## Regional Disparities in Hungary: Drivers and Implications of the Digital and Green Transitions (Section 1 & Section 2)

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [Regional Disparities in Hungary: Drivers and Implications of the Digital and Green Transitions (Section 1 & Section 2)](https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/selected-issues-papers/2024/english/sipea2024037.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/files/publications/selected-issues-papers/2024/english/sipea2024037.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/files/publications/selected-issues-papers/2024/english/sipea2024037.pdf.json)

---

### Introduction: context and headline facts
- Hungary’s per capita income reached 76 percent of the EU average in 2022, up from 66 percent in 2010.
- Integration into global value chains—particularly Germany's automobile manufacturing sector—and increased foreign direct investment (FDI) inflows toward the electric vehicle (EVs) and battery production sector are key drivers of national income convergence.
- Despite national convergence, regional income disparities remain persistently high: Budapest outpaces the rest of the country while growth remains low and stagnant in the least developed southern and northern regions.
- Lagging regions underperform the national average on education, digitalization, infrastructure, and health outcomes (European Commission, 2023).
- EU cohesion funds inflows noted as up to 2 percent of GDP annually since joining the EU in 2014 (EU, 2024).

### Analytical approach and empirical scope
- Two main analytical goals:
  - Examine drivers of regional income disparities in Hungary using beta convergence and growth decomposition techniques.
  - Analyze regional disparities through the lens of the digital and green transitions and identify targeted policy interventions to prevent amplification of existing gaps.
- Empirical scope: conditional beta convergence among Hungary’s NUTS 3 regions during 2000–2019 (region and time fixed effects included).
- Growth decomposition framework follows Balakrishnan and others (2022); components include labor productivity (GDP per worker), employment-to-labor-force ratio (labor utilization), labor force participation rate, and working-age share.

### Key findings on drivers of regional disparities
- Beta convergence:
  - National-level evidence of beta convergence under different model specifications.
  - Heterogeneous dynamics at sub-national (NUTS 3) level—poorer regions often grow slower and fail to catch up.
- Dominant divergence drivers:
  - Divergence in labor productivity and labor force participation have been the key drivers of regional income disparities over the last two decades.
  - Convergence observed in working-age share and labor utilization; divergence is large and statistically significant for labor productivity and labor force participation.
- Regional heterogeneity and sectoral composition:
  - Some lagging NUTS 3 regions in the north (example given: HU331—Bács-Kiskun) are gradually catching up with higher-income regions (example given: HU120—Pest).
  - Lagging regions tend to have higher employment shares in industry (manufacturing subsector) and agriculture, but lower shares in high-productivity services (professional business services, real estate, finance & insurance, ICT).
  - The higher industrial employment shares in lagging regions point to low value-added regional industrial activity and an uncompetitive SME financing structure with strong dependence on public subsidies (European Commission, 2023).

### Role of institutions and reform levers
- Good governance (proxied by low corruption perception, quality institutions, impartial public service delivery) has a statistically significant effect in reducing disparities and promoting regional income convergence.
- Institutional reforms that can help speed up regional convergence include:
  - Increasing female labor force participation.
  - Incentivizing migration (increasing population density and spatial density via inter- and intra-regional labor mobility).
  - Increasing investment in R&D to promote regional dynamism amid structural transformations.
- Empirical links:
  - Increasing female labor force participation and population density are associated with promoting regional income convergence.
  - Closing governance gaps can incentivize private investment and economic diversification.

### Digital transition: exposure, preparedness, modeled impacts, and policy implications
- Exposure and preparedness:
  - Hungary is relatively less exposed (below regional AI exposure median) to AI-related labor market disruptions but is largely underprepared to integrate and harness AI technologies.
  - The IMF AI Preparedness Index (Cazzaniga and others, 2024) is referenced as the standard IMF indicator for AI preparedness.
- Model-based assessment:
  - A Cobb-Douglas aggregated task-based model (à la Acemoglu and Restrepo, 2022), calibrated to Hungary, links AI productivity effects to the share of digitally skilled labor force in each region.
  - Model results indicate thriving regions are likely to enjoy higher productivity gains from AI, potentially widening regional income disparities.
  - Increased investment in digital infrastructure (internet access and digitized public services) can help narrow income gaps and the urban-rural productivity gap.
- Policy implications for the digital transition:
  - Active labor market policies and flexibility, coupled with strong legal frameworks, are critical for facilitating AI-induced labor market transitions.
  - Enhancing digital infrastructure and literacy has a statistically significant effect in reducing the urban-rural productivity gap.

### Green transition: distributional risks, regional concentration, and policy levers
- Distributional risks and regional concentration:
  - The green transition may deepen disparities through regional differences in labor market outcomes, depending on carbon intensity of regional activity and employment structure.
  - The green share of total employment tends to be larger in higher-income regions.
  - Lagging regions are more carbon intensive (per unit of output) than higher-income counterparts, exposing them to structural challenges in transitioning to carbon neutrality.
- Labor market exposure and education:
  - Workers in poorer and carbon-intensive regions are often not highly skilled and thus more exposed to unfavorable labor market outcomes from the green transition.
  - Greenness of labor markets is positively correlated with educational attainment.
  - Evidence cited: green-intensive jobs provide wage premium (Bergant and others, 2022) largely owing to their higher skill requirement.
- Targeted spending and incentives:
  - Regression results show training, including reskilling, can reduce disparities in green employment.
  - Prioritizing and incentivizing private R&D investment can have a similar positive effect on green employment.
- Policy levers for an inclusive green transition:
  - Investment in reskilling workers and incentivizing green R&D can promote an inclusive transition from brown to green jobs in regional economies.
  - Policies should address sectoral composition (move toward high-productivity, low-carbon activities) and support diversification away from carbon-intensive, low-value-added activities.

### Synthesis of policy recommendations
- Strengthen governance and local institutional capacity to reduce regional disparities and attract private investment.
- Promote female labor force participation to narrow regional LFP differentials and speed convergence.
- Incentivize population density increases and labor mobility (inter- and intra-regional migration) to attract investment and improve efficiency.
- Invest in digital infrastructure and digital literacy to reduce the urban-rural productivity gap and enable regions to capture AI-related productivity gains.
- Implement active labor market policies, legal frameworks, and reskilling programs to manage AI-induced labor market transitions.
- Direct targeted investments toward R&D and green R&D to support structural diversification and enable an inclusive green transition away from carbon-intensive activities.
- Provide incentives for green private investments and targeted spending to facilitate transitions in lagging regions.

### Conclusions on convergence and regional disparities
- Current state: Hungary’s convergence to the average EU income level is underway, but at a slow and uneven pace amid persistently high regional disparities.
- Distributional pattern:
  - Budapest and its surrounding areas have surged ahead, benefiting from higher levels of investment, better infrastructure, and greater access to global markets.
  - Many rural and less developed regions have lagged, characterized by low productivity and higher unemployment rates.
- Risks from the twin transitions:
  - The ongoing twin digital and green transitions could worsen these disparities: thriving regions (e.g., Budapest) are better positioned to capitalize on emerging opportunities, while lagging regions risk falling further behind amid lower levels of digital readiness and concentration of employment in carbon-intensive, low-value added sectors.
- Mitigation levers: Investment toward reskilling workers and incentives for green R&D can play a vital role in closing the urban-rural income and green employment gaps.

*Source: sipea2024037 - Section 1 & Section 2*

### Section 1

### Regional Disparities in Hungary: Drivers and Implications of the Digital and Green Transitions (Section 1)

### Introduction: context and headline facts
- Hungary’s per capita income reached 76 percent of the EU average in 2022, up from 66 percent in 2010.
- Integration into global value chains—particularly Germany's automobile manufacturing sector—and increased foreign direct investment (FDI) inflows toward the electric vehicle (EVs) and battery production sector are key drivers of national income convergence.
- Despite national convergence, regional income disparities remain persistently high: Budapest outpaces the rest of the country while growth remains low and stagnant in the least developed southern and northern regions.
- Lagging regions underperform the national average on education, digitalization, infrastructure, and health outcomes (European Commission, 2023).
- EU cohesion funds inflows noted as up to 2 percent of GDP annually since joining the EU in 2014 (EU, 2024).

### Analytical approach and objectives
- Two main analytical goals:
  - Examine drivers of regional income disparities in Hungary using beta convergence and growth decomposition techniques.
  - Analyze regional disparities through the lens of the digital and green transitions and identify targeted policy interventions to prevent amplification of existing gaps.
- Empirical scope: conditional beta convergence among Hungary’s NUTS 3 regions during 2000–2019 (region and time fixed effects included).
- Growth decomposition framework follows Balakrishnan and others (2022); components include labor productivity (GDP per worker), employment-to-labor-force ratio (labor utilization), labor force participation rate, and working-age share.

### Key findings on drivers of regional disparities
- Beta convergence: national-level evidence of beta convergence under different model specifications, but heterogeneous dynamics at sub-national (NUTS 3) level—poorer regions often grow slower and fail to catch up.
- Divergence drivers:
  - Divergence in labor productivity and labor force participation have been the key drivers of regional income disparities over the last two decades.
  - Convergence observed in working-age share and labor utilization; divergence is large and statistically significant for labor productivity and labor force participation.
- Regional heterogeneity:
  - Some lagging NUTS 3 regions in the north (example given: HU331—Bács-Kiskun) are gradually catching up with higher-income regions (example given: HU120—Pest).
  - Lagging regions tend to have higher employment shares in industry (manufacturing subsector) and agriculture, but lower shares in high-productivity services (professional business services, real estate, finance & insurance, ICT).
  - The higher industrial employment shares in lagging regions point to low value-added regional industrial activity and an uncompetitive SME financing structure with strong dependence on public subsidies (European Commission, 2023).

### Role of institutions and other reforms
- Good governance (proxied by low corruption perception, quality institutions, impartial public service delivery) has a statistically significant effect in reducing disparities and promoting regional income convergence.
- Institutional reforms that can help speed up regional convergence include:
  - Increasing female labor force participation.
  - Incentivizing migration (increasing population density and spatial density via inter- and intra-regional labor mobility).
  - Increasing investment in R&D to promote regional dynamism amid structural transformations.
- Empirical links:
  - Increasing female labor force participation and population density are associated with promoting regional income convergence.
  - Closing governance gaps can incentivize private investment and economic diversification.

### Digital transition: exposure, preparedness, and impacts
- Hungary’s AI exposure and preparedness context:
  - Hungary is relatively less exposed (below regional AI exposure median) to AI-related labor market disruptions but is largely underprepared to integrate and harness AI technologies.
  - The IMF AI Preparedness Index (Cazzaniga and others, 2024) is referenced as the standard IMF indicator for AI preparedness.
- Model-based assessment:
  - A Cobb-Douglas aggregated task-based model (à la Acemoglu and Restrepo, 2022), calibrated to Hungary, links AI productivity effects to the share of digitally skilled labor force in each region.
  - Model results indicate thriving regions are likely to enjoy higher productivity gains from AI, potentially widening regional income disparities.
  - Increased investment in digital infrastructure (internet access and digitized public services) can help narrow income gaps and the urban-rural productivity gap.
- Policy implications for the digital transition:
  - Active labor market policies and flexibility, coupled with strong legal frameworks, are critical for facilitating AI-induced labor market transitions.
  - Enhancing digital infrastructure and literacy has a statistically significant effect in reducing the urban-rural productivity gap.

### Green transition: distributional risks and regional concentration
- The green transition may deepen disparities through regional differences in labor market outcomes, depending on carbon intensity of regional activity and employment structure.
- Empirical pattern:
  - The green share of total employment tends to be larger in higher-income regions.
  - Lagging regions are more carbon intensive (per unit of output) than higher-income counterparts, exposing them to structural challenges in transitioning to carbon neutrality.
- Labor market exposure:
  - Workers in poorer and carbon-intensive regions are often not highly skilled and thus more exposed to unfavorable labor market outcomes from the green transition.
- Policy levers for an inclusive green transition:
  - Investment in reskilling workers and incentivizing green R&D can promote an inclusive transition from brown to green jobs in regional economies.
  - Policies should address sectoral composition (move toward high-productivity, low-carbon activities) and support diversification away from carbon-intensive, low-value-added activities.

### Policy recommendations (synthesized)
- Strengthen governance and local institutional capacity to reduce regional disparities and attract private investment.
- Promote female labor force participation to narrow regional LFP differentials and speed convergence.
- Incentivize population density increases and labor mobility (inter- and intra-regional migration) to attract investment and improve efficiency.
- Invest in digital infrastructure and digital literacy to reduce the urban-rural productivity gap and enable regions to capture AI-related productivity gains.
- Implement active labor market policies, legal frameworks, and reskilling programs to manage AI-induced labor market transitions.
- Direct targeted investments toward R&D and green R&D to support structural diversification and enable an inclusive green transition away from carbon-intensive activities.

*Source: IMF Selected Issues Paper (SIP/2024/037), completed July 18, 2024.*

### Section 2

### Section 2: Regional implications of the digital and green transitions

### Greenness of labor markets and education
- The greenness of labor markets is positively correlated with educational attainment (Figure 6, right panel).
- Evidence cited: green-intensive jobs provide wage premium (Bergant and others, 2022) largely owing to their higher skill requirement.
- Implication: Higher-income regions are positioned to thrive in the transition to carbon neutrality, potentially widening regional income disparities (Maucorps and others, 2023).

### Role of targeted spending and incentives for green investments
- Analytical approach: The green job share of total employment in each Hungarian region is regressed on a range of controls, including the share of workers benefiting from training and R&D spending as separate independent variables.
- Key findings:
  - Training, including in the form of reskilling, can reduce disparities in green employment (results summarized in Figure 7).
  - Prioritizing and incentivizing private R&D investment can have a similar positive effect on green employment.
- Policy focus: Targeted spending and incentives for green investments can help green regional labor markets by enabling workers to transition to greener opportunities and incentivizing green R&D investments.

### Conclusions on convergence and regional disparities
- Current state: Hungary’s convergence to the average EU income level is underway, but at a slow and uneven pace amid persistently high regional disparities.
- Distributional pattern:
  - Budapest and its surrounding areas have surged ahead, benefiting from higher levels of investment, better infrastructure, and greater access to global markets.
  - Many rural and less developed regions have lagged, characterized by low productivity and higher unemployment rates.
- Risks from transitions:
  - The ongoing twin digital and green transitions could worsen these disparities.
  - Thriving regions (e.g., Budapest) are better positioned to capitalize on emerging opportunities.
  - Lagging regions risk falling further behind amid lower levels of digital readiness and concentration of employment in carbon-intensive, low-value added sectors.
- Mitigation levers: Investment toward reskilling workers and incentives for green R&D can play a vital role in closing the urban-rural income and green employment gaps.

### Policy recommendations and required reforms
- Deeper, targeted reforms are needed to facilitate a balanced and sustainable income convergence path.
- Recommended interventions:
  - Invest in digital infrastructure and education in lagging regions.
  - Provide incentives for green private investments.
  - Strengthen good governance at the regional level, including anti-corruption measures and improvements in the regulatory quality of public institutions, to promote dynamism and growth in regional economies.

*Source: sipea2024037 - Section 2*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/selected-issues-papers/2024/english/sipea2024037.pdf_
