## Statement by the Managing Director on the Independent Evaluation Office Report on the Evolving Application of the IMF’s Mandate

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [Statement by the Managing Director on the Independent Evaluation Office Report on the Evolving Application of the IMF’s Mandate](https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/pp/2024/english/ppea2024029.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/files/publications/pp/2024/english/ppea2024029.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/files/publications/pp/2024/english/ppea2024029.pdf.json)

---

### Findings
- The IEO evaluation finds that the application and the scope of the Fund’s mandate were consistent with its legal framework and with the needs and priorities of the Fund’s membership.
- The Fund has steadily stepped up engagement in a broader set of macro-critical policy areas, reflecting an agile and adaptive response to global challenges including the Global Financial Crisis (GFC), COVID-19 pandemic, conflicts, and climate change.
- The Fund faces a trilemma of scope, traction, and resources when adopting new policy areas.
- In the context of a flat real budget during 2003-2023, work on newer policy areas was covered through reallocating resources, internal savings, and staff overtime.
- Some stakeholders felt insufficiently consulted during the Fund’s expansion into newer policy areas.
- The IEO report offers lessons that can be drawn on to improve Fund processes going forward.

### General response and approach
- The Managing Director concurs with the thrust of the evaluation and fully endorses the IEO’s two recommendations:
  - (i) enhance clarity regarding surveillance in newer policy areas; and
  - (ii) better track budget data by policy area.
- The Managing Director qualifies support for two recommendations:
  - (iii) enhance the Fund’s decision-making process; and
  - (iv) clarify interaction with external partners,
  due to concerns about the IEO’s proposed approach to implementation (development of a Fund-wide institutional strategy for engagement in newer policy areas and establishment of high-level principles for engagement with partners).
- Preferred approach: leverage existing workstreams and processes—especially the Comprehensive Surveillance Review (CSR)—and adjust engagement with partners within individual strategies or policy reviews where substantive collaboration is needed.
- In preparing the Management Implementation Plan (MIP), staff will carefully consider how best to implement Board-endorsed recommendations, drawing on the IEO’s suggestions while ensuring synergies with existing workstreams and being mindful of resource constraints.

### Recommendation 1 — Decision-making process (IEO proposal)
- IEO recommendation: The Board and management should enhance the decision-making process by:
  - (i) developing an inclusive Fund-wide institutional strategy for Fund engagement in newer policy areas; and
  - (ii) taking a more holistic approach when endorsing individual strategies for newer policy areas by better linking decisions related to scope, required resources, and risk management implications.

- Recommendation 1: Summary of Specific Suggestions (as in the IEO proposal)
  - Elements for an institutional strategy:
    - An assessment of alternative options for which policy areas to engage in and the desired level of engagement (ranging from signaling macrocriticality to engagement on par with traditional core policies).
    - An assessment of implications for the budget, overall size, and risk profile of the Fund, including impact on staff work pressures and overall well-being, and positioning in the international financial system.
    - An assessment of the desired balance between flexibility and consistency when implementing surveillance in newer policy areas, including principles of engagement and the extent of interpretation of “similar circumstances” for evenhandedness.
  - Elements for endorsing individual strategies:
    - An assessment of the perimeter, depth, frequency, and required Fund expertise of the newer policy area.
    - An assessment of adequacy of allocated resources and their source to avoid impacting other Fund activities and placing unsustainable demands on staff.
    - A comprehensive risk assessment covering risks of engaging and not engaging across all six Level-1 risks of the ERM Framework.
    - How the Fund intends to engage with other partners on the newer policy area.

- Managing Director’s position on Recommendation 1
  - Supports the goal of enhancing the Fund’s decision-making process but prefers leveraging synergies within existing workstreams rather than a separate Fund-wide institutional strategy.
  - The upcoming Comprehensive Surveillance Review (CSR) will:
    - include an assessment of implementation of the 2021 CSR surveillance priorities;
    - re-assess Fund surveillance priorities going forward to ensure surveillance remains fit for purpose; and
    - guide desired levels of Fund engagement in newer policy areas, aligning in spirit with the medium-term strategy recommended by the IEO (work on the 2026 CSR will aim to align in spirit).
  - Other inputs that may inform strategic thinking include the 80th anniversary of the Bretton Woods institutions (IMF and World Bank) and the Fund for the Future workstream.
  - Sub-recommendation II (holistic and consultative decision-making) is promising and can be embodied without an explicit institutional strategy.

- Operational steps already underway related to Recommendation 1
  - Office of Budget and Planning (OBP) work to ensure consistent inclusion of both gross and net resource requirements for new initiatives and policy reviews.
  - Progress in integrating risk considerations into operations since establishment of the office of risk management, including bi-annual enterprise risk reports that integrate tradeoffs between risk mitigation and budget constraints.
  - Departments will comprehensively assess enterprise risks related to engaging and not engaging in new policy areas supported by Document Risk Self Assessments (DRSAs) for policy papers; ORM will support departments in building risk assessment capacity.

### Recommendation 2 — Budget data tracking
- IEO recommendation: Management and staff should produce budget data in a manner that allows tracking by policy area, across all Fund activities and operations; the Board should consider which policy areas need to be tracked and the level of granularity required.

- Managing Director’s position on Recommendation 2
  - Supports this recommendation.
  - Work to strengthen granularity of budget data in key policy areas is underway, as highlighted in Box 1 of the FY25-27 budget report.
  - Reporting now includes information on where resourcing is increasing and where savings are being derived, and activity and tracking have picked up since the IEO review period of FY12-23, including newer areas like climate.
  - Staff will target high-quality information of greatest relevance to strategic decision making; specific issue areas to be tracked will reflect engagement with the Board.
  - Progress requires weighing costs and benefits, prioritization to ensure high-impact investments of scarce resources and staff time, and avoiding excessive ongoing reporting burdens while ensuring data quality.
  - OBP will report on ongoing efforts to strengthen budget data as part of the FY27-29 medium-term budget.

- Recommendation 2: Summary of Specific Suggestions (as in the IEO proposal)
  - Collecting, tracking, and reporting budget data multidimensionally (by policy area, output area, country grouping, department) across all Fund activities would allow more precise cost and resource estimation.
  - Benefits: help the Board understand resource allocation and impact of trade-offs across new and existing activities.
  - Costs and challenges: significant resource implications in dollars and staff time; need to adapt current time registration system or invest in a multidimensional system; require additional staff inputs to register policy areas systematically; transition involves process planning, change management, and compliance/data quality risks.
  - Recommendation to review which policy areas need tracking and the required level of granularity to balance costs.

- Additional points
  - IEO highlighted gap between scale of resources staff indicated would be needed for work in new areas supported by augmentation (like climate) and the scale of resourcing ultimately approved; this was an informed Board decision as part of the augmentation framework.
  - FY25-27 budget data point to spending pressures reflecting a tight overall budget and ongoing developments, including impact of strong demand for RST operations on climate demand.
  - Difficult trade-offs implied by these pressures will continue to require Board, management, and staff attention.

### Recommendation 3 — Surveillance guidance
- IEO recommendation: Management and staff should enhance clarity of key elements regarding surveillance in newer policy areas by updating the 2022 Guidance Note for Surveillance under Article IV Consultations.

- Recommendation 3: Summary of Specific Suggestions (questions for an updated Guidance Note)
  - Perimeter:
    - (i) how should staff determine if a structural issue is macrocritical;
    - (ii) to what extent is coverage of macrocritical structural issues required;
    - (iii) what time horizon(s) should staff consider when assessing macrocriticality.
  - Provision of policy advice:
    - (i) how should staff determine if the Fund has expertise on a particular structural issue;
    - (ii) to what extent should staff provide policy advice when Fund expertise exists but supply is lacking;
    - (iii) should the IMF expertise filter be applied at all.
  - Depth:
    - (i) how to determine relevance, severity, and urgency of a macrocritical structural issue, both independently and relative to others;
    - (ii) what are the different depths of engagement.
  - Frequency:
    - how should staff determine when and how often to engage on a macrocritical structural issue.
  - Uniformity of treatment:
    - (i) how should staff determine which similar circumstances are relevant when assessing evenhandedness;
    - (ii) should the Fund adopt an output-based approach to evenhandedness.

- Managing Director’s position on Recommendation 3
  - Supports updating the Staff Guidance Note (SGN) to ensure clearer and more consistent guidance about IMF surveillance activities in newer policy areas.
  - Will continue comprehensive SGN updates following completion of ongoing periodic CSR.
  - In the interim, management will continue practices to enhance clarity while avoiding overly specific requirements that constrain country teams, including regular updates to operational guidance.
  - Will strive to include greater guidance on perimeter, depth, and frequency while mindful of trade-offs between specificity and staff flexibility.

### Recommendation 4 — Engagement with partners
- IEO recommendation: The IMF should adopt an Executive Board-approved high-level Statement of Principles for Engagement with Partners to establish a coherent best practice framework.

- Recommendation 4: Details (as in the IEO proposal)
  - An Executive Board-approved high-level Statement of Principles would provide an institutional anchor for engagement with partners.
  - A principles approach would guide rationale, objectives, policies, monitoring, evaluation criteria and modalities, while providing flexibility for formal, informal, or ad hoc framework arrangements with partners.
  - Principles would help mitigate risks related to time lags from the Fund’s “learning by doing” pilot projects and inform decision making on expected engagement with partners when approving a new policy area.

- Managing Director’s position on Recommendation 4
  - Partially supports with qualifications.
  - Agrees the Fund’s engagement with external partners increased over time and that other international organizations have sought out the Fund.
  - Observes that current organic and tailored two-way engagement has occurred in absence of a formal framework and appears to work in being specific, tailored, and consistent with the Fund’s legal framework.
  - Concern: given diversity of engagements, any Statement of Principles would likely be so general as to have limited practical use.
  - Preferred approach: review and assess (and if necessary adjust) engagement with partners within context of individual strategies or policy reviews when substantive collaboration is called for.
  - As part of Recommendation 3 (surveillance clarity), strive to provide greater clarity on demarcation of responsibilities between the Fund and other partners to enable holistic assessment of the Fund’s contribution and complementarity with external partners.

### Implementation and next steps
- Leverage the Comprehensive Surveillance Review (CSR) and other existing workstreams (including the 80th anniversary inputs and Fund for the Future) rather than create separate institutional strategies.
- OBP to continue work on consistent inclusion of gross and net resource requirements and report on budget data strengthening as part of the FY27-29 medium-term budget.
- Continue integrating risk considerations via ORM, bi-annual enterprise risk reports, and DRSAs for policy papers.
- Staff to target high-quality, Board-relevant budget and tracking information while balancing costs and reporting burdens.
- MIP will reflect careful consideration of Board-endorsed recommendations, drawing on IEO suggestions and ensuring synergies with existing processes and resource constraints.

### Recommendations and Board/Management Positions (Section 2)
- Recommendation 1: The Board and management should enhance the decision-making process by: (i) developing an inclusive Fund-wide institutional strategy for Fund engagement in newer policy areas; and (ii) taking a more holistic approach when endorsing individual strategies for newer policy areas by better linking the decisions related to their scope, required resources, and risk management implications.
  - Position: Qualified support
- Recommendation 2: Management and staff should address operational challenges by producing budget data in a manner that allows tracking by policy area, across all Fund activities and operations. The Board should consider what policy areas need to be tracked and the level of granularity required, balancing the need for more detailed data with the costs and complexity involved in providing such data.
  - Position: Support
- Recommendation 3: Management and staff should enhance clarity of key elements regarding its surveillance in newer policy areas by updating the 2022 Guidance Note for Surveillance under Article IV Consultations.
  - Position: Support
- Recommendation 4: The IMF should adopt an Executive Board-approved high-level Statement of Principles for Engagement with Partners to establish a coherent best practice framework.
  - Position: Qualified support

*Statement by the Managing Director, June 3, 2024; Executive Board Meeting June 10, 2024*

### Section 1

### Statement by the Managing Director on the Independent Evaluation Office Report on the Evolving Application of the IMF’s Mandate

### Findings
- The IEO evaluation finds that the application and the scope of the Fund’s mandate were consistent with its legal framework and with the needs and priorities of the Fund’s membership.
- The Fund has steadily stepped up engagement in a broader set of macro-critical policy areas, reflecting an agile and adaptive response to global challenges including the Global Financial Crisis (GFC), COVID-19 pandemic, conflicts, and climate change.
- The Fund faces a trilemma of scope, traction, and resources when adopting new policy areas.
- In the context of a flat real budget during 2003-2023, work on newer policy areas was covered through reallocating resources, internal savings, and staff overtime.
- Some stakeholders felt insufficiently consulted during the Fund’s expansion into newer policy areas.
- The IEO report offers lessons that can be drawn on to improve Fund processes going forward.

### General response and approach
- The Managing Director concurs with the thrust of the evaluation and fully endorses the IEO’s two recommendations:
  - (i) enhance clarity regarding surveillance in newer policy areas; and
  - (ii) better track budget data by policy area.
- The Managing Director qualifies support for two recommendations:
  - (iii) enhance the Fund’s decision-making process; and
  - (iv) clarify interaction with external partners,
  due to concerns about the IEO’s proposed approach to implementation (development of a Fund-wide institutional strategy for engagement in newer policy areas and establishment of high-level principles for engagement with partners).
- Preferred approach: leverage existing workstreams and processes—especially the Comprehensive Surveillance Review (CSR)—and adjust engagement with partners within individual strategies or policy reviews where substantive collaboration is needed.
- In preparing the Management Implementation Plan (MIP), staff will carefully consider how best to implement Board-endorsed recommendations, drawing on the IEO’s suggestions while ensuring synergies with existing workstreams and being mindful of resource constraints.

### Recommendation 1 — Decision-making process (IEO proposal)
- IEO recommendation: The Board and management should enhance the decision-making process by:
  - (i) developing an inclusive Fund-wide institutional strategy for Fund engagement in newer policy areas; and
  - (ii) taking a more holistic approach when endorsing individual strategies for newer policy areas by better linking decisions related to scope, required resources, and risk management implications.

Recommendation 1: Summary of Specific Suggestions (as in the IEO proposal)
- Elements for an institutional strategy:
  - An assessment of alternative options for which policy areas to engage in and the desired level of engagement (ranging from signaling macrocriticality to engagement on par with traditional core policies).
  - An assessment of implications for the budget, overall size, and risk profile of the Fund, including impact on staff work pressures and overall well-being, and positioning in the international financial system.
  - An assessment of the desired balance between flexibility and consistency when implementing surveillance in newer policy areas, including principles of engagement and the extent of interpretation of “similar circumstances” for evenhandedness.
- Elements for endorsing individual strategies:
  - An assessment of the perimeter, depth, frequency, and required Fund expertise of the newer policy area.
  - An assessment of adequacy of allocated resources and their source to avoid impacting other Fund activities and placing unsustainable demands on staff.
  - A comprehensive risk assessment covering risks of engaging and not engaging across all six Level-1 risks of the ERM Framework.
  - How the Fund intends to engage with other partners on the newer policy area.

Managing Director’s position on Recommendation 1
- Supports the goal of enhancing the Fund’s decision-making process but prefers leveraging synergies within existing workstreams rather than a separate Fund-wide institutional strategy.
- The upcoming Comprehensive Surveillance Review (CSR) will:
  - include an assessment of implementation of the 2021 CSR surveillance priorities;
  - re-assess Fund surveillance priorities going forward to ensure surveillance remains fit for purpose; and
  - guide desired levels of Fund engagement in newer policy areas, aligning in spirit with the medium-term strategy recommended by the IEO (work on the 2026 CSR will aim to align in spirit).
- Other inputs that may inform strategic thinking include the 80th anniversary of the Bretton Woods institutions (IMF and World Bank) and the Fund for the Future workstream.
- Sub-recommendation II (holistic and consultative decision-making) is promising and can be embodied without an explicit institutional strategy.

Operational steps already underway related to Recommendation 1
- Office of Budget and Planning (OBP) work to ensure consistent inclusion of both gross and net resource requirements for new initiatives and policy reviews.
- Progress in integrating risk considerations into operations since establishment of the office of risk management, including bi-annual enterprise risk reports that integrate tradeoffs between risk mitigation and budget constraints.
- Departments will comprehensively assess enterprise risks related to engaging and not engaging in new policy areas supported by Document Risk Self Assessments (DRSAs) for policy papers; ORM will support departments in building risk assessment capacity.

### Recommendation 2 — Budget data tracking
- IEO recommendation: Management and staff should produce budget data in a manner that allows tracking by policy area, across all Fund activities and operations; the Board should consider which policy areas need to be tracked and the level of granularity required.

Managing Director’s position on Recommendation 2
- Supports this recommendation.
- Work to strengthen granularity of budget data in key policy areas is underway, as highlighted in Box 1 of the FY25-27 budget report.
- Reporting now includes information on where resourcing is increasing and where savings are being derived, and activity and tracking have picked up since the IEO review period of FY12-23, including newer areas like climate.
- Staff will target high-quality information of greatest relevance to strategic decision making; specific issue areas to be tracked will reflect engagement with the Board.
- Progress requires weighing costs and benefits, prioritization to ensure high-impact investments of scarce resources and staff time, and avoiding excessive ongoing reporting burdens while ensuring data quality.
- OBP will report on ongoing efforts to strengthen budget data as part of the FY27-29 medium-term budget.

Recommendation 2: Summary of Specific Suggestions (as in the IEO proposal)
- Collecting, tracking, and reporting budget data multidimensionally (by policy area, output area, country grouping, department) across all Fund activities would allow more precise cost and resource estimation.
- Benefits: help the Board understand resource allocation and impact of trade-offs across new and existing activities.
- Costs and challenges: significant resource implications in dollars and staff time; need to adapt current time registration system or invest in a multidimensional system; require additional staff inputs to register policy areas systematically; transition involves process planning, change management, and compliance/data quality risks.
- Recommendation to review which policy areas need tracking and the required level of granularity to balance costs.

Additional points
- IEO highlighted gap between scale of resources staff indicated would be needed for work in new areas supported by augmentation (like climate) and the scale of resourcing ultimately approved; this was an informed Board decision as part of the augmentation framework.
- FY25-27 budget data point to spending pressures reflecting a tight overall budget and ongoing developments, including impact of strong demand for RST operations on climate demand.
- Difficult trade-offs implied by these pressures will continue to require Board, management, and staff attention.

### Recommendation 3 — Surveillance guidance
- IEO recommendation: Management and staff should enhance clarity of key elements regarding surveillance in newer policy areas by updating the 2022 Guidance Note for Surveillance under Article IV Consultations.

Recommendation 3: Summary of Specific Suggestions (questions for an updated Guidance Note)
- Perimeter:
  - (i) how should staff determine if a structural issue is macrocritical;
  - (ii) to what extent is coverage of macrocritical structural issues required;
  - (iii) what time horizon(s) should staff consider when assessing macrocriticality.
- Provision of policy advice:
  - (i) how should staff determine if the Fund has expertise on a particular structural issue;
  - (ii) to what extent should staff provide policy advice when Fund expertise exists but supply is lacking;
  - (iii) should the IMF expertise filter be applied at all.
- Depth:
  - (i) how to determine relevance, severity, and urgency of a macrocritical structural issue, both independently and relative to others;
  - (ii) what are the different depths of engagement.
- Frequency:
  - how should staff determine when and how often to engage on a macrocritical structural issue.
- Uniformity of treatment:
  - (i) how should staff determine which similar circumstances are relevant when assessing evenhandedness;
  - (ii) should the Fund adopt an output-based approach to evenhandedness.

Managing Director’s position on Recommendation 3
- Supports updating the Staff Guidance Note (SGN) to ensure clearer and more consistent guidance about IMF surveillance activities in newer policy areas.
- Will continue comprehensive SGN updates following completion of ongoing periodic CSR.
- In the interim, management will continue practices to enhance clarity while avoiding overly specific requirements that constrain country teams, including regular updates to operational guidance.
- Will strive to include greater guidance on perimeter, depth, and frequency while mindful of trade-offs between specificity and staff flexibility.

### Recommendation 4 — Engagement with partners
- IEO recommendation: The IMF should adopt an Executive Board-approved high-level Statement of Principles for Engagement with Partners to establish a coherent best practice framework.

Recommendation 4: Details (as in the IEO proposal)
- An Executive Board-approved high-level Statement of Principles would provide an institutional anchor for engagement with partners.
- A principles approach would guide rationale, objectives, policies, monitoring, evaluation criteria and modalities, while providing flexibility for formal, informal, or ad hoc framework arrangements with partners.
- Principles would help mitigate risks related to time lags from the Fund’s “learning by doing” pilot projects and inform decision making on expected engagement with partners when approving a new policy area.

Managing Director’s position on Recommendation 4
- Partially supports with qualifications.
- Agrees the Fund’s engagement with external partners increased over time and that other international organizations have sought out the Fund.
- Observes that current organic and tailored two-way engagement has occurred in absence of a formal framework and appears to work in being specific, tailored, and consistent with the Fund’s legal framework.
- Concern: given diversity of engagements, any Statement of Principles would likely be so general as to have limited practical use.
- Preferred approach: review and assess (and if necessary adjust) engagement with partners within context of individual strategies or policy reviews when substantive collaboration is called for.
- As part of Recommendation 3 (surveillance clarity), strive to provide greater clarity on demarcation of responsibilities between the Fund and other partners to enable holistic assessment of the Fund’s contribution and complementarity with external partners.

### Implementation and next steps
- Leverage the Comprehensive Surveillance Review (CSR) and other existing workstreams (including the 80th anniversary inputs and Fund for the Future) rather than create separate institutional strategies.
- OBP to continue work on consistent inclusion of gross and net resource requirements and report on budget data strengthening as part of the FY27-29 medium-term budget.
- Continue integrating risk considerations via ORM, bi-annual enterprise risk reports, and DRSAs for policy papers.
- Staff to target high-quality, Board-relevant budget and tracking information while balancing costs and reporting burdens.
- MIP will reflect careful consideration of Board-endorsed recommendations, drawing on IEO suggestions and ensuring synergies with existing processes and resource constraints.

*Statement by the Managing Director, June 3, 2024; Executive Board Meeting June 10, 2024*

### Section 2

### Section 2

### Recommendations and Board/Management Positions

- Recommendation 1: The Board and management should enhance the decision-making process by: (i) developing an inclusive Fund-wide institutional strategy for Fund engagement in newer policy areas; and (ii) taking a more holistic approach when endorsing individual strategies for newer policy areas by better linking the decisions related to their scope, required resources, and risk management implications.
  - Position: Qualified support

- Recommendation 2: Management and staff should address operational challenges by producing budget data in a manner that allows tracking by policy area, across all Fund activities and operations. The Board should consider what policy areas need to be tracked and the level of granularity required, balancing the need for more detailed data with the costs and complexity involved in providing such data.
  - Position: Support

- Recommendation 3: Management and staff should enhance clarity of key elements regarding its surveillance in newer policy areas by updating the 2022 Guidance Note for Surveillance under Article IV Consultations.
  - Position: Support

- Recommendation 4: The IMF should adopt an Executive Board-approved high-level Statement of Principles for Engagement with Partners to establish a coherent best practice framework.
  - Position: Qualified support

*Source: ppea2024029 - Section 2*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/pp/2024/english/ppea2024029.pdf_
