## 1. Electricity Consumption

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [1. Electricity Consumption](https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/selected-issues-papers/2025/english/sipea2025136.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/files/publications/selected-issues-papers/2025/english/sipea2025136.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/files/publications/selected-issues-papers/2025/english/sipea2025136.pdf.json)

---

### Overview and key takeaway
- Desynchronization from Russia's electricity grid provides an opportunity to modernize Latvia's electricity infrastructure and achieve a greener, more secure, and efficient electricity supply.
- Pursuing higher self-sufficiency and autarky would be costly and inefficient; greater integration with neighboring and EU electricity grids and increased risk sharing would deliver cheaper, less volatile electricity prices and greater resilience.

### Electricity demand and consumption (Background)
- Most of Latvia’s electricity is used in industry and services.
- Latvia’s electricity consumption has increased only modestly since 2005 due to:
  - Income growth (positive impact on demand).
  - Improvements in energy efficiency (drag on consumption).
- Sectoral trends:
  - Services sector: emerging key driver of electricity demand growth.
  - Transport sector: decline in electricity usage from an already low base.
- Per capita consumption:
  - Latvia: 3.7 MWh annually.
  - EU average: 5.7 MWh.
- Implication: significant potential for growth in electricity consumption as the economy catches up and electrification/greening proceeds.

### Electricity generation, mix, and system balance
- Latvia’s electricity consumption is mainly covered by local generation with a high share of renewables.
- Generation mix (2024):
  - Hydroelectric power: about 56 percent of electricity generation in 2024.
  - Natural gas: about a quarter of electricity production in 2024 (serves as balancing source).
  - Wind, solar, and biomass: growing contribution since 2010.
- Production shortfall:
  - Latvia experiences a production shortfall of approximately 1 TWh annually, covered through imports.
- Hydro characteristics and challenges:
  - Hydro generation is primarily run-of-river (no large reservoirs), producing high seasonal variability.
  - Generation peaks during spring months but falls well below monthly consumption levels for the rest of the year.
  - High interannual volatility depending on precipitation and snowmelt.
- Resulting balancing needs:
  - Natural gas co-generation and electricity imports are key balancing sources.

### Electricity prices and volatility
- Price surge and current levels:
  - In 2022, electricity prices surged to as much as ten times the pre-shock average.
  - Prices have receded but remain well above pre-pandemic levels.
  - Latvia's electricity prices are currently close to the EU average.
- Historical averages shown:
  - 2015-20 average: 40.5 euros/MWh.
  - 2024-25 average: 91.8 euros/MWh.
- Components of final electricity bill for households and non-households:
  - Basic energy cost: approximately 50-60 percent of total.
  - Transmission costs: 20-30 percent.
  - Taxes: 20 percent.
- Price volatility:
  - Price volatility over time and dispersion across countries rose sharply after the shock and has not returned to pre-crisis levels.
- Role of marginal gas prices:
  - EU electricity prices largely based on marginal spot pricing; natural gas prices drive electricity prices for a larger share of time than gas’s share in the power mix.
  - Natural gas was the price-setting technology 63 percent of the time in 2022 in the EU, despite accounting for only 20 percent of the electricity mix.
  - When gas prices rise sharply (as in 2022-23), electricity prices follow; gas price volatility has largely subsided, but electricity prices remain high and volatile, indicating lingering market fragmentation effects.

### Market fragmentation, interconnection, and price convergence
- Interconnection status:
  - Significant interconnection capacity built across Western Europe, but substantial gaps remain; the system remains fragmented with limited network integration.
- Effects of fragmentation:
  - Fragmentation amplifies impacts of idiosyncratic shocks and prevents efficient risk sharing across markets.
  - Stark price differences can arise across neighboring bidding zones due to bottlenecks preventing exports (examples: September 2023 and summer 2024).
- Price convergence metrics:
  - Northern Europe pricing zone (DNK, EST, FIN, LVA, LTU, NOR, SWE):
    - Low-price convergence (>10 EUR/MWh difference between adjacent zones) escalated from approximately 50 percent of the time in 2017 to about 95 percent of the time in 2023.
  - Insufficient market connectivity reduces arbitrage and exacerbates inefficiencies.

### Benefits of closer integration with EU electricity markets
- Aggregate benefits from deeper integration:
  - Risk sharing across regions when demand and supply are not aligned.
  - Reduced need for expensive backup capacity.
  - Less price volatility.
  - Reduced fossil-fuel burn and GHG emissions.
  - More RES generation with less investment through harnessing regional renewable advantages.
  - More system flexibility with less storage investment.
  - Higher consumer surplus from increased competition.
- Quantified findings from studies:
  - Greater integration within subsets of countries could reduce needed dispatchable generation capacity by nearly 20 percent and storage capacity by 30 percent (Zachmann and others 2024; Roth and Schill, 2023).
  - A significant increase in cross-border electricity trade could boost annual EU GDP by around 0.1 percent in 2030 (Dolphin and others 2024).
- Storage and investment implications (based on referenced modeling):
  - Short-duration and long-duration storage needs are materially lower with interconnection versus without interconnection.
- Broader economic impacts:
  - Lower and less volatile electricity prices would support investor confidence and corporate investment, including in energy-intensive and high-innovation sectors (e.g., data centers for AI, quantum computing, digital services), thereby strengthening productivity growth.

### Renewable potential and transition considerations
- Renewable capacity factors:
  - Differences in renewable potential across the EU imply gains from exploiting regional comparative advantages for siting RES.
  - Growth of RES weight in generation and electrification of end uses will further influence average price levels and volatility in an integrated market.

### Recent policy developments and opportunities for Latvia
- Synchronization event:
  - On February 8, 2025, the three Baltic countries disconnected from the Russia/Belarus/Estonia/Latvia/Lithuania (BRELL) grid and synchronized with the Continental Europe Synchronous Area (CESA) electricity grid.
  - The transition resulted in higher electricity prices in the short term.
- Opportunity:
  - The synchronization with CESA is an opportunity to modernize Latvia’s electricity infrastructure and leverage closer EU integration for higher risk sharing, greater energy security, lower volatility, and lower prices in the long run.

### Policy implications and recommendations (implied by analysis)
- Prioritize deeper integration with neighboring and EU electricity markets to:
  - Enhance risk sharing and reduce price volatility.
  - Lower the need for expensive domestic back-up capacity and storage investments.
  - Increase RES deployment in cost-effective locations and reduce overall system costs.
- Strengthen regional and EU-level collaboration on grid upgrades and market design to:
  - Resolve cross-zonal congestion and reduce price fragmentation.
  - Improve arbitrage opportunities and market efficiency.
- Complement integration with targeted domestic measures to manage seasonal variability (given run-of-river hydro profile):
  - Maintain flexible balancing capacity (e.g., gas co-generation while decarbonizing).
  - Invest strategically in grid upgrades that enable higher RES integration and cross-border flows.

---

### 15. High and volatile electricity prices have macroeconomic costs

#### Macroeconomic channels and costs
- Competitiveness: high electricity price disparity puts energy-intensive industries at a disadvantage in export markets.
- Investment: high electricity price volatility hurts investment.
- Consumption: high energy costs and high price volatility reduce household consumption.
- Taxes: high electricity prices are associated with lower excise tax revenue.

#### Econometric approach and data
- Hypothesis: high electricity prices may affect manufacturing employment in Latvia; tested with firm-level regressions of employment on electricity price level or volatility, firm size (fixed tangible assets), and firm controls.
- Regression specification: includes sector (2-digit NACE), year, and year*sector fixed effects.
- Data sources and sample:
  - Firm data: Orbis for 2010-2022.
  - Electricity price levels: Eurostat (prices exclude taxes; category “Consumption from 500 MWh to 1999 MWh – band IC”).
  - Electricity price volatility: intraday prices from ENTSO-E recorded every 15 minutes (96 data points per day) to compute daily averages; annual standard deviation determined over approximately 365 data points.
  - The analysis focuses on Latvian manufacturing firms, excluding small firms (with less than two employees).
  - The sample includes 49,561 observations. Regression tables report Observations: 49,551 for electricity price level models and 35,073 for electricity price volatility models.

#### Key empirical findings (firm-level estimates)
- Electricity price level:
  - Aggregate elasticity: -0.25 — a 10 percent increase in electricity prices reduces employment in manufacturing by 2.5 percent.
  - Industry heterogeneity: larger negative impacts in beverages, leather, pharmaceutical, and transport equipment.
  - Regression table highlights: Electricity price level coefficient estimates include -0.249*** and -0.724*** across specifications; Fixed tangible assets coefficient 0.313***; R-squared 0.477.
  - Sectoral coefficients vary (examples drawn from Table 3): Food products (models report -0.168, -0.192***, -0.249***, -0.249***), Beverages (examples include -0.952*** and -1.033***), Leather (examples include -0.818* and -0.899**), Basic pharmaceuticals (examples include -0.880* and -0.961**).
- Electricity price volatility:
  - Aggregate elasticity: -0.066 — a 10 percent increase in electricity price volatility reduces employment in manufacturing by 0.66 percent.
  - Industry heterogeneity: volatility effects are heterogeneous across sectors; some sectors show statistically significant negative effects in sectoral models.
  - Regression table highlights: Electricity price volatility coefficient estimates include -0.0665***, -0.0810***, and -0.185*** across specifications; Fixed tangible assets coefficient 0.314***; R-squared 0.475.
  - Sectoral volatility coefficients vary (examples from Table 4): Beverages (model values include -0.0686*** and -0.198***), Textiles (examples -0.0873** and -0.0808***), Wood (examples -0.0507*** and -0.101***), Computer & electronics (example -0.0751*** in some specifications).
- Caveat: job losses in manufacturing may be offset by job creation in less electricity-intensive sectors, such as services; however, effects can be long-lasting in the presence of labor market frictions.

#### Policy implications and recommendations
- Improve interconnections to other European power grids to unlock the benefits of a unified energy market.
- Coordinate policies and investments at the EU and national levels to fully integrate Latvia into Europe’s power grid.
- Consider pooling resources with neighboring countries to develop grid infrastructures that provide shared benefits across borders.
- Streamline domestic permitting processes to reduce the time and costs associated with building interconnections and more renewables.
- Rationale: closer integration of Europe’s electricity markets could significantly increase economic activity; estimates range from 0.5 to 3.5 percent level increase in GDP, with the average EU country experiencing a 1.5 percent increase in GDP (Arnold and others 2025).

*Source: sipea2025136 — 1. Electricity Consumption (Republic of Latvia, INTERNATIONAL MONETARY FUND, July 31, 2025)*

### 1. Electricity Consumption ________________________________________________________________ 2

### sipea2025136 - 1. Electricity Consumption

### Overview and key takeaway
- Desynchronization from Russia's electricity grid provides an opportunity to modernize Latvia's electricity infrastructure and achieve a greener, more secure, and efficient electricity supply.
- Pursuing higher self-sufficiency and autarky would be costly and inefficient; greater integration with neighboring and EU electricity grids and increased risk sharing would deliver cheaper, less volatile electricity prices and greater resilience.

### Electricity demand and consumption (Background)
- Most of Latvia’s electricity is used in industry and services.
- Latvia’s electricity consumption has increased only modestly since 2005 due to:
  - Income growth (positive impact on demand).
  - Improvements in energy efficiency (drag on consumption).
- Sectoral trends:
  - Services sector: emerging key driver of electricity demand growth.
  - Transport sector: decline in electricity usage from an already low base.
- Per capita consumption:
  - Latvia: 3.7 MWh annually.
  - EU average: 5.7 MWh.
- Implication: significant potential for growth in electricity consumption as the economy catches up and electrification/greening proceeds.

### Electricity generation, mix, and system balance
- Latvia’s electricity consumption is mainly covered by local generation with a high share of renewables.
- Generation mix (2024):
  - Hydroelectric power: about 56 percent of electricity generation in 2024.
  - Natural gas: about a quarter of electricity production in 2024 (serves as balancing source).
  - Wind, solar, and biomass: growing contribution since 2010.
- Production shortfall:
  - Latvia experiences a production shortfall of approximately 1 TWh annually, covered through imports.
- Hydro characteristics and challenges:
  - Hydro generation is primarily run-of-river (no large reservoirs), producing high seasonal variability.
  - Generation peaks during spring months but falls well below monthly consumption levels for the rest of the year.
  - High interannual volatility depending on precipitation and snowmelt.
- Resulting balancing needs:
  - Natural gas co-generation and electricity imports are key balancing sources.

### Electricity prices and volatility
- Price surge and current levels:
  - In 2022, electricity prices surged to as much as ten times the pre-shock average.
  - Prices have receded but remain well above pre-pandemic levels.
  - Latvia's electricity prices are currently close to the EU average.
- Historical averages shown:
  - 2015-20 average: 40.5 euros/MWh.
  - 2024-25 average: 91.8 euros/MWh.
- Components of final electricity bill for households and non-households:
  - Basic energy cost: approximately 50-60 percent of total.
  - Transmission costs: 20-30 percent.
  - Taxes: 20 percent.
- Price volatility:
  - Price volatility over time and dispersion across countries rose sharply after the shock and has not returned to pre-crisis levels.
- Role of marginal gas prices:
  - EU electricity prices largely based on marginal spot pricing; natural gas prices drive electricity prices for a larger share of time than gas’s share in the power mix.
  - Natural gas was the price-setting technology 63 percent of the time in 2022 in the EU, despite accounting for only 20 percent of the electricity mix.
  - When gas prices rise sharply (as in 2022-23), electricity prices follow; gas price volatility has largely subsided, but electricity prices remain high and volatile, indicating lingering market fragmentation effects.

### Market fragmentation, interconnection, and price convergence
- Interconnection status:
  - Significant interconnection capacity built across Western Europe, but substantial gaps remain; the system remains fragmented with limited network integration.
- Effects of fragmentation:
  - Fragmentation amplifies impacts of idiosyncratic shocks and prevents efficient risk sharing across markets.
  - Stark price differences can arise across neighboring bidding zones due to bottlenecks preventing exports (examples: September 2023 and summer 2024).
- Price convergence metrics:
  - Northern Europe pricing zone (DNK, EST, FIN, LVA, LTU, NOR, SWE):
    - Low-price convergence (>10 EUR/MWh difference between adjacent zones) escalated from approximately 50 percent of the time in 2017 to about 95 percent of the time in 2023.
  - Insufficient market connectivity reduces arbitrage and exacerbates inefficiencies.

### Benefits of closer integration with EU electricity markets
- Aggregate benefits from deeper integration:
  - Risk sharing across regions when demand and supply are not aligned.
  - Reduced need for expensive backup capacity.
  - Less price volatility.
  - Reduced fossil-fuel burn and GHG emissions.
  - More RES generation with less investment through harnessing regional renewable advantages.
  - More system flexibility with less storage investment.
  - Higher consumer surplus from increased competition.
- Quantified findings from studies:
  - Greater integration within subsets of countries could reduce needed dispatchable generation capacity by nearly 20 percent and storage capacity by 30 percent (Zachmann and others 2024; Roth and Schill, 2023).
  - A significant increase in cross-border electricity trade could boost annual EU GDP by around 0.1 percent in 2030 (Dolphin and others 2024).
- Storage and investment implications (based on referenced modeling):
  - Short-duration and long-duration storage needs are materially lower with interconnection versus without interconnection.
- Broader economic impacts:
  - Lower and less volatile electricity prices would support investor confidence and corporate investment, including in energy-intensive and high-innovation sectors (e.g., data centers for AI, quantum computing, digital services), thereby strengthening productivity growth.

### Renewable potential and transition considerations
- Renewable capacity factors:
  - Differences in renewable potential across the EU imply gains from exploiting regional comparative advantages for siting RES.
  - Growth of RES weight in generation and electrification of end uses will further influence average price levels and volatility in an integrated market.

### Recent policy developments and opportunities for Latvia
- Synchronization event:
  - On February 8, 2025, the three Baltic countries disconnected from the Russia/Belarus/Estonia/Latvia/Lithuania (BRELL) grid and synchronized with the Continental Europe Synchronous Area (CESA) electricity grid.
  - The transition resulted in higher electricity prices in the short term.
- Opportunity:
  - The synchronization with CESA is an opportunity to modernize Latvia’s electricity infrastructure and leverage closer EU integration for higher risk sharing, greater energy security, lower volatility, and lower prices in the long run.

### Policy implications and recommendations (implied by analysis)
- Prioritize deeper integration with neighboring and EU electricity markets to:
  - Enhance risk sharing and reduce price volatility.
  - Lower the need for expensive domestic back-up capacity and storage investments.
  - Increase RES deployment in cost-effective locations and reduce overall system costs.
- Strengthen regional and EU-level collaboration on grid upgrades and market design to:
  - Resolve cross-zonal congestion and reduce price fragmentation.
  - Improve arbitrage opportunities and market efficiency.
- Complement integration with targeted domestic measures to manage seasonal variability (given run-of-river hydro profile):
  - Maintain flexible balancing capacity (e.g., gas co-generation while decarbonizing).
  - Invest strategically in grid upgrades that enable higher RES integration and cross-border flows.

*Source: sipea2025136 — 1. Electricity Consumption (Republic of Latvia, INTERNATIONAL MONETARY FUND, July 31, 2025)*

### 15.      High and volatile electricity prices have macroeconomic costs:

### 15.      High and volatile electricity prices have macroeconomic costs:

### Macroeconomic channels and costs
- Competitiveness: high electricity price disparity puts energy-intensive industries at a disadvantage in export markets.
- Investment: high electricity price volatility hurts investment.
- Consumption: high energy costs and high price volatility reduce household consumption.
- Taxes: high electricity prices are associated with lower excise tax revenue.

### Econometric approach and data
- Hypothesis: high electricity prices may affect manufacturing employment in Latvia; tested with firm-level regressions of employment on electricity price level or volatility, firm size (fixed tangible assets), and firm controls.
- Regression specification: includes sector (2-digit NACE), year, and year*sector fixed effects.
- Data sources and sample:
  - Firm data: Orbis for 2010-2022.
  - Electricity price levels: Eurostat (prices exclude taxes; category “Consumption from 500 MWh to 1999 MWh – band IC”).
  - Electricity price volatility: intraday prices from ENTSO-E recorded every 15 minutes (96 data points per day) to compute daily averages; annual standard deviation determined over approximately 365 data points.
  - The analysis focuses on Latvian manufacturing firms, excluding small firms (with less than two employees).
  - The sample includes 49,561 observations. Regression tables report Observations: 49,551 for electricity price level models and 35,073 for electricity price volatility models.

### Key empirical findings (firm-level estimates)
- Electricity price level:
  - Aggregate elasticity: -0.25 — a 10 percent increase in electricity prices reduces employment in manufacturing by 2.5 percent.
  - Industry heterogeneity: larger negative impacts in beverages, leather, pharmaceutical, and transport equipment.
  - Regression table highlights: Electricity price level coefficient estimates include -0.249*** and -0.724*** across specifications; Fixed tangible assets coefficient 0.313***; R-squared 0.477.
  - Sectoral coefficients vary (examples drawn from Table 3): Food products (models report -0.168, -0.192***, -0.249***, -0.249***), Beverages (examples include -0.952*** and -1.033***), Leather (examples include -0.818* and -0.899**), Basic pharmaceuticals (examples include -0.880* and -0.961**).
- Electricity price volatility:
  - Aggregate elasticity: -0.066 — a 10 percent increase in electricity price volatility reduces employment in manufacturing by 0.66 percent.
  - Industry heterogeneity: volatility effects are heterogeneous across sectors; some sectors show statistically significant negative effects in sectoral models.
  - Regression table highlights: Electricity price volatility coefficient estimates include -0.0665***, -0.0810***, and -0.185*** across specifications; Fixed tangible assets coefficient 0.314***; R-squared 0.475.
  - Sectoral volatility coefficients vary (examples from Table 4): Beverages (model values include -0.0686*** and -0.198***), Textiles (examples -0.0873** and -0.0808***), Wood (examples -0.0507*** and -0.101***), Computer & electronics (example -0.0751*** in some specifications).
- Caveat: job losses in manufacturing may be offset by job creation in less electricity-intensive sectors, such as services; however, effects can be long-lasting in the presence of labor market frictions.

### Policy implications and recommendations
- Improve interconnections to other European power grids to unlock the benefits of a unified energy market.
- Coordinate policies and investments at the EU and national levels to fully integrate Latvia into Europe’s power grid.
- Consider pooling resources with neighboring countries to develop grid infrastructures that provide shared benefits across borders.
- Streamline domestic permitting processes to reduce the time and costs associated with building interconnections and more renewables.
- Rationale: closer integration of Europe’s electricity markets could significantly increase economic activity; estimates range from 0.5 to 3.5 percent level increase in GDP, with the average EU country experiencing a 1.5 percent increase in GDP (Arnold and others 2025).

*Source: IMF staff calculations and analysis as presented in “15. High and volatile electricity prices have macroeconomic costs” (Republic of Latvia, Selected Issues Paper).*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/selected-issues-papers/2025/english/sipea2025136.pdf_
