## Tax Revenue Growth and Formalization, Republic of Kosovo

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [Tax Revenue Growth and Formalization, Republic of Kosovo](https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/selected-issues-papers/2023/english/sipea2023026.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/files/publications/selected-issues-papers/2023/english/sipea2023026.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/files/publications/selected-issues-papers/2023/english/sipea2023026.pdf.json)

---

### Introduction
- Kosovo’s tax revenue over 2021–22 has surpassed tax base growth and posted the largest increase among western Balkan countries.
- Kosovo’s tax system is based on consumption and income taxes, which together make up around 25 percent of GDP.
- Consumption taxes (VAT, excise, and customs) have historically been the major source of revenue; income taxes (CIT and PIT) have played a more limited role.
- Increasing formalization is a policy priority to expand fiscal space and level the playing field; tax administration actions include more frequent risk-based audits and inspections and budgetary incentives to formalize workers.

### Recent Developments in Tax Revenues
- Tax revenues overshot pre-pandemic levels already in 2021 driven by a strong rebound in diaspora inflows, mobility normalization, and supportive policies; consumption taxes in percent of 2021 GDP overshot pre-pandemic levels.
- Tax revenue growth continued in 2022 parallel to the surge in inflation. Economic activity slowed in 2022 due to the terms-of-trade shock on private demand and inflation, but VAT and income taxes kept rising as a share of GDP.
- Excises declined in 2022 as taxes per unit were largely unchanged; customs duties continued to decline with ongoing implementation of free trade agreements with the European Union and Türkiye.
- Female employment share in total employment rose from around 30 percent in 2012 to around 40 percent in 2022.

### Disentangling the Sources of Tax Revenue Increase: Accounting Framework and Key Quantitative Findings
- A simple accounting framework is applied to decompose tax revenue changes into components: inflation, change in real tax base (real demand), buoyancy (yield changes from GDP relative to potential and revenue elasticity), change in effective tax rate, and changes in the tax gap (collection improvements, including formalization).
- Assumed elasticities of tax revenues to the output gap: 0.85 for VAT, 0.5 for PIT, and 0.7 for CIT.
- Summary of principal quantified findings (2020–2022 and selected years):

  - Aggregate total tax revenues (CIT, PIT, and VAT)
    - Change in total tax revenues: 2019 = 63.5; 2020 = -86.7; 2021 = 321.7; 2022 = 262.1; Cumulative 2020-2022 = 497.1 (Millions of euro).
    - Contribution factors (Millions of euro, cumulative 2020-2022):
      - Inflation: 50.9 (2019), 20.0 (2020), 130.4 (2021), 171.4 (2022); cumulative 321.8.
      - Change in real demand: 3.1 (2019), -19.2 (2020), 22.0 (2021), 6.1 (2022); cumulative 8.9.
      - Buoyancy: 9.0 (2019), -62.9 (2020), 47.3 (2021), 0.0 (2022); cumulative -15.5.
      - Change in effective tax rate: 0.6 (2019), -9.2 (2020), 13.6 (2021), 6.3 (2022); cumulative 10.7.
      - Collection improvement, including formalization: 0.1 (2019), -15.4 (2020), 108.3 (2021), 78.3 (2022); cumulative 171.2.
    - Interpretation: Inflation contributed around 65 percent of the cumulative increase in revenues in 2020–22; collection improvements, including formalization, contributed around 35 percent of the cumulative change.

  - Value-Added Taxes (VAT)
    - Change in total VAT revenues (Millions of euro): 2019 = 46.6; 2020 = -75.6; 2021 = 268.2; 2022 = 190.1; Cumulative 2020-2022 = 382.7.
    - Contribution factors (Millions of euro, cumulative 2020-2022):
      - Inflation: 49.2 (2019), 10.5 (2020), 130.1 (2021), 146.4 (2022); cumulative 287.0.
      - Change in real demand: -8.3 (2019), -9.1 (2020), -7.5 (2021), -1.9 (2022); cumulative -18.5.
      - Buoyancy: 7.6 (2019), -52.8 (2020), 39.6 (2021), 0.0 (2022); cumulative -13.2.
      - Change in effective tax rate: 0.6 (2019), -8.2 (2020), 12.3 (2021), 4.5 (2022); cumulative 8.6.
      - Collection improvement, including formalization: -2.5 (2019), -16.1 (2020), 93.7 (2021), 41.1 (2022); cumulative 118.7.
    - Share of VAT revenue increases explained by tax administration improvements including formalization:
      - On a year-on-year basis, improvements in tax administration contributed about 35 percent of VAT revenue increases in 2021 and around 22 percent of VAT increases in 2022.
      - Overall, about a third of VAT revenue increases in 2020–22 could be explained by improvements in tax administration, including increased formalization.

  - Personal Income Taxes (PIT)
    - Change in total PIT revenues (Millions of euro): 2019 = 9.1; 2020 = -1.8; 2021 = 24.8; 2022 = 24.5; Cumulative 2020-2022 = 47.5.
    - Contribution factors (Millions of euro, cumulative 2020-2022):
      - Inflation: 1.6 (2019), 7.2 (2020), 3.2 (2021), 15.0 (2022); cumulative 25.4.
      - Change in real demand: 6.2 (2019), -7.5 (2020), 14.8 (2021), 4.4 (2022); cumulative 11.8.
      - Buoyancy: 0.7 (2019), -5.2 (2020), 4.1 (2021), 0.0 (2022); cumulative -1.1.
      - Change in effective tax rate: -0.1 (2019), -0.7 (2020), 0.9 (2021), 0.7 (2022); cumulative 0.9.
      - Collection improvement, including formalization: 0.7 (2019), 4.4 (2020), 1.8 (2021), 4.3 (2022); cumulative 10.5.
    - Role of formalization: Improvements in tax collection could explain about one fifth (22 percent in cumulative contributions shown) of PIT revenue increases over 2020–22. In 2021 increased numbers of employees (change in real demand) contributed around 60 percent of PIT revenue growth in 2021.

  - Corporate Income Taxes (CIT)
    - Change in total CIT revenues (Millions of euro): 2019 = 7.8; 2020 = -9.3; 2021 = 28.7; 2022 = 47.6; Cumulative 2020-2022 = 66.9.
    - Contribution factors (Millions of euro, cumulative 2020-2022):
      - Inflation: 0.1 (2019), 2.2 (2020), -2.8 (2021), 10.0 (2022); cumulative 9.4.
      - Change in real demand: 5.2 (2019), -2.6 (2020), 14.7 (2021), 3.5 (2022); cumulative 15.6.
      - Buoyancy: 0.7 (2019), -4.9 (2020), 3.6 (2021), 0.0 (2022); cumulative -1.3.
      - Change in effective tax rate: 0.1 (2019), -0.3 (2020), 0.5 (2021), 1.1 (2022); cumulative 1.2.
      - Collection improvement, including formalization: 1.8 (2019), -3.8 (2020), 12.8 (2021), 33.0 (2022); cumulative 42.0.
    - Role of formalization: Improved tax collection could explain about two thirds (63 percent in cumulative contributions shown) of CIT revenue increases over 2020–22. The number of CIT paying businesses increased strongly during the recovery; newly registered firms’ contribution to CIT revenues rose from around 4 percent of annual CIT in 2019 to 6 percent in 2021.

- Aggregate interpretation: Tax base changes (including both inflation and changes in the real tax base) explained about 60 percent of the increase in tax revenues; effective tax rates remained about constant; output gap at end-2022 is only slightly negative.

### Conclusions and Stylized Policy Implications
- Estimated contribution of formalization:
  - Formalization efforts by the government, Kosovo’s Agency of Statistics (KAS), and Customs contributed around 35 percent of the cumulative change in tax revenues in 2020–22.
  - Inflation contributed around 65 percent of the cumulative revenue increase in 2020–22.
- Policy implications to sustain and deepen formalization gains:
  - Continue and deepen tax administration efforts by TAK and Customs (audits, inspections, penalties, and other measures).
  - Address informality via a multi-pronged strategy that includes:
    - Simplifying tax procedures.
    - Enhancing public governance and transparency to raise awareness and trust in public institutions.
    - Strengthening the education system.
    - Improving financial inclusion.
    - Increasing electronic payments.
    - Improving the judicial system.

*Prepared by Amanda Edwards, Ezgi O. Ozturk, and Selim Thaci (IMF Selected Issues Paper SIP/2023/026).*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/selected-issues-papers/2023/english/sipea2023026.pdf_
