## ppea2023026

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [ppea2023026](https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/pp/2023/english/ppea2023026.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/files/publications/pp/2023/english/ppea2023026.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/files/publications/pp/2023/english/ppea2023026.pdf.json)

---

### Executive summary and headline figures
- Overall net income for FY 2023 projected at about SDR 1.8 billion.
- Projected FY 2024 annual net income: SDR 2.9 billion (US$3.9 billion).
- Precautionary balances projected to reach SDR 22.6 billion (US$30.0 billion) at end-FY-2023 (increase of SDR 1.7 billion since end-FY 2022).
- Indicative medium-term target for precautionary balances: SDR 25 billion, expected to be reached by late FY 2024 or early FY 2025.
- Executive Board decision: margin for the basic lending rate (SDR interest rate plus fixed margin) remains at 100 basis points for FY 2023 and FY 2024.

### FY 2023 projected results — income and expense composition
- Overall net operational income of the GRA (after adjusting for an estimated pension-related gain) projected at about SDR 2.0 billion for FY 2023 (slightly lower than April 2022 estimate of SDR 2.1 billion).
- Key projected income lines (FY 2023):
  - Total lending income: SDR 2.6 billion.
  - Margin income: SDR 939 million.
  - Service charges: SDR 112 million.
  - Commitment fees: SDR 197 million.
  - Surcharges: SDR 1,402 million.
- Investment income — Fixed-Income Subaccount (FI):
  - Projected FI investment income for FY 2023: SDR 66 million (compared with SDR 240 million estimated in April 2022).
  - FY 2022-end retained loss in the FI: SDR 222 million; no transfer of FI income to the GRA projected for FY 2023.
- Endowment Subaccount (EA):
  - EA projected FY 2023 loss: US$299 million (about SDR 210 million).
  - EA negative return: 3.2 percent cumulative loss through end-February (US$378 million cumulative loss through end-February).
  - EA cushion (retained investment income) eroded to 2 percent of portfolio value at end-February (target cushion: 15 percent).
  - Proposal: delay initiation of EA payout by one year and retain any FY 2023 EA investment loss or income in the EA.
- Implicit returns on interest-free resources:
  - Projected implicit returns: SDR 97 million for FY 2023 (reflecting increase in average SDR interest rate from 0.8 percent to 2.1 percent).
- SDR Department expenses for FY 2023 estimated at SDR 8.7 million (proposed Decision).

### Pension-related measurement and effects (IAS 19)
- Pension-related remeasurement gain for FY 2023 estimated at about SDR 0.3 billion (SDR 348 million in Annex table).
- Key actuarial drivers and values:
  - Discount rate increased from 4.18 percent at start of the year to 5.03 percent by end-February 2023 (increase of 85 basis points); this increase expected to contribute an estimated SDR 1,298 million to remeasurement gains in FY 2023.
  - Actuarially-determined remeasurement loss on assets projected at about SDR 882 million.
  - Net periodic pension cost after funding: SDR 74 million (FY 2023).
  - Total IAS 19 gains/(losses) projected for FY 2023: SDR 274 million (selected table entries).
- Uncertainty: pension-related adjustment is highly sensitive to discount rate and asset-return assumptions; finalized after year-end using inputs as of April 30, 2023.

### Disposition decisions, reserves, and IA transfers
- Allocation of FY 2023 GRA net income:
  - Portion equivalent to projected pension-related remeasurement gain to be placed in the special reserve.
  - Remainder of GRA FY 2023 net income to be placed equally in the special and general reserves (framework adopted April 2022).
  - If a pension-related remeasurement loss occurs, it is to be placed to the Fund’s general reserve to offset cumulative remeasurement gains.
- Projected reserve and transfer outcomes:
  - After placement of FY 2023 net income to reserves and adjustments, projected precautionary balances: SDR 22.6 billion at end-FY 2023 (increase of SDR 1.7 billion since end-FY 2022).
  - Combined balance in reserves projected to total SDR 28.5 billion after placement of FY 2023 GRA net income.
  - Cumulative transfers made thus far to the IA from the GRA: about SDR 26.5 billion.
  - Staff proposes transferring currencies equivalent to the full amount of the increase in reserves from the GRA to the IA for investment in the FI (estimated transfer about SDR 2 billion for FY 2023).
- Proposed Decisions summary (FY 2023):
  - Decision 1: SDR Department assessment for FY 2023 (assessment rate: 0.00131269 percent of net cumulative SDR allocations debited April 30, 2023).
  - Decision 2: Income of the FI and EA for FY 2023, if any, to be retained in the respective IA subaccounts.
  - Decision 3: Placement of FY 2023 GRA net income to Special and General Reserves per pension-related allocation framework.
  - Decision 4: Transfer of currencies from the GRA to the IA equivalent to the increase in reserves following FY 2023 net income placement.
  - Decision 5: Completion of FY 2024 review and conclusion that no adjustment to margin (100 basis points) is warranted.

### FY 2024 income outlook, assumptions, and key projections
- Desk-survey baseline (excluding pension-related gain or loss):
  - Projected net income for FY 2024: about SDR 2.9 billion.
  - Assumes basic lending margin maintained at 100 basis points.
- Table 3 highlights (selected FY 2023 → FY 2024 comparisons, in millions of SDRs unless noted):
  - Operational income: 2,822 → 3,825
  - Lending income: 2,650 → 2,739
    - Margin for the rate of charge: 939 → 958
    - Service charges and other income: 112 → 90
    - Commitment fees: 197 → 219
    - Surcharges: 1,402 → 1,472
  - Investment income: 66 → 936
    - Fixed-Income subaccount (reserves): 66 → 842
    - Endowment subaccount payout: 0 → 94
  - Interest free resources: 97 → 135
  - Reimbursements: 9 → 15
  - Expenses: 1,131 → 1,141
  - Net operational income before provision: 1,691 → 2,684
  - Pension-related remeasurement gain: 348 → 0
  - Net operational income after remeasurement gain: 2,039 → 2,684
  - Endowment subaccount investment income: -210 → 240
  - Net income position: 1,829 → 2,924
  - Fund credit (average stock, SDR billions): 93.9 → 95.8
  - SDR interest rate (average, in percent): 2.1 → 3.6
  - US$/SDR exchange rate (average): 1.33 → 1.35
  - Precautionary balances (end of period, SDR billions): 22.6 → 25.1
- Key FY 2024 drivers and assumptions:
  - FI investment income projected at about SDR 842 million in FY 2024 reflecting higher projected SDR interest rates and investment strategy refinements.
  - EA projected investment income about SDR 334 million in FY 2024 (projected average returns ~5.41 percent nominal over medium term); initial payout assumed 1.5 percent commencing FY 2024 with FY 2024 payout equivalent to about SDR 94 million.
  - Income retained in the EA (not distributed) expected to be equivalent to about SDR 240 million in FY 2024 (in SDR terms).
  - Suspension of PRGT reimbursement reduces expected GRA income by about SDR 273 million through the remaining 3-year period.

### EA payout policy, cushion, and operational considerations
- EA cushion target and status:
  - Target cushion sized to absorb one extreme event (two-standard deviation market shock); target about 15 percent.
  - EA cushion estimated around 2 percent at end-February 2023, below the 15 percent target.
- Staff proposal:
  - Further delay EA payout in FY 2023 and reassess commencement in FY 2024 based on adequacy of cushion, market conditions, and Fund income outlook.
  - If payouts commence, apply constant real payout rule (payout increased annually by GED) and NAV-based suspension limits.
- Practical considerations and examples:
  - Example initial payout of 1.5 percent with cushion size of 5 percent implies a maximum limit of 1.6 percent of NAV that would trigger suspension if exceeded.
  - If suspension is triggered, staff will reassess cushion, calculate a new maximum limit, and propose recommencement only after these steps.
- Alternatives:
  - Board could initiate EA payouts sooner and protect EA real value through direct transfers to the EA (per Articles and IA Rules); such transfers require further staff analysis of implications for other financial policies.

### Key risks, sensitivities, and stress points
- Main external risks and sensitivities:
  - Russia’s ongoing war in Ukraine and associated adverse shocks.
  - Inflationary pressures and monetary policy tightening raising global interest rates.
  - Financial market volatility impacting FI and EA subaccounts.
  - Uncertainty in pension-related remeasurement driven by discount rate and asset-return assumptions.
  - A more shock-prone global economic outlook affecting lending demand and program stability.
- Sensitivity examples (Table 4 highlights, in millions of SDRs):
  - SDR interest rate by 50 basis points: Implicit returns 19
  - Margin for the rate of charge by 20 basis points: 192
  - US dollar vis-à-vis SDR by five percent: - Administrative expenses 50
  - US dollar vis-à-vis SDR by 1 US cent: - Endowment Subaccount 48
  - Investment income margin by 50 basis points: 147
- Credit risk and provisioning:
  - Staff finalizing annual IFRS 9-related country assessments; no impact expected for FY 2023 at this stage.
  - Recording a material provision for impairment losses expected to remain rare, but if required would reduce income and precautionary balances.

### Operational and governance notes; NIM implementation status
- Executive Board discretion:
  - Under the Articles, Executive Board has discretion over IA income disposition; IA income may be retained and reinvested in the IA or transferred to the GRA for expenses (Article XII, Section 6 (f)(iv)).
- NIM status (selected elements):
  - Creation of EA funded with SDR 4.4 billion of gold sale profits; investment rules and payout framework adopted; payouts assumed to commence in FY 2024 subject to cushion adequacy.
  - Most NIM elements in place; implementation advanced though actual non-lending income contribution has historically been much lower than initial expectations due to prolonged low interest rates.
- Burden sharing and margin review:
  - Staff concludes no fundamental changes warrant adjustment to the margin for FY 2024 (margin remains at 100 basis points).
  - EMBI-based cross-check: median for the lowest quartile EMBI spread stands at 56 basis points above the current margin as of March 2023 (relative to 42 basis points at time of 2022 income review).
  - Rise in SDR interest rate (end-February 2023): from 0.05 percent in FY 2021 to 3.437 percent; burden sharing capacity reached SDR 1,175 million at end-February 2023.

*Source: Review of the Fund’s Income Position for FY 2023 and FY 2024 (April 7, 2023; Annexes and excerpts).*

### 22.6 billion (US$30.0 billion) at end FY- 2023.

### REVIEW OF THE FUND’S INCOME POSITION FOR FY 2023 AND FY 2024

### Executive summary
- The Fund’s overall net income for FY 2023 is projected at about SDR 1.8 billion.
- Projected FY 2024 annual net income: SDR 2.9 billion (US$3.9 billion).
- Precautionary balances are projected to reach SDR 22.6 billion (US$30.0 billion) at the end of FY- 2023 (an increase of SDR 1.7 billion since end-FY 2022).
- Indicative medium-term target for precautionary balances: SDR 25 billion, expected to be reached by late FY 2024 or early FY 2025.
- The Executive Board decision: margin for the basic lending rate (SDR interest rate plus fixed margin) remains at 100 basis points for FY 2023 and FY 2024.

### FY 2023 projected results — main components and changes
- Overall net operational income of the GRA (after adjusting for an estimated pension-related gain) is projected at about SDR 2.0 billion for FY 2023 (slightly lower than April 2022 estimate of SDR 2.1 billion).
- Key projected income and expense lines:
  - Total lending income: SDR 2.6 billion (about SDR 54 million lower than April 2022 estimate).
  - Margin income: SDR 939 million (SDR 20 million lower than April 2022, reflecting a SDR 2.0 billion lower average projected stock of credit outstanding).
  - Service charges: SDR 112 million (SDR 6 million lower than April 2022).
  - Commitment fees: SDR 197 million (broadly in line with April 2022).
  - Surcharges: SDR 1,402 million (about SDR 29 million lower than April 2022).
- Investment income — Fixed-Income Subaccount (FI):
  - Projected investment income from the FI for FY 2023: SDR 66 million (compared with SDR 240 million estimated in April 2022).
  - FY 2022-end retained loss in the FI: SDR 222 million (the FY 2023 investment income outturn is not expected to fully offset this retained loss).
  - No transfer of income from the FI to the GRA is projected for meeting FY 2023 administrative expenses.
- Endowment Subaccount (EA) — retained investment income and payout timing:
  - EA projected FY 2023 loss: US$299 million, equivalent to about SDR 210 million.
  - EA experienced negative return of 3.2 percent (cumulative loss of US$378 million) through end-February.
  - EA cushion (retained investment income) eroded to 2 percent of portfolio value at end-February (target cushion: 15 percent).
  - Proposal: delay initiation of EA payout by one year and retain any FY 2023 EA investment loss or income in the EA.
- Pension-related measurement:
  - Pension-related remeasurement gain estimated to contribute about SDR 0.3 billion for FY 2023 (subject to uncertainty given volatile market conditions and sensitivity to discount rate and asset-return assumptions).
  - IAS 19 requires actuarial remeasurement of post-employment obligations.
- Implicit returns on interest-free resources:
  - Projected implicit returns: SDR 97 million for FY 2023, reflecting an increase in the average SDR interest rate from the earlier projection of 0.8 percent to 2.1 percent.
- Reimbursements to the GRA:
  - Expenses of conducting the business of the SDR Department in FY 2023 are estimated at SDR 8.7 million (proposed Decision).

### Disposition decisions and reserve placement
- Allocation of FY 2023 GRA net income:
  - A portion equivalent to the projected pension-related remeasurement gain is to be placed in the special reserve.
  - The remainder of GRA FY 2023 net income is to be placed equally in the special and general reserves (based on the allocation framework for isolating volatile pension-related remeasurement gains and losses).
- After placement of GRA FY 2023 net income to reserves (and adjustment of precautionary balances for pension funding status on an economic basis), projected precautionary balances: SDR 22.6 billion at end-FY 2023 (increase of SDR 1.7 billion since end-FY 2022).
- Proposed transfer: currencies equivalent to the increase in the Fund’s GRA reserves to be transferred from the GRA to the Investment Account.
- EA payout decision:
  - Proposal to delay the decision to initiate EA payout under the Board-approved 2018 framework by another year because the EA cushion of retained investment income has been eroded to extremely low levels.

### FY 2024 income outlook and policy on margin for the rate of charge
- Projected FY 2024 net income (excluding pension-related gain or loss): about SDR 2.9 billion.
- Projections subject to considerable uncertainty and sensitivity to assumptions, notably:
  - Potential scale of new lending and timing/amount of disbursements under approved arrangements.
  - Market performance affecting Fund’s investment and retirement plan asset portfolios amid high inflation, geopolitical tensions, and a more shock-prone environment.
  - Discount rate used to measure retirement plan obligations and realized asset returns.
- Executive Board conclusion for the midpoint comprehensive review of the two-year margin period: margin remains unchanged at 100 basis points.
- Positive projected net income for FY 2024 should allow continued accumulation of precautionary balances toward the SDR 25 billion target.

### Key risks, sensitivities, and operational context
- Sources of greater-than-normal uncertainty:
  - Russia’s ongoing war in Ukraine and the adverse shocks from this conflict.
  - Inflationary pressures and monetary policy tightening that raised global interest rates.
  - Financial market volatility impacting FI and EA subaccounts.
  - Uncertainty in pension-related remeasurement due to discount rate and asset-return assumptions.
  - A more shock-prone global economic outlook affecting lending demand and program stability.
- Sensitivity examples highlighted:
  - Changes in discount rate and asset returns can have a large impact on pension-related gains/(losses) and on actual income outcomes.
  - FI investment income outlook substantially reduced versus prior projection due to sharp rise in bond yields during the year.
- Operational and governance notes:
  - Under the Articles, Executive Board has discretion over IA income disposition; IA income may be retained and reinvested in the IA or transferred to the GRA for expenses (Article XII, Section 6 (f)(iv)).
  - Reimbursements frameworks and timing follow Articles of Agreement and Board decisions (including PRGT reimbursement arrangements and costing approach to determine GRA reimbursement estimates).

*Source: Review of the Fund’s Income Position for FY 2023 and FY 2024 (April 7, 2023).*

### Annex II, Review of the Fund's Income Position for FY 2022 and FY 2023–2024 (04/12/22).

### Annex II, Review of the Fund's Income Position for FY 2022 and FY 2023–2024 (04/12/22)

### FY2023: Initial and Current Projections (Key figures and variances)
- A. Operational income
  - Initial Projections: 3,056
  - Current Projections: 2,822
  - Variance: -234
- Lending income
  - Initial Projections: 2,704
  - Current Projections: 2,650
  - Variance: -54
  - Margin for the rate of charge: 959 → 939 (Variance -20)
  - Service charges and other income: 118 → 112 (Variance -6)
  - Commitment fees: 196 → 197 (Variance 1)
  - Surcharges: 1,431 → 1,402 (Variance -29)
- Investment income
  - Initial Projections: 305
  - Current Projections: 66
  - Variance: -239
  - Fixed-Income Subaccount (reserves): 240 → 66 (Variance -174)
  - Endowment Subaccount payout: 2 → 65 (Variance 0 then -65 recorded in table)
- Interest free resources
  - Initial Projections: 3
  - Current Projections: 38
  - Variance: 97
  - (Net reflected as 59 in table next column)
- Reimbursements
  - Initial Projections: 9
  - Current Projections: 9
  - Variance: 0
  - SDR Department: 9 → 9 (Variance 0)
  - PRG Trust: 4 → 0 (Variance 0)
  - RST: 0 → 0 (Variance 0)
- B. Expenses
  - Initial Projections: 992
  - Current Projections: 1,131
  - Variance: 139
  - Net administrative expenditures: 918 → 972 (Variance 54)
  - Capital budget items expensed: 15 → 25 (Variance 10)
  - Depreciation: 59 → 60 (Variance 1)
  - Net periodic pension cost after funding: 0 → 74 (Variance 74)
- C. Net operational income before provision (A-B)
  - Initial Projections: 2,064
  - Current Projections: 1,691
  - Variance: -373
- Provision for loan impairment losses: 0 → 0 (Variance 0)
- D. Net operational income
  - Initial Projections: 2,064
  - Current Projections: 1,691
  - Variance: -373
- Pension-related remeasurement gain
  - Initial Projections: 0
  - Current Projections: 348
  - Variance: 348
- E. Net operational income after remeasurement gain
  - Initial Projections: 2,064
  - Current Projections: 2,039
  - Variance: -25
- Endowment Subaccount - Retained income: 75 → -210 (Variance -285)
- Net income position
  - Initial Projections: 2,139
  - Current Projections: 1,829
  - Variance: -310
- Fund credit (average stock, SDR billions): 95.9 → 93.9 (Variance -2.0)
- SDR interest rate (average, in percent): 0.8 → 2.1 (Variance 1.3)
- US$/SDR exchange rate (average): 1.41 → 1.33 (Variance -0.08)
- Precautionary balances (end of period, SDR billions): 22.9 → 22.6 (Variance -0.3)

### Expenses and Related Operational Notes
- Total GRA expenses estimated at SDR 1,131 million, about SDR 139 million higher than April 2022 projection.
- Drivers of the expense variance:
  - Net administrative expenditures: SDR 972 million, about SDR 54 million higher than April 2022 projection, mainly due to US dollar appreciation against the SDR.
  - Capital budget items expensed: SDR 25 million, SDR 10 million higher than April 2022 projection, reflecting new HQ maintenance projects being expensed.
  - Depreciation broadly in line with previous projections.
  - Net periodic pension costs after funding discussed separately (see Pension-related Adjustment).
- Reimbursements and trust administration:
  - No proposed reimbursements of administrative expenses related to SDA resources in the CCR and PRG-HIPC Trusts for FY 2023.
  - In July 2021, Board approved suspension of reimbursement to the GRA of PRGT administration costs for fiscal years 2022-2026; PRGT administrative expenses for FY 2023 estimated at SDR 84.4 million (about SDR 8 million lower than earlier estimates in SDR terms).
  - RST set-up costs included in FY 2023 budget; reimbursement to the GRA of operational costs of administering the RST expected to commence in FY 2024.

### Pension-Related (IAS 19) Adjustment — Findings and Projections
- Overall pension-related adjustment expected to contribute about SDR 274 million to net income in FY 2023.
- IAS 19 components: (i) remeasurement gains/(losses); (ii) net periodic pension cost after funding.
- Remeasurement gains/(losses) drivers and projections:
  - Net actuarial remeasurement gains projected at SDR 348 million, largely attributable to increase in the discount rate and offset partially by negative excess returns on plan assets.
  - Discount rate:
    - Increased from 4.18 percent at start of the year to 5.03 percent by end-February 2023 (an increase of 85 basis points).
    - The 85 basis points increase expected to contribute an estimated SDR 1,298 million to remeasurement gains in FY 2023.
    - Note: interest rates volatile; current estimated April-end remeasurement gain subject to high uncertainty.
  - Asset revaluation:
    - Actuarially-determined remeasurement loss of about SDR 882 million projected, mainly reflecting significant decline in plan asset returns due to high inflation, supply chain issues, and geopolitical uncertainty.
- Net periodic pension cost after funding: SDR 74 million
  - Represents difference between:
    - Accruals (actuarially determined annual service cost expense and net interest gain of SDR 44 million) totaling accruals, and
    - Funding (cash appropriation) projected at SDR 151 million.
  - Service costs decreased in FY 2023 due to higher discount rate and changes to pensionable gross remuneration formulas (service cost - current projected at -269).
- COLA assumptions:
  - Historically long-term COLA assumption 2 percent.
  - Adjusted for recent years: 8.5 percent for FY 2022 (actual), and 4 percent projected for FY 2023.
- Table 2 reconciliation of pension-related gains/(losses) (in millions of SDRs) — selected rows (Actual/Projected):
  - Accrual vs. Funding: FY 2020 -91; FY 2021 -352; FY 2022 -62; FY 2023 -74
  - Pension cost accrual: FY 2020 -238; FY 2021 -504; FY 2022 -213; FY 2023 -225
  - Service cost - current: FY 2020 -310; FY 2021 -407; FY 2022 -367; FY 2023 -269
  - Interest expense on pension liability: FY 2020 -377; FY 2021 -335; FY 2022 -351; FY 2023 -441
  - Expected income on pension asset: FY 2020 366; FY 2021 244; FY 2022 336; FY 2023 485
  - Pension funding: FY 2020 147; FY 2021 152; FY 2022 151; FY 2023 151
  - Remeasurement gains/(losses): FY 2020 -2,880; FY 2021 3,155; FY 2022 1,515; FY 2023 348
    - Discount rate change component: FY 2020 -2,173; FY 2021 421; FY 2022 2,273; FY 2023 1,298
    - 'Excess return' on assets component: FY 2020 -944; FY 2021 2,532; FY 2022 -487; FY 2023 -882
  - Total IAS 19 gains/(losses): FY 2020 -2,971; FY 2021 2,803; FY 2022 1,453; FY 2023 274
  - Discount rate - at end of period (in percent): FY 2020 2.73; FY 2021 3.02; FY 2022 4.18; FY 2023 5.03
- Uncertainty:
  - Actual FY 2023 pension-related adjustment highly uncertain; finalized after year-end using inputs as of April 30, 2023. Impact reported in annual financial statements scheduled for completion in June 2023.

### Credit Risk and Provisioning
- Fund’s provisioning framework adapted to comply with IFRS 9 “Financial Instruments” and reflects unique nature of the Fund’s lending.
- Staff finalizing annual IFRS 9-related country assessments (commenced in early February); based on analysis so far, no impact expected for FY 2023 at this stage.
- Staff will update the Board on annual impairment assessment results before FY 2023 annual financial statements are finalized.
- Under the framework, recording a material provision for impairment losses is expected to remain rare given the Fund’s multilayered credit risk management.

### Disposition Decisions and Investment Account (IA) Subaccounts — Key Proposals
- Disposition decisions to be considered by the Executive Board include:
  - Use of any investment income earned in FY 2023 from the Fixed-Income Subaccount (FI) and the Endowment Subaccount (EA).
  - Placement of net income to reserves and allocation between special and general reserves.
  - Transfer of currencies from the GRA to the IA.
- A. Investment Income from Subaccounts and timing of EA payout:
  - Fixed-Income Subaccount:
    - FY 2022 FI loss: SDR 222 million.
    - Staff proposes that projected FI income of SDR 66 million for FY 2023 be offset against the retained loss until fully recouped.
    - Therefore, no FI income expected to be transferred to the GRA in FY 2023; projected FY 2023 income reflected in IA retained earnings.
  - Endowment Subaccount:
    - EA projected to incur a loss of about US$299 million (SDR 210 million) in FY 2023.
    - Staff proposes net investment loss for FY 2023 be retained in the subaccount and that initiation of EA payout be further delayed.
    - Equivalent amount reflected in IA retained earnings, reducing cumulative retained earnings of the IA to about SDR 1,758 million.
- EA payout timing and cushion considerations:
  - April 2018 Board decision delayed EA payout by three years; further delays occurred in April 2021 and April 2022.
  - EA payout delay intended to build a target cushion sized to absorb one extreme event (set at a 15 percent loss / two-standard deviation market shock).
  - Following recent investment losses, EA cushion estimated around 2 percent at end-February 2023, below the 15 percent target.
  - Initiating payouts with a limited cushion could lead to a reasonably high likelihood of suspension in the near future given volatile market conditions.
  - Fund currently has sufficient resources to cover administrative expenditures; further delay of EA payout not significant to overall income position.
  - Projections indicate rebuilding the cushion to 15 percent under the baseline scenario could take a number of years.
  - The EA’s cushion to be reassessed again in FY 2024 in accordance with the EA payout framework.
- Option for direct transfers to protect EA real value:
  - Board could decide to initiate EA payouts sooner and protect EA real value through a direct transfer (additional transfers to the EA are permissible under the Articles and Rules and Regulations of the IA).
  - As part of net income disposition decisions, Board could place part of net income traditionally transferred from GRA to IA to the EA instead of the FI.
  - Rules and Regulations for the IA permit transfer of assets between subaccounts upon Board approval.
  - Transfers to the EA may establish or replenish a cushion but could have implications for other financial policies requiring further staff analysis.
- Figure 1 summary note:
  - Assumption that no transfer of income from the FI and that EA payout will not begin at least until FY 2024 to allow buildup of retained income cushion.
  - In event of a remeasurement loss being recognized, it would be placed to the general reserve to offset cumulative remeasurement gains from previous years.

*Source: Annex II, Review of the Fund’s Income Position for FY 2022 and FY 2023–2024 (04/12/22).*

### 15.      Against this background, staff proposes to further delay the EA payout in FY 2023 and

### ppea2023026 - 15.      Against this background, staff proposes to further delay the EA payout in FY 2023 and

### Disposition decision on EA payout
- Staff proposes to further delay the EA payout in FY 2023 and reassess its commencement in FY 2024.
- Initiation of the payout is subject to consideration of:
  - the adequacy of the cushion,
  - market conditions at the time,
  - the Fund’s income outlook.
- Given the EA is more likely to achieve the return target and the possibilities described, the Board could decide to implement the payout in FY 2024.

### Allocation of net income (Articles and recent framework)
- The Articles of Agreement require annual determination of allocation of the Fund’s net income.
- Net income of the GRA may be distributed to members or placed to general and special reserves.
- In April 2022 Directors adopted a framework to isolate pension-related remeasurement gains and losses in the special reserve to avoid distorting allocations to distributable reserves.
- Directors broadly agreed to:
  - place all pension-related remeasurement gains and losses to the Fund’s special reserve, and
  - allocate any remaining positive net income to the Fund’s special and general reserves in equal parts.
- Staff proposal for FY 2023 (proposed Decision 3):
  - Any pension-related remeasurement gain be placed to the Fund’s special reserve.
  - Any remaining positive net income be allocated equally to the general and special reserves.
  - Alternatively, any pension-related remeasurement loss is to be placed to the Fund’s general reserve to offset the cumulative remeasurement gains from previous years.
- Projections if equal allocation maintained in FY 2023:
  - special reserve would increase by about SDR 1.2 billion to SDR 14.9 billion,
  - general reserve would rise by SDR 0.8 billion to SDR 13.6 billion.
- Transitory rule: since the cumulative remeasurement gain in the general reserve amounts to SDR 1,020 million at April 30, 2022, any remeasurement losses are to be allocated to the general reserve until the gain is cleared down to zero.

### Transfer of currencies to the IA (FI investment)
- Article XII, Section 6(f)(ii) permits transfer of additional GRA currencies to the IA if the Fund’s reserves exceed the cumulative amount of previous transfers from the GRA to the IA.
- After placement of FY 2023 GRA net income to reserves, combined balance in reserves projected to total SDR 28.5 billion.
- This would remain above the net cumulative amount of transfers made thus far to the IA from the GRA of about SDR 26.5 billion.
- Staff proposes to transfer currencies equivalent to the full amount of the increase in reserves from the GRA to the IA for investment in the FI (proposed Decision 4).
- Note: A transfer of about SDR 2 billion is estimated for FY 2023.

### FY 2024 income outlook — summary and key projections
- Economic backdrop: uncertainty from the war in Ukraine, inflation uncertainty, higher global interest rates, tightening monetary policies, and equity market volatility.
- Countercyclical demand for Fund resources could increase lending income over the medium term.
- Under the desk survey scenario, excluding pension-related gain or loss:
  - Net income for FY 2024 is projected at about SDR 2.9 billion.
  - Projections assume the basic lending margin is maintained at 100 basis points.
- Table 3 key figures (in millions of SDRs unless noted):
  - Operational income: FY2023 = 2,822; FY2024 = 3,825
  - Lending income: FY2023 = 2,650; FY2024 = 2,739
    - Margin for the rate of charge: FY2023 = 939; FY2024 = 958
    - Service charges and other income: FY2023 = 112; FY2024 = 90
    - Commitment fees: FY2023 = 197; FY2024 = 219
    - Surcharges: FY2023 = 1,402; FY2024 = 1,472
  - Investment income: FY2023 = 66; FY2024 = 936
    - Fixed-Income subaccount (reserves): FY2023 = 66; FY2024 = 842
    - Endowment subaccount payout: FY2023 = 0; FY2024 = 94
  - Interest free resources: FY2023 = 97; FY2024 = 135
  - Reimbursements: FY2023 = 9; FY2024 = 15
    - SDR Department: FY2023 = 9; FY2024 = 9
    - PRG Trust: FY2023 = 0; FY2024 = 0
    - RST: FY2023 = 0; FY2024 = 6
  - Expenses: FY2023 = 1,131; FY2024 = 1,141
    - Net administrative expenditures: FY2023 = 972; FY2024 = 1,045
    - Capital budget items expensed: FY2023 = 25; FY2024 = 32
    - Depreciation: FY2023 = 60; FY2024 = 64
    - Net periodic pension cost after funding: FY2023 = 74; FY2024 = 0
  - Net operational income before provision (A-B): FY2023 = 1,691; FY2024 = 2,684
  - Provision for loan impairment losses: FY2023 = 0; FY2024 = 0
  - Net operational income: FY2023 = 1,691; FY2024 = 2,684
  - Pension-related remeasurement gain: FY2023 = 348; FY2024 = 0
  - Net operational income after remeasurement gain: FY2023 = 2,039; FY2024 = 2,684
  - Endowment subaccount investment income: FY2023 = -210; FY2024 = 240
  - Net income position: FY2023 = 1,829; FY2024 = 2,924
  - Fund credit (average stock, SDR billions): FY2023 = 93.9; FY2024 = 95.8
  - SDR interest rate (average, in percent): FY2023 = 2.1; FY2024 = 3.6
  - US$/SDR exchange rate (average): FY2023 = 1.33; FY2024 = 1.35
  - Precautionary balances (end of period, SDR billions): FY2023 = 22.6; FY2024 = 25.1

### Key FY 2024 income drivers and assumptions
- Lending income:
  - Margin and surcharge income projected higher in FY 2024 reflecting potential new demand and continued disbursements.
  - Commitment fees in FY 2024 of SDR 219 million reflect two-year commitment fees on two precautionary arrangements scheduled to expire in FY 2024.
- Fixed-Income Subaccount:
  - Investment income projected at about SDR 842 million in FY 2024 reflecting higher projected SDR interest rates and refinements to the investment strategy.
  - A sharp rise in interest rates beyond expectations could temper gains.
- Endowment Subaccount (EA):
  - Projected investment income about SDR 334 million in FY 2024 based on projected average returns of about 5.41 percent in nominal terms over the medium term (about 200 basis points higher than April 2022 projection).
  - Return projections subject to considerable uncertainty due to asset-class volatility.
  - Income projections assume an initial payout of 1.5 percent commencing in FY 2024, with increase in US dollar terms by the GED rate each year thereafter.
    - Estimated payout in FY 2024 would be equivalent to about SDR 94 million (equivalent to about 1.5 percent of the US dollar value of the portfolio translated at the projected US dollar/SDR exchange rate for the year).
    - Income retained in the EA and not distributed as a payout, in SDR terms, is expected to be equivalent to about SDR 240 million in FY 2024.
  - Income accumulation expected to help replenish the previously depleted EA cushion; adequacy of cushion is a pre-requisite for payout commencement.
  - EA cushion to be reassessed and initial payout aligned to prevailing market conditions and decided by the Board later in FY 2024.
- Interest-free resources and reimbursements:
  - Income from interest-free resources projected higher reflecting the rise in interest rates in FY 2023 and higher projected SDR interest rate path.
  - Suspension of reimbursements from the PRG Trust from FY 2022 to FY 2026 will reduce expected GRA income by about SDR 273 million through the remaining 3-year period.

### RST costs and reimbursements
- RST recurring costs from FY 2024 onwards reflect:
  - trust management expenses (transaction execution, financial reporting and audit, periodic reviews),
  - operational work (country program design and review, economic policy analysis and program negotiations, climate finance, collaboration with World Bank and others, operational policy reviews).
- A management fee was approved to cover trust management costs; the fee is a budget receipt affecting gross administrative budget but net administrative budget unchanged.
- FY 2024 trust management cost estimated at US$4.8 million in FY 2023 dollars (versus US$5–6 million initially estimated).
- Operational costs for RST activities covered through climate-related augmentation resources and regular budget resourcing; estimated cost for FY 2024 is about US$8 million in FY 2023 dollars.
- From FY 2024 onwards, operational (including overhead) costs of administering the RST will be reimbursed to the GRA.

### Expenditures and budget context
- Net administrative expenses consistent with medium-term budget estimates, including reprioritization and allocation of augmentation framework for FY 2023–2025.
- Capital budget items expensed for FY 2024 expected to be higher reflecting resumption of facilities-related investments.
- Periodic pension costs are not projected beyond FY 2023.

### Key risks to Fund income and finances
- Principal risks identified:
  - cancellations, rephasing, or timing changes of purchases under existing and potential arrangements, and early repurchases, which could lower Fund income;
  - difficulty assessing spillover financing needs from the war in Ukraine, inflation pressures, and pandemic impacts, potentially resulting in new loan programs, augmentations, or rephasing;
  - substantial changes in actuarial assumptions affecting annual pension-related gain or loss;
  - market volatility affecting non-lending investment income;
  - credit risk inherent in the Fund’s role and potential IFRS 9 impairment provisioning.
- Staff is conducting IFRS 9-related impairment assessments for FY 2023.
- No provision for impairment losses is incorporated in projections given current circumstances, but such provisioning would reduce income and precautionary balances if required.

### Sensitivity analysis (Table 4 highlights, in millions of SDRs)
- SDR interest rate by 50 basis points: Implicit returns 19
- Margin for the rate of charge by 20 basis points: 192
- US dollar vis-à-vis SDR by five percent: - Administrative expenses 50
- US dollar vis-à-vis SDR by 1 US cent: - Endowment Subaccount 48
- Investment income margin by 50 basis points: 147
- Pension-related gain or loss is highly unpredictable and sensitive principally to asset performance and discount rate assumptions.
- In the unlikely event IFRS 9 provisioning is required, Fund income would be reduced accordingly.

*Source: Review of the Fund’s Income Position for FY 2023 and FY 2024 (excerpts).*

### conclusion by June 2023.

### Conclusion by June 2023

### Review of the Margin for the Rate of Charge
- Rule I-6(4) requires the Executive Board to set the margin over the SDR interest rate for two financial years and to review the Fund’s income position before the end of the first year; the margin may be adjusted only if warranted by fundamental changes in underlying factors.
- Staff does not propose any change in the level of the margin in FY 2024; completion of the review is proposed in Decision 5.
- The margin was set under the exceptional circumstances clause in April 2022.

### Coverage of Intermediation Costs
- Service charges projected in FY 2023: US$149 million.
- An unchanged margin of 100 basis points would provide margin income of about US$1,249 million in FY 2023.
- Estimated intermediation costs in FY 2023: about US$122 million.
- Commitment fees and surcharges projected in FY 2023:
  - Commitment fees: about US$262 million.
  - Surcharges: about US$1,865 million.
- Estimated FY 2023 intermediation costs are lower than earlier projections due to refinements in the cost estimation approach.

### Reserve Accumulation and Precautionary Balances
- Potential reserve accumulation with a margin of 100 basis points:
  - 12.3 percent in FY 2023.
  - 11.7 percent in FY 2024.
- Projected actual reserve accumulation:
  - 10.8 percent of reserves in FY 2023.
- Precautionary balances projected by end-FY 2023: SDR 22.6 billion (lower than SDR 22.9 billion estimated in April 2022).
- Table-derived figures (selected):
  - Income from margin (100 basis points) projected: US$1,249 million (FY 2023) and US$1,293 million (FY 2024).
  - Potential reserve accumulation (100 basis points, in US$ millions): 3,403 (FY 2023) and 3,568 (FY 2024).
  - Actual reserve accumulation (100 basis points, in US$ millions): 2,624 (FY 2023) and 3,413 (FY 2024).
  - Actual reserve accumulation (100 basis points, as a percent): 9.5% (FY 2023) and 11.2% (FY 2024).
  - Precautionary balances at end of FY (100 basis points, in SDR billions): 22.6 (FY 2023) and 25.1 (FY 2024).
- Indicative medium-term target of SDR 25 billion is expected to be reached by late FY 2024 or early FY 2025.

### Alignment of Fund Borrowing Costs with Market Conditions
- Staff cross-checks the margin’s alignment with long-term credit market conditions using EMBI-based benchmarks (lowest quartile of EMBI spreads).
- As of March 2023:
  - Composite EMBI spreads increased by 20 basis points in the past year.
  - The lowest quartile of the EMBI spreads has been unchanged.
  - The median for the lowest quartile EMBI spread stands at 56 basis points above the current margin, relative to 42 basis points at the time of the 2022 income review.
- Overall assessment: no fundamental change in the alignment of the margin with long-term credit market conditions; the cost of Fund credit at the current margin remains broadly in line with staff benchmarks.

### Exceptional Circumstances Clause and New Income Model (NIM) Implementation
- The margin was set under the exceptional circumstances clause in April 2022 because investment income (main source of non-lending income) was negative in FY 2022 and non-lending income was projected to cover only an average of 75 percent of the Fund’s non-lending administrative expenses over the medium term at that time.
- Recent rise in interest rates is projected to boost investment income sharply in the medium term; non-lending income coverage of non-lending expenses is expected to rise to above 100 percent in the medium term.
- For FY 2023, the Fund will still need to rely on lending income to cover a portion of non-lending operational costs given low expected returns on the investment portfolio.
- Most elements of implementing the NIM are now in place; under Rule I-6(4)(b) the Executive Board will set the margin again next year for FY 2025–2026 and may revisit the application of the exceptional circumstances clause.

### Burden Sharing Capacity and Interest Rate Effects
- The sharp increase in interest rates has raised the Fund’s burden sharing capacity recently.
- As of end-February 2023:
  - SDR interest rate rose from a low of 0.05 percent in FY 2021 to 3.437 percent by end-February 2023.
  - Burden sharing capacity reached SDR 1,175 million at end-February 2023.
  - The burden sharing rate stands at zero basis points; there has been no burden sharing adjustment since the settlement of Sudan’s overdue GRA charges in June 2021.

*Source: REVIEW OF THE FUND’S INCOME POSITION FOR FY 2023 AND FY 2024 (conclusion by June 2023).*

### 40.      Income risks. Consistent with the Fund’s Enterprise Risk framework, FIN staff conducted a

### 40.      Income risks.

### Enterprise Risk Self-Assessment
- FIN staff conducted a risk self-assessment consistent with the Fund’s Enterprise Risk framework to identify and assess the most critical enterprise risks in the context of the Review of the Fund’s Income Position for FY 2023 and FY 2024 (Table 7).
- The assessment recognizes that risk mitigation activities are embedded in the Fund’s income position review, but significant residual risk related to external drivers can only be partly addressed through risk management.

- Top identified risks (as reported in Table 7):
  - #1 Adequacy of Operational Income
    - Risk: Partial shortfall in operational income stemming from the waiver of reimbursement of PRGT costs to the GRA and from lack of the transfer of income and/or payouts from the Fixed-Income Subaccount and Endowment Subaccount, respectively.
    - Note: This is more than offset by the high lending income expected in FY 2023.
  - #2 Adequacy of Operational Income
    - Risk: Income risks related to maintaining rate of charge remain unchanged; no fundamental changes warrant adjustment of the margin for setting the rate of charge set at 100 basis points.
    - Observation: The rate for FY 2023-24, set in April 2022 using the exceptional circumstances clause, remains sufficient to cover non lending expenses not covered by the shortfall in investment income, and to build up reserves.
    - Related risks (surcharges policy, impact on precautionary balances) are covered in respective policy papers.
  - #3 Income Adjustments Due to IFRS-related Requirements
    - Risk: Volatility from remeasurement of the Fund's defined benefit plans on income and special and general reserves.
    - Risk: Potential impact on income of annual credit impairment assessments; concerns about a member’s ultimate repayment could trigger a provision for expected credit losses under IFRS 9, reducing income and (accumulation of) precautionary balances and affecting the balance sheet.
    - Note: This risk exists with or without the policy.

### Proposed Decisions (summary)
- Decisions Pertaining to FY 2023:
  - Decision 1: Assessment on SDR Department participants for reimbursement of the General Department for expenses of conducting the business of the SDR Department in FY 2023.
  - Decision 2: Income of the Fixed-Income and Endowment Subaccounts for FY 2023, if any, to be retained in the respective subaccounts.
  - Decision 3: Placement of FY 2023 GRA net income to the Fund’s Special Reserve and the General Reserve:
    - Net income up to the amount of the pension-related gain (or loss) in FY 2023 will be placed in the Fund’s Special Reserve (or General Reserve).
    - Any additional net income amount will be placed in equal parts to the Fund’s Special Reserve and General Reserve.
  - Decision 4: Transfer of currencies from the GRA to the Investment Account equivalent to the increase of the special and general reserves following the placement of FY 2023 net income.
- Decisions Pertaining to FY 2024:
  - Decision 5: Completion of the review of the Fund’s income position; conclusion that there are no fundamental changes that warrant adjustment to the current rate of charge at 100 basis points over the SDR interest rate for FY 2024.

- Voting thresholds:
  - Decisions 1, 2, 3, and 5 may be adopted by a majority of the votes cast.
  - Decision 4 may be adopted by a 70 percent majority of the total voting power.

### Decisions (text excerpts and specifics)
- Decision 1. Assessment under Article XX, Section 4 for FY 2023
  - (i) The General Department shall be reimbursed for the expenses of conducting the business of the SDR Department for the period of May 1, 2022 through April 30, 2023.
  - (ii) An assessment shall be levied on all participants in the SDR Department. The special drawing right holdings accounts of participants shall be debited on April 30, 2023 with an amount equal to 0.00131269 percent of their net cumulative allocations of special drawing rights. The total assessment shall be paid into the General Department.
- Decision 2. Income of the Fixed-Income and Endowment Subaccounts
  - The income of the Fixed-Income and Endowment Subaccounts for FY 2023, if any, shall be retained in the Fixed-Income Subaccount and Endowment Subaccount, respectively, and invested according to the Rules and Regulations for the Investment Account.
- Decision 3. Placement of FY 2023 Net Income of the General Resources Account to the Special Reserve and General Reserve
  - Net income of the General Resources Account for FY 2023 equivalent to the pension-related remeasurement gain (or loss) shall be placed to the Fund’s Special Reserve (or General Reserve).
  - Any net income in FY 2023 that exceeds the amount of the remeasurement gain (or loss) shall be placed in equal parts to the Fund’s Special Reserve and General Reserve.
- Decision 4. Transfer of Currencies to the Investment Account for FY 2023
  - Pursuant to Article XII, Section 6(f)(ii), transfer from the General Resources Account to the Investment Account currencies in an amount equivalent to the difference between the Fund’s general and special reserves as of April 30, 2023 and the cumulative amount of previous transfers of currencies from the General Resources Account to the Investment Account.
  - This transfer shall be effected in the context of the Financial Transactions Plan covering the period August, 2023-January 2024.
  - Currencies transferred pursuant to this decision shall be used for immediate investment in the Fixed-Income Subaccount in accordance with the Rules and Regulations for the Investment Account.
- Decision 5. The Rate of Charge on the Use of Fund Resources for FY 2024
  - Pursuant to Rule I-6(4)(a), the Fund completed the review and concluded that for FY 2024 there are no fundamental changes to warrant any adjustment to the margin for the basic rate of charge as determined by Decision No. 17238-(22/39), adopted April 28, 2022.

### Annex I — Decisions in Effect Related to the FY 2023 Income Position (highlights)
- Rate of Charge
  - The margin for calculating the basic rate of charge in FY 2022 was set in 2022 at 100 basis points for a period of two years (FY 2023–24). 1
  - This decision was adopted under the exceptional circumstances clause of Rule I-6(4).
- Burden Sharing for Deferred Charges
  - Income losses resulting from unpaid charges are shared equally between debtor and creditor members under the burden sharing mechanism largely pursuant to decisions taken in 2000 and 2009.
- Special Charges
  - For overdue repurchases, the special rate of charge is set to equal the excess, if any, of the SDR interest rate over the basic rate of charge (Paragraph 3 of Decision No. 8165-(85/189), as amended).
  - Since under the current system the basic rate of charge is always in excess of the SDR interest rate, members are not subject to special charges on overdue repurchases.
  - The next review of the special charges framework is planned for FY 2025.
- Suspension of PRGT reimbursement through FY 2026
  - In July 2021, the Board approved the suspension of reimbursement of the GRA for the costs of administering the PRGT for the fiscal years 2022-2026.
  - Temporary suspension is permissible under the Fund’s new income model adopted in 2008 and the three-pillar framework for the self-sustained PRGT adopted in 2012.

### Annex II — EA Payout Policy Framework—Key Features
- April 2018 endorsement of payouts from the EA to the GRA based on the IA review framework; aims to balance contribution to Fund income with preserving the real value of the EA corpus.
- Key features:
  - Annual payout amounts in US dollars will be determined according to a constant real payout rule.
  - The deflator for annual inflation adjustments will be the Fund’s annual GED.
  - Annual payouts will be decided at the time of the Fund’s net income disposition decisions; initial nominal US dollar value aligned with prevailing return outlook.
  - Payout subject to a NAV-based limit which would trigger suspension of payouts; initial value of payout and NAV-based limit decided by the Board prior to the first payout.
  - Payouts delayed for three years (until FY 2021) to build a cushion of retained investment income.
  - The retained investment income (“cushion”) would be reassessed at the end of the three-year period.

### Annex III — Implementation of the New Income Model (NIM) — Status Update FY 2023
- NIM objectives: diversify Fund’s income sources and reduce reliance on lending income.
- Implementation status (selected elements):
  - Amendment to the Articles of Agreement to broaden investment authority: amendment came into effect in February 2011 following ratification by three-fifths of IMF members representing 85 percent of the total voting power.
  - Creation of an endowment funded with profits from the sale of 403.3 metric tons of the Fund’s gold holdings; gold sales completed in December 2010 and realized total profits of SDR 6.85 billion.
    - SDR 4.4 billion of the gold profits was used to fund the endowment; remaining SDR 2.45 billion were distributed to members to help finance concessional lending in October 2012 and October 2013.
  - Adoption of new rules and regulations for the Investment Account: approved January 2013.
  - Investment of the endowment: 3-year phased implementation completed in 2018.
  - Executive Board reviewed the investment strategy for the endowment in 2018 and in 2022; in 2018 approved a payout policy framework and delay in initiating payouts until an adequate cushion established. Payouts are assumed to commence in FY 2024.
  - Adopting a new rule for the margin for the basic rate of charge: Decision No. 15044–(11/119) adopted December 9, 2011; under the new rule the margin should be set to cover intermediation costs and help build reserves, but margin has so far been set under the exceptional circumstances clause.
  - Reimbursement of PRGT expenses: practice resumed in FY 2013 and subsequently suspended from FY 2021 to FY 2026; cumulative impact of the suspension is expected to be SDR 273 million over the remaining three-year period.
  - Review of the investment strategy for the Fixed-Income subaccount: expanded FI strategy approved in 2015; Board reviewed experience in 2022 and added a target margin of 50 basis points above the SDRi to the current investment objective.

- Developments and context:
  - Significant progress made; almost all NIM elements now in place, increasing diversification of income.
  - Since the global financial crisis, lending income has increased while non-lending income has been highly constrained by very low sustained global interest rates.
  - The average 3-month SDR interest rate was around 4 percent in 2007 when the NIM was designed; since then the rate declined dramatically and averaged mostly close to the 5 basis point floor until end-2021.
  - Expectation at NIM conception was for investment income to cover most/all non-lending expenses; actual contribution has been much smaller (around one tenth on average).
  - Prospect for achieving initial expectations could improve as global interest rates have been rising sharply since the beginning of 2022; staff will continue to monitor developments.

*Source: Review of the Fund’s Income Position for FY 2023 and FY 2024 (excerpt).*

### Annex IV. Endowment Payout—Practical Considerations

### Annex IV. Endowment Payout—Practical Considerations

### Criteria endorsed for a constant real payout rule
- The Board endorsed a set of criteria for determining a constant real payout rule, supplemented by safeguards to help protect the value of the EA in real terms (Annex II).

### Reassess adequacy of retained income cushion (“cushion”) based on EA NAV
- Target cushion could be sized so the portfolio could absorb one extreme event equivalent to a two-standard deviation market shock.
- The two-standard deviation market-shock equivalent cushion was around 15 percent in 2018.
- Time required to achieve the required cushion would be uncertain and subject to market conditions.
- The Board could decide to delay payouts for a certain period with the intent of building an adequate income cushion in the EA.
- The EA cushion represents the difference between the EA’s NAV and its corpus.
- The corpus is estimated based on principal amounts invested in the EA since inception, adjusted for the GED.
- These parameters are calculated monthly by the Fund’s custodian.

### Review return outlook/projections for EA
- The initial value of the payout would need to be aligned with a conservative estimate of the projected long-term EA real returns in US dollar terms.
- The estimate should be associated with a relatively high level of confidence (or conversely a lower-than-average probability of underperformance).

### Determination and evolution of the payout amount
- The constant real payout rule is used to determine future payout amounts after the initial payout is determined.
- Under this rule, the payout amount for any given year would be calculated as the prior year’s USD payout increased by the deflator (GED).
- If the payout amount as a percentage of NAV exceeds the maximum limit specified, it will be suspended.

### Maximum limit of payout to trigger suspension
- Based on the level of the EA’s cushion, a maximum limit would be set as a percentage of NAV to trigger suspension of future payouts.
- An adequate cushion is a prerequisite for commencing payouts and to prevent a start-stop scenario.
- Example: a 1.5 percent initial value of the payout and cushion size of 5 percent would imply a maximum limit of 1.6 percent.
  - In this example, if in future years the payout amount reaches 1.6 percent of the current EA NAV, a suspension of payouts would be triggered.
- Following a suspension, staff will need to repeat the reassessment of the EA cushion and calculate a new maximum limit before proposing to recommence payouts.

### Operational implications after suspension
- After a suspension is triggered:
  - Reassess the EA cushion using the procedure described above.
  - Calculate a new maximum limit.
  - Propose recommencement of payouts only after these steps.

### Connections to Annex V and Annex VI projections (selected relevant points)
- Annex V shows projected returns for the Endowment Subaccount in SDR terms and reports:
  - Return on investments-Endowment subaccount: Actual through Feb. 2023 = -3.18; FY 2023 = -3.22; FY 2024 = 5.29 (values in percent as shown).
- Annex VI notes projection assumptions related to payout timing and levels:
  - The projections assume a 1.5 percent payout from the EA commencing in FY 2024.
  - Illustrative scenarios for FY 2033: continued payout of 1.5 percent in a low investment return environment (Scenario B); a higher payout of 2 percent in a high investment return environment (Scenario A).

*Annex IV. Endowment Payout—Practical Considerations (from the provided IMF content).*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/pp/2023/english/ppea2023026.pdf_
