## sipea2025082

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [sipea2025082](https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/selected-issues-papers/2025/english/sipea2025082.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/files/publications/selected-issues-papers/2025/english/sipea2025082.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/files/publications/selected-issues-papers/2025/english/sipea2025082.pdf.json)

---

### Importance of Labor Market Analysis
- Well-functioning labor markets promote inclusive economic growth (IMF, 2017).
- Main goals of labor market policies: ensure high and stable employment and productivity while providing adequate worker protection (IMF, 2019).
- Flexible labor legislation and Active Labor Market Policies (ALMPs) are needed to balance efficiency and equity.
- Regional comparison:
  - CCA: less advanced labor market policies, limited unemployment benefits, underdeveloped ALMPs, and rigid labor codes contributing to high informality.
  - EMEU: more comprehensive social safety nets, more prevalent ALMPs, and greater labor market effectiveness.

### Demographics and Labor Supply — Key Findings
- Population structure and trends:
  - About 32 percent of the population is under 15 years.
  - 5.7 percent of the population is over 65 years.
  - Population growth: almost 2 percent per year since 2000.
  - Medium-term population growth estimated at 1.4 percent per year.
  - World Bank projection: labor force projected to grow by about 50,000 every year.
- Labor absorption needs:
  - Staff estimate: economy needs to grow by over 6.5 percent a year over the medium to long term to generate sufficient jobs and contain unemployment.
- Labor force and employment structure:
  - Total employed: approximately 2.33 million persons.
  - Formally employed: 0.58 million persons.
    - Public sector: 0.34 million.
    - SOE: 0.04 million.
    - Agriculture and Industry (formal): 0.09 million.
    - Services (formal): 0.11 million.
  - Informally employed: 1.75 million persons.
    - Agriculture (informal): 0.34 million.
    - Industry (informal): 0.55 million.
    - Services (informal): 0.86 million.
  - Labor force participation (LFP) rate: 65.6 percent.
  - Formal sector employs only about 600,000 people.
  - Public sector accounts for around 60 percent of employment in the formal economy.

### Informality and Macro Implications
- Informal economy employs 1.75 million people.
- Informal sector estimated to account for 19 percent of GDP in 2023.
- Informal employment characterized by absence of social protection, low wages, and minimal job security.

### Recent Macro and Productivity Trends
- Average economic growth over last 18 years: 4.9 percent.
- Unemployment declined from about 8 percent to 4 percent over the same period.
- Productivity remains low; output per worker is the lowest in the CCA region.
- Sectoral specifics:
  - Gold mining: accounts for 6.5 percent of GDP but employs only 0.2 percent of the workforce.
  - Agriculture employs 24 percent of the workforce and contributes under 9 percent of GDP.
- Unit labor costs indicate lower productivity in agriculture, non-gold industry, and transport and communication sectors.

### Labor Market Competitiveness and Costs
- Unit labor costs:
  - The Kyrgyz Republic’s unit labor costs are higher than elsewhere in the CCA region.
  - Since 2018: 5 percent average annual increase in real wages in the Kyrgyz Republic (outpaced only by Kazakhstan and Uzbekistan).
  - Wage gains have outpaced productivity gains, reducing competitiveness relative to regional peers.

### Gender and Inclusion
- Participation and employment gaps:
  - Approximately 70 percent of working-age men are employed compared to only 45 percent of women.
  - Gender gap in labor force participation is sizable and the fastest-growing in the region.
  - Employment in agriculture declined from 727,000 in 2014 to 460,000 in 2022, disproportionately affecting women.
  - In the formal sector the gender gap is relatively small; in the informal sector the gender gap is significant.
- Gender pay gap:
  - On average, women in the Kyrgyz Republic earn 25 percent less than men.
  - Women concentrated in lower-paying sectors (agriculture and trade); higher-paying sectors (industry, transport, communication) are male-dominated.
- Barriers for women:
  - Parenthood and caregiving responsibilities reduce female labor force participation.
  - Limited availability of affordable childcare restricts women’s employment opportunities.
  - Remote work remains underdeveloped; recent Labor Code revisions envisage remote and hybrid work by agreement.

### Labor Market Institutions, Safety Nets, and Education
- Labor market regulation and competitiveness:
  - Labor market regulations in the Kyrgyz Republic are more restrictive compared to CCA average (Global Competitiveness Index components).
  - Specific rigidities: quota system and burdensome procedures for foreign work permits, cumbersome hiring and firing procedures, strict documentation requirements.
  - New Labor Code revisions envisage simplified mechanisms for concluding employment contracts and allow remote/hybrid work by agreement.
- Unemployment benefits and ALMPs:
  - Unemployed benefit coverage in the Kyrgyz Republic: 0.3 percent of unemployed receiving unemployment benefits.
  - Comparator averages: CCA average 5.4 percent; Emerging Europe average 20.0 percent.
  - Challenges: significant informal employment complicates eligibility verification; limited technical and administrative capacity to provide job search assistance and training.
- Education and human capital:
  - Government spending on public education covers 11 years of schooling and exceeds 7 percent of GDP.
  - Learning-adjusted years of schooling: 8.4 years.
  - 64 percent of primary school graduates are not proficient in reading and comprehension.
  - Primary school completion rate: 93 percent.
  - Preschool coverage: 28.3 percent of kids (compared with 92.5 percent in Kazakhstan and 74 percent in Uzbekistan).
  - Expected years of schooling for men and women are similar but below international comparators.

### Education Quality and Labor-Market Skill Gaps
- Adult skills:
  - Sixty percent of adults in the Kyrgyz Republic have less than a basic understanding of literacy and numeracy in a problem-solving context, including computer literacy.
  - Comparative benchmarks:
    - 22 percent for literacy in Europe and Central Asia countries.
    - 25 percent for numeracy in Europe and Central Asia countries.
- Business environment:
  - The 2023 World Bank Enterprise Survey identifies the lack of skilled and adequately educated workers as one of the main obstacles for businesses.
  - The Kyrgyz Republic falls below the averages for the CCA and EMEU on the Human Development Index.

### Growth and Job-Creation Needs (Reiterated)
- Staff analysis suggests the Kyrgyz economy needs to grow by over 6.5 percent per year in the medium to long term to create sufficient jobs for about 50,000 new entrants in the labor market each year.
- Without higher growth and more flexible labor market regulations the country will face challenges in containing unemployment, poverty, social inequality, and outmigration of talents.

### Labor Market Policy Design — Findings and Recommendations
- Findings:
  - Current labor market design contributes to inequality, low productivity, and high informality.
  - Protecting jobs rather than protecting workers limits labor market flexibility.
- Recommendations:
  - Adopt more flexible hiring and retention rules that prioritize protecting workers rather than protecting jobs, following approaches used in more advanced economies.
  - Simplify procedures for hiring foreign professionals to facilitate knowledge transfer and enhance private sector efficiency.
  - Implement structural reforms to improve the business climate, including measures that strengthen governance, transparency, and competition, and support private sector development to raise potential output and generate more jobs and income.

### Social Safety Net and Active Labor Market Policies (ALMPs) — Recommendations
- Strengthen the social safety net and develop active labor market policies.
- Establish an unemployment insurance system that scales up during economic downturns and scales back when the economy stabilizes.
- Expand vocational training programs and job search assistance to better align training with labor market demands.
- Provide job placement services, career counseling, and upskilling opportunities to support job seekers.

### Education System Reform — Problems and Policy Priorities
- Problems and consequences:
  - Inadequate education leads to skills and gender gaps, low wages, higher unemployment and informality, and constrains the economy’s capacity to diversify and transition into higher-value industries.
- Policy priorities:
  - Deliver more years of quality learning and skill development aligned with labor market demands.
  - Improve tertiary education and expand access to vocational training programs.
  - Enhancing education would also help mitigate emigration.
- Note: The Government of the Kyrgyz Republic has adopted Education Development Strategy 2040 aiming to improve the quality of education.

### Gender Equality and Labor Force Participation — Policy Measures
- Recommendations to increase female labor force participation and growth contribution:
  - End gender restrictions on access to certain positions.
  - Expand affordable childcare services.
  - Promote flexible work arrangements.
  - Develop skills training programs tailored to women to empower their workforce participation.

*Source: IMF Selected Issues Paper chapter "LABOR MARKET CHALLENGES AND POLICY REFORMS IN THE KYRGYZ REPUBLIC" (May 7, 2025).*

### 1. Population Tree of the Kyrgyz Republic in 2023 ______________________________________ 4

### 1. Population Tree of the Kyrgyz Republic in 2023

### A. Importance of Labor Market Analysis
- Well-functioning labor markets promote inclusive economic growth (IMF, 2017).
- Main goals of labor market policies: ensure high and stable employment and productivity while providing adequate worker protection (IMF, 2019).
- Flexible labor legislation and Active Labor Market Policies (ALMPs) are needed to balance efficiency and equity.
- CCA region vs EMEU:
  - CCA: less advanced labor market policies, limited unemployment benefits, underdeveloped ALMPs, and rigid labor codes contributing to high informality.
  - EMEU: more comprehensive social safety nets, more prevalent ALMPs, and greater labor market effectiveness.

### B. Key findings on demographics and labor supply
- Demographic structure and trends:
  - About 32 percent of the population is under 15 years.
  - 5.7 percent of the population is over 65 years.
  - Population growth: almost 2 percent per year since 2000.
  - Medium-term population growth estimated at 1.4 percent per year.
  - World Bank projection: labor force projected to grow by about 50,000 every year.
- Labor absorption needs:
  - Staff estimate: economy needs to grow by over 6.5 percent a year over the medium to long term to generate sufficient jobs and contain unemployment.
- Labor force and employment structure:
  - Total employed: approximately 2.33 million persons.
  - Formally employed: 0.58 million persons.
    - Public sector: 0.34 million.
    - SOE: 0.04 million.
    - Agriculture and Industry (formal): 0.09 million.
    - Services (formal): 0.11 million.
  - Informally employed: 1.75 million persons.
    - Agriculture (informal): 0.34 million.
    - Industry (informal): 0.55 million.
    - Services (informal): 0.86 million.
  - Labor force participation (LFP) rate: 65.6 percent.
  - Formal sector employs only about 600,000 people (Table 1).
  - Public sector accounts for around 60 percent of employment in the formal economy.
- Informality and its macro implications:
  - Informal economy employs 1.75 million people.
  - Informal sector estimated to account for 19 percent of GDP in 2023.
  - Informal employment characterized by absence of social protection, low wages, and minimal job security.
- Recent macro and productivity trends:
  - Average economic growth over last 18 years: 4.9 percent.
  - Unemployment declined from about 8 percent to 4 percent over the same period.
  - Productivity remains low; output per worker is the lowest in the CCA region.
  - Gold mining: accounts for 6.5 percent of GDP but employs only 0.2 percent of the workforce.
  - Agriculture employs 24 percent of the workforce and contributes under 9 percent of GDP.
  - Unit labor costs indicate lower productivity in agriculture, non-gold industry, and transport and communication sectors.

### C. Labor market competitiveness and costs
- Unit labor costs:
  - The Kyrgyz Republic’s unit labor costs are higher than elsewhere in the CCA region.
  - Since 2018: 5 percent average annual increase in real wages in the Kyrgyz Republic (outpaced only by Kazakhstan and Uzbekistan).
  - Wage gains have outpaced productivity gains, reducing competitiveness relative to regional peers.
- Cross-country output per worker (2023, constant 2015 prices, thousand USD) — figure cited (no new numeric table beyond chart in source).

### D. Gender and inclusion
- Gender gaps in participation and employment:
  - Approximately 70 percent of working-age men are employed compared to only 45 percent of women.
  - Gender gap in labor force participation is sizable and the fastest-growing in the region.
  - Employment in agriculture declined from 727,000 in 2014 to 460,000 in 2022, disproportionately affecting women.
  - In the formal sector the gender gap is relatively small; in the informal sector the gender gap is significant.
- Gender pay gap:
  - On average, women in the Kyrgyz Republic earn 25 percent less than men.
  - Women concentrated in lower-paying sectors (agriculture and trade); higher-paying sectors (industry, transport, communication) are male-dominated.
- Barriers for women:
  - Parenthood and caregiving responsibilities reduce female labor force participation.
  - Limited availability of affordable childcare restricts women’s employment opportunities.
  - Remote work remains underdeveloped; recent Labor Code revisions envisage remote and hybrid work by agreement.

### E. Labor market institutions, safety nets, and education
- Labor market regulation and competitiveness:
  - Labor market regulations in the Kyrgyz Republic are more restrictive compared to CCA average (Global Competitiveness Index components).
  - Specific rigidities: quota system and burdensome procedures for foreign work permits, cumbersome hiring and firing procedures, strict documentation requirements.
  - New Labor Code revisions envisage simplified mechanisms for concluding employment contracts and allow remote/hybrid work by agreement.
- Unemployment benefits and ALMPs:
  - Unemployed benefit coverage in the Kyrgyz Republic: 0.3 percent of unemployed receiving unemployment benefits.
  - Comparator averages: CCA average 5.4 percent; Emerging Europe average 20.0 percent.
  - Challenges: significant informal employment complicates eligibility verification; limited technical and administrative capacity to provide job search assistance and training.
- Education and human capital:
  - Government spending on public education covers 11 years of schooling and exceeds 7 percent of GDP.
  - Learning-adjusted years of schooling: 8.4 years.
  - 64 percent of primary school graduates are not proficient in reading and comprehension.
  - Primary school completion rate: 93 percent.
  - Preschool coverage: 28.3 percent of kids (compared with 92.5 percent in Kazakhstan and 74 percent in Uzbekistan).
  - Expected years of schooling for men and women are similar but below international comparators.

### F. Policy implications and recommended reforms (as described in source)
- Demand-side and structural reforms to absorb growing labor supply:
  - Achieve higher and more inclusive growth (over 6.5 percent a year in medium to long term).
  - Implement structural reforms to raise potential output.
- Improve business environment and governance:
  - Provide a market-friendly business climate.
  - Improve governance and a competitive environment to stimulate private sector growth and entrepreneurship.
- Labor market reforms and institutional strengthening:
  - Strengthen labor markets through more flexible labor legislation that balances basic job protection with easier hiring and firing procedures.
  - Develop and expand Active Labor Market Policies (ALMPs): vocational training, job search assistance, job retraining, apprenticeships, and job placement services.
  - Expand and better fund unemployment benefits and make them more responsive during economic shocks.
  - Simplify procedures for employment contracts and hiring foreign talent where appropriate.
- Address informality and human capital bottlenecks:
  - Reduce informality by easing compliance costs for small and medium-sized enterprises.
  - Invest in human capital: improve education outcomes, increase preschool coverage, and enhance learning quality to raise labor productivity.
- Promote gender inclusion:
  - Increase access to affordable childcare.
  - Promote remote and hybrid work arrangements (as envisaged in recent Labor Code revisions) to facilitate women's participation.

*Source: IMF Selected Issues Paper chapter "LABOR MARKET CHALLENGES AND POLICY REFORMS IN THE KYRGYZ REPUBLIC" (May 7, 2025).*

### 17.      There is significant room to improve the quality of education in the Kyrgyz Republic.

### 17.      There is significant room to improve the quality of education in the Kyrgyz Republic.

### Education quality and labor-market skill gaps
- Sixty percent of adults in the Kyrgyz Republic have less than a basic understanding of literacy and numeracy in a problem-solving context, including computer literacy.
- Comparative benchmarks from the source:
  - 22 percent for literacy in Europe and Central Asia countries.
  - 25 percent for numeracy in Europe and Central Asia countries.
- The 2023 World Bank Enterprise Survey identifies the lack of skilled and adequately educated workers as one of the main obstacles for businesses.
- The Kyrgyz Republic falls below the averages for the CCA and EMEU on the Human Development Index.

### Growth and job-creation needs
- Staff analysis suggests the Kyrgyz economy needs to grow by over 6.5 percent per year in the medium to long term to create sufficient jobs for about 50,000 new entrants in the labor market each year.
- Without higher growth and more flexible labor market regulations the country will face challenges in containing unemployment, poverty, social inequality, and outmigration of talents.

### Labor market policy design — findings and recommendations
- Findings:
  - Current labor market design contributes to inequality, low productivity, and high informality.
  - Protecting jobs rather than protecting workers limits labor market flexibility.
- Policy recommendations:
  - Adopt more flexible hiring and retention rules that prioritize protecting workers rather than protecting jobs, following approaches used in more advanced economies.
  - Simplify procedures for hiring foreign professionals to facilitate knowledge transfer and enhance private sector efficiency.
  - Implement structural reforms to improve the business climate, including measures that strengthen governance, transparency, and competition, and support private sector development to raise potential output and generate more jobs and income.

### Social safety net and active labor market policies
- Recommendations:
  - Strengthen the social safety net and develop active labor market policies.
  - Establish an unemployment insurance system that scales up during economic downturns and scales back when the economy stabilizes.
  - Expand vocational training programs and job search assistance to better align training with labor market demands.
  - Provide job placement services, career counseling, and upskilling opportunities to support job seekers.

### Education system reform
- Problems and consequences:
  - Inadequate education leads to skills and gender gaps, low wages, higher unemployment and informality, and constrains the economy’s capacity to diversify and transition into higher-value industries.
- Policy priorities:
  - Deliver more years of quality learning and skill development aligned with labor market demands.
  - Improve tertiary education and expand access to vocational training programs.
  - Enhancing education would also help mitigate emigration.
- Note: The Government of the Kyrgyz Republic has adopted Education Development Strategy 2040 aiming to improve the quality of education.

### Gender equality and labor force participation
- Recommendations to increase female labor force participation and growth contribution:
  - End gender restrictions on access to certain positions.
  - Expand affordable childcare services.
  - Promote flexible work arrangements.
  - Develop skills training programs tailored to women to empower their workforce participation.

*Source: sipea2025082 - 17.      There is significant room to improve the quality of education in the Kyrgyz Republic.*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/selected-issues-papers/2025/english/sipea2025082.pdf_
