## Update on the standard template to collect data on government revenues from natural resources

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [Update on the standard template to collect data on government revenues from natural resources](https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/pp/040617update-on-the-standard-template-to-collect-data-on-government-revenues-from-natural-resources.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/files/publications/pp/040617update-on-the-standard-template-to-collect-data-on-government-revenues-from-natural-resources.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/files/publications/pp/040617update-on-the-standard-template-to-collect-data-on-government-revenues-from-natural-resources.pdf.json)

---

### Overview and purpose
- Objective: facilitate fiscal policy formulation and analysis in resource-rich economies by improving availability and cross-country comparability of financial data on the budget contribution of natural resource revenues.
- Basis: classifications of the Government Finance Statistics Manual 2014 (GFSM 2014).
- Key intended features:
  - Data reported for revenues from natural resources under each GFSM 2014 category are (i) consistent with the data reported for total revenues for each corresponding category, and (ii) comparable across countries.
  - Methodologically sound, analytically relevant, and cross-country comparable format.
- Relationship to IMF work:
  - Supports Fund surveillance and provides input for the Model for Fiscal Analysis of Resource Industries (FARI model) and the Fiscal Transparency Code.
  - Incorporated into the Fund’s capacity development (CD) work, including donor-funded CD activities by the Statistics Department (STA) and the Institute for Capacity Development’s course on Macroeconomic Management in Resource-Rich Countries.
- Data availability route:
  - STA does not currently envision collecting this kind of government revenue data directly.
  - Data can be extracted by interested stakeholders, including IMF country teams, from national EITI reports that are now based on the standard template.

### Field-testing in six countries — main findings and practical outputs
- Field-test countries: Indonesia, Kazakhstan, Mongolia, Norway, Peru, and Zambia.
- Selection criteria: broad regional representation, different levels of statistical development, willingness of authorities to participate, and EITI membership with three or more EITI reports.
- Main findings:
  - Natural resource revenue streams for all six field-test countries were linked without significant difficulty to the standard template’s GFSM 2014-based revenue categories and sub-categories.
  - Multi-year data sets for all six pilot countries were collected and made comparable across countries.
  - Consistency of the revenue data from natural resources collected with the total government finance statistics (GFS) revenue data reported to the Statistics Department (STA) and the fiscal statistics reported to the relevant area departments was verified for each of the six countries.
  - The original template and definitions remained essentially unchanged after field-testing.
  - Issues affecting data quality and comparability were identified; best addressed through EITI International Secretariat guidance to member countries on representativeness of extractive companies selected and payments to government to be reported.
- Practical outputs:
  - Bridge tables linking national revenue streams to the standard template prepared.
  - Four to six-year time series for resource revenues compiled for all field-test countries.
  - Bridge tables and datasets for Norway and Peru prepared; analogous tables for all six countries included in country reports.
- Reconcilability:
  - Figures in EITI reports for pilot countries generally consistent with data in corresponding GFS categories reported to the IMF.
  - Rent category tends to match closely between EITI and GFS; other categories often represent partial components of larger aggregates (e.g., corporate income taxes).
  - In some cases, GFS compilers had assigned a national revenue stream to an inappropriate category; adjustments were made and reclassification recommended.

### Adoption by EITI and implications
- Timeline:
  - In early 2015, EITI International Secretariat incorporated the standard template within its mandatory reporting requirements as part of a Summary Data Template (SDT).
  - EITI membership expanded from 32 to 51 over the last three years, now including the United States and the United Kingdom.
- Implication: Availability of data aligned with the standard template has increased significantly and is expected to continue to improve.
- EITI adaptations:
  - SDT revenue table applies only to payments to government by extractive industries (oil, gas, mining) and links detailed categories to data reported by individual extractive enterprises.
  - The standard template retains broader applicability (natural resource enterprises and employees; can include fishing and forestry) and presents totals for each detailed revenue category.
  - Small changes made jointly by STA and EITI: streamlined categories, industry terminology, added withdrawals from income of quasi-corporations, breakdown of production entitlements, deleted social security employee contributions and one VAT sub-category.

### Funding, partnerships, and implementation support
- Project funding: Managing Natural Resource Wealth Topical Trust Fund (MNRW-TTF); project approved by the Steering Committee of the MNRW-TTF on June 17, 2014.
- EITI International Secretariat support: facilitated access to officials, reporting infrastructure, and National EITI Commissions.
- All six field-test countries were EITI members that had already produced several EITI reports.
- Capacity development and next steps:
  - STA to continue cooperation and support to EITI to enhance country reporting under the new template.
  - Phase 2 of the MNRW-TTF provides resources for multi-country workshops and technical assistance missions.
  - IMF does not intend to collect the data centrally; interested users (including IMF country teams and users of the FARI model and Fiscal Transparency Code) encouraged to rely on EITI reports.

### Distribution of resource revenues across countries — key statistics and country examples
- Most important revenue categories include taxes on income, profits, and capital gains, and rent; relative importance varies significantly across countries.
- Country examples and magnitudes:
  - Peru: income taxes are dominant (62 percent).
  - Kazakhstan: the overall mix of income and other tax categories accounted for 72 percent.
  - Indonesia: non-tax resource revenues, primarily rent, were significant (69 percent).
  - Norway: rent-type payments do not play a role; Norway largely relies on withdrawals of income from quasi-corporations.
  - Zambia: dividend revenues are highest (8 percent).
  - Indonesia dividend share: 4 percent.
  - Mongolia dividend share: 5 percent.
- Resource revenue shares of GDP (pilot examples):
  - Kazakhstan: 12 percent of GDP.
  - Indonesia: 4 percent of GDP.
- Country data examples (reported values preserved exactly):
  - Norway (in millions of NOK) — selected categories and yearly values:
    - Ordinary taxes on income, profits and capital gains: 85,803; 78,243; 58,830; 61,501; 88,802
    - Extraordinary taxes on income, profits, and capital gains: 142,868; 127,693; 96,779; 103,733; 150,839
    - Other rent payments not included elsewhere: 1,781; 1,517; 1,373; 1,470; 1,842
    - Pollution taxes (CO2 tax on petroleum extraction): 2,251; 2,189; 2,166; 2,215; 3,392
    - Pollution taxes (NOx tax on petroleum extraction): 436; 204; 729; 2
    - Dividends from government-owned enterprises (Statoil dividends): 13,887; 13,350; 12,818; 15,489; 16,940
    - Withdrawals of income from quasi-corporations (SDFI cash flow): 148,889; 127,775; 104,053; 95,339; 153,759
    - Total Resource Revenue: 395,483; 350,803; 276,039; 279,794; 415,866
  - Peru (in millions of soles) — selected categories and yearly values:
    - Tax on income: 7,641.5; 9,811.7; 8,506.5; 6,371.8; 7,295.2
    - Tax on income: mining companies: 6,117.3; 8,392.3; 4,760.2; 5,837.9; 6,449.7
    - Tax on income: hydrocarbon companies: 1,524.2; 1,419.4; 1,046.3; 533.9; 845.5
    - Mining royalties: 451.3; 693.8; 566.5; 334.1; 348.3
    - Hydrocarbon royalties: 4,339.5; 4,884.9; 3,218.4; 2,203.3; 2,790.4
    - Special tax on mining: 365.6; 130.1; n.a.; n.a.; n.a.
    - Special levy on mining: 1,140.7; 302.4; n.a.; n.a.; n.a.
    - Validity rights: 32.2; 35.5; 24.6; 22.4; 22.7
    - Total Resource Revenue: 13,970.8; 15,858.4; 12,316.0; 8,931.6; 10,456.6

### Conceptual distinctions and illustrative reclassifications
- Definitions:
  - Rent (GFSM 2014): revenue receivable by the owners of a natural resource for putting the resource at the disposal of another institutional unit for use of the natural resource in production. Distinguishes rent from rental income generated by fixed assets and differs from the broader economic interpretation of rent.
  - Tax revenue: revenues based on the government’s ability to impose and collect taxes (six main types in GFSM 2014 classification).
  - Non-tax revenue: all revenues not based on taxes; rent is a subset of non-tax revenue.
- Illustrative reclassifications from field tests:
  - Kazakhstan: revenues obtained from production entitlements were misclassified as taxes; correction entailed a 0.8 percent of GDP downward revision in tax revenue (and a corresponding increase in rent).
  - Norway: “net cash flow from SDFI” represents operating surplus of government’s investment in oil concessions handled by a quasi-corporation outside general government; it is a nontax revenue (withdrawals of income from quasi-corporations) but not rent.
- Purpose: use of the standard template and GFSM 2014-based classification aims to address such inconsistencies for cross-country comparability.

### Data collection issues identified and recommended practices
- Scope and enterprise selection:
  - National EITI Commissions determine which extractive enterprises and payments are included; discretion leads to variation across countries.
  - Common threshold rules observed: absolute output value (e.g., more than US$25 million) or percentage of total industry output (e.g., one or two percent); sometimes accompanied by minimum coverage of total value of hydrocarbon or mining industry output (e.g., 85 percent or 95 percent).
- Direct vs indirect payments:
  - Some national reports include only direct payments (e.g., Norway and Peru); others include indirect payments (e.g., Mongolia and Kazakhstan include export taxes, VAT, fees, charges).
  - Variation in reported payment types complicates cross-country comparisons.
- Production-sharing arrangements:
  - Payments may be recorded in physical terms or omitted if government’s share is delivered to a public corporation and not monetized in reporting.
  - Recommended: value output delivered under production-sharing arrangements at market prices and record as government revenue (as done in Indonesia and Norway).
- Timeliness and frequency:
  - EITI reports are available annually and often with a long lag; EITI Standard requires reports with data no older than the second-to-last complete accounting period, but this lag is sometimes exceeded.
  - Lag hinders timely fiscal analysis.
  - IMF-suggested practice: national entity compiling monthly/quarterly GFS could include a supplemental revenue table separately identifying natural resource revenues to facilitate reconciliation with EITI data.
- Data compilation approach:
  - Not advisable to collect template data directly from natural resource enterprises because of likely unfamiliarity with GFSM 2014 classifications.
  - Recommended: collect enterprise-level data using national templates tailored to country practice, then apply the standard template to aggregate and present data in GFSM 2014-consistent format.
  - Preferable entity to fill the template for EITI reports: the independent administrator for each EITI reporting country (usually large accounting firms familiar with international statistical classifications).
  - National entity responsible for compiling GFS (Ministry of Finance, Statistical Office, or Central Bank) could assist independent administrators to prepare the bridge table.
  - STA stands ready to provide support when classification doubts arise.

### Level of detail, scope, and reporting guidance
- Level of detail:
  - The level of detail provided by the categories and sub-categories of the standard template is adequate to meet the analytical needs of many users.
  - Users seeking greater detail can obtain it in EITI national reports; the EITI revenue template links categories and sub-categories to national revenue streams by company.
- Scope endorsed: "All significant payments to government by natural resource enterprises should be reported."
  - Payments to government by individuals employed by natural resource enterprises (personal income tax, social contributions) should also be included to obtain a more complete picture; information on these payments is available from tax authorities and social security funds.
- Guidance needs:
  - A guidance note, developed by STA based on GFSM 2014, was identified as necessary to explain categories and sub-categories and to address borderline and potentially confusing cases (e.g., licenses versus administrative fees; production entitlements; withholding taxes; environmental funds; payments for pipelines).
- Early uptake:
  - STA co-hosted a Data Storytellers Bootcamp with EITI during the EITI Global Conference in Lima, Peru in February 2016.
  - As of February 28, 2017: a total of 37 countries have reported the SDT to the EITI International Secretariat, including the revenue table. The EITI is reviewing submissions and consulting with STA on proper classification in a few cases.

### Key features of the final standard template
- Definition of natural resource products: broadly unchanged from original, except refined petroleum products are excluded.
- At greatest level of detail there are now 33 individual data categories for revenues from natural resources.
- Major additions/changes:
  - Addition of a category for withdrawals from income of natural resource quasi-corporations.
  - Breakdown of production entitlements under rent into categories depending on whether the entitlement is delivered or paid to government or a government-owned enterprise.
- Otherwise, the original classification structure remains the same.

### Appendix excerpt — EITI Revenue Template (GFS codes of revenue streams from extractive companies)
- 11ETaxes
  - 111ETaxes on income, profits and capital gains
    - 1112E1   Ordinary taxes on income, profits and capital gains
    - 1112E2   Extraordinary taxes on income, profits and capital gains
  - 112ETaxes on payroll and workforce
  - 113ETaxes on property
  - 114ETaxes on goods and services
    - 1141E   General taxes on goods and services (VAT, sales tax, turnover tax)
    - 1142E   Excise taxes
    - 1145E   Taxes on use of goods/permission to use goods or perform activities
      - 114521E      Licence fees
      - 114522E      Emission and pollution taxes
      - 11451E      Motor vehicle taxes
  - 115ETaxes on international trade and transactions
    - 1151E   Customs and other import duties
    - 1152E   Taxes on exports
    - 1153E1   Profits of natural resource export monopolies
  - 116EOther taxes payable by natural resource companies
- 12ESocial contributions
  - 1212ESocial security employer contributions
- 14EOther revenue
  - 141EProperty income
    - 1412E   Dividends
      - 1412E1      From state-owned enterprises
      - 1412E2      From government participation (equity)
    - 1413E   Withdrawals from income of quasi-corporations
    - 1415E   Rent
      - 1415E1      Royalties
      - 1415E2      Bonuses
  - 1415E      Production entitlements (in-kind or cash)
    - 1415E31         Delivered/paid directly to government
    - 1415E32         Delivered/paid to state-owned enterprise(s)
    - 1415E4    Compulsory transfers to government (infrastructure and other)
    - 1415E5    Other rent payments
  - 142ESales of goods and services
    - 1421E   Sales of goods and services by government units
    - 1422E   Administrative fees for government services
  - 143EFines, penalties, and forfeits
  - 144E1Voluntary transfers to government (donations)
- 15ERevenues not classified
- Notes included in the appendix emphasize that:
  - Data should only be entered for the items in blue; black items are sums of blue items.
  - Only payments to governments from companies on their own behalf are to be included; payments on behalf of employees (e.g., personal income tax/PAYE, employee social security contributions) are to be excluded.
  - The letter E in the GFS codes denotes codes used for revenues from extractive companies; digits to the left of an E are actual GFS codes and digits to the right of an E are subcategories created exclusively for revenues from extractive companies.

*Prepared by Alberto F. Jiménez de Lucio and Gary S. Jones; Approved By Louis Marc Ducharme; April 6, 2017. Source: Update on the Standard Template to Collect Data on Government Revenues from Natural Resources (IMF).*

### EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

### EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

### Overview
- Paper provides an update on the status of the standard template to collect data on government revenues from natural resources (hereafter, referred to as “standard template”), originally presented to the Executive Board in January 2014 (SM/14/28).
- Discusses: (i) the field-testing of the standard template in six countries, which confirmed the feasibility of applying it more broadly; (ii) the final version of the template based on outcomes of consultation with the international community and the field-testing visits; and (iii) the adoption of the template by the Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative (EITI) International Secretariat as a mandatory reporting requirement for its member countries.

### Purpose and development of the standard template
- Objective: facilitate fiscal policy formulation and analysis in resource-rich economies by improving availability and cross-country comparability of financial data on the budget contribution of natural resource revenues.
- Basis: classifications of the Government Finance Statistics Manual 2014 (GFSM 2014).
- Key intended features:
  - Data reported for revenues from natural resources under each GFSM 2014 category are (i) consistent with the data reported for total revenues for each corresponding category, and (ii) comparable across countries.
  - Methodologically sound, analytically relevant, and cross-country comparable format.
- Relationship to IMF work:
  - Supports Fund surveillance and provides input for the Model for Fiscal Analysis of Resource Industries (FARI model) and the Fiscal Transparency Code.
  - Incorporated into the Fund’s capacity development (CD) work, including donor-funded CD activities by the Statistics Department (STA) and the Institute for Capacity Development’s course on Macroeconomic Management in Resource-Rich Countries.
- Data availability route:
  - STA does not currently envision collecting this kind of government revenue data directly.
  - Data can be extracted by interested stakeholders, including IMF country teams, from national EITI reports that are now based on the standard template (https://eiti.org/data).

### Consultation and key conceptual feedback
- Public consultation period: February – April 2014.
- Main conceptual comments received included:
  - Suggested exclusion of refined petroleum products from the list of natural resource products.
  - Need to identify separately the various types of revenues that constitute rent.
  - Scope of the definition of natural resources could be broadened to include forestry, fishery, and water resources.
- Comments on application and data features:
  - Need for greater disaggregation of data; inclusion of state-owned enterprises; use of industry terms; identifying the level of government for which data are collected; need to identify withholding taxes separately and include tax expenditures or concessions.
  - Suggestions on establishing a database and ensuring public access to granular data.
- Outcome: final version of the standard template and this paper incorporate many of the comments received.

### Field-testing in six countries
- Field-test selection criteria: broad regional representation, different levels of statistical development, willingness of authorities to participate, and EITI membership with three or more EITI reports.
- Countries selected: Indonesia, Kazakhstan, Mongolia, Norway, Peru, and Zambia.
- Main findings from field-tests:
  - Natural resource revenue streams for all six field-test countries were linked without significant difficulty to the standard template’s GFSM 2014-based revenue categories and sub-categories.
  - Multi-year data sets for all six pilot countries were collected and made comparable across countries.
  - Consistency of the revenue data from natural resources collected with the total government finance statistics (GFS) revenue data reported to the Statistics Department (STA) and the fiscal statistics reported to the relevant area departments was verified for each of the six countries.
  - The original template and definitions remained essentially unchanged after field-testing.
  - Issues affecting data quality and comparability were identified; best addressed through EITI International Secretariat guidance to member countries on representativeness of extractive companies selected and payments to government to be reported.
- Practical outputs from field-tests:
  - Bridge tables prepared linking national revenue streams to the standard template; a four to six-year time series for these revenues compiled for all field-test countries.
  - Bridge tables and datasets for Norway and Peru shown in Table 1 (in source); analogous tables prepared for all six countries and included in country reports.
- Reconcilability with existing data:
  - Figures in EITI reports for pilot countries generally consistent with data in corresponding GFS categories reported to the IMF.
  - Rent category tends to match closely between EITI and GFS; other categories often represent partial components of larger aggregates (e.g., corporate income taxes).
  - In some cases, GFS compilers had assigned a national revenue stream to an inappropriate category; adjustments were made and reclassification recommended.

### Adoption by EITI and implications
- In early 2015, EITI International Secretariat incorporated the standard template within its mandatory reporting requirements as part of a Summary Data Template (SDT).
- EITI related developments:
  - Minor changes to the standard template and a guidance note describing revenue categories were drafted following discussions in Oslo.
  - EITI membership expanded from 32 to 51 over the last three years, now including the United States and the United Kingdom.
- Implication: Availability of data aligned with the standard template has increased significantly and is expected to continue to improve.

### Funding and partnerships
- Project funded under the Managing Natural Resource Wealth Topical Trust Fund (MNRW-TTF); project approved by the Steering Committee of the MNRW-TTF on June 17, 2014.
- EITI International Secretariat provided critical support: facilitating access to officials, reporting infrastructure, and National EITI Commissions.
- All six field-test countries were EITI members that had already produced several EITI reports.

### Relevance for IMF work and next steps
- Relevance:
  - The template addresses limitations in existing data and aids fiscal policy analysis where natural resource revenues are macro-critical (noted previously as important for about one-third of the Fund’s membership in earlier Board papers).
  - Useful for fiscal modeling (FARI model) and transparency assessments under the Fiscal Transparency Code.
- Next steps:
  - Continued collaboration with the EITI International Secretariat.
  - Use of available government revenue data in national EITI reports for the IMF’s surveillance and analytical use.
  - Capacity development efforts to assist countries in implementing the template’s international classifications will continue.

*Prepared by Alberto F. Jiménez de Lucio and Gary S. Jones; Approved By Louis Marc Ducharme; April 6, 2017.*

### 16.      Government revenues from natural resources are concentrated in a few categories.

### 16. Government revenues from natural resources are concentrated in a few categories

### Distribution of resource revenues across countries
- Most important revenue categories include taxes on income, profits, and capital gains, and rent; their relative importance varies significantly from country to country.
- Country examples and magnitudes:
  - Peru: income taxes are dominant (62 percent).
  - Kazakhstan: the overall mix of income and other tax categories accounted for 72 percent.
  - Indonesia: non-tax resource revenues, primarily rent, were significant (69 percent).
  - Norway: rent-type payments do not play a role; Norway largely relies on withdrawals of income from quasi-corporations.
  - Zambia: dividend revenues are highest (8 percent).
  - Indonesia dividend share noted as 4 percent; Mongolia dividend share noted as 5 percent.
- Resource revenue shares of GDP (pilot examples):
  - Kazakhstan: 12 percent of GDP.
  - Indonesia: 4 percent of GDP.

### Country data examples (reported values preserved exactly)
- Norway (in millions of NOK) — selected categories and yearly values as reported:
  - Ordinary taxes on income, profits and capital gains: 85,803; 78,243; 58,830; 61,501; 88,802
  - Extraordinary taxes on income, profits, and capital gains: 142,868; 127,693; 96,779; 103,733; 150,839
  - Other rent payments not included elsewhere: 1,781; 1,517; 1,373; 1,470; 1,842
  - Pollution taxes (CO2 tax on petroleum extraction): 2,251; 2,189; 2,166; 2,215; 3,392
  - Pollution taxes (NOx tax on petroleum extraction): 436; 204; 729; 2
  - Dividends from government-owned enterprises (Statoil dividends): 13,887; 13,350; 12,818; 15,489; 16,940
  - Withdrawals of income from quasi-corporations (SDFI cash flow): 148,889; 127,775; 104,053; 95,339; 153,759
  - Total Resource Revenue: 395,483; 350,803; 276,039; 279,794; 415,866
- Peru (in millions of soles) — selected categories and yearly values as reported:
  - Tax on income: 7,641.5; 9,811.7; 8,506.5; 6,371.8; 7,295.2
  - Tax on income: mining companies: 6,117.3; 8,392.3; 4,760.2; 5,837.9; 6,449.7
  - Tax on income: hydrocarbon companies: 1,524.2; 1,419.4; 1,046.3; 533.9; 845.5
  - Mining royalties: 451.3; 693.8; 566.5; 334.1; 348.3
  - Hydrocarbon royalties: 4,339.5; 4,884.9; 3,218.4; 2,203.3; 2,790.4
  - Special tax on mining: 365.6; 130.1; n.a.; n.a.; n.a.
  - Special levy on mining: 1,140.7; 302.4; n.a.; n.a.; n.a.
  - Validity rights: 32.2; 35.5; 24.6; 22.4; 22.7
  - Total Resource Revenue: 13,970.8; 15,858.4; 12,316.0; 8,931.6; 10,456.6

### Conceptual distinction: rent, tax revenue, and non-tax revenue (Box 2)
- Rent (GFSM 2014 definition): revenue receivable by the owners of a natural resource for putting the resource at the disposal of another institutional unit for use of the natural resource in production.
  - Distinguishes rent from rental income generated by fixed assets.
  - Differs from the broader economic interpretation of rent (revenues in excess of all necessary costs of production).
- Tax revenue: revenues based on the government’s ability to impose and collect taxes (six main types in GFSM 2014 classification).
- Non-tax revenue: all revenues not based on taxes; rent is a subset of non-tax revenue.
- Illustrative reclassifications from field tests:
  - Kazakhstan: revenues obtained from production entitlements were misclassified as taxes; correction entailed a 0.8 percent of GDP downward revision in tax revenue (and a corresponding increase in rent).
  - Norway: “net cash flow from SDFI” represents operating surplus of government’s investment in oil concessions handled by a quasi-corporation outside general government; it is a nontax revenue (withdrawals of income from quasi-corporations) but not rent.
- Use of the standard template and GFSM 2014-based classification aims to address such inconsistencies for cross-country comparability.

### Data collection and field-test issues identified
- Scope and reporting enterprise selection:
  - National EITI Commissions determine which extractive enterprises and payments are included; discretion leads to variation across countries.
  - Common threshold rules: absolute output value (e.g., more than US$25 million) or percentage of total industry output (e.g., one or two percent); sometimes accompanied by minimum coverage of total value of hydrocarbon or mining industry output (e.g., 85 percent or 95 percent).
- Direct vs indirect payments reported:
  - Some national reports include only direct payments (e.g., Norway and Peru report direct payments only); others include indirect payments (e.g., Mongolia and Kazakhstan include export taxes, VAT, fees, charges).
  - Variation in reported payment types complicates cross-country comparisons.
- Production-sharing arrangements:
  - Payments related to production-sharing arrangements may be recorded in physical terms or omitted if government’s share is delivered to a public corporation and not monetized in reporting.
  - Recommended: value output delivered under production-sharing arrangements at market prices and record as government revenue (as done in Indonesia and Norway).
- Timeliness and frequency:
  - EITI reports are available annually and often with a long lag; EITI Standard requires reports with data no older than the second-to-last complete accounting period, but this lag is sometimes exceeded.
  - Lag hinders timely fiscal analysis.
  - IMF-suggested practice: national entity compiling monthly/quarterly GFS could include a supplemental revenue table separately identifying natural resource revenues to facilitate reconciliation with EITI data.

### Relevance and benefits of the standard template
- Addresses lack of international guidelines and inconsistent national classifications that impede cross-country comparability of natural resource revenue statistics.
- Enables methodologically consistent statistics to:
  - Measure degree of resource revenue dependence.
  - Identify tax and non-tax sources of individual revenue streams.
  - Improve accuracy of revenue forecasts by comparing resource-related government revenue with production, profits, and exports data.
  - Support cross-country comparisons and IMF surveillance.
- Example: among the six pilot countries, resource revenues were highest in Kazakhstan and Norway; resource revenue composition varies with some countries deriving most from taxes and others from non-tax sources.

### Key features of the final standard template
- Definition of natural resource products: broadly unchanged from original, except refined petroleum products are excluded.
  - Exclusion reflects stakeholder feedback that refined petroleum products are manufactured products.
- Mining product definition refinement considered (based on Peru’s experience) but not incorporated because additional required information is not readily available.
- Classification structure:
  - At the greatest level of detail, there are now 33 individual data categories for revenues from natural resources.
  - Major additions/changes:
    - Addition of a category for withdrawals from income of natural resource quasi-corporations (important for at least one field-test country).
    - Breakdown of production entitlements under rent into categories depending on whether the entitlement is delivered or paid to government or a government-owned enterprise.
  - Otherwise, the original classification structure remains the same.

*Source: EITI country reports; Update on the Standard Template to Collect Data on Government Revenues from Natural Resources (IMF).*

### 26.      The level of detail provided by the categories and sub-categories of the standard

### Update on the standard template to collect data on government revenues from natural resources

### Level of detail and scope of reporting
- The level of detail provided by the categories and sub-categories of the standard template is adequate to meet the analytical needs of many users.
- Concern from the international community about possible loss of detailed information was noted; users seeking greater detail can find it in the EITI national reports.
- The EITI’s revenue template links the categories and sub-categories to the national revenue streams by company.
- Under the final standard template, the definition of government revenues from natural resources should cover all significant receipts, direct or indirect, from natural resource enterprises.
- Two interpretations of payments to government were identified:
  - (i) only direct payments, and
  - (ii) both direct and indirect payments.
- The document endorses the second interpretation: "All significant payments to government by natural resource enterprises should be reported."
- Payments to government by individuals employed by natural resource enterprises (personal income tax, social contributions) should also be included to obtain a more complete picture; information on these payments is available from the tax authority and the social security fund.

### Data collection approach and practicalities
- Using the template to collect data directly from natural resource enterprises is not advisable because most enterprises are likely to be unfamiliar with the detailed GFSM 2014 revenue classification, leading to difficulties and errors.
- Recommended approach:
  - Use national templates tailored to each country’s regulations and practices to collect data from natural resource enterprises.
  - Afterwards, apply the standard template to aggregate and present the national data in a format that follows internationally accepted guidelines to facilitate cross-country comparisons.
- The standard template can be used by any country independently of the methodology it follows to compile its fiscal statistics (GFSM 1986, GFSM 2001, GFSM 2014).

### EITI International Secretariat adoption and adaptations
- The EITI International Secretariat has adopted the standard template as a mandatory reporting requirement for its member countries, making it an internationally accepted guideline.
- Timeline and events:
  - During a visit to the first field-test country (Norway) in October 2014, the EITI International Secretariat expressed interest in the potential use of the standard template.
  - In February 2015, the EITI International Secretariat introduced a SDT as a new mandatory reporting requirement for all members; one of the three tables in the SDT is essentially the standard template.
- The EITI revenue template in the SDT:
  - Applies only to payments to government by extractive industries—defined as the oil, gas, and mining sectors—whereas the standard template can apply to payments by natural resource enterprises and its employees, and can include sectors such as fishing and forestry.
  - Includes only the detailed revenue categories to be reported by natural resource enterprises and specific codes for the detailed revenue categories; the standard template includes both detailed and broader revenue categories and does not have specific codes for the detailed categories.
  - Links detailed categories to data reported by individual natural resource enterprises, whereas the standard template presents only totals for each detailed revenue category.
- The standard template was jointly tailored by STA staff and EITI International Secretariat staff with small changes to:
  - Streamline the template by limiting categories and sub-categories shown to only those for which data are actually requested;
  - Express categories and sub-categories in terms familiar to the extractive industries;
  - Add one category (withdrawal from income of quasi-corporations) and a breakdown of one sub-category (production entitlements);
  - Delete one category (social security employee contributions) and one sub-category (unrequited value added taxes).

### Guidance, responsibilities, and capacity building
- A guidance note, developed by STA based on the GFSM 2014, was identified as necessary to explain categories and sub-categories and to address borderline and potentially confusing cases (e.g., licenses versus administrative fees; production entitlements; withholding taxes; environmental funds; payments for pipeline passing through a country’s territory).
- Scope discussions and EITI views:
  - EITI considered that only payments made by enterprises on their own behalf should be included in EITI reports; payments made by enterprises on behalf of employees (withholding personal income tax/PAYE and employee contributions to social security) were to be excluded in EITI reports.
  - EITI view was that only companies in the extractive industries (oil, gas, mining) and only their upstream activities should be included; payments related to both direct and indirect taxes should be included, though some current EITI reporters report only direct taxes.
- Appropriate entity to fill in the template:
  - Preferably the independent administrator for each EITI reporting country (usually large accounting firms familiar with international statistical classifications).
  - Key factor: independent administrators should prepare an accurate bridge table between national revenue streams and the template categories and sub-categories.
  - EITI country managers should gain basic familiarity with the template and GFSM 2014 revenue classification and codes to address questions from independent administrators.
  - STA stands ready to provide support when classification doubts arise.
  - The national entity responsible for compiling GFS (Ministry of Finance, Statistical Office, or Central Bank) could assist independent administrators to prepare the bridge table.

### Early experience, uptake, and implementation challenges
- STA co-hosted a data event (Data Storytellers Bootcamp) with the EITI International Secretariat during the EITI Global Conference in Lima, Peru in February 2016 to raise awareness and assist country representatives in preparing bridge tables.
- Initial experience shows some countries have difficulties linking national revenue streams to the international classification for the first time, but with guidance are able to compile the template.
  - One reason for difficulties: national secretariats (rather than recommended independent administrators) are undertaking the task.
- As of February 28, 2017:
  - A total of 37 countries have reported the SDT to the EITI International Secretariat, including the revenue table.
  - The EITI is reviewing submissions and consulting with STA on proper classification in a few cases.
- The EITI’s use of the revenue table in its SDT provides users with access to detailed EITI reports; IMF staff can access this information for surveillance and monitoring purposes and use the international classification to identify natural resource-related revenues within a government’s total revenues to support more detailed fiscal analysis in resource-rich countries.

### Next steps and further methodological development
- Focus going forward: implementation of the framework and ensuring as many EITI members as possible report their national revenue streams to the EITI in the international classification developed under this project.
- The IMF does not intend to collect the relevant data itself; interested users—including IMF country teams and users of the FARI model and Fiscal Transparency Code—are encouraged to rely on EITI reports for country data.
- STA will continue cooperation and support to EITI to enhance country reporting under the new template, including through capacity development activities.
- Phase 2 of the MNRW-TTF provides resources to develop capacity in member countries to apply the standard template, including multi-country workshops and several technical assistance missions to individual countries.
- Additional scope to extend international statistical methodologies to other aspects of natural resources:
  - Apply international classifications to expenses, transactions in non-financial assets, and recognition of natural assets in government balance sheets.
  - Continue work on the Guide to Analyze Natural Resources in National Accounts and undertake a capacity development project: six multi-country compilation workshops and technical assistance missions to more than a dozen individual countries are currently envisioned.
  - STA will assess the need to develop methodological guidance in other topical domains, such as external sector statistics.

*Update on the Standard Template — International Monetary Fund*

### Appendix III. EITI Revenue Template

### Appendix III. EITI Revenue Template

### GFS codes of revenue streams from extractive companies

- 11ETaxes
  - 111ETaxes on income, profits and capital gains
    - 1112E1   Ordinary taxes on income, profits and capital gains
    - 1112E2   Extraordinary taxes on income, profits and capital gains
  - 112ETaxes on payroll and workforce
  - 113ETax e s on prope rty
  - 114ETaxes on goods and services
    - 1141E   General taxes on goods and services (VAT, sales tax, turnover tax)
    - 1142E   Ex ci se  tax e s
    - 1145E   Taxes on use of goods/permission to use goods or perform activities
      - 114521E      Li ce nce  fe e s
      - 114522E      Emi ssi on and pol l uti on tax e s
      - 11451E      Motor ve hi cl e  tax e s
  - 115ETaxes on international trade and transactions
    - 1151E   Customs and other import duties
    - 1152E   Tax e s on e x ports
    - 1153E1   Profits of natural resource export monopolies
  - 116EOther taxes payable by natural resource companies

- 12ESocial contributions
  - 1212ESocial security employer contributions

- 14EOther revenue
  - 141EProperty income
    - 1412E   Dividends
      - 1412E1      From state - owne d e nte rpri se s
      - 1412E2      From government participation (equity)
    - 1413E   Withdrawals from income of quasi-corporations
    - 1415E   Rent
      - 1415E1      Royal ti e s
      - 1415E2      Bonuse s
  - 1415E      Production entitlements (in-kind or cash)
    - 1415E31         Delivered/paid directly to government
    - 1415E32         Delivered/paid to state-owned enterprise(s)
    - 1415E4    Compulsory transfers to government (infrastructure and other)
    - 1415E5    Other rent payments
  - 142ESales of goods and services
    - 1421E   Sales of goods and services by government units
    - 1422E   Administrative fees for government services
  - 143EFines, penalties, and forfeits
  - 144E1Voluntary transfers to government (donations)

- 15ERevenues not classified

### Notes

- 1. Da ta  s houl d onl y be enter ed for  the i tems  i n bl ue. The i tems  i n bl a c k a r e the s um of items in blue.
- 2. O nl y pa yments  to gover nments  fr om c ompa ni es  on thei r  own beha l f a r e to be i nc l uded. Pa yments  to gover nments  fr om c ompa ni es  on beha l f of thei r  empl oyees  a r e to be exc l uded (for  exa mpl e, personal income tax/PAYE, employee social security contributions).
- 3. The l etter  E i n the GFS c odes  mea ns  tha t thes e a r e the c odes  us ed for  the r evenues  fr om extr a c ti ve  compa ni es . The di gi ts  to the l eft of a n E a re a ctua l  GFS codes . The di gi ts  to the ri ght of a n E a re s ubc a tegor i es  c r ea ted exc l us i vel y for  r evenues  fr om extr a c ti ve c ompa ni es .

*Appendix III. EITI Revenue Template — source PDF content.*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/pp/040617update-on-the-standard-template-to-collect-data-on-government-revenues-from-natural-resources.pdf_
