## ppea2021073

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [ppea2021073](https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/pp/2021/english/ppea2021073.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/files/publications/pp/2021/english/ppea2021073.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/files/publications/pp/2021/english/ppea2021073.pdf.json)

---

### EXECUTIVE SUMMARY — Precautionary balances: role and recent decision context
- Precautionary balances are a key element of the Fund’s multilayered framework to mitigate financial risks and provide buffers to absorb losses from credit, income, and other financial risks.
- Composition: balances in the general and special reserves (excluding gold sales profits). The SCA-1 was included prior to its full distribution in the context of Sudan’s arrears clearance.
- At the last bi-annual review (completed on October 30, 2020) the Board decided to raise the indicative medium-term target for precautionary balances to SDR 25 billion and kept the minimum floor at SDR 15 billion.
- Directors called for a reassessment of the adequacy of precautionary balances before the next regular review given heightened pandemic-related uncertainty.

### Developments since the last review — risk drivers and market indicators
- Overall financial risks remain elevated but have not increased significantly since the last review.
- Key drivers of credit risk:
  - Historically high exposure.
  - Significant loan concentration toward the largest borrower, whose repurchase schedule is bunched in the near future.
  - A sizable share of emergency financing without ex-post conditionality in the lending portfolio.
- Market-based indicators and ratings suggest perceived credit quality of sovereign debt issued by the Fund’s borrowers remains weak.
- Investment risks: expected returns across all asset classes are lower than in the past.

### Precautionary balances — composition, levels, and coverage ratios
- Composition and governance:
  - Special reserve: first line to absorb administrative losses; funded by gold investment program proceeds and net income allocations; no distributions can be made under the Fund’s Articles.
  - General reserve: absorbs capital losses and meets administrative losses; funded through income allocations; distributions may be made with Board approval by a 70 percent majority of total voting power.
  - SCA-1: fully distributed in June 2021 and currently has zero balances.
- Levels and changes (exact figures):
  - Precautionary balances: SDR 20.0 billion at end-FY 2021; SDR 16.0 billion at end-FY 2020.
  - Precautionary balances: SDR 19.3 billion at end-July 2021 after SCA-1 distribution of SDR 1.1 billion and SDR 0.3 billion net operational income in FY 2022 through July 2021.
  - General reserves: estimated increase from SDR 10.8 billion in FY 2020 to SDR 12.2 billion.
  - Special reserves: estimated increase from SDR 4.2 billion in FY 2020 to SDR 7.1 billion at end-July 2021.
  - GRA net income in FY 2021: SDR 4.0 billion, including IAS19 gains of SDR 3.2 billion; net operational income through July 2021: SDR 0.3 billion (assumes equal allocation of income earned through end-July).
- Coverage ratios (exact figures):
  - Coverage relative to lending capacity: increased from 2.2 percent at the time of the last review to 2.7 percent.
  - Ratio of precautionary balances to credit outstanding: rose to about 21 percent at end-July 2021 from about 19 percent in August last year.
  - Ratio of precautionary balances to commitments: improved to 10.5 percent.
  - Note: coverage relative to outstanding credit and commitments remains lower than before the pandemic.

### Assessment of adequacy and staff proposals
- Staff proposal: leave the medium-term target at SDR 25 billion and the minimum floor at SDR 15 billion unchanged at this time.
- Rationale:
  - Taking into account expected new demand for Fund lending, SDR 25 billion remains within the indicative range of the forward-looking measure of average credit outstanding.
  - Other qualitative considerations point to elevated risk but do not suggest significant deterioration compared to the last review.
- Timing: the target will be reassessed at the next regular review in about a year’s time.

### Pace of accumulation and projection (operational income and balances)
- Projected accumulation:
  - With projected increase in lending income, pace of reserve accumulation expected to remain adequate relative to the medium-term target.
  - SDR 25 billion target would be reached in early Fiscal Year (FY) 2025 under the desk survey scenario—even after factoring in the proposed budget augmentation—one year earlier than projected at the 2020 review.
- Recent operational income and period balances (exact figures):
  - PB - beginning of period: 17.7 (FY 2020); 16.0 (FY 2021); 20.0 (FY 2022 end-July)
  - Operational income: 2.3 (FY 2020); 2.1 (FY 2021); 0.7 (FY 2022 through end-July)
    - lending income incl. surcharges: 1.9; 2.0; 0.7
    - non-lending income: 0.4; 0.1; 0.0
  - Admin expenses: -0.9; -1.2; -0.3
  - Net operational income: 1.4; 0.9; 0.3
  - IAS19 gain/loss: -3.0; 3.2; 0.0
  - Distribution of SCA-1: -1.1
  - PB - end of period: 16.0 (FY 2020); 20.0 (FY 2021); 19.3 (FY 2022 end-July)

### Credit outstanding, concentration, scheduled repurchases, and perceived credit quality
- Credit outstanding and commitments (exact figures and projections):
  - Fund credit outstanding: nearly SDR 90 billion in September 2021.
  - Increase since 2020 review: SDR 4.1 billion (4.8 percent).
  - Projected peak in FY 2022 at about SDR 92.8 billion based on arrangements as of end-September 2021.
  - Without new demand, Fund credit expected to fall below SDR 90 billion by end-FY 2022.
  - Compared to 2020 review, projected credit path increased by an average of about SDR 7 billion over FY 2022‒24.
  - Total commitments: nearly SDR 182 billion at end-September 2021.
- Concentration and regional exposure (exact figures):
  - Credit concentration to the largest borrower: about 34 percent as of end-September 2021 (down from 48 percent at end-2019).
  - Share of outstanding credit toward five largest borrowers (Argentina, Egypt, Ukraine, Pakistan, Ecuador): 68 percent as of end-September 2021.
  - Exposures at end-September 2021: Argentina SDR 30.6 billion; Egypt SDR 14.2 billion; Ukraine SDR 6.7 billion; Pakistan SDR 5.0 billion; Ecuador SDR 4.3 billion.
- Scheduled repurchases (exact figures):
  - Total scheduled repurchases in FY 2023‒25: nearly SDR 63 billion—average SDR 21 billion per year.
  - Argentina’s repurchases: SDR 15.5 billion in FY 2023 and SDR 10.3 billion in FY 2024; relative to quota peaks at 486 percent of quota in FY 2023.
  - Repurchases of single tranche RFIs: about SDR 15.8 billion, bulk in FY 2024‒25.
- Perceived credit risks:
  - Average sovereign credit rating of Fund borrowers remains at levels last seen in the early 2000s.
  - Share of Fund lending to members rated CCC to CC and SD: over 40 percent of total Fund credit at end-September 2021 (up from 30 percent in 2002‒03 and 21 percent in 2012).
  - Weighted average sovereign spreads of the Fund’s largest five borrowers peaked in spring 2020, declined through early-September 2020, but remain relatively high and have risen since then.

### Income and investment risks — projected income and Fund accounts
- Projected operational income (excluding IAS 19 pension gains/losses): staff projects total operational income would exceed total expenditures by an average of about SDR 1.2 billion annually in the three-year period through FY 2024.
- Drivers and risks:
  - Projected lending income higher over the medium term due to new GRA arrangements.
  - Investment income projections moderately higher due to larger-than-anticipated reserve accumulation; partly offset by suspension of PRGT reimbursements from FY 2022 to FY 2026.
  - Expenses projected higher reflecting proposed structural augmentation of 6 percent of net administrative budget in real U.S. dollar terms, phased in over FY 2023‒25.
  - Of average lending income projected through FY 2023, about 34 percent is from the Fund’s largest borrower and almost 38 percent by the next four largest borrowers.
  - Additional income risks: cancellations/changes in timing of purchases, uncertainties in global interest rate and U.S. dollar/SDR exchange rate, potential need for impairment recognition under IFRS 9 (no provisions recognized to date).

- Investment subaccounts:
  - FI: expanded fixed-income strategy performed well; downside risk limited though lower fixed-income returns provide less protection if rates increase; refinements may improve return margin without materially increasing risk.
  - EA: exceeded long-term return target of 3 percent real in US dollars due to strong market performance; future return risks greater given low yields, elevated equity valuations, and high inflation uncertainty; strategy needs evolution to mitigate erosion of real value of capital.

### Surcharges — role, historical trajectory, distribution, and projections
- Role and framework:
  - Surcharges provide incentives to limit exposures, encourage timely repurchases, and strengthen the Fund’s balance sheet to build precautionary balances.
  - Current framework: level-based surcharge of 200 basis points for total GRA credit outstanding exceeding 187.5 percent of quota (introduced 2016), plus time-based surcharge of 100 basis points when credit exceeds threshold for more than three years (51 months for Extended Arrangements).
- Historical surcharge income (exact figures):
  - Peak in FY 2015: SDR 1,463 million.
  - Fell to SDR 371 million in FY 2018.
  - Rose to SDR 931 million in FY 2021.
  - Share of surcharge income in total lending income: 53 percent in FY 2015; 32 percent in FY 2018; 47 percent in FY 2021.
- FY 2021 borrower counts and distribution:
  - FY 2021: 53 borrowing members subject to basic charges; 16 also subject to surcharges.
  - Top five surcharge payers (Argentina, Egypt, Ukraine, Pakistan, Ecuador) accounted for 95 percent of total surcharges income of SDR 931 million.
  - FY 2021: out of 53 GRA borrowing members, 37 paid no surcharges.
  - For 16 members that paid surcharges in FY 2021:
    - Median effective cost of borrowing: around 1.9 percent.
    - Implies an effective surcharge of 0.83 percent (net of the basic rate of charge).
    - For most surcharge-paying members, surcharge payments amounted to less than 5 percent of quota.
- Effective surcharge dynamics:
  - Average effective surcharge rate (for total credit outstanding) is substantially lower than the marginal surcharge rate; approaches the marginal rate asymptotically for very large exposures.
  - Even when market rates spiked, the effective cost of borrowing from the Fund for countries with large BOP needs remained relatively low and stable.

### Medium-term projections of surcharge income — scenario results (selected exact figures)
- Baseline (without new arrangements):
  - Number of surcharge-paying members subject to level-based surcharges: FY22 18, FY27 10.
  - Number subject to time-based surcharges: FY22 7, FY27 9.
  - Total Fund credit outstanding at year-end (SDR millions): FY22 89,486; FY23 74,315; FY24 51,421; FY25 32,757; FY26 22,888; FY27 16,609.
  - Amount of surcharges income collected (SDR millions): FY22 1,231; FY23 1,078; FY24 598; FY25 379; FY26 219; FY27 144.
  - Precautionary Balances (SDR billions, end of year): FY22 20.7; FY23 22.0; FY24 22.6; FY25 22.7; FY26 22.6; FY27 22.4.
  - Share of surcharge income in operational income (percent): FY22 47.1; FY23 46.5; FY24 39.1; FY25 33.1; FY26 25.3; FY27 17.2.
  - Share of lending income in operational income (percent): FY22 94.3; FY23 92.2; FY24 81.0; FY25 70.1; FY26 56.2; FY27 40.4.
- Desk survey scenario:
  - Total Fund credit outstanding at year-end (SDR millions): FY22 96,979; FY23 102,677; FY24 92,355; FY25 76,391; FY26 67,041; FY27 57,828.
  - Amount of surcharges income collected (SDR millions): FY22 1,261; FY23 1,521; FY24 1,485; FY25 1,309; FY26 1,161; FY27 1,057.
  - Precautionary Balances (SDR billions, end of year): FY22 20.8; FY23 22.8; FY24 24.9; FY25 26.4; FY26 27.7; FY27 28.9.
  - Share of surcharge income in operational income (percent): FY22 46.8; FY23 49.9; FY24 49.0; FY25 51.5; FY26 50.3; FY27 47.0.
  - Share of lending income in operational income (percent): FY22 94.4; FY23 93.9; FY24 90.0; FY25 85.4; FY26 81.3; FY27 74.8.
- WEO model-based scenario:
  - Total Fund credit outstanding at year-end (SDR millions): FY22 102,122; FY23 134,785; FY24 156,472; FY25 167,843; FY26 161,666; FY27 136,521.
  - Amount of surcharges income collected (SDR millions): FY22 1,263; FY23 1,531; FY24 1,633; FY25 1,958; FY26 2,132; FY27 2,081.
  - Precautionary Balances (SDR billions, end of year): FY22 20.8; FY23 23.2; FY24 26.0; FY25 29.1; FY26 32.4; FY27 35.6.
  - Share of surcharge income in operational income (percent): FY22 46.3; FY23 45.9; FY24 43.1; FY25 47.6; FY26 49.4; FY27 48.9.
  - Share of lending income in operational income (percent): FY22 94.5; FY23 94.4; FY24 91.9; FY25 90.6; FY26 89.1; FY27 85.1.
- Adverse scenario:
  - Total Fund credit outstanding at year-end (SDR millions): FY22 150,351; FY23 226,095; FY24 266,707; FY25 297,632; FY26 267,662; FY27 198,106.
  - Amount of surcharges income collected (SDR millions): FY22 1,314; FY23 2,454; FY24 2,899; FY25 3,592; FY26 4,069; FY27 3,516.
  - Precautionary Balances (SDR billions, end of year): FY22 20.8; FY23 24.9; FY24 29.9; FY25 36.0; FY26 42.6; FY27 48.2.
  - Share of surcharge income in operational income (percent): FY22 47.1; FY23 48.8; FY24 48.4; FY25 50.7; FY26 53.5; FY27 52.6.
  - Share of lending income in operational income (percent): FY22 94.6; FY23 96.3; FY24 94.5; FY25 93.8; FY26 92.5; FY27 88.5.
- Hypothetical two-year suspension of surcharges during FY 2023‒24 under the desk survey scenario: expected negative impact of SDR 3 billion on cumulative net operational income and reserves accumulation; precautionary balances projected to reach SDR 25 billion by FY 2027 only (about two years later than current desk survey projection).

### SCA-1, provisioning, and accounting implications
- SCA-1 role and recent action:
  - SCA-1 held contributions to protect against credit losses from member failures to settle overdue GRA obligations.
  - Distributions used to facilitate debt relief for Liberia, Somalia, and Sudan.
  - On May 10, 2021, the Board approved distribution of the full remaining amount in SCA-1 of SDR 1,066 million for Sudan’s arrears clearance and debt relief.
  - Staff proposal: keep SCA-1 open with a zero balance for the time being; could be replenished should new arrears arise.
- Provisioning and impact on precautionary balances (illustrative exact figures):
  - Effect of a hypothetical loan loss provision of SDR 2 billion on end-FY 2021:
    - Before provision: Credit outstanding 89.8; Precautionary balances 20.0.
    - Effect of provision: Credit outstanding (2.0); Precautionary balances (2.0).
    - After provision: Credit outstanding 87.8; Precautionary balances 18.0.
    - Indicative range for precautionary balances (20% lower bound / 30% upper bound):
      - Lower bound (20%): Before 18.0; Effect (0.4); After 17.6.
      - Higher bound (30%): Before 26.9; Effect (0.6); After 26.3.
  - Absent SCA-1, absence increases likelihood that the Fund would record a provision should new arrears arise; Executive Board would be consulted before any impairment loss is recorded.
- Funding constraints for a successor SCA: burden sharing capacity currently extremely low; using distribution of GRA income or reserves to fund a successor SCA would redistribute balances within precautionary balances and could reduce overall levels.

### Pension accounting (IAS 19) — volatility, alternative economic basis, and implications
- IAS 19 volatility drivers and sensitivity:
  - IAS 19 pension-related gains/losses include annual pension expense and actuarial remeasurement.
  - Defined benefit obligation measurement sensitive to nominal discount rate; a 50bps change in discount rate can change DBO valuation by approximately SDR 1 billion.
  - Discount curve: FTSE AA zero coupon hypothetical bond yields (6 months to 30 years).
- Alternative proposal (economic / long-term basis):
  - Use a long-term measure representative of expected long-term asset returns (3 percent real) and add back/(deduct) net defined benefit liability/(asset) before adjusting for long-term basis.
  - Long-term assumptions: 3 percent real return implies 5 percent nominal expected return assuming 2 percent inflation.
  - Operational effect: smoothing DBO fluctuations and producing a more gradual, less volatile precautionary balances path.
- Retrospective comparison (exact figures, Table 5 excerpts, In SDR millions unless stated):
  - Accounting basis: Defined Benefit Obligations (A): FY 2016 -8,068; FY 2017 -8,433; FY 2018 -8,625; FY 2019 -9,596; FY 2020 -12,018; FY 2021 -11,425.
  - Plan Assets (B): FY 2016 7,560; FY 2017 8,645; FY 2018 9,077; FY 2019 9,559; FY 2020 9,010; FY 2021 11,220.
  - Net Asset/(Liability) (B - A) (C): FY 2016 -508; FY 2017 212; FY 2018 452; FY 2019 -37; FY 2020 -3,008; FY 2021 -205.
  - IAS 19 basis Funding Ratio (B/A): FY 2016 94%; FY 2017 103%; FY 2018 105%; FY 2019 100%; FY 2020 75%; FY 2021 98%.
  - Economic basis (5% nominal / 3% real): Defined Benefit Obligations (D): FY 2016 -6,571; FY 2017 -7,139; FY 2018 -7,377; FY 2019 -7,975; FY 2020 -8,278; FY 2021 -8,259.
  - Net Asset/(Liability) Economic (F = E - D): FY 2016 989; FY 2017 1,506; FY 2018 1,700; FY 2019 1,584; FY 2020 732; FY 2021 2,961.
  - 3% real basis Funding Ratio (E/D): FY 2016 115%; FY 2017 121%; FY 2018 123%; FY 2019 120%; FY 2020 109%; FY 2021 136%.
  - Precautionary Balances (Accounting basis): FY 2016 15,223; FY 2017 16,713; FY 2018 17,469; FY 2019 17,656; FY 2020 15,984; FY 2021 20,013.
  - Precautionary Balances (Retrospective Economic Basis): FY 2016 15,731; FY 2017 16,501; FY 2018 17,017; FY 2019 17,693; FY 2020 18,992; FY 2021 20,218.
- Transition timing and effect:
  - If approved, transition to new approach anticipated to commence in FY 2022.
  - Transition entails adding back SDR 205 million to the opening (end-FY 2021) precautionary balances, raising the current path by SDR 205 million from FY 2022 onwards, provided Plan’s funding ratio projected to remain above 100 percent on an economic basis.
  - Any change applied prospectively; staff to monitor for potential material underfunded positions.

### Governance, framework, methodology, and demand modeling
- Framework:
  - Interim review uses the transparent rules-based framework employed since 2010; no changes to broad framework proposed.
  - Assessment anchored in forward-looking measure of average credit outstanding over three years (average of past 12 months and projections 2 years forward).
- Demand for new programs methodology:
  - Panel logit regression on 96 countries over 1992–2019, 104 GRA arrangements; threshold probability 3.9 percent (minimizes Type I and Type II errors).
  - With 3.9 percent threshold, model correctly identifies 88 percent of new programs over 1992–2019.
  - Prediction for FY 2022‒23 uses October 2021 WEO baseline and 2021 year-to-date average VIX 19.8.
- Logit estimation selected coefficients (dy/dx) and sample stats:
  - Past program (dummy): 0.419*** (SE 0.064, P-value 0.000)
  - Reserve accumulation: -0.0469* (SE 0.026, P-value 0.071)
  - External Financing Needs: 0.684** (SE 0.293, P-value 0.020)
  - GDP growth: -0.0951*** (SE 0.026, P-value 0.000)
  - GDP per capita: -0.965*** (SE 0.179, P-value 0.000)
  - Credit gap: 0.0229** (SE 0.009, P-value 0.012)
  - Government stability: -0.330*** (SE 0.074, P-value 0.000)
  - VIX: 0.0700*** (SE 0.026, P-value 0.008)
  - Pseudo R2: 0.440; Observations: 2,113; Countries: 96; GRA Arrangements: 138; Likelihood ratio (p-value): 0.002.

### Burden sharing capacity and limits
- SDR interest rate: at minimum threshold of 0.050 percent.
- Fund’s burden sharing capacity as of September 2021: about SDR 15 million, compared to SDR 23 million at time of last review (Annex III).
- Current burden sharing capacity very low relative to projected charges coming due; emergence of new unpaid charges could have sizeable negative impact on Fund income.
- Fund’s current credit capacity: US$1 trillion (unchanged). Applying 6 percent would yield an indicative target of more than SDR 40 billion (about 60 percent higher than current SDR 25 billion target).

### Issues for Directors (questions presented)
- Do Directors agree with staff’s assessment of the credit risks facing the Fund?
- Do Directors agree that the indicative medium-term target for precautionary balances should be maintained at SDR 25 billion while being monitored closely in light of large exposures and pandemic-related evolving credit risks?
- Do Directors see merit that the minimum floor for precautionary balances be kept unchanged at SDR 15 billion, but be revisited after the next review of the Investment Account?
- Do Directors agree that it would not appear necessary at this point to take additional steps to accelerate the pace of precautionary balance accumulation?
- Do Directors consider that the role of surcharges and their design remain broadly appropriate?
- Do Directors see merit in reflecting further on the role of surcharges in the Fund financing model?
- Do Directors see merit in maintaining the SCA-1 account with a zero balance?
- Do Directors see merit in adjusting the measurement of precautionary balances to address accounting volatility due to IAS 19?
- Do Directors consider appropriate an adjustment for a potential underfunded position of the pension Fund that would reflect the long-term economic risk of the plan?

*Source: IMF Finance Department; prepared November 12, 2021; figures and analysis as of end-September 2021.*

### EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

### EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

### Precautionary balances: role and recent decision context
- Precautionary balances are a key element of the Fund’s multilayered framework to mitigate financial risks and provide buffers to absorb losses from credit, income, and other financial risks.
- Composition: balances in the general and special reserves (excluding gold sales profits). The SCA-1 was included prior to its full distribution in the context of Sudan’s arrears clearance.
- At the last bi-annual review (completed on October 30, 2020) the Board decided to raise the indicative medium-term target for precautionary balances to SDR 25 billion and kept the minimum floor at SDR 15 billion.
- Directors called for a reassessment of the adequacy of precautionary balances before the next regular review given heightened pandemic-related uncertainty.

### Developments since the last review
- Overall financial risks remain elevated but have not increased significantly since the last review.
- Key drivers of credit risk:
  - Historically high exposure.
  - Significant loan concentration toward the largest borrower, whose repurchase schedule is bunched in the near future.
  - A sizable share of emergency financing without ex-post conditionality in the lending portfolio.
- Market-based indicators and ratings suggest perceived credit quality of sovereign debt issued by the Fund’s borrowers remains weak.
- Investment risks: expected returns across all asset classes are lower than in the past.

### Precautionary balances composition, size, and coverage
- Precautionary balances currently comprise the Fund’s general and special reserves.
  - Special reserve: established as a first line to absorb administrative losses; initially funded by proceeds from a gold investment program and later net income allocations. Under the Fund’s Articles, no distributions can be made from the special reserve.
  - General reserve: established to absorb capital losses and meet administrative losses; funded through income allocations. General reserve distributions may be made to members with Board approval by a 70 percent majority of total voting power.
- The SCA-1 (First Special Contingent Account) was fully distributed to contributors in June 2021 in the context of Sudan’s arrears clearance and debt relief and currently has zero balances.
- Levels and changes:
  - Precautionary balances stood at SDR 20.0 billion at end-FY 2021, compared to SDR 16.0 billion at end-FY 2020.
  - Precautionary balances were at SDR 19.3 billion at end-July 2021 after taking into account the SCA-1 distribution of SDR 1.1 billion and SDR 0.3 billion net operational income in FY 2022 through July 2021.
  - General reserves estimated to have increased from SDR 10.8 billion in FY 2020 to SDR 12.2 billion.
  - Special reserves estimated to have increased from SDR 4.2 billion in FY 2020 to SDR 7.1 billion at end-July 2021.
  - The general and special reserve accumulation reflects a GRA net income of SDR 4.0 billion in FY 2021, stemming mainly from large pension related (IAS19) gains (SDR 3.2 billion), as well as SDR 0.3 billion net operational income through July 2021 (assumes equal allocation of income earned through end-July).
- Coverage ratios:
  - Coverage relative to lending capacity increased from 2.2 percent at the time of the last review to 2.7 percent (the highest since 2009).
  - The ratio of precautionary balances to credit outstanding rose to about 21 percent at end-July 2021 from about 19 percent in August last year.
  - The ratio of precautionary balances to commitments improved to 10.5 percent.
  - Despite improvements, coverage relative to outstanding credit and commitments remains lower than before the pandemic.

### Assessment of adequacy and staff proposals
- Staff proposes to leave the medium-term target of SDR 25 billion and the minimum floor of SDR 15 billion unchanged at this time.
- Rationale:
  - Taking into account expected new demand for Fund lending, the current target of SDR 25 billion would remain within the indicative range of the forward-looking measure of average credit outstanding.
  - Other qualitative considerations point to elevated risk but do not suggest a significant deterioration compared to the last review.
- Timing:
  - The target will need to be reassessed at the next regular review in about a year’s time.

### Pace of accumulation and projection
- With the projected increase in lending income, the pace of reserve accumulation is expected to remain adequate relative to the medium-term indicative target.
- Even after factoring in the proposed budget augmentation, the SDR 25 billion target would be reached in early Fiscal Year (FY) 2025 under the desk survey scenario—one year earlier than projected at the 2020 review.
- Recent operational income and adjustments included in accumulation:
  - PB - beginning of period: 17.7 (FY 2020); 16.0 (FY 2021); 20.0 (FY 2022 end-July)
  - Operational income: 2.3 (FY 2020); 2.1 (FY 2021); 0.7 (FY 2022 through end-July)
    - lending income incl. surcharges: 1.9; 2.0; 0.7
    - non-lending income: 0.4; 0.1; 0.0
  - Admin expenses: -0.9; -1.2; -0.3
  - Net operational income: 1.4; 0.9; 0.3
  - IAS19 gain/loss: -3.0; 3.2; 0.0
  - Distribution of SCA-1: -1.1
  - PB - end of period: 16.0 (FY 2020); 20.0 (FY 2021); 19.3 (FY 2022 end-July)

### Issues related to SCA-1, accounting, and policy factors affecting reserves
- The paper reviews policy factors discussed in recent Board meetings that affect the level and accumulation of reserves. These include:
  - The role of the First Special Contingent Account (SCA-1), after its full distribution in the context of Sudan’s arrears clearance.
  - IFRS 9 credit impairment provisioning.
  - The income volatility created by accounting for pensions revaluations under IAS 19.
  - Surcharge policies and the role of surcharges in reserve accumulation.
- Recent Board engagements informing the analysis:
  - Informal session on March 8, 2021 on the interim update of the Fund’s income position for FY 2021, including options for treatment of IAS 19 remeasurement gains and losses.
  - Annual Review of the Fund’s Income Position for FY 2021 and FY 2022 discussed April 27, 2021, where the Board agreed to maintain the margin for the rate of charge at 100 basis points over the SDR interest rate for FY 2022.
  - Informal discussion on the role of the SCA-1 on March 31, 2021, and the Board decision on modalities of clearance of Sudan’s arrears on April 30, 2021.
  - Informal engagement on the role of surcharges on September 17, 2021.

### Governance, framework, and next steps
- The interim review uses the transparent and rules-based framework employed since 2010 to guide the assessment while allowing room for judgment; no changes to the broad framework are proposed.
- The paper also discusses:
  - Projected pace of accumulation of precautionary balances under different demand scenarios.
  - Further analysis of the role of surcharges in reserve accumulation.
  - Treatment of pensions net assets/(liability) under IAS 19 and impact on precautionary balances.
  - Enterprise risk implications of staff proposals are summarized in Box 2.
- The target and minimum floor will be reassessed at the next regular review in about a year’s time.

*November 12, 2021 — Prepared by Finance Department; approved by Bernard Lauwers (FIN).*

### 11.      Credit outstanding has nearly

### 11.      Credit outstanding has nearly matched the previous peak following the global financial crisis

### Credit outstanding and total commitments
- Fund credit outstanding reached nearly SDR 90 billion in September 2021, close to maximum levels reached during FY 2012‒13.
- Credit outstanding increased by SDR 4.1 billion (4.8 percent) compared to the time of the 2020 review, driven mostly by disbursements under upper credit tranche programs.
- Only two new Rapid Financial Instrument (RFI) and three RFI blends with the Rapid Credit Facility were approved after October 2020, with total GRA disbursements of SDR 0.6 billion.
- The rise in new financing has more than offset sizable early repurchases by Greece and Morocco.
- Based on current arrangements as of end-September 2021, credit outstanding would peak in FY 2022 at about SDR 92.8 billion.
- Without new demand, Fund credit is expected to fall below SDR 90 billion by the end of FY 2022.
- Compared to the 2020 review, the projected credit path has increased by an average of about SDR 7 billion over the period FY 2022‒24.
- Total commitments were nearly SDR 182 billion at end-September 2021 (includes undrawn balances under existing arrangements and precautionary arrangements, including FCLs for Chile, Colombia, Mexico and Peru, and the PLL for Panama).

### Credit concentration and regional exposure
- Credit concentration to the largest borrower reached about 34 percent as of end-September 2021, down from a peak of 48 percent at end-2019 and nearly 38 percent at the time of the last review.
- The share of outstanding Fund credit toward the five largest borrowers (Argentina, Egypt, Ukraine, Pakistan and Ecuador) stood at 68 percent as of end-September 2021, close to the historical average.
- Regional concentration remains tilted toward the Western Hemisphere reflecting sizable outstanding credit from Argentina and significant exposure on a commitment basis through FCL arrangements with Chile, Mexico, Colombia, and Peru and the PLL to Panama.
- At end-September 2021 the Fund’s exposure to Argentina amounted to SDR 30.6 billion; exposure to Egypt was SDR 14.2 billion; exposures to the other three largest borrowers were SDR 6.7 billion to Ukraine; SDR 5.0 billion to Pakistan; and SDR 4.3 billion to Ecuador.

### Emergency financing instruments and scheduled repurchases
- As of end-September 2021, the share of outstanding RFIs was about 17 percent of the Fund’s outstanding lending portfolio—significantly higher than before the pandemic and just slightly above the share at the time of the last review.
- GRA disbursements under the RFI and RFI blends since the last review amounted to SDR 0.6 billion.
- Total scheduled repurchases in FY 2023‒25 amount to nearly SDR 63 billion—an average of SDR 21 billion per year, reflecting scheduled repurchases by Argentina and repurchases associated with one-off RFI disbursements.
- Argentina’s repurchases alone account for SDR 15.5 billion in FY 2023 and SDR 10.3 billion in FY 2024; relative to quota, Argentina’s scheduled repurchases peak at 486 percent of quota in FY 2023.
- Repurchases of single tranche RFIs disbursements account for about SDR 15.8 billion, with the bulk scheduled in FY 2024‒25.

### Perceived credit risks: sovereign ratings and spreads
- The average sovereign credit rating of the Fund’s borrowers, weighted by Fund outstanding credit in each rating category, remains at levels last observed in the early 2000s.
- The share of Fund lending to member countries rated CCC to CC and SD represents over 40 percent of total Fund credit at end-September 2021, up from an average 30 percent in 2002‒03, and 21 percent in 2012.
- The number of Fund borrowers rated less than BB remains at historical highs following the increase in emergency lending during the pandemic.
- The weighted average of sovereign spreads of the Fund’s largest five borrowers peaked in spring 2020, declined through early-September 2020, but remain relatively high and have risen since then.

### Income risks and projected operational income
- Staff projects total operational income, excluding IAS 19 pension gains or losses, would exceed total expenditures by an average of about SDR 1.2 billion annually in the three-year period through FY 2024.
- Projected lending income is higher over the medium term than in the last review, reflecting mainly new GRA arrangements approved since then.
- Investment income projections are moderately higher over the medium term, reflecting larger-than-anticipated reserve accumulation since the last review; these are partly offset by the suspension of PRGT reimbursements from FY 2022 to FY 2026.
- Expenses are projected to be higher reflecting a proposed structural augmentation of 6 percent of the net administrative budget in real U.S. dollar terms, phased in over FY 2023‒25.
- Of the average lending income projected through FY 2023, about 34 percent is accounted for by the Fund’s largest borrower and almost 38 percent by the next four largest borrowers.
- Additional risks to income include: (i) cancellations and changes in the timing of purchases under existing arrangements; (ii) uncertainties around the global interest rate environment and U.S. dollar/SDR exchange rate path; and (iii) potential need for impairment recognition under IFRS 9. No provisions for impairment have been recognized to date.

### Financial risks related to investments
- Financial risks related to the Endowment Subaccount (EA) and the Fixed-Income Subaccount (FI) remain elevated.
- FI investments: the FI’s expanded investment strategy has performed well, generating returns consistently in excess of the SDR interest rate and demonstrating resilience; estimated downside risk remains limited, though lower fixed-income returns provide limited protection if rates increase. Refinements may be considered to improve return margin without materially increasing risk.
- EA investments: the EA exceeded its long-term return target of 3 percent real in US dollars due to strong market performance; going forward, risks to the return outlook are greater given historically low yield levels, elevated equity valuations (for some markets), and high inflation uncertainty. The EA strategy would need to evolve to mitigate erosion of the real value of capital and improve probability of achieving its return target.

### Assessment of precautionary balances and scenarios
- Staff assessment: credit exposures and associated risks remain elevated. Taking into account expected increase in demand for Fund lending, the current target for precautionary balances of SDR 25 billion is expected to remain within the indicative range and higher than its mid-point. Other qualitative considerations point to elevated risk but do not suggest a significant deterioration compared to the October 2020 review. Staff proposes to leave the medium-term target unchanged; the target will be reassessed at the next regular review in about a year.
- The assessment is anchored in the 2010 rules-based framework, starting from a forward-looking measure of average credit outstanding over three years (average of past 12 months and projections 2 years forward).

Baseline and alternative scenarios (forward-looking measure and indicative ranges)
- Baseline (existing arrangements, no new arrangements): forward-looking measure of credit outstanding would peak at about SDR 79 billion in FY 2022 (some SDR 7 billion higher than projected at the time of the previous review). The calculated indicative range for FY 2022 would be about SDR 16 to nearly 24 billion, with the midpoint at nearly SDR 20 billion.
- Desk survey scenario (staff desk assessments): 13 countries (of which 8 have received emergency financing) would enter new Fund-supported programs in FY 2022–23 for a total of about SDR 45 billion. Indicative range would increase to between nearly SDR 20 billion and 29 billion in FY 2022; the current SDR 25 billion target would be near the mid-point.
- WEO model-based scenario (October 2021 WEO baseline): new demand for Fund programs, including successor arrangements, could reach nearly SDR 148 billion over FY 2022‒23; indicative range could be between about SDR 24 billion and SDR 35 billion in FY 2022. The forward-looking credit measure in FY 2022 is anticipated to be nearly SDR 23 billion lower than projected at the time of the last review. The SDR 25 billion target would remain within the indicative range, although significantly below its mid-point.
- Adverse scenario: new demand for Fund programs could reach nearly SDR 213 billion and all FCL and PLL arrangements are assumed fully drawn, for total disbursements around SDR 72 billion. In this scenario the indicative range would rise to between around SDR 36 billion and SDR 53 billion in FY 2022, significantly above the SDR 25 billion target.

- Note: Baseline projections assume purchases and repurchases under existing active non-precautionary arrangements take place as scheduled and no drawings under existing precautionary arrangements.

*Source: IMF Finance Department; figures and analysis as of end-September 2021.*

### 23.      Other relevant risk factors, discussed in the previous review, remain elevated, but have

### 23.      Other relevant risk factors, discussed in the previous review, remain elevated, but have

### Credit and concentration risks
- Sizable total credit combined with a heavy concentration of the loan portfolio toward the largest borrower.
- Risks compounded by a heavy bunching of scheduled repurchases in FY 2023‒25 and significant challenges facing Argentina, exacerbated by the COVID-19 crisis.
- Market-based indicators: perceived average credit quality of sovereign debt of Fund borrowers is weak, but do not point to significant deterioration compared to the last review.
- Regional concentration has increased only slightly since the last review.
- Share of RFIs in loan portfolio: emergency financing instruments share of the credit portfolio remains elevated and has risen only marginally since the last review; repurchases are bunched in FY 2024‒25; RFIs are not subject to ex-post/upper credit tranche (UCT) conditionality.
- Global outlook and COVID-19 uncertainty: economic fundamentals of many Fund borrowers deteriorated with the pandemic; balance of payments financing may become challenging for several borrowers; risks and vulnerabilities have not worsened compared to the past review as discussed in the October 2021 Global Financial Stability Report and Fiscal Monitor.

### Level and concentration of precautionary arrangements
- Commitments under the Fund’s precautionary arrangements: about SDR 84 billion as of end-September 2021, slightly higher than SDR 82 billion at the last review.
- All four FCL arrangements and the only outstanding PLL arrangement are concentrated in one region.
- Probability of significant correlated drawdowns can no longer be deemed as small as before the COVID-19 pandemic, though probability of further drawings under these arrangements appears relatively low at this juncture.

### Burden sharing capacity and lending capacity
- SDR interest rate at the minimum threshold of 0.050 percent.
- Fund’s burden sharing capacity as of September 2021: about SDR 15 million, compared to SDR 23 million at the time of the last review (Annex III).
- Current burden sharing capacity is very low relative to projected charges coming due over the coming year; emergence of new unpaid charges could have a sizeable negative impact on Fund income.
- Executive Board discussed precautionary balances target to credit capacity ratio of 6 percent historically.
- Fund’s current credit capacity: US$1 trillion (unchanged from the last review).
- Applying 6 percent to US$1 trillion would yield an indicative target of more than SDR 40 billion, 60 percent higher than the current target.

### Indicative medium-term target for precautionary balances
- Staff proposal: maintain the indicative medium-term target for precautionary balances at SDR 25 billion.
- Rationale: current target close to the midpoint of the indicative range under the desk survey scenario, which staff considers the most plausible scenario for demand of new Fund programs.
- An increase in the target would be predicated on significant additional lending, which desk surveys currently do not anticipate.

### Minimum floor
- Minimum floor unchanged at SDR 15 billion at the 2020 review.
- Considerations: precautionary balances are an important source of Fund income; Fund credit can be volatile and increase sharply; building precautionary balances takes time.
- Staff proposal: keep the floor at SDR 15 billion for now.
- Note: case for raising the floor could be revisited if outlook for longer-term investment returns deteriorates; preferable to revisit after the Review of the Investment Account planned for January 2022.

### Pace of accumulation and projected timing
- Under the desk survey scenario (including proposed budget augmentation), the SDR 25 billion target would be reached in early FY 2025—one year earlier than projected at the 2020 review.
- Under a scenario with new financing beyond the desk survey (consistent with the October 2021 WEO baseline), the SDR 25 billion target would be exceeded by the end of FY 2024.
- Under the more adverse scenario, which assumes full drawdown of existing FCL and PLL arrangements, the SDR 25 billion target would be nearly achieved in FY 2023.
- Under the baseline with no new arrangements, precautionary balances would not reach the SDR 25 billion target within the forecasting period of FY 2022‒26.
- Projections take into account: full SCA-1 distribution, five-year suspension of the PRGT reimbursement of expenses for FY 2022‒26 approved by the Board in July 2021, a 6 percent budget augmentation starting in FY 2023 phased-in in three equal increments before full augmentation in FY 2025, and unchanged levels of charges, surcharges and fees.
- Projected path subject to significant uncertainty: sensitive to assumptions about potential new programs and timely completion of program reviews; weaker program performance affecting scheduled purchases and charges could slow accumulation; heightened credit risks could impact income.
- Staff view: no additional steps needed now to speed up accumulation; continue close monitoring and discussion with the Board at the next regular review in about a year.

### Analysis of surcharges
- Role under scrutiny given global pandemic: surcharges remain integral to the Fund’s multi-layered risk management framework.
- Surcharges objectives: provide incentives to limit exposures, encourage timely repurchases, and help strengthen Fund’s balance sheet to allow accumulation of precautionary balances as credit exposures grow.
- Current framework: level and time-based surcharges introduced in 2009; level-based surcharge of 200 basis points for total GRA credit outstanding exceeding the threshold set at 187.5 percent of quota in 2016; additional time-based surcharge of 100 basis points broadly aligned with maturity profile of GRA facilities and applies when credit exceeds the threshold for more than three years (or 51 months in case of Extended Arrangements).
- Surcharge income trajectory:
  - Peak in FY 2015: SDR 1,463 million.
  - Fell to SDR 371 million in FY 2018.
  - Rose to SDR 931 million in FY 2021.
  - Share of surcharge income in total lending income: 53 percent in FY 2015; 32 percent in FY 2018; 47 percent in FY 2021.
- Borrower counts:
  - FY 2021: 53 borrowing members subject to basic charges; 16 also subject to surcharges.
  - FY 2015: 29 borrowing members (10 surcharge paying members).
  - FY 2018: 27 borrowing members (9 surcharge paying members).
- Surcharges support Fund’s role as global lender of last resort by building precautionary balances to protect reserve assets and enable low-cost assistance.
- Effective surcharge dynamics:
  - Average effective surcharge rate (for total credit outstanding) is substantially lower than the marginal surcharge rate; the former approaches the latter asymptotically for very large exposures.
  - Even when market rates spiked, the effective cost of borrowing from the Fund for countries with large BOP needs remained relatively low and stable.
- Distribution of surcharge income:
  - Heaviest users of Fund resources have consistently accounted for the bulk of surcharge income.
  - In FY 2021, the top five surcharge payers—Argentina, Egypt, Ukraine, Pakistan, and Ecuador—accounted for 95 percent of total surcharges income of SDR 931 million.
  - Surcharge income represented about 45 percent of operational income in FY 2021.
- Cost comparison and repayment behavior:
  - For top five surcharge-paying members, the unweighted average effective cost of borrowing from the Fund has remained significantly lower compared to the unweighted average market rate for these members.
  - Many borrowers with credit outstanding exceeding the surcharge threshold made early repayments before the pandemic, particularly after time-based surcharges became effective.
  - Since the pandemic onset, two large early repurchases occurred: Morocco in January 2021 and Greece in March 2021 (Greece was already below the level-based surcharge threshold at the pandemic onset).
  - For some members subject to time-based surcharges, market access remains limited or very costly.
- FY 2021 surcharge payment details:
  - Out of 53 GRA borrowing members, 37 paid no surcharges.
  - For 16 members that paid surcharges in FY 2021:
    - Median effective cost of borrowing: around 1.9 percent.
    - Implies an effective surcharge of 0.83 percent (net of the basic rate of charge).
    - For most surcharge-paying members, surcharge payments amounted to less than 5 percent of quota.
    - Largest borrowers paid a relatively high share of surcharges (in percent of their quotas), reflecting exceptionally high level and/or duration of exposure.

*International Monetary Fund — Adequacy of the Fund’s Precautionary Balances (excerpt)*

### 36.      The projected amount of surcharge income, its impact across the membership, and its

### ppea2021073 - 36.      The projected amount of surcharge income, its impact across the membership, and its

### Medium-term projections of surcharge income (main findings)
- Projections are sensitive to future demand for GRA resources.
- Baseline (without new arrangements):
  - Number of surcharge-paying members would steadily decline to ten by FY 2027.
  - Total surcharge income, its share in operational income, and lending income’s share in operational income would decline significantly over the medium term.
  - Contribution of the five largest surcharge payers to total surcharge income would remain elevated and in line with the historical trend.
  - Share of time-based surcharges in total surcharge income would fluctuate around 25 percent during FY 2022‒25 before rising to about 33 percent by FY 2027.
  - Table (selected figures):
    - Number of surcharge-paying members subject to level-based surcharges: FY22 18, FY27 10.
    - Number subject to time-based surcharges: FY22 7, FY27 9.
    - Total Fund credit outstanding at year-end (SDR millions): FY22 89,486; FY23 74,315; FY24 51,421; FY25 32,757; FY26 22,888; FY27 16,609.
    - Amount of surcharges income collected (SDR millions, by year): FY22 1,231; FY23 1,078; FY24 598; FY25 379; FY26 219; FY27 144.
    - Share of top 5 surcharge-paying members in total surcharges income (percent): FY22 94.2; FY23 91.2; FY24 84.2; FY25 88.0; FY26 89.1; FY27 95.0.
    - Precautionary Balances (SDR billions, end of year): FY22 20.7; FY23 22.0; FY24 22.6; FY25 22.7; FY26 22.6; FY27 22.4.
    - Share of surcharge income in operational income (percent): FY22 47.1; FY23 46.5; FY24 39.1; FY25 33.1; FY26 25.3; FY27 17.2.
    - Share of lending income in operational income (percent): FY22 94.3; FY23 92.2; FY24 81.0; FY25 70.1; FY26 56.2; FY27 40.4.

- Desk survey scenario:
  - Number of surcharge-paying members would increase to 22 by FY 2024 before declining to 19 by FY 2027.
  - Total surcharge income projected to peak at about SDR 1.5 billion by FY 2023.
  - Share of surcharge income in operational income would hover around 50 percent for the next several years.
  - Lending income’s share in operational income would decline gradually from around 94 percent in FY 2022 to around 75 percent by FY 2027.
  - Five largest surcharge payers would account for above 90 percent of total surcharge income.
  - Share of time-based surcharges would fluctuate around ¼ to ⅓.
  - Table (selected figures):
    - Total Fund credit outstanding at year-end (SDR millions): FY22 96,979; FY23 102,677; FY24 92,355; FY25 76,391; FY26 67,041; FY27 57,828.
    - Amount of surcharges income collected (SDR millions): FY22 1,261; FY23 1,521; FY24 1,485; FY25 1,309; FY26 1,161; FY27 1,057.
    - Precautionary Balances (SDR billions, end of year): FY22 20.8; FY23 22.8; FY24 24.9; FY25 26.4; FY26 27.7; FY27 28.9.
    - Share of surcharge income in operational income (percent): FY22 46.8; FY23 49.9; FY24 49.0; FY25 51.5; FY26 50.3; FY27 47.0.
    - Share of lending income in operational income (percent): FY22 94.4; FY23 93.9; FY24 90.0; FY25 85.4; FY26 81.3; FY27 74.8.

- WEO model-based scenario:
  - Number of surcharge-paying members would increase to 38 in FY 2024 and FY 2025.
  - Total surcharge income would increase by 50 percent to exceed SDR 2 billion during FY 2026‒27.
  - Share of surcharge income in operational income would stay in the range of 46 to 49 percent for the next several years.
  - Lending income’s share in operational income would decline from around 95 percent in FY 2022 to 85 percent in FY 2027.
  - Contribution of largest five surcharge payers to total surcharge income would decline to the range of 72‒74 percent during FY 2025‒27 from around 94 percent in FY 2022.
  - Share of time-based surcharges projected to decline from about 25 percent in FY 2022 to about 17 percent by FY 2026, before returning to about 25 percent by FY 2027.
  - Table (selected figures):
    - Total Fund credit outstanding at year-end (SDR millions): FY22 102,122; FY23 134,785; FY24 156,472; FY25 167,843; FY26 161,666; FY27 136,521.
    - Amount of surcharges income collected (SDR millions): FY22 1,263; FY23 1,531; FY24 1,633; FY25 1,958; FY26 2,132; FY27 2,081.
    - Precautionary Balances (SDR billions, end of year): FY22 20.8; FY23 23.2; FY24 26.0; FY25 29.1; FY26 32.4; FY27 35.6.
    - Share of surcharge income in operational income (percent): FY22 46.3; FY23 45.9; FY24 43.1; FY25 47.6; FY26 49.4; FY27 48.9.
    - Share of lending income in operational income (percent): FY22 94.5; FY23 94.4; FY24 91.9; FY25 90.6; FY26 89.1; FY27 85.1.

- Adverse scenario:
  - Number of surcharge-paying members and surcharge income would increase even more sharply.
  - Table (selected figures):
    - Total Fund credit outstanding at year-end (SDR millions): FY22 150,351; FY23 226,095; FY24 266,707; FY25 297,632; FY26 267,662; FY27 198,106.
    - Amount of surcharges income collected (SDR millions): FY22 1,314; FY23 2,454; FY24 2,899; FY25 3,592; FY26 4,069; FY27 3,516.
    - Precautionary Balances (SDR billions, end of year): FY22 20.8; FY23 24.9; FY24 29.9; FY25 36.0; FY26 42.6; FY27 48.2.
    - Share of surcharge income in operational income (percent): FY22 47.1; FY23 48.8; FY24 48.4; FY25 50.7; FY26 53.5; FY27 52.6.
    - Share of lending income in operational income (percent): FY22 94.6; FY23 96.3; FY24 94.5; FY25 93.8; FY26 92.5; FY27 88.5.

### Hypothetical surcharge relief during the pandemic
- A hypothetical two-year suspension of surcharges during FY 2023‒24 under the desk survey scenario:
  - Expected negative impact of SDR 3 billion on cumulative net operational income and reserves accumulation as well as on the precautionary balances level.
  - Precautionary balances would be projected to reach the target level of SDR 25 billion by FY 2027 only, i.e., about two years later than currently projected under the desk survey scenario.

### Evolution and structure of surcharges (historical and policy context)
- Surcharges were introduced in 1997 with the establishment of the Supplemental Reserve Facility (SRF).
- In 2000:
  - Level-based surcharges were introduced on purchases in the credit tranches and under extended arrangements, starting at 200 percent of quota with a two-step increase.
  - A schedule of repurchase expectations policy (TBRE) was introduced.
- In 2009:
  - Surcharges were streamlined and aligned across all GRA facilities.
  - TBRE was eliminated and replaced by time-based surcharges on credit outstanding under all GRA facilities.
- At the 2016 review:
  - Threshold for level-based surcharges changed from 200 percent of quota (13th review) to 187.5 percent of quota (14th review).
  - Trigger for time-based surcharges for credit under the Extended Fund Facility (EFF) moved from 36 months to 51 months.
- Table 2 historical highlights (selected figures, as of end of fiscal year April 30, in SDR millions):
  - Number of member countries with GRA credit outstanding: 2012 37; 2021 53.
  - Amount of Surcharge Income Collected (SDR millions, by year): 2012 907; 2013 1,241; 2014 1,398; 2015 1,463; 2016 787; 2017 583; 2018 371; 2019 419; 2020 752; 2021 931.
  - From level-based surcharges: 2012 907; 2013 1,151; 2014 1,126; 2015 991; 2016 554; 2017 424; 2018 284; 2019 374; 2020 709; 2021 863.
  - From time-based surcharges: 2013 89; 2014 272; 2015 473; 2016 233; 2017 159; 2018 87; 2019 45; 2020 43; 2021 68.

### SCA-1 account, provisioning, and implications for precautionary balances
- Role and recent actions:
  - The SCA-1 held contributions targeted to protect the Fund against potential credit losses from member failures to settle overdue GRA obligations.
  - Distributions of SCA-1 balances have been used to facilitate debt relief for Liberia, Somalia, and Sudan.
  - On May 10, 2021, the Board approved distribution of the full remaining amount in SCA-1 of SDR 1,066 million for Sudan’s arrears clearance and debt relief.
- Views and funding constraints:
  - Executive Directors expressed mixed views on a successor SCA; preference to prioritize Sudan’s arrears clearance over discussion of a successor SCA.
  - Funding options for a successor SCA are limited; burden sharing capacity is currently extremely low.
  - Using distribution of GRA income or reserves to fund a successor SCA would redistribute balances within precautionary balances and could reduce overall levels due to leakage.
  - Other staff-considered options raise issues of members’ willingness, timing of domestic approvals, and operational questions.
- Impact on provisioning and accounting:
  - SCA-1 historically allowed the Fund to record loans in arrears at full face value to the extent SCA-1 covered principal arrears.
  - Absence of SCA-1 increases likelihood that the Fund would record a provision should new arrears arise.
  - If new arrears emerge and expected credit losses are material, an impairment loss provision would be recognized; the Executive Board would be consulted before any impairment loss is recorded.
  - A provision for impairment losses reduces precautionary balances (charged against income), but the indicative precautionary target range based on credit outstanding would also be lower since credit outstanding would be reduced by the provision.
  - Illustrative Table 4 (effect of a hypothetical loan loss provision of SDR 2 billion):
    - Before provision (end-FY 2021): Credit outstanding 89.8; Precautionary balances 20.0.
    - Effect of hypothetical provision of SDR 2 billion: Credit outstanding (2.0); Precautionary balances (2.0).
    - After hypothetical provision: Credit outstanding 87.8; Precautionary balances 18.0.
    - Indicative range for precautionary balances:
      - Lower bound (20%): Before 18.0; Effect (0.4); After 17.6.
      - Higher bound (30%): Before 26.9; Effect (0.6); After 26.3.
  - Staff proposal: keep SCA-1 open with a zero balance for the time being; could be replenished should new arrears arise. Staff to monitor need for further SCA funding and viability of funding options.

### Pension accounting and volatility in precautionary balances
- Since adoption of amended IAS 19 in FY 2014, the Fund’s annual income has been subject to significant volatility reflected in special and general reserves and precautionary balances.
- Pension-related (IAS 19) gains or losses are mainly driven by periodic remeasurement of the defined benefit obligation and revaluation of plan assets.

*Source: ppea2021073 - 36.*

### 46. While recognizing that income volatility cannot be eliminated due to requirements

### 46. While recognizing that income volatility cannot be eliminated due to requirements under International Financial Reporting Standards, some Directors have questioned the merits of including the pension-related (IAS 19) gains and losses in the computation of precautionary balances as a buffer for economic risks.

### Pension-related volatility under IAS 19
- IAS 19 pension-related gains or losses in the income statement comprise two components: (i) annual pension expense, and (ii) actuarial remeasurement.
- The measurement of the defined benefit obligation (DBO) under IAS 19 is sensitive to the fluctuation of the nominal discount rate determined by reference to market yields on “high quality corporate bonds” at the end of a reporting period.
- The key drivers of volatility are the discount rate and asset returns; a 50bps change in the discount rate can change the DBO valuation by approximately SDR 1 billion.
- The Fund uses the Financial Times Stock Exchange (FTSE) discount curve comprising yields on hypothetical AA zero coupon bonds with maturities from 6 months up to 30 years.
- The net defined benefit asset or liability is the difference between the Fund’s defined benefit obligations and the fair value of plan assets.

### Alternative: economic / long-term basis for precautionary balances
- Proposal: reflect how plan assets are invested and managed, using a long-term measure representative of expected long-term asset returns and related ability to meet defined benefit obligations.
- Operationally: add back to/(deduct from) Fund reserves the net defined benefit liability/(asset) before adjusting for the long-term or economic basis.
- Rationale: the long-term/economic basis (smoothing) better reflects the role of precautionary balances as a buffer for economic and financial risks compared with point-in-time actuarial assumptions under IAS 19.

### Funding and return assumptions
- On an economic basis, assets are expected to generate, in the long-term, at least a 3 percent real rate of return to meet future pension and other employee benefits obligations.
- A 3 percent real return assumes a 5 percent nominal expected return on assets based on an expected 2 percent rate of inflation.
- The assumed nominal return reflects the Pension Committee’s estimate of future experience for plan asset returns, reflecting current asset allocation, expected changes during the current plan year, current market conditions and the Fund’s expectations based on an experience study conducted in 2020.
- The over- or underfunded position of the plans could be re-computed using the long-term discount rate which equates to the expected return on assets.
- The actual real return on assets has consistently exceeded the expected 3 percent real return in the short, medium, and long term.

### Impact on precautionary balances (retrospective comparison: Accounting vs Economic basis) — key figures from Table 5 (In SDR millions)
- Accounting basis:
  - A] Defined Benefit Obligations: FY 2016 -8,068; FY 2017 -8,433; FY 2018 -8,625; FY 2019 -9,596; FY 2020 -12,018; FY 2021 -11,425
  - DBO based on IAS 19 Discount Rate (Nominal AA Corporate Bond Rate): FY 2016 3.75%; FY 2017 3.97%; FY 2018 4.05%; FY 2019 3.86%; FY 2020 2.73%; FY 2021 3.02%
  - B] Plan Assets: FY 2016 7,560; FY 2017 8,645; FY 2018 9,077; FY 2019 9,559; FY 2020 9,010; FY 2021 11,220
  - C] Net Asset/(Liability) Pension & Other Employee Benefits (B - A): FY 2016 -508; FY 2017 212; FY 2018 452; FY 2019 -37; FY 2020 -3,008; FY 2021 -205
  - IAS 19 basis (‘point in time’) Funding Ratio (B/A): FY 2016 94%; FY 2017 103%; FY 2018 105%; FY 2019 100%; FY 2020 75%; FY 2021 98%
- Economic basis:
  - D] Defined Benefit Obligations: FY 2016 -6,571; FY 2017 -7,139; FY 2018 -7,377; FY 2019 -7,975; FY 2020 -8,278; FY 2021 -8,259
  - Long-term Discount Rate (3% real return + inflation): FY 2016 5%; FY 2017 5%; FY 2018 5%; FY 2019 5%; FY 2020 5%; FY 2021 5%
  - E] Plan Assets: FY 2016 7,560; FY 2017 8,645; FY 2018 9,077; FY 2019 9,559; FY 2020 9,010; FY 2021 11,220
  - F] Net Asset/(Liability) Pension & Other Employee Benefits (E - D): FY 2016 989; FY 2017 1,506; FY 2018 1,700; FY 2019 1,584; FY 2020 732; FY 2021 2,961
  - 3% real basis (long-term basis) Funding Ratio (E/D): FY 2016 115%; FY 2017 121%; FY 2018 123%; FY 2019 120%; FY 2020 109%; FY 2021 136%
- Precautionary Balances (Accounting basis): FY 2016 15,223; FY 2017 16,713; FY 2018 17,469; FY 2019 17,656; FY 2020 15,984; FY 2021 20,013
- Adjustments (Add/(Subtract): IAS 19 Net Asset/(Liability) (line C)): FY 2016 508; FY 2017 -212; FY 2018 -452; FY 2019 37; FY 2020 3,008; FY 2021 205
- Precautionary Balances (Retrospective Economic Basis): FY 2016 15,731; FY 2017 16,501; FY 2018 17,017; FY 2019 17,693; FY 2020 18,992; FY 2021 20,218
- Note: Precautionary balances currently represent the Fund’s special and general reserves (excluding gold sales profits) and reflect the accounting valuation under IAS 19; replacing with the 5 percent long-term nominal rate smooths DBO fluctuations.

### Implications of switching to economic basis and operational considerations
- Replacing the accounting valuation with a long-term economic measure and taking a prudent stance on economic gains results in a more gradual and less volatile accumulation path for precautionary balances.
- If the revised funding ratio based on the 3 percent long-term real rate of return (or 5 percent nominal) is above 100 percent (net asset position) (Line F, Table 5), consideration could be given to not making further changes to precautionary balances after adjusting for the accounting net asset/(liability) position.
- If the revised funding ratio is below 100 percent, precautionary balances could be adjusted by the re-computed underfunded position to reflect long-term economic risk.
- Recent history shows no underfunded position when applying the long-term funding ratio given cumulative real returns well above 3 percent (nominal returns well above 5 percent), though underfunding cannot be ruled out under adverse market conditions.
- The Fund’s annual funding valuation exercise for the SRP and the RSBIA takes a longer-term view; based on FY 2022 actuarial projections and assuming a contribution rate of 14 percent of pensionable gross remuneration over the medium term, the SRP is adequately funded over the medium to long term (average funded term for last five years is 15 years) and the long-term economic risk is zero. The RSBIA has also been adequately funded over the medium term.

### Transition timing and quantitative effect
- If Directors approve, transition to the new approach is anticipated to commence in FY 2022.
- Transition entails adding back SDR 205 million to the opening (end-FY 2021) precautionary balances (see Table 5), raising the current precautionary balances path under scenarios by SDR 205 million from FY 2022 onwards, provided the Plan’s funding ratio is projected to remain above 100 percent on an economic basis.
- Any change would be applied prospectively; staff will monitor for potential material underfunded positions.

### Comparator practices and enterprise risk implications
- Practices among comparator institutions vary widely; treatment of pension-related gains and losses was not clearly denoted by most institutions surveyed and ranged from no mention of pension risks to referencing that pension risks are considered and measured based on funding methodologies approved by the Pension Committee.
- Enterprise risk implications of staff proposal:
  - Financial risks: maintaining the current medium-term target and floor for precautionary balances preserves credit risk buffers; adjustments to address IAS 19 volatility would make precautionary balances a more stable measure for financial risk mitigation.
  - Business, income, and reputational risks: maintaining the target and floor better positions the Fund for engagement with members affected by the pandemic and mitigates business and reputational risks; keeping the SCA-1 account with a zero balance for the time being is useful.
  - Residual risks: concentration of the loan portfolio, uncertain global outlook, borrower challenges, and limits/risks to accelerating reserve accumulation; close monitoring and a next regular review in about a year are key mitigations.
  - The approach to address IAS 19 volatility would be more reflective of business risks and reduce relevant reputational risks.

### Issues for Directors (as presented)
- Do Directors agree with staff’s assessment of the credit risks facing the Fund?
- Do Directors agree that the indicative medium-term target for precautionary balances should be maintained at SDR 25 billion while being monitored closely in light of large exposures and pandemic-related evolving credit risks?
- Do Directors see merit that the minimum floor for precautionary balances be kept unchanged at SDR 15 billion, but be revisited after the next review of the Investment Account?
- Do Directors agree that it would not appear necessary at this point to take additional steps to accelerate the pace of precautionary balance accumulation?
- Do Directors consider that the role of surcharges and their design remain broadly appropriate?
- Do Directors see merit in reflecting further on the role of surcharges in the Fund financing model?
- Do Directors see merit in maintaining the SCA-1 account with a zero balance?
- Do Directors see merit in adjusting the measurement of precautionary balances to address accounting volatility due to IAS 19?
- Do Directors consider appropriate an adjustment for a potential underfunded position of the pension Fund that would reflect the long-term economic risk of the plan?

*Source: IMF Finance Department.*

### 3.      Based on this framework, the Board has increased the target for precautionary

### 3.      Based on this framework, the Board has increased the target for precautionary

### Changes to Floor and Target
- The Board increased the indicative medium-term target in 2012, 2018 and 2020, when it was set at SDR 25 billion.
- A minimum floor of SDR 10 billion for precautionary balances was agreed in 2010 and increased to SDR 15 billion in 2016. The floor was reaffirmed in 2020.
- Review year table (In billions of SDRs) summarized:
  - Before 2010 review: Floor - , Target 10
  - 2010: Floor 10, Target 15
  - 2012: Floor 10, Target 20
  - 2014: Floor 10, Target 20
  - 2016: Floor 15, Target 20
  - 2018: Floor 15, Target 20
  - 2020: Floor 15, Target 25
- Rationale: the floor provides a buffer given that Fund credit is highly volatile and it takes considerable time to rebuild precautionary balances.

### Framework and Methodology (overview)
- The framework shares elements with rating agencies' methodologies assessing capital adequacy in supranational lending institutions.
- The two-year projection is based on scheduled net disbursements under existing non-precautionary arrangements; methodology does not require explicit analysis of possible future arrangements or delays in scheduled disbursements or early repurchases.
- Scenario analysis is used to indicate how the indicative range would be affected by different projections to inform Board judgment.

### Demand for New Programs (Annex II) — Methodology
- Uses a panel logit regression to identify countries likely to tap IMF resources under the General Resources Account (GRA).
- Sample: 96 advanced, emerging and frontier market economies over 1992–2019, and 104 GRA arrangements.
- Model relates probability of entering a new Fund arrangement to global and country-specific determinants (external financing needs, financial market volatility, global financial conditions, GDP growth, etc.).
- Threshold for predicted probability of entering a program determined by minimizing weighted average of Type I and Type II errors. With equal weights (1:1), threshold = 3.9 percent.
- Using 3.9 percent threshold, model correctly identifies 88 percent of new programs over 1992–2019.
- Prediction for FY 2022 and FY 2023 uses October 2021 WEO baseline and 2021 year-to-date average VIX level of 19.8.
- A country is assumed to enter a new IMF program if its predicted probability exceeds 3.9 percent in a given year.
- Under this approach, 47 countries are predicted to enter a new Fund-supported program; 28 are assumed to come forward in FY 2022‒23 based on staff analysis.

### Baseline Scenario — Projected Demand and Credit Path
- Average size of Fund programs (excluding precautionary arrangements) over the past decade used: about 5 percent of GDP.
- Aggregate new demand for IMF financing under 28 arrangements could reach about SDR 148 billion over FY 2022‒23.
- Comparison: previous review projected 29 new arrangements totaling SDR 138 billion over FY 2021‒22.
- Under the WEO model-based baseline scenario:
  - Combination assumed: 11 Stand–By Arrangements (SBAs), 16 Extended Fund Facilities (EFFs), and a Precautionary Liquidity Line (PLL).
  - Even phasing assumed: three years for SBAs, four years for EFFs.
  - Average outstanding stock of Fund credit projected to rise from about SDR 86.7 billion in FY 2021 to a peak of SDR 166.7 billion in FY 2026 (including existing and prospective arrangements).
  - Peak if only existing arrangements considered: SDR 90.7 billion.
  - Incremental increase over stock from existing arrangements at peak: about SDR 76 billion in FY 2026.

### Impact on Precautionary Balances
- As a result of projected new arrangements, precautionary balance would surpass the indicative target by FY 2024 and reach nearly SDR 36 billion over the medium term.
- Projections based only on existing arrangements would not reach the indicative target over the medium term.

### Adverse (Resurging Pandemic) Scenario
- Adverse scenario assumptions:
  - Projected growth for 2021–22 for a country falls by ½ standard deviation of its historical values relative to the October 2021 WEO baseline.
  - High financial market shock: VIX level of 40.
  - Average access per arrangement rises to about 7 percent of GDP (excluding precautionary arrangements).
  - All current FCL/PLL arrangements are drawn.
- Under this adverse scenario:
  - Outstanding stock of Fund credit projected to increase by about SDR 121.5 billion above the peak under the WEO model-based baseline scenario.
  - Precautionary balances would increase to SDR 48 billion over the medium term.

### Logit Estimation Results (selected coefficients and sample statistics)
- Dependent variable: Start of a GRA Arrangement (dummy).
- Selected marginal effects (dy/dx), robust SE, P-value:
  - Past program (dummy): 0.419***, 0.064, 0.000
  - Reserve accumulation: -0.0469*, 0.026, 0.071
  - External Financing Needs: 0.684**, 0.293, 0.020
  - GDP growth: -0.0951***, 0.026, 0.000
  - GDP per capita: -0.965***, 0.179, 0.000
  - Credit gap: 0.0229**, 0.009, 0.012
  - Government stability: -0.330***, 0.074, 0.000
  - VIX: 0.0700***, 0.026, 0.008
- Pseudo R2: 0.440
- Observations: 2,113
- Countries: 96
- GRA Arrangements: 138
- Likelihood ratio (p-value): 0.002
- Notes: panel logit estimation using random effects; ***, **, * denote significance at 1, 5, and 10 percent respectively.

### Burden Sharing Mechanism — Role and Capacity (Annex III)
- Role:
  - Established in 1986 to compensate Fund for unpaid charges by members in arrears ("deferred charges") by temporary financing from creditor and debtor members in equal amounts via increases in the rate of charge paid by debtor members and reductions in remuneration to creditor members.
  - Mechanism helps protect Fund’s income position and enables recognition of no impairment for credit outstanding under IFRS by collecting equivalent amounts from other members.
  - If loss of income from deferred charges exceeds mechanism capacity, carrying value of the asset in arrears may need reduction, potentially leading to an impairment loss that would reduce annual lending income and pace of accumulation of precautionary balances.
- Capacity definition:
  - Total capacity = maximum feasible reduction in remuneration expenses + maximum feasible increase in income from charges.
  - Article V, Section 9 (a): rate of remuneration shall be no less than four-fifths (80 percent) of the SDR interest rate, limiting maximum reduction to 0.2 * SDR Interest Rate * Remunerated Reserve Tranche Positions.
  - Board has set current floor for remuneration at 85 percent of the SDR interest rate (changeable with 70 percent majority of total voting power).
  - Maximum capacity of symmetrical burden sharing = twice the above amount, since debtors and creditors contribute equally.
  - Practical limits: contributing debtor base may decline in event of arrears, limiting feasible adjustment to rate of charge.
- Factors affecting capacity:
  - Quota payments: quota increases raise reserve tranche positions and remunerated portion, increasing capacity.
  - Outstanding credit and Fund borrowing: remunerated reserve tranche positions increased from about SDR 40 billion at end-2017 to about SDR 101 billion at end-September 2021. No burden sharing adjustment is made to interest paid to creditors on borrowed resources; borrowing-financed outstanding credit does not affect burden sharing capacity.
  - SDR interest rate: as burden sharing adjustments are set as proportion of SDR interest rate, a higher SDR rate increases capacity. As of end-September 2021, SDR interest rate was at its floor of 0.050 percent, compared to 0.733 percent as of end-November 2017.
- Recent capacity developments:
  - As of end-September 2021, annual burden sharing capacity (with remuneration floor at 85 percent of SDR interest rate) was about SDR 15 million, compared to over SDR 86 million at end-2017, and SDR 23 billion at time of the last review in 2020.
  - Residual burden sharing capacity equals burden sharing capacity as there are no outstanding overdue charges.

*Source: IMF Finance Department and Annexes II–III of the provided document.*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/pp/2021/english/ppea2021073.pdf_
