policy analysts should consult with the revenue administration’s operational managers on the feasibility of tax policy proposals under consideration.
- Revenue administration managers should:
  - Alert the TPU of possible weaknesses in tax legislation identified while processing and auditing tax declarations.
  - Ensure anonymized taxpayer data is made available regularly in the format and within timeframes required by the TPU.
- Institutional roles over the policy cycle:
  - Ministry of Finance role: Decides the broad policy parameters, taking into account advice on practical administrative and compliance considerations. Greater relative influence during the early stages of policy development when broad policy issues are decided.
  - Revenue Administration role: Advises ministry of finance on likely administrative and compliance issues of high level policy options. Responsible for specification of the operational policy features, including those that must be codified in legislation. Greater influence during detailed operational design of legislation.
- Recommendation: Formalize the TPU–revenue administration relationship under a firm institutional arrangement (for example, a protocol), especially where the revenue administration is a semi-autonomous revenue authority.
- Conflict resolution: The protocol should provide for conflict resolution when the Treasury and revenue administration cannot agree. The Treasury must ensure the revenue administration’s opposing view is provided to the executive (the minister) in the format approved by the revenue administration; the minister should provide direction and utilize input from legislative counsel or a tax advisory body.

### Access to Taxpayer Data and Confidentiality
- TPU access to taxpayer data is essential for modeling and analysis, but such data are legally protected and often subject to strict secrecy rules.
- Safeguards and modalities:
  - Identity of taxpayers must be concealed, or for large taxpayers information must be merged with aggregate data if identification would otherwise be possible (for example, if only one big oil company or brewery is operating in the jurisdiction).
  - Access to taxpayer data is best achieved through signing binding protocols; informal understandings or individual conduct are insufficient.
  - Allowing TPU staff to take oaths of secrecy to access confidential individualized taxpayer data is neither common nor favored by revenue administrations.
  - The TPU may encourage revenue administrations to share anonymized taxpayer data with academic researchers or international organizations under strict disclosure agreements.
- Recommendation: TPU should be supported by a binding agreement with the revenue administration about accessing sanitized taxpayer data for modeling purposes—while honoring important taxpayer confidentiality protocols enforced by the revenue administration.

### Coordination with External Stakeholders and Public Engagement
- The TPU should coordinate with the private sector, the statistical office, and parliament’s legislative counsel to ensure smooth and sound tax reform processes that receive broad public support.
- TPUs should be judicious about which external institutions contribute to tax policy formulation to avoid perceptions of state capture by private sector interests.
- Communication and transparency:
  - Stakeholders should be informed about the need for tax policy reforms through active information campaigns.
  - TPU research and policy discussion papers should be widely available on the government’s website.
- Use of commissions and advisory boards:
  - Special one-off commissions have been used to deflect political difficulties during major structural tax reforms; examples of countries using commissions include Australia, Canada, Columbia, Germany, India, Italy, Japan, the Netherlands, New Zealand, Norway, Poland, South Africa, Sweden, and the United Kingdom.
  - Risks: Governments may appoint commissions to postpone hard decisions or cherry-pick acceptable recommendations while ignoring elements critical to the tax system’s integrity.
  - Permanent review bodies or tax advisory boards can screen public support before draft legislation is tabled; governance rules should excuse members from deliberating on matters where they have a direct interest to mitigate lobbying or special-interest capture.

### The Australian Integration Model (summary)
- Designed to move from a sequential to a holistic tax design process by combining units of different institutions in project committees or cross-functional teams.
- Key features:
  - Membership drawn from the Treasury’s tax policy unit, the revenue administration and its specialist units, and parliament’s counsel.
  - Treasury’s TPU retains primary accountability for tax policy development and oversight of tax laws and regulations.
  - The Australian Taxation Office is primarily responsible for design and development of legislative, administrative, and compliance systems and for implementation and ongoing administration.
  - The Office of Parliamentary Counsel has primary responsibility for detailed tax design and drafting of tax legislation.
- Operational requirements for working committees: proper resourcing, agreed research briefs, appointed team leaders, and effective project management arrangements.

### How to Establish a TPU: Practical Lessons and Recommendations
- 1. Establishing a TPU requires broad support in government and wide political consensus on the importance of effective, efficient, and fair domestic revenue mobilization. The ministry of finance should convey the TPU’s central role.
- 2. A TPU may start on a small scale and grow gradually. Example initial composition for low-income countries: a small TPU comprising perhaps five staff—for example, two analysts focusing on direct and indirect taxes, one tax lawyer, and two economists in the revenue analysis section (focusing on tax expenditure budgeting and revenue projections).
- 3. The revenue analysis section of the TPU may initially operate as a technical working group with delegated staff, for example, from the statistical bureau, leveraging scarce skills until TPU capacity expands.
- 4. Drafting of tax laws may initially be assigned to the attorney general’s office, with growing TPU involvement over time. An interdepartmental committee with treasury and revenue administration representation can execute the legal drafting process; ultimately, TPU tax lawyers may draft laws or provide expert advice where drafting is in another agency.
- 5. The TPU should ultimately employ an interdisciplinary group of experts with qualifications in economics, econometrics, statistics, tax law, and accountancy. Staff should have advanced academic qualifications and experience in government, budgeting, and taxation.
- 6. TPU staff positions need clear job descriptions and performance agreements aligned with the short- and medium-term strategic plans of the unit.
- 7. TPU leadership must have solid experience in tax policy theory and contemporary tax debates; leadership should be apolitical to provide objective advice and will engage with legislative counsel, parliament’s committees on public finance, taxpayer associations, and practitioners.
- 8. The TPU should be supported by a binding agreement with the revenue administration about accessing sanitized taxpayer data for modeling purposes—while honoring taxpayer confidentiality protocols enforced by the revenue administration.
- 9. A newly created TPU should disseminate information publicly—for example, through releasing tax analysis working papers and aggregated tax statistics (for example, revenue structure, sectors’ revenue contributions, and distributional analyses)—to improve public profile and perceptions of objectivity.
- 10. Complex analyses may be contracted out to local academic institutions as part of long-term academic backstopping; include an internship program managed by the TPU to identify, attract, and retain competent analysts. TPU management should mentor staff and encourage life-long training.

### Implementation caveat
- The translation of these lessons into operational advice requires assessment of country-specific circumstances, capabilities, and preferences.

*International Monetary Fund | October 2017*

### Box 1. The African Tax Institute

### Box 1. The African Tax Institute

### Interactions between the TPU and the Revenue Administration
- Tax policy analysts should consult with the revenue administration’s operational managers on the feasibility of tax policy proposals under consideration.
- Revenue administration managers should:
  - Alert the TPU of possible weaknesses in tax legislation identified while processing and auditing tax declarations.
  - Ensure anonymized taxpayer data is made available regularly in the format and within timeframes required by the TPU.
- Institutional roles over the policy cycle:
  - Ministry of Finance role: Decides the broad policy parameters, taking into account advice on practical administrative and compliance considerations. Greater relative influence during the early stages of policy development when broad policy issues are decided.
  - Revenue Administration role: Advises ministry of finance on likely administrative and compliance issues of high level policy options. Responsible for specification of the operational policy features, including those that must be codified in legislation. Greater influence during detailed operational design of legislation.
- Recommendation: Formalize the TPU–revenue administration relationship under a firm institutional arrangement (for example, a protocol), especially where the revenue administration is a semi-autonomous revenue authority.
- Conflict resolution: The protocol should provide for conflict resolution when the Treasury and revenue administration cannot agree. The Treasury must ensure the revenue administration’s opposing view is provided to the executive (the minister) in the format approved by the revenue administration; the minister should provide direction and utilize input from legislative counsel or a tax advisory body.

### Access to Taxpayer Data and Confidentiality
- TPU access to taxpayer data is essential for modeling and analysis, but such data are legally protected and often subject to strict secrecy rules.
- Safeguards and modalities:
  - Identity of taxpayers must be concealed, or for large taxpayers information must be merged with aggregate data if identification would otherwise be possible (for example, if only one big oil company or brewery is operating in the jurisdiction).
  - Access to taxpayer data is best achieved through signing binding protocols; informal understandings or individual conduct are insufficient.
  - Allowing TPU staff to take oaths of secrecy to access confidential individualized taxpayer data is neither common nor favored by revenue administrations.
  - The TPU may encourage revenue administrations to share anonymized taxpayer data with academic researchers or international organizations under strict disclosure agreements.
- Recommendation: TPU should be supported by a binding agreement with the revenue administration about accessing sanitized taxpayer data for modeling purposes—while honoring important taxpayer confidentiality protocols enforced by the revenue administration.

### Coordination with External Stakeholders and Public Engagement
- The TPU should coordinate with the private sector, the statistical office, and parliament’s legislative counsel to ensure smooth and sound tax reform processes that receive broad public support.
- TPUs should be judicious about which external institutions contribute to tax policy formulation to avoid perceptions of state capture by private sector interests.
- Communication and transparency:
  - Stakeholders should be informed about the need for tax policy reforms through active information campaigns.
  - TPU research and policy discussion papers should be widely available on the government’s website.
- Use of commissions and advisory boards:
  - Special one-off commissions have been used to deflect political difficulties during major structural tax reforms; examples of countries using commissions include Australia, Canada, Columbia, Germany, India, Italy, Japan, the Netherlands, New Zealand, Norway, Poland, South Africa, Sweden, and the United Kingdom.
  - Risks: Governments may appoint commissions to postpone hard decisions or cherry-pick acceptable recommendations while ignoring elements critical to the tax system’s integrity.
  - Permanent review bodies or tax advisory boards can screen public support before draft legislation is tabled; governance rules should excuse members from deliberating on matters where they have a direct interest to mitigate lobbying or special-interest capture.

### The Australian Integration Model (summary)
- Designed to move from a sequential to a holistic tax design process by combining units of different institutions in project committees or cross-functional teams.
- Key features:
  - Membership drawn from the Treasury’s tax policy unit, the revenue administration and its specialist units, and parliament’s counsel.
  - Treasury’s TPU retains primary accountability for tax policy development and oversight of tax laws and regulations.
  - The Australian Taxation Office is primarily responsible for design and development of legislative, administrative, and compliance systems and for implementation and ongoing administration.
  - The Office of Parliamentary Counsel has primary responsibility for detailed tax design and drafting of tax legislation.
- Operational requirements for working committees: proper resourcing, agreed research briefs, appointed team leaders, and effective project management arrangements.

### How to Establish a TPU: Practical Lessons and Recommendations
- 1. Establishing a TPU requires broad support in government and wide political consensus on the importance of effective, efficient, and fair domestic revenue mobilization. The ministry of finance should convey the TPU’s central role.
- 2. A TPU may start on a small scale and grow gradually. Example initial composition for low-income countries: a small TPU comprising perhaps five staff—for example, two analysts focusing on direct and indirect taxes, one tax lawyer, and two economists in the revenue analysis section (focusing on tax expenditure budgeting and revenue projections).
- 3. The revenue analysis section of the TPU may initially operate as a technical working group with delegated staff, for example, from the statistical bureau, leveraging scarce skills until TPU capacity expands.
- 4. Drafting of tax laws may initially be assigned to the attorney general’s office, with growing TPU involvement over time. An interdepartmental committee with treasury and revenue administration representation can execute the legal drafting process; ultimately, TPU tax lawyers may draft laws or provide expert advice where drafting is in another agency.
- 5. The TPU should ultimately employ an interdisciplinary group of experts with qualifications in economics, econometrics, statistics, tax law, and accountancy. Staff should have advanced academic qualifications and experience in government, budgeting, and taxation.
- 6. TPU staff positions need clear job descriptions and performance agreements aligned with the short- and medium-term strategic plans of the unit.
- 7. TPU leadership must have solid experience in tax policy theory and contemporary tax debates; leadership should be apolitical to provide objective advice and will engage with legislative counsel, parliament’s committees on public finance, taxpayer associations, and practitioners.
- 8. The TPU should be supported by a binding agreement with the revenue administration about accessing sanitized taxpayer data for modeling purposes—while honoring taxpayer confidentiality protocols enforced by the revenue administration.
- 9. A newly created TPU should disseminate information publicly—for example, through releasing tax analysis working papers and aggregated tax statistics (for example, revenue structure, sectors’ revenue contributions, and distributional analyses)—to improve public profile and perceptions of objectivity.
- 10. Complex analyses may be contracted out to local academic institutions as part of long-term academic backstopping; include an internship program managed by the TPU to identify, attract, and retain competent analysts. TPU management should mentor staff and encourage life-long training.

### Implementation caveat
- The translation of these lessons into operational advice requires assessment of country-specific circumstances, capabilities, and preferences.

*International Monetary Fund | October 2017*

### 2. Austria

### 2. Austria

### Institutional roles and responsibilities
- Experts in the Ministry of Finance (MOF) design tax policies and—through a consultative process with representatives from other ministries, scholars, external experts—draft the annual finance bill with the contained tax proposals.
- Legal specialists drive the design of the tax bill and its associated regulations. Given the complex technical nature of tax law, the MOF’s technocrats lead the process.
- The Council of Ministers (cabinet), after the public comment period, authorizes the tax law’s promulgation on the basis of unanimous approval.

### Social partnership and stakeholder participation
- The post-World War II “social partnership” requires the reconciliation of social partners’ different interests—namely:
  - the Austrian Federal Economic Chamber;
  - the Chamber of Agriculture;
  - the Austrian Federal Chamber of Labor; and
  - the Austrian Trade Union Federation.
- Each of these bodies have their own tax experts that participate, through comments, in the conceptualization phase towards a draft tax law.

### Legislative process and transparency requirements
- The legislative process must be fair and transparent and it must ensure that the general public is adequately informed.
- Formal requirements and compliance with specific deadlines are especially important to ensure transparency.
- In order for the National Council to be able to assess a tax proposal, a bill must be presented in the form of a motion.
- In the National Council, bills are deliberated in the relevant committees and in the plenary. Before a bill is adopted, it must be studied and discussed in detail.
- The Federal Provinces are also involved in the legislative process. Their representatives in the Federal Council can confirm, or veto, a bill passed by the National Council.
- Before a law enters into force, it must be authenticated by the federal president as having been passed in good order. Once authenticated, it is published in the Federal Law Gazette.

### Public consultation and circulation of drafts
- A draft tax bill is circulated to all state departments, federal governments, and interest groups for comment.
- The draft is also published on the home page of the parliament’s website, allowing all political stakeholders to provide further input.
- The Council of Ministers must consider these comments, but is not bound by them.

*Source: howtonote1707 - 2. Austria*

### 9. Czech Republic

### 9. Czech Republic

### Institutional arrangements and core functions
- The Department for Tax Policy, Cooperation, and Administration in the Ministry of Finance (MOF) coordinates inputs from a number of tax departments in the MOF and those that are involved with the formulation of tax policies.
- The Department reviews the tax system’s individual revenue instruments and customs duties in order to raise revenues in line with the annual budget requirements.
- The tax department usually works on two or three big tax policy reform projects during the political term of a government.
- The Administrative Operations Department formulates policies on user-charging and functions as an appellation body for some decisions on tax administration.
- The Tax Legislation Department prepares draft tax legislation based on solutions delivered by the Area Departments for all direct and indirect taxes and guides tax bills through the legislative process.

### Revenue forecasting, enforcement, and international agendas
- The Department for Tax Policy, Cooperation, and Administration Department proposes additional revenue raising measures as needed by coordinating closely with the public budget department, which, on a quarterly basis, reviews the revenue predictions, as influenced by macroeconomic developments.
- The department maintains a tax statistics database, designs strategies for combating tax evasion, and implements some European Union (EU) and Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development tax-related agendas (that is, international tax cooperation).
- International agenda tasks (communication with the European Community and representing the country in the EU Council, value added tax and excise harmonization; direct tax harmonization; and tax treaty negotiations) are spread across separate departments, such as Indirect Taxes, Direct Taxes, Property and Road Tax. These departments are also responsible for the design of these respective taxes.
- The Section Taxation and Customs of the MOF is headed by the Deputy Minister in Charge of Taxation and Customs and covers customs management and procedures, including the gambling tax.

### Role of the Financial Administration (FA) and inter-service consultation
- The Czech Republic’s tax administration—the Financial Administration (FA)—has considerable impact on tax design through its regular inter-service consultations with the Minister of Finance.
- The FA is consulted for input before the tax amendment bill is circulated for comment to other ministries.
- Formulation of tax policies does not follow a rigid procedural process. It is largely driven by the needs of the day and the make-up of working committees, constituted from relevant ministerial departments.
- Very often, an informal arrangement develops within a group of experts tasked with the drafting of tax options.
- Newly drafted tax law amendments closely adhere to government’s legislative rules and guidelines and aim to comply with international treaties, EU law, and case law.

### Public consultation, stakeholder engagement, and political influence
- Draft legislation is circulated for comment through a formal inter-service consultative process among ministries, regions, the office of the president, and both chambers of parliament. Draft legislation is also published on the website of the ministry.
- The Legislative Council of Government reviews the draft tax bill for its constitutionality.
- The so-called “Tripartism”, which is a voluntary conciliation body made up of trade unions, employers, and government, is specifically requested to comment on the draft tax bill.
- Public consultations are the practice for any legislative proposal, preceded by the obligatory inter-departmental or inter-service consultations in which all members of the government and their services must be involved.
- Non-governmental bodies (including professional chambers and employer federations, associations, and academia) receive the tax laws amendment bill for comments and are granted opportunities to discuss individually their comments with the Ministry of Finance.
- Tax dialogue with trade unions, employer organizations, and other stakeholders takes place after tax proposals have been assumed into draft legislation, with the exception of the Chamber of Tax Advisers, which is often consulted before the release of draft legislation.
- Political parties, especially those who have taken political control of the MOF, wield strong influence over the agenda and substance of tax policy design.

### External advisory bodies and analytic influence
- The influence of academia, the media, and tax practitioners on structural tax reforms varies.
- Independent research institutes and universities can, to some extent, influence tax reform deliberations.
- Although the tax reform process is directed by the political forces of the day, in the past, some Prime Ministers have chosen to rely on independent advisory bodies, such as the National Economic Council of Government that was established in 2009. It is staffed by economists, advising government on broad public policy topics, one being public finance.

*howtonote1707 - 9. Czech Republic*

### 15. Japan

### 15. Japan

### Institutional structure
- The Tax Commission Office (under the cabinet) releases tax proposals for the following year.
- The Tax Commission (Tax Advisory Commission) comprises 39 members:
  - 19 appointed for certain periods until the end of the specific tax discussion.
  - 20 standing members, with a three-year term.
- The Tax Commission is under the direction of the cabinet’s office (Prime Minister’s Office/Cabinet Office).
- The Tax Bureau for National Taxes in the Ministry of Finance (MOF) and the Tax Bureau of the Ministry of Internal Affairs and Communication (for local taxes) support the annual tax law amendment procedure.
- The Tax Bureau in the MOF comprises the following divisions:
  - (1) Planning and Administration
  - (2) Tax Research
  - (3) Income Tax and Property Tax Policy
  - (4) Indirect Tax Policy
  - (5) Corporate Tax Policy
  - (6) International Tax Policy (tax treaties, and so on)
- In-house trained tax lawyers in the MOF’s Tax Bureau draft the annual tax law amendment bill, with comments from the National Tax Agency (RA).

### Annual cycle and process of tax policy design
- Usual timeline:
  - November: The Tax Commission publishes, for comment, its report on planned tax law amendments for the following fiscal year.
  - December: The Commission’s tax reform proposal (Taiko), as approved by cabinet on the basis of consensus, is released.
  - January (following year): The draft bill (prepared in the Ministry’s Tax Bureau responsible for tax policy design) is released.
  - Mid-December: Deadline for finalizing proposals when ad hoc advisory committees are used.
  - March: The annual tax law amendment bill is approved by both Houses of Parliament, usually by the end of March, becoming effective April 1 (but effective date can differ depending on the contents of the amendments).
- Process notes:
  - The Tax Commission reviews tax system changes on an ongoing basis and focuses on structural tax system changes and topical themes (for example, amendments to consumption taxes, and revisiting domestic anti-avoidance legislation addressing base erosion and profit shifting).
  - The Tax Commission can appoint ad hoc advisory committees for special reviews; private sector and tax practitioner participation is possible.
  - The Cabinet’s Legislative Council must vet the tax law amendment bill before it is tabled in the Diet.
  - The Budget and Finance Committee of the Diet conducts hearings and consultations with interested parties; it has its own non-partisan staff of tax analysts that independently evaluate the annual tax laws amendment bill.
  - An individual party member can propose tax law changes but with little chance of acceptance due to the ruling party pushing its preferred tax plan.

### Roles and responsibilities
- Tax Commission (Cabinet Office / Prime Minister’s Office):
  - Chairs often esteemed academics (e.g., an esteemed professor in Tax Law); historically chaired by leading economists or academics.
  - Focuses on structural changes and major tax reform themes.
  - Produces the Taiko reflecting the consensus of represented Leading Parties.
- Ministry of Finance (Tax Bureau):
  - Drafts the annual tax law amendment bill with in-house tax lawyers.
  - Responsible for divisions listed above covering planning, research, policy areas, and international tax policy.
- National Tax Agency (RA):
  - Provides comments on draft bills.
- Diet (both Houses of Parliament) and its committees:
  - Budget and Finance Committee manages hearings and provides iterative consultation culminating in bill approval.
  - Cabinet’s Legislative Council vets bills pre-Diet.

### Legislative and regulatory features
- Approval and enactment:
  - The annual tax law amendment bill is approved by both Houses of Parliament, usually by the end of March, becoming effective April 1 (effective date may differ by amendment content).
- Drafting and vetting:
  - The Commission’s Taiko is released in December; draft bill is prepared by the MOF Tax Bureau in January; hearings by the Budget and Finance Committee follow; approval occurs in March.
  - Tax regulations are issued as cabinet orders and are not subject to parliamentary debate.
- Stakeholder participation:
  - The Tax Commission calls for submissions from stakeholders before final tax design is accepted and translated into draft legislation.
  - Ad hoc advisory committees may include private sector and tax practitioners to meet tight time frames.

### Key timelines and numeric facts
- Tax Commission membership: 39 members (19 appointed for certain periods; 20 standing members).
- Standing member term: three-year term.
- Publication/decision calendar:
  - November: report on planned tax law amendments published for comment.
  - December: Taiko released (cabinet-approved tax reform proposal).
  - January: draft bill prepared by MOF Tax Bureau.
  - Mid-December: latest finalization deadline when ad hoc advisory committees are used.
  - End of March: usual approval by both Houses of Parliament.
  - April 1: usual effective date for the annual tax law amendment bill (may differ by content).

### Public consultation and engagement
- It is common practice for tax law amendments and tax reform initiatives to be accompanied by public consultation.
- The Tax Commission solicits submissions from stakeholders for tax reviews before final tax design is translated into draft legislation.
- Ad hoc advisory committees provide a mechanism for private sector and tax practitioner input under tight time frames.

*Source: 15. Japan — content from howtonote1707.*

### 20. Russia

### 20. Russia

### Institutional responsibilities and core functions
- The Ministry of Finance (MOF) is the federal executive body responsible, among other things, for tax policy formulation, including customs duties and associated valuation.
- The Department of Tax Policy and Customs within the MOF is advancing tax policy design.
- The MOF has no veto power over tax proposals originating in other ministries; other ministries can only object and make counter-proposals aimed at mitigating adverse social impacts stemming from proposed tax law amendments.
- MOF formulates tax policy based on:
  - revenue analysis of existing taxes, and
  - comparing Russian tax trends against other global comparators.
- Other line ministries review the tax system independently from the MOF and influence it materially according to their mandates (for example, Ministry of Economic Development on economic growth and development; Ministry of Regional Development on fiscal federalism).
- The Administration (the Office) of the Russian President closely evaluates the tax system’s revenue potential as it assists the President to coordinate, develop and implement the federal budget cost-effectively.

### Historical and stakeholder involvement in tax code development
- Since 1996 the Federal Ministry of Finance, the Administration of the President and the State Duma used a number of external experts to “elaborate” and refine the Russian Federation’s Tax Code.
- Each draft was circulated for comment; the second part of the tax code is the product of extensive consultations with many research institutes and experts (domestic and international).
- The Deputy Minister of Finance coordinated the 1996 tax reform process.
- Academia, the media, business and employer associations, and trade unions contributed through conferences and commenting on draft tax laws and have influenced tax instrument design.

### Legislative initiation and drafting process
- According to the Russian Constitution, organs of state that can initiate tax laws include: the President, Council of the Russian Federation, members of the Higher Chamber of the Federal Parliament, members of the Lower Chamber of the Parliament (the Duma), federal government, and regional parliaments.
- The person submitting draft tax legislation is responsible for its preparation and may use inputs from academia and business associations.
- Draft tax laws most frequently accepted are those drafted by the federal government.
- Initiators of draft federal tax laws involve the public and business associations in preparatory discussions.

### Parliamentary and consultative processes
- MOF organizes tax reform discussions with business and academia through:
  - the Consultative Council of the Ministry, and
  - participation of experts and academics in parliamentary hearings (a total of three) in meetings of the Committee on the Budget and Taxes in the federal parliament.
- Many suggested amendments to tax laws are made by members of parliament; conciliation procedures exist when executive and committee views differ greatly on important tax legislation.
- Use of “green” and “white” papers for policy development is not common.

### Judicial and secondary-legislation practices
- In preparing tax rulings, the Russian Supreme Commercial Court involves expert opinions.
- Secondary tax legislation such as regulations are not publicly debated prior to adoption but are published before adoption, enabling stakeholders to object in writing.

*FISCAL AFFAIRS DEPARTMENT HOW-TO NOTES — content from source PDF chapter "20. Russia"*

### 25. United States

### 25. United States

### Institutional framework and leadership
- The well-resourced US Treasury leads tax design with lawyers dominating the process.
- The tax policy formulation is decentralized to introduce checks and balances.
- The president, working through the Department of the Treasury, formulates tax proposals that are then tabled in Congress for debate.
- Promulgation of tax legislation requires agreement of the House of Representatives, the Senate, and the president.

### Roles and capacities
- Treasury has a high-caliber economic analysis capacity supporting tax design on the back of economic and distributional impact analyses, with high accuracy in revenue forecasting.
- The Office of Tax Policy in the Treasury includes lawyers and economists with specialist knowledge and experience in tax policy design.
- The IRS has extensive contact with all taxpayer cohorts and sectors and releases, next to its tax administration function, policy documents (say on taxpayer service, collection due processes, voluntary compliance strategies, fraud detection, appeals, debt collections, and so on).
- The IRS also contributes to legislative initiatives such as the simplification of the tax code.
- Congress has a material influence on the direction of tax design, backstopped by its own high-quality research capacity through the Joint Committee on Taxation and the Congressional Budget Office, with a research capacity that is unparalleled internationally.
- A large number of high-quality think tanks support policymakers with alternative tax design options. They also serve in an advisory role a diverse range of business interests which lobby independently the White House, Treasury, Joint Committee on Taxation, Senate Finance Committee, House Ways and Means Committee, plus individual representatives on tax proposals benefiting mostly narrow sectoral interests.
- Both the House Ways and Means Committee and the Senate Finance Committee are very influential in the tax policy development.

### Policy process and consultations
- There are limited formal consultations by Treasury but there are many informal discussions with taxpayer groups and practitioners which influence the ultimate tax design in varied ways.
- Tax policy proposals undergo extensive consultations underpinned by in-depth quantitative analyses.
- Many tax options are prepared given the availability of competing tax policy choices from within government but also from tax practitioners, taxpayer associations, academics from think tanks and research institutes.
- The process is premised on forging compromise tax positions because the same political party does not usually control all three branches of government.

### Risks, challenges, and consequences
- Irrespective of Congress’s impressive own tax analytical capacity, very often the integrity of tax policy is eroded by rogue tax provisions attached to non-fiscal legislative proposals.
- The availability of competing inputs is associated with the risk of fragmentation and accompanying complexity in taxation.
- This translates into a protracted process before tax policy decisions are promulgated.
- Political partisanship, and the many checks and balances, could lead to polarized debates that may end in stalemates.

*Sources: Individual Ministry of Finance and Treasury websites; Wales and Wales 2012; Arnold 2013; and Lang and others 2016.*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/howtonotes/howtonote1707.pdf_
