## ch2annex

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [ch2annex](https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/reo/apd/2023/october/english/ch2annex.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/files/publications/reo/apd/2023/october/english/ch2annex.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/files/publications/reo/apd/2023/october/english/ch2annex.pdf.json)

---

### Inflation developments in China (Online Box 2.1)
- Inflation in China has been noticeably subdued compared with the rest of the region.
- Average inflation has been lower than before the pandemic.
- Drivers and dynamics:
  - External price pressures and pandemic repercussions contributed, but idiosyncratic factors also play a role.
  - Economic weakness and slack, and lower commodity and food prices, have coincided with falling inflation.
  - Core inflation has remained subdued throughout 2023 amid a still-negative output gap, spare capacity in the industrial sector, and labor market weakness (high youth unemployment, weak PMI employment sub-indices).
  - Increases in food and energy prices have been noticeably less than in the rest of the Asia-Pacific region and the world, in part because of administered prices.
  - Combined effects produced negative inflation in July, temporarily, and have kept inflation at just above zero in August.
  - Static or falling rents made a negative contribution to CPI inflation; the real estate cycle could have mitigated inflation in services components of CPI.
  - Lockdowns, low pass-through of external inflation pressures to domestic prices, and additional effects from the real estate cycle have kept inflation low.

### Phillips curve estimates (Online Box 2.2)
- Model specification:
  - Core inflation equation estimated with contemporaneous and up to four lags of import, food, and energy price indices; constraint imposed that coefficients on past and expected inflation sum to one.
  - Variables include: annualized growth rate of core CPI (πc_t), 3-year-ahead inflation expectations from Consensus Forecasts (πe_t), output gap (ŷ_t, HP-filtered quarterly real output), annualized growth rate of the import price index (πI_t), annualized growth rate of the food CPI (πF_t), annualized growth rate of the energy CPI (πE_t). All price indices are in local currencies.
  - Estimated as a panel regression with country and time fixed effects for 9 advanced and emerging Asia-Pacific economies and 12 advanced and emerging economies in the rest of the world from 1995Q1 (or first available) to 2023Q2 at quarterly frequency.
- Structural estimates and comparisons:
  - Persistence of core inflation is higher in Asia-Pacific advanced economies than in advanced economies in the rest of the world.
  - Point estimates of persistence for Asia-Pacific emerging economies are slightly lower than those for peer economies in the rest of the world, but not significantly so.
  - The slope of the Phillips Curve (coefficient of the output gap) is higher in Asia’s advanced and emerging economies than for peers in other regions.
  - The Phillips Curve is estimated to be particularly flat in advanced economies outside Asia.
  - Overall: propagation of shocks (how much inflation is affected by changes in output gaps, import prices, and inflation expectations) in Asia and Pacific economies is similar to that in advanced and emerging market peers and does not explain the on-average lower inflation of the region.
- Inflation accounting:
  - Fitted values and historical data used to calculate contributions of each component to core inflation.
  - Average contributions for five advanced and four emerging Asia-Pacific economies show notable effects from external prices to core inflation in 2021 to 2023, especially in emerging economies.
  - Contributions from external prices are generally less than those seen in the rest of the world.
  - Contributions from estimated output gaps are generally small.
  - Substantial residuals are present, particularly during 2022.

### Policy measures (Online Box 2.3)
- Monetary policy:
  - Central banks across the Asia and Pacific region resorted to accommodative monetary policy soon after the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic.
  - Some countries were constrained by the zero lower bound as they entered the pandemic: Australia, Korea, New Zealand, Thailand.
  - Several countries reduced reserve requirements: Bangladesh, China, India, Indonesia, Malaysia, Philippines.
  - Timing of rate hikes:
    - Korea and New Zealand started raising policy rates prior to the Federal Reserve’s initiating its tightening cycle.
    - Other central banks started raising policy rates only after the Federal Reserve started raising the Fed Funds rate.
    - The size of cumulative policy rate hikes in the region has been less than the policy rate hikes implemented by the Federal Reserve.
    - Vietnam lowered its policy rate, after raising them for a short period in 2022, due to a slowdown in the economy.
  - Unconventional tools:
    - Large scale asset purchases: Australia, Japan.
    - Open market operations in the secondary market: Korea, Philippines.
    - Open market operations in the primary market: Indonesia, Philippines.
    - Indonesia designed mechanisms to allow temporary central bank participation in budget financing, including transfers to budget to reduce effective interest costs of the budget; all these mechanisms were discontinued in 2022.
    - Forward guidance used: India (state- and time-contingent forward guidance on policy rates and asset purchases), Reserve Bank of New Zealand (indicated it will keep monetary policy stimulatory for a considerable time and noted operational readiness for negative interest rates), Reserve Bank of Australia (cash rate low until durable progress toward full employment).
  - FX interventions:
    - Several EM central banks intervened in their FX markets depending on capital flows and external pressures, either purchasing FX amid inflow surges or intervening to support currencies.
    - The pace and scale of US tightening led to strong external pressures in 2022, with many EMDEs intervening to support local currencies even as their NEERs witnessed greater stability.
- Fiscal policy:
  - All countries in the region responded with strong fiscal support measures directed toward health-related spending and support to households and firms.
  - Size of fiscal stimulus depended on fiscal space:
    - Singapore: about 21 percent of 2020 GDP, with about two-thirds in above-the-line measures.
    - Australia: fiscal stimulus amounted to 20 percent of GDP (60 percent of this stimulus expired by end-FY20/21 and the remaining is projected to be disbursed by FY24/25).
    - Japan: total above-the-line fiscal measures in 2020-2021 amounted to 18.5 percent of GDP, with about 13 percent of GDP on public investment.
    - China: discretionary fiscal measures amounting to 4.7 percent of 2020 GDP centered on an increase in infrastructure investment, providing an estimated boost to GDP growth of 2.2 percentage points.
  - Other measures: cash handouts or consumption vouchers to households (Hong Kong SAR, India, Japan, Malaysia, Singapore).
  - Fiscal tightening:
    - Governments have steadily tightened fiscal policy as most COVID-19 related policy measures have largely expired; tightening fiscal stance in most Asia-Pacific countries in 2022 relative to 2020.
    - The pandemic helped strengthen mechanisms for providing targeted support to households.
- Price controls:
  - In response to rising commodity prices, most ASEAN-4 countries provided subsidized fuel and energy, helping suppress overall prices but raising subsidy bills.
  - Indonesia and Malaysia have longstanding energy subsidies; Thailand provided energy subsidies starting in 2022.
  - Singapore does not subsidize energy prices but continues rebates for low-income households for utility bills.
  - Food and agriculture subsidies primarily used by lower-income countries such as Bangladesh and India.
- Financial sector policies:
  - Counter-cyclical capital buffers (CCyB) were lowered: Australia, Hong Kong SAR.
  - Allowance for banks to use capital conservation buffers: Indonesia.
  - Credit-support measures and subsidies:
    - Bangladesh: bulk of COVID-19 stimulus in the form of an interest subsidy for working capital loans and loans to cottage, micro, small and medium enterprises at subsidized interest rates.
    - China: increased bank lending targets, subsidized local banks’ loan repayment moratoria, and deployed non-interest rate instruments to support smaller firms.
    - Hong Kong SAR: introduced a US Dollar Liquidity Facility, encouraged banks to use liquidity buffers, provided government guarantees for low-interest loans for SMEs, personal loans for unemployed and self-employed individuals, and loan moratoria on principal payments for affected SMEs, sectors, and households.
    - Korea: broad support package for credit and financial markets including SME lending and guarantee programs, stabilization funds for bond markets and key industries, and various regulatory measures.
    - Loan moratoria implemented by some governments: Malaysia, Singapore.

*INTERNATIONAL MONETARY FUND | October 2023*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/reo/apd/2023/october/english/ch2annex.pdf_
