## tarea2024029

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [tarea2024029](https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/tar/2024/english/tarea2024029.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/files/publications/tar/2024/english/tarea2024029.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/files/publications/tar/2024/english/tarea2024029.pdf.json)

---

### Preface — mission, team, and stakeholder engagement
- Mission type: Public Investment Management Assessment (PIMA) and Climate PIMA (C-PIMA).
- Mission dates: September 27 to November 10, 2022.
- Lead: Eivind Tandberg.
- Team members: Cristian Alonso (remotely), Jacques Charaoui, Tjeerd Tim (all FAD), Mia Pineda (LEG), Katja Funke, Ed Hearne (both FAD experts).
- External contributors: Nataliya Biletska, Hosam Hasan, Mohamed Yehia Abd El Karim (all World Bank), Dina Mohamed Eldemerdash Elkhishin (World Bank consultant).
- Local reception: Mr. Ahmed Kamaly (Deputy Minister for Planning Affairs, MPED) and Mr. Ahmed Kouchouk (Vice-Minister for Fiscal Policies, MoF).
- Presentation of preliminary conclusions: presented to Mr. Ahmed Kamaly, Mr. Ahmed Kouchouk, and Dr. Mohamed Maait, Minister of Finance.
- Stakeholder meetings: MoF units (Macro-Fiscal Policy Unit, General Budget Department, Economic Authorities and Units Budget Department, Financing Department, Debt Management Unit, Accounts and Financial Directorates Department, Final Accounts Department, PPP Central Unit); MPED units; multiple line ministries and agencies including Ministry of Agriculture, Ministry of Environment, Ministry of International Cooperation, Ministry of Transport, Ministry of Housing, Utilities and Urban Communities, Ministry of Health, Ministry of Education, Ministry of Petroleum and Mineral Resources, Egyptian Natural Gas Holding Company, Accountability State Authority (ASA), National Investment Bank (NIB), New Urban Communities Authority (NUCA), National Telecom Regulatory Authority, Egyptian Water and Wastewater Regulatory Agency, Egyptian Electricity Utility and Consumer Protection Agency, Gas Regulatory Authority, National Centre for Planning State Land Uses (NCPSLU), General Authority for Government Services, Cairo Governorate, Ismailia Governorate.
- Additional engagement: local technical and financial partners; interpreters and IMF resident staff support acknowledged.

### Executive summary — key findings
- Vulnerability and exposure
  - Egypt is highly vulnerable to climate change and at high risk from natural hazards, primarily due to dependence on the Nile River.
  - Egypt ranked 107th of 182 countries in the 2021 ND-Gain Country Index.
  - The densely populated Nile Delta is one of the world’s three “extreme” vulnerability hotspots.
  - Projected climate risks: sea level rises, droughts, increased frequency and intensity of extreme weather events (heat waves, sand and dust storms, heavy rain, flash floods, rockslides).
  - Potentially affected sectors: energy, water management, agriculture, tourism, health, fisheries, coastal zones, the Suez Canal.

- National commitments and planning
  - Egypt’s updated NDC includes quantitative target: reduce Green House Gas (GHG) emissions of the three major GHG-emitting sectors (energy, transport, and oil) by 23.5 percent by 2030 compared to business-as-usual (BAU).
  - NDC adaptation objectives: focus on vulnerable sectors and developing a climate adaptation plan (at an early stage).

- Demographics and fiscal constraints
  - Egypt’s population is expected to grow by 44 percent from 2022 to 2050.
  - More than 50 percent of the population expected to live in urban environments.
  - Authorities indicate high investment needs and limited ability to finance them; better public investment management can improve climate outcomes for a given resource envelope.

### C-PIMA overall findings
- Scope: C-PIMA assesses five public investment management practices from a climate change perspective; conducted jointly with a standard PIMA.
- General assessment
  - Improvements made in climate-aware planning and coordination across the public sector.
  - Initial steps taken to reflect climate change issues in appraisal and selection of investment projects.
  - Significant work remains: climate change is not fully integrated in national, sectoral, construction, and spatial planning frameworks and regulations.
  - Coordination of climate-relevant public investments largely limited to central government; PPP framework does not address climate risks.
  - Limited progress on climate-sensitive budgeting, portfolio management, and fiscal risk management: climate-related investment spending not systematically identified in budgets; no disaster risk management plan; fiscal risk statement does not include climate impacts on infrastructure.

### Summary assessment by phase/institution
- C1 Climate-aware planning
  - Institutional Strength: MEDIUM.
  - Reform priority: Medium
- C2 Coordination between entities
  - Institutional Strength: MEDIUM.
  - Reform priority: Medium
- C3 Project appraisal and selection
  - Institutional Strength: MEDIUM.
  - Reform priority: Medium
- C4 Budgeting and portfolio management
  - Institutional Strength: LOW.
  - Reform priority: High
- C5 Risk management
  - Institutional Strength: LOW.
  - Reform priority: High

### Principal recommendations (three main recommendations and selected time-bound activities)
1. Integrate strategies and objectives for climate change adaptation and mitigation in national, sectoral, construction and spatial planning processes
   - Actions:
     - Publish a climate change chapter in the public investment plans (2024).
     - Develop centralized guidance and support to agencies for the preparation and costing of climate-aware public investment strategies (2023 – 24).
     - Integrate national climate objectives and climate-related capital projects in sectoral plans (2024 – 25).
     - Integrate climate change in construction codes, and urban and spatial planning processes (2023 – 25).
   - Priority: Medium
   - Responsible: MPED, MoE, in coordination with other agencies.

2. Reflect climate change considerations more comprehensively in project selection, budgeting, and portfolio management decisions
   - Actions:
     - Identify climate-related investment spending in plans and budgets (2023 – 24).
     - Introduce more detailed climate change-related methodologies for conducting project appraisal (2024).
     - Carry out and publish ex-post reviews of climate impacts of investment projects (2024).
     - Create a register of key infrastructure assets including information on their exposure to climate change-related risks (2024 – 25).
   - Priority: High
   - Responsible: MPED, MoF, in coordination with MoE and other agencies.

3. Strengthen management of climate-related fiscal risks
   - Actions:
     - Assess and monitor climate-related risks on key infrastructure assets (2025).
     - Expand the Fiscal Risks Statement to include climate-related fiscal risks (2024).
     - Develop comprehensive climate and disaster risk management plan (2023 – 25).
     - Consider need for additional financing mechanisms to manage climate risks (2024 – 25).
   - Priority: High
   - Responsible: MoF, MPED, in coordination with MoE.

### NCCS 2050 goals and costing (Box 1)
- National goals (selected examples)
  - Goal 1: Sustainable economic growth and low-emissions development (increase renewable energy share, reduce GHG from fossil fuels, increase energy efficiency, sustainable production and waste management).
  - Goal 2: Adaptive capacity and resilience to climate change (protect citizens' health, minimize loss and damage to assets and ecosystems, develop resilient infrastructure and services, implement disaster risk reduction systems, strengthen women's response considerations).
  - Goal 3: Climate change action governance (define roles and responsibilities, improve international climate profile, sectoral policy reforms, enhance institutional/procedural/legal arrangements).
  - Goal 4: Climate financing infrastructure (promote local green banking, green credit lines, green bonds, private sector engagement, green jobs).
  - Goal 5: Scientific research, technology transfer, knowledge management, awareness (strengthen research and technology transfer, disseminate climate-relevant knowledge).

- NCCS 2050 estimated program costs (units: Million USD)
  - Mitigation program costs:
    - Industry 130
    - Electricity 144,153
    - Petroleum 1,689
    - Transport 57,477
    - Civil Aviation 25
    - Housing and Utilities 31
    - Waste 7,627
    - Required funding 211,133
  - Adaptation program costs:
    - Agriculture 52,400
    - Transport 1,273
    - Civil Aviation 9
    - Irrigation, Water Resources 59,108
    - Biodiversity 199
    - Required funding 112,990

### Section II — Climate PIMA framework (overview)
- C1. Climate-aware planning: Is public investment planned from a climate change perspective?
- C2. Coordination between entities: Is there effective coordination across central government, subnational governments (SNGs), public corporations (PCs) and private sector entities?
- C3. Project appraisal and selection: Do project appraisal and selection include climate-related analysis and criteria?
- C4. Portfolio management and oversight: Is climate-related investment spending subject to active management and oversight?
- C5. Risk management: Are fiscal risks relating to climate change and infrastructure incorporated in budgets and fiscal risk analysis and managed according to a plan?

### Detailed assessment — C1 to C5 (findings and reform priorities)

- C1. Climate-aware Planning (Strength: Medium; Reform Priority: High)
  - Key findings:
    - Egypt has started incorporating climate into public investment plans, but they do not yet consider climate targets adequately.
    - NDC and NCCS 2050 contain quantitative mitigation targets and qualitative adaptation measures.
    - Unified Planning Law 18/2022 introduced approach to integrate climate into long-term, medium-term, and annual planning.
    - Environmental Sustainability Standards Guide (ESSG) provides broad guidance to identify green infrastructure projects but climate considerations/targets not fully integrated in national and sectoral public investment plans.
    - Attention focused more on mitigation than adaptation; plans lack information about costs of public investment projects and their effects on climate targets.
    - A climate vulnerability map is being developed with spatial climate change risk information up to the year 2100.
    - Limited enforcement powers for climate-relevant building codes and spatial plans; no mechanism for systematic technical or financial support to planners.
  - Reform priorities:
    - Integrate climate change adaptation and mitigation in construction codes, spatial and urban planning, and investment planning frameworks.
    - Provide centralized guidance and technical support for climate-aware investment strategies.
    - Include a climate change public investment chapter in development plans.

- C2. Coordination Between Entities (Strength: Medium; Reform Priority: Medium)
  - Key findings:
    - Coordination primarily at central government level; NCCC supervises steering climate activities; MoE serves as technical secretariat.
    - MPED mainstreaming role; ESSG guidance emphasizes mitigation over adaptation and lacks concise project classification guidance.
    - Unified Planning Law covers public sector but lacks law defining climate roles for local governments and lacks active information-sharing mechanism between government levels.
    - PC framework does not require all public corporations to develop climate strategies aligned with national climate targets.
    - Government committed to increasing green projects from 30% in 2021/22 to 50% in 2024.
  - Reform priorities:
    - Increase cross-sector and multi-level coordination.
    - Define climate responsibilities for public sector entities in legal mandates.
    - Develop information-sharing and investment coordination mechanisms between central and sub-national governments.

- C3. Project Appraisal and Selection (Strength: Medium; Reform Priority: High)
  - Key findings:
    - MPED Addendum—Guidance on Sustainability Analysis requires environmental impact assessment for each major infrastructure project including climate aspects.
    - Climate indicators include proximity to coastal areas/Nile/natural reserves, carbon footprint, energy and water use efficiency, use of renewable energy.
    - Energy and construction sectors have energy efficiency standards considered in project design.
    - Green bond framework requires standardized environmental assessment; projects for green bond financing selected from pre-selected pool; framework verified by independent external party.
    - PPP framework does not explicitly address climate-related risk allocation or contract management; PPP Law 2010 executive regulations amended to allow unsolicited private proposals using innovative technologies that reduce carbon emissions.
    - Guidance on Sustainability Analysis provides systematic approach but lacks detailed methodologies and a consistent baseline.
  - Reform priorities:
    - Develop detailed methodologies and consistent baseline for assessing climate impacts in project appraisal.
    - Integrate climate-related appraisal requirements into PPP frameworks, risk allocation, and contract management.

- C4. Budgeting and Portfolio Management (Strength: Low; Reform Priority: High)
  - Key findings:
    - Climate-related public investment expenditures are not identified in budget documents.
    - Tagging allocations would help set performance expectations, accountabilities, and could attract international climate finance or sovereign Green Bonds.
    - Recent green bond issuance mentioned a few projects but identification was not based on a definition of climate-related spending.
    - Shift to program budgeting could facilitate identification and reporting of climate-related expenditures, including PPPs and transfers.
    - Ex-post reviews are limited and have not assessed climate-related environmental impacts or exposure of infrastructure assets.
    - Asset registers exist but are not required to contain exposure or damage information due to climate change; maintenance practices are emerging.
  - Reform priorities:
    - Tag climate-related public investment expenditures in budget documents; consider program budgeting.
    - Expand ex-post review coverage to assess climate impacts and asset exposure.
    - Incorporate climate vulnerability information into asset registers; create centralized asset register and reporting responsibilities.
    - Pilot systematic monitoring of climate implications on selected key public assets.

- C5. Risk Management (Strength: Low; Reform Priority: High)
  - Key findings:
    - National Disaster Risk Management Strategy 2030 (NDRMS) mentions climate change as a risk but does not assess or address it; finalization pending.
    - Financing mechanisms targeted at managing public infrastructure exposure to climate risks have not been a focus; budget contingency reserve can be used.
    - No comprehensive fiscal risk assessment incorporating climate-related risks to public infrastructure.
    - Decentralized asset registers limit central access for consistent comprehensive risk assessment.
    - Fiscal Risk Statement has been initiated and coverage is being expanded by MoF.
  - Reform priorities:
    - Finalize assessment and integration of climate risks within the NDRMS and other frameworks.
    - Conduct comprehensive fiscal risk assessments incorporating climate-related risks to public infrastructure.
    - Develop financing mechanisms targeted at managing exposure informed by consistent assessments.
    - Centralize or ensure access to asset register information including climate vulnerability for fiscal risk analysis.

### Assessing the expected impact of climate-related risks on public infrastructure
- Overview
  - High reform priority: assess impacts and define strategies through a disaster risk management strategy and financing arrangements.
  - Need comprehensive database of key infrastructure including exposure to climate change–related implications.
  - Recommend a risk-based approach, initially focusing on particular infrastructure assets or regions with high vulnerability.
  - If assessment reveals emergency financing requirements beyond budget contingencies, explore options for specific financing mechanisms.

- Example: State Asset Insurance Scheme in Indonesia (Box 3)
  - Introduced as part of National Disaster Risk Financing and Insurance strategy (DFRI).
  - 2019: state building insurance scheme introduced for Ministry of Finance buildings; extended in 2020 to other ministries' buildings.
  - Estimated insurance value of government buildings to be covered: IDR371 trillion, approximately 13 percent of GDP.
  - Insurance premium for disaster risks estimated to be 0.2 percent of building values.
  - Plans to expand scope to include buildings, bridges, transportation modes, and other government properties.
  - Eligibility: assets in disaster-prone areas, high probability to be damaged or lost, and significant contribution to public services.

### Legal framework and institutional roles
- Legal instruments and PIM interaction
  - Newly enacted PFM law and Unified Planning Law (UPL) contain elements that may support climate-related policies: principle of sustainability, requirement for medium-term budget framework, transition to program-based budgeting.
  - Multiple laws may significantly impact PIM framework from climate perspective (list provided in source).
- Institutional roles needing clarification
  - MPED and MoF lead investment and budget planning; line ministries, economic authorities, and local administrations implement projects.
  - NCCC composed of Prime Minister and representatives; MoE technical secretariat.
  - NCCC’s and MoE’s roles in each stage of the PIM cycle lack definition; climate-related laws could more clearly set out roles of regulators of natural resources.

### IT systems, data management, and capacity building
- IT systems and tagging
  - Climate tagging not yet supported by existing IT applications.
  - Opportunities to implement tagging through reforms: program and performance budgeting (PBB) and adding tagging fields to ISIPPM to interface with GFMIS.
- Capacity building
  - Guidance on Sustainability Analysis and project appraisal for 2020 green bond were important steps.
  - Capacity building skewed toward mitigation rather than adaptation.
  - Need more capacity at all government levels to integrate climate considerations into development planning.
  - At MoF level, essential to develop capacity to monitor and mitigate climate risks, including preparing a climate section in the fiscal risk statement.

### Key recommendations (summary)
- Issue 1. Integrate strategies and objectives for climate change adaptation and mitigation in national, sectoral, construction and spatial planning processes.
  - Publish a climate change chapter in the public investment plans.
  - Develop centralized guidance and support to agencies for preparation and costing of climate-aware public investment strategies.
  - Integrate national climate objectives and climate-related capital projects in sectoral plans.
  - Integrate climate change in construction codes, and urban and spatial planning processes.

- Issue 2. Reflect climate change considerations more comprehensively in the PIM-cycle.
  - Identify climate-related investment spending in plans and budgets.
  - Introduce more detailed climate change-related methodologies for conducting project appraisal.
  - Carry out and publish ex-post reviews of climate impacts of investment projects.
  - Create a register of key infrastructure assets including information on their exposure to climate change–related risks.

- Issue 3. Strengthen management of climate-related (fiscal) risks.
  - Assess and monitor climate-related risks on key infrastructure assets.
  - Expand the Fiscal Risks Statement to include climate-related fiscal risks.
  - Develop a comprehensive climate and disaster risk management plan.
  - Consider need for additional financing mechanisms to manage climate risks.

### Appendix: Action Plan (selected actions and responsibilities; timeline columns: 2023 2024 2025)
- Recommendation 1 (Priority: Medium)
  - Publish a climate change chapter in the public investment plans. Responsible: MPED, MoE, line ministries.
  - Review and update guidelines, circulars, regulations, decrees, and acts to address mitigation and adaptation across PIM stages. Responsible: MPED, MoE, line ministries.
  - Integrate national climate objectives in sectoral plans. Responsible: MPED, line ministries.
  - Integrate climate change in construction codes and urban/spatial planning. Responsible: MoE, MPED, MoH, NCPSLU, other relevant ministries.
  - Develop centralized guidance and support for climate-aware public investment strategies. Responsible: MoE, MPED.

- Recommendation 2 (Priority: High)
  - Create a register of key infrastructure assets including exposure information and a risk monitoring system. Responsible: MEPD, relevant line ministries.
  - Identify climate-related spending and develop a climate tagging system for mitigation and adaptation in GFMIS and ISIPPM. Responsible: MPED, MoF.
  - Introduce detailed climate change–related methodologies for project appraisal, including standardized assumptions and standard shadow prices for GHGs. Responsible: MPED, MoE.
  - Carry out and publish ex-post reviews of climate impacts of investment projects; pilot reviews and use findings to refine procedures. Responsible: MPED, MoE.

- Recommendation 3 (Priority: High)
  - Assess and monitor climate-related risks on key infrastructure assets using the asset register.
  - Expand the Fiscal Risk Statement to include quantitative analysis of fiscal risks related to climate change, including long-term fiscal sustainability under different climate change scenarios and climate-related natural disasters, and quantitative assessment of discrete fiscal risks related to infrastructure assets. Responsible: MoF, MPED.
  - Develop a comprehensive climate and disaster risk management plan: register public infrastructure assets exposed to climate change risks, determine timely damage assessment and prioritization mechanisms, formalize assessment and disaster risk management procedures and allocation of roles. Responsible: MoE, MPED, Agencies responsible for disaster management.
  - Consider additional financing mechanisms to manage climate risks: assess financing needs and identify mechanisms (e.g., contingencies, credit lines, CAT bonds, prudent debt levels). Responsible: MoE, MPED, Agencies responsible for disaster management.

- Cross-cutting
  - Define roles and responsibilities for SNGs and key organizations (e.g., NCCC, MoE, NCPSLU) in each stage of the PIM cycle and formalize them in the legal framework. Responsible: MPED and MoE.

*Source: tarea2024029 - Preface (IMF | Technical Report – Egypt Climate PIMA).*

### Preface ................................................................................................................

### Preface

### Mission and team
- Mission type: Public Investment Management Assessment (PIMA) and Climate PIMA (C-PIMA).
- Mission dates: September 27 to November 10, 2022.
- Lead: Eivind Tandberg.
- Team members: Cristian Alonso (remotely), Jacques Charaoui, Tjeerd Tim (all FAD), Mia Pineda (LEG), Katja Funke, Ed Hearne (both FAD experts).
- External contributors: Nataliya Biletska, Hosam Hasan, Mohamed Yehia Abd El Karim (all World Bank), Dina Mohamed Eldemerdash Elkhishin (World Bank consultant).
- Local reception: Mr. Ahmed Kamaly (Deputy Minister for Planning Affairs, MPED) and Mr. Ahmed Kouchouk (Vice-Minister for Fiscal Policies, MoF).
- Presentation of preliminary conclusions: presented to Mr. Ahmed Kamaly, Mr. Ahmed Kouchouk, and Dr. Mohamed Maait, Minister of Finance.

### Meetings and stakeholder engagement
- MoF engagements: Macro-Fiscal Policy Unit (MFPU), General Budget Department, Economic Authorities and Units Budget Department, Financing Department, Debt Management Unit, Accounts and Financial Directorates Department, Final Accounts Department, PPP Central Unit.
- MPED engagements: Mr. Gameel Helmy (Minister Assistant for monitoring affairs), Planning Affairs Feasibility Studies, Regional Planning Department, Plan Preparation and Monitoring Department, PPPs Unit.
- Other government and public entities met: Ministry of Agriculture; Ministry of Environment; Ministry of International Cooperation; Ministry of Transport; Ministry of Housing, Utilities and Urban Communities; Ministry of Health; Ministry of Education; Ministry of Petroleum and Mineral Resources; Egyptian Natural Gas Holding Company; Accountability State Authority (ASA); National Investment Bank (NIB); New Urban Communities Authority (NUCA); National Telecom Regulatory Authority; Egyptian Water and Wastewater Regulatory Agency; Egyptian Electricity Utility and Consumer Protection Agency; Gas Regulatory Authority; National Centre for Planning State Land Uses (NCPSLU); General Authority for Government Services; Cairo Governorate; Ismailia Governorate.
- Additional engagement: local technical and financial partners; interpreters and IMF resident staff support acknowledged.

### Executive summary — key findings
- Vulnerability and exposure:
  - Egypt is highly vulnerable to climate change and at high risk from natural hazards, primarily due to dependence on the Nile River.
  - Egypt ranked 107th of 182 countries in the 2021 ND-Gain Country Index.
  - The densely populated Nile Delta is one of the world’s three “extreme” vulnerability hotspots.
  - Projected climate risks: sea level rises, droughts, increased frequency and intensity of extreme weather events (heat waves, sand and dust storms, heavy rain, flash floods, rockslides).
  - Potentially affected sectors: energy, water management, agriculture, tourism, health, fisheries, coastal zones, the Suez Canal.

- National commitments and planning:
  - Egypt’s updated NDC includes quantitative target: reduce Green House Gas (GHG) emissions of the three major GHG-emitting sectors (energy, transport, and oil) by 23.5 percent by 2030 compared to business-as-usual (BAU).
  - NDC adaptation objectives: focus on vulnerable sectors and developing a climate adaptation plan (at an early stage).

- Demographics and fiscal constraints:
  - Egypt’s population is expected to grow by 44 percent from 2022 to 2050.
  - More than 50 percent of the population expected to live in urban environments.
  - Authorities indicate high investment needs and limited ability to finance them; better public investment management can improve climate outcomes for a given resource envelope.

### C-PIMA overall findings
- Scope: C-PIMA assesses five public investment management practices from a climate change perspective; conducted jointly with a standard PIMA.
- General assessment:
  - Improvements made in climate-aware planning and coordination across the public sector.
  - Initial steps taken to reflect climate change issues in appraisal and selection of investment projects.
  - Significant work remains: climate change is not fully integrated in national, sectoral, construction, and spatial planning frameworks and regulations.
  - Coordination of climate-relevant public investments largely limited to central government; PPP framework does not address climate risks.
  - Limited progress on climate-sensitive budgeting, portfolio management, and fiscal risk management: climate-related investment spending not systematically identified in budgets; no disaster risk management plan; fiscal risk statement does not include climate impacts on infrastructure.

### Summary assessment by phase/institution (as presented)
- C1 Climate-aware planning
  - Institutional Strength: MEDIUM. Climate change is not fully integrated in national, sectoral, construction and spatial planning frameworks and regulations, for climate change mitigation and adaptation.
  - Reform priority: Medium
- C2 Coordination between entities
  - Institutional Strength: MEDIUM. The framework to guide and coordinate mostly focusses on climate change (mitigation)-related public investments of the central government.
  - Reform priority: Medium
- C3 Project appraisal and selection
  - Institutional Strength: MEDIUM. Guidelines require climate-related analysis according to standard methodology and vision 2030 specifies climate criteria for project selection, but PPP framework does not address climate risks.
  - Reform priority: Medium
- C4 Budgeting and portfolio management
  - Institutional Strength: LOW. Climate-related investment spending are not identified in a systematic way, hindering active management and oversight.
  - Reform priority: High
- C5 Risk management
  - Institutional Strength: LOW. There is no disaster risk management plan, and the fiscal risk statement does not include climate impacts on infrastructure, but budget contingency can be used for natural disasters.
  - Reform priority: High

### Principal recommendations (three main recommendations and selected time-bound activities)
1. Integrate strategies and objectives for climate change adaptation and mitigation in national, sectoral, construction and spatial planning processes
   - Publish a climate change chapter in the public investment plans (2024).
   - Develop centralized guidance and support to agencies for the preparation and costing of climate-aware public investment strategies (2023 – 24).
   - Integrate national climate objectives and climate-related capital projects in sectoral plans (2024 – 25).
   - Integrate climate change in construction codes, and urban and spatial planning processes (2023 – 25).
   - Priority: Medium
   - Responsible: MPED, MoE, in coordination with other agencies.

2. Reflect climate change considerations more comprehensively in project selection, budgeting, and portfolio management decisions
   - Identify climate-related investment spending in plans and budgets (2023 – 24).
   - Introduce more detailed climate change-related methodologies for conducting project appraisal (2024).
   - Carry out and publish ex-post reviews of climate impacts of investment projects (2024).
   - Create a register of key infrastructure assets including information on their exposure to climate change-related risks (2024 – 25).
   - Priority: High
   - Responsible: MPED, MoF, in coordination with MoE and other agencies.

3. Strengthen management of climate-related fiscal risks
   - Assess and monitor climate-related risks on key infrastructure assets (2025).
   - Expand the Fiscal Risks Statement to include climate-related fiscal risks (2024).
   - Develop comprehensive climate and disaster risk management plan (2023 – 25).
   - Consider need for additional financing mechanisms to manage climate risks (2024 – 25).
   - Priority: High
   - Responsible: MoF, MPED, in coordination with MoE.

### NCCS 2050 goals and costing (Box 1)
- Five national goals (selected examples summarized):
  - Goal 1: Sustainable economic growth and low-emissions development (increase renewable energy share, reduce GHG from fossil fuels, increase energy efficiency, sustainable production and waste management).
  - Goal 2: Adaptive capacity and resilience to climate change (protect citizens' health, minimize loss and damage to assets and ecosystems, develop resilient infrastructure and services, implement disaster risk reduction systems, strengthen women's response considerations).
  - Goal 3: Climate change action governance (define roles and responsibilities, improve international climate profile, sectoral policy reforms, enhance institutional/procedural/legal arrangements).
  - Goal 4: Climate financing infrastructure (promote local green banking, green credit lines, green bonds, private sector engagement, green jobs).
  - Goal 5: Scientific research, technology transfer, knowledge management, awareness (strengthen research and technology transfer, disseminate climate-relevant knowledge).

- NCCS 2050 estimated program costs (as presented; units: Million USD):
  - Mitigation program costs:
    - Industry 130
    - Electricity 144,153
    - Petroleum 1,689
    - Transport 57,477
    - Civil Aviation 25
    - Housing and Utilities 31
    - Waste 7,627
    - Required funding 211,133
  - Adaptation program costs:
    - Agriculture 52,400
    - Transport 1,273
    - Civil Aviation 9
    - Irrigation, Water Resources 59,108
    - Biodiversity 199
    - Required funding 112,990

*Source: tarea2024029 - Preface (IMF | Technical Report – Egypt Climate PIMA).*

### Section II. Climate Assessment of Public Investment

### Section II. Climate Assessment of Public Investment Management in Country

### A. CLIMATE PIMA FRAMEWORK

- The Climate PIMA assesses five key public investment management practices from the climate change perspective and is an extension of the existing PIMA framework.
- The CC PIMA covers the following issues:
  - C1. Climate-aware planning: Is public investment planned from a climate change perspective?
  - C2. Coordination between entities: Is there effective coordination of decision making on climate change-related public investment across the public sector? This includes central government, subnational governments (SNGs), public corporations (PCs) and private sector entities.
  - C3. Project appraisal and selection: Do project appraisal and selection include climate-related analysis and criteria?
  - C4. Portfolio management and oversight: Is climate-related investment spending subject to active management and oversight? Emphasizes systematic and consistent benefits management over the project lifecycle.
  - C5. Risk management: Are fiscal risks relating to climate change and infrastructure incorporated in budgets and fiscal risk analysis and managed according to a plan?

### B. DETAILED ASSESSMENT

#### C1. Climate-aware Planning (Strength: Medium; Reform Priority: High)

- Findings:
  - Egypt has started incorporating climate into public investment plans, but they do not yet consider climate targets adequately.
  - Egypt’s NDC and NCCS 2050 contain various objectives, some quantitative targets for mitigation, and some qualitative measures for adaptation.
  - The NCCS 2050 includes measures to mainstream climate change into public investment management.
  - Through the Unified Planning Law, the Ministry of Planning and Economic Development (MPED) has introduced a comprehensive approach to integrating climate change into long-term, medium-term, and annual national planning processes.
  - The Environmental Sustainability Standards Guide (ESSG) provides broad guidance to identify green infrastructure projects but climate considerations and targets have not been fully integrated into national and sectoral public investment plans.
  - Attention has focused more on mitigation than adaptation; plans lack information about costs of public investment projects and their effects on climate targets.
  - The Ministry of Housing’s green building code provides guidance for energy efficient construction but does not address other key sectors or adaptation.
  - A climate vulnerability map is being developed with spatial climate change risk information up to the year 2100.
  - Authorities are not yet defining comprehensive, locally specific construction restrictions in areas exposed to climate change risks or a comprehensive register of up-to-date construction and spatial planning climate change mitigation and adaptation requirements.
  - Limited powers constrain enforcement of climate change-relevant building codes and spatial plans.
  - The ESSG includes high-level guidance on introducing climate change into the public investment cycle; the Egypt Environmental Agency (EEA) provides specialized training; various line ministries are implementing climate change units.
  - There is no mechanism for systematic technical or financial support to planners integrating climate change into public investment planning.

- Reform priorities / recommendations:
  - Firmly integrate climate change adaptation and mitigation in construction codes, and spatial and urban planning and investment planning frameworks.
  - Develop clear guidance and centrally organized technical support on how to equally integrate climate change adaptation and mitigation into investment planning activities.
  - Include a climate change public investment chapter in all relevant development plans outlining an overview of all climate change-related investments across sectors and their expected effects.
  - Fully integrate climate change adaptation and mitigation into construction and spatial and urban planning regulations.

- Legal and policy references:
  - Unified Planning Law 18/2022, adopted in June 2022 (Articles 1, 2, and 7).
  - The ESSG was introduced through cabinet meeting resolution 115, 2020.

#### C2. Coordination Between Entities (Strength: Medium; Reform Priority: Medium)

- Findings:
  - Decision-making on public investment from a climate change perspective is coordinated at the central government level.
  - The NCCC holds a supervisory role for steering climate change activities and integrating climate change into national development planning across the public sector.
  - The MoF budget guidelines reference climate change–relevant planning documents, acts, and regulations.
  - MPED is responsible for mainstreaming climate change into the investment planning framework; MPED instructions include guidance on identifying and reporting green projects as provided in the ESSG.
  - The ESSG focuses more on mitigation and less on adaptation and does not include concise guidance on assessing and classifying projects according to their expected effects related to national climate change targets and risks.
  - The Unified Planning Law covers the entire public sector and requires local governments to base priorities on national plans, but there is no law defining climate change–related roles and responsibilities for local governments and no active information-sharing mechanism between government levels for climate-aware planning.
  - The 2015 Environmental Law stipulates MoE oversees development of cooperative links with regional and local governments but does not provide clear information-sharing requirements.
  - PC framework does not require all PCs to develop a climate change strategy or to ensure investments are consistent with national climate targets beyond general laws and expectations; PC ownership rights and monitoring exercised bilaterally.

- Reform priorities / recommendations:
  - Increase coordination of climate-related public investment across the public sector.
  - Identify climate change responsibilities for public sector entities involved in public investment planning and consider adding climate change responsibilities in legal mandates of key agencies.
  - Develop a climate change information-sharing and investment coordination mechanism between central government, sub-national governments, and other identified government agencies.

- Note:
  - The ESSG and government commitment: The government has committed to increasing the percentage of green projects as a percentage of total investments from 30% in 2021/22 to 50% in 2024.

- Example provided:
  - Box 2 describes a governance approach in the Netherlands where regional strategies and a national platform coordinate a nationwide energy transition, support capacity building, and provide mechanisms to seek compliance with overall climate targets.

#### C3. Project Appraisal and Selection (Strength: Medium; Reform Priority: High)

- Findings:
  - Appraisal requires climate-related analysis conducted according to a standard methodology with central support.
  - MPED issued an Addendum—Guidance on Sustainability Analysis—requiring an environmental impact assessment for each major infrastructure project including climate aspects (mitigation and adaptation).
  - Climate aspects include indicators such as environmental sensitivity of the site in relation to proximity to coastal areas, Nile River or natural reserves, carbon footprint, energy and water use efficiency, use of renewable energy whenever possible, and others.
  - In some sectors (energy and construction), projects must meet energy efficiency standards which are considered in project design.
  - Egypt’s green bond framework requires a standardized environmental assessment for projects financed from green bond proceedings; green bond financing framework was verified by an independent external party and can finance new and existing projects. The MoF selected projects for green bond financing from a pool of pre-selected projects.
  - The specific requirements for climate-related analysis are more stringent than general project appraisal requirements; this can lead to a project being deemed to have significant positive climate impacts while overall costs and benefits remain highly uncertain.
  - Climate-related aspects are not considered explicitly in the PPP framework for risk allocation or contract management. The PPP executive regulations (under PPP Law 2010) were amended to allow unsolicited private sector proposals using innovative technologies that reduce carbon emissions. The Dry Port PPP project includes climate related aspects and is under consideration by the PPP Central Unit of the MoF.
  - Selection of public investment projects for state budget funding includes a requirement to apply environmental sustainability standards per MPED Circular.
  - Egypt's vision 2030 includes climate-related projects among selection criteria; some sectoral projects have climate-related aspects including mitigation and adaptation.
  - A systematic approach requires a common methodology and consistent baseline across government entities. The Guidance on Sustainability Analysis provides a systematic approach but detailed methodologies and a consistent baseline for climate impacts are yet to be developed.

- Reform priorities / recommendations:
  - Develop detailed methodologies and a consistent baseline for assessing climate impacts in project appraisal.
  - Ensure climate-related appraisal requirements are integrated across PPP frameworks, risk allocation, and contract management.

#### C4. Budgeting and Portfolio Management (Strength: Low; Reform Priority: High)

- Findings:
  - Climate-related public investment expenditures in the central government are not yet identified in budget documents.
  - Tagging expenditure allocations would help set performance expectations, accountabilities, and control across the public investment cycle and could attract international climate finance or sovereign Green Bonds.
  - Recent green bond issuance mentioned a few projects to be financed by proceeds, but project identification was not based on a definition of climate-related spending.
  - A gradual shift to a program budgeting system could facilitate identification and application of planned climate-related public expenditures, financing sources, and outputs/outcomes in budget documents.
  - Identification should also cover PPPs, climate-related transfers to local administrations, economic authorities, and public business sector corporations implementing climate-related investments.
  - Ex-post reviews are limited and have not assessed actual climate-related environmental impacts of public investments or projects, or the exposure of infrastructure assets to climate-related disasters.
  - National Communications and a Biennial Report prepared since 1998 are published on EEA website but do not assess impacts of climate change on projects or asset exposure.
  - Audit reports are not readily accessible, mirroring gaps in Central Audit Organization transparency.
  - Climate-related risks are not explicitly addressed in government asset management policies and practices; asset registers are widely present but not required to contain exposure or damage information due to climate change.
  - Maintenance due to exposure has been undertaken occasionally, but well-defined asset management policies, practices, and methodologies for routine maintenance are still emerging.

- Reform priorities / recommendations:
  - Tag climate-related public investment expenditures in budget documents and consider program budgeting to support identification and reporting.
  - Expand ex-post review coverage to assess climate-related impacts and exposure of infrastructure assets to climate-related disasters.
  - Incorporate climate vulnerability information into asset registers and develop centralized asset register and reporting responsibilities.
  - Pilot systematic monitoring of climate implications on selected key public assets, then gradually expand coverage.

#### C5. Risk Management (Strength: Low; Reform Priority: High)

- Findings:
  - The National Disaster Risk Management Strategy 2030 (NDRMS) mentions climate change as a risk but does not assess or address it; finalization of work in this direction is pending.
  - Government entities are mostly focused on preparing for or managing hazards that have occurred in the past.
  - Specific financing mechanisms targeted at managing exposure of public infrastructure to climate-related risks have not been a focus; the budget contingency reserve can be used for this purpose.
  - Without comprehensive and consistent assessment of climate-related risks and their implications, defining financing needs and efficient financing mechanisms will be difficult.
  - Government does not conduct a fiscal risk assessment incorporating climate-related risks to public infrastructure.
  - Asset registers maintained by entities include condition information but do not systematically assess or record climate vulnerability; registers are maintained decentrally, limiting central access for consistent comprehensive risk assessment.
  - Such an assessment could feed into the Fiscal Risk Statement, which has been initiated and whose coverage is being expanded by the MoF.

- Reform priorities / recommendations:
  - Finalize assessment and integration of climate risks within the NDRMS and other risk management frameworks.
  - Conduct comprehensive fiscal risk assessments incorporating climate-related risks to public infrastructure.
  - Develop financing mechanisms targeted at managing exposure of public infrastructure to climate-related risks informed by consistent assessments.
  - Centralize or ensure access to asset register information including climate vulnerability to enable consistent fiscal risk analysis and incorporation into the Fiscal Risk Statement.

*IMF | Technical Report – Egypt Climate PIMA*

### 26. Assessing the expected impact of climate-related risks on public infrastructure and

### 26. Assessing the expected impact of climate-related risks on public infrastructure and

### Overview
- Assessing the expected impact of climate-related risks on public infrastructure and defining strategies for how to address them adequately through a disaster risk management strategy and financing arrangements is identified as a high reform priority.
- Efficient management of climate-related hazards and slow moving climate change requires information on existing and newly developed infrastructure and its exposure to implications of climate change.
- A comprehensive database of key infrastructure including information on exposure to climate change–related implications could provide a basis for developing a strategy for managing the risks from this exposure.
- A risk-based approach, initially focusing on particular infrastructure assets or regions with high vulnerability, could be followed.
- If assessment reveals emergency financing requirements beyond budget contingencies or reallocations, options for introducing specific financing mechanisms should be explored.

### Example: State Asset Insurance Scheme in Indonesia (Box 3)
- Indonesia introduced a State Asset Insurance Policy program as part of the National Disaster Risk Financing and Insurance strategy (DFRI).
- In 2019 the government introduced a state building insurance scheme as the first phase of the State Asset Insurance mechanism.
- The scheme:
  - Provides insurance for natural disasters, funded by a pool of private insurers.
  - Was introduced for the Ministry of Finance’s buildings in 2019 and extended to buildings belonging to other ministries in 2020.
  - Has an estimated insurance value of government buildings to be covered amounting to IDR371 trillion, approximately 13 percent of GDP.
  - Has an insurance premium for disaster risks estimated to be 0.2 percent of building values.
  - Plans to expand the scope to include buildings, bridge, transportation modes, and other government properties.
  - Requires assets to be located in disaster-prone areas, have high probability to be damaged or lost in case of natural disaster, and have significant contribution to public services.
- Source: Indonesia Ministry of Finance.

### Legal Framework (Cross-cutting issues)
- The general legal framework for PIM has been recently updated, but its interaction with the climate change framework remains to be defined.
- The newly enacted PFM law and UPL contain elements that may support climate-related policies, such as:
  - The principle of sustainability.
  - The requirement for a medium-term budget framework.
  - Transition to program-based budgeting.
- Many laws may significantly impact the PIM framework from a climate perspective (list provided in source includes Law 4/1994, M Decree 1912/2015, Presidential Decree 275/1997, Law 43/1979, PM Decree 495/1977, Law 198/2014, Law 196/2017, Law 4/1988, Presidential Decrees 409 and 1451/1973, Law 135/1956, Law 147/2021, Law 202/2020, Decree 365/1978, Law 87/2015, Decree 203/2014, Law 119/2008, Law 138/2006, Law 84/1968, Law 62/1974, Law 3/1982, Law 72/2017, Law 159/1979).
- Institutional roles need clarification:
  - MPED and MoF lead investment planning and budget planning.
  - Line ministries, economic authorities, and local administrations implement specific projects.
  - NCCC is a coordinating body composed of the Prime Minister and representatives; MoE serves as technical secretariat.
  - NCCC’s and MoE’s roles in each stage of the PIM cycle lack definition, potentially weakening mainstreaming of climate change considerations.
  - Climate-related laws could more clearly set out roles of regulators of natural resources (land use, water, petroleum) in achieving climate-related sectoral objectives.

### IT Systems and Data Management
- Climate tagging is not yet supported by existing IT applications.
- Opportunities exist to implement climate change monitoring and reporting functionality through ongoing reforms:
  - Implementing program and performance budgeting (PBB) is an opportunity to introduce a tagging system in the Government Financial Management Information System (GFMIS).
  - Specific tagging fields could be added to the Integrated System for Investment Plan Preparation and Monitoring (ISIPPM) system to be interfaced with the GFMIS.
  - This would create a budget tool for monitoring and tracking of climate-related expenditures.

### Capacity Building
- Climate-related skills need further development.
- Issuance of the Guidance on Sustainability Analysis and project appraisal and selection for the 2020 green bond were important steps.
- Capacity building to date is skewed more toward climate change mitigation than adaptation, reflecting CD support from the international community.
- More capacity is needed at all levels of government to effectively integrate climate change considerations into development planning.
- At the MoF level, essential to develop capacity to monitor and mitigate climate risks, including preparing a climate section in the fiscal risk statement.

### Key Recommendations (summary)
Issue 1. Integrate strategies and objectives for climate change adaptation and mitigation in national, sectoral, construction and spatial planning processes.
- Publish a climate change chapter in the public investment plans.
- Develop centralized guidance and support to agencies for preparation and costing of climate-aware public investment strategies.
- Integrate national climate objectives and climate-related capital projects in sectoral plans.
- Integrate climate change in construction codes, and urban and spatial planning processes.

Issue 2. Reflect climate change considerations more comprehensively in the PIM-cycle.
- Identify climate-related investment spending in plans and budgets.
- Introduce more detailed climate change-related methodologies for conducting project appraisal.
- Carry out and publish ex-post reviews of climate impacts of investment projects.
- Create a register of key infrastructure assets including information on their exposure to climate change–related risks.

Issue 3. Strengthen management of climate-related (fiscal) risks.
- Assess and monitor climate-related risks on key infrastructure assets.
- Expand the Fiscal Risks Statement to include climate-related fiscal risks.
- Develop a comprehensive climate and disaster risk management plan.
- Consider need for additional financing mechanisms to manage climate risks.

### Appendix: Action Plan (selected actions and responsibilities)
- Timeline columns: 2023 2024 2025 (as presented in source).
- Recommendation 1 (Priority: Medium)
  - Publish a climate change chapter in the public investment plans.
    - Action: Publish and gradually expand content.
    - Responsible Agency: MPED, MoE, line ministries.
  - Ensure mitigation and adaptation addressed at all PIM stages: review and update guidelines, circulars, regulations, decrees, and acts.
    - Responsible Agency: MPED, MoE, line ministries.
  - Integrate national climate objectives in sectoral plans: develop guidance and integrate as sectoral plans are updated.
    - Responsible Agency: MPED, line ministries.
  - Integrate climate change in construction codes and urban and spatial planning: review and integrate considerations into codes, plans, and accompanying regulations.
    - Responsible Agency: MoE, MPED, MoH, NCPSLU, and other relevant ministries.
  - Develop centralized guidance and support to agencies for climate-aware public investment strategies.
    - Responsible Agency: MoE, MPED.

- Recommendation 2 (Priority: High)
  - Create a register of key infrastructure assets including exposure information and a risk monitoring system.
    - Responsible Agency: MEPD, and relevant line ministries.
  - Identify climate-related spending and develop a climate tagging system for mitigation and adaptation in the GFMIS and ISIPPM systems.
    - Responsible Agency: MPED, MoF.
  - Introduce detailed climate change–related methodologies for project appraisal, including standardized assumptions and standard shadow prices for GHGs.
    - Responsible Agency: MPED, MoE.
  - Carry out and publish ex-post reviews of climate impacts of investment projects; pilot reviews and use findings to refine procedures.
    - Responsible Agency: MPED, MoE.

- Recommendation 3 (Priority: High)
  - Assess and monitor climate-related risks on key infrastructure assets using the asset register.
  - Expand the Fiscal Risk Statement to include quantitative analysis of fiscal risks related to climate change, including long-term fiscal sustainability under different climate change scenarios and climate-related natural disasters, and quantitative assessment of discrete fiscal risks related to infrastructure assets.
    - Responsible Agency: MoF, MPED.
  - Develop a comprehensive climate and disaster risk management plan: register public infrastructure assets exposed to climate change risks, determine timely damage assessment and prioritization mechanisms, formalize assessment and disaster risk management procedures and allocation of roles.
    - Responsible Agency: MoE, MPED, Agencies responsible for disaster management.
  - Consider additional financing mechanisms to manage climate risks: assess financing needs and identify mechanisms (e.g., contingencies, credit lines, CAT bonds, prudent debt levels).
    - Responsible Agency: MoE, MPED, Agencies responsible for disaster management.

- Cross-cutting
  - Define roles and responsibilities for SNGs and key organizations (e.g., NCCC, MoE, NCPSLU) in each stage of the PIM cycle and formalize them in the legal framework.
    - Responsible Agency: MPED and MoE.

*IMF | Technical Report – Egypt Climate PIMA*

### Appendix 2. C-PIMA Questionnaire

### Appendix 2. C-PIMA Questionnaire

### C1. Climate-aware planning
- C1. Climate-aware planning: Is public investment planned from a climate change perspective?
  - C1.a Are national and sectoral public investment strategies and plans consistent with NDC or other overarching climate change strategy on mitigation and adaptation?
    - QUESTION NOT MET: National and sectoral public investment strategies and plans are not consistent with NDC or other overarching climate change strategy.
    - PARTIALLY MET: National public investment strategies and plans are consistent with NDC or other overarching climate change strategy for some sectors.
    - FULLY MET: National and sectoral public investment strategies and plans are consistent with NDC or other overarching climate change strategy for most sectors.
  - C1.b Do central government and/or sub-national government regulations on spatial and urban planning, and construction address climate-related risks and impacts on public investment?
    - QUESTION NOT MET: Central government and/or sub-national government regulations on spatial and urban planning, and construction do not address climate-related risks and impacts on public investment.
    - PARTIALLY MET: Central government and/or sub-national government regulations on spatial and urban planning, or construction (through building codes) addresses climate-related risks and impacts on public investment.
    - FULLY MET: Central government and/or sub-national government regulations on spatial and urban planning, and construction (through building codes) address climate-related risks and impacts on public investment.
  - C1.c Is there centralized guidance/support for government agencies on the preparation and costing of climate-aware public investment strategies?
    - QUESTION NOT MET: There is no centralized guidance/support for government agencies on the preparation and costing of climate-aware public investment strategies.
    - PARTIALLY MET: There is centralized guidance/support for government agencies on the preparation of climate-aware public investment strategies.
    - FULLY MET: There is centralized guidance/support for government agencies on the preparation and costing of climate-aware public investment strategies.

### C2. Coordination between entities
- C2. Coordination between entities: Is there effective coordination of decision making on climate change-related public investment across the public sector?
  - C2.a Is decision making on public investment coordinated across central government from a climate-change perspective?
    - QUESTION NOT MET: Decision making on public investment is not coordinated across central government from a climate-change perspective.
    - PARTIALLY MET: Decision making on public investment is coordinated across budgetary central government from a climate-change perspective.
    - FULLY MET: Decision making on public investment is coordinated across all central government, including externally financed projects, PPPs and extra-budgetary entities, from a climate-change perspective.
  - C2.b Is the planning and implementation of capital spending of SNGs coordinated with the central government from a climate-change perspective?
    - QUESTION NOT MET: The planning and implementation of capital spending of SNGs is not coordinated with the central government from a climate-change perspective.
    - PARTIALLY MET: The central government issues guidance on the planning and implementation of capital spending from a climate-change perspective and information on major climate-related projects of SNGs is shared with the central government.
    - FULLY MET: The central government issues guidance on the planning and implementation of capital spending from a climate-change perspective, information on major climate-related projects of SNGs is shared with the central government and is published alongside data on central government projects, and there are formal discussions between central government and SNGs on the planning and implementation of climate-related investments.
  - C2.c Does the regulatory and oversight framework for public corporations ensure that their climate-related investments are consistent with national climate policies and guidelines?
    - QUESTION NOT MET: The regulatory and oversight framework for public corporations does not promote consistency between their climate-related investments and national climate policies and guidelines.
    - PARTIALLY MET: The regulatory and oversight framework for public corporations promotes consistency between their climate-related investments and national climate policies and guidelines.
    - FULLY MET: The regulatory and oversight framework for public corporations requires that their climate-related investments be consistent with national climate policies and guidelines.

### C3. Project appraisal and selection
- C3. Do project appraisal and selection include climate-related analysis and criteria?
  - C3.a Does the appraisal of major infrastructure projects require climate-related analysis to be conducted according to a standard methodology with central support?
    - QUESTION NOT MET: The appraisal of major infrastructure projects does not require climate-related analysis to be conducted according to a standard methodology.
    - PARTIALLY MET: The appraisal of major infrastructure projects requires climate-related analysis to be conducted according to a standard methodology.
    - FULLY MET: The appraisal of major infrastructure projects requires climate-related analysis to be conducted according to a standard methodology, and a summary of appraisals is published or subject to independent external review.
  - C3.b Does the framework for managing longer-term public investment contracts, such as PPPs, explicitly address climate-related challenges?
    - QUESTION NOT MET: The referred framework does not include explicit consideration of climate change for risk allocation or contract management.
    - PARTIALLY MET: The referred framework includes explicit consideration of climate change with respect to how risks are allocated between the parties in infrastructure contracts.
    - FULLY MET: The referred framework includes explicit consideration of climate change with respect to how risks are allocated between the parties in infrastructure contracts, and contract managers in government departments and agencies are mandated to address climate-related challenges.
  - C3.c Are climate-related elements included among the criteria used by the government for the selection of infrastructure projects?
    - QUESTION NOT MET: Either there are no explicit selection criteria or climate-related elements are not included among the criteria used by the government for the selection of projects for financing.
    - PARTIALLY MET: Climate-related elements are included among the criteria used by the government for the selection of all major budget-funded projects, and the criteria are published.
    - FULLY MET: Climate-related elements are included among the criteria used by the government for the selection of all major projects, including externally financed projects, projects financed by extra-budgetary entities, and PPPs, and the criteria are published.

### C4. Budgeting and portfolio management
- C4. Budgeting and portfolio management: Is climate-related investment spending subject to active management and oversight?
  - C4.a Are planned climate-related public investment expenditures, sources of financing, outputs and outcomes identified in the budget and related documents, monitored, and reported?
    - QUESTION NOT MET: Planned climate-related public investment expenditures are not identified in the budget and related documents.
    - PARTIALLY MET: Some planned climate-related public investment expenditures are identified in the budget and related documents, including investment expenditures funded externally, by extra-budgetary entities, and PPPs.
    - FULLY MET: Most planned climate-related public investment expenditures, sources of financing, and outputs and outcomes are identified in the budget and related documents, including investment expenditures funded externally, by extra-budgetary entities, and PPPs, and expenditure on these projects is monitored and reported.
  - C4.b Are ex-post reviews or audits conducted of the climate change mitigation and adaptation outcomes of public investments?
    - QUESTION NOT MET: No ex-post reviews or audits are conducted of the climate change mitigation and adaptation outcomes of public investments.
    - PARTIALLY MET: Ex-post reviews or audits are conducted for selected major public investments of either the climate change mitigation or adaptation outcomes.
    - FULLY MET: Ex-post reviews or audits are conducted and published for selected major public investments of both the climate change mitigation and adaptation outcomes.
  - C4.c Do the government’s asset management policies and practices, including the maintenance of assets, address climate-related risks?
    - QUESTION NOT MET: Neither the government’s asset management policies and practices nor methodologies for estimating the maintenance needs of climate change-exposed infrastructure assets address climate-related risks.
    - PARTIALLY MET: Methodologies prepared by the government for estimating the maintenance needs of some climate change-exposed infrastructure assets address climate-related risks.
    - FULLY MET: Methodologies prepared by the government for estimating the maintenance needs and associated costs of most climate change-exposed infrastructure assets address climate-related risks, and government asset registers include climate-related information of these assets.

### C5. Risk management
- C5. Risk management: Are fiscal risks relating to climate change and infrastructure incorporated in budgets and fiscal risk analysis and managed according to a plan?
  - C5.a Does the government publish a national disaster risk management strategy that incorporates the potential impact of climate change on public infrastructure assets and networks?
    - QUESTION NOT MET: Either there is no published national disaster risk management strategy, or the strategy does not identify the key climate-related risks to public infrastructure assets and networks.
    - PARTIALLY MET: The government publishes a national disaster risk management strategy that identifies the key climate-related risks to public infrastructure assets and networks in terms of hazards, exposure, and vulnerability.
    - FULLY MET: The government publishes a national disaster risk management strategy that identifies and analyses the key climate-related risks to public infrastructure assets and networks in terms of hazards, exposure and vulnerability, and includes the government’s plans to mitigate and respond to these risks.
  - C5.b Has the government put in place ex ante financing mechanisms to manage the exposure of the stock of public infrastructure to climate-related risks?
    - QUESTION NOT MET: The government has not put in place any ex-ante financing mechanisms to manage the exposure of the stock of public infrastructure to climate-related risks.
    - PARTIALLY MET: There is an annual contingency appropriation in the budget or other financing mechanisms that is available to meet the costs of climate-related damages to public infrastructure.
    - FULLY MET: There is an annual contingency appropriation in the budget and other financing mechanisms that are available to meet the costs of climate-related damages to public infrastructure.
  - C5.c Does the government conduct and publish a fiscal risk analysis that incorporates climate-related risks to public infrastructure assets?
    - QUESTION NOT MET: The government does not conduct a fiscal risk analysis that incorporates climate-related risks to public infrastructure assets.
    - PARTIALLY MET: The government conducts and publishes a fiscal risk analysis that incorporates a qualitative assessment of climate-related risks to public infrastructure assets over the medium term.
    - FULLY MET: The government conducts and publishes a fiscal risk analysis that incorporates a quantitative assessment of climate-related risks to public infrastructure assets over the medium term and policies to mitigate these risks, and a qualitative assessment of the risks that may arise over the long-term.

*Appendix 2. C-PIMA Questionnaire*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/tar/2024/english/tarea2024029.pdf_
