## sipea2025153

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [sipea2025153](https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/selected-issues-papers/2025/english/sipea2025153.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/files/publications/selected-issues-papers/2025/english/sipea2025153.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/files/publications/selected-issues-papers/2025/english/sipea2025153.pdf.json)

---

### Overview: macro-critical nature and tourism dependence
- Climate change is a major threat to long-term growth and wellbeing for Andorra given its economic dependance on tourists visiting during the ski season.
- Measures taken now to fight the climate crisis will create a more resilient and greener economy.

### Climate trends and shrinking snow cover
- Since 1950, the country has experienced an increase in temperature averaging 0.20°per decade—most evident during the summer season—resulting in systemically higher annual maximum and minimum temperatures throughout the year.
- Patterns of precipitation show a tendency towards the shrinking of total pluviometry, including a decrease in the frequency of heavy rain and an increase in dry periods.
- Annual rainfall has decreased by—22.01 mm per decade since 2050.
- The reduction in winter precipitation and higher annual temperatures are leading to snow cover decreases in the Pyrenean region.
- Projected annual snow cover in Andorra is expected to decline by 75–100cm by 2090.
- Implications for tourism and infrastructure:
  - Decreasing days with sufficient snow for alpine skiing activities and a migrating snow line to higher altitudes.
  - Redistribution of the Pyrenean market between vulnerable and resilient ski resorts, and toward those at higher altitude (short-to-medium term benefit for Andorra).
  - Over time, increased reliance on artificial snowmaking; higher temperatures reduce the number of resorts that can operate profitably and shorten ski seasons.
  - Intensification of global warming could impact landscapes and tourism infrastructure and alter tourism flows.
  - Water demand for snowmaking could lead to conflicts between intensive water-demand sectors.

### Emissions profile and energy dependency
- CO2 emissions level in Andorra is estimated at 5.6 metric tons per capita (at the same level as the EU average), slightly higher than neighboring France and Spain.
- Andorra’s forest mass absorbs 23 percent of the CO2 emissions (data from 2017).
- The percent decline in emissions since 1990 in Andorra has been lower than the EU’s average, driven in part by transport-sector emissions that have not fallen rapidly enough.
- Energy intensity:
  - After a rapid decline since the early 2000s, Andorra’s energy intensity has been relatively stable between 98 and 115 units of energy per unit of GDP.
  - Comparable Eurozone values: 118–122.
- Sectoral emissions:
  - The energy sector emits more than 95 percent of greenhouse emissions in Andorra.
  - The mobility subsector accounts for more than half of energy demand.
  - Fossil fuels amount to 75 percent of demand, of which 2/3 are related to mobility.
  - The remaining 25 percent of energy demand are related to electricity consumption and energy production.
  - Mobility represents 56 percent of GHG emissions and 52 percent of the energy demand.
- Fuel tourism and cross-border effects:
  - 76 percent of the fuels sold in Andorra for road transport are consumed in the neighboring countries.
- Energy origin and production:
  - Imported electricity from France and Spain amounts to 76 percent of the demand.
  - The remaining 24 percent is locally produced, almost all of which comes from renewable sources.
  - Of locally produced electricity, 81 percent is hydraulic and the remaining is also green.

### Climate change impacts on energy
- Climate change is expected to negatively affect hydropower, thermoelectric and wind production.
- Expected increase in frequency and intensity of extreme weather could impact energy production and distribution systems.
- Higher temperatures will change consumption patterns:
  - Increases in summer energy demand are expected, which will be only partly compensated by a decrease in electricity demand for heating in the winter.

### Regulatory and strategic framework
- Key laws, plans, and institutions:
  - Decree of 29-4-2015 creating the Office of Energy and Climate Change (OECC).
  - Nationally Determined Contribution: first submitted in 2017 and updated in 2020 and 2022.
  - National Law 21/2018: of 13 September, on the promotion of the energy transition and climate change (Litecc).
  - Sustainable Development Goals: national strategic plan for the implementation of the United Nations 2030 Agenda, approved 17 April 2019.
  - Declaration of the state of climate and ecological emergency in January 2020.
  - National energy strategy against climate change: mitigation and adaptation measures over the period 2020-2050.
  - Edict of the 27-1-2021: call for grants from the Renova program for 2021.
  - Andorran strategy for environmental education for sustainability: approved in 2022.
  - Green Fund: 2022 general budget law creates a Green Fund for the energy transition and the fight against climate change.
  - Carbon Tax: as an additional element of the excise tax on hydrocarbons whose use general GHG emissions.
  - Law 25/2022 on circular economy (LEC).
  - Law 31/2022 for the development and diversification of the livestock and agricultural sectors.
  - Multiple decrees to regulate emissions, energy efficiency, transport, among others.

### Andorra’s Climate Change Strategy: objectives, targets, and programs
- Overall objectives:
  - Reduce 37 percent of non-absorbed emissions compared to 2005 levels by 2030.
  - Achieve carbon neutrality by 2050.
  - Note: The authorities plan to revise the target on reduction of non-absorbed emissions from 37 to 55 percent by 2030.
- Key sectoral targets:
  - Mobility (2030): Reduction of 50 percent internal emissions from mobility; 20 percent electric vehicles.
  - Buildings (2030): Reduce consumption by 40 percent.
  - Electricity (2030): 33 percent electricity consumption from national production; 100 percent imported electricity with zero emissions.
  - Electricity (2050): 50 percent electricity consumption from national production.
  - 2050: Decarbonization across Mobility, Buildings, Electricity.
- Five action programs and principal activities:
  - Decarbonization: Energy transition; sustainable, connected, and safe mobility; agriculture and forest management respectful towards the territory’s sink capacity; circular economy; industry and use of industrial products.
  - Adaptation and Resilience: Plan for adaptation to climate change; promotion of nature-based solutions for greater resilience.
  - Financing Tools: National carbon credit market and renewable energy; Green Fund and other taxation tools.
  - Social Transition: Sensitization and dissemination on carbon neutrality; educational transition; training to achieve carbon neutrality; user information and protection; participation of different agents.
  - Innovation, Research and Observation: Innovation; research and knowledge transfer; systemic observation.
- Cross-cutting measures:
  - Incentivizing citizens’ behavioral changes, public and private sustainable finance, carbon pricing, and other market mechanisms.
  - Waste management and circular economy, ecosystem services, biodiversity, land use, and agriculture.
  - International cooperation: membership in the Pyrenees Climate Change Observatory and the Ibero—American Network of Climate Change Agencies.

### Mitigation measures and emphasis on mobility and electrification
- Key mitigation measures:
  - Improve the electricity sector, promote renewable energies and high-efficiency energy technologies, and encourage energy savings and energy efficiency (particularly in construction).
  - Forces Elèctriques d'Andorra (FEDA), the electricity SOE, is executing infrastructure and digitalization investments.
- Mobility measures:
  - Prioritize public transport and promote motorized or assisted non-public mobility (walking, biking, etc.).
  - Electrify motorized mobility with clean energy.
  - Study alternative means of transport including cable transport.
  - Consider requiring companies with more than one hundred workers to have collective and sustainable mobility plans.
  - Promote electric mobility in private and public fleets and implement/ manage charging infrastructure nationwide.
  - Acknowledge the importance of improvements in car efficiency in neighboring countries given the significance of tourist cars.

### Feasibility assessment and scope of the paper
- The paper assesses the feasibility and estimated costs of the mitigation agenda and additional policies needed to limit the impact of climate change on the Andorran economy.
- Methodology and structure:
  - Describes climate trends and projections in the country.
  - Stocks sources of emissions.
  - Summarizes the proposed climate change strategy: objectives, key targets, and planned activities.
  - Uses the Climate Policy Assessment Tool (CPAT) to assess feasibility of achieving the decarbonization objective under different scenarios of carbon tax and efficiency gains.
  - Concludes with a policy discussion including the important adaptation component of the climate agenda in Andorra.

### Financing tools and fiscal architecture
- General points:
  - Decarbonization and adaptation are expensive and require appropriate financing tools. Resources currently allocated may be insufficient and need scaling up. The full cost of the climate change strategy is unknown pending further understanding of adaptation efforts. A voluntary and regulated emission offset system is being put in place.
- Green Fund:
  - Established to help finance climate mitigation and adaptation initiatives.
  - Primarily intended to finance existing aid programs such as the Engega Plan (electric vehicle incentives) and the Renova program (energy efficiency of buildings), and to provide universal access to public transportation.
  - Incorporated into the draft general budget law annually; sustained by earmarked taxes, complementary budgetary allocations in the State’s general budget laws, donations, and other contributions.
- Carbon tax (introduced 2022):
  - Tax rate of the CO2 branch set at €30 per ton of carbon dioxide equivalent, half assumed by the government.
  - Current carbon tax is below the regional average of €42 per ton of CO2.
  - IMF estimate cited: a floor of USD75 per ton of CO2 is needed for advanced economies to reduce emissions by 29 percent by 2030.
  - More recent estimates cited: a rate of €120 per ton of CO2 would be needed in 2030 to decarbonize by 2050 in euro area countries.
- FEDA and private sector financing of energy transition:
  - FEDA has a 5-year investment plan at cost of €208.80 million (7.43 percent of 2024 GDP) that is currently being executed.
  - Investment plan—main projects (2024–28):
    - Electricity Generation: 97.62 Millions of EUR — 3.47 Percent of 2024 GDP
    - Transmission: 45.01 Millions of EUR — 1.60 Percent of 2024 GDP
    - Distribution (electricity): 8.34 Millions of EUR — 0.30 Percent of 2024 GDP
    - Heating Generation: 9.70 Millions of EUR — 0.35 Percent of 2024 GDP
    - Heating Distribution: 19.56 Millions of EUR — 0.70 Percent of 2024 GDP
    - Mobility Electric charge: 1.32 Millions of EUR — 0.05 Percent of 2024 GDP
    - Mobility: 2.03 Millions of EUR — 0.07 Percent of 2024 GDP
    - Waste Environment: 0.70 Millions of EUR — 0.02 Percent of 2024 GDP
    - Efficiency: 10.32 Millions of EUR — 0.37 Percent of 2024 GDP
    - General Digitalization: 9.34 Millions of EUR — 0.33 Percent of 2024 GDP
    - Others: 4.86 Millions of EUR — 0.17 Percent of 2024 GDP
    - Total: 208.80 Millions of EUR — 7.43 Percent of 2024 GDP
- Public debt and green financing:
  - All public debt issues since 2021, amounting to EUR1.175 billion, provide financing to be used under the “Green, social and Sustainability Framework”. Green bonds help allocate funds to climate policies.

### CPAT methodology and model specifics
- CPAT toolkit description:
  - Jointly developed by the IMF and the World Bank; a “model of models” covering over 200 countries to estimate economic and non-economic effects of climate mitigation policies; four components: mitigation, distribution, air pollution, transport.
  - Paper focuses on the CPAT mitigation model due to data limitations.
- CPAT mitigation model specifics:
  - Reduced-form macro-energy model estimating impacts on energy consumption, prices, GHGs by sector, local air pollutants, revenue, GDP, and welfare.
  - Uses projections of income growth and fuel prices to project energy consumption across sectors (power, residential, transport, industries) and energy sources (fossil fuels, other non-renewables, renewables).
  - Distinguishes energy consumption in power, industry, transport, buildings, and other sectors; distinguishes energy sources by fossil fuels and electricity.
- Energy demand equation and efficiency parameter:
  - Sector-specific demand for energy source E is driven by change in usage of energy-consuming products, change in energy consumption rate in that sector, and previous sectoral demand; rewritten form includes growth effect, exogenous technical change effect (less rebound), and price effect (own price elasticity, endogenous efficiency, rebound).
  - Autonomous annual energy efficiency improvement parameter captures productivity gains from technical efficiency improvements and capital turnover.
  - Examples cited: between 2020 and 2020 vehicle efficiency improved by 1.7 percent; residential buildings 1.3 percent annually; power plants: coal 0.5 percent annual productivity growth; natural gas, nuclear, hydro 1 percent; renewables observed productivity growth rate of 5 percent.
  - In CPAT baseline, energy efficiency parameter set at around 0.5–1 percent annually and varied across sectors/fuels. Scenario analysis increases this parameter.

### CPAT results and scenario findings
- High-level conclusion:
  - Achieving decarbonization in Andorra requires a significant increase in the carbon tax and very ambitious efficiency gains. Comparison made versus a net zero by 2050 path.
- Specific scenario for decarbonization:
  - Increase the carbon tax to €150 per ton by 2030 accompanied by efficiency gains of at least 5 percent in the power, transport, and residential sectors.
  - Caveat: 5 percent efficiency gains may be too ambitious with existing technologies and current pace of innovation; transport emissions are largely exogenous and dominant, requiring major overhaul of the transport system (including reduction in absolute number of vehicles transiting in the country and transition to cleaner transport for locals and tourists).
- Carbon tax alone:
  - Insufficient to achieve carbon neutrality in Andorra; pricing tools alone fail to reduce emissions rapidly in advanced economies where income and price elasticities of energy are low.
- Macroeconomic and consumption implications of a carbon tax of €150 per ton by 2030 (with and without efficiency gains):
  - Fiscal revenues from fossil fuel excises estimated to reach between 0.5–0.8 percent of GDP depending on efficiency gains.
  - Impact on GDP growth estimated to be limited (model does not account for potential impact on fuel tourism).
  - Energy price changes: carbon tax could lead to an over 100 percent increase in oil prices; other sources of energy expected to increase between 26 and 61 percent depending on energy type.
- Selected tabulated fuel price entries (as presented in the source):
  - Gasoline — US$ per liter — 1.49 1.89 26%
  - Diesel — US$ per liter — 1.27 1.72 35%
  - LPG — US$ per liter — 0.66 0.95 44%
  - Kerosene — US$ per liter — 0.69 1.12 61%
  - Oil — US$ per barrel — 65.31 40.51 115%
  - Electricity — US$ per kwh — 0% (entries presented in source graphics)
  - Coal / Natural gas — US$ per gigajoule (GJ) — entries presented in source graphics (e.g., 13.35; 18.34; 49% in source visuals)

### Policy discussion and recommendations
- Assessment:
  - Andorra’s climate change strategy is ambitious and comprehensive on mitigation, but adaptation measures need strengthening and acceleration.
- Financing gaps and tools:
  - Some elements have identified funding (FEDA’s investment plan is the most concrete); the Green Fund aids allocation but may need scaling up.
  - Gradual but proactive increases in the carbon tax could help achieve decarbonization.
- Complementarity and realism of tools:
  - Pricing tools need to be complemented with large-scale energy efficiency improvements.
  - Efficiency gains of at least 5 percent may be unrealistic with current technologies; the transport sector is a major emissions source and relies heavily on fossil fuels from foreign cars subject to owners’ country regulations.
  - Major transformation of the transportation sector is essential, including reducing reliance on fuel tourism.
  - Ramp up renewable energy deployment.
- Adaptation urgency:
  - Accelerate adaptation policy design and implementation given dependence on winter tourism.
  - Assess feasibility and estimated costs of adaptation policies because structural transformations and infrastructure needs are challenging and costly.
  - Diversification of tourism across the year and reducing seasonality are priorities but require slow and resource-intensive structural change.

*Prepared by Michelle Tejada (EUR).*

### 1.       Climate change has become a macro-critical issue, particularly in economies such as

### 1.       Climate change has become a macro-critical issue, particularly in economies such as

### Overview: macro-critical nature and tourism dependence
- Climate change is a major threat to long-term growth and wellbeing for Andorra given its economic dependance on tourists visiting during the ski season.
- Measures taken now to fight the climate crisis will create a more resilient and greener economy.

### Climate trends and shrinking snow cover
- Since 1950, the country has experienced an increase in temperature averaging 0.20°per decade—most evident during the summer season—resulting in systemically higher annual maximum and minimum temperatures throughout the year.
- Patterns of precipitation show a tendency towards the shrinking of total pluviometry, including a decrease in the frequency of heavy rain and an increase in dry periods.
- Annual rainfall has decreased by—22.01 mm per decade since 2050.
- The reduction in winter precipitation and higher annual temperatures are leading to snow cover decreases in the Pyrenean region.
- Projected annual snow cover in Andorra is expected to decline by 75–100cm by 2090.
- Implications for tourism and infrastructure:
  - Decreasing days with sufficient snow for alpine skiing activities and a migrating snow line to higher altitudes.
  - Redistribution of the Pyrenean market between vulnerable and resilient ski resorts, and toward those at higher altitude (short-to-medium term benefit for Andorra).
  - Over time, increased reliance on artificial snowmaking; higher temperatures reduce the number of resorts that can operate profitably and shorten ski seasons.
  - Intensification of global warming could impact landscapes and tourism infrastructure and alter tourism flows.
  - Water demand for snowmaking could lead to conflicts between intensive water-demand sectors.

### Emissions profile and energy dependency
- CO2 emissions level in Andorra is estimated at 5.6 metric tons per capita (at the same level as the EU average), slightly higher than neighboring France and Spain.
- Andorra’s forest mass absorbs 23 percent of the CO2 emissions (data from 2017).
- The percent decline in emissions since 1990 in Andorra has been lower than the EU’s average, driven in part by transport-sector emissions that have not fallen rapidly enough.
- Energy intensity:
  - After a rapid decline since the early 2000s, Andorra’s energy intensity has been relatively stable between 98 and 115 units of energy per unit of GDP.
  - Comparable Eurozone values: 118–122.
- Sectoral emissions:
  - The energy sector emits more than 95 percent of greenhouse emissions in Andorra.
  - The mobility subsector accounts for more than half of energy demand.
  - Fossil fuels amount to 75 percent of demand, of which 2/3 are related to mobility.
  - The remaining 25 percent of energy demand are related to electricity consumption and energy production.
  - Mobility represents 56 percent of GHG emissions and 52 percent of the energy demand.
- Fuel tourism and cross-border effects:
  - 76 percent of the fuels sold in Andorra for road transport are consumed in the neighboring countries.
- Energy origin and production:
  - Imported electricity from France and Spain amounts to 76 percent of the demand.
  - The remaining 24 percent is locally produced, almost all of which comes from renewable sources.
  - Of locally produced electricity, 81 percent is hydraulic and the remaining is also green.

### Climate change impacts on energy
- Climate change is expected to negatively affect hydropower, thermoelectric and wind production.
- Expected increase in frequency and intensity of extreme weather could impact energy production and distribution systems.
- Higher temperatures will change consumption patterns:
  - Increases in summer energy demand are expected, which will be only partly compensated by a decrease in electricity demand for heating in the winter.

### Regulatory and strategic framework (Box 1)
- Decree of 29-4-2015 creating the Office of Energy and Climate Change (OECC).
- Nationally Determined Contribution: first submitted in 2017 and updated in 2020 and 2022.
- National Law 21/2018: of 13 September, on the promotion of the energy transition and climate change (Litecc).
- Sustainable Development Goals: national strategic plan for the implementation of the United Nations 2030 Agenda, approved 17 April 2019.
- Acknowledgement of the climate crisis and declaration of the state of climate and ecological emergency in January 2020.
- National energy strategy against climate change: mitigation and adaptation measures over the period 2020-2050.
- Edict of the 27-1-2021: call for grants from the Renova program for 2021.
- Andorran strategy for environmental education for sustainability: approved in 2022.
- Green Fund: 2022 general budget law creates a Green Fund for the energy transition and the fight against climate change.
- Carbon Tax: as an additional element of the excise tax on hydrocarbons whose use general GHG emissions.
- Law 25/2022 on circular economy (LEC).
- Law 31/2022 for the development and diversification of the livestock and agricultural sectors.
- Multiple decrees to regulate emissions, energy efficiency, transport, among others.

### Andorra’s Climate Change Strategy: objectives, targets, and programs
- Overall objectives:
  - Reduce 37 percent of non-absorbed emissions compared to 2005 levels by 2030.
  - Achieve carbon neutrality by 2050.
  - Note: The authorities plan to revise the target on reduction of non-absorbed emissions from 37 to 55 percent by 2030.
- Key sectoral targets (Table 1):
  - Mobility (2030): Reduction of 50 percent internal emissions from mobility; 20 percent electric vehicles.
  - Buildings (2030): Reduce consumption by 40 percent.
  - Electricity (2030): 33 percent electricity consumption from national production; 100 percent imported electricity with zero emissions.
  - Electricity (2050): 50 percent electricity consumption from national production.
  - 2050: Decarbonization across Mobility, Buildings, Electricity.
- Five action programs and principal activities (Table 2):
  - Decarbonization: Energy transition; sustainable, connected, and safe mobility; agriculture and forest management respectful towards the territory’s sink capacity; circular economy; industry and use of industrial products.
  - Adaptation and Resilience: Plan for adaptation to climate change; promotion of nature-based solutions for greater resilience.
  - Financing Tools: National carbon credit market and renewable energy; Green Fund and other taxation tools.
  - Social Transition: Sensitization and dissemination on carbon neutrality; educational transition; training to achieve carbon neutrality; user information and protection; participation of different agents.
  - Innovation, Research and Observation: Innovation; research and knowledge transfer; systemic observation.
- Cross-cutting measures:
  - Incentivizing citizens’ behavioral changes, public and private sustainable finance, carbon pricing, and other market mechanisms.
  - Waste management and circular economy, ecosystem services, biodiversity, land use, and agriculture.
  - International cooperation: membership in the Pyrenees Climate Change Observatory and the Ibero—American Network of Climate Change Agencies.

### Mitigation measures and emphasis on mobility and electrification
- Key mitigation measures:
  - Improve the electricity sector, promote renewable energies and high-efficiency energy technologies, and encourage energy savings and energy efficiency (particularly in construction).
  - Forces Elèctriques d'Andorra (FEDA), the electricity SOE, is executing infrastructure and digitalization investments.
- Mobility measures:
  - Prioritize public transport and promote motorized or assisted non-public mobility (walking, biking, etc.).
  - Electrify motorized mobility with clean energy.
  - Study alternative means of transport including cable transport.
  - Consider requiring companies with more than one hundred workers to have collective and sustainable mobility plans.
  - Promote electric mobility in private and public fleets and implement/ manage charging infrastructure nationwide.
  - Acknowledge the importance of improvements in car efficiency in neighboring countries given the significance of tourist cars.

### Feasibility assessment and scope of the paper
- The paper assesses the feasibility and estimated costs of the mitigation agenda and additional policies needed to limit the impact of climate change on the Andorran economy.
- Methodology and structure:
  - Describes climate trends and projections in the country.
  - Stocks sources of emissions.
  - Summarizes the proposed climate change strategy: objectives, key targets, and planned activities.
  - Uses the Climate Policy Assessment Tool (CPAT) to assess feasibility of achieving the decarbonization objective under different scenarios of carbon tax and efficiency gains.
  - Concludes with a policy discussion including the important adaptation component of the climate agenda in Andorra.

*Prepared by Michelle Tejada (EUR).*

### 18.      The authorities are also working on other sectors contributing to climate change, even

### 18.      The authorities are also working on other sectors contributing to climate change, even

### Sectors and strategic priorities
- Other sectors targeted (to a lesser extent):  
  - i) the promotion of agriculture and forest management cognizant of the territory’s sink capacity;  
  - ii) a move towards a circular economy that allows for greater savings in the consumption of raw material, energy, and water;  
  - iii) ensuring the development of a green economy with high value-added industries based on clean and sustainable technologies.

### Climate adaptation: vulnerabilities and priorities
- Key adaptation imperatives: accelerate adaptation to increase socio-economic and environmental resilience; guarantee the quality and supply of water; maintain the tourist appeal of the Pyrenees.  
- Prior work and status:  
  - A participatory process in 2014 assessed vulnerabilities and produced an initial roadmap.  
  - Further studies are ongoing to identify adaptation measures, assess costs, design a monitoring system, and improve impact indicators.  
  - Focus (in line with Litecc priority sectors): tourism, energy, health, and agriculture.  
- Imperative: further develop climate adaptation components and accelerate implementation to strengthen resilience.

### Financing tools and fiscal architecture
- General points: decarbonization and adaptation are expensive and require appropriate financing tools. Resources currently allocated may be insufficient and need scaling up. The full cost of the climate change strategy is unknown pending further understanding of adaptation efforts. A voluntary and regulated emission offset system is being put in place.
- Green Fund:  
  - Established to help finance climate mitigation and adaptation initiatives.  
  - Primarily intended to finance existing aid programs such as the Engega Plan (electric vehicle incentives) and the Renova program (energy efficiency of buildings), and to provide universal access to public transportation.  
  - Incorporated into the draft general budget law annually; sustained by earmarked taxes, complementary budgetary allocations in the State’s general budget laws, donations, and other contributions.
- Carbon tax (introduced 2022):  
  - Tax rate of the CO2 branch set at €30 per ton of carbon dioxide equivalent, half assumed by the government.  
  - Current carbon tax is below the regional average of €42 per ton of CO2.  
  - IMF estimate cited: a floor of USD75 per ton of CO2 is needed for advanced economies to reduce emissions by 29 percent by 2030.  
  - More recent estimates cited: a rate of €120 per ton of CO2 would be needed in 2030 to decarbonize by 2050 in euro area countries.
- FEDA and private sector financing of energy transition:  
  - FEDA has a 5-year investment plan at cost of €208.80 million (7.43 percent of 2024 GDP) that is currently being executed.  
  - Investment plan—main projects (2024–28):  
    - Electricity Generation: 97.62 Millions of EUR — 3.47 Percent of 2024 GDP  
    - Transmission: 45.01 Millions of EUR — 1.60 Percent of 2024 GDP  
    - Distribution (electricity): 8.34 Millions of EUR — 0.30 Percent of 2024 GDP  
    - Heating Generation: 9.70 Millions of EUR — 0.35 Percent of 2024 GDP  
    - Heating Distribution: 19.56 Millions of EUR — 0.70 Percent of 2024 GDP  
    - Mobility Electric charge: 1.32 Millions of EUR — 0.05 Percent of 2024 GDP  
    - Mobility: 2.03 Millions of EUR — 0.07 Percent of 2024 GDP  
    - Waste Environment: 0.70 Millions of EUR — 0.02 Percent of 2024 GDP  
    - Efficiency: 10.32 Millions of EUR — 0.37 Percent of 2024 GDP  
    - General Digitalization: 9.34 Millions of EUR — 0.33 Percent of 2024 GDP  
    - Others: 4.86 Millions of EUR — 0.17 Percent of 2024 GDP  
    - Total: 208.80 Millions of EUR — 7.43 Percent of 2024 GDP
- Public debt and green financing: all public debt issues since 2021, amounting to EUR1.175 billion, provide financing to be used under the “Green, social and Sustainability Framework”. Green bonds help allocate funds to climate policies.

### CPAT (Climate Policy Assessment Tool) methodology and application
- Tool description: CPAT toolkit (jointly developed by the IMF and the World Bank) is a “model of models” covering over 200 countries to estimate economic and non-economic effects of climate mitigation policies; four components: mitigation, distribution, air pollution, transport. The paper focuses on the CPAT mitigation model due to data limitations.
- CPAT mitigation model specifics:  
  - Reduced-form macro-energy model estimating impacts on energy consumption, prices, GHGs by sector, local air pollutants, revenue, GDP, and welfare.  
  - Uses projections of income growth and fuel prices to project energy consumption across sectors (power, residential, transport, industries) and energy sources (fossil fuels, other non-renewables, renewables).  
  - Distinguishes energy consumption in power, industry, transport, buildings, and other sectors; distinguishes energy sources by fossil fuels and electricity.
- Energy demand equation (model description): sector-specific demand for energy source E is driven by change in usage of energy-consuming products, change in energy consumption rate in that sector, and previous sectoral demand. Rewritten form includes growth effect, exogenous technical change effect (less rebound), and price effect (own price elasticity, endogenous efficiency, rebound).
- Energy efficiency parameter: autonomous annual energy efficiency improvement parameter captures productivity gains from technical efficiency improvements and capital turnover. Examples cited: between 2020 and 2020 vehicle efficiency improved by 1.7 percent; residential buildings 1.3 percent annually; power plants: coal 0.5 percent annual productivity growth; natural gas, nuclear, hydro 1 percent; renewables observed productivity growth rate of 5 percent. In CPAT baseline, energy efficiency parameter set at around 0.5–1 percent annually and varied across sectors/fuels. Scenario analysis increases this parameter.

### CPAT results and scenario findings
- High-level conclusion: achieving decarbonization in Andorra requires a significant increase in the carbon tax and very ambitious efficiency gains. Comparison made versus a net zero by 2050 path.
- Specific scenario for decarbonization: increase the carbon tax to €150 per ton by 2030 accompanied by efficiency gains of at least 5 percent in the power, transport, and residential sectors.  
  - Caveat: 5 percent efficiency gains may be too ambitious with existing technologies and current pace of innovation; transport emissions are largely exogenous and dominant, requiring major overhaul of the transport system (including reduction in absolute number of vehicles transiting in the country and transition to cleaner transport for locals and tourists).
- Carbon tax alone: insufficient to achieve carbon neutrality in Andorra; pricing tools alone fail to reduce emissions rapidly in advanced economies where income and price elasticities of energy are low.
- Macroeconomic and consumption implications of a carbon tax of €150 per ton by 2030 (with and without efficiency gains):  
  - Fiscal revenues from fossil fuel excises estimated to reach between 0.5–0.8 percent of GDP depending on efficiency gains.  
  - Impact on GDP growth estimated to be limited (model does not account for potential impact on fuel tourism).  
  - Energy price changes: carbon tax could lead to an over 100 percent increase in oil prices; other sources of energy expected to increase between 26 and 61 percent depending on energy type.
- Scenario visuals (CPAT outputs summarized): total energy consumption by sector under different scenarios; fiscal revenues from fossil fuel excises over time; GDP impacts by year; energy price changes for €150/tCO2 in 2030 (weighted by consumption).

### Selected numerical results and price impacts (as presented)
- Carbon tax and regional comparisons:  
  - Andorra carbon tax: €30 per ton CO2 (half assumed by the government).  
  - Regional average: €42 per ton CO2.  
  - IMF cited floors/benchmarks: USD75 per ton CO2 (reduce emissions by 29 percent by 2030 in advanced economies); €120 per ton CO2 needed in 2030 to decarbonize by 2050 in euro area countries.
- FEDA investment plan cost: €208.80 million (7.43 percent of 2024 GDP).
- Fiscal revenue estimate range from carbon tax scenario: between 0.5–0.8 percent of GDP.
- Energy price change examples (weighted by consumption, for €150/tCO2 in 2030): described qualitatively as over 100 percent increase in oil and between 26 and 61 percent for other energy types.
- Tabulated fuel price entries (as presented in the source):  
  - Gasoline — US$ per liter — 1.49 1.89 26%  
  - Diesel — US$ per liter — 1.27 1.72 35%  
  - LPG — US$ per liter — 0.66 0.95 44%  
  - Kerosene — US$ per liter — 0.69 1.12 61%  
  - Oil — US$ per barrel — 65.31 40.51 115%  
  - Electricity — US$ per kwh — 0.01 0% (entries presented in source graphics)  
  - Coal / Natural gas — US$ per gigajoule (GJ) — entries presented in source graphics (e.g., 13.35; 18.34; 49% in source visuals)

### Policy discussion and recommendations
- Assessment: Andorra’s climate change strategy is ambitious and comprehensive on mitigation, but adaptation measures need strengthening and acceleration.  
- Financing gaps: some elements have identified funding (FEDA’s investment plan is the most concrete); the Green Fund aids allocation but may need scaling up. Gradual but proactive increases in the carbon tax could help achieve decarbonization.  
- Complementarity of tools: pricing tools need to be complemented with large-scale energy efficiency improvements. Efficiency gains of at least 5 percent may be unrealistic with current technologies; the transport sector is a major emissions source and relies heavily on fossil fuels from foreign cars subject to owners’ country regulations. Therefore:  
  - Major transformation of the transportation sector is essential, including reducing reliance on fuel tourism.  
  - Ramp up renewable energy deployment.  
- Adaptation urgency: accelerate adaptation policy design and implementation given dependence on winter tourism; assess feasibility and estimated costs of adaptation policies because structural transformations and infrastructure needs are challenging and costly. Diversification of tourism across the year and reducing seasonality are priorities but require slow and resource-intensive structural change.

*sipea2025153 - 18.      The authorities are also working on other sectors contributing to climate change, even*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/selected-issues-papers/2025/english/sipea2025153.pdf_
