## tarea2024006

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [tarea2024006](https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/tar/2024/english/tarea2024006.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/files/publications/tar/2024/english/tarea2024006.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/files/publications/tar/2024/english/tarea2024006.pdf.json)

---

### Preface — Mission and participants
- IMF Fiscal Affairs Department (FAD) in-person mission to Yerevan from May 2 to May 12.
- Mission objectives:
  - Identify bottlenecks in execution of large foreign-funded investment projects.
  - Support development of an Action Plan to strengthen the public investment management (PIM) institutional framework and practical implementation of planning, budgeting, implementing, and monitoring of large capital projects.
- Mission team:
  - Led by Mr. Ian Hawkesworth (FAD).
  - Included Mr. Pierre Messali (FAD expert).
- Principal Armenian counterparts and stakeholders met:
  - Deputy Finance Ministers: Mr. Eduard Hakobyan, Mr. Avag Avanesyan, Mr. Vahan Sirunyan.
  - Ministry of Finance: Mr. Argam Aramyan; Ms. Ruzanna Gabrielyan; Ms. Marine Meliqyan; Ms. Tamara Ghalayan; Mr. Suren Minasyan.
  - Ministry of Economy: Ms. Ani Ispiryan; Ms. Lilya Sirakanyan.
  - Ministry of Territorial Administration and Infrastructure (MTAI): Mr. Armen Manukyan; Ms. Gohar Karakhanyan; Mr. Hrayr Harutyunyan.
  - Ministry of Health: Mr. Hayk Khurshudyan; Mr. Yervand Elibekyan.
  - Audit Chamber, Sustainable Urban Development Investment Program, Armenian Territorial Development Fund.
  - International financial institutions: World Bank, Asian Development Bank, French Development Agency (AFD).
- Support and logistics:
  - Thanks to Mr. Mehdi Raissi (IMF Resident Representative) and Mr. Vahram Janvelyan (IMF Local Economist).
  - Interpreters: Ms. Marietta Sahakyan and Ms. Lilit Simonyan.

### Executive Summary — Key findings
- Report scope:
  - Analyzes current public investment practices in Armenia; covers historical background, bottlenecks and solutions for domestically and foreign financed projects, and presents a multiyear Action Plan.
- PFM and PIM institutional context:
  - MTEF introduced in 2003.
  - Performance-based budgeting (PBB) introduced in 2017.
  - PFM strategy in place; current version covers 2019-2023.
  - PIM decree adopted in 2021 and substantially amended in 2023.
  - The PIM decree introduces a unified planning methodology for domestic and foreign finance but does not address allocation and implementation phases governed by the Budget System Law (BSL).
- Execution performance and pipeline:
  - Investment performance: steady execution of domestically financed capital expenditure; large swings in execution of externally financed projects.
  - There are 20 large projects off track in terms of implementation delays (Annex 6).
    - This represents almost half of all ongoing projects and almost 70 percent in terms of value (USD) of all projects.
  - Since 2021, 40 Project Concept Notes (PCNs) have been prepared.
    - 16 were submitted and assessed by the Public Investment Committee (PIC).
      - 10 could proceed to the feasibility study (FS) stage.
      - 5 were rejected outright.
      - 1 was approved for immediate implementation (urgent project).
    - 24 projects remain waiting for PIC approval.
  - The new PIM process has not yielded any new ordinary projects ready for inclusion in the budget for 2024.

### Principal conclusions and reform focus
- Authorities have established enabling PFM/PIM legal and institutional frameworks; the core challenge is implementation and capacity building for the new PIM procedures.
- Many issues overlap across domestically and externally financed projects, especially monitoring and evaluation.
- The report supports the Government in meeting two structural benchmarks under the Stand-by Arrangement with the IMF:
  1. Develop an action plan to strengthen the PIM institutional framework and processes, identifying bottlenecks across planning, budgeting, implementing, and monitoring large capital projects.
  2. Conduct a study to identify bottlenecks in the execution of foreign funded projects.

### Recommendations — Selected (timing and lead actors)
- Domestic financed projects
  - Ensure consistency of the definition of public investments across laws and regulations guiding PIM to eliminate misunderstandings on the implementation of the new PIM decree.
    - Time/Importance: Q4 2023 / High
    - Actor: MoF, MoE
  - Require that all investment projects above 1 billion Armenia Dram (AMD), regardless of funding source, submit a project concept note as part of their budget submission to ensure MoF and MoE have sufficient information.
    - Time/Importance: Q1 2025 onwards / High
    - Actor: MoF, MoE
  - Adopt a gradual approach to implementing the new planning procedures in the 2023 PIM Decree to avoid congestion and build capacity.
    - Time/Importance: Q4 2023 / High
    - Actor: MoE, MoF
  - Redesign the institutional framework for project monitoring to ensure timely and accurate information supporting decision-making on non-performing projects.
    - Time/Importance: Q4 2023 onwards / High
    - Actor: MoF, MoE, DPM
  - Strengthen availability of information on public investment projects by addressing fragmentation of data.
    - Time/Importance: Q2 2024 / Medium
    - Actor: MoF, MoE, LMs
  - Strengthen capital budgeting by better integrating PIM with planning and strategic documents, the MTEF, and PBB.
    - Time/Importance: Q3 2024 / Medium
    - Actor: MoF, MoE, LMs

- Externally financed projects
  - Develop one or two pilot projects in close coordination with one or more development partners to identify possible upgrades to the PIM decree, regulations, procedures, tools, and processes.
    - Time/Importance: Q4 2023 / High
    - Actor: MoF, MoE, DPM
  - Strengthen the existing monitoring framework underpinning implementation of externally financed projects to better identify delays and take corrective action.
    - Time/Importance: Q1 2024 / High
    - Actor: MoF, MoE
  - Identify actions to enhance regulatory and institutional enabling environment for complex projects, targeting specific implementation issues.
    - Time/Importance: Q4 2023 / Medium
    - Actor: MoF, MoE, DPM

### PIM process overview — historical background and institutional roles
- Recent reforms:
  - MTEF introduced in 2003.
  - PBB legislative framework introduced in 2017 and first applied for fiscal year 2019.
  - PFM strategy current version covers 2019-2023.
  - PIM decree adopted in 2021 and substantially amended in 2023, aligning broadly with international standards.
- Stakeholders and roles:
  - Prime Minister (PM) and Prime Minister’s Office (PMO).
  - Ministry of Economy (MoE): secretariat of the Public Investment Committee (PIC) and gatekeeper of the planning phase; scrutinizes all proposals prior to PIC decisions.
  - Ministry of Finance (MoF): responsible for allocation phase and monitoring of domestically financed projects.
  - Public Investment Committee (PIC): chaired by PM, includes MoF and MoE, decides whether projects proceed through planning phases and are accepted/ranked within the official project pipeline.
- PIMA 2018 core weaknesses echoed:
  - Weak link between planning documents and investment decisions.
  - Fragmented and low credibility of the investment budget framework.
  - Non-comprehensive information on capital expenditure.
  - Weak project management framework and limited performance audit capacity.

### PIC decision-making, MCA appraisal, and thresholds
- PIC composition and process:
  - Chaired by the Prime Minister; composed of the Deputy Prime Minister, the Chief of Staff of the PM, the Minister of Economy, and the Minister of Finance.
  - Secretariat held by the MoE; PIC meets at least three times a year; PM has casting vote in case of equality.
  - Decisions: (i) approving, (ii) rejecting (definitely), or (iii) sending back for further development.
- MCA scoring:
  - Uses a multicriteria analysis (MCA) with six criteria: five qualitative and one quantitative (EIRR).
  - Coefficient per criterion from 0 to 3; aggregated scoring scale: 17 (highest) to 3 (lowest).
  - Quantitative EIRR scoring: 1 (from 0.1 percent to 5 percent of the base rate) to 3 (15 percent more than the base rate); score 0 if EIRR not calculated or less than 0.1 percent than the base rate.
  - Base rate for EIRR: 6 percent for projects in health and education sectors and 9 percent for projects in other sectors.
- Coverage thresholds:
  - PIC oversees all new projects above a threshold of AMD 1 billion.
  - For projects prepared in 2024 to be included in the 2025 budget the threshold is AMD 1 billion. For those prepared in 2023 to be included in the 2024 budget the threshold is temporarily fixed to AMD 3 billion.
- Implementation outcomes (Projects Prepared in 2021−22 under the PIM Decree):
  - A. Prepared since 2021 by LM: 40
  - B. Of these submitted and assessed by the PIC: 16
    - C. Approved for Feasibility Study: 10
    - D. Rejected: 5
    - E. Urgent project approved for direct implementation: 1
  - F. Waiting for initial PIC submission (A-C-D-E): 24
  - G. Ordinary projects to be included in the 2024 budget: none

### MCA strengths and implementation challenges
- Strength: MCA-based scoring and ranking is "a commendable initiative."
- Challenges:
  - Weighing of subjective assumptions is difficult.
  - Relying on only six criteria may distort assessment across sectors.
  - EIRR introduced at the PCN stage is "not in line with international practices" which recommend EIRR at later appraisal stages.
  - The Decree does not impact budgeting decisions; PIC ranking may be ignored.

### Definitions, legal consistency, and recommended legal amendments
- Problem: Absence of coherent legal definition of an investment project in the BSL and PIM decree slows PIM reform; new projects are often misclassified as ongoing.
  - Example: New contracts for segments of the North-South Corridor were presented as ongoing projects during the 2024 budget preparation process, whilst being in fact new projects according to the PIM decree.
- Legislative inconsistencies:
  - PBB classification treats programs and projects interchangeably; PIM decree is aligned with GFS but does not govern budgeting.
  - PIM decree does not include “replacement of depreciated asset” in its definition of investment expenditure; this is "not in line with GFS."
- Recommended amendments:
  - Amend the PIM decree by removing the phrase "...or replacing an existing depreciated asset..." from the definition of Public investment project.
  - Amend the BSL (Article 1.2., part 3) by adding: "Capital expenditures with defined objectives and results within a specific time period and structured by an underlying contract or legal document constitute a capital project."

### IT systems, data issues, and IFMIS recommendations
- Main IT/data issues:
  - Fragmented information across MoE and MoF; two different lists of projects not easily reconciled.
  - Insufficient granularity: capital projects often classified as budget programs at a higher level; poor non-financial information; no geographic financial information.
  - Externally financed projects reported only if budgeted in MoF system; MoE reports projects not yet budgeted.
  - Reporting of externally financed projects based on PIU successor units transferred semi-manually (generally through Excel sheets).
- Recommended IT solution:
  - Develop a full-fledged IFMIS with a PIM module to record expenses and provide real-time detailed reporting for both domestically and externally financed projects.
  - Upgrade and align budget classification of investment expenditures and projects with GFS and PBB international practices.
  - Use results of the on-going PEFA to define new requirements and align the updated IFMIS accordingly.

### Integration with MTEF and PBB
- Risks:
  - Slow implementation of the new PIM process could undermine the MTEF and PBB frameworks.
- Integration issues:
  - Projects identified case-by-case and budgeted under separate MTEF ceilings; does not ensure multiyear budgeting or inclusion of operating costs.
  - PBB lacks a three-level program classification (program, sub-program, project activity level), causing projects to be mixed with sub-programs.
- Short-term proposals:
  - Adopt a gradual approach to PIM Decree implementation.
  - Require PCNs for on-going projects above AMD 1 billion to prevent misclassification.
  - Pilot MCA implementation with selected Line Ministries.

### Project execution, monitoring, PIU history, and capacity gaps
- Monitoring fragmentation:
  - MoF Budget Department monitors domestically financed projects quarterly; PMO monitors externally financed projects with quarterly meetings with development partners.
  - Monitoring is limited in non-financial data and not set up to support corrective decision-making.
- PIU history:
  - PIUs were disbanded in 2018; some transformed into "foundations." MoF PIU fully disbanded, leaving a capacity gap.
  - Discontinuation weakened technical capacity in engineering, design, contracting, approvals with development partners; high staff turnover; language barriers.
- Monitoring effectiveness:
  - Execution rates "abnormally low" for externally financed projects compared to domestically financed projects.
  - No regulatory requirement to re-assess feasibility study when significant changes occur.
  - Planned MoF Monitoring and Evaluation Unit in Budget Department should support data gathering, analysis, follow up, and integration of MoF and PMO monitoring tracks.

### Enhancing domestically financed PIM — capacity building and transitory reforms
- Strategic focus:
  - Concentrate reforms where capacity limitations are most acute.
  - Continue support to Line Ministries on PCN preparation and feasibility studies; MoE needs capacity to assess feasibility studies.
  - Capacity building via dedicated staff, coaching, or embedded advisors.
  - Training for MoE to score projects using MCA; pilot MCA with three LMs.
- Short-term transitory solutions and thresholds:
  - The 2023 PIM decree sets project cost thresholds:
    - AMD 3 billion for proposals prepared in 2023 to be included in the 2024 budget (temporary).
    - AMD 1 billion for projects prepared in 2024 to be included in the 2025 budget and beyond.
  - Concern: "This AMD 1 billion threshold is too low for infrastructure projects, especially under the existing capacity constraints, risking that a backlog of projects will develop."
  - Recommendation: Extend the duration of the AMD 3 billion threshold by one year (2024 projects for 2025 budget) to allow additional time to build capacity.
  - Numeric note: AMD 3 billion is "Approximately $2.6 million."

### Monitoring and evaluation — institutional design and practical steps
- Proposed redesign:
  - Establish a project monitoring and evaluation unit at the MoF Budget Department to support MoF and PMO monitoring roles in a unified manner.
  - Launch a stock take on samples of low performing projects above AMD 3 billion to identify typology of systemic risks.
  - Develop proactive monitoring framework and criteria for when feasibility studies should be re-reviewed.
  - Publish an online early warning dashboard and improve transparency of project progress.
  - Strengthen Audit Chamber to undertake performance (value-for-money) audits in line with INTOSAI standards (ISSAI 300).
- Example system: Malaysia Project Monitoring System II (SPP II) — features weekly/monthly/yearly reports, S-curve early warnings, GIS module, lessons-learned matrix.

### Externally financed projects — drivers of under-execution and reforms
- Key drivers of under-execution:
  - Limited implementation capacity, weak strategic planning, slow decision-making, frequent changes in project management staff, tender delays, currency fluctuations, Covid pandemic, war in Nagorno-Karabakh.
  - Discontinuation of PIUs weakened implementation capacity.
- Importance of external financing:
  - External resources funded approximately 90 and 60 percent, respectively, of the total capital budget in the 2018 and 2022 budgets.
- Reforms:
  - Integrate donor-related complexities into the PIM cycle; ensure early referral to development partners and financing for preparatory works.
  - Strengthen project preparation capacity across all stages.
  - Streamline approvals, permits, access to sub-soil infrastructure information, and address long judicial delays for expropriation and resettlement (waiting times "up to two years").
  - Establish structured processes and a one-stop forum for decision-makers to resolve implementation bottlenecks.

### Case example — Yerevan Solid Waste Project (YSWP)
- Timeline and facts:
  - Agreement between EU/EBRD and Government/City of Yerevan signed in 2014; construction had not commenced by spring 2023.
  - Benchmark completion period for this type of project: 4.5 years.
- Causes of delay:
  - New contract type (Design, Build, Operate concession) with little market knowledge.
  - Initial consultant failed to complete assignment; re-tendering caused several years' delay prior to tendering.
  - Bid evaluation took 16 months; bid committee had 10 members.
  - Exogenous factors: Covid Pandemic, the war with Azerbaijan, change of Mayor of Yerevan.
  - Bidding cancelled due to only one bidder; project being restructured and decision pending on contract type.

### Annex 3 — Timeline for gradual implementation of the PIM Decree (selected)
- Proposed Amendments timeline (years shown as in source):
  - 2023: Extending the 2023 AMD 3 bn threshold to 2024 for new projects — "3bn"
  - 2024: "3bn"
  - 2025: "1bn"
  - 2026: "1bn"
  - 2027: "1bn"
- PCN required when proposing on-going projects above AMD 1 bn threshold:
  - 2023: "no"
  - 2024: "no"
  - 2025: "yes"
  - 2026: "yes"
  - 2027: "yes"
- Piloting the MCA implementation:
  - 2023–2025: "Pilot"
  - 2026: "Full Scale"
  - 2027: "Full Scale"

### Annex 1 — Selected Draft Action Plan items (high-level highlights)
- I. Strengthening the PIM Legal and Regulatory Framework
  - Adopt gradual approach to implementing new procedures of the 2023 PIM Decree.
  - Extend to the 2025 budget the AMD 3 billion threshold above which projects must follow new PIM procedures.
  - Amend part 3 of article 1.2. of the Budget Systems Law to define the concept of investment project consistent with PIM decree.
  - Amend the 2023 PIM Decree in line with GFSM: article 1.3.2 by removing the sentence “…or replacing an existing depreciated asset”.
- II. Strengthening PIM Budgeting and Planning Process
  - Require all investment projects above AMD 1 billion, regardless of funding, to submit project concept note.
  - Develop a PBB codification of projects based on an ad hoc sequential list.
  - Strengthen integration of PIM with planning/strategic documents, the MTEF, and PBB during the 2025 budgeting process.
  - Develop one or two pilot projects in coordination with one or more development partners.
  - Undertake a study of PIU-successor units to precisely identify capacity gaps.
- III. Stronger PIM Implementation and Monitoring
  - Redesign institutional framework for project monitoring for domestic and foreign financed projects.
  - Establish project monitoring and evaluation unit at MoF Budget Department.
  - Task the MoF unit to: enhance monitoring frequency and detail; publish an online dashboard; determine realistic spendability of requested funds.
  - Establish periodic meetings between DPM, MoF, MoE, LMs and relevant development partners to review non-performing projects.
  - Launch a stock take on low performing projects above AMD 3 billion.
  - Propose Audit Chamber expand scope toward public investment performance audits.
- IV. Cross cutting solutions
  - Include a PIM module in the on-going design of the IFMIS.
  - Develop a comprehensive capacity enhancement plan for all key PIM stakeholders; steering committee led by PM, MoE, MoF, and development partners (observers).
  - Continue capacity building support for MoE, MoF, DPM’s office, LMs for completing PCNs for the 2025 budget.

*IMF Technical Assistance Report — Preface and Executive Summary (tarea2024006)*

### Preface ____________________________________________________________________________ 6

### Preface

### Mission and participants
- IMF Fiscal Affairs Department (FAD) in-person mission to Yerevan from May 2 to May 12.
- Mission objectives:
  - Identify bottlenecks in execution of large foreign-funded investment projects.
  - Support development of an Action Plan to strengthen the public investment management (PIM) institutional framework and practical implementation of planning, budgeting, implementing, and monitoring of large capital projects.
- Mission team:
  - Led by Mr. Ian Hawkesworth (FAD).
  - Included Mr. Pierre Messali (FAD expert).
- Principal Armenian counterparts and stakeholders met:
  - Deputy Finance Ministers: Mr. Eduard Hakobyan, Mr. Avag Avanesyan, Mr. Vahan Sirunyan.
  - Ministry of Finance: Mr. Argam Aramyan; Ms. Ruzanna Gabrielyan; Ms. Marine Meliqyan; Ms. Tamara Ghalayan; Mr. Suren Minasyan.
  - Ministry of Economy: Ms. Ani Ispiryan; Ms. Lilya Sirakanyan.
  - Ministry of Territorial Administration and Infrastructure (MTAI): Mr. Armen Manukyan; Ms. Gohar Karakhanyan; Mr. Hrayr Harutyunyan.
  - Ministry of Health: Mr. Hayk Khurshudyan; Mr. Yervand Elibekyan.
  - Audit Chamber, Sustainable Urban Development Investment Program, Armenian Territorial Development Fund.
  - International financial institutions: World Bank, Asian Development Bank, French Development Agency (AFD).
- Support and logistics:
  - Thanks to Mr. Mehdi Raissi (IMF Resident Representative) and Mr. Vahram Janvelyan (IMF Local Economist).
  - Interpreters: Ms. Marietta Sahakyan and Ms. Lilit Simonyan.

### Key findings from the Executive Summary
- Report scope:
  - Analyzes current public investment practices in Armenia.
  - Covers historical background, bottlenecks and solutions for domestically and foreign financed projects, and presents a multiyear Action Plan.
- PFM and PIM institutional context:
  - MTEF introduced in 2003.
  - Performance-based budgeting (PBB) introduced in 2017.
  - PFM strategy in place; current version covers 2019-2023.
  - PIM decree adopted in 2021 and substantially amended in 2023.
  - The PIM decree introduces a unified planning methodology for domestic and foreign finance but does not address allocation and implementation phases governed by the Budget System Law (BSL).
- Execution performance and project pipeline:
  - Investment performance: steady execution of domestically financed capital expenditure; large swings in execution of externally financed projects.
  - There are 20 large projects off track in terms of implementation delays (Annex 6).
    - This represents almost half of all ongoing projects and almost 70 percent in terms of value (USD) of all projects.
  - Since 2021, 40 Project Concept Notes (PCNs) have been prepared.
    - 16 were submitted and assessed by the Public Investment Committee (PIC).
      - 10 could proceed to the feasibility study (FS) stage.
      - 5 were rejected outright.
      - 1 was approved for immediate implementation (urgent project).
    - 24 projects remain waiting for PIC approval.
  - The new PIM process has not yielded any new ordinary projects ready for inclusion in the budget for 2024.
- Key systemic issues identified:
  - Definitions and classification:
    - Challenges around definitions of investment expenditures, projects, programs.
    - New projects being classified as ongoing projects, bypassing PIM scrutiny.
  - Budgeting and planning:
    - Budgeting for new projects may not reflect PIC approved amounts and can be more optimistic (i.e., lower), undermining MTEF validity and PBB usefulness.
  - Monitoring and implementation capacity:
    - Project monitoring responsibilities split between MoF and Prime Minister’s Office (PMO) with insufficient capacity and information.
    - Monitoring not set up to support decision-making for corrective action.
    - Discontinuation of Project Implementation Units (PIUs) has weakened implementation capacity; MoF is establishing a Monitoring and Evaluation Unit in its Budget Department to address this.
  - Information systems:
    - Issues with IT systems and fragmented data hinder comprehensive PIM information.

### Principal conclusions and reform focus
- Authorities have established enabling PFM/PIM legal and institutional frameworks; the core challenge is implementation and capacity building for the new PIM procedures.
- Many issues overlap across domestically and externally financed projects, especially monitoring and evaluation.
- The report supports the Government in meeting two structural benchmarks under the Stand-by Arrangement with the IMF:
  1. Develop an action plan to strengthen the PIM institutional framework and processes, identifying bottlenecks across planning, budgeting, implementing, and monitoring large capital projects.
  2. Conduct a study to identify bottlenecks in the execution of foreign funded projects.

### Recommendations (selected, with timing and lead actors)
Domestic financed projects
- Ensure consistency of the definition of public investments across laws and regulations guiding PIM to eliminate misunderstandings on the implementation of the new PIM decree.
  - Time/Importance: Q4 2023 / High
  - Actor: MoF, MoE
- Require that all investment projects above 1 billion Armenia Dram (AMD), regardless of funding source, submit a project concept note as part of their budget submission to ensure MoF and MoE have sufficient information.
  - Time/Importance: Q1 2025 onwards / High
  - Actor: MoF, MoE
- Adopt a gradual approach to implementing the new planning procedures in the 2023 PIM Decree to avoid congestion and build capacity.
  - Time/Importance: Q4 2023 / High
  - Actor: MoE, MoF
- Redesign the institutional framework for project monitoring to ensure timely and accurate information supporting decision-making on non-performing projects.
  - Time/Importance: Q4 2023 onwards / High
  - Actor: MoF, MoE, DPM
- Strengthen availability of information on public investment projects by addressing fragmentation of data.
  - Time/Importance: Q2 2024 / Medium
  - Actor: MoF, MoE, LMs
- Strengthen capital budgeting by better integrating PIM with planning and strategic documents, the MTEF, and PBB.
  - Time/Importance: Q3 2024 / Medium
  - Actor: MoF, MoE, LMs

Externally financed projects
- Develop one or two pilot projects in close coordination with one or more development partners to identify possible upgrades to the PIM decree, regulations, procedures, tools, and processes.
  - Time/Importance: Q4 2023 / High
  - Actor: MoF, MoE, DPM
- Strengthen the existing monitoring framework underpinning implementation of externally financed projects to better identify delays and take corrective action.
  - Time/Importance: Q1 2024 / High
  - Actor: MoF, MoE
- Identify actions to enhance regulatory and institutional enabling environment for complex projects, targeting specific implementation issues.
  - Time/Importance: Q4 2023 / Medium
  - Actor: MoF, MoE, DPM

### Overview of the PIM process (Historical Background — key points)
- Recent PFM reforms that strengthened PIM institutions/processes:
  - MTEF introduced in 2003.
  - PBB legislative framework introduced in 2017 and first applied for fiscal year 2019.
  - PFM strategy current version covers 2019-2023.
  - PIM decree adopted in 2021 and substantially amended in 2023, aligning broadly with international standards.
- Investment performance dynamics:
  - Alternating under- and over-execution of public investment across periods (PIMA 2018): under before 2015 and from 2018 onwards; over-execution in 2015-2017.
  - Over-execution in 2015-2017 driven by cost overruns, catch-up of delayed works (e.g., North-South Highway Tranche 2 implemented in 2016 resulting in more than 100 percent over-execution), and faster-than-expected tender outcomes.
  - Slowdown in execution coincided with disbandment of PIUs.
- Main stakeholders and roles:
  - Prime Minister (PM) and Prime Minister’s Office (PMO).
  - Ministry of Economy (MoE): secretariat of the Public Investment Committee (PIC) and gatekeeper of the planning phase; scrutinizes all proposals prior to PIC decisions.
  - Ministry of Finance (MoF): responsible for allocation phase and monitoring of domestically financed projects.
  - Public Investment Committee (PIC): chaired by PM, includes MoF and MoE, decides whether projects proceed through planning phases and are accepted/ranked within the official project pipeline.
- PIMA 2018 identified core weaknesses across the PIM cycle:
  - Weak link between planning documents and investment decisions due to inconsistencies in content and horizons of planning documents and mismatch with MTEF resources.
  - Fragmented and low credibility of the investment budget framework: multiyear ceilings for domestically financed projects not binding and separate decision-making for externally financed projects.
  - Non-comprehensive information on capital expenditure: failure to consolidate project information in a single database; Integrated Financial Management Information System (IFMIS) setup behind schedule.
  - Weak project management framework: ineffective rules for reprioritizing non-performing projects; lack of a centralized structure with mandate to reprioritize complex projects; limited performance audit capacity (Audit Chamber focused on financial audit).

*IMF Technical Assistance Report — Preface and Executive Summary (tarea2024006)*

### 6. The 2018 PIMA report also provided a set of recommendations grouped around eight main

### 6. The 2018 PIMA report also provided a set of recommendations grouped around eight main

### Summary of 2018 PIMA recommendations (Table 1)
- Planning
  1. Improve the hierarchical structure of investments strategy document to: (i) define consistent planning horizons; (ii) ensure consistency of project information; and (iii) include resource envelop constraints.
  2. Develop a unified appraisal methodology to ensure comparability across all major projects regardless of financing sources or implementers.
- Allocation
  3. Establish the MoF’s power to challenge the project cost estimate baselines and require reappraisal of the projects for reprioritization when their budgets are persistently under- or over-executed.
  4. Amend the Budget System Law to establish restrictions on in-year adjustments to capital expenditure.
  5. Establish a project selection process based on a “gateway” approach, where the central agency has a veto on all major projects at the project concept and appraisal stages, together with a centralized pipeline of projects, which have been ranked and selected.
- Implementation
  6. Improve the system and capacity for public procurement associated with capital projects.
  7. Establish a constraint on in-year changes in project implementation plans and complete the transformation of the Audit Chamber from the Control Chamber.
- Cross-Cutting issues
  8. Establish in the MoF a dedicated unit covering all domestic and externally financed projects, in order to ensure that projects are consistently appraised and selected prior to funding negotiations and inclusion in the budget.

### IMF FAD follow-up TA (November 2019 and November 2021) — key proposals
- 2019 report proposed:
  - assigning functions, roles, and responsibilities to the PIM stakeholders (Deputy Prime Minister, MoE, MoF and Line-ministries);
  - strengthening the appraisal methodology at preparation and selection stages of projects; and,
  - setting-up a framework for budgeting and monitoring projects.
- 2021 report covered:
  - the PIM decree issued in May 2021 and flagged inconsistencies in the project preparation process and limited scope that does not rule the allocation and implementation phases after projects have been included in the pipeline;
  - the potential conflicting results of both the PIM and Program Based Budgeting (PBB) when aligning budgeting and prioritization of projects by focusing on results (inputs, outputs, and outcomes).

### Reforms adopted and institutionalization
- Main reforms adopted:
  - adoption of a PIM decree in 2021, amended in early 2023, defining a methodology to appraise and select projects broadly in line with international standards; the decree covers many of the eight recommendations of the PIMA report (in particular, recommendations 2 and 5) and gives the MoE a leading role in the PIM process;
  - the 2003 amendment of the Budget System Law (BSL) to introduce a Medium-term Expenditure Framework (MTEF) and the 2017 amendment to introduce a Program-Based Budget system (PBB);
  - adoption of the PFM Strategy 2019 aimed at strengthening links between the PIM process (including PPP) and the budget and MTEF, though implementation is lagging.
- 2023 PIM decree institutionalizes the PIM process further and establishes a Public Investment Committee (PIC) chaired by the Prime Minister. The PIC oversees preparation from a standardized Project Concept Note (PCN) until inclusion in the project pipeline prior to budgeting (Annex 2).
- Coverage threshold:
  - PIC oversees all new projects, regardless of form and financing, above a threshold of AMD 1 billion.
  - For projects prepared in 2024 to be included in the 2025 budget the threshold is AMD 1 billion. For those prepared in 2023 to be included in the 2024 budget the threshold is temporarily fixed to AMD 3 billion.

### Limits and legal/regulatory gaps
- The 2023 Decree does not cover the allocation and implementation phases of the PIM cycle, which remain governed by the 2017 BSL procedure.
- There is no legal obligation to include projects approved and ranked in the PIC pipeline in the budget; the BSL does not prevent projects from being budgeted without prior examination through the PIM process.
- No unified legal cross-reference between the PIM decree and the BSL; government justification is that they rule different procedures (PIM: technical/financial project requirements; BSL: budgeting according to global fiscal objectives).
- No new procedure to monitor execution of projects with a portfolio optimization focus.
- Urgent projects and projects involving state secrets are excluded from the PIM procedure; one project has been deemed urgent.

### Institutional roles and responsibilities (overview)
- Public Investment Committee (PIC)
  - Chair: Prime Minister (PM).
  - Role: gatekeeper for the planning phase; decides movement from PCN to feasibility study, appraisal, and inclusion in the prioritized pipeline.
  - Plays no role in allocation phase nor in spending decisions regarding continuation of ongoing projects.
- Prime Minister
  - Chairs PIC and is responsible for monitoring implementation of foreign financed investment projects; this monitoring is essentially discussion-based with no dedicated supporting staff.
- Ministry of Economy (MoE)
  - Secretariat of the PIC.
  - Ensures documentation quality for PIC decisions.
  - Responsible for conducting the MCA used for appraising projects and submits analysis to the PIC for scoring and ranking.
- Ministry of Finance (MoF)
  - Fiscal guardian; monitors implementation of domestically financed projects.
  - Checks financial estimates and fiscal affordability as a member of the PIC.
  - Responsible for the budgeting phase governed by the BSL and for monitoring and evaluation of domestically financed projects; setting up a dedicated unit in the MoF Budget Department.
- Line Ministries (LMs)
  - Propose projects and develop project documentation; must include PIC-vetted projects in initial budget submission, but budgeting then becomes negotiation with the MoF.
  - Submit financial and non-financial implementation reports to the MoF and the PM.
  - Current quality of documents and level of analysis is weak.

### PIC decision-making, appraisal and scoring details (Box 1)
- Composition
  - PIC chaired by the Prime Minister; composed of the Deputy Prime Minister, the Chief of Staff of the PM, the Minister of Economy, and the Minister of Finance.
  - Secretariat held by the MoE; PIC meets at least three times a year; PM has casting vote in case of equality.
- Functions and scoring methodology
  - PIC responsible for preselection stages of new public investment projects (above AMD 3 billion in 2023 and AMD 1 billion from 2024).
  - Decisions at each stage: (i) approving, (ii) rejecting (definitely), or (iii) sending back for further development.
  - Uses a multicriteria analysis (MCA) with six criteria: five qualitative (impact on human capital; significance for public service delivery; strategic compliance with official plans; impact on climate change; risk assessment including climate risks) and one quantitative (EIRR).
  - EIRR definition: “a preliminary financial and economic analysis - preliminary systematic assessment of the financial and economic costs and benefits of the draft project, based on available data and/or preliminary research aimed at assessing the financial and economic viability of the draft project, including the economic internal rate of return (EIRR).”
  - Scoring rules:
    - Coefficient attributed to each criterion from 0 to 3 (3 best, 0 lowest).
    - Quantitative EIRR scoring: 1 (from 0.1 percent to 5 percent of the base rate) to 3 (15 percent more than the base rate); score is 0 if EIRR not calculated or less than 0.1 percent than the base rate.
    - Base rate for EIRR: 6 percent for projects in health and education sectors and 9 percent for projects in other sectors.
    - Aggregated scoring scale: 17 (highest) to 3 (lowest).
  - PIC also decides on projects that should be implemented in PPP format (in practice after the (pre)-feasibility study stage).
  - Decisions of the PIC are valid for three years; if not budgeted during this period, the project must follow the procedure again, including a new feasibility study.

### Capacity challenges and current implementation outcomes
- Progress to date (Table 3: Projects Prepared in 2021−22 under the PIM Decree — all domestically financed)
  - A. Prepared since 2021 by LM: 40
  - B. Of these submitted and assessed by the PIC: 16
    - C. Approved for Feasibility Study: 10
    - D. Rejected: 5
    - E. Urgent project approved for direct implementation: 1
  - F. Waiting for initial PIC submission (A-C-D-E): 24
  - G. Ordinary projects to be included in the 2024 budget: none
- Observations and risks
  - The 10 projects approved by the PIC to move to the feasibility study stage are small or medium sized and mostly equipment purchases; most are not complex infrastructure projects except one penitentiary construction.
  - Risk that only a few projects will complete the planning phase, creating a backlog and undermining credibility of the new process — risk heightened if projects that previously avoided PIM are required to use it or if complex projects enter the process.
  - Suggested mitigation: gradually phase in mandatory use of the PIM process by project size.
- Capacity constraints
  - MoE PIM unit has experienced high staff turnover and remains understaffed.
  - Line Ministries lack experience preparing and managing large and complex projects; historically these were externally financed and managed by PIUs until 2018.
  - Training of LMs has begun but needs continuation.
  - The MoE’s scrutiny has filtered a relatively high number of proposals: seven returned to LMs prior to PIC submission and five rejected by the PIC after submission; one project deemed urgent.
- Status of new projects for 2024 budget
  - No ordinary new projects have been yielded by the new PIM process for inclusion in the 2024 budget.

*IMF Technical Assistance Report (excerpts provided in the source content).*

### 22. The Multi-Criteria Analysis (MCA) as defined by the PIM decree to appraise projects is

### 22. The Multi-Criteria Analysis (MCA) as defined by the PIM decree to appraise projects is

### MCA-based appraisal: strengths and implementation challenges
- The MCA-based scoring and ranking of projects by the MoE prior to submission to the PIC is "a commendable initiative."
- Implementation challenges in Armenia:
  - The weighing of subjective assumptions for project appraisal can be difficult.
  - Relying on only six criteria for appraising a project, even when including advanced quantitative measures such as EIRR, "may distort the assessment of projects in different sectors."
  - The ranking of the PIC may be ignored entirely because "the Decree does not impact the budgeting decision."
  - Many countries choose to gradually phase in the usage of MCA given these challenges.
- Note on EIRR: "The introduction of the EIRR criteria by the decree at the PCN stage is not in line with international practices which recommend introducing this concept only at the later stage of appraisal, when all the necessary technical and economic data are available."

### Definitions, legal consistency, and proposed corrections
- Problem: Absence of a coherent legal definition of an investment project in the BSL and PIM decree slows PIM reform.
  - New project proposals are frequently and mistakenly classified by LMs and the MoF as ongoing projects, exempting them from the PIM process.
  - Example: "New contracts for segments of the North-South Corridor were presented as ongoing projects during the 2024 budget preparation process, whilst being in fact new projects according to the PIM decree."
- Legislative inconsistency:
  - The PBB classification treats programs and projects interchangeably or presents a project linked to a program as on-going while it may be a new project (new contract, new financing).
  - The 2023 PIM decree's definition is in line with GFS, but it "does not govern the budgeting process which is ruled by the BSL."
  - The PIM decree does not include “replacement of depreciated asset” in its definition of investment expenditure; this is "not in line with GFS."
- Recommended legal amendments:
  - Amend the PIM decree by removing the phrase "...or replacing an existing depreciated asset..." from the definition of Public investment project (Box 2 recommendation).
  - Amend the BSL (Article 1.2., part 3) by adding: "Capital expenditures with defined objectives and results within a specific time period and structured by an underlying contract or legal document constitute a capital project."

### IT systems, data granularity, and reconciliation issues
- Main issues:
  - The current information system for capital expenditures is fragmented across the MoE and the MoF, undermining the quality and availability of project information.
  - MoF’s system records budget execution for budgeted projects; MoE’s registers projects not yet budgeted — resulting in two different lists of projects that are not easily reconciled.
  - Insufficient granularity of project-level data:
    - Capital projects often classified as budget programs at a higher level of aggregation.
    - Non-financial information about projects is either poor or missing.
- Box 3: Characteristics of existing IT systems
  - MoF System:
    - Centralized budget execution reporting system linked to the payment system and available on-line.
    - Capital expenditures reported with uneven degree of details; program and project classifications often conflated.
    - Externally financed projects reported only if budgeted.
    - Poor reporting of non-financial information and no geographic financial information.
    - Reporting of externally financed projects based on data from PIU successor units, transferred semi-manually (generally through Excel sheets).
  - MoE System:
    - Reports advancement of projects life-cycle until inclusion in the pipeline (stages of execution and for some projects expenses reporting).
    - Reports externally financed projects either budgeted or not, based on PIUs reports.
- Recommended IT solution:
  - Develop a full-fledged IFMIS with a PIM module to record expenses and provide real-time detailed reporting for both domestically and externally financed projects.
  - Upgrade and align budget classification of investment expenditures and projects with GFS and PBB international practices.
  - Use results of the on-going PEFA to define new requirements and align the updated IFMIS accordingly.
  - "The IFMIS PIM module should also be aligned with normal practice."

### Integration with MTEF and PBB frameworks
- Risk: Slow implementation of the new PIM process could undermine the MTEF and PBB frameworks and compromise further reforms.
- Key integration issues:
  - Many investment projects are identified and approved on a case-by-case basis and then budgeted under MTEF ceilings determined separately; this does not ensure multiyear budgeting of projects or inclusion of future operating costs.
  - PBB integration issues:
    - Investment projects are defined as sub-programs ("measures"), and may conflict with program classification for larger projects that are often classified as programs themselves.
    - Good PBB practice requires a three-level program classification: program, sub-program, and project (activity level). Armenia lacks this activity level so projects are mixed with sub-programs.
    - Integration of capital expenditures and subsequent operational expenditures should be done within each program at the project level; this is difficult if projects are not properly identified.
- Historical relevance: "The 2019 and 2021 FAD TA reports’ findings ... remain valid and their recommendations essential to linking the on-going reforms."

### Project execution, monitoring, and PIU-related capacity gaps
- Monitoring fragmentation:
  - MoF’s Budget Department monitors domestically financed projects quarterly based on execution reports from LMs and the MoF IT system; reporting of non-financial data is limited.
  - The PM’s Office monitors externally financed projects (including physical performance) with information from LMs and PIU successor units and coordinates quarterly meetings with development partners.
  - Some monitoring is undertaken at the individual and project portfolio levels in LMs.
- PIU history and consequences:
  - PIUs were disbanded in 2018; some transformed into government-owned "foundations."
  - Discontinuation of PIUs weakened project implementation capacity; the MoF PIU was fully disbanded leaving a capacity gap.
  - Consequences included weakened technical capacity in engineering, design, contracting, approvals with development partners, high staff turnover, and an increasingly cautious administrative culture due to an anti-corruption drive.
  - Language barriers for staff at implementing units have become an issue in certain places.
- Monitoring effectiveness:
  - Project execution monitoring does not support corrective decision-making; limited reformulation of nonperforming projects suggests portfolio reviews are not effective.
  - Execution rates are "abnormally low" for externally financed projects compared to domestically financed projects.
  - There is no regulatory requirement to re-assess the feasibility study when significant changes in project scope or key assumptions occur.
  - The planned monitoring and evaluation unit in the MoF budgeting department should support data gathering, analysis, follow up, and integration of the two monitoring tracks (MoF and PM Office).

### Enhancing domestically financed PIM: capacity building and transitory reforms
- Strategic focus:
  - Reforms should concentrate where capacity limitations are most acute.
  - LMs should continue to receive support on PCN preparation and feasibility studies, including drafting Terms of Reference for commissioning studies to specialized firms.
  - MoE needs capacity to assess and evaluate the quality of feasibility studies; World Bank is supporting MoE in developing methodology expected to underpin a forthcoming ministerial instruction.
  - Capacity building should focus on dedicated staff, possibly via coaching or embedded advisors.
  - Training is also needed for MoE to score projects using MCA; experience will improve PIC decision-making quality and speed and reduce backlog.
- Short-term transitory solutions:
  - Adopt a gradual approach to implementation of the 2023 PIM decree to avoid backlog while improving project preparation quality.
  - Thresholds in the PIM decree:
    - The 2023 PIM decree sets a project cost threshold of AMD 3 billion as the threshold above which proposals prepared in 2023 for the 2024 budget must follow the new process; threshold is lowered to AMD 1 billion for the 2025 budget and beyond.
    - Concern: "This AMD 1 billion threshold is too low for infrastructure projects, especially under the existing capacity constraints, risking that a backlog of projects will develop."
    - Recommendation: Extend the duration of the current threshold of AMD 3 billion by one year (2024 projects for 2025 budget) to allow additional time to build capacity within MoE and LMs.
    - Numeric note: AMD 3 billion is "Approximately $2.6 million."
  - Require all projects to develop a concept note (PCN) at the beginning of the budgeting stage:
    - Currently projects presented as on-going to the MoF are not required to be supported by a PCN, preventing MoF from checking whether alleged on-going projects are actually new.
    - Proposal: Require all projects to be presented with a concept note using the PIM Decree’s standardized template; to be consistent with the PIM Decree, threshold to produce a PCN for on-going projects should be fixed at AMD 1 billion.
  - Pilot MCA implementation:
    - Undertake pilot cases to gain experience using MCA.
    - Government could require three LMs to use MCA methodology at full scale and make it optional for remaining LMs during the pilot period; an informed decision on methodology adjustments to follow the pilot.
- Proposed legislative amendments (excerpt from Table 4):
  - 2023 PIM decree Article 2: Amend to extend AMD 3 billion threshold implementation into 2024 (for the 2025 budget) and lower to AMD 1 billion in 2025; rationale: "This will allow a more gradual implementation of the new process and will avoid additional bottlenecks."

*IMF Technical Assistance Report | 20–25*

### Annex 3

### Annex 3

### Timeline for gradual implementation of the PIM Decree
- Proposed Amendments of PIM decree timeline (years shown as in source):
  - 2023: Extending the 2023 AMD 3 bn threshold to 2024 for new projects — "3bn"
  - 2024: "3bn"
  - 2025: "1bn"
  - 2026: "1bn"
  - 2027: "1bn"
- PCN required when proposing on-going projects above AMD 1 bn threshold:
  - 2023: "no"
  - 2024: "no"
  - 2025: "yes"
  - 2026: "yes"
  - 2027: "yes"
- Piloting the MCA implementation:
  - 2023–2025: "Pilot"
  - 2026: "Full Scale"
  - 2027: "Full Scale"
- Quoted policy text excerpts:
  - "starting in 2025 for on-going projects worth of AMD 1 billion or more."
  - 2023 PIM decree amendment: "New article 50 bis: Articles 46 to 50 will be implemented on a pilot basis in three Line Ministries designated by ministerial instruction from 2024 to 2026 and will be optional for the other Line Ministries."

### Integrating PIM and budgeting (Medium- to Long-Term Structural Solutions)
- Key findings:
  - Current program budget classification hinders consistent identification of capital projects within programs and should be revised.
  - A comprehensive program classification reform would be complex and lengthy.
  - 2021 FAD TA recommended a temporary ad hoc numerical coding for each individual project from a pre-established sequential list; this recommendation has not yet been implemented.
  - A technical constraint of the budget IT system (2-digits, i.e., going beyond 99 projects) prevents integration of the ad hoc list; the Treasury IT system at the MoF accepts 4-digit information and MoF officials were positive about this possibility.
  - "But, until now, no project has reached the stage of appraisal and MCA."
- Principles for integrating PIM, PBB and MTEF:
  - Reflect estimated multiyear cost of projects in MTEF and annual budget, including relevant operating costs.
  - MTEF ceilings should include accurate estimates costs of on-going projects and approved new projects.
  - Budgeting of projects needs best possible assessment of costs contained in a project pipeline database.
  - PCN template requires project’s investment and current costs to be included.
  - Ensure project cost approved by the PIC are also budgeted by the MoF; all adjustments must be documented and explicitly approved by the MoF.

### Project monitoring and evaluation
- Orientation and institutional design:
  - Monitoring should be more oriented towards problem solving.
  - A new MoF unit should develop a monitoring framework and tools in close collaboration with the Prime Minister’s Office (PMO) responsible for foreign financed projects.
  - Recommendation that the new unit become the monitoring and evaluation unit for all investment projects, harmonize standards across the public sector, and provide hands-on support to Line Ministry (LM) implementing units—mirroring the original role of the MoF’s now disbanded PIU.
  - The PMO should expand from monitoring external projects to providing support when bottlenecks are encountered—becoming a one-stop-shop for problems requiring high-level political push.
- Implementation steps:
  - Start with a stock take and review of investment projects, irrespective of financing, selecting a sample to identify systemic execution-stage risks and draw a typology of risks by criteria (sector, financing, design, procurement, etc.).
  - Develop criteria for when a project’s feasibility study should be reviewed by the PIC or Government given significant changes in specifics of the project and/or project assumptions.
  - Proactive project monitoring should proceed in parallel with PIM IFMIS improvements, including a PIM module.
  - Development of a published early warning dashboard recommended.
- Audit and ex-post review:
  - Strengthen and upgrade ex-post review of investment spending by the Audit Chamber.
  - Current Audit Chamber (AC) work program largely focused on financial audit; performance (value-for-money) audit coverage is limited.
  - AC could launch a general review on public investment spending; to date no review of public investment included in the annual audit plan.

### Example: Malaysia Project Monitoring System II (SPP II)
- System features highlighted:
  - Generates monitoring reports weekly, monthly, yearly to provide condensed view of progress and status of all projects irrespective of funding.
  - Focuses on identifying project risks monthly and empowers project managers and central agencies to act quickly.
  - Uses California Expenditure Curve (S-curve) principle: percentage of time lapsed versus percentage of money spent to generate early warnings.
  - Includes Geographic Information System Module for physical location and regional monitoring.
  - Produces problem identification report to compile lessons-learned matrix; reports are simple to interpret by technical, financial personnel and politicians.
- Source caption in text: "Source: Malaysia PIMA 2017, IMF, FAD."

### Recommendations (executive summary of C. Recommendations)
- Recommendation 1:
  - Ensure consistency of the definition of public investments across laws and regulations guiding PIM to eliminate misunderstandings on implementation of the new decree.
  - Authorities should amend the BSL and PIM Decree as indicated in Box 3 and Annex 1.
- Recommendation 2:
  - Ensure MoF and MoE have sufficient information on new and ongoing investment projects by requiring all investment projects above AMD 1 billion in LMs’ budget requests, regardless of funding source, to submit a project concept note.
  - "The provision should take place in 2025." PIM Decree should be amended as indicated in Table 4, measure 2 and Annex 1.
- Recommendation 3:
  - Adopt a gradual approach to implementing new procedures of the 2023 PIM Decree, in particular the MCA methodology.
  - Amend PIM Decree as indicated in Table 4, measures 1 and 3 and develop a capacity enhancement program; see Annex 1.
- Recommendation 4:
  - Redesign institutional framework for project monitoring to ensure timely and accurate information that supports decision-making on non-performing projects. This entails:
    - (i) establish a project monitoring unit at the Budget Department (MoF) as part of its ongoing functional reorganization;
    - (ii) launch a stock take on a sample of low performing projects (including externally financed) above AMD 3 billion;
    - (iii) develop a pro-active projects monitoring framework;
    - (iv) update the PIM Decree with criteria for when a project’s feasibility study should be reviewed by the PIC;
    - (v) extend the scope of audit of the Audit Chamber for investment projects.
- Recommendation 5:
  - Strengthen information availability on public investment projects by addressing data fragmentation and ensuring consistency between PIM and PBB, including:
    - (i) implementation of a PIM module with the future IFMIS;
    - (ii) develop a temporary PBB codification to better identify projects.
- Recommendation 6:
  - Strengthen capital investments budgeting by better integrating PIM with planning and strategic documents, the MTEF, PBB and the budget process during 2025, referencing recommendations IV.1.a. of the 2019 FAD TA report and 3.3 and 3.6 of the 2021 FAD TA report.

### Enhancing the PIM process for externally financed projects
- Key drivers of under-execution:
  - Under-execution mainly driven by limited implementation capacity, not by limited financing or need to hit fiscal targets as in 2017.
  - Identified institutional weaknesses: weak strategic planning, slow decision-making by project-sponsoring agencies, frequent changes in project management staff, frequent delays in tender procedures, low implementation capacity.
  - Additional factors: changing macro assumptions that impact input costs, slow communication with development partners, currency fluctuations reducing available financing on projects under construction, Covid pandemic and the war in Nagorno-Karabakh.
  - Discontinuation of PIUs has weakened government project implementation capacity.
- Importance of external financing:
  - External resources funded approximately 90 and 60 percent, respectively, of the total capital budget in the 2018 and 2022 budgets.
- Reforms to overcome bottlenecks:
  - Better integrate donor-related complexities into the PIM project cycle; donor-funded projects are often large, complex, multiyear and subject to both country and development partner procedures (e.g., procurement, project adjustments).
  - Address gaps in knowledge on project safeguards and English language proficiency in PIU successor units.
  - Strengthen project preparation capacity across stages: initial concept → feasibility study → design → structuring → tendering → award.
  - Streamline processes for approvals, permits, and access to pre-existing sub-soil infrastructure information; address long judicial delays for expropriation and resettlement (noted waiting times "up to two years").
  - Establish structured processes (with high-level support and cross-stakeholder representation) for identifying issues and solutions, and focus on straightforward fixes such as a forum with decision-makers, government commitment to deadlines on contractor inquiries, enhanced transparency and e-procurement.

### Case example: Implementation difficulties with Yerevan Solid Waste Project (YSWP)
- Timeline and facts:
  - Agreement between EU/EBRD and Government/City of Yerevan signed in 2014; construction had not commenced by spring 2023.
  - Benchmark completion period for this type of project: 4.5 years.
- Causes of delay:
  - Design, Build, Operate concession contract was new to Armenia in the sector; little market knowledge on scope and bidding.
  - Initial consultant failed to complete assignment, necessitating re-tendering and causing several years' delay prior to tendering.
  - Bid evaluation took 16 months; bid committee had 10 members which complicated agreement.
  - Exogenous factors: Covid Pandemic, the war with Azerbaijan, change of Mayor of Yerevan.
  - Bidding cancelled due to only one bidder; project being restructured to be more marketable with a decision pending on contract type (e.g., BTO).
- Source for this box: "Source: EBRD April 2023"

*IMF Technical Assistance Report — Annex 3*

### Box 8. New York City Capital Process Reform Task Force

### Box 8. New York City Capital Process Reform Task Force

### Task Force purpose and composition
- Mayor Eric Adams convened a Capital Process Reform Task Force in April 2022 to undertake a comprehensive review of the city’s capital process and to develop recommendations for reform with the goals of reducing project completion time, saving taxpayer money, enhancing participation, and building capacity.
- The Task Force consisted of individuals with different expertise in the capital process, including construction contractors, design professionals, labor leaders, City agencies, and the City Comptroller.
- The Task Force was managed by the Mayor’s Office of Policy and Planning.
- Work was organized by six working groups focused on: Project Pipeline; Reform Procurement; Streamline Approvals; Public Participation; Manage Projects More Effectively; Performance Management and Reporting.

### Task Force recommendations (December 2022)
- lowering some thresholds for central approvals;
- allowing new contract types;
- cutting redundant regulation around procurement;
- better e-bidding;
- frontloading some payments so contractors have a buffer for delays in permitting;
- allowing changes to contracts under a streamlined process in certain cases (e.g., as a result of new technology, safety enhancements, better future maintenance);
- streamlined and standardized invoice checklists;
- better project implementation tracking.

### Coordination with utilities
- The Task Force identified particular challenges around coordination with utility companies and suggested that senior city officials host regular meetings with senior utility company executives to enhance coordination and avoid project delays.

### Status of recommendations
- Most recommendations have been accepted, some of which require legal reform at the State level.

*Source: https://www.nyc.gov/assets/home/downloads/pdf/press-releases/2022/CP-Reform-Task-Force.pdf and https://www.nyc.gov/assets/home/downloads/pdf/press-releases/2023/CP_ReformTaskForce.pdf*

---

### Monitoring of externally financed projects — key findings (paragraph 48)
- Monitoring for externally financed projects is anchored with the PM’s Office; for domestically financed projects it is with the MoF.
- An upgrade of the project implementation and monitoring framework across those two institutions along with enhancements of technical and human capacity is needed to develop a problem-solving capacity.
- There is no national guidance or procedure for when to reevaluate the feasibility of the project in light of significant changes in the assumptions.
- Development partners’ investment frameworks could somewhat mitigate this if they provide for a systematic restructuring process in relevant cases.
- The PIM decree (Art. 13) specifies feasibility studies have a validity of three years only.
- Experience shows assumptions may turn out to be faulty well within such a timeframe.
- There is a lack of public transparency about project progress, with limited access to project information for stakeholders and the public.
- There is little focus on identifying problems early to take corrective action.
- It is important that the proposed Monitoring Unit in the MoF’s Budgeting Department becomes operational as soon as possible and can provide secretarial service to the MoF and PMs Office when undertaking project monitoring.

### Related recommendations in the report
- Develop one or two pilot projects in close coordination with one or more development partners to demonstrate that the PIM process works for large and complex projects and, if necessary, identify upgrades to the PIM decree, other regulation, procedures, tools, and processes that can enhance the outcomes of externally financed projects. (Recommendation 7)
- Strengthen the monitoring framework underpinning the implementation of externally financed projects to better identify delays in implementation, take corrective actions, and support decision making. The monitoring framework upgrade should happen in a unified manner with the domestically financed projects. (Recommendation 8)
- Identify actions to enhance the regulatory and institutional enabling environment for the implementation of complex projects. (Recommendation 9)

---

### Annex 1 — Selected Draft Action Plan items (high‑level highlights)
- General sequencing covers 2023, 2024, 2025 with quarter-level planning.
- I. Strengthening the PIM Legal and Regulatory Framework
  - Adopt a gradual approach to implementing the new procedures of the 2023 PIM Decree to enable stakeholders to better understand and put in practice the new requirements for project preparation.
  - Extend to the 2025 budget the AMD 3 billion threshold above which projects must follow the new PIM procedures, including having the approval from the PIC.
  - Amend part 3 of article 1.2. of the Budget Systems Law to define the concept of investment project consistent with the definition of the PIM decree article 1.3.2. Proposed insertion: “Capital expenditures with defined objectives and results within a specific time period and structured by an underlying contract or legal document constitute a capital project”.
  - Amend the 2023 PIM Decree in line with GFSM: article 1.3.2 by removing the sentence “…or replacing an existing depreciated asset”.
- II. Strengthening PIM Budgeting and Planning Process
  - Ensure MoF and MoE have access to information on new and ongoing investment projects to appropriately allocate budget resources.
  - Require all investment projects above AMD 1 billion, and regardless of their form or funding, to submit project concept note as per the template in the PIM Decree.
  - Develop a PBB codification of projects based on an ad hoc sequential list of projects.
  - Strengthen integration of PIM with planning/strategic documents, the MTEF, and PBB during the 2025 budgeting process.
  - Develop one or two pilot projects in coordination with one or more development partners (a relevant partner could be the EU) to pilot new project preparation procedures. (Rec. 7)
  - Undertake a study of the PIU-successor units to precisely identify capacity gaps (responsibilities, procedures, resources, project management skills, language, and other personal skills).
  - Take stock of potential bottlenecks between the PIM decree and development partners’ processes, including:
    - i. ensure government-identified projects for external financing are referred to the selected partner at a sufficiently early stage and with sufficient commitment;
    - ii. secure financing of preparatory works (feasibility study, appraisal, inclusion in the pipeline, and budgeting for domestic financing) in line with each actor’s internal procedures;
    - iii. update the PIM decree if necessary to remove legal uncertainty that may undermine development partner participation.
  - Consider piloting the MCA with support of 3 LMs to determine whether the methodology needs further refinement.
- III. Stronger PIM Implementation and Monitoring
  - Redesign institutional framework for project monitoring for domestic and foreign financed projects to ensure strong project implementation, corrective action, and realistic budgeting.
  - Establish a project monitoring and evaluation unit at the MoF Budget Department to support PM’s and MoF’s monitoring role in a unified manner.
  - Re-establish MoF responsibility to harmonize standards and support LMs/foundations throughout the project cycle, anchored in the new monitoring and evaluation unit.
  - Task the MoF monitoring and evaluation unit to:
    - i. enhance monitoring in terms of frequency and detail of problem projects;
    - ii. publish an online dashboard on project progress compared to the original baseline as set out in the PIC decision and what actions have been taken in response;
    - iii. determine whether the national funds, donor funds, that a LM is requesting will realistically be spent taking into consideration the LMs implementation performance in recent years.
  - Establish periodic meetings between DPM, MoF, MoE, LMs and relevant development partners to review and decide on non-performing projects and regulatory changes.
  - Launch a stock take on a sample of low performing projects (including externally financed) above AMD 3 billion to identify a topology of systemic risks and key delay factors.
  - Enhance the PM’s Office procedure to help implementation of projects that are not on track (“one-stop shop”).
  - Improve monitoring by developing a pro-active monitoring framework supporting decision-making for corrective measures for all funding sources and develop criteria for when a project’s feasibility study should be re-submitted.
  - Develop better reporting templates on externally financed projects in close coordination with development partners and use these to create an early warning procedure for problem projects.
  - Propose the Audit Chamber (AC) expand the scope of its current risk-based methodology toward public investment projects by focusing on both financial and non-financial performance indicators and consider conducting performance audits in line with INTOSAI standards (ISSAI 300).
  - Undertake a study of implementing units, local governments, and LMs to identify greatest regulatory barriers (licenses/permits, infrastructure information, expropriation rules). The Deputy PM, supported by the MoF, should lead the work, develop a strategy and workplan and monitor implementation.
- IV. Cross cutting solutions for enhancing the PIM Process
  - Include a PIM module in the on-going design of the IFMIS.
  - Develop a comprehensive capacity enhancement plan and program for all key PIM stakeholders. A steering committee led by the PM, MoE, MoF, and development partners (observers) should establish a clear program containing a theory of change, deliverables, and timelines.
  - Continue capacity building support for MoE, MoF, DPM’s office, LMs for completing PCNs for the 2025 budget.
  - Undertake capacity building actions to create in-house competences at the AC for investment projects’ audits.
  - Key components of the program should include:
    - i. a curriculum covering management, technical, soft skills (language);
    - ii. alignment with university programs;
    - iii. guidance, manuals, tools, and a community of practice;
    - iv. a system for validation of the skills attained (examination).

*Italic: IMF Technical Assistance Report*

### Annex 2. PIM Process According to 2023 Decree

### Annex 2. PIM Process According to 2023 Decree

### Process overview
- High-level sequence: Identification & Feasibility Study → Quality Check
- Pre-Selection stage precedes formal identification

### Roles and validation
- LM (Line Ministry)
- PIC (Project Implementation Center)
- LM (validates)
- MoE (Ministry of Economy)
- MoF (Ministry of Finance)

### Documents and stages
- Draft Concept note
- Concept Note
- ToRs for Feasibility Study
- Feasibility Study

*Annex 2. PIM Process According to 2023 Decree — IMF Technical Assistance Report*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/tar/2024/english/tarea2024006.pdf_
