## Second Progress Assessment of the Implementation of the Recommendations of the ISR — Executive Summary

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [Second Progress Assessment of the Implementation of the Recommendations of the ISR — Executive Summary](https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/pp/2025/english/ppea2025025.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/files/publications/pp/2025/english/ppea2025025.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/files/publications/pp/2025/english/ppea2025025.pdf.json)

---

### Background and context
- In October 2021, the Fund’s Executive Board launched the Institutional Safeguards Review (ISR).
- ISR recommendations finalized in June 2022 to strengthen Data and Analysis Integrity (DAI) frameworks and improve trust in the Dispute Resolution System (DRS).
- Implementation Plan (IP) issued in December 2022 comprising 71 actions: six for DAI and 65 for DRS/External Panel (EP) matters.
- Management and the Board decided in December 2022 that overall implementation would be subject to follow-up and validation by the Office of Internal Audit (OIA).

### Engagement objectives, scope, and approach
- Objective: Independently validate progress on the remaining 26 IP actions (in progress or delayed) since the first OIA assessment.
- Fieldwork substantially completed by mid-May 2025.
- Engagement exclusions:
  - Did not assess adequacy of IP design.
  - Did not assess composition/structure of IP Workstreams and Task Teams.
  - Did not assess reasonableness of net cost/resource implications.
  - Did not assess operating effectiveness of completed IP actions.
- Methods: Examination of documentation and interviews with key stakeholders (COM, D&I, ETO, HRD, LEG, OII, SEC).
- Conducted in conformance with The Institute of Internal Auditors’ Global Internal Audit Standards.

### Key findings and completion statistics (May 2025)
- Of the original 71 IP actions:
  - 65 IP actions have been completed (five for DAI and 60 for EP).
  - 6 IP actions remain in progress or delayed status (one DAI and five EP).
  - Overall completion rate: 92 percent.
- From the 26 actions that were in progress or delayed after the first OIA assessment:
  - 20 have been completed (19 EP actions and 1 DAI action).
  - 6 remain in progress or delayed.
- From OIA’s first assessment (July 2024):
  - 45 IP actions had been completed (4 DAI actions and 41 EP actions).

### Completed IP actions — DAI
- One additional DAI action completed in May 2025 regarding reporting of undue influence:
  - Management approved strengthening existing mechanisms rather than creating a new complaint mechanism solely for undue influence.
  - Strengthened role of the Ethics Office (ETO) as a central point of contact to support employees responding to undue influence concerns.
  - Commitment by DRS heads, ETO, and OII to annually track cases of undue influence.
  - Beginning in FY2026, annual engagement with Management and the Board will include a dedicated discussion of any undue influence concerns raised by relevant offices.
- Total DAI actions completed: 5 out of 6.

### Completed IP actions — EP (Leadership, tone from the top, DRS, oversight)
- 19 additional EP actions completed in this second assessment, bringing EP completions to 60 out of 65 EP actions (92 percent).
- Key implementations and milestones cited:
  - Revisions to, and publication of, the Board Code of Conduct (October 2024).
  - Publication of the Managing Director’s Terms of Appointment (October 2024) and the framework for application of standards of ethical conduct vis-à-vis the MD (March 2025).
  - Revisions to Grievance Committee processes (October 2024).
  - Streamlining and improvement of the Administrative Review (AR) processes for benefits and non-benefits cases (February 2025).
  - Expansion of the legal advisor function (April 2025).
  - Various communication, training and outreach efforts by Management, COM, HRD and DRS offices during CY 2024–25.
- Five EP actions were implemented with documented modifications compared to the original IP (EP 35–37, EP 41, EP 42); OIA found the modifications reasonable and well documented.

### In progress and delayed IP actions
- DAI:
  - One DAI action remains in progress (17 percent of DAI actions): audit of the upcoming Common Review System (CRS) slated for deployment around end CY 2025; the audit is tentatively scheduled for FY 2027 to allow time for system implementation.
- EP:
  - Four EP actions remain delayed and one EP action is in progress as of May 2025.
  - Delayed actions include:
    - Issuance of a new standalone whistleblower policy (expected completion during Q1 FY 2026).
    - Implementation of remaining recommendations of OIA’s 2021 Audit of the Enterprise Risk Management framework (planned through FY 2028).
  - In-progress action: access by Offices of Executive Directors (OED) personnel to formal DRS services, to be revisited by end FY 2026.
  - Implementation of a majority of delayed actions is anticipated by end CY 2025 (where applicable to specific actions).

### Conclusions and forward-looking considerations
- OIA does not propose new forward-looking opportunities in this assessment.
- OIA reiterates prior comments: with most IP actions completed, staff may wish to document the principles of a monitoring framework for future years, particularly for EP actions. Such a framework would:
  - Require coordination across departments.
  - Define follow-up arrangements for various action plans.
  - Monitor implementation to sustain momentum of implemented changes.
- Annual DRS Board briefings led by Management and DRS Offices could report on application of the monitoring framework and effectiveness of implemented actions.
- OIA will discontinue standalone ISR reporting to the Board with this assessment but will continue to monitor the six remaining action plans and report to Management and the Board on an ad hoc basis or through OIA’s semiannual Activity Reports to the Board.

### Annex highlights — selected implementation updates and timelines
- DAI 1A, DAI 2, DAI 3, DAI 4A: Completed (guidance notes and clarified roles issued in 2023).
- DAI 1B (undue influence mechanism): Completed (Management approved strengthening existing mechanisms in May 2025; annual tracking and FY2026 Board engagement established).
- CRS / DAI 4B:
  - CRS project executed in four phases spanning through "end CY 2025."
  - Releases 1, 2 and 3 are scheduled for "May, September and December 2025, respectively."
  - OIA’s Program of Work tentatively scheduled an audit of the review process for "FY 2027."
  - OIA assessment: "In progress."
- EP — Governance, ethics, and transparency:
  - Board Code of Conduct revised and published (approved October 1, 2024).
  - Managing Director ethical framework and Terms of Appointment published (October 2024; March 2025).
  - Ethics Committee may seek external legal counsel as needed (amendment to para. 25).
- DRS access and transparency:
  - EP 3A: OED access to informal DRS mechanisms completed (June 2023 approval).
  - EP 3B (formal DRS access for OED): In progress; to be revisited end FY 2026.
  - EP 10B/10C/10D: Toolkit, real-time tracker, and intranet disclosures deemed no further action; status marked Completed.
- Dispute Resolution System reforms and resourcing:
  - EP 11–13: Changes to DRS employment framework and centralization of investigations completed (Staff Handbook updates June 2023).
  - EP 14A/14B: Joint meetings and Management-led Board briefings on DRS annual reports completed (June 2023).
  - EP 38: DRS, Ethics, and Investigation Offices collectively received the largest structural percentage increase in the Fund (24.6%) for FY24 budget allocations and about 47% after including transitional funds; builds on overall 30 percent increase in FY23 and about 80 percent upward shift since FY22.
- Administrative Review and Grievance reforms (EP 17, EP 36, EP 37, EP 39, EP 41, EP 42):
  - Revised Grievance Committee processes approved October 11, 2024 and published in the Staff Handbook.
  - AR streamlining: Management approved Task Team proposals in February 2025 adjusting mandatory steps and timelines (single "45-business day limit" for HRD review of benefits cases; consolidated one-step review of benefits decisions).
  - EP 41 (reinstatement remedies): Task Team recommended no additional rule for terminated employees; rationale accepted by Management in February 2025.
  - EP 42 (contractual employees access): LEG recommended de-prioritizing; OIA assessment: "Completed." Management approved closure on June 25, 2025.
- Establishment of Staff Legal Counsel (EP 35 / SLC alternative):
  - Management approved in April 2025 a proposal to expand SAC legal advisor hours to double current weekly hours with an annual budgetary allocation of "$90,000" as a pilot (recommended assessment after "18 months").
  - SAC legal advisor to provide confidential advice to all Fund employees; will not represent staff in disputes with the Fund.
  - OIA assessment: "Completed."
- Whistleblower policy and related protections (EP 8(iv)(E), EP 8(vii), EP 24A):
  - Preliminary draft whistleblower policy prepared; revised timeline "Q1 FY 2026."
  - Extension of Independent Review access to three years being considered as part of whistleblower policy work.
  - OIA assessment: "Delayed."
- Enterprise Risk Management (EP 16A) follow-up:
  - Remaining recommendations linked to OIA follow-up audits tentatively scheduled for "FY 2028."
  - Implementation of some actions planned through FY 2028; OIA assessment: "Delayed."
- Culture, outreach, and training initiatives:
  - COM, HRD, D&I, and ETO delivered ongoing outreach and training during CY 2023–25 (examples: "Take 5 Conversations" workshop; mandatory ethics and diversity trainings; MD listening sessions).
  - Staff Engagement Survey (SES) and follow-up pulse surveys:
    - SES included trust, speak-up culture, and retaliation questions to set a baseline; follow-up surveys planned after 2 years of the SES.
  - Ongoing initiatives intended to foster speak-up culture, strengthen manager training on retaliation avoidance, and pilot psychological safety workshops for managers starting in FY26.

*Office of Internal Audit — Second Progress Assessment of the Implementation of the Recommendations of the ISR (June 30, 2025).*

### EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

### SECOND PROGRESS ASSESSMENT OF THE IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RECOMMENDATIONS OF THE ISR — EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

### Background and context
- In October 2021, the Fund’s Executive Board launched the Institutional Safeguards Review (ISR) to ensure the Fund’s systems reflected a robust governance structure that meets the highest standards.
- The ISR made recommendations in June 2022 to strengthen Data and Analysis Integrity (DAI) frameworks and improve trust in the Dispute Resolution System (DRS).
- An Implementation Plan (IP) was issued in December 2022 comprising 71 actions: six for DAI and 65 for DRS/External Panel (EP) matters.
- Management and the Board decided in December 2022 that the overall implementation would be subject to follow-up and validation by the Office of Internal Audit (OIA).

### Engagement objectives, scope, and approach
- Objective: Independently validate progress on the remaining 26 IP actions (in progress or delayed) since the first OIA assessment.
- Fieldwork substantially completed by mid-May 2025.
- Engagement did not assess: adequacy of the IP design; composition/structure of IP Workstreams and Task Teams; reasonableness of net cost/resource implications; operating effectiveness of completed IP actions.
- Methods: Examination of documentation and interviews with key stakeholders (COM, D&I, ETO, HRD, LEG, OII, SEC).
- Conducted in conformance with The Institute of Internal Auditors’ Global Internal Audit Standards.

### Key findings and completion statistics (May 2025)
- Of the original 71 IP actions:
  - 65 IP actions have been completed (five for DAI and 60 for EP).
  - 6 IP actions remain in progress or delayed status (one DAI and five EP).
  - Overall completion rate: 92 percent.
- From the 26 actions that were in progress or delayed after the first OIA assessment:
  - 20 have been completed (19 EP actions and 1 DAI action).
  - 6 remain in progress or delayed.
- From OIA’s first assessment (July 2024): 45 IP actions had been completed (4 DAI actions and 41 EP actions).

### Completed IP actions — DAI
- One additional DAI action completed in May 2025 regarding reporting of undue influence.
  - Management approved strengthening existing mechanisms rather than creating a new complaint mechanism solely for undue influence.
  - Strengthened role of the Ethics Office (ETO) as a central point of contact to support employees responding to undue influence concerns.
  - Commitment by DRS heads, ETO, and OII to annually track cases of undue influence.
  - Beginning in FY2026, annual engagement with Management and the Board will include a dedicated discussion of any undue influence concerns raised by relevant offices.
- Total DAI actions completed: 5 out of 6.

### Completed IP actions — EP (Leadership, tone from the top, DRS, oversight)
- 19 additional EP actions completed in this second assessment, bringing EP completions to 60 out of 65 EP actions (92 percent).
- Key implementations and milestones cited by OIA:
  - Revisions to, and publication of, the Board Code of Conduct (October 2024).
  - Publication of the Managing Director’s Terms of Appointment (October 2024) and the framework for application of standards of ethical conduct vis-à-vis the MD (March 2025).
  - Revisions to Grievance Committee processes (October 2024).
  - Streamlining and improvement of the Administrative Review (AR) processes for benefits and non-benefits cases (February 2025).
  - Expansion of the legal advisor function (April 2025).
  - Various communication, training and outreach efforts by Management, COM, HRD and DRS offices during CY 2024–25.
- Five EP actions were implemented with documented modifications compared to the original IP (EP 35–37, EP 41, EP 42); OIA found the modifications reasonable and well documented.

### In progress and delayed IP actions
- DAI:
  - One DAI action remains in progress (17 percent of DAI actions): audit of the upcoming Common Review System (CRS) slated for deployment around end CY 2025; the audit is tentatively scheduled for FY 2027 to allow time for system implementation.
- EP:
  - Four EP actions remain delayed and one EP action is in progress as of May 2025.
  - Delayed actions include:
    - Issuance of a new standalone whistleblower policy (expected completion during Q1 FY 2026).
    - Implementation of remaining recommendations of OIA’s 2021 Audit of the Enterprise Risk Management framework (planned through FY 2028).
  - In-progress action: access by Offices of Executive Directors (OED) personnel to formal DRS services, to be revisited by end FY 2026.
  - Implementation of a majority of delayed actions is anticipated by end CY 2025 (where applicable to specific actions).

### Conclusions and forward-looking considerations
- OIA does not propose new forward-looking opportunities in this assessment.
- OIA reiterates prior comments: with most IP actions completed, staff may wish to document the principles of a monitoring framework for future years, particularly for EP actions. Such a framework would:
  - Require coordination across departments.
  - Define follow-up arrangements for various action plans.
  - Monitor implementation to sustain momentum of implemented changes.
- Annual DRS Board briefings led by Management and DRS Offices could report on application of the monitoring framework and effectiveness of implemented actions.
- OIA will discontinue standalone ISR reporting to the Board with this assessment but will continue to monitor the six remaining action plans and report to Management and the Board on an ad hoc basis or through OIA’s semiannual Activity Reports to the Board.

*Office of Internal Audit — Second Progress Assessment of the Implementation of the Recommendations of the ISR (June 30, 2025).*

### Annex I. ISR Action Tracker—Completed Action as of First OIA Assessment

### Annex I. ISR Action Tracker—Completed Action as of First OIA Assessment

### Data and Analysis Integrity (DAI)
- DAI 1A
  - Recommendation: Clarify the terms of engagement of OED with staff in staff’s conduct of analysis.
  - Owner: SEC, LEG, SPR
  - Implementation Update: Joint note - clarifying the terms of engagement of OED with staff in staff’s conduct of analysis—was issued in June 2023. The note incorporates guidance applicable to staff and the guidance applicable to OEDs, with the staff guidance issued by Management and the relevant sections applicable to OEDs concurrently approved by the Executive Board.
  - Status: Completed
  - OIA Assessment (March 2024): Completed

- DAI 2
  - Recommendation: Clarify the role of management in the clearance of staff papers and positions.
  - Owner: LEG, SPR, OMD
  - Implementation Update: Guidelines were issued in February 2023—which clarify that Management’s role requires taking decisions on the basis of staff analysis and advice, while recognizing that Management has the prerogative to provide guidance on staff’s work and to exercise judgment on strategic issues within the framework of the Articles of Agreement and Board-approved policies.
  - Status: Completed
  - OIA Assessment (March 2024): Completed

- DAI 3
  - Recommendation: Complete ongoing work to help ensure evenhanded coverage of emerging areas in surveillance.
  - Owner: SPR
  - Implementation Update: Interim guidance note, issued to staff in April 2023, provides the latest operational guidance on these specific areas, consistent with the respective Board-approved strategies.
  - Status: Completed
  - OIA Assessment (March 2024): Completed

- DAI 4A
  - Recommendation: Further strengthen the transparency and documentation of internal review process.
  - Owner: SPR
  - Implementation Update: Guidance has been issued expanding the perimeter of documents using the e-Review system for interdepartmental review and Management clearance.
  - Status: Completed
  - OIA Assessment (March 2024): Completed. Part of the Guidance Note will only apply post CRS implementation to certain documents.

### External Panel (EP)
- EP 2
  - Recommendation: Review framework for publication of summary financial interests of Fund Management.
  - Owner: ETO, LEG, OMD, Board’s Ethics Committee (CAM)
  - Implementation Update: The framework for the publication of summary financial statements and interests of the Managing Director and the Deputy Managing Directors has been finalized. The first summary statements will be published on the Fund’s external website by the close of CY 2023.
  - Status: Substantially completed; summary statements to be published in Q4 of CY 2023
  - OIA Assessment (March 2024): Completed

- EP 3A
  - Recommendation: Enable OED access to informal DRS mechanisms.
  - Owner: LEG, MDT, OMB, SEC, Board’s CAM
  - Implementation Update: The Executive Board approved in June 2023 a proposal to grant all OED personnel access to the Ombuds and Mediation offices on the same basis as Fund staff—this enables OED personnel to seek guidance and support in navigating difficult workplace situations in a voluntary, informal, and confidential setting.
  - Status: Completed
  - OIA Assessment (March 2024): Completed

- EP 7
  - Recommendation: Unethical conduct should be penalized consistently, and the sanctions imposed for such conduct should be communicated to staff (for instance through regular anonymized reporting on cases of unethical conduct and the consequences for the wrongdoer).
  - Owner: OII
  - Implementation Update: HRD and LEG, as Management’s advisors in the review of disciplinary cases and determination of sanctions to be imposed, regularly liaise to ensure that penalties imposed on staff and contractual employees are consistent and continue to do so. OII Annual Reports for 2021 and 2022—issued in May 2023—included additional information about cases that have been investigated by OII, to provide more substantive summaries of cases the Office has addressed as well as their outcomes—balanced to ensure the appropriate levels of confidentiality regarding personnel matters.
  - Status: Ongoing
  - OIA Assessment (March 2024): Completed. OII’s Annual Report is published. Content has been expanded to give more information on the nature of individual cases investigated allowing readers to better understand the context, severity of allegations, and sanctions taken. The expanded OII Annual Report is intended to be published annually on an ongoing basis.

- EP 8(ii)
  - Recommendation: Where the Independent Review process concludes that retaliation has occurred, the fact than an employee’s actions were determined to be retaliatory should be considered in their performance evaluations, with appropriate consequences attached.
  - Owner: OII
  - Implementation Update: The decision as to whether a failure of an employee—to appropriately document his/her decision or meet the obligations conferred by the Retaliation policy but acted in good faith—is made by the Responsible Official considering the OII Investigation Report (i.e., the Director, HRD for A-level staff, the MD, or her delegate for B-level staff).
  - Status: Ongoing
  - OIA Assessment (March 2024): Completed. Updates to the Staff Handbook address the recommendation in design. The assessment process will be implemented on a continuous basis.

- EP 8(iii)
  - Recommendation: Update Retaliation Policy to require investigation of misconduct where it is concluded that retaliation has occurred.
  - Owner: OII
  - Implementation Update: Necessary updates to Retaliation Policy incorporated in Staff Handbook updates and published in June 2023.
  - Status: Completed
  - OIA Assessment (March 2024): Completed

- EP 8(iv)(A)
  - Recommendation: Update Retaliation Policy to provide for advice and early informal resolution for those who fear retaliation.
  - Owner: OII
  - Implementation Update: Necessary updates to Retaliation Policy incorporated in Staff Handbook updates and published in June 2023.
  - Status: Completed
  - OIA Assessment (March 2024): Completed

- EP 8(iv)(B)
  - Recommendation: Conduct awareness-raising event to share information with all staff on the various DRS Offices, the Ethics Office, and OII and mechanisms available to them, including to protect against retaliation.
  - Owner: COM, DRS
  - Implementation Update: A number of events have been regularly conducted to raise awareness. These include: (i) DRS Open House/awareness-raising event held in December 2022; (ii) “Meet your Ombudsperson”; “Ask me Anything with the Ethics Office” (on staff responsibilities as International Civil Servants”; (iii) “Insider” video with the Head of Office of Internal Investigation (OII); (iv) Mandatory Ethics Course for Fund staff including in-person sessions for Departments and training sessions for Heads of Department: (v) the Staff Association Committee (SAC)-convened DRS Townhall in November 2023 covered the roles/mandates of the DRS, Ethics, and Investigation Offices and used a case study to demonstrate in a practical way how these Offices could be leveraged by staff.
  - Status: Completed
  - OIA Assessment (March 2024): Completed

- EP 8(iv)(C)
  - Recommendation: Conduct formal Townhall with DRS office Heads, Ethics Office, OII, as well as with SAC on Activities/Annual Reports of DRS Offices.
  - Owner: COM, DRS
  - Implementation Update: DRS/ISR townhall (under the auspices of SAC) delivered in November 2023.
  - Status: Completed
  - OIA Assessment (March 2024): Completed

- EP 8(iv)(D)
  - Recommendation: Continue ongoing communications and outreach initiatives.
  - Owner: COM
  - Implementation Update: As also outlined in the Action Items #13 and 18 above, this is an ongoing effort. A Fund-wide Townhall was ISR held in February 2023 and a Fund-all communication on ISR progress was issued to staff in July. The ISR page has been updated with relevant resources and recent documents and has been disseminated as part of the FUNDALL message. The IP “Action Tracker” is also available on the ISR page, for Fund-wide access.
  - Status: Ongoing
  - OIA Assessment (March 2024): Completed. Various communications actions during CY 2023 address the recommendation. Communications initiatives are intended to be carried out periodically.

- EP 8(v)(A)
  - Recommendation: Update Retaliation Policy to include affirmative supervisory responsibility to report misconduct.
  - Owner: OII
  - Implementation Update: Necessary updates to Retaliation Policy incorporated in Staff Handbook updates and published in June 2023.
  - Status: Completed
  - OIA Assessment (March 2024): Completed

- EP 8(vi)
  - Recommendation: Update Retaliation Policy for OII to create a positive obligation on the Internal Investigator to consider the implementation of interim measures in all cases involving allegations of retaliation and to formally document their conclusion.
  - Owner: OII
  - Implementation Update: Necessary updates to Retaliation Policy incorporated in Staff Handbook updates and published in June 2023.
  - Status: Completed
  - OIA Assessment (March 2024): Completed

- EP 8(viii)(A)
  - Recommendation: Staff Engagement Survey (SES) to include questions on trust, speak-up culture, and retaliation and to set a baseline.
  - Owner: HRD
  - Implementation Update: SES sent out to staff included relevant questions and will serve to establish a baseline which will provide the basis for comparison in follow-up surveys.
  - Status: Completed
  - OIA Assessment (March 2024): Completed

- EP 8(viii)(B)
  - Recommendation: Follow-up Pulse Surveys to the SES to measure progress on these issues.
  - Owner: HRD
  - Implementation Update: Follow-up surveys on specific aspects to be administered after 2 years of the SES.
  - Status: Action Not Due. End CY 2024.
  - OIA Assessment (March 2024): Completed in FY 2025.

- EP 8(ix)
  - Recommendation: Amend TORs of Mediator and Ombudsperson to explicitly consider allegations of undue influence.
  - Owner: LEG
  - Implementation Update: Terms of References of Ombuds and Mediation Office have been amended – to explicitly consider allegations of undue influence - and were approved by Management in July 2023.
  - Status: Completed
  - OIA Assessment (March 2024): Completed

- EP 9A(i)
  - Recommendation: Share with staff high-level information about the number and nature of matters considered by Ethics Committee at the end of each Committee's Term.
  - Owner: Board’s Ethics Committee
  - Implementation Update: First Summary Report issued in CY 22 Q4. Report to be issued at the end of each Ethics Committee’s term going forward.
  - Status: Completed
  - OIA Assessment (March 2024): Completed

- EP 9A(ii)
  - Recommendation: Require systematic training on Board Code of Conduct for new OED Staff at the beginning of each term and on an annual basis.
  - Owner: Board’s Ethics Committee
  - Implementation Update: A regular schedule of ethics training has been introduced for all OED personnel, with the first session delivered in Q1 of CY 2023.
  - Status: Ongoing
  - OIA Assessment (March 2024): Completed. Training was first delivered in CY 2023. Training is intended to be conducted annually on an ongoing basis.

- EP 9B
  - Recommendation: Resume Publication of Information on Administrative and Grievance Committee Process.
  - Owner: GC
  - Implementation Update: Grievance Committee Annual Reports (for 2022, 2021 and 2020) published; Publication of redacted copies of GC recommendations has also been completed. Annual Reports for Admin Reviews published for 2019/2020/2021/2022.
  - Status: Completed
  - OIA Assessment (March 2024): Completed

- EP 10A
  - Recommendation: All DRS Information to be updated centrally on DRS Intranet Page.
  - Owner: COM
  - Implementation Update: The DRS webpage continues to be updated on an ongoing basis with recent updates and information notices.
  - Status: Ongoing
  - OIA Assessment (March 2024): Completed. A comprehensive DRS intranet page was created in CY

*Source: OIA Report on Progress Assessment of the Implementation of the Recommendations of the ISR (July 26, 2024).*

### 2023. The page is updated

### 2023. The page is updated

### Dispute Resolution System (DRS) transparency and case-tracking
- EP 10B: Create a Tool-Kit for Self-Represented employees on the DRS.
  - Owner: HRD
  - Implementation update: Work not deemed a priority given planned work to engage a Staff Legal Counsel (EP35) who would develop guidance materials to assist staff, as part of their Terms of Reference.
  - Status: No further action is envisaged. Completed
- EP 10C: Each relevant office or process should post a real-time case “tracker” on a secure intranet page for staff to monitor their case.
  - Owner: ITD
  - Implementation update: Determined there is no need for an expansive technology solution or real-time case-tracker. Given dissemination of Annual Reports, greater access to work of DRS, Ethics, and Investigation Offices, and planned streamlining, Offices will leverage existing internal tracking mechanisms and tools.
  - Status: No further action is envisaged. Completed
- EP 10D: Intranet page should show nature of individual complaints over past two to five years, timelines, substantiation, recommended consequences, and decisions.
  - Owners: LEG, DRS, HRD and COM
  - Implementation update: Information on nature of cases and outcomes already made available on respective intranet pages. Efficient approach: draw on non-confidential information from internal tracking mechanisms of DRS, Ethics, and Investigation offices and reports.
  - Status: No further action is envisaged. Completed. No additional work envisaged given budgetary constraints and information already available on the intranet.

### Investigations, centralization, and independence
- EP 11: Implement changes to the DRS employment framework in early 2021 to allow DRS leaders and employees to elect conversion to staff positions.
  - Owners: DRS, HRD
  - Implementation update: Executive Board approved changes in June 2023 to align with comparator IFI organizations.
  - Status: Completed
- EP 12: OII should not require authorization from Management or HRD before investigating cases.
  - Owner: OII
  - Implementation update: Necessary changes incorporated in Staff Handbook Updates published in end-June 2023.
  - Status: Completed
- EP 13: Investigations of allegations of misconduct should be centralized and conducted by OII only.
  - Owner: OII
  - Implementation update: OII established as centralized entry point; changes incorporated in Staff Handbook.
  - Status: Completed

### Reporting, Board engagement, and transparency of Offices
- EP 14A: Convene joint meetings between DRS & Ethics and Investigation Offices to discuss Annual Reports with Management and Board.
  - Owner: ETO
  - Implementation update: Joint meeting held in June 2023 between Management and the DRS, Ethics, and Investigation Offices to discuss Annual Reports and main themes.
  - Status: Completed
- EP 14B: Brief the board annually on activities of DRS offices.
  - Owner: ETO
  - Implementation update: Management-led Board briefing held in June 2023 to engage Executive Directors and identify systemic issues and cross-cutting trends.
  - Status: Completed
- EP 34: Provide a transparent learning process regarding Administrative Tribunal (AT) cases; include a Lessons Learned section in LEG memoranda and annual management statement.
  - Owner: LEG
  - Implementation update: Annual memorandum issued to Management in July 2023 which included a “Lessons Learned” section; to be issued annually going forward.
  - Status: Completed

### OIA, monitoring, and resources
- EP 15A: Enhance OIA independence by requiring EAC approval of OIA’s Program of Work.
  - Owner: OIA
  - Implementation update: OIA’s Charter amended; External Audit Committee approved OIA’s FY24 Program of Work.
  - Status: Completed
- EP 16B: Evaluate how to solve OIA’s capacity constraints.
  - Owner: OIA
  - Implementation update: OIA secured increases in structural budget envelope for FY23 and additional transition resources for FY24. Ongoing evaluation via annual budget cycle and accountability framework; Director of OIA can flag resource adequacy to EAC if needed.
  - Status: Completed
- EP 16C: Better monitor timely implementation of OIA’s and IEO’s recommendations.
  - Owner: OIA
  - Implementation update: OIA completed triage exercise to help departments view open audit issues; monitoring and reporting of IEO recommendations validated and reported by OIA through Periodic Monitoring Reports (PMRs). OIA’s Thirteenth PMR scheduled for Board discussion in November 2023. PMR reports are published; monitoring process implemented continuously.
  - Status: Ongoing / Completed (OIA assessment: IEO and OIA’s recommendations are sufficiently monitored on a periodic basis)
- EP 18: Impose appropriate and consistent sanctions for substantiated misconduct.
  - Owners: HRD, LEG, OII
  - Implementation update: Addressed through EP 7 response—OII Annual Reports now provide substantive summaries of cases and outcomes.
  - Status: Ongoing / Completed (OIA assessment: HRD and LEG will continue to coordinate to discuss consistency of sanctions)

### Deterrence, retaliation protections, and career safeguards
- EP 19B: Visible, transparent, decisive action is needed to support DRS and deter improper conduct.
  - Owners: HRD, LEG, OII
  - Implementation update: Addressed through actions under EP 7 (regular anonymized reporting of unethical conduct and consequences).
  - Status: Ongoing / Completed (see EP 7 and EP 18 updates)
- EP 24B: Employees who use and prevail in the DRS should receive HRD support to ensure careers are not negatively impacted; periodic review every 3 years to assess protections.
  - Owners: HRD, OII
  - Implementation update: Existing policy provides protection via IMF’s Retaliation Policy for employees who use the DRS whether or not they prevail. Employees may engage DRS services and if retaliation established, remedial action will be taken. Staff Handbook policy and outreach in CY 2023 address the recommendation; outreach and remedial actions intended to be implemented continuously.
  - Status: Ongoing / Completed

### Performance management, culture change, and training
- EP 25: Peer reviewers/witnesses/GC members to record contributions in APR and receive positive acknowledgement.
  - Owner: HRD
  - Implementation update: Briefing notes and annual guidance for 2023 APR cycle updated; SHRPs reinforced message in FY23 ATME outreach. Continuing effort as part of annual APR/ATME cycle.
  - Status: Completed
- EP 26: Reduce litigiousness by creating accountability measures for HRD and LEG and managers; missed timelines reflected in performance reviews.
  - Owner: HRD
  - Implementation update: When individual staff do not meet deadlines due to performance deficiencies, this is reflected in performance reviews and considered in promotions.
  - Status: Ongoing / Completed (existing policies and documentation evidence completion; intended as continuous)
- EP 30: Cultural change workstream to inventory past/ongoing initiatives and conduct focus groups/interviews to define current culture and behaviors; analysis from CY22 Q4 to CY23 Q4; formal proposal expected December 2023 and considered for FY25 budget.
  - Owners: COM, D&I, HRD
  - Implementation update: Organizational Culture Change (OCC) Task Team started February 2023; inventory completed; focus group sessions completed in June/July 2023; results align with ISR recommendations and will inform additional actions. A draft proposal under review; formal proposal expected to Management in December 2023 to be tabled for FY25 budget discussions.
  - Status: On track for completion / Completed (Management approved staff proposal for an action plan in January 2024)
- EP 31: ETO and Office of Mediation to strengthen training to prepare Peers for Respectful Workplace (PRWs) and raise ethics awareness.
  - Owners: ETO, MDT
  - Implementation update: Several training modules launched and completed in CY 2023. Mediation Office and Ethics Advisor to further strengthen PRW training.
  - Status: Ongoing / Completed (training first delivered in CY 2023; intended to be annual)

### HRD structure, administrative review, and resourcing
- EP 32: Establish Employee Relations Unit within HRD to enhance adherence to timelines and early dispute resolution.
  - Owner: HRD
  - Implementation update: Draft proposal formulated after benchmarking; consultation with stakeholders; expected finalization and submission to Management in Q1 of CY 2024 for FY25 budget considerations.
  - Status: Delayed. Revised target date- Q1 of CY 2024. Completed (Management approved on December 20, 2023, staff proposal to augment staffing of HRD’s Employment Practices (EP) unit and other measures to allow timelier processing of administrative review and early dispute resolution cases. Management rejected initial recommendation for two separate units.)
- EP 38: Evaluate resource allocation to DRS offices to ensure timelines and procedural requirements are met.
  - Owners: DRS, HRD
  - Implementation update: Comprehensive workforce planning exercise for FY24 completed for DRS, Ethics, and Investigation Offices. The Offices collectively received the largest structural percentage increase in the Fund (24.6%) for FY24 budget allocations and about 47% after including transitional funds. This builds on an overall 30 percent increase in DRS resourcing in FY23 with an overall upward shift in resources since FY22 of about 80 percent.
  - Status: Completed
- EP 40: Create a form for filing requests for administrative review and include a section asking for description of measures the complainant would like HR to take.
  - Owner: HRD
  - Implementation update: HRD rolled out a standardized online Administrative Review Intake Form and an Exit Questionnaire.
  - Status: Completed

*Source: ppea2025025 - 2023. The page is updated*

### Annex II. ISR Action Tracker—Additional Completed Action as of Second OIA

### Annex II. ISR Action Tracker—Additional Completed Action as of Second OIA

### Data and Analysis Integrity (DAI)
- DAI 1B
  - Recommendation: Explore effective mechanisms to raise concerns by staff about undue influence.
  - Owner: LEG, SEC, SPR, Board
  - Status/Timeline: Delayed. Revised target date–Q3 of CY 2024
  - Staff Implementation Update:
    - Management approved in May 2025 staff’s conclusion that there does not appear to be sufficient demand to warrant an entirely new complaint mechanism dedicated exclusively to undue influence. Rather, Management approved staff’s proposal to further strengthen existing mechanisms, including a strengthened role of the Ethics Office (ETO) where ETO serves as a central point of contact for employees seeking support to respond to undue influence concerns and plays a primary role in supporting employees in responding to concerns and safeguarding the integrity of their analysis.
    - ETO would also receive information on complaints of undue influence received through the Integrity Hotline that do not warrant an investigation, and could, with the consent of the complainant, refer concerns of undue influence which could amount to misconduct, to OII, the Board Ethics Committee, or other appropriate bodies for appropriate action where necessary. ETO’s Terms of Reference will be updated accordingly.
    - Finally, the proposal includes a commitment from the DRS heads, ETO and OII to annually track cases of undue influence, and beginning in FY2026, the annual engagement with Management and the Board would include a dedicated discussion of any undue influence concerns raised by the relevant offices. ETO will develop easy and accessible information material to inform employees of the multiple avenues available to raise concerns of undue influence, and the central role of the Ethics Office.
  - OIA Assessment and Comments (May 2025): Completed.

*Source:  OIA Report on Progress Assessment of the Implementation of the Recommendations of the ISR (July 26, 2024) for column 1-5. Staff update (COM, D&I, HRD, LEG, OIA, OII, and SEC) provided during February-May 2025 for column 6.*

### External Panel (EP)
- EP 1A
  - Recommendation: Ethics Committee (and the Board) to complete a full review of the Board’s Code of Conduct.
  - Owner: Board’s Ethics Committee, ETO, LEG
  - Status/Timeline: Delayed. Revised target date–Q1/Q2 of CY 2024.
  - Staff Implementation Update:
    - The Board approved the Ethics Committee’s proposed changes to Board Code of Conduct on October 1, 2024. The new Board Code of Conduct is published on the Fund’s external website: IMF Staff Ethics, Financial Disclosure, and Resolution of Staff Disputes: Annual Reports. Changes in the Code of Conduct include measures to protect staff against retaliation.
  - OIA Assessment and Comments (May 2025): Completed. Linkage to EP 5, EP 21 and EP 23.

- EP 1B
  - Recommendation: Ethics Committee (and the Board) to review the ethical framework applicable to the Managing Director.
  - Owner: Board’s Ethics Committee, ETO, LEG
  - Status/Timeline: Delayed. Revised target date–Q1/Q2 of CY 2024.
  - Staff Implementation Update:
    - The Board approved the Ethics Committee’s recommendation to enhance transparency around the ethical framework applicable to the Managing Director (MD) on October 1, 2024. This led to the publishing of the MD’s contract and the framework for the application of the standards of ethical conduct vis-à-vis the MD on the Fund’s external website: IMF Staff Ethics, Financial Disclosure, and Resolution of Staff Disputes: Annual Reports
  - OIA Assessment and Comments (May 2025): Completed.

- EP 5
  - Recommendation: In cases involving the conduct of the Managing Director, or in other cases in which a potential conflict of interest may arise, the Secretariat of the Ethics Committee should be an external lawyer, rather than staff of the Fund.
  - Owner: Board’s Ethics Committee
  - Status/Timeline: Action not due. Revisit after review of Board’s Code of Conduct.
  - Staff Implementation Update:
    - This issue was considered by the Ethics Committee and the Board as part of the review of the Board Code of Conduct. The Committee and the Board’s deliberations are Strictly Confidential, but the result was that the Board agreed to amend para. 25 of the Board Code of Conduct to add the following sentence: “In addition, the Ethics Committee may at any time seek the views of external legal counsel and/or ethics advisors on any matter before it, including where the Committee is seized of a matter concerning the Managing Director.”
  - OIA Assessment and Comments (May 2025): Completed. Linkage to EP 1A.

- EP 6
  - Recommendation: Management and the Board should lead culture change efforts across the Fund with strong, visible messaging backed by action and should make the inculcation of a culture of dialogue and integrity a strategic priority.
  - Owner: COM, HRD, D&I, DRS
  - Status/Timeline: Ongoing. From CY 2022 Q4 onwards.
  - Staff Implementation Update:
    - COM has supported various internal communications efforts implemented by HRD and the DRS, D&I, and Ethics offices during FY25. Those include several blogs and articles promoting a positive workplace, ethical values, preventing harassment, and increasing awareness of the Mediation Office and its support to staff. COM also supported the Ethics Office (ETO)’s two sessions on receiving gifts & hospitality and on political activities, and most recently, the Ethics Office’s 25th anniversary panel discussion focusing on the Fund’s values and the importance of ethics. A DRS Townhall was organized on March 2025 event with SAC and all DRS offices.
    - All new hires receive a list of mandatory trainings which include several ethics and diversity & inclusion trainings “Positive Workplace—Preventing Harassment at Work”, “Navigating Ethics for International Civil Servants”, Navigating Ethics: Conflicts of Interest”, “Understanding Unconscious Bias”, and “Impact of Micro-Behaviors”.
  - OIA Assessment and Comments (May 2025): Completed. Outreach, training and communication efforts are of an ongoing nature. Linkage to EP 27–29.

- EP 8(v)(B)
  - Recommendation: Identify and adjust Management training programs (for Managers/Supervisors on how to avoid behaviors that could amount to retaliation).
  - Owner: D&I, ETO
  - Status/Timeline: On track for completion. CY 2023 Q4.
  - Staff Implementation Update:
    - An expanded portfolio of online culture change training on various topics was launched on March 4, 2025. Positive workplace e-learning was rolled out to all staff by ETO. D&I office formed a small cross-functional group to develop an initiative to promote a speak-up culture working with ETO. An interactive workshop on psychological safety for managers is developed and will be piloted with select departments starting in FY26, with plans for Fund-wide implementation contingent on the success of the pilot.
  - OIA Assessment and Comments (May 2025): Completed. Outreach, training and communication efforts are of an ongoing nature. Linkage to EP 27–29.

- EP 17
  - Recommendation: The Fund should initiate efforts to streamline and improve the Grievance Committee process.
  - Owner: LEG
  - Status/Timeline: On track for completion. Q4 CY 2023.
  - Staff Implementation Update:
    - The revised Grievance Committee processes have been approved by Management on October 11, 2024 and published in the Staff Handbook, together with new rules of procedure.
  - OIA Assessment and Comments (May 2025): Completed. Linkage to EP 39.

- EP 19A
  - Recommendation: There should be visible, strategic, and frequent communication of the Managing Director’s stance against retaliation, and visible action should be taken when an allegation of retaliation is substantiated.
  - Owner: OMD, COM, HRD, OII
  - Status/Timeline: Ongoing
  - Staff Implementation Update:
    - DMDs and the MD have addressed the issue of retaliation and internal justice systems in a handful of events, including most recently at the Townhall on her second term and the MD video remarks for the Ethics Office’s 25th anniversary event.
  - OIA Assessment and Comments (May 2025): Completed. Outreach, training and communication efforts are of an ongoing nature. Linkage to EP 6 and EP 20.

- EP 20
  - Recommendation: With the help of the Office of Innovation and Change, the Ethics Office and the Ombudsperson, the Managing Director should host roundtable discussions designed to generate buy-in and build shared expectations about how common workplace challenges, such as issues of data analysis and integrity, bullying or retaliation, will be managed. The information gathered through this process should inform the adoption of new policies as needed.
  - Owner: OMD, Other dpts
  - Status/Timeline: Ongoing
  - Staff Implementation Update:
    - COM continues to support Management in its engagement with staff, including the MD’s listening sessions with several groups across the Fund to hear their concerns and recommendations. Eight listening sessions were conducted in the first half of FY25 and at least five more are scheduled for the second half of FY25 and into FY26. In these sessions the MD addressed issues and challenges in the workplace, including integration, diversity and promotion, as well as burnout, increasing work pressures, and overall staff well-being.
    - In addition, COM has supported OMD with MD speeches for Townhalls, including the 2024 Annual Meetings Townhall, where the Managing Director announced the Fund-wide streamlining exercise, and the Townhall on the MD’s vision for her second term. The FDMD also engages regularly with mission chiefs ahead of the Spring and Annual Meetings to listen to their main concerns and provide guidance.
  - OIA Assessment and Comments (May 2025): Completed. Outreach, training and communication efforts are of an ongoing nature. Linkage to EP 6 and EP 19A.

- EP 21
  - Recommendation: The Fund's mission and work will occasionally give rise to concerns about the impact of political pressure on data integrity and analysis. To increase trust in the Fund, both internally from staff and externally from the public, it is critical that the Executive Board support efforts to create greater internal consensus and more detailed policies that are used to resolve these concerns when they arise. This report recommends that the Ethics Officer and Ombudsperson engage in roundtable dialogues on these matters. Executive Board members should be active participants in these conversations, then support the resulting policies and norms.
  - Owner: Board
  - Status/Timeline: Partially completed. Review of Board Code of Conduct planned to be completed in Q1 of CY 2024.
  - Staff Implementation Update:
    - In addition to the Board paper on engagement between OEDs and staff already completed in 2023, note in the revised Board Code of Conduct, in particular the following addition in para. 6: “Executive Directors should not exert pressure on staff in a manner that is inappropriate (e.g., by implicit or explicit intimidations, or withholding information), and/or insist that staff take actions that are not justified by Fund policies.” Changes in the Code of Conduct include measures to protect staff against retaliation.
  - OIA Assessment and Comments (May 2025): Completed. Linkage to DAI 1A (previously completed), DAI 1B and EP 1A.

- EP 23
  - Recommendation: Hold each other accountable to the highest ethical standards, including the expectation that all employees will be treated respectfully and professionally. While formal power over other Executive Board members may be limited, the Executive Board has deep reserves of informal influence which it can harness to hold each other accountable.
  - Owner: Board
  - Status/Timeline: Planned for completion in Q1 of CY 2024.
  - Staff Implementation Update:
    - The comprehensive review of the Board Code of Conduct supports implementation of this recommendation. See EP 1A.
  - OIA Assessment and Comments (May 2025): Completed. Linkage to EP 1A.

- EP 27
  - Recommendation: Supervisors should engage in collaborative problem-solving and dialogue on difficult issues such as data analysis and integrity and should discuss difficult topics on an ongoing basis with the goal of building shared expectations to avoid and manage conflicts productively.
  - Owner: D&I, ETO, MDT
  - Status/Timeline: Ongoing
  - Staff Implementation Update:
    - As part of the culture change initiative, a joint session with ETO and D&I entitled “Reimagining Culture Change and Positive workplace at the Fund” was held on June 27, 2024. The session drew a high level of participation with strong engagement throughout. D&I and the Ethics Office looks forward to continuing this joint effort by hosting additional sessions on relevant topics.
    - Training and outreach provided by ETO and MDT, including through Peers for a Respectful Workplace (PRW) program. For example, ETO launched a post-pandemic update of the mandatory e-learning course, Positive Workplace—Preventing Harassment at Work in June
  - OIA Assessment and Comments (May 2025): Completed. Outreach, training and communication efforts are of ongoing nature. Linkage to EP 6 and EP 8(v)(B), and EP 8(iv)B-D (previously completed).

*Source:  OIA Report on Progress Assessment of the Implementation of the Recommendations of the ISR (July 26, 2024) for column 1-5. Staff update (COM, D&I, HRD, LEG, OIA, OII, and SEC) provided during February-May 2025 for column 6.*

### 2024. MDT has developed a workshop titled “Take 5

### ppea2025025 - 2024. MDT has developed a workshop titled “Take 5 Conversations.”

### Outreach, training, and workplace culture initiatives
- MDT developed a workshop titled “Take 5 Conversations” that "provides simple strategies and tips for Fund staff to effectively handle challenging conversations and workplace issues and address offensive behavior in a respectful manner."
- HRD provided the board a briefing on Engagement survey results in November 2024.
- SEC has organized regular meetings between MD and the Board on work program and work environment as well as retreats.
- Departments manage departmental specific actions in a decentralized manner and discuss them with Department Directors twice a year in the Accountability Framework Exercise.
- The 2023 and 2024 annual reports of different DRS offices and the administrative review show "significant increases in use of the informal and formal avenues of the DRS" attributed to policy reforms and increased outreach.
- Outreach, training and communication efforts are described as "of ongoing nature."
- Linkage to EP 6 noted.

### Encouraging use of Dispute Resolution Services (DRS) and informal mechanisms
- Employees are encouraged to "ask for help and be willing to help" and to be "bold in asking for help from HRD, the Mediator, and the Ombudsperson."
- If those efforts fail, employees "should be willing to give the DRS a try rather than allow problems to go unresolved."
- Employees are encouraged to volunteer as Ethics Ambassador, Peers for a Respectful Workplace, and other functions.
- The Staff Association Committee (SAC) "has long held an annual Townhall, and as of this year a Fair to showcase the DRS services."
- Status for DRS outreach/training: "Ongoing" and "Completed" (outreach, training and communication efforts are of ongoing nature).
- Linkage to EP 8(v)(B) and EP 27-28, and EP 8(iv)B-D (previously completed).

### Establishment of a Staff Legal Counsel (SLC) function (EP 35)
- Recommendation: "Develop a proposal for the establishment of a Staff Legal Counsel (SLC) function."
- Owner: LEG
- Status/Timeline: Delayed. Expected to be developed by Q2 of CY 2024.
- Staff Implementation Update:
  - Management approved in April 2025 a proposal by an HRD-led Task Team (with LEG and SAC) to leverage the existing SAC legal advisor function to provide advice to individual employees through an expansion of the legal advisor’s weekly hours.
  - This expansion would "double the number of hours currently available for advice to individual employees" through a modest increase in the annual budgetary allocation of "$90,000."
  - The SAC legal advisor would "function autonomously and independently to provide confidential advice to all Fund employees (not only SAC members) on internal disputes."
  - The legal advisor "would not represent staff in disputes with the Fund."
  - The approach is recommended "as a pilot" to allow assessment after "a reasonable period of time (for e.g., 18 months)" before further financial commitment.
- OIA Assessment and Comments: "Completed. While Management did not endorse the creation of a standalone full time counsel function, the Task Team proposal is an improvement to services available to staff."

### Administrative Review (AR) process changes (EP 36, EP 37)
- EP 36 Recommendation: "The first step of the Administrative Review process should be mandatory for benefits disputes, but optional for all other types of Administrative Review matters."
  - Owner: HRD
  - Status/Timeline: Action Not Due. CY 2024 Q4.
  - Staff Update: Management approved in February 2025 a Task Team proposal that the first step of AR "remain mandatory for benefits and other types of AR matters."
  - The Task Team recommended consolidating the review of benefits decisions to a one-step process within HRD (from two).
  - The revised rule will be incorporated into the "Fall FY 2026 update of the Staff Handbook."
  - HRD is preparing updated electronic Intake Forms and FAQs for HR-Web pages.
  - OIA Assessment: "Completed. While Management did not endorse the original action plan, the Task Team proposal still includes several improvements to the functioning of the AR processes."
  - Linkage to EP 37 and EP 41.
- EP 37 Recommendation: "Short, enforced timelines should be put in place for administrative review cases, as well as preliminary assessments and substantive investigations, with consequences to the Fund or its officials for missed timelines."
  - Owner: HRD
  - Status/Timeline: Action Not Due. CY 2024 Q4.
  - Staff Update:
    - Management approved in February 2025 the Task Team recommendation not to endorse enforcing 20-day timelines for AR cases.
    - Task Team recommended a single "45-business day limit for HRD review of benefits cases."
    - For non-benefits cases: "no extension of the 45-day deadline for decision is recommended," but greater use of existing provision to agree to extensions where needed.
    - Task Team did not recommend imposing consequences on the Fund; instead recommended stronger use of existing steps (communication, enhanced intake requirements, clarifying third-party administrator challenges).
  - OIA Assessment: "Completed. While Management did not endorse the original action plan, the Task Team proposal includes several improvements to the functioning of the AR processes."
  - Linkage to EP 36.

### Grievance Committee, reinstatement, and contractual employee access (EP 39, EP 41, EP 42)
- EP 39 Recommendation: "The Fund should re-brand and re-cast the current Grievance Committee placing greater emphasis on equity and being a less judicialized process."
  - Owner: LEG
  - Status/Timeline: Delayed. Revised target date–Q2 of CY 2024.
  - Note: See update for EP 17.
  - OIA Assessment: "Completed. Linkage to EP 17."
- EP 41 Recommendation: "The Fund should devote greater efforts to offer a comparable position within the organization to an employee whose employment was wrongfully terminated."
  - Owners: HRD, LEG, OII
  - Status/Timeline: Delayed. Revised target date–Q3 of CY 2024.
  - Staff Update:
    - Management approved in February 2025 the Task Team’s recommendation that no additional rule for terminated employee was needed for three reasons:
      1. Termination decisions are taken by or in consultation with the Director of HRD (or Management) and not subject to administrative review by the HR Director.
      2. If a terminated staff member seeks review by the Grievance Committee, the Committee may recommend reinstatement as appropriate.
      3. If challenged before the Tribunal and the Tribunal determines termination is wrongful, the Tribunal may order reinstatement; however, even with a binding Tribunal judgment the Fund retains discretion to pay monetary damages instead of implementing the prescribed measure.
  - OIA Assessment: "Completed. While Management did not endorse the original action plan, the Task Team’s rationale appears reasonable given remedies afforded to staff through the Grievance Committee and Tribunal processes."
  - Linkage to EP 36 and EP 37.
- EP 42 Recommendation: "All employees of the Fund (including contractual employees) should enjoy the same access to all the DRS and related offices, including the Grievance Committee and the Administrative Tribunal."
  - Owner: LEG
  - Status/Timeline: Action Not Due. CY 2024 Q4.
  - Staff Update:
    - LEG notes contractual employees already have access to many elements of the dispute resolution system, including administrative review and arbitration for employment disputes.
    - Arbitration for contractual employees gives rise to a final and binding decision and takes place before a sole arbitrator (the Chair of the Grievance Committee).
    - Contractual employees have access to the Administrative Tribunal with respect to claims arising under the Fund’s benefit plans.
    - LEG recommended eliminating or deprioritizing this item for the second and final OIA progress assessment given substantial progress on ISR recommendations.
  - OIA Assessment: "Completed. Management approved LEG’s proposal to close this action plan on June 25, 2025."

### ISR Action Tracker — Data and Analysis Integrity (DAI) and External Panel items (selected)
- DAI 4B Recommendation: "Assess adaption of review process after the roll-out of the Common Review System (CRS) as part of the Integrated Digital Workplace (IDW) Program."
  - Owners: OIA, SPR
  - Status/Timeline: Action not due. After rollout of IDW.
  - Update:
    - CRS project executed in four phases: prototyping, piloting, implementation and stabilization—spanning through "end CY 2025."
    - Releases 1, 2 and 3 are scheduled for "May, September and December 2025, respectively."
    - OIA’s Program of Work tentatively scheduled an audit of the review process for "FY 2027."
  - OIA Assessment: "In progress. Linkage to EP 16A."
- EP 3B Recommendation: "Enable OED Access to Formal DRS"
  - Owners: Board’s CAM, LEG, SEC
  - Status/Timeline: Action not due. Revisit end-CY 2024.
  - Update:
    - The Administrative Tribunal issued a judgment in a case brought by an Administrative Assistant in OED—the first time the Tribunal considered a matter brought by an OED employee.
    - CAM will be briefed on the ruling; Committee may offer guidance on extending access to formal DRS and may first gain experience with OED access to informal DRS.
    - Action plan to be revisited by year-end FY 2026.
  - OIA Assessment: "In progress."
- EP 8(iv)(E) Recommendation: "Develop stand-alone Whistleblower Policy."
  - Owner: OII
  - Status/Timeline: Delayed. Revised target date–Q1/Q2 of CY 2024.
  - Update:
    - Preliminary draft prepared, informed by consultations with LEG and ETO and benchmarking comparator organizations.
    - Proposal will define terms, delineate responsibilities of institutional actors, and codify protections afforded to whistleblowers.
    - Revised timeline is "Q1 FY 2026."
  - OIA Assessment: "Delayed."
- EP 8(vii) Recommendation: "Extend the period for access to Independent Review (IR) to three years."
  - Owner: OII
  - Status/Timeline: Delayed. Revised target date–Q1/Q2 of CY 2024.
  - Update: Being considered as part of the work on developing a Whistleblower Policy.
  - OIA Assessment: "Delayed. Linkage to EP 8(iv)(E)."
- EP 16A Recommendation: "Strengthen implementation of the '3 Lines' Model by addressing shortcomings described in the OIA Audit Report of the Fund’s Enterprise Risk Management (ERM) Framework published in 2021."
  - Owners: OIA, ORM
  - Status/Timeline: On track for completion CY 2024 Q1/Q2.
  - Update:
    - Periodic communications with ORM to obtain updates on remaining six recommendations.
    - Two recommendations rely on OIA follow-up audits tentatively scheduled for "FY 2028."
    - One recommendation (review of the exceptional access policy) closed in December 2024 after issuance of an IEO report.
    - The Board and the EAC are apprised semiannually on status of implementation.
  - OIA Assessment: "Delayed. Linkage to DAI 4B."
- EP 24A Recommendation: "Complainants should not be required to be re-assigned or to take a different position if they do not desire that action."
  - Owner: OII
  - Status/Timeline: Planned for completion in Q2 of CY 2024.
  - Update: Work on developing a whistleblower policy (EP 8(iv)) will codify protections, including that complainants should not be required to be reassigned.
  - OIA Assessment: "Delayed. Linkage to EP 8(iv)(E)."

*Source: OIA Second Progress Assessment of the Implementation of the Recommendations of the ISR (staff updates February–May 2025; OIA Assessment May 2025).*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/pp/2025/english/ppea2025025.pdf_
