## sipea2025066

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [sipea2025066](https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/selected-issues-papers/2025/english/sipea2025066.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/files/publications/selected-issues-papers/2025/english/sipea2025066.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/files/publications/selected-issues-papers/2025/english/sipea2025066.pdf.json)

---

### A. Introduction — key findings
- Reducing energy dependence in the ECCU entails improving energy efficiency and shifting from fossil fuels to renewable energy (RE).
- The energy transition (ET) will affect the transmission of and vulnerability to shocks (e.g., from natural disasters or commodity markets) while helping to reduce economic imbalances and enhance growth potential.
- Oil price shocks have large macroeconomic effects: the 2022 oil price spike led to oil imports rising by nearly 3 percentage points of GDP.
- Major challenges to the ET include high up-front costs of RE technology, small electricity market size limiting economies of scale, limited land availability, grid integration challenges for variable RE, extreme weather threats to RE infrastructure, high costs of capital, limited fiscal space, and inadequate and varying regulatory frameworks.

### B. The Energy Landscape — supply, generation, consumption, and costs
- Primary energy supply (2021):
  - Imported oil products met 96 percent of the ECCU’s primary energy needs in 2021.
  - RE accounted for just 1 percent of the energy supply in 2021 (higher in Dominica and St. Vincent and the Grenadines due to hydroelectric plants).
  - Traditional biofuels account for 7 percent of energy in Grenada and St. Lucia, and 3 percent across the ECCU on average.
- Roles of imported oil in the energy matrix:
  - About two-fifths are used for electricity generation (diesel).
  - Two-fifths are used in final consumption (e.g., domestic transport and cooking as LPG).
  - The remaining one-fifth is used to refuel international ships and aircraft.
- Electricity generation and distribution:
  - Most ECCU countries use aging diesel generators that are less efficient than newer models or natural gas plants.
  - If ECCU efficiency had kept pace with advanced economies (AEs), oil use in electricity generation would have been 10 percent lower in 2021.
  - Transmission and distribution losses are 15-20 percent in the ECCU, versus a 6 percent average in AEs.
  - Electricity prices in the ECCU in 2021 ranged from US$0.26/kWh to US$0.37/kWh.
  - Comparative prices: median price of $0.10/kWh in emerging market economies (EMEs) and US$0.19/kWh in advanced economies (AEs).
  - Electricity utilities are typically vertically integrated monopolies (state owned and privately owned), often prioritizing reliability over RE goals; the lack of independent regulators impedes new market entrants.
- Energy consumption by sector (2021):
  - Transport accounts for over half of final energy consumption.
  - Households consumed 24 percent.
  - Commercial sector (mainly hotels) about 13 percent.
  - Industry 7 percent.
  - Transport relies entirely on oil (mainly gasoline); commercial sector uses electricity for over 90 percent of its total energy needs; air conditioning accounts for more than half of electricity consumption by hotels.

### C. Strategies for a Successful Energy Transition — components and trade-offs
- Two key components of the ET:
  - Replacing oil with RE in electricity (about 40 percent of oil use).
  - Replacing oil in end-uses through electrification (e.g., EVs, electric cookers); some uses may need alternative fuels like green hydrogen or methanol (particularly for international transport).
- Recommended strategic approach:
  - Combine energy efficiency and RE generation, with a more gradual electrification of other sectors.
- Energy efficiency:
  - Can be among the most cost-effective approaches and should be prioritized.
  - Example: a US$0.9 billion investment in energy efficiency from 2020-2040 could lower CARICOM’s energy consumption by 18 percent, resulting in a net reduction in energy expenditure of US$6.1 billion—5.2 percent of 2023 GDP (Masson and Erhardt 2020).
- RE expansion:
  - Rapid expansion can reduce oil dependency and potentially lower costs but requires investment in energy storage and grid upgrades to manage intermittency.
- Electrification of transport and other sectors:
  - Should be gradual given high investment needs and limited RE generation.
  - EV adoption may not reduce oil imports in the near term if electricity is still generated from oil-fired plants; effectiveness depends on the RE share in the electricity mix.
- Energy security and resilience:
  - Incorporate a mix of RE sources, invest in energy storage and backup generation (including conventional energy), implement smart grid solutions (including demand flexibility), and introduce insurance mechanisms.
  - Countries developing geothermal energy (Dominica, Grenada, St. Kitts and Nevis, St. Vincent and the Grenadines) must ensure infrastructure resilience to natural disasters.

### D. The Energy Transition as an Opportunity to Strengthen the ECCU — macroeconomic and structural impacts
- Short- and medium-term macroeconomic effects depend on how ET affects energy costs and how upfront investments are financed.
- Upfront capital needs vs operating costs:
  - RE entails large upfront capital investment and lower operating costs; fossil fuels have lower initial investment needs but higher ongoing costs.
  - Example: reducing energy costs in Antigua and Barbuda by about 40 percent could require up-front capital equivalent to 25 percent of GDP (IRENA, 2021).
- Near-term effects:
  - RE projects may boost growth via increased public and private investment.
  - Targeted measures may be needed to protect vulnerable households from potential cost increases.
  - Fiscal implications include government investments, taxes, and subsidies to incentivize RE adoption; phasing out fossil fuel subsidies and potential green tax revenues could offset initial pressures, but carbon pricing faces political challenges.
  - Current account deficits may temporarily widen due to RE technology imports, while foreign direct investment in RE could partly compensate with timing lags.
  - Investments in RE could create new jobs (e.g., solar installation), partly compensating for losses in fossil-fuel related sectors (e.g., ICE mechanics).
- Medium-term effects:
  - ET could boost growth and competitiveness, build resilience to oil price shocks, and enhance macrofinancial stability.
  - Example: a two-thirds reduction in electricity costs in St. Kitts and Nevis could increase GDP by 1.1 percent (IMF 2024).
  - ET improves external balances by permanently reducing oil imports, though foreign financing requires future repayments.
  - Reduced vulnerability to oil price shocks would lower inflation variability and strengthen monetary policy transmission.
  - Higher growth could boost tax revenues and improve long-term debt dynamics; net outcomes depend on policy mixes and financing approaches.

### E. Policy Options — design principles and specific measures
- Overarching principles:
  - Balance maximizing ET opportunities with minimizing adverse effects.
  - Crowding in private investment is critical given high government debt and limited fiscal space.
  - Sound fiscal frameworks, sustainable incentives, clear regulatory policies, and protection for vulnerable households and workers are required.
- Macroeconomic and fiscal policy:
  - Maintain sound, stable, and credible macroeconomic frameworks; the currency union provides an anchor, but high debt levels demand prudent fiscal management to create fiscal space for the ET.
  - Mobilize revenue and rationalize spending (e.g., better targeting of transfers and subsidies, including on fossil fuels).
  - Adopt rules-based fiscal frameworks.
- Incentive design and equity:
  - Well-designed fiscal incentives can accelerate the ET and attract private investment, but must be tailored to the ECCU context.
  - Carbon pricing requires caution given high energy costs; assess financial soundness of public utilities and provide targeted household support.
  - Alternative measures: feebates, tax credits, import tariff exemptions for energy-efficient appliances, and phasing out explicit fossil fuel subsidies.
  - Complementary measures: energy efficiency standards in building codes and fuel efficiency regulations.
  - Address equity issues via progressive pricing, targeted support for affordability, and workforce transition programs (retraining).
- Regulatory and institutional reforms:
  - Strengthen energy regulatory frameworks with independent energy regulators to catalyze private sector investment.
  - Improve permitting processes and the business environment to reduce investor risk.

### Investment incentives and regulatory frameworks
- Regulations should incentivize investment from both large-scale RE producers (e.g., through robust power purchase agreements) and smaller producers, such as households (e.g., net metering for rooftop solar), while avoiding grid cannibalization.
- Transparent public-private partnership frameworks with strong governance can protect government interests while attracting private investment (Queyranne et al., 2019).

### Regional cooperation and coordination
- Regional cooperation can play a key role in facilitating a successful ET.
- Coordination across ECCU members can unlock economies of scale through harmonized policies and energy regulations, standardized processes, and consistent incentive structures.

### Innovative finance and risk mitigation
- Innovative financial instruments (e.g., guarantees and blended finance), supported by Multilateral Development Banks, can derisk energy investments and unlock private finance.
- Initiatives can help overcome policy, institutional, and technical barriers to improve access to finance to accelerate RE investments.

### Examples of initiatives and scope
- Caribbean Resilient Renewable Energy Infrastructure Investment Facility: can help overcome policy, institutional, and technical barriers to improve access to finance to accelerate RE investments, with first projects taking place in Grenada and St. Lucia (Mukhi, 2022; Antoine, 2022).
- The Sustainable Energy Facility (SEF) for Eastern Caribbean Countries: can help reduce financial, technical and institutional barriers to geothermal energy development in five Eastern Caribbean countries, while providing institutional strengthening and capacity building to their governments and partners.

*Source: IMF Selected Issues Paper SIP/2025/066, "Powering the Future: Energy Transition Strategies for the ECCU," completed April 9, 2025.*

### Section 1

### sipea2025066 - Section 1

### A. Introduction — key findings
- Reducing energy dependence in the ECCU entails improving energy efficiency and shifting from fossil fuels to renewable energy (RE).
- The energy transition (ET) will affect the transmission of and vulnerability to shocks (e.g., from natural disasters or commodity markets) while helping to reduce economic imbalances and enhance growth potential.
- Oil price shocks have large macroeconomic effects: the 2022 oil price spike led to oil imports rising by nearly 3 percentage points of GDP.
- Major challenges to the ET include high up-front costs of RE technology, small electricity market size limiting economies of scale, limited land availability, grid integration challenges for variable RE, extreme weather threats to RE infrastructure, high costs of capital, limited fiscal space, and inadequate and varying regulatory frameworks.

### B. The Energy Landscape — supply, generation, consumption, and costs
- Primary energy supply (2021):
  - Imported oil products met 96 percent of the ECCU’s primary energy needs in 2021.
  - RE accounted for just 1 percent of the energy supply in 2021 (higher in Dominica and St. Vincent and the Grenadines due to hydroelectric plants).
  - Traditional biofuels account for 7 percent of energy in Grenada and St. Lucia, and 3 percent across the ECCU on average.
- Roles of imported oil in the energy matrix:
  - About two-fifths are used for electricity generation (diesel).
  - Two-fifths are used in final consumption (e.g., domestic transport and cooking as LPG).
  - The remaining one-fifth is used to refuel international ships and aircraft.
- Electricity generation and distribution:
  - Most ECCU countries use aging diesel generators that are less efficient than newer models or natural gas plants.
  - If ECCU efficiency had kept pace with advanced economies (AEs), oil use in electricity generation would have been 10 percent lower in 2021.
  - Transmission and distribution losses are 15-20 percent in the ECCU, versus a 6 percent average in AEs.
  - Electricity prices in the ECCU in 2021 ranged from US$0.26/kWh to US$0.37/kWh.
  - Comparative prices: median price of $0.10/kWh in emerging market economies (EMEs) and US$0.19/kWh in advanced economies (AEs).
  - Electricity utilities are typically vertically integrated monopolies (state owned and privately owned), often prioritizing reliability over RE goals; the lack of independent regulators impedes new market entrants.
- Energy consumption by sector (2021):
  - Transport accounts for over half of final energy consumption.
  - Households consumed 24 percent.
  - Commercial sector (mainly hotels) about 13 percent.
  - Industry 7 percent.
  - Transport relies entirely on oil (mainly gasoline); commercial sector uses electricity for over 90 percent of its total energy needs; air conditioning accounts for more than half of electricity consumption by hotels.

### C. Strategies for a Successful Energy Transition — components and trade-offs
- Two key components of the ET:
  - Replacing oil with RE in electricity (about 40 percent of oil use).
  - Replacing oil in end-uses through electrification (e.g., EVs, electric cookers); some uses may need alternative fuels like green hydrogen or methanol (particularly for international transport).
- Recommended strategic approach:
  - Combine energy efficiency and RE generation, with a more gradual electrification of other sectors.
- Energy efficiency:
  - Can be among the most cost-effective approaches and should be prioritized.
  - Example: a US$0.9 billion investment in energy efficiency from 2020-2040 could lower CARICOM’s energy consumption by 18 percent, resulting in a net reduction in energy expenditure of US$6.1 billion—5.2 percent of 2023 GDP (Masson and Erhardt 2020).
- RE expansion:
  - Rapid expansion can reduce oil dependency and potentially lower costs but requires investment in energy storage and grid upgrades to manage intermittency.
- Electrification of transport and other sectors:
  - Should be gradual given high investment needs and limited RE generation.
  - EV adoption may not reduce oil imports in the near term if electricity is still generated from oil-fired plants; effectiveness depends on the RE share in the electricity mix.
- Energy security and resilience:
  - Incorporate a mix of RE sources, invest in energy storage and backup generation (including conventional energy), implement smart grid solutions (including demand flexibility), and introduce insurance mechanisms.
  - Countries developing geothermal energy (Dominica, Grenada, St. Kitts and Nevis, St. Vincent and the Grenadines) must ensure infrastructure resilience to natural disasters.

### D. The Energy Transition as an Opportunity to Strengthen the ECCU — macroeconomic and structural impacts
- Short- and medium-term macroeconomic effects depend on how ET affects energy costs and how upfront investments are financed.
- Upfront capital needs vs operating costs:
  - RE entails large upfront capital investment and lower operating costs; fossil fuels have lower initial investment needs but higher ongoing costs.
  - Example: reducing energy costs in Antigua and Barbuda by about 40 percent could require up-front capital equivalent to 25 percent of GDP (IRENA, 2021).
- Near-term effects:
  - RE projects may boost growth via increased public and private investment.
  - Targeted measures may be needed to protect vulnerable households from potential cost increases.
  - Fiscal implications include government investments, taxes, and subsidies to incentivize RE adoption; phasing out fossil fuel subsidies and potential green tax revenues could offset initial pressures, but carbon pricing faces political challenges.
  - Current account deficits may temporarily widen due to RE technology imports, while foreign direct investment in RE could partly compensate with timing lags.
  - Investments in RE could create new jobs (e.g., solar installation), partly compensating for losses in fossil-fuel related sectors (e.g., ICE mechanics).
- Medium-term effects:
  - ET could boost growth and competitiveness, build resilience to oil price shocks, and enhance macrofinancial stability.
  - Example: a two-thirds reduction in electricity costs in St. Kitts and Nevis could increase GDP by 1.1 percent (IMF 2024).
  - ET improves external balances by permanently reducing oil imports, though foreign financing requires future repayments.
  - Reduced vulnerability to oil price shocks would lower inflation variability and strengthen monetary policy transmission.
  - Higher growth could boost tax revenues and improve long-term debt dynamics; net outcomes depend on policy mixes and financing approaches.

### E. Policy Options — design principles and specific measures
- Overarching principles:
  - Balance maximizing ET opportunities with minimizing adverse effects.
  - Crowding in private investment is critical given high government debt and limited fiscal space.
  - Sound fiscal frameworks, sustainable incentives, clear regulatory policies, and protection for vulnerable households and workers are required.
- Macroeconomic and fiscal policy:
  - Maintain sound, stable, and credible macroeconomic frameworks; the currency union provides an anchor, but high debt levels demand prudent fiscal management to create fiscal space for the ET.
  - Mobilize revenue and rationalize spending (e.g., better targeting of transfers and subsidies, including on fossil fuels).
  - Adopt rules-based fiscal frameworks.
- Incentive design and equity:
  - Well-designed fiscal incentives can accelerate the ET and attract private investment, but must be tailored to the ECCU context.
  - Carbon pricing requires caution given high energy costs; assess financial soundness of public utilities and provide targeted household support.
  - Alternative measures: feebates, tax credits, import tariff exemptions for energy-efficient appliances, and phasing out explicit fossil fuel subsidies.
  - Complementary measures: energy efficiency standards in building codes and fuel efficiency regulations.
  - Address equity issues via progressive pricing, targeted support for affordability, and workforce transition programs (retraining).
- Regulatory and institutional reforms:
  - Strengthen energy regulatory frameworks with independent energy regulators to catalyze private sector investment.
  - Improve permitting processes and the business environment to reduce investor risk.

*Source: IMF Selected Issues Paper SIP/2025/066, "Powering the Future: Energy Transition Strategies for the ECCU," completed April 9, 2025.*

### Section 2

### sipea2025066 - Section 2

### Investment incentives and regulatory frameworks
- Regulations should incentivize investment from both large-scale RE producers (e.g., through robust power purchase agreements) and smaller producers, such as households (e.g., net metering for rooftop solar), while avoiding grid cannibalization.
- Transparent public-private partnership frameworks with strong governance can protect government interests while attracting private investment (Queyranne et al., 2019).

### Regional cooperation and coordination
- Regional cooperation can play a key role in facilitating a successful ET.
- Coordination across ECCU members can unlock economies of scale through harmonized policies and energy regulations, standardized processes, and consistent incentive structures.

### Innovative finance and risk mitigation
- Innovative financial instruments (e.g., guarantees and blended finance), supported by Multilateral Development Banks, can derisk energy investments and unlock private finance.
- Initiatives can help overcome policy, institutional, and technical barriers to improve access to finance to accelerate RE investments.

### Examples of initiatives and scope
- Caribbean Resilient Renewable Energy Infrastructure Investment Facility: can help overcome policy, institutional, and technical barriers to improve access to finance to accelerate RE investments, with first projects taking place in Grenada and St. Lucia (Mukhi, 2022; Antoine, 2022).
- The Sustainable Energy Facility (SEF) for Eastern Caribbean Countries: can help reduce financial, technical and institutional barriers to geothermal energy development in five Eastern Caribbean countries, while providing institutional strengthening and capacity building to their governments and partners.

*Source: sipea2025066 - Section 2*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/selected-issues-papers/2025/english/sipea2025066.pdf_